May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

75
MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION Tuesday, May 27, 2014 – 1:00 P.M. A Closed Session is scheduled from 11:30 A.M. – 1:00 P.M. to discuss legal and contractual matters. AGENDA 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION – Tuesday, May 27, 2014 – 11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. 3. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AND RECOGNITIONS A. Retirement Recognition of Pam Marshall, Accountant B. Retirement Recognition of PFC Charles Zukas 4. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC Any person who may wish to speak on a matter scheduled for discussion on the Work Session Agenda may be heard during Comments from the Public for a period of three (3) minutes or such time as may be deemed appropriate by the Council President. Anyone wishing to be heard shall state their name, address and the Agenda item on which he or she wishes to speak. 5. NEW BUSINESS A. TAB Funding Allocation Recommendation for OC Bikefest presented by Greg Shockley, Chairman B. Request to Sole Source Purchase a Wastewater Grinder presented by Wastewater Superintendent C. Request for Approval of OCPD General Orders presented by Police Chief 1. G.O. 200 P1 – Personal Relationships (new) 2. G.O. 200 B1 – General Conduct & Compliance with Rules and Regulations (update) 3. G.O. 400 P1 – Plain Clothes Operations Guidelines (new) 4. G.O. 800 A1 – General Appearance Standards (update) D. West Ocean City EMS Service Report presented by Fire Chief 6. ADJOURN

Transcript of May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Page 1: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

 

MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL  

WORK SESSION Tuesday, May 27, 2014 – 1:00 P.M. 

  

A Closed Session is scheduled from 11:30 A.M. – 1:00 P.M. to discuss legal and contractual matters.  

AGENDA  

1.  CALL TO ORDER  

2.  REPORT ON CLOSED SESSION – Tuesday, May 27, 2014 – 11:30 a.m.  – 1:00 p.m.  

3.  ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS AND RECOGNITIONS   A. Retirement Recognition of Pam Marshall, Accountant   B. Retirement Recognition of PFC Charles Zukas 

 

4.  COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC   Any person who may wish to speak on a matter scheduled for discussion on the Work Session Agenda 

may be heard during Comments from the Public for a period of three (3) minutes or such time as may be deemed appropriate by the Council President.  Anyone wishing to be heard shall state their name, 

address and the Agenda item on which he or she wishes to speak.   

5.  NEW BUSINESS  

  A.  TAB Funding Allocation Recommendation for OC Bikefest presented by Greg Shockley, Chairman  

  B.  Request to Sole Source Purchase a Wastewater Grinder presented by Wastewater Superintendent  

  C.  Request for Approval of OCPD General Orders presented by Police Chief      1. G.O. 200 P‐1 – Personal Relationships (new)     2. G.O. 200 B‐1 – General Conduct & Compliance with Rules and Regulations (update)     3. G.O. 400 P‐1 – Plain Clothes Operations Guidelines (new)     4. G.O. 800 A‐1 – General Appearance Standards (update) 

 

  D.  West Ocean City EMS Service Report presented by Fire Chief  

6.  ADJOURN  

Page 2: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

2. Report on Closed Session – May 27, 2014 – 11:30 a.m. – 1:00 p.m. – Legal and Contractual Matters

Page 3: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

NOTICE OF CLOSED SESSION OF MAYOR & CITY COUNCIL OF OCEAN CITY

AUTHORITY: State Government Article: Section 10-508(a) Annotated Code of Maryland PURPOSES:

1. To discuss: (i) the appointment, employment, assignment, promotion, discipline, demotion,

compensation, removal, resignation or performance evaluation of appointees, employees or officials over whom it has jurisdiction; or

(ii) any other personnel matter that affects one or more specific individuals;

2. To protect the privacy or reputation of individuals with respect to a matter that is not related to public business

3. To consider the acquisition of real property for the public purpose and matters directly related thereto;

4. Consider a matter that concerns the proposal for a business or industrial organization to locate, expand or locate in the state;

5. Consider the investment of public funds; 6. Consider the marketing of public securities;

X 7. Consult with counsel to obtain legal advice;

8. Consult with staff, consultants or other individuals about pending or potential litigations;

9. Conduct collective bargaining negotiations or consider matters that relate to the negotiations;

10. Discuss public security if the public body determines that public discussion would constitute a risk to the public or public security, including;

a) the deployment of fire and police services and staff; and b) the development and implementation of emergency plans 11. Prepare, administer or grade a scholastic, licensing or qualifying examination;

12. Conduct or discuss an investigative proceeding on actual or possible criminal conduct;

13. Comply with a specific constitutional, statutory or judicially imposed

requirement that prevents public disclosures about a particular proceeding or matter; or

X

14. Before a contract is awarded or bids are opened, discuss a matter directly related to a negotiation strategy or the contents of a bid or proposal, if public discussion or disclosure would adversely impact the ability of the public body to participate in the competitive bidding or proposal process

DATE AND TIME: Tuesday, May 27, 2014 11:30 a.m. PLACE: City Hall SUBJECT: Legal and Contractual Matters VOTE: UNANIMOUS OTHER: FOR: AGAINST:

ABSTAIN: ABSENT:

Page 4: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

REPORT OF CLOSED SESSION OF THE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF OCEAN CITY

Prior to this open session of the Mayor and City Council being held on Tuesday, May 27,

2014, a closed session was held on Tuesday, May 27, 2014 at 12:00 p.m. The following

is a report of the closed session.

1. A statement of the time, place, and purpose of the closed session is attached.

2. A record of the vote of each member as to closing the session is attached.

3. A citation of the authority under the law for closing the session is attached.

4. (a) Topics of Discussion: Legal and Contractual Matters

(b) Persons present:

Mayor Richard Meehan City Manager David Recor Council President Lloyd Martin Council Secretary Mary Knight Council Members Doug Cymek; Margaret Pillas; Brent Ashley; Dennis Dare and

Joe Mitrecic City Solicitor Guy Ayres City Engineer Terry McGean Public Works Director Hal Adkins Public Works Chief Deputy Director Jim Parsons Golf Superintendent Joe Perry Executive Office Associate Diana Chavis Action(s) taken:

Motion to close meeting:

Time adjourned:

Page 5: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

3. ACKNOWLEGEMENTS AND RECOGNITIONS

A. Retirement Recognition of Pam Marshall, Accountant

Page 6: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

IN APPRECIATION OF PAMELA MARSHALL 15 YEARS OF SERVICE

Pamela Marshall has contributed Fifteen (15) years of dedicated service to the Town of Ocean City, where she began her career in 1999; and WHEREAS, Pamela Marshall has played an integral role in the Finance Department for the Town of Ocean City for 15 years; and WHEREAS, Pam served on the Pension Board as a Trustee representing General Employees. She completed pension accounting and sent out monthly reports to trustees as well as prepared reports for Comprehensive Annual Financial Report; and WHEREAS, Pam Marshall’s skill and experience have been instrumental in the overall success of the Finance Department for the Town of Ocean City, Maryland. NOW, THEREFORE, I, Richard W. Meehan, Mayor of the Town of Ocean City, Maryland, along with the Ocean City Council, do hereby commend Pam for her Fifteen (15) years of devoted service and wish her a happy and healthy retirement. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and caused the Great Seal of the Town of Ocean City, Maryland to be affixed this 27th day of May in the year of Our Lord two thousand and fourteen. ______________________________ RICHARD W. MEEHAN Mayor

Page 7: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

3. ACKNOWLEGEMENTS AND RECOGNITIONS

B. Retirement Recognition of PFC Charles Zukas

Page 8: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

IN APPRECIATION OF CHARLES ZUKAS 26 YEARS OF SERVICE

Charles Zukas has contributed Twenty-six (26) years of dedicated service to the Town of Ocean City, where he began his career in 1989; and WHEREAS, Charles Zukas has played an integral role in the Police Department for the past 26 years; and WHEREAS, During his career with the Ocean City Police Department, Charles was certified as an Intoximeter Operator on November 18, 1994 and he has completed more than 1,000 breath tests since then. This is a very impressive stat; and WHEREAS, In addition to his distinguished career with the Ocean City Police Department, Charles is a Gulf War Veteran; and WHEREAS, Charles Zukas’ skill and experience has been instrumental in the overall success of the Police Department for the Town of Ocean City, Maryland. NOW, THEREFORE, I, Richard W. Meehan, Mayor of the Town of Ocean City, Maryland, along with the Ocean City Council, do hereby commend Charles for his Twenty-six (26) years of devoted service and wish him a happy and healthy retirement. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and caused the Great Seal of the Town of Ocean City, Maryland to be affixed this 27th day of May in the year of Our Lord two thousand and fourteen. _______________________________ RICHARD W. MEEHAN Mayor

Page 9: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

4. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC

Any person who may wish to speak on a matter scheduled for discussion on the Work

Session Agenda may be heard during Comments from the Public for a period of three (3) minutes or such time as may be deemed appropriate by the Council President. Anyone wishing to be heard shall state their name, address and the subject on which he or she wishes to speak.

Page 10: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

5. NEW BUSINESS

A. TAB Funding Allocation Recommendation for OC Bikefest presented by Greg Shockley, Chairman

Page 11: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

TOWN OF

The White Marlin Capital of the World

TO: The Honorable Mayor, Council President and Members of Council THRU: David L. Recor, ICMA-CM, City Manager FROM: Donna Abbott, Tourism and Marketing Director RE: Tourism Advisory Board Update and Funding Recommendation DATE: May 21, 2014

ISSUE(S): TAB update and request to approve funding recommendation SUMMARY: Tourism Advisory Board Chairman Greg Shockley will present an

update on TAB’s April 10, 2014 meeting. TAB seeks approval from the Mayor and Council for $35,000 from its allocation to support funding BikeFest 2014 scheduled for September 11-14 in Ocean City. The new owner of BikeFest, Kathy Michael, has requested funding in the amount of $35,000 to assist with marketing and security for the 2014 event. TAB approved the funding request with the understanding that there could be a reduced sliding scale for any future requests given this event has received funding the past few years and was able to make a profit last year.

FISCAL IMPACT: Funds are available in TAB’s current allocation RECOMMENDATION: Approve TAB recommendation. ALTERNATIVES: Defer to Mayor and Council. RESPONSIBLE STAFF:

Donna Abbott, Tourism and Marketing Director

COORDINATED WITH: Greg Shockley, Tourism Advisory Board Chairman ATTACHMENT(S): Bikefest request for TAB allocation

Agenda Item # 5A

Council Meeting May 27, 2014

Page 12: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

1  Revised  5/12  

 

Application  for  Tourism  Development  Grant  

Ocean  City,  Maryland  Tourism  Advisory  Board  

 

Funding  Cycle:                   Date:        

Application  Deadline:  

 

I. Applicant  Profile    a. Organization/Agency:  

   

b. Address:    

 c. Project  Director/Promoter:  

   

d. Phone  Number:    

 e. Email  Address:  

   

f. Source  of  Operating  Funds:  

 

g. Total  Budget  Amount  for  Project:    

 h. Is  your  organization  for  profit  or  non-­‐profit:  

 

 

 

OC  JAMS  LLC  dba  OC  BikeFest  

Owners  Capital  

[email protected]  

262-­‐642-­‐7158  

KATHY  MICHEAL  

W1166  HIDDEN  OAKS  DRIVE,  EAST  TROY,  WI  53120  

March  27,  2014  

profit  

$700,000  w/$70k  inkind  

Page 13: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

2  Revised  5/12  

II. Type  of  Project      X Special  Event    Promotional  DVD/CD    Printed  Material    Co-­‐op  Advertising    Other___________________________    Please  include  your  organizations  specific  project/event  history  including  results,  awards  or  credentials  received.                  

III. Project/Request  Summary  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

a. Narrative  description  of  Project  or  Event  –  Must  include  needs  assessment/purpose  of  project,  project  outline,  and  intended  results.  You  may  also  attach  a  Business  Plan  and  /or  a  power  point  presentation.  

We  are  hosting  a  four-­‐day  motorcycle  event  at  two  locations,  the  OC  Convention  Center  and  the  Inlet  (using  the  Sunfest  setup)  with  a  focus  on  providing  quality  experiences  to  attract  consumers  to  OC  for  extended  stays.    The  experiences  include  national  music  act,  stunt  teams,  vendors,  and  much  more.    Admission  will  be  charged  at  the  Inlet  where  the  musical  acts  will  perform.    The  average  attendee  is  52  years  of  age  and  has  an  annual  income  of  $92k.    Nationally,  motorcyclists  spend  more  money  on  consumables  because  they  typically  don’t  have  space  to  carry  much  on  their  motorcycles.    The  boardwalk  merchants  have  been  pleased  with  the  foot  traffic  as  well.    TAB  funds  will  be  used  to  assist  in  the  marketing  of  the  event  and  to  off  set  cost  of  security  needed  to  provide  a  safe  experience  for  both  the  attendees  and  the  community.    In  2013,  estimated  attendance  was  125k,  an  increase  over  2012.    Our  expectation  is  to  increase  that  number  to  150k,  bringing  in  excess  of  17  million  dollars  to  Ocean  City  in  merchant  revenue.  

b. Dates  of  Event  (if  applicable)  September  11  –  14,  2014  

This  is  the  fourth  year  of  the  event.    The  event  results  have  been  positive  and  earned  media  articles  in  two  national  and  four  regional  motorcycle  magazines  as  we  as  local  publications,  radio  and  television  coverage.      The  number  of  “heads  on  beds”  has  increased  each  year  at  mid  season  rates.    According  to  restaurants/bars  we  have  been  in  contact  with,  some  have  experienced  record  sales  during  the  event.    The  event  also  produces  in  excess  of  $50  for  local  charities.  

Page 14: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

3  Revised  5/12  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

   

IV. Financial  Information  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

d. Anticipated  Room  Nights  generated:  What  steps  (if  any)  have  been  taken  to  collaborate  with  HMRA/hotel  community  for  room  accommodations  and  tracking  method?  We  are  working  with  Susan  Jones,  OCHMRA,  to  evaluate  past  usage  and  establish  methods  to  increase  the  number  of  hotels  participating  in  our  marketing  efforts  as  well  as  increase  the  number  of  nights  per  stay.    By  nature,  when  our  attendees  have  had  a  great  experience  in  a  city,  they  tend  to  return  on  their  own.    We  believe  that  we  will  generate  over  35,000  room  nights  plus  many  rental  units  not  measured  by  OCHMRA.    

Project  Budget  

1. Total  Project  Budget         $700k  +  $70k  inkind  2. Amount  Requested  from  TAB       $35,000  3. Fund  provided  by  Applicant       $200,000  4. Additional  Sponsor  Funds  Leveraged     $150,000  

List  other  funding  sources:  Will  include  vendor  fees,  merchandise  fees,  and  gate  fees  at  the  Inlet.    

 

*Please  attach  a  detailed  budget.  A  budget  is  required  for  all  applications.  

c. Anticipated  visitor  attendance  from  outside  30  mile  radius/other  ROI  or  economic  impact  indicators.      

 Approximately  150k  attendees,  with  100k+  at  the  convention  center  and  30k  at  the  Inlet.  

Page 15: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

4  Revised  5/12  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

All  applicants  must  provide  at  least  3  references  illustrating  applicant’s  history  of  successful  event  production  and  fulfillment  of  financial  obligations.    

OC  JAMS  only  produces  this  one  event,  and  has  done  so  successfully  for  the  past  three  years.    In  2011  and  2012  the  event  reported  a  lost  of  approximately  $183,000  and  was  still  able  to  meet  all  financial  obligations.    In  2013,  all  financial  obligations  were  met  successfully  and  the  event  promoters  experienced  a  small  profit.    OC  JAMS  is  owned  by  Kathy  Micheal,  who  has  owned  and  operated  another  successful  event  management  company  for  17  years.  

Is  your  company  bonded?  __yes_________________  

Collateral  materials  detail  (specify  type  and  number  printed).  Please  attach.  

1.      Rack  brochure      (print  run  150k)                                                    $6,000.00  2.      Rally  Guides  (print  run  30k)                                                                    $14,000.00  3.      4-­‐page  event  guides  (print  run  20k)                                        $0  (earned  media)  4.                                                                                                                                                                            $___________________  

Marketing  promotions  Detail  (focus  on  media  expenditures  outside  of  30  Mile  radius  of  OCMD)  

1.    Trade  Shows                                                                                                                          $7,000.00  2.      Web                                                                                                                                                    $5,000.00  3.      Radio/Television                                                                                                          $25,000.00  4.      Print                                                                                                                                                    $15,000.00  

Other  (please  be  specific)  

1.                                                                                                                                                                            $___________________  2.                                                                                                                                                                            $___________________  3.                                                                                                                                                                            $___________________  4.                                                                                                                                                                            $___________________  

Page 16: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

5  Revised  5/12  

XSignature (Promoter/Project Director)

XSignature (Authorized TAB Administrator)

 

 

Return  Application  to:  Tourism  Advisory  Board    

12320  Ocean  Gateway  Ocean  City,  MD  21842.  Phone:  410-­‐213-­‐0144.  Email:  [email protected]  

Application  Procedures  

1. Contact  Tourism  Advisory  Board  Chair  Melanie  Pursel  for  application  consideration  and  any  questions.  

[email protected]    

410-­‐213-­‐144 Ext.  102    

2. Fill  out  application  and  submit  to  chair.  All  sections  MUST  be  completed.  3. TAB  Chair  will  contact  Applicant  to  schedule  a  presentation  to  the  Board  after  reviewing  and  

rating  the  application.  Applicant  may  receive  additional  question  regarding  application  4. Applicant  will  be  contacted  with  TAB’s  decision.  5. All  awards  are  based  on  funding  availability  and  approval  of  Mayor  and  City  Council.  

Criteria/Selection  

1. All  Projects  must  have  a  detailed  budget  attached,  specifying  the  amount  requested.  2. Projects  will  be  rated  on:  

a. Ability  to  leverage  additional  funds/overall  budget  b. Financial  stability  of  promoter/applicant  c. Economic  impact  d. Target  market  e. Geographic  location  of  event  f. Uniqueness  and  ability  to  attract  visitors  

 

 

 

Page 17: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

5. NEW BUSINESS

B. Request to Sole Source Purchase of Wastewater Grinder presented by Wastewater Superintendent

Page 18: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

TOWN OF

The White Marlin Capital of the World

TO: The Honorable Mayor, Council President and Members of Council THRU: David L. Recor, ICMA-CM, City Manager FROM: Charlie Felin, Wastewater Department Superintendent RE: Sole Source Purchase of Wastewater Grinder DATE: May 5, 2014

ISSUE(S): Improvements to aging wastewater collections system infrastructure

SUMMARY: A replacement grinder is needed at the 2nd St. Pumping Station.

The existing unit has reached the end of its useful life. The grinder is required for screening purposes to protect downstream equipment from damage. Riordan Materials is the manufacturer’s representative for Franklin Miller. We are requesting permission to sole source purchase one (1) Franklin Miller Dimminutor from Riordan Materials.

FISCAL IMPACT: Quote is $38,500.00, including freight. Funding for the unit is

included in the FY 14 budget. RECOMMENDATION: Approve sole source purchase request. ALTERNATIVES: Using emergency by-pass is not recommended long term. RESPONSIBLE STAFF:

Charlie Felin, Wastewater Department Superintendent

COORDINATED WITH: Jim Parsons, Chief Deputy Director of Public Works Randy Bradford, Wastewater Department Asst. Superintendent

ATTACHMENT(S): 1) Memorandum

2) Proposal from Riordan Materials Corp. / Franklin Miller Inc.

Agenda Item # 5B

Council Meeting May 13, 2014

Page 19: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 20: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 21: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

5. NEW BUSINESS

C. Request for Approval of OCPD General Orders presented by Police Chief

1. G.O. 200 P-1 – Personal Relationships (new) 2. G.O. 200 B-1 – General Conduct & Compliance (update) 3. G.O. 400 P-1 – Plain Clothes Operations Guidelines (new) 4. G.O. 800 A-1 – General Appearance Standards (update)

Page 22: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

251662

TOWN OF

The White Marlin Capital of the World

TO: The Honorable Mayor, Council President and Members of Council THRU: David L. Recor, ICMA-CM, City Manager FROM: Ross Buzzuro, Chief of Police RE: Approval of updated Ocean City Police Department General Orders DATE: May 16, 2014

ISSUE(S): Presentation of four (4) policy matters that govern police department operations.

SUMMARY: Two policies have been updated:

G.O. 200 B-1 General Conduct & Compliance with Rules/Regulations G.O. 800 A-1 General Appearance Standards Two new policies are being proposed to address operational and administrative needs within the Department: G.O. 200 P-1 Personal Relationships G.O. 400 P-1 Plain Clothes Operations Guidelines

FISCAL IMPACT: Not applicable RECOMMENDATION: Approve suggested changes to the policies. ALTERNATIVES: No staff alternatives suggested. RESPONSIBLE STAFF: Captain Gregory Guiton

Lieutenant Brian Cardamone

COORDINATED WITH: Guy Ayres, City Solicitor ATTACHMENTS: A draft of each policy in order of presentation, those updated

followed by new policies.

Agenda Item # 5C

Council Meeting May 27, 2014

Page 23: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 24: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 25: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 26: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 27: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 28: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 29: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 30: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 31: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 32: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 33: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 34: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 35: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 36: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 37: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 38: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 39: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 40: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 41: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 42: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 43: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 44: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 45: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 46: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 47: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 48: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 49: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 50: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 51: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 52: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 53: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 54: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 55: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 56: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 57: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 58: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 59: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 60: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda
Page 61: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

WORK SESSION -MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL TUESDAY, MAY 27, 2014

5. NEW BUSINESS

D. West Ocean City EMS Service Report presented by Fire Chief

Page 62: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

TOWN OF

The White Marlin Capital of the World

TO: The Honorable Mayor, Council President and Members of Council THRU: David L. Recor, ICMA-CM, City Manager FROM: Chris Larmore, Fire Chief RE: Analysis of West Ocean City EMS Service DATE: May 21, 2014

ISSUE(S): West Ocean City EMS Service SUMMARY: One of the items listed as high priority on the 2014 Strategic Plan

Policy Agenda is a review of West Ocean City EMS service. This report provides information regarding medical calls for service to the West Ocean City area, past and current totals/statistics/data, and costs related to that service.

FISCAL IMPACT: Not applicable RECOMMENDATION: Not applicable ALTERNATIVES: Not applicable RESPONSIBLE STAFF: Chris Larmore, Fire Chief COORDINATED WITH: Deputy Chief Chuck Barton

Captain Kat Hartley Finance Administrator Martha Bennett

ATTACHMENT(S): Report

Agenda Item # 5D

Council Meeting May 27, 2014

Page 63: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Report for City Manager, Mayor, and City Council

 

EMS Service - West Ocean City

Fire Chief Chris Larmore

March 30, 2014

Page 64: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Executive Summary - This document reviews Emergency Medical Service provided to the West

Ocean City (WOC) area by the Ocean City Fire Department (OCFD). The alternatives to reduce

or expand the service are also provided. While these references are estimates, they should

provide the City Manager and Mayor & City Council (M&CC) with a factual baseline to

determine if the current or modified service is adequate, and funded equitably by Worcester

County.

The OCFD medic unit typically responding to WOC is staffed with three

providers; at least two of which are advanced life support technicians; the third

can be basic level technician. This exceeds the minimum of all other Worcester

EMS units by at least one paramedic.

In 2013, the average time for a unit to arrive in WOC from time of dispatch was 6

minutes 24 seconds.

In 2013, the total EMS call volume for the WOC area was 675. This represents

15.4% of the total EMS calls for service by the Department.

The FY 2013 budget for the Career Division was $7,419,703. The Worcester

County contribution for this EMS service for the same period was $1,181,255,

representing 15.9% of the total budget. (see appendix A for contribution formula)

The estimated annual cost to place one additional medic unit in the WOC area is

estimated to be an additional $1,487,200 after initial startup costs.

The estimated revenue lost to the TOC by no longer responding to the WOC as an

initial response unit is estimated to be $394,552.

The citizenry has been overwhelming supportive of the current arrangement, in

addition to the Authority having Jurisdiction.

Page 65: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

History – Emergency Medical Services has been provided to the residents in WOC by the

staffed ambulance crews since their inception. Initially, service was provided by the Ocean City

Volunteer Fire Company (OCVFC), subsequently by Ocean City Emergency Services, and today

by the OCFD. Provisions made during times of anticipated delayed response such as July 4th,

White Marlin Open, as well as any extended closure of the Route 50 Bridge, OCFD staffed units

have been temporarily placed at the fire house located on Keyser Point Road, owned and

operated by the OCVFC. A significant change was made in 2010/2011 when staffing was

increased to three providers on the ambulance to mirror the corporate limits change. At the same

time, the decision was made to decrease the response from the career personnel on “silent fire

alarms” in WOC. Please note, there has not been a single documented complaint regarding the

EMS service by the citizenry, to the knowledge of both the current Fire Chief, and EMS Deputy

Chief of the OCFD. The WOC overall response area has been decreased over the years, because

the Berlin Fire Company has expanded their “first due areas” under the County’s Box Area

Assignments. The TOC typically keeps an unstaffed ambulance at the firehouse located on

Keyser Point Road for the use of the OCVFC.

This report was an included initiative in the Town of Ocean City’s Strategic Master Plan.

Page 66: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Call Volume – The EMS calls generated in the WOC area have become fairly consistent over

the last 3 years as noted in the outline below. The total calls for EMS service have been from

668 – 678 over the last three years, representing 14.08 to 15.40% of the Department’s total EMS

call volume.

Service Baseline – The OCFD provides advanced medical service to the residents of WOC, via

an ambulance with a 3 person crew, consisting of two advanced life support technicians and one

basic level technician. The remainder of Worcester County, as well as a large number of

departments nationwide, staff a medic unit with two providers. (Several Departments in

Worcester County staff with one primary provider, and rely on an on-call volunteer driver.)

Ocean City Fire Department

Emergency Medical Services Call Volume (Calls)

Call Location/Year

Within Ocean City 4,026 84.83% 4,057 84.68% 3,665 83.64%

West Ocean City 668 14.08% 678 14.15% 675 15.40%

Delaware 31 0.65% 34 0.71% 33 0.75%

Out of District in MD 21 0.44% 22 0.46% 9 0.21%

Total: 4,746 100.00% 4,791 100.00% 4,382 100.00%

2011 2012 2013

Page 67: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Response Times - The average response time from dispatch to the location of the call in 2013

for the WOC area was 6 minutes and 24 seconds.

NFPA 1720 references in numerous sections, the “Authority having Jurisdiction” (AHJ), to

determine the level of service. NFPA 1720 references a fractile of 8 minutes travel time from

dispatch 90% of the time. There are not specific references to areas outside of the municipality,

providing the primary service. With an impeccable history of citizenry approval, as well as the

approval of the AHJ, the current level of service is acceptable. There was a considerable effort

and exhaustive time to make comparisons within the remainder of Worcester County response

times. Because of a difference in both software systems, as well as protocols, this was deemed

highly improbable.

Mean (Average) Response Time Fractile, 90%All EMS Calls In-Town West OC All Calls In-Town West OC

2011 4:16 3:51 6:40 7:21 6:16 9:462012 4:25 4:04 6:20 7:23 6:37 9:392013 4:23 3:59 6:24 7:16 6:18 9:38

Mean (Average) Response Time: Calculated from time of unit dispatch to the arrival of the first-arriving unit.

Fractile time:Calculated from time of unit dispatch to the arrival of the first-arriving unit.Fractile (90%) means a unit was on the scene 90% of the time in X minutes or less.

Page 68: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Cost of Current Service – In FY ‘13 the TOC received $1,181,255 from the County toward an

overall budget of $7,419,703. This represents a 15.9% contribution, excluding billed services.

FY '11 FY '12 FY '13

Salaries & Wages 4,381,173 4,378,131 4,475,772Employee Benefits 2,001,399 2,029,726 2,107,512Professional Services 42,770 30,607 43,619Repair/Maintenance 38,452 39,612 42,565Rentals 500 4,550Communications 25,946 26,226 18,720Other Purchased Services 38,470 31,314 32,548General Supply 238,090 238,123 254,767Energy 26,270 22,513 25,500Vehicle Supply/Repair 165,811 210,571 204,606Capital Outlay 20,740Intragovernmental 212,743 238,255 209,544Depreciation 51,500 40,008

Total Operating Expenses

7,222,624 7,306,326 7,419,703

Average of 2011-2013

7,316,218

1% 2%

Revenue:EMS Service Fees: 1,259,055 1,314,000 1,098,690Mileage Charges: 278,145 293,429 244,210Total Service Fees: 1,537,200 1,607,429 1,342,900

Recognized Billing Revenue: 822,328 760,421 923,718

Worcester County FundingParamedic funding 210,000 210,000 180,000Ambulance funding 90,000 90,000 90,000

24/7 Coverage 30,000 30,000 30,000745,999 889,908 881,255

1,075,999 1,219,908 1,181,255

* Services Fees Billed Detail

FY '11 FY '12 FY '13

In Town 879,535 931,190 769,130Out of Town 379,520 382,810 329,560

1,259,055 1,314,000 1,098,69070% | 30% 71% | 29% 70% | 30%

Note: Mileage charges cannot be segregated by call location.Collections: Approximately 55% of In Town billing is collected. Approximately 50% of Out of Town billing is collected.

OCFD Career Division-Costs & Revenue

Percent Difference Year-to-Year

Percentage In Town/Out of Town:

Service Reimbursement

Operating Expenses:

Page 69: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Cost to Increase Service – Should the AHJ request the TOC to staff a medic unit in WOC, it

may add an additional annual expense of approximately $1,487,200, after the County

contribution of $75,000. Initial startup cost could be estimated at $358,615. Note that, if the

AHJ decides the additional service warrants the cost, it may pose an imparity to the remainder of

the residents and Fire Companies in the County.

Detailed breakdown of annual costs as well as startup cost provided in Appendix

B & C

FY '13

Salaries & Wages 4,475,772Employee Benefits 2,107,512Professional Services 43,619Repair/Maintenance 42,565Rentals 4,550Communications 18,720Other Purchased Services 32,548General Supply 254,767Energy 25,500Vehicle Supply/Repair 204,606Capital OutlayIntragovernmental 209,544Depreciation

Total Operating Expenses

7,419,7037,419,7031,562,2008,981,903

Worcester County FundingParamedic funding 180,000$ Ambulance funding 90,000$

24/7 Coverage 30,000$ 881,255$

1,181,255$ 1,181,25575,000

1,256,255

Additional annual cost to budget 1,562,200-75,000

1,487,200

Additional annual cost to budget

Additional Wor. Co. funding for EMS unit/personnel

OCFD Operational Costs With Staffing In WOC

Less, additional Wor. Co. funding for EMS unit/personnel

Operating Expenses:

Service Reimbursement

Page 70: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Cost to Decrease Service – If the TOC were to discontinue EMS service to WOC, it may result

in a loss ($394,552) in overall revenue, based on the current formula utilized by the County.

 

Effect of Providing No EMS Service to West Ocean City

FY 2013 Budget Without WOC With Marginal Cost ReductionSalaries & Wages 4,475,772 -89,792 4,385,980Employee Benefits 2,107,512 2,107,512Professional Services 43,619 43,619Repair/Maintenance 42,565 42,565Rentals 4,550 4,550Communications 18,720 18,720Other Purchased Services 32,548 -280 32,548General Supply 254,767 -12,017 242,750Energy 25,500 25,500Vehicle Supply/Repair 204,606 -28,645 175,961Capital OutlayIntergovernmental 209,544 209,544Depreciation

7,419,703 -130,734 7,289,249Reduction: -1.76%

Marginal Cost Reduction: 130,734

Revenue Changes:Decrease WOC Billing Revenue (Est): (164,780) <-Collections estimated at 50% of Out-of-Town BillingDecrease Wor. Co. Grant Funding (Est): (360,506)Total Gain (Loss) of Revenue: (525,286)

Net Gain (Loss) to the Town: (394,552)

Page 71: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Appendix A 

 

 

 

 

 

Worcester County Emergency Service Funding

The amount Worcester County provides to ambulance services for transport of patient to a hospital per calendar year is broken down as follows:

Transport to hospital within city limits $187 Transport to hospital outside city limits $748 Non-transports $187 Mileage Supplement: A mileage supplement is paid for transports >25 miles @ 0.505/mile. For Ocean City, transports to AGH do not qualify. The mileage supplement applies to transports to PRMC and Beebe. Paramedic provider (Per Full-time provider) $5000 Ambulance (Per Ambulance) $10,000 24/7 Service $30,000

Page 72: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Appendix B 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ambulance(model) 255,000$

Ambulance EquipmentBackboards (2) 2 @ 180$ 360$ Bags; Drug 200$ Cardiac Monitor Defibrillator 33,000$ Engle Cooler 800$ Fluid Warmer 575$ KED 380$ MCT CF 53 4,800$ MCT Dock 800$ Narc Safe 1,500$ Pediatric 750$ Portable Suction 1,400$ Power load system 18,500$ Power Stretcher 15,000$ Sager Splint 500$ Scoop Stretcher 695$ Scott SCBA (2) 2 @ 8,000$ 16,000$ Spinal Straps set 125$ Splint Kit 300$ Stair Chair 7,500$ Trauma 180$ Water Rescue can, rope 250$ Subtotal 103,615$

Total 358,615$

OCFD Ambulance and Equipment Costs

Page 73: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Appendix C 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

One Medic Unit, 3 personnel 24 hrs/day x 365 days/yr = 8760 hours/year

Full time employee works 48 hrs/wk x 39 weeks + 36 hrs/wk x 13 weeks = 2340 hours/year

Preliminary Staffing Factor = 8760 = 3.742340

2340Vacation time 3.19 wks = 143.78Holiday time 12 x 8 hrs = 96Personal time 2 x 8 hrs = 16Sick time 12 x 8 hrs = 96Net Hours Employee Available 1988.22

Total hours/year for 3 positions 8760 = 4.41Net Hours Employee Available 1988

One Medic Crew 3 @ 4.41 = 13.22 13

hours/year

hours/year

(8784 in a Leap Year)

Total Number of Employees Needed to Fill 3 Positions

Current Average Length of Annual Time Off

(positions)

Full Time Employees for One Position

Staffing for a West Ocean City EMS Unit

Full time employees

Page 74: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda

Appendix C continued: 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

PersonnelSalary 58,462$ Benefit package 29,216$ Hiring to Road Costs 20,017$ Subtotal 107,695$

Staffing Factor 3 Providers x 24/7 13 employees1,400,030$

New Ambulance 358,615$ Vehicle Lease 21,250$ Equipment Cost 103,615$ Insurance

124,865$

Building Costs 149,219$ 25% 37,305$

1,562,200$

Cost of Staffing West Ocean City

Additional cost to annual budget

Page 75: May 27 2014 Complete Agenda