LIS 677 Interface Critique LIS 677 Presented by Blanca Polo.
Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
-
Upload
butlerspicks -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
1/25
Assignment 3 Needs Assessment of Moses Cone Health
System Libraries
Group 2:Kyle Butler
Mark ColtrainMimi Smith-DeCoster
Ashanti WhiteAnthony Chow
LIS 650
May 27, 2011
Table of ContentsEXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3INTRODUCTION 3METHODS 6RESULTS 9CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS 23
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
2/25
STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE NEEDS ASSESSMENT EXPERIENCE 24 WORKS CITED
APPENDICES 26
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
3/25
I. Executive SummaryGroup 2 performed a needs assessment of Moses Cone Health System (MCHS) Libraries
located in Greensboro, North Carolina. This included libraries at three hospitals: Moses Cone,
Wesley Long and the Womens Hospital of Greensboro. According to their website, Moses Coneis the major health care system in Guilford, Randolph, Rockingham and Alamance counties in
the Triad of North Carolina. Leslie Mackler, MLIS, is Director of the Moses Cone Medical
Libraries and was our main contact and source of information regarding the MCHS Libraries.
She has worked for MCHS in various capacities for over thirty years and is currently based at the
Moses Cone Library. Her staff includes two full-time librarians: Peggy Wynn, MLIS, at Wesley
Long Hospital and Laura Enyon, MLIS, at the Womens Hospital.We decided a combination of interviews with the librarians and a survey of the patrons
at all locations would be the most prudent approach to this assessment. Kyle Butler and Mimi
Smith-DeCoster interviewed Mackler in-person at Moses Cone and we also emailed an
abbreviated version of the questions we asked Mackler to Enyon and Wynn. The interviewswere a success with 100% participation and thoughtful answers to our questions. The surveys
were a slightly different story.
According to Mackler in one of our initial email exchanges, Walk-in traffic in Cone
Library averages 100-150 a day, Womens averages 25 a day, less for Wesley. The number of
patrons accessing the librarys resources online is undetermined. Patrons range from physicians
and nurses to non-clinical staff, EMTs, patients and patients families. All three libraries had a
combined gate count number of 40,000 in 2010 (Mackler, Personal Interview). We received a
total of nineteen responses to our survey: ten completed the online version and nine
completed the paper version. Nineteen is actually misleading number because, according to
Qualtrics, while nineteen surveys were started only seventeen were actually completed. We
believe the major reason for the low participation was the fact that the MCHS Libraries werealso participating in a National Library of Medicine/UNC-Chapel Hill research project, which
included an online survey on the value of hospital libraries, at the same time we were
collecting data for our survey (Mackler, library survey). Despite the potential confusion, Mackler
agreed to post a link to our survey on the MCHS Librarys website and all three librarians posted
flyers at their libraries promoting our survey along with making paper copies of the survey
available for patrons.Results of the survey were mixed. The handful of responses we received gave us the
smallest of snapshots of the pace of life at the MCHS Libraries. While not enough to determine
if they are raving fans (we speculate that they are), the patrons who answered certainly
represented a relatively wide swath as far as demographics go. Either way, it is apparent thatMackler, Wynn and Enyon are doing something right in each of their respective hospital
libraries.II. Introduction
Moses Cone Health System, or MCHS, was founded in 1911 by a trust established by
Berth Lindau Cone (mosescone.com, History). Since that time, the system has become a multi-
hospital system that consists of LeBauer HealthCare, Penn Nursing Center, Moses Cone
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
4/25
MedCenter-High Point, and Moses Cone MedCenter-Kernersville among other facilities
(mosescone.com, History). Moses Cone is a not-for-profit system but remains a premier North
Carolina healthcare institution. In fiscal year 2007, it was the fourth busiest hospital in North
Carolina when it comes to heart catheterizations (mosescone.com, History). According to their
website, MCHS supports patients in Guilford County, Randolph County, and other areas in the
Piedmont. With more than 7,400 employees, the system provides in- and outpatient servicesthat range from neonatal care to bypass surgery and cancer treatment (mosescone.com, About
Us). As a part of the Greensboro Area Health Education Center, Moses Cone Health System
provides students and doctors access to the latest developments in medical care.Moses Cone Health System Library is designed to the educational and informational
needs of the medical staff, employees, patients and families of the Moses Cone Health System,
the community, and the health care providers in the Greensboro AHEC region. Like the
healthcare system it supports, the library actually has three locationsin the Moses H. Cone
Memorial Hospital, Wesley Long Community Hospital, and Womens Hospital of Greensboro
(gahec.org, Library Services). An amalgamation of a special and academic library, the MHCS
Library System provides services designed to aid in the research process. Reference questions
can be conducted in-person or online through email and chat (gahec.org, Library Services).The library subscribes to numerous databases, such as DermIs: Atlas of Dermatology
and Health Services/Technology Assessment Text (HSTAT), which are available free of charge
through the librarys website (gahec.org, Journals). Other databases are available, and MCHS
Library professionals can assist or perform literature searches for MCHS and AHEC affiliated
staff and to agencies located within the Greensboro AHEC region (gahec.org, Library Services).
Search services are free for staff, residents, interns and North Carolina Libraries. Literature
services for businesses, special libraries, and students at other institutions will be charged a
minimum fee of $75 (gahec.org, Outreach). Affiliated individuals can request books. MCHS
managers can also request the table of contents of each issue of selected journals (gahec.org,
Outreach). Additionally, the library provides interlibrary loans, personal book orders, andinstruction for end-user searching.III. MethodsDesign
The methods of data collection were tailored to suit the time limitations of various
library constituencies and the level of information that was deemed appropriate to collect from
them. A face-to-face meeting of approximately 45 minutes was conducted with Leslie Mackler,
the director of the Moses Cone/AHEC library system. Given the work schedules of the two
hospital branch librarians, Peggy Wynn and Laura Eynon, their input was solicited by way of anemail-based interview, consisting of open-ended questions of a qualitative nature. Patrons
were invited to participate in an online survey conducted through Qualtrics, and paper surveys
were also made available. The online survey was made available through a link on the librarys
website and by way of flyers placed in the library.Exploratory research employed the resources provided on the Moses Cone Librarys
website. Based on communication with Leslie Mackler, it was decided that a needs assessment
should include not only the Moses Cone Hospital Library, but also the libraries of the Womens
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
5/25
Hospital and Wesley Long Hospital, as the three hospitals actually operate as a unified system
rather than autonomous entities.The patron-directed survey was designed to address library services and resources,
while the questions for the librarians focused more on institutional missions and goals,
administrative interactions, but also on patron needs.Subjects
Given the limited time available, Team 2 elected not to seek approval from the
University of Greensboros Institutional Review Board. Instead, it was made clear to librarians
at the AHEC libraries and any patrons electing to participate in the patron survey that all data
collected was to be used solely for the purposes of a class project and not for publication or
further research. This was deemed satisfactory by the director of the AHEC libraries. In addition,
all patron survey responses are entirely anonymous.Due to time overlap with an unrelated survey, this survey was not distributed by email.
As a result, an accurate count of potential responses compared to actual responses cannot be
made.Demographics
The Greensboro AHEC system employs approximately 7,400 medical professionals.
Other patron groups for the AHEC libraries include medical students, patients and families of
patients, and the general community. Patron participants in the survey were asked to indicate
their relationship with the library and/or role in relation to the hospital system. See the results
section for a statistical breakdown of participant roles.Instrumentation
Data collection began with email communication with Leslie Mackler, defining the scope
and depth of the needs assessment and arranging logistics. Data was ultimately collected via 1)
an in-person meeting with Leslie Mackler; 2) email-based surveys with the Laura Eynon and
Peggy Wynn, the librarians of the Womens Hospital and Wesley Long Hospital libraries,
respectively; and 3) Email and paper surveys of patrons (content of the email and paper surveys
was identical).
Data Analysis and PresentationGiven the largely qualitative nature of the survey, responses were evaluated with
relation to services used, services desired, frequency of use, and demographic within the user
base. Qualtrics reports were used to represent and interpret the data.Design Limitation
In the real world, there is always room for improvement. In an ideal world, this needs
assessment would have been timed to not conflict with another survey related to the
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
6/25
Greensboro AHEC libraries, thus allowing for email contact to hospital employees. A longer
period of survey availability would have also aided in soliciting more responses. While some
paper surveys were provided, making them more available and advertised would have further
increased their effectiveness.Conversely, it is evident that the concise survey format and simplified questions were
convenient for respondents as only two surveys were started but not completed. The medicallibrarians were of great help in publicizing the survey but given a more generous data collection
time period, both investigators and librarians could have been more successful in informing
patrons of the needs assessment process and survey.IV. Results
Our results paint a fascinating portrait of the types of challenges the MCHCS Libraries
overcome or attempt to overcome daily in addition to the many goals and missions that they
already get right. According to Mackler, the Moses Cone libraries have challenges common to
many libraries: budget challengesthere are challenges getting people to use information.
Theres using the information we provide, I should say, the information resources we provide,because, you know, everythings on Google. There are challenges approving ROI [Return on
Investment] (Mackler, Personal Interview). And some not as common to other libraries,
Theres just challenges in a big corporation when youre in a not for profit department in a for
profit organization, getting some of the things done that you need to get done (Mackler).Mackler also says that so far, despite the sluggish economy, budget has not been as
much of an issue for the Moses Cone Libraries, but adds that she has been doing more group
purchasing with consortiumgetting more bang for our buck. She also adds experience to her
arsenal of dealing with challenges: In terms of running through politics here, because Ive been
here so long, I just try to navigate the system. Always have a plan A, B, and C.As far as Moses Cones primary goals or functions, Mackler says that, Our mission is to
support the organization and the organizations goals. She goes on to say that she and herstaff fulfill it by, providing what people need and hopefully pushing information out until they
realize its there. This measured not only by regular stats but also by satisfaction surveys
available to patrons. Mackler says of these, weve had some really good satisfaction surveys in
terms of results so I think were meeting a lot of those needs.In addition to the satisfaction surveys and day-to-day statistics, Mackler says the
libraries participate in another biennial survey called a P & P survey, its what people would
prefer to see and how we carry it out. The Moses Cone Librariesalso participate in national
benchmarking which, according to Mackler, is currently very popular in healthcare. The
libraries also participate in the Medical Library Associations benchmarking process. Even when
the libraries are not participating in assessments, Mackler stays hard at work analyzing the datashe collects for the libraries internal quality indicators. The trends she extracts from this data
go into quarterly reports.Mackler also discussed how Moses Cones patrons interact with the libraries resources
has changed in that people do not physically come into the libraries as much as they did at one
time. She and her staff handle much more telephone and electronic reference now than ever
before. She also added that the rise of search engines like Google has a lot to do with how
many patrons they see these days. She also added that a consequence of Google is that while
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
7/25
patrons can find simple information on their own more and more, the difficulty of the libraries
reference questions has increased, so the librarians spend as much time doing research now
than ever before.Still, no matter what, patron feedback is important to Mackler and her staff
and she says, depending on the nature of the feedback, they try to be as responsive as possible
to requests for materials and fixes to problems.As far as the ideal library, Mackler says she would invest in more electronic resources
(databases, software and hardware), replace old books and pay the staff more. She also says
she would like to redesign the website to make it more functional and hire a librarian to do
outreach. Despite not being as close to its ideal state as it could be, Mackler is very positive
about the MCHCS Libraries within the context of the hospital: This librarys in a good place.
And I think the value, particularly in the past few years that weve been able to bring to our
services, and the institution, and the people that work here, is recognized. We get invited to
committees, we get invited to MISUs, and we get invited to put things on the intranet. So I feel
pretty good about that.Still, Mackler does not take the libraries position for granted, adding, But, you know,
all it takes is one new administrator saying I dont want it and thats the end of it. Its what
happened to a friend of mine, and its what happened to one of our new librarians.Peggy Wynn and Laura Enyon also discussed challenges for their particular libraries,
Wesley Long and the Womens Hospital, respectively. Both libraries are smaller in size and cater
to a smaller population than Moses Cone but demographics are largely the same as Moses
Cone. Wynn and Enyon said their biggest challenge to overcome is marketing and outreach, or,
letting staff and patients know the library is there to helpbased on this sentiment, it appears
creating raving fans is often in the forefront of their minds (Wynn and Enyon, E-mail
interviews). Wynn participates in new employee orientation classes and gets out and makes
rounds to promote the library by word of mouth. Enyon gets out and interacts with staff as
well but both are limited in this type of outreach by time constraints for themselves and their
patrons.Wynn said the best measure of success for her was her regular collection and use of
statistics, which Enyon echoed. Both discussed adhering to their mission by assisting their
particular patrons as best they can by staying up-to-date on information, technology trends and
other related subjects.Wynns statement from her interview on how Wesley Longs patrons interact with the
librarys resources bears repeating as it is extremely well put and indicative of a larger trend
across all three libraries:Many of the services and resources are accessed online or through email.
Because there is limited face to face contact, it is still important to do a good
reference interview and often I have several email exchanges prior to a literaturesearch. Patrons often just ignore information they do not think is useful rather
than letting you know more specifically what they need. Patrons appreciate
prompt service and response to their needs.The same goes for Enyons statement:I feel like my experience with how my patrons use and interact is a very personal
one. Because we are such a small hospital, I know my patrons. So, I can tweak
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
8/25
searches in ways I know they will appreciate. Which just makes them look upon
the library that much more favorably.
Patron SurveyOur ten-question survey was available for ten days, March 23 through April 1, 2011.
Mackler had a link posted on the Moses Cone Libraries web page for patrons to access the
online survey. We used the web-based Qualtrics survey program. We also printed paper
surveys and made them available at each library. As was explained in the Executive Summary,
we had a total of seventeen responses to our survey: eight online and nine in-person.
1. How would you classify your position?
# Answer Response %1 Physician 2 13%2 Nurse 5 33%3 Paraprofessional 1 7%4 Patient 0 0%5 Other (please specify) 7 47%
Total 15 100%Other (please specify)Serviceradiology technologistEMTEMT
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
9/25
Statistic ValueMin Value 1Max Value 5Mean 3.33Variance 2.81Standard Deviation 1.68Total Responses 15
2. Which of these libraries do you use most frequently?
# Answer Response %1 Moses Cone 5 33%2 Wesley Long 6 40%3 Women's Hospital 0 0%4 I Use Only The Library's Online Resources 4 27%
Total 15 100%Statistic ValueMin Value 1Max Value 4Mean 2.20Variance 1.46Standard Deviation 1.21
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
10/25
Total Responses 15
3. Which of these library services do you use? (Check all that apply)
# Answer Response %1 Live Chat/Ask a Librarian 0 0%2 Online Databases 6 43%3 In-person help 4 29%4 Computer Workstations 6 43%5 Print Journals 4 29%6 Books 4 29%7 None of these (please list the ones you do use) 2 14%None of these (please list the ones you do use)Statistic ValueMin Value 2Max Value 7Total Responses 14
4. How often do you use in-person library services or resources? (check all that apply and
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
11/25
please list resources accordingly, such as: in-person help, computers, journals, or books)
#
Answer
Response
%
1 Daily 0 0%2 2-3 Times a Week 5 33%3 Once a Week 2 13%4 2-3 Times a Month 2 13%5 Once a Month 1 7%6 Less than Once a Month 3 20%9 Never 3 20%
Daily 2-3 Times aWeek Once aWeek 2-3 Times aMonth Once aMonth Less than Once aMonth
Statistic ValueMin Value 2Max Value 9Total Responses 15
5. How often do you use online library resources? (check all that apply and please list
resources accordingly, such as: online chat, online databases, other resources through library
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
12/25
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
13/25
Statistic ValueMin Value 1Max Value 2Mean 1.77Variance 0.19Standard Deviation 0.44Total Responses 13
7. If you answered yes to the previous question, were your difficulties resolved?# Answer Response %1 Yes (please explain) 2 40%2 No (please explain) 3 60%
Total 5 100%Yes (please explain) No (please explain)Lack of computer knowledge was the reason I need in
person assistance. unable to find information ondrugs/side effectsLinks are ClearJust good with computers
Statistic ValueMin Value 1Max Value 2Mean 1.60Variance 0.30Standard Deviation 0.55Total Responses 5
8. What services would you like to see at your library that are not already provided?Text Responsespecific for oncology
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
14/25
Statistic ValueTotal Responses 1
9. What would you say are your primary reasons for not using medical library services orresources? (Check all that apply)# Answer Response %1 Do not have the time 2 33%2 Not aware of services/ resources in general 0 0%3 Not aware of specific services/resources 1 17%4 Inconvenient library hours 1 17%5 Inconvenient library location 0 0%6 Library resources not relevant to my needs 3 50%7 No need, resources available elsewhere 0 0%Statistic ValueMin Value 1Max Value 6Total Responses 6
10. How can your library better align existing services or resources to meet your expectationsand/or needs?Text ResponseConnect with other communities for access like UNC Chapel Hill.Statistic ValueTotal Responses 1
These results are straightforward. User demographics are mixed between physicians,
nurses, and support staff. Of those surveyed, few had difficulties, and those problems appear to
have been resolved. Equally interesting is the wide range of services rendered, the frequency of
use, and the types of access. As Wynn and Enyon note, many of the libraries patrons log on to
workstations for personal use: email, online banking, etc. and we think our results definitely
have shades of that, as well. While we cannot say for sure, those surveyed could very well be
raving fans since there are so few problems reportedthe two that stand out are making
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
15/25
resources more specific to oncology and connecting with other communities for access like
UNC Chapel Hill. Mackler appears to be working on the latter with her consortia work.
Outreach from all three librarians seems successful; only one person was unaware of
specific library resources. However, it would be interesting to conduct the survey again with a
longer window of time for patrons to complete it, more advertising of the survey (perhaps with
some incentives) and promoting it during a period when no other surveys are beingconductedespecially during times of surveys that are much more official than a graduate
school class project! The results are revealing but with only fifteen responses, we can only
deduce so much. An extensive study indicative of the forty thousand patrons that visited the
libraries and the undetermined amount of online users would offer more thorough results.V. Conclusion & Recommendations
The Moses Cone Health Care System Libraries at Moses Cone Hospital, Wesley Long
Hospital and the Womens Hospital of Greensboro all appear to be maintaining as healthy a
population of patrons as to be expected in 2011. The librarians are proactive in communicating
with patrons in regards to their complaints and meeting patron needs. The librarians appear tobe keeping up with current trends in medical librarianship; they collect and analyze statistics on
a regular basis in addition to participating in internal and wider-spread benchmarking processes
to maintain national standards.
Our group recommends that the librarians continue to do what theyre doing: listening
and paying attention to their users in thoughtful ways. We also recommend that librarians
continue to explore ways to, as Mackler says, get more bang for their buck through various
areas like accessing electronic resources through consortia and cultivating other partnerships
with medical and research libraries.
The fact that the library has such small staff appears to be an asset in the sense that all
are so dedicated to hospital patrons, research and current library trends but, as Mackler points
out, another potentially tech-savvy librarian dedicated solely to outreach for all three librarieswould be ideal. Since the libraries have yet to suffer from major budgetary setbacks, perhaps it
would be prudent for Mackler to compose a 1-, 3- and 5-year plan in which she could, based on
the wealth of stats she and her staff collect along with anecdotal evidence, prove to hospital
administrators that another position is essential to the librarys continued success especially in
light of the fact that the move of many patrons to Google-influenced online resources is an
obvious and potentially detrimental shift.VI. Strengths and Weaknesses of the Needs Assessment Experience
Overall, this needs assessment project turned out to be an enjoyable endeavor. However, there
were definitely some aspects of the assignment that we could have handled differently. One ofthe areas that we might have done a better job with involved the distribution of the written
surveys. We did get some responses, but unfortunately not as many as we hoped for in order to
get a better representation of library users. One idea might have been to take an afternoon or
two and hand out some written surveys to the patrons at Moses Cone Library. Its possible this
would not have made a great deal of difference, but sometimes people are more willing to fill
out surveys when the papers are personally handed to them, rather than just sitting on a table.
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
16/25
Additionally, we were a little more time-constrained than we would have liked, but had we
been able to get the surveys out a bit sooner then we might have gotten more responses for
our data sample.Despite these minor drawbacks, the pros far outweighed the cons when working on this needs
assessment. Despite the fact that our group was not based in one centralized location, we wereable to successfully complete the project thanks to frequent and productive correspondence.
The assistance we received from the librarians at Moses Cone, Womens Hospital, and Wesley
Long was enormously beneficial on this project. Leslie Mackler was particularly helpful, taking
time out of her busy schedule to sit down for a recorded interview, plus providing quick
responses to the numerous e-mails we sent out over the past several weeks. In addition to
Mackler, we also got wonderful responses from Peggy Wynn and Laura Enyon, whose
perspectives helped mold our understanding of the critical issues and challenges facing medical
libraries today.
Works Cited"About Us." Moses Cone Health System. Moses Cone Health System, 2011. Web. 25 Apr. 2011."About Us: Library Services." Moses Cone Health System Library. Greensboro Area Health
Education Center, n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011."About Us: Outreach Services." Moses Cone Health System Library. Greensboro Area Health
Education Center, n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011.Enyon, Laura. E-mail interview. 6 Apr. 2011.
"History." Moses Cone Health System. Moses Cone Health System, 2011. Web. 25 Apr. 2011.
"Journals." Moses Cone Health System Library. Greensboro Area Health Education Center, n.d.
Web. 25 Apr. 2011.
"Library Services." Moses Cone Health System Library. Greensboro Area Health Education
Center, n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2011.Mackler, Leslie. "library survey." Message to Mark Coltrain. 14 Mar. 2011. E-mail.
Mackler, Leslie. "Needs Assessment." Message to Mark Coltrain. 1 Mar. 2011. E-mail.
Mackler, Leslie. Personal interview. 23 Mar. 2011.
Wynn, Peggy. E-mail interview. 6 Apr. 2011.
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
17/25
VII. AppendicesLeslie Mackler InterviewKYLE: Alright, what is your title, and how long have you been a librarian at Moses Cone?LESLIE: My title is Director of Medical Library. I like to think of it more as Director of the Moses
Cone Health System Library, but officially its the medical library. And Ive been here over 30
years, in a variety of capacities.
KYLE: Ok. Describe some of the major challenges the Moses Cone libraries regularly encounter,
and what are some examples of how youve overcome those challenges?MIMI: We can start with what the challenges areLESLIE: Well, there are all sorts of challenges. There are budget challengesthere are challenges
getting people to use information. Theres using the information we provide, I should say, the
information resources we provide, because, you know, everythings on Google. There are
challenges approving ROI. Were lucky here, I dont have space challenges, but I know a lot of
people who do. And theres just challenges in a big corporation when youre in a not for profit
department in a for profit organization, getting some of the things done that you need to get
done.
KYLE: OK, how have you been able to overcome some of those challenges, if you can think of
any?LESLIE: Well with budget I try to fly under the radar. And so far, everyones getting budget cuts,
but we havent had any budget cuts, which has been very good. Weve been working on doing
more group purchasing with consortium, so were working on getting more bang for our buck.
In terms of running through politics here, because Ive been here so long, I just try to navigatethe system. Always have a plan A, B, and C.
MIMI: Well that in a way speaks to your experience here. If someone just came in here
tomorrow, they would have no way of knowing how to navigate all that.
LESLIE: Well you do get some bruised kneecaps, so it plays both ways.
KYLE: Were actually gonna skip ahead a little bit because weve already alluded to it, but to
what extent are the current economic conditions affecting the library?LESLIE: Well, you know, when journals go up 8% every year, and you have to cut back, and
databases expenses are constantly going up, and I know that I cant present a budget thats that
high every year, so you have to make tough choices. As I said, we join a consortium so wereable to purchase more things by group purchasing. Now some of our expenses have really
decreased, in some cases we dont use half the supplies we used to. I dont have to worry about
catalog cards and that kind of stuff. And also, when we hire people, they expect to have a living
wage.
MIMI: I wanted to ask, you said something about flying under the radarhow do you mean?
LESLIE: Well what I mean is that Im not going to present a budget every year thats 10% above
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
18/25
what it was so I try to keep it below increase. Sometimes I can even make a decrease in case
they need to buy big things, like robots for the OR.
KYLE: Just generally, if you could, describe your patrons that you have here.LESLIE: Well physicians, nurses, allied health. Were also open to the public. We do get patient
families. Because of the number of people going back to school we get people also, maybeemployees going back to school getting their RN or bachelors or masters, so we have a lot of
that.
MIMI: What about empathizing with patients?LESLIE: Well if someone comes in thats gotten a horrible diagnosis, you take time with them.
You dont just give them a medical textbook. And actually for any level of health care
professional we try and get them the information they need that they can understand. I guess
also in our situation we get a number of physicians who are stressed, they have a patient and
they have one who maybe had a bad outcome, and we have to work with that and not take it
personally when theyre making certain demands.
MIMI: Thats where I was going to go with it next. Because sometimes people have complaints
and I guess you just addressed how it is when people have some issue with what services
are/arent provided.
LESLIE: I guess that could be a piece of it. Also in this particular environment you find a lot of
people who are stressed. Some physicians arent getting reimbursed, or are in a time crunch,
they cant spend the time with certain patients and so sometimes that plays out with how they
treat other people.
MIMI: We have addressed this some, but could you talk a little bit about your annual budget
and whether its increased or decreased over this past year?
LESLIE: Weve been fortunate. Ive been able to get the budget I requested. And, as I said, I
dont do major increases. In fact, this year I was able to say Well, were not buying a lot of
something, and just shift things out. We have a line-item budget here so everything supplies is
on one line. Books and journals are all on one line here. And then e-resources are on another
line. And everything has to be justified. Each item is written outwhy do we want a particular
item, etc.
KYLE: Are there any particular materials that get priority here at the library?LESLIE: Journals.
KYLE: Moving forward, what sorts of changes do you foresee at the library in the years to
come?LESLIE: Well it wouldnt surprise me if we had a smaller space. Mostly the kinds of things were
trying to deliver now are at point of care. So those are the kinds of products were looking
atthe kinds of services were trying to provide. And, were trying to do a lot more with
embedding librarians into hospital committees so that people get to know us because they
dont have to come here. Were also moving outside. Were doing more things with knowledge
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
19/25
management within the organization. Weve got someone who works on the system-wide
intranet. Were doing lots of other things, as Im sure every librarian is.
MIMI: Ok, so describe what you think is the best part of your job.LESLIE: As a hospital librarian, I get to do a little bit of everything, and I like that. I love doing
program planning.thinking of things to do and coming up with new ideas.KYLE: What would you say is your librarys mission, and how does your staff fulfill it?LESLIE: Well our mission is to support the organization and the organizations goals. How do we
fulfill it? Hopefully by providing what people need and hopefully pushing information out until
they realize that its there. And actually, we get satisfaction surveys and weve had some really
good satisfaction surveys in terms of results so I think were meeting a lot of those needs.MIMI: How do you, in particular, and the staff, in general, measure the librarys successes or
shortcomings?LESLIE: Thats a good question because I feel like we do a lot of measurements and take a lot of
statistics. We do have a satisfaction survey and theres another one called a P & P survey, its
what people would prefer to see and how we carry it out. We do that about every other year.
And then theres national benchmarking, which is really big in healthcare now. Of course
theres the MLA benchmark that we participate in.
MIMI: Im also interested to know, internally, when everyone else isnt saying What do you
think? is there any way you use those stats to perceive how youre doing?LESLIE: Oh yes, we have quality indicators and I look at thoseactually we all look at those
quarterly because I like to look at trends to see whats going on.
MIMI: Could you discuss your observations and impressions of how patrons interact with and
use the librarys services and resources?LESLIE: Well, its evolved in that we dont see as many people as we used to. They can email us
or callpeople used to come in and we just dont see that as much.
MIMI: Do you see that as a weakness?LESLIE: Its just different. Previously we had control of the information. We were the only ones
who could do in-line searches but now anyone can go to Google so the kind of things were
getting from them are much more difficult to find. It takes me a longer time to do a search.
Plus, as I said, theres a lot more demand for outcomes and they want literature or data thats
outcome based. National guidelines are big with nursing so we have to find national guidelines.
Clearly theyre not asking as much, but were taking as much time searching.KYLE: How does patron feedback influence the decision making process?LESLIE: Well it depends on what the feedback is. We always try and be responsive. If somebody
has a problem, we try and get that fixed. We try and be responsive if people want certain
materials that have a health system wide use, not just one department. So we try to be
responsive. Theres a big issue right now that were undergoing with 2 particular products and
there is a group that feels very strongly that thats the only product thatthey cant practice
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
20/25
medicine without it. And a lot of that was because of how it was marketed, so weve been going
through a big thing with them. On the other hand thisll cost us $100,000, which is a big chunk
of my budget. And then with this product for example Ive been surveying others at the top 10
teaching hospitals to see what they do. So Im trying to get my data together to see who else is
doing it, where we are in our budget , what the usage is, and other products that we have thatare similar and we try to gather a lot of data.
KYLE: Obviously youve alluded to keeping statisticshow do you use the statistics?LESLIE: I report them. I use statistics when I talk to the staff. I use statistics when I talk to my
boss. Its a very metriccentric institution, and so, when I need them, I have them.
MIMI: That leads into the next question, which is, seeing how things really are on the front lines
doesnt always translate well to how decisions are being made from above, so do you think
thats an issue here? And do you feel that your boss and bosss boss take your input into
consideration when making big decisions on budget and that type of thing?LESLIE: Sometimes decisions are just made and you roll with it. We were told to close on
Sundays and we just did it. Just roll with it. And sometimes you can have input but theres
another political party thats pushing it another way, and you have to kinda work your way
around. Its probably not a good answer, but sometimes you roll with it, and sometimes you
fight it. There was one decision that was made that I just felt was morally wrong and I just went
all the way up the chain of command. I didnt necessarily get what I wanted but I got something
that at least was good for everybody. So it really depends.
KYLE: Andif things were great and you had an unlimited budget, what changes would you
make to the library?LESLIE: If I had an unlimited budget.Well clearly Id get more resourcesMIMI: What type of resources?LESLIE: I probably would look at more types of electronic resources that we could afford. I
wouldnt just go out and buy stuff because its not all being used. Really, weve got a lot of
computer stuff now though so we dont really have needs that way. I mean, it would be nice for
everyone to have flat screens. Butyeah there would probably be more resources I would get. I
might also look at replacing some of these old books. And I would pay the staff. But, I would
expect more too.KYLE: I dont suppose you know generally how many patrons come here on a daily basisLESLIE: Well not daily basis, but last year, we had 40,000. We have a counter at the exit. But
that includes this library and Womens because I have a counter there.
KYLE: So its between Cone and the Womens Hospital?LESLIE: Yes.
KYLE: What about Wesley Long?LESLIE: I dont have a counter there. She has about 15-20 a day, I think she said. But were not
sure because shes part time.
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
21/25
MIMI: And is it open somehow when shes not there?LESLIE: Theres a combination key. And Womens as well, theres a combination key so you can
go in there 24/7.
MIMI: Can I ask why, in the future, you perceive having a smaller space?
LESLIE: Well you know, real estate is bucks. Actually, were lucky here because they are buildinga new towerbutI could see that. I think our key is not so muchI mean, interlibrary loan is so
cheap now and we can get things so quickly. Before when we had residency programs you had
to have backlogs of journals and now you can either get them online or through interlibrary
loan. I think the key issue is what are we doing as librarians? And its not just managing
resources, so Im not sure we need all that. However, having said that, we do get a lot of people
who are working on their degrees and are looking for a quiet place or something like that so
people may still come in and use that.
KYLE: I was just gonna ask how confident you were in the future of the library, becausewho
knows whats gonna happen with the recession?LESLIE: I thinkthis librarys in a good place. And I think the value, particularly in the past few
years that weve been able to bring to our services , and the institution, and the people that
work here, is recognized. We get invited to committees, we get invited to MISUs, and we get
invited to put things on the intranet. So I feel pretty good about that. But, you know, all it takes
is one new administrator saying I dont want it and thats the end of it. Its what happened to
a friend of mine, and its what happened to one of our new librarians.
MIMI: Im just looking back at this idea of the mission being to support the missions of the
institution. Do you ever findlike, at UNCG were finding that trying tofit the departments
missions with the university missions that sometimes its a good fit, sometimes itswell thats
not really something we do How do you find that interaction to be or is it not as imposed upon
you?LESLIE: Well it is, because everything we do is supposed to fit within that. Were undergoing a
big culture shift here so its a hard question for me to answer. I think I know where were going
but the parameters havent been set. We have this triple-A cost quality service and were
supposed to be a patient centered culture and were all undergoing training for all of that. So
its a very interesting time here.
You know, Im thinking back to your question on if I had a bigger budget what would I do, and
Im thinking I would hire another person for more outreach, that would be a goal. Im not sure
wed have a clinical librarian here but that would be nice to have something with the faculty.
Thered have to be some big changes though for that to happen. Looking ahead though that
would be a very interesting project. Id bring in somebody to do a websitewe have constraints
on our website, but I would bring in somebody to support that. Those are the 2 biggest needs,
and were trying to fill it as best we can.
KYLE: Since you started here, obviously there have been a lot of changes. What do you think the
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
22/25
best change has been, and what do you think the worst change has been?LESLIE: Thats an excellent question. I think the best changes that weve seen are the tools of
the technology. The worst changeI cant start all over again. Its just been a lot of fun. Its just
fun. I think the future is just marvelousfabulous. Youre living at a great time. You dont have
to type catalog cards.MIMI: Thank you very much.LESLIE: Great. If theres anything else you know where to find me. Thanks.Peggy Wynn InterviewInterview Questions:I have answered these questions particular to Wesley Long. The Wesley Long Library is only
staffed 20 hours per week. Other times patrons may access the library using a key code. They
may check out books, use computers and use the library space to study.Describe some of the major challenges your library regularly encounters. What are some
examples of how youve overcome those challenges?At Wesley Long, the primary challenge has been letting people know there is a library and what
the services are. It is easy to make regular library users happy but the challenge is in getting
nonusers to value the services and use them.I have started making a library presentation at all New Employee Orientation sessions. These
are held every 2 weeks and there have been 40-60 new employees at each session. We are also
participating in nursing and nurse tech skills fairs.I try to round on the floors from time to time and offer specific services (lit searches,
information retrieval, computer instruction)Another challenge is serving patrons when they have needs within a 20 hour work week. It is a
bit of a Catch 22- if you are not present, patrons dont come. If patrons dont come in, the
library doesnt appear to be busy.Describe your patrons. How does patron feedback influence your decision making process? And
how easy is it to empathize with what they want--and subsequently implement any measures
to deal with their request(s)?Wesley Long sees high numbers of non clinical hospital employees. Many of these patrons do
not have computers or internet service at home and use the computers to check email etc.
There are a handful of physicians that use the library space frequently and another group that
uses document retrieval and lit search services. Nursing staff often request lit searches and
document retrieval. Many of the libraries online services, journals, wikis, and toolboxes are
used by clinical staff.System wide, library usage is measured by website hits. The library also sends out a yearly
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
23/25
survey to users and tries to meet requests and needs as much as financially and logistically
reasonable.How do you, in particular, measure your librarys successes or shortcomings? How do you fulfill
the librarys mission?All three libraries keep monthly statistics on library usage. In addition, we monitor website hits.
We are able to track wiki hits also. Success is measured by increases in these numbers.Moses Cone Health System Library supports the educational and informational needs of the
medical staff, employees, patients and families of the Moses Cone Health System, the
community, and the health care providers in the Greensboro AHEC region.The mission of the library (above) is supported by providing competent, friendly service to all
staff and visitors. The librarians strive to stay up to date on current literature and provide
proactive services such as monthly alerts and TOC service. We listen to what our patrons want
and try to fulfill those needs.Discuss your observations and impressions of how patrons interact with and use the libraries
services and resources.Many of the services and resources are accessed online or through email. Because there is
limited face-to-face contact, it is still important to do a good reference interview and often I
have several email exchanges prior to a literature search. Patrons often just ignore information
they do not think is useful rather than letting you know more specifically what they need.
Patrons appreciate prompt service and response to their needs.What do you value most about what you do?It is an immense pleasure to serve and be helpful. I am proud to be a part of a profession that
values the sharing of information.Laura Enyon InterviewI have answered these questions particular to Womens Hospital. My little library is staffed 32
hours per week. I work M-Thurs at Womens, Fridays I work at Cone (I am the cataloger for all
the libraries materials, and I do the cataloging from Cone). Other times patrons may access the
library using a key code. They may check out books, use computers, watch VHS tapes, and use
the library space to study.Describe some of the major challenges your library regularly encounters. What are some
examples of how youve overcome those challenges?Like Peggy, I find I am constantly having to market the library. I am lucky because I work in a
much smaller hospital (Womens has 134 beds compared to Cone 536 beds and Wesley Long
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
24/25
175 beds + cancer center), so I know most of the employees at Womens Hospital. Once
someone has used the library services, they are apt to remember me. I still go up to the
different departments once in a while to make sure they remember I am around.Another issue is time. I work mainly with nurses at Womens, and it is becoming increasingly
difficult for them to get away to visit the library. Likewise, if I try to go up to the floors, it is not
very helpful because they are extremely busy. When our patient census gets below a certain
level, they send staff (nurses) home, so time is more and more valuable. I try to respond quickly
to emails, as the nurses do have time to shoot me an email from the floor.I also worked on several committees at Womens Hospital it is a great way to meet people
and show off skills.Describe your patrons. How does patron feedback influence your decision making process? And
how easy is it to empathize with what they wantand subsequently implement any measures
to deal with their request(s)?Most of my physical presence patrons are non-clinical staff using computers to access bank
information, email, etc. I also have physician assistants visit my library when they are on
rotation. It is a place they can sit and chat, check school email, study, etc. I try to keep my
library open for small groups to use, etc. I dont want people to think they have to be totally
silent. (Since my library is much smaller than Cone, I dont have to worry about a group talking
interrupting someone elsewhere in the library.)The patrons I do the most work for are nurses. As I said previously, they are becoming more
and more strapped for time. Yet, they are also getting pushed to do research. The libraries
system-wide are all still trying to figure out the best way to reach our nurses. I find it very easy
to empathize with my nurses. I know they want to do the research, but they just dont have the
time. I try to work around their schedules.
How do you, in particular, measure your librarys successes or shortcomings? How do you fulfill
the librarys mission?(Peggy answered this well!)All three libraries keep monthly statistics on library usage. In addition, we monitor website hits.
We are able to track wiki hits also. Success is measured by increases in these numbers.Moses Cone Health System Library supports the educational and informational needs of the
medical staff, employees, patients and families of the Moses Cone Health System, the
community, and the health care providers in the Greensboro AHEC region.The mission of the library (above) is supported by providing competent, friendly service to all
staff and visitors. The librarians strive to stay up to date on current literature and provide
proactive services such as monthly alerts and TOC service. We listen to what our patrons want
-
7/31/2019 Lis 650 Needs Assessment Final
25/25
and try to fulfill those needs.Discuss your observations and impressions of how patrons interact with and use the libraries
services and resources.I feel like my experience with how my patrons use and interact is a very personal one. Because
we are such a small hospital, I know my patrons. So, I can tweak searches in ways I know they
will appreciate. Which just makes them look upon the library that much more favorably.What do you value most about what you do?I love research. And, I really appreciate that I can help the nurses stay up-to-date on the newest
information ... in turn giving our patients the best care possible. I deal with lit searches for the
NICU, so I like knowing I am helping out the smallest of our patients.