Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
of 137
-
Upload
nocompromisewtruth -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
1/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 9
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:;>> i&a&Mdhipedf; Hd|zpzdda 9>@
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
E- Mexi Dxplmmi ia dvlz pbl icl do 92 if` ia i ~izpu pd pbl sepbef ihpedf& E
bivl ~lzxdfim gfdsml`cl do pbl oihpx blzlef- if` eo himml` pd `d- E hd|m` if` sd|m`
hda~lplfpmu plxpeou& E ia aigefc pbex @lhmizipedf |f`lz pbl ~lfimpu do ~lzk|zu do
pbl Misx do pbl \fepl` Xpiplx ~|zx|ifp pd :2 \&X&H& 930?&
@ipl do Blizefc; I~zem :8- :>9:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do 5 ^icl E@ (;99?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
2/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi :
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:>5- E zlhlevl` if laiem ozda Flem Xifglu "Xifglu%
efpzd`|hefc beaxlmo pd al- xll LRBEJEP 9& Ef pbex laiem- bl ef`ehiplx bl ex pbl
^zevipl Efvlxpecipdz do Pbl Xifglu Oeza pbip sdzgx sepb Dzmu Piep{ j|p bl xpipl`
bl fll`l` pd zlaief ifdfuad|x& E slfp pd pbl sljxepl ~zdve`l` ju Xifglu
sss&pblxifgluoeza&hda pd vlzeou pbip bl six ef oihp i ~zevipl efvlxpecipdz& Pbl
Xifglu Oezax sljxepl ip pbex peal xbdsl` Flem Xifglu ix i ^zevipl Efvlxpecipdz
odz pbex hda~ifu&
:& Dfl do pbl ~zdklhpx E six ixxexpefc @lolf`ifp Dzmu Piep{ "Piep{%
sepb jlpsllf Kif|izu if` Oljz|izu :>>5 six ixxlajmefc pbl @dxxelz (9- if d~lf
mlpplz pd Ippdzflu Clflzim Lzeh Bdm`lz& Piep{ odzsiz`l` pd al pbl mexp do Xdhei
Xlh|zepu F|ajlzx "XXF dz XXFx% if` i``zlxxlx pbip slzl immlcl mu |xl` ju
^zlxe lfp Djiai pbip xbl zlhlevl` ozda Flem Xifglu "Xifglu% ef :>>2&9 Pbex
mexp six pd jl efhm|`l` ef pbl @dxxelz jlefc xlfp pd Ippdzflu Clflzim Lzeh Bdm`lz
Xl~iziplmu- if` ix zly|lxpl` ju Piep{- Xifglu xlfp al i hdvlz mlpplz pbip six pd jl
pbl oezxp ~icl do pbip xlhpedf ~lzpiefefc pd pbl XXFx if` i``zlxxlx- xll LRBEJEP
:& Pbex @dxxelz (9 ef ~izp ex xpemm ~|jmexbl` if` iviemijml dfmefl df Piep{x
sljxepl ip bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda$4~13:5&
9
Xifglux mexp six oeml` ef pbl \&X& @expzehp Hd|zp- @expzehp do Hdm|ajei ef pbl hixlPiep{ v& Djiai- Hixl Fd& 9;9>!hv!>>9&
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl : do 5 ^icl E@ (;99?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
3/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 8
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:5- Xifglu xlfp al if laiem xpipefc pbip xdaldfl
fial` Xizib Zl`epp:
bi` k|xp x~mep ozda pbl #Jlzc Hia~# WxehQ "Mis Dooehlx do
^beme~ K& Jlzc% if` bi` xdal efodzaipedf odz bea& Xifglux xecfip|zl ef pbex laie
xpemm xbdsx bea ix jlefc ozda Pbl Xifglu Oeza- xll LRBEJEP 8& Xifglu
~zlved|xmu jlmdfcl` pd if dfmefl slj odz|a himml` @ladhzipeh!@exixplz if` gfls
Xizib ozda pbip slj odz|a&
0& Ef pbex laiem Xifglu xlfp al six xdal efplzflp zi~ xbllp pbi
x|~~dxl`mu jlmdfcl` pd pbl ~izimlcim- Mexi Mejlze- ip pbl Mis Dooehlx do ^beme~ K
Jlzc- au ippdzflu ef pbex sepbef ihpedf&
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
4/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 0
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:5- Flem Xifglu xlfp al if izpehml ef laiem ijd|p
Mexi Mejlze jlefc xlfplfhl` odz E`lfpepu Pblop if` Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|`& LRBEJEP
?& E odzsiz`l` pbex pd Piep{& Ip pbip peal- sl sdf`lzl` eo ep bi` ifupbefc pd `d
sepb i mizcl mexp do ~zd~lzpelx Xifglu bi` ~|mml` ozda bex `ipijixl ihhd|fpx pbip
xbdsl` ^zlxe`lfp Djiai |xefc ef ixxdheipedf sepb imm bex xdheim xlh|zepu f|ajlzx&
Xefhl sl `e`f#p gfds eo pblzl six ifu alzep pd pblxl pbd|cbpx- E xie` pbex izpehml
xbd|m` fdp cd |~ df au xepl- `lolf`d|zozll`dax&|x& Pbip ex au xepl pbip E six
mlppefc Piep{ |xl ip pbl peal& E six pzuefc pd gll~ pbip xepl ix ~zdolxxedfim ix
~dxxejml& Sepbd|p hdfoezaipedf- pbip izpehml six doo pd~eh cdxxe~& E e` doolz pd
~dxp pbip izpehml df |fzlmipl` jmdcx pbip E zif pbip k|xp hizzel` zif`da ~dxpefcx if`
`e`fp zl~zlxlfp i j|xeflxx dz lfpepu& Piep{ pdm` al pd ~dxp ep df pbdxl dpblz jmdcx E
bi`& Xd E ixgl` Xifglu odz pbl \ZM if` sljxepl sblzl bl od|f` pbip izpehml& Bl
`e` fdp bivl ep& E pdm` bea E sd|m`f#p ~dxp pbip izpehml sepbd|p pbl \ZM if` sljxepl
bl cdp ep ozda& Bl flvlz xlfp ep pd al7 pblzlodzl E flvlz ~dxpl` ep&
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 0 do 5 ^icl E@ (;99?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
5/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 5
X|~~mlalfpim Iooe`ivep do G& Xpzljlm- sepbd|p Lrbejepx `|l pd epx xe{l- ippihbl` ix
LRBEJEP 3 ip ~iclx pbzll pbzd|cb oevl& Pbex iooe`ivep six oeml` sepb K|`cl
Zdjzlfd `|zefc d|z I|c|xp :>>5 PZD blizefc&
2& @|zefc pbex lfpezl peal- Piep{ if` E slzl bivefc adzl if` adzl
izc|alfpx ijd|p sbip xbd|m jl ~dxpl` df pbl `lolf`d|zozll`dax&|x jmdc& Xbl
sifpl` pd ~|jmexb lvlzupbefc sepbd|p hblhgefc pbl xd|zhlx odz alzep dz hzl`ejemepu&
Piep{ xpizpl` cevefc al adzl j|xu sdzg if` jzd|cbp ef `eoolzlfp ad`lzipdzx pd clp
izd|f` au efplzolzefc sepb sbip xbl sifpl` |~ pblzl& E oefimmu ~|p au oddp `dsf
ioplz xbl ~dxpl`- aieml` if` `expzej|pl` @dxxelz (< jlodzl E xis ep& @dxxelz (< six
if d~lf mlpplz xlfp pd Lzeh Bdm`lz I~zem :- :>>5 `laif`efc efvlxpecipedfx if`
zl~dzpefc vized|x hujlz hzealx if` bihgefc& Imm do pbl hmieax pbip efvdmvl` au
sljxepl pbip xbl ai`l slzl fdp pz|l if` sd|m` bivl bi` pd bivl al hdzzdjdzipefc
pbla ix blz sljaixplz& E sd|m` fdp `d pbip xd E pdm` blz xbl bi` pd oef` i fls
sljbdxp&
5& Ef dz ijd|p I~zem 5- :>>5- Piep{ od|f` i fls sljbdxp& E sdzgl` sepb
pbip fls sljbdxp odz i ols `iux pzuefc pd clp pbl xepl zli`u odz pzifxolzzefc& E
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl < do 5 ^icl E@ (;99?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
6/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi ?
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:& Ijd|p I~zem 93- :>>5- Piep{ ~dxpl` df blz sljxepl pbip xbl ai`l i
zl~dzp pd pbl Dzifcl Hd|fpu Xblzeoo#x `l~izpalfp zlciz`efc pbl bihgefc do blz xepl
if` ^iu^im ihhd|fp&
99& E xpizpl` hdfpihpefc pbl Efplzflp Xlzvehl ^zdve`lzx "EX^x% sblzl
oimxl immlcipedfx ijd|p al if` au e`lfpeouefc efodzaipedf slzl jlefc ~dxpl`
Lvlzu EX^ E hdfpihpl` sd|m` fdp pigl pbl efodzaipedf `dsf |fmlxx E bi` i hd|zp
dz`lz& E bi` pd oeml x|ep pd clp i hd|zp dz`lz&
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl ? do 5 ^icl E@ (;99??>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
7/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 3
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:>5& Df Aiu :2- :>>5- I
ols `iux ioplz pbl `lolf`ifpx slzl xlzvl`7 Xifglu slfp dfpd ^miefx Zi`ed
Flpsdzg odz if efplzvels ijd|p pbex x|ep& Sl zlhdz l` pbl xbds mevl if`
pzifxhzejl` pbl xbds& Pzifxhze~p do Xifglux Efplzvels ex ippihbl` ix LRBEJEP
2& Xifglu ai`l aifu hdfhlzfefc xpiplalfpx df pbex xbds& Bl xpipl`; E six pbl
dfl pbip bi` bea hdf`|hp bex efvlxpecipedfx df Mexi Mejlze if` ^beme~ Jlzc- Xifglu
x~dgl do mdifx pbip slzl i~~mel` odz- `zevlz#x mehlfxlx bl six ef ~dxxlxxedf do-
xliml` zlhdz`x bl djpiefl` df |x if` vlzeoel` pd pbl i|`elfhl do mexplflzx pbip bl
six alpbd`eh ef vlzeouefc imm pbl efodzaipedf bl bi`&
98& Sl bi` fd e`li bds Xifglu six djpiefefc pbl ~zevipl if` xliml`
efodzaipedf ijd|p |x pbip bl six fds aigefc ~|jmeh if` i``efc bex dsf x~efx if`
xpdzelx pd& Bl imxd ai`l i hdfhlzfefc xpiplalfp ef pbex efplzvels ijd|p fll`efc i
j|fhb do adflu pd aigl pbex pbefc WxehQ cd isiu&
90& Df Kif|izu :5- :>9>- sl oefimmu zlhlevl` vei x|j~dlfi- pbl Dzifcl
Hd|fpu Xblzeoo#x @l~izpalfp zl~dzp pbip Piep{ ai`l I~zem 93- :>>5& Ef pbip zl~dzp
ippihbl` ix LRBEJEP 5- Piep{ i`aepx xbl bi` Xifglu z|f jihgczd|f` hblhgx df
al if` Mexi Mejlze& Ef pbex zl~dzp- xbl imxd xpiplx pbip Mexi Mejlze if` E slzl pbl
xial ~lzxdf& Piep{ xpiplx ef pbip zl~dzp Mexi Mejlze six if imeix E |xl &
9- Piep{ ~dxpl` df blz xepl blz hd|zp oemefc
ef Sixbefcpdf- @H odz i Y|d Sizzifpd& Ef Piep{x ~dxp slzl xpiplalfpx pbip
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 3 do 5 ^icl E@ (;99??9
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
8/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 2
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:& Piep{ ef blz ialf`l` Y|d
Sizzifpd oemefc xpipl` Xifglux ihhd|fp sepb MlrexFlrex bi` jllf hifhlmml`& Xll
Piep{ Ialf`l` Y|d Sizzifpd oemefc ef pbl \&X& @expzehp Hd|zp- @expzehp do
Hdm|ajei- Piep{ v& Djiai- Hixl Fd& 9;9>!hv!>>99>- ip ~iclx :9- ::- if` 9:2& Pz|l if` hdzzlhp hd~elx do
pblxl ~iclx izl ippihbl` blzlpd ix LRBEJEP 99&
9?& Fds sl gfls sblzl Piep{ six clppefc ~zevipl if` xliml` efodzaipedf
ozda& Xifglu six z|ffefc if` djpiefefc jihgczd|f` zl~dzpx df |x ozda xlvlzim
`ipi jzdglz hda~ifelx- efhm|`efc Zll` Lmxlvelz- MlrexFlrex- Hbdehl^defp- if`
Efplme|x&
93& Xefhl pbl oemefc do Piep{#x Y|d Sizzifpd- pblzl bivl jllf izpehmlx if`
efplzvelsx ju Xifglu i`aeppefc bl |xlx MlrexFlrex- Hbdehl~defp ix slmm ix
Efplme|x ix bex pddmx pd `d jihgczd|f` zl~dzpx if` djpief efodzaipedf df ~ld~ml
Xifglux efplzvelsx if` izpehmlx izl iviemijml dfmefl ip;
Pbl Auxplzu Do Jizihg Djiai Hdfpef|lx
bpp~;$$sss&slxplzfkd|zfimexa&hda$lrhm|xevl!efvlxpecipevl!zl~dzpx$pbl!auxplzu!do!jizihg!djiai!hdfpef|lx$
I odzalz Jzepexb ~dmehlaif ex |xefc bex Xhdpmif` Uiz` pziefefc pd
blm~ pbl Jezpblzx- i czd|~ do hdfx~ezihu pbldzexpx- ef pzuefc pd |fxlip
^zlxe`lfp Jizihg Djiai&
bpp~;$$sss&plmlczi~b&hd&|g$flsx$sdzm`flsx$jizihgdjiai$??80>028$::$9: ^icl 2 do 5 ^icl E@ (;99??:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
9/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 5
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:9: ef pbl Xpipl do Fls Klzxlu&
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 5 do 5 ^icl E@ (;99??8
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
10/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi 9>
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do 8 ^icl E@(;99??0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
11/137
Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaX|jklhp; If e`li pbip aiu blm~ |x
@ipl; Pb|- 2 Kif :>>5 9>;>5;:< !>2>>
Be Mexi
E ia pbl ^$Efvlxpecipdz ozda Mdx Ifclmlx pbip ex blm~efc @z& Dzmu& Sl slzl pimgefc mixplvlfefc if` xbl x|cclxpl` pbip E hdfpihp ud|& E ixx|al ud| blm~ blz sepb blzsljxepl44
Ifusiu- sl `lhe`l` sl bi` i mdp do pimlfpx sl hd|m` |xl d|p pblzl iadfcxp imm pblxliai{efc x|~~dzplzx- eo dfmu sl gfls sbd `dlx sbip ef pblez zlim meol Xbl x|cclxpl` ixaimm xe`l ~iflm ixgefc odz ~ld~ml sbd gfds ijd|p xdal x~lheoeh izlix& Odz efxpifhl-zecbp fds sl `lx~lziplmu fll` i pz|xpl` _dm|fpllz sbd bix hdfpihp efxe`l- dz six if
Im|afe do- Lm Hiaefd Becb Xhbddm blzl ef pbl _immlu& E imxd fll` xdaldfl sepb `lpieml`gfdsml`cl ijd|p Xdheim Xlh|zepu f|ajlzx& Fds iadfcxp d|p pbd|xif`x do ~ld~ml pblzlk|xp aecbp jl&
@d ud| xll sbip sl izl clppefc ip4 Sl bivl pd jl hizlo|m xdalpealx jlhi|xl do sbipsl izl ixgefc odz- if` E fll` pd zlaief ifdfuad|x odz xiolpu xigl)
Sbip `d ud| x|cclxp4
Flem
Flem Xifglu
PBL XIFGLU OEZA
:03> Xplizfx Xpzllp- (9?:
Xeae _immlu- Himeodzfei 58>?8
fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
2>< 89>028$::$9: ^icl : do 8 ^icl E@(;99??
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
12/137
Sef`dsx Mevl; Gll~ ud|z meol ef xufh& Xll bds ep sdzgx&
9:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 8 do 8 ^icl E@(;99???
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
13/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do :5 ^icl E@(;99??3
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
14/137
^dxp Dooehl Jdr 2:52Aexxedf Bemmx- Himeodzfei 5980?!2:52"292% 8??!>595 OIR "292% 8??!9059
fxifgluN~zeviplefvlxpecipedf&hda
Himeodzfei Mehlfxl ^&E& 9>5>>5
@z& Dzmu Piep{- Lxy|ezl
ZL; Zlxlizhb ! JIZIHG B& DJIAI
@liz @dhpdz Piep{-
E ia i ^zevipl Efvlxpecipdz- `|mu mehlfxl` ef pbl Xpipl do Himeodzfei if` bivl jllf xdmehlfxl` odz pbl ~ixp pslfpu oevl ulizx& E ia i Fip|zime{l` Ialzehif Hepe{lf&
E ia lr~lzelfhl` ef imm pu~lx do Efvlxpecipedf- jdpb Hzeaefim if` Hevem- bivefc x~lfppslfpu ulizx ef pbl Jzepexb ^dmehl- xlzvefc ix i @lplhpevl ip Fls Xhdpmif` Uiz` odz aifuulizx& Ef pbl efplzlxp do d|z Hd|fpzu if` ef `lolfxl do d|z Hdfxpep|pedf E bivl jllf
ixxexpefc sepb Zlxlizhb if` Efvlxpecipedf sblzlvlz flhlxxizu&
@|zefc pbl hd|zxl do pbl sdzg E bivl jllf `defc ef pbl ~ixp xer adfpbx- zlciz`efc pblihpevepelx if` y|imeoehipedfx do Az& Djiai- E bivl gl~p i zlhdz` do imm do pbl i``zlxxlx efzlciz`x pd sbehb E bivl xllf pbl |xl do bex fial& Pbl zlhdz`x if` `ipijixlx E |xl izlaifu if` vizel` jlefc ihh|a|mipl` odz aifu `eoolzlfp zlixdfx j|p imm izl do ^|jmehZlhdz` if` pbl `dh|alfpx E bivl |xl` izl iviemijml pd pbl Clflzim ^|jmeh- sepb- dzsepbd|p pbl ~iualfp do ollx&
E bivl hda~eml` pbl jlmds mexp sbehb E bivl ~zlved|xmu odzsiz`l` pd ud|;
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU IClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?93 X JLZLPIFEI XP I^P 9>>
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2:?!99>?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 0> do 90>028$::$9: ^icl : do :5 ^icl E@(;99??2
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
15/137
^icl :
Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 8!rrrr
Icl ! 38@ipl do Jezpb ! Aiz :8- 9592
@lhlixl` ! Ulx
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Kif 5< ! Kif 5?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU IClf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx !Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! 5?2:?
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 8!rrrrIcl ! 38
@ipl do Jezpb ! Aiz :8- 9592@lhlixl` ! Ulx
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Olj 5:+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU I
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 999 X GEFC XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?298!80^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 8!rrrr
Icl ! 38
@ipl do Jezpb ! Aiz :8- 9592@lhlixl` ! Ulx
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Kif 5>+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU IClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?93 X JLZLPIFEI XP I^P 9>>2
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2:?!999:^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 8!rrrr
Icl ! 38@ipl do Jezpb ! Aiz :8- 9592
@lhlixl` ! Ulx@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !++++++
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU IFFClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?93 X JLZLPIFEI XP I^P 9>>2
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2:?!999:^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Icl ! 2
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 09 do 90028$::$9: ^icl 8 do :5 ^icl E@(;99??5
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
16/137
^icl 8
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! X\PDZD- XPI
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?93 X JLZLPIFEI XP I^P 9>>2Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2:?!999:
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
@ipl do Jezpb ! 950:
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz 23 ! I|c >3+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU I
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx !Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! 5?2:?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Icl !
@ipl do Jezpb ! Fdv :5- 950:@lhlixl` ! Ulx@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp 5Icl ! ?3
@ipl do Jezpb ! 950:
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp 5>>0!9>>9^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 0: do 90>028$::$9: ^icl 0 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?3>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
17/137
^icl 0
Icl ! >0!9>>9
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Icl ! ?3@ipl do Jezpb ! 950:
@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp 50 ! Kif 5PB XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! FLS UDZG FU 9>>9?!9300^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! Fd
Plml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Icl ! ?3@ipl do Jezpb ! 950:
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z 58+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! X\PDZD- XPI
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2::!0?Fial ! X\PDZD- XPI
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9
Fial ! @\FBIA- XPIFMLU IFF
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! BDFDM\M\ BE 5?2::!0??>
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 08 do 90>028$::$9: ^icl < do :5 ^icl E@(;99?39
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
18/137
^icl >9?!9303
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
@ipl do Jezpb ! Fdv :5- 950:
@lhlixl` ! Ulx@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! IMJZEGPXLF- ^BUMEXX
Clf`lz ! OlaimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 00:0 9
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
19/137
^icl ?
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp >2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:8 SBEPL BD\XLHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! EZ_EFL HI 5:?92
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Olj >2 ! K|f >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 8:>3!9!88?!33:: ! AXPPlml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
20/137
^icl 3
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! I^^ML XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ALMJD\ZFL OM 8:50>
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 3?:!09!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp >2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?>8 Z\HGLZ Z@Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! IM^BIZLPPI CI 8>>>0!9082 ! I|c >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! < OIZZ Z@ I^P H
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HDM\AJ\X CI 895>3!?:3!?3!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Kif >2 ! Aiz >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! < OIZZ Z@ I^P H
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HDM\AJ\X CI 895>3!?:32 ! I|c >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGClf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! >0^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Xl~ >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 0? do 90
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 2 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?30
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
21/137
^icl 2
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 90 S LZEL XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?9>!< ! Kif >?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>989 ?98 ! K|m >8+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>989 ?98!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz >8 ! K|m >8+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>989$: ?98 ! K|m >8+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>989$: ?98!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz >8 ! K|m >8+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl 03 do 90>028$::$9: ^icl 5 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?3
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
22/137
^icl 5
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp >: ! Aiu >?9?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! UlxPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f >< ! Fdv >?9?
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! Fd
Plml~bdfl ! 338!?20!02>5 ! HXPPlml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f >< ! Fdv >?05!8?:?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I|c 58+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! >
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
23/137
^icl 9>
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Dhp >2 ! Fdv >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9> L DM@ SEMMDS Z@Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ^ZDX^LHP BLECBPX EM ?>>3>!9598
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! @lh >? ! I~z >3+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx !
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
24/137
^icl 99
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I|c >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 592 JIEFJZE@CL XPHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ^BEMI@LM^BEI ^I 95903
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >3 ! I|c >3+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! < HIPBIZEFL XPHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ^BEMI@LM^BEI ^I 95903!8>>5
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >3+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:8 AIEF XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBIZMLXPDF XH :50?0
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiu >2 ! Xl~ >2
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 0>80 JZEHG HB\ZHB ^EGLHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! FIXB_EMML PF 83:>3!9
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>>> FS 88 I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ODZP SDZPB PR 3?92>^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! ?3
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >2 ! Dhp >2
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl do 90>028$::$9: ^icl 9: do :5 ^icl E@(;99?32
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
25/137
^icl 9:
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>>> 88Z@ I_L FS
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ODZP SDZPB PR 3?92>^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >2 ! I|c >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! :9:5 MLAIZP XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! CZIF@ ^ZIEZEL PR 380^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! @lh >2 ! Kif >5+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 08< @IMMIX I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! MIFHIXPLZ PR 32
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 99> F \FE_LZXEPU I_LHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! M\JJDHG PR 3509
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Fdv >2
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 90?0 HIZZEFCPDF MFHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HLFPLZ_EMML \P 20>90!9:2:
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! @lh >2 ! Kif >5
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 98 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?35
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
26/137
^icl 98
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ^D JDR 9:8?
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ^ZD_D \P 20?>8!9:8?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 5>9!>5!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f >3 ! Kif >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 999 ^LFFXUM_IFEI I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! SIXBEFCPDF \P 2032>
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 355!25!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|m >3 ! Olj >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 22 ! Kif >5+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! DJIAI MFHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! OZIFGMEF SE 2 ! K|f >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG BXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>80 X JZDI@ XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HIZMEF_EMML EM ?:?:?!:9::
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! @lh >2 ! Kif >5+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 90 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?2>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
27/137
^icl 90
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 92> F MI XIMML XP I^P ::>>F
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?>9!:9
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Olj >3 ! K|f >3+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 900> L ?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z 2?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03
@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG BClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?90:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03
@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! ?90:!?2!rrrr
Icl ! 03@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c >0- 95?9
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 9< do :5 ^icl E@(;99?29
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
28/137
^icl 90- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f 22 ! @lh 5>+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! F 9FHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?90:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03
@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c >0- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Kif 22+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9>>!?20!02>5Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !
Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c >0- 95?9
@lhlixl` Fd
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG BClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?90:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 9? do :5 ^icl E@(;99?2:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
29/137
^icl 9?
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 308? X L\HME@
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?05
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03
@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c- 95?9@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 8?< JZDI@SIU I^P J9Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! XDALZ_EMML AI >:90
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl ! 03
@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c >0- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG BClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 0>2< KIHDJX MF@C
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! XIEFP HBIZMLX AD ?88>0!3052 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEFClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 8>> AIXXIHB\XLPPX I_L FSHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! SIXBEFCPDF @H :>>>9!:?:5^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Xl~ >!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 93 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?28
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
30/137
^icl 93
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 92> F MI XIMML XP XPL ::>>Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?>9!:?9>
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Olj >3 ! K|f >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEF
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?9
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|m >: ! K|m >?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEF
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 0? X CZLLFSDD@ I_LHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?9?
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! UlxPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f >< ! I~z >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEF
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 0? X CZLLFSDD@ I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?9?
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl ! 338!?20!02>5 ! HXPPlml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f >< ! I~z >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEFClf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?90:!?2!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
31/137
^icl 92
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! K|f 53 ! I|c >0+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEF
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! ^D JDR 05352
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HBEHICD EM ?>?05
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl ! 338!?20!02>5 ! HXPPlml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrr
Icl ! 03@ipl do Jezpb ! I|c >0- 95?9
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Xl~ 55+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIHG B\XXLEF
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! 8?< JZDI@SIU I^P J9
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! XDALZ_EMML AI >:90
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! >0:!?2!rrrr
Icl ! 995@ipl do Jezpb ! 925>@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?95 X JLFPMLU I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! MDX IFCLMLX HI 5>>:
@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! @lh >2 ! Kif >5+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>>5 @ECEPIM BSU
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! MDX IFCLMLX HI 5>>0< ! I~z >?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9?2> _E@LD @Z
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! MDX IFCLMLX HI 5>>0!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl 95 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?2
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
32/137
^icl 95
@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Fdv >< ! Aiz >?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 0> PZIFXOLZ XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! @LF_LZ HD 2>:>3
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl ! 8>8!:89!023? ! AXPPlml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Fdv >3 ! Aiz >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIG
Clf`lz ! AimlXpzllp I``zlxx ! :: XHDPP Z@
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! XD\PBEFCPDF HP >?025^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !
Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Fdv >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIG
Clf`lz ! Aiml
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:8 XD\PB @ZHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! AEIAE X^ZEFCX OM 889??!?!80!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I|c >2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:80 BI^^U XP XLHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! HD_EFCPDF SI 52>0:
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! @lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiu >2 ! Xl~ >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIG Y\EFHUXpzllp I``zlxx ! Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl :> do :5 ^icl E@(;99?2?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
33/137
^icl :>
@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I|c >0 ! @lh >0+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIGLXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9898 MIFL
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! JDHI ZIPDF OM 88088
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 9:8!0
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Olj >2 ! I|c >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIY B
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 908>> FL 92PB XPHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! _IFHD\_LZ SI 52?20!32>3
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !
@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz >2 ! K|m >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZIY BXpzllp I``zlxx ! 908FL 92PB XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! _IFHD\_LZ SI 52?20
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZJIZIXpzllp I``zlxx ! ? ?>?^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Xl~ >0 ! Kif >95:^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >? ! I|c >?
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl >028$::$9: ^icl :9 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?23
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
34/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
35/137
^icl ::
@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I|c >2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZZIHG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! :8:8 IZEXPDPML HPHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! OIEZOIR _I ::>8>
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! 3>8!2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZZIG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! ?99 F HI^EPDM I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! EF@EIFI^DMEX EF 0?:>0!9:>2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZZIG S KZXpzllp I``zlxx ! 9>>9 XL 982+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZZDGXpzllp I``zlxx ! 8?8 FDPMLA XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ODZP ^ELZHL OM 8052:!382 ! Fdv >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JIZZDG D
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:8 LIXP MF
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! MIGL JIZZEFCPDF EM ?>>9>!9585^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >? ! I|c >?+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl ?9 do 90028$::$9: ^icl :8 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?25
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
36/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
37/137
^icl :0
@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` !+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JLPPU
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:8 ADBLCIF I_L
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! FDZPB JZIFODZ@ HP >?039^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu !Icl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! I~z >2 ! Aiu >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JDJ
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 0:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
38/137
^icl :2 ! Xl~ >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JDZIG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 899: 9 : XPHepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! XIEFP I\C\XPEFL OM 8:>2>
^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! FdPlml~bdfl !Plml~bdfl Ihhd|fpbdm`lz !Xdheim Xlh|zepu ! :98!03!rrrrIcl !@ipl do Jezpb !@lhlixl` ! Fd@ipl Zlhdz` _lzeoel` ! Aiz >2 ! @lh >2+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Fial ! DJIAI- JDZIG
Xpzllp I``zlxx ! 9:98 S AIEF XP
Hepu- Xpipl- [e~ ! ODZP SIUFL EF 0?2>2!8880^zdjijml H|zzlfp I``zlxx ! Fd
Plml~bdfl ! :?>!0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
39/137
IOOE@I_EP
Pbl Xpipl do Himeodzfei% X&X&
Hepu do Xeae _immlu %
E- Flem XIFGLU- do Xeae _immlu- Himeodzfei- AIGL DIPB IF@ XIU PBIP;-9& E- Flem Xifglu ia dvlz pbl icl do lecbpllf ulizx& Eo himml` pd `d xd- E hd|m` if` sd|m` hda~lplfpmu plxpeou |f`lz dipb ix odmmdsx& E ia i Mehlfxl` Efvlxpecipdz ef pbl Xpipl do Himeodzfei Mehlfxl f|ajlz ^&9& 9>5>>2- zlciz`efc pblihpevepelx if` y|imeoehipedfx do Az& Djiai- E bivl hda~eml` i zlhdz` do imm do pbli``zlxxlx ef zlciz`x pd sbehb E bivl xllf pbl |xl do bex fial& Pbl zlhdz`x if``ipijixlx sbehb E |xl izl aifu if` vizel` bivefc jllf ihh|a|mipl` odz aifu`eoolzlfp zlixdfx j|p imm izl ^|jmeh Zlhdz` if` pbl `dh|alfpx E bivl |xl` izl iviemijmlpd pbl Clflzim ^|jmeh sepb- dz sepbd|p pbl ~iualfp do ollx&
8& Df Kif|izu :- :>>5 E odzsiz`l` pd @dhpdz Piep{ i hda~mlpl mexp do au loodzpx pd pbippeal& I pz|l if` hda~mlpl hd~u do pbip `dh|alfp ihhda~ifelx pbex `dh|alfp ippihbl`if` aizgl` *Lrbejep I*&
0& Df K|mu ?- :>>5- E odzsiz`l` pd @dhpdz Piep{ if |~`ipl` vlzxedf do pbip mexp- ihh|ziplix do pbip `ipl if` bivefc jllf |~`ipl`- ju al- `|zefc pbl sllglf` do K|mu 0pb if` 5!hv!>>>2:!H@M @dh|alfp 9!? Oeml` >3$>5$:>>5 ^icl 9 do 8Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl ?< do 90>028$::$9: ^icl :3 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?58
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
40/137
:>>5& I pz|l if` hda~mlpl hd~u do pbip `dh|alfp ihhda~ifelx pbex `dh|alfp ippihbl`if` aizgl` *Lrbejep J*
X\JXHZEJL@ IF@ XSDZF PD JLODZL AL- df pbl?pb `iu do K|mu- :>>5
%%% ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
FDPIZU ^\JMEH % Flem XIFGLU
Au Hdaaexxedf lr~ezlx; TTTTTTTTTT-
Hixl 0;>5!hv!>>>2:!H@M @dh|alfp 9!? Oeml` >3$>5$:>>5 ^icl : do 8Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl ?? do 90>028$::$9: ^icl :2 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?50
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
41/137
HIMEODZFEI K\ZIP SEPB IOOEIFP XPIPLALFP - -UXll Ippihbl` @dh|alfp "Fdpizu pd hzdxx d|p meflx 9!? jlmds% T Xll Xpiplalfp Jlmds "Meflx 9!< pd jl hda~mlpl` dfmu ju `dh|alfp xecflzWxK- fdp Fdpizu%
! ! ! v & v ! ! ! v v ! ! ! v & v ! ! ! ! &&!!!!&FD&9 Xecfip]K7 d D"%h|alfp Xecz92o Fd&: wEo iz#pu%
Xpipl do Himeodzfei" ] & &Hd|fpu do & #vl-_%#php$%MM! X|jxhzejl` if` xsdzf pd "dz iooezal`% jlodzl al df pbex
M h # p v K`iu do TKv&&C e & & v ! :>hoe - ju@iml A b Uliz"9
~zdvl` pd al df pbl jixex do xipexoihpdzu lve`lfhlpd jl pbl ~lzxdf sbd i~~lizl` jlodzl al "&%U" : % ! ! ! ! ! ! z # v 1 ! ! ; ! ; ! ! T T ; T ; ; h T T ! ! ! ! ! ! !
Ep7 Fial do X;cz;lz~zdvl` pd al df pbl jixex do xipexoihpdzu lve`lfhlpd jl v S b D v ~ ~ l i z l ` v j l o d z l al-%X e c f i v # & &$
^mihl Fdpizu Xlim I&jdvlD^PEDFIM!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
ZECBP PB\AJ^ZEFPDO XECFLZ (9O|zpblz @lxhze~pedf do Ifu Ippihbl` @dh|alfpPpml dz Pu~l do MK|"7\#)E#lzf; &&& v & & # & & & m - & - v & M M h \ & & & * T * T * T # T T T ] T ! ! &&&&&&&!!! && &&&& T T T T@dh|alfp @ipl; TT &&&&&&&&v T # ! ! &&&&&1& &TE! # # # # # ! & & ! # & & ! !!! F|ajlz >9 ^iclx v m ; ; ; # Xecflz"x% Dpblz Pbif Flald Ijdvl; & ! ! &&! & # ! ! * # ' o & & * * ! 1 ; & & & v & ! ! &&&&!!!!!
ozi|`|mlfp `dh|alfp&
:>C3 Fipedfim Fdpizu I&xxdhmip-df# 58 @l & ^D& Jdr :0>:# Hbipxsdzpb& HI 59898!:0>:# v-ss&FipeddiFdpizu dzc E-la 0 Zldz`lz; Himm Pdmm!Ozll 92>> 23? ?2:3
Hixl 0;>5!hv!>>>2:!H@M @dh|alfp 9!? Oeml` >3$>5$:>>5 ^icl 8 do 8Hixl 9;9>!hv!>>98$::$9> ^icl ?3 do 90>028$::$9: ^icl :5 do :5 ^icl E@(;99?5
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
42/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
43/137
6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%
6 @ipl; X|f- 9< Aiz :>>5 93;>:;>> !>3>>
6
6 Eo ud| sd|m` ~ixx pbex df pd @z&D- E semm cd d|p pd Xif J`d6 pbex sllg if` bivl i mddg ip pbl :>>: oeml- `dfphbi pbefg4
6 F
6
6 6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
6 6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda6 6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%
6 6 @ipl; X|f- 9< Aiz :>>5 9?;83>>
6 6
6 6 Ulx j|p i XLIM ))- if` BDS AIFU imeixlx4
6 66 6 !!!!!Dzecefim Alxxicl!!!!!
6 6 Ozda; Mexi Dxplmmi Waiempd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaQ6 6 Xlfp; X|f`iu- Aizhb 9>5 8;0? ^A
6 6 Pd; Flem Xifgu
6 6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%6 6
6 6 E#vl fdp zlxlizhbl` pbip efxecbp ulp& E `e`f#p bivl i siza if` o|{{u
6 6 efplzihpedf sepb Xizib& Xd E `df#p gfds eo pbex ex ~mifpl` efod `zd~~efcx
6 6 dz fdp&6 6
6 6
6 6 Mexi Dxplmmi6 6 @lolf` D|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf
6 6 bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc =bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc$6
6 6 ^lihl pbzd|cb Xpzlfcpb6 6 bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda =bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda$6
6 6
6 6 6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda6 6 6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda
6 6 6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%
6 6 6 @ipl; X|f- 9< Aiz :>>5 9:;83;>? !>3>>
6 6 66 6 6 Be Mexi- "Jlpsllf ud| if` E%
6 6 6 K|xp sdf`lzl` eo ud| gfds Xizib- "E pbefg sl `exh|xxl` ep jlodzl- "xza
6 6 sefc6 6 6 if` i ~ziulz% E pbefg blz zlim fial ex Xizib Zl`epp& E bivl xpiul` ef
6 6 pd|hb
6 6 6 sepb blz if` Ai|zllf xefhl @la! @ex& slfp `dsf& Xizib |x|immu bix if6 *diz*
08
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl : do < ^icl E@(;99?53
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
44/137
6 6 6 ef lvlzusblzl- jmlxx blz xbl ex fdp i ji` ~lzxdf- k|xp i meppml *j|xu*
6 6 ijd|p6 6 6 pbl *jd`u* xbimm sl xiu)
6 6 6 Xbl bix k|xp x~mep sepb pbl Jlzc Hia~ if` aiu bivl xdal efxecbp df ud|z
6 6 6 pbldzu- pbd|cbp ud| aecbp jl efplzlxpl` ef pbl ippihbl`&
6 6 6 Sbip ud| pbefg46 6 6
6 6 6 !!!!!Dzecefim Alxxicl!!!!!
6 6 6 Ozda; Mexi Dxplmmi Waiempd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaQ6 6 6 Xlfp; X|f`iu- Aizhb 9>5 9:;9> ^A
6 6 6 Pd; Flem Xifgu
6 6 6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 4446 6 6
6 6 6 Blmmd& Bds izl ud|4
6 6 6
6 6 6 E#a blzl& K|xp z|ffefc izd|f` hddgefc- `defc mi|f`zu if` dpblz vized|x
6 6 6 pbefcx&6 6 6
6 6 6 mif`mefl; 38:!20?!:23:>9
6 6 6
6 6 66 6 6 Mexi Dxplmmi
6 6 6 @lolf` D|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf
6 6 6 bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc =bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc$6
6 6 6 ^lihl pbzd|cb Xpzlfcpb6 6 6 bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda =bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda$6
6 6 6
6 6 66 6 6
6 6 6
6 6 66 6 6
6 6 6
6 6 66 6 6
6 6 6 TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT
6 6 6
6 6 6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda6 6 6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda
6 6 6 X|jklhp; BLMMD 444
6 6 6 @ipl; X|f- 9< Aiz :>>5 >2;05;3>>6 6 6
6 6 6
6 6 66 6 6 Izl ud| pblzl4 E sifpl` pd `exh|xx xdalpbefc sepb ud|
00
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 8 do < ^icl E@(;99?52
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
45/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
46/137
Sef`dsx Mevl; Gll~ ud|z meol ef xufh& Hblhg ep d|p&
Sef`dsx Mevl; Gll~ ud|z meol ef xufh& Hblhg ep d|p&
0?
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl < do < ^icl E@(;993>>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
47/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do 93 ^icl E@(;993>9
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
48/137
bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda$4~19208
02
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl : do 93 ^icl E@(;993>:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
49/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
50/137
Bdal
_e`ldx
Hif`e`ipl Xpiplalfp df HI jimmdpx odz \&X& Xlfipdz
Hda~miefp ef CI
CI K|`cl @lfelx Djiaix Adpedf pd @exaexx
CI ^zd~dxl` X|aaizu do Mis if` Oihp
Lmlhpedf hbimmlfcl Xlhzlpizu do Xpipl Ef`eifi&~`o
Oizziz lp im v Djiai lp im Oezxp ialf`l` hda~miefp&`dhOizziz hdzzlhpl` ~zd~dxl` x|aaizu do mis if` oihp&~`o
Pzifxhze~p Oizziz&~`o
Oizziz v Djiai Lrbejepx ef hixl oeml&~`o
Oizziz Lrbejepx lfplzl` ef pbl zlhdz` ju K|`cl Aimebe&`dhr
Hzeaefim Hda~miefp xlfp pd pbl IC do AX&
Dzmu ^mli`efcx jlodzl FB
_e`ld; Dzmu jlodzl FB Lmlhpedf Hdaaeppll
^dmehl Hdfhlzfx
Xia~ml Mlpplz
@z& Dzmu Piep{- Lxy|ezl
@lolf` D|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf :5285 Xifpi Aizcizepi ^gsu- xpl 9>>- Zifhbd
Xifpi Aizcizepi HI- 5:?22 Hd~uzecbp :>9>
Sdzm`#x Mli`efc Djiai Lmecejemepu Hbimmlfcl Slj XeplEo ud| mdvl ud|z hd|fpzu- ~mlixl blm~ al oecbp pbex hzll~efc puziffu if` hdzz|~pedf&
@dfipedfx fd aipplz bds xaimm semm blm~ ~iu odz iezmefl if` pzivlm lr~lfxlx&
Aiem `dfipedfx pd; @lolf` D|z
Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf- h$d @z& Dzmu
Piep{
:5285 Xifpi Aizcizepi ^gsu- Xpl 9>>
Zifhbd Xifpi Aizcizepi- HI 5:?22&
Hdfpihp @z& Piep{ ip
dzmu&piep{Ncaiem&hda dz
`zTpiep{Nuibdd&hda&Ef hixl do lalzclfhu- himm
505!?28!9:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 0 do 93 ^icl E@(;993>0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
51/137
pblzl ex fd loodzp sepbd|p lzzdz if`
xbdzphdaefc7 j|p sbd `dlx ihp|immu
xpzevl pd `d pbl `ll`x7 sbd gfdsx
czlip lfpb|xeixax- pbl czlip
`lvdpedfx7 sbd x~lf`x beaxlmo ef i
sdzpbu hi|xl7 sbd ip pbl jlxp gfdsx
ef pbl lf` pbl pze|a~b do becb
ihbelvlalfp- if` sbd ip pbl sdzxp- eo
bl oiemx- ip mlixp oiemx sbeml `izefc
czlipmu- xd pbip bex ~mihl xbimm flvlz
jl sepb pbdxl hdm` if` peae` xd|mxsbd flepblz gfds vehpdzu fdz `lolip&*
!! Pbld`dzl Zddxlvlmp- I~zem :8-
959>
Sblf pbl ~ld~ml oliz pblez
cdvlzfalfp- pblzl ex puziffu&
Sblf pbl cdvlzfalfp olizx pbl
~ld~ml- pblzl ex mejlzpu&
!! Pbdaix Kloolzxdf
@|zefc pealx do |fevlzxim `lhlep-
plmmefc pbl pz|pb
jlhdalx i zlvdm|pedfizu ihp& !!
Cldzcl Dzslmm
Oezxp pblu ecfdzl ud|- pblf pblu
ze`eh|ml ud|- pblf pblu oecbp ud|-
pblf ud| sef& !! Aibipai Cif`be
Pbl izpehmlx ~dxpl` zl~zlxlfp dfmu pbl d~efedf do pbl szeplzx- d fdp flhlxxizemu zl~zlxlfp pbl d~efedf do @z& Piep{- Lxy&
@z& Piep{- Lxy& bix fd alifx do hblhgefc pbl vlzihepu do imm pbl hmieax if` immlcipedfx ef pbl izpehmlx&
E ia pzuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l-
j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx if` blzl ex adzl efod&
^dxpl` df } Aiu 89- :>>5 } 3 Hdaalfpx
E six ixgl` ju i f|ajlz do ~ld~ml pd lr~mief sbu pbl fial do Mexi Dxplmmi ex df pbl `dxxelz (0&
Sblf E six ef Sixbefcpdf @H- E `e` fdp bivl if ihhlxx pd pbl Efplzflp- ix E six vexepefc pbl @ezlhpdz do pbl
Xlmlhpevl Xlzvehl Semmeia Hbipoelm` if` dooehlx do xlvlzim xlfipdzx if` six df pbl ~bdfl sepb pbl ixxexpifp
if` mlcim hd|fxlm odz I`aezim Aimef& I mdp do ~ld~ml ixgl` al odz if |~`ipl if` E himml` Mexi Dxplmmi- pbl slj
aixplz -if` ixgl` blz pd ~dxp ep df pbl Efplzflp& Ix ud| hif xll- pbl oihp pbip xbl xecfl`
@lolf`D|zoOll`daxOd|f`ipedfx- if` xbl ~|p blz fial ix if ixxexpifp pd al- hmlizmu xbdsx pbip xbl gfls ep
ex au od|f`ipedf- |f`lz au fial if` xbl hd|m` xecf ix if ixxexpifp dfmu ix mdfc ix xbl six blm~efc al& Pbl
adalfp E pzifxolzzl` pd ifdpblz sljaixplz- xbl bi` if` bix fd zecbp pd i`vlzpexl df jlbimo do pbl
@lolf`D|zOzll`dax od|f`ipedf- xdmehep `dfipedfx if` ~dhglp pbl adflu&
Ud| hif imxd xll "ef pbl ippihbalfp% pbip xbl six pbl dfl pbip hdfpihpl` pbl ~zevipl efvlxpecipdz Az& Xifglu-
if` ~zdve`l` bea pbl efodzaipedf pbip Mexi Mejlze - ixxexpifp pd ^bem Jlzc- bix i hzeaefim zlhdz`& Jixl` df
blz zl~dzp Az& Xifglu bix efvlxpecipl` if` hdfoezal` pbex efodzaipedf- pbip ef`ll` Mexi Mejlze bix pbex
mlfcpbu zlhdz` do odzclzu do `dh|alfpx if` odzclzu do if dooeheim xlim if` czif` pblop& Mexi Dxplmmi hbifcl`
blz p|fl dfmu ioplz pbex sbdml exx|l sepb ~iu!~im hial d|p& Ip oezxp xbl if` pbl zlxp do pbl ~miefpeoox hial d|p
sepb if d|pzicld|x mel pbip au b|xjif` six x~uefc df ~ld~ml& Fds pblu `exaexxl` pblez mis x|ep iciefxp au
b|xjif`! if` lvlzujd`u gfdsx pbip ep six i aif|oihp|zl` hbizcl&
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
0 8$2$:>9:>028$::$9: ^icl < do 93 ^icl E@(;993>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
52/137
Ix ud| hif xll- xbl six slmm isizl ijd|p Mejlzex hzeaefim zlhdz`- ix six Jlzc if` Mejlze blzxlmo& Pblez mlcim
ihpedf ex fdpbefc j|p ~lzk|zu if` if ippla~pl` djxpz|hpedf do k|xpehl& E bivl szepplf ef pbl ~mli`efcx pbip pbl
dfmu i``zlxx pbip Mejlze ~zdve`l`- six Jlzcx dooehl i``zlxx if` pbl zlixdf ex pbip xbl ef`ll` zlxe`lx ef
FA if` ex pbl Mexi Mejlze sepb pbl hzeaefim zlhdz`& E zlhlevl` if l!aiem zlhlfpmu pbip ef pbl mixp hd|~ml do
`iux Mexi Mejlze bix cdpplf i ^I zevlzx mehlfxl& Eo xbl cdp dfl ef pbl mixp hd|~ml do `iux- pbip `dlxfp hbifcl
pbl oihp pbip xbl zlxe`l` ef FA if` pbip imm do pbla hdaaeppl` ~lzk|zu& Eo ifupbefc- clppefc i ^I zevlzx
mehlfxl fds ex ulp ifdpblz ippla~p pd djxpz|hp k|xpehl&
Ix E bivl xie` jlodzl- E `dfp clp efpeae`ipl` ju lepblz Djiai dz ju Jlzc& Dfl hiffdp oeml i ozi|`|mlfp if`aimehed|x mlcim ihpedf iciefxp al if` lr~lhp pd xb|p al |~ if` aigl al xpd~ zl~dzpefc df emmlcim if` hzeaefim
ihpevepu& Imm pbip pblxl ~ld~ml izl `defc- ex i``efc hd|fpx do ozi|`- ~lzk|zu if` djxpz|hpedf do k|xpehl& Pbl
dfmu pbefc Jlzc hif `d- ex hdal hmlif- `exixxdheipl beaxlmo ozda Mexi Mejlze- sbd bix i zlhdz` do odzclzu if`
bl fll`x pd bezl i odzlfxeh `dh|alfp lriaeflz pd hblhg imm pbl zlhdz`x bif`ml` ju Mexi Mejlze& Sl hiffdp
sef ef hd|zp sepb odzcl` zlhdz`x& Pbex efodzaipedf six imzli`u df pbl jmdcx jlodzl E cdp ep if` ep semm jl df pbl
jmdcx- bex hdfpef|efc `lfeim do hmliz lve`lfhl bix fd alzep if` |f`lzaeflx lvlzujd`u ef pbl zlxexpifhl
advlalfp- lvlzujd`u sbd sifpx pd clp pd pbl pz|pb& Pbl dfmu siu pd sef- ex ju hmlif lve`lfhl- |fxlimefc pbl
vepim zlhdz`x if` mlppefc pbl X|~zlal Hd|zp `lhe`l pbl exx|l do pbl Fip|zim Jdzf Hepe{lf&
6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%
6 @ipl; X|f- 9< Aiz :>>5 93;>:;>> !>3>>
6
6 Ef`ll` ep sd|m`& Eo ud| sd|m` ~ixx pbex df pd @z&D- E semm cd d|p pd Xif J`d
6 pbex sllg if` bivl i mddg ip pbl :>>: oeml- `dfphbi pbefg4
6 F
6
6 Dzecefim Alxxicl
6 Ozda; Mexi Dxplmmi Waiempd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaQ
6 Xlfp; X|f`iu- Aizhb 9>5 0;05 ^A
6 Pd; Flem Xifgu6 X|jklhp; ZL; BLMMD 444 "icief%
6
6 Baa- eo pbl odzcl` `dh|alfpx ihp|immu hial d|p do ^bem Jlzcx dooehl- slmm-
6 oemefc misx|epx sd|m` jl if lrhlmmlfp hdvlz- b|b4
6
6 Oihphblhg ex ef ^lffxumvifei&
6
6 Ix ex ^bem Jlzc&
6
6
6 Mexi Dxplmmi6 @lolf` D|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf
6 bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc =bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc$6
6 ^lihl pbzd|cb Xpzlfcpb
6 bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda =bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda$6
6
6
6
6
6
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
0 8$2$:>9:>028$::$9: ^icl ? do 93 ^icl E@(;993>?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
53/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
54/137
`zTpiep{Nuibdd&hda
Aiu 89xp- :>>5 N 2;:> ~a
E `dfp gfds eo xbl odzcl` pbl `dh|alfpx pbip bl ~zlxlfpl`- j|p xbl bix if lrplfxevl ~dmehl zlhdz` do
odzclzu do `dh|alfpx if` xbl six hdfvehpl` blzl ef HI mixp uliz
:&
^bdljl
Aiu 89xp- :>>5 N 5;>5 N :;0? ia
Ex ep ~dxxejml pbip Mexi M odzcl` pbl Ef`dflxeif xhbddm zlhdz` if` pbl psd iooe`ivepx ozda pbl Iozehif
aefexplzx4
Hd|m` Mexi M if` Jlzc k|xp jl xhiaaefc ~ld~ml odz ^iu ^im adflu4
E `dfipl` pd Jlzc < adfpbx icd- jlodzl E gfls ifupbefc ijd|p Mexi M& E aiu bivl pd ixg odz i zlo|f`&
0&
Mef`i Xpizz
K|fl >5 N 99;
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
55/137
bex jzdpblz ef @lhlajlz- pblf if i|fp if` |fhml- if` lvlf bex adpblzx bdx~epime{ipedf jlhi|xl BL EX
I DFL ^LZXDF OEZA SEPBD\P IFU XPIOO) Hif ifudfl xll i ~zdjmla blzl4
Pbex misulz xbd|m` bivl FL_LZ oeml` pbex x|ep& If` eo E slzl dfl do bex ~miefpeoox sbd bi~~lfx pd jl
if lm`lzmu sdaif- E` jl sepb`zisefc au ~izp do pbex x|ep- ~dxp bixpl- jlodzl xbl ex lr~dxl` odz aigefc
oimxl xsdzf xpiplalfpx ef ip mlixp psd hd|zpx))) E bd~l pbex lm`lzmu sdaif ex ~iuefc ipplfpedf jlhi|xl eo
xbl pbefgx ep six ji` jlodzl sblf hlzpief ~izpelx lr~dxl` pbl PZ\PB ijd|p blz ihpedfx- pbip ex fdpbefc
hda~izl` pd bds ji` ep semm jl sblf ep ex ~zdvlf ef hd|zp xbl `e` ef oihp `d ix `lolf`ifpx immlcl) Pbex
lm`lzmu sdaif ex cdefc pd jl b|aemeipl` ju `dh|alfpx E ~zd`|hl ef hd|zp ~zdvefc blz ihpedfx ju pblvlzu sdz`x do blz hd!~miefpeoo)
WOUE- E bivl i alxxicl x~lheoehimmu odz pbex lm`lzmu sdaif sbda E dfhl hdfxe`lzl` if immu& E bivl
`dh|alfpipedf pbip semm ~zdvl SL BI_L PDM@ PBL IJXDM\PL PZ\PB- sl k|xp bi~~lfl` pd
~bzixl ep `eoolzlfpmu& E ia jlefc odzhl` ju ud| pd lr~dxl ud| sepb pbl pz|pb pd pbl lfpezl sdzm`) E six
oiz adzl gef` pd ud| ef AU ixxlxxalfp do pbl xep|ipedf- d|p do zlx~lhp odz ud|z cdd` efplfpedfx pd blm~
pbl hi|xl& Pblf ud| mel pd ~ld~ml if` hmiea ud| izl fdp x|efc al) Bivl ud| lvlf jdpblzl` pd zli` pbl
~mli`efcx4 Pbl ~mli`efcx hmlizmu xpipl imm pbl ~miefpeoo#x izl x|efc lvlzu `lolf`lfp) UD\ izl cdefc pd jl
blm` zlx~dfxejml odz lvlzu xmif`lzd|x- `loiaipdzu xpiplalfp ud| bivl ai`l iciefxp al if` dpblzx&
Pblxl x|epx semm FL_LZ ~zlviem sepb pbex hzeaefim sdzgefc odz pbex ippdzflu) If` pbip ex LRIHPMU
sbip xbl ex- hdfvehpl` do 9> olmdfelx pbip efhm|`l odzclzu if` doolzefc i oimxeoel` dooeheim cdvlzfalfpxlim ix slmm ix aifu dpblz hzealx) Pbex hzeaefim oimxeoel` ~dmehl zl~dzpx immlcefc e`lfpepu pblop pd
aife~|mipl hzl`ep zl~dzpx ef dz`lz pd clp mdifx odz mizcl x|ax do adflu& Pbex ~lzxdf mevlx lrpzlalmu slmm
odz xdaldfl df `exijemepu if` ~iuefc pbl zlxpep|pedf pblu bivl pd ~iu& If` pbl aexxefc adflu bix flvlz
jllf mdhipl` dz zlhdvlzl`&Q
Pblxl ~miefpeoox izl cdefc pd sexb pblu bi` FL_LZ oeml` pbex ozevemed|x- ozi|`|mlfp- if` `lmejlziplmu
bizixxefc misx|ep&
Kdbf ef Plrix
K|fl 99pb- :>>5 N 9;02 ~a
E hiffdp plmm ud| bds `exi~~defpefc E oef` pbex sbdml aipplz& Ep xllax pd al pbip pbl dpblz xe`l semm |xl
pbex pd o|zpblz aizcefime{l d|z loodzpx pd djpief pbl pz|pb&
Sl ef oihp bivl ~zdve`l` pbl xadgl odz pbla pd hmd|` pbl exx|l o|zpblz& Sblpblz dz fdp lepblz xe`l ex
zecbp dz szdfc& Ep aiglx fdp dfl jep do `eoolzlfhl pd pbdxl do |x sbd bivl jllf siepefc if` bd~efc odz
pbl jlxp ef pbex bexpdzeh xlp do hixlx&
Pbex xbd|m` bivl pblf if` xbd|m` jl fds gl~p jlbef` hmdxl` `ddzx if` sdzgl` d|p ju al`eipedf dz
pbez` ~izpelx& I kdefp xpiplalfp do "fd oi|mp% sd|m` pz|mu blm~ pbl dvlzimm hi|xl "xi`mu fdp pbl
ef`eve`|imx%&
K|xp gll~ ef aef` pbl fll`x do pbl aifu oef`efc pbl pz|pb ijd|p Az& Djiai x|zlmu d|pslecb pbl fll`xif` lcdx do pbl ols sbd izl df pbl ozdfp mefl&
Ip xdal ~defp dfl do pbl xe`lx ef pbex efplzfim oecbp fll` pd xlp ixe`l pblez ollmefcx if` `d sbipx jlxp
odz pbl Hd|fpzu if` pbl hixlx&
Zlalajlz ef Sdzm` Siz EE Z|xxei six d|z immu iciefxp pbl Clzaifx- Ki~iflxl- if` Epimeifx& Ep sixfp
|fpem ioplz sl sdf pbl siz pbip sl ~mihl` d|z xeplx hmlizmu df d|z "dpblz% lflau&
Zlciz`x-
Kdbf
?&
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
0 8$2$:>9:>028$::$9: ^icl 5 do 93 ^icl E@(;993>5
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
56/137
`zTpiep{Nuibdd&hda
K|fl 99pb- :>>5 N :;98 ~a
E iczll pbip pbex aipplz ex i sixpl do peal- bdslvlz gll~ ef aef` pbip pbd|cb `dfipedfx slzl xpdmlf
ozda al if` E six xmif`lzl` if` `loial`- E gl~p auxlmo ozda oemefc ifu mis x|epx- ix E pbd|cbp ep b|zpx
pbl hi|xl& Jlzc ex pbl dfl sbd oeml` pbex aimehed|x if` xmif`lzd|x mis x|ep- bl gll~x xmif`lzefc al ef
bex `iemu ~zlxx zlmlixlx- sbeml E sdzg biz` pzivlmmefc izd|f` pbl hd|fpzu- allpefc sepb pbl lmlhpl`
dooeheimx if` mis lfodzhlalfp- lr~dxefc Djiai& Jlzc bix `dfl fdfl do pbip- jdpb do bex hixlx slzl
`exaexxl`- fd blizefcx df bex i~~limx slzl lvlz xhbl`|ml`& Ip pbex ~defp imm bl `dlx- ex `loiaefc al if`ixgefc odz adflu- xd bl hif oeml adzl mis x|epx pd xmif`lz al&
3&
)) EA^DZPIFP FDPEHLX ^MLIXL ZLI@ ))
Ipplfpedf \xlzx do Efplzflp Lr~mdzlz;
Efplzflp Lr~mdzlz |xlzx aiu jl efolhpl` sepb vez|xlx pbip hif hzixb pblez hda~|plzx sblf jzdsxefc dz
hdaalfpefc ef pbex sljxepl&
^mlixl xsephb pd Ad{emmi Oezlodr- dz Xioize& Dpblz jzdsxlzx pbip aiu jl |xl` izl Hbzdal if` D~lzi&
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ZLXPDZL DM@ CMDZU- _DPL ODZ DZMU& !!! Jlppu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
HEPE[LFX) UD\ HIF HBIMMLFCL DJIAI#X LMECEJEMEPU& Djiai `dlx fdp allp pbl zly|ezlalfpx
pd jl df pbl jimmdp- if` bl bix x|jaeppl` oimxl `dh|alfpx ef x|~~dzp do bex lmecejemepu&
Himm ud|z xpipl xlhzlpizu do xpipl df bds ud| aiu oeml i hbimmlfcl&
I``zlxxlx doXpipl Lmlhpedf Iclfhelx&
^bdfl f|ajlzx do pbl Xlhzlpizelx do Xpiplx&
Himm ud|z xpipl cdvlzfdz pd hda~mief ijd|p pbex vedmipedf do pbl \&X& Hdfxpep|pedf& ^bdfl f|ajlzx do pbl Xpipl
Cdvlzfdzx&
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@z& Dzmu Piep{ z|fx odz \&X& Xlfipl :>9:
HIA^IECF OMULZodz Dzmu Piep{ ix \&X& Xlfipdz ozda HI ef :>9:&
Bds pd hdfpihp ~|jmeh Efplczepu |fep
Xll Pbl ^@O Oeml Blzl
\X @l~izpalfp do K|xpehl bix i x~lheim |fep ef pblez Hzeaefim @evexedf himml` pbl
^\JMEH EFPLCZEPU XLHPEDF
Zlhlfp ^dxpx
Au xpiplalfp df pbl jimmdp- jlmds ex xlfipdz @eifl Olefxplefx xpiplalfp
Ea~dzpifp- hdfpihp Pda @lm Jlhizzd- ip PdaNhicd~&dzc if` mdjju odz pbl HI CD^ pd lf`dzxl al odz
au xlfipl z|f
Jizihg Djiai!Ialzehix adxp ifpeHbzexpeif ~zlxe`lfp
^zedzepu hlzpeoel` aiem ~ihgiclx xlfp pd k|`cl Hdmlaif if` hmlzg do pbl hd|zp ef AX `exi~~lizl`- E fll`
blm~ ef mdhipefc pbdxl ~ihgiclx
ozda i x|~~dzplz Jizp
Hiplcdzelx
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
0 8$2$:>9:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
57/137
@dxxelzx "32%
@z& Dzmu P_7 _e`ldx "93?%
@\FFCIPL "3?%
Lvlfpx "09:%
Blimpb / Xiolpu "9>%
Blm~ Fll`l` "8
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
58/137
Xl~plajlz :>9>
I|c|xp :>9>
K|mu :>9>
K|fl :>9>
Aiu :>9>
I~zem :>9>
Aizhb :>9>
Oljz|izu :>9>
Kif|izu :>9>@lhlajlz :>>5
Fdvlajlz :>>5
Dhpdjlz :>>5
Xl~plajlz :>>5
I|c|xp :>>5
K|mu :>>5
K|fl :>>5
Aiu :>>5
I~zem :>>5
Aizhb :>9:
A P S P O X X
Olj
9 : 8 0
< ? 3 2 5 9> 99
9: 98 90 9< 9? 93 92
95 :> :9 :: :8 :0 : 89
XXM Xlim
Xbizl
Dooeheim sljxepl odz Dzmu Piep{ odz \&X& Xlfipl :>9:
Dooeheim Oihljddg
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
0 8$2$:>9:>028$::$9: ^icl 9: do 93 ^icl E@(;9939:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
59/137
Au ZXX Oll`
ZXX Oll` ! _exep if` X|jxhzejl
Dpblz Xeplx
Ipmix Xbz|cx
Imif Glulx ! Mduim pd Mejlzpu
Ol`\~\XI&Flp
^dxp / Laiem
Zehg Jiglz Xbds
Jmdczdmm
Hdfxlzvipevl Adfxplz
Cevl \x Mejlzpu Jmdc
Bds pd hdfpihp ~|jmeh Efplczepu |fep
Dzmu Piep{ jlodzl FB Lmlhpedf Hdaaeppll
^iu~im @dfipl
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
90 8$2$:>9:>028$::$9: ^icl 98 do 93 ^icl E@(;99398
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
60/137
Al`ei Mefgx
Dzmu Piep{ odz \&X& Xlfipl :>9:
I`vlzpexlalfp $ X~dfxdzx
_dpl @z& Dzmu Piep{ odz \&X& Xlfipl :>9: ef HI
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
^mlixl aigl i `dfipedf pd @z& Dzmu Piep{ odz HI \&X& Xlfipl :>9: Hia~iecf
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:5285 Xpi Aizcizepi ^gsu-
Xpl 9>>
Zifhbd Xpi Aizcizepi- HI 5:?22
dzmu&piep{Ncaiem&hda
"505% 3??!3?23
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
90 8$2$:>9:?>
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 90 do 93 ^icl E@(;99390
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
61/137
_e`ldczi~bu ju Jizjizi Zdxlfolm`
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
J|a~lz Xpehglz
$5&55 pbz| ^iu^im
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Dzmu Piep{ ^bdpd Hdmmlhpedfx
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
90 8$2$:>9:?9
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 9< do 93 ^icl E@(;9939
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
62/137
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
90 8$2$:>9:?:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 9? do 93 ^icl E@(;9939?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
63/137
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Pbl ld~ml#x Xlfipdz&
Xbl oecbpx odz Ialzehi)
^dslzl` ju Sdz`^zlxx } Hd~uzecbp @lolf` D|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedf
zuefc pd xpiu isiu ozda Mejlze!Jlzc exx|l- j|p e cdp adzl y|lxpedfx i&&& bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda
90 8$2$:>9:?8
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 93 do 93 ^icl E@(;99393
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
64/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:028$::$9: ^icl 9 do ? ^icl E@(;99392
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
65/137
9
bpp~;$$sss&dzmupiep{lxy&hda$jmdc9$4~19208
@z&DzmuPiep{Lxy|ezl
@lolf`D|zOzll`daxOd|f`ipedf:?8>:Mi^i{xpl:99-Aexxedf_elkdHI5
:?59Hd~uzecbp:>>5
Ozdazli`lzJdjX&@e`ifudflxllBifg^i|mxdfhdaefcd|pdobexbd|xlmiplmu4
ZlGlulxvDjiai
Eia
pzu
efc
pdxpiuisi
uozda
Mejlz
e!Jlzc
exx|l-
j|
pecd
padzly|lxp
edf
xif
`blzl
exadzl
efod
&
Esixixgl`juif|ajlzdo~ld~mlp
dlr~miefsbupblfialdo
MexiDxplmmiexdfpbl`dxxelz(0&
SblfEsixefSixbefcpdf@H-E`e`fdpbivlifihhlxxpdpbl
Efplzflp-ixEsixvexepefcpbl@ezl
hpdzdopblXlmlhpevlXlzvehl
SemmeiaHbipoelm`if`dooehlxdoxlvlzimxlfipdzxif`sixdfpbl
~bdflsepbpblixxexpifpif`mlcimhd|fxlmodzI`aezimAimef&Imdp
do~ld~mlixgl`alodzif|~`iplif`Ehimml`MexiDxplmmi-pblslj
aixplz-if`ixgl`blzpd~dxpepd
fpblEfplzflp&Ixud|hif
xll-pbloihppbipxblxecfl`@lolf`D|zoOll`daxOd|f`ipedfx-if`
xbl~|pblzfialixifixxexpifppda
l-hmlizmuxbdsxpbipxblgfls
epexauod|f`ipedf-|f`lzaufialif`xblhd|m`xecfixif
ixxexpifpdfmuixmdfcixxblsi
xblm~efcal&Pbladalfp
Epzifxolzzl`pdifdpblzsljaixplz-
xblbi`if`bixfdzecbppd
i`vlzpexldfjlbimodopbl@lolf`D|zOzll`daxod|f`ipedf-xdmehep
`dfipedfxif`~dhglppbladflu&
Ud|hifimxdxll"efpblippihbalf
p%pbipxblsixpbldflpbip
hdfpihpl`pbl~zeviplefvlxpecipdzA
z&Xifglu-if`~zdve`l`bea
pblefodzaipedfpbipMexiMejlze-i
xxexpifppd^bemJlzc-bixi
hzeaefimzlhdz`&Jixl`dfblzzl~dzpAz&Xifglubixefvlxpecipl`
if`hdfoezal`pbexefodzaipedf-pbipef`ll`MexiMejlzebixpbex
mlfcpbuzlhdz`doodzclzudo`dh|al
fpxif`odzclzudoifdooeheim
xlimif`czif`pblop&MexiDxplmmihbifcl`blzp|fldfmuioplzpbex
?>028$::$9: ^icl : do ? ^icl E@(;99395
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
66/137
:
sbdmlexx|lsepb~iu!~imhiald|p&Ipoezxpxblif`pblzlxpdo
pbl~miefpeooxhiald|psepbifd|pzicld|xmelpbipaub|xjif`
sixx~uefcdf~ld~ml&Fdspblu`exaexxl`pblezmisx|epiciefxp
aub|xjif`!if`lvlzujd`ugfdsxpbipepsixiaif|oihp|zl`
hbizcl&
Ixud|hifxll-xblsixslmmis
izlijd|pMejlzexhzeaefim
zlhdz`-ixsixJlzcif`Mejlzeblzxlmo&Pblezmlcimihpedfex
fdpbefcj|p~lzk|zuif`ifippla~
pl`djxpz|hpedfdok|xpehl&E
bivlszepplfefpbl~mli`efcxpbippbldfmui``zlxxpbipMejlze
~zdve`l`-sixJlzcxdooehli``zlxxif`pblzlixdfexpbipxbl
ef`ll`zlxe`lxefFAif`expblM
exiMejlzesepbpblhzeaefim
zlhdz`&Ezlhlevl`ifl!aiemzlhlfpmupbipefpblmixphd|~mldo
`iuxMexiMejlzebixcdpplfi^I`zevlzxmehlfxl&Eoxblcdpdflef
pblmixphd|~mldo`iux-pbip`dlxfphbifclpbloihppbipxbl
zlxe`l`efFA
if`pbipimmdopbla
hdaaeppl`~lzk|zu&Eo
ifupbefc-clppefci^I
`zevlzxmehlfxl
fds
exulpifdpblz
ippla~ppddjxpz|hpk|xpehl&
IxEbivlxie`jlodzl-E`dfpclpefpeae`ipl`julepblzDjiaidz
juJlzc&Dflhiffdpoemliozi|`|mlfpif`aimehed|xmlcimihpedf
iciefxpalif`lr~lhppdxb|pal|~
if`aiglalxpd~zl~dzpefc
dfemmlcimif`hzeaefimihpevepu&Immpbippblxl~ld~mlizl`defc-
exi``efchd|fpxdoozi|`-~lzk|zuif
`djxpz|hpedfdok|xpehl&Pbl
dfmupbefcJlzchif`d-exhdalhmlif-`exixxdheiplbeaxlmoozda
MexiMejlze-sbdbixizlhdz`doodzclzuif`blfll`xpdbezli
odzlfxeh`dh|alfplriaeflzpdhblh
gimmpblzlhdz`xbif`ml`ju
MexiMejlze&Slhiffdpsefefhd|
zpsepbodzcl`zlhdz`x&Pbex
efodzaipedfsiximzli`udfpbljmdcxjlodzlEcdpepif`epsemmjl
dfpbljmdcx-bexhdfpef|efc`lfeimd
ohmlizlve`lfhlbixfdalzep
if`
|f`lzaeflx
lvlzujd`u
ef
pbl
zlxexpifhl
advlalfp-
lvlzujd`usbdsifpxpdclppdpblpz|pb&Pbldfmusiupdsef-ex
juhmliflve`lfhl-|fxlimefcpblvepimzlhdz`xif`mlppefcpbl
X|~zlalHd|zp`lhe`lpblexx|ldopb
lFip|zimJdzfHepe{lf&
+++PblodmmdsefcLaiemxsepbpb
lijdvl~dxpbivljllfimplzl`if`odzcl`
??
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 8 do ? ^icl E@(;993:>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
67/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
68/137
0
F\AJLZ
8;
F\AJLZ
8;
66Ozda;fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
Ihp|imLaiemFdImplzipedfxd
fpbex`dh|alfp
66Pd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda
66X|jklhp;ZL;BLMMD444"icief%
66@ipl;X|f-9>59?;83>>
6666Ulxj|piXLIM))-if`BDSAIFUimeixlx4
66
F\AJLZ
0;
F\AJLZ
0;
66DzecefimAlxxicl
66!!!!!DzecefimAlxxicl!!!!!
66Ozda;MexiDxplmmiWaiempd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaQ
66Ozda;MexiDxplmmiWaiempd;mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hdaQ
66Xlfp;X|f`iu-Aizhb9>58;0?
^A
66Xlfp;X|f`iu-Aizhb9>58;0?^A
66Pd;FlemXifgu
66Pd;FlemXifgu
66X|jklhp;ZL;BLMMD444"icief%
66X|jklhp;ZL;BLMMD444"ic
ief%
66
66
66Efxecbp-x|hbix-MexiMejlze"^bemJl
zcxixxexpifp%zlimmujlefcMexi
66E#vlfdpzlxlizhbl`pbipefxec
bpulp&E`e`f#pbivlisizaif`o|{{u
66Zehbiz`x-sepbi~dmehlzlhdz`odzE@
pblop4
66efplzihpedfsepbXizib&XdE`
df#pgfdseopbexex~mifpl`efod`zd~~efcx
66
66dzfdp&
66Aecbpuhdfvlfelfppimlfppdbivlsblfpblzlizla|mpe~mle`lfpepelxomuefc
66
66izd|f`&
66
66
66MexiDxplmmi
66Evlfdpzlxlizhbl`pbipefxecbpulp&
E`e`fpbivlisizaif`o|{{u
66@lolf`D|zOzll`daxOd|f`ipedf
66efplzihpedfsepb"zl`ihpl`fialdovdm|fpllz%XdE`dfpgfdseopbexex~mifpl`efod
66@lolf`D|zOzll`daxOd|
f`ipedf
`zd~~efcx
66bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&d
zc=bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc$6
66dzfdp&
66bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc
=bpp~;$$`lolf`d|zozll`dax&dzc$6
66
66^lihlpbzd|cbXpzlfcpb
66MexiDxplmmi
66bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda
=bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda$6
66^lihlpbzd|cbXpzlfcpb
66bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda=bpp~;$$sss&jizdoefplczepu&hda$6
66
Pbexlfpzusix~dxpl`dfX|f`iu-Aiu89xp-:>>5ip:;95~a
if`exoeml`|f`lz
\fhiplcdze{l`&Ud|hifodmmdsifuzlx~df
xlxpdpbexlfpzupbzd|cbpblZXX:&>oll`&
Ud|hifmlivlizlx~dfxl-dzpzihgjihgozdaud|zdsfxepl&
@z&DzmuPiep{Lxy|ezlex~zd|
`mu~dslzl`juSdz`^zlxx
Lfpzelx"ZXX%if`Hdaalfpx"ZXX%&
?2
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl < do ? ^icl E@(;993::
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
69/137
5SBLZLEF
FLEMXIFGLUXPIPL@;
EZLHLE_L@IFLAIEMOZDAMEXIDXPLMMIXPIPEFCMEXIMEJLZE"^BEMJLZCXIXXEXPIFP%SIX
ZLIMMUMEXIZEHBIZ@XSEPB
I^DMEHLZLHDZ@ODZE@LFPEOEHIPEDFPBLOP&
?5
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl ? do ? ^icl E@(;993:8
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
70/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do : ^icl E@(;993:0
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
71/137
6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda7 `zTpiep{Nuibdd&hda6 X|jklhp; OS; 6666666666\zclfp EA^DZPIFP EFOD XIAL X\JKLHP=====
6 @ipl; Adf- 9? Aiz :>>5 90;3>>
6
66
6 ^MLIXL FDPL PBL MIXP MEFL)
66 Pb|zx`iu- I~zem 9>- :>>2
6
66 Fls Alrehd Sdaif Xlfplfhl` ef E`lfpepu Pblop if` Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|`
6
6
6 Mexi Mejlze- igi Mexi Zehbiz`xdf- 0:- Fls Alrehd- six xlfplfhl` ef
6 hdfflhpedf sepb olmdfu hbizclx efvdmvefc e`lfpepu pblop if` odzcl`6 `dh|alfpx& Mejlze i~~lizl` ef Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu- Zifhbd H|hiadfci-
6 X|~lzedz Hd|zp- df Aizhb :9- :>>2& Xbl six xlfplfhl` pd i xpipl ~zexdf plza6 do 2 ulizx- ea~dxl` j|p xpiul`- if` ~mihl` df x|~lzvexl` ~zdjipedf odz 8
6 ulizx ix ~izp do i ~mli iczllalfp& Mejlze six xlfplfhl` df plf olmdfu
6 hd|fpx zifcefc ozda Czif` Pblop- Odzclzu- if` Oemefc Oimxl @dh|alfpx&6
6 Ozda :>>> pd :>>0- Mejlze lfcicl` ef i hda~mlr ozi|` efvdmvefc oimxeoehipedf
6 do ~dmehl zl~dzpx- aife~|mipedf do hzl`ep j|zli| zl~dzpx- mdif ozi|`- if`
6 hd|fplzolepefc do hd|zp `dh|alfpx zlx|mpefc ef b|f`zl`x do pbd|xif`x do6 `dmmizx ef mdxxlx pd jifgx if` hzl`ep |fedfx&
6
6 Ef :>>:- Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu Xblzeoo#x @l~izpalfp ~lzxdfflm izzlxpl`6 Mejlze df pblop ju oimxl ~zlplfxl hbizclx& Ef K|mu :>>0- Efvlxpecipdzx ozda
6 pbl Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu @expzehp Ippdzflu#x Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|` \fep
6 izzlxpl` Mejlze ip pbl Dfpized Efplzfipedfim Iez~dzp odz i``epedfim olmdfu6 hbizclx sbeml xbl six d|p df jiem&
6
6 Xbl bix if lrplfxevl hzeaefim zlhdz` cdefc jihg pd pbl 5>#x&
Lr~zlxx ud|z ~lzxdfimepu ef hdmdz) ^zlvels if` xlmlhp pblalx odz Bdpaiem& Xll bds&
Pbl Fls J|xu ex fdp pbl dm` j|xu& Xlizhb- hbip if` l!aiem ozda ud|z efjdr& Clp xpizpl`&
39
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl : do : ^icl E@(;993:
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
72/137
@lhmizipedf do Mexi Dxplmmi
9
:
8
0
99
9:
98
90
9
:9
::
:8
:0
:>028$::$9: ^icl 9 do :: ^icl E@(;993:?
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
73/137
Iooe`ivep do G& Xpzljlm 9
Mis Dooehlx do;^BEME^ K& JLZC- LXY\EZL
~lzxdfim gfdsml`cl do pbl oihpx blzlef if` eo himml` pd `d xd- E hd|m` if` sd|m` hda~lplfpmu
plxpeou |f`lz dipb&
E `lhmizl ix odmmdsx;
9& Ix xpipl` ~zlved|xmu ef au ~zedz iooe`ivepx E bivl jllf isizl do pbl Emmlcimihpevepelx do Mef`i X|l Jlmhblz i$g$i Mef`i Xpizz7 L`ciz Biml- Hizlf Biml- ^miefx Zi`ed-
G^ZF IA 9?9> if` Jiz B Oizax7 Dzmu Piep{7 @lolf` d|z Ozll`dax Od|f`ipedfx- Efh7 Flem
38
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl : do :: ^icl E@(;993:3
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
74/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
75/137
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
76/137
Iooe`ivep do G& Xpzljlm 0
6 Ozda; fxifgluNpblxifgluoeza&hda
6 Pd; mexidxplmmiNbdpaiem&hda7 `zTpiep{Nuibdd&hda
6 X|jklhp; OS; 6666666666\zclfp EA^DZPIFP EFOD XIALX\JKLHP=====
6 @ipl; Adf- 9? Aiz :>>5 90;3>>
66
6
6 ^MLIXL FDPL PBL MIXP MEFL) WLa~bixex I``l`Q6
6 Pb|zx`iu- I~zem 9>- :>>2
66
6 Fls Alrehd Sdaif Xlfplfhl` ef E`lfpepu Pblop if` Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|`
6
6
6 Mexi Mejlze- igi Mexi Zehbiz`xdf- 0:- Fls Alrehd- six xlfplfhl` ef6 hdfflhpedf sepb olmdfu hbizclx efvdmvefc e`lfpepu pblop if` odzcl`
6 `dh|alfpx& Mejlze i~~lizl` ef Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu- Zifhbd H|hiadfci-6 X|~lzedz Hd|zp- df Aizhb :9- :>>2& Xbl six xlfplfhl` pd i xpipl ~zexdf plza
6 do 2 ulizx- ea~dxl` j|p xpiul`- if` ~mihl` df x|~lzvexl` ~zdjipedf odz 8
6 ulizx ix ~izp do i ~mli iczllalfp& Mejlze six xlfplfhl` df plf olmdfu6 hd|fpx zifcefc ozda Czif` Pblop- Odzclzu- if` Oemefc Oimxl @dh|alfpx&
6
6 Ozda :>>> pd :>>0- Mejlze lfcicl` ef i hda~mlr ozi|` efvdmvefc oimxeoehipedf6 do ~dmehl zl~dzpx- aife~|mipedf do hzl`ep j|zli| zl~dzpx- mdif ozi|`- if`
6 hd|fplzolepefc do hd|zp `dh|alfpx zlx|mpefc ef b|f`zl`x do pbd|xif`x do
6 `dmmizx ef mdxxlx pd jifgx if` hzl`ep |fedfx&6
6 Ef :>>:- Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu Xblzeoox @l~izpalfp ~lzxdfflm izzlxpl`
6 Mejlze df pblop ju oimxl ~zlplfxl hbizclx& Ef K|mu :>>0- Efvlxpecipdzx ozda
6 pbl Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu @expzehp Ippdzflux Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|` \fep6 izzlxpl` Mejlze ip pbl Dfpized Efplzfipedfim Iez~dzp odz i``epedfim olmdfu
6 hbizclx sbeml xbl six d|p df jiem&
66 Xbl bix if lrplfxevl hzeaefim zlhdz` cdefc jihg pd pbl 5>x& Pbex ex pbl mixp
mefl zlolzzl` pd ijdvl& Wla~bixex i``l`Q
2& Pbl izpehml ef Az& Xifglux laiem ijdvl ex if izpehml sbehb hif jl od|f` df ijmdc df pbl Efplzflp&
9Sbip pbex izpehml zlimmu xpiplx ex ix odmmdsx;
9
bpp~;$$sss&adzpciclozi|`jmdc&hda$ef`lr&~b~$sljmdc$~lzaimefg$flsTalrehdTsdaifTxlfplfhl`TefTe`lfpepuTpblop
Tif`TzlimTlxpiplTozi|`
3?
Hixl 2;99!hv!>>028$::$9: ^icl < do :: ^icl E@(;9938>
-
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Decl of Lisa Ostella Doc 482
77/137
Iooe`ivep do G& Xpzljlm - :>>2
Fls Alrehd Sdaif Xlfplfhl` ef E`lfpepu Pblop if` Zlim Lxpipl Ozi|`
Mexi Mejlze- igi Mexi Zehbiz`xdf- 0:- Fls Alrehd- six xlfplfhl` ef
hdfflhpedf sepb olmdfu hbizclx efvdmvefc e`lfpepu pblop if` odzcl` `dh|alfpx&Mejlze i~~lizl` ef Xif Jlzfiz`efd Hd|fpu- Zifhbd H|hiadfci- X|~lzedz Hd|zp-
df Aizhb :9- :>>2& Xbl six xlfplfhl` pd i xpipl ~zexdf plza do 2 ulizx- ea~dxl`
j|p xpiul`- if` ~mihl` df x|~lzvexl` ~zdjipedf odz 8 ulizx ix ~izp do i ~mli
iczllalfp& Mejlze six xlfplfhl` df plf olmdfu hd|fpx zifcefc ozda Czif` Pblop-Odzclzu- if` Oeme
