Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
Transcript of Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
1/28
Research Methods forBusiness Management
(MOD001105)Module Leader: Dr Noah Karley
Email: [email protected] Room LAB322 Ext. 5739
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
2/28
Lecture 3Understanding Research
Philosophy
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
3/28
Teaching Objectives
By the end of this lecture/seminar you should be able to: Define the key terms ontology, epistemology and axiologyand explain their relevance to business research. Explain the relevance for business research of philosophical
perspectives such as positivism, realism, pragmatism andinterpretivism. Understand the main research paradigms which aresignificant for business research.State your own epistemological, ontological and axiologicalpositions.
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
4/28
Influences on business research
Source: Bryman and Bell 2011 Figure 1.2
Epistemology , Ontology and Axiology (values) are branches of philosophy
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
5/28
Introduction
At every stage in our research we make
assumptions.These include assumptions about humanknowledge, the nature of the realities youencounter in your research, and what is important
or of value. These assumptions shape your your researchquestions, the methods you use and how youinterpret your findings
Therefore it is important to be able to recogniseand articulate what the philosophical choices andcommitments underpinning your research choicesare
6
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
6/28
Philosophical considerations
Question
What is the nature ofreality? ( ontology )
Something that isexternal to the socialworld
Something that exists inthe socially negotiatedmeanings that people
give to it
What is consideredacceptable knowledge?(epistemology )
Knowledge based onobservable phenomena
Law like generalisations
Knowledge aboutsubjective meanings
Details of specific cases
What is the role ofvalues in research?(axiology )
Research should bevalue-free
Research is shaped byvalues
Source: based on Saunders et al. 2012 Table 4.1
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
7/28
Ontological considerations Social ontology: the nature of social entities
What kind of objects exist in the social world?
Are social entities organisations, management- external to social actors or constructed by
them?
Source: Based on Tom Owens, Bryman and Bell 2011 - Powerpoints
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
8/28
Ontology: Objectivism
Objectivism is an ontological position that asserts thatsocial phenomena and their meanings have anexistence that is independent of social actors.
It implies that social phenomena and the categoriesthat we use in everyday discourse have an independentexistence that is separate from social actors.
Source: Bryman and Bell 2011 Key concept 1.13 Page 21
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
9/28
Ontology - Objectivism
An example of this may be management itself .
You may argue that management is an objective entityand therefore adopt an objectivist stance to studymanagement in a specific organisation.
In order to substantiate your view you would say thatthe managers in the organisation have job descriptionswhich prescribe their duties, there are operating
procedures to which they are supposed to adhere, theyare part of a formal structure which locates them in ahierarchy with people reporting to them and they in turnreport to more senior managers.
12
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
10/28
Ontology: ObjectivismObjectivism emphasises the structural aspects ofmanagement and assumes that management is similarin all organisations.
Insofar as management does differ in organisations it is afunction of the different objective aspects of
management e.g. different job descriptions, processes,hierarchical relations.
Within the same organisation there is an assumption
that management is the same thing
And that if anyone else studied management in thesame organisation they would arrive at the same findings 13
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
11/28
Ontology - Subjectivism / constructionism
Subjectivism asserts that social entities like management,culture, organisations - are created through the perceptions and actions of social actors. Social entities have a reality that is experienced and
performed, enactedAs social interactions between actors are a continualprocess, social entities are dynamic they are in a constantstate of revision
Social entities are also multiple they are different fordifferent people
Subjectivism is often associated with the termconstructionism, or social constructionism. 14
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
12/28
Constructionism
Social phenomena and their meanings arecontinually being generated by social actors
Social phenomena and categories are produced
through social interaction Social phenomena and categories are in a constant
state of revision Researchers' own accounts of the social world are
constructions
we are also participating in theconstruction of social reality through our research
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
13/28
Epistemological considerations
What is (or should be) considered acceptable knowledge?
Can the social world be studied
scientifically
?
Is it appropriate to apply the methods of the naturalsciences to social science research?
Positivism and interpretivism are two contrastingepistemological positions
Source: Based on Tom Owens, Bryman and Bell 2011 - Powerpoints
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
14/28
Epistemology: Positivism
If your research reflects the philosophy of positivism
you will probably adopt the philosophical stance ofthe natural scientist .
Social entities and phenomena can be studied in the
same way that scientists study non-living things andnon-humans
If you are a positivist, it is likely that you will prefer
collecting data about an observable reality and searchfor regularities and causal relationships in your data tocreate law-like generalisations like those produced byscientists. 21
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
15/28
Epistemology: Realism
Realism is a branch of epistemology which is similar topositivism in that it assumes a scientific approach to thedevelopment of knowledge.
Realism is another philosophical position which relates toscientific enquiry. The essence of realism is that what wesense is reality: that objects have an existenceindependent of the human mind.
The philosophy of realism is that there is a reality quiteindependent of the mind. In this sense, realism is opposedto idealism, the theory that only the mind and its contentsexist.
23
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
16/28
Direct realism and critical realism
Direct realism: Objects exist independently ofour knowledge of them.
Critical realism: What we experience of the realworld are sensations and images of things inthe real world, not the things directly.
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
17/28
Epistemology: Interpretivism
Interpretivism is taken to denote an alternative to thepositivist orthodoxy .
It is predicated upon the view that a research strategy isrequired that respects the differences between peopleand social entities and the objects of the naturalsciences
It therefore requires the social scientist to grasp thesubjective meaning of social action .
Source: Based on Tom Owens, Bryman and Bell 2011 - Powerpoints
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
18/28
Axiology - values
Axiology is a branch of philosophy that studies judgementsabout value.
Choosing one topic rather than another suggests that youthink one of the topics is more important.
Your choice of philosophical approach is a reflection ofyour values, as is your choice of data collection techniques.
Researchers demonstrate axiological skill by being able toarticulate their values as a basis for making judgementsabout what research they are conducting and how they goabout doing it. 29
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
19/28
Influences of personal values onbusiness research
The personal beliefs or the feelings of researcher affect everystage of research process, from the choice of research area tothe interpretation of results.
If we recognize that research cannot be value-free, we mightattempt to limit its constraint on objectivity.
Feminist writers (among others) argue for consciously value-ladenresearch, in which the researcher empathises with the
researched and encourages reciprocity.
Source: Bryman and Bell 2011 p. 30
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
20/28
Pragmatism
Pragmatism asserts that concepts are only relevant
where they support action . This means that the most important determinant ofyour position on each of the continua is the researchquestion one position may be more appropriatethan another for answering a particular question.For pragmatists, the importance of the meaning ofan idea (or a research finding) are its practicalconsequences .Pragmatists recognise that there are many different
ways of interpreting the world and undertakingresearch, that no single point of view can ever givethe entire picture and that there maybe multiplerealities. 32
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
21/28
What is a research paradigm?
Paradigms are a cluster of beliefs anddictates that influence:
What should be studied How research should be done How results should be interpreted
Source: Based on Tom Owens, Bryman and Bell 2011 - Powerpoints
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
22/28
Two Contrasting Research Paradigms
36
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
23/28
Objectivism and Interpretivism
http ://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1DDWVlgXTI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1DDWVlgXTIhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1DDWVlgXTIhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1DDWVlgXTIhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1DDWVlgXTI -
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
24/28
Sociological paradigms in organisational analysis
Radical humanistIndividuals needemancipation from thesocial arrangement oforganizations
Radical structuralistStructural powerrelationships result inconflict
InterpretativeOrganizations do notexist apart from theperceptions of peopleworking in them studytheir experiences
FunctionalistProblem-solvingorientation leading torational explanation
Radical
Regulatory
Sub
j
ectiv
ist
Ob
j
ectiv
ist
Source: Based on Tom Owens, Bryman and Bell 2011 Powerpoints; original fromBurrell and Morgan 1982
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
25/28
SummaryOntology is a branch of philosophy which is concerned with
the nature of social phenomena as entities .
Objectivism is the ontological position which holds thatsocial entities exist in reality external to social actors
whereas the subjectivist / constructionst view is that socialphenomena are created through the perceptions andconsequent actions of social actors.
40
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
26/28
Summary
Epistemology concerns what constitutes acceptable
knowledge in a field of study.
Positivism relates to the philosophical stance of thenatural scientist. This entails working with an observable
social reality and the end product can be law-likegeneralisations similar to those in the physical and naturalsciences.
The essence of realism is that objects have an existence
independent of the human mind.Interpretivism is an epistemology that advocates that it isnecessary for the researcher to understand the subjectivemeaning of social action. 41
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
27/28
Summary
Axiology is a branch of philosophy that studies judgements about values.
Pragmatism holds that the most important
determinant of the epistemology, ontology andaxiology adopted is the research question .
42
-
8/10/2019 Lecture 3 Understanding Research Philosophy
28/28
References
Gay, L. R. Mills, G. E. and Airasian. P. W. (2008).Educational Research: Competencies for Analysisand Applications. Harlow: Prentice Hall.
Saunders, M. Lewis, P. and Thornhill, A. (2012).Research Methods for Business Students. Harlow:Prentice Hall. Chapter 3.Bryman, A. and Bell, E. (2011) Business Researchmethods. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Chapter4 43 43 43 43 43 43 43 43