KyaKyaRRosa -osa -11908908
Transcript of KyaKyaRRosa -osa -11908908
4
Kya Rosa - 1908Kya Rosa - 1908
Inaugural Lecture and Address Inaugural Lecture and Address
at University of Pretoria, at University of Pretoria, 28 July 200528 July 2005
Virtual Thermodynamic Potential
Ignacy Cukrowski
Professor and Head
Department of Chemistry
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Outline of the presentation
Introduction
A bit of historyDynamic physical chemistry (kinetics) Equilibrium physical chemistry (thermodynamic)
Potentiometric (equilibrium) data by non-equilibrium equationSolution chemistry - work done in South Africa
Dynamic (non-equilibrium) data by potentiometric equation
Virtual thermodynamics in action - examples
Conclusions
Department of Chemistry at UP – my vision
Acknowledgements
4
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Alessandro Giuseppe Antonio Anastasio(1745 – 1827)VOLTA
On 20 March 1800, Volta, Italian physicist, informs the President of the Royal Society, Sir Joseph Banks, of the invention of the pile.
Pile device was the first in history "electric battery”,a source of continuous current
New source of energy
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Volta demonstrating the Voltaic Pile to Napoleon
Bonaparte
In June 1800, Napoleon reconfirms Volta as Professor of Experimental
Physics
at the University of Pavia.
Till today presidents of some European countries confirm scientists as Full Professor at Universities
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Michael Faraday (1791-1867 )English physicist and chemist
Faraday at work in his bottle-lined laboratory in the basement of the Royal Institution in London.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Michael Faraday
Theory of electrochemistry
Faraday's two laws of electrochemistry:
(1) The amount of a substance deposited on each electrode of an electrolytic cell is directly proportional to the quantity of electricity passed through the cell.
(2) The quantities of different elements deposited by a given amount of electricity are in the ratio of their chemical equivalent weights
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Here, members of the Royal Institution attend a lecture on
Magnetism and Light
by Professor Faraday
(London 1846)
Many years later, as Maxwell later freely admitted, the basic ideas for his mathematical theory of electrical and magnetic fields came from Faraday.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Faraday introduced to science
paramagnetics and diamagnetics
Tyndall said:
"Michael Faraday was the greatest experimental philosopher the world has ever seen; ... the mighty investigator”
Every year on Christmas Day, he presented at the Royal Institution his Faraday Lectures for Children
Christmas lectures for children continue to this day.
Two electrical units (for capacitance and charge) were named after Michael Faraday to honour his accomplishments
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
The discoveries by Galvani, Volta, Faraday and others indicated a promising future for dynamic electrochemistry.
Walther Hermann Nernst (1864 - 1941)German physicist and chemist
The Nobel Prize in Chemistry 1920Nobel Lecture, December 12, 1921Studies in Chemical Thermodynamics
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
The Nernst Equation and the Third Law of Thermodynamics
RTnFEK o=lnQ
nFRTEE ln−= o ∆rG° = –RT ln K
∆rG° = –nFE°
The brilliant thermodynamic analysis made by Nernst (1891) opened up excellent ways of getting at the
free energy changes in chemical reactions
NERNST Father of Equilibrium ElectrochemistryOverthermodynamical approach prevents
development of charge transfer at interfaces.
The direct conversion of chemical to electrical energy
was stopped for some 50 years.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Dynamic Electrochemistry becomes recognisedMax Volmer (1885 – 1965)
German professor of physical chemistry and electrochemistry
Max Volmer’s work formed the basis of phenomenological kinetic electrochemistry
Butler-Volmer equation
QnFRTEE ln−= o
Max Volmer became a director of the Institute of Physical Chemistry
and Electrochemistry.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Dynamic Electrochemistry – highest Honours
Jaroslav Heyrovský, father of electroanalyticalchemistry, recipient of the Nobel Prize.
All voltammetric methods used now in electroanalytical chemistry originate from polarography developed by him.
Jaroslav Heyrovský and his son Michael
(1890 - 1967)Charles University, Prague
1959
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Dynamic Electrochemistry - well established science
Wiktor Kemula The portrait of Frumkinpainted in the Picasso's manner
Alexander Naumovich Frumkin"father" of Russian electrochemistry.
A.N. Frumkin and J. O'M. Bockris (U.S.A. 1960)
According to Bockris:
“The Great Nernstian Hiatus”
was ended by Frumkin
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 2005
EQUILIBRIUM E-CHEMISTRY
DYNAMIC E-CHEMISTRY (KINETICS)
28 July 2005
M. Volmer J. Heyrovský A.N. FrumkinWalther Hermann Nernst
Physical Chemistry textbook
by Atkins
Physical Chemistry textbook
by AtkinsPhysical Chemistry textbook
by Levine
Analytical Chemistry
textbooks
Analytical Chemistry
textbooks
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Metal-Ligand interactions ( MpLqHr)Model of a Metal-Ligand system & thermodynamic stability constants
EQUILIBRIUM E-CHEMISTRY
DYNAMIC E-CHEMISTRY
Glass electrode potentiometry
Nernst equation
Thermodynamic potential
Voltammetric techniques
Many simplified equation
Thermodynamics
Kinetics (electron transfer)
Transport (to & from interface)
Two different WORLDS that did not talk to each other at all.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.65 -0.60 -0.55 -0.50 -0.45 -0.40 -0.35 -0.30 -0.25 -0.20Potential / V
Nor
mal
ised
cur
rent
(A)
p[H](1)p[H](n)
p[H]
Dynamic and labile M-L system
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.70 -0.60 -0.50 -0.40 -0.30 -0.20Potential / V
Nor
mal
ised
cur
rent
∆ Ip
(B)
p[H](1)
p[H](n)
Inert metal complexes
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.70 -0.60 -0.50 -0.40 -0.30 -0.20Potential / V
Nor
mal
ised
cur
rent
(C)
p[H](1)
p[H](n)
p[H]
Mixed (labile & inert) M-L system
Homogeneous
Equilibria
Reversible
Interfacial
kinetics?Quasi-Reversible
Irreversible
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
jTML L
nFRT
II
nFRTE js
c ][lnln)()(
/ β=−21∆
jTMLs
c LnFRT
II
nFRTE
N
j ][lnln)()(
/ ∑=−0
21 β∆
∑=N j
TMX XXF j0
0 ][][ β
∑=N i
Tj
TYMX YXYXF ij0
00 ][][],[ β
1) Main experimental variable – ∆E
Lingane
DeFord-Hume
Leden–DeFord–Hume
Leden–Schaap–Mc Master
1941
1951
1961
1951
Still regarded as the method in the field
Harris, Quantitative Chemical Analysis, 5th ed. 1999Skoog, …Fundamentals of Anal. Chem 6th ed. 1992
Dynamic and labile M-L system
Mass-balance equations not involved
No rigorous refinement of stability constants
Limited applications with quite uncertain results
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
][][
LKLKDDD
ML
MLMLM++=
1
( )( )2)( )(
)()(
MN
MNNNMMNNNLML
I
IcIcIIKK
−−×=
2) Experimental variable – ∆I
Kačena and Matoušek
Inert comlex ML (at fixed pH)
Schwarzenbach
1952
1953
For over 40 years there was not a significant
progress made in the field
Is there any room for
further development?
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
A paradigm shift
(1996)
( ))()(
)( ][][lnln
)(
)()()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
II
nFRTEE
s
ccs
=
−−
Any kind of comlex MxL(1)yL(2)z (at any experimental conditions)
Corrected shift in potential (∆Ep or ∆E1/2) or change in potential (ISE)
Cukrowski
[M] from mass-balance equations; modelling–refinement: ECFC & CCFC
I. Cukrowski, Anal. Chim. Acta 336 (1996) 23-36
I. Cukrowski, M. Adsetts, J. Electroanal. Chem. 429 (1997) 129-137
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
50
100
150
200
250
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
p[H]
Cor
rect
ed s
hift
/ mV
Cdx(OH)y
Pbx(OH)y
Cd-DPA-2
Pb-DPA-2
Cd-PICOL
Pb-PICOLCd-HEEN
( ))(
)()( )()()()( ln
ixixix s
ccsII
nFRTEECS
−−=
Corrected shift & Experimental Complex Formation Curves
Objective function to be reproduced by theoretical model
I. Cukrowski, M. Adsetts, J. Electroanal. Chem. 429 (1997) 129-137
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
M + 4H + L ↔ M(H4L) βM(H4L) = [MH4L] / [M][H]4[L] M + 2H + L ↔ M(H2L) βM(H2L) = [MH2L] / [M][H]2[L] 2M + L ↔ M2L βM2L = [M2L] / [M]2[L] M + L ↔ ML βML = [ML] / [M][L] M + 2L ↔ ML2 βML2 = [ML2] / [M][L]2 M + L + OH ↔ ML(OH) βML(OH) = [ML(OH)] / [M][L][OH]
M + OH ↔ M(OH) βM(OH) = [M(OH)] / [M][OH] M + 2OH ↔ M(OH)2 βM(OH)2 = [M(OH)2] / [M][OH]2 M + 3OH ↔ M(OH)3 βM(OH)3 = [M(OH)3] / [M][OH]3 M + 4OH ↔ M(OH)4 βM(OH)4 = [M(OH)4] / [M][OH]4 2M + OH ↔ M2(OH) βM2(OH) = [M2(OH)] / [M]2[OH] 4M + 4OH ↔ M4(OH)4 βM4(OH)4 = [M4(OH)4] / [M]4[OH]4
H + L ↔ HL K1H = [HL] / [H][L]
H + HL ↔ H2L K2H = [H2L] / [H][HL]
H + H2L ↔ H3L K3H = [H3L] / [H][H2L]
H + H3L ↔ H4L K4H = [H4L] / [H][H3L]
H + H4L ↔ H5L K5H = [H5L] / [H][H4L]
H + H5L ↔ H6L K6H = [H6L] / [H][H5L]
Complexes:Protonated
Polynuclear
Labile
Inert
hydroxo
I. Cukrowski et al, Anal. Chim. Acta 379 (1999) 217-226
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
[MT] = [M] + βM(H4L)[M][H]4[L] + βM(H2L)[M][H]2[L]+ 2βM2L[M]2[L] + βML[M][L] + βML2[M][L]2 +
βML(OH)[M][L][OH] + βM(OH)[M][OH] + βM(OH)2[M][OH]2 + βM(OH)3[M][OH]3 + βM(OH)4[M][OH]4 +
2βM2(OH)[M]2[OH] + + 4βM4(OH)4[M]4[OH]4
[LT] = [L] + K1H[H][L] + K1
HK2H[H]2[L] + K1
HK2HK3
H[H]3[L] + K1HK2
HK3HK4
H[H]4[L] + K1HK2
HK3HK4
HK5H[H]5[L]
+ K1HK2
HK3HK4
HK5HK6
H[H]6[L] + βM(H4L)[M][H]4[L] + βM(H2L)[M][H]2[L] + βM2L[M]2[L] + βML[M][L] +
2βML2[M][L]2 + βML(OH)[M][L][OH]
)(][][ln
ix
T
MM
nFRT
Computed Complex
Formation Curve
Theoretical model
{q(RT/nF)}/p
New definition of Nernstian slope
(modelling of M-L systems)
I. Cukrowski et al, Anal. Chim. Acta 379 (1999) 217-226
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Nernstian data by DYNAMIC ELECTROCHEMISTRY equation
ECFC and CCFC for Cd(II)-Glycine system studied by DPP and ISE
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
p[H]
Shift
in p
oten
tial /
mV
ISE: [L T]:[M T] = 5.7[M T] = 1E-3 M
ISE; [L T]:[M T] = 50[M T] = 5E-4 M
DPP: [L T]:[M T] = 400[M T] = 8.32E-5 M
( ))()(
)( ][][ln
)()(ln)()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
sIcI
nFRTcEsE
=
−−
I. Cukrowski, G. Ngigi, Electroanalysis 13 No. 15 (2001) 1242-1252
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Metal-Ligand interactions ( MpLqHr)
Model of a Metal-Ligand system & thermodynamic stability constants
EQUILIBRIUM E-CHEMISTRY DYNAMIC E-CHEMISTRY
( ))()(
)( ][][ln
)()(ln)()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
sIcI
nFRTcEsE
=
−−
Potentiometric data changed to
Virtual dynamic dataThe same equation is valid for fully dynamic
and reversible M-L system studied by voltammetry
Nernst domain by equation for the dynamic data treatment at any experimental conditions
I. Cukrowski, G. Ngigi, Electroanalysis 13 No. 15 (2001) 1242-1252
I. Cukrowski, N. Maseko, Electroanalysis 15 No. 17 (2003) 1377-1388
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Quantitative voltammetric analysis of a metal ion
Concentration
Cur
rent
E p = const
8
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
ISE response vs. [M2+]
-Log [M]
ISE
Pote
ntia
l or E
p / m
V
slope = 30 mV
2 3 4 5
ISE
pote
ntia
l / m
V
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
-0.7 -0.65 -0.6 -0.55 -0.5 -0.45 -0.4 -0.35
Applied potential / mV
Cur
rent
/ ar
bitr
ary
units
E p
‘Virtual ISE’ from polarographic results
Virtual thermodynamic dataD
PP p
eak
pote
ntia
l / m
V
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.65 -0.60 -0.55 -0.50 -0.45 -0.40 -0.35 -0.30 -0.25 -0.20Potential / V
Norm
alis
ed c
urre
nt
p[H](1)p[H](n)
p[H]
Peak of a free metal ionPeak representing
all metal species Shift in Ep
{Ep(s) – Ep(c)}
H2N OH
ODPP of a labile (or dynamic) M-L system
Glycine
Cd-Glycine-OH system
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 9.5 10pH
Cor
rect
ed s
hift
in p
eak
pote
ntia
l / (m
V)ECFC CCFC
[M] from solving mass-balance
equation
( ))()(
)( ][][ln
)()(ln)()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
sIcI
nFRTcEsE
=
−−
Refinement of stability constants: complex formation curves
I. Cukrowski, Anal. Chim. Acta 319 (1996) 39 – 48.I. Cukrowski, M. Adsetts, J. Electroanal. Chem. 429 (1997) 129 - 137
Cd-Glycine-OH system
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005Virtual thermodynamic data
)(*
)()( )(
)()(ln)( ixp
ixixp E
sIcI
nFRTcE =
+ )()()(* sIcIifcEE pp <<
y = 29.423x - 427.76R2 = 0.9998
-640
-620
-600
-580
-560
-540
-520
-7-6.5-6-5.5-5-4.5-4-3.5
Log [M ]
Cor
rect
ed E
p(ob
s) /
mV
E p* /
mV
Each datum point {Ep* at pH(i)} is theoretically calculated using
Nernst thermodynamics by dedicated software, e.g. ESTA
E = E° + 0.030 log [M]E = E° + RT/nF ln [M]
DPP as a ‘virtual’ potentiometric sensor.
Cd-Glycine-OH system
I. Cukrowski, J. Zhang, Electroanalysis 16, No. 8 (2004) 612 - 626
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7pH
Labi
le p
eak
curr
ent
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
-0.70 -0.60 -0.50 -0.40 -0.30 -0.20Potential / V
Norm
alis
ed c
urre
nt
p[H](1)
p[H](n)
p[H]
OHHO
OO
OH
N
Cd-HIDA-OH system
I. Cukrowski, N. Maseko, Electroanalysis 15 No. 17 (2003) 1377-1388
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5
pH
Shift
in th
e pe
ak p
oten
tial /
mV
Experimental and Computed Complex Formation Curves
( ))()(
)( ][][ln
)()(ln)()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
sIcI
nFRTcEsE
=
−−
ECFC
CCFC
Shift
Labile peak
Cd-HIDA-OH systemI. Cukrowski, N. Maseko, Electroanalysis 15 No. 17 (2003) 1377-1388
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
y = 29.48x - 453.80R2 = 1.00
-680
-660
-640
-620
-600
-580
-560
-7.5-7-6.5-6-5.5-5-4.5-4-3.5
Log [M ]
Cor
rect
ed p
eak
pote
ntia
l / m
V )(*
)()( )(
)()(ln)( ixp
ixixp E
sIcI
nFRTcE =
+
Virtual thermodynamic data
E = E° + RT/nF ln [M]
‘Virtual’ potentiometric [Cd] (ISE) sensor from voltammetry
Cd-HIDA-OH systemI. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, unpublished results
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
p[H]
Cor
rect
ed S
hift
in E
1/2 /
mV
Complex Formation Curves
N C
O
OH )(*
)()( )(
)()(ln)( ixp
ixixp E
sIcI
nFRTcE =
+
y = 19.62x + 174.72R2 = 1.00
-150-130-110-90-70-50-30-101030507090
-17-16-15-14-13-12-11-10-9-8-7-6-5-4log [M]
E1/
2(virt
) / m
V
(B)Virtual thermodynamic data
‘Virtual’ potentiometric Bi(III) sensor from voltammetry
E = E° + RT/nF ln [M]
Bi(III)-(Picolinic Acid)-OH system
I. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, A. v Aswegen, Helv. Chim. Acta, Vol. 87 (2004) 2135 – 2158
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Ni-MDP-OH system
Fitting of a DCTAST wave for Ni-MDP-OH at pH 2.847
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-1.2 -1.15 -1.1 -1.05 -1 -0.95 -0.9 -0.85 -0.8 -0.75 -0.7
Potential / V
Cur
rent
Fitting of a DCTAST wave for Ni-MDP-OH at pH 2.847
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-1.2 -1.15 -1.1 -1.05 -1 -0.95 -0.9 -0.85 -0.8 -0.75 -0.7
Potential / V
Cur
rent
Fitting of a DCTAST wave for Ni-MDP-OH at pH 2.847
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-1.2 -1.15 -1.1 -1.05 -1 -0.95 -0.9 -0.85 -0.8 -0.75 -0.7
Potential / V
Cur
rent
Fitting of a DCTAST wave for Ni-MDP-OH at pH 2.847
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-1.2 -1.15 -1.1 -1.05 -1 -0.95 -0.9 -0.85 -0.8 -0.75 -0.7
Potential / V
Cur
rent
Fitting of a DCTAST wave for Ni-MDP-OH at pH 2.847
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
-1.2 -1.15 -1.1 -1.05 -1 -0.95 -0.9 -0.85 -0.8 -0.75 -0.7
Potential / V
Cur
rent
P
OH
O
CH2 OHP
OH
O
HO
MDP
Involved heterogeneous kinetics:
(irreversible electron transfer)
Irreversible and mixed M-L-OH system
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Ni-MDP-OH system
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
2.5 3.5 4.5 5.5 6.5 7.5 8.5
pH
Cur
rent
/ ar
bitr
ary
units
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
Nor
mal
ised
cur
rent
/ ar
bitr
ary
units
Expected
Normalised observed
Involved homogeneous kinetics:
(mixed M-L system)
Involved heterogeneous kinetics:
(irreversible electron transfer)
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Kinetics of the M-L-OH system
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Virtual potential in modelling of the M-L-OH system
Ni-MDP-OH system
-1120
-1100
-1080
-1060
-1040
-1020
-1000
-11 -10 -9 -8 -7 -6
log [L]
E 1/2
/ m
V
Virtual potentialSlope = 30 mV / log [L]
M + L = ML
Virtual potentialSlope = 41 mV / log [L]
M + L = MLand M + 2L = ML2
Observed potentialSlope = 25 mV / log [L]
M + L = ML
(B)
Involved homogeneous kinetics:
(mixed M-L system)
Involved heterogeneous kinetics:
(irreversible electron transfer)
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Virtual potential (E1/2*) vs. [Ni]. DCP as a ‘virtual’ potentiometric sensor.
Ni-MDP-OH system
y = 29.613x - 864.51
-1120
-1100
-1080
-1060
-1040
-1020
-1000
-8.5 -8 -7.5 -7 -6.5 -6 -5.5 -5
log [M]
Virt
ual p
oten
tial /
mV
)(*
)()( )(
)()(ln)( ixp
ixixp E
sIcI
nFRTcE =
+
E = E° + RT/nF ln [M]
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Kinetic and equilibrium data working together in refinement operations
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
6 7 8 9 10 11
pA
Zbar
M
LT:MT = 2
Formation of ML
Formation of ML2
Formation of MLx(OH)y
log β Technique ML ML2 ML(OH)2 ML2(OH)2 OF/HF Ref. DCP 8.18(01) 13.86(03) ― ― 0.45 TW GEP 7.27* 7 7.98(01) 13.85(01) ― 21.59(03) 0.060 TW 7.98(01) 13.83(01) 16.78(03) ― 0.058 TW 7.98(fixed) 13.85(fixed) 16.71(07) 20.52(45) 0.059 TW VP-DC&GEP? 7.94(02) 13.75(02) 16.75(05) ― 0.018 TW ‡
Ni-MDP-OH system
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
y = 0.983x + 3.5421
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
1 3 5 7 9 11 13log K MOH
log
KM
L
Ca Mg
Cd
Ni
Zn Pb
Sm Ho
SnSm-MDP = 9.55Ho-MDP = 9.74
(B)
y = 1.0591x + 3.2796
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Sm-MDP = 9.74Ho-MDP = 9.95
CaMg
Cd
Ni
ZnPb
Sm Ho
Linear Free Energy Relationships in prediction of Log K1
I. Cukrowski, D.M. Mogano and J.R. Zeevaart, sent to J. Inorg. Biochem.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5Computed pH
Cur
rent
/ ar
bitra
ry u
nits
Observed current
Expected current
Normalized current
(A)
A study of Bi(III) by 2 voltammetric techniques
Bi(III)-EDDA-OH systemM(HL) – labile; ML & ML2 - inert
I. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, Chem. Anal., Vol. 50 (2005) 3-36
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5
Calculated pH
Hal
f-wav
e Po
tnet
ial /
mV
pKa4 = 1.4 pKa3 = 2.36
E j
Correction for the decrease in Id
E 1/2(virt) = E 1/2(obs) corrected for E j and decrease in Id
(46 mV / log unit)
Experimental pointsE 1/2 corrected for the formation of Bi(OH)
y = –5.49x4 + 33.12x3 – 83.97x2 + 121.18x – 6.8
E 1/2(M) = 77.3 mV
∆E 1/2
∆E 1/2
(A)
A study of Bi(III) by 2 voltammetric techniques
I. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, Chem. Anal., Vol. 50 (2005) 3-36
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
ML(Circles)
y = 19.238x + 162.88R2 = 0.9997
M(HL) + ML(Squares)
y = 19.487x + 164.62R2 = 0.9997
ML(DPP, triangles)
y = 19.607x + 188.06R2 = 0.9994
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
-9.2-8.7-8.2-7.7-7.2-6.7-6.2-5.7-5.2-4.7
Log [Bi]
E(vi
rt) /
mV
(B)
2 voltammetric techniques as virtual ISE in the study of Bi
I. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, Chem. Anal., Vol. 50 (2005) 3-36
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
y = 19.51x + 166.79
40
45
50
55
60
65
70
75
-18 -17.5 -17 -16.5 -16 -15.5log [L]
E(vi
rt) /
mV
-6.7-6.5-6.3-6.1-5.9-5.7-5.5-5.3-5.1-4.9-4.7log [M]
Slope 19 mV(ML)
Slope 26 mV (ML + ML2)
(B)Double function of virtual potential (modelling & refinement)
E = E° + RT/nF ln [M]
ML2 inertML labileM(HL) labile
0.03931.70 ± 0.0417.07 ± 0.0818.85 ± 0.07VP-DP & VP-DC
pH 1.7 and A-B
Acid-base and ligand titration voltammetric data from 2 virtual sensors refined
simultaneously by ESTA
I. Cukrowski, J.M. Zhang, Chem. Anal., Vol. 50 (2005) 3-36
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Metal-Ligand interactions ( MpLqHr)
Model of a Metal-Ligand system & thermodynamic stability constants
( ))()(
)( ][][ln
)()(ln)()(
ix
T
ixix M
MnFRT
sIcI
nFRTcEsE
=
−−
DYNAMIC E-CHEMISTRY
Change in thermodynamic potential (ISE)
Virtual dynamic data
)(*
)()( )(
)()(ln)( ixp
ixixp E
sIcI
nFRTcE =
+
Dynamic data in the form of a virtual thermodynamic potential
QnFRTEE ln−= o
EQUILIBRIUM E-CHEMISTRY
Now two different WORLDS are talking to each other
Virtual THERMODYNAMICS is working
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
1. Polarography-based virtual potentiometric sensor:
a) does not have linearity range limits (the response is of the widest-known linearity, by far better than reigning for so many years glass electrode)
b) is ion non-specific (opposite to real ISE)
c) in principle, several metal ions might be monitored (opposite to ISE)
d) should be possible to monitor pH (if the M-L system is known)
2. Simultaneous refinement of data from several polarographic experiments (e.g. DPP and DCP).
3. Simultaneous refinement of glass electrode potentiometric (low [LT]:[MT]) and polarographic data (large [LT]:[MT]) from several titrations.
Conclusions (Solution Chemistry)
4. Simultaneous refinement of glass electrode, and ISE or metallic potentiometric as well as polarographic data from several titrations.
5. Prediction of species formed (modelling of solution composition)must be based on the analysis of virtual potential
6. Significantly improved reliability of models and refined stability constants.
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Quo Vadis?
Nobel Prize in Literature 1905
Henryk Sieńkiewicz
simplyThe Best
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
For any University in the world the challenge is to:
1. Accept public support and broaden its social contribution without compromising its traditional independence
2. Strike a satisfactory balance between teaching and research
3. Find an ideal blend of required and elected courses
4. Satisfy students continuous demands for better instruction and satisfy promotion criteria based mainly on faculty member’s scholarly work
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Each university’s basic traditional function is to:
1. Enable students to learn from their cultural heritage
2. Help students to realize their intellectual and creative abilities
3. Encourage students to become humane and responsible people
4. Expend knowledge across the entire spectrum of disciplines
5. Add to the understanding and enjoyment of life
6. Provide imaginative solutions to the problems of society
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
University of Pretoria:
1. In many respects, is as any other University in the World2. Has the same social functions to perform3. Has the same aims and goals to achieve
4. Is, to some extend, a unique establishment, as any other University is
We, as the University, are not that different
But as Department of Chemistry, we are very much different
simplyThe Best
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
What is University known and internationally recognized for?
Number of students, or number of faculty staff?Rector, Dean, HOD (administrative leaders)?Wonderful or excellent (or unbearable) administration?Best (or worst) teaching facilities (lecture theatres or laboratories)?
No, not at all
Famous scientists (discoveries made)? Nobel prize winners – where they were educated?Nobel prize winners – where they have made their contributions?Published excellent research work
Yes, very much so
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005simply
The Best
TEAM WORK
Exceptional teaching
Outstandingresearch
National and internationalstanding and recognition
To become the bestimplies
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005simply
The BestTo become a strong Research
Department requires
Outstanding Research
Unique Expertise in the Department
Centre of Excellence
Strong research activities
Existing Research
Build on existingstrengths
Develop potential strengths
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005simply
The Best
Promote fundamental and applied research
App
lied
Res
earc
h
THRIP
Contractual work
Industrialpartners
Diff
eren
t sou
rces
of in
com
efr
om re
sear
chac
tiviti
es
Fund
amen
tal
Res
earc
h
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005simply
The BestDedication to
highest quality teaching
1. Excellence in teaching of 1st year chemistry
2. Establish and support a team of staff members dedicated to education
3. Research in education to be tested on our own chemistry students(continuous refinement of operation in improving educational goals)
4. Well-designed teaching program throughout the whole chemistry course, from 1st to 4th year level
5. Promote and support students with outstanding performance in chemistry
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005simply
The BestOperational Structure of the Department
CommitteeLeaderHOD
Committee
EXCO
Tim
e-ta
bled
and
ad
hoc
mee
tings
Ann
ual r
epor
t
1
3
4
2
Gen
eral
Sta
ff
Mee
ting
TEAM WORK
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005
Operational Structure of the Department
Departmental Committees
1. Educational Research Activities (ERA) - Marietjie Potgieter2. Departmental Teaching Coordination Committee - Wentzel Schoeman3. Research Coordination Committee (RCC) - Simon Lotz4. Maintenance and Safety Committee (MSC) - Robert Vleggaar5. Communication (liaison, publicity) Committee (CC) – Wentzel Schoeman6. Aesthetics Committee (AC) – Christien Strydom7. Support and Technical Staff Committee (STSC) – Robin Muir8. Fixed Facilities Committee (FFC) – Peet van Rooyen9. Centre for Interfacial Chemistry Committee (CICC) – Ignacy Cukrowski10. IT (PhD students and Staff Facilities) Committee (ITC) – Peet van Rooyen11. Finance Committee (FC) – Robert Vleggaar
8
Inaugural Lecture at UP Inaugural Lecture at UP 28 July 200528 July 2005Recent students involved in solution chemistry
University of Pretoria
Wits University
Valentine ChristienPreeti
Anton
Tumaini
Jian CarenCarina
Castelo Branco
Winny Geoffrey
Janine
Daniel
Philemon
Industry (SASOL, Anglo-Platinum, NECSA, CISA, PBMR)Metrohm (Switzerland) and Swiss Lab (SA)
NRF
Co-workers (local and abroad)
Acknowledgments