KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION)chich.edu.pk/wp-content/uploads/Download-File.pdf ·...

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s DWP M/s MediquipsM/s Shirazi

TradingM/s Siemens

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes No

Technical Evaluation

Dated: 05-10-2017Package No/Tender Number: PC/115677/01/CH&ICH

Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Echo Cardiography as Package

Part - I

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (BID EVALUATION)

(To be evaluated by Purchase Department)

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes No

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes No

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Non Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s DWP M/s MediquipsM/s Shirazi

TradingM/s Siemens

01Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate

by the ManufacturerYes Yes Yes Yes

Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION)

To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee)

(All Evaluation parameters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

PART - II

02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for

the specific tender in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes

03

Certificate from the Manufacturer about the

after sales services through agent or itself (In

casespecifically demanded in the specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes Yes Yes Yes

05Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/

Calibration EquipmentYes Yes Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes No

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Non Responsive

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATION

Package No/Tender Number: PC/115677/01/CH&ICH Dated: 05-10-2017

(All evaluation parmeters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item

Sr. No.Brand Philips Toshiba GE

ModelAffinity 70

EPIQ-7Aplio - 400

Aplio - I 900

Vivid S 60 N

Vivid E 95

Netherland Japan USA

USA (Affinity 70

EPIQ-7)

Japan/Malaysia

Aplio - 400

Aplio - I 900

Norway

(Vivid S 60 N

Vivid E 95)

Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted Accepted Accepted

Specifications: Accepted Accepted Accepted

PART - III

Specification Compliance / Evaluation Parameters

1Echo Cardiography as Package

Country of Manufacturer

Compliance with defined quality standards

Country of Origin of Product

/Model Number


Accepted Accepted Accepted


Responsive Responsive Responsive

Siemens Acuson S 1000 Acuson SC 2000

USA USA, Japan, RSK & Netherlands

(Acuson S 1000 Acuson SC 2000) Compliance Not Accepted Warranty offered is not

according to the required tender specifications Not Accepted Not Accepted

Non Responsive

Technical Eligibility of Product:

Technical Eligibility of Firm:

Technical Status:

Engr. Ahmed Maqsood Electromedical Engineer

Engr. Muhammad Umair Kabeer Biomedical Engineer

Dr. Khalid Hameed Zaighum DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Usaid Qureshi Assistant Professor Pead Cardiology

Dr. Syed Najam Haider Associate Professor Pead Cardiovascular Surgery

Engr. Nazir Zaidi Electromedical Engineer Mayo Hospital, Lahore

Dr. Asif ur Rehman Associate Professor Cardiology

PIC, Lahore

Dr. Zubair Akram Prof. of Cardiology/ HOD

Allama Iqbal Medical College Jinnah Hospital, Lahore

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s DWP M/s Shirazi Trading

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Portable Echo Cardiography


Part - I


03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s DWP M/s Shirazi Trading

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes

02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific tender in

specifications)Yes Yes


(To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee)


PART - II

03Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through

agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the specifications)Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes Yes

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Yes


PART - III



Item Sr. No.

M/s DWP M/s Shirazi Trading

Brand Philips GE

Model CX 50 Vivid IQ

Netherland USA

Singapore (CX 50) China (Vivid IQ)

Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Compliance

Specifications: Accepted Accepted

Accepted Compliance

Accepted Accepted

Responsive Responsive



14Portable Echo

Machine

Technical Status:

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number





Responsive ResponsiveTechnical Status:




Dr. Usaid Qureshi Assistant Professor Pead

Cardiology




PIC, Lahore



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Shirazi Trading M/s Mediquips




Name of the Equipment and Qty:- SonoSite Portable Ultrasound

Part - I










Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Shirazi Trading M/s Mediquips


To be evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee)


PART - II


02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific tender

in specifications)Yes Yes

03

Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services

through agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the

specifications)

Yes Yes



06 Warranty Yes Yes


KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATIONPackage No/Tender Number: PC/115677/24/CH&ICH Dated: 05-10-2017(All evaluation parmeters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr. No.

M/s Shirazi Trading M/s Mediquips

Brand GE Konica Minolta

ModelVenue 50

Sonosite Portable

Ultrasound Mahchine

SONIMAGE HS-1

USA Japan

China

(Venue 50

Sonosite Portable Ultrasound

Mahchine)

Japan (SONIMAGE HS-1)




PART - III



24 Sonosite Portable Ultrasound Machine


Specification Compliance features wise:


Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted


Specification



Technical Status:





Dr. Muhammad Asim Assistant Professor of Cardiovasular

Dr. Saeedah Asaf Associate Professor Anesthesia

Cardiovascular Surgery


Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Hospicare M/s Amtronech M/s Ozawa Traders

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes No



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Holter Monitor with Event Recorder



01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes No

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Non Responsive Responsive Non Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Hospicare M/s Amtronech M/s Shirazi Trading

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes


Yes Yes Yes




PART - II


in specifications)Yes Yes Yes

03



specifications)

Yes Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes Yes Yes

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATIONPackage No/Tender Number: PC/115677/02/CH&ICH Dated: 05-10-2017(All evaluation parmeters defined below are mandatory for compliance.)

Item Sr. No.

M/s Amtronech M/s Shirazi Trading

Brand Mortara BTL Industries

Model DR 200/Ea BTL Cardio-Point- Holter-08-H300

USA UK

USA

(DR 200/Ea)Bulghria

(BTL Cardio-Point- Holter-08-H300)



Compliance 1- Event loop recorder (Qty 03) as

mentioned in bid

not quoted

Compliance Not accepted


Specifications:


PART - III



2Holter Monitor

with event recorder

Compliance Not acceptedCompliance Not acceptedCompliance Not accepted

M/s Hospicare Cardioline

Walk 400H

Itlay Itlay

(Walk 400H)

Compliance 1- Event loop recorder (Qty 03)

as mentioned in bid not quoted NNoott aacccceepptteedd Not accepted Not accepted

Non Responsive Responsive Non Responsive

Specifications:Technical Eligibility of Product:Technical Eligibility of Firm:

Technical Status:





Dr. Syed Najam Haider Associate Professor Pead Cardiovascular

Surgery



PIC, Lahore



Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Total

TechnologyM/s Dymedix M/s Medi Urge

M/s Noor

International

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes No Yes No



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Fluid & Blood Warmer



01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes No Yes No



04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes



Remarks: Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Total


M/s Noor

International


Yes Yes Yes Yes


Evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee)


PART - II





03




Yes Yes Yes Yes




06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.M/s Total


M/s Noor

International

BrandBelmont Instrumen

Co.Enthermics Stihler Electronic The Surgical Company

Model Buddy 2 IV NOW1 Astoflo Plus ECO Fluido Compact

USA Not mentioned Germany Netherland

USA

(Buddy 2)

USA

(IV NOW1)

Germany (Astoflo

Plus ECO)

Netherland (Fluido

Compact)Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Non compliance Non compliance Compliance Non compliance

Fluid & Blood

Warmer

PART - III



Online system is not

Additional cost of

disposable

Additional cost of

disposable



3

Not accepted Not accepted Compliance Not acceptedNot accepted Not accepted Compliance Not accepted

Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Non Responsive

Technical Eligibility of Product:Technical Eligibility of Firm:

Technical Status:

Online system is not

Quoted

Under Specs

disposable

set of cassette

and patient IV line

and as per End User

Requirement

disposable

set of cassette

and patient IV line per

End User

Requirement

Compliance Specifications:









Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Vertex Medical M/s Shirazi Trading



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Anesthesia Workstation










Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Vertex Medical M/s Shirazi Trading

01Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the

ManufacturerYes Yes

02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific

Yes Yes




PART - II

02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific

tender in specifications)Yes Yes

03



specifications)

Yes Yes



06 Warranty Yes Yes




Evaluated by Technical Evaluation Committee

Item

Sr. No.M/s Vertex Medical M/s Shirazi Trading

Brand Drager Werk GE

Model Primus+IACS C700 Avance CS2+B850Germany USA

Germany/USA(Primus) USA/Europe/Mexico(Avance CS2+B850)Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Compliance Accepted AcceptedAccepted AcceptedAccepted Accepted


Specifications:Technical Eligibility of Product:Technical Eligibility of Firm:

Technical Status:

Compliance with defined quality standards Country of Origin of Product/Model Number

PART - III



6Anesthesia

Workstation









Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Hospitcare

Systems

M/s Human

Health Care

M/s Noor

International

M/s Biotech

Services

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Portable ECG


Evaluated by Purchase Department








Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Hospitcare

Systems

M/s Human

Health Care

M/s Noor

International

M/s Biotech

Services




Yes Yes Yes Yes




PART - II



03




Yes Yes Yes Yes









Item

Sr. No.M/s Hospitcare

Systems

M/s Human Health

Care

M/s Noor

InternationalBrand Cardioline Kalamed Nihon Kohden

Model ECG100+ KES-301 CardiofaxCItlay Germany Japan

Itlay(ECG100+) Germany (KES-301) Japan (CardiofaxC)Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Compliance Compliance




PART - III



27 Portable ECG





M/s Biotech Services

Suzuken KenzCardico 306 Japan Japan (Kenz306 ) Compliance Compliance AAcccceepptteedd Accepted Accepted

Responsive



Technical Status:









Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Endo Kare M/s Almed Solutions



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Fiber Optic Bronchoscope



01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes






Remarks: Non Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Endo Kare M/s Almed Solutions





PART - II

02 Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific tender in specifications) Yes Yes

03Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or

itself (In casespecifically demanded in the specifications)Yes Yes



06 Warranty Yes Yes




Evaluated by Technical Committee

Item

Sr. No.M/s Endo Kare M/s Almed Solutions

Brand Olympus Karl StorzModel (LF-GP/TP/DP) C-Mac

Japan GermanyJapan & Germany (LF-GP/TP/DP) Japan (C-Mac)

Compliance Compliance Specification Compliance features wise: Non compliance Compliance

Incomplete offer ComplianceNot accepted AcceptedNot accepted Accepted

Non Responsive Responsive

Technical Eligibility of Product:Technical Eligibility of Firm:

Technical Status:

PART - III


Country of Manufacturer Country of Origin of Product/Model Number


Specifications:

12F. Optic

Bronchoscope

Non Responsive ResponsiveTechnical Status:









Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Dymedix System M/s Human Health Care




Name of the Equipment and Qty:- BP Appratus


Evaluated by Purchase Committee








Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Dymedix System M/s Human Health Care


Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific tender in




PART - II







06 Warranty Yes Yes





Item

Sr. No.

M/s Dymedix System M/s Human Health Care

Brand W.A Baun Co.

Model 250USA

USA (0250)Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted

Accepted

Accepted

Accepted

PART - III





Specifications:



15 BP Apparatus

Accepted

Responsive

Yamasu Yamasu

Japan Japan Compliance Accepted Accepted Accepted

Accepted

ResponsiveTechnical Status:










Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Amtronech M/s Hospicare

Systems

M/s Reliance

Medical

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes Yes



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Near IR Spectroscopy



01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes Yes






Remarks: Non Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Amtronech M/s Hospicare

Systems

M/s Reliance

Medical






PART - II


specifications)Yes Yes Yes

03Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services


specifications)

Yes Yes Yes



06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.

M/s Hospicare Systems M/s Reliance Medical

Brand Medtronic Cobidien Casemed

ModelINOVOS Cerebral

OximeterFore-Sight Elite

USA USA

USA (INOVOS)

Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance

Accepted

PART - III





Specifications:

4Near Infrared

Spectroscopy

Accepted

Accepted

Accepted

M/s Amtronech

Masimo

Masimo Root Systems

Maxico USA & Maxico (Masimo Root Systems)

Compliance Non Compliance

SSeennssoorrss ffoorr neonates aarree nnoott available Not Accepted Accepted


USA (Fore-Sight Elite)


Accepted

Accepted Accepted

Responsive



Technical Status:

Specifications:









Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s

Forecare

M/s Eastern

Medical

M/s Vertex

Medical

M/s Sigma

InternationalM/s Meditech

M/s Human

Healthcare

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Suction Machine (Portable)

Part - I



01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s

Forecare

M/s Eastern

Medical

M/s Vertex

Medical

M/s Sigma

InternationalM/s Meditech

M/s Human

Healthcare


by the ManufacturerYes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes


Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes




PART - II


the specific tender in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

03





04 Bidder Past performance Yes Yes Yes Yes Unsatisfactory Yes


Calibration EquipmentYes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Resposive Resposive Responsive Resposive Non Resposive Resposive

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - PRODUCT EVALUATIONPackage No/Tender Number: PC/115677/17/CH&ICH Dated: 05-10-2017


Item

Sr. No.

M/s Forecare M/s Eastern Medical M/s Vertex Medical M/s Sigma International M/s MeditechM/s Human

Healthcare

Brand Medist Cheiron Medela Italian Medical ARDO SIEM - Nova

Model ME VACS M - 90 Victoria Basic Suction Pump New Hospivack 400 Ardo Suction Pump 611-A1 Max

Slovakia Czech Republic Switzerland Itlay UK Itlay

Slovakia

(ME VACS M - 90)

Czech

Republic(Victoria)

Switzerland

(Basic Suction Pump)Itlay (New Hospivack 400)

UK/Switzerland

(Ardo Suction Pump)Itlay (611-A1 Max)

Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted Accepted Not accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted


/Model Number


PART - III



1Suction

Machine(Portable)

specs

Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted Not accepted Not accepted Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted Not accepted Accepted

Not Accepted

(On previous

performance based)

Accepted

Responsive Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive


Technical Status:


Plastic body, not reliable

Sppecifications: Accepted Acceppted

to operate on hhiighh









Qty & Specs not as per requirement, I.e. 12 Nos. & 50 L/M

load

Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Hospicare M/s AmtronechM/s Bio Tech

Services

M/s Al Kareem

Medical Tech




Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Pulse Oximeter










Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Hospicare M/s AmtronechM/s Bio Tech

Services

M/s Al Kareem

Medical Tech


Yes Yes Yes Yes



Evaluted by Technical Committee

PART - II





03




Yes Yes Yes Yes








Evaluted by Technical Committee

Item

Sr. No.

M/s HospicareM/s

AmtronechM/s Bio Tech Services

Brand Medtronic Masimo Medlab

Model Nellcor PM100N Rad-97 Vitromap

USA USA Germany

USA (Nellcor

PM100N)USA (Rad-97) Germany (Vitromap)




M/s Al Kareem Medical Tech Andromeda VT-900 Series USA USA, China & Germany

(VT-900 Series) Compliance Compliance Accepted AAcccceepptteedd Accepted

Responsive




PART - III



16 Pulse Oximeter



Specifications:






Technical Status:









Responsive

Part - I

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Hoora

Pharma

M/s Meditec

Instruments

M/s Sigma

International

M/s Global

Marketing

Services

M/s AM Sales &

ServicesM/s Roche

M/s S Ejazuddin &

Co

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes



Name of the Equipment and Qty:- ABG Machine


Evaluated by Purchase Department

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Hoora

Pharma

M/s Meditec

Instruments

M/s Sigma

International

M/s Global

Marketing

Services

M/s AM Sales &

ServicesM/s Roche

M/s S Ejazuddin &

Co


by the ManufacturerYes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes


the specific tender in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

03




Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory)




Part-II


Calibration EquipmentYes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory)

06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.

M/s Hoora PharmaM/s Meditec

Instruments

M/s Sigma

International

M/s Global

Marketing

Services

M/s AM Sales &

ServicesM/s Roche

M/s S Ejazuddin

& Co

Brand SIEMENS Medica Co. Convergent OPTI Medical Nova Biomedical Cobas Radio Medical

Model Rapid Lab 348Easy State Blood

Gas AnalyserLiquical OPTI CCA - TS2

State Profile pHOx

PlusCobas B 221

ABL 80 Flex

Germany USA Germany UK USA Switzerland Denmark

USA (Rapid Lab

348)

USA (Easy State Blood

Gas Analyser)

Germany

(Liquical)

UK (OPTI CCA -

TS2)

USA (State Profile

pHOx Plus)EEC/Japan/USA

(Cobas B 221)

Denmark (ABL 80

Flex)

Compliance Compliance Complaince Complaince Complaince Complaince Complaince

Specification Compliance features wise: Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted

Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted Accpted



Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive


/Model Number

PART - III



21 ABG Machine



Technical Status:


Specifications:









Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Claris MedicalM/s Alliance

Medical




Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Dual Chamber Pacemaker










Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Claris MedicalM/s Alliance

Medical01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes



Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or




PART - II

03Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or

itself (In casespecifically demanded in the specifications)Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory)

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory)

06 Warranty Yes Yes





Item

Sr. No.M/s Claris Medical M/s Alliance Medical

Brand Osypka Medical Osypka AG

Model PACE 203 PACE 203 H

USA, Germany Germany

USA, Germany (PACE 203) Germany (PACE 203 H)


Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Compliance

Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted


PART - III



8Dual Chamber

Pacemaker




Specifications:

Responsive ResponsiveTechnical Status:









Part - I

Sr. NoEvaluation ParametersM/s Crocus

Scientific Trading M/s MediTech M/s Medi Serve

M/s Iqbal &

Company

M/s Medi

UrgeM/s Bbraun

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes No No Yes Yes Yes




Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Infusion Pumps








Remarks: Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

PART - II

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Crocus

Scientific Trading M/s MediTech M/s Medi Serve

M/s Iqbal &

Company

M/s Medi

UrgeM/s Bbraun

01Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by

the ManufacturerYes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes


the specific tender in specifications)Yes

Yes but not

enoughYes Yes Yes Yes

03

Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after

sales services through agent or itself (In Yes

Yes but not

satisfactory Yes Yes Yes Yes




03 sales services through agent or itself (In


Yes satisfactory

performance

Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Doubtful Poor Yes (Satisfactory)Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)


Calibration EquipmentNot mentioned No Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Non Responsive Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.

M/s Crocus Scientific

Trading M/s MediTech M/s Medi Serve

M/s Iqbal &

CompanyM/s Medi Urge M/s Bbraun

Brand SCO MED Codan Argus Smiths Medical Carefusion Fresenius Bbraun

Model IFP-1800

Argus 717 V

Wolumetric Infusion

Pump

Grasevy 1200

Infusion PumpAlaris - GW Agilia VP Infusomat P

Germany Switzerland Czech Republic Switzerland France Germany

Germany (IFP-1800)

Switzerland

(Argus 717 V

Wolumetric Infusion

Pump)

UK

(Grasevy 1200

Infusion Pump)

UK (Alaris - GW)France (Agilia

VP)

Germany

(Infusomat P)

Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Not Accepted Not Accepted Not Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted


PART - III



9 Infusion Pump


Specification Compliance features wise: Not Accepted Not Accepted Not Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Not Accepted Not Accepted Not Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Not Accepted Not Accepted Not Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Non Resposive Non Resposive Non Resposive Resposive Responsive Responsive

Specifications:

Price is mentioned in

technical bid

No past performance

record found

Accepted


Technical Status:

1-Display parameters

not according to

requirement

2-Warranty one year

only

1-Very poor past

performance

2-Infusion pump

operates on only 5

brands IVs

Infusion set (not

Accepted Accepted











Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Infant Radiant Warmer

Part - I

Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Medi UrgeM/s Dymedix

Systems

M/s Med

Equips

M/s Alam

Medix

M/s Shirazi

Tading




01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Medi Urge M/s Med

Equips

M/s Alam

Medix

M/s Shirazi

Trading





03




Yes Yes Yes Yes

Yes Yes Yes

PART - II



04 Bidder Past performanceYes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)Yes (Satisfactory)


Calibration Equipment

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes


06 Warranty Yes

M/s Dymedix Systems

Yes

Satisfactory

Yes

Yes

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive


Item

Sr. No.

M/s Medi UrgeM/s Dymedix

Systems

M/s Med

Equips

M/s Alam

Medix

M/s Shirazi

TadingBrand Cobams SRL Shvabe Zurich Atom Medicor GE

ModelLR - 90 (COD

07A)SNO UOMZ Sun Flower VLR - 2101 Lullabay Warmer

Itlay Switzerland Japan Hungary USA

Itlay

(LR - 90 (COD

07A))

Switzerland,

Russia (SNO

UOMZ)

Japan

(Sun Flower)

Hungary

(VLR - 2101)

India

(Lullabay

Warmer)

Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance


PART - III





11Infant Radiant

Warmer


Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted


Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

AcceptedAccepted Accepted Accepted AcceptedTechnical Eligibility of Product:


Technical Status:

Specifications:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Head Light

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Medi Urge M/s Dymedix Systems

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory)


01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes NO






Remarks: Responsive Non Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Medi Urge M/s Dymedix Systems





Evaluated by Techincal Committee


PART - II

02specifications)

Yes Yes



04 Bidder Past performance Yes (Satisfactory) Average

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes (Satisfactory) Yes (Satisfactory)

06 Warranty Yes Yes





Item

Sr. No.M/s Medi Urge M/s Dymedix Systems

Brand Integra Ecleris

Model Luxtec MLX 300 LUXUSA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number USA & Canada (Luxtec MLX 300) USA (LUX)Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Acceptable Not Accepted

Acceptable Under specsAcceptable Not Accepted

Acceptable Not Accepted

Responsive Non Responsive

Specifications:



Technical Status:


PART - III



23 Head Light

Responsive Non ResponsiveTechnical Status:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Non-Invasive Monitor

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Vertex

MedicalM/s Mediquips M/s Al-Kareem M/s Vital Care









Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Vertex

Medical

M/s

Mediquips

M/s

Al-Kareem

M/s

Vital Care

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes Yes Yes Yes


in specifications)Yes Yes

Yes

(Satisfactory)Yes


PART - II





specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes


(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration EquipmentYes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)

Yes

(Satisfactory)






Item

Sr. No.M/s Vertex

MedicalM/s Mediquips M/s Al-Kareem M/s Vital Care

Brand Drager Nihon Kohden Veiele Heyer Medical AG

Model Vista 120 Life Scope SE 1500 VizOR-17Germany Japan Sweden Germany

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number China(Vista 120) Japan(Life Scope) Sweden(SE 1500) Germany(VizOR-17)

Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable

Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable AcceptableAccepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive


Technical Status:


22Non-Invasive

Monitor

PART - III



Specifications:Technical Eligibility of Product:

Responsive Responsive Responsive ResponsiveTechnical Status:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Defibrillator

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Human

HealthcareM/s Mediquips M/s Biotech M/s Sigma

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No Yes Yes Yes







Remarks: Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Human




in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes


through agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the Yes Yes Yes Yes

PART - II




03 through agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the

specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes


(Satisfactory)

Yes


Yes

(Satisfactory)

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration EquipmentYes

(Satisfactory)

Yes


Yes

(Satisfactory)






Item

Sr. No.M/s Human


BrandUS Defib Medical

Technologies

Nihon Kohden

Cardio LifeInnomed Bexen Cardio

Model Cardiostart TEC-5631K Cardio aid 360-B Reanibex-800Japan Hungary Spain

Country of Origin of Product/Model NumberJapan /

TEC-5631K

Hungary /

Cardio aid 360-B

Spain /

Reanibex-800Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable

PART - III




22 Defibrillator

Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable



USA

USA / Cardiostart

Compliance Non Compliance Not as per

requirement , 1- Local Trolley quoted 2-Technical data not attached)

Not Acceptable Acceptable Non Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Specifications:



Technical Status:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Ventilator

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Noor

Internation

M/s Eastern

Medical

M/s

Hospicare

M/s Shirazi

Trading

M/s Vertex

Medical

M/s Total

Technologies

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes







Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Noor

Internation

M/s Eastern

MedicalM/s Hospicare

M/s Shirazi

Trading

M/s Vertex

Medical

M/s Total

Technologies

01Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the

ManufacturerYes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

02Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the

specific tender in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

PART - II




02specific tender in specifications)


03

Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales

services through agent or itself (In casespecifically

demanded in the specifications)



(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

05Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration

Equipment

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

Yes

(Staisfactory)

06 Warranty Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.

M/s Noor

Internation

M/s Eastern

Medical

M/s Shirazi

Trading

M/s Vertex

Medical

M/s Total

Technologies

Brand Hamilton E Vent Medical GE Drager WorkLowenstein

MedicalModel G-5 Inspiration 7i Care Scape R860 Avita V 300 Elise 600

Switzerland USA USA Germany Germany

Country of Origin of Product/Model NumberSwitzerland (G-

5)

USA

(Inspiration 7i)

USA(Care Scape

R860)

Germany

(Avita V 300)

Germany (Elise

600)

Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted

Accepted

Internal battery

M/s Hospicare

Covedian

New Port E 360 USA

USA (New Port E 360)

Compliance Accepted No Buit in Nebulizer

Model of Nebulizer,

Accepted Accepted AcceptedSpecifications:

PART - III




7 Ventilator

Accepted

requirement

backup not Air Compressor, according to Humidifier not


Accepted Not Accepted Accepted Accepted Accepted


Responsive Not Responsive

Quoted

Not Accepted Accepted

Not Responsive Responsive Responsive Responsive

Specifications:



Technical Status:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Forced Air Warmer

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Dymedix Systems M/s Reliance Medical









Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Dymedix Systems M/s Reliance Medical




PART - II









06 Warranty Yes Yes





Item

Sr. No.M/s Dymedix Systems M/s Reliance Medical

Brand Cocoon IOB Medical

Model CWS 4000 IOB Warming UnitAustrailia USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number USA(IOB Warming Unit)Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted

Accepted Compliance

Compliance

Responsive

Specifications:



Technical Status:

PART - III




26Forced Air

Warmer

Australia (CWS 4000)

Compliance Accepted Accepted Compliance Compliance

RResponsiive ResponsiveTechnical Status:










Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Laser Printer (Colour)

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Vertex M/s Google Tech









Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Vertex M/s Google Tech

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer No Yes




PART - II




agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the specifications)No Yes



06 Warranty Yes Yes

Remarks: Non Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.M/s Vertex M/s Google Tech

Brand HP Hp

Model No Model Mentioned HP/M452NWUSA USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number (Not Mentioned) ChinaCompliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Not Acceptable Acceptable

Not Acceptable Acceptable

Acceptable Acceptable

Acceptable Acceptable


Specifications:



Technical Status:

PART - III


29 Laser Printer



Non Responsive ResponsiveTechnical Status:



Mazhar Iqbal Noor Computer Programmer

Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge

Dr. Khalid Hameed Zaighum

(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim

Assistant Professor of Cardiovasular

Dr. Usaid Qureshi Assistant Professor

Pead Cardiology


Surgery


Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Computer System

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s VertexM/s Generation

System

M/s Fatemi

ImpexM/s Google Tech.









Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s VertexM/s Generation

System

M/s Fatemi

ImpexM/s Google Tech.



in specifications)Yes Yes Yes Yes

PART - IIKNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION)



02in specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes



specifications)

Yes Yes Yes Yes


05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes Yes Yes Yes

06 Warranty Yes Not Mentioned Yes Yes

Remarks: Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.

M/s VertexM/s Generation

SystemM/s Fatemi Impex M/s Google Tech.

Brand HP Lenovo Lenovo LenovoModel HP/800G3 Lenovo/M910 Lenovo /M910 Lenovo /M910

USA USA USA USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number China(HP/800G3)China(Lenovo/M

910)

China(Lenovo

/M910)

China(Lenovo

/M910)Compliance No Compliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Not Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable

CompliancePrinter without

Networking QoutedAcceptable Acceptable

Acceptable Not Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable

Specifications:


PART - III


30 Computer System



Acceptable Not Acceptable Acceptable Acceptable

Responsive Non Responsive Responsive Responsive


Technical Status:




Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge


(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim



Pead Cardiology


Surgery


Name of the Equipment and Qty:- DSL LINE wireless

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Optcl


01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) Yes

02 Original Receipt of Tender (Mandatory) Yes

03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes

04 Bid Security (Mandatory) Yes

05 Bid Validity (Mandatory) Yes

06 Delivery Period (Mandatory) Yes

Remarks: Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Optcl

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes


PART - II



02 Technical & Engineering capability (As defined for the specific tender in specifications) Yes

03Certificate from the Manufacturer about the after sales services through agent or itself (In

casespecifically demanded in the specifications)Yes

04 Bidder Past performance Yes

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes

06 Warranty Yes

Remarks: Responsive




Item Sr. No.

M/s Optcl

Brand CISCO

Model Linksys WAP300N

USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number USA

Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Acceptable

AcceptableAcceptable

Acceptable

Responsive

Specifications:



Technical Status:

PART - III


31 DSL Line






Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge


(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim



Pead Cardiology


Surgery


Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Video Conference

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s Amtech M/s Commtel System









Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s Amtech M/s Commtel System




PART - II









06 Warranty Yes Yes





Item

Sr. No.M/s Amtech M/s Commtel System

Brand Polycom/Samsung Huawei/Sony

ModelPolycom RealPresence Group 500,

Samsung Smart LED 55" MU 7000Huawei TE 40, Sony KDL 55

Thialand China

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number USA ChinaCompliance Compliance

Specification Compliance features wise: Accepted Accepted

Not Accepted Specifications are not according to the AcceptedSpecifications:

PART - III


32 Video Conference



Specifications are not according to the

requirements

Accepted

Accepted Accepted

Accepted Accepted


Specifications:



Technical Status:




Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge


(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim



Pead Cardiology


Surgery


Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Laptop Computer

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation ParametersM/s Google

TechM/s Fatemi Impex M/s Vertex

01 Complete Package/Tender (Mandatory) No No Yes







Remarks:Non

ResponsiveNon Responsive Responsive

Sr. # Evaluation ParametersM/s Google

TechM/s Fatemi Impex M/s Vertex



in specifications)Yes Yes Yes

PART - II






specifications)

Yes Yes Yes



06 Warranty Yes No Yes

Remarks: Responsive Non Responsive Responsive




Item

Sr. No.M/s Google Tech M/s Fatemi Impex M/s Vertex

Brand Lenovo HP HP

Model Lenovo IP320 Pro Book 450 G4Pro Book 450 G4 +

402 DNEUSA USA USA

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number China China China


Specification Compliance features wise: Non Compliance Partial Compliance Compliance

Incomplete pakage Printer

not Quoted

Printer not Quoted giving 1

year warranty not according

to tender

Compliance

Not Acceptable Not Acceptable Acceptable


Specifications:



PART - III


33 Laptop Computer




Non Responsive Non Responsive Responsive


Technical Status:




Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge


(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim



Pead Cardiology


Surgery


Name of the Equipment and Qty:- Multimedia Projector

Part - I



Sr. No Evaluation Parameters M/s National Industrial M/s Mecatech




03 Affidavit from Bidder Yes No





Sr. # Evaluation Parameters M/s National Industrial M/s Mecatech

01 Exclusive Authorization / Sole Agent Certificate by the Manufacturer Yes No



PART - II




specifications)Yes Not Satisfactory


agent or itself (In casespecifically demanded in the specifications)Yes Not Attached

04 Bidder Past performance Yes Not Available

05 Availability of relevant Tools and Testing/ Calibration Equipment Yes Not Mentioned

06 Warranty Yes Not Mentioned





Item

Sr. No.M/s National Industrial M/s Mecatech

Brand NEC Not MentionedModel NEC P501 X SCX 4001 X 1

Japan Japan

Country of Origin of Product/Model Number Japan JapanYes No

Specification Compliance features wise: Compliance Non Compliance

ComplianceIncomplete bidding documents, No

certificates, Under Specification item

quoted

Specifications:

PART - III


35Multimedia

Projector



quotedAcceptable Not Accepted

Acceptable Not Accepted

Responsive Non Responsive



Technical Status:




Mr. Riaz Shahid

I.T Incharge


(DMS (Purchase)

Dr. Muhammad Asim



Pead Cardiology


Surgery

KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION)chich.edu.pk/wp-content/uploads/Download-File.pdf ·...

Documents

Transcript of KNOCK DOWN CRITERIA - (VENDOR EVALUATION)chich.edu.pk/wp-content/uploads/Download-File.pdf ·...