Kimberlin v. Walker - 20140701 Transcript Redacted

8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker - 20140701 Transcript Redacted

1/60


2/60

"# $%& '"(')"$ '*)($ +*( ,*#$-*,&(. '*)#$./ ,0(.10#2

333333333333333333333333333345

56(&$$ 7",6&(1"# 5

589:;>/ 5

5?@ 5 ';?;9 #A@ BCDEFF

500(*# G017&(/ &$ 01@ 5

52H>H


3/60

B

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

8 ( * ' & & 2 " # - U

THE COURT: And youre representing yourself, correct?

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .H\ \;L@

$%& '*)($5 099 L;VS=@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .H\/ MAOL SA


4/60

R

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

]H/ 9;=HL:99M :;VOL:=;?H9M/ a;=S :99HV:=;A>HL =SLAOVS =SH

=S;


5/60

_

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 33 aAO9I `O\= LH9:M 33 LH9:=H =A

,:LM9: =SH 9:a/ :


6/60

F

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

cant testify because of a perjury conviction.

THE COURT: Oh I get it. But were not at trial yet.

,(@ 7IMBERLIN: I know. Im just 33

$%& '*)($5 6O= MAO `O\= a:AL MAOL

I;\JA?HLM :LVO]H


7/60

Y

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

: 9;==9H@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 Im just trying to get to that 33

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 I just want to know what Im 33 "

dont know what Im paying attention to, thats all.

THE COURT: I think youre capable of followinV ;=@

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 *K:M@

THE COURT: If I didnt I would slow him down but I

=S;


8/60

C

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 UA :99 L;VS= \A =SH< MAO 33

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 33 [LAIOJ=;A< A> IAJO]H


9/60

E

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

MR. OSTRONIC: Objection, your honor. Hes

\[HJO9:=;


10/60

PD

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

S:[[H


11/60

PP

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

THE COURT: Well I knew what the complaints all about

I dont33 you know, thats why we 33

MR. KIMBERLIN: So right now theyre coming in and

=LM;:J=\ :LH =SH >:J=\@

Did they defame me? Im not a pedophile. Im not a

murderer. Im not a terrorist. You know, these are things that

they say every day. Im not a rapist. They say Im a rapist.

$S;\ ;\ aS:= =SHM $aHH=@ " ]H:A99Aa@ " O


12/60

PQ

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 GH99 ]A?H A


13/60

PB

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99 a;=S >:9\H 9;VS= MAO S:?H =A \SAa

=S:= =SHM aH>;J;H =SH [9H:I;


14/60

PR

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

A=SHL \;IH :AL I dont 33

THE COURT: Why dont we hear from the defense and

=SH< MAO J:< LHTO=@ %Aa ;\ =S:=b

MR. KIMBERLIN: Oh, I guess thats fine.

THE COURT: Because all youre doing at this point is

=H99;


15/60

P_

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

THE COURT: I]


16/60

PF

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

JA> =S:= S:\ :?AL/ H?HLM =;]H@ .AO K


17/60

PY

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

[AL=L:M:9\@

.AO KA99Aa ]H =A JAOL=/ JA]H AO= :


18/60

PC

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

JAOL= :A99Aa MAO@

MR. KIMBERLIN: But all the other ones Ive met the

\=:=O=ALM IH>;


19/60

PE

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 33 \=:9K;;L\=

:]H;L\= =SH;9HI@

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 $SH I:=H a:\ :LAO 0[L;9/

1:LLM J:99HI/ \A 33

$%& '*)($5 *K:M THJ:O\H :]H JA][9:;


20/60

QD

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

October of 13 33

$%& '1&(75 $S:= a:\ PgQB MAOL SA


21/60

QP

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

dont have motions on.

$%& '*)($5 ,J':;


22/60

QQ

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

MR. OSTRONIC: Thats what I would say/ MH:S@

THE COURT: And thats harassment and with respect to

JAO


23/60

QB

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

MR. OSTRONIC: Well Ill just go down, first of all,

just to show as to plaintiffs motion for summary judgment.

0V:;< " a;99 [A; S:\


24/60

QR

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

[LA?;IH\ ;9HI a;=S ]:9;JH/ :;9HI

a;=SAO= [LAT:T9H J:O\H@ 0\ MAO K=H< AL : ?:L;H=M of reasons and its not

`O\= THJ:O\H A> :T\H [LAT:T9H J:O\H TO= =SHLH J:< TH A=SHL

]:==HL\ := =SH< e[SA S:\ [LA?;IHI


25/60

Q_

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,L@ ,J':;< :


26/60

QF

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 099 L;VS= ]A?;

[LAJH\\/ =S;\ A:J= MH\ " =S;:;L9M \;][9H AAL O\/

MAOL SA :TO\H A> [LAJH\\ LH^O;LH\ =S:=

=SH [9:;> H\=:T9;\S =S:= :LLH\= A> =SH [HL\A =SH [LA[HL=M A> =SH [9:;>/ LH\O9=HI >LA] =SH :TO\H A>

[LAJH\\@ %H S:\ =SH [LA[HL=M A> =SH [9:;>/ :AL =S;\ JAOL= =A LH\= SHLH ;< ,:LM9: [LA[HL=Mb

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 .H\/ :\ >:L :\ JA:L :\

:TO\H A> [LAJH\\ MH\/ MAOL SA


27/60

QY

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

33

$%& '*)($5 " =SAOVS= =SH H9H]H;L\= A> :99 =SH -H] J:\H/

aS;JS " K ;\ >:];9;:L a;=S THJ:O\H SH J;=HI ;=@ ":J=/ MAOL SA


28/60

QC

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

=S:= MAO \O[[AL=HI =S:= MAO =H\=;>;HI ;< =S:= A J;?;9 [LAJH\\

aS;JS \SAa\ =S:= =SH :TO\H A> [LAJH\\ a;99 JA]H >LA] 33 J: >;9H\ ;< >LA ]H SHLH@ 0TO\H

A> [LAJH\\ SHLH@ Im sorry, this is the1:KH %:99AaH99

Homeowners Association/ : QDDR J:\H aS;JS \=:=H\ =S:= =A

]:;AL :TO\H A> [LAJH\\@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 *K:M@

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 0 QDDR J:\H/ MAOL SA


29/60

QE

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

Homeowners Association, H= :9@ A< ':][TH99 ?@ =S:= 1:KH

%:99AaH99 Homeowners Association/ :nd thats at 157 Maryland

app. 504. And the language here Im directed to is, The tort

A> :TO\H A> [LAJH\\ ;\ JA


30/60

BD

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

=A 33 I knew that I couldnt show :TO\H A> [LAJH\\ THJ:O\H "

hadnt been arrested. It wasnt for the lack of them trying.

$SHM >;9HI J:\H :>=HL J:\H :>=HL J:\H =A S:?H ]H :LLH\=HI >AL

L:[H/ >AL \H4O:9 :TO\H/ >AL S:L:\\]HAL [HL`OLM 33

$%& '*)($5 2A MAO S:?H : J:\H 9:a A< JA


31/60

BP

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 *K:M@

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 .AOL SA


32/60

BQ

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

MAO cant then say well there was conspiracy to do so. And I 33

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 ,M 33

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 33 S:?H I;LHJ= J:\H 9:a A> QDPR SHLH

L;VS= ;< >LA MAO@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 0

[HL\A


33/60

BB

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 UO\=:; ':][TH99

?@ 1:KH %:99AaH99/ =SHM J;=H %HLL;:]:=;A


34/60

BR

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

K


35/60

B_

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

THJ:O\H SH S:\ \O]]:LM `OIV]H


36/60

BF

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 2;I MAO [LA[HL9M :


37/60

BY

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

;;9HI >AL ;]]HI;:=H \:


38/60

BC

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

:LVO]H


39/60

BE

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

H]A=;A


40/60

RD

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 2A MAO a:


41/60

RP

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

anybody on earth would say thats emotional distress. And Im

going to present that at trial. My daughters going to testify,

shes going to get up on that stand and shes going to cry, and

shes going to say that my friends cant even spend the night at

]M SAO\H THJ:O\H =SH\H VOM\ S:?H =A9I =SH;L [:LH :99/ : W;LV;:J=/ =S:= a:\ =S;\ 9:\= MH:L ;< =SH J:\H


42/60

RQ

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

A> &44A< ,AT;9H 'AL[/ ?@ 09TL;VS= IHJ;IHI TM AOL 'AOL= A>

0[[H:9\/ AOL >AJO\ 33 =SHM \:M AOL >AJO\/ =SO\/ ;\ [LA[HL9M A:]:=ALM >;9;


44/60

RR

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

[OT9;J:=;A


45/60

R_

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 33 A< :99 A> =SH\H :J=;A =SH\H

[9H:I; =SH\H =aHH=\/ S:?H MAO V;?H< S;] JA[;H\ A> :99

A> =SA\H =S;


46/60

RF

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " \:;I =S:= " aAO9I : ;=\H9>@ $SH ,:LM9:


47/60

RY

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

VA= :


48/60

RC

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 (;VS=/ ,L@ 7;]THL9;HL A> :99 A> =S;\

IH>:]:=ALM IAJO]HH


49/60

RE

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

^OH\=;A< A> V;?;


50/60

_D

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

;J:=H A> \HL?;JH >;9HI a;=S =SH JAOL=

33

$%& '*)($5 099 L;VS=@


51/60

_P

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 33 A< : =;]H9M T:\;\ A< =S:= LHV:LI

=AA@

,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .AOL SA;?H3];


52/60

_Q

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '*)($5 'AO


53/60

_B

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

TH==HL AL \H?H< I:M\/ MAOL SA


54/60

_R

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 *K:M@

$%& '*)($5 099 I;\JA?HLM ]O\= TH JA][9H=HI TM =SH

[9:;> :H


55/60

__

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

:\KHI >AL : LO9;


56/60

_F

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 *K:M/ MAOL SA A>>HL;>HL : a;=


57/60

_Y

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

MR. KIMBERLIN: Well and thats what I was asking

because theyre 33 : 9A= A> =SH 33

$%& '*)($5 .H:S, I dont think youre in a position

A> \=LH RgYgPD e[SAAL [LA=HJ=;?H ALIHL/ MAOL

SA


58/60

_C

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

,(@ *U$(*#"'5 %H I;I/ MAOL SA


59/60

_E

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

QB

QR

Q_

$%& '1&(75 'AOL= \=:


60/60

FD

P

Q

B

R

_

F

Y

C

E

PD

PP

PQ

PB

PR

P_

PF

PY

PC

PE

QD

QP

QQ

i 2;V;=:99M \;V

Kimberlin v. Walker - 20140701 Transcript Redacted

Documents

Transcript of Kimberlin v. Walker - 20140701 Transcript Redacted