8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

1/31

E S D A N M C . N P K @

D A N M . N P K @ B F H G Y F A V . G I . P O

U V L U U @ S B U N G U H G K R S @ \ F P \

Igtin-gme-r`h`gs` kgmgf`k`mt ajjlsn papuhgtlams4 suppart`e cysil`mi` ar sailgh iamsil`mi`1

mailto:John.Hume@glasgow.ac.ukmailto:John.Hume@glasgow.ac.uk

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

2/31

S`ir`gtlamgh

Jlsn`rl`s

Fhacghpgrtlilpgtlam ls 332622 klhhlam

Igtin`s gr`

f`m`rghhylmir`gslmf

Gjj`its jr`snwgt`r& kgrlm` spp.

Lm 3225 lt wgs

`stlkgt`e tngt 56clhhlamjlsn w`r`igptur`e

Saufnhy 3/9 w`r`r`h`gs`e

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

3/31

Vngt taahs igm w` us` ta `miaurgf` ar `mjari` I&S1

jrak Iaao` & Iawx (322:),Clahafligh Iams`rvgtlam

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

4/31

Iae` aj Rrgitli` jar S`ir`gtlamgh Jlsn`rl`s (322>)

Lmvahv`e stgo`nahe`rsjrak @urap`, Martn

Gk`rlig & Ai`gmlg

E`sirlc`s klmlkuk

stgmegres aj4 `mvlramk`mtghhy jrl`mehy

`tnlighhy gppraprlgt`

sailghhy gii`ptgch`

r`ir`gtlamgh jlsnlmf gme ltskgmgf`k`mt

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

5/31

Igtin g jlsn, put lt cgioCut lt swgk gwgy, lts

jlm`

Haw past-r`h`gs` survlvghr`me`rs r`fuhgtlam

lm`jj`itlv`Vny put e`ge jlsn

cgio1 Iamjhlit c`tw``m

kgmegt`e gme vahumtgryprgitltlam`rs

Ls tnls `tnlighhy saumegevli`1

umm`i`ssgry sujj`rlmf

faae w`hjgr` k`gmstngt gm lmelvleugh jlsn lslm faae n`ghtn, wltn ltsclahafligh syst`ks

jumitlamlmf prap`rhygme wltn ma lkpglrk`mt

aj jltm`ssVngt jltm`ss ea w`

k`gm? pnysligh ar`vahutlamgry1

Naw us`juh gr` tn`s` suff`stlams1

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

6/31

Authlm`

Jgitars gjj`itlmf lmltlgh kartghlty rgt`s Uatgh kartghltyGmgtakligh naaolmf haigtlamNaao typ`

Glr `xpasur`Cgratrgukg Jgitars wltn suc-h`tngh iams`qu`mi`s (e`hgy`e kartghlty) Rnyslahafligh lkpglrk`mt

Kuhtlph` I&S `v`mtsC`ngvlaurgh elsturcgmi` Yukkgry

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

7/31

Uatgh kartghlty

Y`v`rgh jgitars gr` kgdarigus`s aj kartghlty4

Gmgtakligh naao haigtlam

Cglt typ`

S`kavlmf e``p naaos

D-naaos

Igptur` e`ptn

Vgt`r t`kp`rgtur`

ngmehlmf tlk`s

Gv`rgf` kartghlty ls7>%girass ghh sp`il`s (365stuel`s)

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

8/31

Gmgtakligh naaolmf haigtlam

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

9/31

Gmgtakligh naaolmf haigtlam

Kartghlty ls fr`gt`r wn`mnaao`e gmywn`r` cut tn`kautn

Gpprax. 73-tlk`s

kar` hlo`hy ta el` Y`v`r` trgukg (ch``elmf)

ls iarr`hgt`e wltn naaohaigtlam

E``p naaolmf (fut ara`sapngfus) ls nlfnhytrgukgtli

gegpt`e jrak Cgin`h`r & Cuio`h (3225),Jlsn`rl`s S`s`grin

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

10/31

Lm f`m`rghG e``phy naao`e chgio

cr`gk

E``phy naao`e jlsn r`qulr`fr`gt`r ngmehlmf tlk`s

Slso aj s`v`r` egkgf` taarfgms

Vars` wn`m gtt`kptlmf tar`kav`

Igm c` igus`e cy4

Mgturgh cglts Mgv` gmfh`rs Ykghh naaos D-naaos

E``phy s`t naaos

jrak Frlxtl `t gh. (322>),Jlsn`rl`s S`s`grin

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

11/31

Lm f`m`rghJr`qu`miy aj sn`eelmf

naaos

02 -

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

12/31

Ylmfh` naaos Ur`ch` naaos

Naao typ`4 slmfh` vs. tr`ch`

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

13/31

Lm f`m`rgh Ur`ch` naao lm gitlam

Ur`ch` naaos igus`j`w`r kartghltl`s

H`ss hlo`hy ta s`t lmirltligh haigtlams

Ykghh slmfh` naaosigus` nlfn rgt`s aj

kartghlty Un`y gr` kar` hlo`hy ta

r`suht lm e``phy-naao`ejlsn

Naao typ`4 slmfh` vs. tr`ch`

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

14/31

Ilrih` naao D-naao

Naao typ`4 ilrih` vs. D-naao

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

15/31

Lm f`m`rghGthgmtli & Rgiljli sglhjlsn

naaolmf haigtlams

Ilrih` naaos gr` kar` hlo`hyta s`t lm tn` kautn

Unls r`eui`s ngmehlmftlk`s

D-naaos gr` kar` hlo`hy tac` swghhaw`e

Un`s` wlhh s`t lm tn` fut ar

a`sapngfus Kartghlty rgt`s gpp`gr

iamslst`mthy haw`rwn`m uslmf ilrih`naaos

Naao typ`4 ilrih` vs. D-naao

gegpt`e jrak Rrlmi` `t gh. (3223),GJYY

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

16/31

Cgrc`e naao Cgrch`ss naao

Naao typ`4 cgrc`e vs. cgrch`ss naaos

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

17/31

Lm f`m`rghMa eljj`r`mi`s lm

kartghlty rgt`s

Cgrc`e naaos igus`

lmir`gs`e ngmehlmftlk`s

Naw`v`r, tn`y eamat r`suht lm fr`gt`rkartghlty rgt`s

Cgrc`e naaor`strlitlams gpp`gr matta c` cgs`e am `vle`mi`

Yp`il`s K`tnae S`j`r`mi`

raio cgss cgrc`e vs.cgrch`ss dlfs

Iaao` `t gh.(3227)

raio cgss cgrc`e vs.cgrch`ss warks

Iaao` `t gh.(3227)

sghkamle spp. cgrc`e vs.cgrch`ss slmfh`s& tr`ch`s

EuCals &Eucl`hzlf (3225)

chu`flhhs cgrc`e slmfh`snaao`e lma`sapngfus

Sac`rt `t gh.(3273)

wghh`y` cgrc`e vs.cgrch`ss hlv`cglt

S``v`s & Ytgph`s(3277)

Naao typ`4 cgrc`e vs. cgrch`ss naaos

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

18/31

Glr `xpasur`

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

19/31

Lm f`m`rghrglmcaw traut jahhawlmf

:2s aj `x`rils`

E`prlv`s jlsn aj axyf`m wn`mtn`y kust r`iav`r

Ytramf pasltlv` iarr`hgtlamc`tw``m `xpasur` eurgtlamgme igrelavgsiuhgr vgrlgch`s

Ytramf m`fgtlv` iarr`hgtlamc`tw``m `xpasur` eurgtlamgme swlkklmf p`rjarkgmi`

Glr `xpasur` jahhawlmf`x`rils` fr`gthy lmir`gs`stn` hlo`hlnaae ajkartghlty

Glr `xpasur`

gegpt`e jrak J`rfusam & Uujts (7

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

20/31

Un` lkpgit aj cgratrgukg

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

21/31

Un` `jj`its aj cgratrgukg @xapntnghklg (pap-`y`)

Jarks fgs cucch`s tngt

r`suht lm4Chaae ihats

@kcahlsks

Ng`karrngflmf

Fut `xpuhslam Suptur`e fgs chgee`r

@xapntnghklg

Un` lkpgit aj cgratrgukg

rasy raiojlsn? Saf`rs `t gh. (3277),Jlsn`rl`s S`s`grin

@y` elsphgi`k`mt igm c` gs fr`gt gs :7%aj tatgh caey h`mftn

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

22/31

Lm f`m`rghIgptur` e`ptn gme

kartghlty

Ytramf pasltlv`

iarr`hgtlam c`tw``migptur` e`ptn gmekartghlty

Gssailgt`e wltn

cgratrgukg

Un` lkpgit aj cgratrgukg

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

23/31

Yuc-h`tngh iams`qu`mi`s aj I&S

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

24/31

Lm f`m`rgh N`grt rgt` t`h`k`try ajgmfh`e hgrf`kautn cgss

I&S slfmljligmthy

`h`vgt`s str`ss narkam`h`v`hs & igrelgi autput

Lt ghsa elsruptsaskar`fuhgtary igpgilty

Ghh aj wnlinm`fgtlv`hy lkpgitkartghlty rgt`s

Rnyslahafligh elsturcgmi`

gegpt`e jrak Iaao` `t gh. (3225),D. aj Gpp. Lintn.

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

25/31

Lm f`m`rgh Iakp`msgtary frawtn lmgmfh`e hgrf`kautn cgss

I&S lmt`rrupts markghjargflmf c`ngvlaur

Lmdury Ytr`ss S`t`mtlam Naw`v`r, frawtn rgt`

ea`s mat gpp`gr gjj`it`e

Hgrf`kautn cgss (52 egys) Vnlt`-spatt`e ingrr (02 egys) Vnlt` s`gcgss (

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

26/31

Lm f`m`rgh Uaurmgk`mt gmfhlmf jarchgio cgss

C`ngvlaur stramfhylmjhu`mi`s past-r`h`gs`kartghlty gme suc-h`tngh lkpgits

S`h`gs`e jlsn igmelsp`rs` kgmy oksjrak igptur` slt`

Kgy tgo` w``os arkamtns ta r`turm

C`ngvlaurgh elsturcgmi`

gegpt`e jrak Vlhe` (3229),Jlsn`rl`s

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

27/31

Chgio cgssgmfhlmf

taurmgk`mts

Lmir`gs`e m`stgcgmeamk`mt rgt`s.

E`pr`ss`er`praeuitlv` autput.

Ykghh`r ajjsprlmf.

Naw`v`r,papuhgtlam h`v`h`jj`its gpp`grklmlkgh ta m`utrgh.

Yuff`stsc`ngvlaurgh `jj`itskgy c` snart-hlv`e.

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

28/31

Kglm jlmelmfs

Kartghlty rgt`s jahhawlmf g I&S `v`mt vgry wle`hy?wltn gm gv`rgf` aj 7>% girass jr`snwgt`r gme kgrlm`sp`il`s.

Lmir`gs`e kartghlty rgt`s jahhawlmf g I&S `v`mtwn`m naaos gr` s`t lm gmgtakligh haigtlams atn`rtngm tn` kautn.

Ylmfh` gme tr`ch` naaos r`suht lm eljj`r`mt autiak`s

jahhawlmf g I&S `v`mt? wltn g r`eui`e hlo`hlnaae ajkartghlty wn`m uslmf tr`ch` naaos gs g r`suht ajsnart`r ngmehlmf tlk`s.

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

29/31

Kglm jlmelmfs

Un`r` ls hltth` `kplrligh `vle`mi` suppartlmf tn`wle`hy n`he c`hl`j tngt cgrch`ss naaos r`suht lm gr`eui`e hlo`hlnaae aj kartghlty jahhawlmf g I&S`v`mt.

Mgturgh cglts ngv` tn` pat`mtlgh ta r`suht lm g fr`gt`rhlo`hlnaae aj kartghlty jahhawlmf g I&S `v`mtiakpgr`e wltn grtljlilgh hur`s.

Hlm`-iuttlmf jar lmelvleughs e``phy-naao`e ls g vlgch`kgmgf`k`mt prgitli` tngt r`eui`s tn` hlo`hlnaae ajkartghlty jahhawlmf g I&S `v`mt.

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

30/31

Kglm jlmelmfs

G p`rlae aj glr xpasur`, `xgi`rcgt`e cy p`rlaes aj `x`rils`prlar ta hgmelmf g jlsn, lmir`gs`s tn` hlo`hlnaae aj kartghltyeurlmf g I&S `v`mt.

G I&S `v`mt slfmljligmthy `h`vgt`s str`ss narkam` h`v`hs,igrelgi autput gme elsrupts askar`fuhgtary igpgilty? ghh aj

wnlin kgy m`fgtlv`hy lkpgit kartghlty rgt`s.

Kuhtlph` I&S `v`mts ea mat m`i`ssgrlhy r`suht lm iakprakls`ehamf-t`rk frawtn.

Ghtnaufn snart-t`rk c`ngvlaur kgy c` ght`r`e cy g I&S `v`mt

kgmy sp`il`s ea mat `xnlclt hamf-t`rk `jj`its. Unls iauhesuff`st jlsn papuhgtlams gr` mat s`v`r`hy lkpgit`e cy tn`elsturcgmi` aj skghh mukc`rs aj lmelvleughs `v`m eurlmfs`msltlv` p`rlaes aj tn` hlj` iyih`, suin gs spgwmlmf.

8/14/2019 John Hume: "Catch-and-release management of fish populations: supported by science or social conscience?"

31/31

Maw S`ge tn` S`part

haufns-gf`miy.arf/LCLY