International Telecommunication Union Results of the first FGFN meeting in Lulea Naotaka MORITA...

InternationalTelecommunicationUnion

Results of the first FGFN meeting in Lulea

Naotaka MORITA

Chairman of FGFN

17 November 2009


Objectives of FGFN

The objective of the Focus Group is to document results that would be helpful for developing Recommendations for future networks.

To achieve this objective the Focus Group will • gather new ideas relevant to Future Networks and

identify potential study areas on Future Networks,• describe visions of the Future Networks,• identify a timeframe of Future Networks,• identify potential impacts on standards development,

and• suggest future ITU-T study items and related actions.


Draft meeting plan

Year 2009 Year 2010

1 4 7 10 1 4 7 10

X1/12-23 SG13Geneva

X9/2-12 SG13Argentina

X Jan.NGN-GSI

X5/11-22 NGN-GSIGeneva

X AprilSG13

X4/28-30 TSAG

XFeb.TSAG

X Sept.NGN-GSI

X Dec.SG13

SG13/NGN-GSI

XFG-FN#16/29-7/3Lulea/w FIRE

XFG-FN#211/16-20Salt lake/w GENI

X5/11-13FIAPrague

X7/14-17GSC

FG on future networks

FG set up

preparationX

3/3 EC FIRE3/31 GENI

Note: meetings in italic are not yet determined.

XFG-FN#3Jan.

XFG-FN#4March

XFG-FN#5June


Meeting plan for the 1st FG-FN

4

SundayJune 28

MondayJune 29

TuesdayJune 30

WednesdayJuly 1

ThursdayJuly 2

FridayJuly 3

15:00-18:00 9:00-18:00 9:00-18:00 9:00 - 18:309:30 - 18:00

9:00-15:00

Closed meeting of preparation team

ITU-TFG-FN at Quality Hotel

ITU-TFG-FN at Quality Hotel

FIRE and Living labs - Future Internet by the people at House of Culture

FIRE - Tutorials and Workshops at Luleå University of Technology

ITU-TFG-FN and Q.21 meeting at Quality Hotel

Procedure discussion and contribution review

Contribution review

9:30-11:00Joint meeting with FIRE and FG-FN

Wrap up and future planning

Meeting venue: Luleå, Sweden, June 29-July 3Detail information is given in ITU-T TSB Circular 37 andhttps://fireweekitu.axaco.se


Results of the 1st FGFN in Lulea

A) The first ITU-T FGFN meeting took place at the Quality Hotel in Lulea, Sweden, from 29 June to 3 July, 2009. Thirty eight participants brought twenty three contributions to the meeting.

B) Framework of existing research activities in China, Europe, Korea, and Japan were introduced. Framework of other regions’ activities should be taken into account. Further inputs are expected.

C) Two deliverables were identified to be produced by FG-FN, which are 1) Future Networks: vision, concept, and requirements (Agreed scope and table of contents were in FGFN-OD-05, editors are Myung-Ki Shin, ETRI and Daisuke Matsubara, Hitachi) and 2) framework of network virtualization (title only, editor is Sangjin Jeoung, ETRI).

D) Based on contributions, initial thoughts on the design of future networks, i.e., concept, key characteristics, and requirements of Future Networks were collected in FGFN-OD-06 (formerly FGFN-TD).

E) Eleven technical inputs were summarized in “project description format,” which are given in FGFN-OD-07 (formerly FGFN). More inputs are expected to formulate specific technology areas. The project description template is given in FGFN-OD-08 (formerly FGFN-TD-08).

F) In order to create a useful and convincing Future Network vision, the meeting agreed to review ongoing research activities from specific viewpoints of technology in parallel with concept discussion.


Results of the 1st FGFN in LuleaG) There was common understanding that the estimated target date for prototyping

and phased deployment of Future Networks should roughly fall between 2015 and 2020. This estimate is based on two factors: First, the status of current and evolving technologies that would be employed in the experimentation and development of FNs as presented by contributions to the Focus Group meeting. Second, any novel development that might take place well beyond that estimate is too speculative and is outside the mandate of this focus group.

H) Working method of FG-FN was agreed, which is given in FGFN-OD-09 (formerly FGFN-TD-07).

I) Chairman proposed tentative meeting plan, candidate tasks, and document structure of FGFN. The meeting agreed to follow the proposals, which are given in FGFN-OD-xx (formerly FGFN-TD-05).

J) A vice chairman, Mr. Hyoung Jun KIM, ETRI Korea, was appointed. Further volunteers for vice chairman are expected.

K) Chairman was suggested to continue collocation meetings with existing research organizations.

L) Two draft Recommendations which had been produced by Q.21 were raised for information. Since FGFN agreed to contribute Q.21 work in a comprehensive manner, FGFN believed that Q.21 should wait for FGFN inputs before further advancing the work on two drafts by freezing the editing process.


Results of the 1st FGFN in Lulea

M) Eight liaison statements were produced to reply to incoming liaison queries including one previously received by SG13 on the matter of FGFN. They are given in FGFN-OD-10.

N) Thanks to the local supporters, FGFN participants joined FIRE –living lab events in the same week.

O) The FIRE - FGFN joint meeting was held in the morning of 2 July 2009. Fabrizio Sestini, EC, DG INFSO and Naotaka Morita, chairman of FGFN chaired the meeting. The agenda is given in FGFN-TD-05. Documents are given in FGFN-TD-09. Chairman of FGFN made three presentations and FIRE experts made three presentations. Experts on both sides exchanged their views including mutual possible benefit of collaboration. Although the meeting did not identify any urgent need for standardization with regard to FIRE activities, the meeting agreed to continue information exchange and collaboration.


Major output documents at 1st meeting (07/2009)

Collection ofproject

descriptions

Technology description per study area A as framework or

overview

Consolidated vision

Technology description per study area B as framework or

overview

Technology description per study area C as framework or

overview


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions


descriptions

Research organization information




CNGIFP7/FIRE

NwGN/Akari

11 project descriptions

(FGFN-OD08)

One draft frameworkon network

virtualization as title

Draft deliverable with scope (FGFN-OD05)

and collection of inputs (FGFN-OD06)


IDContributionNumber

Source Title

1 C-22 CNGI - Beijing Jiaotong UniversityLatest research on Next Generation Internet in China

2 C-21CNGI - Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications

Future Internet research and experimentdeployment in CNGI-CERNET2 project

3 C-9SICS and Ericsson based on research in the EU 7FP project 4WARD

Networking of Information for Future Networks

4 C-16NEC Europe Ltd. based on research in EU FP6 project ANA

Abstractions for an autonomic networking architecture

5 C-17NEC Europe Ltd. based on research in EU7 project ResumeNet

Network Resilience as a prime feature of Future Networks

6 C-11 BT Internet resource sharing: a way forward?

7 C-19 University of Paderborn, GermanyIdeas and Practical Challenges for a Cooperation and Coding Framework

8 C-23 Hitachi Autonomic Internet

9 C-5 ETRIVirtualized Programmable Platform for Future Network Research and Experimentation

10 C-14 NICTIntroduction of AKARI architecture design project

11 C-2 KDDI R&D Laboratories, Inc. Introduction of Minimum Core concept

List of project descriptions


List of output documents produced by 1st FGFN

Doc. number Content

FGFN-OD-01 Meeting report

02 List of contributions

03 Meeting agenda

04 List of participants

05 Future Networks: vision, concept, and requirements

06 First Collection of Concept, Key Characteristics and Requirements of Future Networks

07 Eleven project descriptions

08 Template of project description

09 Working method of FGFN

10 Eight outgoing liaison statements

11 Meeting plan, candidate tasks, and document structure of FGFN


Meeting plan for the 2nd FG-FN in Salt lake

11

SundayNov. 15

Monday16

Tuesday17

Wednesday18

Thursday19

Friday20

AM9:00-11:00Preparation team meeting

No meeting

9:00-12:00No meeting on ITU-T,Recommended to attend GEC6 at Grand America (Note 1)

9:00-12:00ITU-T FG-FN

9:00-12:00ITU-T FG-FN

9:00-12:00ITU-T FG-FN

PM

13:00-18:00No meeting on ITU-T,Recommended to attend GEC6 in the University of Utah (Note 1)

13:30-18:00ITU-T FG-FN at Audubon(Note 2)

13:30-18:00Presentation on FIND and IRTF (TBD)

13:30-18:00ITU-T FG-FN

13:30-15:00ITU-T FG-FN

Meeting venue: Grand America hotel in Salt lake, USA.Date: November 16 – 20, 2009.Detail information is given in ITU-T TSB Circular 57 and its addendum.

Note 1: Participants to ITU-T FGFN are encourage to observe GEC session. The details are available at http://guest.cvent.com/EVENTS/Info/Summary.aspx?i=2adbef3a-b5cc-4536-bfa0-a2ed4d677338 Note 2: From 17 to 20 November the FG-FN sessions will take place at Grand America hotel, Salt Lake City.


• http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/focusgroups/fn/index.html


AppendixMeeting plan, tasks, and

document structure of FGFN


Draft task plan for FG-FNs

14

FG-FN #1June-July2009

FG-FN #2November2009

FG-FN #3Spring2010

FG-FN #4Summer2010

EventCollocation with FIRE

Collocation with GEC

Major tasks

1. Set up work method and structure1. Set up work method and structure

2. Review/group existing activities2. Review/group existing activities

4. Create/update descriptions of existing activities4. Create/update descriptions of existing activities

5. Identify/describe benefits and visions5. Identify/describe benefits and visions

6. Identify/describe attributes6. Identify/describe attributes

7. Build key vocabulary7. Build key vocabulary

3. Set up/maintain external collaboration channels3. Set up/maintain external collaboration channels

8. Draft action plans8. Draft action plans

Note: meetings in italic are not yet determined.


Tasks (1/2)

1. Set up work method and structure Including nomination of vice chairpersons If necessary, set up sub groups with leaders

2. Review and group existing activities Introduction to ongoing research projects Categorize projects/technologies into some study areas

3. Set up and maintain external collaboration channels IRTF, GENI/FIND, FP7/FIRE, CNGI, FIF, AKARI/NwGN,

ISO/IEC JTC1/SC6 Work methods and representatives

4. Create and update descriptions of existing activities Use of project description template proposed by ITU

15


Tasks (2/2)

1. Identify and describe benefits and visions Formulate major study areas by reference to existing

activities Issues of major concerns, key

concepts/ideas/technologies to make a breakthrough, and expected benefits

Consolidate network and service visions, if possible

2. Identify and describe attributes Detailed descriptions of concepts/ideas/technologies in

terms of attributes/characteristics/capabilities

3. Build key vocabulary

4. Draft action plans Based on the outputs, suggest future action plans for

ITU-T and other organizations 16


Document transition

17

Deliverablesproduced by Focus Group

Recommendations and Supplementsproduced by Study Group

Recommendationsas normative

Supplementsas informative


Proposed document structure

18

Collection ofproject descriptions

Technology description per study area A as framework or overview

Consolidated vision

Future networks

Use case and service scenario

Requirementsas stage 1

Architecture w/ IF and flowas stage 2

Protocolas stage 3

Existing networks

Vocabulary

Technology description per study area B as framework or overview

Technology description per study area C as framework or overview









International Telecommunication Union Results of the first FGFN meeting in Lulea Naotaka MORITA...

Documents

Transcript of International Telecommunication Union Results of the first FGFN meeting in Lulea Naotaka MORITA...