In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs...

27
In the Hot Seat : Loopholes in Cooperative Insurance that Could Doom the Board Lessons for Board Members from Professional Insurance Buyer Attorneys

Transcript of In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs...

Page 1: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

In the Hot Seat: Loopholes in Cooperative Insurance that

Could Doom the Board

Lessons for Board Members from

Professional Insurance Buyer Attorneys

Page 2: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

What Have You Gotten Into?

2

Page 3: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

In the Hot Seat

3

Page 4: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

When it Comes to Insurance . . .

4

Page 5: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Who Packs Your Coop’s Parachute?

Page 6: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Insurance Buying is Usually Dreaded

by Cooperative Board Members

Complexities Involved

Confused How to Compare Different Agents / Proposals

Do Not Read Insurance Policies and Rely Upon Sales Agents

Worry Will be Blamed if Inadequate Coverage

6

Page 7: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Insurance Buying is Usually Dreaded

by Cooperative Board Members

“Bid” the Insurance Yearly to Get the Lowest Price – Creating More Possibilities for Unintended Gaps

Coop Owners May Have Not Even Buy Homeowners Insurance and Believe the Master Coop Policy Should Cover Any Loss

Management Companies Are Usually Not Licensed Agents and Not Qualified to Assess Coverages

7

Page 8: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

But We Bought a D & O Policy . . .

8

Page 9: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Most Board Members Think They Are

Protected by D & O Insurance and

They Need Not Worry

Yet Many D & O Policies Actually ExcludeInsurance Related Decisions

9

Page 10: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Other D & O Policy Issues

• Managing Agent Coverage Optional

• Insured v. Insured Exclusions

• Employment Practices Coverage

• What Limit? What Deductible(s)?

10

Page 11: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

The Law Requires that You Read the Coop’s

Insurance Policies & Ask Questions . . .

As A Board Member - Have You?

Did You Understand What You Read?11

Page 12: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Property Insurance: Not Just Fire Insurance

12

Page 13: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

General Liability Insurance

13

Page 14: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

But We Don’t Own Any Vehicles . . .

14

Page 15: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Workers’ Comp. Insurance

15

Page 16: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty
Page 17: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Other Policies

• Cyber

• Crime

• Pollution

• Management Company Insurance Program

• Contractors Insurance Program

• Coop Owners Insurance Policy

17

Page 18: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

One Insurance Proposal Is 7 Pages -

Another Is 20 Pages . . .

Which One is Better?

18

Page 19: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

One Insurer Offers A Rate Guarantee If You

Agree Not To Shop For 3 Years…

Should You?

19

Page 20: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

One Proposal Is 15% Less Premium

Than Your Expiring Policies

Does It Cover You Adequately?

20

Page 21: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

One Proposal Offers Guaranteed Replacement While

Another Offers “Blanket” Insurance Limits . . .

Which Is Better?

21

Page 22: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

One Agent Is Recommending A Pollution Liability Policy

& Also A Cyber Insurance Policy

Do We Need These?

22

Page 23: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

We Have a $5,000,000 Umbrella Policy

Do We Really Need A Higher Limit?

23

Page 24: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Who Packs

Your Paracute?

Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU

Professional Insurance Buyer

21500 Haggerty Rd., Ste. 140

Northville, MI 48167

P / 248-321-8941 F / 248-692-4012

Email: [email protected]

Page 25: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

How a Professional Cooperative

Insurance Buyer Can Help Your Board

• Evaluates the policies the cooperative has to identify gaps

• Develops bid specifications for agents and insurers to use when quoting

• Evaluates competing proposals and negotiates with agents / insurers for you

• Makes recommendations on selecting the right agent

• Advises on premium cost reduction

• Removes a lot of potential liability of board members by deferring to professionals

25

Page 26: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

Call Us for Examples of What We Have

Accomplished for Other Cooperatives

• Michael S. Hale, J.D., AAI

Professional Insurance Buyer

Attorney Representing Coops

• Melissa L. Hirn, J.D., AAI

Professional Insurance Buyer

Attorney Representing Coops

26

Page 27: In the Hot Seatcoophousing.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/10.14... · 10/10/2018  · Who Packs Your Paracute? Michael S. Hale, Esq., CPCU Professional Insurance Buyer 21500 Haggerty

We Help Cooperatives Buy Insurance

Contact Us At:

www.clairmont-advisors.com

[email protected]

Phone - 248-321-8941

27