Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion...

19
Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion [email protected] www.do.se, [email protected], 08-120 20 700

Transcript of Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion...

Page 1: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast

Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion

[email protected]

www.do.se, [email protected], 08-120 20 700

Page 2: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

The legal framework in Sweden

The Discrimination ActAct concerning the Swedish Equality Ombudsman

Entered into effect 1 January 2009

The DO also has a role in re to the Parental Leave Act

Page 3: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

The Swedish Equality Ombudsman (DO)

Public authorityAnti-discrimination and equality promotionGender, transgender, ethnicity, religion, age,

sexual orientation and disabilityBroad mandate – taking cases to court,

supervision re legal duties and promotion Katri Linna is the head of the authorityAbout 110 employees

Page 4: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Discrimination

[email protected]

Page 5: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Who is free from prejudice?

Harvard Implicit Association Test( https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/demo/ )

People with openly racist/sexist/homophobic/etc opinions have the same levels of underlying prejudices as those who claim that they have no prejudices

Difference between the man on the soap-box and those in the crowd?

[email protected]

Page 6: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Contributing to change?

It is a sad historical fact that privileged groups have seldom given up their privileges voluntarily.

Martin Luther King

[email protected]

Page 7: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

A negative spiral

[email protected]

Disempower-ment

Denial of discrimination

Diversity without

regard to competence

Page 8: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Changing attitudes or behaviour?

Earl Warren – Chief Justice US S Ct 1953-1969

Many believed ”that you cannot wipe out racial discrimination by law, only through changing the hearts and minds of men.”

This is a ”false credo. True, prejudice cannot be wiped out, but infliction of it upon others can.”

[email protected]

Page 9: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Interplay of discrimination grounds

[email protected]

I want the samesalary as my Swedish

co-workers!

The men or the women?

Page 10: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Need to apply to all grounds

[email protected]

Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw 1992

“When feminism does not explicitly oppose racism, and when antiracism does not incorporate opposition to patriarchy, race and gender politics often end up being antagonistic to each other and both interests lose.”

Page 11: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Developing effective public measures

Five challenges in Sweden

Focus on changing behaviour in making choices on strategies and policies

Clean the stairs from the top – otherwise lose to the principle of least resistance

Empowerment – civil society advocacy Discrimination must cost Understand the interplay between different measures as

well as grounds

[email protected]

Page 12: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Some public agencies have a promotion duty

Recommendations in developing a strategy

Examine various roles in which the agency risks discriminating or can counteract discrimination

Agencies are employers, service providers, rule-makers and the source of public contracts

Examine also that which is already done to promote equality re gender, ethnicity and disability

Consult with discriminated groups

[email protected]

Page 13: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Concrete ideas – key employment contracts

Include in the employment contracts of the head of the agency (and others) a clause that states:

one factor in salary development and job retention is the ability to counteract discrimination and promote equality

[email protected]

Page 14: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Concrete ideas – as employers/service providers

Situation testing can be used to test if there are indications of equality problems.

Possibly in cooperation with discriminated groups

See e.g. Proving discrimination

[email protected]

Page 15: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

[email protected]

Elements of an Equality Clause

1 – APPLICABLE ANTI-DISCRIMINATION LAW

2 - DUTY TO REPORT

3 – APPLY TO SUB-CONTRACTORS

4 - RETAIN THE RIGHT TO CANCEL THE CONTRACT

Page 16: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Equality clause in the Glass House Inquiry

§ 1 The supplier shall throughout the contract period, in his business activities in Sweden, abide by the current law against discrimination.

§ 2 The supplier, during the contract period, has a duty, at the request of the contracting entity, to provide a written report concerning the measures, equality plans etc., that have been undertaken in accordance with the duties specified in § 1. The report shall be submitted to the contracting entity within one week after a request is made unless some other agreement has been reached in the individual case.

§ 3. In the contracts with sub-contractors, the supplier shall apply the same duty to them as is specified in § 1. The supplier shall be responsible to the contracting entity for a sub-contractor’s violation of the duties in § 1. The supplier shall also ensure that the contracting entity can upon request be informed of the sub-contractor’s measures, plans etc. in accordance with § 2.

§ 4 As it is of substantial importance to the contracting entity that its suppliers live up to basic democratic values, a violation of the duties in §§ 1-3 shall constitute a significant breach of the contract. The contracting entity therefore retains the right to cancel the contract if the supplier or a sub-contractor violates the conditions in §§ 1-3. However, the contract will not be cancelled if the supplier immediately remedies the situation or undertakes other relevant measures with the purpose of achieving compliance with § 1, or if the violation is considered to be insignificant.

[email protected]

Page 17: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

A positive spiral

[email protected]

Empowerment

Counteract discrimination

Promotes equality

Page 18: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

Equality is the foundation

"Where … do human rights begin? In small places, close to home … the neighborhood; the school or college; the factory, farm, or office. Such are the places where every man, woman, and child seeks equal justice, equal opportunity, equal dignity without discrimination. Unless these rights have meaning there, they have little meaning anywhere."

Eleanor Roosevelt

[email protected]

Page 19: Impacting equality Equinet 29-30 April 2010 Belfast Paul Lappalainen, Head of Equality Promotion paul.lappalainen@do.se , do@do.se, 08-120 20.

[email protected]

Aha! Now I see them...!