Imagining the Impossible

Magical, Scientific, and Religious Thinkingin Children

CAMBRIDGE

2i )b

r The Makings of the'I he Narure.nd Flf.hon .f

Magical Mind

1

gjc.cnrru on i trip,itr. dirnin!!, \!rih g( Jtnnad.s dr rn

P. n,frxe ot rh.s. iN*dions or.

ind irs p.nry rhR n s issunFhon rr. trc w.nJ.r ra,nitu rm!honsr..o rnrJrorl'd!nct,ii(LF

, ,. ... , ,.: ,..,e\tsln!r rvodd5 1!r disord, hox,

t,, P' ","r o .,

10r . ^ ,,

dcfiniir< misirb:rJ tr trs ilrtwo

,'',^,''''.i".rldL8h tu.ri rsrlit srh Fr2. d MrLn ih nig[ wdsrr{

rcady tutedli ar!.fDN trruror .rstr rvl:r,nowski .drbibtrr.j ,,,,, ., L..r "",, 1.1"., ,. .,j, ",",.

Prislriis orrd! er6ciry, bur ain!tr.es' i: moj .'F|n|Ii.Idly litr]q

pu/rLci Thus rgh s.i!.s h,r(

nisir nrl h.re .roltrh.n'LL! iJnigi. ?s wonhy or r.llied is io,rnF!d{t rdil pdxti,,llr b.n.Ii.i.n

mi[N slmPnhdr nrgi. I dNirht ri,i d $rr/tr llM'sp.rh . inrlrtr); t x, r@ d, rr6t6 (' r. "iiwni ornoil,tritj Dd scrc,nrrr r.osidr.J i subc!. or ), ioil d,.ri& ,t n"Llii (rin.enu niE() (!{ rrver. r$eo/r'!r5e; Nrn,r,,urz/U72; Trrrd, 1479/ 1etll

dkt hdel5 aLdrg rh. ln.s d.rtrmhrJ bv srn,Prd,) W.5.! tt(5)opdhdr nasicar liwr r oia, i5 ('nri!ri.! drc .or. .r rh'1 ri. .I.gorv ,\b$ndrLl ttun

:' /r ',i '

isr{ ! Lh rhLs pr.n !.(htr^{, r3t0/rese, l\{rtrs, Leol/ ezls "Lirc produrr likc" lFn/.

l3e01le.s), 'hc iDisr $LuL5 tl'. dlicd" (Mius, l!0r/re7r), oi

drll noPdi5 A frnorrP'.r|.

r..l ro '.i, rir.rt(tsoni obi(rrthn(,crr(cns r'h! L.$ oi dpf.

ihr ! otnrnbsin D d'.r.trlP.bnd}i!Nr(. rJ.rthd.r,iof or i!(f hd.rs il /t!'d dt.tti' ' t!'tt!r'\'ttlnt'vtdnun{i.r nlh'a\ \,f trt,r (lu nL.r Dir b. phri.

Efra.b !'it L. sr-!!mrul, 6 ih* itu !m! obidd, h th. lDr!rnh.i, nD) id as bolh a n)ur

m.iinlcd rry i rhtlr obi.d ( lpf ide') rlrt..ihds trDrh tu sDtrrd

,. Lhr llnns dD( rrr. r, tn 4dn r(!r,,? 0r!(ihrlmm ydLn()nhd:" rliu$, f!r2lre72)rnd nrt $at! luren dt 1,1rt uttttLd rrr./ir. drr !rr1 ( ir,r pi,r {u.,r\,h. \h,,Lc.- Nr.r$s. re02/rr72) Fl r"wn,sonbd dr ril|d,

hrflne.l Ii th!.rg.r i plsit^e.

\,11.'rr(.t 1hl nrr. nNJ r)p].,,1

pa, isr rtum ir rl.ri b rrrcd !d, s.ii fi..rllr !,,Ld,n.d i{ir..!

0nolllr6tr'Il,/s]br!..hrIind

qbi bdw{n h{, ,i1!f'< (f li(h\cln.robi(d.ud,6ry$s u) o(od.,8ir.rll Do*r.[\!

trthoaQr slqnJ, riolh, ,.ur)

Lrd$ssr rrr!.Lid rnd Lh! qnes

Furq,tric.,.r o.ilrq ,rr (rul,"!nqn.l rr $ Lh! lLr\u3 n,!!

rtr Meut t,t )! nk!f;rr Mnt

n'vllr!{Dl'll|]-f,{nl

i ,,r'!,,11r,. rt,,r ,,,N'r'rr uulr,

;,:,.,'. 11.: r,",i:;':l;f;;,.'l

llilil:i""*''*' "' -"''"'','qr {hj.!hr.r,r,r.g.ft nlor4 *

nrnt o , irrnc iufrlnj )

rmr+,Is !1rr ! rr dJ odis,,,,..,,,r,h",,,,,,";,,,:,; ;,::l

iill:ii,tl: it':;:: "" '" - '". ."",,'. ,,.;.;'.;.i.:r ii:l

r,1.,,r.,,,,.,*.r,,, rr,"..,,,r.,i.,.",_,*"l",_i_-i",liit,,,.,ll:1l::l;:1' *:'':''-*', .","1;. ill;l:,;,"'r,;l'.,iill::.;pt,1,.,."tr,,,"r..,"r .,,rir,,,,, t.,,,,,r,,,,,,,i.i;;;::,,,:]r,

;i'."":::::1 """".'-'-';".', ".,,''";i. ;,;'"i"*;;;.i; I illi.

r. d[E'r.t$ir i]r r ]'Li. iiLl

n,r,ryi$ sedir5 ag wif fnrnL.

oJ Nlouorf 0e36) Lruror*DhL

b rbc !r.ur'.i dissun, 'o{ firh+rrb! drt.lLPi.ror nd{r ovr n 3r

\hiF\LLLr.c d% tu.! Itn,t nrt! I

r!u,tl!s oI sin'iL.r v i', rr. dcIru!'d Llrosi(! dars lii'nmg r,.b!(n trl .rA) I rhobs, ifL.i gdi (r s , John r: K.fr.dr') or imig6d Likorp.Nr:,,r irna rr iL(! s, Adol!r,Ir rrr)!rDfsh

Rozin, Mllmir, ri \.n.,ofr (re36) .in,l Rorn. M{l\rrr,, .miRo$ tL.reo) i $.\ o,rd rt fa,nlifr|ll )y Pnld (r!33) } .i

!.fo415rU)..I(lc!!n[i.(L!,tln.n.iD,/imarj! q!'iLi tl,! rtrcrot/oLlcd) rvc!rrnlrLr ( rhs'n tri

!{k lrr fo{!dr.ur(L hbu.lr rltpa,ti.4]d n

r 'rD

liLL{rtr l,.$q!r 4lnjln

Dd., rn p.nr" 1nvo, M.frrirh, & Ro$, rero). porod,rLr $+r

T

r ii \ I i i /\r r

F.ns! F Ntl5 tLirzlr/re66),j.i;r t

n,FP.n.r bd'rf i, !rr i nrnoln, r

Jri f .\(Lr{fr!o h$ \hour rh

ri tu. rn. nn,r rNhsiPt.rr$d),.i " k.,* kr." s s!n.rLL\

1, trr.r r,um.r5 r,d. ffunr,(r

ifN' r (!.s, nlr ra m,!lrr, tr

x

.at and 5vo6ojn rurri.rrio,rr {.

licron ru!.d i nix m z. Posi

r.n and physidt .gJtm5, rh. rii,lrvrys of an:EdrJ .md nn.qr[.

0s36) dsrcsr.rer rh\ urh yo,Ds iduLts rn on DDnirul*on, ir..n r r ehsr or the pini.iPin\,

ndd'N naw or iu c. .0id,nr trs iLtr!1or i Picr<ied n {

r rcrc it ibundanr.:,nrtLe5 or rI

rhc.o imininrsi'.r)0nrrryirsgunor(rori8ih6lrs,(rhdsirhi dL:LL.d P.F.i).' d sotuur t.ir h{h r.cc, rh!s, F$ph a,. tu

.$ lsiil.c.rr Le Ls noi i lumdirne poDon), ind i .y. rhr s .omm.n in rfdtdir nDLt5

P ".frl iirnrPnrtnc ory r, rlrF. J 6[cih isi D.ioi adili,

iod.of..rof hun,nrslRo,n, rer6t rMmodh!ncsipi'Lidln )

ri\ rnr ri.rt.,1 rr s rniu w.n!r(rhrr dfsun is nrh,r P.vclaurenrmoon i1!] DPor,nn (os n,rr

lrq icJ (n$.u rfir] (Fm^rr3e0/ e5er Ncnc,off & Rdzh, rese) Th$ prhcipt nfts, I rj'.trlur onr Eirr hkc or llr Prof(cxtrnnr., N1. as 1t9$l) dl.s tl'c b

lUulLl!.|t'.bt8nN6go]v!lcul(lr.hb.s rr hrLp rr.m g0r lin

N.N)o'l ind Ro,i,r ns3q) Ldrgd i,r c loic ln bc .r D "fou.( Lrh vfu cd" nonr; ,\Nr.a

--=---....-

) lihr n\c[ ,nF.$5iDi i<hnqLL!),

lrhih \n id.fr.trL .a.+r ntr du rp!d6! n{ nitLr Ll. iiie(L isd4 b!.ntur Dr Dlico

lrMn q, trn rrj(tirr dr..Llin DituL tunl$ 1fs, liai,r, is['$s!., lood rnnr, 30 .ros {ar.

lIeof,h,]LdnL'u.ILL'!LLcL

n p,.l'rin!\ rt s r a(rRl rn[ lL,nlr lfui.nrq A!'d.nL\,

oJfuuLlt|)l]L1aj'rinr"h&l

,i N.n.n*t liee.t .NLqr uLrr

rhrn c .,.rl r1r {r o\d$

ran "AoiL| r ii! r,N 1r s, trLt, ' il d,ihn).r!l 1.Ll n thc

s(n is *.kingr_/ nnrtu rnonl Lrrn bad food.ar.6 conriEionb!li!G,d/oi physicir po Lulon L.sdnns

unlcdlo]mu.rolthcmor.ntooJ

c!i nlrhoo rn "{tf rlurBbdhsrr.d .onrnuousrf irhcrcbl, n)nbsins .rd Fdlnr lr) porrllins)

(ct (hotunft, Fotq Et\ ru nqibkr, pitnuLi.l) th! rpqiurs or rlp hollf tnourh, nGblr, cr!)(nonn, NcD.dt, rrrcw ., cl&lon, & v.ci, 19e5). Notir'! dri.d.Ds di$;{s ac !h,cd!nz!{l \ nLdr y deri.ls on tlt lna haod,

Neubss drL N.narort (1993) sfnnshtpliy an i'nponarl

'oLc i:r b

thr (t) bul:nns bnrec in padnrddu,gir wifiorhi!. "ntrrrr" (2) prrx ns hdrs b c\pcli !rs.dtr.srdrny or pollLrion ILom rhr bodrr.sc t; iod 11) buLLmics\6ou d trh),t)aAaditn ! b.onLasiof sccni

1,ord t lo o\-uf $udf onFir(r.rot r|(l .onbol5 lNcn{oft, sllNp.k N{$!r & cl&'d, reeo is

srll ki ter.i.n r.nL.nR oI oi

nd J m rmpnirry rrlidi L&

ftn5m reJ t.dd' i.odugila's $ilEt dlluws . .orLaeious rnti(y (i'r rhs -a., ir -oLrs) to hrvcLndiiqr b rra orhsr lt is poss Lrl!.lh rhc darsrr oI micobc rff.physiGl illiras, p.iticulirlt \ii dr n,orign, soN oI llr. b.sir rupsks orco igtun (p bfln 1 (rbdrrl dos! i'Elnsitn{ty, dcs ib.d b. o}l mrk. ldirhre 5.nr w h

tusP{1 ro inr!.riof

Mth a d..d body lr s , Ronn, N6.kLn[, & Mc! rulq, ]ee{l Mrrr

poDr htrien., bo.le mii.Dit6rr, i ldc h (Rozhctil, re!3)I lor'ev{, i',1tu pircan of rr.sc

A trinr'pildomih 1n Lidlr !lLllr]rs

ar rn rr nd friq\rnrb 8r\' {rdr !tl, '$|ed

ki r1. f stg!Lrnr.ir srn$ r ,,"Ir,rhdrlJa,u[!Jrh(t. 1c6fn rpopLr

Poritnr.o trlnrn

Lry irnoli f.orrc, or rhr r pos!.isiotrsour*n | ( +qJi\ ot uiLlo!nd

'tdry Pqnn lrrn)nfr !ni rrrunt(u!{:.Nl!y, Nl.(rud,&n I r4',' i,,l

rsfo'I c(!s.n , lhrr i .Lne.De (r ! r,boQ o\in,o, h andrLr.untrd{(), d'se; ulrLLr i {,or

M.nl!|th &u[trul!|,ll!]1)

nlrr.r,i.$ ii ,$,d{es

Pioatr(l, iriLcd, pr!r{&| 0r ..

td.,$rir'Sl!, rlr. crrcd wis nru.

.,.,, | ,l) i ,\.i.rR, rotr.ih.( Nnrrnrs

^U)5?,) (;!LiLr

l$s ti'r I PtuJltud \orr, rn!o!{1 b Lr. th! iur! Pow.,trt prt

llre5l Ln i n.!Ly 4hs. rhr Pi r. p

.nsnr,.r i rft'ld rr,f rirr

s{m: (nr rs., n ..dodont, llr ri !trusLr,

[1,trLLcon <Dfr oi N) tn]rJl,rsh ArDs rnk hrhiv.'s rtrg.rslJ

Yori!,nhLrn hN. b.rn nrw. !)

Itrv,d)o []r 'Nrtr

otILLL\ j

rll \un{o (Lr r($rlr.Dnrk\. .rv ',nhcrrb.h lirndn'

sqil nrr Dc, r]lrsh i nrriAlir oisrrrwr L"

,'''''idn,th tln. t(l,nF5(eE, olsni J!iJ, +ilt 3!k!,.(1,) ,r.

inhctur (Rofr & N.m{orf, e!01, hrr on {idci( p,D.rirrw. h.n. \-f(iL\ uiudd

^0rsli.oo

'r (\r drt o*KL) ntr ., !rd) br.xrr{rt, ,! +ifioi{l nr ,, $qro

!'r w L[ ArDs tR!r, { n, r!er)

i\ ih. ,.h ,r lN.n..t c

n0.u.,D,i, _v (L r, qeo !{v ho

lilhrfir.ti(rl !{r'u.ni n ! ( r, ,r p rot r[.f. rrom.v, ral .io hrrsnfr his cr I

^unsrcrlDion.n:isljn,fir ndn,r nLr$,n r ir(rivD.r., ,ree?tPi r. Pi s nr.d dr.i a,dh$ iLi

i no) tu on. in{\ riq \,1r ,

Dfdtr Pirti+Dns npd'L.d that Llror: p.'nr wIL,

^lDS tlr( th.r, voul.l f.c FDnoniLrrr rodrng,

rN.'rn,fI.1aL,19e1).Lrlrnos'idri. cvdcn..,

(Mrs\, resl)n'$.* rh r'!di/d. rDa4'

'(tr Nia. ,ad('

n$rrtrcdoi.o id { dr r hLrJhl

$) ^nuioo

u trs.!!ru. ri .i!rf( n frr ririds

6({kL u rhanr, nrd)Ih.t h$!ftNtiotrft n! pqnr mr!r6LL[{r, iriLru]rr

'h.u !bj(c rtl

urc o rined llsntra 3N r$ (tnorJs or rlr s,t r,u h( Drtr(. whiLc

cats 6 0 ifur' (rie*5 (Nlmcrir.ug, & sh{dl,1e3e), q,q' nl'oL

tr, \:l(d trur !wn *diiliuc(1, poniir. i,rnp.bon (c s, MdhqThcruii, rdL$r Dr.r) b. ntr! tl'. t,Nr d\rr

ri$ d,i,,g! rru rs $dglI pntn! rs

^lnaNr iny rlFc ofPr)Pedr G d

rrhr',r, nlLudos pl,r!a'l rdribuLls 1.o1 , !D(rh ,rc),.biLiLfsGb.nsrlL qerJDni ), r'd drposid.is (p$onility .hanrLs'nniDo.ilwonh,.n tunh.i, Thr Lisi. p'ii.ipis ol.onL^sion arrr,h,,LJ nJlFs u ,,r tli! pnrp.*)

hr rq.nN rc ki$mirlcd rrom irb : [\ sdid' .drrin .tns

cnnn,(,ur niheoppos edre.bd..Tl'osalaqeLnr'f o$!hrtr'

oo a qtrlrii i.e lipldlJ lld

sf hinbr,sh (sicn !il. itur ,a\!r r, r,e {q, J8d!) or Llrr.r

s (ons ndr vrrh b.rirf h hi.k\!,1

h Mt t . lltt t Mt\i rt uttl

I

:r7a srrwnsshe pr!.n@n thc rhouEhrof lricndrheh (Rd,n, oi il, r$e) ra, wddv publ,r,cd,.

w. hara nored rhiLalLsorti offrop{ris, cn8,ns rroD inilrcn/iror mrSd't (,nh8uo \!h c rLl r.ws of drrdsso, we rhoughi i

, thr .o.ragrur $nr( DYolr(\1,m,ghibc ilirfc..nr ror.rijf.Lenr rypes ofpopr L.s-rhLr nn(m noiic & nhnrc. inre,\irv arpl

Nrmcrolr Rozinllee.r)h.dpar0.ipin6in gLncr.f(uinurerrcnrorrieds ri.r i!9., $1€!qLibourwlniirg rh! s!!.r{.rfr{ iriys bis.d on tlr l.Br rh* on.

s o's orirr by s!.i,rg \,h 6Dodtr'r.s urlLtrt.d b.tli pdrtu! d

oo$ (c s, ro(c,r sood p.'son,.nunt, lul ps$r);phy\iirrLLn.!\(rarrdh!,^r)srrindirisrdGoar!.d funriliri.N wse phFicil ka, s(rilttr, trc sw. .'1, sembolir (!s, ur

rd.r rl*h rt), dr'!pn ual'( !.wn) r niJu{Lror lvqilJli a\

lc!!\. R)dcrs rhc tid Lno rr

e.rii_v is !\.rv<] G{!rt, ir opFond trr hi.. aidr cs of biancsr *rcr thr( rt nonPhrsi.rl

nrcndion wrh Ltr sw. ft (c.9,

.rro rcrrinrJ ro th. d.ncnhry rotion of urhSs Lr.mg "pand' iiuts D,nd {ic,Ihc'tcmiod nE vilr." orthcsnc cr)rrndsptrirol

i4]|lhliltg(F{hi}*irn.Ar IrrDr, & rr$clrIttJ. r+rr)

(NoruLn & {/n, rrrr)LriLr tur

r{ rn, ral dNrlu !n[ .nfl.l

!rr, fr!r) h.J.{n! \ !r!

(rr D nrlr,ll., dr, \rd rv,&l&

^srnndt, friri) !(hr( r!m! \i,rl, Lr r

I

rs r ir,. .-r-^r_. "r

r^h",foers ri) .(Dkoshq orid$ (Non-i,rr t n-a. r*1 ,r_-u.s o

*_".. -,rr_" irrr,.*.". ,., *06Jr tiLrh nrto $. hdm. s s,nEni ro, u! Japrn\., nl nn aL

D,r1r,,? ,i'drJqrr., r,?ri, { c,rririctr

'''t''".,

''1"rurid wirh dir un., rhq LlitfELuELt (rhd..l d orrr,lh

lqtr5 of a3! lr;[o I Rqr, & rLL

n.rui.n by pr ud ol ta {Lipnv. tuodionins

J,tru f , r&,rr\,1-o0,!.i,1irrii.\nhourl' rlr. licld.roAnn,q' prr

' ,1- s " -

'..1''''t-""t,cst..'.i]b$|L.dwl.y*.r,.r tunJrnmhiqui iiludsmcntsand rnt{qns (Nisbdi& Rs'19sr) Tl,e rid.liim5 rll( Lhcy.'r. Labor \ og d.!ic.: iLLtDriru i

rr dslKil 4n ,5on(,&r!'5[r, r]s2) rlh r dt 5&r)r,1 qn

A*l.I*'',Ih.".!^ti..yj".

.I 'r,..,s"itF

synr^ i tM oP,r oi.f 'ud8^on.L

hn'DiG. d

lKal rmro, sn,r'. d. Ildskv,

''...-"..

r qor !, tlnl hf{nnfun iLr

Th !n*r\' 6 tht M4:rrt Mti

bod_r 1 n(5 noiru!ri1!.n roil.t sc s) iro.s nor runh.hr,g! ou!

EhMn{ ir97) apPii.lr rhc iPPro

DGihEtul orrdotu (LLlt{sie\) inlls .blcds in! .r.nts ,rrj limituion of tra humin mhi"

(p 637) rhc bv ot 'm,L{nY, ror

rpn:scnhiiccn(\: hqdrh., whj.

shllrq s daftriLior of LLk.n$s/l

, !d, uvtur\ trl .nLrrl\l ir

N'drtiioJ Ro$(re30),$tusno

ro{ cLlr.nrudua il 6 ii$Prl(iod rr. mocl rhl$aLl d,finid,

orua L,{rd.n p.oplo, ind rrr. ,!r pos!\lontJd qrnushit r.P

(ntj,r*qq (s.! K.lmrmin, sro

l

rrrirr, 5r!, ir. o4uJ i,irliilidr r,iDrt'r

Ar aLr$ .lrhoulh nor inNnr ihlo.lrffoinr ru$ or rr'rr!iri liiLmin bodr, dlr da rrLcnr

r k o\ rollNo 1ir37), Likorrire37),iod rnkorrndlomnu(ie31r)

','.,'.'l'''.

Gftii! {.om iltr .r|Ir sLg oI tro,ll 6 ( hn. ) PLlb r "ti o1or"nliqni lwh{e\.mnh.')

^ 1or.c'.. rcr.' s.lm

-L.ni i! !ell (s.. iirt)tr & l.ho1li.n b) A r,$srh of rhrs iPf

trr o.! rri n (cs, so.n noful) 'r i)

LE!s, Rt'n h.b Pruridll.u rr\ss or

nrhir!,aL-, ry'o!.!iilrodrEi.don b(nuPPri d.

Di\ AlinN r{h thb ftu(ssf i'

rrr lRorir.r i , !,r' 19971 q--'

mon dn.dLy "prcprosmDmd," if ra'5qtr. ot h hs ltlei strbitlt

ro oihtrJ sddno Ptslr.r shl(nJ (rqr) dishnsubhed b.h{u

inutr,qc .n!l ioninurr'. n'nPrdt nnidtriDns rlr antLNrir hid, .1r), r'li.ris dlni uil'rt.{

rnirg G..G,fi & KorrDs, re.6lr;sh&r{rnh. !7r) B}.d oo rr

.q,Luri,ni. hino,r.ri !1!r.t\.tvih.!r.r hod,nrr,h,d,Nn

" (gi11rl.s5 ot rd.nd's ii pl

,d itred<LLt Lf.$l!rA. rht rhr*i vd5 stalilr^ I r, rrrrrtu n,b! r rs$rli inruslr)(rrL.r t& R'i,,Its2;5 tr

rh(ulrh i !(rs of i,!6 iioiDr\. Ln$r. rHe !r!* 1r )

Bor( (ree], Leer, ree5) P(!,nE,

(rtrs,fhr\, Mr .r!l

rrr,,fri. l r'ri!rr r, r'rr 'rrrdr,

r i*Lr rdlf rir ih\!0r.bj!d di oai L.LLL.in .i,u

'i,r[\toL.ir(,' a'r7.imihi]ri 1req0) rt $iliouL 1, Lm!'i

\

urFsollib[,Glg vili'FnsLi, irr5, shLL.J|., ret) c'rl$ 1Le7 ]

L+* n.t. .. *r*"0 . +

r. slr lrs75) ol.nr ri dur h(N

rrrl rnL r'iri t !!t.l r.,

Prr\i srnftDb, r pD.,.:q$ oi iDk,,LDr) Pi.dLd rD! I

tr1.h ..ftnPti rhc

nin!i,,\ r,o trro!.15( ri.flld' fi. t|l.o, & R.]fjt' ],,1]; l

crrtrhr.r,tr,f$iu n\nhrootr0!l ffbfnrDrL,srl (o ,r l

r i rrmn{'l! thvr-r n,h+ ,c. .

Jrc$ G( rioolr, 1957, Ftr{lki (

1L[rLs.l9rs) Lin!{dLen i*. I6ni f,!lri.\ rhe rh!n! q$ii D

lltomm!n r l.\ ru.]r hrfl]], rl,tnso litrr \ ,!ri.l,l!

r Lnr\ 4c,ur 'f ! ts

munl]|ogr, J1!1 icknl}\1.\Lg! lllt P

c i,Li rrrr hnc n, r,Dtrnr \!r,rn

i

rt. It*,as t ,tr Mi?nd Mid

wh.iher nxgi ls the rcsrLL.tr prddvioce (i' rh. .rs! .f .o.ragn n), tlr!l.d[ii g.n{ilaldriredurt ot$. hu n i'rtlnn ior procsir'! svrun, r.rtrral o!r!(r h orpmboJKl lrpuiru or domh +r.!ili. },tuad)ptrr or oiepileJ

a nudrb.r oi flnnss M.n LLhnlv, r Lmp .s [ur il iduilv Dmt]s rrr!rnLiu.nncsor thc rct wo L,i

,,.rps Nny or drr prcpcd.s.r ihc cr Nodd, irnftLne rtrins as a

Pi f.iPir P!!n!'ro3'.ir (hnn f,,bd rtDr hdP nnbm rtu. cdsor

mhJ r.rl ia\ Gn lrrsnnl

h*r!r$ or whrt rppgr t, bg q

souillr,, dr! h$iry oI $. oLri.ns

Lit!, td rt h.r tilq rrrr! iuddMrSiur du*oE ( nndLmes {rJpiic d !{nrtDr.5 pdncn ic,

r /11'r -\.,/ iNr. rvr I

(:ij b t,&!trir.\d.AJ (Far

{}L\!r n (Le0) i,rttr qis(

o \riIIns ^tru(Lisr,Ir,3!r

4. ,. r) ,1 rd'(a3)hi,. J, ii.oLrv. c n, ( R, /ir P 0!rr nnn.b'n&(tJ>rF.L

n,i! J E i,.q.F I

^ (Lesr) /ri!4, -r,rr rrff''hl

r"r r',uir c'q^. r.r "r,,,L{./i L:. & lr$f6oi, M (r}1r) M,11

ind u rhth I r r! bqi rP!(, L Ntrrc (1'].]] l.l !l{(|di.|lJ r9,j

h \r nn!{ ri t s .ru (L (), !

''''''''ln"It t) t tt tt\t)t\! |

rhF1 M 0e2) r cfli., rrd! ot rr,ryi (R 3nh. .da ) N4!1! r! rl"qrn & .o ouB r \d P!

dos4Lq leD Dor)

{Lt.NJ Rrte6uni(n'rrf*

!j"nifrdln.lm*li$Neq{dr c 0ee5) M.$Qrdrhius

, d|{5 "dl

Pj /ddR: L

nqe) 'Yqi ,( ,!h ,-o! qr : APrLyi

1r421 synP hrrNlnqtt .. & noi ( r (re, r[!.D.!sqi

Nqnr0fi c J, !h(Fir N{64. ri,

(Ml6odr,o,-ir M.r8 ( hdiPhonc!

N6bdf n & (o$, r_ ( e&) rrortr rt|lR 5t .st, )r sinn\!sondr,(rdid L(srqeotu1.r tr' NJ: rqt a tsi I

ir.!J\ i \ rcFi!Jr\xd. 1 rLrlrrtriu^ r I lri!r, n rdo,(PP 2$ 2rt {,.6rruBd,l 0!3,,,. aLri;.oi,qr.I o/r! r{'d rirtrF, NJ Ro{u

Anidrd (J d{ I o^ oi r. [dhrd ,1d

^$dr{, c 0s7)

,,drr.4ai 15 ri) \!i Yrk R! Lrda!

Tr( Ir,i'{r irt lijn(r ^1ur

Rdf . oeq) s(i4r!,/s,h4d, r\.i

tu?i,I trtf) nN isi p.idsi'*

& ^qrd,i /i\r, Nr irFi rh!drrd!omru oi eePL4r i{J nilntJ !L

(q D' f' ]i o( A t], & lhoJd, R (

rw!, r, HorL,l, & rn..!rj, c R

rir L.' ( J!r.ri !dqrl!i,,{,,rr,rn, r in, [,,, !({icr c r, D

Rdii r. & d.r,, 1! (re7r) 18!ir! hi!!c &r poior.noiir.

iintrdr, i rr lwr nrsi(s! /inrvl

Ro,o' l' Nl D]]' l-' e \.nsJ' {i{rfr / rr dfoilrrr,ui

N,ii, r, & N{rn[,. t (1,q,.is d, Li: J sr ris, c r r dr l

rrnrrtur, (rr rir,lc r6NN', ir,.,fdfi.3, & !o(, r! (Frt T!

rf, f{tr F nLbqi!p ! /.r{rrLllR6urrrriirirr.}r,Is

^d{\Jllll''''{|vd(t{rs{'.r,']'-J6;r;]nhiFil N4[jq F, & N!nn;l'. ljll ]]n! 'o!$ i d! L\

3a ClrolNenqotrandPaulRozin

shPed{, R ^ treTn

0'."-''''''.t'',

''ilqlo4'L41,!./8/rh, ii:,ai

" tu, I .o 1, .... ......i:."

.,,., .,",.d,",..p....-:,-;,i i : ;". j

MhI \irqhd P 4r he L 2@177rvro, 0 o 0e4) P.hr& crrlr nq m 6tphe.uqton.tut., c6b-. NsL ydk, c./cn tulss 1b.8.