Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s...

46
Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue

Transcript of Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s...

Page 1: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue

Page 2: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 3: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 4: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 5: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 6: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 7: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 8: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

220 Milligrams /Liter

Page 9: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 10: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 11: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

Under Resourced

Under Funded

Under Valued

Page 12: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 13: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1986 Facility Planning

Page 14: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1986 Facility Planning

Page 15: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1986 Effluent BOD5

Page 16: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1986 Effluent TSS

Page 17: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 18: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 19: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1992 Stateline Road WWTP

Page 20: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 21: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 22: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 23: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 24: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 25: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 26: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 27: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

ABB PIC

Page 28: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 29: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 30: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 31: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 32: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92
Page 33: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

PE

RAS

To

Secondary

Clarifiers

ML Recycle

Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process

Page 34: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

0

40

80

120

160

200

240

08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92 01/24/93 03/21/93 05/16/93 07/11/93

SV

I (m

L/g

)

Aerobic SRT 11 - 13 6 - 9 10 - 13 10

1.0 - 1.2 0.7 - 1.0 0.8 - 1.2Selector F:M

Initial Selector Performance

Low F:M Filaments Abound

Page 35: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

Response: RAS Chlorination

Rapid Recovery

Friday Lesson!

SRT Control via Wasting Calculator

Page 36: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

1993 Stress Testing Confirms Results, Beloit Experience Contributes to Industry Selector Design Paradigm Shift

Page 37: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

PE

RAS

To

Secondary

Clarifiers

ML Recycle

Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors Go Anaerobic, Bio-P From the Get Go • Great For NR 217 Phase 1

Compliance

Page 38: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

Struvite (MgNH4PO4) Shows Up in Filtrate System

Bio-P & Anaerobic Digestion: Early Struvite Experiences

Page 39: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

…Yes Sir…Struvite!!!

Page 40: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

Also Helps Control Sidestream P Loads

Ferric Addition

Struvite Mitigation

Page 41: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

It’s Been a Rewarding 25 Year Journey…

Page 42: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

…With Its Share of Fun!

Page 43: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Jan91

Jul91

Jan92

Jul92

Jan93

Jul93

Jan94

Jul94

Jan02

Jul02

Jan03

Jul03

Jan04

Jul04

Jan05

Jul05

Jan06

Jul06

Jan07

Jul07

Jan08

Jul08

Jan09

Jul09

Jan10

Jul10

Jan11

Jul11

Jan12

Jul12

Jan13

Jul13

Jan14

Jul14

Jan15

Jul15

Jan16

Jul16

Effl

ue

nt

CB

OD

5 C

on

cen

trat

ion

(m

g/L

)

City of Beloit Effluent CBOD Compliance 1991-94/2002-2016

Page 44: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Jan91

Jul91

Jan92

Jul92

Jan93

Jul93

Jan94

Jul94

Jan02

Jul02

Jan03

Jul03

Jan04

Jul04

Jan05

Jul05

Jan06

Jul06

Jan07

Jul07

Jan08

Jul08

Jan09

Jul09

Jan10

Jul10

Jan11

Jul11

Jan12

Jul12

Jan13

Jul13

Jan14

Jul14

Jan15

Jul15

Jan16

Jul16

Effl

ue

nt

TSS

Co

nce

ntr

atio

n (

mg

/L)

City of Beloit Effluent TSS Compliance 1991-94/2002-2016

Page 45: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

401

/2/2

01

3

3/2

/20

13

5/2/

201

3

7/2/

201

3

9/2

/20

13

11

/2/2

01

3

1/2/

201

4

3/2/

201

4

5/2/

201

4

7/2

/20

14

9/2/

201

4

11

/2/2

01

4

1/2

/20

15

3/2

/20

15

5/2/

201

5

7/2/

201

5

9/2

/20

15

11

/2/2

01

5

1/2/

201

6

3/2/

201

6

5/2

/20

16

7/2

/20

16

9/2/

201

6

11

/2/2

01

6

Bottom Line…Results • Effluent Quality • Community Service & Return on Invested Trust • Capacity for the Future

• Original 8 MGD/25,000 ppd BOD • Mid 90s Rerate 11.3 MGD/37,000 ppd BOD

2013-2016 Effluent BOD5

Page 46: Harry Mathos/City of Beloit Bill Marten/Donohue...RAS To Secondary Clarifiers ML Recycle Beloit’s Anoxic Selectors MLE Process . 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 08/07/92 10/02/92 11/27/92

99.0277777778%