Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2...

71
“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges THE W RLD IS FAT Barry Popkin Department Of Nutrition School Of Public Health And Medicine Department Of Economics The University Of North Carolina At Chapel Hill “Over 2 billion people in the world are overweight”

Transcript of Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2...

Page 1: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

THE W RLD IS FAT

Barry Popkin Department Of Nutrition

School Of Public Health And Medicine Department Of Economics

The University Of North Carolina At Chapel Hill

“Over 2 billion people in the world are overweight”

Page 2: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Outline: Why is this occurring?

• Dr. Sewell-water and sanitation. My beginnings also • Global Obesity Dynamics and Consequences • Major Global Drivers • How We Move: A cause but not a solution • The World is Flat and Fat • Selected economic issues to consider • How do we proceed

Page 3: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Figure 1. Stages of the Nutrition Transition

Urbanization, economic growth, technological changes for work, leisure, & food processing, mass media growth

Pattern 1 Collecting Food

• Diverse Wild plants & animal food diet

• Drink potable water • Labor intensive

Pattern 3 Receding Famine

• Starchy, low variety, low fat, high fiber diet

• Drink non potable water often • Labor-intensive work/leisure

• Increased fat, sugar, processed foods diet • Drink Sugary Beverages, juices • Shift in technology

of work and leisure • Sedentarism high

Pattern 4 Chronic Disease(NCD’s)

• Reduced fat, increased fruit, veg, CHO, fiber, diet • Drink water, low calorie beverages • Replace sedentarianism with purposeful changes

in recreation, other activity

Pattern 5 Behavioral Change

• Monoculture ag. • Cereals

dominate diet • Drink water • Labor-intensive

Pattern 2 Famine

Low fertility,low life expectancy

Lean & robust, high disease rate

Slow mortality decline

MCH deficiencies, weaning disease, stunting

Accelerated life expectancy, shift to increased NR-NCD, increased disability period

Obesity & NR-NCD emerge, and medical cures keep us alive

Extended healthy aging, reduced NR-NCD

Reduced body fatness & NR-NCD’s, improved

disease prevention

High fertility, high MCH mortality, low life expectancy

Nutritional deficiencies emerge, stature declines

Source: Popkin 2002 revised 2013.

Page 4: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Mismatch: Biology which has evolved over the millennia clashes with modern technology

Biology Technology

Sweet preferences cheap caloric sweeteners, food processing benefits

Thirst and hunger/satiety mechanisms not linked Caloric beverage revolution

Fatty food preference Edible oil revolution-high yield oilseeds, cheap removal of oils

Desire to eliminate exertion Technology in all phases of movement/exertion

Page 5: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

High Income vs.. Transitional and Low Income Countries

• Obesity has existed in the West for 120 years, Big increase in 1980’s

• Low and Middle Income World: last 30 years • Globally: overweight and obesity exceeds greatly

undernutrition in numbers

Page 6: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges
Page 7: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Shifts in Underweight and Overweight Across the Low and Middle Income World, 1990-2010*

Underweight Overweight 2010 1990

Percentage

South Asia

Sub-Saharan Africa

East Asia and Pacific

Central Asia

Latin America and the Caribbean

Middle East and North Africa

Page 8: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Regional Population-Weighted Percent Underweight, Overweight, and Annualized Change in Prevalence :1990’s to 2000’s

Underweight Overweight

Percentage

South Asia

Sub-Saharan Africa

East Asia and Pacific

Europe and Central Asia

Latin America and the Caribbean

Middle East and North Africa

Page 9: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Regional Population-Weighted Percent Underweight, Overweight, and Annualized Change–1990’s 2000’s, Rural/Urban

Percentage

Underweight Overweight

Sub-Saharan Africa

South Asia

Middle East and North Africa

Latin America and the Caribbean

Europe and Central Asia

East Asia and Pacific

Rural Underweight Overweight

Sub-Saharan Africa

South Asia

Middle East and North Africa

Latin America and the Caribbean

Europe and Central Asia

East Asia and Pacific

Urban

Page 10: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Percentage Underweight Overweight

Country (GDP) Mexico (3116) Brazil (3087)

Turkey (2784) Namibia (1661)

Kazakhstan (1647) Jordan (1268) Peru (1213)

Colombia (1213) Morocco (1033)

Dominican Rep. (983) Cameroon (916)

Cote d'Ivoire (862) Guatemala (857) Zimbabwe (839) Senegal (789) Egypt (759) Bolivia (731)

Armenia (637) Indonesia (621)

Haiti (478) Guinea (463) Zambia (418) Ghana (398) Benin (387) India (374)

Kenya (366) Rwanda (359)

Burkina Faso (333) Lesotho (330)

Niger (319) China (314) Nigeria (292) Chad (289)

Bangladesh (286) Mali (279)

Madagascar (273) Cambodia (266) Ethiopia (250)

Nicaragua (245) Uganda (243) Malawi (200) Nepal (190)

Mozambique (182) Tanzania (172) Vietnam (98)

Annualized Change in the Prevalence of Overweight and Underweight 1990's-2000's sorted by GNP per capita*

Page 11: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Annualized Change in the Prevalence of Overweight and Underweight 1990's-2000's Sorted by GNP per capita*

Underweight Percentage Overweight

Urban Country (GDP)

Mexico (3116) Brazil (3087)

Turkey (2784) Namibia (1661)

Kazakhstan (1647) Jordan (1268) Peru (1213)

Colombia (1213) Morocco (1033)

Dominican Rep. (983) Cameroon (916)

Cote d'Ivoire (862) Guatemala (857) Zimbabwe (839) Senegal (789) Egypt (759) Bolivia (731)

Armenia (637) Indonesia (621)

Haiti (478) Guinea (463) Zambia (418) Ghana (398) Benin (387) India (374)

Kenya (366) Rwanda (359)

Burkina Faso (333) Lesotho (330)

Niger (319) China (314) Nigeria (292) Chad (289)

Bangladesh (286) Mali (279)

Madagascar (273) Cambodia (266) Ethiopia (250)

Nicaragua (245) Uganda (243) Malawi (200) Nepal (190)

Mozambique (182) Tanzania (172) Vietnam (98)

Rural Country (GDP)

Mexico (3116) Brazil (3087)

Turkey (2784) Namibia (1661)

Kazakhstan (1647) Jordan (1268) Peru (1213)

Colombia (1213) Morocco (1033)

Dominican Rep. (983) Cameroon (916)

Cote d'Ivoire (862) Guatemala (857) Zimbabwe (839) Senegal (789) Egypt (759) Bolivia (731)

Armenia (637) Indonesia (621)

Haiti (478) Guinea (463) Zambia (418) Ghana (398) Benin (387) India (374)

Kenya (366) Rwanda (359)

Burkina Faso (333) Lesotho (330)

Niger (319) China (314) Nigeria (292) Chad (289)

Bangladesh (286) Mali (279)

Madagascar (273) Cambodia (266) Ethiopia (250)

Nicaragua (245) Uganda (243) Malawi (200) Nepal (190)

Mozambique (182) Tanzania (172) Vietnam (98)

Underweight Percentage Overweight

Page 12: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Australian Youth Gain Fat, Shift Body Shape

Based on the research of Olds (2009) EJCN 1-13.

Page 13: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

The consequences vary by race-ethnicity: Body fat composition in the East vs. the West

(Yajnik & Yudkin 2004)

Page 14: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Chinese Adolescent males ages12-18 face major problems(comparison with NHANES published results)

Males aged 12-18(US 12-19)

China CHNS fasting blood-2009

United States NHANES publications

High HbA1c 1.2% 0.5%

CRP>3 10.4% 8.5%

Glucose≥126 mg/dL 0.7% 0.28%

IFG (100-126mg/dL) 7.5% 20%

IFG (100-126mg/dL) 7.5% 20%

Yan et al (2012) Obesity Reviews 13 (9): 810-21 China Health and Nutrition Survey team

Page 15: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Children 7-17.99 Adult 18-39.99 Adult>40 FOOTNOTES:Yan et al (2012) Obesity Reviews 13 (9): 810-21 Proportion of the population with none, or one or more of the following cardiometabolic risk factors: impaired/diabetic (HbA1c≥5.7%), hypertension (140/90, or age-sex specific percentiles for pediatric population), high TC (≥200 mg/dL), high LDL (>130 mg/dL), low HDL(<40 mg/dL), high TG (≥150 mg/dL), high CRP High CRP (≥3).

Proportion of The CHNS Sample with CVD Risk Factors by Age Group (age 7-17.99 Years; age 18-39.99 Years, and age ≥40 Years

Page 16: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

The burden of disease is shifting rapidly towards the poor.

• Burden of obesity and related chronic diseases are either greater among the poor or shifting to the poor.

• More recent work by Jones-Smith et al (AJE,2011; Popkin, Ng, Adair, Nutr. Reviews 2011; Jones-Smith et al, IJO 2011) suggests majority of countries poor still less overweight but the rate of changes suggest time before the burden shifts to the poor. Others disagree but mainly their focus is on cross-sectional data.

Page 17: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Equity matters also

• In further results in those 3 papers, we find that as GDP gets higher, the more equitable the income distribution, the more likely it is for the burden of obesity to shift to the poor. This is not terribly surprising either and is an indication of more equitable access to the obesity promoting features of society, such as energy dense foods, sedentary occupations and labor saving devices.

Page 18: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Major Food System Shifts : Linkages from Farm to Food Sales are Rapidly Shifting • This represents a major shift away from fresh farmers

markets to c-stores and supermarkets for the Low and middle income countries.

• Traditional chain – Farmers sale directly in markets or sell to middlemen. – Small mills and processors at local level – Complex varied distribution

• Rapid transition to modern system varied across Latin America, Africa, Asia at various times over 1980-2010 – Modern: farmer to processors or supermarkets

Page 19: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Fresh Markets are disappearing, replaced by convenience stores and supermarkets

• In 1990 15-20% of food sold in supermarkets in Latin America

• In 2000: 60% of the average population share. They are becoming the main buyers in the supply chains for processed foods

• Top 5 chains control two-thirds of the supermarket sector in Latin America (Wal-Mart, Carrefour, Ahold)

• Asia, urban Africa underway

Page 20: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Shift In Growth and Size of Sales for a Subset of Retailers in Asia

• First wave South Korea($42B), Taiwan – Annual compound sales growth 2001-09: 10-12%

• Second wave: Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand ($18B) – Annual compound sales growth 2001-09: 13-18.5%

• Third wave: China($91B), India, Vietnam – Annual compound sales growth 2001-09: 28-50%

Page 23: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Types of foods & beverages

Raw & Perishable

Packaged and processed

Prepared

Public data Intake

NHANES Foods as reported

NHANES Foods as reported

NHANES 2007/08: 30% of calories

prepared away from home

34% of calories eaten away from home ‡

Food composition

USDA SR, FNDDS, MPED 7,500 USDA food codes

Commercial data

Sales/ purchase

Household panel until 2006 only

Retail Scan & household panels

600,000 UPCs Consumer panels

Nutrition USDA SR ~ 200,000 unique formulations §

At least 1,800 Fast Food items/meals

The modern food supply is not what we think it is from our limited measurement

‡ Poti & Popkin, JADA, 2011 § Ng, & Popkin, JADA 2012

Page 24: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

What drives caloric increases and leads to added energy imbalance?

• Energy imbalance clear major cause

• Understand any diet ( high/low protein, fat, or complex carbohydrates diets) all can reduce weight

• The drivers of calorie increases are clear. • Some beginning sense that lower glycemic foods (e.g.....

sugar, refined carbohydrates) may play a role in weight gain, also continued weight loss.

Page 25: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Page 26: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Sources of Major Global Dietary Shifts • Global increases in:

– Caloric sweetener use, especially in beverages – animal source foods – refined carbohydrates, ultra refined highly processed

foods – snacking, away-from-home eating, precooked food

• Global decreases in: – legumes, vegetables, fruits in most countries – food preparation time

• Only in Low and middle income world: increased edible oil use and food frying

Page 27: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

From Traditional to Modern Snacking

Page 28: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Always loved sweetness.

Sweet foods are naturally good and are safe sources of energy and nutrients

What about conditioning, issues of habituation:

animal models do not help. We know little.

First major global shift: sweetness, added sugars

Page 29: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

What are the implications of eating food and drinking water on energy balance?

General Properties Food Water

Hunger – Feeding Sensations that promote attainment of minimal food energy needs

Thirst – Drinking Sensations that promote attainment of minimal hydration needs

Energy Excess Stored

Water Excess Excreted

Energy Deficit: Die in 1-2 months Water Deficit : Die in 3-7 days

Page 30: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Remarkably Short History for Caloric Beverages: Might the Absence of Compensation Relate to This Historical Evolution?

AD

BC

E 1000

0 B

CE

2000

00 B

CE

Beg

inni

ng

of T

ime

100000 BCE 200000 BCE

Homo Sapiens

Pre-

Hom

o Sa

pien

s

200,

000B

CE

- 10,

000

BC

E O

rigin

of H

uman

s

Mod

ern

Bev

erag

e Er

a 10

,000

BC

E - p

rese

nt

0

Earliest possible date Definite date

Water, Breast Milk

2000 BCE Milk (9000 BCE)

Beer (4000 BCE)

Wine (5400 BCE) Wine, Beer, Juice (8000 BCE)

(206 AD) Tea (500 BCE)

Brandy Distilled (1000-1500)

Coffee (1300-1500)

Lemonade (1500-1600)

Liquor (1700-1800)

Carbonation (1760-70)

Pasteurization (1860-64)

Coca Cola (1886)

US Milk Intake 45 gal/capita (1945)

Juice Concentrates (1945)

US Coffee Intake 46 gal/capita (1946)

US Soda Intake 52/gal/capita (2004)

Page 31: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Mourao, .. (2007). "Effects of food form..." IJO:31(11): 1688-95.

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

Kca

ls p

er d

ay c

onsu

med

Comparison of consumption of a beverage and a solid food on total Energy Intake shows beverage consumption in any macronutrient form significantly increases dairy energy intake

Liquid

Solid

Liquid

Solid

Liquid

Solid

Carbohydrate (Watermelon)

Fat (Coconut)

Protein (Dairy)

*

*

*

Page 32: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Total Calories and Volume of Food and Beverages Purchased in the United States Containing Nutritive Sweeteners (NS)

and Non-nutritive Sweeteners (NNS), 2005-2009

a. Containing any Nutritive Sweeteners (NS) b. Containing any Non-Nutritive Sweeteners (NNS)

Sources: Nielsen Homescan 2005-2009, Gladson Nutrition Database 2007 and 2010

Page 33: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

8.0

20002001200220032004200520062007200820092010

Per Capita Daily Calories Sold (kcal) The Coca-Cola Company - China

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

Per Capita Daily Calories Sold (kcal) PepsiCo - China

Bottled Water Carbonates Fruit/Vegetable Juice Sports and Energy Drinks RTD

Source: Kleiman,Ng, Popkin, 2012

Chinese Trends 2000-2010 in Daily Calories

Page 34: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Second major global concern: snacking

• Snacking is a norm created by the food industry • The history of snacking‒very rare use until the 1900’s

except for festivals, royalty, war. No mention of food in early coffee houses. Only in pubs/inns and for meals.

• When did snacking become a norm? Really in the US began post WWII

• Today a different issue: Brazil, Mexico, the US are three countries where our studies show over 22% of kcal come from snacks, increasingly highly processed foods and beverages.

Page 35: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Number of meals plus snacks (2-day average)

A. Children, 2-18 years B. Adults, ≥ 19 years

Source: Popkin, and Duffey American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2010): 91

Daily Meal Frequency Among US Children, Ages 2-18 and US Adults Ages 19 and Older

1977-78 1994-98 2003-2006 2007-2008

Page 36: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Third major shift: Fatty Foods and edible oils in particular

• Fatty foods: smoother, affects taste in many ways

Page 37: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Fat Preference Key for Survival: Technology, Marketing have Utilized

this Preference for Fatty Food

Page 38: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Vegetable oils: the third leg Edible Oil Consumption Still Rising in China

(grams per day per capita)

Year 1989 1991 1997 2006 2009

Poorest (lowest income tertile) 11.8 19.4 26.5 30.8 37.6

Middle income tertile 15 22.4 29 35.4 43.5

Richest (highest income tertile) 17.4 26.9 32.2 33.9 37.7

Average for total adult population 14.8 22.9 29.2 33.4 39.6

% of all calories per capita from edible oil 4.9 7.8 11.3 13.2 14.4

Source: China Health and Nutrition Survey for adults aged 20-45

Page 39: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Animal Source Foods: the fourth component Trends in Global Prices for Beef, 1990 US Dollars

Source: International Food Price Research Institute Cited in Delgado & Courbois 1998

Page 40: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Daily Intake of Animal Source Foods in China (grams/day),1991-2009*

poultry

Beef, lamb, mutton, other red meat

All dairy

eggs

Pork & pork products

* Adjusted for age and gender

A. Children Aged 2-18 B. Adults Aged 19 and Older

Page 41: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Dynamics of Developed and Developing Country Beef, Pork and Poultry Food Available for Consumption

Developed Countries Developing Countries

Page 42: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Why the concern about movement and activity

• Important direct health benefits. For kids enhances learning in a vast array of ways.

• Vast array of direct benefits from improved bone health to prevention of diabetes and cardiovascular health to healthier aging

• Important for prevention of 4-5 different cancers

• Indirect benefits via reduced obesity

• Not simple to stop the major declines in energy expended in market and home production, transportation nor to control increases in sedentary activity

Page 43: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Context for the following data • Use a physiological measure called metabolic equivalent

of task (MET), which describes the amount of energy spent in accomplishing a task

• a person who slept 24 hours in a day would expend 151 MET hours per week, and an active adult who did vigorous activity for 30 minutes to an hour every day, but otherwise had a desk job, would expend between 240 and 265 MET-hours per week.

Source: Ng S.W. & Popkin B.M. Obesity Reviews (2012). “Modernization , Time Use and Physical Activity: A shift away from movement across the globe“; Obesity Reviews 13 (8):659-80

Page 44: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Source: Ng S.W. & Popkin B.M. Obesity Reviews 13 (8):659-80

US Adults Met-hours Per Week of All Physical Activity, and Hours/Week of Time in Sedentary Behavior: Measured for 1965-2009 and Forecasted for 2010-2030

Page 45: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 2018 2021 2024 2027 2030

Aver

age

hour

s pe

r wee

k br

ing

sede

ntar

y

Aver

age

MET

-hou

rs p

er w

eek

Year

Active Leisure PA

Travel PA

Domestic PA

Occupational PA

Sedentary Time (hrs/week)

by 2030: 188 MET-hr./week

2009: 213 MET-hr./week

by 2020: 200 MET-hr./week

1991: 399 MET-hr./week

Source: Ng S.W. & Popkin B.M. Obesity Reviews (2012). “Modernization , Time Use and Physical Activity: A shift away from movement across the globe“; Obesity Reviews 13 (8):659-80

Chinese Adults Met-hours per Week of Physical Activity & Hours/Week of Time in Sedentary Behavior: Measured for 1991-2009 and Forecasted for 2010-2030

Page 46: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

The Struggle Over the Millennia to Eliminate Arduous Effort Could Not

Foresee Modern Technology

Page 47: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Food Policy-The Orientation of the Agricultural-Food Sector May be the Key

• 1880’s: first cash crop research stations-sugar • Slow evolution of research, subsidies, funding • Orientation: global spread of US and European approach:

focus on basic staples and then animal source foods

Popkin EMBO Rep 2011;12:11-8.

Page 48: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Trends in Global Prices for Beef, 1990 US Dollars

Source: International Food Price Research Institute Cited in Delgado & Courbois 1998

Page 49: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Relative Prices in the United States, 1983-2005

SSB’s

fresh fruits/veggies

sugar/sweets

total

fats/oils

Page 50: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

The Policy Intervention Ladder

• Eliminate choice • Restrict choice • Guide choice through disincentives • Guide choice through incentives • Guide choices through changing the default policy • Enable choice • Provide information • Do nothing or simply monitor the situation

Source Susan Jebb from the Nuffield Council Bioethics Public Health: Ethical Issues

Page 51: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Global Public Health Solutions to Obesity, Related Comorbidities, Disabilities

• Beverages: new science has led this to become a major target.

• Restrict labeling on package fronts. Gov’t sponsored front-of-the label signs designating healthfulness

• Restriction, control for school feeding, many gov’t food programs across the globe

• Mass media: control advertising of unhealthy foods and beverages

Page 52: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Economic Policies Might Work

• Tobacco is the prime example of the value of price policy

• Examples show the potential.

• However no examples exist for unhealthy foods taxed for healthy reasons with any linkage to measures of health outcomes—only longitudinal studies linking price changes to beverage changes to health outcomes.

Page 53: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Methods: Price Elasticity of Demand

• Elasticity= % change in demand

% change in price

• Own-price elasticity

• Cross-price elasticity

$ kcals % % Δ Δ

$ % % kcals Δ Δ

Negative

Negative or positive

Page 54: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Adult health significant improvement with a 10% change in the price of soda

US example of a longitudinal study of 5000 adults aged 20-34 over 20 years: similar elasticities seen in research on Mexico and the UK adults.

Per

cent

Cha

nge

in o

utco

me

Source: Duffey et al, Archives of Internal Medicine, 2010

Page 55: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges
Page 56: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Why act: obesity debilitates, smoking kills!

• Early mortality not as important as early retirement

• Early disability

• Increased absenteeism

• Increased presenteeism—i.e. lower productivity at work

Page 57: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

The Indirect Costs of Obesity (BMI 35+) in U.S.

The total annual cost of obesity (BMI 35+) is estimated to be $44.7 billion among full-time employees in the US

Source: Finkelstein E.A., DiBonaventura M., Burgess S.M., Hale B.C. The Costs of Obesity in the Workplace. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2010 Oct;52(10), 971-976.

Page 58: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Is the private sector the answer?

• Corporate voluntarism abounds: few rigorous evaluations. We are involved in one factory to fork analysis which examines the pledge in reduction of calories sold but also purchases by key subpopulations and ultimately dietary intake.

• Private sector activities are increasing with the major focus on fulltime workforce.

• Also not just food manufacturers but some retailers initiated major activities (e.g.... Wal-Mart, Safeway, Kroger)

Page 59: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Global changes among insurers, companies

• Discovery: largest insurer South Africa works not just directly with employees of small companies but also with supermarket chains in areas they live in, provides incentives for healthy eating. Only subset of employees enrolled.

• Safeway: US essentially has had constant health costs for five years by working with 100,000 employees across the US and with an insurance company on this topic Only subset of employees enrolled.

• Many factories do this at worksite but other smaller ones use insurers to handle the major shifts

Page 60: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Other companies

• Dow Chemical: individual consultation with RD, also group consultation, support groups, funded membership in programs such as weight watchers. Covered both employees and families.

• General Mills: screening tool created in 2004. At each manufacturing location developed classes, competitions, nutrition centers.

• Energy Corp of America: 300 employees. Comprehensive wellness program rare for smaller companies. Followed up risk assessment with in-person coaching session.

Page 61: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“Over 2 billion people in the world are overweight”

Now think of the individual outside the company context: The Economic Costs

to the Individual Is Reduced Today • Tremendous increase in medical, pharmacological and

surgical treatments for the risk factors and diseases that are related to obesity – Statins for cholesterol – Metformin for diabetes – Many successful Blood Pressure medications – Over 1.5 million procedures performed in 2008 in the

U.S. aimed at opening up clogged arteries

Page 62: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“Over 2 billion people in the world are overweight”

The Economic Costs to the Individual Reduced Today

• Among today’s obese population, the prevalence of high cholesterol and high blood pressure are now 21, and 18 percentage points lower, respectively, than among obese persons 30 to 40 years ago (Gregg et al., 2006)

• Today’s obese population has better blood pressure and Cholesterol values than normal weight adults had a few decades ago because of medications (Gregg et al., 2006)

• Being obese is not so costly anymore

Page 63: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“Over 2 billion people in the world are overweight”

But it is those without insurance, the low income and SES of the world who are

most vulnerable • The array of successful interventions in low and middle

income countries or even high income countries are few • UK Foresight initiative very promising before ended by

different politics of voluntarism. But very interesting to see what the UK started.

Page 64: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

Societal influences Individual psychology

Biology

Activity environment

Individual activity Food

consumption Food production

Page 65: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

And by leveraging wider policies and funding on prevention e.g. for children

Physical Activity

• £783m 08-11 to support PE/Sports Strategy – 5 hours per week • £235m 08-11 to create/regenerate 3,500 play spaces in parks/public spaces • Cycling/school transport

Schools • All schools have a legal duty to promote pupils wellbeing, including health • School assessment takes account of wellbeing indicators • The voluntary Healthy Schools Programme is very popular with heads: 98%

of schools participate, 75% have been accredited

Healthier Food

• £650m 2005-11 to support food and nutritional standards for food in schools • Growing popularity of breakfast clubs as part of schools extended services • Cooking is compulsory in primary schools

Early Years

• New national Sure Start Children’s Centres – one-stop shop for advice on parenting, health, childcare, employment (full network of 3,500 by spring 2010)

• Developing authoritative, evidence-based messages on eating and active play for children under five

• Healthy Child Programme for children under five

Page 66: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

A £372m Investment in Tackling Obesity

Physical Activity

• Be Active, Be Healthy National Physical Activity Plan setting the goal of increasing activity in 2 million more adults by 2012

• £30m invested in nine 'Healthy Towns,' which lead the way in improving the built environment

Incentives & Workplace

• Business Health Check Tool to promote boardroom reporting of staff health and wellbeing; get 75% of large firms to sign up

• £66m in local allocations to support local action on overweight and obesity • National contract of child weight management providers • All adults aged 40-74 to have BMI assessed as part of vascular risks

Personal Advice &

Care

Children • National programme to weigh and measure all 4 and 11 year olds • Ads for unhealthy food banned around children’s TV and other media

Healthier Food

• Widespread front of pack labelling on food in stores • Powers to restrict proliferation of fast food restaurants near schools and

parks • Project to supply fresh fruit and vegetables in stores in deprived areas

Page 67: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Low and middle income countries • Little documentation of some very impressive efforts so

June Bellagio meeting to get documentation, push evaluation

• Trade policies, taxation changes in Western Pacific

• Major set of programs and policy changes in Mexico(beverage panel, national consensus obesity prevention, strong school food and beverage policy, front of the package label), Chile a few(e.g. label bad foods)

• Thailand, many others started some effective components

• To date no major declines in overweight in LMIC’s after some initial hope for Brazil

Page 68: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Conflicts between current programs and changing needs

• Two worlds—Infection diseases( HIV-AIDS, malaria, TB,etc) vs. NCD’s domination of deaths and global situation where NCD’s are stressing systems.

• Chile: eliminated undernutrition, fought to keep old programs, adverse effects.

• Mexico: Opportunidades and before that Progressa. As needs changed, income and feeding programs focused on the poor led to increased obesity. Realization led to rapid shifts in food programs, food store content for the poor very quickly

• US: SNAP, WIC,School Feeding histories.

Page 69: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

Global emerging conflicts between the different sides of current agricultural &

food system • Animal source foods: positive & negative health effects

• Major environmental costs: Water use, carbon emissions, etc. Vast needs for water conservation in ag.

• Globally: modern food system with improved sanitation & control of the cold chain for food linked with access to ultraprocessed foods and beverages.

• Dual burden for many nations: need to address wasting and stunting and also reduce the risks of NCD’s is the major challenge. Complex intergenerational issues.

Page 70: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

In the US see the conflicts daily

• Major health and health care costs

• Critical economic burden of obesity and all the nutrition-related chronic diseases

• A food industry that is motivated to sell more calories unless price, regulatory and other changes shift the equation

• The enormous size and power not only of the food industry but equally of all the biological forces that have led us to our current global situation must be addressed

Page 71: Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and … › sites › default › ...“close to 2 billion people overweight” Global Obesity: Current Patterns, Dynamics and Future Challenges

“close to 2 billion people overweight”

THE BOOK “The most serious epidemic ever is insidiously engulfing the world. Barry Popkin draws upon his decades of research and experience to describe its origins–and a set of potential solutions. Those interested in the future of mankind should read this book.” Walter Willett, author of Eat,

Drink, and Be Healthy, and

chair, Department of Nutrition,

Harvard University

Walter Willett, author of Eat,