Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx...

36
EGS Generation 3 QDC Qualification Status October 2010 QualTech NP A Curtiss Wright Flow Control Company 1

Transcript of Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx...

Page 1: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

EGS Generation 3 QDCQualification Status

October 2010

QualTech NPA Curtiss Wright Flow Control Companyg p y

1

Page 2: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Who is Q ?QualTech?

2

Page 3: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Enhanced Environmental PParameters

New qualification test provided enhancedNew qualification test provided enhancedparameters beyond previous testing. Toaccomplish this, EGS QDC design was modified.New test parameters include:

• Thermal aging 1,226 hours g g ,• LOCA Pressure to 109 psig• MSIV Steam Break Test to > 500°F• Post-LOCA Submergence at 285°F/62 psig for 32 days• Radiation 2.3E8 rads

3

Page 4: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Original vs. Gen 3 QDC

½” size is shown ¾” and 1 ½” NPT sizes are also available

4

½ size is shown. ¾ and 1 ½ NPT sizes are also available.

Page 5: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Enhanced Design

• All materials upgraded for improved radiation d th l i tand thermal resistance

• Mechanical seals have been added at cable seal area for submergencearea for submergence

• Wave spring force has been reduced for ergonomic advantage (1/2 inch size only)ergonomic advantage (1/2-inch size only)

• Improved wire/cable strain reliefTwo piece backshell for interface versatility• Two piece backshell for interface versatility

5

Page 6: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Wire/Cable Insulation Optionsp

• XLPEXLPE • PEEKSili R bb ith t i l t l• Silicone Rubber with stainless steel armor

6

Page 7: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Test Sequence• Baseline• Vibration Aging (IEEE382, 5-200 Hz, g g ( , ,

Resonance > 100 Hz)• Thermal Cycling (10 cycles, 30°C to 121°C)y g ( y )• Cycle Aging (160 disconnects)• Thermal Aging (1226 hr at 126°C, QL = 60 yrs at g g ( , y

50°C + 35 days at 121°C Abnormal Condition)• Functional Tests • Radiation Aging (3E7 rads-air, 5E5 rad/hr)

7

Page 8: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Test Sequence (cont’d)q ( )• Thermal Cycling (10 cycles, 30°C to 121°C)• Functional Tests• Seismic (10 g RIM OBE sine sweeps to 100 Hz. 10 g

RIM SSE sine beats to 64 Hz. Plus RMF SSE at table limit)limit)

• Functional Tests• Accident Radiation (2.8 rads-air, TID=2.3E8)( , )• Functional Tests• LOCA/Submergence Simulation (Show Profiles)• MSIV/MSLB Simulation (Show Profiles)• Post – test Inspections

8

Page 9: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Baseline

9

Page 10: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

SEISMIC RIM OBE

10

Page 11: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

SEISMIC RMF RRS

11

Page 12: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Seismic Testing

12

Page 13: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Generic LOCA Profile

13

Page 14: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Composite Generic LOCA

(Original Profile)

14

Page 15: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Actual LOCA Profile

15

Page 16: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

QDC Prior to LOCA

Submergence Level

16

Page 17: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

QDC Prior to LOCA

17

Page 18: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

QDC After LOCA

18

Page 19: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

QDC After LOCA

19

Page 20: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Required MSLB/MSIV

20

Page 21: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Actual MSLB

21

Page 22: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental TestingReport No. EGS-TR-23009-14 was published in September 2009. After thereport was issued, the AP1000 LOCA and MSIV profiles were revisedupward Therefore additional supplemental testing was performed on agedupward. Therefore, additional supplemental testing was performed on agedspare specimens 2 and 8. First, the 27.5 hour MSIV test was performedand then a 32+day LOCA Test was performed. After 28 hours, Specimen 8was submerged for ~31days while Specimen 2 remained in the steamwas submerged for 31days while Specimen 2 remained in the steamenvironment above the submergence level. The specimens survived bothtests.

22

Page 23: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Required Profile

23

Page 24: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental MSIV Test Profile

500

550

09-027S: EGS QDC Supplemental MSIVSteam Test per EGS-TR-23066-06 Rev 0 § 3.2.3

started 20 May 2010 @ ATS, Delaware, OH

Average

400

450

F)

Average

Specified

300

350

mpe

ratu

re (°

New Required Peak = 500°F

200

250Tem

100

150

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500

El d Ti ( d )

24

Elapsed Time (seconds)

Page 25: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental MSIV TestSpecimens 2 & 8 Prior to MSIVSpecimens 2 & 8 Prior to MSIV

25

Page 26: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental MSIV TestSpecimens 2 & 8 Prior to MSIVSpecimens 2 & 8 Prior to MSIV

26

Page 27: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental MSIV Test Specimens 2 & 8 Post MSIVSpecimens 2 & 8 Post MSIV

27

Page 28: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

LOCALOCAProfile

Duration Temperature (○F) Press(psia)(p )

1 Second 300 26.610 Seconds 375 63.319 Seconds 437 72.821 Seconds 437 72.830 Seconds 395 72.82 Minutes 395 72 82 Minutes 395 72.8

22 Minutes 315 82.750 Minutes 315 79.8

2 Hours 291 62.07 Hours 291 60.0

28 Hours 285 60.030 Days 285 60 0

28

30 Days 285 60.0

Page 29: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

QDC Supplemental LOCA

29

Page 30: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

10-013S: EGS QDC Supplemental LOCAIndividual Temperaturesp

30

Page 31: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental LOCA Specimens 2 & 8 Prior to LOCASpecimens 2 & 8 Prior to LOCA

Submergence Level

31

Page 32: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental LOCASpecimen 2 After LOCASpecimen 2 After LOCA

32

Page 33: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Supplemental LOCA Specimen 8 After LOCASpecimen 8 After LOCA

33

Page 34: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Test ReportsEGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published September 30, 2009

Original Test of Specimens 1-8, including LOCA for Specimens 1, 3, 5 & 7 and MSIV for S i 4 & 6 Thi tSpecimens 4 & 6. This report will be revised by December 2011 to reference Supplemental Testing in 2010.g

EGS-TR-23066-08, Rev. A Published July 26, 2010

Supplemental MSIV Test of Pre-Aged Specimens 2 & 8 to envelope revised AP1000 MSIVenvelope revised AP1000 MSIV Profile.

EGS-TR-23066-11, DRAFT Expected October 15 2010

Supplemental LOCA Test of Specimens 2 & 8 to envelopeExpected October 15, 2010 Specimens 2 & 8 to envelope revised AP1000 LOCA Profile, including submergence.

34

Page 35: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Results

• Program was successful and Gen 3QDC h l d b li d FQDCs have already been supplied Forthe First AP1000 Units in China.

35

Page 36: Generation 3 Qualification Status (3).pptx [Read-Only]site.ieee.org/npec-sc2/files/2017/06/SC-2Mtg10-2_Att11_Deist-Gen3-… · Test Reports EGS-TR-23009-14 Rev. Original Published

Questions and Contact Information• Gary Elam• QualTech NP, a business unit of Curtiss-Wright Flow

C t l CControl Company• (256) 722-8500 ext.136• gelam@curtisswright [email protected]• Darryl Deist• Strategic Account Managerg g• Office: (1) 931-293-2843

Mobile: (1) 256-665-3032ddeist@curtisswright com• [email protected]

36