General Program - IESA-CSIC · 4 COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH...
14
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH 4 - 5 November 2011 General Program www.iesa.csic.es
Transcript of General Program - IESA-CSIC · 4 COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH...
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL
CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
4-5 November 2011
General Programwww.iesa.csic.es
3
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
November 4
15:00-15:45 Registration
15:45-16:00 Welcome and opening session Salón de actos (Ground Floor) Eduardo Moyano Director of the IESA Joan Font IESA-CSIC
16:00-17:00 Plenary Lecture Ground Floor
Gianpaolo Baiocchi Watson Institute, Brown University Potentials and limits of ethnographic
contributions:Appraisalsfromfieldwork in different cultural settings
17:00-17:30 Coffee
17:30-19:30 Twosimultaneousworkshops Evaluation of participatory processes-1 Sala de reuniones (First Floor) Methodological innovations Ground Floor
21:00 Dinner “Amaltea” Restaurant Ronda Isasa, 10
4
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
November 509:00-10:30 Twosimultaneousworkshops Action research-1 Sala de reuniones (First Floor) Surveys Salón de actos (Ground Floor)
10:30-11:00 Coffee
11:00-13:00 Twosimultaneousworkshops Evaluation of participatory processes-2 First Floor Action Research-2 Ground Floor 13:00-14:30 Lunch
14:30-16:00 Twosimultaneousworkshops Ethnographic methodologies First Floor E-participation Ground Floor
16:15-17:15 Plenary lecture Ground Floor André Bächtiger Institute of Political Science, University of Bern Measuring democratic deliberation among citizens and elites
17:15-18:00 Conclusion session Fernando Aguiar Deputy Academic Director of the IESA Concluding comments Yves Sintomer Université Paris-8 Graham Smith University of Southampton
18:00-19:00 Glass of wine
5
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
ACADEMIC PROGRAMIn eachworkshop 3-4 paperswill be presented (15-20minutespresentation each), followed by a common discussion that will be startedbythesession’sdiscussant(10minutes).
WorkshopEvAluATIonofpArTIcIpAToryprocEssEs-1Sala de reuniones (First Floor)
November 4 17:30 | 19:30
Workshop ChairKimmo Grönlund Åbo Akademi University, Finland.
DiscussantIsmael Blanco Universitat Autònoma Barcelona, Spain.
Papers
The facilitation of citizens’ initiatives: an application of de-sign experiment methodologyJudithBakker,s.A.H.Denters,pieter-JanKlokandMirjanoudevrielinkSchool of Management and Governance, University of Twente
challenges in the implementation of theArea-Based Develop-ment approach in a rural cross border area of the Western Ba-lkansareaoftheWesternBalkansSilvia L. Saravia Matus, Geertrui Louwagie and Fabien Santini Eu-ropean Commission, Joint Research Centre, Institute for Prospective Technological Studies Gert Guri International School on Local Development, University of TrentoMarius Lazdinis European Commission, Directorate General for Agriculture and Rural DevelopmentBoban Ilic Regional Rural Development Standing Working Group of South Eas-tern Europe Sergio Gomez y Paloma European Commission, Joint Research Centre, Insti-tute for Prospective Technological Studies
Sociological research and participation: a case study on a residen-tial tourism destination in BrazilAntonio Aledo Tur, Hugo Garcia Andreu and Guadalupe Ortiz Instituto Universitario de Investigaciones Turísticas, Universidad de Alicante
DeliberativeTransformationandIntersubjectiveconsistencySimon Niemeyer School of Politics & International Relations Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
6
WorkshopMETHODOLOGICAL INNOvATIONSSalón de actos (Ground Floor)
November 4 | 17:30 - 19:30
Workshop ChairÅsa Bengtsson Åbo Akademi University, Finland
DiscussantDonatella della Porta European University Institute
Papers
What we can and cannot learn about participation from experimental designs?The advantages and drawbacks ofdifferent methodological strategiesIrenafiketUniversity of Siena
How to gain general conclusions from small-n-Analysis?Using Weberian approach on ideal types. An illustration ba-sed on experiences with participatory budgeting in Europe Carsten Herzberg University of Postdam
Towards a comparative analysis of democratic innovations: lessonsfromanfs-QcAofparticipatorybudgetingMatt Ryan and Graham Smith University of Southampton
potentialandproblemsofmeta-analysisinresearchonpar-ticipatory deliberative innovationsBrigitte GeisselGoethe University Frankfurt
7
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
WorkshopAcTIonrEsEArcH-1Sala de reuniones (First Floor)
November 5 | 9:00 - 10:30
Workshop ChairErnesto Ganuza Instituto de Estudios Sociales AvanzadosConsejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (IESA-CSIC)
DiscussantJulien Talpin Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, University Lille 2
Papers
forapublicsociologyofparticipation.Areflexiveperspec-tive on a research led in an associationHéloïse Nez University Paris 13; Laboratoire Architecture Ville Urbanisme Environne-ment , Lavue, Paris
Why governance researchers should practice what they preachCatherine Durose Local Governance Research Unit at De Montfort University, Leicester
Collaborative Community Research: the challenge of brin-ging participatory values to participation researchHeatherBlakeyInternational Centre for Participation Studies, Peace Studies, University of Bradford
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
8
WorkshopSURvEYSSalón de actos (Ground Floor)
November 5 | 9:00 - 10:30
Workshop ChairDonatella della Porta European University Institute
DiscussantMarc Hooghe Catholic University of Leuven
Papers
Popular perceptions of political processes_a critical review of alternative measurementsÅsa Bengtsson Åbo Akademi University, Finland
“Do what you should do...” Improving the measurement of political participation from samples of Cordoba’s Silvina Brussino, Patricia Sorribas, Hugo H. Rabbia and Débora ImhoffUniversidad Nacional de Córdoba, Argentina
Assessing and redressing the validity of a web survey about local participationCarolina Galais Universitat Autónoma BarcelonaJoan Font Instituto de Estudios Sociales Avanzados, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (IESA-CSIC)Pau Alarcón Instituto de Estudios Sociales Avanzados, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (IESA-CSIC)Dolores Sesma Instituto de Estudios Sociales Avanzados, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (IESA-CSIC)
9
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
WorkshopEvAluATIonofpArTIcIpAToryprocEssEs-2Sala de reuniones (First Floor)
November 5 | 11:oo-13:00
Workshop ChairBrigitte Geißel Goethe University Frankfurt
DiscussantYves SintomerUniversité Paris-8
Papers
The challenge of deliberative participation in the health care sector: potentials and limitationsMauro Serapioni Centro Estudos Sociais, Universidade de Coimbra
When Change happens. Participatory Practices and their outcomes: an Advocacy Coalition PerspectiveMassimo Allulli Cittalia-Centro europeo di studi e ricerche per i comuni e le città
The experience of the Presidential Advisory Boards and the constructionofthepublicproblemsinchilepost-transitionFélix Aguirre Universidad de ValparaísoMaría Angélica Cruz Universidad de ValparaísoManuel Antonio Garretón Universidad de Chile
Possibilities of institutional participative devices in Public Opinion research: the case of “Public Debate”Beatriz Mañas Ramírez Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
10
WorkshopAcTIonrEsEArcH-2Salón de actos (Ground Floor)
November 5 | 11:00-13:00
Workshop ChairRosa Borge Internet Interdisciplinary Institute, Open University of Catalonia
DiscussantGraham Smith University of Southampton
Papers
Challenging the social reality: the role of social scientistsInês Pereira, Luísa veloso Pedro Abrantes and Susana Henriques University Institute of Lisbon
Autonomousactivist-research:Thecaseofthesquatters’Movement in MadridMiguel Angel Martínez López Universidad Complutense de MadridElísabeth Lorenzi Fernández Ramón Adell Argilés Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia Alexia Rahona Saure Alto Comisionado de las Naciones Unidas para los Refugiados
Participatory methodologies in landscape planning: a dis-cussionbasedontheexperienceofthesancristobal-Ezka-baMountain(navarra)Jesús Oliva and Andoni Iso Public University of Navarra
11
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
WorkshopETHNOGRAPHIC METHODOLOGIESSala de reuniones (First Floor)
November 5 | 14:30 - 16:00
Workshop ChairYves Sintomer Université Paris-8
DiscussantGianpaolo Baiocchi Watson Institute, Brown University
Papers
Evaluating the impact of participatory democracy on ac-tors: the virtue of ethnographic methodsJulien Talpin Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, University Lille 2
Direct observation in participatory processes: effectiveness and validityGianfranco Pomatto University of Turin
Limits and opportunities of the ethnographic methodology inparticipationresearch:threecasestoreflectaboutElísabeth Lorenzi
COLLOQUIUM METHODOLOGICAL CHALLENGES IN PARTICIPATION RESEARCH
12
WorkshopE-pArTIcIpATIon Salón de actos (Ground Floor)
November 5 | 14:30 - 16:00
Workshop ChairAndré BächtigerInstitute of Political Science, University of Bern
DiscussantHenry Milner University of Montreal
Papers
Conceptualizing and measuring participation in the age of the internet: Is online political engagement really different tooffline?rachelGibsonandMartacantijochInstitute for Social Change, University of Manchester validity in online panel research-representativeness andAttrition in the Finnish eOpinion panelKimmo Grönlund and Kim Strandberg Åbo Akademi, Finland
The study of individual participation: how experiments and panel data can help with analysing the effect of Internet useRosa Borge Internet Interdisciplinary Institute, Open University of Catalonia
C/ Campo Santo de los Mártires, 714004 Córdoba-España
Tlf.: 957 760 626 fax.: 957 760 153
www.iesa.csic.es
