BB30055: Genes and genomes Genomes - Dr. MV Hejmadi (bssmvh)
From Genes to Genomes
-
Upload
andres-medrano-rodriguez -
Category
Documents
-
view
237 -
download
0
Transcript of From Genes to Genomes
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 1/14
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD 17
BlackwellScience,Ltd
Pathogen profileSoftrot erwiniae
Soft rot erwiniae: from genes to genomes
IAN K . TOTH*, KENNETH S . BELL , MARIA C . HOLEVA AND PAUL R . J . B IRCH
Plant-Pathogen Interactions Programme, Scottish Crop Research Institute, Invergowrie, Dundee DD2 5DA, UK
SUMMARY
The soft rot erwiniae, Erwinia carotovora
ssp. atroseptica
(
Eca
)
, E.
carotovora
ssp. carotovora
(
Ecc
) and E. chrysanthemi
(
Ech
) are
major bacterial pathogens of potato and other crops world-wide.
We currently understand much about how these bacteria attack
plants and protect themselves against plant defences. However,the processes underlying the establishment of infection, differ-
ences in host range and their ability to survive when not causing
disease, largely remain a mystery. This review will focus on our
current knowledge of pathogenesis in these organisms and dis-
cuss how modern genomic approaches, including complete
genome sequencing of Eca
and Ech
, may open the door to a new
understanding of the potential subtlety and complexity of soft rot
erwiniae and their interactions with plants.
Taxonomy
:
The soft rot erwiniae are members of the Entero-
bacteriaceae
, along with other plant pathogens such as Erwinia
amylovora
and human pathogens such as Escherichia coli
,
Salmonella
spp. and Yersinia
spp. Although the genus name Erwinia
is most often used to describe the group, an alternative genus name
Pectobacterium
was recently proposed for the soft rot species.
Host Range:
Ech
mainly affects crops and other plants in
tropical and subtropical regions and has a wide host range that
includes potato and the important model host African violet
(
Saintpaulia ionantha
). Ecc
affects crops and other plants in sub-
tropical and temperate regions and has probably the widest host
range, which also includes potato. Eca
, on the other hand, has a
host range limited almost exclusively to potato in temperate
regions only.
Disease Symptoms:
Soft rot erwiniae cause general tissue
maceration, termed soft rot disease, through the production of plant cell wall degrading enzymes. Environmental factors such as
temperature, low oxygen concentration and free water play an
essential role in disease development. On potato, and possibly
other plants, disease symptoms may differ, e.g. blackleg disease
is associated more with Eca
and Ech
than with Ecc.
Useful Websites:
http://www.scri.sari.ac.uk/TiPP/Erwinia.htm,
http://www.ahabs.wisc.edu:16080/
∼
pernalab/erwinia/index.htm,
http://www.tigr.org/tdb/mdb/mdbinprogress.html,
http://www.sanger.ac.uk/Projects/E_carotovora/.
INTRODUCTION
The soft rot erwiniae are pathogens of many plant species, affect-ing crops in temperate to tropical regions world-wide. Eca
has a
narrow host range restricted almost exclusively to potato in tem-
perate regions. Ech
is more frequent in subtropical and tropical
climates and has a host range that includes carnation, leopold
lily, maize, pineapple, potato and African violet (
Saintpaulia ion-
antha
), the latter of which has been used extensively as a model
system for research. Ech
also causes disease on certain crops and
other plants in temperate regions, e.g. dahlia and potato. Ecc
mainly affects crops in subtropical and temperate regions and
has probably the widest host range, including Brussels sprout,
carrot, celery, cucumber, capsicum, turnip, chicory and potato.
However, many other crops are rotted by these pathogens post-harvest (for reviews see Pérombelon and Kelman, 1980; Pérom-
belon and Salmond, 1995). Ech
and Ecc
are phenotypically and
genetically more diverse than Eca
and, in some cases, different
groups of Ecc
and Ech
can be related to geographical location
and, in the case of Ech
, host range (Avrova et al
., 2002; Boccara
et al
., 1991; Nassar et al
., 1994a, 1996; Smith and Bartz, 1990;
Toth et al
., 1999a).
When not causing disease, the soft rot erwiniae appear to
undergo endophytic, epiphytic and saprophytic lifestyles in
plants, on plant surfaces and in the soil and ground water, respec-
tively (Pérombelon and Kelman, 1980; Pérombelon and Salmond,
1995). However, little is known about these alternative life-styles.For example, during the period when Erwinia
cells are present in
intercellular spaces within the plant, but before infection is initi-
ated, a period that can last for several months, does the pathogen
lie dormant and unrecognized by the plant or is there a dynamic
process of bacterial cell growth countered by plant defences? Do
the erwiniae attach to plant cells or is infection initiated from
free-living bacteria? Ecc
is virtually ubiquitous in temperate soils,
while Eca
is often difficult to isolate: Does the wider host range
of Ecc
and its greater genetic diversity assist in this survival, and
*Correspondence: E-mail: [email protected]
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 2/14
18
I. K. TOTH et al.
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY
(2003) 4
( 1 ) , 17–30 © 2003 BLACKWELL PUBL ISH ING LTD
is it able to compete better with other micro-organisms through
the production of anti-microbial compounds?
Pathogenicity determinants of these bacteria have been
studied for over 80 years, but in the last 20 years, with the impact
of molecular approaches, significant progress has been made
in understanding disease processes. However, more questions
remain unanswered. For example, what are the early signalling
events between pathogen and plant that allow the disease proc-
ess to begin? Do soft rot erwiniae translocate proteins into plant
cells that interfere with the resistance process (virulence genes)
and are these proteins recognized by non-hosts to trigger the
hypersensitive response (HR), a ubiquitous, localized, pro-
grammed cell death that prevents further spread of the patho-
gen? This article provides an overview of our current knowledge
on soft rot erwinia pathogenicity, but we also look to the future
and genomics, which may provide new insights into our under-
standing of many aspects of the biology of these pathogens.
TAXONOMY
The genus Erwinia
was first described in 1917 to encapsulate all
members of the Enterobacteriaceae
that cause disease on plants,
irrespective of their relatedness to other members of the family
(Pérombelon, 1990). Over the years this has caused many
nomenclatural difficulties and has led to the relocation of various
species into other genera, notably E. stewartii
to Pantoea stew-
artii
(Mergaert et al
., 1993), E. herbicola
to Pantoea agglomerans
(Gavini et al
., 1989), E. dissolvens
to Enterobacter dissolvens
(Brenner et al
., 1986) and E. salicis
to Brenneria salicis
(Hauben
et al
., 1998). It has also been suggested by Hauben et al
. (1998),on the basis of 16S rDNA sequence analysis, that the soft rot
erwinias be renamed Pectobacterium carotovorum
ssp. atrosep-
ticum
(for Eca
), Pectobacterium carotovorum
ssp. carotovorum
(for Ecc
) and Pectobacterium chrysanthemi
(for Ech
), supporting
an earlier proposal by Waldee (1945) to rename the group sim-
ilarly. However, at present ‘
Pectobacterium
’ has not been widely
adopted by the ‘
Erwinia
’ research community.
THE DISEASE PROCESS
The soft rot erwinias are found on plant surfaces and in soil where
they may enter the plant via wound sites or through naturalopenings on the plant surface, e.g. lenticels. Once inside the plant
they reside in the vascular tissue and intercellular spaces of
suberized or thin-walled parenchymatous tissues (as found in
lenticels and wounds) where they remain until environmental
conditions, including free water, oxygen availability and temper-
ature, become suitable for disease development (Pérombelon
and Kelman, 1980; Pérombelon and Salmond, 1995).
Free water is essential for optimal disease development, even
in suitable temperature and oxygen-limiting conditions, and may
have several functions. As motility has been linked to virulence in
Eca
(Mulholland et al
., 1993) and also appears to be co-regulated
with other virulence factors in Eca
and Ech
(Condemine et al
.,
1999; Harris et al
., 1998; Shih et al
., 1999), free water may allow
bacterial cells to move more easily through plant tissue. An
increase in free water may also lead to a decrease in available
oxygen, creating a micro-aerobic or anaerobic environment
within the plant. This has little effect on the pathogen’s ability to
grow, but has a major effect on limiting oxygen-dependent
defences within the plant (Bolwell and Wojtaszek, 1997). It may
also lead to an increase in the turgidity of plant cells, with oxygen
deficiency affecting cell membrane integrity, together leading to
solute leakage and increased susceptibility to decay (Pérombelon
and Lowe, 1975). In addition to free water and oxygen depletion,
temperature is an important factor in disease development, and
can influence which of the soft rot erwiniae cause disease. For
example, Pérombelon et al
. (1987a) showed that a soil temper-
ature of 20°
C was an important transition point, above which Eca
,and below which Ech
, were not apparently pathogenic. The abil-
ities of the soft rot erwiniae to grow at different temperatures is
also clearly demonstrated in vitro
, where it is used to differentiate
the pathogens, i.e. at 27 °
C all three pathogens will grow, at
33.5 °
C only Ecc
and Ech
will grow and at 37 °
C only Ech
will
grow (Pérombelon et al.
, 1987b). However, in addition to differ-
ences in growth, a tight thermal regulation on the production of
cell wall degrading enzymes (exoenzymes) has been demon-
strated (Lanham et al
., 1991; Nguyen et al
., 2002).
The big guns: plant cell wall degrading enzymes
The main weapon in the soft rot erwinia arsenal is the co-
ordinated production of high levels of multiple exoenzymes, includ-
ing pectinases, cellulases and proteases, which break down plant
cell walls and release nutrients for bacterial growth (for reviews
on exoenzymes see Barras et al
., 1994; Pérombelon, 2002; Py
et al
., 1998; Thomson et al
., 1999). Cellulases, which exhibit
mainly endoglucanase activity, break down cellulose in the prim-
ary and secondary cell walls of the host plant. There are at least
two cellulases in both Ech
(CelZ, Y) and Ecc
(CelV, S) and, while
not essential for pathogenicity, they do appear to act in synergy
with other exoenzymes of various classes to attack the plant
(Boccara et al
., 1994; Boyer et al
., 1984, 1987; Mäe et al
., 1995;Saarilahti et al
., 1990; Walker et al
., 1994). Several proteases in
Ech
, and at least one in Ecc
have also been described (Dahler
et al
., 1990; Kyöstiö et al
., 1991). These may act either to provide
amino acids for biosynthesis of microbial proteins or degradation
of host proteins associated with resistance (Heilbronn and Lyon,
1990; Kyöstiö et al
., 1991) but, like cellulases, appear to play only
a minor role in pathogenesis (Marits et al
., 1999).
Pectinases are the main exoenzymes involved in disease devel-
opment. These exoenzymes break down and utilize pectins in the
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 3/14
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 4/14
20 I. K. TOTH et al.
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 ( 1 ) , 17–30 © 2003 BLACKWELL PUBL ISH ING LTD
produce a small diffusible molecule called N-(3-oxohexanoyl)-L-
homoserine lactone (OHHL), which is constitutively expressed by
soft rot erwiniae at low basal levels (Jones et al ., 1993; Pirhonen
et al ., 1991; for reviews see Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat et al .,
1996; Loh et al ., 2002; Miller and Bassler, 2001; Thomson et al .,
1999). As the bacterial population increases within the plant to
reach a high cell density, thought to be around 10 6 cells/mL,
OHHL reaches a critical level within the population, sufficient to
fully activate the genes expR and carR . These transcriptional act-ivators, in turn, induce the production of exoenzymes and the
antibiotic carbapenem, respectively (and likely other pathogeni-
city factors) but also have an auto-inducing effect on the expI
and carI genes themselves, again accelerating the production of
pathogenicity factors (McGowan et al ., 1995; Nasser et al ., 1998;
Reverchon et al ., 1998). Interestingly, OHHL is unstable at low
alkaline pH, which may explain why an early response of plants
to soft rot erwinia attack is to alkalize the site of infection to a
pH of > 8.2 (Byers et al ., 2002).
Secretion
The rapid induction of exoenzymes and other pathogenicity fac-
tors within the bacterial cell is of little consequence unless they
can be efficiently targeted to the extracellular environment. To
accomplish this, soft rot erwiniae have a number of secretion sys-
tems (Types I, II and III) all of which have very different mechan-
isms that appear to be conserved between different bacterial
species both within and outside the Erwinia genus. The Type I sys-
tem secretes protease from the cytoplasm to the extracellularspace in a single step but, while this system has been studied in
detail in Ech , it appears to have a relatively minor role in patho-
genicity (Dahler et al ., 1990; Delepelaire and Wandersman, 1990;
Létoffé et al ., 1990). The Type II system, on the other hand, is
essential for pathogenicity and secretes pathogenicity deter-
minants such as pectinases and cellulases in a two-step mechanism.
The first step is a sec -dependent protein export system that
exports proteins to the periplasm. The second step, controlled by
a 15 gene out cluster, includes the formation of a structure that
Fig. 1 (a) Comparison of healthy potato plant (left) and plant infected with Erwinia carotovora ssp. atroseptica (right) showing severe wilting and stem rot due to
blackleg disease (see base of stem). (b) African violet (Saintpaulia ionantha ) leaf infected with Erwinia chrysanthemi . (c) Growth of soft rot erwinia on crystal violet
pectate (CVP) medium showing characteristic cavities formed by the production of exoenzymes. (d) In planta virulence screening assay by stab inoculation of Erwinia
carotovora subsp. atroseptica into potato stems showing increasing severity from left to right.
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 5/14
Soft rot erwiniae 21
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
spans the periplasmic compartment and outer membrane and
channels proteins, recognized by a signal sequence, to the out-
side of the cell. The system has been studied extensively in Ecc
and Ech and is present in Eca (Andro et al ., 1984; Ji et al ., 1987;
Murata et al ., 1990; Thurn and Chatterjee, 1985; for reviews see
Russel, 1998; Sandkvist, 2001; Thomson et al ., 1999). However,
despite a high level of interspecies amino acid identity within
the soft rot erwiniae, out genes from Ecc do not complement
mutations in equivalent genes in Ech and vice versa , suggesting
a degree of species-specificity (Py et al ., 1991). Regulation of the
Type II system is, at least in part, under the control of KdgR and
may also operate under a quorum-sensing mechanism (Condemine
and Robert-Baudouy, 1995; Condemine et al ., 1992).
The Type III secretion system—an indicator of subtlety?
The Type III secretion system (TTSS) in the soft rot erwiniae is not
involved in the secretion of exoenzymes but it may still play a cru-cial role in the plant interaction and, as such, is currently under
intense scrutiny within the research community (for reviews see
Collmer and Beer, 1998; Galan and Collmer, 1999; Hueck, 1998;
Mudgett and Staskawicz, 1998). The TTSS in Gram-negative bac-
teria, often referred to as the hrp (hypersensitive response and
pathogenicity) system in phytopathogens, translocates ‘effector’
proteins into host plant cells to assist in bacterial virulence and
can elicit an HR on non-host plants (Lahaye and Bonas, 2001).
However, little is known about the role of these effectors once
inside the plant cell.
E. amylovora (Ea ) has the best characterized TTSS in the
Erwinia genus, and mutations in the Ea hrp cluster lead toreduced virulence and loss of HR (Barny et al ., 1990; Collmer and
Beer, 1998; Eastgate, 2000). An Ea Type III secretion effector
(TTSE), HrpN (harpin), when expressed in E. coli , and purified also
elicits an HR (Wei et al ., 1992). However, when the hrpN gene is
mutated in different Ea strains, different virulence and HR pheno-
types are seen, suggesting a degree of strain-specificity (Barny
et al., 1995; Wei et al ., 1992). The Ea hrp cluster also includes a
second HR-inducing TTSE gene, hrpW, with an accompanying
chaperone (Gaudriault et al ., 1998; Kim and Beer, 1998), and
adjacent to the cluster is the disease specific operon dspEF (dspAB ).
DspE is also secreted by the Hrp system (with DspF acting as its
chaperone) and is required for pathogenicity but not the HR(Bogdanove et al ., 1998a,b; Gaudriault et al ., 1997). DspE belongs
to the AvrRxb/YopJ family of TTSEs, which are thought to act as
transcriptional regulators that repress the host defence response
(Lahaye and Bonas, 2001).
Hrp gene clusters have been identified in Ech (Ham et al .,
1998), Ecc (Rantakari et al ., 2001) and Eca (Bell et al ., 2002) but
their structural organization differs. In Ech , the hrpN and hrpC
operons are flanked by hecAB and plcA whilst the TTSEs hrpW
and dspE and their chaperones are not found at this locus (Kim
and Beer, 1998; Kim et al., 1998). In contrast, the organization in
Eca is more similar to that in Ea : plcA is not found at this locus,
hrpW is present (with chaperone) and dspEF are also present
adjacent to the hrp cluster. Eca does however, have hecAB genes
similar to those of Ech , outside the hrp cluster (next to dspEF )
(Bell et al ., 2002) and these have not been reported in Ea . The
ability of the TTSS in Ech to deliver TTSEs has been demon-
strated using the Hrp-dependent avirulence protein AvrB from
P. syringae (Ham et al ., 1998). Additionally, in Ech, the use of a
multiple pel – mutant (pelABCE –), deficient in exoenzyme action,
elicits an HR on tobacco, hrpN –/pelABCE – double mutants do not,
while a single Ech hrpN – mutant shows reduced virulence on
chicory (Bauer et al ., 1994; Bauer et al ., 1995). Recent studies with
improved bioassays, including a lower bacterial inoculum and
a number of susceptible varieties of African violet, have added
further weight to the perceived importance of the hrp cluster in
Ech pathogenesis (Yang et al ., 2002). Mutants in hrpG and hrcC
are greatly reduced in virulence on certain cultivars but producesignificant disease on others and are indistinguishable from the
wild-type on potato tubers. A hrpN mutant shows delayed symp-
toms on Africa violet but when deleted in five major pel genes is
non-pathogenic, suggesting that the presence of pectic enzymes
may be sufficient to mask the effects of some mutations. On
tobacco, hrpG and hrcC mutants do not produce an HR, while a
hrpN mutant gives a reduced HR (Yang et al ., 2002). Unlike Ech ,
Ecc does not normally elicit an HR on tobacco but it can do so
when HrpN production is de-repressed (Cui et al ., 1996). How-
ever, hrpN – mutants retain their wild-type ability to macerate
celery petioles (Mukherjee et al ., 1997). Nevertheless, a role for
the TTSS in Ecc pathogenicity is proposed by Rantakari et al .(2001) who found that Ecc growth during the early stages of
infection of Arabidopsis is reduced in a hrcC – mutant, although
the mechanism and the effector protein(s) have yet to be
determined. The role of the Eca hrp cluster in either pathogenicity
or HR has not yet been determined but, together with further
work on Ech and Ecc , is likely to be the focus of detailed study in
the coming years.
Iron acquisition and protection from plant defences
Another process that is crucial for pathogenesis is iron uptake,
which was first linked to pathogenicity in Ech through the iso-lation of cell surface mutants (Expert and Toussaint, 1985; for
review see Expert, 1999). Ech produces the siderophores chryso-
bactin and achromobactin in order to acquire iron from the iron-
poor environment of the plant apoplast. Mutants defective in
chrysobactin-mediated iron transport remain localized within
African violet leaves, suggesting a role in bacterial spread
throughout the plant (Enard et al ., 1988). Mutants deficient in
the biosynthesis of achromobactin, however, fail to spread from
the site of inoculation altogether, and could be involved at the
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 6/14
22 I. K. TOTH et al.
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 ( 1 ) , 17–30 © 2003 BLACKWELL PUBL ISH ING LTD
very onset of infection (Enard and Expert, pers. comm.). In Ech a
number of pectate lyase genes are also regulated by iron, adding
to the complexity of exoenzyme production and also clearly demon-
strating the precision with which these pathogens initiate dis-
ease (Sauvage and Expert, 1994). Ecc produces both chrysobactin
and aerobactin but no role in disease development has yet been
demonstrated for either siderophore (Bull et al ., 1996; Franza
et al ., 1991; Ishimaru and Loper, 1992), and in Eca , novel sequences
similar to genes involved in iron acquisition have been identified
and are currently under investigation (Bell et al., unpublished data).
Although soft rot generally occurs in anaerobic conditions
when the host response is impaired (Pérombelon and Kelman,
1980), the oxidative burst is an important form of host defence
against the soft rot erwiniae (Bolwell and Wojtaszek, 1997). Sev-
eral virulence-associated genes have been identified that protect
against damage by this mechanism, including some that utilize
iron. For example, the suf operon in Ech is thought to be involved
in incorporating iron into antioxidant defence in the form of Fe-Sclusters, and mutants in genes from this operon show an
increased susceptibility to oxidative stress and reduced viru-
lence (Nachin et al ., 2001). Similarly, the iron-containing flavo-
haemoprotein HmpX, mutants of which show reduced virulence,
may defend against reactive oxygen damage and is also required
for Pel synthesis in microaerobic conditions (Favey et al ., 1995).
Other genes in Ech involved in defence against the oxidative
burst include sodA (superoxide dismutase), which may negate
the effects of superoxide anions (O2– ) by their conversion to H2O2
(Santos et al ., 2001), msrA (methionine sulphoxide reductase),
which encodes a protein that repairs oxidized proteins (El Hassouni
et al ., 1999), and ind genes that, in some Ech strains, encodethe production of the blue pigment indigoidine that also confers
increased resistance to oxidative stress (Reverchon et al ., 2002).
In all cases, mutations in these genes reduce virulence.
In addition to oxidative stress, plants produce antimicrobial
peptides, and the sap operon (sensitivity to antimicrobial peptides)
in Ech, homologous to a similar system in Salmonella typhimurium,
defends against such peptides. SapA, a periplasmic component of
the system, binds the antimicrobial peptide and transports it to
the cytoplasm, where it is degraded. A mutation in sapA shows
reduced virulence on a level similar to that observed in a pel –/
hrp – double mutant (Lopez-Solanilla et al ., 1998, 2001).
THE BACTERIAL CELL SURFACE
The bacterial cell surface is the first line of defence against any
attempt by the host to prevent infection, and it is therefore not
surprising that some genes required for full pathogenicity were
first identified as cell surface mutants. For example, the siderophore-
dependant iron assimilation system in Ech was revealed by ana-
lysis of mutants with defective cell surface composition (Expert
and Toussaint, 1985) (see above). An rffG - mutant in Eca , isolated
on the basis of altered phage resistance and reduced virulence,
has a pleiotropic phenotype, including cell surface defects. It
shows alterations in the synthesis of enterobacterial common
antigen, outer membrane proteins, lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and
flagella, as well as reduced enzyme production, lack of motility
and an increased sensitivity to surface-active agents (Toth et al .,
1999b). Other phage resistant mutants of Ech show a structural
change to the LPS core region, are reduced in virulence but unaf-
fected in exoenzyme production and other phenotypes (Schoonejans
et al ., 1987). The eps genes of Ech , which are required for the
synthesis of extracellular polysaccharide (EPS), and apparently
involved in LPS synthesis, are also required for full virulence.
These genes are directly linked to exoenzyme production and are
under the control of the exoenzyme repressor PecT (Condemine
et al ., 1999). Although no precise roles for the above mutations
or the cell surface components they synthesize have yet been
determined, they may be involved in protection against host
defences or attachment to host cells (see below).Osmoregulated periplasmic glucans (OPGs), which are cell
envelope components of all Gram-negative bacteria, are also
essential for the in planta growth of Ech (Page et al ., 2001).
Mutants in two OPG synthesis genes (opgGH ) lack OPG and are
completely non-virulent. Like rffG and eps, they show a pleio-
tropic phenotype, in this case exhibiting reduced exoenzyme syn-
thesis, excess exopolysaccharide synthesis and reduced motility,
and while reduced exoenzyme synthesis is expected to contribute
to loss of virulence, co-inoculation experiments with mutant and
wild-type strains have shown that the OPGs themselves are
essential for growth in planta .
The importance of the cell surface in attachment of the soft roterwiniae to host plant cells during pathogenesis is not clear, yet
in other enterobacterial pathogens this process is essential for
successful infection (Cao et al ., 2001). In Ech the outer mem-
brane protein intimin, which is also found in E. coli , allows Ech to
bind to animal cells (Duarte et al ., 2000) but any role for intimin
in binding to plant cells during infection has yet to be determined.
The strongest evidence for attachment comes from Wallace and
Pérombelon (1992), who showed that Ecc cell binding to potato
leaf surfaces is reduced by treatment with a haemagglutinin
inhibitor, suggesting a role for haemagglutinins in such binding.
A region of the Eca genome containing sequences similar to hae-
magglutinin or adhesin-like genes in various animal and plantpathogens has recently been identified (Bell et al ., 2002) and two
genes of this sort have also been found in Ech , although their role
in binding has not yet been established (Kim et al ., 1998).
Competition in the disease environment
With successful release of nutrients during infection comes
competition and scavenging from other opportunistic micro-
organisms and, indeed, other pectolytic and non-pectolytic bacteria
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 7/14
Soft rot erwiniae 23
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
are often isolated from diseased plant tissues (Pérombelon and
Salmond, 1995). The soft rot erwiniae may compete with these
bacteria by producing antibiotics. For example, some strains of
Ecc produce carbepenem (Parker et al ., 1982), an antibiotic that is
co-regulated with pathogenicity factors (including exoenzymes)
through quorum sensing (see above). In this way, during expon-
ential growth within the plant prior to disease initiation, the
rapid onset of exoenzyme production is accompanied by anti-
biotic production (Byers et al ., 2002; McGowan et al ., 1995), which
may prevent other bacteria profiting from the nutrients released.
The pab gene in Ech may also be involved in antibiotic biosynthesis,
with the gene contiguous to it ( ybiT ) appearing to encode an
ABC transporter involved in antibiotic resistance to this or other
antibiotics. When tested in potato tubers or chicory leaves , ybiT
mutants retain full virulence but, in the presence of the wild-type
strain or selected saprophytic bacteria, show a reduced ability to
compete (Llama-Palacios et al ., 2002).
GENE EXPRESSION DURING PLANT–ERWINIA
INTERACTIONS
Interactions between plants and pathogens involve complex recogni-
tion events that lead to signalling cascades and the regulation
of numerous genes that are required for the interaction. Recent
years have seen the development of new technologies for invest-
igating changes in gene expression during infection (Birch and
Kamoun, 2000), and several of these have been applied to gain
an insight into host defence responses to Eca and Ecc and into
changes in gene expression in Ech .
The plant response
Many exoenzymes produced by the soft rot erwiniae trigger plant
defences, probably through the release of elicitor-active cell wall
fragments (Davis et al ., 1984; Palva et al ., 1993). Indeed, E. caro-
tovora culture filtrates containing these enzymes, and oligogalac-
turonides (OGAs) derived from enzymatic breakdown of pectin,
up-regulate a variety of defence genes in the non-host plant Ara-
bidopsis thaliana (Norman et al ., 1999; Norman-Setterblad et al .,
2000; Vidal et al ., 1997, 1998). More recently, a technique called
suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) has been used to
generate a cDNA library enriched for sequences up-regulated1 h after infiltration of potato leaves with Eca (Dellagi et al .,
2000a,b). Amongst the sequences recovered was a potato gene
encoding a WRKY DNA binding protein that was shown to be up-
regulated by culture filtrate from sonicated, recombinant E. coli
containing either pelB or pelD , again associating plant defence
responses with cell wall elicitor activity (Dellagi et al ., 2000b). In
an independent study, Ecc and OGAs were both shown to up-
regulate novel receptor-like protein kinase genes in potato that
were again isolated using SSH (Montesano et al ., 2001).
Recent work by Asai et al . (2002) describes a signalling cascade
involved in innate immunity in Arabidopsis, which may explain
the role of the above induced plant factors in resistance to the soft
rot erwiniae. The innate immune system, a first line of defence against
infectious disease, functions to detect pathogen-associated
molecular patterns (PAMPs). For example, flagellin represents a
PAMP in bacterial pathogens of both animals and plants (and is
conserved in soft rot erwiniae). In plants, a receptor-like kinase,
FLS2, mediates the innate immune response to flagellin (Gomez-
Gomez and Boller, 2002) and, following recognition of flagellin
by FLS2, the plant response is mediated by a MAP kinase signal-
ling cascade and WRKY22/29 transcription factors. Constitutive
activation of this pathway provides resistance to pathogens (Asai
et al ., 2002) and it is likely that additional PAMPs (or other pathogen-
derived signals) may converge into a conserved MAP kinase
signalling cascade. Additional PAMPs could, for example, include
OGAs as these are products of pectin breakdown generated by
plant pathogens. The WRKY transcription factor and receptor-likekinases up-regulated by soft rot erwiniae (see above) may thus be
components of an innate immune response to OGAs in potato; an
area currently under investigation (P. Birch, pers. comm.).
Gene expression in the pathogens
While in vitro studies have proved invaluable for identifying patho-
genicity determinants and their regulators, more subtle inter-
actions may be missed in the absence of direct contact with
the plant or plant material. To address this, Beaulieu and Van
Gijsegem (1990) studied gene expression in Ech in the presence
of plant extract using a promotorless antibiotic resistance gene inphage Mu. Some mutants were found to be affected in pectate
lyase (pelA) production, iron assimilation and galacturonate
catabolism, the importance of the latter only coming to light
through this approach (Beaulieu and Van Gijsegem, 1990). In an
attempt to determine whether plant induction was host specific,
Beaulieu and Van Gijsegem (1992) then tested these and other
reduced virulence mutants on other plant species. While most
plant-inducible mutants showed similar reductions in virulence
on all plants tested, some differences were observed, e.g. one
mutant was virulent on pea plantlets but exhibited reduced virul-
ence on African violet and Witloof chicory leaves. More recently, a
number of studies have shown the induction of secondary pectatelyases following in-planta gene expression (Beaulieu et al ., 1993;
Kelemu and Collmer, 1993—see above). However, while the above
approaches have proved effective in identifying novel genes inducible
by plant extract, they still fall short of a true interaction with the
living host since, for example, active plant regulatory and bio-
chemical processes are essential for events such as HR elicitation
by HrpNEa (He et al ., 1994). With this in mind, novel technologies
for profiling differential gene expression in soft-rot erwiniae at
different stages of infection are being developed or adopted.
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 8/14
24 I. K. TOTH et al.
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 ( 1 ) , 17–30 © 2003 BLACKWELL PUBL ISH ING LTD
Isolation of differentially expressed genes from both host and
pathogen during their interaction is dependent on the method of
cDNA synthesis. Studies in ‘Plant Response’ (see above) use an
oligo-dT primer to synthesize cDNA, which anneals to the poly A
tail at the 3′ end of eukaryotic mRNAs. Prokaryotic mRNAs lack
3′ poly A tails, and thus bacterial cDNA cannot be synthesized
by this method. However, using a mixture of 11-mer primers
designed to anneal to conserved regions in the 3 ′ ends of entero-
bacterial genes, representative cDNAs were synthesized from Eca
and Ecc and differential gene expression was profiled using
cDNA-amplified fragment length polymorphism (cDNA-AFLP)
(Dellagi et al ., 2000c). This approach offers the potential to dis-
tinguish differentially expressed bacterial and plant genes during
Erwinia –plant interactions by using different strategies for cDNA
synthesis. The two cDNA populations may then be compared
using cDNA-AFLP profiling.
DNA microarray technology has recently been applied to study
differential gene expression in Ech during its interaction withAfrican violet (Okinaka et al ., 2002). An array consisting of
≈ 5000 randomly selected 2.5–3.5 kb genomic clones was
synthesized and screened with cDNAs produced from cultured
bacterial cells and from infected plant tissue. Clones containing
differentially expressed genes were sequenced, and those found
to be up-regulated in planta included genes encoding virulence
factors, iron scavengers, transporters and proteins involved in
protection from plant response mechanisms, as well as a number
of novel genes as yet unpublished. It was found that many of
these differentially expressed genes did not appear to directly
damage the host, but might aid survival in planta . Even with
these approaches, however, studying the plant–Erwinia inter-action transcriptome has involved challenging the plant with large
inoculum levels of the pathogen. Under these conditions, pathogen
levels may be above those required for the activation of exoenzyme
production through quorum sensing or other regulation mecha-
nisms. As a consequence, the early more subtle interactions may
be missed. The effect of reducing quantities of inoculum, in which
exoenzymes are at a basal level of production, more in keeping
with the early stages of natural infection, has yet to be studied.
It will be interesting to see in the coming years whether microar-
rays and PCR-based technologies such as SSH and cDNA-AFLP
are sensitive enough to detect changes in both host and pathogen
gene expression during the natural onset of infection.
GENOMICS
Genome sequencing and comparative genomics
Whole genome sequencing has already profoundly influenced
the direction of research for a number of microbes, and Erwinia
will be no exception. Genome sequencing projects have been
initiated recently for both Eca strain SCRI1043 (http://
www.scri.sari.ac.uk/TiPP/Erwinia.htm; http://www.sanger.ac.uk/
Projects/E_carotovora/) and Ech strain 3937 (http://
www.ahabs.wisc.edu:16080/∼pernalab/erwinia/index.htm; http://
www.tigr.org/tdb/mdb/mdbinprogress.html). In both cases, high
throughput sequencing of random small insert clones has been
completed (to approximately eightfold genome coverage) and is
being followed by assembly and gap closure by directed sequen-
cing. Preliminary analysis of random shotgun sequence data sug-
gests that both genomes are approximately 5 Mb (Julian Parkhill
and Nicole Perna, pers. comms.). The complete sequences of both
genomes are due for release in 2003. They will serve as blueprints
for future research into all aspects of these pathogens’ biology,
particularly in the search for effectors and elicitors involved in
pathogenicity and host-specificity.
As a prelude to the complete sequencing of Eca and Ech, par-
tial (sample) sequencing of both genomes was undertaken. Bell
et al . (2002) targeted a selected region of the Eca genome. Two
large overlapping fragments of cloned genomic DNA (spanning≈ 200 kb) from a Bacterial Artificial Chromosome (BAC) library
were partially sequenced to reveal the same complement of 28
hrp genes as found in Ea (see above). In addition, sequences
flanking the hrp cluster included orthologues of known or put-
ative pathogenicity operons from other Erwinia species, such as
dspAB (Ea ), hecAB and pecSM (E. chrysanthemi ), sequences sim-
ilar to X. fastidiosa haemagglutinin-like genes, and sequences
similar to rhizobacterial opine catabolism genes. BAC end
sequences from other loci around the Eca genome showed simi-
larity to more genes of interest, including those involved in iron
acquisition and phytotoxin synthesis in Pseudomonas spp. (Bell
et al., unpublished data). In Ech , a random sample of 1777genomic sequences revealed genes encoding exoenzymes, regu-
latory and Hrp proteins. However, it also revealed sequences
similar to genes involved in the synthesis of phytohormones and
phytotoxins, and in opine catabolism (N. Perna and F. Blattner, pers.
comm.). Only 61% of the Ech sequences showed a strong degree
of similarity to E. coli , suggesting that as much as 2.0 Mb of the
genome might carry genes specific to its plant pathogenic life-style.
Both of these limited sequencing efforts imply that Eca and Ech may
have hitherto unsuspected traits that could be relevant to disease,
and indeed to life in the absence of disease, and it will be
interesting to see what emerges from whole genome sequencing.
The availability of two complete soft rot erwinia genomesequences will allow a thorough comparison of their many
shared genes. For example, it is clear that there are similarities
in the genes that encode, regulate and facilitate the export of
exoenzymes (see above). However this comparison will also
reveal genetic differences between the species in terms of exo-
enzymes, Type III effectors and other pathogenicity factors. This will
be invaluable in understanding their biology more fully, including
the molecular bases for differences in host-range and disease
symptoms. Comparisons of the soft rot erwiniae genomes with
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 9/14
Soft rot erwiniae 25
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
those of other enterobacterial pathogens (e.g. Blattner et al .,
1997; McClelland et al ., 2001; Parkhill et al ., 2001a,b) will shed
light on the evolution of this bacterial family. The picture currently
emerging is of a shared enterobacterial chromosomal ‘backbone’
derived from a common ancestor but with extensive horizontal
gene transfer (that may confer novel traits upon the recipients),
as well as gene loss by deletion or decay into non-functional
pseudogenes (that may reflect changes in the life-style of the
bacteria, such as restricting host range) (Parkhill et al ., 2001a,b;
Perna et al ., 2001a,b). The availability of an increasing number of
annotated and relatively well-characterized enterobacterial
genomes should allow these similarities and differences to be
defined and functions readily assigned to many of the genes
in the soft rot erwiniae genomes. Many common features are
shared between plant and animal pathogens, e.g. regulatory
genes, secretion systems, attachment mechanisms and defences
from host oxidative bursts (Cao et al ., 2001), and comparative
genomics will help to elucidate the functions of such genes in thesoft rot erwiniae. Besides those genes involved in pathogenesis,
new insights into nutrient utilization, possible starvation mechan-
isms and other environment-associated processes may also be
revealed. On the other hand, genes found in the soft rot erwiniae
but not in other enterobacteria (many of which are animal path-
ogens) may be involved in plant pathogenesis or other plant-
associated life-style, especially where similar genes are found in
other plant-associated bacteria.
Several complete plant pathogen and plant symbiont genome
sequences have already been published (da Silva et al ., 2002;
Galibert et al ., 2001; Goodner et al ., 2001; Kaneko et al ., 2000;
Salanoubat et al ., 2002; Simpson et al ., 2000; Wood et al ., 2001)and several more are well advanced <http://www.tigr.org/tdb/
mdb/mdbinprogress.html>. This has lead to the identification of
many candidate pathogenicity determinants in both poorly and
well-studied phytopathogens. Searching soft rot erwiniae
genome sequences for homologies to known pathogenicity
genes and the use of bioinformatic approaches to identify con-
served regulatory motifs may identify novel targets for research,
i.e. in the latter case leading to the identification of pathogenicity
‘regulons’ under common transcriptional control (Collmer et al .,
2001; Salanoubat et al ., 2002). For example, as soft rot erwiniae
are known to possess both kdgR and hrp box promoter
sequences (Liu et al ., 1999; Rantakari et al ., 2001; Reverchonet al ., 1989), complete genome sequences should reveal all
genes that possess these promoter motifs and perhaps identify
novel conserved motifs, helping to unravel the complex cascades
that lead to disease development and host resistance.
Functional genomics
With a complete genome sequence, various high throughput
approaches are available to investigate gene function. DNA
microarrays will allow us to measure temporal changes in the
expression of all genes during adaptations to, for example, phys-
iological conditions (including anaerobiosis and responses to
other environmental stresses), pathogenesis (including the differ-
ent stages of disease processes on different hosts) or different
life-styles (including saprophytic, epiphytic and endophytic). This
approach has already proved valuable for Ech (see above) despite
the lack of a complete and defined gene set for the array (Okinaka
et al ., 2002). Where changes under the conditions described are at
the translational, rather than transcriptional level (e.g. temperature),
parallel analyses of the proteome can be made. Moreover, pro-
teomics is a way to unequivocally identify membrane-associated
or secreted proteins, which are most likely to interact with the plant.
Following the identification of candidate genes, good systems
for gene ‘knock-out’ are essential to further investigate their func-
tion. The soft rot erwiniae are well suited to such functional studies
due to their genetic amenability (Thomson et al ., 1999) and, to
facilitate functional genomic studies in Eca , a pooled ‘mutationgrid’ has been constructed (Bell et al., unpublished data), allow-
ing rapid PCR screening for mutations in any given gene. In this
way, and with appropriate bioassays, numerous gene targets
derived from the above approaches may be assessed.
CONCLUSIONS
For over 20 years the use of molecular biology has led to signi-
ficant advances in our understanding of pathogenicity in the soft
rot erwiniae. The large-scale coordinated production and target-
ing of exoenzymes clearly has a major impact on disease devel-
opment. However, as we investigate further, other more subtlemolecular processes are implicated in interactions with the plant,
including cell-to-cell attachment, defence against plant re-
sponses and the possibility of protein delivery directly into the
host cell through a Type III secretion system. The soft rot erwiniae
are now entering the genomics era and we will soon have the full
catalogue of genes that these organisms possess. This informa-
tion, together with new methods for analysing gene expression
in planta , the analysis and comparison of whole genome
sequences, and novel approaches to high throughput gene func-
tional analyses, is certain to reveal more of the biology of these
pathogens, their survival in the environment, and the nature of
their interactions with both host and non-host plants.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Following the sad death of Prof. Noel Keen we would like to
dedicate this review to him for his drive and enthusiasm in
obtaining funds for the E. chrysanthemi genome sequencing
project and for many unparalleled years of creative thought and
quality scientific achievements in the field of plant–pathogen
interactions. We would like to thank SEERAD for their financial
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 10/14
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 11/14
Soft rot erwiniae 27
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
mutants deficient in oligogalacturonide lyase. Proc . Natl Acad . Sci . USA,
78, 3920–3924.
Collmer, A. and Beer, S.V. (1998) hrp genes and their function. Meth .
Microbiol . 27, 139–148.
Condemine, G., Castillo, A., Passeri, F. and Enard, C. (1999) The PecT
repressor co-regulates synthesis of exopolysaccharides and virulence fac-
tors in Erwinia chrysanthemi . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 12, 45–52.Condemine, G., Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N. and Robert-Baugouy, J.
(1986) Isolation of Erwinia chrysanthemi kduD mutants altered in pectin
degradation. J . Bacteriol . 165, 937–941.
Condemine, G., Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N. and Robert-Baugouy, J.
(1992) Some of the out genes involved in secretion of pectate lyases in
Erwinia chrysanthemi are regulated by KdgR . Mol . Microbiol . 6, 3199–
3211.
Condemine, G. and Robert-Baudouy, J. (1987) Tn5 insertion in kdgR ,
a regulatory gene of the polygalacturonate pathway in Erwinia chry -
santhemi . FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 42, 39–46.
Condemine, G. and Robert-Baudouy, J. (1995) Synthesis and secretion
of Erwinia chrysanthemi virulence factors are coregulated. Mol . Plant-
Microbe Interact . 8, 632–636.
Cui, Y., Chatterjee, A. and Chatterjee, A.K. (2001) Effects of the two-
component system comprising GacA and GacS of Erwinia carotovora subsp.
carotovora on the production of global regulatory rsmB RNA, extracellular
enzymes and harpin(Ecc). Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 14, 516–526.
Cui, Y., Madi, L., Mukherjee, A., Dumenyo, C.K. and Chatterjee, A.K.
(1996) The RsmA(-) mutants of Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora
strain Ecc71 overexpress hrpN (Ecc ) and elicit a hypersensitive reaction-
like response in tobacco leaves. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 9, 565–573.
Dahler, G.S., Barras, F. and Keen, N.T. (1990) Cloning of genes encoding
metaloproteases from Erwinia chrysanthemi EC16. J . Bacteriol . 172,
5803–5815.
Davis, K.R., Lyon, G.D., Darvill, A.G. and Albersheim, P. (1984) Host–
pathogen interactions XXV. Endopolygalacturonic acid lyase from
Erwinia carotovora elicits phytoalexin accumulation by releasing plantcell wall fragments. Plant Physiol . 74, 52–60.
Delepelaire, P. and Wandersman, C. (1990) Protein secretion in Gram-
negative bacteria—the extracellular metalloprotease B from Erwinia
chrysanthemi contains a C-terminal secretion signal analogous to that of
Escherichia coli alpha hemolysin. J . Biol . Chem . 265, 17118–17125.
Dellagi, A., Birch, P.R.J., Heilbronn, J., Avrova, A.O., Montesano, M.
and Lyon, G.D. (2000a) A potato gene, erg-1, is rapidly induced by
Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica, Phytophthora infestans, ethylene,
and salicylic acid. J . Plant Physiol . 157, 201–205.
Dellagi, A., Birch, P.R.J., Heilbronn, J., Lyon, G.D. and Toth, I.K. (2000c)
cDNA-AFLP analysis of differential gene expression in the bacterial plant
pathogen Erwinia carotovora . Microbiology 146, 165–171.
Dellagi, A., Heilbronn, J., Avrova, A.O., Montesano, M., Stewart, H.E.,
Toth, I.K., Cooke, D.E.L., Lyon, G.D. and Birch, P.R.J. (2000b) A potato
gene encoding a WRKY-like transcription factor is induced in susceptible
interactions with Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica and Phyto -
phthora infestans and is co-regulated with class I endo-chitinase
expression. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 13, 1092–1101.
Duarte, X., Anderson, C.T., Grimson, M., Barabote, R.D., Strauss, R.E.,
Gollahon, L.S. and San Fransisco, M.J.D. (2000) Erwinia chrysanthemi
strains cause death of human gastrointestinal cells in culture and express
an intimin-like protein. FEMS Microbiol . Lett . 190, 81–86.
Eastgate, J.A. (2000) Erwinia amylovora : the molecular basis of fireblight
disease. Mol . Plant Pathol . 1, 325–329.
El Hassouni, M., Chambost, J.P., Expert, D., van Gijsegem, F. and Barras, F.
(1999) The minimal gene set member msrA, encoding peptide methio-
nine sulfoxide reductase, is a virulence determinant of the plant patho-
gen Erwinia chrysanthemi . Proc . Natl Acad . Sci . USA, 96, 887–892.
Enard, C., Diolez, A. and Expert, D. (1988) Systemic virulence of Erwinia
chrysanthemi 3937 requires a functional iron assimilation system. J . Bac-
teriol . 170, 2419–2426.Expert, D. (1999) Withholding and exchanging iron: interactions between
Erwinia spp. and their p lant hosts. Ann . Rev . Phytopathol . 37, 307–334.
Expert, D. and Toussaint, A. (1985) Bacteriocin resistant mutants of
Erwinia chrysanthemi possible involvement of iron acquisition in phyto-
pathogenicity. J . Bacteriol . 163, 221–227.
Favey, S., Labesse, G., Vouille, V. and Boccara, M. (1995) Flavohaemo-
globin hmpX —a new pathogenicity determinant in Erwinia chrysan-
themi strain 3937. Microbiology 141, 863–871.
Franza, T., Enard, C., van Gijsegem, F. and Expert, D. (1991) Genetic
analysis of the Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937 chrysobactin iron transport
system—characterisation of a gene cluster involved in uptake and bio-
synthetic pathways. Mol . Microbiol . 5, 1319–1329.
Galan, J.E. and Collmer, A. (1999) Type III secretion machines: Bacterial
devices for protein delivery into host cells. Science , 284, 1322–1328.
Galibert, F., Finan, T.M., Long, S.R., and 53 other authors (2001) The
composite genome of the legume symbiont Sinorhizobium meliloti . Sci-
ence , 293, 668–672.
Gaudriault, S., Brisset, M.N. and Barny, M.A. (1998) HrpW of Erwinia
amylovora , a new Hrp-secreted protein. FEBS Lett . 428, 224–228.
Gaudriault, S., Malandrin, L., Paulin, J.P. and Barny, M.A. (1997) DspA,
an essential pathogenicity factor of Erwinia amylovora showing homo-
logy with AvrE of Pseudomonas syringae , is secreted via the Hrp secretion
pathway in a DspB-dependent way. Mol . Microbiol . 26, 1057–1069.
Gavini, F., Mergaert, J., Beji, A., Mielcarek, C., Izard, D., Kersters, K.
and Deley, J. (1989) Transfer of Enterobacter agglomerans (Beijerinck,
1888) Ewing and Fife 1972 to Pantoea gen-nov as Pantoea agglomerans
comb. nov. and description of Pantoea dispersa sp. nov. Int . J . Syst . Bac- teriol . 39, 337–345.
van Gijsegem, F. (1989) Relationship between the pel genes of the pelADE
cluster in Erwinia chrysanthemi strain B374. Mol . Microbiol . 3, 1415–
1424.
Gomez-Gomez, L. and Boller, T. (2002) Flagellin perception: a paradigm
for innate immunity. Trends Plant Sci . 7, 251–256.
Goodner, B., Hinkle, G., Gattung, S. and 28 other authors (2001)
Genome sequence of the plant pathogen and biotechnology agent Agro-
bacterium tumefaciens C58. Science , 294, 2323–2328.
Ham, J.H., Bauer, D.W., Fouts, D.E. and Collmer, A. (1998) A cloned
Erwinia chrysanthemi Hrp (type III protein secretion) system functions in
Escherichia coli to deliver Pseudomonas syringae Avr signals to plant
cells and to secrete Avr proteins in culture. Proc . Natl Acad . Sci . USA, 95,
10206–10211.
Harris, S.J., Shih, Y.L., Bentley, S.D. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1998) The
hexA gene of Erwinia carotovora encodes a LysR homologue and regu-
lates motility and the expression of multiple virulence determinants. Mol .
Microbiol . 28, 705–717.
Hauben, L., Moore, E.R., Vauterin, L., Steenackers, M., Mergaert, J.,
Verdonck, L. and Swings, J. (1998) Phylogenetic position of phytopathogens
within the Enterobacteriaceae . Syst . Appl . Microbiol . 21, 384–397.
He, S.Y., Bauer, D.W., Collmer, A. and Beer, S.V. (1994) Hypersensitive
response elicited by Erwinia amylovora harpin requires active plant
metabolism. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 7, 289–292.
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 12/14
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 13/14
Soft rot erwiniae 29
© 2003 BLACKWELL PUBLISHING LTD MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 (1 ) , 17–30
Mudgett, M.B. and Staskawicz, B.J. (1998) Protein signalling via type III
secretion pathways in phytopathogenic bacteria. Curr . Opin . Microbiol .
1, 109–115.
Mukherjee, A., Cui, Y., Liu, Y. and Chatterjee, A.K. (1997) Molecular
characterization and expression of the Erwinia carotovora hrpN Ecc gene,
which encodes an elicitor of the hypersensitive reaction. Mol . Plant-
Microbe Interact . 10, 462–471.Mulholland, V., Hinton, J.C., Sidebotham, J., Toth, I.K., Hyman, L.J.,
Pérombelon, M.C., Reeves, P.J. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1993) A pleio-
tropic reduced virulence (Rvi–) mutant of Erwinia carotovora subspecies
atroseptica is defective in flagella assembly proteins that are conserved
in plant and animal bacterial pathogens. Mol . Microbiol . 9, 343–356.
Murata, H., Fons, M., Chatterjee, A., Collmer, A. and Chatterjee, A.K.
(1990) Characterisation of transposition insertion Out– mutants of
Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora defective in enzyme export and of
a DNA segment that complements out mutations in Erwinia carotovora
subsp. carotovora , Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica and Erwinia
chrysanthemi . J . Bacteriol . 172, 2970–2978.
Nachin, L. and Barras, F. (2000) External pH: an environmental signal that
helps to rationalize pel gene duplication in Erwinia chrysanthemi . Mol .
Plant Microbe Interact . 13, 882–886.
Nachin, L., El Hassouni, M., Loiseau, L., Expert, D. and Barras, F.
(2001) SoxR-dependent response to oxidative stress and virulence of
Erwinia chrysanthemi : the key role of SufC, an orphan ABC ATPase. Mol .
Microbiol . 39, 960–972.
Nassar, A., Bertheau, Y., Dervin, C., Narcy, J.P. and Lemattre, M.
(1994a) Ribotyping of Erwinia chrysanthemi strains in relation to their
pathogenic and geographic distribution. Appl . Env . Microbiol . 60, 3781–
3789.
Nassar, A., Darrasse, A., Lemattre, M., Kotoujansky, A., Dervin, C.,
Vedel, R. and Bertheau, Y. (1996) Characterisation of Erwinia chrysan-
themi by pectolytic isozyme polymorphism and restriction fragment
length polymorphism analysis of PCR-amplified fragments of pel genes.
Appl . Env . Microbiol . 62, 2228–2235.Nasser, W., Bouillant, M.L., Salmond, G.P.C. and Reverchon, S. (1998)
Characterization of the Erwinia chrysanthemi expI-expR locus directing
the synthesis of two N-acyl-homoserine lactone signal molecules. Mol .
Microbiol . 29, 1391–1405.
Nasser, W. and Reverchon, S. (2002) H-NS dependant activation of pectate
lyases synthesis in the phytopathogenic bacterium Erwinia chrysanthemi
is mediated by the PecT repressor. Mol . Microbiol . 43, 733–748.
Nasser, W., Reverchon, S., Condemine, G. and Robert-Boudouy, J.
(1994b) Specific interactions of Erwinia chrysanthemi KdgR repressor
with different operators of genes involved in pectinolysis. J . Mol . Biol .
236, 427–440.
Nguyen, H.A., Kaneko, J. and Kamio, Y. (2002) Temperature-dependant
production of carotovoricin Er and pectin lyase in phytopathogenic
Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora Er. Biosci . Biotech. Biochem . 66,
444–447.
Norman, C., Vidal, S. and Palva, E.T. (1999) Oligogalacturonide-
mediated induction of a gene involved in jasmonic acid synthesis in
response to the cell-wall-degrading enzymes of the plant pathogen Erwinia
carotovora . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 12, 640–644.
Norman-Setterblad, C., Vidal, S. and Palva, E.T. (2000) Interacting sig-
nal pathways control defence gene expression in Arabidopsis in response
to cell-wall degrading enzymes of Erwinia carotovora . Mol . Plant-
Microbe Interact . 13, 430–438.
Okinaka, Y., Yang, C.H., Perna, N.T. and Keen, N.T. (2002) Microarray
profiling of Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937 genes that are regulated during
plant infection. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 15, 619–629.
Page, F., Altabe, S., Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N., Lacroix, J.M.,
Robert-Baudouy, J. and Bohin, J.P. (2001) Osmoregulated periplasmic
glucan synthesis is required for Erwinia chrysanthemi pathogenicity.
J . Bacteriol . 183, 3134–3141.
Palva, T.K., Holmstrom, K.-O., Heino, P. and Palva, E.T. (1993) Inductionof the plant defense response by exoenzymes of Erwinia carotovora
subsp. carotovora . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 6, 190–196.
Parker, W.L., Rathnum, M.L., Wells, J.S. Jr, Trejo, W.H., Principe, P.A.
and Sykes, R.B. (1982) SQ 27 860, a simple carbapenem produced by
species of Serratia and Erwinia . J . Antibiot . 35, 653–660.
Parkhill, J., Dougan, G., James, K.D. and 38 other authors (2001a)
Complete genome sequence of a multiple drug resistant Salmonella
enterica serovar Typhi CT18. Nature , 413, 848–852.
Parkhill, J., Wren, B.W., Thomson, N.R. and 32 other authors (2001b)
Genome sequence of Yersinia pestis , the causative agent of plague.
Nature , 413, 523–527.
Perna, N.T., Plunket III, G., Burland, V., Mau, B., Glasner, J.D. and
Blattner, F.R. (2001b) Comparative analyses of enterobacterial genomes
Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 10th International Congress , Abstract 57.
Perna, N.T., Plunkett III, G. and Burland, V. and 25 other authors
(2001a) Genome sequence of enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli
O157:H7. Nature , 409, 529–533
Pérombelon, M.C.M. (1990) The genus Erwinia . In: The Prokaryotes
(Balows, A., Truper, H.G., Dworkin, M., Harder, W. and Schleifer, K.-H.,
eds), 2nd edn, Vol. III, pp. 2899–2921. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Pérombelon, M.C.M. (2002) Potato diseases caused by soft rot erwinias:
an overview of pathogenesis. Plant Pathol . 51, 1–12.
Pérombelon, M.C.M. and Kelman, A. (1980) Ecology of soft rot erwinias.
Ann . Rev . Phytopathol . 18, 361–387.
Pérombelon, M.C.M. and Lowe, R. (1975) Studies on the initiation of
bacterial soft rot in potato tubers. Potato Res . 18, 64–82.
Pérombelon, M.C.M., Lumb, V.M. and Zutra, D. (1987a) Pathogenicty of soft rot erwinias to potato plants in Scotland and Israel. J . Appl . Bacteriol .
63, 73–84.
Pérombelon, M.C.M., Lumb, V.M. and Hyman, L.J. (1987b) A rapid
method to identify and quantify soft rot erwinias on seed potato tubers.
EPPO Bull . 17, 25–35.
Pérombelon, M.C.M. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1995) Bacterial soft rots. In:
Pathogenesis and Host Specificity in Plant Diseases , Vol. 1. Prokaryotes
(Singh, U.S., Singh, R.P. and Kohmoto, K., eds), pp. 1–20. Oxford, UK:
Pergamon.
Pirhonen, M., Saarilati, H., Karlsson, M.B. and Palva, E.T. (1991) Iden-
tification of pathogenicity determinants of the plant pathogen Erwinia
carotovora . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 4, 276–367.
Pissavin, C., Robert-Baudouy, J. and Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N.
(1996) Regulation of pelZ , a gene of the pelB-pelC cluster encoding a
new pectate lyase of Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937. J . Bacteriol . 178,
7187–7196.
Py, B., Barras, F., Harris, S., Robson, N. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1998)
Extracellular enzymes and their role in Erwinia virulence. Meth . Micro-
biol . 27, 157–168.
Py, B., Chippaux, M. and Barras, F. (1991) Secretion of cellulase in
Erwinia chrysanthemi and Erwinia carotovora is species specific. FEMS
Microbiol . Lett . 79, 315–322.
Rantakari, A., Virtaharju, S., Taira, S., Palva, E.T., Saarilahti, H.T. and
Romantschuk, M. (2001) Type III secretion contributes to the pathogenesis
8/9/2019 From Genes to Genomes
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/from-genes-to-genomes 14/14
30 I. K. TOTH et al.
MOLECULAR PLANT PATHOLOGY (2003) 4 ( 1 ) , 17–30 © 2003 BLACKWELL PUBL ISH ING LTD
of the soft-rot pathogen Erwinia carotovora : partial characterisation of
the hrp gene cluster. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 14, 962–968.
Reverchon, S., Bouillant, M.L., Salmond, G. and Nasser, W. (1998)
Integration of the quorum-sensing system in the regulatory networks
controlling virulence factor synthesis in Erwinia chrysanthemi . Mol .
Microbiol . 29, 1407–1418.
Reverchon, S., Huang, Y., Bourson, C. and Robert-Baudouy, J. (1989)Nucleotide sequence of the Erwinia chrysanthemi ogl and pelE genes,
negatively regulated by the kdgR gene product. Gene , 85, 125–134.
Reverchon, S., Rouanet, C., Expert, D. and Nasser, W. (2002) Charac-
terization of indigoidine biosynthetic genes in Erwinia chrysanthemi and
the role of this blue pigment in pathogenicity. J . Bacteriol . 184, 654–665.
Russel, M. (1998) Macromolecular assembly and secretion across the bacterial
cell envelope: Type II protein secretion systems. J . Mol . Biol . 279, 485–499.
Saarilahti, H.T., Henirssat, B. and Palva, E.T. (1990) CelS: a novel en-
doglucanase identified from Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora .
Gene , 90, 9–14.
Salanoubat, M., Genin, S. and Artiguenave, F. and 25 other authors
(2002) Genome sequence of the plant pathogen Ralstonia solana -
cearum . Nature , 415, 497–502.
Sandkvist, M. (2001) Biology of type II secretion. Mol . Microbiol .40, 271–283.
Santos, R., Franza, T., Laporte, M.L., Sauvage, C., Touati, D. and
Expert, D. (2001) Essential role of superoxide dismutase on the patho-
genicity of Erwinia chrysanthemi strain 3937. Mol . Plant-Microbe Inter-
act . 14, 758–767.
Sauvage, C. and Expert, D. (1994) Differential regulation by iron of
Erwinia chrysanthemi pectate lyases: pathogenicity of iron transport reg-
ulatory (cbr ) mutants. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 7, 71–77.
Schoonejans, E., Expert, D. and Toussaint, A. (1987) Characterisation
and virulence properties of Erwinia chrysanthemi lipopolysaccharide-
defective phi EC2-resistant mutants. J . Bacteriol . 169, 4011–4017.
Shevchik, V.E., Robert-Baudouy, J. and Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N.
(1997) Pectate lyase PelI of Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937 belongs top a
new family. J . Bacteriol . 179, 7321–7330.Shih, Y.L., Harris, S.J., Borner, G., Rivet, M.M. and Salmond, G.P.C.
(1999) The hexY genes of Erwinia carotovora ssp. carotovora and ssp.
atroseptica encode novel proteins that regulate virulence and motility co-
ordinately. Env . Microbiol . 1, 535–547.
da Silva, A.C.R., Ferro, J.A. and Reinach, F.C. and 62 other authors
(2002) Comparison of the genomes of two Xanthomonas pathogens with
differing host specificities. Nature , 417, 459–463.
Simpson, A.J.G., Reinach, F.C., Arruda, P. and 113 other authors
(2000) The genome sequence of the plant pathogen Xylella fastidiosa .
Nature , 406, 151–159.
Smith, C. and Bartz, J.A. (1990) Variation in the pathogenicity and aggres-
siveness of strains of Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora isolated from
different hosts. Plant Dis . 74, 505–509.
Thomson, N.R., Thomas, J.D. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1999) Virulence
determinants in the bacterial phytopathogen Erwinia . Meth . Microbiol .
29, 347–426.
Thurn, K.K. and Chatterjee, A.K. (1985) Single-site chromosomal Tn5 insertions affect the export of pectolytic and cellulolytic enzymes in
Erwinia chrysanthemi EC16. Appl . Env . Microbiol . 50, 894–898.
Toth, I.K., Bertheau, Y., Hyman, L.J., Laplaze, L., López, M.M.,
McNicol, J., Niepold, J., Persson, P., Sletten, A., van der Wolf, J.M.
and Pérombelon, M.C.M. (1999a) Evaluation of phenotypic and mole-
cular typing techniques for determining diversity in Erwinia carotovora
subspecies atroseptica . J . Appl . Microbiol . 87, 770–781.
Toth, I.K., Thorpe, C.J., Bentley, S.D., Mulholland, V., Hyman, L.J.,
Pérombelon, M.C.M. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1999b) Mutation in a gene
required for both lipopolysaccharide and enterobacterial common
antigen biosynthesis affects virulence in the plant pathogen Erwinia
carotovora subspecies atroseptica . Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 12,
499–507.
Vidal, S., Eriksson, A.R.B., Montesano, M., Denecke, J. and Palva, E.T.
(1998) Cell wall degrading enzymes from Erwinia carotovora cooperate
in the salicylic acid-independent induction of plant defense responses.
Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 11, 23–32.
Vidal, S., Ponce de León, I., Denecke, J. and Palva, E.T. (1997) Salicylic
acid and the plant pathogen Erwinia carotovora induce defence genes
via antagonistic pathways. Plant J . 11, 115–123.
Waldee, E.L. (1945) Comparative studies of some peritrichous phyto-
pathogenic bacteria. Iowa State College J . Sci . 19, 435–484.
Walker, D.S., Reeves, P.J. and Salmond, G.P.C. (1994) The major secreted
cellulase, CelV, of Erwinia carotovora subsp. carotovora is an important
soft rot virulence factor. Mol . Plant-Microbe Interact . 7, 425–431.
Wallace, A. and Pérombelon, M.C.M. (1992) Haemagglutinins and
fimbriae of soft rot erwinias. J . Appl . Bacteriol . 73, 114–119.Wei, Z.M., Laby, R.J., Zumoff, C.H., Bauer, D.W., He, S.Y., Collmer, A.
and Beer, S.V. (1992) Harpin, elicitor of the hypersensitive response pro-
duced by the plant pathogen Erwinia amylovora . Science , 257, 85–88.
Wood, D.W., Setubal, J.C., Kaul, R. and 49 other authors (2001) The
genome of the natural genetic engineer Agrobacterium tumefaciens C58.
Science , 294, 2317–2323.
Yang, C.H., Gavilanes-Ruiz, M., Okinaka, Y., Vedel, R., Berthuy, I.,
Boccara, M., Chen, J.W., Perna, N.T. and Keen, N.T. (2002) hrp genes
of Erwinia chrysanthemi 3937 are important virulence factors. Mol . Plant
Microbe Interact . 15, 472–480.