Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles,...
Transcript of Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles,...
![Page 1: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The Role of Universities in City Foresight
Final report of the Future of Cities Research Network
PaulCowie,JohnGoddardandMarkTewdwr-Jones
![Page 2: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
The Role of Universities in City Foresight
Final report of the Future of Cities Research Network
March2016
PaulCowie,JohnGoddardandMarkTewdwr-Jones
Thisreportisintendedfor:
Policymakersandawiderangeofprofessionalsandresearcherswhoseinterestsrelatetoallaspectsofthefutureofcitiesandtheroleofhighereducationinstitutions.ThereportsummariesworkfundedbytheGovernmentOfficeforScienceForesightFutureofCitiesprojectandisbasedontheongoingactivitiesoftheresearchnetworkpartners:NewcastleUniversity,CardiffUniversity,UniversityofLiverpool,UniversityofManchester,andUniversityCollegeLondon.Thenetworkleadacademicscomprisedof:
DrPaulCowie,ProfessorJohnGoddardandProfessorMarkTewdwr-Jones,Newcastle.
ProfessorKevinMorganandDrDavidWaite,Cardiff.
ProfessorAlanHardingandDrNicolaHeadlam,Liverpool.
DrJoeRavetzandProfessorIanMiles,Manchester.
DrMicheleAcutoandDrElizabethRapoport,UCL.
Thereportshouldbecitedas:
Cowie,P.,Goddard,J.andTewdwr-Jones,M.(2016),TheRoleofUniversitiesinCityForesight.FinalreportoftheFutureofCitiesResearchNetwork,NewcastleInstituteforSocialRenewal,NewcastleUniversity,Newcastle.
![Page 3: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Contents
1. Introduction2. ResearchNetworkevents3. Thenetwork’srelationshiptootherForesightFutureofCitiesinitiatives
4. Lessonsfromthenetwork5. Goingforward6. TheCivicUniversityandCityForesight7. Aproofofconcept
![Page 4: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
1. Introduction
1.1AstheUKGovernmentOfficeforSciencenationalForesightFutureofCitiesproject(2013-15)developedandprogressed,itbecameincreasinglyapparentthatagrowingnumberofcitiesaroundtheUKsawanopportunitytoinitiatetheirownForesightprojectatalocalscale.Inseveralinstances,thisresultedinthelocaluniversityoruniversitiesplayingakeyroleinmobilisingacademicandotherlocalsourcesofknowledgeandexpertisetobuildcapacitytoundertakeanongoingandsustainablecityfuturesprocess.MorespecificallyintheForesightprocess,theuniversitiesaredemonstratingthatbyworkinginpartnershipwithothers,theycanplayaleadershiproleasan‘anchorinstitution’,linkingthecitytoglobalbodiesofknowledge.
1.2TherangeofcityeventshostedbynationalForesighthaverevealedawiderangeofmethodsthatcanbeusedtobuildthislocalcapacity,includinglocalvariantsofnationalForesightstructuresandprocesses(suchasLeadExpertGroup,StakeholderGroup,stateofknowledgereviews,scenariosandsystemsmapping).Inaddition,othermethodscontinuetobedeployedsuchaspublicexhibitions,Delphisurveys,competitions,varioussocialmediaandcivicleadershipdevelopmentprogrammeswiththeaimoffacilitatingtheparticipationofcivilsocietymorewidelyindebateaboutthefutureofthecity.
1.3TheForesightFutureofCitiesResearchNetwork,fundedbytheGovernmentOfficeforScience,wasestablishedinJanuary2015.ThisnetworkhasbeenabletoengagefourcitieswherethelinkbetweenauniversityandcityintheForesightprocessistakingshape.TheseareNewcastleUniversityinNewcastle,UniversityofLiverpoolinLiverpool,CardiffUniversityinCardiffandUniversityofManchesterinManchester.Inaddition,UCLhasbeenlinkedtotheForesightFutureofCitiesResearchNetworktobuildoninternationalworkoncityleadershipthatisrelevanttoUCL’smissiontobe‘London’sGlobalUniversity’.
1.4Thisreportoutlineswhatthenetworkhasachievedsofar.Thenextsectiongivesanoverviewofthenetworkingactivityundertakensincetheinceptionofthenetworkin2015.Thereportthengoesontogiveamoredetailedreviewofeachofthenetworkmeetingsbeforehighlightingsomeoftheinitialoutcomesandfindingsgeneratedbythenetwork.Finally,intrueforesightingtradition,itlookstothefutureofthenetworkandoutlinesopportunitiestotakethenetworkforward.
![Page 5: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
2. ResearchNetworkevents
2.1TheForesightFutureofCitiesResearchNetworkcomprisesofacoreof5cities:Newcastle(networkcoordinators),Manchester,Liverpool,CardiffandLondon.Eachcitywithinthenetworkhasapartnershipbetweenauniversityandatleastonecivicinstitutionfromthatcityregion.Table2.1setsouteachofthecitiesandthepartnershipsinvolvedintheForesightFutureofCitiesResearchNetwork.
Table1:FutureofCities-networkcitiesandtheirpartnerships
CityRegion PartnershipsNewcastle NewcastleUniversity,NorthumbriaUniversity,
NewcastleCityCouncil&NELEPGreaterManchester ManchesterUniversity,GMLEPLiverpool LiverpoolUniversity,LCRLEP,NorthHousingCardiff CardiffUniversity,CardiffCityCouncil,Welsh
AssemblyLondonUCL N/A
2.2ItshouldbenotedthatinLondon,UCLweremembersofthenetworkbutwerenotinvolvedinundertakingaForesight-fundedlocalcasestudyfortheGovernmentOfficeforScience.
2.3TheNetworkmet4timesduring2015-16andtable2.2outlineseachofthemeetingsandtheparticipantsatthosemeetings.
MeetingVenue AttendeesNewcastle16thJan2015
Prof.MarkTewdwr-Jones,NewcastleUniversityProf.JohnGoddard,NewcastleUniversityDrPaulCowie,NewcastleUniversityPatRichie,CEXNewcastleCityCouncilProf.AlanHarding,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversityDrNicolaHeadlam,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversityProf.IanMiles,ManchesterUniversityProf.KevinMorgan,CardiffUniversityDrElizabethRapoport,UCLDrJamesPaskins,UCLProf.SirAlanWilson,GovernmentOfficeforScienceEleriJones,GovernmentOfficeforScience
Liverpool21stMay2015
DrJoeRavetz,ManchesterUniversityProf.MarkTewdwr-Jones,NewcastleUniversityProf.JohnGoddard,NewcastleUniversityProf.AlanHarding,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversityDrNicolaHeadlam,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversity
![Page 6: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Prof.SirAlanWilson,GovernmentOfficeforScienceDrMicheleAcuto,UCL
Manchester24thJune2015
DrJoeRavetz,ManchesterUniversityProf.IanMiles,ManchesterUniversityProf.MarkTewdwr-Jones,NewcastleUniversityProf.JohnGoddard,NewcastleUniversityProf.AlanHarding,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversityDrNicolaHeadlam,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversityDrDavidWaite,CardiffUniversityProf.SirAlanWilson,GovernmentOfficeforScience
Cardiff7thJuly2015
Prof.KevinMorgan,CardiffUniversityDrSimonLannon,CardiffUniversityDrCarlaDeLaurentis,CardiffUniversityDrDavidWaite,CardiffUniversityMarkBarry,AdvisorWelshGovernmentPaulOrdersCEX,CardiffCCJaneForshaw,DirectorEnvironment,CardiffCCProfJonGoddard,NewcastleUniversityDrPaulCowie,NewcastleUniversityProf.TimDixon,ReadingUniversityDrJoeRavetz,ManchesterUniversityDrNicolaHeadlam,HeseltineInstitute,LiverpoolUniversity
UCL28thJanuary2016
DrMicheleAcuto,UCLProfBrianCollins,UCL–UKCRICProf.MarkTewdwr-Jones,NewcastleUniversityProf.JohnGoddard,NewcastleUniversityDrPaulCowie,NewcastleUniversityAndrewLewis,NewcastleCityCouncilProf.SirAlanWilson,GovernmentOfficeforScienceDrJoeRavetz,ManchesterUniversityIneSteenmans,GovernmentOfficeforScience
![Page 7: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
3. Thenetwork’srelationshiptootherForesightFutureofCitiesinitiatives
3.1Figure1givesanoverviewofthevariouscityfuturesinitiativescentredaroundthenationalForesightFutureofCitiesprojectandtherelationshipbetweentheseinitiatives.
Figure1:FutureofCitiesNetworkanditsrelationshiptootherprojects
NationalForesight
FutureofCitiesNetwork CityPilots CityVision
Community
Newcastle
Cardiff
Manchester
Liverpool
London:UCLcityleadership
DevolutionAgenda/Societal
Challenges
ForesightWorkingPapers
•Rochdale•Bristol•MiltonKeynes
•Belfast•Birmingham•Cambridge•Derby•Derry/Londonderry•Edinburgh•Glasgow•Lancaster•LeedsLeicester
•London•Nottingham•Oxford•Reading•Sheffield•Newcastle•Liverpool•Manchester•Cardiff
Otherfuturecity/regioninitiatives• NorthernPowerhouse• Catapult– FutureCities• ESRCUrbanTransformations• Etc……….
![Page 8: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
4. Lessonsfromthenetwork
4.1Eachofthecasestudycitieshashighlightedhowcontextandplacespecificallyinfluencedthenetwork’spartnersapproachestoforesighting.Figure2.2givesanoverviewoftheforesightmethodologyasadaptedtotheregionalscale:
Figure2:OverviewofaRegionalForesightMethodology
RegionalForesightMethod:Methodology:Governance
PrivateSector Public
Universities Stakeholders
LeadExpertGroup
• Mobilisingtheacademy• Collatingevidence
Stage1:Baseline
• Internal– Placebased• External– Societalchallenges
Stage2:Driversforchange
Stage3:Scenariosforfuture
• PoliticalEngagement• Publicdebate
Stage4:Pathwaystoscenario
Stakeholderengagementmethods•UrbanRoom•Stakeholderworkshops•Culturalevents:Debates,Theatre,festivalsetc•Onlinetools:gamingorblogging• SocialMedia•DelphiSurvey•Etc………
Policyengagementmethods• PolicyCabinets• Jointcommittees•Workinggroups•Etc…….
CitiesNetwork
NationalPolicy
Atallstagesoftheprocess
4.2Inthetophalfofthefiguresitsthegovernancearrangements.Thisrelatestoboththegovernanceoftheforesightprocessaswellasthegovernanceinstitutionsandcapacityoftheregionitself.Thedifferentcasestudiesundertakenrevealedarangeofdifferentapproachestothis.
4.3InNewcastle,theprocesswasinitiatedbytheuniversitywhothensoughttodrawintheotherthreeelementsoftheregion:privatesector,publicsectorandcivilsociety.Asoutlinedinthe“NewcastleCityFutures2065”report(Tewdwr-Jonesetal,2015;seewww.newcastlecityufutures.org),thisjoiningupofsectoralinterestswasdonethroughavarietyofstakeholderevents.Thejoined-upapproachtofutureplanninghassincebeenformalisedthroughtheCityFuturesDevelopmentGroup(CFDG).CFDGisacollaborativearrangementbetweenthetwoNewcastleuniversities,NewcastleCityCouncil,theNELEP,andotherpolicyorganisations.ThispartnershipisafirstinNewcastlebutalsoisinnovativefornortherncorecitiesandintendstogeneratelongtermthinkingforthecityanditswiderregion,relateongoingandnewresearchtopolicymakers,andinitiatecollaborativeandcoproductionarrangementsforfutureresearchgrantsandthedeliveryofdemonstratorprojects.
![Page 9: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
4.4ThepurposeoftheCFDG,therefore,istoprovideaone-stopshopfortheuniversities,Council,NELEP&industrytodiscussemergingandnewareasofresearchthatcouldbeofbenefittothecity,toidentifyongoingresearchbeingundertakenattheuniversitiesandcollegesthatcouldbedisseminatedtoapolicyaudience,andtohearofcityintelligenceneedstoinformfutureresearchprojectbids.
4.5Incontrast,Cardiffisapproachingtheissuefromadifferentdirection.Thereareanumberofpolicysectorspecificinitiativeslookingtothefuturebuttheinitiativesintheregionlackcoordination.CardiffUniversityisnowseekingtofulfilthisroleandbringtogetherthecomplimentaryfutureplans.
4.6Theexperienceoftwoothercitiesinthenetworkhighlightthechallengesinvolvedinthistypeofcollaborativeproject.InbothLiverpoolandManchester,ithasbeendifficultfortheuniversitytodevelopaworkingrelationshipwiththecityinstitution(s).Inbothcases,attemptsweremadetobringthecityintotheprojectwithlittlesuccessotherthanthereceiptoffundinginthecaseofLiverpool.Thismaybeduetoserendipityoralackofit.InthecaseofbothNewcastleandCardiff,thecitieswereatanearlystageofinitiatingfuturethinkingandwerejustbeginningtogettogripswiththeimplicationsofdevolvedgovernance.InthecaseofManchesterandtoaslightlylesserextentLiverpool,thecityregionshadalreadybeenthroughacycleoffuturesthinkingalbeitoverashortertimeperiodasthe50yearstackledintheForesightFutureofCitiesproject.Agooddealofpoliticalandinstitutionalcapitalhasbeencommittedtothe‘ManchesterModel’andsotointroduceanewelementtothisexistingprocesshasprovedtobedifficult.
![Page 10: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
5. GoingForward
5.1Thereareundoubtedchallengesinbringingtwodiverseinstitutions,suchasuniversitiesandcitycouncils,togethertodeveloplongtermthinkingcapacityinthepartnershiparoundcityfutures.Thevariouscitiesinthenetworkhadtackledthisindifferentways:NewcastlewasabletousetheForesightprojectasacatalysttobuildandstrengthennascentconnectionsbetweentheuniversityandthecity.Thiswasperhapsinspiteof,ratherbecauseof,theongoingdevolutionagenda.Incontrast,Cardiffhasbeenusingopportunitiesarounddevolutiontocreateamorestrategicapproachtofutureplanning.InthecasesofLiverpoolandManchester,therehasbeenalackofconnectivitybetweenthecityauthoritiesandagenciesanduniversityforesightprojectthatpreventedanylongtermcapacitytobedeveloped.
5.2Futureresearchisneededtounderstandtheissuesunderpinningthesefailuresaswellasresearchintowhatworks.Thisexperiencewassummedupwellbythequestionaroundthetermsofcivicengagementofuniversities:“Shouldcitiesbeanchoredinuniversitiesaswellas(orinplaceof)universitiesbeinganchoredincities?”
5.3Thisleadsontotheissueofcapacityandleadershipintheprocessofcityfutures.OneofthelessonstocomeoutofthecityfuturesResearchNetworkwastheneedforcapacityandresourcesinbothsetsofinstitutions.Foresight(longterm)thinkingislowonthelistofprioritiesforlocalgovernment.Inthecurrentageofausterity,localauthoritiesareworkingflatoutwithlessstafftomanagethecurrentsituation.Inthiscontext,takingastrategiclongtermapproachtoshapingtheirfuturesisperhapsseenasanunnecessaryburdenorevenluxurywhiletheyarepreoccupiedwithmoreimmediateservicedeliveryconcerns.
5.4Therearealsoconstraintstothistypeoflongtermcapacitybuildingwithinuniversities.Notwithstandingthegreaterprofile‘impact’isgettingwithinframeworkssuchastheResearchExcellenceFramework(REF),thechallengespresentedofengaginginforesightthinkingwithoutsideinstitutionsbecomesnotable.Longtermcollaborationandco-productionhastoovercomeawholerangeofinternalinstitutionalbarrierswithinuniversities.Firstandforemostofthesebarriersisthecommitmentofresourcestoanon-academicendeavour.Citiesandfuturesthinkingisofteninter-disciplinary;assuchittendstofallbetweenthenaturalandsocialsciences.Thiscanleadtocompetitionforleadershipofcitiesinitiativesorelseabenignneglectbyboth,eachexpectingtheothertotakethelead.Thesecondissueisthatofacademicattainment.Oneofthemaingoalsofacademicsistopublishinternational-respectedresearchintheirdisciplinaryfield.Partoftheforesightmethodreliesonresearchofthistypetoinformdecisionmakingprocesses,butagreaterpartofthestoryisaboutthetranslationtoappliedworking.Thisdoesnotnecessarilytickenoughboxesinthemetric-drivenworlduniversitiesareincreasinglybecoming.
![Page 11: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
5.5WithinWhitehall,policyinterventionislimitedtoperceivedmarketfailure.Inallotherinstances,barrierstothefreeoperationofthemarketmustberemoved.ThisposessomethingofadilemmafortheForesightMethodfoundedasitisontheideaoflongtermplanningandstrategicdecisionmakingbetweenthefourelementsofcivicsociety:privatesector;publicsector;theacademyandcivicsociety.Thatitnottosaythemarketisabsentfromfuturesplanning,butthatitarguablydoesnotholdthedominantpositionitdoeswithindaytodaypolicyagendas.Forexample,futuresthinkingaroundwhatareoftenreferredtoasthegrandsocietalchallenges(eghealth,demography,sustainability,democracy)requiresstrategieswhichmaynotbeconsideredtobeentirelymarketfriendly.Itmaybethatfutureworkoncityforesightmethodologyneedstobridgethegapbetweenamarketandplannedsolutiontothesocietalchallengesfacingcities.
![Page 12: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
6. TheCivicUniversityandCityForesightthroughAnchoring
6.1Goingforward,theForesightFutureofCitiesResearchNetworkhasdemonstratedthroughevidencethatthereisastrongargumentforuniversitiestoplayapivotalroleasacoordinatingandfacilitatingmechanismatthecityscale.ThroughForesightplace-basedmechanisms,universitiescanenhancetheirroleasurban‘anchorinstitutions’,withtheacademiccommunityassistinginurbanknowledgecreationandsharingtoinformpolicyandpracticethathasabearingonthefutureofthecity.
6.2Inthepastfewyears,theconceptoflocal‘anchorinstitutions’hasgrownbeyonditsorigininU.S.urbanpolicyandstartedtogainawidercurrency.Theconceptofanchoringlacksapreciseorconsistentdefinitionbutgenerallyreferstolargelocally-embeddedinstitutions,typicallynon-governmentalpublicsector,culturalorothercivicorganisations,thatareofsignificantimportancetotheeconomyandwidercommunitylifeofthecitiesinwhichtheyarebased.Thepresenceoftheseinstitutionsisunderstoodtogeneratepositiveexternalitiesandrelationshipsthatcansupportor‘anchor’widereconomicactivitywithinthelocality.
6.3AccordingtotheWorkFoundation:
“anchorinstitutionsdonothaveademocraticmandateandtheirprimarymissionsdonotinvolveregenerationorlocaleconomicdevelopment.Nonethelesstheirscale,localrootednessandcommunitylinksaresuchthattheyareacknowledgedtoplayakeyroleinlocaldevelopmentandeconomicgrowth,representingthe‘stickycapital’aroundwhicheconomicgrowthstrategiescanbebuilt.”(TheWorkFoundation,2010,p.3).
6.4IntheForesightprocess,universitiesandcitiescanidentifyassetsandopportunitiesthrough:thedisseminationofexistingdataandintelligencetovariedaudiences;theprovisionofnewdataandintelligence;developingsystemsthinkingacrossfragmentedgovernanceanddeliverybodies;promotingnewnetworkingrelationshipsbetweenactorsandagencies;andundertakingfuturesworkthatrelatesmorereadilytocircumstancesineachcitythanthematicexercisesrelatingtoasingleknowledgedomain.
6.5Suchactivitiesaccordwithagrowingrecognitionofthecivicroleofpublicuniversitiesastheyseektorespondtomajorlongtermsocietalchallengessuchclimateanddemographicchangethathavelocalaswellasglobalmanifestations.Thiscanbeillustratedbythestructuresandinternalinstitutionscreatedbytheuniversitiesinthisnetwork:UCL-SustainableCitiesGrandChallenge;Manchester-Cities@Manchester;Liverpool-HeseltineInstitute;andNewcastle-SocietalChallengethemes.Theseinternalstructuresareattemptstomarshaltheirresearchthattranscendindividualschoolandfacultydisciplinestoaddresstheinnovativespacesbetweenthemasaresponsetograndsocietalchallenges.
![Page 13: Foresight FoC Role of universities in cities foresight v4...Dr Joe Ravetz and Professor Ian Miles, Manchester. Dr Michele Acuto and Dr Elizabeth Rapoport, UCL. The report should be](https://reader036.fdocuments.us/reader036/viewer/2022071218/604f17f5b4c2c436e313cd84/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
7. Aproofofconcept
7.1Thisnetworkandtheactivitiesofitsmembershasdelivereda‘proofofconcept’modelforaregionallybasedforesightmethod.Intwooutofthefourcitycases,stableandongoinginstitutionalrelationshipshavebeendevelopedbetweenthefoursectors:university,publicsector,privatesectorandcivilsociety.Moreworkneedstobeundertakentounderstandthebarriersthatpreventsimilarcapacitybuildingtooccurinothercities.However,pursuingforesightlongtermthinkingincitiesisnotstraightforwardinobjectiveorpractice.Constantmanagementofrelationshipsandpartnerships,togetherwitharequirementtoraisethinkingandexpectationsbeyondnarrowagendasandpoliticalshorttermism,ispartoftheprocess;andforeverysuccessinthisregardtherewillalsobesetbacks.Thesesetbacksareonlytobeexpectedwhenseekingtoattemptaproofofconcept;indeedtheexperiencefromsetbacksisoftenmorevaluablethantheexperienceofsuccess.Whatisimportant,however,isthataworkingandreplicablemodelofregionalforesightcanbepursued,developedandadoptedbyothers.