Epic Product Battles of History: Lego vs GI Joe

30
Epic Product Battles of History: vs. By 1 st Lieutenant Alejandro Perez

description

This session is about the epic fight about 2 very different products in the same market space. One was "a product looking for a theme", while the other was "a theme looking for a product". In a UFC (Ultimate Fighting Champion) format, their begins, their struggles, their "Pros and Cons" and their outcomes are good fables for all PMs to reflect on.

Transcript of Epic Product Battles of History: Lego vs GI Joe

Page 1: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Epic Product

Battles of History:

vs.

By 1st Lieutenant Alejandro Perez

Page 2: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Agenda

• Speaker Introduction

• Introduction of the Contenders

• The Fight: 4 Rounds

• Market Results

• Discussion

• Mental Exercise

Page 3: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Personal Intro

• Global MBA

• Major in Finance

• Major in Business Admin

• Minor in Military Science

• 11 Years in the US Army

• Leadership, QM, and Logistics

• 2 Years of Corporate

• BAE Systems, Inc.

• 2 Years in Entrepreneurship

• SPOTS Tracking Systems, Inc.

Page 4: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe
Page 5: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Introducing the Contenders

• In one corner! • On the Other Corner!

Page 6: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Introducing GI Joe

• The Transformation

• Multi Product Offering

• “Theme looking for Products”

• Marketing Strategy

Page 7: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

GI Joe:

The Shorter (more cost effective) American Hero

• The Transformation (12” to 3 ¾”)

1964 to 1984 - 12” Action Figure 1982 to Now – 3 ¾” Action Figure

Reduced Costs

Increase in Quality

Page 8: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

GI Joe:

The “2 Sided” American Hero

• Multi-Product Offering:

• Hasbro provides both the “Problems and the Solutions”.

Page 9: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

The Nazis:

The Evil “Us vs Them” Mass Product Offering

• Multi-Product Nazi Offering:

• The Nazis provides both the “Problems and the Solutions”.

Page 10: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

G.I. Joe:

The “Soul Searching” American Hero

• G.I. Joe is a “Theme looking for a product”.

• Highly one dimensional theme: G.I. Joe vs. Cobra

• Only minor modifications can be done to survive

• (EX: G.I Joe: Retaliation)

• It can grow stale

• What if World Peace is reached? Does the theme die?

Page 11: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

GI Joe:

The Real “Marketing” American Hero

Product Offering Campaigns

• A Real American Hero (1982–1994)

• Stars & Stripes Forever – TRU Exclusives (1997–1998)

• A Real American Hero Collection (2000–2002)

• G.I. Joe vs Cobra (2002–2005)

• Direct to Consumer (DTC) (2005–2006)

• 25th Anniversary (2007–2009)

• The Rise of Cobra (2009)

• The Pursuit of Cobra (2010–2011)

• 30th Anniversary (2011–2012)

• Retaliation (2012)

Supplementary Offerings

• Comics

• Cartoon

• Film

• Video games

Page 12: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Summary: GI Joe

• The Transformation

• Multi Product Offering

• “Theme looking for Products”

• Marketing Strategy

Page 13: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Introducing Lego

• Modularity

• The Mutable Product Offering

• “Products Looking for Themes”

• Marketing Strategy

Page 14: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Lego Modular Maniacs!

• Modularity

• Standardization for Configuration

• Do it yourself

• IKEA style

Standardization reduced Costs

No Assembly reduces Costs

Page 15: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Lego Mutant Maniacs!

• The Mutant Value Proposition

• Modularity can lead to:

• Self Explorative Value Position

• Customer Define Value Position

Standardization leads to Modularity

Modularity increases Value Position

Page 16: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Lego Rip-off Maniacs!

• “Products Looking for Themes”.

• It does not compete on Quality, but the replication of their

modularity on different themes.

Page 17: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Lego Marketing Maniacs!

• Licensed themes

• Robotics sets

• Video games

• Official website

• Business consultancy

• Theme parks

• Retail stores

• Children's clothes

• Board games

• Films and television

• Books and magazines

Page 18: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Summary: Lego

• Modularity

• The Mutable Product Offering

• “Products Looking for Themes”

• Marketing Strategy

Page 19: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Round 1! Fight!!

• Ding, Ding, Ding!

Page 20: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Transformation vs. Modularization

• G.I. Joe wins the 1st Round

• Quality and Cost Reduction.

• Modularity is Clunky and can

be Problematic.

Page 21: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Round 2! Fight!!

• Ding, Ding, Ding!

Page 22: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Multi Product vs. Mutable Product Offering

• Lego wins the 2nd Round

• G.I. Joe cannot mutate its VP.

• Modularity allows multiple

variations in the Value

Proposition

Page 23: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Round 3! Fight!!

• Ding, Ding, Ding!

Page 24: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Theme to Product vs. Product to Theme

• Lego wins the 3rd Round

• G.I. Joe has a very constant themes and thus a limited audience.

• Modularity allows for theme changes and explore new markets.

Page 25: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Round 4! Fight!!

• Ding, Ding, Ding!

Page 26: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Marketing vs. Marketing

• Lego wins the 4th Round

• Close call, however:

• Lego has more market presence

due to its efforts.

Page 27: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

What do the Judges say?

$2.5 Billion $18.7 Billion

Page 28: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Lego Wins!

Page 29: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Discussion

• Lessons Learned

• Opinions

• Thoughts

Page 30: Epic Product Battles of History:  Lego vs GI Joe

Mental Exercise

vs.