Entire Series of Huawei Quidway Router Products - Sietsiet.net/download/Switch_comparison.pdf ·...
Transcript of Entire Series of Huawei Quidway Router Products - Sietsiet.net/download/Switch_comparison.pdf ·...
Entire Series of Huawei Quidway Router ProductsEntire Series of Huawei Quidway Router Products
International Data Communication Product Dept.International Data Communication Product Dept.
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Huawei Switches Advantages OverviewHuawei Switches Advantages Overview
Huawei Switches Advantages Overview
• Provide similar features
• Higher performance
• Lower cost when provide the same service
• Cisco provide only basic features for free. (TCO is even lower than it looks like )
• Do customization for our customer
Huawei Switches Weakness OverviewHuawei Switches Weakness Overview
Huawei Switch Weakness Overview
• Brand
• Provide less protocolAlready cover the most features needed todayCisco Proprietary( some of them different with industry’s standard, we choose industry’s standard )Old protocolsLess required by customerWill provide later
• Weak in high-end switches.
Huawei Switches Strategies OverviewHuawei Switches Strategies Overview
Huawei Switch Strategies Overview• Replace Cisco( most common situation )
•Put Huawei switches where Catalyst is put.•Do what Catalyst switches does.
• Use standard protocol•Cisco proprietary protocol is not open, so lead our customer to use standard protocol, to keep open.
•Use the power of the customization.•Cisco do not customize their products.•Huawei will be glad to do for large project or strategic partner or customer.
•Fast growth•Quidway Switches keep up Catalyst switches at a faster pace.
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Catalyst Switches Product SeriesCatalyst Switches Product Series
Quidway Switches Product SeriesQuidway Switches Product Series
Quidway S3500
Quidway S5516
Quidway S8016Quidway S6500Quidway S8500
Quidway S2000 Quidway S3000
Quidway S5000
End-to-End Solution of Ethernet NetworkFrom Core to Desktop
Competitor mapCompetitor map
Quidway S3000Quidway S5000Currently, similar with CatalystKeep up with Catalyst in 2004.
Small Wiring ClosetsSmall Branch OfficesDepartment Workgroups
Catalyst2970/2950
Quidway S3500Quidway S5500Currently, similar with CatalystKeep up with Catalyst in 2004.
Small Wiring ClosetsMedium Branch OfficesSmall Datacenter AccessSmall Network Aggregation
Catalyst 3750/3550
Quidway S6500Keep up with Catalyst in 2004.Get ahead in some particular area.
Medium Wiring ClosetsSmall/Medium Distribution/CoreMedium Datacenter Access/CoreLarge/Medium Branch Offices
Catalyst 4500
Quidway S8500Newly introduced.Keep up with Catalyst on capacity, port density, performance, etc. in 2004Keep up with Catalyst on Service. In 2005
CoreDistributionDatacenter Access/Core + ServicesHigh Performance Wiring Closets
Catalyst 6500
Huawei productsMain FocusCisco Products
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Catalyst 6500Catalyst 6500
• aCEF720 • dCEF720• Hardware IPv6, MPLS
• 720Gb/s Integrated Fabric w/ 40Gb/slot
• High Density 10/100/1000 and 10GbE
• 32Gb/s• 15Mpps L3• High Density 10/100
• Inline Power Support
• 256Gb/s SFM• 210Mpps CEF L3• Services Integration
• Enhanced Media Support
• 10GbE Interfaces• Full Voice Integration
More to Come…
• End to End Secure Converged Network Services
• From the Wiring Closet
• To the Core• To the Datacenter • To the WAN Edge
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 Future
Catalyst 6500 ChassisCatalyst 6500 Chassis
C6503 C6506 C6509 C6513
•6503/6506/6509/6513 3/6/9/13Slots Maximum 2/5/8/12 for Line Cards•32/256/720-Gbps integrated switching fabric•Up to 400Mpps forwarding performance•GE port density: 48 ports per line card•4×10 GE aCEF720( blocking )or 2×10GE dCEF720( non-blocking )•In-line power•FlexWAN ( T1/E1, T3/E3, 155MATM )•16×155M 4×622M 1×2.5GPOS/SDH•Content Switching Module( L4-7 Switching )•Intrusion Detection Syste•MPLS L2/L3 VPN•IPv6 hardware ready
Catalyst 6500 supervisor engineCatalyst 6500 supervisor engine
•MSFC for Supervisor Engine Provide L3 routing protocol and software forwardingf•PFC for Supervisor Engine Provide hardware forwarding and ACL•DFC for Line card: Provide lookup, Routing table download and ACL
15Mpps30Mpps210Mpps
YESClassicCEF256dCEF256
YESSupervisor Engine 2 MSFC2PFC2
Supervisor Engine 720
Supervisor Engine 2 PFC2
Supervisor Engine 1A MSFCPFC
Supervisor Engine 1A PFC
Supervisor Engine 1A
ClassicCEF256dCEF256CEF720aCEF720dCEF720
NO
Classic
NO
NO
L3 forwarding
15Mpps30Mpps210Mpps30MppsMaximum 400Mpps
YESYES
30MppsYESYES
15MppsYESYES
15MppsYESYES
15MppsYES
Performance
Flow ClassificationL2 forwarding
Quidway 8500 Switches SeriesQuidway 8500 Switches Series
S8505/08/12 7/10/14 Slot Chasiss5/8/12 I/O SlotsBackplane Maximum 1.8TbpsSwitching Capacity Maximum 720GbpsForwarding Maximum 432M pps576GE/576FE/48 10GE Interface
Quidway S8500 Spec.Quidway S8500 Spec.
High switching capacity and forwarding performance 1.8T Backplane720Gbps Switching Capacity430Mpps Forwarding Performance
Longest-prefix Matching Routing128K Routes
High density1×10GE 2×10GE > 4×10GE12×GE 24×GE-> 48×GE48FE, 32FE+4GE, 20FE SFP 4*155M POS+8GE > 2.5G/10G POS
Flexible ConfigurationsTwo type of Line cards --- For Metro and Enterprise.
Quidway S8500 Spec.Quidway S8500 Spec.
Service MPLS Layer3 VPNCARPolicy-based routingEqual Cost Multi-Path
ManagementHGMPSNMP v3
Security/AvailabilityL2/3/4 ACLIEEE 802.1x AuthenticationBuild in authentication severDual Control, Switch fabric, Power.
Quidway S8500 StrategiesQuidway S8500 Strategies
Follow up first, then overpass.In 2004
Build up the advanced platform.Keep up with Cisco on capacity, performance, port densityProvide most common line cardsProvide MPLS VPN10GE
In 2005More line cardsMore service cards( Web Switching, IDS, IPv6 )
Quidway S8500 Strategies( Cont. )Quidway S8500 Strategies( Cont. )
Quidway S8500 is based on a high performance platform. Catalyst is not. It costs much more to get a real high performance.
Shared bus fabric: only 15MppsCEF256: 30Mpps( Centralized address lookup, distributed forwarding )Classic and CEF256 is low efficient.Upgrade from old architecture cost moreSupervisor Engine 720 alone will not take you high performance
Quidway S8500 provide better MPLSCatalyst 6500 need OSM to provide MPLSMPLS is Distributed, but L3 forwarding is centralized.
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Quidway Catalyst 4000/4500Quidway Catalyst 4000/4500
Future
Catalyst 4500 SeriesSupervisor IV
64 GbpsL2/3/4 48 Mpps
240port GE Wire speed
Redundant Sup IV (4507R)1+1 Power
In-line powerOptional NetFlow
64 GbpsL2/3/4 48Mpps
240 port GEWire speed
Catalyst 4006Supervisor III
2002
24 GbpsL2 18 MppsL3 6 Mpps
240 port GE
Catalyst 4006
2000
24 GbpsL2 18 Mpps96 port GE
Catalyst 4003
1999 2003
Catalyst 4500 Series
Supervisor II-PLUS
Supervisor IVLow cost
For SMB Core
•Keep Centralized forwarding•50G Engine•IPV6
Catalyst 4500Catalyst 4500
4500 is an upgrade, based on the 4000 Series.Compatible with 4000 line card
Quidway S6500Quidway S6500
S6503 S6506 S6506R
64G Backplane 4 Slots chassis144FE/144GE
Catalyst 4503
128G Backplane7 Slots chassis288FE/288GE
Catalyst 4506
S6503/06E
96G+480G Backplane4/8 Slots288FE/288GE
Catalyst 4503/4506/45077R
128G Backplane8 Slots chassis288FE/288GE
Catalyst 4507R
Quidway S6500 Forwarding EnginesQuidway S6500 Forwarding Engines
Salience II64Gbps48Mpps
Salience III
Salience I64Gbps48Mpps
iSalience I32Gbps24MppsWith Daughter card interface
iSalience II32Gbps24MppsWith Daughter card interface
6503 Chassis
6506 Chassis
6506R Chassis
6503/06E Chassis
Quidway S6500 Weakness & AdvantagesQuidway S6500 Weakness & Advantages
Quidway S6500 Weakness:Lower capacity, port density( E series will upgrade to 480Gbps Backplane and 240Gbps switch fabric, 48GE per line card )POE( Q3 2004 )IPv6 ( 2005)Low-speed WAN interfaces( No plan )
Quidway S6500 Advantage:10GE line card( Q2 2004 )NATPBRPerformance( Cisco Supervisor II+ Engine: low price, low performance, centralized forwarding even for the local L2 traffic).
Quidway S6500E compare to CiscoQuidway S6500E compare to Cisco
2402409628814410/100 Port
24024096240120Gigabit
NONONO6/243/1210GE
1:1 Switch Fabric 1:1 Control
1:1 Power1:1 Power1:1 Power
1:1 Switch Fabric 1:1 Control
1:1 Power2:1 Power Redundancy
12Gbps12Gbps12Gbps16Gbps+80Gbps16Gbps+80GbpsBandwidth per slot
48Mpps48Mpps21Mpps120Mpps60MppsThroughput
64Gbps64Gbps28Gbps96Gbps+480Gbps48Gbps+240GbpsBackplane
55263Interface Module Slots
76384Total Slots
Catalyst 4507R
Catalyst4506
Catalyst 4503
Quidway S6506E
Quidway S6503E
Quidway S6500E compare to ciscoQuidway S6500E compare to cisco
IGMPPIM-DMPIM-SMDVMRP
MBGPMOSPF
IGMPPIM-DMPIM-SMDVMRP
MBGPMOSPF
IGMPPIM-DMPIM-SMDVMRP
MBGPMOSPF
IGMPPIM-DMPIM-SM
IGMPPIM-DMPIM-SM
Multicast
HSRPHSRPHSRPVRRPVRRPRouter Redundancy
RIPOSPF
BGPIS-IS
RIPOSPF
BGPIS-IS
RIPOSPF
BGPIS-IS
RIPOSPF
BGP
RIPOSPF
BGP
Routing Protocol
STP/RSTP/MSTP/PVST+/RPVST+
STP/RSTP/MSTP/PVST+/RPVST+
STP/RSTP/MSTP/PVST+/RPVST+
STP/RSTP/MSTP
STP/RSTP/MSTPSpanning Tree
88888QoS Queues
32K32K32KMAC address
2K(S II+)/4K(S IV)
2K(S II+)/4K(S IV)
2K(S II+)/4K(S IV)4K4KVLANs
8K8K8K128/GE128/GEACL
32K(S II+)/128K(S IV)
32K(S II+)/128K(S IV)
32K(S II+)/128K(S IV)64K64KIP Routes
Catalyst 4507R
Catalyst4506
Catalyst 4503
Quidway S6506E
Quidway S6503E
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Entire Series of Quidway Router ProductsEntire Series of Quidway Router Products
Catalyst 3550
Catalyst® 3750
General LAN Switching
Catalyst 2970
Long-Reach Ethernet
LRE 48-port POTS splitter
575 and 585 LRE CPEs
Catalyst 2950-LRE
Industrial Ethernet
Catalyst 2955
Small Form-factor
Catalyst 2940Catalyst 2950
Pric
e an
d Fe
atur
es
Scalability
Special Applications
Compete with Catalyst 3550/3750Compete with Catalyst 3550/3750
S3528P/GS3552P/G
S3526
C3550/C3750 EMI
S5516C3750G
C3550-12G/T
Catalyst 3550/3750 Gigabit Ethernet
S3526C
S3526E
C3550/C3750 SMI
S3552F-SI
S3526F
C3550-24-FX SMI
S3526E-F
Catalyst 3550/3750 Fiber Fast Ethernet
Cheap QOS
4K VLAN
Rich feature C3550-24-FXEMI
Rich feature
Cheap QOS
S3552F-EIC3550/C3750 EMIMetro/MPLS
Catalyst 3550/3750 Fast Ethernet
Q3 2004
Quidway S3528/3552 P/G & 3552F-SI AdvantagesQuidway S3528/3552 P/G & 3552F-SI Advantages
Routing
32G Switching capacity, wire-speed forwarding
Longest-prefix matching 4K routes.
512 Routing Interfaces.
PBR / ECMP
ACL/QoS/Flow Classification
L2-4 flow classification, FC based rate-limiting, redirection, priority
Port based rate-limiting.
WRR/SP
8 Queue per port
4K 802.1Q VLANs
Web-portal 802.1x Authentication. Internal Authentication Server
Quidway S3552F-EI(Dev.) AdvantagesQuidway S3552F-EI(Dev.) AdvantagesRouting
32G Switching capacity, wire-speed forwarding
Longest-prefix matching 64K routes.
512 Routing Interfaces.
PBR / ECMP
ACL/QoS/Flow Classification
L2-4 flow classification, FC based rate-limiting, redirection, priority
Port based rate-limiting.
WRR/SP
8 Queue per port
4K 802.1Q VLANs
Web-portal 802.1x Authentication. Internal Authentication Server
MPLS L3 VPN
Compete with Catalyst 3550/3750Compete with Catalyst 3550/3750
Catalyst have only 8 routing interfaces in Catalyst 3550
MAC based IEEE802.1x Authentication
Web portal( no software need on the subscriber side )
3526C/E provide full feature even the L2~7 ACL while Catalyst
SMI only support RIP and static route
Large number of VLAN is needed in Metro Access/Aggregation
Quidway 3552/3528 have more gigabit uplink ports
Quidway S3552F-EI: Large routing table, MPLS VPN.
Performance/Price
ContentsContents
Overview
Product line
Quidway S8500 vs Catalyst 6500
Quidway S6500 vs Catalyst 4500
Quidway S3500/5500 vs Catalyst 3550/3750
Quidway S2000/3000/5000 vs Catalyst 2950/2970
Compete with Catalyst 2950/2970Compete with Catalyst 2950/2970
Gigabit
S5024S5012 C2970
New S2000
S2000
C2950-12/24-SIC2940
S3026C/G/S-SI
S3026
C2950SX-SI
S3026C/G/T
S3026E
C2950C/T/G-EI
S3050C C2950G-48S3026E-F
Fast Ethernet with Gigabit UplinkFiber Interfaces
S3026F
QOS
4K VLAN
S3552F-SI
Q2 2004
Quidway S3000 Series AdvantageQuidway S3000 Series Advantage
Common Large capacity 12.8Gbps(3050 16Gbps),Wire-speed IEEE 802.1x Authentication. Internal Authentication Server IGMP SNOOPING RSTP/MSTP MAC Filtering / MAC address lock. SNMPv3 RMON WEB TELNET CONSOLE HGMP
3026C-SI 3026G-SI 3026S-SI Port based rate-limiting 128 VLAN
3026E/3026C/3026G/3026T/3026E-F/3050 L2~7 Flow Classification. 4 Queue per port 256 VLAN
Compete with Cisco 2950Compete with Cisco 2950Quidway S3000/2000 to compete with Catalyst 2950
Quidway S3000 EI similar to Catalyst 2950 EMI
Quidway S3000 SI and S2000 is much stronger than Catalyst
2950 SMI
Rate-limiting
DSCP priority mapping
64 VLAN vs 128 VLAN
802.1x Authentication. Internal Authentication Server
MAC based 802.1x Authentication
Performance/Price
New Quidway S2000 Series SwitchesNew Quidway S2000 Series SwitchesS2008Z
Plastic box L2 switch8 100BASE-TXNo Fans, Silent operation.External PowerWall or Desk mountable1.6G capacity
S2016C16 100BASE-TX 1FE Expansion SlotNo Fans, Silent operationAC/DC Power3.4G capacity
S2403I24+1 100BASE-TX + 1 FE Expansion SlotNo Fans, Silent operationAC/DC Power5.2G capacity
New Quidway S2000 Series SwitchesNew Quidway S2000 Series SwitchesWire speed performance512 VLANQOS
4Queue per port/ WRR/SP802.1p DSCPPort based rate-limiting
Silent Operation( No Fans )2016C support 802.3af Power over EthernetHGMPMulticast: IGMP SNOOPING802.1X Authentication Internal Authentication ServerPort mirroring/Link Aggregation
?Questions & CommentsQuestions & Comments