Energy Efficiency Concepts - HMGh-m-g.com/multifamily/aheea/MF Bldgs High-Perf Design... ·...
Transcript of Energy Efficiency Concepts - HMGh-m-g.com/multifamily/aheea/MF Bldgs High-Perf Design... ·...
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
11
Energy Efficiency ConceptsEnergy Efficiency Concepts
1. Energy Efficiency and Conservation2. Comfort and perception3. Proactive Design4. Performance-based Design Goals5. Integrated Systems Design Process6. Long-term cost-effectiveness
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
22
Energy Savings TermsEnergy Savings Terms
ConservationBehavioral approachImmediate resultsShort-term effectsOccupants may be uncomfortableReduces waste
EnergyEfficiency
Technological approachSmaller resultsLong-term effectsOccupants comfortable
Site GenerationTechnological approachSupplying energy, not reducing the need for itEliminates transmission losses
“Demand” = Time at which you use conservation, efficiency or generation
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
33
Comfort and PerceptionComfort and Perception10% of all occupants are always dissatisfiedHuman thermal comfort is determined ≈ 30% from air temperature≈ 50% from radiant (surface) temperature
Using energy to control surface temperatures has nearly twice the impact on human comfort
Low-E glass reflects body heat in, sunlight out
Radiant heating and cooling warms or cools the body first and eliminates draft, dust and noise
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
44
Performance-based AnalysisPerformance-based Analysis
Building energy simulation software makes performance-based whole building analysis possible:Comparison of combinations of energy efficiency measures
Comparison of proposed design against a baseline (e.g. Title 24)Evaluation of building performance relative to a threshold (e.g. incentive programs)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
55
Building Energy SimulationBuilding Energy Simulation
Buildings are modeled using weather data specific to one of 16 CA climate zones
Calculations for compliance (Title 24)
Calculations for energy efficiency design
Same software can be used for both
Each specific energy measure can be modeled
Interactions between measures can be modeled
66
Performance-Based DesignPerformance-Based Design
• Evaluation of combined measures allows for substitutions of individual measures and then re-evaluation
• Energy performance feedback loop is an essential tool in the energy efficient design process
• Enables evaluation of most cost-effective solutions
• Skilled energy consultant becomes key design team specialist
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
77
Integrated Systems DesignIntegrated Systems DesignIndividual building components are considered as part of integrated and interactive systems:
The building envelope design impacts HVAC sizingSkylights with daylighting controls reduce electric lighting loadsElectric lighting increases cooling requirementsWaste heat from one system can power another
Separate building loads are aggregated into a single interactive whole building model
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
88
Proactive Design withPerformance-based DesignProactive Design withPerformance-based Design
Measures performancein energy (kBTU/sf/yr) savings/square foot/year and by % improvement over threshold
Allows trade-off between measures
Can result in more cost-effective solutions
But, watch out for “gaming”…“What is the least I can do to meet compliance?”
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
99Maximize Cost-Effectiveness with Proactive DesignMaximize Cost-Effectiveness with Proactive Design
Involve an energy consultant as early as possible in the design process Optimize building orientation, window areas and any other potential design restrictions BEFORE they are locked in by the entitlement process Think high performance, versus adapting to limitations set by others in the design processEarly team collaboration results in the most cost-effective solutions
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1010
Long-term cost-effectivenessLong-term cost-effectivenessFirst cost is important but look at life-cycle costDoes energy efficiency add value to a building?If energy costs continue to sharply rise, where will people want to live?Owners: can you afford not to build an energy efficient building?Designers: can you afford not to become expert in the design of energy efficient buildings?
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1111
Utilize Parametric AnalysesUtilize Parametric AnalysesParametric analysis
Design optimization method
Take one variable type (e.g. window solar heat gain properties) and test with a series of values
Results show relationships between elements
Test sensitivities toBuilding orientation
Window area and orientation distribution
Hot water heating equipment efficiency, distribution system and controls…etc
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1212
Title 24 BasicsTitle 24 Basics
Mandatory Measureslighting efficiencyshell insulation minimumsequipment efficiency minimumsappliance standards
Prescriptive Packagesestablishes Performance baseline Climate Zone dependant
Performance Calculation
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1313Title 24’s Performance ApproachTitle 24’s Performance Approach
The Energy Performance Approach for a building shows how much energy the proposeddesign is estimated to use, compared to the estimated energy use of the standard design. The difference is expressed as a percentage of the standard design.
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1414
Performance ApproachPerformance ApproachT-24 Performance Approach compares standard prescriptive design to proposed design
Envelope: Orientation, Insulation, Windows, Assemblies
HVAC: Heating and Cooling equipment and distribution
DHW:Central and individual water heating equipment & distribution
Software programs are used to demonstrate at least 15% > T-24 and positive electric energy savings
EnergyPro (Low rise and High rise)MICROPAS (Low rise only)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1515
At least 15% > 2005 code (MICROPAS)At least 15% > 2005 code (MICROPAS)
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE: RESIDENTIAL COMPUTER METHOD CF-1R Page 1=============================================================================
==MICROPAS7 ENERGY USE SUMMARY
----------------------------Energy Use Standard Proposed Compliance
(kTDV/sf-yr) Design Design Margin ----------------------- ---------- ---------- ----------Space Heating.......... 4.38 5.12 -0.74 Space Cooling.......... 2.08 2.62 -0.54 Water Heating.......... 23.11 16.61 6.50
-------- -------- --------Total 29.57 24.35 5.22
*** Building complies with Computer Performance ****** HERS Verification Required for Compliance ***
=================================================================
Compliance Margin / Standard Design:Negative Electric Energy: Does not comply
5.22/29.57 = 17.65%
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1616
Low-Rise Title 24 Form CF-1R (EnergyPro)Low-Rise Title 24 Form CF-1R (EnergyPro)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1717
High-rise Multifamily and T-24High-rise Multifamily and T-24High-rise buildings are modeled differently than Low-rise
Envelope and HVAC = Non-residential stdsLighting and Domestic Hot Water (DHW) = Residential stdsHigh-rise and Low-rise use different calculation engines
High-rise calculations de-emphasize envelope measuresAssume internal heat gain as in typical non-res buildings
For buildings w/ central DHW system:The water heaters/boilers need to meet efficiency requirements of sections 111 and 113, andAutomatic controls that shut-off the circulating pump when there is no need for hot water are required
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1818
High-Rise Title 24 PERF-1 Code ComplianceHigh-Rise Title 24 PERF-1 Code Compliance
only 11.4%
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
1919
High-Rise Title 24 PERF-1 Program ComplianceHigh-Rise Title 24 PERF-1 Program Compliance
13.73/63.62 =21.58%Subtract Lighting & ReceptacleDivide Margin by New Standard
=63.62
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2020
Prescriptive Envelope RequirementsPrescriptive Envelope Requirements
Low rise Package D-Table 151-C
LR see appendix B in 2005 standards
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2121Prescriptive Envelope RequirementsPrescriptive Envelope Requirements
HR See p. 84 in 2005 standards
High rise Table 143 B
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2222
Title 24 Yesterday and BeforeTitle 24 Yesterday and Before
1998 2001 Code2001 was ~10% more stringent than 1998
2001 2005 Code
On average, 2005 ~15% more stringent than 2001
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2424Time Dependent Valuation (TDV)Time Dependent Valuation (TDV)
Based on work by PG&E and other investor owned utilities
Make standards reflect the reality that the cost of energy depends on the hour and season
TDV changes the way energy is ‘valued’ based on the time of use of that energy
Time of day or season no longer irrelevant
Higher value for on-peak savings
Lower value for off-peak
Neutral for savings that are both on & off
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2525
TDV EnergyTDV Energy
With flat energy value a kW saved is valued the same for every hour of the day
With flat energy value a kW saved is valued the same for every hour of the day
Monday Friday
With TDV value a kW saved during a high-cost peak hour is valued more highly than a kW saved during an off-peak hour
With TDV value a kW saved during a high-cost peak hour is valued more highly than a kW saved during an off-peak hour
Flat Energy Value
Flat Energy Value
Time Dependent Energy Value
Time Dependent Energy Value
Ene
rgy
valu
e
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2626
TDV Energy CalculationTDV Energy Calculation
Energy use values for the proposed and standard designs are estimated for each hour (8760 hr/yr)Each hour of year, energy use estimate multiplied by TDV value for that hour
TDV values vary for each hour of the year, and by Energy fuel type (electricity/natural gas/propane) California climate zone, and Building type (low-rise residential or nonresidential, high-rise residential or hotel/motel)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2727
How does TDV impact the measures that give you credit in T-24?How does TDV impact the measures that give you credit in T-24?
TDV favors technologies that save more energy on-peak than off-peakGreater credit for:
Higher EER air conditionersLower SHGC glazingBetter duct insulation (in unconditioned spaces)Daylighting controls for lighting
Greater penalties for:West-facing glassOversized, unshaded windows/skylights
Generally neutral or lower credits for:Economizers Envelope insulationHigh efficiency water heating
This affects trade-off choices using the performance approach (computer programs)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2828On-Site Verification & MaintenanceOn-Site Verification & Maintenance
On-site verification ensures that buildings are built per designHERS Raters are special inspectors with expertise in energy efficiency measuresVerification and/or Diagnostic TestingBuilding component commissioningExpect more HERS compliance creditmeasures, up to full building commissioning
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
2929
HERS Measures vs. HERS Verification HERS Measures vs. HERS Verification
HERS Measures give a project credit in T-24
To meet minimum code complianceTo exceed the code in the performance approach
Whether or not any HERS measures have been claimed in T-24, a HERS Rater must be used to certify a residential project at 15% above code for Utility Program purposes
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3030
HERS Measures that give credit in T-24HERS Measures that give credit in T-24
High EER for ACQuality Insulation Installation (QII)Maximum cooling capacityDuct surface area and R-valueAir handler Fan Watt DrawSupply duct location and deeply buried ducts
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3131Upcoming 2008 Title 24 StandardsUpcoming 2008 Title 24 Standards
Lower prescriptive U-factors for windows
Additional HERS measures
Required ventilation in residential code
Minimum prescriptive reflectivity of roof materials in specific CZ
Opaque building elements have different default assumptions in non-res calculations methods
Improved controls required for outdoor site-lighting
Demand response programmable thermostats
Will be in place April, 2009
Sponsored by
Southern California EdisonPresented by the
Heschong Mahone Group, Inc.
Multifamily New Homes: High Performance Energy Efficiency DesignMultifamily New Homes: High Performance Energy Efficiency Design
What Measures in 2005 Standardsachieve a ~15% Compliance
Margin?
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3333What Measures are Necessary?What Measures are Necessary?
Measures vary by building typeHigh-rise versus low-riseCentral versus distributed systemsAmount of building self shadingBuilding geometry
Measures vary by climate zoneFocus on measures affecting largest energy usePeak demand related measures first
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3434
Primary Energy Efficiency Design Decisions: Order of Consideration for MF projects
Primary Energy Efficiency Design Decisions: Order of Consideration for MF projects
Determine OccupanciesCentral vs. Individual systems% Glazing
OrientationEnvelope Improvements
InsulationWindowsHERS Measures
Mechanical Efficiency Upgrades
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3535
How Do We Make MF Units More Energy Efficient?How Do We Make MF Units More Energy Efficient?
Envelope“High performance”WindowsProperly installed insulationAir tight envelope
Water heatingCentral systemsSmart controlsHigh efficiency
High efficiency HVAC systems
Maximize equipment efficiency Minimize distribution lossesSize equipment correctly
Whole Building Design
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3636Going Beyond Heating, Cooling and Water HeatingGoing Beyond Heating, Cooling and Water Heating
AppliancesENERGY STARRefrigeratorWasherDishwasherDryer - Gas!
WaterLow flowH-Axis washer
LightingT-8s and electronic ballastsCFLs - Compact Fluorescent LampsReflector bulbs in “can”lightsOccupancy sensors
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3737
For both high-rise & low-rise measures vary by:Climate Zone (Coastal or Inland)Primary Energy Efficiency Design Decisions mentioned in last slide
High-rise projectsDon’t receive credit for most HERS measures
Since envelope and HVAC are non-residentialMeasure that do impact: duct testing, not QII, ducts in conditioned space, etcTherefore No ENERGY STAR® designation
Roof measures have less impactDHW higher percentage of total budgetMetal Framing and high framing factors = need more insulation
Measures for Low-rise vs. High-riseMeasures for Low-rise vs. High-rise
Sponsored by
Southern California EdisonPresented by the
Heschong Mahone Group, Inc.
Multifamily New Homes: High Performance Energy Efficiency DesignMultifamily New Homes: High Performance Energy Efficiency Design
Methods and Measures Part I
Title 24 & Building EnvelopeTitle 24 & Building Envelope
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
3939
Energy Design MeasuresEnergy Design MeasuresT-2
4
Perf
orm
an
ce
Cre
dit
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4040
Building Efficiency MeasuresBuilding Efficiency Measures
A. Site Considerations
B. Building Envelope
C. Lighting
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4141
Site ConsiderationsSite Considerations
Climate ZoneSun (orientation)Wind
Stack effectCross ventilation
Site Energy Generation
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4242
California’s Climate ZonesCalifornia’s Climate Zones
Not typical climate zones, e.g. “alpine” or “desert”Based on combination of energy use, temperature, weather data and other factorsA geographic area grouped for the purpose of creating an “energy budget”The energy budget is the maximum energy a building can consume in one year
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4343
California Climate ZonesCalifornia Climate Zones
Coastal Climate Zones: 1-7
Inland Climate Zones: 8-16
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4444
Cooling-Dominated Climate ZonesCooling-Dominated Climate Zones
2005
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4545
Site InfluencesSite Influences
Sun and Wind are most important site influencesBuildings interact with them primarily through shape, shade and the material properties of the building envelope, e.g:
Solar transmittance of windowsAir infiltration properties of building envelopeReflectivity and emissivity of outer surfaces
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4646
Passive Wind DesignPassive Wind Design
Cross Ventilation for Free Cooling
Inlet, without outletBreeze will not readily enter space
Inlet and outletCross ventilationStack effect improves flow
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4747
Passive Wind DesignPassive Wind Design
Taking Advantage of the Stack EffectWindow or roof opening higher than inlet opening
Warm air rises and exhaustsCool air drawn in through lower openings and replaces warm air
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4848
Situating the BuildingSituating the Building
Building OrientationShort faces of building East-WestLong faces of building facing North-South
Use inter-building shading to minimize afternoon solar heat gainSloped roofs facing south for eventual site generation (solar-thermal and photovoltaics)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
4949
Shading DevicesShading Devices
Proper sizing of overhangs Sun position calculatordetermine azimuth and angleswww.geocities.com/senol_gulgonul/sun/
Building-integrated landscapingPlant deciduous trees on the south sideUse photovoltaic panels for shading
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5050
Site Energy GenerationSite Energy Generation
Photovoltaics (solar electric)Solar Water Heating (solar thermal)Wind PowerFuel CellsMicroTurbinesNet Metering
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5151
Colorado Court, Santa MonicaColorado Court, Santa Monica
44-unit Single Resident Occupancy buildingDesigned for 100% energy independence27.4 kWCEC rated PV system
204 modules @ 140 wattsModules shade building
Roof-mounted natural gas-fired 30 kW microturbine
Generates electricity and uses waste heat for space and water heating Pugh+Scarpa Architecture
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5252
Model Low-Income HousingModel Low-Income Housing
Passive solar first!Orientation to control solar cooling loadsShading of south facing windows; minimize west facing Shape for exposure to prevailing winds (natural ventilation)Window design to maximize natural ventilationInterior design to enhance daylighting and natural air flow
Source: Pugh+Scarpa Architecture
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5353
Building Efficiency MeasuresBuilding Efficiency Measures
A. Site Considerations
B. Building Envelope
C. Lighting
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5454
Building Envelope MeasuresBuilding Envelope Measures
Insulation
Windows, Doors, Skylights
Radiant Barriers
Thermal Mass
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5555
Insulation BasicsInsulation Basics
Insulation resists the flow of heatMeasured by R-value (R = Resistance)In some climate zones, a radiant barrier over “standard practice” insulation is more effective than a higher insulation R-value Better insulation can help reduce HVAC equipment size
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5656
Insulation TypesInsulation TypesFibrous Insulation
Blankets BattsLoose-fill
Spray FoamRigid Foam PanelsInsulating Concrete Forms (ICF)Foam Core Concrete Panels
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5757
Insulation IssuesInsulation Issues
Standard practice = Poor installation
Gaps and voidsNot in contact with air barrier (drywall)Compression
= “Thermal Bypass”Insulation is cost effective—wheninstalled correctly
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5858
New ENERGY STAR Insulation Requirements: TBC/QIINew ENERGY STAR Insulation Requirements: TBC/QII
Blower door tests measure air infiltration and verify the tightness of the building envelopeBut, EPA found that many tight buildings were losing more heat than expectedFurther investigations with infrared cameras uncovered what is now comprehensively called the Thermal BypassThermal Bypass Checklist is now a requirement for the ENERGY STAR label
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
5959
2005 Insulation Changes2005 Insulation Changes
Effective R-value significantly less in 2005 for “standard” insulation installationNew “joint appendix” for wall assembliesVerified quality installation provides benefits over standard installation
But still has lower R-value compared to 2001 Title 24 standards
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6060
Insulation Quality ImpactInsulation Quality Impact
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6161
Old AssumptionsOld Assumptions
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6262Realistic Basis for a Framing FactorRealistic Basis for a Framing Factor
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6363
Insulation: the Air BarrierInsulation: the Air Barrier
Source: Doug Beaman, Douglas Beaman AssociatesBut batts NOT installed in contact w/ air barrier
Insulation can look OK at first glance…
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6464
Insulation: Wiring and PlumbingInsulation: Wiring and Plumbing
Source: Doug Beaman, Douglas Beaman Associates
Behind boxes and wiringCompressedGaps and Voids
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6565Quality Insulation Installation (QII)Quality Insulation Installation (QII)
Changes in 2005 Title 24Std installation of insulation: R-value de-rated by 13% Quality Insulation Installation: full R-value rating
HERS Rater inspects for QII:Fully lofted and filled framing cavities (no compression)Full contact with air barrierRim joists insulatedBatts butt-fit or split around wiring and plumbingWall cavities caulked or foamed for air-tight sealPre-insulation of hard to access wall stud cavitiesKnee walls and skylight shafts insulated to min. R-19Insulation over all recessed lighting fixtures
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6666
Cellulose Spray InsulationCellulose Spray Insulation
Source: Doug Beaman, Douglas Beaman Associates
Fills irregular spacesFlush with air barrier
No cutting and splittingBut, must allow to dry
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6767
InsulationInsulation
In continuous contact with air barrierNo gapsNo compressionsNo voids
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6868
Infiltration / ExfiltrationInfiltration / Exfiltration
Air leakage through wall can cause substantial energy loss
House wrapBlower door test for leakage
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
6969
Windows and GlazingWindows and Glazing
Select based on NFRC* performance valuesDesign appropriate shading devicesIf you can’t shade, then minimize SHGC*Minimize U-factors, e.g. dual pane glazingBetter windows can help reduce heating and cooling equipment size – saving first costs * NFRC = National Fenestration Ratings Council
* SHGC = Solar Heat Gain Coefficient
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7070
NFRC Window LabelNFRC Window Label
National Fenestration Rating Council (NFRC)
Window energy rating system based on whole product performance Required during building inspection
the only reliable way to determine window energy properties and to compare products
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7171
What to Look For: PerformanceWhat to Look For: Performance
U-factor of 0.40, or lessSHGC of 0.36, or lessVisible light transmittance (VLT) of 0.50 or moreLow emissivity (Low E)
Reduces U-factor (heat loss) and SHGC (heat gain)
Low-emittance (Low-E) coatings are deposited on a window to reduce the U-factor by suppressing radiative heat flow.
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7272
Window Technologies:Spectrally selective, low-E insulating glass
Low-E coatings: Reduce solar heat gain in the summerReduce heat loss in the winter
Vinyl, composite or thermal-break aluminum framesInsulating spacers
Cardinal LoE3-366 Glasswhole window, vinyl frame:
U-factor = 0.34SHGC = 0.20VT = 0.43
(varies by window type; average values)
What to Look for: TechnologiesWhat to Look for: Technologies
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7373
Buildings with more than 10,000 ft2 of site built vertical fenestration are required to have the fenestration certified under the NFRC-100SB rating and labeling proceduresLarger high-rise apartment buildings may trigger this requirement - at about 100,000 ft2
[assuming 10% fenestration to floor area ratio]
High Rise FenestrationHigh Rise Fenestration
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7474
2005 Code Fenestration Issues2005 Code Fenestration Issues
Allowable west-facing glass is limited to 5% of floor area (performance trade-off)
Standard multifamily design is based upon actual glazing area instead of 16% or 20% (up to 20%)
Fenestration U-factors changed
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7575
Most effective in cooling-dominated zones Can complement ceiling insulation with a lower R-valueCost per sq ft coming down rapidlyDoes not carry heating penalty of cool roofs
Radiant BarrierRadiant Barrier
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7676
Radiant BarrierRadiant BarrierTypes
Single-sided foil stapled to roof joists (retrofit)Foil-faced roof sheathing (new construction)
InstallationMust be adjacent to air gapMust face down--to avoid dust accumulation
BenefitsReduces attic air temperature by 30-50 degreesReduced heat gain in duct workNo additional labor costs (new construction
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7777
Thermal MassThermal MassThermal mass as a design element
Reduces interior temperature swingsAbsorbs heat during the day and re-emits at night (reduces heating demand in winter)Releases heat at night and re-absorbs during the day (reduces cooling demand in summer)Works best when mass is directly exposed to the interior air mass and in climates with large daily temperature swings
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7878
Building Efficiency MeasuresBuilding Efficiency Measures
A. Site Considerations
B. Building Envelope
C. Lighting
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
7979
Lighting OverviewLighting Overview
LightingTerminologyTitle 24Equipment
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8080
Lighting Industry TerminologyLighting Industry TerminologyLamp = Light BulbLumen = A unit of Visible LightLuminaire = Light FixtureEfficacy = efficiency of lighting product (Lumens/watt)
Picture Source: National Renewable Energy Laboratory
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8181
Title 24 TerminologyTitle 24 Terminology
2005 CEC Definition of “High Efficacy“No screw-based fixtures meet the definitionMust have electronic ballasts if > 13 watts
60 lumens per wattover 40 watts50 lumens per wattover 15 watts to 40 watts40 lumens per watt15 watts or lessMinimum Lamp EfficacyLamp Power Rating
TABLE 150-C HIGH EFFICACY LAMP REQUIREMENTS
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8282
Lighting and Title 24Lighting and Title 24
Mandatory measures: Lighting requirements are all mandatoryNot part of prescriptive packageNot part of residential energy performance calculation budgetPrimarily impacts dwelling unitsThe Standards apply only to permanently installed luminaires
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8383
2005 Lighting Code Summary2005 Lighting Code Summary“High Efficacy” fixtures required in almost all rooms
Kitchens: Minimum 50% of installed LightingBathrooms, Garages, Laundry & Utility Rooms: High Efficacy or have occupant sensorOther rooms (hallways, dining rooms, family rooms & bedrooms, etc.): High Efficacy or have occupant sensor (or dimmer)Outdoor Lighting: High Efficacy or shall be controlled by a photocontrol/motion sensor combination
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8484
2005 Lighting Code Summary2005 Lighting Code SummaryMultifamily Common Areas (Low Rise)
High efficacy luminaires OR have occupancy sensorsHigh Rise – Nonresidential Standards apply
Parking lot lighting, for more than 8 cars are required to meet Nonresidential Standards
Lamps over 100 W = 60 lumens/watt OR have a motion sensorLamps over 175 W must be “cut-off” ratedLuminaires must be controlled by photocontrol OR astronomical time switch
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8585
2005 Code Details2005 Code DetailsKitchens
50% of the installed watts must be “high efficacy” fixturesWattage determined by the maximum rated wattage of the fixture (not lamp) times the total number of lamps.
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8686
2005 Code Details2005 Code Details
Recessed fixtures in insulated ceilings
Must be Insulated Cover (IC) - rated for direct contact with insulationMust be “air tight” (AT)Beware electronic ballasts not designed for high temperatures found in attic spaces
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8787
Other 2005 Code DetailsOther 2005 Code Details
Common Areas (hallways, lobbies, corridors, stairwells)
must be high efficacy or controlled by an occupancy sensor
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8888
Other 2005 Code DetailsOther 2005 Code DetailsScrew-in, “modular” Compact Fluorescent Lamps (CFLs) not allowedMust use pin-based, “hardwired” compact fluorescent fixturesElectronic BallastsOccupancy SensorsMotion sensor/photocell
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
8989
Screw-in Compact Fluorescent LampsScrew-in Compact Fluorescent Lamps
“High Efficacy”fixturesEnergy Star labeled fixturesPin-based equipment not sold in grocery stores
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9090
Lighting EquipmentLighting Equipment
Wide variety of types and sizes available
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9191
Lighting ControlsLighting Controls
DimmersOccupancyPhotosensorsTimersMotion Sensors
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9292
California Kitchen Lighting SystemCalifornia Kitchen Lighting System
Funded by CECPartners include SMUD, Lithonia, CLTC (California Lighting Technology Center) and othersProduct commercially available by Lithonia50 lumens per watt (high efficacy)One ballast operating two fixturesFixture costs reduced by over 50% High output lamps (26 watts CFL)
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9393
Lithonia “CKP” Recessed FixturesLithonia “CKP” Recessed Fixtures
California Kitchen Lighting System Residential kitchen demo
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9494
LED Lighting: The Future?LED Lighting: The Future?
Light Emitting DiodeApprox 20 lumens per wattCan be installed:
Under countersHallways, staircases
Still Limited by ProductionStay Tuned!
7/31/20087/31/2008 Multifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDCMultifamily Comprehensive Training - LACDC
9595
Lighting ManufacturersLighting ManufacturersSunpark LightingBrownlee LightingSea Gull LightingAccess LightingAmerican Fluorescent Corp.ASL Energy Efficient LightingLaMar LightingLithoniaProgress LightingAll other manufacturers (including decorative) can retrofit existing lamps on a special order basis