2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT...

36
February 10, 2012 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily Market Dynamics Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily Research, Mortgage Bankers Association

Transcript of 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT...

Page 1: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

February 10, 2012

2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT

Multifamily Market Dynamics

Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily Research, Mortgage Bankers Association

Page 2: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Rental in the Broader Housing Market

• MBA’s Commercial/Multifamily Quarterly Data Book

• MBA Analysis of American Housing Survey

• MBA Analysis of Census Population Projections

• MBA Analysis of Housing Vacancy Survey

• Reports from MBA’s Research Institute for Housing America

• MBA Analysis of Housing Starts Data

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 3: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Thousands of Households, by Tenure and Structure Size, 2009

3

Source: Census Bureau, American Housing Survey.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 4: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Composition of renter households, by building size, 2009

4

Source: Census Bureau, American Housing Survey.

Thousands of households

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 5: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Composition of Renter Households, by Building Size, 2009

5

Source: Census Bureau, American Housing Survey.

Thousands of households

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 6: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Thousands of Households, by Tenure and Household Income, 2009

6

Source: Census Bureau, American Housing Survey.

Thousands of households

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 7: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Changes in Number of Owner- & Renter-occupied Households, & Homeownership Rate

7

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association and Census Bureau.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 8: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Projected population change, by age, 2010 –2015 & 2015 – 2020

8

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association and Census Bureau

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 9: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Number of Owner- & Renter-occupied Households, by Age of Householder, 2000 to 2010

9

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association and Census Bureau.

Less than 35 years old Age 35 to 44 Age 45 to 54 Age 55 to 64 Age 65 and older

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 10: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Home-Buying Sentiment for Owners and Renters Since 1992

10

Source: Data from Gary V. Engelhardt, “The Great Recession and Attitudes Toward Home-Buying,” Research Institute for Housing America (2011).

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 11: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Home-Buying and Selling Sentiment Since 1992

11

Source: Data from Gary V. Engelhardt, “The Great Recession and Attitudes Toward Home-Buying,” Research Institute for Housing America (2011).

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 12: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Factors Affecting Homeownership Rates

12

Source: Homeownership Boom and Bust 2000 to 2009: Where Will the Homeownership Rate Go from Here?, Stuart A. Gabriel and Stuart S. Rosenthal, Research Institute for Housing America (2011).

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 13: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Percent of Tenants “Probably” or “Definitely” Intend to Renew

13

Source: Kingsley Associates.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 14: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Fundamentals

• MBA’s Commercial/Multifamily Quarterly Data Book

• MBA Analysis of REIS Data

• MBA Analysis of NCREIF NOI Data

• MBA Analysis of Equity Residential Quarterly Earnings

• MBA Analysis of Real Capital Analytics Data

• MBA Analysis of Moody’s, NCREIF and Green Street Property Price Data

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 15: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Commercial/Multifamily Vacancy & Occupancy Rates, by Property Type by Quarter

15

Source: Reis, Inc.© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 16: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Year-over-Year Percent Change in Net Operating Income Among NCREIF Properties

16

Source: NCREIF.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 17: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Thousands of Households, by Tenure and Household Income, 2009

17

Source: Equity Residential.

Q3 2009 to Q3 2010 Q3 2010 to Q3 2011

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 18: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Commercial/Multifamily Property Sales Volume, Properties & Portfolios $5 million & Greater

18

Source: Real Capital Analytics.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 19: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Commercial/Multifamily Capitalization Rates, Properties & Portfolios $5 Million & Greater

19

Sources: Real Capital Analytics and Federal Reserve Board.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 20: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Indexes of Commercial/Multifamily Property Prices (2007Q3 = 100)

20

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association, Moody’s/REAL and NCREIF.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 21: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Indexes of Commercial/Multifamily Property Prices & the Dow Jones Industrial Average (2007Q3 = 100)

21

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association, Moody’s/REAL and NCREIF and Dow Jones.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 22: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Indexes of Commercial/Multifamily Property Prices (2007Q3 = 100) & Multifamily Mortgage Debt Outstanding ($thousands)

22

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Moody’s/REAL and NCREIF.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 23: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Housing Starts, Seasonally Adjusted at Annual Rate, Thousands of Units

23

Source: Census Bureau.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 24: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Finance

• MBA’s Annual Report on Multifamily Lending

• MBA’s Annual Origination Summation

• MBA’s Quarterly Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Bankers Originations Index

• MBA’s Quarterly Analysis of Mortgage Debt Outstanding

• MBA’s Annual Report on Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Maturity Volumes

• MBA’s Quarterly Analysis of Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Delinquency Rates

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 25: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Yields on Treasury Nominal Securities at Constant Maturity, Monthly Averages of Daily Data (percent)

25

Source: Federal Reserve Board.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 26: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Total & Institutional Multifamily Lending ($Millions)

26

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Annual Origination Summation and Annual Report on Multifamily Housing.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 27: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Mortgage Bankers Multifamily & Commercial/Multifamily Origination Indexes (index value, 2001 avg quarter = 100, right)

27

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Bankers Origination Index.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 28: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Index of Quarterly Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Bankers’ Originations, by Investor Group (2001 average quarter = 100)

28

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Bankers Origination Index.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 29: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Originations for Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac & Total & Institutional Multifamily Lending ($Millions)

29

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association, Annual Origination Summation and Annual Report on Multifamily Lending, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac press releases.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 30: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Lending in 2010, by Lender Average Loan Size

30

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Annual Report on Multifamily Lending.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 31: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Mortgage Debt Outstanding ($millions)

31

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association analysis of Federal Reserve Board’s Flow of Funds.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 32: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily Mortgage Debt Outstanding ($millions)

32

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Quarterly Analysis of Commercial/Multifamily Mortgage Debt Outstanding.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 33: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Multifamily and Other Commercial Mortgage Delinquency Rates Among Major Investor

33

Sources: Mortgage Bankers Association and Census Bureau.

Bank & Thrift (90+ day delinquency or nonaccrual) CMBS (30+ day delinquency including REO)

Life Companies (60+ day delinquency including in process of foreclosure)

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac (60+ day delinquency)

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 34: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Non-Bank UPB of Outstanding Multifamily Mortgages, by Year of Maturity, as of Dec. 31, 2010

34

Source: Mortgage Bankers Association, Commercial/Multifamily Loan Maturity Volumes.

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 35: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

Contact Information & MBA Resources

Jamie WoodwellVice President

Commercial Real Estate ResearchMortgage Bankers Association

1717 Rhode Island Ave NW, Washington, DC 20036

[email protected]

MBA homepage: www.mortgagebankers.org

MBA research page: www.mortgagebankers.org/research

Research Institute for Housing America:http://www.housingamerica.org

MBA Newslink:http://www.mortgagebankers.org/NewsandMedia/MBANewsLink

© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved

Page 36: 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT Multifamily ... · 2012 TRANSUNION PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SUMMIT. Multifamily Market Dynamics. Jamie Woodwell, Vice President, Commercial/Multifamily

MBA’s Commercial/Multifamily Real Estate Research Reports

www.mortgagebankers.org/research© 2012 Mortgage Bankers Association All Rights Reserved