Effective Designs and Practices for Formal Cooperative Learning

(Teamwork & Problem-Based Learning)

Karl A. SmithUniversity of Minnesota

ksmith@umn.eduwww.ce.umn.edu/~smith

Formal Cooperative Learning Task Groups

Design team failure is usually due to failed team dynamics (Leifer, Koseff & Lenshow, 1995).

It’s the soft stuff that’s hard, the hard stuff is easy (Doug Wilde, quoted in Leifer, 1997)

4

Top Three Main Engineering Work Activities

(Burton, Parker & LeBold, 1998)

Engineering Total• Design – 36%• Computer

applications – 31%• Management –

29%

Civil/Architectural1. Management –

45%2. Design – 39%3. Computer

applications – 20%

Burton, L., Parker, L, & LeBold, W. 1998. U.S. engineering career trends. ASEE Prism, 7(9), 18-21.

5

Pseudo-group

Traditional G roup

C ooperative G roup

H igh-perform ing C ooperative G roup

Individual M em bers

PE

RF

OR

MA

NC

E L

EV

EL

TYPE O F G R O U P

Teamwork

6

Characteristics of Effective Groups• Record your list

A team is a small number of people with complementary skills who are committed to a common purpose, performance goals, and approach for which they hold themselves mutually accountable

• SMALL NUMBER• COMPLEMENTARY SKILLS• COMMON PURPOSE & PERFORMANCE GOALS• COMMON APPROACH• MUTUAL ACCOUNTABILITY

--Katzenbach & SmithThe Wisdom of Teams

8

--Katzenbach & Smith (2001) The Discipline ofTeams

Six Basic Principles of Team Discipline

! Keep team membership small

! Ensure that members have complimentary skills

! Develop a common purpose

! Set common goals

! Establish a commonly agreed upon workingapproach

! Integrate mutual and individual accountability

Cooperative Learning is instruction that involves people working in teams to accomplish a common goal, under conditions that involve both positive interdependence (all members must cooperate to complete the task) and individual and group accountability (each member is accountable for the complete final outcome).

Key Concepts

•Positive Interdependence•Individual and Group Accountability•Face-to-Face Promotive Interaction•Teamwork Skills•Group Processing

11

Teamwork Skills

•Communication• Listening and Persuading

•Decision Making•Conflict Management•Leadership

Group Task and Maintenance Roles

Group Task Roles Group Maintenance Roles

Initiating Encouraging

Seeking Information Expressing Feelings

Giving Information Harmonizing

Seeking Opinions Compromising

Giving Opinions Facilitating Communications

Clarifying Setting Standards or Goals

Elaborating Testing Agreement

Summarizing Following

•Team Charter

• Team name, membership, and roles• Team Mission Statement• Anticipated results (goals)• Specific tactical objectives• Ground rules/Guiding principles for team participation• Shared expectations/aspirations

Code of Cooperation

•EVERY member is responsible for the team’s progress and success.•Attend all team meetings and be on time.•Come prepared.•Carry out assignments on schedule.•Listen to and show respect for the contributions of other members; be an active

listener.•CONSTRUCTIVELY criticize ideas, not persons.•Resolve conflicts constructively,•Pay attention, avoid disruptive behavior.•Avoid disruptive side conversations.•Only one person speaks at a time.•Everyone participates, no one dominates.•Be succinct, avoid long anecdotes and examples.•No rank in the room.•Respect those not present.•Ask questions when you do not understand.•Attend to your personal comfort needs at any time but minimize team disruption.•HAVE FUN!!•?Adapted from Boeing Aircraft Group Team Member Training Manual

15

Ten Commandments: An Affective Code of Cooperation

• Help each other be right, not wrong.• Look for ways to make new ideas work, not for reasons they won't.• If in doubt, check it out! Don't make negative assumptions about each other.• Help each other win, and take pride in each other's victories.• Speak positively about each other and about your organization at every opportunity.• Maintain a positive mental attitude no matter what the circumstances.• Act with initiative and courage, as if it all depends on you.• Do everything with enthusiasm; it's contagious.• Whatever you want; give it away.• Don't lose faith.• Have fun

Ford Motor Company

16

Group Ground Rules Contract Form (Adapted from a form developed by Dr. Deborah Allen, University of Delaware)

Project groups are an effective aid to learning, but to work best they require that all groups members clearly understand their responsibilities to one another. These project group ground rules describe the general responsibilities of every member to the group. You can adopt additional ground rules if your group believes they are needed. Your signature on this contract form signifies your commitment to adhere to these rules and expectations. All group members agree to:

1. Come to class and team meetings on time. 2. Come to class and team meetings with assignments and other necessary

preparations done. Additional ground rules:

1.

2. If a member of the project team repeatedly fails to meet these ground rules, other members of the group are expected to take the following actions: Step 1: (fill in this step with your group) If not resolved: Step 2: Bring the issue to the attention of the teaching team. If not resolved: Step 3: Meet as a group with the teaching team. The teaching team reserves the right to make the final decisions to resolve difficulties that arise within the groups. Before this becomes necessary, the team should try to find a fair and equitable solution to the problem. Member’s Signatures: Group Number:______________ 1.____________________________ 2.____________________________

3.____________________________ 4.____________________________

Group Processing Plus/Delta Format

PlusThings That Group Did Well

DeltaThings Group Could Improve

Formal Cooperative Learning

1. Jigsaw

2. Peer Composition or Editing

3. Reading Comprehension/Interpretation

4. Problem Solving, Project, or Presentation

5. Review/Correct Homework

6. Constructive Academic Controversy

7. Group Tests

Professor's Role inFormal Cooperative Learning

1. Specifying Objectives

2. Making Decisions

3. Explaining Task, Positive Interdependence, and Individual Accountability

4. Monitoring and Intervening to Teach Skills

5. Evaluating Students' Achievement and Group Effectiveness

Comparison of Learning Groups

Less Structured (Traditional) More Structured (Cooperative)

Low interdependence. Members takeresponsibility only for self. Focus is onindividual performance only.

High positive interdependence. Membersare responsible for own and each other’slearning. Focus is on joint performance.

Individual accountability only Both group and individual accountability. Members hold self and others accountablefor high quality work.

Assignments are discussed with littlecommitment to each other’s learning.

Members promote each other’s success. The do real work together and help andsupport each other’s efforts to learn.

Teamwork skills are ignored. Leader isappointed to direct members’ participation.

Teamwork skills are emphasized. Membersare taught and expected to use social skills. All members share leadershipresponsibilities.

No group processing of the quality of itswork. Individual accomplishments arerewarded.

Group processes quality of work and howeffectively members are working together. Continuous improvement is emphasized.rewarded. Continuous improvement is emphasized.

Kolb=s Experiential Learning Cycle

Observation and Reflections

Concrete Experience

Formulation of abstract concepts and generalizations

Testing implicationsof concepts innew situations

Problem-Based Learning

Problem posed

Identify what weneed to know

Learn it

Apply it

START

Subject-Based Learning

Told what weneed to know

Learn it

Given problem toillustrate how to use it

START

Normative Professional Curriculum:

1. Teach the relevant basic science,

2. Teach the relevant applied science, and

3. Allow for a practicum to connect the science to actual practice.

Problem-Based Learning (PBL)

Problem-based learning is the learning that results from the process of working toward the understanding or resolution of a problem. The problem is encountered first in the learning process B Barrows and Tamlyn, 1980

Core Features of PBL$ Learning is student-centered$ Learning occurs in small student groups$ Teachers are facilitators or guides$ Problems are the organizing focus and stimulus for learning$ Problems are the vehicle for the development of

clinical problem-solving skills$ New information is acquired through self-directed

learning

Problem Based Cooperative Learning Format

TASK: Solve the problem(s) or Complete the project.

INDIVIDUAL: Estimate answer. Note strategy.

COOPERATIVE: One set of answers from the group, strive for agreement, make sure everyone is able to explain the strategies used to solve each problem.

EXPECTED CRITERIA FOR SUCCESS: Everyone must be able to explain the strategies used to solve each problem.

EVALUATION: Best answer within available resources or constraints.

INDIVIDUAL ACCOUNTABILITY: One member from your group may be randomly chosen to explain (a) the answer and (b) how to solve each problem.

EXPECTED BEHAVIORS: Active participating, checking, encouraging, and elaborating by all members.

INTERGROUP COOPERATION: Whenever it is helpful, check procedures, answers, and strategies with another group.

Cooperative Learning Research Support Johnson, D.W., Johnson, R.T., & Smith, K.A. 1998. Cooperative learning

returns to college: What evidence is there that it works? Change, 30 (4), 26-35.

• Over 300 Experimental Studies• First study conducted in 1924• High Generalizability• Multiple Outcomes

Outcomes

1. Achievement and retention2. Critical thinking and higher-level

reasoning3. Differentiated views of others4. Accurate understanding of others'

perspectives5. Liking for classmates and teacher6. Liking for subject areas7. Teamwork skills

Small-Group Learning: Meta-analysis

Springer, L., Stanne, M. E., & Donovan, S. 1999. Effects of small-group learning on undergraduates in science, mathematics, engineering, and technology: A meta-

analysis. Review of Educational Research, 69(1), 21-52.

Small-group (predominantly cooperative) learning in postsecondary science, mathematics, engineering, and technology (SMET). 383 reports from 1980 or later, 39 of which met the rigorous inclusion criteria for meta-analysis.

The main effect of small-group learning on achievement, persistence, and attitudes among undergraduates in SMET was significant and positive. Mean effect sizes for achievement, persistence, and attitudes were 0.51, 0.46, and 0.55, respectively.

Strategies for Energizing Large

Classes: From Small Groups to

Learning Communities:

Jean MacGregor,James Cooper,

Karl Smith,Pamela Robinson

New Directions for Teaching and Learning,

No. 81, 2000.Jossey- Bass

From Small Groups to Learning Communities: Energizing Large Classes

1. The argument for making large classes seem small2. Getting started: Informal small-group strategies in

large classes3. Going deeper: Formal small-group learning in large

classes (included in handout)4. Restructuring large classes to create communities of

learners5. Implementing small-group learning: Insights from

successful practitioners6. Making small-group learning and learning

communities a widespread reality

29

The Harvard Assessment Seminars B Richard J. Light

All the specific findings point to, and illustrate, one main idea. It is that students who get the most out of college, who grow the most academically, and who are the happiest, organize their time to include interpersonal activities with faculty members, or with fellow students, built around substantive, academic work.

Environmental Factors That Enhance Students= Academic and Personal Development and SatisfactionAlexander Astin in What matters in college:

Four critical years revisited. Jossey-Bass, 1993.

Student-student interactionStudent-faculty interactionA faculty that is very student-orientedDiscussing racial/ethnic issues with other studentsHours devoted to studying B Time on taskTutoring other studentsSocializing with students of different race/ethnicityA student body that has high socioeconomic statusAn institutional emphasis on diversityA faculty that is positive about the general education programA student body that values altruism and social activism

30

Making the Most of CollegeRichard J. Light

Harvard University Press (2001)

1. Meet the faculty2. Take a mix of courses3. Study in groups4. Write, write, write5. Speak another language6. Consider time7. Hold the drum

31

Fostering Student Engagement in Learning: Lessons from Recent Research

Alexander AstinCollaboration (May, 2001)

1. Service-learning2. Interdisciplinary studies3. Common courses4. Extensive writing5. Collaborative learning6. Independent study7. Multiculturalism

32

Key Features of Cooperative Learning

Active/InteractiveCooperativePersonal (before professional)Structure (before task)Knee-to-Knee, Eye-to-Eye/Space/FocusChallenging task (worthy of group effort)Students talking through the material (cognitive rehearsal)Learning groups are small (2-5) and assignedHeterogeneousYour own cooperative group

33

The biggest and most long-lasting reforms of undergraduate education will come when individual faculty or small groups of instructors adopt the view of themselves as reformers within their immediate sphere of influence, the classes they teach every day.

K. Patricia Cross

34

We never educate directly, but indirectly by means of the environment. Whether we permit chance environments to do the work, or whether we design environments for the purpose makes a great difference.John Dewey, 1906

It could well be that faculty members of the twenty-first century college or university will find it necessary to set aside their roles as teachers and instead become designers of learning experiences, processes, and environments James Duderstadt, 1999

35

Cooperative Lesson Planning Form Grade Level: __________ Subject Area: ____________________ Date:__________

Lesson: ________________________________________________________________

Objectives

Academic: ______________________________________________________________

Teamwork Skills: _______________________________________________________

Preinstructional Decisions

Group Size: __________ Method Of Assigning Students: ____________________

Roles: _________________________________________________________________

Room Arrangement: ____________________________________________________

Materials: _____________________________________________________________

One Copy Per Group One Copy Per Person

J igsaw Tournament

Other: ______________________

Explain Task And Cooperative Goal Structure

1. Task: _______________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

2. Criteria For Success: _________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

3. Positive Interdependence: ____________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

4. Individual Accountability: ___________________________________________

5. Intergroup Cooperation: ______________________________________________

6. Expected Behaviors: ____________________________________________________

36

Monitoring And Intervening

1. Observation Procedure: ______ Formal ______ Informal

2. Observation By: ______ Teacher ______ Students ______ Visitors

3. Intervening For Task Assistance: _____________________________________

______________________________________________________________________

4. Intervening For Teamwork Assistance: ________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

5. Other: ______________________________________________________________

Evaluating And Processing

1. Assessment Of Members’ Individual Learning: _________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

2. Assessment Of Group Productivity: ___________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

3. Small Group Processing: _____________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

4. Whole Class Processing: _____________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

5. Charts And Graphs Used: ____________________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

6. Positive Feedback To Each Student: __________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

7. Goal Setting For Improvement: _______________________________________

____________________________________________________________________

8. Celebration: _________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________

9. Other: ______________________________________________________________