STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 1 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-1 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 1 63.03-1-1 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 120,000 766.95 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 120,000 County Tax 120,000 636.31 3761 E Lake Rd 12-1-2.1 120,000 Community Colleges 120,000 133.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 1000.00 DPTH 1394.00 Town Tax 120,000 62.03 EAST-0953627 NRTH-0913144 Chargebacks 120,000 2.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,832 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 120,000 TO 213.23 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 1,839.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,839.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-2 ****************** 3700 E Lake Rd BILL 2 63.03-1-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 37,000 236.48 Corsoro Julie E Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,300 County Tax 37,000 196.19 3700 East Lake Rd 12-1-3 37,000 Community Colleges 37,000 41.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 231.00 Town Tax 37,000 19.12 EAST-0954804 NRTH-0912512 Chargebacks 37,000 0.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,748 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 37,000 TO 65.75 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 64.35 MT 64.35 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 699.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 699.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-4 ****************** Rt 5 BILL 3 63.03-1-4 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 119,000 760.56 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 119,000 County Tax 119,000 631.00 11593 Beachcliff Dr 13-1-2 119,000 Community Colleges 119,000 132.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 26.40 Town Tax 119,000 61.51 EAST-0955413 NRTH-0913415 Chargebacks 119,000 2.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,434 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 119,000 TO 211.45 TOTAL TAX --- 1,799.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,799.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-7 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 4 63.03-1-7 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 19,400 123.99 Payne Fred V Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,800 County Tax 19,400 102.87 3050 Kings Rd 13-3-11.1 19,400 Community Colleges 19,400 21.62 Saint Augustine, FL 32086 ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 19,400 10.03 EAST-0956246 NRTH-0913066 Chargebacks 19,400 0.36 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,133 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 19,400 TO 34.47 TOTAL TAX --- 293.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 293.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 2 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-8 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 5 63.03-1-8 447 Truck termnl Medicaid 34,000 217.30 Trinity Circle LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,400 County Tax 34,000 180.29 3761 East Lake Rd 13-3-11.2.1 34,000 Community Colleges 34,000 37.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 682.00 Town Tax 34,000 17.57 EAST-0956175 NRTH-0913007 Chargebacks 34,000 0.63 DEED BOOK 1957 PG-00079 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 34,000 TO 60.42 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,552 TOTAL TAX --- 514.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 514.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-9 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 6 63.03-1-9 447 Truck termnl Medicaid 107,900 689.61 Trinity Circle LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,400 County Tax 107,900 572.14 3761 East Lake Rd 13-3-11.2.2 107,900 Community Colleges 107,900 120.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 107,900 55.77 EAST-0956096 NRTH-0912942 Chargebacks 107,900 2.00 DEED BOOK 1957 PG-00079 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 107,900 TO 191.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 150,909 TOTAL TAX --- 1,631.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,631.48 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-10 ***************** 3653 E Lake Rd BILL 7 63.03-1-10 447 Truck termnl - ASSOC Medicaid 346,930 2,217.31 Trinity Circle LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,500 County Tax 346,930 1,839.61 3761 East Lake Rd 13-3-10 346,930 Community Colleges 346,930 386.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 346,930 179.32 EAST-0956011 NRTH-0912880 Chargebacks 346,930 6.42 FULL MARKET VALUE 485,217 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 346,930 TO 616.47 TOTAL TAX --- 5,245.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,245.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-11 ***************** 3661 E Lake Rd BILL 8 63.03-1-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,800 62.63 Trinity Circle LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 County Tax 9,800 51.96 3761 East Lake Rd 13-3-9 9,800 Community Colleges 9,800 10.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Town Tax 9,800 5.07 EAST-0955880 NRTH-0912804 Chargebacks 9,800 0.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,706 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,800 TO 17.41 TOTAL TAX --- 148.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 148.17 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 3 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-12 ***************** 3667 E Lake Rd BILL 9 63.03-1-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,600 61.36 Ferrante Kathleen M Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,600 County Tax 9,600 50.90 Greene Kenneth D 13-3-8 9,600 Community Colleges 9,600 10.70 104 Spencer Rd ACRES 2.30 Town Tax 9,600 4.96 Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 EAST-0955717 NRTH-0912678 Chargebacks 9,600 0.18 DEED BOOK 1696 PG-00210 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,600 TO 17.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,427 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 3.00 MT 3.00 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 223.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 223.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-13 ***************** 3673 E Lake Rd BILL 10 63.03-1-13 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,000 428.21 Salgado Feliciano Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 County Tax 67,000 355.27 Salgado Noelia 13-3-7 67,000 Community Colleges 67,000 74.66 3673 East Lake Rd ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 67,000 34.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955604 NRTH-0912581 Chargebacks 67,000 1.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,706 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 67,000 TO 119.05 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,088.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,088.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-14 ***************** 3677 E Lake Rd BILL 11 63.03-1-14 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Wisniewski James J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 Medicaid 78,090 499.09 Wisniewski Carolyn S 13-3-6 82,500 County Tax 78,090 414.08 3677 East Lake Rd ACRES 1.10 Community Colleges 78,090 87.02 PO Box 506 EAST-0955525 NRTH-0912520 Town Tax 82,500 42.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FULL MARKET VALUE 115,385 Chargebacks 82,500 1.53 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 82,500 TO 146.60 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 821.70 MT 821.70 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 2,088.25** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,088.25 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 4 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-15 ***************** 3681 E Lake Rd BILL 12 63.03-1-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,100 51.77 Wisniewski James J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 County Tax 8,100 42.95 Wisniewski Carolyn S 13-3-5 8,100 Community Colleges 8,100 9.03 3677 East Lake Rd ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 8,100 4.19 PO Box 506 EAST-0955450 NRTH-0912455 Chargebacks 8,100 0.15 Dunkirk, NY 14048 DEED BOOK 1958 PG-00078 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,100 TO 14.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,329 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 147.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 147.48 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-16 ***************** 3685 E Lake Rd BILL 13 63.03-1-16 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 13,200 84.36 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,200 County Tax 13,200 69.99 6523 S Transit Rd 13-3-4 13,200 Community Colleges 13,200 14.71 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 13,200 6.82 EAST-0955370 NRTH-0912404 Chargebacks 13,200 0.24 DEED BOOK 1978 PG-00399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 13,200 TO 23.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,462 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 224.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 224.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-17 ***************** 3689 E Lake Rd BILL 14 63.03-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 57,370 366.66 Doyle Walter J IV Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 57,370 304.21 3689 East Lake Rd 13-3-3 57,370 Community Colleges 57,370 63.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.03 Town Tax 57,370 29.65 EAST-0955270 NRTH-0912370 Chargebacks 57,370 1.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,238 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,370 TO 101.94 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 943.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 943.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-18 ***************** 3693 E Lake Rd BILL 15 63.03-1-18 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,400 Tampio James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 3693 East Lake Rd 13-3-2 53,970 VET DIS C 41142 8,096 0 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 391.00 Medicaid 38,524 246.22 EAST-0955183 NRTH-0912344 County Tax 38,524 204.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,483 Community Colleges 38,524 42.93 Town Tax 51,570 26.66 Chargebacks 51,570 0.95 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,970 TO 95.90 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 692.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 692.53 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 5 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-19 ***************** 3695 E Lake Rd BILL 16 63.03-1-19 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 88,500 565.62 Brinkman Helen P Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,100 County Tax 88,500 469.28 3695 East Lake Rd 13-3-1 88,500 Community Colleges 88,500 98.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 88,500 45.74 EAST-0955060 NRTH-0912329 Chargebacks 88,500 1.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,776 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 88,500 TO 157.26 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 3.00 UN 226.76 TOTAL TAX --- 1,564.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,564.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-20 ***************** 3701 E Lake Rd BILL 17 63.03-1-20 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 2,100 13.42 Brinkman Helen P Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 2,100 11.14 3695 E Lake Rd 6-1-26.1 2,100 Community Colleges 2,100 2.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 0.50 DPTH 2.38 Town Tax 2,100 1.09 ACRES 0.90 Chargebacks 2,100 0.04 EAST-0955156 NRTH-0912153 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,100 TO 3.73 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00417 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,937 TOTAL TAX --- 31.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 31.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-21 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 18 63.03-1-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,300 8.31 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 6523 S Transit Rd 6-1-26.3 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 EAST-0955351 NRTH-0912077 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 DEED BOOK 2253 PG-147 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 TOTAL TAX --- 19.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-22 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 19 63.03-1-22 321 Abandoned ag Medicaid 6,200 39.63 Payne Fred V Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,200 County Tax 6,200 32.88 3050 Kigns Rd 13-3-13 6,200 Community Colleges 6,200 6.91 St Augustine, FL 32086 ACRES 12.40 Town Tax 6,200 3.20 EAST-0956213 NRTH-0912439 Chargebacks 6,200 0.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,671 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,200 TO 11.02 TOTAL TAX --- 93.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 93.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 6 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-23 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 20 63.03-1-23 321 Abandoned ag Medicaid 17,000 108.65 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,000 County Tax 17,000 90.14 6523 Transit Dr S 6-1-27 17,000 Community Colleges 17,000 18.94 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 29.60 Town Tax 17,000 8.79 EAST-0955826 NRTH-0911411 Chargebacks 17,000 0.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,776 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 17,000 TO 30.21 TOTAL TAX --- 257.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 257.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-24 ***************** 3701 E Lake Rd BILL 21 63.03-1-24 416 Mfg hsing pk Medicaid 443,200 2,832.59 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 41,600 County Tax 443,200 2,350.09 6523 S Transit Rd 6-1-26.2 443,200 Community Colleges 443,200 493.86 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 3.20 Town Tax 443,200 229.08 EAST-0955004 NRTH-0912070 Chargebacks 443,200 8.20 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00417 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 443,200 TO 787.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 619,860 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 40.50 UN 3,061.20 TOTAL TAX --- 9,762.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9,762.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-2 ****************** 3816 Lake Shore Dr E BILL 22 63.17-1-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 33,500 214.11 Strefeler Joseph Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,300 County Tax 33,500 177.64 3816 Lake Shore Dr E 12-1-32.1 33,500 Community Colleges 33,500 37.33 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 58.70 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 33,500 17.32 EAST-0952572 NRTH-0910863 Chargebacks 33,500 0.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,853 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 33,500 TO 59.53 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 582.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 582.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-3 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 23 63.17-1-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 41,500 265.24 Woloszyn Nancy Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 41,500 220.06 55 Ounce St 12-1-31.1 41,500 Community Colleges 41,500 46.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.38 Town Tax 41,500 21.45 EAST-0952591 NRTH-0910970 Chargebacks 41,500 0.77 DEED BOOK 1955 PG-00504 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 41,500 TO 73.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,042 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 703.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 703.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 7 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-4 ****************** 3808 E Lake Rd BILL 24 63.17-1-4 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Mleczko Anthony Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Mleczko Bernice 12-1-31.2 123,800 Medicaid 118,800 759.28 3808 East Lake Rd ACRES 0.73 County Tax 118,800 629.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952618 NRTH-0911089 Community Colleges 118,800 132.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 173,147 Town Tax 106,024 54.80 Chargebacks 106,024 1.96 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 123,800 TO 219.98 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 2.00 UN 151.17 TOTAL TAX --- 1,949.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,949.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-5 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 25 63.17-1-5 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Szalkowski Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 3804 E Lake Rd 12-1-31.3 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 390.90 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 EAST-0952663 NRTH-0911137 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 TOTAL TAX --- 15.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-6 ****************** 3804 E Lake Rd BILL 26 63.17-1-6 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,755 Szalkowski Richard E Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,500 VETS CNTY 41102 775 0 3804 E Lake Rd 12-1-30 50,500 Medicaid 49,725 317.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.87 County Tax 49,725 263.67 EAST-0952672 NRTH-0911212 Community Colleges 49,725 55.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,629 Town Tax 47,745 24.68 Chargebacks 47,745 0.88 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,500 TO 89.73 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 827.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 827.76 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 8 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-7 ****************** 3792 E Lake Rd BILL 27 63.17-1-7 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 66,500 425.02 Koprowski Kenneth J Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,800 County Tax 66,500 352.62 3792 E Lake Road 12-1-29 66,500 Community Colleges 66,500 74.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.60 Town Tax 66,500 34.37 EAST-0952690 NRTH-0911659 Chargebacks 66,500 1.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,007 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 66,500 TO 118.16 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,081.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,081.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-8 ****************** 3788 E Lake Rd BILL 28 63.17-1-8 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Anders Arthur J Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,100 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Anders A 12-1-28 53,000 Medicaid 48,000 306.78 3788 E Lake Rd FRNT 60.00 DPTH 200.00 County Tax 48,000 254.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953104 NRTH-0911305 Community Colleges 48,000 53.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,126 Town Tax 35,224 18.21 Chargebacks 35,224 0.65 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,000 TO 94.18 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 803.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 803.42 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-9 ****************** 3786 E Lake Rd BILL 29 63.17-1-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 56,000 357.91 Deszcz John B III Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 56,000 296.94 3786 East Lake Rd 12-1-27 56,000 Community Colleges 56,000 62.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 56,000 28.95 EAST-0953025 NRTH-0911519 Chargebacks 56,000 1.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,322 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,000 TO 99.51 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 922.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 922.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 9 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-10 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 30 63.17-1-10 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 69,500 444.19 Bromberg Matthew K Dunkirk Csd 060300 26,500 County Tax 69,500 368.53 638 Central Ave 12-1-26 69,500 Community Colleges 69,500 77.44 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 20.40 Town Tax 69,500 35.92 EAST-0952972 NRTH-0912175 Chargebacks 69,500 1.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,203 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,500 TO 123.50 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 621.35 MT 621.35 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 2.00 UN 151.17 TOTAL TAX --- 1,823.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,823.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-11 ***************** 11616 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 31 63.17-1-11 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Forbes Lukas P Dunkirk Csd 060300 40,100 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 11616 Cedar Cliff Dr 12-1-1 132,210 Medicaid 127,210 813.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.30 County Tax 127,210 674.54 EAST-0952960 NRTH-0912965 Community Colleges 127,210 141.75 FULL MARKET VALUE 184,909 Town Tax 114,434 59.15 Chargebacks 114,434 2.12 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 132,210 TO 234.93 TOTAL TAX --- 1,925.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,925.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-12 ***************** 11579 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 32 63.17-1-12 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 76,430 488.48 Farrell Cathleen Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 County Tax 76,430 405.27 11579 Cedar Cliff Dr 12-1-19 76,430 Community Colleges 76,430 85.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 76,430 39.51 EAST-0953254 NRTH-0912300 Chargebacks 76,430 1.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,895 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 76,430 TO 135.81 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,231.24** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,231.24 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 10 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-13 ***************** 11565 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 33 63.17-1-13 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,395 Szocki Agnes Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 VETS CNTY 41102 450 0 11565 Cedar Cliff Dr 12-1-20 80,000 Medicaid 79,550 508.42 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 100.00 County Tax 79,550 421.82 EAST-0953414 NRTH-0912116 Community Colleges 79,550 88.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,888 Town Tax 78,605 40.63 Chargebacks 78,605 1.45 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 80,000 TO 142.15 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,278.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,278.70 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-14 ***************** 11557 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 34 63.17-1-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 79,250 506.51 Penfold Priscilla N Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 79,250 420.23 11557 Cedar Cliff Dr 12-1-21 79,250 Community Colleges 79,250 88.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 79,250 40.96 EAST-0953488 NRTH-0912029 Chargebacks 79,250 1.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 110,839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 79,250 TO 140.82 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 19.15 MT 19.15 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,293.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,293.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-15 ***************** 11553 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 35 63.17-1-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 62,180 397.41 Favata Christine M Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 County Tax 62,180 329.71 11553 Cedar Cliff Dr 12-1-22 62,180 Community Colleges 62,180 69.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 62,180 32.14 EAST-0953568 NRTH-0911938 Chargebacks 62,180 1.15 DEED BOOK 2675 PG-444 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 62,180 TO 110.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,965 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,015.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,015.78 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 11 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-16 ***************** 11545 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 36 63.17-1-16 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Mctigue Thomas M Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,500 Medicaid 57,090 364.88 Mctigue Maureen 12-1-23 61,500 County Tax 57,090 302.72 11545 Cedar Cliff Dr FRNT 151.90 DPTH 113.80 Community Colleges 57,090 63.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953655 NRTH-0911838 Town Tax 61,500 31.79 DEED BOOK 2114 PG-00453 Chargebacks 61,500 1.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,014 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,500 TO 109.28 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 949.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 949.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-17 ***************** 11535 Cedar Cliff Dr BILL 37 63.17-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 52,500 335.54 Medina Carlos A Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 52,500 278.38 Ameno Yvonne 12-1-24 52,500 Community Colleges 52,500 58.50 11535 Cedar Cliff Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 52,500 27.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953748 NRTH-0911726 Chargebacks 52,500 0.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,427 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 52,500 TO 93.29 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 869.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 869.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-18 ***************** 3760 E Lake Rd BILL 38 63.17-1-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 53,000 338.74 Shevlin Jeffrey Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 53,000 281.03 3760 Lake Shore Dr 12-1-25 53,000 Community Colleges 53,000 59.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 183.00 Town Tax 53,000 27.39 EAST-0953661 NRTH-0911667 Chargebacks 53,000 0.98 DEED BOOK 1701 PG-00127 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,000 TO 94.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,126 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 876.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 876.97 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 12 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-19 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 39 63.17-1-19 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,755 Lawhon Susan Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,100 VETS CNTY 41102 775 0 Lawhon Wallace 6-1-12 68,000 Medicaid 67,225 429.65 50 Howard St Apt 232 ACRES 0.40 County Tax 67,225 356.46 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0953545 NRTH-0911306 Community Colleges 67,225 74.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,105 Town Tax 65,245 33.72 Chargebacks 65,245 1.21 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,000 TO 120.83 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 43.45 MT 43.45 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,135.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,135.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-20 ***************** S.e. Of Rt5 BILL 40 63.17-1-20 311 Res vac land Medicaid 600 3.83 Lawhon Susan Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 Wallace Gerald 6-1-5.2 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 50 Howard St Apt 232 ACRES 0.80 Town Tax 600 0.31 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0953617 NRTH-0911129 Chargebacks 600 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 TOTAL TAX --- 9.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-21 ***************** 3775 E Lake Rd BILL 41 63.17-1-21 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,778 Mekus Craig E Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,000 VETS CNTY 41102 500 0 Mekus Judy L 6-1-11 49,000 Medicaid 48,500 309.97 3775 East Lake Rd ACRES 0.24 County Tax 48,500 257.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953468 NRTH-0911264 Community Colleges 48,500 54.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,531 Town Tax 47,222 24.41 Chargebacks 47,222 0.87 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,000 TO 87.07 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 809.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 809.12 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 13 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-22 ***************** 3779 E Lake Rd BILL 42 63.17-1-22 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 51,000 325.95 Taber Charity Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,000 County Tax 51,000 270.43 3779 E Lake Rd 6-1-10 51,000 Community Colleges 51,000 56.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.24 Town Tax 51,000 26.36 EAST-0953410 NRTH-0911223 Chargebacks 51,000 0.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,329 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 51,000 TO 90.62 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 846.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 846.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-23 ***************** 3783 E Lake Rd BILL 43 63.17-1-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 73,660 470.78 Panfil Carl P Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 County Tax 73,660 390.59 Maryanne Lee 6-1-9 73,660 Community Colleges 73,660 82.08 3783 East Lake Rd FRNT 70.00 DPTH 145.00 Town Tax 73,660 38.07 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953351 NRTH-0911183 Chargebacks 73,660 1.36 DEED BOOK 2132 PG-00419 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,660 TO 130.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,021 GE001 Miscellaneous charge .00 MT SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,189.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,189.36 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-24 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 44 63.17-1-24 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Miner Philip B Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Miner Kathleen L 6-1-8 56,000 Medicaid 47,180 301.54 3785 E Lake Rd FRNT 70.00 DPTH 145.00 County Tax 47,180 250.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953292 NRTH-0911144 Community Colleges 47,180 52.57 DEED BOOK 2684 PG-598 Town Tax 56,000 28.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,322 Chargebacks 56,000 1.04 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,000 TO 99.51 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 809.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 809.37 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 14 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-25 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 45 63.17-1-25 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 52,020 332.47 Normand Michael S Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 County Tax 52,020 275.84 Normand Jennifer L 6-1-7 52,020 Community Colleges 52,020 57.97 3797 East Lake Rd ACRES 0.23 Town Tax 52,020 26.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953070 NRTH-0910988 Chargebacks 52,020 0.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,755 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 52,020 TO 92.44 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 862.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 862.16 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-26 ***************** 3799 E Lake Rd BILL 46 63.17-1-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 49,500 316.37 Bekeleski Diane M Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,100 County Tax 49,500 262.48 3799 E Lake Rd 6-1-6 49,500 Community Colleges 49,500 55.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 76.30 DPTH 146.00 Town Tax 49,500 25.59 EAST-0953008 NRTH-0910945 Chargebacks 49,500 0.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,231 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,500 TO 87.96 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 824.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 824.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-1 ****************** Wildwood Dr BILL 47 63.17-2-1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,900 44.10 Kahabka Loyd J Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,900 County Tax 6,900 36.59 Kahabka Judith A 12-1-18 6,900 Community Colleges 6,900 7.69 3758 Wildwood Dr FRNT 110.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 6,900 3.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953435 NRTH-0912328 Chargebacks 6,900 0.13 DEED BOOK 1878 PG-00199 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,900 TO 12.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,650 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 129.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 129.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-2 ****************** 3758 Wildwood Dr BILL 48 63.17-2-2 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Kahabka Loyd J Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 Medicaid 66,090 422.40 Kahabka Judith A 12-1-17 70,500 County Tax 66,090 350.45 3758 Wildwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Community Colleges 66,090 73.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953507 NRTH-0912239 Town Tax 70,500 36.44 DEED BOOK 1878 PG-00199 Chargebacks 70,500 1.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 98,601 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 70,500 TO 125.27 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,085.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,085.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 15 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-3 ****************** 3754 Wildwood Dr BILL 49 63.17-2-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,000 389.87 Mcgraw Christine L Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 61,000 323.46 3754 Wildwood Dr 12-1-16 61,000 Community Colleges 61,000 67.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 61,000 31.53 EAST-0953595 NRTH-0912297 Chargebacks 61,000 1.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,315 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,000 TO 108.39 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 997.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 997.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-4 ****************** 3750 Wildwood Dr BILL 50 63.17-2-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 82,500 527.28 Szczublewski Mary Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 82,500 437.46 3750 Wildwood Dr 12-1-15 82,500 Community Colleges 82,500 91.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 82,500 42.64 EAST-0953675 NRTH-0912355 Chargebacks 82,500 1.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 115,385 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 82,500 TO 146.60 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,323.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,323.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-5 ****************** 3748 Wildwood Dr BILL 51 63.17-2-5 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,600 42.18 Szczublewski Mary Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 6,600 35.00 3750 Wildwood Dr 12-1-14 6,600 Community Colleges 6,600 7.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 6,600 3.41 EAST-0953758 NRTH-0912412 Chargebacks 6,600 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,231 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,600 TO 11.73 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 124.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 124.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-6 ****************** 11593 Beach Cliff Dr BILL 52 63.17-2-6 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 105,860 676.58 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 105,860 561.33 11593 Beach Cliff Dr 12-1-12 105,860 Community Colleges 105,860 117.96 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 203.00 Town Tax 105,860 54.72 EAST-0953718 NRTH-0912539 Chargebacks 105,860 1.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 148,056 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 105,860 TO 188.10 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,676.24** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,676.24 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 16 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-7 ****************** 11593 Beach Cliff Dr BILL 53 63.17-2-7 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 13,100 83.73 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,000 County Tax 13,100 69.46 11593 Beach Cliff Dr 12-1-2.2 13,100 Community Colleges 13,100 14.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 49.50 DPTH 190.00 Town Tax 13,100 6.77 EAST-0953661 NRTH-0912599 Chargebacks 13,100 0.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,322 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 13,100 TO 23.28 TOTAL TAX --- 198.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 198.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-8 ****************** 3742 Wildwood Dr BILL 54 63.17-2-8 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 72,500 463.36 Bartkowiak Charles E Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,700 County Tax 72,500 384.43 Bartkowiak Claire M 12-1-13 72,500 Community Colleges 72,500 80.79 3742 Wildwood Dr FRNT 135.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 72,500 37.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953848 NRTH-0912483 Chargebacks 72,500 1.34 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 72,500 TO 128.83 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,171.81** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,171.81 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-9 ****************** 3732 Wildwood Dr BILL 55 63.17-2-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 91,510 584.86 Thomas James Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,400 County Tax 91,510 485.24 3732 Wildwood Dr 12-1-10 91,510 Community Colleges 91,510 101.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 185.50 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 91,510 47.30 EAST-0953993 NRTH-0912640 Chargebacks 91,510 1.69 DEED BOOK 2131 PG-00113 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 91,510 TO 162.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,986 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 539.57 MT 539.57 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,998.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,998.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-10 ***************** 11594 Beach Cliff Dr BILL 56 63.17-2-10 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 135,000 862.82 Hallmark Joseph E Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 135,000 715.84 Hallmark Michele J 12-1-11 135,000 Community Colleges 135,000 150.43 11594 Beachcliff Dr FRNT 120.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 135,000 69.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953912 NRTH-0912736 Chargebacks 135,000 2.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 188,811 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 135,000 TO 239.88 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 2,116.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,116.84 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 17 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-11 ***************** Breezwood Dr BILL 57 63.17-2-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,300 8.31 Hallmark Joseph E Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 Hallmark Michele J 12-1-2.4 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 11594 Beachcliff Dr ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954013 NRTH-0912860 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 TOTAL TAX --- 19.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-12 ***************** 3729 Breezewood Dr BILL 58 63.17-2-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,300 8.31 Stegle Edward Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 Stegle Maureen A 12-1-2.5 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 3730 Wildwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954080 NRTH-0912934 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 DEED BOOK 2052 PG-00187 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 TOTAL TAX --- 19.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-13 ***************** Wildwood Dr BILL 59 63.17-2-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 7,200 46.02 Stegle Edward H III Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 County Tax 7,200 38.18 Stegle Maureen A 12-1-2.9 7,200 Community Colleges 7,200 8.02 3736 Wildwood Dr FRNT 120.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 7,200 3.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954226 NRTH-0912900 Chargebacks 7,200 0.13 DEED BOOK 2126 PG-00215 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,200 TO 12.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,070 TOTAL TAX --- 108.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 108.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-14 ***************** 3730 Wildwood Dr BILL 60 63.17-2-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 179,130 1,144.86 Stegle Edward J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 County Tax 179,130 949.84 Stegle Maureen A 12-1-2.3 179,130 Community Colleges 179,130 199.61 3730 Wildwood Dr FRNT 200.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 179,130 92.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954116 NRTH-0912785 Chargebacks 179,130 3.32 DEED BOOK 2052 PG-00187 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 179,130 TO 318.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 250,531 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 2,784.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,784.11 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 18 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-15 ***************** 3727 Wildwood Dr BILL 61 63.17-2-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,500 476.15 Szach Ronald Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 74,500 395.04 Szach Mary Jane 12-1-2.8 74,500 Community Colleges 74,500 83.02 3727 Wildwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 74,500 38.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954272 NRTH-0912707 Chargebacks 74,500 1.38 DEED BOOK 2113 PG-00527 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 74,500 TO 132.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,196 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,202.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,202.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-16 ***************** 3729 Wildwood Dr BILL 62 63.17-2-16 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Hellwig Timothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Hellwig Lisa A 12-1-2.7 100,000 Medicaid 95,000 607.17 3729 Wildwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 County Tax 95,000 503.74 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954204 NRTH-0912632 Community Colleges 95,000 105.86 DEED BOOK 2113 PG-00525 Town Tax 82,224 42.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 139,860 Chargebacks 82,224 1.52 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100,000 TO 177.69 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,514.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,514.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-17 ***************** 3731 Wildwood Dr BILL 63 63.17-2-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 94,000 600.78 Smith Robert L Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 94,000 498.44 Smith Patricia L 12-1-2.6 94,000 Community Colleges 94,000 104.74 3731 Wildwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 94,000 48.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954141 NRTH-0912556 Chargebacks 94,000 1.74 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-00268 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 94,000 TO 167.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 131,469 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,496.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,496.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-18 ***************** 3733 Wildwood Dr BILL 64 63.17-2-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 75,390 481.83 Smoczynski Harry D Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 75,390 399.76 3733 Wildwood Dr 12-1-9 75,390 Community Colleges 75,390 84.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 75,390 38.97 EAST-0954075 NRTH-0912483 Chargebacks 75,390 1.40 DEED BOOK 2057 PG-00109 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 75,390 TO 133.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 105,441 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,215.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,215.52 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 19 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-19 ***************** 3743 Wildwood Dr BILL 65 63.17-2-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 81,000 517.69 Levandoski Frank Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 County Tax 81,000 429.51 Levandoski Patricia 12-2-1.3 81,000 Community Colleges 81,000 90.26 PO Box 135 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 81,000 41.87 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953968 NRTH-0912357 Chargebacks 81,000 1.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 113,287 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 81,000 TO 143.93 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,300.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,300.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-20 ***************** 3747 Wildwood Dr BILL 66 63.17-2-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 73,000 466.56 Johnson Susan M Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 73,000 387.09 3747 Wildwood Dr 12-2-1.2 73,000 Community Colleges 73,000 81.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 73,000 37.73 EAST-0953878 NRTH-0912294 Chargebacks 73,000 1.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,098 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,000 TO 129.71 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,179.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,179.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-21 ***************** 3749 Wildwood Dr BILL 67 63.17-2-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,600 42.18 Szalkowski James Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 6,600 35.00 Poweski Wendy 12-2-1.5 6,600 Community Colleges 6,600 7.35 3746 Crestwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 6,600 3.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953800 NRTH-0912233 Chargebacks 6,600 0.12 DEED BOOK 2092 PG-00213 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,600 TO 11.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,231 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 124.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 124.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-22 ***************** Wildwood Dr BILL 68 63.17-2-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 11,200 71.58 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 County Tax 11,200 59.39 3761 E Lake Rd 12-2-1.1 11,200 Community Colleges 11,200 12.48 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 240.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 11,200 5.79 EAST-0953668 NRTH-0912141 Chargebacks 11,200 0.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,664 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 11,200 TO 19.90 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 194.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 194.35 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 20 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-23 ***************** 3754 Crestwood Dr BILL 69 63.17-2-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,500 393.06 Dolce Jordyn B Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 County Tax 61,500 326.11 Crane Benjamin E 12-2-5 61,500 Community Colleges 61,500 68.53 Crane David & Jean FRNT 120.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 61,500 31.79 3754 Crestwood Dr EAST-0953699 NRTH-0912032 Chargebacks 61,500 1.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 DEED BOOK 1830 PG-00239 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,500 TO 109.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,014 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,005.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,005.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-24 ***************** 3750 Crestwood Dr BILL 70 63.17-2-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 58,500 373.89 Bailey Sylvia Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,200 County Tax 58,500 310.20 3750 Crestwood Dr 12-2-4 58,500 Community Colleges 58,500 65.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.25 Town Tax 58,500 30.24 EAST-0953798 NRTH-0912095 Chargebacks 58,500 1.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 58,500 TO 103.95 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 960.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 960.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-25 ***************** 3746 Crestwood Dr BILL 71 63.17-2-25 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Szalkowski James Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 Medicaid 56,650 362.06 Poweski Wendy 12-2-3 64,000 County Tax 56,650 300.39 3746 Crestwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 Community Colleges 56,650 63.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953883 NRTH-0912156 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 949.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 949.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-26 ***************** 3742 Crestwood Dr BILL 72 63.17-2-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 58,000 370.69 Ganey Marie A Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 58,000 307.55 3742 Crestwood Dr 12-2-2 58,000 Community Colleges 58,000 64.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 58,000 29.98 EAST-0953964 NRTH-0912217 Chargebacks 58,000 1.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,119 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 58,000 TO 103.06 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 952.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 952.57 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 21 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-27 ***************** 3743 Crestwood Dr BILL 73 63.17-2-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 7,700 49.21 Levandoski Frank J Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,700 County Tax 7,700 40.83 PO Box 135 12-2-1.4 7,700 Community Colleges 7,700 8.58 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.10 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 7,700 3.98 EAST-0954050 NRTH-0912280 Chargebacks 7,700 0.14 DEED BOOK 1760 PG-00096 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,700 TO 13.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,769 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 141.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 141.42 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-28 ***************** 3737 Crestwood Dr BILL 74 63.17-2-28 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Hansen Walter R Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 Medicaid 52,590 336.11 3737 Crestwood Dr 12-3-4.2 57,000 County Tax 52,590 278.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 126.00 Community Colleges 52,590 58.60 EAST-0954165 NRTH-0912174 Town Tax 57,000 29.46 DEED BOOK 1835 PG-00555 Chargebacks 57,000 1.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,720 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,000 TO 101.28 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 880.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 880.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-29 ***************** 3739 Crestwood Dr BILL 75 63.17-2-29 311 Res vac land Medicaid 4,700 30.04 Hansen Walter R Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,700 County Tax 4,700 24.92 3737 Crestwood Dr 12-3-4.3 4,700 Community Colleges 4,700 5.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 110.00 Town Tax 4,700 2.43 EAST-0954100 NRTH-0912126 Chargebacks 4,700 0.09 DEED BOOK 1835 PG-00555 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,700 TO 8.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,573 TOTAL TAX --- 71.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 71.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-30 ***************** 3741 Crestwood Dr BILL 76 63.17-2-30 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 11,760 75.16 Grzegorzewski Larry M Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,400 County Tax 11,760 62.36 Krystofik Deborah A 12-3-4.1 11,760 Community Colleges 11,760 13.10 3743 Crestwood Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 11,760 6.08 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954061 NRTH-0912095 Chargebacks 11,760 0.22 DEED BOOK 1651 PG-00289 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 11,760 TO 20.90 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,448 TOTAL TAX --- 177.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 177.82 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 22 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-31 ***************** 3743 Crestwood Dr BILL 77 63.17-2-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 66,500 425.02 Grzegorzewski Larry M Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 66,500 352.62 Krystofik Deborah A 12-3-3 66,500 Community Colleges 66,500 74.10 3743 Crestwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 66,500 34.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953999 NRTH-0912053 Chargebacks 66,500 1.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,007 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 66,500 TO 118.16 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,081.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,081.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-32 ***************** 3749 Crestwood Dr BILL 78 63.17-2-32 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 5,000 Kozlowski Michael P Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Kozlowski Angela 12-3-2 85,000 VET DIS C 41142 12,750 0 3749 Crestwood Dr FRNT 120.00 DPTH 100.00 Medicaid 67,840 433.58 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953893 NRTH-0911965 County Tax 67,840 359.72 DEED BOOK 2438 PG-630 Community Colleges 67,840 75.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,881 Town Tax 80,000 41.35 Chargebacks 80,000 1.48 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 85,000 TO 151.04 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,138.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,138.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-33 ***************** 3750 E Lake Rd BILL 79 63.17-2-33 312 Vac w/imprv P-RATA VET 41003 0 3,111 Kozlowski Michael P Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,700 VETS CNTY 41102 875 0 Kozlowski Angela 12-3-1 12,400 Medicaid 11,525 73.66 3749 Crestwood Dr ACRES 0.83 County Tax 11,525 61.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953874 NRTH-0911854 Community Colleges 11,525 12.84 DEED BOOK 2438 PG-627 Town Tax 9,289 4.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,343 Chargebacks 9,289 0.17 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12,400 TO 22.03 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 199.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 199.61 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 23 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-34 ***************** 3744 E Lake Rd BILL 80 63.17-2-34 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,900 395.62 Hernandez Samuel Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,200 County Tax 61,900 328.23 3744 E Lake Rd 12-3-8 61,900 Community Colleges 61,900 68.98 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 110.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 61,900 31.99 EAST-0954003 NRTH-0911902 Chargebacks 61,900 1.15 DEED BOOK 1761 PG-00242 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,900 TO 109.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,573 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,011.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,011.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-35 ***************** 3738 E Lake Rd BILL 81 63.17-2-35 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 63,000 402.65 Koczwara David Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 63,000 334.06 3738 E Lake Rd 12-3-7 63,000 Community Colleges 63,000 70.20 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 EAST-0954111 NRTH-0911978 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 DEED BOOK 2681 PG-469 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,000 TO 111.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,028.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,028.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-36 ***************** 3734 E Lake Rd BILL 82 63.17-2-36 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,955 Deszcz Robert M Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,100 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 3734 East Lake Rd 12-3-6 40,000 Medicaid 32,650 208.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 150.00 County Tax 32,650 173.13 EAST-0954203 NRTH-0912042 Community Colleges 32,650 36.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,944 Town Tax 38,045 19.66 Chargebacks 38,045 0.70 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 40,000 TO 71.08 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 585.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 585.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-37 ***************** 3730 E Lake Rd BILL 83 63.17-2-37 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 47,150 301.35 Jackson Gregory A Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,200 County Tax 47,150 250.01 3730 E Lake Rd 12-3-5 47,150 Community Colleges 47,150 52.54 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 47,150 24.37 EAST-0954262 NRTH-0912082 Chargebacks 47,150 0.87 DEED BOOK 2098 PG-00349 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 47,150 TO 83.78 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,944 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 788.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 788.51 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 24 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-38 ***************** 3724 E Lake Rd BILL 84 63.17-2-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 63,000 402.65 Raczek Dolores K Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 63,000 334.06 Revocable Trust 12-1-8 63,000 Community Colleges 63,000 70.20 Trustee FRNT 100.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 3724 E Lake Shore Drive EAST-0954380 NRTH-0912167 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,000 TO 111.95 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,028.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,028.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-39 ***************** 3720 E Lake Rd BILL 85 63.17-2-39 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Kosciuszko Susan M Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 Medicaid 64,590 412.81 3720 East Lake Rd 12-1-7 69,000 County Tax 64,590 342.49 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 150.00 Community Colleges 64,590 71.97 EAST-0954458 NRTH-0912221 Town Tax 69,000 35.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,503 Chargebacks 69,000 1.28 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,000 TO 122.61 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,062.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,062.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-40 ***************** 3716 E Lake Rd BILL 86 63.17-2-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,000 389.87 Johnson Rexford P Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,400 County Tax 61,000 323.46 Johnson W 12-1-6 61,000 Community Colleges 61,000 67.97 3716 E Lake Rd FRNT 86.40 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 61,000 31.53 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954533 NRTH-0912269 Chargebacks 61,000 1.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,315 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,000 TO 108.39 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 997.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 997.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-41 ***************** 3714 E Lake Rd BILL 87 63.17-2-41 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 21,400 136.77 Johnson Rexford P Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,300 County Tax 21,400 113.47 Johnson J 12-1-5 21,400 Community Colleges 21,400 23.85 3716 E Lake Rd FRNT 115.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 21,400 11.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954611 NRTH-0912327 Chargebacks 21,400 0.40 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,930 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 21,400 TO 38.03 TOTAL TAX --- 323.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 323.58 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 25 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-42 ***************** 3712 E Lake Rd BILL 88 63.17-2-42 311 Res vac land Medicaid 5,900 37.71 Nowak Peter R Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 5,900 31.29 1372 Courthouse Rd 12-1-4 5,900 Community Colleges 5,900 6.57 Stafford, VA 22554 FRNT 115.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 5,900 3.05 EAST-0954704 NRTH-0912395 Chargebacks 5,900 0.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,252 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,900 TO 10.48 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 114.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 114.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-43 ***************** 3711 E Lake Rd BILL 89 63.17-2-43 416 Mfg hsing pk Medicaid 263,000 1,680.89 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 61,100 County Tax 263,000 1,394.57 6523 S Transit Rd 6-1-25 263,000 Community Colleges 263,000 293.06 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 4.70 Town Tax 263,000 135.94 EAST-0954755 NRTH-0911917 Chargebacks 263,000 4.87 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00417 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 263,000 TO 467.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 367,832 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.50 UN 113.38 TOTAL TAX --- 4,090.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,090.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-44 ***************** 3701 E Lake Rd BILL 90 63.17-2-44 416 Mfg hsing pk Medicaid 29,000 185.35 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,300 County Tax 29,000 153.77 6523 S Transit Dr 6-1-24 29,000 Community Colleges 29,000 32.31 Lockport, NY 14094 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 156.00 Town Tax 29,000 14.99 EAST-0954608 NRTH-0912059 Chargebacks 29,000 0.54 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00417 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 29,000 TO 51.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,559 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.50 UN 113.38 TOTAL TAX --- 551.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 551.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-45 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 91 63.17-2-45 433 Auto body Medicaid 30,000 191.74 Hillery Kathy Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,300 County Tax 30,000 159.08 RT 1 6-1-23 30,000 Community Colleges 30,000 33.43 PO Box 102 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 30,000 15.51 Boling, TX 77420 EAST-0954483 NRTH-0911968 Chargebacks 30,000 0.56 DEED BOOK 2019 PG-00014 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 30,000 TO 53.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,958 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 245.30 MT 245.30 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 774.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 774.52 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 26 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-46 ***************** S Of Rt 5 BILL 92 63.17-2-46 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,000 38.35 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,000 County Tax 6,000 31.82 6523 S Transit Rd Rear Land 6,000 Community Colleges 6,000 6.69 Lockport, NY 14094 6-1-22.3 Town Tax 6,000 3.10 ACRES 0.21 Chargebacks 6,000 0.11 EAST-0954593 NRTH-0911703 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,000 TO 10.66 DEED BOOK 2194 PG-00391 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,392 TOTAL TAX --- 90.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 90.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-47.1 *************** 3731 E Lake Rd BILL 93 63.17-2-47.1 421 Restaurant Medicaid 90,000 575.21 DePietro Louis Dunkirk Csd 060300 25,200 County Tax 90,000 477.23 DiPoetro Amy 6-1-22.1 90,000 Community Colleges 90,000 100.29 3731 E Lake Rd FRNT 3.20 DPTH 5.56 Town Tax 90,000 46.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.20 Chargebacks 90,000 1.67 EAST-0954382 NRTH-0911867 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 90,000 TO 159.92 DEED BOOK 2109 PG-00090 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 381.15 MT 381.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,874 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,817.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,817.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-47.2 *************** E Lake Rd BILL 94 63.17-2-47.2 415 Motel Medicaid 96,530 616.95 BK Equities LLS Dunkirk Csd 060300 25,200 County Tax 96,530 511.85 107 Bliss St 6-1-22.4 96,530 Community Colleges 96,530 107.56 Westfield, NY 14787 ACRES 2.20 Town Tax 96,530 49.89 EAST-0954401 NRTH-0911570 Chargebacks 96,530 1.79 DEED BOOK 2109 PG-00090 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 96,530 TO 171.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,007 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 6.00 UN 453.51 TOTAL TAX --- 1,913.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,913.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-48 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 95 63.17-2-48 311 Res vac land Medicaid 5,000 31.96 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,000 County Tax 5,000 26.51 3745 E Lake Rd 6-1-22.2 5,000 Community Colleges 5,000 5.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.12 Town Tax 5,000 2.58 EAST-0954186 NRTH-0911733 Chargebacks 5,000 0.09 DEED BOOK 2194 PG-00386 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,000 TO 8.88 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,993 TOTAL TAX --- 75.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 75.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 27 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-49 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 96 63.17-2-49 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,640 16.87 Bartelo Joseph Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,640 County Tax 2,640 14.00 Bartelo Sharon 6-1-20.3 2,640 Community Colleges 2,640 2.94 3745 Lake Shore Drive E FRNT 65.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 2,640 1.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954121 NRTH-0911722 Chargebacks 2,640 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,692 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,640 TO 4.69 TOTAL TAX --- 39.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 39.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-50 ***************** 3745 E Lake Rd BILL 97 63.17-2-50 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 5,000 Bartelo Joseph Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,100 VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 3745 E Lake Rd 6-1-19.1 73,000 Medicaid 68,590 438.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.25 County Tax 68,590 363.70 EAST-0954064 NRTH-0911682 Community Colleges 68,590 76.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,098 Town Tax 68,000 35.15 Chargebacks 68,000 1.26 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,000 TO 129.71 GE001 Miscellaneous charge .00 MT SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,120.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,120.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-51 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 98 63.17-2-51 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Schwerk John Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 3749 E Lake Rd 6-1-19.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 5.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0954027 NRTH-0911656 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 TOTAL TAX --- 1.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-52 ***************** 3745 E Lake Rd BILL 99 63.17-2-52 449 Other Storag Medicaid 212,570 1,358.58 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 34,800 County Tax 212,570 1,127.16 3745 E Lake Rd 6-1-20.1 212,570 Community Colleges 212,570 236.87 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 212,570 109.87 EAST-0954155 NRTH-0911493 Chargebacks 212,570 3.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 297,301 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 212,570 TO 377.72 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 3,289.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,289.72 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 28 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-53 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 100 63.17-2-53 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,000 383.47 Schwerk John Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,400 County Tax 60,000 318.15 3749 E Lake Rd 6-1-18 60,000 Community Colleges 60,000 66.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.30 Town Tax 60,000 31.01 EAST-0954013 NRTH-0911611 Chargebacks 60,000 1.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,916 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,000 TO 106.61 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 200.20 MT 200.20 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,183.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,183.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-54 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 101 63.17-2-54 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,000 345.13 Rosario Mario O Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 County Tax 54,000 286.34 Rosario Dawn L 6-1-17 54,000 Community Colleges 54,000 60.17 3751 East Lake Rd ACRES 0.22 Town Tax 54,000 27.91 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953947 NRTH-0911600 Chargebacks 54,000 1.00 DEED BOOK 2100 PG-00013 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 54,000 TO 95.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,524 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 892.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 892.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-55 ***************** 3757 E Lake Rd BILL 102 63.17-2-55 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,780 273.42 Wolcott Shirley Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 42,780 226.84 3757 East Lake Rd 6-1-16 42,780 Community Colleges 42,780 47.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.34 Town Tax 42,780 22.11 EAST-0953878 NRTH-0911553 Chargebacks 42,780 0.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,832 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,780 TO 76.02 GE001 Miscellaneous charge 654.50 MT 654.50 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,376.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,376.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-56 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 103 63.17-2-56 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 3761 E Lake Rd 6-1-15 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.11 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 EAST-0953939 NRTH-0911466 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 DEED BOOK 1736 PG-00252 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,600 TO 2.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 TOTAL TAX --- 24.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.19 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 29 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-57 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 104 63.17-2-57 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,900 12.14 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,900 County Tax 1,900 10.07 3761 E Lake Rd 6-1-20.2 1,900 Community Colleges 1,900 2.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 1,900 0.98 EAST-0954006 NRTH-0911263 Chargebacks 1,900 0.04 DEED BOOK 1736 PG-00254 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,900 TO 3.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,657 TOTAL TAX --- 28.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 28.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-2-58 ***************** E Lake Rd BILL 105 63.17-2-58 449 Other Storag Medicaid 303,000 1,936.54 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,100 County Tax 303,000 1,606.67 3761 E Lake Rd 6-1-14 303,000 Community Colleges 303,000 337.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 303,000 156.61 EAST-0953812 NRTH-0911472 Chargebacks 303,000 5.61 DEED BOOK 1736 PG-00252 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 303,000 TO 538.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 423,776 SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 1.00 UN 75.59 TOTAL TAX --- 4,657.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,657.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-1 ****************** 4557 W Lake Rd BILL 106 78.04-1-1 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 72,000 460.17 Griffin Dan D Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 72,000 381.78 Griffin Gretchen 3-3-1 72,000 Community Colleges 72,000 80.23 4557 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.07 Town Tax 72,000 37.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938867 NRTH-0904038 Chargebacks 72,000 1.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,699 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,000 TO 152.33 SW002 Shorewood water 72,000 TO C 5.60 TOTAL TAX --- 1,118.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,118.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-2 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 107 78.04-1-2 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 45,000 287.61 447 Lake Shore Drive West LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 45,000 238.61 c/o Scott Krieger 3-3-2 45,000 Community Colleges 45,000 50.14 6380 Wiltshire Blvd Ste 1800 ACRES 8.00 Town Tax 45,000 23.26 Los Angeles, CA 90048 EAST-0939573 NRTH-0904074 Chargebacks 45,000 0.83 DEED BOOK 2629 PG-103 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 45,000 TO 95.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,937 SW002 Shorewood water 45,000 TO C 3.50 TOTAL TAX --- 699.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 699.16 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 30 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-3 ****************** 4561 W Lake Rd BILL 108 78.04-1-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,000 472.95 Balzer Edward J Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,900 County Tax 74,000 392.39 4561 West Lake Rd 3-3-3 74,000 Community Colleges 74,000 82.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 9.80 Town Tax 74,000 38.25 EAST-0939478 NRTH-0903874 Chargebacks 74,000 1.37 DEED BOOK 2110 PG-00550 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 74,000 TO 156.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,497 SW002 Shorewood water 74,000 TO C 5.76 TOTAL TAX --- 1,149.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,149.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-5 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 109 78.04-1-5 322 Rural vac>10 Medicaid 31,100 198.77 Legrano Barbara Dunkirk Csd 060300 31,100 County Tax 31,100 164.91 7 Bryant Pl 3-3-5.1 31,100 Community Colleges 31,100 34.65 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 53.30 Town Tax 31,100 16.07 EAST-0939377 NRTH-0903025 Chargebacks 31,100 0.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 43,497 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 31,100 TO 65.80 SW002 Shorewood water 31,100 TO C 2.42 TOTAL TAX --- 483.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 483.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-6 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 110 78.04-1-6 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 32,950 210.59 Jaffray James Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 32,950 174.72 Jaffray Kristen 3-3-5.2 32,950 Community Colleges 32,950 36.72 68 W 5Th St ACRES 0.82 Town Tax 32,950 17.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938027 NRTH-0903361 Chargebacks 32,950 0.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,084 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 32,950 TO 69.71 SW002 Shorewood water 32,950 TO C 2.56 TOTAL TAX --- 511.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 511.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-1 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 111 78.20-2-1 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 95,500 610.36 Munro Donald Dunkirk Csd 060300 95,500 County Tax 95,500 506.39 1427 N Jasmine Ave 3-1-1.1 95,500 Community Colleges 95,500 106.42 Tarpon Springs, FL 34689 ACRES 4.90 Town Tax 95,500 49.36 EAST-0936931 NRTH-0903375 Chargebacks 95,500 1.77 DEED BOOK 2343 PG-12 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 95,500 TO 202.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 133,566 SW002 Shorewood water 95,500 TO C 7.43 TOTAL TAX --- 1,483.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,483.79 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 31 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-2 ****************** 4620 W Lake Rd BILL 112 78.20-2-2 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 271,600 1,735.86 Goldman Martin D Dunkirk Csd 060300 81,300 County Tax 271,600 1,440.17 4620 West Lake Rd 3-1-1.5 271,600 Community Colleges 271,600 302.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.30 Town Tax 271,600 140.38 EAST-0937050 NRTH-0903532 Chargebacks 271,600 5.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 379,860 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 271,600 TO 574.64 SW002 Shorewood water 271,600 TO C 21.13 TOTAL TAX --- 4,219.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,219.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-3 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 113 78.20-2-3 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 265,000 1,693.68 Shutt Patrickson J Dunkirk Csd 060300 66,300 County Tax 265,000 1,405.17 Shutt Joyce K 3-1-1.3 265,000 Community Colleges 265,000 295.29 4618 West Lake Rd ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 265,000 136.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937212 NRTH-0903569 Chargebacks 265,000 4.91 DEED BOOK 2265 PG-724 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 265,000 TO 560.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 370,629 SW002 Shorewood water 265,000 TO C 20.62 TOTAL TAX --- 4,117.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,117.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-4 ****************** 4616 W Lake Rd BILL 114 78.20-2-4 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Burlett James R Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 VET DIS CT 41141 14,700 16,788 Burlett Helen M N Side Of Rt5 67,150 Medicaid 45,100 288.24 4616 West Lake Rd 3-1-1.4 County Tax 45,100 239.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.44 Community Colleges 45,100 50.26 EAST-0937467 NRTH-0903213 Town Tax 50,362 26.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,916 Chargebacks 50,362 0.93 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,150 TO 142.07 SW002 Shorewood water 67,150 TO C 5.22 TOTAL TAX --- 751.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 751.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-5 ****************** 4610 W Lake Rd BILL 115 78.20-2-5 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 244,480 1,562.53 Wheeler George Dunkirk Csd 060300 84,200 County Tax 244,480 1,296.37 4610 Lake Shore Dr W 3-1-2 244,480 Community Colleges 244,480 272.42 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.61 Town Tax 244,480 126.37 EAST-0937346 NRTH-0903594 Chargebacks 244,480 4.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 341,930 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 244,480 TO 517.26 SW002 Shorewood water 244,480 TO C 19.02 TOTAL TAX --- 3,798.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,798.50 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 32 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-6 ****************** 4608 W Lake Rd BILL 116 78.20-2-6 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 235,000 1,501.94 Wells Susan L Dunkirk Csd 060300 103,600 County Tax 235,000 1,246.10 4608 W Lake Rd 3-1-3 235,000 Community Colleges 235,000 261.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Town Tax 235,000 121.47 EAST-0937528 NRTH-0903605 Chargebacks 235,000 4.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 328,671 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 235,000 TO 497.20 SW002 Shorewood water 235,000 TO C 18.28 TOTAL TAX --- 3,651.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,651.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-7 ****************** 4509 W Lake Rd BILL 117 78.20-2-7 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 138,500 885.19 Star Family Limited Partnershi Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,100 County Tax 138,500 734.40 400 5th Ave S Ste 201 3-1-4.1 138,500 Community Colleges 138,500 154.33 Naples, FL 34102 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 138,500 71.59 EAST-0937743 NRTH-0903559 Chargebacks 138,500 2.56 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,706 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 138,500 TO 293.03 SW002 Shorewood water 138,500 TO C 10.78 TOTAL TAX --- 2,151.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,151.88 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-8 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 118 78.20-2-8 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 53,600 342.57 Star Family Limited Partnershi Dunkirk Csd 060300 53,600 County Tax 53,600 284.22 400 5th Ave S Ste 201 3-1-4.2 53,600 Community Colleges 53,600 59.73 Naples, FL 34102 ACRES 0.70 Town Tax 53,600 27.70 EAST-0937608 NRTH-0903807 Chargebacks 53,600 0.99 DEED BOOK 2173 PG-00046 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 53,600 TO 113.40 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,965 SW002 Shorewood water 53,600 TO C 4.17 TOTAL TAX --- 832.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 832.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-9 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 119 78.20-2-9 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 644,000 4,115.95 Star Family Limited Partnershi Dunkirk Csd 060300 67,900 County Tax 644,000 3,414.84 400 5th Ave S Ste 201 3-1-5 644,000 Community Colleges 644,000 717.61 Naples, FL 34102 ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 644,000 332.87 EAST-0937728 NRTH-0903928 Chargebacks 644,000 11.92 DEED BOOK 2137 PG-00234 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 644,000 TO 1,362.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 900,699 SW002 Shorewood water 644,000 TO C 50.10 TOTAL TAX --- 10,005.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 10,005.84 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 33 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-10 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 120 78.20-2-10 311 Res vac land Medicaid 18,200 116.32 Star Family Limited Partnershi Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,200 County Tax 18,200 96.51 400 5th Ave S Ste 201 3-1-7.2 18,200 Community Colleges 18,200 20.28 Naples, FL 34102 ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 18,200 9.41 EAST-0937910 NRTH-0903675 Chargebacks 18,200 0.34 DEED BOOK 2137 PG-00234 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 18,200 TO 38.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,455 SW002 Shorewood water 18,200 TO C 1.42 TOTAL TAX --- 282.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 282.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-11 ***************** 4584 W Lake Rd BILL 121 78.20-2-11 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 234,980 1,501.81 Berner John D Dunkirk Csd 060300 46,800 County Tax 234,980 1,245.99 4584 West Lake Rd 3-1-6 234,980 Community Colleges 234,980 261.84 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 234,980 121.46 EAST-0937847 NRTH-0904014 Chargebacks 234,980 4.35 DEED BOOK 1783 PG-00270 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 234,980 TO 497.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 328,643 SW002 Shorewood water 234,980 TO C 18.28 TOTAL TAX --- 3,650.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,650.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-12.1 *************** 4576 W Lake Rd BILL 122 78.20-2-12.1 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 393,640 2,515.84 Gotowka Walter J Dunkirk Csd 060300 126,980 County Tax 393,640 2,087.29 Gotowka Carol A 3-1-7.1 393,640 Community Colleges 393,640 438.63 4576 West Lake Rd ACRES 3.60 Town Tax 393,640 203.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938093 NRTH-0903937 Chargebacks 393,640 7.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 550,545 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 393,640 TO 832.85 SW002 Shorewood water 393,640 TO C 30.63 TOTAL TAX --- 6,115.99** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,115.99 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-12.2 *************** 4576 W Lake Rd BILL 123 78.20-2-12.2 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 2,040 13.04 Berner John D Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,040 County Tax 2,040 10.82 4584 West Lake Rd 3-1-7.1 2,040 Community Colleges 2,040 2.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.12 Town Tax 2,040 1.05 EAST-0938019 NRTH-0903770 Chargebacks 2,040 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,853 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,040 TO 4.32 SW002 Shorewood water 2,040 TO C .16 TOTAL TAX --- 31.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 31.70 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 34 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-13 ***************** 4568 W Lake Rd BILL 124 78.20-2-13 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 136,000 869.21 Ippolito Louis Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,000 County Tax 136,000 721.15 4568 W Lake Rd 4568 W Lake Rd 136,000 Community Colleges 136,000 151.55 Dunkirk, NY 14048 3-2-7 Town Tax 136,000 70.30 ACRES 0.87 Chargebacks 136,000 2.52 EAST-0938345 NRTH-0903932 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 136,000 TO 287.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 190,210 SW002 Shorewood water 136,000 TO C 10.58 TOTAL TAX --- 2,113.05** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,113.05 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-14 ***************** 4568 W Lake Rd BILL 125 78.20-2-14 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Burnside Ronald E Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,300 Medicaid 91,910 587.42 4568 W Lake Rd 3-2-8 99,260 County Tax 91,910 487.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.40 Community Colleges 91,910 102.42 EAST-0938203 NRTH-0904098 Town Tax 99,260 51.31 DEED BOOK 1717 PG-00161 Chargebacks 99,260 1.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,825 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 99,260 TO 210.01 SW002 Shorewood water 99,260 TO C 7.72 TOTAL TAX --- 1,448.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,448.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-15 ***************** 4568 W Lake Rd BILL 126 78.20-2-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 87,000 556.04 Spacciapolli Lawrence G Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,500 County Tax 87,000 461.32 Spacciapolli Daryl B 3-2-1 87,000 Community Colleges 87,000 96.94 4568 W Lake Rd ACRES 0.28 Town Tax 87,000 44.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938209 NRTH-0904191 Chargebacks 87,000 1.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,678 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 87,000 TO 184.07 SW002 Shorewood water 87,000 TO C 6.77 TOTAL TAX --- 1,351.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,351.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-16 ***************** 4566 W Lake Rd BILL 127 78.20-2-16 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 90,000 575.21 Clement Kenneth A Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,700 County Tax 90,000 477.23 Krzal Edyta 3-2-6 90,000 Community Colleges 90,000 100.29 4566 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.02 Town Tax 90,000 46.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938398 NRTH-0904060 Chargebacks 90,000 1.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 90,000 TO 190.42 SW002 Shorewood water 90,000 TO C 7.00 TOTAL TAX --- 1,398.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,398.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 35 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-17 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 128 78.20-2-17 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,000 19.17 Randazzo Salvatore D Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,000 County Tax 3,000 15.91 Randazzo Barbara L 3-2-2.1 3,000 Community Colleges 3,000 3.34 4558 Lake Shore Drive W FRNT 65.00 DPTH 65.00 Town Tax 3,000 1.55 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938350 NRTH-0904197 Chargebacks 3,000 0.06 DEED BOOK 2086 PG-00064 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,000 TO 6.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,196 SW002 Shorewood water 3,000 TO C .23 TOTAL TAX --- 46.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 46.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-18 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 129 78.20-2-18 311 Res vac land Medicaid 11,800 75.42 Randazzo Salvatore D Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,800 County Tax 11,800 62.57 Randazzo Barbara L Back Land 11,800 Community Colleges 11,800 13.15 4558 Lake Shore Dr West 3-2-2.2 Town Tax 11,800 6.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 95.00 DPTH 149.00 Chargebacks 11,800 0.22 EAST-0938419 NRTH-0904167 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,800 TO 24.97 DEED BOOK 2099 PG-412 SW002 Shorewood water 11,800 TO C .92 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,503 TOTAL TAX --- 183.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 183.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-19 ***************** 4558 W Lake Rd BILL 130 78.20-2-19 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Randazzo Salvatore Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,800 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Randazzo Barbara L 3-2-5 145,000 Medicaid 140,000 894.77 4558 W Lake Rd ACRES 0.70 County Tax 140,000 742.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938541 NRTH-0904104 Community Colleges 140,000 156.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 202,797 Town Tax 127,224 65.76 Chargebacks 127,224 2.35 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 145,000 TO 306.79 SW002 Shorewood water 145,000 TO C 11.28 TOTAL TAX --- 2,179.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,179.31 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 36 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-20 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 131 78.20-2-20 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,440 53.94 Sanden Rose Marie Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,440 County Tax 8,440 44.75 4550 W Lake Rd 3-2-3 8,440 Community Colleges 8,440 9.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.29 Town Tax 8,440 4.36 EAST-0938645 NRTH-0904154 Chargebacks 8,440 0.16 DEED BOOK 2125 PG-00108 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,440 TO 17.86 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,804 SW002 Shorewood water 8,440 TO C .66 TOTAL TAX --- 131.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 131.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.20-2-21 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 132 78.20-2-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Grissom Larry A Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 15307 Brandonwood Pl 3-2-4 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Houston, TX 77069 FRNT 33.00 DPTH 44.00 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0938722 NRTH-0904208 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 500 TO 1.06 SW002 Shorewood water 500 TO C .04 TOTAL TAX --- 7.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-1 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 133 80.01-1-1 449 Other Storag Medicaid 234,000 1,495.55 Muldowney Development Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 152,600 County Tax 234,000 1,240.80 10 Beach St Encludes 6-1-4 234,000 Community Colleges 234,000 260.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 6-1-3.3 Town Tax 234,000 120.95 ACRES 28.30 Chargebacks 234,000 4.33 EAST-0952904 NRTH-0910094 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 234,000 TO 415.80 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-729 WD024 E lake rd ind water 234,000 TO C 715.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 327,273 TOTAL TAX --- 4,253.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,253.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-3 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 134 80.01-1-3 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 91,400 584.16 ROM Properties Management Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 24,700 County Tax 91,400 484.65 106 Berry Rd 6-1-5.1 91,400 Community Colleges 91,400 101.85 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 19.20 Town Tax 91,400 47.24 EAST-0953873 NRTH-0910504 Chargebacks 91,400 1.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,832 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 91,400 TO 162.41 GE001 Miscellaneous charge .00 MT SD024 East lake rd sewer 2 2.00 UN 151.17 TOTAL TAX --- 1,533.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,533.17 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 37 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-4 ****************** 3761 E Lake Rd BILL 135 80.01-1-4 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 78,700 502.99 Farrell J. William Dunkirk Csd 060300 78,700 County Tax 78,700 417.31 3761 E Lake Rd 6-1-13 78,700 Community Colleges 78,700 87.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.63 Town Tax 78,700 40.68 EAST-0954064 NRTH-0910775 Chargebacks 78,700 1.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 110,070 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 78,700 TO 139.84 SD023 East lake rd sewer 1 1.00 FE 25.00 TOTAL TAX --- 1,214.98** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,214.98 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-5 ****************** E Lake Rd BILL 136 80.01-1-5 321 Abandoned ag Medicaid 16,300 104.18 Lakeside Park LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,300 County Tax 16,300 86.43 6523 Transit Dr S 6-1-21 16,300 Community Colleges 16,300 18.16 Lockport, NY 14094 ACRES 28.70 Town Tax 16,300 8.43 EAST-0954742 NRTH-0910960 Chargebacks 16,300 0.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,797 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 16,300 TO 28.96 TOTAL TAX --- 246.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 246.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-7 ****************** Industrial Rd BILL 137 80.01-1-7 340 Vacant indus Medicaid 140,600 898.61 Nestle Purina Petcare Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 140,600 County Tax 140,600 745.54 Tax Departmant 4C 6-3-1.2.1 140,600 Community Colleges 140,600 156.67 1 Checkerboard Sq ACRES 55.90 Town Tax 140,600 72.67 St Louis, MO 63164 EAST-0955691 NRTH-0910149 Chargebacks 140,600 2.60 DEED BOOK 2017 PG-00038 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 140,600 TO 249.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,643 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 140,600 TO C 32.53 TOTAL TAX --- 2,158.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,158.45 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-14 ***************** 3692 Middle Rd BILL 138 80.01-1-14 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 55,500 354.71 Yuen David L Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,400 County Tax 55,500 294.29 Yuen Elaine 6-4-1 55,500 Community Colleges 55,500 61.84 3692 Middle Road ACRES 10.00 Town Tax 55,500 28.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954780 NRTH-0908343 Chargebacks 55,500 1.03 DEED BOOK 1782 PG-00082 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,500 TO 98.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,622 WD005 Urban wtr1 55,500 TO C 55.30 TOTAL TAX --- 894.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 894.48 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 38 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-15 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 139 80.01-1-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 35,500 226.89 Bialaszewski Susan K Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,600 County Tax 35,500 188.24 Bialaszewski Bernard 6-4-2 35,500 Community Colleges 35,500 39.56 3662 Middle Rd ACRES 5.30 Town Tax 35,500 18.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955355 NRTH-0908403 Chargebacks 35,500 0.66 DEED BOOK 2044 PG-00508 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 35,500 TO 63.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 49,650 WD005 Urban wtr1 35,500 TO C 35.37 TOTAL TAX --- 572.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 572.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-16 ***************** 3624 Middle Rd BILL 140 80.01-1-16 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Levandoski Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,500 Medicaid 62,150 397.22 3624 Middle Rd 6-4-3 69,500 County Tax 62,150 329.55 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.90 Community Colleges 62,150 69.25 EAST-0955730 NRTH-0908472 Town Tax 69,500 35.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,203 Chargebacks 69,500 1.29 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,500 TO 123.50 WD005 Urban wtr1 69,500 TO C 69.26 TOTAL TAX --- 1,025.99** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,025.99 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-17 ***************** 3608 Middle Rd BILL 141 80.01-1-17 242 Rurl res&rec VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Addington Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,100 Medicaid 55,650 355.67 3608 Middle Road 6-4-4 63,000 County Tax 55,650 295.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.50 Community Colleges 55,650 62.01 EAST-0956163 NRTH-0908629 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,000 TO 111.95 WD005 Urban wtr1 63,000 TO C 62.78 TOTAL TAX --- 921.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 921.23 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 39 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-18 ***************** 3603 Middle Rd BILL 142 80.01-1-18 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Bentley Donald Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,500 Medicaid 61,650 394.02 3603 Middle Road 7-4-8 69,000 County Tax 61,650 326.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.87 Community Colleges 61,650 68.70 EAST-0956436 NRTH-0907778 Town Tax 69,000 35.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,503 Chargebacks 69,000 1.28 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,000 TO 122.61 WD005 Urban wtr1 69,000 TO C 68.76 TOTAL TAX --- 1,017.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,017.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-19 ***************** 3611 Middle Rd BILL 143 80.01-1-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,930 434.16 Samuelson Thomas M Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,000 County Tax 67,930 360.20 Samuelson Sandra G 7-4-7 67,930 Community Colleges 67,930 75.69 3611 Middle Rd ACRES 4.30 Town Tax 67,930 35.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0956313 NRTH-0907528 Chargebacks 67,930 1.26 DEED BOOK 1984 PG-00376 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 67,930 TO 120.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,007 WD005 Urban wtr1 67,930 TO C 67.69 TOTAL TAX --- 1,094.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,094.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-20 ***************** 3611 Middle Rd BILL 144 80.01-1-20 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,800 11.50 Samuelson Thomas M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 1,800 9.54 Samuelson Sandra G 7-4-6 1,800 Community Colleges 1,800 2.01 3611 Middle Rd ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 1,800 0.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0956196 NRTH-0907789 Chargebacks 1,800 0.03 DEED BOOK 1984 PG-00376 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,800 TO 3.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 WD005 Urban wtr1 1,800 TO C 1.79 TOTAL TAX --- 29.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-21 ***************** 3621 Middle Rd BILL 145 80.01-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 83,500 533.67 Gould James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,100 County Tax 83,500 442.76 Gould Jan E 7-4-5 83,500 Community Colleges 83,500 93.04 3531 Werle Rd ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 83,500 43.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0956088 NRTH-0907616 Chargebacks 83,500 1.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 116,783 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 83,500 TO 148.37 WD005 Urban wtr1 83,500 TO C 83.21 TOTAL TAX --- 1,345.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,345.76 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 40 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-22 ***************** 3629 Middle Rd BILL 146 80.01-1-22 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 55,190 352.73 Gunther Timothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 County Tax 55,190 292.65 3629 Middle Road 7-4-4.1 55,190 Community Colleges 55,190 61.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.50 Town Tax 55,190 28.53 EAST-0955943 NRTH-0907622 Chargebacks 55,190 1.02 DEED BOOK 1926 PG-00245 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,190 TO 98.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,189 WD005 Urban wtr1 55,190 TO C 55.00 TOTAL TAX --- 889.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 889.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-23 ***************** 3639 Middle Rd BILL 147 80.01-1-23 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Schwertfager Marilyn L Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 3639 Middle Rd 7-4-4.2 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.16 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0955852 NRTH-0907782 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 WD005 Urban wtr1 1,200 TO C 1.20 TOTAL TAX --- 19.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-24 ***************** 3639 Middle Rd BILL 148 80.01-1-24 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Tyma Stanley III Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 Medicaid 58,590 374.46 3639 Middle Rd 7-4-3 63,000 County Tax 58,590 310.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.55 Community Colleges 58,590 65.29 EAST-0955805 NRTH-0907814 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,000 TO 111.95 WD005 Urban wtr1 63,000 TO C 62.78 TOTAL TAX --- 958.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 958.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-25 ***************** 3651 Middle Rd BILL 149 80.01-1-25 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 63,500 405.84 Gibbon Edwin V Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,200 County Tax 63,500 336.71 Mleczko Frederick J 7-4-1 63,500 Community Colleges 63,500 70.76 3651 Middle Rd ACRES 4.50 Town Tax 63,500 32.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955545 NRTH-0907786 Chargebacks 63,500 1.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,811 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,500 TO 112.83 WD005 Urban wtr1 63,500 TO C 63.28 TOTAL TAX --- 1,023.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,023.42 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 41 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-26 ***************** 11308 Urban Rd BILL 150 80.01-1-26 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,720 Karpinske David J Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,900 VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Karpinske Janis 7-4-2 68,000 Medicaid 63,590 406.42 11308 Urban Rd ACRES 3.40 County Tax 63,590 337.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955562 NRTH-0907412 Community Colleges 63,590 70.86 DEED BOOK 1766 PG-00182 Town Tax 65,280 33.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,105 Chargebacks 65,280 1.21 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,000 TO 120.83 WD005 Urban wtr1 68,000 TO C 67.76 TOTAL TAX --- 1,038.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,038.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-27 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 151 80.01-1-27 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Tofil Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,100 County Tax 1,500 7.95 11309 Urban Rd 7-3-9 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.16 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 EAST-0955173 NRTH-0907340 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 DEED BOOK 2058 PG-00352 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,500 TO 2.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 WD005 Urban wtr1 1,500 TO C 1.49 TOTAL TAX --- 24.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-28 ***************** 11309 Urban Rd BILL 152 80.01-1-28 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 80,240 512.83 Tofil Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,600 County Tax 80,240 425.48 11309 Urban Rd 7-3-8 80,240 Community Colleges 80,240 89.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.00 Town Tax 80,240 41.47 EAST-0955081 NRTH-0907658 Chargebacks 80,240 1.49 DEED BOOK 2058 PG-00352 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 80,240 TO 142.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,224 WD005 Urban wtr1 80,240 TO C 79.96 TOTAL TAX --- 1,293.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,293.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-29 ***************** 3683 Middle Rd BILL 153 80.01-1-29 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,500 348.32 Rak Edward J II Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 54,500 288.99 3683 Middle Road 7-3-7 54,500 Community Colleges 54,500 60.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 54,500 28.17 EAST-0955027 NRTH-0907888 Chargebacks 54,500 1.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,224 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 54,500 TO 96.84 WD005 Urban wtr1 54,500 TO C 54.31 TOTAL TAX --- 878.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 878.37 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 42 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-30 ***************** 3689 Middle Rd BILL 154 80.01-1-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Raczka Joan Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 64,000 339.36 3689 Middle Road 7-3-6 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 EAST-0954825 NRTH-0907670 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 WD005 Urban wtr1 64,000 TO C 63.77 TOTAL TAX --- 1,031.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,031.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-31 ***************** 3699 Middle Rd BILL 155 80.01-1-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 63,160 403.67 Lane Glendora Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 63,160 334.91 3699 Middle Road 7-3-5 63,160 Community Colleges 63,160 70.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 63,160 32.65 EAST-0954674 NRTH-0907680 Chargebacks 63,160 1.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,336 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,160 TO 112.23 WD005 Urban wtr1 63,160 TO C 62.94 TOTAL TAX --- 1,017.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,017.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-32 ***************** 3707 Middle Rd BILL 156 80.01-1-32 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 49,000 313.17 Snader Daniel W Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 49,000 259.82 3707 Middle Road 7-3-4 49,000 Community Colleges 49,000 54.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.30 Town Tax 49,000 25.33 EAST-0954509 NRTH-0907686 Chargebacks 49,000 0.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,531 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,000 TO 87.07 WD005 Urban wtr1 49,000 TO C 48.83 TOTAL TAX --- 789.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 789.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-33 ***************** 3713 Middle Rd BILL 157 80.01-1-33 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 47,000 300.39 Laemmerhirt Ernest Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 County Tax 47,000 249.22 3713 Middle Rd E 7-3-3 47,000 Community Colleges 47,000 52.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.13 Town Tax 47,000 24.29 EAST-0954376 NRTH-0907970 Chargebacks 47,000 0.87 DEED BOOK 2681 PG-782 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 47,000 TO 83.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,734 WD005 Urban wtr1 47,000 TO C 46.83 TOTAL TAX --- 757.49** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 757.49 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 43 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-34 ***************** 3719 Middle Rd BILL 158 80.01-1-34 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,640 387.56 Rushboldt Paul R Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,600 County Tax 60,640 321.55 Rushboldt Raymond M 7-3-2 60,640 Community Colleges 60,640 67.57 3719 Middle Rd ACRES 3.20 Town Tax 60,640 31.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954277 NRTH-0907699 Chargebacks 60,640 1.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,811 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,640 TO 107.75 WD005 Urban wtr1 60,640 TO C 60.43 TOTAL TAX --- 977.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 977.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-35 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 159 80.01-1-35 314 Rural vac<10 Medicaid 4,860 31.06 Maslach Ronald J Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,860 County Tax 4,860 25.77 61 N Beagle St Non Trans 4,860 Community Colleges 4,860 5.42 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-2-4.1 Town Tax 4,860 2.51 ACRES 8.10 Chargebacks 4,860 0.09 EAST-0954680 NRTH-0907300 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,860 TO 8.64 DEED BOOK 1974 PG-00329 WD005 Urban wtr1 4,860 TO C 4.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,797 TOTAL TAX --- 78.33** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 78.33 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-36 ***************** 3731 Middle Rd BILL 160 80.01-1-36 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 62,000 396.26 Wilkins Scott Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,100 County Tax 62,000 328.76 3843 Webster Rd 7-3-1.1 62,000 Community Colleges 62,000 69.09 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 4.40 Town Tax 62,000 32.05 EAST-0953968 NRTH-0907711 Chargebacks 62,000 1.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,713 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 62,000 TO 110.17 WD005 Urban wtr1 62,000 TO C 61.78 TOTAL TAX --- 999.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 999.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-37 ***************** 3737 Middle Rd BILL 161 80.01-1-37 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Wilkins Elizabeth A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 64,000 339.36 3737 Middle Road 7-3-1.2 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 EAST-0953866 NRTH-0907895 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 DEED BOOK 2132 PG-00094 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 WD005 Urban wtr1 64,000 TO C 63.77 TOTAL TAX --- 1,031.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,031.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 44 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-45 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 162 80.01-1-45 311 Res vac land Medicaid 980 6.26 Nestle Purina Petcare Company Dunkirk Csd 060300 980 County Tax 980 5.20 Tax Department 4C 7-1-1 980 Community Colleges 980 1.09 1 Checkerboard Sq ACRES 0.52 Town Tax 980 0.51 St. Louis, MO 63164 EAST-0952637 NRTH-0907937 Chargebacks 980 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,371 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 980 TO 1.74 TOTAL TAX --- 14.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-46 ***************** 3800 Middle Rd BILL 163 80.01-1-46 710 Manufacture BUSINV 897 47610 1494,735 1494,735 Nestle Purina Petcare Company Dunkirk Csd 060300 289,500 BUSINV 897 47610 72,660 72,660 Tax Departmnet 4C includes lots 8,9 & 10 12718,610 BUSINV 897 47610 13,203 13,203 1 Checkerboard Sq 6-2-1.4.1 BUSINV 897 47610 111,935 111,935 St Louis, MO 63164 ACRES 47.40 Medicaid 11026,077 70,470.21 EAST-0953620 NRTH-0908812 County Tax 11026,077 58,466.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 17788,266 Community Colleges 11026,077 12,286.39 Town Tax 11026,077 5,699.16 Chargebacks 11026,077 204.09 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12718,610 TO 22,599.90 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 11026,077 TO C 2,551.02 1692,533 EX TOTAL TAX --- 172,277.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 172,277.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-47 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 164 80.01-1-47 710 Manufacture Medicaid 1800,000 11,504.22 Nestle Purina Petcare Company Dunkirk Csd 060300 31,200 County Tax 1800,000 9,544.58 Tax Department 4C 6-2-1.4.2 1800,000 Community Colleges 1800,000 2,005.75 1 Checkerboard Square ACRES 2.60 Town Tax 1800,000 930.38 St. Louis, MO 63164 EAST-0953922 NRTH-0909126 Chargebacks 1800,000 33.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 2517,483 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1800,000 TO 3,198.45 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 1800,000 TO C 416.45 TOTAL TAX --- 27,633.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 27,633.15 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 45 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-51 ***************** Stegelske Ave BILL 165 80.01-1-51 449 Other Storag Medicaid 48,000 306.78 The Red Wing Co Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 County Tax 48,000 254.52 c/o ConAgra Prorerty Tax Group 6-1-1.3.1 48,000 Community Colleges 48,000 53.49 PO Box 641370 ACRES 0.28 Town Tax 48,000 24.81 Omaha, NY 68164 EAST-0952551 NRTH-0909013 Chargebacks 48,000 0.89 DEED BOOK 1850 PG-00521 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 48,000 TO 85.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,133 WD024 E lake rd ind water 48,000 TO C 146.67 TOTAL TAX --- 872.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 872.45 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-52 ***************** Stegelske Ave BILL 166 80.01-1-52 449 Other Storag Medicaid 280,000 1,789.54 Lakeside Warehouse Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 27,600 County Tax 280,000 1,484.71 c/o ConAgra Property Tax Group 6-1-1.1 280,000 Community Colleges 280,000 312.00 PO Box 641370 ACRES 2.04 Town Tax 280,000 144.73 Omaha, NE 68164 EAST-0952648 NRTH-0909380 Chargebacks 280,000 5.18 DEED BOOK 1850 PG-00506 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 280,000 TO 497.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 391,608 WD024 E lake rd ind water 280,000 TO C 855.59 TOTAL TAX --- 5,089.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,089.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-55 ***************** Rt 5 BILL 167 80.01-1-55 710 Manufacture IND DEVEL 18020 3300,000 3300,000 Atwater Capital LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 116,400 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 5030 NW 24th Cir Includes 6-1-1.3.201&202; 3300,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Boca Raton, FL 33431 includes 80.01-1-49,50,54 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 ACRES 10.50 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0952914 NRTH-0909566 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 4615,385 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3300,000 TO 5,863.82 WD024 E lake rd ind water 3300,000 TO C 10,083.71 TOTAL TAX --- 15,947.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15,947.53 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-2 ****************** Urban Rd BILL 168 80.03-3-2 322 Rural vac>10 Medicaid 28,400 181.51 Cherry Pauline M Dunkirk Csd 060300 28,400 County Tax 28,400 150.59 10168 Miller Rd Formerly 80.03-2-2 28,400 Community Colleges 28,400 31.65 Fredonia, NY 14063 7-5-2 Town Tax 28,400 14.68 ACRES 59.22 Chargebacks 28,400 0.53 EAST-0953046 NRTH-0906084 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 28,400 TO 50.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 39,720 WD005 Urban wtr1 28,400 TO C 28.30 TOTAL TAX --- 457.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 457.72 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 46 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-3 ****************** Urban Rd BILL 169 80.03-3-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 11,100 70.94 Vazquez Ernest L Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,100 County Tax 11,100 58.86 PO Box 645 Formerly 80.03-2-3 11,100 Community Colleges 11,100 12.37 Erie, PA 16502 7-5-3.1 Town Tax 11,100 5.74 ACRES 12.90 Chargebacks 11,100 0.21 EAST-0953708 NRTH-0906296 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 11,100 TO 19.72 DEED BOOK 2685 PG-328 WD005 Urban wtr1 11,100 TO C 11.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,524 TOTAL TAX --- 178.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 178.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-4 ****************** Urban Rd BILL 170 80.03-3-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 55,500 354.71 Virella Concepcion Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,000 County Tax 55,500 294.29 127 Barton St Formerly 80.03-2-4 55,500 Community Colleges 55,500 61.84 Buffalo, NY 14213 7-5-3.3 Town Tax 55,500 28.69 ACRES 11.00 Chargebacks 55,500 1.03 EAST-0953992 NRTH-0906358 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,500 TO 98.62 DEED BOOK 2295 PG-701 WD005 Urban wtr1 55,500 TO C 55.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,622 TOTAL TAX --- 894.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 894.48 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-5 ****************** 11171 Urban Rd BILL 171 80.03-3-5 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 77,000 492.12 Latona Walter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 77,000 408.30 Latona Patricia Formerly 80.03-2-5 77,000 Community Colleges 77,000 85.80 11171 Urban Rd 7-5-3.2 Town Tax 77,000 39.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 140.00 DPTH 300.00 Chargebacks 77,000 1.43 EAST-0954059 NRTH-0905636 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 77,000 TO 136.82 DEED BOOK 2131 PG-00362 WD005 Urban wtr1 77,000 TO C 76.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 107,692 TOTAL TAX --- 1,241.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,241.00 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 47 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-6 ****************** Urban Rd BILL 172 80.03-3-6 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 35,790 228.74 Latona Walter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,700 County Tax 35,790 189.78 Latona Patricia Formerly 80.03-2-6 35,790 Community Colleges 35,790 39.88 11171 Urban Rd 7-5-4 Town Tax 35,790 18.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.90 Chargebacks 35,790 0.66 EAST-0954244 NRTH-0906418 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 35,790 TO 63.60 DEED BOOK 1931 PG-00366 WD005 Urban wtr1 35,790 TO C 35.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,056 TOTAL TAX --- 576.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 576.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-7 ****************** 11181 Urban Rd BILL 173 80.03-3-7 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 105,000 671.08 Dejesus Neftali Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,900 County Tax 105,000 556.77 11181 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-7 105,000 Community Colleges 105,000 117.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-5-5.2 Town Tax 105,000 54.27 ACRES 5.93 Chargebacks 105,000 1.94 EAST-0954445 NRTH-0906470 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 105,000 TO 186.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 146,853 WD005 Urban wtr1 105,000 TO C 104.63 TOTAL TAX --- 1,692.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,692.27 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-8 ****************** Urban Rd BILL 174 80.03-3-8 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 113,620 726.17 Tarnowski Kenneth E Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 113,620 602.48 Tarnowski Nancy A Formerly 80.03-2-8 113,620 Community Colleges 113,620 126.61 11225 Urban Rd 7-5-5.1 Town Tax 113,620 58.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.70 Chargebacks 113,620 2.10 EAST-0954613 NRTH-0906517 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 113,620 TO 201.89 DEED BOOK 1866 PG-00134 WD005 Urban wtr1 113,620 TO C 113.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 158,909 TOTAL TAX --- 1,831.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,831.20 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 48 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-9 ****************** 11237 Urban Rd BILL 175 80.03-3-9 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,500 Moore Gerald J Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 11237 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-9 72,500 Medicaid 67,500 431.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-5-6 County Tax 67,500 357.92 ACRES 5.60 Community Colleges 67,500 75.22 EAST-0954795 NRTH-0906583 Town Tax 55,000 28.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,399 Chargebacks 55,000 1.02 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 72,500 TO 128.83 WD005 Urban wtr1 72,500 TO C 72.24 TOTAL TAX --- 1,095.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,095.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-10 ***************** 11257 Urban Rd BILL 176 80.03-3-10 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 86,500 552.84 Kucharski James Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,500 County Tax 86,500 458.67 11257 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-10 86,500 Community Colleges 86,500 96.39 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-5-7.1 Town Tax 86,500 44.71 ACRES 2.90 Chargebacks 86,500 1.60 EAST-0954988 NRTH-0906577 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 86,500 TO 153.70 DEED BOOK 1646 PG-00112 WD005 Urban wtr1 86,500 TO C 86.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,979 TOTAL TAX --- 1,394.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,394.11 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-11 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 177 80.03-3-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Carey David Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 Carey Elegra Formerly 80.03-2-11 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 11285 Urban Rd 7-5-7.2 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 EAST-0955008 NRTH-0907114 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 WD005 Urban wtr1 1,200 TO C 1.20 TOTAL TAX --- 19.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 49 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-12 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 178 80.03-3-12 230 3 Family Res Medicaid 52,000 332.34 Roland Lawrence G Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,900 County Tax 52,000 275.73 Roland Mildred Formerly 80.03-2-12 52,000 Community Colleges 52,000 57.94 11285 Urban Rd 7-5-8 Town Tax 52,000 26.88 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.84 Chargebacks 52,000 0.96 EAST-0955159 NRTH-0907046 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 52,000 TO 92.40 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,727 WD005 Urban wtr1 52,000 TO C 51.82 TOTAL TAX --- 838.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 838.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-13 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 179 80.03-3-13 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Matias Wanda M Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,200 County Tax 64,000 339.36 11259 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-13 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-5-9 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 ACRES 0.55 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 EAST-0955133 NRTH-0906743 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 DEED BOOK 1683 PG-00245 WD005 Urban wtr1 64,000 TO C 63.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 TOTAL TAX --- 1,031.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,031.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-14 ***************** 11272 Urban Rd BILL 180 80.03-3-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 81,000 517.69 De Snyder Living Trust Marian Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,200 County Tax 81,000 429.51 11272 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-14 81,000 Community Colleges 81,000 90.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-12 Town Tax 81,000 41.87 ACRES 5.30 Chargebacks 81,000 1.50 EAST-0955521 NRTH-0906975 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 81,000 TO 143.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 113,287 WD005 Urban wtr1 81,000 TO C 80.71 TOTAL TAX --- 1,305.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,305.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-15 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 181 80.03-3-15 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 14,710 14,710 Gould James Dunkirk Csd 060300 22,300 Medicaid 7,590 48.51 Gould Jan E Formerly 80.03-2-15 22,300 County Tax 7,590 40.25 3531 Werle Rd 7-7-14 Community Colleges 7,590 8.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 23.60 Town Tax 7,590 3.92 EAST-0956275 NRTH-0905574 Chargebacks 7,590 0.14 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2054 PG-00468 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 22,300 TO 39.63 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FULL MARKET VALUE 31,189 WD005 Urban wtr1 22,300 TO C 22.22 TOTAL TAX --- 163.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 163.13 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 50 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-16 ***************** 3621 Middle Rd BILL 182 80.03-3-16 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 21,550 21,550 Gould James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 29,600 Medicaid 8,050 51.45 Gould Jan E Formerly 80.03-2-16 29,600 County Tax 8,050 42.69 3531 Werle Rd 7-7-13 Community Colleges 8,050 8.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 27.60 Town Tax 8,050 4.16 EAST-0955908 NRTH-0905553 Chargebacks 8,050 0.15 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 41,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 29,600 TO 52.60 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD005 Urban wtr1 29,600 TO C 29.50 TOTAL TAX --- 189.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 189.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-17 ***************** 11264 Urban Rd BILL 183 80.03-3-17 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 41,500 265.24 Halas Patricia Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,100 County Tax 41,500 220.06 50 Howard St Apt 232 Formerly 80.03-2-17 41,500 Community Colleges 41,500 46.24 Fredonia, NY 14063 7-7-11 Town Tax 41,500 21.45 ACRES 20.00 Chargebacks 41,500 0.77 EAST-0955565 NRTH-0905575 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 41,500 TO 73.74 DEED BOOK 2020 PG-00440 WD005 Urban wtr1 41,500 TO C 41.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,042 TOTAL TAX --- 668.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 668.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-18 ***************** 11246 Urban Rd BILL 184 80.03-3-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 57,000 364.30 Pagano Anthony J Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 County Tax 57,000 302.25 Pagano Scott Formerly 80.03-2-18 57,000 Community Colleges 57,000 63.52 11246 Urban Rd 7-7-10 Town Tax 57,000 29.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Chargebacks 57,000 1.06 EAST-0955173 NRTH-0906459 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,000 TO 101.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,720 WD005 Urban wtr1 57,000 TO C 56.80 TOTAL TAX --- 918.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 918.67 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-19 ***************** 11236 Urban Rd BILL 185 80.03-3-19 240 Rural res Medicaid 101,560 649.09 Salerno Daniel J Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,300 County Tax 101,560 538.53 Salerno Kimberly A Formerly 80.03-2-19 101,560 Community Colleges 101,560 113.17 11236 Urban Rd 7-7-9 Town Tax 101,560 52.49 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 29.09 Chargebacks 101,560 1.88 EAST-0955172 NRTH-0905157 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 101,560 TO 180.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,042 WD005 Urban wtr1 101,560 TO C 101.20 TOTAL TAX --- 1,636.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,636.82 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 51 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-20 ***************** 11228 Urban Rd BILL 186 80.03-3-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 88,480 565.50 Jagoda Thomas A Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,900 County Tax 88,480 469.17 Jagoda April A Formerly 80.03-2-20 88,480 Community Colleges 88,480 98.59 11228 Urban Rd 7-7-8 Town Tax 88,480 45.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.50 Chargebacks 88,480 1.64 EAST-0954960 NRTH-0905660 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 88,480 TO 157.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,748 WD005 Urban wtr1 88,480 TO C 88.17 TOTAL TAX --- 1,426.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,426.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-21 ***************** 11208 Urban Rd BILL 187 80.03-3-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 82,500 527.28 Koczwara Walter J Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 82,500 437.46 11208 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-21 82,500 Community Colleges 82,500 91.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-7 Town Tax 82,500 42.64 ACRES 2.00 Chargebacks 82,500 1.53 EAST-0954778 NRTH-0905703 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 82,500 TO 146.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 115,385 WD005 Urban wtr1 82,500 TO C 82.21 TOTAL TAX --- 1,329.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,329.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-22 ***************** 11200 Urban Rd BILL 188 80.03-3-22 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Bowers Paul L Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 Medicaid 114,600 732.44 Bowers Lynn S Formerly 80.03-2-22 119,010 County Tax 114,600 607.67 11200 Urban Rd 7-7-6.1 Community Colleges 114,600 127.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.90 Town Tax 119,010 61.51 EAST-0954560 NRTH-0904924 Chargebacks 119,010 2.20 DEED BOOK 2105 PG-00681 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 119,010 TO 211.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,448 WD005 Urban wtr1 119,010 TO C 118.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,861.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,861.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-23 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 189 80.03-3-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 138,000 881.99 Halas Rosemary Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,000 County Tax 138,000 731.75 11194 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-23 138,000 Community Colleges 138,000 153.77 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-6.2 Town Tax 138,000 71.33 ACRES 6.00 Chargebacks 138,000 2.55 EAST-0954392 NRTH-0904860 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 138,000 TO 245.21 DEED BOOK 1775 PG-00105 WD005 Urban wtr1 138,000 TO C 137.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 193,007 TOTAL TAX --- 2,224.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,224.11 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 52 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-24 ***************** 11174 Urban Rd BILL 190 80.03-3-24 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 4,088 Sam Regina Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 VETS CNTY 41102 1,150 0 11174 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-24 76,000 Medicaid 74,850 478.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-4 County Tax 74,850 396.90 ACRES 1.80 Community Colleges 74,850 83.41 EAST-0954233 NRTH-0905346 Town Tax 71,912 37.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,294 Chargebacks 71,912 1.33 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 76,000 TO 135.05 WD005 Urban wtr1 76,000 TO C 75.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,207.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,207.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-25 ***************** 11194 Urban Rd BILL 191 80.03-3-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,500 22.37 Halas Rosemary Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,500 County Tax 3,500 18.56 11194 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-25 3,500 Community Colleges 3,500 3.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-5 Town Tax 3,500 1.81 ACRES 5.80 Chargebacks 3,500 0.06 EAST-0954191 NRTH-0904757 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,500 TO 6.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,895 WD005 Urban wtr1 3,500 TO C 3.49 TOTAL TAX --- 56.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 56.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-26 ***************** 11164 Urban Rd BILL 192 80.03-3-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 80,000 511.30 Smagner John A Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 80,000 424.20 11164 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-26 80,000 Community Colleges 80,000 89.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-3.2 Town Tax 80,000 41.35 FRNT 228.70 DPTH 380.00 Chargebacks 80,000 1.48 ACRES 2.00 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 80,000 TO 142.15 EAST-0954027 NRTH-0905224 WD005 Urban wtr1 80,000 TO C 79.72 DEED BOOK 1875 PG-00095 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,888 TOTAL TAX --- 1,289.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,289.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 53 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-27 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 193 80.03-3-27 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 28,800 184.07 Smagner John A Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,900 County Tax 28,800 152.71 11164 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-27 28,800 Community Colleges 28,800 32.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-3.1 Town Tax 28,800 14.89 ACRES 14.10 Chargebacks 28,800 0.53 EAST-0953799 NRTH-0904698 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 28,800 TO 51.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,280 WD005 Urban wtr1 28,800 TO C 28.70 TOTAL TAX --- 464.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 464.17 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-29 ***************** Roberts Rd BILL 194 80.03-3-29 852 Landfill Medicaid 76,100 486.37 City Of Dunkirk Dunkirk Csd 060300 76,100 County Tax 76,100 403.52 Central Ave Landfill 76,100 Community Colleges 76,100 84.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 Formerly 80.03-2-29 Town Tax 76,100 39.33 9-6-2 Chargebacks 76,100 1.41 ACRES 27.70 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 76,100 TO 135.22 EAST-0954670 NRTH-0903658 WD058 Comprehensive Water 76,100 TO 38.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,434 TOTAL TAX --- 1,189.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,189.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-33 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 195 80.03-3-33 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 40,000 255.65 Dejesus Neftali Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,800 County Tax 40,000 212.10 11181 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-33 40,000 Community Colleges 40,000 44.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 9-6-3 Town Tax 40,000 20.68 ACRES 5.80 Chargebacks 40,000 0.74 EAST-0953197 NRTH-0903675 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 40,000 TO 71.08 DEED BOOK 1717 PG-00190 WD058 Comprehensive Water 40,000 TO 20.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,944 TOTAL TAX --- 625.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 625.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-34 ***************** 11070 Urban Rd BILL 196 80.03-3-34 475 Junkyard Medicaid 17,300 110.57 DeJesus Neftali Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,300 County Tax 17,300 91.73 11181 Urban Rd Formerly 80.03-2-34 17,300 Community Colleges 17,300 19.28 Dunkirk, NY 14048 7-7-2 Town Tax 17,300 8.94 ACRES 16.90 Chargebacks 17,300 0.32 EAST-0953060 NRTH-0904604 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 17,300 TO 30.74 DEED BOOK 1801 PG-00151 WD005 Urban wtr1 17,300 TO C 17.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,196 TOTAL TAX --- 278.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 278.82 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 54 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-2 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 197 80.17-1-2 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 2,300 14.70 Davis John R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 2,300 12.20 176 Fizell Ave 7-6-10 2,300 Community Colleges 2,300 2.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 82.00 Town Tax 2,300 1.19 EAST-0952454 NRTH-0904413 Chargebacks 2,300 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,217 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,300 TO 4.09 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,300 TO 1.18 TOTAL TAX --- 35.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 35.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-3 ****************** Tenney St BILL 198 80.17-1-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Shaw Bobbi L Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 63 Tenney St 7-6-9 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 38.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0952436 NRTH-0904357 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 1982 PG-00337 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-4 ****************** 11047 S Roberts Rd BILL 199 80.17-1-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 36,000 230.08 Krzyzanowski Ernest Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,900 County Tax 36,000 190.89 Krzyzanowski Marcella 7-6-2 36,000 Community Colleges 36,000 40.11 11047 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.15 Town Tax 36,000 18.61 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952511 NRTH-0904403 Chargebacks 36,000 0.67 DEED BOOK 1677 PG-00028 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 36,000 TO 63.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,350 WD058 Comprehensive Water 36,000 TO 18.41 TOTAL TAX --- 562.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 562.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-5 ****************** 11045 S Roberts Rd BILL 200 80.17-1-5 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 37,500 239.67 Krzyzanowski Ernest Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,400 County Tax 37,500 198.85 Krzyzanowski Marcella 7-6-3 37,500 Community Colleges 37,500 41.79 11045 S Roberts Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 133.00 Town Tax 37,500 19.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952519 NRTH-0904341 Chargebacks 37,500 0.69 DEED BOOK 1880 PG-00005 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 37,500 TO 66.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,448 WD058 Comprehensive Water 37,500 TO 19.18 TOTAL TAX --- 586.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 586.19 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 55 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-7 ****************** 11043 S Roberts Rd BILL 201 80.17-1-7 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 4,600 29.40 Krzyzanowski Marcella M Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,400 County Tax 4,600 24.39 11039 South Roberts Rd 7-6-4 4,600 Community Colleges 4,600 5.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.15 Town Tax 4,600 2.38 EAST-0952540 NRTH-0904293 Chargebacks 4,600 0.09 DEED BOOK 2444 PG-769 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,600 TO 8.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,434 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,600 TO 2.35 TOTAL TAX --- 71.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 71.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-8 ****************** 11047 S Roberts Rd BILL 202 80.17-1-8 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 9,900 63.27 Krzyzanowski Ernest Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 9,900 52.50 Krzyzanowski Marcella 7-6-6.2 9,900 Community Colleges 9,900 11.03 11047 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.20 Town Tax 9,900 5.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952459 NRTH-0904286 Chargebacks 9,900 0.18 DEED BOOK 2085 PG-00057 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,900 TO 17.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,846 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,900 TO 5.06 TOTAL TAX --- 154.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 154.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-9 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 203 80.17-1-9 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 Noto James Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 55 Tenney St 7-6-8 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 10.00 DPTH 42.20 Town Tax 200 0.10 EAST-0952443 NRTH-0904196 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 WD058 Comprehensive Water 200 TO .10 TOTAL TAX --- 3.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-10 ***************** Tenney St BILL 204 80.17-1-10 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Noto James Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 55 Tenney St 7-6-7 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 10.00 DPTH 10.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0952433 NRTH-0904167 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 2033 PG-00059 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 56 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-11 ***************** 11039 S Roberts Rd BILL 205 80.17-1-11 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 13,154 Krzyzanowski Ernest Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 VETS CNTY 41102 3,700 0 Krzyzanowski Marcella 7-6-5 40,500 Medicaid 36,800 235.20 11039 South Roberts Rd ACRES 0.22 County Tax 36,800 195.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952568 NRTH-0904227 Community Colleges 36,800 41.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,643 Town Tax 27,346 14.13 Chargebacks 27,346 0.51 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 40,500 TO 71.97 WD058 Comprehensive Water 40,500 TO 20.71 TOTAL TAX --- 578.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 578.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-12 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 206 80.17-1-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Gilmore Mary Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 PO Box 983 7-6-6.1 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Arcadia, FL 34265 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0952554 NRTH-0904107 Chargebacks 900 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 900 TO 1.60 WD058 Comprehensive Water 900 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 14.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-14 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 207 80.17-1-14 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,500 54.33 Halicki Ronald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,500 County Tax 8,500 45.07 3816 Franklin Ave 9-5-2 8,500 Community Colleges 8,500 9.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 8,500 4.39 EAST-0952574 NRTH-0903793 Chargebacks 8,500 0.16 DEED BOOK 1849 PG-00347 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,500 TO 15.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,888 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,500 TO 4.35 TOTAL TAX --- 132.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 132.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-15 ***************** Cc Road 80 BILL 208 80.17-1-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,300 8.31 Pacos David Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 10758 Center Rd 9-5-6 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 Forestville, NY 14062 ACRES 0.47 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 EAST-0952475 NRTH-0903558 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,300 TO .66 TOTAL TAX --- 20.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.31 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 57 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-17 ***************** 11009 S Roberts Rd BILL 209 80.17-1-17 433 Auto body Medicaid 56,080 358.42 Valentine Leslie K Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,400 County Tax 56,080 297.37 11009 South Roberts Rd 9-5-3.2 56,080 Community Colleges 56,080 62.49 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 56,080 28.99 EAST-0952784 NRTH-0903684 Chargebacks 56,080 1.04 DEED BOOK 2331 PG-821 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,080 TO 99.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,434 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,080 TO 28.68 TOTAL TAX --- 876.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 876.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-18 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 210 80.17-1-18 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 100 0.64 Pacos David J Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 10758 Center Rd 9-5-3.1 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Forestville, NY 14062 ACRES 0.03 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0952847 NRTH-0903623 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-19 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 211 80.17-1-19 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 100 0.64 Valentine Leslie K Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 11009 South Roberts Rd 9-5-4.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.01 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0952780 NRTH-0903598 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 2331 PG-821 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-20 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 212 80.17-1-20 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 9,000 57.52 Pacos David J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 County Tax 9,000 47.72 10758 Center Rd 9-5-4.1 9,000 Community Colleges 9,000 10.03 Forestville, NY 14062 FRNT 170.00 DPTH 287.00 Town Tax 9,000 4.65 EAST-0952756 NRTH-0903539 Chargebacks 9,000 0.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,587 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,000 TO 15.99 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,000 TO 4.60 TOTAL TAX --- 140.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 140.68 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 58 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-21 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 213 80.17-1-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,700 55.60 Pacos David Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,700 County Tax 8,700 46.13 10758 Center Rd 9-1-1 8,700 Community Colleges 8,700 9.69 Forestville, NY 14062 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 8,700 4.50 EAST-0952706 NRTH-0903376 Chargebacks 8,700 0.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,168 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,700 TO 15.46 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,700 TO 4.45 TOTAL TAX --- 135.99** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 135.99 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-22 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 214 80.17-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 10,300 65.83 Pacos David Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,300 County Tax 10,300 54.62 10758 Center Rd 9-2-1 10,300 Community Colleges 10,300 11.48 Forestville, NY 14062 ACRES 2.90 Town Tax 10,300 5.32 EAST-0952751 NRTH-0903147 Chargebacks 10,300 0.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,406 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 10,300 TO 18.30 WD058 Comprehensive Water 10,300 TO 5.27 TOTAL TAX --- 161.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 161.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-24 ***************** Fulstom Ave BILL 215 80.17-1-24 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Wickham Roberta J Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 3814 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-1 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 82.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 EAST-0952488 NRTH-0902954 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 DEED BOOK 1852 PG-00095 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,600 TO 2.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,600 TO .82 TOTAL TAX --- 25.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 25.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-25 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 216 80.17-1-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Wills Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 Wills Mary Jane 9-3-2 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 3812 Greenhurst Ave ACRES 0.18 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952567 NRTH-0902953 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,600 TO 2.84 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,600 TO .82 TOTAL TAX --- 25.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 25.01 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 59 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-26 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 217 80.17-1-26 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,200 14.06 Martin Ronald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,200 County Tax 2,200 11.67 Martin Brenda 9-3-3 2,200 Community Colleges 2,200 2.45 3802 Greenhurst Ave ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 2,200 1.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952666 NRTH-0902953 Chargebacks 2,200 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,077 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,200 TO 3.91 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,200 TO 1.13 TOTAL TAX --- 34.40** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 34.40 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-27 ***************** 3798 Greenhurst Ave BILL 218 80.17-1-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Sell William Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 3798 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-4 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 EAST-0952765 NRTH-0902952 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 DEED BOOK 1797 PG-00020 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 26.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-28 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 219 80.17-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Mcquiggan John F Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 Mcquiggan Nina M 9-3-5 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 3794 Greenhurst Dr FRNT 80.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952847 NRTH-0902951 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 DEED BOOK 1843 PG-00183 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 26.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-29 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 220 80.17-1-29 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,000 383.47 Holly Gary C Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,100 County Tax 60,000 318.15 10967 S Roberts Rd 9-3-6 60,000 Community Colleges 60,000 66.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.66 Town Tax 60,000 31.01 EAST-0953015 NRTH-0902949 Chargebacks 60,000 1.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,916 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,000 TO 106.61 WD058 Comprehensive Water 60,000 TO 30.68 TOTAL TAX --- 937.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 937.89 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 60 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-30 ***************** 10963 S Roberts Rd BILL 221 80.17-1-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 29,000 185.35 Maine Francis W Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,900 County Tax 29,000 153.77 10963 South Roberts Rd 9-3-7.1 29,000 Community Colleges 29,000 32.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.43 Town Tax 29,000 14.99 EAST-0953106 NRTH-0902843 Chargebacks 29,000 0.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 29,000 TO 51.53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 29,000 TO 14.83 TOTAL TAX --- 453.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 453.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-31 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 222 80.17-1-31 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 5,000 Mcquiggan John F Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,000 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Mcquiggan Nina 9-3-7.2 60,610 Medicaid 55,610 355.42 3794 Greenhurst Ave ACRES 0.31 County Tax 55,610 294.87 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952957 NRTH-0902844 Community Colleges 55,610 61.97 DEED BOOK 1663 PG-00012 Town Tax 55,610 28.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,769 Chargebacks 55,610 1.03 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,610 TO 107.70 WD058 Comprehensive Water 60,610 TO 30.99 TOTAL TAX --- 880.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 880.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-32 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 223 80.17-1-32 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,400 15.34 Mcquiggan John F Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 2,400 12.73 Mcquiggan Nina 9-3-8.2 2,400 Community Colleges 2,400 2.67 3794 Greenhurst Ave FRNT 40.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,400 1.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952869 NRTH-0902845 Chargebacks 2,400 0.04 DEED BOOK 1663 PG-00012 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,400 TO 4.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,357 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,400 TO 1.23 TOTAL TAX --- 37.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 37.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-33 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 224 80.17-1-33 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,400 15.34 Mcquiggan John F Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 2,400 12.73 Mcquiggan Nina M 9-3-8.1 2,400 Community Colleges 2,400 2.67 3794 Greenhurst Dr FRNT 40.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,400 1.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952827 NRTH-0902845 Chargebacks 2,400 0.04 DEED BOOK 1843 PG-00183 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,400 TO 4.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,357 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,400 TO 1.23 TOTAL TAX --- 37.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 37.51 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 61 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-34 ***************** 3798 Greenhurst Ave BILL 225 80.17-1-34 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 61,410 392.49 Sell William Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,700 County Tax 61,410 325.63 3798 Greenhurst Rd 9-3-9 61,410 Community Colleges 61,410 68.43 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 61,410 31.74 EAST-0952764 NRTH-0902848 Chargebacks 61,410 1.14 DEED BOOK 1797 PG-00020 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,410 TO 109.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 85,888 WD058 Comprehensive Water 61,410 TO 31.40 TOTAL TAX --- 959.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 959.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-35 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 226 80.17-1-35 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,400 15.34 Martin Ronald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 2,400 12.73 Martin Brenda 9-3-10 2,400 Community Colleges 2,400 2.67 3802 Greenhurst Ave FRNT 40.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,400 1.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952708 NRTH-0902847 Chargebacks 2,400 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,357 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,400 TO 4.26 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,400 TO 1.23 TOTAL TAX --- 37.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 37.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-36 ***************** 3802 Greenhurst Ave BILL 227 80.17-1-36 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Martin Ronald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 Medicaid 64,260 410.70 Martin Brenda 9-3-11 71,610 County Tax 64,260 340.74 3802 Greenhurst Ave FRNT 40.00 DPTH 100.00 Community Colleges 64,260 71.61 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952671 NRTH-0902847 Town Tax 71,610 37.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,154 Chargebacks 71,610 1.33 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 71,610 TO 127.24 WD058 Comprehensive Water 71,610 TO 36.62 TOTAL TAX --- 1,025.25** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,025.25 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-37 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 228 80.17-1-37 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,400 15.34 Martin Ronald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 2,400 12.73 Martin Brenda 9-3-12 2,400 Community Colleges 2,400 2.67 3802 Greenhurst Ave FRNT 40.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,400 1.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952629 NRTH-0902847 Chargebacks 2,400 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,357 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,400 TO 4.26 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,400 TO 1.23 TOTAL TAX --- 37.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 37.51 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 62 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-38 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 229 80.17-1-38 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,500 15.98 Wills Mary Jane Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 2,500 13.26 3812 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-13 2,500 Community Colleges 2,500 2.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 41.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,500 1.29 EAST-0952588 NRTH-0902848 Chargebacks 2,500 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,497 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,500 TO 4.44 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,500 TO 1.28 TOTAL TAX --- 39.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 39.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-39 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 230 80.17-1-39 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Wills Mary Jane Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 AGED C 41802 19,295 0 3812 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-14 43,000 Medicaid 19,295 123.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 41.00 DPTH 100.00 County Tax 19,295 102.31 EAST-0952548 NRTH-0902848 Community Colleges 19,295 21.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,140 Town Tax 43,000 22.23 Chargebacks 43,000 0.80 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 43,000 TO 76.41 WD058 Comprehensive Water 43,000 TO 21.99 TOTAL TAX --- 368.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 368.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-40 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 231 80.17-1-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 39,000 249.26 Wickham Roberta J Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 39,000 206.80 3814 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-15 39,000 Community Colleges 39,000 43.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 41.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 39,000 20.16 EAST-0952508 NRTH-0902849 Chargebacks 39,000 0.72 DEED BOOK 1852 PG-00095 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 39,000 TO 69.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 54,545 WD058 Comprehensive Water 39,000 TO 19.94 TOTAL TAX --- 609.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 609.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-41 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 232 80.17-1-41 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,500 15.98 Wickham Roberta J Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 2,500 13.26 3814 Greenhurst Ave 9-3-16 2,500 Community Colleges 2,500 2.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 41.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 2,500 1.29 EAST-0952468 NRTH-0902849 Chargebacks 2,500 0.05 DEED BOOK 1852 PG-00095 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,500 TO 4.44 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,497 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,500 TO 1.28 TOTAL TAX --- 39.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 39.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 63 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-1 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 233 80.17-2-1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Dejesus Neftali Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 11181 Urban Rd 9-6-4 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 78.00 DPTH 276.00 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 EAST-0953154 NRTH-0903410 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 DEED BOOK 1813 PG-00293 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,500 TO 2.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,500 TO .77 TOTAL TAX --- 23.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-2 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 234 80.17-2-2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 Murphy Clifford 9-6-5 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 3730 New Rd FRNT 78.30 DPTH 214.50 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953170 NRTH-0903331 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 DEED BOOK 1955 PG-00009 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,400 TO 2.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,400 TO .72 TOTAL TAX --- 21.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-3 ****************** Kolpien Ave BILL 235 80.17-2-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,900 12.14 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,900 County Tax 1,900 10.07 Murphy Clifford 9-6-6 1,900 Community Colleges 1,900 2.12 3730 New Rd ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 1,900 0.98 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953520 NRTH-0903369 Chargebacks 1,900 0.04 DEED BOOK 1955 PG-00009 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,900 TO 3.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,657 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,900 TO .97 TOTAL TAX --- 29.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.70 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-4.1 **************** S Roberts Rd BILL 236 80.17-2-4.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,870 11.95 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,870 County Tax 1,870 9.92 Murphy Clifford 9-6-7 1,870 Community Colleges 1,870 2.08 3730 New Rd ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 1,870 0.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954082 NRTH-0903365 Chargebacks 1,870 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,615 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,870 TO 3.32 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,870 TO .96 TOTAL TAX --- 29.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.23 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 64 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-4.2 **************** S Roberts Rd BILL 237 80.17-2-4.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 630 4.03 Hudsonn-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 630 County Tax 630 3.34 3724 New Rd 9-6-7 630 Community Colleges 630 0.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 630 0.33 EAST-0954082 NRTH-0903365 Chargebacks 630 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 881 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 630 TO 1.12 WD058 Comprehensive Water 630 TO .32 TOTAL TAX --- 9.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-5 ****************** Kolpien Ave BILL 238 80.17-2-5 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 7,160 45.76 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 7,160 37.97 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-2 7,160 Community Colleges 7,160 7.98 10972 S Roberts Rd FRNT 80.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 7,160 3.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953399 NRTH-0903133 Chargebacks 7,160 0.13 DEED BOOK 1948 PG-00353 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,160 TO 12.72 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,014 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,160 TO 3.66 TOTAL TAX --- 111.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 111.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-6 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 239 80.17-2-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-3 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10972 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953477 NRTH-0903133 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-7 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 240 80.17-2-7 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-4 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10972 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953558 NRTH-0903132 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 65 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-8 ****************** Kolpien Rd BILL 241 80.17-2-8 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Sek Michael K Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Sek Julie B 9-7-5 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10923 South Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953640 NRTH-0903131 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-9 ****************** Kopien Ave BILL 242 80.17-2-9 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Sek Michael K Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Sek Julie B 9-7-6 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 10932 South Roberts Rd ACRES 0.83 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953760 NRTH-0903131 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-10 ***************** Kopien Ave BILL 243 80.17-2-10 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Purol Bonnie 9-7-7 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.83 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953919 NRTH-0903129 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-11 ***************** Kopien Ave BILL 244 80.17-2-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Purol Bonnie 9-7-8 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954038 NRTH-0903128 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 66 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-12 ***************** Kopien Ave BILL 245 80.17-2-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Purol Bonnie 9-7-9 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954118 NRTH-0903128 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-13.1 *************** Kopien Ave BILL 246 80.17-2-13.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 930 5.94 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 930 County Tax 930 4.93 Purol Bonnie 9-7-10 930 Community Colleges 930 1.04 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 930 0.48 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954279 NRTH-0903127 Chargebacks 930 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,301 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 930 TO 1.65 WD058 Comprehensive Water 930 TO .48 TOTAL TAX --- 14.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-13.2 *************** Kopien Ave BILL 247 80.17-2-13.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 470 3.00 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 470 County Tax 470 2.49 3724 New Rd 9-7-10 470 Community Colleges 470 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 470 0.24 EAST-0954279 NRTH-0903127 Chargebacks 470 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 657 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 470 TO .84 WD058 Comprehensive Water 470 TO .24 TOTAL TAX --- 7.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-14 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 248 80.17-2-14 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 3724 New Rd 9-7-11 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0954357 NRTH-0902901 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 67 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-15 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 249 80.17-2-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Purol Bonnie 9-7-12 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954277 NRTH-0902902 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-16 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 250 80.17-2-16 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 Purol Bonnie 9-7-13 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954116 NRTH-0902903 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,400 TO 2.49 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,400 TO .72 TOTAL TAX --- 21.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-17 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 251 80.17-2-17 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Purol Bonnie 9-7-14 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.82 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953915 NRTH-0902904 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-18 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 252 80.17-2-18 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Sek Michael K Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Sek Julie B 9-7-15 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 10932 South Roberts Rd ACRES 0.82 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953756 NRTH-0902905 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 68 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-19 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 253 80.17-2-19 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Sek Michael K Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Sek Julie B 9-7-16 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10932 South Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953636 NRTH-0902905 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-20 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 254 80.17-2-20 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-17 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 10972 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953554 NRTH-0902906 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-21 ***************** Rear Land Off Roberts Rd BILL 255 80.17-2-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 300 1.92 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 300 1.59 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-18.1 300 Community Colleges 300 0.33 10972 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 300 0.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953485 NRTH-0902906 Chargebacks 300 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 420 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300 TO .53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 300 TO .15 TOTAL TAX --- 4.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-22 ***************** Rear Of Roberts Rd BILL 256 80.17-2-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Halicki Angeline M Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 10948 South Roberts Rd 9-7-18.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 42.00 DPTH 114.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0953448 NRTH-0902855 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 2292 PG-609 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 69 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-23 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 257 80.17-2-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 111,000 709.43 Kaminski Angeline M Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 111,000 588.58 10948 S Roberts Rd 9-7-19 111,000 Community Colleges 111,000 123.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.51 Town Tax 111,000 57.37 EAST-0953345 NRTH-0902854 Chargebacks 111,000 2.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,245 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 111,000 TO 197.24 WD058 Comprehensive Water 111,000 TO 56.76 TOTAL TAX --- 1,735.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,735.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-24 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 258 80.17-2-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 50,000 319.56 Burlingame David E Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 County Tax 50,000 265.13 10966 S Roberts Rd 9-7-20 50,000 Community Colleges 50,000 55.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 122.00 DPTH 255.00 Town Tax 50,000 25.84 EAST-0953322 NRTH-0902970 Chargebacks 50,000 0.93 DEED BOOK 1789 PG-00248 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,000 TO 88.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,930 WD058 Comprehensive Water 50,000 TO 25.57 TOTAL TAX --- 781.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 781.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-25 ***************** 10972 S Roberts Rd BILL 259 80.17-2-25 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 65,000 415.43 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 65,000 344.67 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-21 65,000 Community Colleges 65,000 72.43 10972 Roberts Rd FRNT 123.00 DPTH 175.50 Town Tax 65,000 33.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953261 NRTH-0903082 Chargebacks 65,000 1.20 DEED BOOK 1948 PG-00353 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 65,000 TO 115.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 90,909 WD058 Comprehensive Water 65,000 TO 33.24 TOTAL TAX --- 1,016.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,016.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-2-26 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 260 80.17-2-26 311 Res vac land Medicaid 5,400 34.51 Brandt Carl O Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,400 County Tax 5,400 28.63 Fafinski Deborah A 9-7-1 5,400 Community Colleges 5,400 6.02 10972 S Roberts Rd FRNT 122.00 DPTH 272.80 Town Tax 5,400 2.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953238 NRTH-0903193 Chargebacks 5,400 0.10 DEED BOOK 1948 PG-00353 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,400 TO 9.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,552 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,400 TO 2.76 TOTAL TAX --- 84.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 84.41 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 70 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-1 ****************** Cc Road 80 BILL 261 80.18-1-1 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 1,300 8.31 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 PO Box 648 9-6-8 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.60 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 EAST-0954855 NRTH-0903356 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,300 TO .66 TOTAL TAX --- 20.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-2 ****************** New Rd BILL 262 80.18-1-2 312 Vac w/imprv AG DIST 41720 25,670 25,670 Alvarado Mayra Dunkirk Csd 060300 32,700 Medicaid 20,930 133.77 10750 Temple St 9-6-11, 9-9-1 46,600 County Tax 20,930 110.98 Dunkirk, NY 14048 9-10-1.2 9-13-1.2 Community Colleges 20,930 23.32 9-6-9 Town Tax 20,930 10.82 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT ACRES 25.50 Chargebacks 20,930 0.39 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 EAST-0955661 NRTH-0903024 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 46,600 TO 82.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,175 WD058 Comprehensive Water 46,600 TO 23.83 TOTAL TAX --- 385.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 385.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-6 ****************** Kolpien Ave BILL 263 80.18-1-6 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 200 1.28 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 PO Box 648 9-8-5 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 200 0.10 EAST-0955212 NRTH-0903116 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 WD058 Comprehensive Water 200 TO .10 TOTAL TAX --- 3.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-7 ****************** Alma Ave BILL 264 80.18-1-7 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 400 2.56 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 400 County Tax 400 2.12 PO Box 648 9-8-6 400 Community Colleges 400 0.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 400 0.21 EAST-0955170 NRTH-0902893 Chargebacks 400 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 400 TO .71 WD058 Comprehensive Water 400 TO .20 TOTAL TAX --- 6.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6.26 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 71 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-8 ****************** Kolpien Ave BILL 265 80.18-1-8 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 200 1.28 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 PO Box 648 9-8-4 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 200 0.10 EAST-0955138 NRTH-0903117 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 WD058 Comprehensive Water 200 TO .10 TOTAL TAX --- 3.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-9 ****************** Kolpien Ave BILL 266 80.18-1-9 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 1,300 8.31 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 PO Box 648 9-8-3 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 EAST-0954855 NRTH-0903119 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,300 TO .66 TOTAL TAX --- 20.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-10 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 267 80.18-1-10 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 1,300 8.31 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 PO Box 648 9-8-7 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 EAST-0954850 NRTH-0902896 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,300 TO .66 TOTAL TAX --- 20.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-11 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 268 80.18-1-11 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 100 0.64 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 PO Box 648 9-8-8 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0954529 NRTH-0902898 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 72 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-12 ***************** Kolpien Ave BILL 269 80.18-1-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Mekus Steven Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 43251 Waverly Ct 9-8-2 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Hollywood, MD 20636 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0954568 NRTH-0903123 Chargebacks 500 0.01 DEED BOOK 1683 PG-00186 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.18-1-13 ***************** Haze Ave BILL 270 80.18-1-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Mekus Steven Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 43251 Waverly Ct 9-8-1 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Hollywood, MD 20636 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0954491 NRTH-0903124 Chargebacks 500 0.01 DEED BOOK 1683 PG-00186 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-2 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 271 95.02-1-2 322 Rural vac>10 - WTRFNT Medicaid 338,000 2,160.24 G H Graf Realty Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 338,000 County Tax 338,000 1,792.26 PO Box 214 2-1-1.4 338,000 Community Colleges 338,000 376.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 51.90 Town Tax 338,000 174.71 EAST-0935997 NRTH-0902203 Chargebacks 338,000 6.26 DEED BOOK 1998 PG-00070 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 338,000 TO 715.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 472,727 SW002 Shorewood water 338,000 TO C 26.30 TOTAL TAX --- 5,251.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,251.53 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-3 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 272 95.02-1-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,200 58.80 G H Graf Realty Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 9,200 48.78 PO Box 214 3-4-3 9,200 Community Colleges 9,200 10.25 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 9,200 4.76 EAST-0936530 NRTH-0901839 Chargebacks 9,200 0.17 DEED BOOK 1998 PG-00070 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,200 TO 19.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,867 SW002 Shorewood water 9,200 TO C .72 TOTAL TAX --- 142.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 142.94 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 73 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-4 ****************** 4662 W Lake Rd BILL 273 95.02-1-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 91,310 583.58 Grace Douglas J Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 91,310 484.18 Grace Jane S 3-4-2 91,310 Community Colleges 91,310 101.75 4662 W Lake Rd ACRES 0.59 Town Tax 91,310 47.20 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936590 NRTH-0902010 Chargebacks 91,310 1.69 DEED BOOK 2066 PG-00224 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 91,310 TO 193.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,706 SW002 Shorewood water 91,310 TO C 7.10 TOTAL TAX --- 1,418.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,418.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-5 ****************** 4658 W Lake Rd BILL 274 95.02-1-5 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Panek John T Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 VET DIS C 41142 7,800 0 Panek Marilyn J 3-4-1.2 78,000 Medicaid 62,850 401.69 4658 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.01 County Tax 62,850 333.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936624 NRTH-0902110 Community Colleges 62,850 70.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,091 Town Tax 78,000 40.32 Chargebacks 78,000 1.44 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 78,000 TO 165.03 SW002 Shorewood water 78,000 TO C 6.07 TOTAL TAX --- 1,017.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,017.84 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-6 ****************** 4652 W Lake Rd BILL 275 95.02-1-6 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Rosario Wilfredo Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 Medicaid 68,470 437.61 4652 W Lake Rd 3-4-1.1 72,880 County Tax 68,470 363.07 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.80 Community Colleges 68,470 76.30 EAST-0936653 NRTH-0902416 Town Tax 72,880 37.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,930 Chargebacks 72,880 1.35 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,880 TO 154.20 SW002 Shorewood water 72,880 TO C 5.67 TOTAL TAX --- 1,075.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,075.87 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 74 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-9 ****************** 10866 Temple Rd BILL 276 95.02-1-9 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Victor Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 Medicaid 32,650 208.67 10866 Temple Rd 3-3-7 40,000 County Tax 32,650 173.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.89 Community Colleges 32,650 36.38 EAST-0937636 NRTH-0902959 Town Tax 40,000 20.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,944 Chargebacks 40,000 0.74 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 40,000 TO 84.63 SW002 Shorewood water 40,000 TO C 3.11 TOTAL TAX --- 527.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 527.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-10 ***************** 4617 W Lake Rd BILL 277 95.02-1-10 210 1 Family Res VET WAR CT 41121 4,410 8,820 Hayden Warde C Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 Medicaid 70,590 451.16 Hayden Nancy J 3-3-6 75,000 County Tax 70,590 374.31 4617 West Lake Rd ACRES 2.60 Community Colleges 70,590 78.66 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937764 NRTH-0903219 Town Tax 66,180 34.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,895 Chargebacks 66,180 1.22 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 75,000 TO 158.68 SW002 Shorewood water 75,000 TO C 5.84 TOTAL TAX --- 1,104.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,104.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-11 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 278 95.02-1-11 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Schafer Audrey A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 10860 Temple Rd 3-3-8.3 58,000 Medicaid 50,650 323.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.30 County Tax 50,650 268.57 EAST-0937881 NRTH-0902928 Community Colleges 50,650 56.44 DEED BOOK 1887 PG-00153 Town Tax 40,224 20.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,119 Chargebacks 40,224 0.74 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 58,000 TO 122.71 SW002 Shorewood water 58,000 TO C 4.51 TOTAL TAX --- 797.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 797.48 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 75 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-12 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 279 95.02-1-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 400 2.56 Schafer Audrey A Dunkirk Csd 060300 400 County Tax 400 2.12 10860 Temple Rd 3-3-8.4 400 Community Colleges 400 0.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 131.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 400 0.21 EAST-0938090 NRTH-0902954 Chargebacks 400 0.01 DEED BOOK 1972 PG-00311 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 400 TO .85 FULL MARKET VALUE 559 SW002 Shorewood water 400 TO C .03 TOTAL TAX --- 6.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6.23 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-13 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 280 95.02-1-13 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,244 Rizzo John C Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,600 VETS CNTY 41102 1,300 0 Rizzo Sandra L 3-3-8.2 72,900 Medicaid 71,600 457.61 10850 Temple Rd ACRES 0.94 County Tax 71,600 379.66 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937980 NRTH-0902807 Community Colleges 71,600 79.78 DEED BOOK 1683 PG-00072 Town Tax 71,656 37.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,958 Chargebacks 71,656 1.33 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,900 TO 154.24 SW002 Shorewood water 72,900 TO C 5.67 TOTAL TAX --- 1,115.33** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,115.33 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-18 ***************** Next To RR BILL 281 95.02-1-18 120 Field crops AG COMMIT 41730 290 290 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,900 Medicaid 1,610 10.29 Fred Milagros 3-7-2 1,900 County Tax 1,610 8.54 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 5.60 Community Colleges 1,610 1.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940007 NRTH-0901793 Town Tax 1,610 0.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,657 Chargebacks 1,610 0.03 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,900 TO 4.02 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,900 TO .97 TOTAL TAX --- 26.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 76 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-20 ***************** Next To RR BILL 282 95.02-1-20 120 Field crops AG COMMIT 41730 9,770 9,770 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 23,700 Medicaid 13,930 89.03 Fred Milagros 3-7-4 23,700 County Tax 13,930 73.86 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 38.60 Community Colleges 13,930 15.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0939569 NRTH-0900814 Town Tax 13,930 7.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 33,147 Chargebacks 13,930 0.26 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 23,700 TO 50.14 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 23,700 TO 12.12 TOTAL TAX --- 248.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 248.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-21 ***************** 4534 Willow Rd BILL 283 95.02-1-21 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Lawrie Robert W Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,600 Medicaid 61,090 390.44 4534 Willow Rd 4-3-3.3 65,500 County Tax 61,090 323.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.70 Community Colleges 61,090 68.07 EAST-0939758 NRTH-0899690 Town Tax 65,500 33.86 DEED BOOK 1890 PG-00326 Chargebacks 65,500 1.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,608 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 65,500 TO 138.58 WD058 Comprehensive Water 65,500 TO 33.50 TOTAL TAX --- 989.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 989.59 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-22 ***************** 4542 Willow Rd BILL 284 95.02-1-22 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 95,580 610.87 Ellis Eirik Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,200 County Tax 95,580 506.82 4542 Willow Road 4-3-4 95,580 Community Colleges 95,580 106.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.83 Town Tax 95,580 49.40 EAST-0939907 NRTH-0899373 Chargebacks 95,580 1.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 133,678 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 95,580 TO 202.22 WD058 Comprehensive Water 95,580 TO 48.88 TOTAL TAX --- 1,526.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,526.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 77 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-23 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 285 95.02-1-23 120 Field crops AG COMMIT 41730 1,260 1,260 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 Medicaid 6,840 43.72 Fred Milagros 4-3-3.1 8,100 County Tax 6,840 36.27 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 17.60 Community Colleges 6,840 7.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0939507 NRTH-0899486 Town Tax 6,840 3.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,329 Chargebacks 6,840 0.13 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,100 TO 17.14 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,100 TO 4.14 TOTAL TAX --- 112.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 112.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-24 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 286 95.02-1-24 120 Field crops AG COMMIT 41730 1,900 1,900 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,200 Medicaid 12,300 78.61 Fred Milagros 4-3-2 14,200 County Tax 12,300 65.22 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 32.80 Community Colleges 12,300 13.71 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938679 NRTH-0899245 Town Tax 12,300 6.36 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,860 Chargebacks 12,300 0.23 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 14,200 TO 30.04 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 14,200 TO 7.26 TOTAL TAX --- 201.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 201.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-26 ***************** Next To RR BILL 287 95.02-1-26 120 Field crops AG DIST 41720 180 180 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 Medicaid 420 2.68 Fred Milagros 3-7-5 600 County Tax 420 2.23 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 1.00 Community Colleges 420 0.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938600 NRTH-0900250 Town Tax 420 0.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 Chargebacks 420 0.01 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 600 TO 1.27 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 WD058 Comprehensive Water 600 TO .31 TOTAL TAX --- 7.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.19 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 78 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-30 ***************** 10750 Temple Rd BILL 288 95.02-1-30 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 21,390 21,390 Alvarado Mayra Dunkirk Csd 060300 34,100 Medicaid 81,080 518.20 10750 Temple Rd 3-3-10 102,470 County Tax 81,080 429.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.70 Community Colleges 81,080 90.35 EAST-0938068 NRTH-0900864 Town Tax 81,080 41.91 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 143,315 Chargebacks 81,080 1.50 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 102,470 TO 216.80 SW002 Shorewood water 102,470 TO C 7.97 TOTAL TAX --- 1,306.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,306.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-31 ***************** 10727 Temple Rd BILL 289 95.02-1-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 95,000 607.17 Mockovak Paul W II Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,000 County Tax 95,000 503.74 10727 Temple Rd 3-5-5.2 95,000 Community Colleges 95,000 105.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.50 Town Tax 95,000 49.10 EAST-0937587 NRTH-0900380 Chargebacks 95,000 1.76 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,867 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 95,000 TO 201.00 SW002 Shorewood water 95,000 TO C 7.39 TOTAL TAX --- 1,476.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,476.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-32 ***************** 10727 Temple Rd BILL 290 95.02-1-32 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 5,700 36.43 Mockovak Paul W II Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 County Tax 5,700 30.22 10727 Temple Rd 3-5-5.1 5,700 Community Colleges 5,700 6.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 5,700 2.95 EAST-0937633 NRTH-0900683 Chargebacks 5,700 0.11 DEED BOOK 2114 PG-00459 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,700 TO 12.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,972 SW002 Shorewood water 5,700 TO C .44 TOTAL TAX --- 88.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 88.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-33 ***************** 10750 Temple Rd BILL 291 95.02-1-33 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 8,120 8,120 Alvarado Mayra Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 Medicaid 3,080 19.68 10750 Temple Rd 3-5-4 11,200 County Tax 3,080 16.33 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 10.30 Community Colleges 3,080 3.43 EAST-0937558 NRTH-0901240 Town Tax 3,080 1.59 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 15,664 Chargebacks 3,080 0.06 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,200 TO 23.70 SW002 Shorewood water 11,200 TO C .87 TOTAL TAX --- 65.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 65.66 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 79 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-36 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 292 95.02-1-36 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 10,800 69.03 TLC Properties Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 10,800 57.27 Lamar Advertising 3-5-1 10,800 Community Colleges 10,800 12.03 1565 WEST 12TH St ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 10,800 5.58 Erie, PA 16501 EAST-0937246 NRTH-0902573 Chargebacks 10,800 0.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,105 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 10,800 TO 22.85 SW002 Shorewood water 10,800 TO C .84 TOTAL TAX --- 167.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 167.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-38 ***************** 4657 W Lake Rd BILL 293 95.02-1-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 70,110 448.09 Lyford Craig Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 70,110 371.76 Lyford Rosemary 3-5-10.1 70,110 Community Colleges 70,110 78.12 4657 West Lake Rd ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 70,110 36.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936980 NRTH-0901927 Chargebacks 70,110 1.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 98,056 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 70,110 TO 148.34 SW002 Shorewood water 70,110 TO C 5.45 TOTAL TAX --- 1,089.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,089.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-39 ***************** 4663 W Lake Rd BILL 294 95.02-1-39 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,955 Byham Michael F Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,100 VETS CNTY 41102 550 0 4663 W Lake Rd 3-5-9 86,500 Medicaid 85,950 549.33 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.90 County Tax 85,950 455.75 EAST-0936836 NRTH-0901816 Community Colleges 85,950 95.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,979 Town Tax 84,545 43.70 Chargebacks 84,545 1.56 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 86,500 TO 183.01 SW002 Shorewood water 86,500 TO C 6.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,335.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,335.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-40 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 295 95.02-1-40 311 Res vac land Medicaid 5,200 33.23 Dunkirk Ben Miss Ed Inst Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,200 County Tax 5,200 27.57 111 South Rdg Ste 302 3-5-8 5,200 Community Colleges 5,200 5.79 Rye Brook, NY 10573 ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 5,200 2.69 EAST-0936861 NRTH-0901574 Chargebacks 5,200 0.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,273 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,200 TO 11.00 SW002 Shorewood water 5,200 TO C .40 TOTAL TAX --- 80.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 80.78 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 80 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-41 ***************** 4701 W Lake Rd BILL 296 95.02-1-41 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 33,000 210.91 Perry James Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,700 County Tax 33,000 174.98 4701 W Lake Rd 3-5-7.1 33,000 Community Colleges 33,000 36.77 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 20.10 Town Tax 33,000 17.06 EAST-0936908 NRTH-0900997 Chargebacks 33,000 0.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,154 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 33,000 TO 69.82 SW002 Shorewood water 33,000 TO C 2.57 TOTAL TAX --- 512.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 512.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-44 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 297 95.02-1-44 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Nasca Ronald A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 4719 West Lake Rd 3-5-6.1 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 580.00 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 EAST-0936678 NRTH-0900206 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 DEED BOOK 1860 PG-00243 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,600 TO 3.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 SW002 Shorewood water 1,600 TO C .12 TOTAL TAX --- 24.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-45 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 298 95.02-1-45 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 29,000 185.35 Nasca Ronald A Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,600 County Tax 29,000 153.77 4719 West Lake Rd 4-1-1 29,000 Community Colleges 29,000 32.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 29,000 14.99 EAST-0936479 NRTH-0900114 Chargebacks 29,000 0.54 DEED BOOK 1860 PG-00243 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 29,000 TO 61.36 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,559 SW002 Shorewood water 29,000 TO C 2.26 TOTAL TAX --- 450.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 450.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-46 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 299 95.02-1-46 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,900 12.14 Nasca Ronald A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,900 County Tax 1,900 10.07 4719 West Lake Rd 4-1-2 1,900 Community Colleges 1,900 2.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 1,900 0.98 EAST-0936673 NRTH-0900092 Chargebacks 1,900 0.04 DEED BOOK 1860 PG-00243 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,900 TO 4.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,657 SW002 Shorewood water 1,900 TO C .15 TOTAL TAX --- 29.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.52 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 81 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-47 ***************** 10727 Temple Rd BILL 300 95.02-1-47 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Mockovak Paul W II Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 10727 Temple Rd 4-1-3 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.70 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0937250 NRTH-0899909 Chargebacks 900 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 900 TO 1.90 SW002 Shorewood water 900 TO C .07 TOTAL TAX --- 13.98** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13.98 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-48 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 301 95.02-1-48 449 Other Storag Medicaid 149,100 952.93 Casella Waste Mngmnt of NY Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 83,200 County Tax 149,100 790.61 3903 Bellaire Blvd 4-1-4 149,100 Community Colleges 149,100 166.14 Houston, TX 77025 ACRES 11.00 Town Tax 149,100 77.07 EAST-0936837 NRTH-0899681 Chargebacks 149,100 2.76 DEED BOOK 1688 PG-00195 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 149,100 TO 315.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 208,531 SW002 Shorewood water 149,100 TO C 11.60 TOTAL TAX --- 2,316.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,316.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-49 ***************** 4743 W Lake Rd BILL 302 95.02-1-49 433 Auto body Medicaid 20,000 127.82 Vecchiarella Vincent J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,400 County Tax 20,000 106.05 4740 Willow Rd 4-1-5 20,000 Community Colleges 20,000 22.29 PO Box 658 ACRES 3.90 Town Tax 20,000 10.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048-9501 EAST-0936725 NRTH-0899122 Chargebacks 20,000 0.37 DEED BOOK 2113 PG-00193 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 20,000 TO 42.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,972 SW002 Shorewood water 20,000 TO C 1.56 TOTAL TAX --- 310.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 310.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-50 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 303 95.02-1-50 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 76,500 488.93 Vecchiarella Vincent J Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,100 County Tax 76,500 405.64 4740 Willow Rd 4-1-6.1 76,500 Community Colleges 76,500 85.24 PO Box 658 ACRES 3.60 Town Tax 76,500 39.54 Dunkirk, NY 14048-9501 EAST-0936403 NRTH-0899056 Chargebacks 76,500 1.42 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,993 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 76,500 TO 161.86 SW002 Shorewood water 76,500 TO C 5.95 TOTAL TAX --- 1,188.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,188.58 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 82 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-51 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 304 95.02-1-51 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,600 54.96 Vecchiarella Vincent J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 8,600 45.60 4740 Willow Rd 4-1-6.2 8,600 Community Colleges 8,600 9.58 PO Box 658 ACRES 0.57 Town Tax 8,600 4.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048-9501 EAST-0936418 NRTH-0899425 Chargebacks 8,600 0.16 DEED BOOK 2156 PG-00521 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,600 TO 18.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,028 SW002 Shorewood water 8,600 TO C .67 TOTAL TAX --- 133.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 133.62 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-52 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 305 95.02-1-52 553 Country club Medicaid 791,000 5,055.46 Shorewood Assoc Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 227,500 County Tax 791,000 4,194.31 4958 Shorewood Dr 2-1-8.1 791,000 Community Colleges 791,000 881.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 141.00 Town Tax 791,000 408.85 EAST-0934328 NRTH-0899212 Chargebacks 791,000 14.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 1106,294 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 791,000 TO 1,673.57 SW002 Shorewood water 791,000 TO C 61.54 TOTAL TAX --- 12,289.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 12,289.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-53 ***************** 4732 W Lake Rd BILL 306 95.02-1-53 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 50,500 322.76 Greene Kenneth D Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,800 County Tax 50,500 267.78 4732 W Lake Rd 2-1-7 50,500 Community Colleges 50,500 56.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.00 Town Tax 50,500 26.10 EAST-0936152 NRTH-0899802 Chargebacks 50,500 0.93 DEED BOOK 2141 PG-00054 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 50,500 TO 106.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,629 SW002 Shorewood water 50,500 TO C 3.93 TOTAL TAX --- 784.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 784.62 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-54 ***************** 4722 W Lake Rd BILL 307 95.02-1-54 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 56,000 357.91 Tilley Kelly Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 56,000 296.94 Jourdanais Edward W 2-1-6 56,000 Community Colleges 56,000 62.40 c/o Patricia Jourdanais ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 56,000 28.95 4722 W Lake Rd EAST-0936158 NRTH-0900098 Chargebacks 56,000 1.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 DEED BOOK 2630 PG-212 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 56,000 TO 118.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,322 SW002 Shorewood water 56,000 TO C 4.36 TOTAL TAX --- 870.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 870.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 83 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-55 ***************** 4722 W Lake Rd BILL 308 95.02-1-55 311 Res vac land Medicaid 7,800 49.85 Tilley Kelly Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,800 County Tax 7,800 41.36 Jourdanais Edward W 2-1-5 7,800 Community Colleges 7,800 8.69 c/o Patricia Jourdanais FRNT 86.60 DPTH 258.00 Town Tax 7,800 4.03 4722 W Lake Rd EAST-0936259 NRTH-0900213 Chargebacks 7,800 0.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 DEED BOOK 2630 PG-212 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,800 TO 16.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,909 SW002 Shorewood water 7,800 TO C .61 TOTAL TAX --- 121.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 121.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-56 ***************** 4716 W Lake Rd BILL 309 95.02-1-56 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 6,399 Wunder Robert M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,300 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 4716 W Lake Rd 2-1-4 60,000 VET DIS C 41142 9,000 0 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 258.00 Medicaid 43,650 278.98 EAST-0936261 NRTH-0900306 County Tax 43,650 231.46 DEED BOOK 1656 PG-00160 Community Colleges 43,650 48.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,916 Town Tax 53,601 27.71 Chargebacks 53,601 0.99 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 60,000 TO 126.95 SW002 Shorewood water 60,000 TO C 4.67 TOTAL TAX --- 719.40** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 719.40 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-57 ***************** 4710 W Lake Rd BILL 310 95.02-1-57 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 43,000 274.82 Tynan Stephen J Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,900 County Tax 43,000 228.01 Tynan Maureen S 2-1-3 43,000 Community Colleges 43,000 47.92 4710 West Lake Rd ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 43,000 22.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936266 NRTH-0900475 Chargebacks 43,000 0.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,140 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 43,000 TO 90.98 SW002 Shorewood water 43,000 TO C 3.35 TOTAL TAX --- 668.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 668.11 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 84 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-58 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 311 95.02-1-58 322 Rural vac>10 Medicaid 6,400 40.90 Village of Fredonia Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,400 County Tax 6,400 33.94 9-11 Church St 2-1-2 6,400 Community Colleges 6,400 7.13 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 17.00 Town Tax 6,400 3.31 EAST-0935312 NRTH-0900417 Chargebacks 6,400 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,951 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 6,400 TO 13.54 SW002 Shorewood water 6,400 TO C .50 TOTAL TAX --- 99.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 99.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-59 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 312 95.02-1-59 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 208,530 1,332.76 Ayuyao Nilo F Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,100 County Tax 208,530 1,105.74 Henson Ruth D 2-1-13 208,530 Community Colleges 208,530 232.37 4885 Shorewood Dr E ACRES 0.98 Town Tax 208,530 107.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0934027 NRTH-0900258 Chargebacks 208,530 3.86 DEED BOOK 2098 PG-00124 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 208,530 TO 441.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 291,650 SW002 Shorewood water 208,530 TO C 16.22 TOTAL TAX --- 3,239.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,239.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-60 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 313 95.02-1-60 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,100 19.81 Shorewood Assoc Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,100 County Tax 3,100 16.44 4958 Shorewood Dr 2-1-14.1 3,100 Community Colleges 3,100 3.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 120.00 Town Tax 3,100 1.60 EAST-0934200 NRTH-0900355 Chargebacks 3,100 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,336 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,100 TO 6.56 SW002 Shorewood water 3,100 TO C .24 TOTAL TAX --- 48.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 48.16 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-61 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 314 95.02-1-61 311 Res vac land Medicaid 17,300 110.57 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,300 County Tax 17,300 91.73 4880 Shorewood Dr E 2-1-14.2 17,300 Community Colleges 17,300 19.28 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 151.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 17,300 8.94 EAST-0934099 NRTH-0900426 Chargebacks 17,300 0.32 DEED BOOK 2098 PG-00119 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,300 TO 36.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,196 SW002 Shorewood water 17,300 TO C 1.35 TOTAL TAX --- 268.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 268.79 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 85 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-1 ****************** Wilbur Rd BILL 315 95.03-1-1 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 32,670 208.80 O'brocta Steven W Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,900 County Tax 32,670 173.23 10508 Wilbur Rd 1-12-2.10 32,670 Community Colleges 32,670 36.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 19.10 Town Tax 32,670 16.89 EAST-0931488 NRTH-0896545 Chargebacks 32,670 0.60 DEED BOOK 2032 PG-00224 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 32,670 TO 69.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 45,692 SW002 Shorewood water 32,670 TO C 2.54 TOTAL TAX --- 507.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 507.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-2 ****************** Wilbur Rd BILL 316 95.03-1-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 44,390 283.71 O'brocta Steven W Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 44,390 235.38 10508 Wilbur Rd O'brocta Diana 1/4 Of1/2 44,390 Community Colleges 44,390 49.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 Interest Town Tax 44,390 22.94 1-12-2.20 Chargebacks 44,390 0.82 ACRES 1.50 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 44,390 TO 93.92 EAST-0932066 NRTH-0896345 SW002 Shorewood water 44,390 TO C 3.45 DEED BOOK 3136 PG-00219 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,084 TOTAL TAX --- 689.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 689.68 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-3 ****************** 10508 Wilbur Rd BILL 317 95.03-1-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,460 386.41 O'brocta Walter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,000 County Tax 60,460 320.59 10508 Wilbur Rd 2-5-14 60,460 Community Colleges 60,460 67.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.50 Town Tax 60,460 31.25 EAST-0932572 NRTH-0896384 Chargebacks 60,460 1.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,559 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 60,460 TO 127.92 SW002 Shorewood water 60,460 TO C 4.70 TOTAL TAX --- 939.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 939.36 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-5 ****************** Wilbur Rd BILL 318 95.03-1-5 320 Rural vacant Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Smoczynski Arthur Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 Smoczynski Elaine 2-5-16.2 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 10538 Wilbur Rd ACRES 0.17 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932308 NRTH-0896828 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,600 TO 3.39 SW002 Shorewood water 1,600 TO C .12 TOTAL TAX --- 24.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.86 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 86 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-6.1 **************** 10530 Wilbur Rd BILL 319 95.03-1-6.1 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 94,570 604.42 Fields Kamie L Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,770 County Tax 94,570 501.46 10530 Wilbur Rd 2-5-16.1 94,570 Community Colleges 94,570 105.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.14 Town Tax 94,570 48.88 EAST-0932573 NRTH-0896709 Chargebacks 94,570 1.75 DEED BOOK 1756 PG-00072 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 94,570 TO 200.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,266 SW002 Shorewood water 94,570 TO C 7.36 TOTAL TAX --- 1,469.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,469.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-6.2 **************** 10530 Wilbur Rd BILL 320 95.03-1-6.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 430 2.75 Smoczynski Arthur F Dunkirk Csd 060300 430 County Tax 430 2.28 Smoczynski Elaine 2-5-16.1 430 Community Colleges 430 0.48 10538 Wilbur Rd FRNT 70.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 430 0.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932573 NRTH-0896709 Chargebacks 430 0.01 DEED BOOK 1756 PG-00072 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 430 TO .91 FULL MARKET VALUE 601 SW002 Shorewood water 430 TO C .03 TOTAL TAX --- 6.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6.68 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-7 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 321 95.03-1-7 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 58,500 373.89 O'brocta Paul T Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,800 County Tax 58,500 310.20 4905 W Lake Rd 2-5-13.1 58,500 Community Colleges 58,500 65.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 16.50 Town Tax 58,500 30.24 EAST-0933121 NRTH-0897199 Chargebacks 58,500 1.08 DEED BOOK 2349 PG-814 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 58,500 TO 123.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,818 SW002 Shorewood water 58,500 TO C 4.55 TOTAL TAX --- 908.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 908.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-8 ****************** 4901 W Lake Rd BILL 322 95.03-1-8 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Polvino Russell D Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,000 Medicaid 91,550 585.12 4901 W Lake Rd 2-5-13.2 98,900 County Tax 91,550 485.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.50 Community Colleges 91,550 102.01 EAST-0933285 NRTH-0897748 Town Tax 98,900 51.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,322 Chargebacks 98,900 1.83 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 98,900 TO 209.25 SW002 Shorewood water 98,900 TO C 7.69 TOTAL TAX --- 1,442.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,442.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 87 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-9 ****************** 4893 W Lake Rd BILL 323 95.03-1-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 38,500 246.06 Kwiej Alphonse Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 38,500 204.15 Kwiej Sadie J 2-5-12 38,500 Community Colleges 38,500 42.90 4893 W Lake Rd ACRES 3.30 Town Tax 38,500 19.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0933389 NRTH-0897194 Chargebacks 38,500 0.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,846 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 38,500 TO 81.46 SW002 Shorewood water 38,500 TO C 3.00 TOTAL TAX --- 598.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 598.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-10 ***************** 4891 W Lake Rd BILL 324 95.03-1-10 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 51,000 325.95 Gee James L Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 51,000 270.43 4891 West Lake Rd 2-5-11 51,000 Community Colleges 51,000 56.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.30 Town Tax 51,000 26.36 EAST-0933464 NRTH-0897193 Chargebacks 51,000 0.94 DEED BOOK 2083 PG-00198 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 51,000 TO 107.90 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,329 SW002 Shorewood water 51,000 TO C 3.97 TOTAL TAX --- 792.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 792.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-11.1 *************** W Lake Rd BILL 325 95.03-1-11.1 446 Cold storage Medicaid 123,860 791.62 A. Sam Family Farm LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 88,860 County Tax 123,860 656.77 PO Box 407 2-5-8 123,860 Community Colleges 123,860 138.02 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 22.10 Town Tax 123,860 64.02 EAST-0933779 NRTH-0897190 Chargebacks 123,860 2.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 173,231 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 123,860 TO 262.06 SW002 Shorewood water 123,860 TO C 9.64 TOTAL TAX --- 1,924.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,924.42 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-11.2 *************** W Lake Rd BILL 326 95.03-1-11.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,640 10.48 Sam Charles E Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,640 County Tax 1,640 8.70 PO Box 407 2-5-8 1,640 Community Colleges 1,640 1.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.40 Town Tax 1,640 0.85 EAST-0933779 NRTH-0897190 Chargebacks 1,640 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,294 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,640 TO 3.47 SW002 Shorewood water 1,640 TO C .13 TOTAL TAX --- 25.49** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 25.49 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 88 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-12 ***************** 4869 W Lake Rd BILL 327 95.03-1-12 446 Cold storage Medicaid 310,520 1,984.61 A. Sam Family Farm LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 29,900 County Tax 310,520 1,646.55 PO Box 407 2-5-10 310,520 Community Colleges 310,520 346.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.25 Town Tax 310,520 160.50 EAST-0933655 NRTH-0897914 Chargebacks 310,520 5.75 FULL MARKET VALUE 434,294 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 310,520 TO 656.99 SW002 Shorewood water 310,520 TO C 24.16 TOTAL TAX --- 4,824.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,824.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-13.1 *************** 4873 W Lake Rd BILL 328 95.03-1-13.1 314 Rural vac<10 Medicaid 280 1.79 A. Sam Family Farm LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 280 County Tax 280 1.48 PO Box 407 2-5-9 280 Community Colleges 280 0.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.02 Town Tax 280 0.14 EAST-0933904 NRTH-0898051 Chargebacks 280 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 392 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 280 TO .59 SW002 Shorewood water 280 TO C .02 TOTAL TAX --- 4.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.03-1-13.2 *************** 4873 W Lake Rd BILL 329 95.03-1-13.2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 195,000 1,246.29 Sam Charles E Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,420 County Tax 195,000 1,034.00 PO Box 407 2-5-9 195,000 Community Colleges 195,000 217.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 195,000 100.79 EAST-0933904 NRTH-0898051 Chargebacks 195,000 3.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 272,727 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 195,000 TO 412.57 SW002 Shorewood water 195,000 TO C 15.17 TOTAL TAX --- 3,029.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,029.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-1 ****************** 4855 W Lake Rd BILL 330 95.04-1-1 242 Rurl res&rec P-RATA VET 41003 0 5,511 Trippi Vincent Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,500 VETS CNTY 41102 1,550 0 4855 West Lake Rd 2-5-7 73,390 Medicaid 71,840 459.15 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.42 County Tax 71,840 380.93 EAST-0934216 NRTH-0897185 Community Colleges 71,840 80.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,643 Town Tax 67,879 35.09 Chargebacks 67,879 1.26 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 73,390 TO 155.28 SW002 Shorewood water 73,390 TO C 5.71 TOTAL TAX --- 1,117.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,117.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 89 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-3 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 331 95.04-1-3 444 Lumber yd/ml Medicaid 424,020 2,710.01 Erie Shore Holdings LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 134,000 County Tax 424,020 2,248.38 4867 W Lake Rd includes 95.04-1-2 424,020 Community Colleges 424,020 472.49 Dunkirk, NY 14048 2-5-6.2 Town Tax 424,020 219.17 ACRES 18.00 Chargebacks 424,020 7.85 EAST-0934546 NRTH-0897910 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 424,020 TO 897.12 DEED BOOK 1963 PG-00078 SW002 Shorewood water 424,020 TO C 32.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 593,035 TOTAL TAX --- 6,588.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,588.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-4 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 332 95.04-1-4 447 Truck termnl Medicaid 239,220 1,528.91 Rexford William C Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,600 County Tax 239,220 1,268.47 9466 Lamberton Rd 2-5-5 239,220 Community Colleges 239,220 266.56 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 10.70 Town Tax 239,220 123.65 EAST-0935046 NRTH-0897490 Chargebacks 239,220 4.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 334,573 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 239,220 TO 506.13 SW002 Shorewood water 239,220 TO C 18.61 TOTAL TAX --- 3,716.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,716.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-5 ****************** West Lake Rd BILL 333 95.04-1-5 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Porpiglia Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,600 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 326 Dove St 2-5-4 68,500 Medicaid 63,500 405.84 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.70 County Tax 63,500 336.71 EAST-0935435 NRTH-0897759 Community Colleges 63,500 70.76 DEED BOOK 1794 PG-00278 Town Tax 50,724 26.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,804 Chargebacks 50,724 0.94 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 68,500 TO 144.93 SW002 Shorewood water 68,500 TO C 5.33 TOTAL TAX --- 990.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 990.73 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 90 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-6 ****************** 4791 W Lake Rd BILL 334 95.04-1-6 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 80,700 515.77 Gotowka Timothy M A Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,000 County Tax 80,700 427.92 4791 West Lake Rd 2-5-3.1 80,700 Community Colleges 80,700 89.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.20 Town Tax 80,700 41.71 EAST-0935758 NRTH-0898124 Chargebacks 80,700 1.49 DEED BOOK 1738 PG-00212 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 80,700 TO 170.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,867 SW002 Shorewood water 80,700 TO C 6.28 TOTAL TAX --- 1,253.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,253.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-8 ****************** 4757 Willow Rd BILL 335 95.04-1-8 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 33,860 216.41 Catalano Frederick D Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 33,860 179.54 10604 Linwood Dr 2-5-3.2 33,860 Community Colleges 33,860 37.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.60 Town Tax 33,860 17.50 EAST-0936057 NRTH-0898731 Chargebacks 33,860 0.63 DEED BOOK 1929 PG-00548 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 33,860 TO 71.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,357 SW002 Shorewood water 33,860 TO C 2.63 TOTAL TAX --- 526.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 526.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-14 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 336 95.04-1-14 311 Res vac land Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Fred Milagros Combined With 4-4-3.1 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 10655 Temple Rd 4-4-2 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 EAST-0937528 NRTH-0898799 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO DEED BOOK 2346 PG-484 WD058 Comprehensive Water 0 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 0 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 91 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-15 ***************** 10655 Temple Rd BILL 337 95.04-1-15 241 Rural res&ag AG COMMIT 41730 8,570 8,570 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 23,200 GREENHOUSE 42120 5,800 5,800 Fred Milagros 4-4-3.1 152,100 Medicaid 137,730 880.26 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 12.90 County Tax 137,730 730.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938041 NRTH-0898946 Community Colleges 137,730 153.47 DEED BOOK 2346 PG-484 Town Tax 137,730 71.19 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 212,727 Chargebacks 137,730 2.55 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 146,300 TO 309.54 5,800 EX WD058 Comprehensive Water 146,300 TO 74.82 5,800 EX TOTAL TAX --- 2,222.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,222.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-16 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 338 95.04-1-16 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Tilley Steven R Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 Anizewski Stephanie L 4-4-3.2 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 PO Box 485 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 218.00 Town Tax 900 0.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938263 NRTH-0898359 Chargebacks 900 0.02 DEED BOOK 1676 PG-00221 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 900 TO 1.90 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 WD058 Comprehensive Water 900 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 14.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-17 ***************** 4636 Willow Rd BILL 339 95.04-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Tilley Steven R Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,800 County Tax 64,000 339.36 Anizewski Stephanie L 4-4-4 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 PO Box 485 ACRES 0.42 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938203 NRTH-0898346 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 64,000 TO 135.41 WD058 Comprehensive Water 64,000 TO 32.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,022.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,022.12 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 92 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-18 ***************** 4644 Willow Rd BILL 340 95.04-1-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 63,500 405.84 Vecchio Constantino Life Us Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 63,500 336.71 Vecchio Anna Life Us 4-4-5 63,500 Community Colleges 63,500 70.76 4644 Willow Rd ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 63,500 32.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938004 NRTH-0898307 Chargebacks 63,500 1.18 DEED BOOK 2631 PG-885 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 63,500 TO 134.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,811 WD058 Comprehensive Water 63,500 TO 32.47 TOTAL TAX --- 1,014.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,014.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-19 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 341 95.04-1-19 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,800 11.50 DeMonte Kenneth Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 1,800 9.54 156 Willow Rd 4-4-7.2 1,800 Community Colleges 1,800 2.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 1,800 0.93 EAST-0937727 NRTH-0898367 Chargebacks 1,800 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,800 TO 3.81 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,800 TO .92 TOTAL TAX --- 28.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 28.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-20 ***************** 4678 Willow Rd BILL 342 95.04-1-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 88,340 564.60 Jakubowski William Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 County Tax 88,340 468.43 4678 Willow Rd 4-4-6 88,340 Community Colleges 88,340 98.44 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.80 Town Tax 88,340 45.66 EAST-0937472 NRTH-0898321 Chargebacks 88,340 1.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,552 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 88,340 TO 186.91 WD058 Comprehensive Water 88,340 TO 45.18 TOTAL TAX --- 1,410.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,410.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-21 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 343 95.04-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 30,470 194.74 Bender Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,900 County Tax 30,470 161.57 4996 Morewood Dr 4-4-7.1 30,470 Community Colleges 30,470 33.95 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.90 Town Tax 30,470 15.75 EAST-0937320 NRTH-0898503 Chargebacks 30,470 0.56 DEED BOOK 2009 PG-00485 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 30,470 TO 64.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 42,615 WD058 Comprehensive Water 30,470 TO 15.58 TOTAL TAX --- 486.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 486.62 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 93 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-22 ***************** 10603 Chestnut Rd BILL 344 95.04-1-22 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 39,500 252.45 Hubbard Amber L Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,300 County Tax 39,500 209.45 10603 Chestnut Rd 4-5-2 39,500 Community Colleges 39,500 44.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.24 Town Tax 39,500 20.42 EAST-0936884 NRTH-0898263 Chargebacks 39,500 0.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,245 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 39,500 TO 83.57 WD058 Comprehensive Water 39,500 TO 20.20 TOTAL TAX --- 630.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 630.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-24 ***************** 10593 Chestnut St BILL 345 95.04-1-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 58,000 370.69 Botticello Michael A Sr Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 58,000 307.55 Botticello Lisa M 4-5-3 58,000 Community Colleges 58,000 64.63 10593 Chestnut Rd ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 58,000 29.98 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936716 NRTH-0898034 Chargebacks 58,000 1.07 DEED BOOK 1902 PG-00475 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 58,000 TO 122.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,119 WD058 Comprehensive Water 58,000 TO 29.66 TOTAL TAX --- 926.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 926.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-25 ***************** Chestnut Rd BILL 346 95.04-1-25 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 47,600 304.22 Szukala John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,800 County Tax 47,600 252.40 Szukala Dolores 4-5-4 47,600 Community Colleges 47,600 53.04 10577 Temple Rd ACRES 12.00 Town Tax 47,600 24.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936877 NRTH-0897707 Chargebacks 47,600 0.88 DEED BOOK 2063 PG-00137 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 47,600 TO 100.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,573 WD058 Comprehensive Water 47,600 TO 24.34 TOTAL TAX --- 760.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 760.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-26 ***************** Chestnut Rd BILL 347 95.04-1-26 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Szukala John Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 10577 Temple Rd 4-5-5 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 PO Box 64 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937196 NRTH-0897672 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 DEED BOOK 2063 PG-00137 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,000 TO 2.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.97 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 94 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-27 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 348 95.04-1-27 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 192,300 1,229.03 Ellman James D Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,800 County Tax 192,300 1,019.68 Griffis Cynthia S 4-6-2.2.3 192,300 Community Colleges 192,300 214.28 10520 Chestnut Rd ACRES 7.50 Town Tax 192,300 99.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937680 NRTH-0897419 Chargebacks 192,300 3.56 DEED BOOK 2079 PG-00564 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 192,300 TO 406.86 FULL MARKET VALUE 268,951 WD058 Comprehensive Water 192,300 TO 98.34 TOTAL TAX --- 3,071.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,071.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-28 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 349 95.04-1-28 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 24,900 24,900 Demonte Kenneth Dunkirk Csd 060300 41,600 Medicaid 79,050 505.23 156 Willow Rd 4-6-2.2.4 103,950 County Tax 79,050 419.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 24.40 Community Colleges 79,050 88.09 EAST-0938055 NRTH-0897728 Town Tax 79,050 40.86 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2119 PG-00014 Chargebacks 79,050 1.46 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FULL MARKET VALUE 145,385 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 103,950 TO 219.93 WD058 Comprehensive Water 103,950 TO 53.16 TOTAL TAX --- 1,327.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,327.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-29 ***************** 10607 Temple Rd BILL 350 95.04-1-29 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 47,700 304.86 Strefeler Steven F Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 47,700 252.93 10607 Temple Rd 4-6-1 47,700 Community Colleges 47,700 53.15 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.33 Town Tax 47,700 24.66 EAST-0938451 NRTH-0898200 Chargebacks 47,700 0.88 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,713 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 47,700 TO 100.92 WD058 Comprehensive Water 47,700 TO 24.39 TOTAL TAX --- 761.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 761.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-30 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 351 95.04-1-30 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 27,000 172.56 Smoczynski Arthur C Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 27,000 143.17 10538 Wilbur Rd 4-7-1 27,000 Community Colleges 27,000 30.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 27,000 13.96 EAST-0938741 NRTH-0898248 Chargebacks 27,000 0.50 DEED BOOK 2001 PG-00519 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 27,000 TO 57.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,762 WD058 Comprehensive Water 27,000 TO 13.81 TOTAL TAX --- 431.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 431.22 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 95 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-31 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 352 95.04-1-31 484 1 use sm bld Medicaid 228,700 1,461.67 Chadwick Bay Broadcasting Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 68,400 County Tax 228,700 1,212.69 PO Box 209 4-7-3 228,700 Community Colleges 228,700 254.84 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 15.60 Town Tax 228,700 118.21 EAST-0939913 NRTH-0898791 Chargebacks 228,700 4.23 DEED BOOK 2139 PG-00634 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 228,700 TO 483.87 FULL MARKET VALUE 319,860 WD058 Comprehensive Water 228,700 TO 116.95 TOTAL TAX --- 3,652.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,652.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-32 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 353 95.04-1-32 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 71,270 71,270 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 85,200 Medicaid 27,030 172.75 Fred Milagros 4-7-4.2.2 98,300 County Tax 27,030 143.33 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 32.40 Community Colleges 27,030 30.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0939517 NRTH-0898004 Town Tax 27,030 13.97 DEED BOOK 2074 PG-00557 Chargebacks 27,030 0.50 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 137,483 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 98,300 TO 207.98 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 98,300 TO 50.27 TOTAL TAX --- 618.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 618.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-33 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 354 95.04-1-33 311 Res vac land AG COMMIT 41730 360 360 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 400 Medicaid 40 0.26 Fred Milagros 4-7-4.3 400 County Tax 40 0.21 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 0.11 Community Colleges 40 0.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0939084 NRTH-0897636 Town Tax 40 0.02 DEED BOOK 2074 PG-00557 Chargebacks 40 0.00 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 559 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 400 TO .85 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 400 TO .20 TOTAL TAX --- 1.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.58 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 96 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-34 ***************** 10576 Temple Rd BILL 355 95.04-1-34 210 1 Family Res CW_15_VET/ 41162 4,410 0 Walldorff Henry Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 Medicaid 63,090 403.22 10576 Temple Rd 4-7-4.1 67,500 County Tax 63,090 334.54 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.84 Community Colleges 63,090 70.30 EAST-0939111 NRTH-0897518 Town Tax 67,500 34.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,406 Chargebacks 67,500 1.25 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,500 TO 142.81 WD058 Comprehensive Water 67,500 TO 34.52 TOTAL TAX --- 1,021.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,021.53 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-35 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 356 95.04-1-35 120 Field crops Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Walldorff Henry G Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 10576 Temple Rd 4-7-4.2.1 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.40 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 EAST-0939319 NRTH-0897360 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,400 TO 2.96 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,400 TO .72 TOTAL TAX --- 22.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 22.36 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-36 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 357 95.04-1-36 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 11,050 11,050 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,100 Medicaid 3,050 19.49 Fred Milagros 4-7-5 14,100 County Tax 3,050 16.17 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 7.60 Community Colleges 3,050 3.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940041 NRTH-0897261 Town Tax 3,050 1.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,720 Chargebacks 3,050 0.06 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 14,100 TO 29.83 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 14,100 TO 7.21 TOTAL TAX --- 77.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 77.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-37 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 358 95.04-1-37 152 Vineyard Medicaid 4,200 26.84 Joy Russell C Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,200 County Tax 4,200 22.27 Joy Barbara B 4-9-1 4,200 Community Colleges 4,200 4.68 556 Temple St ACRES 3.90 Town Tax 4,200 2.17 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0939761 NRTH-0896252 Chargebacks 4,200 0.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 4,200 TO 8.89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,200 TO 2.15 TOTAL TAX --- 67.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 67.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 97 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-39 ***************** 10577 Temple Rd BILL 359 95.04-1-39 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 82,000 524.08 Szukala John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,900 County Tax 82,000 434.81 PO Box 64 4-6-2.1 82,000 Community Colleges 82,000 91.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 180.00 DPTH 117.00 Town Tax 82,000 42.38 EAST-0938882 NRTH-0897458 Chargebacks 82,000 1.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,685 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 82,000 TO 173.49 WD058 Comprehensive Water 82,000 TO 41.93 TOTAL TAX --- 1,309.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,309.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-40 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 360 95.04-1-40 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Szukala John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 10577 Temple Rd 4-6-2.2.1 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 PO Box 64 ACRES 0.09 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938720 NRTH-0897433 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 DEED BOOK 2136 PG-00067 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,000 TO 2.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-41 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 361 95.04-1-41 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 320 320 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 400 Medicaid 80 0.51 Fred Milagros 4-6-2.3 400 County Tax 80 0.42 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 0.18 Community Colleges 80 0.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938852 NRTH-0897322 Town Tax 80 0.04 DEED BOOK 2074 PG-00561 Chargebacks 80 0.00 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 559 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 400 TO .85 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 400 TO .20 TOTAL TAX --- 2.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2.11 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-42 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 362 95.04-1-42 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 28,830 28,830 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 35,100 Medicaid 6,270 40.07 Fred Milagros 4-6-2.2.2 35,100 County Tax 6,270 33.25 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 12.90 Community Colleges 6,270 6.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938636 NRTH-0897123 Town Tax 6,270 3.24 DEED BOOK 2074 PG-00561 Chargebacks 6,270 0.12 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 49,091 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 35,100 TO 74.26 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 35,100 TO 17.95 TOTAL TAX --- 175.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 175.88 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 98 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-43 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 363 95.04-1-43 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 17,780 17,780 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,600 Medicaid 3,820 24.41 Fred Milagros 4-6-3 21,600 County Tax 3,820 20.26 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 7.70 Community Colleges 3,820 4.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938895 NRTH-0896675 Town Tax 3,820 1.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,210 Chargebacks 3,820 0.07 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 21,600 TO 45.70 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 21,600 TO 11.05 TOTAL TAX --- 107.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 107.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-44.1 *************** 10523 Chestnut St BILL 364 95.04-1-44.1 322 Rural vac>10 AG COMMIT 41730 4,220 4,220 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,130 Medicaid 1,910 12.21 Fred Milagros 4-6-4 6,130 County Tax 1,910 10.13 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 4.60 Community Colleges 1,910 2.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0938129 NRTH-0896697 Town Tax 1,910 0.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,573 Chargebacks 1,910 0.04 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 6,130 TO 12.97 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 6,130 TO 3.13 TOTAL TAX --- 41.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 41.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-44.2 *************** 10523 Chestnut St BILL 365 95.04-1-44.2 322 Rural vac>10 Medicaid 8,270 52.86 Ihrig Steven Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,270 County Tax 8,270 43.85 5076 West Shorewood Dr 4-6-4 8,270 Community Colleges 8,270 9.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.20 Town Tax 8,270 4.27 EAST-0938129 NRTH-0896697 Chargebacks 8,270 0.15 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 11,566 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,270 TO 17.50 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2016 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,270 TO 4.23 TOTAL TAX --- 132.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 132.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-45 ***************** 10523 Chestnut Rd BILL 366 95.04-1-45 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 85,700 547.73 Briggs James R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,600 County Tax 85,700 454.43 Briggs Kimberley A 4-5-6.2 85,700 Community Colleges 85,700 95.50 10523 Chestnut Rd ACRES 2.25 Town Tax 85,700 44.30 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0937438 NRTH-0897140 Chargebacks 85,700 1.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 119,860 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 85,700 TO 181.32 WD058 Comprehensive Water 85,700 TO 43.83 TOTAL TAX --- 1,368.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,368.70 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 99 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-46 ***************** Chestnut Rd BILL 367 95.04-1-46 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 11,440 11,440 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 34,200 Medicaid 22,760 145.46 Fred Milagros 4-5-6.1 34,200 County Tax 22,760 120.69 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 34.65 Community Colleges 22,760 25.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936907 NRTH-0896787 Town Tax 22,760 11.76 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,832 Chargebacks 22,760 0.42 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 34,200 TO 72.36 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 34,200 TO 17.49 TOTAL TAX --- 393.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 393.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-47 ***************** Chestnut Rd BILL 368 95.04-1-47 323 Vacant rural Medicaid 7,700 49.21 Szukala John Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,700 County Tax 7,700 40.83 10577 Temple Rd 2-3-2 7,700 Community Colleges 7,700 8.58 PO Box 64 ACRES 24.96 Town Tax 7,700 3.98 Dunkirk, NY 14063 EAST-0936016 NRTH-0896990 Chargebacks 7,700 0.14 DEED BOOK 2063 PG-00137 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,700 TO 16.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,769 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,700 TO 3.94 TOTAL TAX --- 122.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 122.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-1 ****************** 4958 Shorewood Dr BILL 369 95.10-1-1 553 Country club - WTRFNT Medicaid 385,000 2,460.62 Shorewood Assoc Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 138,000 County Tax 385,000 2,041.48 4958 Shorewood Dr 2-4-20 385,000 Community Colleges 385,000 429.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.30 Town Tax 385,000 199.00 EAST-0932468 NRTH-0899301 Chargebacks 385,000 7.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 538,462 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 385,000 TO 814.57 SW002 Shorewood water 385,000 TO C 29.95 TOTAL TAX --- 5,981.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,981.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-2 ****************** 4948 Shorewood Dr BILL 370 95.10-1-2 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 205,000 1,310.20 Simcik Christopher S Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 205,000 1,087.02 Doyle Jane L 2-4-19 205,000 Community Colleges 205,000 228.43 Trustee FRNT 80.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 205,000 105.96 4948 Shorewood Dr EAST-0932666 NRTH-0899416 Chargebacks 205,000 3.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 DEED BOOK 1991 PG-00370 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 205,000 TO 433.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 286,713 SW002 Shorewood water 205,000 TO C 15.95 TOTAL TAX --- 3,185.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,185.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 100 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-3 ****************** 4944 Shorewood Dr BILL 371 95.10-1-3 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 123,500 789.32 Barbuto Richard V Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 123,500 654.86 Barbuto Ann K 2-4-18.2 123,500 Community Colleges 123,500 137.62 1707 Ridge Rd FRNT 80.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 123,500 63.83 Leavenworth, KS 66048 EAST-0932731 NRTH-0899462 Chargebacks 123,500 2.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,727 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 123,500 TO 261.30 SW002 Shorewood water 123,500 TO C 9.61 TOTAL TAX --- 1,918.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,918.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-4 ****************** 4940 Shorewood Dr BILL 372 95.10-1-4 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 140,650 898.93 Reiner Henry C Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 140,650 745.80 4940 Shorewood Dr 2-4-18.1 140,650 Community Colleges 140,650 156.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 140,650 72.70 EAST-0932796 NRTH-0899508 Chargebacks 140,650 2.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,713 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 140,650 TO 297.58 SW002 Shorewood water 140,650 TO C 10.94 TOTAL TAX --- 2,185.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,185.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-6 ****************** Shorewood Dr BILL 373 95.10-1-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 17,250 110.25 Garretson Homer E Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,250 County Tax 17,250 91.47 Garretson Gloria 2-4-18.3.2 17,250 Community Colleges 17,250 19.22 4942 Shorewood Dr FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 17,250 8.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932876 NRTH-0899569 Chargebacks 17,250 0.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,126 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,250 TO 36.50 SW002 Shorewood water 17,250 TO C 1.34 TOTAL TAX --- 268.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 268.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-7 ****************** 4932 E Shorewood Dr BILL 374 95.10-1-7 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 160,000 1,022.60 Garretson Gloria O Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 160,000 848.41 4932 Shorewood Dr 2-4-17 160,000 Community Colleges 160,000 178.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.56 Town Tax 160,000 82.70 EAST-0932953 NRTH-0899620 Chargebacks 160,000 2.96 DEED BOOK 1715 PG-00266 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 160,000 TO 338.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 223,776 SW002 Shorewood water 160,000 TO C 12.45 TOTAL TAX --- 2,485.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,485.93 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 101 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-8 ****************** 4928 Shorewood Dr BILL 375 95.10-1-8 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 157,000 1,003.42 Safford Thomas B Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 157,000 832.50 Safford Jamie R 2-4-16 157,000 Community Colleges 157,000 174.95 PO Box 8 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 157,000 81.15 Stonyford, CA 95979 EAST-0933033 NRTH-0899713 Chargebacks 157,000 2.91 DEED BOOK 1661 PG-00299 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 157,000 TO 332.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 219,580 SW002 Shorewood water 157,000 TO C 12.21 TOTAL TAX --- 2,439.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,439.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-9 ****************** 4922 Shorewood Dr BILL 376 95.10-1-9 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 291,720 1,864.45 Bishop Jay G Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 291,720 1,546.86 4922 Shorewood Dr 2-4-15 291,720 Community Colleges 291,720 325.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 291,720 150.78 EAST-0933123 NRTH-0899796 Chargebacks 291,720 5.40 DEED BOOK 2334 PG-131 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 291,720 TO 617.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 408,000 SW002 Shorewood water 291,720 TO C 22.70 TOTAL TAX --- 4,532.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,532.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-10 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 377 95.10-1-10 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 3,300 21.09 Bishop Jay G Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,300 County Tax 3,300 17.50 12 Center St 2-4-14 3,300 Community Colleges 3,300 3.68 Fredonia, NY 14063 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 3,300 1.71 EAST-0933184 NRTH-0899854 Chargebacks 3,300 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,615 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,300 TO 6.98 SW002 Shorewood water 3,300 TO C .26 TOTAL TAX --- 51.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 51.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-12.1 *************** 4912 Shorewood Dr BILL 378 95.10-1-12.1 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 231,420 1,479.06 Nash Donald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 93,000 County Tax 231,420 1,227.11 Nash Sarah B 2-4-13 231,420 Community Colleges 231,420 257.87 36 Central Ave FRNT 240.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 231,420 119.62 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0933288 NRTH-0899952 Chargebacks 231,420 4.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 323,664 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 231,420 TO 489.63 SW002 Shorewood water 231,420 TO C 18.00 TOTAL TAX --- 3,595.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,595.57 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 102 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-12.2 *************** 4912 Shorewood Dr BILL 379 95.10-1-12.2 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 15,580 99.58 Bishop G. Jay Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,580 County Tax 15,580 82.61 4922 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-13 15,580 Community Colleges 15,580 17.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 240.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 15,580 8.05 EAST-0933288 NRTH-0899952 Chargebacks 15,580 0.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 21,790 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 15,580 TO 32.96 SW002 Shorewood water 15,580 TO C 1.21 TOTAL TAX --- 242.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 242.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-13 ***************** 4912 Shorewood Dr BILL 380 95.10-1-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,700 55.60 Nash Donald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,700 County Tax 8,700 46.13 Nash Sarah B 2-1-9 8,700 Community Colleges 8,700 9.69 36 Central Ave ACRES 0.61 Town Tax 8,700 4.50 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0933516 NRTH-0899896 Chargebacks 8,700 0.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,168 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,700 TO 18.41 SW002 Shorewood water 8,700 TO C .68 TOTAL TAX --- 135.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 135.17 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-14 ***************** 4912 Shorewood Dr BILL 381 95.10-1-14 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 30,000 191.74 Nash Donald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 30,000 County Tax 30,000 159.08 Nash Sarah B 2-4-12 30,000 Community Colleges 30,000 33.43 36 Central Ave FRNT 80.00 DPTH 197.00 Town Tax 30,000 15.51 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0933402 NRTH-0900058 Chargebacks 30,000 0.56 DEED BOOK 1914 PG-00164 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 30,000 TO 63.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,958 SW002 Shorewood water 30,000 TO C 2.33 TOTAL TAX --- 466.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 466.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-15 ***************** 4904 Shorewood Dr BILL 382 95.10-1-15 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 130,150 831.82 Welka Adrian A Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 130,150 690.13 4904 Shorewood Dr 2-4-11 130,150 Community Colleges 130,150 145.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 195.00 Town Tax 130,150 67.27 EAST-0933464 NRTH-0900114 Chargebacks 130,150 2.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 182,028 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 130,150 TO 275.37 SW002 Shorewood water 130,150 TO C 10.13 TOTAL TAX --- 2,022.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,022.16 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 103 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-16 ***************** 4904 Shorewood Dr BILL 383 95.10-1-16 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 7,000 44.74 Welka Adrian A Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,000 County Tax 7,000 37.12 4904 Shorewood Dr 2-4-10.2 7,000 Community Colleges 7,000 7.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 202.00 Town Tax 7,000 3.62 EAST-0933502 NRTH-0900147 Chargebacks 7,000 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,790 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,000 TO 14.81 SW002 Shorewood water 7,000 TO C .54 TOTAL TAX --- 108.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 108.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-17 ***************** 4901 Shorewood Dr BILL 384 95.10-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 190,000 1,214.33 Osula Collins Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,400 County Tax 190,000 1,007.48 4901 Shorewood Dr 2-1-10 190,000 Community Colleges 190,000 211.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.89 Town Tax 190,000 98.21 EAST-0933657 NRTH-0899966 Chargebacks 190,000 3.52 DEED BOOK 1705 PG-00042 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 190,000 TO 401.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,734 SW002 Shorewood water 190,000 TO C 14.78 TOTAL TAX --- 2,952.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,952.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-18 ***************** 4895 Shorewood Dr BILL 385 95.10-1-18 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 63,000 402.65 Lawrence Jonathan I Dunkirk Csd 060300 63,000 County Tax 63,000 334.06 Lawrence Margaret J 2-4-10.1 63,000 Community Colleges 63,000 70.20 4895 Shorewood Dr ACRES 0.18 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0933557 NRTH-0900204 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 63,000 TO 133.29 SW002 Shorewood water 63,000 TO C 4.90 TOTAL TAX --- 978.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 978.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-19 ***************** 4895 Shorewood Dr BILL 386 95.10-1-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 319,130 2,039.63 Lawrence Jonathan I Dunkirk Csd 060300 22,400 County Tax 319,130 1,692.20 Lawrence Margaret J 2-1-11 319,130 Community Colleges 319,130 355.61 4895 Shorewood Dr FRNT 160.00 DPTH 320.00 Town Tax 319,130 164.95 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0933800 NRTH-0900046 Chargebacks 319,130 5.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 446,336 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 319,130 TO 675.20 SW002 Shorewood water 319,130 TO C 24.83 US001 Unpaid sewer 20.00 MT 20.00 TOTAL TAX --- 4,978.33** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,978.33 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 104 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-20 ***************** 4892 Shorewood Dr BILL 387 95.10-1-20 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 206,650 1,320.75 Putnam Daniel A Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 206,650 1,095.77 4892 Shorewood Dr 2-4-9 206,650 Community Colleges 206,650 230.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 202.00 Town Tax 206,650 106.81 EAST-0933655 NRTH-0900291 Chargebacks 206,650 3.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,021 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 206,650 TO 437.22 SW002 Shorewood water 206,650 TO C 16.08 TOTAL TAX --- 3,210.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,210.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-21 ***************** 4889 Shorewood Dr BILL 388 95.10-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 218,230 1,394.76 Genovese Ralph Dunkirk Csd 060300 22,800 County Tax 218,230 1,157.17 4889 Shorewood Dr 2-1-12 218,230 Community Colleges 218,230 243.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 300.00 Town Tax 218,230 112.80 EAST-0933933 NRTH-0900140 Chargebacks 218,230 4.04 DEED BOOK 1911 PG-00415 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 218,230 TO 461.72 FULL MARKET VALUE 305,217 SW002 Shorewood water 218,230 TO C 16.98 TOTAL TAX --- 3,390.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,390.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-22 ***************** 4888 Shorewood Dr E BILL 389 95.10-1-22 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 151,690 969.49 Boelter Karl E Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 151,690 804.34 4888 Shorewood Drive East 2-4-8 151,690 Community Colleges 151,690 169.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 151,690 78.41 EAST-0933726 NRTH-0900365 Chargebacks 151,690 2.81 DEED BOOK 1723 PG-00269 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 151,690 TO 320.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 212,154 SW002 Shorewood water 151,690 TO C 11.80 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 2,356.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,356.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-23 ***************** 4884 Shorewood Dr BILL 390 95.10-1-23 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 210,420 1,344.84 Kutner Mark M Dunkirk Csd 060300 69,000 County Tax 210,420 1,115.76 Kutner Rita K 2-4-7 210,420 Community Colleges 210,420 234.47 4884 Shorewood Dr FRNT 160.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 210,420 108.76 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0933810 NRTH-0900451 Chargebacks 210,420 3.89 DEED BOOK 2109 PG-00085 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 210,420 TO 445.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 294,294 SW002 Shorewood water 210,420 TO C 16.37 US001 Unpaid sewer 12.30 MT 12.30 TOTAL TAX --- 3,281.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,281.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 105 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-24 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 391 95.10-1-24 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 19,000 121.43 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,000 County Tax 19,000 100.75 4880 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-6 19,000 Community Colleges 19,000 21.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 19,000 9.82 EAST-0933882 NRTH-0900521 Chargebacks 19,000 0.35 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 19,000 TO 40.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 26,573 SW002 Shorewood water 19,000 TO C 1.48 TOTAL TAX --- 295.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 295.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-25 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 392 95.10-1-25 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 19,000 121.43 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,000 County Tax 19,000 100.75 4880 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-5 19,000 Community Colleges 19,000 21.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 19,000 9.82 EAST-0933910 NRTH-0900548 Chargebacks 19,000 0.35 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 19,000 TO 40.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 26,573 SW002 Shorewood water 19,000 TO C 1.48 TOTAL TAX --- 295.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 295.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-26 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 393 95.10-1-26 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,000 VET DIS C 41142 14,700 0 4880 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-4 194,500 Medicaid 172,450 1,102.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 County Tax 172,450 914.42 EAST-0933938 NRTH-0900575 Community Colleges 172,450 192.16 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 Town Tax 194,500 100.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 272,028 Chargebacks 194,500 3.60 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 194,500 TO 411.52 SW002 Shorewood water 194,500 TO C 15.13 TOTAL TAX --- 2,739.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,739.53 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-27 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 394 95.10-1-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,000 12.78 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 County Tax 2,000 10.61 4880 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-3 2,000 Community Colleges 2,000 2.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 2,000 1.03 EAST-0933977 NRTH-0900597 Chargebacks 2,000 0.04 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,000 TO 4.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,797 SW002 Shorewood water 2,000 TO C .16 TOTAL TAX --- 31.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 31.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 106 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-28 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 395 95.10-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 4880 E Shorewood Dr 2-4-2 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 180.00 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 EAST-0934020 NRTH-0900605 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,000 TO 2.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 SW002 Shorewood water 1,000 TO C .08 TOTAL TAX --- 15.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-29 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 396 95.10-1-29 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Will Edward D Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 1,600 8.48 4880 East Shorewood Dr 2-4-1 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 95.00 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 EAST-0934082 NRTH-0900620 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 DEED BOOK 2134 PG-00578 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,600 TO 3.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 SW002 Shorewood water 1,600 TO C .12 TOTAL TAX --- 24.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-1 ****************** 5174 Woodland BILL 397 95.13-1-1 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 80,500 514.49 Callagee Christine A Dunkirk Csd 060300 54,600 County Tax 80,500 426.85 828 Sea Pine Ln 1-1-40 80,500 Community Colleges 80,500 89.70 Las Vegas, NV 89107 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 220.00 Town Tax 80,500 41.61 EAST-0928947 NRTH-0897198 Chargebacks 80,500 1.49 DEED BOOK 1802 PG-00063 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 80,500 TO 170.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,587 SW002 Shorewood water 80,500 TO C 6.26 US001 Unpaid sewer 677.80 MT 677.80 TOTAL TAX --- 1,928.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,928.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-2 ****************** 5170 Shorewood Dr BILL 398 95.13-1-2 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 295,000 1,885.41 Strychalski James T Dunkirk Csd 060300 69,000 County Tax 295,000 1,564.25 Strychalski Irene D 1-1-39 295,000 Community Colleges 295,000 328.72 5170 Shorewood Dr FRNT 138.00 DPTH 260.00 Town Tax 295,000 152.48 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929032 NRTH-0897266 Chargebacks 295,000 5.46 DEED BOOK 1727 PG-00070 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 295,000 TO 624.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 412,587 SW002 Shorewood water 295,000 TO C 22.95 TOTAL TAX --- 4,583.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,583.42 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 107 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-3 ****************** 5162 Shorewood Dr BILL 399 95.13-1-3 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 136,000 869.21 Matson Marion H Dunkirk Csd 060300 55,500 County Tax 136,000 721.15 Jill Hoovler 1-1-38 136,000 Community Colleges 136,000 151.55 162 Griswold Ct ACRES 0.57 Town Tax 136,000 70.30 Delaware, OH 43015 EAST-0929123 NRTH-0897341 Chargebacks 136,000 2.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 190,210 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 136,000 TO 287.74 SW002 Shorewood water 136,000 TO C 10.58 TOTAL TAX --- 2,113.05** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,113.05 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-4 ****************** 5158 W Shorewood Dr BILL 400 95.13-1-4 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 190,000 1,214.33 Dziduch Gerald J Dunkirk Csd 060300 68,000 County Tax 190,000 1,007.48 Dziduch Cheryl C 1-1-37 190,000 Community Colleges 190,000 211.72 5158 W Shorewood Dr FRNT 145.20 DPTH 229.00 Town Tax 190,000 98.21 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929230 NRTH-0897407 Chargebacks 190,000 3.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,734 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 190,000 TO 401.99 SW002 Shorewood water 190,000 TO C 14.78 TOTAL TAX --- 2,952.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,952.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-5 ****************** 5148 Shorewood Dr BILL 401 95.13-1-5 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VETS T 41103 0 17,776 Town Carter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 70,200 VETERAN EX 41111 5,000 5,000 Town Mary Ann 1-1-36 167,450 Medicaid 162,450 1,038.26 5148 West Shorewood Dr ACRES 0.84 County Tax 162,450 861.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929363 NRTH-0897472 Community Colleges 162,450 181.02 DEED BOOK 2400 PG-382 Town Tax 144,674 74.78 FULL MARKET VALUE 234,196 Chargebacks 144,674 2.68 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 167,450 TO 354.28 SW002 Shorewood water 167,450 TO C 13.03 TOTAL TAX --- 2,525.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,525.45 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 108 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-6 ****************** Farm Ln BILL 402 95.13-1-6 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Degolyer Mary A Dunkirk Csd 060300 41,200 Medicaid 106,150 678.43 5140 Shorewood Dr 1-1-34 113,500 County Tax 106,150 562.87 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 162.00 DPTH 200.00 Community Colleges 106,150 118.28 EAST-0929482 NRTH-0897555 Town Tax 113,500 58.67 DEED BOOK 1770 PG-00081 Chargebacks 113,500 2.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 158,741 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 113,500 TO 240.14 SW002 Shorewood water 113,500 TO C 8.83 TOTAL TAX --- 1,669.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,669.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-7 ****************** 5144 Shorewood Dr BILL 403 95.13-1-7 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 211,170 1,349.64 Lydic Brian D Dunkirk Csd 060300 70,600 County Tax 211,170 1,119.74 Lydic Pamela S 1-1-35 211,170 Community Colleges 211,170 235.31 5144 W Shorewood Dr FRNT 150.00 DPTH 243.00 Town Tax 211,170 109.15 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929623 NRTH-0897627 Chargebacks 211,170 3.91 DEED BOOK 2422 PG-701 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 211,170 TO 446.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 295,343 SW002 Shorewood water 211,170 TO C 16.43 TOTAL TAX --- 3,280.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,280.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-8 ****************** 5122 Shorewood Dr BILL 404 95.13-1-8 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 176,480 1,127.92 Benchley Cornelius R Dunkirk Csd 060300 36,500 County Tax 176,480 935.79 Benchley Pamela L 1-1-33 176,480 Community Colleges 176,480 196.65 5122 Shorewood Dr FRNT 79.20 DPTH 166.00 Town Tax 176,480 91.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929696 NRTH-0897718 Chargebacks 176,480 3.27 DEED BOOK 2340 PG-730 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 176,480 TO 373.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 246,825 SW002 Shorewood water 176,480 TO C 13.73 TOTAL TAX --- 2,741.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,741.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-9 ****************** 5120 Shorewood Dr BILL 405 95.13-1-9 220 2 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 111,360 711.73 Bender Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 42,300 County Tax 111,360 590.49 4996 Morewood Dr 1-1-32 111,360 Community Colleges 111,360 124.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 79.70 DPTH 168.00 Town Tax 111,360 57.56 EAST-0929751 NRTH-0897795 Chargebacks 111,360 2.06 DEED BOOK 2329 PG-220 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 111,360 TO 235.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,748 SW002 Shorewood water 111,360 TO C 8.66 TOTAL TAX --- 1,730.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,730.20 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 109 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-10 ***************** 5120 Shorewood Dr BILL 406 95.13-1-10 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 5,600 35.79 Bender Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,600 County Tax 5,600 29.69 4996 Morewood Dr 1-1-31.2 5,600 Community Colleges 5,600 6.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 167.00 Town Tax 5,600 2.89 EAST-0929779 NRTH-0897833 Chargebacks 5,600 0.10 DEED BOOK 2000 PG-00569 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,600 TO 11.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,832 SW002 Shorewood water 5,600 TO C .44 TOTAL TAX --- 87.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 87.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-11 ***************** 5120 Shorewood Dr BILL 407 95.13-1-11 312 Vac w/imprv - WTRFNT Medicaid 5,600 35.79 Bender Properties, LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,600 County Tax 5,600 29.69 4996 Morewood Dr 1-1-31.1 5,600 Community Colleges 5,600 6.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 169.00 Town Tax 5,600 2.89 EAST-0929792 NRTH-0897848 Chargebacks 5,600 0.10 DEED BOOK 2018 PG-00321 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,600 TO 11.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,832 SW002 Shorewood water 5,600 TO C .44 TOTAL TAX --- 87.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 87.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-12 ***************** 5110 Shorewood Dr BILL 408 95.13-1-12 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 130,350 833.10 Altwies Thomas A Dunkirk Csd 060300 47,900 County Tax 130,350 691.19 PO Box 73 includes 95.13-1-13 130,350 Community Colleges 130,350 145.25 Ironton, MO 63650 1-1-30 Town Tax 130,350 67.38 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 145.00 Chargebacks 130,350 2.41 EAST-0929823 NRTH-0897888 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 130,350 TO 275.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 182,308 SW002 Shorewood water 130,350 TO C 10.14 TOTAL TAX --- 2,025.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,025.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-14 ***************** 5104 Shorewood Dr BILL 409 95.13-1-14 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 116,500 744.58 Will James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 42,900 County Tax 116,500 617.75 5104 Shorewood Dr 1-1-28 116,500 Community Colleges 116,500 129.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 85.00 DPTH 169.00 Town Tax 116,500 60.22 EAST-0929881 NRTH-0897973 Chargebacks 116,500 2.16 DEED BOOK 1648 PG-00117 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 116,500 TO 246.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 162,937 SW002 Shorewood water 116,500 TO C 9.06 TOTAL TAX --- 1,810.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,810.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 110 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-15 ***************** 5102 Shorewood Dr W BILL 410 95.13-1-15 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT P-RATA VET 41003 0 6,933 Conti Rebecca A Dunkirk Csd 060300 44,600 VETS CNTY 41102 1,950 0 Smith Michael F 1-1-27 129,000 Medicaid 127,050 812.01 22 Leon Pl FRNT 85.00 DPTH 160.00 County Tax 127,050 673.69 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0929929 NRTH-0898047 Community Colleges 127,050 141.57 DEED BOOK 2680 PG-774 Town Tax 122,067 63.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 180,420 Chargebacks 122,067 2.26 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 129,000 TO 272.93 SW002 Shorewood water 129,000 TO C 10.04 TOTAL TAX --- 1,975.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,975.59 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-16 ***************** 5098 Shorewood Dr W BILL 411 95.13-1-16 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 122,930 785.67 Wright William Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 42,600 County Tax 122,930 651.84 Wright Colleen B 1-1-26 122,930 Community Colleges 122,930 136.98 56 Warwick Rd FRNT 75.00 DPTH 183.00 Town Tax 122,930 63.54 Jamestown, NY 14701 EAST-0929976 NRTH-0898115 Chargebacks 122,930 2.28 DEED BOOK 2680 PG-196 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 122,930 TO 260.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 171,930 SW002 Shorewood water 122,930 TO C 9.56 TOTAL TAX --- 1,909.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,909.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-17 ***************** 5096 Shorewood Dr BILL 412 95.13-1-17 260 Seasonal res - WTRFNT Medicaid 73,000 466.56 Gourley Roger A Dunkirk Csd 060300 42,600 County Tax 73,000 387.09 14392 Route 957 1-1-25 73,000 Community Colleges 73,000 81.34 Sugar Grove, PA 16350 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 180.00 Town Tax 73,000 37.73 EAST-0930020 NRTH-0898177 Chargebacks 73,000 1.35 DEED BOOK 1940 PG-00486 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 73,000 TO 154.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,098 SW002 Shorewood water 73,000 TO C 5.68 TOTAL TAX --- 1,134.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,134.20 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 111 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-18 ***************** 10619 Linwood Dr BILL 413 95.13-1-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 95,000 607.17 Alonge Jack B Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,500 County Tax 95,000 503.74 10619 Linwood Dr 1-3-1 95,000 Community Colleges 95,000 105.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048-9003 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 129.00 Town Tax 95,000 49.10 EAST-0930084 NRTH-0898008 Chargebacks 95,000 1.76 DEED BOOK 2034 PG-00319 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 95,000 TO 201.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,867 SW002 Shorewood water 95,000 TO C 7.39 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 1,476.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,476.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-19 ***************** 10611 Linwood Dr BILL 414 95.13-1-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 72,000 460.17 Schrantz Frank M Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 72,000 381.78 Schrantz Wendy 1-3-2 72,000 Community Colleges 72,000 80.23 10611 Linwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 72,000 37.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930123 NRTH-0897918 Chargebacks 72,000 1.33 DEED BOOK 1981 PG-00530 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,000 TO 152.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,699 SW002 Shorewood water 72,000 TO C 5.60 US001 Unpaid sewer 686.40 MT 686.40 TOTAL TAX --- 1,805.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,805.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-20 ***************** 10605 Linwood Dr BILL 415 95.13-1-20 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Griswold John P Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,500 Medicaid 105,090 671.65 Griswold Lois R 1-3-3 109,500 County Tax 105,090 557.24 10605 Linwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 224.20 Community Colleges 105,090 117.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930180 NRTH-0897831 Town Tax 109,500 56.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 153,147 Chargebacks 109,500 2.03 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 109,500 TO 231.68 SW002 Shorewood water 109,500 TO C 8.52 TOTAL TAX --- 1,644.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,644.82 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 112 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-21 ***************** 10601 Linwood Dr BILL 416 95.13-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 80,000 511.30 Woods Elizabeth A Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,800 County Tax 80,000 424.20 370 Congon Ave 1-3-4 80,000 Community Colleges 80,000 89.14 Elgin, IL 60120 FRNT 127.40 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 80,000 41.35 EAST-0930231 NRTH-0897757 Chargebacks 80,000 1.48 DEED BOOK 1876 PG-00404 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 80,000 TO 169.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,888 SW002 Shorewood water 80,000 TO C 6.22 TOTAL TAX --- 1,242.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,242.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-22 ***************** 10595 Linwood Dr BILL 417 95.13-1-22 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,955 Hube P Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 VETS CNTY 41102 550 0 Miller Life Estate To H&p Hube 78,000 Medicaid 77,450 495.00 Attn: Hube Henry F & P J 1-3-5 County Tax 77,450 410.68 10595 Linwood Dr FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 Community Colleges 77,450 86.30 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930270 NRTH-0897695 Town Tax 76,045 39.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,091 Chargebacks 76,045 1.41 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 78,000 TO 165.03 SW002 Shorewood water 78,000 TO C 6.07 TOTAL TAX --- 1,203.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,203.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-23 ***************** 10587 Linwood Dr BILL 418 95.13-1-23 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Boehm Robert C Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,900 Medicaid 85,590 547.03 10587 Linwood Dr 1-3-6 90,000 County Tax 85,590 453.84 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 126.40 DPTH 168.20 Community Colleges 85,590 95.37 EAST-0930339 NRTH-0897589 Town Tax 90,000 46.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 125,874 Chargebacks 90,000 1.67 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 90,000 TO 190.42 SW002 Shorewood water 90,000 TO C 7.00 TOTAL TAX --- 1,341.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,341.85 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 113 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-24 ***************** 5053 W Lake Rd BILL 419 95.13-1-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 58,000 370.69 O'Connell Michael R Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 County Tax 58,000 307.55 5053 West Lake Road 1-12-8 58,000 Community Colleges 58,000 64.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 58,000 29.98 EAST-0930700 NRTH-0897543 Chargebacks 58,000 1.07 DEED BOOK 2052 PG-00034 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 58,000 TO 122.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 81,119 SW002 Shorewood water 58,000 TO C 4.51 TOTAL TAX --- 901.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 901.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-25 ***************** 5063 W Lake Rd BILL 420 95.13-1-25 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Saller Edwin Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,900 AGED C/S 41805 22,575 0 Saller Mary See 1-12-9.1 52,500 Medicaid 22,575 144.28 5063 West Lake Rd 1-12-9.2 County Tax 22,575 119.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 300.00 Community Colleges 22,575 25.16 EAST-0930585 NRTH-0897410 Town Tax 52,500 27.14 DEED BOOK 2038 PG-00479 Chargebacks 52,500 0.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,427 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 52,500 TO 111.08 SW002 Shorewood water 52,500 TO C 4.08 TOTAL TAX --- 432.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 432.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-26 ***************** 5073 W Lake Rd BILL 421 95.13-1-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 87,190 557.25 Kalfas Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,500 County Tax 87,190 462.33 5073 West Lake Road 1-12-10 87,190 Community Colleges 87,190 97.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 87,190 45.07 EAST-0930482 NRTH-0897319 Chargebacks 87,190 1.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,944 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 87,190 TO 184.47 SW002 Shorewood water 87,190 TO C 6.78 TOTAL TAX --- 1,354.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,354.67 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 114 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-27 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 422 95.13-1-27 312 Vac w/imprv P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,067 Saller Edwin Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,200 VETS CNTY 41102 300 0 Saller Mary 1-12-9.1 4,200 Medicaid 3,900 24.93 5063 West Lake Rd ACRES 3.50 County Tax 3,900 20.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930660 NRTH-0897066 Community Colleges 3,900 4.35 DEED BOOK 2038 PG-00481 Town Tax 3,133 1.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,874 Chargebacks 3,133 0.06 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 4,200 TO 8.89 SW002 Shorewood water 4,200 TO C .33 TOTAL TAX --- 60.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 60.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-28 ***************** 5073 W Lake Rd BILL 423 95.13-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Kalfas Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 5073 W Lake Rd 1-12-11 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 300.00 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 EAST-0930390 NRTH-0897235 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,400 TO 2.96 SW002 Shorewood water 1,400 TO C .11 TOTAL TAX --- 21.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-29 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 424 95.13-1-29 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Harper Rodney M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 Harper Estella 1-12-12 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 5083 West Lake Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 300.00 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930353 NRTH-0897202 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 DEED BOOK 2040 PG-00096 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,400 TO 2.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 SW002 Shorewood water 1,400 TO C .11 TOTAL TAX --- 21.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-30 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 425 95.13-1-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,560 431.79 Harper Rodney M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 67,560 358.24 Harper Estelle 1-12-13 67,560 Community Colleges 67,560 75.28 5083 West Lake Rd FRNT 150.00 DPTH 300.00 Town Tax 67,560 34.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930278 NRTH-0897135 Chargebacks 67,560 1.25 DEED BOOK 2040 PG-00096 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,560 TO 142.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,490 SW002 Shorewood water 67,560 TO C 5.26 TOTAL TAX --- 1,049.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,049.68 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 115 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-31 ***************** 5091 W Lake Rd BILL 426 95.13-1-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,960 434.35 Buck David P Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 67,960 360.36 Buck Mary E 1-12-16 67,960 Community Colleges 67,960 75.73 5091 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 67,960 35.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930167 NRTH-0897035 Chargebacks 67,960 1.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,049 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,960 TO 143.79 SW002 Shorewood water 67,960 TO C 5.29 TOTAL TAX --- 1,055.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,055.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-32 ***************** 5084 W Lake Rd BILL 427 95.13-1-32 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 110,000 703.04 Bleck Deborah J Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,400 County Tax 110,000 583.28 5084 W Lake Rd 1-3-9 110,000 Community Colleges 110,000 122.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 142.00 DPTH 186.50 Town Tax 110,000 56.86 EAST-0930081 NRTH-0897372 Chargebacks 110,000 2.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 153,846 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 110,000 TO 232.73 SW002 Shorewood water 110,000 TO C 8.56 TOTAL TAX --- 1,709.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,709.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-33 ***************** 5078 W Lake Rd BILL 428 95.13-1-33 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 90,990 581.54 Whitehead John W Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,600 County Tax 90,990 482.48 Whitehead Mary 1-3-8 90,990 Community Colleges 90,990 101.39 5078 West Lake Road FRNT 99.00 DPTH 186.50 Town Tax 90,990 47.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930175 NRTH-0897453 Chargebacks 90,990 1.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,259 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 90,990 TO 192.51 SW002 Shorewood water 90,990 TO C 7.08 TOTAL TAX --- 1,413.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,413.71 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-34 ***************** 5072 W Lake Rd BILL 429 95.13-1-34 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 76,240 487.27 Kalfas Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,600 County Tax 76,240 404.27 5072 West Lake Road 1-3-7 76,240 Community Colleges 76,240 84.95 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 99.00 DPTH 186.50 Town Tax 76,240 39.41 EAST-0930251 NRTH-0897522 Chargebacks 76,240 1.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,629 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 76,240 TO 161.31 SW002 Shorewood water 76,240 TO C 5.93 TOTAL TAX --- 1,184.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,184.55 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 116 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-35 ***************** 10595 Linwood Dr BILL 430 95.13-1-35 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,200 14.06 Hube P Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,200 County Tax 2,200 11.67 Miller J Life Estate To Hube H & P 2,200 Community Colleges 2,200 2.45 Attn: Hube Henry F & P J 1-3-11 Town Tax 2,200 1.14 10595 Linwood Dr FRNT 99.00 DPTH 103.00 Chargebacks 2,200 0.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.23 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,200 TO 4.65 EAST-0930174 NRTH-0897637 SW002 Shorewood water 2,200 TO C .17 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,077 TOTAL TAX --- 34.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 34.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-36 ***************** 5078 Farm Dr BILL 431 95.13-1-36 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 19,400 123.99 Whitehead John W Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,400 County Tax 19,400 102.87 5078 W Lake Rd 1-3-10 19,400 Community Colleges 19,400 21.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 125.00 DPTH 240.00 Town Tax 19,400 10.03 EAST-0930032 NRTH-0897527 Chargebacks 19,400 0.36 DEED BOOK 1646 PG-00258 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 19,400 TO 41.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,133 SW002 Shorewood water 19,400 TO C 1.51 TOTAL TAX --- 301.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 301.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-37 ***************** 5117 Farmlane Rd BILL 432 95.13-1-37 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 24,930 159.33 Will Robert Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,200 County Tax 24,930 132.19 10586 Farmlane Rd 1-3-12.1 24,930 Community Colleges 24,930 27.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 125.00 DPTH 155.40 Town Tax 24,930 12.89 EAST-0929943 NRTH-0897600 Chargebacks 24,930 0.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,867 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 24,930 TO 52.75 SW002 Shorewood water 24,930 TO C 1.94 TOTAL TAX --- 387.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 387.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-38 ***************** Farmlane Rd BILL 433 95.13-1-38 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 2,700 17.26 Hall Gerald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 County Tax 2,700 14.32 Hall Sarah M Back Land 2,700 Community Colleges 2,700 3.01 5109 W Shorewood Dr 1-3-12.2 Town Tax 2,700 1.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.21 Chargebacks 2,700 0.05 EAST-0930041 NRTH-0897670 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,700 TO 5.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,776 SW002 Shorewood water 2,700 TO C .21 TOTAL TAX --- 41.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 41.96 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 117 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-39 ***************** 5105 Shorewood Dr BILL 434 95.13-1-39 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 117,000 747.77 Maternowski Gary Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,600 County Tax 117,000 620.40 Maternowski Lorraine 1-3-15 117,000 Community Colleges 117,000 130.37 5105 Shorewood Dr FRNT 123.40 DPTH 222.80 Town Tax 117,000 60.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930017 NRTH-0897858 Chargebacks 117,000 2.17 DEED BOOK 1884 PG-00209 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 117,000 TO 247.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 163,636 SW002 Shorewood water 117,000 TO C 9.10 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 1,817.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,817.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-40 ***************** 5109 W Shorewood Dr BILL 435 95.13-1-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 137,420 878.28 Hall Gerald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 137,420 728.68 5109 Shorewood Dr 1-3-14.1 137,420 Community Colleges 137,420 153.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 60.20 DPTH 161.00 Town Tax 137,420 71.03 EAST-0929957 NRTH-0897791 Chargebacks 137,420 2.54 DEED BOOK 2385 PG-735 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 137,420 TO 290.75 FULL MARKET VALUE 192,196 SW002 Shorewood water 137,420 TO C 10.69 TOTAL TAX --- 2,135.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,135.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-41.1 *************** 5109 W Shorewood Dr BILL 436 95.13-1-41.1 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 28,860 184.45 Hall Gerald W Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,760 County Tax 28,860 153.03 Hall Sarah M 1-3-14.2.1 28,860 Community Colleges 28,860 32.16 5109 W Shorewood Dr FRNT 51.70 DPTH 140.00 Town Tax 28,860 14.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929931 NRTH-0897715 Chargebacks 28,860 0.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,364 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 28,860 TO 61.06 SW002 Shorewood water 28,860 TO C 2.25 TOTAL TAX --- 448.40** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 448.40 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-41.2 *************** Shorewood Dr BILL 437 95.13-1-41.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Hall Gerald Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 Hall Sarah 1-3-14.2.2 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 5109 West Shorewood Dr FRNT 10.00 DPTH 159.00 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929936 NRTH-0897754 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,500 TO 3.17 SW002 Shorewood water 1,500 TO C .12 TOTAL TAX --- 23.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.31 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 118 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-42 ***************** 5117 Shorewood Dr BILL 438 95.13-1-42 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,000 345.13 Will Robert Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 54,000 286.34 5117 Shorewood Dr 1-3-13 54,000 Community Colleges 54,000 60.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 116.60 DPTH 110.00 Town Tax 54,000 27.91 EAST-0929853 NRTH-0897697 Chargebacks 54,000 1.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,524 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 54,000 TO 114.25 SW002 Shorewood water 54,000 TO C 4.20 TOTAL TAX --- 839.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 839.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-43 ***************** 10559 Farm Ln BILL 439 95.13-1-43 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Penharlow Robert L Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 Medicaid 82,750 528.87 Penharlow Martha A 1-4-1 87,160 County Tax 82,750 438.79 10559 Farm Lane FRNT 85.30 DPTH 125.00 Community Colleges 82,750 92.21 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929792 NRTH-0897591 Town Tax 87,160 45.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,902 Chargebacks 87,160 1.61 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 87,160 TO 184.41 SW002 Shorewood water 87,160 TO C 6.78 TOTAL TAX --- 1,297.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,297.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-44 ***************** 5131 Shorewood Dr BILL 440 95.13-1-44 311 Res vac land Medicaid 11,400 72.86 Boris Daniel Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 11,400 60.45 Boris Patricia 1-4-8 11,400 Community Colleges 11,400 12.70 5131 Shorewood Dr FRNT 85.30 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 11,400 5.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929739 NRTH-0897527 Chargebacks 11,400 0.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,944 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,400 TO 24.12 SW002 Shorewood water 11,400 TO C .89 TOTAL TAX --- 177.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 177.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-45 ***************** 5131 Shorewood Dr BILL 441 95.13-1-45 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 148,030 946.09 Boris Daniel Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 148,030 784.94 Boris Patricia 1-4-7 148,030 Community Colleges 148,030 164.95 5131 Shorewood Dr FRNT 85.40 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 148,030 76.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929689 NRTH-0897457 Chargebacks 148,030 2.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 207,035 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 148,030 TO 313.20 SW002 Shorewood water 148,030 TO C 11.52 TOTAL TAX --- 2,299.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,299.95 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 119 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-46 ***************** 10559 Farm Ln BILL 442 95.13-1-46 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 16,350 104.50 Penharlow David L Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,100 County Tax 16,350 86.70 Penharlow Lisa 1-4-2 16,350 Community Colleges 16,350 18.22 9025 Spoden Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 255.00 Town Tax 16,350 8.45 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0929812 NRTH-0897435 Chargebacks 16,350 0.30 DEED BOOK 2439 PG-769 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 16,350 TO 34.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,867 SW002 Shorewood water 16,350 TO C 1.27 TOTAL TAX --- 254.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 254.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-47 ***************** 10577 Farm Ln BILL 443 95.13-1-47 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 33,000 210.91 Graham Robert M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 33,000 174.98 1331 Moon Ridge Dr 1-4-4 33,000 Community Colleges 33,000 36.77 Pittsburgh, PA 15241 FRNT 59.20 DPTH 65.00 Town Tax 33,000 17.06 EAST-0929858 NRTH-0897373 Chargebacks 33,000 0.61 DEED BOOK 2678 PG-35 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 33,000 TO 69.82 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,154 SW002 Shorewood water 33,000 TO C 2.57 TOTAL TAX --- 512.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 512.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-48 ***************** 10577 Farm Ln BILL 444 95.13-1-48 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,900 63.27 Graham Robert M Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 County Tax 9,900 52.50 1331 Moon Ridge Dr 1-4-3 9,900 Community Colleges 9,900 11.03 Pittsburgh, PA 15241 FRNT 126.10 DPTH 77.00 Town Tax 9,900 5.12 EAST-0929913 NRTH-0897403 Chargebacks 9,900 0.18 DEED BOOK 2678 PG-35 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,900 TO 20.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,846 SW002 Shorewood water 9,900 TO C .77 TOTAL TAX --- 153.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 153.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-49.1 *************** 5094 W Lake Rd BILL 445 95.13-1-49.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,340 8.56 Graham Robert M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,340 County Tax 1,340 7.11 1331 Moon Ridge Dr 1-4-5.1 1,340 Community Colleges 1,340 1.49 Pittsbrugh, PA 15241 ACRES 0.10 Town Tax 1,340 0.69 EAST-0929815 NRTH-0897340 Chargebacks 1,340 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,340 TO 2.84 SW002 Shorewood water 1,340 TO C .10 TOTAL TAX --- 20.81** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.81 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 120 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-49.2 *************** 5094 W Lake Rd BILL 446 95.13-1-49.2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 102,170 652.99 Thies Terrance Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,400 County Tax 102,170 541.76 Thies Margaret 1-4-5.2 102,170 Community Colleges 102,170 113.85 5094 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 102,170 52.81 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929922 NRTH-0897224 Chargebacks 102,170 1.89 DEED BOOK 2633 PG-201 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 102,170 TO 216.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 142,895 SW002 Shorewood water 102,170 TO C 7.95 TOTAL TAX --- 1,587.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,587.42 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-50 ***************** 5116 Lake Shore Dr W BILL 447 95.13-1-50 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 101,500 648.71 Kosierb Eric W Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,000 County Tax 101,500 538.21 Kosierb Tara M 1-4-6.3 101,500 Community Colleges 101,500 113.10 5116 Lake Shore Drive Wes ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 101,500 52.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929616 NRTH-0896958 Chargebacks 101,500 1.88 DEED BOOK 2136 PG-00497 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 101,500 TO 214.75 FULL MARKET VALUE 141,958 OT001 Omitted Tax-DnkT2015 544.49 MT 544.49 SW002 Shorewood water 101,500 TO C 7.90 US001 Unpaid sewer 2,140.58 MT 2,140.58 TOTAL TAX --- 4,262.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,262.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-51 ***************** 5116 W Lake Rd BILL 448 95.13-1-51 311 Res vac land Medicaid 35,000 223.69 Dziduch Gerald J Dunkirk Csd 060300 35,000 County Tax 35,000 185.59 Dziduch Cheryl C 1-4-6.1 35,000 Community Colleges 35,000 39.00 5158 W Shorewood Dr ACRES 2.90 Town Tax 35,000 18.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929556 NRTH-0897217 Chargebacks 35,000 0.65 DEED BOOK 1957 PG-00502 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 35,000 TO 74.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 48,951 SW002 Shorewood water 35,000 TO C 2.72 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 543.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 543.79 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 121 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-1-52 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 449 95.13-1-52 311 Res vac land Medicaid 40,290 257.50 Maytum Mark R Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 County Tax 40,290 213.64 Maytum Julie S 1-4-6.2 40,290 Community Colleges 40,290 44.90 5198 Lake Rd FRNT 126.00 DPTH 190.00 Town Tax 40,290 20.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929605 NRTH-0897350 Chargebacks 40,290 0.75 DEED BOOK 1893 PG-00227 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 40,290 TO 85.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,350 SW002 Shorewood water 40,290 TO C 3.13 TOTAL TAX --- 625.99** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 625.99 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-2 ****************** Shorewood Dr BILL 450 95.13-2-2 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 139,040 888.64 Stokes Bruce A Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,500 County Tax 139,040 737.27 Stokes Sandra H 1-1-23 139,040 Community Colleges 139,040 154.93 58 Viola Cir FRNT 100.00 DPTH 182.00 Town Tax 139,040 71.87 Seabrook, NH 03874 EAST-0930077 NRTH-0898258 Chargebacks 139,040 2.57 DEED BOOK 2349 PG-804 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 139,040 TO 294.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 194,462 SW002 Shorewood water 139,040 TO C 10.82 TOTAL TAX --- 2,160.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,160.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-3 ****************** 5084 Shorewood Dr BILL 451 95.13-2-3 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 112,000 715.82 Lawhead Kent Dunkirk Csd 060300 38,500 County Tax 112,000 593.88 5084 Shorewood Drive West 1-1-22 112,000 Community Colleges 112,000 124.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 57.70 DPTH 190.00 Town Tax 112,000 57.89 EAST-0930127 NRTH-0898322 Chargebacks 112,000 2.07 DEED BOOK 2122 PG-00499 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 112,000 TO 236.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 156,643 SW002 Shorewood water 112,000 TO C 8.71 TOTAL TAX --- 1,740.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,740.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-4 ****************** 5082 Shorewood Dr W BILL 452 95.13-2-4 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 116,000 741.38 Comello Carol A Dunkirk Csd 060300 39,700 County Tax 116,000 615.10 5082 Shorewood Dr West 1-1-21 116,000 Community Colleges 116,000 129.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 178.00 Town Tax 116,000 59.96 EAST-0930159 NRTH-0898372 Chargebacks 116,000 2.15 DEED BOOK 2102 PG-00663 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 116,000 TO 245.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 162,238 SW002 Shorewood water 116,000 TO C 9.02 TOTAL TAX --- 1,802.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,802.30 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 122 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-5 ****************** 5076 Shorewood Dr BILL 453 95.13-2-5 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 98,500 629.54 Ihrig Steven Dunkirk Csd 060300 46,100 County Tax 98,500 522.30 5076 Shorewood Dr 1-1-20 98,500 Community Colleges 98,500 109.76 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 88.20 DPTH 178.00 Town Tax 98,500 50.91 EAST-0930210 NRTH-0898419 Chargebacks 98,500 1.82 FULL MARKET VALUE 137,762 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 98,500 TO 208.40 SW002 Shorewood water 98,500 TO C 7.66 TOTAL TAX --- 1,530.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,530.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-6 ****************** 5074 Shorewood Dr BILL 454 95.13-2-6 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 183,870 1,175.16 Mackowiak David Dunkirk Csd 060300 40,300 County Tax 183,870 974.98 5074 W Shorewood Dr 1-1-19.1 183,870 Community Colleges 183,870 204.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 183,870 95.04 EAST-0930270 NRTH-0898466 Chargebacks 183,870 3.40 DEED BOOK 2436 PG-706 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 183,870 TO 389.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 257,161 SW002 Shorewood water 183,870 TO C 14.31 TOTAL TAX --- 2,856.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,856.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-7 ****************** 5072 Shorewood Dr BILL 455 95.13-2-7 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 132,000 843.64 Hubbard Roxane R Dunkirk Csd 060300 42,600 County Tax 132,000 699.94 Hubbard Robert N 1-1-19.2 132,000 Community Colleges 132,000 147.09 5072 Shorewood Dr ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 132,000 68.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930336 NRTH-0898484 Chargebacks 132,000 2.44 DEED BOOK 2130 PG-00218 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 132,000 TO 279.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 184,615 SW002 Shorewood water 132,000 TO C 10.27 TOTAL TAX --- 2,050.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,050.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-8 ****************** 5068 Shorewood Dr BILL 456 95.13-2-8 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 140,290 896.63 Boettcher Friedrich A Dunkirk Csd 060300 40,500 County Tax 140,290 743.89 Boettcher Susan J 1-1-18 140,290 Community Colleges 140,290 156.33 5068 Shorewood Dr FRNT 53.30 DPTH 213.00 Town Tax 140,290 72.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930397 NRTH-0898501 Chargebacks 140,290 2.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 196,210 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 140,290 TO 296.82 SW002 Shorewood water 140,290 TO C 10.91 TOTAL TAX --- 2,179.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,179.69 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 123 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-9 ****************** 5066 Shorewood Dr BILL 457 95.13-2-9 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 132,500 846.84 Butts Richard J Dunkirk Csd 060300 39,400 County Tax 132,500 702.59 Schrantz Cynthia 1-1-17 132,500 Community Colleges 132,500 147.65 5066 Shorewood Dr FRNT 55.70 DPTH 220.00 Town Tax 132,500 68.49 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930466 NRTH-0898507 Chargebacks 132,500 2.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 185,315 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 132,500 TO 280.34 SW002 Shorewood water 132,500 TO C 10.31 TOTAL TAX --- 2,058.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,058.67 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-10 ***************** 5062 Shorewood Dr BILL 458 95.13-2-10 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Johnson Robert W Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,600 Medicaid 123,150 787.08 Johnson Patricia 1-1-16 130,500 County Tax 123,150 653.01 5062 W Shorewood Dr FRNT 98.40 DPTH 225.00 Community Colleges 123,150 137.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930550 NRTH-0898516 Town Tax 130,500 67.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 182,517 Chargebacks 130,500 2.42 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 130,500 TO 276.11 SW002 Shorewood water 130,500 TO C 10.15 TOTAL TAX --- 1,933.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,933.45 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-11 ***************** 5056 Shorewood Dr BILL 459 95.13-2-11 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 123,400 788.68 Bloise Kimberly A Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 123,400 654.33 5056 W Shorewood Dr 1-1-15 123,400 Community Colleges 123,400 137.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 98.40 DPTH 211.00 Town Tax 123,400 63.78 EAST-0930661 NRTH-0898533 Chargebacks 123,400 2.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 172,587 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 123,400 TO 261.08 SW002 Shorewood water 123,400 TO C 9.60 US001 Unpaid sewer 492.80 MT 492.80 TOTAL TAX --- 2,410.05** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,410.05 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 124 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-12 ***************** 5052 Shorewood Dr BILL 460 95.13-2-12 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 140,000 894.77 Parker Lee A Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,000 County Tax 140,000 742.36 5052 Shorewood Dr 1-1-14 140,000 Community Colleges 140,000 156.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 84.00 DPTH 195.00 Town Tax 140,000 72.36 EAST-0930761 NRTH-0898541 Chargebacks 140,000 2.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 195,804 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 140,000 TO 296.21 SW002 Shorewood water 140,000 TO C 10.89 US001 Unpaid sewer 510.95 MT 510.95 TOTAL TAX --- 2,686.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,686.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-13 ***************** 5040 W Lake Rd BILL 461 95.13-2-13 415 Motel Medicaid 281,960 1,802.07 NORICSTAR Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 192,000 County Tax 281,960 1,495.11 5040 W Lake Rd 1-1-1.1 281,960 Community Colleges 281,960 314.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.80 Town Tax 281,960 145.74 EAST-0930934 NRTH-0898277 Chargebacks 281,960 5.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 394,350 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 281,960 TO 596.56 SW002 Shorewood water 281,960 TO C 21.94 US001 Unpaid sewer 1,399.75 MT 1,399.75 TOTAL TAX --- 5,780.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,780.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-14 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 462 95.13-2-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 85,920 549.13 Mowrey Jerry W II Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,200 County Tax 85,920 455.59 Mowrey Tammy 1-1-13.2 85,920 Community Colleges 85,920 95.74 5051 West Shorewood Dr FRNT 97.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 85,920 44.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930749 NRTH-0898338 Chargebacks 85,920 1.59 DEED BOOK 2014 PG-00365 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 85,920 TO 181.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,168 SW002 Shorewood water 85,920 TO C 6.68 US001 Unpaid sewer 478.50 MT 478.50 TOTAL TAX --- 1,813.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,813.43 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 125 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-15 ***************** 5040 W Lake Rd BILL 463 95.13-2-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 17,000 108.65 NORICSTAR Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,000 County Tax 17,000 90.14 5040 W Lake Rd 1-1-13.1 17,000 Community Colleges 17,000 18.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 17,000 8.79 EAST-0930664 NRTH-0898212 Chargebacks 17,000 0.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,000 TO 35.97 SW002 Shorewood water 17,000 TO C 1.32 TOTAL TAX --- 264.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 264.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-16 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 464 95.13-2-16 311 Res vac land Medicaid 13,700 87.56 Swanson Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,700 County Tax 13,700 72.64 5065 Shorewood Dr 1-1-13.4 13,700 Community Colleges 13,700 15.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.30 Town Tax 13,700 7.08 EAST-0930600 NRTH-0898306 Chargebacks 13,700 0.25 DEED BOOK 2291 PG-136 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 13,700 TO 28.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,161 SW002 Shorewood water 13,700 TO C 1.07 TOTAL TAX --- 212.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 212.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-17 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 465 95.13-2-17 311 Res vac land Medicaid 700 4.47 Swanson Brenda Dunkirk Csd 060300 700 County Tax 700 3.71 5065 Shorewood Dr 1-1-13.3 700 Community Colleges 700 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 25.00 DPTH 126.00 Town Tax 700 0.36 EAST-0930557 NRTH-0898324 Chargebacks 700 0.01 DEED BOOK 1873 PG-00415 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 700 TO 1.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 979 SW002 Shorewood water 700 TO C .05 TOTAL TAX --- 10.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 10.86 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 126 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-18 ***************** 5065 Shorewood Dr BILL 466 95.13-2-18 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 889 Swanson Brenda Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,200 VETS CNTY 41102 250 0 5065 Shorewood Dr 1-1-12 125,000 Medicaid 124,750 797.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 88.00 DPTH 152.00 County Tax 124,750 661.49 EAST-0930510 NRTH-0898307 Community Colleges 124,750 139.01 DEED BOOK 1873 PG-00415 Town Tax 124,111 64.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,825 Chargebacks 124,111 2.30 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 125,000 TO 264.47 SW002 Shorewood water 125,000 TO C 9.73 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 1,938.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,938.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-19 ***************** 10628 Lakewood Dr BILL 467 95.13-2-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 85,000 543.25 Dean Douglas F Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,900 County Tax 85,000 450.72 Dean Billie Jo 1-1-11 85,000 Community Colleges 85,000 94.72 10628 Lakewood Dr FRNT 132.40 DPTH 169.30 Town Tax 85,000 43.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930405 NRTH-0898283 Chargebacks 85,000 1.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,881 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 85,000 TO 179.84 SW002 Shorewood water 85,000 TO C 6.61 TOTAL TAX --- 1,320.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,320.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-20 ***************** 10620 Lakewood Dr BILL 468 95.13-2-20 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 14,221 Baron Glenn Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,700 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 10620 Lakewood Dr Inc 1-1-9 74,170 Medicaid 66,820 427.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 1-1-10 County Tax 66,820 354.32 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 125.00 Community Colleges 66,820 74.46 EAST-0930452 NRTH-0898212 Town Tax 59,949 30.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,734 Chargebacks 59,949 1.11 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 74,170 TO 156.93 SW002 Shorewood water 74,170 TO C 5.77 US001 Unpaid sewer 644.05 MT 644.05 TOTAL TAX --- 1,694.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,694.69 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 127 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-22 ***************** 10618 Lakewood Dr BILL 469 95.13-2-22 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 72,450 463.04 Maxson Donald F Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 72,450 384.17 10618 Lakewood Drive 1-1-8 72,450 Community Colleges 72,450 80.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 72,450 37.45 EAST-0930504 NRTH-0898133 Chargebacks 72,450 1.34 DEED BOOK 2118 PG-00123 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,450 TO 153.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 101,329 SW002 Shorewood water 72,450 TO C 5.64 TOTAL TAX --- 1,125.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,125.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-23 ***************** 10618 Lakewood Dr BILL 470 95.13-2-23 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Maxson Donald F Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 10618 Lakewood Dr 1-1-7 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0930523 NRTH-0898103 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 DEED BOOK 2118 PG-00123 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,200 TO 2.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 SW002 Shorewood water 1,200 TO C .09 TOTAL TAX --- 18.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-24 ***************** 10612 Lakewood Dr BILL 471 95.13-2-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,000 383.47 Hobbs Kathleen M Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 60,000 318.15 10612 Lakewood Drive 1-1-6 60,000 Community Colleges 60,000 66.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 60,000 31.01 EAST-0930549 NRTH-0898063 Chargebacks 60,000 1.11 DEED BOOK 2659 PG-628 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 60,000 TO 126.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,916 SW002 Shorewood water 60,000 TO C 4.67 TOTAL TAX --- 932.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 932.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-25 ***************** 10608 Lakewood Dr BILL 472 95.13-2-25 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Whalen Dolores M Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 Medicaid 63,090 403.22 Warren Patricia 1-1-5 67,500 County Tax 63,090 334.54 16 Fuller Ave FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 Community Colleges 63,090 70.30 Webster, NY 14580 EAST-0930590 NRTH-0898000 Town Tax 67,500 34.89 DEED BOOK 1970 PG-00183 Chargebacks 67,500 1.25 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,406 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,500 TO 142.81 SW002 Shorewood water 67,500 TO C 5.25 TOTAL TAX --- 992.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 992.26 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 128 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-26 ***************** 10604 Lakewood Dr BILL 473 95.13-2-26 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Krystofik Edward Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,300 Medicaid 70,590 451.16 Krystofik Kathleen Sec 01 Bl 01Lot 004 75,000 County Tax 70,590 374.31 10604 Lakewood Drive 1-1-4.1 Community Colleges 70,590 78.66 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 37.00 DPTH 106.60 Town Tax 75,000 38.77 EAST-0930623 NRTH-0897943 Chargebacks 75,000 1.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,895 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 75,000 TO 158.68 SW002 Shorewood water 75,000 TO C 5.84 TOTAL TAX --- 1,108.81** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,108.81 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-27 ***************** 10604 Lakewood Dr BILL 474 95.13-2-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 300 1.92 Krystofik Edward Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 300 1.59 Krystofik Kathleen 1-1-1.2 300 Community Colleges 300 0.33 10604 Lakewood Dr FRNT 30.00 DPTH 73.20 Town Tax 300 0.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930685 NRTH-0897982 Chargebacks 300 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 420 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 300 TO .63 SW002 Shorewood water 300 TO C .02 TOTAL TAX --- 4.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-28 ***************** 5040 W Lake Rd BILL 475 95.13-2-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 NORICSTAR Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 5040 W Lake Rd 1-1-4.2 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 3.00 DPTH 106.60 Town Tax 200 0.10 EAST-0930639 NRTH-0897912 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 200 TO .42 SW002 Shorewood water 200 TO C .02 TOTAL TAX --- 3.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-29 ***************** 5040 W Lake Rd BILL 476 95.13-2-29 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 3,200 20.45 NORICSTAR Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 3,200 16.97 5040 W Lake Rd 1-1-2 3,200 Community Colleges 3,200 3.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 8.00 DPTH 126.00 Town Tax 3,200 1.65 EAST-0930707 NRTH-0897867 Chargebacks 3,200 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,476 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,200 TO 6.77 SW002 Shorewood water 3,200 TO C .25 TOTAL TAX --- 49.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 49.72 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 129 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-30 ***************** 5040 W Lake Rd BILL 477 95.13-2-30 415 Motel Medicaid 13,400 85.64 NORICSTAR Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 13,400 71.05 5040 W Lake Rd 1-1-3 13,400 Community Colleges 13,400 14.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 13,400 6.93 EAST-0930667 NRTH-0897841 Chargebacks 13,400 0.25 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,741 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 13,400 TO 28.35 SW002 Shorewood water 13,400 TO C 1.04 US001 Unpaid sewer 450.45 MT 450.45 TOTAL TAX --- 658.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 658.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-31 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 478 95.13-2-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 87,720 560.64 Liber Lisa L Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,300 County Tax 87,720 465.14 10597 Lakewood Dr 1-2-10 87,720 Community Colleges 87,720 97.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 125.00 DPTH 128.00 Town Tax 87,720 45.34 EAST-0930571 NRTH-0897765 Chargebacks 87,720 1.62 DEED BOOK 2333 PG-575 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 87,720 TO 185.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 122,685 SW002 Shorewood water 87,720 TO C 6.82 TOTAL TAX --- 1,362.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,362.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-32 ***************** 10594 Linwood Dr BILL 479 95.13-2-32 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 72,000 460.17 Muscato Joseph W Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,900 County Tax 72,000 381.78 Muscato Sallie 1-2-11 72,000 Community Colleges 72,000 80.23 10594 Linwood Dr FRNT 126.20 DPTH 163.80 Town Tax 72,000 37.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930471 NRTH-0897690 Chargebacks 72,000 1.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,699 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 72,000 TO 152.33 SW002 Shorewood water 72,000 TO C 5.60 TOTAL TAX --- 1,118.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,118.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-33 ***************** 10596 Linwood Dr BILL 480 95.13-2-33 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 105,000 671.08 Lesch Robert S Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 105,000 556.77 Lesch Susan 1-2-12 105,000 Community Colleges 105,000 117.00 10596 Linwood Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 105,000 54.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930401 NRTH-0897798 Chargebacks 105,000 1.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 146,853 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 105,000 TO 222.15 SW002 Shorewood water 105,000 TO C 8.17 TOTAL TAX --- 1,631.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,631.38 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 130 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-34 ***************** Lakewood Dr BILL 481 95.13-2-34 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,800 17.90 Leber Lisa L Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,800 County Tax 2,800 14.85 10597 Lakewood Dr 1-2-9.1 2,800 Community Colleges 2,800 3.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 2,800 1.45 EAST-0930517 NRTH-0897845 Chargebacks 2,800 0.05 DEED BOOK 2333 PG-575 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,800 TO 5.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,916 SW002 Shorewood water 2,800 TO C .22 TOTAL TAX --- 43.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 43.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-35 ***************** 10609 Lakewood Dr BILL 482 95.13-2-35 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,500 15.98 Borrello John Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 2,500 13.26 10609 Lakewood Dr 1-2-9.2 2,500 Community Colleges 2,500 2.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 2,500 1.29 EAST-0930500 NRTH-0897874 Chargebacks 2,500 0.05 DEED BOOK 1996 PG-00276 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,500 TO 5.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,497 SW002 Shorewood water 2,500 TO C .19 TOTAL TAX --- 38.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 38.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-36 ***************** 10609 Lakewood Dr BILL 483 95.13-2-36 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,700 23.65 Borrello John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,700 County Tax 3,700 19.62 10609 Lakewood Dr 1-2-8 3,700 Community Colleges 3,700 4.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 30.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 3,700 1.91 EAST-0930486 NRTH-0897895 Chargebacks 3,700 0.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,175 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,700 TO 7.83 SW002 Shorewood water 3,700 TO C .29 TOTAL TAX --- 57.49** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 57.49 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-37 ***************** 10609 Lakewood Dr BILL 484 95.13-2-37 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 65,360 417.73 Borrello John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 65,360 346.57 10609 Lakewood Drive 1-2-7 65,360 Community Colleges 65,360 72.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 65,360 33.78 EAST-0930464 NRTH-0897929 Chargebacks 65,360 1.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,413 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 65,360 TO 138.29 SW002 Shorewood water 65,360 TO C 5.09 TOTAL TAX --- 1,015.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,015.50 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 131 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-38 ***************** Lakewood Dr BILL 485 95.13-2-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 37,500 239.67 Crane Steven J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 37,500 198.85 Crane Jill 1-2-6 37,500 Community Colleges 37,500 41.79 5356 W Lake Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 37,500 19.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930437 NRTH-0897971 Chargebacks 37,500 0.69 DEED BOOK 1989 PG-00498 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 37,500 TO 79.34 FULL MARKET VALUE 52,448 SW002 Shorewood water 37,500 TO C 2.92 TOTAL TAX --- 582.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 582.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-39 ***************** 10604 Linwood Dr BILL 486 95.13-2-39 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 56,500 361.10 Catalano Frederick D Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 56,500 299.59 10604 Linwood Dr 1-2-13 56,500 Community Colleges 56,500 62.96 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 56,500 29.20 EAST-0930360 NRTH-0897862 Chargebacks 56,500 1.05 DEED BOOK 1905 PG-00339 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 56,500 TO 119.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,021 SW002 Shorewood water 56,500 TO C 4.40 US001 Unpaid sewer 680.35 MT 680.35 TOTAL TAX --- 1,558.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,558.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-40 ***************** 10604 Linwood Dr BILL 487 95.13-2-40 311 Res vac land Medicaid 600 3.83 Catalano Frederick D Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 10604 Linwood Dr 1-2-14.2 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 10.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 600 0.31 EAST-0930316 NRTH-0897928 Chargebacks 600 0.01 DEED BOOK 1905 PG-00339 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 600 TO 1.27 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 SW002 Shorewood water 600 TO C .05 TOTAL TAX --- 9.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-41 ***************** Linwood Dr BILL 488 95.13-2-41 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 20,210 129.17 Penharlow Randy A Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,100 County Tax 20,210 107.16 10614 Linwood Dr 1-2-14.1 20,210 Community Colleges 20,210 22.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 65.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 20,210 10.45 EAST-0930296 NRTH-0897960 Chargebacks 20,210 0.37 DEED BOOK 2007 PG-00557 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 20,210 TO 42.76 FULL MARKET VALUE 28,266 SW002 Shorewood water 20,210 TO C 1.57 TOTAL TAX --- 314.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 314.00 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 132 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-42 ***************** 10615 Lakewood Dr BILL 489 95.13-2-42 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Bennett Beverly Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 10615 Lakewood Drive 1-2-5 84,500 Medicaid 79,500 508.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 125.00 County Tax 79,500 421.55 EAST-0930395 NRTH-0898034 Community Colleges 79,500 88.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,182 Town Tax 66,724 34.49 Chargebacks 66,724 1.24 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 84,500 TO 178.78 SW002 Shorewood water 84,500 TO C 6.57 TOTAL TAX --- 1,239.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,239.32 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-43 ***************** 10615 Lakewood Dr BILL 490 95.13-2-43 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Bennett Beverly Ann Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 10615 Lakewood Dr 1-2-4.1 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 25.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 EAST-0930362 NRTH-0898086 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,500 TO 3.17 SW002 Shorewood water 1,500 TO C .12 TOTAL TAX --- 23.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-44 ***************** Lakewood Dr BILL 491 95.13-2-44 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Jones Zachary G Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 Jones Lori K 1-2-4.2 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 13554 W 65th Dr Fl 2 FRNT 25.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 Aruada, CO 80004 EAST-0930348 NRTH-0898107 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 DEED BOOK 2009 PG-00221 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,500 TO 3.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 TOTAL TAX --- 23.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-45 ***************** 10614 Linwood Dr BILL 492 95.13-2-45 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,500 431.41 Penharlow Randy A Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 67,500 357.92 10614 Linwood Dr 1-2-15 67,500 Community Colleges 67,500 75.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 67,500 34.89 EAST-0930251 NRTH-0898029 Chargebacks 67,500 1.25 DEED BOOK 2007 PG-00557 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,500 TO 142.81 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,406 SW002 Shorewood water 67,500 TO C 5.25 TOTAL TAX --- 1,048.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,048.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 133 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-46 ***************** 10618 Linwood Dr BILL 493 95.13-2-46 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,500 476.15 Wehrmeyer David B Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 74,500 395.04 Wehrmeyer Katharine M 1-2-16 74,500 Community Colleges 74,500 83.02 5695 Dunning Rd FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 74,500 38.51 Lockport, NY 14094 EAST-0930226 NRTH-0898067 Chargebacks 74,500 1.38 DEED BOOK 2676 PG-401 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 74,500 TO 157.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,196 SW002 Shorewood water 74,500 TO C 5.80 TOTAL TAX --- 1,157.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,157.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-47 ***************** Lakewood Dr BILL 494 95.13-2-47 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 8,800 56.24 Jones Zachary G Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,200 County Tax 8,800 46.66 Jones Lori K 1-2-3 8,800 Community Colleges 8,800 9.81 13554 W 65th Dr Fl 2 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 8,800 4.55 Aruada, CO 80004 EAST-0930326 NRTH-0898139 Chargebacks 8,800 0.16 DEED BOOK 2009 PG-00221 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,800 TO 18.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,308 SW002 Shorewood water 8,800 TO C .68 TOTAL TAX --- 136.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 136.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-48 ***************** Lakewood Dr BILL 495 95.13-2-48 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 57,500 367.50 Jones Zachary G Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,200 County Tax 57,500 304.90 Jones Lori K 1-2-2 57,500 Community Colleges 57,500 64.07 13554 W 65th Dr Fl 2 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 125.00 Town Tax 57,500 29.72 Aruada, CO 80004 EAST-0930301 NRTH-0898181 Chargebacks 57,500 1.06 DEED BOOK 2009 PG-00221 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 57,500 TO 121.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,420 SW002 Shorewood water 57,500 TO C 4.47 TOTAL TAX --- 893.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 893.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-49 ***************** 5081 W Shorewood Dr BILL 496 95.13-2-49 210 1 Family Res AGED C/S 41805 42,500 0 Notaro Geraldine Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,500 Medicaid 42,500 271.63 5081 W Shorewood Dr 1-2-1 85,000 County Tax 42,500 225.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 102.00 Community Colleges 42,500 47.36 EAST-0930274 NRTH-0898248 Town Tax 85,000 43.93 DEED BOOK 2004 PG-00157 Chargebacks 85,000 1.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,881 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 85,000 TO 179.84 SW002 Shorewood water 85,000 TO C 6.61 TOTAL TAX --- 776.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 776.30 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 134 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-50 ***************** Shorewood Dr BILL 497 95.13-2-50 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,500 476.15 Yacklon Jeffrey Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,900 County Tax 74,500 395.04 Yacklon Rebecca 1-2-17 74,500 Community Colleges 74,500 83.02 5087 Shorewood Dr FRNT 159.40 DPTH 105.00 Town Tax 74,500 38.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930189 NRTH-0898154 Chargebacks 74,500 1.38 DEED BOOK 2396 PG-785 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 74,500 TO 157.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,196 SW002 Shorewood water 74,500 TO C 5.80 US001 Unpaid sewer 801.35 MT 801.35 TOTAL TAX --- 1,958.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,958.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-1 ****************** 5008 Morewood Dr BILL 498 95.14-1-1 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 29,500 188.54 Ehmke William H Dunkirk Csd 060300 29,500 County Tax 29,500 156.43 Ehmke Susan A 1-11-2 29,500 Community Colleges 29,500 32.87 5008 Morewood Dr FRNT 49.90 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 29,500 15.25 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931096 NRTH-0898645 Chargebacks 29,500 0.55 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-324 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 29,500 TO 62.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,259 SW002 Shorewood water 29,500 TO C 2.30 TOTAL TAX --- 458.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 458.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-2 ****************** 5008 Morewood Dr BILL 499 95.14-1-2 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 141,300 903.08 Ehmke William H Dunkirk Csd 060300 28,400 County Tax 141,300 749.25 Ehmke Susan A 1-11-1 141,300 Community Colleges 141,300 157.45 5008 Morewood Dr FRNT 49.90 DPTH 195.00 Town Tax 141,300 73.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931144 NRTH-0898665 Chargebacks 141,300 2.62 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-320 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 141,300 TO 298.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,622 SW002 Shorewood water 141,300 TO C 10.99 TOTAL TAX --- 2,195.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,195.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-3 ****************** 5004 Morewood Dr BILL 500 95.14-1-3 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 36,400 232.64 Warmbrodt William Dunkirk Csd 060300 36,400 County Tax 36,400 193.01 5004 Morewood Dr 1-9-4 36,400 Community Colleges 36,400 40.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.90 DPTH 220.00 Town Tax 36,400 18.81 EAST-0931222 NRTH-0898668 Chargebacks 36,400 0.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,909 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 36,400 TO 77.01 SW002 Shorewood water 36,400 TO C 2.83 TOTAL TAX --- 565.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 565.53 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 135 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-4 ****************** 5004 Morewood Dr BILL 501 95.14-1-4 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 129,000 824.47 Warmbrodt William Dunkirk Csd 060300 36,400 County Tax 129,000 684.03 5004 Morewood Dr 1-9-3 129,000 Community Colleges 129,000 143.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.90 DPTH 218.00 Town Tax 129,000 66.68 EAST-0931268 NRTH-0898683 Chargebacks 129,000 2.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 180,420 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 129,000 TO 272.93 SW002 Shorewood water 129,000 TO C 10.04 TOTAL TAX --- 2,004.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,004.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-6 ****************** 4998 Morewood Dr BILL 502 95.14-1-6 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 170,000 1,086.51 Bender Terrence A Dunkirk Csd 060300 66,700 County Tax 170,000 901.43 4998 Morewood Dr Inc 1-9-2 170,000 Community Colleges 170,000 189.43 Dunkirk, NY 14048 1-9-1 Town Tax 170,000 87.87 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 218.00 Chargebacks 170,000 3.15 EAST-0931389 NRTH-0898733 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 170,000 TO 359.68 DEED BOOK 1875 PG-00294 SW002 Shorewood water 170,000 TO C 13.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 237,762 TOTAL TAX --- 2,641.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,641.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-7 ****************** 4996 Morewood Dr BILL 503 95.14-1-7 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 214,600 1,371.56 Parker Paul F Dunkirk Csd 060300 66,000 County Tax 214,600 1,137.93 Parker Marianne Inc 1-8-2 214,600 Community Colleges 214,600 239.13 4996 Morewood Dr 1-8-3 Town Tax 214,600 110.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 152.70 DPTH 205.00 Chargebacks 214,600 3.97 EAST-0931491 NRTH-0898780 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 214,600 TO 454.04 DEED BOOK 1642 PG-00135 SW002 Shorewood water 214,600 TO C 16.70 FULL MARKET VALUE 300,140 TOTAL TAX --- 3,334.25** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,334.25 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-9 ****************** 4988 Morewood Dr BILL 504 95.14-1-9 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 207,150 1,323.94 Morgan William F Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,500 County Tax 207,150 1,098.42 4988 Morewood Dr 1-8-1 207,150 Community Colleges 207,150 230.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 101.80 DPTH 216.00 Town Tax 207,150 107.07 EAST-0931650 NRTH-0898849 Chargebacks 207,150 3.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 289,720 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 207,150 TO 438.28 SW002 Shorewood water 207,150 TO C 16.12 TOTAL TAX --- 3,218.49** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,218.49 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 136 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-10 ***************** 4984 Morewood Dr BILL 505 95.14-1-10 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 154,500 987.45 Pfeister Jeffrey J Dunkirk Csd 060300 55,600 County Tax 154,500 819.24 Pfeister Susan K 1-7-2 154,500 Community Colleges 154,500 172.16 104 Emily Dr FRNT 101.80 DPTH 230.00 Town Tax 154,500 79.86 Pittsburgh, PA 15215 EAST-0931772 NRTH-0898907 Chargebacks 154,500 2.86 FULL MARKET VALUE 216,084 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 154,500 TO 326.88 SW002 Shorewood water 154,500 TO C 12.02 TOTAL TAX --- 2,400.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,400.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-11 ***************** 4980 Morewood Dr BILL 506 95.14-1-11 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Ludwig John E Dunkirk Csd 060300 73,100 Medicaid 226,280 1,446.21 4980 Morewood Dr 1-7-1 230,690 County Tax 226,280 1,199.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 152.70 DPTH 265.00 Community Colleges 226,280 252.14 EAST-0931884 NRTH-0898961 Town Tax 230,690 119.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 322,643 Chargebacks 230,690 4.27 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 230,690 TO 488.08 SW002 Shorewood water 230,690 TO C 17.95 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 3,527.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,527.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-12 ***************** 10689 Wilbur Rd BILL 507 95.14-1-12 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 75,500 482.54 Narraway William A et al Dunkirk Csd 060300 39,600 County Tax 75,500 400.34 10689 Wilbur Rd 1-6-4 75,500 Community Colleges 75,500 84.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.90 DPTH 275.00 Town Tax 75,500 39.02 EAST-0932003 NRTH-0899015 Chargebacks 75,500 1.40 DEED BOOK 2074 PG-00474 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 75,500 TO 159.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 105,594 SW002 Shorewood water 75,500 TO C 5.87 US001 Unpaid sewer 347.60 MT 347.60 TOTAL TAX --- 1,520.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,520.64 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 137 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-13 ***************** Morewood Dr BILL 508 95.14-1-13 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 120,000 766.95 Lane Donald Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,100 County Tax 120,000 636.31 Lane Monica 1-6-3 120,000 Community Colleges 120,000 133.72 203 Gerber Trce FRNT 86.80 DPTH 280.00 Town Tax 120,000 62.03 Pittsburge, PA 15229 EAST-0932066 NRTH-0899050 Chargebacks 120,000 2.22 DEED BOOK 2634 PG-820 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 120,000 TO 253.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 167,832 SW002 Shorewood water 120,000 TO C 9.34 TOTAL TAX --- 1,864.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,864.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-14 ***************** 4972 Morewood Dr BILL 509 95.14-1-14 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 84,000 536.86 Narraway William A Dunkirk Csd 060300 47,500 County Tax 84,000 445.41 10689 Wilbur Rd 1-6-2 84,000 Community Colleges 84,000 93.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.47 Town Tax 84,000 43.42 EAST-0932147 NRTH-0899084 Chargebacks 84,000 1.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,483 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 84,000 TO 177.72 SW002 Shorewood water 84,000 TO C 6.54 US001 Unpaid sewer 571.45 MT 571.45 TOTAL TAX --- 1,876.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,876.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-15 ***************** 10689 Wilbur Rd BILL 510 95.14-1-15 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 88,000 562.43 Narraway William A Dunkirk Csd 060300 44,900 County Tax 88,000 466.62 10689 Wilbur Rd 1-6-1 88,000 Community Colleges 88,000 98.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 54.50 DPTH 284.90 Town Tax 88,000 45.49 EAST-0932192 NRTH-0899113 Chargebacks 88,000 1.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,077 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 88,000 TO 186.19 SW002 Shorewood water 88,000 TO C 6.85 US001 Unpaid sewer 619.85 MT 619.85 TOTAL TAX --- 1,987.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,987.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-16 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 511 95.14-1-16 113 Cattle farm Medicaid 88,500 565.62 Narraway David C Dunkirk Csd 060300 25,600 County Tax 88,500 469.28 10689 Wilbur Rd 1-10-1 88,500 Community Colleges 88,500 98.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 15.40 Town Tax 88,500 45.74 EAST-0931708 NRTH-0898466 Chargebacks 88,500 1.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 88,500 TO 187.24 SW002 Shorewood water 88,500 TO C 6.89 TOTAL TAX --- 1,375.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,375.03 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 138 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-17 ***************** 4925 W Lake Rd BILL 512 95.14-1-17 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Obrocta Paul J Dunkirk Csd 060300 24,300 Medicaid 80,590 515.07 4925 W Lake Rd 2-5-20.1 85,000 County Tax 80,590 427.33 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 9.40 Community Colleges 80,590 89.80 EAST-0932582 NRTH-0898007 Town Tax 85,000 43.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,881 Chargebacks 85,000 1.57 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 85,000 TO 179.84 SW002 Shorewood water 85,000 TO C 6.61 TOTAL TAX --- 1,264.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,264.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-18 ***************** 10564 Wilbur Rd BILL 513 95.14-1-18 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Obrocta James Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,000 Medicaid 117,090 748.35 Obrocta Elaine 2-5-20.2 121,500 County Tax 117,090 620.87 10564 Wilbur Rd ACRES 7.20 Community Colleges 117,090 130.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932579 NRTH-0897586 Town Tax 121,500 62.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 169,930 Chargebacks 121,500 2.25 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 121,500 TO 257.06 SW002 Shorewood water 121,500 TO C 9.45 TOTAL TAX --- 1,831.25** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,831.25 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-19 ***************** 10562 Wilbur Rd BILL 514 95.14-1-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 92,000 587.99 Lombardo Roger J Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 92,000 487.83 Dorler Norma 2-5-19 92,000 Community Colleges 92,000 102.52 10562 Wilbur Rd FRNT 100.00 DPTH 400.00 Town Tax 92,000 47.55 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932443 NRTH-0897084 Chargebacks 92,000 1.70 FULL MARKET VALUE 128,671 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 92,000 TO 194.65 SW002 Shorewood water 92,000 TO C 7.16 TOTAL TAX --- 1,429.40** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,429.40 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-20 ***************** 10542 Wilbur Rd BILL 515 95.14-1-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 69,890 446.68 Majecki Paul R Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 69,890 370.59 10542 Wilbur Road 2-5-18 69,890 Community Colleges 69,890 77.88 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 400.00 Town Tax 69,890 36.12 EAST-0932443 NRTH-0896981 Chargebacks 69,890 1.29 DEED BOOK 2032 PG-00226 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 69,890 TO 147.87 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,748 SW002 Shorewood water 69,890 TO C 5.44 TOTAL TAX --- 1,085.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,085.87 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 139 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-21 ***************** Wilbur Rd BILL 516 95.14-1-21 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Smoczynski Arthur Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 Medicaid 65,230 416.90 Smoczynski Elaine 2-5-17 69,640 County Tax 65,230 345.88 10538 Wilbur Rd ACRES 0.59 Community Colleges 65,230 72.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0932442 NRTH-0896898 Town Tax 69,640 36.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,399 Chargebacks 69,640 1.29 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 69,640 TO 147.34 SW002 Shorewood water 69,640 TO C 5.42 TOTAL TAX --- 1,025.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,025.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-22 ***************** Wilbur Rd BILL 517 95.14-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Callan Mark Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 10589 Wilbur Rd 1-12-1.1 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048-2041 ACRES 0.06 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0932113 NRTH-0897670 Chargebacks 900 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 900 TO 1.90 SW002 Shorewood water 900 TO C .07 TOTAL TAX --- 13.98** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13.98 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-23 ***************** Wilbur Rd BILL 518 95.14-1-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,590 348.90 Callan Mark Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 54,590 289.47 10589 Wilbur Rd 1-12-1.3 54,590 Community Colleges 54,590 60.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 54,590 28.22 EAST-0932118 NRTH-0897817 Chargebacks 54,590 1.01 DEED BOOK 2178 PG-00227 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 54,590 TO 115.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,350 SW002 Shorewood water 54,590 TO C 4.25 TOTAL TAX --- 848.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 848.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-24 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 519 95.14-1-24 311 Res vac land Medicaid 10,700 68.39 Callan Mark Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,700 County Tax 10,700 56.74 10589 Wilbur Rd 1-12-1.2.2 10,700 Community Colleges 10,700 11.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 149.00 DPTH 255.00 Town Tax 10,700 5.53 EAST-0932150 NRTH-0898059 Chargebacks 10,700 0.20 DEED BOOK 2178 PG-00227 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 10,700 TO 22.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,965 SW002 Shorewood water 10,700 TO C .83 TOTAL TAX --- 166.25** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 166.25 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 140 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-25 ***************** Rear Land Wilbur Rd BILL 520 95.14-1-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Ryder Charles W Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 Ryder Charlene M Rear Land 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 4987 West Lake Rd 1-12-1.4 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 EAST-0931953 NRTH-0897811 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,200 TO 2.54 DEED BOOK 2189 PG-00564 SW002 Shorewood water 1,200 TO C .09 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 TOTAL TAX --- 18.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-26 ***************** 4987 W Lake Rd BILL 521 95.14-1-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 141,300 903.08 Ryder Charles W Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,500 County Tax 141,300 749.25 Ryder Charlene M 1-12-1.2.3 141,300 Community Colleges 141,300 157.45 4987 West Lake Rd FRNT 412.00 DPTH 600.00 Town Tax 141,300 73.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.10 Chargebacks 141,300 2.62 EAST-0931774 NRTH-0897833 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 141,300 TO 298.96 DEED BOOK 2333 PG-554 SW002 Shorewood water 141,300 TO C 10.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,622 TOTAL TAX --- 2,195.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,195.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-27.1 *************** 4987 W Lake Rd BILL 522 95.14-1-27.1 320 Rural vacant Medicaid 6,600 42.18 Rotunda Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,600 County Tax 6,600 35.00 307 East Main St 1-12-1.2.1 6,600 Community Colleges 6,600 7.35 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 5.50 Town Tax 6,600 3.41 EAST-0931622 NRTH-0897319 Chargebacks 6,600 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,231 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 6,600 TO 13.96 SW002 Shorewood water 6,600 TO C .51 TOTAL TAX --- 102.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 102.53 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-27.2 *************** Wilbur Rd BILL 523 95.14-1-27.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,160 39.37 Callan Mark Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,160 County Tax 6,160 32.66 10589 Wilbur Rd 1-12-1.2.4 6,160 Community Colleges 6,160 6.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 210.00 Town Tax 6,160 3.18 EAST-0932098 NRTH-0897583 Chargebacks 6,160 0.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,615 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 6,160 TO 13.03 SW002 Shorewood water 6,160 TO C .48 TOTAL TAX --- 95.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 95.69 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 141 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-27.3 *************** Wilber Rd BILL 524 95.14-1-27.3 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 34,160 218.32 Bishop Jay G Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 County Tax 34,160 181.13 4922 E Shorewood Dr 1-12-1.2.1 34,160 Community Colleges 34,160 38.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.00 Town Tax 34,160 17.66 EAST-0931622 NRTH-0897319 Chargebacks 34,160 0.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 34,160 TO 72.27 SW002 Shorewood water 34,160 TO C 2.66 TOTAL TAX --- 530.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 530.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-27.4 *************** 4987 W Lake Rd BILL 525 95.14-1-27.4 322 Rural vac>10 Medicaid 14,400 92.03 Safford Thomas B Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,400 County Tax 14,400 76.36 Safford Jamie R 1-12-1.2.1 14,400 Community Colleges 14,400 16.05 PO Box 8 ACRES 12.00 Town Tax 14,400 7.44 Stonyford, CA 95979 EAST-0931622 NRTH-0897319 Chargebacks 14,400 0.27 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,140 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 14,400 TO 30.47 SW002 Shorewood water 14,400 TO C 1.12 TOTAL TAX --- 223.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 223.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-28 ***************** 5019 W Lake Rd BILL 526 95.14-1-28 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 88,650 566.58 Andrews Andrew Paul Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 88,650 470.07 Andrews Theresa M 1-12-3 88,650 Community Colleges 88,650 98.78 5019 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 88,650 45.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931262 NRTH-0897589 Chargebacks 88,650 1.64 DEED BOOK 1855 PG-00321 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 88,650 TO 187.56 FULL MARKET VALUE 123,986 SW002 Shorewood water 88,650 TO C 6.90 TOTAL TAX --- 1,377.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,377.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-29 ***************** 5025 W Lake Rd BILL 527 95.14-1-29 210 1 Family Res VET COM CT 41131 7,350 14,700 Kachelmeyer Timothy C Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 Medicaid 70,650 451.54 5025 West Lake Rd 1-12-4 78,000 County Tax 70,650 374.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Community Colleges 70,650 78.73 EAST-0931174 NRTH-0897576 Town Tax 63,300 32.72 DEED BOOK 2125 PG-00178 Chargebacks 63,300 1.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,091 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 78,000 TO 165.03 SW002 Shorewood water 78,000 TO C 6.07 TOTAL TAX --- 1,109.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,109.88 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 142 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-30 ***************** 5027 W Lake Rd BILL 528 95.14-1-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 86,500 552.84 Hamernik Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 86,500 458.67 5027 W Lake Rd 1-12-5 86,500 Community Colleges 86,500 96.39 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 86,500 44.71 EAST-0931112 NRTH-0897566 Chargebacks 86,500 1.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,979 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 86,500 TO 183.01 SW002 Shorewood water 86,500 TO C 6.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,343.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,343.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-31 ***************** 5035 W Lake Rd BILL 529 95.14-1-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 83,730 535.14 Barberich Thomas Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 County Tax 83,730 443.98 Barberich Laurie 1-12-6.1 83,730 Community Colleges 83,730 93.30 5035 West Lake Rd ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 83,730 43.28 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931005 NRTH-0897549 Chargebacks 83,730 1.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,105 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 83,730 TO 177.15 SW002 Shorewood water 83,730 TO C 6.51 TOTAL TAX --- 1,300.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,300.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-32 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 530 95.14-1-32 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Wicks Marvin E Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Wicks Joan M 1-12-6.2 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 5043 West Lake Rd ACRES 0.60 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930900 NRTH-0897519 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 500 TO 1.06 SW002 Shorewood water 500 TO C .04 TOTAL TAX --- 7.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-33 ***************** 5043 W Lake Rd BILL 531 95.14-1-33 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Wicks Marvin Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,600 Medicaid 58,650 374.85 5043 W Lake Rd 1-12-7 66,000 County Tax 58,650 310.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.20 Community Colleges 58,650 65.35 EAST-0930835 NRTH-0897520 Town Tax 66,000 34.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,308 Chargebacks 66,000 1.22 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 66,000 TO 139.64 SW002 Shorewood water 66,000 TO C 5.13 TOTAL TAX --- 931.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 931.29 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 143 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-34 ***************** Fourth St BILL 532 95.14-1-34 120 Field crops Medicaid 20,400 130.38 Ehmke William H Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,400 County Tax 20,400 108.17 Ehmke Susan A 1-11-5 20,400 Community Colleges 20,400 22.73 5008 Moorewood Dr ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 20,400 10.54 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931111 NRTH-0898197 Chargebacks 20,400 0.38 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-323 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 20,400 TO 43.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 28,531 SW002 Shorewood water 20,400 TO C 1.59 TOTAL TAX --- 316.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 316.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-35 ***************** 5008 Morewood Dr BILL 533 95.14-1-35 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 32,160 205.54 Ehmke William H Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,200 County Tax 32,160 170.53 Ehmke Susan A 1-11-4 32,160 Community Colleges 32,160 35.84 5008 Morewood Dr FRNT 40.00 DPTH 99.70 Town Tax 32,160 16.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931116 NRTH-0898475 Chargebacks 32,160 0.60 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-324 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 32,160 TO 68.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,979 SW002 Shorewood water 32,160 TO C 2.50 TOTAL TAX --- 499.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 499.67 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.14-1-36 ***************** 5008 Morewood Dr BILL 534 95.14-1-36 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,000 57.52 Ehmke William H Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 County Tax 9,000 47.72 Ehmke Susan A 1-11-3 9,000 Community Colleges 9,000 10.03 5008 Morewood Dr FRNT 63.00 DPTH 99.70 Town Tax 9,000 4.65 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0931117 NRTH-0898527 Chargebacks 9,000 0.17 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-321 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,000 TO 19.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,587 SW002 Shorewood water 9,000 TO C .70 TOTAL TAX --- 139.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 139.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-2 ****************** W Lake Rd BILL 535 95.17-1-2 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT Medicaid 12,000 76.69 Maytum Marilyn S Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,000 County Tax 12,000 63.63 1510 Chesapeake Ave 1-13-9 12,000 Community Colleges 12,000 13.37 Naples, FL 34102 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 87.00 Town Tax 12,000 6.20 EAST-0927917 NRTH-0896298 Chargebacks 12,000 0.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,783 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 12,000 TO 25.39 SW002 Shorewood water 12,000 TO C .93 TOTAL TAX --- 186.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 186.43 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 144 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-4 ****************** 5180 W Lake Rd BILL 536 95.17-1-4 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 208,000 1,329.38 Shubert Michael R Dunkirk Csd 060300 87,000 County Tax 208,000 1,102.93 5180 W Lake Rd 1-13-7 208,000 Community Colleges 208,000 231.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 180.00 DPTH 321.00 Town Tax 208,000 107.51 EAST-0928116 NRTH-0896377 Chargebacks 208,000 3.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 290,909 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 208,000 TO 440.08 SW002 Shorewood water 208,000 TO C 16.18 TOTAL TAX --- 3,231.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,231.71 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-5 ****************** 5162 W Lake Rd BILL 537 95.17-1-5 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 214,870 1,373.28 Schwert Deborah Dunkirk Csd 060300 70,590 County Tax 214,870 1,139.36 5162 W Lake Rd 95.17-1-6.1 & 6.2 & 33.1 214,870 Community Colleges 214,870 239.43 Dunkirk, NY 14048 1-13-6.3 Town Tax 214,870 111.06 ACRES 1.80 Chargebacks 214,870 3.98 EAST-0928232 NRTH-0896442 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 214,870 TO 454.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 300,517 SW002 Shorewood water 214,870 TO C 16.72 TOTAL TAX --- 3,338.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,338.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-6.3 **************** 5160 W Lake Rd BILL 538 95.17-1-6.3 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 282,560 1,805.91 Foley Albert W Dunkirk Csd 060300 109,160 County Tax 282,560 1,498.29 Foley Jean A 97.17-1-33.2 282,560 Community Colleges 282,560 314.86 5160 W Lake Rd 1-13-6.2 Town Tax 282,560 146.05 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.80 Chargebacks 282,560 5.23 EAST-0928339 NRTH-0896537 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 282,560 TO 597.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 395,189 SW002 Shorewood water 282,560 TO C 21.98 TOTAL TAX --- 4,390.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,390.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-7 ****************** Woodlands Dr BILL 539 95.17-1-7 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 144,040 920.59 Briggs Paul Dunkirk Csd 060300 61,500 County Tax 144,040 763.78 5212 Woodlands Dr 1-13-11 144,040 Community Colleges 144,040 160.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 145.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 144,040 74.45 EAST-0928398 NRTH-0896704 Chargebacks 144,040 2.67 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-00178 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 144,040 TO 304.75 FULL MARKET VALUE 201,455 SW002 Shorewood water 144,040 TO C 11.21 TOTAL TAX --- 2,237.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,237.95 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 145 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-8 ****************** Woodlands Dr BILL 540 95.17-1-8 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT VET COM CT 41131 7,350 14,700 Mahany Rowland B Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,000 Medicaid 152,650 975.62 Mahany Marilyn 1-13-12 160,000 County Tax 152,650 809.43 5208 Woodlands Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 208.50 Community Colleges 152,650 170.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0928488 NRTH-0896779 Town Tax 145,300 75.10 DEED BOOK 2004 PG-00441 Chargebacks 145,300 2.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 223,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 160,000 TO 338.52 SW002 Shorewood water 160,000 TO C 12.45 TOTAL TAX --- 2,383.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,383.91 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-9 ****************** 5200 Woodlands Dr BILL 541 95.17-1-9 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Price Robert W Dunkirk Csd 060300 48,700 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Price Mary Beth 1-13-13 172,500 Medicaid 167,500 1,070.53 5200 Woodlands Dr FRNT 100.00 DPTH 209.00 County Tax 167,500 888.18 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0928565 NRTH-0896843 Community Colleges 167,500 186.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 241,259 Town Tax 154,724 79.97 Chargebacks 154,724 2.86 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 172,500 TO 364.97 SW002 Shorewood water 172,500 TO C 13.42 TOTAL TAX --- 2,606.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,606.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-10 ***************** 5196 Woodlands Dr BILL 542 95.17-1-10 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 160,500 1,025.79 Swanson Richard L Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,000 County Tax 160,500 851.06 5196 Woodlands Dr 1-13-14.2 160,500 Community Colleges 160,500 178.85 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 160,500 82.96 EAST-0928643 NRTH-0896908 Chargebacks 160,500 2.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 224,476 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 160,500 TO 339.58 SW002 Shorewood water 160,500 TO C 12.49 TOTAL TAX --- 2,493.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,493.70 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 146 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-12 ***************** Woodlands Dr BILL 543 95.17-1-12 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 118,000 754.17 Allison S. Lang Revocable Trus Dunkirk Csd 060300 57,000 County Tax 118,000 625.70 Allison S. Lang Trustee 1-13-14.1 118,000 Community Colleges 118,000 131.49 54 Ocean Course Dr FRNT 120.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 118,000 60.99 Kiawah Island, SC 29455 EAST-0928720 NRTH-0896976 Chargebacks 118,000 2.18 DEED BOOK 2107 PG-00092 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 118,000 TO 249.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 165,035 SW002 Shorewood water 118,000 TO C 9.18 US001 Unpaid sewer .00 MT TOTAL TAX --- 1,833.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,833.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-13 ***************** Woodlands Dr BILL 544 95.17-1-13 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 124,060 792.90 Ortendahl Jon R Dunkirk Csd 060300 36,000 County Tax 124,060 657.83 Ortendahl Julie D 1-13-15 124,060 Community Colleges 124,060 138.24 5978 Twin Dr FRNT 50.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 124,060 64.12 Mayville, NY 14757 EAST-0928786 NRTH-0897025 Chargebacks 124,060 2.30 DEED BOOK 2013 PG-00080 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 124,060 TO 262.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 173,510 SW002 Shorewood water 124,060 TO C 9.65 TOTAL TAX --- 1,927.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,927.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-14 ***************** 5182 Woodlands Dr BILL 545 95.17-1-14 220 2 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 190,080 1,214.85 Warren John J III Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,000 County Tax 190,080 1,007.91 Barbara Ann Inc 1-13-17 190,080 Community Colleges 190,080 211.81 5182 Woodlands Dr 1-13-16 Town Tax 190,080 98.25 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 90.00 DPTH 209.00 Chargebacks 190,080 3.52 EAST-0928821 NRTH-0897057 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 190,080 TO 402.16 DEED BOOK 1848 PG-00270 SW002 Shorewood water 190,080 TO C 14.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 265,846 TOTAL TAX --- 2,953.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,953.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-16 ***************** 5178 Woodlands Dr BILL 546 95.17-1-16 210 1 Family Res - WTRFNT Medicaid 119,000 760.56 Tallon Sandra R Trest Dunkirk Csd 060300 43,500 County Tax 119,000 631.00 40 Woodburn St 1-13-1 119,000 Community Colleges 119,000 132.60 Frankfort, KY 40601 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 119,000 61.51 EAST-0928899 NRTH-0897128 Chargebacks 119,000 2.20 DEED BOOK 1802 PG-00065 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 119,000 TO 251.78 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,434 SW002 Shorewood water 119,000 TO C 9.26 TOTAL TAX --- 1,848.91** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,848.91 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 147 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-17 ***************** Bay Reef Dr BILL 547 95.17-1-17 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 17,300 110.57 Matson Marion H Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,900 County Tax 17,300 91.73 Jill Hoovler 1-5-1 17,300 Community Colleges 17,300 19.28 162 Griswold Ct FRNT 146.00 DPTH 141.00 Town Tax 17,300 8.94 Delaware, OH 43015 EAST-0929244 NRTH-0897167 Chargebacks 17,300 0.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,196 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,300 TO 36.60 SW002 Shorewood water 17,300 TO C 1.35 TOTAL TAX --- 268.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 268.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-18 ***************** Bay Reef Dr BILL 548 95.17-1-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 110,970 709.23 Kall John P Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,900 County Tax 110,970 588.42 Kall Jane C 1-5-2 110,970 Community Colleges 110,970 123.65 10563 Bay Reef Dr FRNT 120.00 DPTH 141.00 Town Tax 110,970 57.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929318 NRTH-0897056 Chargebacks 110,970 2.05 DEED BOOK 1979 PG-00406 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 110,970 TO 234.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,203 SW002 Shorewood water 110,970 TO C 8.63 TOTAL TAX --- 1,724.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,724.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-19 ***************** 5170 Shorewood Dr BILL 549 95.17-1-19 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Strychalski James T Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Strychalski Irene D 1-5-5 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 5170 Shorewood Dr FRNT 20.00 DPTH 589.00 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929301 NRTH-0896945 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 DEED BOOK 1727 PG-00070 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,000 TO 2.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 SW002 Shorewood water 1,000 TO C .08 TOTAL TAX --- 15.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-20 ***************** 10559 Bay Reef Dr BILL 550 95.17-1-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 91,000 581.60 Kenney Samantha B Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,900 County Tax 91,000 482.53 10559 Bay Reef Dr 1-5-3 91,000 Community Colleges 91,000 101.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.38 Town Tax 91,000 47.04 EAST-0929387 NRTH-0896954 Chargebacks 91,000 1.68 DEED BOOK 2632 PG-791 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 91,000 TO 192.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,273 SW002 Shorewood water 91,000 TO C 7.08 TOTAL TAX --- 1,413.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,413.86 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 148 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-21 ***************** 5128 W Lake Rd BILL 551 95.17-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 83,180 531.62 Dilorenzo Nicholas G Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,700 County Tax 83,180 441.07 Dilorenzo Julianne V 1-5-4 83,180 Community Colleges 83,180 92.69 5128 W Lake Rd FRNT 141.00 DPTH 181.00 Town Tax 83,180 42.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929472 NRTH-0896827 Chargebacks 83,180 1.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 116,336 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 83,180 TO 175.99 SW002 Shorewood water 83,180 TO C 6.47 TOTAL TAX --- 1,292.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,292.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-22 ***************** 5134 W Lake Rd BILL 552 95.17-1-22 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Edwards Martha A Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,200 Medicaid 85,920 549.13 Edwards Michael D 1-5-6 93,270 County Tax 85,920 455.59 5134 West Lake Rd FRNT 121.00 DPTH 181.00 Community Colleges 85,920 95.74 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929361 NRTH-0896730 Town Tax 93,270 48.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,448 Chargebacks 93,270 1.73 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 93,270 TO 197.34 SW002 Shorewood water 93,270 TO C 7.26 TOTAL TAX --- 1,355.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,355.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-23 ***************** 10545 Edgewood Dr BILL 553 95.17-1-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 95,000 607.17 Fancher Rollin L Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,400 County Tax 95,000 503.74 Fancher Yvonne M 1-5-7 95,000 Community Colleges 95,000 105.86 10545 Edgewood Dr FRNT 101.90 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 95,000 49.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929281 NRTH-0896849 Chargebacks 95,000 1.76 DEED BOOK 2680 PG-387 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 95,000 TO 201.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 132,867 SW002 Shorewood water 95,000 TO C 7.39 TOTAL TAX --- 1,476.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,476.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-24 ***************** 10551 Edgewood Dr BILL 554 95.17-1-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 83,500 533.67 Westman Patricia K Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,400 County Tax 83,500 442.76 10551 Edgewood Drive 1-5-8 83,500 Community Colleges 83,500 93.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 101.90 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 83,500 43.16 EAST-0929225 NRTH-0896932 Chargebacks 83,500 1.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 116,783 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 83,500 TO 176.67 SW002 Shorewood water 83,500 TO C 6.50 TOTAL TAX --- 1,297.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,297.35 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 149 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-25 ***************** 10559 Edgewood Dr BILL 555 95.17-1-25 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 115,000 734.99 O'brocta Timothy C Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,400 County Tax 115,000 609.79 PO Box 17 1-5-9 115,000 Community Colleges 115,000 128.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 101.90 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 115,000 59.44 EAST-0929168 NRTH-0897016 Chargebacks 115,000 2.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 160,839 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 115,000 TO 243.31 SW002 Shorewood water 115,000 TO C 8.95 US001 Unpaid sewer 129.25 MT 129.25 TOTAL TAX --- 1,916.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,916.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-26 ***************** 10559 Edgewood Dr BILL 556 95.17-1-26 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 O'brocta Timothy C Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 PO Box 17 1-5-10.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 8.00 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0929137 NRTH-0897063 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 100 TO .21 SW002 Shorewood water 100 TO C .01 TOTAL TAX --- 1.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-27 ***************** 5170 Shorewood Dr BILL 557 95.17-1-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 11,600 74.14 Strychalski James T Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,600 County Tax 11,600 61.51 Strychalski Irene D 1-5-10.1 11,600 Community Colleges 11,600 12.93 5170 Shorewood Dr FRNT 91.10 DPTH 121.00 Town Tax 11,600 6.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929111 NRTH-0897103 Chargebacks 11,600 0.21 DEED BOOK 1727 PG-00070 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,600 TO 24.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,224 SW002 Shorewood water 11,600 TO C .90 TOTAL TAX --- 180.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 180.23 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-28 ***************** 5138 W Lake Rd BILL 558 95.17-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 21,200 135.49 Allison S Lang Revocable Trust Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,200 County Tax 21,200 112.41 Allison S. Lang Trustee 1-13-2.1 21,200 Community Colleges 21,200 23.62 54 Ocean Course Dr FRNT 200.00 DPTH 160.00 Town Tax 21,200 10.96 Kiawah Island, SC 29455 EAST-0929027 NRTH-0896963 Chargebacks 21,200 0.39 DEED BOOK 2108 PG-00330 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 21,200 TO 44.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,650 SW002 Shorewood water 21,200 TO C 1.65 TOTAL TAX --- 329.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 329.37 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 150 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-29 ***************** 5138 W Lake Rd BILL 559 95.17-1-29 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 121,190 774.55 Pacos Audrey A Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,100 County Tax 121,190 642.62 5138 W Lake Rd 1-13-2.2 121,190 Community Colleges 121,190 135.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 121,190 62.64 EAST-0929199 NRTH-0896734 Chargebacks 121,190 2.24 DEED BOOK 2630 PG-383 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 121,190 TO 256.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 169,497 SW002 Shorewood water 121,190 TO C 9.43 TOTAL TAX --- 1,882.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,882.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-30 ***************** Woodlands Dr BILL 560 95.17-1-30 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 24,500 156.59 Allison S Lang Revocable Trust Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,400 County Tax 24,500 129.91 Allison S. Lang Trustee 1-13-3 24,500 Community Colleges 24,500 27.30 54 Ocean Course Dr ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 24,500 12.66 Kiawah, SC 29455 EAST-0928985 NRTH-0896687 Chargebacks 24,500 0.45 DEED BOOK 2107 PG-00092 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 24,500 TO 51.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,266 SW002 Shorewood water 24,500 TO C 1.91 TOTAL TAX --- 380.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 380.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-31 ***************** 5154 W Lake Rd BILL 561 95.17-1-31 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 7,644 Rosas Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,400 VETS CNTY 41102 2,150 0 5154 W Lake Rd 1-13-4 200,000 Medicaid 197,850 1,264.51 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.80 County Tax 197,850 1,049.11 EAST-0928983 NRTH-0896474 Community Colleges 197,850 220.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 279,720 Town Tax 192,356 99.42 Chargebacks 192,356 3.56 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 200,000 TO 423.15 SW002 Shorewood water 200,000 TO C 15.56 TOTAL TAX --- 3,075.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,075.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-32 ***************** 5204 Woodlands Dr BILL 562 95.17-1-32 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 21,300 136.13 Price Robert W Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,100 County Tax 21,300 112.94 Price Mary Beth 1-13-5 21,300 Community Colleges 21,300 23.73 5200 Woodlands Dr FRNT 110.00 DPTH 305.00 Town Tax 21,300 11.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0928776 NRTH-0896683 Chargebacks 21,300 0.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,790 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 21,300 TO 45.07 SW002 Shorewood water 21,300 TO C 1.66 TOTAL TAX --- 330.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 330.93 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 151 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-34 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 563 95.17-1-34 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Matie Carol Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 5161 West Lake Rd 1-12-21.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 20.00 DPTH 20.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0929086 NRTH-0896263 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 1860 PG-00078 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 100 TO .21 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 SW002 Shorewood water 100 TO C .01 TOTAL TAX --- 1.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-35 ***************** W Lake Rd BILL 564 95.17-1-35 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,800 11.50 Narraway William Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 1,800 9.54 10689 Wilbur Rd 1-12-21.1 1,800 Community Colleges 1,800 2.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.75 BANK9999999 Town Tax 1,800 0.93 EAST-0929236 NRTH-0896319 Chargebacks 1,800 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,800 TO 3.81 SW002 Shorewood water 1,800 TO C .14 TOTAL TAX --- 27.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 27.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-36 ***************** 5139 W Lake Rd BILL 565 95.17-1-36 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Begier William E Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 VET DIS CT 41141 14,700 22,842 Begier Geraldine R 1-12-20.1 114,210 Medicaid 92,160 589.02 5139 West Lake Rd ACRES 3.70 County Tax 92,160 488.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929516 NRTH-0896411 Community Colleges 92,160 102.69 DEED BOOK 1735 PG-00085 Town Tax 91,368 47.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 159,734 Chargebacks 91,368 1.69 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 114,210 TO 241.64 SW002 Shorewood water 114,210 TO C 8.89 TOTAL TAX --- 1,479.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,479.84 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-37 ***************** 5129 W Lake Rd BILL 566 95.17-1-37 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 118,950 760.24 Carlson Paul K Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,700 County Tax 118,950 630.74 Carlson Rose Ann 1-12-20.2 118,950 Community Colleges 118,950 132.55 5129 W Lake Rd ACRES 4.90 Town Tax 118,950 61.48 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929842 NRTH-0896518 Chargebacks 118,950 2.20 DEED BOOK 1975 PG-00523 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 118,950 TO 251.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 166,364 SW002 Shorewood water 118,950 TO C 9.25 TOTAL TAX --- 1,848.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,848.13 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 152 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-38 ***************** 5129 W Lake Rd BILL 567 95.17-1-38 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Carlson Paul K Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 Carlson Rose Ann 1-12-19 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 5129 W Lake Rd ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0929994 NRTH-0896565 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 DEED BOOK 1975 PG-00523 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,200 TO 2.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 SW002 Shorewood water 1,200 TO C .09 TOTAL TAX --- 18.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-39 ***************** 5099 W Lake Rd BILL 568 95.17-1-39 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 37,140 237.37 Motto Gerald Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,300 County Tax 37,140 196.94 5099 W Lake Rd 1-12-18 37,140 Community Colleges 37,140 41.39 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.60 Town Tax 37,140 19.20 EAST-0930108 NRTH-0896622 Chargebacks 37,140 0.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,944 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 37,140 TO 78.58 SW002 Shorewood water 37,140 TO C 2.89 TOTAL TAX --- 577.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 577.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-40 ***************** 5099 W Lake Rd BILL 569 95.17-1-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 51,500 329.15 Motto Gerald Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 51,500 273.08 5099 W Lake Rd 1-12-17 51,500 Community Colleges 51,500 57.39 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.80 Town Tax 51,500 26.62 EAST-0930266 NRTH-0896700 Chargebacks 51,500 0.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,028 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 51,500 TO 108.96 SW002 Shorewood water 51,500 TO C 4.01 TOTAL TAX --- 800.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 800.16 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-41 ***************** 5099 W Lake Rd BILL 570 95.17-1-41 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,200 20.45 Motto Gerald Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 3,200 16.97 5099 W Lake Rd 1-12-15 3,200 Community Colleges 3,200 3.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 3,200 1.65 EAST-0930484 NRTH-0896680 Chargebacks 3,200 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,476 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,200 TO 6.77 SW002 Shorewood water 3,200 TO C .25 TOTAL TAX --- 49.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 49.72 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 153 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-42 ***************** 5083 W Lake Rd BILL 571 95.17-1-42 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,500 15.98 Harper Rodney M Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 2,500 13.26 Harper Estelle 1-12-14 2,500 Community Colleges 2,500 2.79 5083 West Lake Rd ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 2,500 1.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0930573 NRTH-0896802 Chargebacks 2,500 0.05 DEED BOOK 2040 PG-00091 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,500 TO 5.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,497 SW002 Shorewood water 2,500 TO C .19 TOTAL TAX --- 38.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 38.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-1 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 572 96.01-1-1 311 Res vac land AG COMMIT 41730 8,560 8,560 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,460 Medicaid 900 5.75 Fred Milagros 4-3-3.2.1 9,460 County Tax 900 4.77 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 3.40 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940133 NRTH-0899788 Town Tax 900 0.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,231 Chargebacks 900 0.02 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,460 TO 20.02 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,460 TO 4.84 TOTAL TAX --- 36.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 36.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-2 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 573 96.01-1-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 67,240 429.75 Fred Roberto Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,440 County Tax 67,240 356.54 4508 Willow Rd 4-3-3.2.2 67,240 Community Colleges 67,240 74.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 67,240 34.76 EAST-0940337 NRTH-0899902 Chargebacks 67,240 1.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,042 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,240 TO 142.26 WD058 Comprehensive Water 67,240 TO 34.39 TOTAL TAX --- 1,073.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,073.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-3 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 574 96.01-1-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 960 6.14 Fred Roberto Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 960 County Tax 960 5.09 4508 Willow Rd 5-1-1.2 960 Community Colleges 960 1.07 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 343.00 Town Tax 960 0.50 EAST-0940450 NRTH-0899996 Chargebacks 960 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,343 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 960 TO 2.03 WD058 Comprehensive Water 960 TO .49 TOTAL TAX --- 15.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.34 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 154 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-4 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 575 96.01-1-4 311 Res vac land Medicaid 240 1.53 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 240 County Tax 240 1.27 Fred Milagros 5-1-1.1 240 Community Colleges 240 0.27 10655 Temple Rd FRNT 30.00 DPTH 343.00 Town Tax 240 0.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940525 NRTH-0900041 Chargebacks 240 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 336 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 240 TO .51 WD058 Comprehensive Water 240 TO .12 TOTAL TAX --- 3.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-5 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 576 96.01-1-5 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 70,870 452.95 Snyder Cathy Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 70,870 375.79 4504 Willow Rd 5-1-2 70,870 Community Colleges 70,870 78.97 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 70,870 36.63 EAST-0940628 NRTH-0900064 Chargebacks 70,870 1.31 DEED BOOK 2120 PG-00010 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 70,870 TO 149.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,119 WD058 Comprehensive Water 70,870 TO 36.24 TOTAL TAX --- 1,131.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,131.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-7 ****************** Willow Rd BILL 577 96.01-1-7 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 73,500 469.76 Heiden Margaret A Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,900 County Tax 73,500 389.74 4501 Willow Rd 5-2-19 73,500 Community Colleges 73,500 81.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.67 Town Tax 73,500 37.99 EAST-0940781 NRTH-0899909 Chargebacks 73,500 1.36 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,797 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 73,500 TO 155.51 WD058 Comprehensive Water 73,500 TO 37.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,173.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,173.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-9 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 578 96.01-1-9 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 3,000 3,000 Agosto Salvador Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,800 Medicaid 800 5.11 429 Park Ave 5-2-17 3,800 County Tax 800 4.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.90 Community Colleges 800 0.89 EAST-0941264 NRTH-0899455 Town Tax 800 0.41 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 5,315 Chargebacks 800 0.01 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,800 TO 8.04 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,800 TO 1.94 TOTAL TAX --- 20.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.64 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 155 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-10 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 579 96.01-1-10 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,200 14.06 Davis Kevin J Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,200 County Tax 2,200 11.67 Davis Melissa M 5-2-16.1 2,200 Community Colleges 2,200 2.45 24 Genet St ACRES 3.60 Town Tax 2,200 1.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0941024 NRTH-0899456 Chargebacks 2,200 0.04 DEED BOOK 2094 PG-00549 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,200 TO 4.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,077 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,200 TO 1.13 TOTAL TAX --- 35.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 35.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-11 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 580 96.01-1-11 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 23,370 149.36 Davis Kevin J Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 23,370 123.92 Davis Melissa M 5-2-16.2 23,370 Community Colleges 23,370 26.04 24 Genet St ACRES 3.80 Town Tax 23,370 12.08 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940704 NRTH-0899466 Chargebacks 23,370 0.43 DEED BOOK 2094 PG-00549 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 23,370 TO 49.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,685 WD058 Comprehensive Water 23,370 TO 11.95 TOTAL TAX --- 373.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 373.23 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-12 ***************** Willow Rd BILL 581 96.01-1-12 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 7,770 49.66 Wolfe James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 7,770 41.20 Wolfe Gail A 5-2-15 7,770 Community Colleges 7,770 8.66 4525 Willow Rd ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 7,770 4.02 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940513 NRTH-0899421 Chargebacks 7,770 0.14 DEED BOOK 2337 PG-817 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,770 TO 16.44 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,867 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,770 TO 3.97 TOTAL TAX --- 124.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 124.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-13 ***************** 4525 Willow Rd BILL 582 96.01-1-13 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 79,380 507.34 Wolfe James A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 79,380 420.92 4525 Willow Rd 5-2-14 79,380 Community Colleges 79,380 88.45 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 79,380 41.03 EAST-0940381 NRTH-0899404 Chargebacks 79,380 1.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,021 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 79,380 TO 167.95 WD058 Comprehensive Water 79,380 TO 40.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,267.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,267.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 156 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-1-14 ***************** 4531 Willow Rd BILL 583 96.01-1-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 91,120 582.37 Julian Philip D Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,700 County Tax 91,120 483.17 4531 Willow Rd 4-7-2 91,120 Community Colleges 91,120 101.54 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 290.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 91,120 47.10 ACRES 1.60 Chargebacks 91,120 1.69 EAST-0940186 NRTH-0899347 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 91,120 TO 192.79 DEED BOOK 2127 PG-00408 WD058 Comprehensive Water 91,120 TO 46.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,441 TOTAL TAX --- 1,455.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,455.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-2 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 584 96.01-2-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Figueroa Ilka Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,100 County Tax 64,000 339.36 10713 Brigham Rd 5-2-3.1 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.88 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 EAST-0942132 NRTH-0899908 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 64,000 TO 135.41 WD058 Comprehensive Water 64,000 TO 32.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,022.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,022.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-3 ****************** 10720 Brigham Rd BILL 585 96.01-2-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 36,500 233.28 Filutze Marjorie A Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 36,500 193.54 122 Prospect St 5-3-1 36,500 Community Colleges 36,500 40.67 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 36,500 18.87 EAST-0942928 NRTH-0900070 Chargebacks 36,500 0.68 DEED BOOK 1783 PG-00221 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 36,500 TO 77.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,049 WD058 Comprehensive Water 36,500 TO 18.67 TOTAL TAX --- 582.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 582.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-4 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 586 96.01-2-4 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,000 51.13 Drummond Mark A Sr Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 8,000 42.42 10696 Brigham Rd 5-3-2 8,000 Community Colleges 8,000 8.91 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 8,000 4.14 EAST-0942709 NRTH-0899973 Chargebacks 8,000 0.15 DEED BOOK 2105 PG-00431 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,000 TO 16.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,189 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,000 TO 4.09 TOTAL TAX --- 127.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 127.77 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 157 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-5 ****************** 10712 Brigham Rd BILL 587 96.01-2-5 484 1 use sm bld Medicaid 23,000 147.00 Drummond Scot C Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,300 County Tax 23,000 121.96 10706 Brigham Rd 5-3-3.2 23,000 Community Colleges 23,000 25.63 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 45.00 DPTH 458.60 Town Tax 23,000 11.89 ACRES 0.47 Chargebacks 23,000 0.43 EAST-0942716 NRTH-0899900 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 23,000 TO 48.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,168 WD058 Comprehensive Water 23,000 TO 11.76 TOTAL TAX --- 367.33** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 367.33 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-6 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 588 96.01-2-6 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,500 393.06 Drummond Shirley Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,800 County Tax 61,500 326.11 10710 Brigham Rd 5-3-3.1 61,500 Community Colleges 61,500 68.53 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 458.60 Town Tax 61,500 31.79 EAST-0942715 NRTH-0899852 Chargebacks 61,500 1.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,014 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 61,500 TO 130.12 WD058 Comprehensive Water 61,500 TO 31.45 TOTAL TAX --- 982.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 982.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-7 ****************** 10706 Brigham Rd BILL 589 96.01-2-7 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 52,820 337.58 Drummond Mark Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 52,820 280.08 10696 Brigham Rd 5-3-4.2 52,820 Community Colleges 52,820 58.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.60 Town Tax 52,820 27.30 EAST-0942632 NRTH-0899786 Chargebacks 52,820 0.98 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 52,820 TO 111.75 WD058 Comprehensive Water 52,820 TO 27.01 TOTAL TAX --- 843.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 843.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-8 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 590 96.01-2-8 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Drummond Mark A Sr Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 10696 Brigham Rd 5-3-4.1 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.40 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 EAST-0943092 NRTH-0899931 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 DEED BOOK 2630 PG-106 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,000 TO 2.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.97 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 158 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-9 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 591 96.01-2-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 109,800 701.76 Drummond Mark A Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,000 County Tax 109,800 582.22 Drummond Brenda J 5-3-5 109,800 Community Colleges 109,800 122.35 10696 Brigham Rd ACRES 16.00 Town Tax 109,800 56.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0943699 NRTH-0899788 Chargebacks 109,800 2.03 DEED BOOK 2339 PG-464 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 109,800 TO 232.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 153,566 WD058 Comprehensive Water 109,800 TO 56.15 TOTAL TAX --- 1,753.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,753.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-11 ***************** 71 W Green St BILL 592 96.01-2-11 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 45,300 289.52 Gage Donald E Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 County Tax 45,300 240.21 71 W Green St 5-3-7 45,300 Community Colleges 45,300 50.48 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 45,300 23.41 EAST-0944394 NRTH-0899501 Chargebacks 45,300 0.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 63,357 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 45,300 TO 95.84 WD058 Comprehensive Water 45,300 TO 23.17 TOTAL TAX --- 723.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 723.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-12 ***************** Lafayette Ave BILL 593 96.01-2-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,100 13.42 Mancuso David Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,100 County Tax 2,100 11.14 Mancuso Carol Rear Land 2,100 Community Colleges 2,100 2.34 50 Lafayette St 5-3-11.5 Town Tax 2,100 1.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 132.00 DPTH 200.00 Chargebacks 2,100 0.04 EAST-0944327 NRTH-0899112 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,100 TO 4.44 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,937 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,100 TO 1.07 TOTAL TAX --- 33.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 33.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-13 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 594 96.01-2-13 120 Field crops Medicaid 4,800 30.68 Foreman Paul Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,800 County Tax 4,800 25.45 10676 Brigham Rd 5-3-8 4,800 Community Colleges 4,800 5.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 11.10 Town Tax 4,800 2.48 EAST-0944031 NRTH-0899446 Chargebacks 4,800 0.09 DEED BOOK 1637 PG-00058 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 4,800 TO 10.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,713 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,800 TO 2.45 TOTAL TAX --- 76.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 76.66 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 159 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-14 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 595 96.01-2-14 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 9,500 60.72 Foreman Paul Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,300 County Tax 9,500 50.37 10676 Brigham Rd 5-3-9 9,500 Community Colleges 9,500 10.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.80 Town Tax 9,500 4.91 EAST-0943458 NRTH-0899241 Chargebacks 9,500 0.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,287 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,500 TO 20.10 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,500 TO 4.86 TOTAL TAX --- 151.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 151.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-15 ***************** 10676 Brigham Rd BILL 596 96.01-2-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,500 476.15 Foreman Paul Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 County Tax 74,500 395.04 10676 Brigham Rd 5-3-10 74,500 Community Colleges 74,500 83.02 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 74,500 38.51 EAST-0942638 NRTH-0899232 Chargebacks 74,500 1.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,196 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 74,500 TO 157.62 WD058 Comprehensive Water 74,500 TO 38.10 TOTAL TAX --- 1,189.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,189.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-16 ***************** 10681 Brigham Rd BILL 597 96.01-2-16 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,500 386.67 Huddleston Kyle Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 60,500 320.80 Rosie Erin 5-2-4.1 60,500 Community Colleges 60,500 67.42 10681 Brigham Rd ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 60,500 31.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0942330 NRTH-0899363 Chargebacks 60,500 1.12 DEED BOOK 2669 PG-614 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 60,500 TO 128.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,615 WD058 Comprehensive Water 60,500 TO 30.94 TOTAL TAX --- 966.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 966.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-17 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 598 96.01-2-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 125,000 798.90 Pogorzelski Raymond J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 125,000 662.82 Pogorzelski Brenda M 5-2-4.3 125,000 Community Colleges 125,000 139.29 10697 Brigham Rd ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 125,000 64.61 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0942341 NRTH-0899582 Chargebacks 125,000 2.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,825 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 125,000 TO 264.47 WD058 Comprehensive Water 125,000 TO 63.92 TOTAL TAX --- 1,996.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,996.32 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 160 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-18 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 599 96.01-2-18 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 1,260 1,260 Agosto Salvador Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 Medicaid 340 2.17 429 Park Ave 5-2-4.2 1,600 County Tax 340 1.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.80 Community Colleges 340 0.38 EAST-0942190 NRTH-0899564 Town Tax 340 0.18 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 Chargebacks 340 0.01 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,600 TO 3.39 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,600 TO .82 TOTAL TAX --- 8.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-19 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 600 96.01-2-19 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 11,990 11,990 Agosto Salvador Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,200 Medicaid 3,210 20.52 429 Park Ave 5-2-5 15,200 County Tax 3,210 17.02 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.60 Community Colleges 3,210 3.58 EAST-0941866 NRTH-0899440 Town Tax 3,210 1.66 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 21,259 Chargebacks 3,210 0.06 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 15,200 TO 32.16 WD058 Comprehensive Water 15,200 TO 7.77 TOTAL TAX --- 82.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 82.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-2 ****************** 10969 Bennet Rd BILL 601 96.02-1-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 40,000 255.65 Smith Leo M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 County Tax 40,000 212.10 10969 Bennett Rd 8-1-1 40,000 Community Colleges 40,000 44.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 40,000 20.68 EAST-0948918 NRTH-0902594 Chargebacks 40,000 0.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,944 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 40,000 TO 71.08 SW001 Bennett road water 40,000 TO C 39.68 TOTAL TAX --- 644.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 644.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-3 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 602 96.02-1-3 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 4,400 28.12 Jackson Jean D Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,400 County Tax 4,400 23.33 10970 Bennett Rd 8-2-1 4,400 Community Colleges 4,400 4.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 55.80 DPTH 160.00 Town Tax 4,400 2.27 EAST-0949179 NRTH-0902729 Chargebacks 4,400 0.08 DEED BOOK 2061 PG-00515 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,400 TO 7.82 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,154 SW001 Bennett road water 4,400 TO C 4.36 TOTAL TAX --- 70.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 70.88 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 161 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-4 ****************** 10970 Bennett Rd BILL 603 96.02-1-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 48,500 309.97 Jackson Jean D Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 County Tax 48,500 257.17 10970 Bennett Rd 8-2-32 48,500 Community Colleges 48,500 54.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 48.00 DPTH 134.90 Town Tax 48,500 25.07 EAST-0949190 NRTH-0902678 Chargebacks 48,500 0.90 DEED BOOK 2061 PG-00515 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 48,500 TO 86.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,832 SW001 Bennett road water 48,500 TO C 48.11 TOTAL TAX --- 781.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 781.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-5 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 604 96.02-1-5 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,400 15.34 Jackson Jean D Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,400 County Tax 2,400 12.73 10970 Bennett Rd 8-2-31 2,400 Community Colleges 2,400 2.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 65.40 DPTH 118.40 Town Tax 2,400 1.24 EAST-0949202 NRTH-0902621 Chargebacks 2,400 0.04 DEED BOOK 2061 PG-00515 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,400 TO 4.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,357 SW001 Bennett road water 2,400 TO C 2.38 TOTAL TAX --- 38.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 38.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-6 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 605 96.02-1-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Jackson Jean D Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 10970 Bennett Rd 8-2-30 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 111.00 DPTH 40.00 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 EAST-0949266 NRTH-0902646 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 DEED BOOK 2061 PG-00515 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 SW001 Bennett road water 1,700 TO C 1.69 TOTAL TAX --- 27.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 27.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-7 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 606 96.02-1-7 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 79,600 508.74 Jakubowski Mary E Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 County Tax 79,600 422.08 255 Maple Ave 8-2-2 79,600 Community Colleges 79,600 88.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Town Tax 79,600 41.14 EAST-0949599 NRTH-0902673 Chargebacks 79,600 1.47 FULL MARKET VALUE 111,329 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 79,600 TO 141.44 SW001 Bennett road water 79,600 TO C 78.96 TOTAL TAX --- 1,282.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,282.53 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 162 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-8 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 607 96.02-1-8 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 59,820 382.32 Millan Estaban Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,400 County Tax 59,820 317.20 Millan Olga 8-2-29.1 59,820 Community Colleges 59,820 66.66 61 Fourth St W EAST-0949812 NRTH-0902505 Town Tax 59,820 30.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,664 Chargebacks 59,820 1.11 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 59,820 TO 106.30 SW001 Bennett road water 59,820 TO C 59.34 TOTAL TAX --- 963.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 963.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-9 ****************** Maple Ave BILL 608 96.02-1-9 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Jakubowski Mary E Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 255 Maple Ave 8-2-3.3 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 10.00 DPTH 171.70 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0949917 NRTH-0902673 Chargebacks 100 0.00 PRIOR OWNER ON 3/01/2014 DEED BOOK 2061 PG-00460 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 Jakubowski John D FULL MARKET VALUE 140 SW001 Bennett road water 100 TO C .10 TOTAL TAX --- 1.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-10 ***************** Maple Ave BILL 609 96.02-1-10 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,000 12.78 Crane Thomas W Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 County Tax 2,000 10.61 253 Maple Ave 8-2-3.1 2,000 Community Colleges 2,000 2.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 2,000 1.03 EAST-0950152 NRTH-0902673 Chargebacks 2,000 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,797 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,000 TO 3.55 SW001 Bennett road water 2,000 TO C 1.98 TOTAL TAX --- 32.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 32.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-11 ***************** E Of Bennett Rd BILL 610 96.02-1-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 Howlett Charles L Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 Howlett Donna M 8-2-3.2 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 267 King St ACRES 0.15 Town Tax 200 0.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950400 NRTH-0902672 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 SW001 Bennett road water 200 TO C .20 TOTAL TAX --- 3.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.22 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 163 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-12 ***************** E Of Bennett Rd BILL 611 96.02-1-12 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 4,510 28.82 Hill Tatyana Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 4,510 23.91 265 King St 8-2-4 4,510 Community Colleges 4,510 5.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 55.00 Town Tax 4,510 2.33 EAST-0950436 NRTH-0902724 Chargebacks 4,510 0.08 DEED BOOK 1641 PG-00048 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,510 TO 8.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,308 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,510 TO 2.31 TOTAL TAX --- 70.49** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 70.49 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-13 ***************** E Of Bennett Rd BILL 612 96.02-1-13 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 4,200 26.84 Howlett Charles Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 4,200 22.27 Howlett Donna M 8-2-5 4,200 Community Colleges 4,200 4.68 267 King St ACRES 0.14 Town Tax 4,200 2.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950461 NRTH-0902699 Chargebacks 4,200 0.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,874 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,200 TO 7.46 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,200 TO 2.15 TOTAL TAX --- 65.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 65.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-14 ***************** E Of Bennett Rd BILL 613 96.02-1-14 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Howlett Charles L Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 Howlett Donna M 8-2-6 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 267 King St ACRES 0.12 Town Tax 100 0.05 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950541 NRTH-0902702 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-16 ***************** King St BILL 614 96.02-1-16 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Hajduk Rudolf Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 Hajduk Ana 8-2-8.2.1 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Lee Hajduk ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 6655 North Main St EAST-0950900 NRTH-0902535 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 PO Box 274 DEED BOOK 1984 PG-00116 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 Cherry Creek, NY 14723 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 164 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-17 ***************** Williams Rd BILL 615 96.02-1-17 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 93,000 594.38 Taddio John Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 93,000 493.14 Rose Mary 8-2-8.2.2 93,000 Community Colleges 93,000 103.63 10 Tenney St FRNT 100.00 DPTH 427.10 Town Tax 93,000 48.07 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950996 NRTH-0902534 Chargebacks 93,000 1.72 DEED BOOK 1664 PG-00162 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 93,000 TO 165.25 FULL MARKET VALUE 130,070 WD058 Comprehensive Water 93,000 TO 47.56 TOTAL TAX --- 1,453.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,453.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-18 ***************** N Of Williams Rd BILL 616 96.02-1-18 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Christopher Nicholas Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Christopher Crystal 8-2-8.1 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 14 Tenney St FRNT 23.00 DPTH 427.10 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951059 NRTH-0902533 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-19 ***************** N Of Williams Rd BILL 617 96.02-1-19 311 Res vac land Medicaid 300 1.92 Christopher Nicholas Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 300 1.59 Christopher Crystal 8-2-10.2 300 Community Colleges 300 0.33 14 Tenney St ACRES 0.28 Town Tax 300 0.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951128 NRTH-0902488 Chargebacks 300 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 420 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300 TO .53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 300 TO .15 TOTAL TAX --- 4.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-20 ***************** N Of Williams Rd BILL 618 96.02-1-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 59,000 377.08 Christopher Nicholas Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 County Tax 59,000 312.85 Christopher Crystal 8-2-9 59,000 Community Colleges 59,000 65.74 14 Tenney St ACRES 0.48 Town Tax 59,000 30.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951126 NRTH-0902652 Chargebacks 59,000 1.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 82,517 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 59,000 TO 104.84 WD058 Comprehensive Water 59,000 TO 30.17 TOTAL TAX --- 922.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 922.27 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 165 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-21 ***************** Lincoln Ave BILL 619 96.02-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,800 394.98 Maslach Bruce Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 61,800 327.70 14 W Tenney St Lot 2 8-2-10.1 61,800 Community Colleges 61,800 68.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 92.00 DPTH 269.00 Town Tax 61,800 31.94 ACRES 1.20 Chargebacks 61,800 1.14 EAST-0951239 NRTH-0902554 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,800 TO 109.81 DEED BOOK 1981 PG-00355 WD058 Comprehensive Water 61,800 TO 31.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,434 TOTAL TAX --- 966.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 966.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-22 ***************** Lincoln Ave BILL 620 96.02-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Maslach Bruce Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 14 W Tenney St Lot 2 8-2-11 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.73 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0951349 NRTH-0902611 Chargebacks 900 0.02 DEED BOOK 1981 PG-00355 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 900 TO 1.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 WD058 Comprehensive Water 900 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 14.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-25 ***************** W Of Railroad Ave BILL 621 96.02-1-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,200 20.45 Miller Peter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 3,200 16.97 509 Main St 8-2-12 3,200 Community Colleges 3,200 3.57 East Aurora, NY 14052 ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 3,200 1.65 EAST-0951552 NRTH-0902594 Chargebacks 3,200 0.06 DEED BOOK 1646 PG-00046 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,200 TO 5.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,476 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,200 TO 1.64 TOTAL TAX --- 50.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 50.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-28 ***************** W Of Railroad Ave BILL 622 96.02-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 14,300 91.39 Miller Peter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,300 County Tax 14,300 75.83 509 Main St 8-2-15 14,300 Community Colleges 14,300 15.93 East Aurora, NY 14052 ACRES 6.30 Town Tax 14,300 7.39 EAST-0951794 NRTH-0902261 Chargebacks 14,300 0.26 DEED BOOK 1646 PG-00046 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 14,300 TO 25.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,000 WD058 Comprehensive Water 14,300 TO 7.31 TOTAL TAX --- 223.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 223.52 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 166 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-29 ***************** Williams Rd BILL 623 96.02-1-29 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 40,110 256.35 Miller Virginia M Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 County Tax 40,110 212.69 3850 Williams St 8-2-19.2 40,110 Community Colleges 40,110 44.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.70 Town Tax 40,110 20.73 EAST-0951954 NRTH-0901772 Chargebacks 40,110 0.74 DEED BOOK 1576 PG-00064 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 40,110 TO 71.27 FULL MARKET VALUE 56,098 SW001 Bennett road water 40,110 TO C 39.79 TOTAL TAX --- 646.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 646.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-30 ***************** Williams Rd BILL 624 96.02-1-30 311 Res vac land Medicaid 15,000 95.87 Miller Peter A Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,000 County Tax 15,000 79.54 509 Main St 8-2-19.1 15,000 Community Colleges 15,000 16.71 East Aurora, NY 14052 ACRES 6.80 Town Tax 15,000 7.75 EAST-0951621 NRTH-0901771 Chargebacks 15,000 0.28 DEED BOOK 1576 PG-00064 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 15,000 TO 26.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,979 SW001 Bennett road water 15,000 TO C 14.88 TOTAL TAX --- 241.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 241.68 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-31 ***************** Williams Rd BILL 625 96.02-1-31 311 Res vac land Medicaid 13,000 83.09 Giallella Patricia L Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,000 County Tax 13,000 68.93 Kosowski Angeline 1/3 Interest Only 13,000 Community Colleges 13,000 14.49 Attn: Giallella Patricia L 8-2-20.1 Town Tax 13,000 6.72 Giallella Pascal A ACRES 5.23 Chargebacks 13,000 0.24 44 Crawford Dr EAST-0951233 NRTH-0901826 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 13,000 TO 23.10 Buffalo, NY 14206-3409 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,182 SW001 Bennett road water 13,000 TO C 12.90 TOTAL TAX --- 209.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 209.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-32 ***************** Williams St BILL 626 96.02-1-32 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 53,500 341.93 Taylor Marian E Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,300 County Tax 53,500 283.69 3884 Williams St 8-2-21 53,500 Community Colleges 53,500 59.62 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.24 Town Tax 53,500 27.65 EAST-0951171 NRTH-0901494 Chargebacks 53,500 0.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,825 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,500 TO 95.07 SW001 Bennett road water 53,500 TO C 53.07 TOTAL TAX --- 862.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 862.02 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 167 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-33.2 *************** Williams Rd BILL 627 96.02-1-33.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,960 57.27 Wilkinson Phillip Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,960 County Tax 8,960 47.51 277 King St 8-2-22.5 8,960 Community Colleges 8,960 9.98 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.80 Town Tax 8,960 4.63 EAST-0951005 NRTH-0901659 Chargebacks 8,960 0.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,531 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,960 TO 15.92 SW001 Bennett road water 8,960 TO C 8.89 TOTAL TAX --- 144.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 144.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-33.3 *************** 277 King St BILL 628 96.02-1-33.3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 57,760 369.16 Wilkinson Phillip E Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,360 County Tax 57,760 306.27 277 King St 8-2-22.6 57,760 Community Colleges 57,760 64.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 57,760 29.85 EAST-0950619 NRTH-0902573 Chargebacks 57,760 1.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,783 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,760 TO 102.63 SW001 Bennett road water 57,760 TO C 57.30 TOTAL TAX --- 930.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 930.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-38 ***************** 10936 Bennett Rd BILL 629 96.02-1-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 46,000 294.00 Shaw Mark Allen Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,200 County Tax 46,000 243.92 Shaw Karen R 8-2-27 46,000 Community Colleges 46,000 51.26 9502 Seymour Rd ACRES 2.80 Town Tax 46,000 23.78 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0949873 NRTH-0902188 Chargebacks 46,000 0.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 64,336 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 46,000 TO 81.74 SW001 Bennett road water 46,000 TO C 45.63 TOTAL TAX --- 741.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 741.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-39 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 630 96.02-1-39 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 63,000 402.65 Morales Jose A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 63,000 334.06 Morales Jeannette 8-2-26 63,000 Community Colleges 63,000 70.20 10930 Bennett Rd ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 63,000 32.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0949889 NRTH-0902102 Chargebacks 63,000 1.17 FULL MARKET VALUE 88,112 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 63,000 TO 111.95 SW001 Bennett road water 63,000 TO C 62.50 TOTAL TAX --- 1,015.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,015.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 168 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-40 ***************** 10924 Bennett Rd BILL 631 96.02-1-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,500 271.63 Klaybor Sharon A Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 42,500 225.36 Fote Paula E 8-2-25 42,500 Community Colleges 42,500 47.36 161 Seawatch Dr ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 42,500 21.97 Myrtle Beach, SC 29572 EAST-0949907 NRTH-0902020 Chargebacks 42,500 0.79 DEED BOOK 1805 PG-00253 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,500 TO 75.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,441 SW001 Bennett road water 42,500 TO C 42.16 TOTAL TAX --- 684.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 684.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-46.1 *************** Williams St BILL 632 96.02-1-46.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 10,280 65.70 Maslach Robert Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,280 County Tax 10,280 54.51 61 N Beagle St 8-1-10.1 10,280 Community Colleges 10,280 11.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 10,280 5.31 EAST-0948767 NRTH-0901510 Chargebacks 10,280 0.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,378 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 10,280 TO 18.27 SW001 Bennett road water 10,280 TO C 10.20 TOTAL TAX --- 165.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 165.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-46.2 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 633 96.02-1-46.2 485 >1use sm bld Medicaid 327,290 2,091.79 Knox Richard R LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 69,700 County Tax 327,290 1,735.47 9373 S Wind Cir Encludes 8-1-11.2 327,290 Community Colleges 327,290 364.70 Holland, NY 14080 8-1-10.2 Town Tax 327,290 169.17 ACRES 4.10 Chargebacks 327,290 6.06 EAST-0949071 NRTH-0901494 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 327,290 TO 581.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 457,748 SW001 Bennett road water 327,290 TO C 324.67 TOTAL TAX --- 5,273.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,273.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-47.1 *************** 10909 Bennett Rd BILL 634 96.02-1-47.1 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Majka Leo Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,160 Medicaid 60,420 386.16 Majka Lenora 8-1-9.1 64,830 County Tax 60,420 320.38 10909 Bennett Rd ACRES 2.80 Community Colleges 60,420 67.33 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0948949 NRTH-0901791 Town Tax 64,830 33.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 90,671 Chargebacks 64,830 1.20 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,830 TO 115.20 SW001 Bennett road water 64,830 TO C 64.31 TOTAL TAX --- 988.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 988.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 169 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-47.2 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 635 96.02-1-47.2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 34,620 221.26 Majka Leo Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 34,620 183.57 Majka Lenora 8-1-9.2 34,620 Community Colleges 34,620 38.58 10909 Bennett Rd ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 34,620 17.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0949090 NRTH-0901682 Chargebacks 34,620 0.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 48,420 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 34,620 TO 61.52 SW001 Bennett road water 34,620 TO C 34.34 TOTAL TAX --- 557.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 557.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-49 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 636 96.02-1-49 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,900 12.14 Vacanti Rose M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,900 County Tax 1,900 10.07 10929 Bennett Rd 8-1-3.2 1,900 Community Colleges 1,900 2.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.55 Town Tax 1,900 0.98 EAST-0948759 NRTH-0902003 Chargebacks 1,900 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,657 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,900 TO 3.38 SW001 Bennett road water 1,900 TO C 1.88 TOTAL TAX --- 30.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 30.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-50 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 637 96.02-1-50 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,800 11.50 Vacanti Rose Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 1,800 9.54 10929 Bennett Rd 8-1-6 1,800 Community Colleges 1,800 2.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 1,800 0.93 EAST-0949009 NRTH-0902001 Chargebacks 1,800 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,800 TO 3.20 SW001 Bennett road water 1,800 TO C 1.79 TOTAL TAX --- 29.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-51 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 638 96.02-1-51 311 Res vac land Medicaid 7,900 50.49 Messere Mary E Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,900 County Tax 7,900 41.89 10921 Bennett Rd 8-1-8 7,900 Community Colleges 7,900 8.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.43 Town Tax 7,900 4.08 EAST-0949220 NRTH-0901915 Chargebacks 7,900 0.15 DEED BOOK 2133 PG-00543 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,900 TO 14.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,049 SW001 Bennett road water 7,900 TO C 7.84 TOTAL TAX --- 127.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 127.29 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 170 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-52 ***************** 10921 Bennett Rd BILL 639 96.02-1-52 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 76,500 488.93 Messere Mary E Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,500 County Tax 76,500 405.64 10921 Bennett Rd 8-1-7 76,500 Community Colleges 76,500 85.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.36 Town Tax 76,500 39.54 EAST-0949204 NRTH-0901999 Chargebacks 76,500 1.42 DEED BOOK 2133 PG-00543 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 76,500 TO 135.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,993 SW001 Bennett road water 76,500 TO C 75.89 TOTAL TAX --- 1,232.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,232.59 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-53 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 640 96.02-1-53 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Vacanti Rose Annette M Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,700 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Vacanti Joann L 8-1-5 41,000 AGED C/S 41805 18,000 0 10929 Bennett Rd ACRES 0.32 Medicaid 18,000 115.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0949165 NRTH-0902096 County Tax 18,000 95.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 57,343 Community Colleges 18,000 20.06 Town Tax 23,224 12.00 Chargebacks 23,224 0.43 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 41,000 TO 72.85 SW001 Bennett road water 41,000 TO C 40.67 TOTAL TAX --- 356.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 356.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-54 ***************** 10935 Bennett Rd BILL 641 96.02-1-54 485 >1use sm bld Medicaid 127,000 811.69 Berger Frank Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,600 County Tax 127,000 673.42 Berger Sally 8-1-4 127,000 Community Colleges 127,000 141.52 10935 Bennett Rd ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 127,000 65.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0949147 NRTH-0902187 Chargebacks 127,000 2.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,622 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 127,000 TO 225.67 SW001 Bennett road water 127,000 TO C 125.98 TOTAL TAX --- 2,046.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,046.27 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 171 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-55 ***************** 10935 Bennett Rd BILL 642 96.02-1-55 449 Other Storag Medicaid 73,000 466.56 Berger Francis Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,400 County Tax 73,000 387.09 Berger Sally 8-1-3.1 73,000 Community Colleges 73,000 81.34 5181 W Main ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 73,000 37.73 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0948853 NRTH-0902187 Chargebacks 73,000 1.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,098 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,000 TO 129.71 SW001 Bennett road water 73,000 TO C 72.42 TOTAL TAX --- 1,176.20** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,176.20 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-1 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 643 96.02-2-1 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 18,000 115.04 Dashiell Patricia A Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,000 County Tax 18,000 95.45 10021 Route 60 8-1-11.1 18,000 Community Colleges 18,000 20.06 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 5.00 Town Tax 18,000 9.30 EAST-0948690 NRTH-0900864 Chargebacks 18,000 0.33 DEED BOOK 2117 PG-00199 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 18,000 TO 31.98 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,175 SW001 Bennett road water 18,000 TO C 17.86 TOTAL TAX --- 290.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 290.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-2 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 644 96.02-2-2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 187,400 1,197.72 Dashiell Patricia Dunkirk Csd 060300 187,400 County Tax 187,400 993.70 10021 Route 60 8-1-11.4.1 187,400 Community Colleges 187,400 208.82 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 18.60 Town Tax 187,400 96.86 EAST-0948990 NRTH-0900627 Chargebacks 187,400 3.47 DEED BOOK 2244 PG-138 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 187,400 TO 332.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 262,098 SW001 Bennett road water 187,400 TO C 185.90 TOTAL TAX --- 3,019.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,019.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-13 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 645 96.02-2-13 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,578 Aviles Francisco J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,300 VETS CNTY 41102 725 0 Aviles Valerie 8-4-7 34,480 Medicaid 33,755 215.74 71 W 4TH St Apt 2 ACRES 0.50 County Tax 33,755 178.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950302 NRTH-0900097 Community Colleges 33,755 37.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 48,224 Town Tax 31,902 16.49 Chargebacks 31,902 0.59 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 34,480 TO 61.27 SW001 Bennett road water 34,480 TO C 34.20 TOTAL TAX --- 544.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 544.89 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 172 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-14 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 646 96.02-2-14 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Aviles Francisco Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 Aviles Valeri 8-4-6.2 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 71 W 4TH St FRNT 12.80 DPTH 218.90 Town Tax 100 0.05 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950318 NRTH-0900160 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 SW001 Bennett road water 100 TO C .10 TOTAL TAX --- 1.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-15 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 647 96.02-2-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 15,500 99.06 Gambino David Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,500 County Tax 15,500 82.19 Gambino Polly 8-4-6.1 15,500 Community Colleges 15,500 17.27 4565 West Main Rd FRNT 137.90 DPTH 218.90 Town Tax 15,500 8.01 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0950276 NRTH-0900222 Chargebacks 15,500 0.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 21,678 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 15,500 TO 27.54 SW001 Bennett road water 15,500 TO C 15.38 TOTAL TAX --- 249.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 249.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-16 ***************** 10798 Bennett Rd BILL 648 96.02-2-16 433 Auto body Medicaid 125,000 798.90 Gambino David A Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,000 County Tax 125,000 662.82 10798 Bennett Rd 8-4-5 125,000 Community Colleges 125,000 139.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 125,000 64.61 EAST-0950248 NRTH-0900357 Chargebacks 125,000 2.31 DEED BOOK 2114 PG-00101 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 125,000 TO 222.11 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,825 SW001 Bennett road water 125,000 TO C 124.00 TOTAL TAX --- 2,014.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,014.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-17 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 649 96.02-2-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 43,800 279.94 Mancuso Family Irrevoc Trust Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,600 County Tax 43,800 232.25 36 N Beaver St 8-4-4 43,800 Community Colleges 43,800 48.81 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 43,800 22.64 EAST-0950204 NRTH-0900568 Chargebacks 43,800 0.81 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,259 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 43,800 TO 77.83 SW001 Bennett road water 43,800 TO C 43.45 TOTAL TAX --- 705.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 705.73 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 173 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-18 ***************** 10834 Bennett Rd BILL 650 96.02-2-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 66,500 425.02 Mourer Ryan Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 County Tax 66,500 352.62 106 Berry Rd 8-4-3 66,500 Community Colleges 66,500 74.10 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 1.90 Town Tax 66,500 34.37 EAST-0950153 NRTH-0900811 Chargebacks 66,500 1.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 93,007 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 66,500 TO 118.16 SW001 Bennett road water 66,500 TO C 65.97 TOTAL TAX --- 1,071.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,071.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-20 ***************** 10850 Bennett Rd BILL 651 96.02-2-20 230 3 Family Res Medicaid 51,500 329.15 Raymond Margaret Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,600 County Tax 51,500 273.08 10850 Bennett Rd 8-4-2.1 51,500 Community Colleges 51,500 57.39 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.90 Town Tax 51,500 26.62 EAST-0949931 NRTH-0900995 Chargebacks 51,500 0.95 DEED BOOK 1842 PG-00293 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 51,500 TO 91.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,028 SW001 Bennett road water 51,500 TO C 51.09 TOTAL TAX --- 829.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 829.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-22 ***************** 3919 Williams St BILL 652 96.02-2-22 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,067 Griewisch Edwin A Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,600 VETS CNTY 41102 300 0 Griewisch Angela 8-4-9 57,000 Medicaid 56,700 362.38 Attn: Griewisch Theodore FRNT 90.00 DPTH 100.00 County Tax 56,700 300.65 3919 Williams St EAST-0950454 NRTH-0901317 Community Colleges 56,700 63.18 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,720 Town Tax 55,933 28.91 Chargebacks 55,933 1.04 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,000 TO 101.28 SW001 Bennett road water 57,000 TO C 56.54 TOTAL TAX --- 913.98** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 913.98 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-23 ***************** Williams St BILL 653 96.02-2-23 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,200 14.06 Gunther Raymond R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,200 County Tax 2,200 11.67 Gunther Linda A 8-4-8 2,200 Community Colleges 2,200 2.45 3915 Williams St ACRES 1.80 Town Tax 2,200 1.14 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950436 NRTH-0900666 Chargebacks 2,200 0.04 DEED BOOK 2001 PG-00505 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,200 TO 3.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,077 SW001 Bennett road water 2,200 TO C 2.18 TOTAL TAX --- 35.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 35.45 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 174 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-24 ***************** Williams St BILL 654 96.02-2-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,000 268.43 Gunther Raymond R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 42,000 222.71 Gunther Linda A 8-4-10 42,000 Community Colleges 42,000 46.80 3915 Williams St ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 42,000 21.71 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950514 NRTH-0900715 Chargebacks 42,000 0.78 DEED BOOK 2001 PG-00505 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,000 TO 74.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,741 SW001 Bennett road water 42,000 TO C 41.66 TOTAL TAX --- 676.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 676.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-25 ***************** Williams St BILL 655 96.02-2-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,920 12.27 Logan Geo H Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,920 County Tax 1,920 10.18 Logan M 8-4-11.1 1,920 Community Colleges 1,920 2.14 20 Douglas St ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 1,920 0.99 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0950590 NRTH-0900563 Chargebacks 1,920 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,685 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,920 TO 3.41 SW001 Bennett road water 1,920 TO C 1.90 TOTAL TAX --- 30.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 30.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-26 ***************** Williams St BILL 656 96.02-2-26 311 Res vac land Medicaid 480 3.07 Gunther Raymond R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 480 County Tax 480 2.55 Gunther Linda 8-4-11.2 480 Community Colleges 480 0.53 3915 Williams St FRNT 65.00 DPTH 292.00 Town Tax 480 0.25 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950608 NRTH-0901226 Chargebacks 480 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 671 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 480 TO .85 SW001 Bennett road water 480 TO C .48 TOTAL TAX --- 7.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-27 ***************** Williams St BILL 657 96.02-2-27 311 Res vac land Medicaid 720 4.60 Gunther Raymond R Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 720 County Tax 720 3.82 Gunther Linda 8-4-12.2 720 Community Colleges 720 0.80 3915 Williams St FRNT 17.00 DPTH 292.00 Town Tax 720 0.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950649 NRTH-0901225 Chargebacks 720 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,007 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 720 TO 1.28 SW001 Bennett road water 720 TO C .71 TOTAL TAX --- 11.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 11.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 175 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-28 ***************** Williams St BILL 658 96.02-2-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,590 42.12 Logan Geo H Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,590 County Tax 6,590 34.94 Logan M 8-4-12.1 6,590 Community Colleges 6,590 7.34 20 Douglas St ACRES 1.90 Town Tax 6,590 3.41 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0950676 NRTH-0900713 Chargebacks 6,590 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,217 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,590 TO 11.71 SW001 Bennett road water 6,590 TO C 6.54 TOTAL TAX --- 106.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 106.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-29 ***************** Williams St BILL 659 96.02-2-29 311 Res vac land Medicaid 10,400 66.47 Logan Geo H Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,400 County Tax 10,400 55.15 Logan M 8-4-13 10,400 Community Colleges 10,400 11.59 20 Douglas St ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 10,400 5.38 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0950778 NRTH-0900711 Chargebacks 10,400 0.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,545 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 10,400 TO 18.48 SW001 Bennett road water 10,400 TO C 10.32 TOTAL TAX --- 167.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 167.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-30 ***************** 3889 Williams St BILL 660 96.02-2-30 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 5,210 5,210 Miller Michael P Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,300 Medicaid 68,860 440.10 3889 Williams St 8-4-14 74,070 County Tax 68,860 365.13 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 12.00 Community Colleges 68,860 76.73 EAST-0951031 NRTH-0900708 Town Tax 68,860 35.59 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 1755 PG-00212 Chargebacks 68,860 1.27 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,594 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 74,070 TO 131.62 SW001 Bennett road water 74,070 TO C 73.48 TOTAL TAX --- 1,123.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,123.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-31 ***************** Williams St BILL 661 96.02-2-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Smith Carl H Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 64,000 339.36 Smith Beverly A 8-4-15 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 3893 Williams St ACRES 0.55 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951017 NRTH-0901263 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 SW001 Bennett road water 64,000 TO C 63.49 TOTAL TAX --- 1,031.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,031.19 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 176 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-32 ***************** Williams St BILL 662 96.02-2-32 449 Other Storag Medicaid 19,900 127.19 Gilbert Charles L Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,400 County Tax 19,900 105.52 Gilbert Sarah R 8-4-16.5 19,900 Community Colleges 19,900 22.17 8960 Glasgow Rd FRNT 225.00 DPTH 123.00 Town Tax 19,900 10.29 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 0.60 Chargebacks 19,900 0.37 EAST-0951482 NRTH-0901305 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 19,900 TO 35.36 DEED BOOK 2111 SW001 Bennett road water 19,900 TO C 19.74 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,832 TOTAL TAX --- 320.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 320.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-33 ***************** Williams St BILL 663 96.02-2-33 449 Other Storag Medicaid 65,400 417.99 Miller Paul V Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 65,400 346.79 Miller Iris 8-4-16.1 65,400 Community Colleges 65,400 72.88 3875 Williams St ACRES 2.90 Town Tax 65,400 33.80 Dunkirk, NY + EAST-0951547 NRTH-0901200 Chargebacks 65,400 1.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,469 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 65,400 TO 116.21 SW001 Bennett road water 65,400 TO C 64.88 TOTAL TAX --- 1,053.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,053.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-34 ***************** 3847 Williams St BILL 664 96.02-2-34 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,000 268.43 Gill Paul R Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 42,000 222.71 Gill Paula 8-4-17 42,000 Community Colleges 42,000 46.80 3847 Williams St ACRES 0.45 Town Tax 42,000 21.71 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951883 NRTH-0901295 Chargebacks 42,000 0.78 DEED BOOK 2133 PG-00169 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,000 TO 74.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,741 SW001 Bennett road water 42,000 TO C 41.66 TOTAL TAX --- 676.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 676.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-35 ***************** 3847 Williams St BILL 665 96.02-2-35 311 Res vac land Medicaid 10,200 65.19 Gill Paul R Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,200 County Tax 10,200 54.09 Gill Paula 8-4-16.4 10,200 Community Colleges 10,200 11.37 3847 Williams St ACRES 2.80 Town Tax 10,200 5.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951939 NRTH-0901134 Chargebacks 10,200 0.19 DEED BOOK 2133 PG-00169 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 10,200 TO 18.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,266 SW001 Bennett road water 10,200 TO C 10.12 TOTAL TAX --- 164.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 164.35 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 177 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-36 ***************** 3875 Williams St BILL 666 96.02-2-36 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 70,150 448.34 Miller Paul V Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,800 County Tax 70,150 371.97 3875 Williams St 8-4-16.2.1 70,150 Community Colleges 70,150 78.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 27.90 Town Tax 70,150 36.26 EAST-0951809 NRTH-0900722 Chargebacks 70,150 1.30 DEED BOOK 1699 PG-00193 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 70,150 TO 124.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 98,112 SW001 Bennett road water 70,150 TO C 69.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,130.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,130.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-37 ***************** Williams St BILL 667 96.02-2-37 311 Res vac land AG COMMIT 41730 80 80 Miller Michael P Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 Medicaid 220 1.41 3889 Williams St 8-4-16.3 300 County Tax 220 1.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.65 Community Colleges 220 0.25 EAST-0951259 NRTH-0900218 Town Tax 220 0.11 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 420 Chargebacks 220 0.00 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300 TO .53 SW001 Bennett road water 300 TO C .30 TOTAL TAX --- 3.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-38 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 668 96.02-2-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 81,910 523.51 Pagan Juan Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,600 County Tax 81,910 434.33 Pagan Bedsaida 10-3-1 81,910 Community Colleges 81,910 91.27 10764 Bennett Rd ACRES 4.00 Town Tax 81,910 42.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950600 NRTH-0899928 Chargebacks 81,910 1.52 DEED BOOK 2020 PG-00111 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 81,910 TO 145.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,559 SW001 Bennett road water 81,910 TO C 81.25 TOTAL TAX --- 1,319.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,319.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-39 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 669 96.02-2-39 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 19,930 19,930 Militello David J Dunkirk Csd 060300 39,200 Medicaid 71,070 454.22 Gordon Mary 10-3-2 91,000 County Tax 71,070 376.85 10756 Bennett Rd ACRES 23.20 Community Colleges 71,070 79.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0951365 NRTH-0899708 Town Tax 71,070 36.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,273 Chargebacks 71,070 1.32 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP009 E dnk fire prot2 91,000 TO 161.70 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 SW001 Bennett road water 91,000 TO C 90.27 TOTAL TAX --- 1,200.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,200.28 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 178 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-40 ***************** 10742 Bennett Rd BILL 670 96.02-2-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 50,000 319.56 Grupa Mark D Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 50,000 265.13 10742 Bennett Rd 10-3-3 50,000 Community Colleges 50,000 55.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 50,000 25.84 EAST-0950681 NRTH-0899604 Chargebacks 50,000 0.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,930 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,000 TO 88.85 SW001 Bennett road water 50,000 TO C 49.60 TOTAL TAX --- 805.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 805.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-41 ***************** 10732 Bennett Rd BILL 671 96.02-2-41 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,000 268.43 Mourer Kenneth R Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 42,000 222.71 10732 Bennett Rd 10-3-4 42,000 Community Colleges 42,000 46.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 42,000 21.71 EAST-0950715 NRTH-0899458 Chargebacks 42,000 0.78 DEED BOOK 2394 PG-875 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,000 TO 74.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,741 SW001 Bennett road water 42,000 TO C 41.66 TOTAL TAX --- 676.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 676.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-42 ***************** 10724 Bennett Rd BILL 672 96.02-2-42 280 Res Multiple P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Spekczynski Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,300 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Spekczynski Bonnie V Part Of 10-3-5 Eligible 105,500 VET DIS C 41142 14,700 0 10724 Bennett Rd For 467 Exemption Medicaid 83,450 533.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 10-3-5..A County Tax 83,450 442.50 ACRES 3.90 Community Colleges 83,450 92.99 DEED BOOK 2080 PG-00231 Town Tax 87,724 45.34 FULL MARKET VALUE 147,552 Chargebacks 87,724 1.62 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 105,500 TO 187.46 SW001 Bennett road water 105,500 TO C 104.66 TOTAL TAX --- 1,407.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,407.92 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 179 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-43 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 673 96.02-2-43 449 Other Storag Medicaid 270,000 1,725.63 Vineyard Centre LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 112,000 County Tax 270,000 1,431.69 435 Main St 10-3-6 270,000 Community Colleges 270,000 300.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 12.37 Town Tax 270,000 139.56 EAST-0951633 NRTH-0899092 Chargebacks 270,000 5.00 DEED BOOK 2391 PG-303 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 270,000 TO 479.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 377,622 SW001 Bennett road water 270,000 TO C 267.84 TOTAL TAX --- 4,350.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,350.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-44 ***************** 10700 Bennett Rd Rd BILL 674 96.02-2-44 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 68,510 437.86 Wilberg John D Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,600 County Tax 68,510 363.28 10700 Bennett Rd 10-3-8 68,510 Community Colleges 68,510 76.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.72 Town Tax 68,510 35.41 EAST-0950828 NRTH-0898978 Chargebacks 68,510 1.27 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,510 TO 121.74 SW001 Bennett road water 68,510 TO C 67.96 TOTAL TAX --- 1,103.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,103.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-45 ***************** 10706 Bennett Rd BILL 675 96.02-2-45 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 84,540 540.31 Smith Peter T Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 84,540 448.28 Smith Mary M 10-3-7 84,540 Community Colleges 84,540 94.20 Attn: Smith Peter ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 84,540 43.70 3177 Whitaker Rd EAST-0950765 NRTH-0899128 Chargebacks 84,540 1.56 Fredonia, NY 14063 FULL MARKET VALUE 118,238 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 84,540 TO 150.22 SW001 Bennett road water 84,540 TO C 83.86 TOTAL TAX --- 1,362.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,362.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-46 ***************** 10707 Bennett Rd BILL 676 96.02-2-46 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,500 348.32 Sosinski Timothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,200 County Tax 54,500 288.99 10707 Bennett Rd 10-2-5 54,500 Community Colleges 54,500 60.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.80 Town Tax 54,500 28.17 EAST-0950316 NRTH-0899039 Chargebacks 54,500 1.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,224 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 54,500 TO 96.84 SW001 Bennett road water 54,500 TO C 54.06 TOTAL TAX --- 878.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 878.12 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 180 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-48 ***************** 10745 Bennett Rd BILL 677 96.02-2-48 473 Greenhouse Medicaid 3,300 21.09 Lydell Ransom B Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,100 County Tax 3,300 17.50 10749 Bennett Road 10-2-2.1 3,300 Community Colleges 3,300 3.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 46.00 DPTH 82.00 Town Tax 3,300 1.71 EAST-0950293 NRTH-0899510 Chargebacks 3,300 0.06 DEED BOOK 1645 PG-00261 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,300 TO 5.86 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,615 SW001 Bennett road water 3,300 TO C 3.27 TOTAL TAX --- 53.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 53.17 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-49 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 678 96.02-2-49 444 Lumber yd/ml Medicaid 196,100 1,253.32 84 Bennett Enterprise Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,300 County Tax 196,100 1,039.83 27 University Park 10-2-2.2 196,100 Community Colleges 196,100 218.51 Fredonia, NY 14063 FRNT 177.00 DPTH 150.00 Town Tax 196,100 101.36 EAST-0950214 NRTH-0899594 Chargebacks 196,100 3.63 DEED BOOK 2028 PG-00230 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 196,100 TO 348.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 274,266 SW001 Bennett road water 196,100 TO C 194.53 TOTAL TAX --- 3,159.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,159.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-50 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 679 96.02-2-50 444 Lumber yd/ml Medicaid 144,840 925.71 84 Bennett Enterprise Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 76,500 County Tax 144,840 768.02 5236 Pebble Beach Blvd 10-2-3.2 144,840 Community Colleges 144,840 161.40 Winter Haven, FL 33884 ACRES 4.40 Town Tax 144,840 74.86 EAST-0949719 NRTH-0899589 Chargebacks 144,840 2.68 DEED BOOK 2028 PG-00230 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 144,840 TO 257.37 FULL MARKET VALUE 202,573 SW001 Bennett road water 144,840 TO C 143.68 TOTAL TAX --- 2,333.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,333.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-51 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 680 96.02-2-51 473 Greenhouse Medicaid 28,400 181.51 Lydell Ranson B Dunkirk Csd 060300 24,800 County Tax 28,400 150.59 10749 Bennett Road 10-2-3.1 28,400 Community Colleges 28,400 31.65 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.00 Town Tax 28,400 14.68 EAST-0948892 NRTH-0899553 Chargebacks 28,400 0.53 DEED BOOK 1645 PG-00261 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 28,400 TO 50.46 FULL MARKET VALUE 39,720 SW001 Bennett road water 28,400 TO C 28.17 TOTAL TAX --- 457.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 457.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 181 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-52.1 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 681 96.02-2-52.1 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 73,100 467.20 Dashiell Patricia Dunkirk Csd 060300 73,100 County Tax 73,100 387.62 10021 Rt 60 10-2-1.1 73,100 Community Colleges 73,100 81.46 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 5.80 Town Tax 73,100 37.78 EAST-0948797 NRTH-0899866 Chargebacks 73,100 1.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,238 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,100 TO 129.89 SW001 Bennett road water 73,100 TO C 72.51 TOTAL TAX --- 1,177.81** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,177.81 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-52.3 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 682 96.02-2-52.3 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 71,400 456.33 Tabone Marie Dunkirk Csd 060300 71,400 County Tax 71,400 378.60 Tabone Paul 10-2-1.1 71,400 Community Colleges 71,400 79.56 Tabone Paul S ACRES 3.50 Town Tax 71,400 36.91 11 Georges Pl EAST-0949834 NRTH-0899801 Chargebacks 71,400 1.32 Fredonia, NY 14063 FULL MARKET VALUE 99,860 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 71,400 TO 126.87 SW001 Bennett road water 71,400 TO C 70.83 TOTAL TAX --- 1,150.42** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,150.42 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-1 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 683 96.03-3-1 120 Field crops AG DIST 41720 3,550 3,550 Agosto Salvador Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,900 Medicaid 8,350 53.37 429 Park Ave 5-2-13 11,900 County Tax 8,350 44.28 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 27.50 Community Colleges 8,350 9.30 EAST-0940857 NRTH-0898673 Town Tax 8,350 4.32 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2121 PG-00617 Chargebacks 8,350 0.15 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,643 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,900 TO 25.18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 11,900 TO 6.09 TOTAL TAX --- 142.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 142.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-3 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 684 96.03-3-3 120 Field crops AG DIST 41720 1,340 1,340 Agosto Salvador Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,000 Medicaid 89,880 574.44 429 Park Ave 5-2-6.1 91,220 County Tax 89,880 476.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.90 Community Colleges 89,880 100.15 EAST-0942042 NRTH-0898771 Town Tax 89,880 46.46 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2121 PG-00617 Chargebacks 89,880 1.66 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,580 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 91,220 TO 193.00 WD058 Comprehensive Water 91,220 TO 46.65 TOTAL TAX --- 1,438.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,438.95 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 182 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-6 ****************** Lafayette Ave BILL 685 96.03-3-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,700 17.26 Prechtl Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,700 County Tax 2,700 14.32 Prechtl Linda Back Land 2,700 Community Colleges 2,700 3.01 43 Lafayette St 5-3-11.4 Town Tax 2,700 1.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 171.00 DPTH 200.00 Chargebacks 2,700 0.05 EAST-0944321 NRTH-0898902 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,700 TO 5.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,776 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,700 TO 1.38 TOTAL TAX --- 43.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 43.13 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-8 ****************** 10618 Brigham Rd BILL 686 96.03-3-8 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Majka Joseph W Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 Medicaid 55,220 352.92 Majka Diana F 5-3-12 62,570 County Tax 55,220 292.81 10618 Brigham Rd ACRES 0.69 Community Colleges 55,220 61.53 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0942613 NRTH-0898036 Town Tax 62,570 32.34 DEED BOOK 2095 PG-00104 Chargebacks 62,570 1.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 87,510 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 62,570 TO 132.38 WD058 Comprehensive Water 62,570 TO 32.00 TOTAL TAX --- 905.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 905.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-9 ****************** Brigham Rd BILL 687 96.03-3-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 70,000 447.39 Johnson Dennis M Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 70,000 371.18 Johnson Anita G 5-3-13 70,000 Community Colleges 70,000 78.00 10614 Brigham Rd ACRES 0.64 Town Tax 70,000 36.18 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0942622 NRTH-0897938 Chargebacks 70,000 1.30 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,902 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 70,000 TO 148.10 WD058 Comprehensive Water 70,000 TO 35.80 TOTAL TAX --- 1,117.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,117.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-10 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 688 96.03-3-10 120 Field crops Medicaid 56,680 362.25 Haase Thomas Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,280 County Tax 56,680 300.55 10598 Brigham Rd 5-3-14.1 56,680 Community Colleges 56,680 63.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 20.10 Town Tax 56,680 29.30 EAST-0943077 NRTH-0897709 Chargebacks 56,680 1.05 DEED BOOK 2682 PG-130 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 56,680 TO 119.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,273 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,680 TO 28.99 TOTAL TAX --- 905.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 905.22 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 183 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-11 ***************** Waldorff Rd BILL 689 96.03-3-11 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,820 11.63 Pietro Anthony J Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,820 County Tax 1,820 9.65 10695 Bennett Rd 5-3-14.3 1,820 Community Colleges 1,820 2.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.30 Town Tax 1,820 0.94 EAST-0943084 NRTH-0897286 Chargebacks 1,820 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,545 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,820 TO 3.85 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,820 TO .93 TOTAL TAX --- 29.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-12 ***************** Waldorff Rd BILL 690 96.03-3-12 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,700 23.65 Pietro Anthony J Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,700 County Tax 3,700 19.62 10695 Bennett Rd Value In 5-3-14.1 3,700 Community Colleges 3,700 4.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 5-3-16.2 Town Tax 3,700 1.91 ACRES 3.10 Chargebacks 3,700 0.07 EAST-0943107 NRTH-0897178 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,700 TO 7.83 DEED BOOK 1946 PG-00170 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,700 TO 1.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,175 TOTAL TAX --- 59.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 59.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-16 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 691 96.03-3-16 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Taylor Norman Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 Taylor Bonnie 5-5-1 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 490 SW Wildwood Dr ACRES 2.75 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 Mayo, FL 32066 EAST-0943729 NRTH-0897002 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,400 TO 2.96 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,400 TO .72 TOTAL TAX --- 22.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 22.36 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-20 ***************** 10523 Brigham Rd BILL 692 96.03-3-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 71,940 459.79 Moore Barry Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 71,940 381.47 Moore Pauline 5-6-6.1 71,940 Community Colleges 71,940 80.16 10523 Brigham Rd FRNT 230.00 DPTH 410.00 Town Tax 71,940 37.18 Dunkirk, NY 14048-2111 EAST-0942110 NRTH-0896426 Chargebacks 71,940 1.33 DEED BOOK 1937 PG-00452 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 71,940 TO 152.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,615 WD058 Comprehensive Water 71,940 TO 36.79 TOTAL TAX --- 1,148.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,148.93 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 184 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-24 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 693 96.03-3-24 210 1 Family Res AGED C/S 41805 32,700 0 Jankowski Larry Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,900 Medicaid 32,700 208.99 Jankowski Allan 5-6-3 65,400 County Tax 32,700 173.39 10505 Brigham Rd ACRES 3.40 Community Colleges 32,700 36.44 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0941556 NRTH-0896210 Town Tax 65,400 33.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 91,469 Chargebacks 65,400 1.21 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 65,400 TO 138.37 WD058 Comprehensive Water 65,400 TO 33.44 TOTAL TAX --- 625.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 625.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-25 ***************** 10523 Brigham Rd BILL 694 96.03-3-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Moore Barry Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 Moore Pauline 5-6-2 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 10523 Brigham Rd ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 Dunkirk, NY 14048-2111 EAST-0941492 NRTH-0896479 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 DEED BOOK 1937 PG-00452 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,700 TO 3.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 27.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 27.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-26 ***************** 10504 Temple Rd BILL 695 96.03-3-26 152 Vineyard Medicaid 64,000 409.04 Sobczak Daniel W et al Dunkirk Csd 060300 24,500 County Tax 64,000 339.36 Sobczak Gary R 5-6-1 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 10504 Temple Rd ACRES 11.04 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940788 NRTH-0896368 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 DEED BOOK 2091 PG-00153 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 64,000 TO 135.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 WD058 Comprehensive Water 64,000 TO 32.73 TOTAL TAX --- 1,022.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,022.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-27 ***************** Temple Rd BILL 696 96.03-3-27 311 Res vac land AG COMMIT 41730 250 250 Fred Roberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 Medicaid 1,750 11.18 Fred Milagros 5-2-12 2,000 County Tax 1,750 9.28 10655 Temple Rd ACRES 4.80 Community Colleges 1,750 1.95 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0940370 NRTH-0897517 Town Tax 1,750 0.90 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,797 Chargebacks 1,750 0.03 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,000 TO 4.23 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,000 TO 1.02 TOTAL TAX --- 28.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 28.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 185 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-28 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 697 96.03-3-28 321 Abandoned ag Medicaid 11,700 74.78 Eimers Roger N Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,700 County Tax 11,700 62.04 9403 Chautauqua Rd 5-2-11 11,700 Community Colleges 11,700 13.04 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 28.00 Town Tax 11,700 6.05 EAST-0941000 NRTH-0897510 Chargebacks 11,700 0.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,364 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,700 TO 24.75 WD058 Comprehensive Water 11,700 TO 5.98 TOTAL TAX --- 186.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 186.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-29 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 698 96.03-3-29 473 Greenhouse Medicaid 44,500 284.41 Eimers Roger N Dunkirk Csd 060300 33,400 County Tax 44,500 235.96 9403 Chautauqua Rd 5-2-10 44,500 Community Colleges 44,500 49.59 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 13.60 Town Tax 44,500 23.00 EAST-0942061 NRTH-0897556 Chargebacks 44,500 0.82 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,238 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 44,500 TO 94.15 WD058 Comprehensive Water 44,500 TO 22.76 TOTAL TAX --- 710.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 710.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-30 ***************** 10611 Brigham Rd BILL 699 96.03-3-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 94,000 600.78 Pacos Karen A Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 94,000 498.44 10611 Brigham Rd 5-2-9 94,000 Community Colleges 94,000 104.74 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.47 Town Tax 94,000 48.59 EAST-0942287 NRTH-0897948 Chargebacks 94,000 1.74 DEED BOOK 1965 PG-00279 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 94,000 TO 198.88 FULL MARKET VALUE 131,469 WD058 Comprehensive Water 94,000 TO 48.07 TOTAL TAX --- 1,501.24** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,501.24 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-31 ***************** Brigham Rd BILL 700 96.03-3-31 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 17,300 110.57 Pacos Matthew Nicholas Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 County Tax 17,300 91.73 Pacos Kenneth 5-2-8 17,300 Community Colleges 17,300 19.28 138 W 5th St ACRES 0.49 Town Tax 17,300 8.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0942293 NRTH-0898048 Chargebacks 17,300 0.32 DEED BOOK 1918 PG-00081 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,300 TO 36.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,196 WD058 Comprehensive Water 17,300 TO 8.85 TOTAL TAX --- 276.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 276.29 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 186 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-1 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 701 96.04-1-1 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 68,150 435.56 Pietro Anthony J Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,800 County Tax 68,150 361.37 10695 Bennett Rd 10-2-6 68,150 Community Colleges 68,150 75.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 18.00 Town Tax 68,150 35.23 EAST-0949276 NRTH-0898933 Chargebacks 68,150 1.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,315 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,150 TO 121.10 SW001 Bennett road water 68,150 TO C 67.60 TOTAL TAX --- 1,098.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,098.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-2 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 702 96.04-1-2 449 Other Storag Medicaid 259,400 1,657.89 Rotunda Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 69,500 County Tax 259,400 1,375.48 307 E Main St 10-3-9.1 259,400 Community Colleges 259,400 289.05 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 6.40 Town Tax 259,400 134.08 EAST-0951580 NRTH-0898820 Chargebacks 259,400 4.80 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-00519 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 259,400 TO 460.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 362,797 SW001 Bennett road water 259,400 TO C 257.32 TOTAL TAX --- 4,179.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,179.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-3 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 703 96.04-1-3 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 12,700 81.17 Rotunda Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,700 County Tax 12,700 67.34 307 E Main St 10-3-9.2 12,700 Community Colleges 12,700 14.15 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 2.93 Town Tax 12,700 6.56 EAST-0951619 NRTH-0898685 Chargebacks 12,700 0.24 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-00519 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12,700 TO 22.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,762 SW001 Bennett road water 12,700 TO C 12.60 TOTAL TAX --- 204.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 204.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-4 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 704 96.04-1-4 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 Rotunda Properties LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 307 E Main St 10-3-9.3.1 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 3.40 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 EAST-0951755 NRTH-0898586 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-00519 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,400 TO 2.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 SW001 Bennett road water 1,400 TO C 1.39 TOTAL TAX --- 22.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 22.56 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 187 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-5 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 705 96.04-1-5 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 35,500 226.89 Krebs Cindy A Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,500 County Tax 35,500 188.24 10668 Bennett Rd 10-3-9.3.2 35,500 Community Colleges 35,500 39.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.66 Town Tax 35,500 18.35 EAST-0951055 NRTH-0898592 Chargebacks 35,500 0.66 DEED BOOK 1917 PG-00559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 35,500 TO 63.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 49,650 SW001 Bennett road water 35,500 TO C 35.22 TOTAL TAX --- 572.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 572.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-6 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 706 96.04-1-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 600 3.83 Selan James Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 10654 Bennett Rd 10-3-10.1 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Town Tax 600 0.31 EAST-0951667 NRTH-0898495 Chargebacks 600 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 SW001 Bennett road water 600 TO C .60 TOTAL TAX --- 9.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.67 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-7 ****************** 10654 Bennett Rd BILL 707 96.04-1-7 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Selan James Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,200 Medicaid 64,150 410.00 10654 Bennett Rd 10-3-10.2 71,500 County Tax 64,150 340.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.70 Community Colleges 64,150 71.48 EAST-0951678 NRTH-0898417 Town Tax 71,500 36.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 100,000 Chargebacks 71,500 1.32 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 71,500 TO 127.05 SW001 Bennett road water 71,500 TO C 70.93 TOTAL TAX --- 1,057.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,057.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-8 ****************** Bennett Rd BILL 708 96.04-1-8 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 The Henry A Strnz Trust Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 7335 Milestrip Rd 10-3-11 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Orchard Park, NY 14127 ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0951691 NRTH-0898316 Chargebacks 900 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 900 TO 1.60 SW001 Bennett road water 900 TO C .89 TOTAL TAX --- 14.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.50 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 188 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-9.1 **************** Bennett Rd BILL 709 96.04-1-9.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,800 11.50 Maloney Lynn Kay Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 1,800 9.54 Jakubowicz Shelley 10-3-12 1,800 Community Colleges 1,800 2.01 7335 Milestrip Rd ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 1,800 0.93 Orchard Park, NY 14127 EAST-0951706 NRTH-0898220 Chargebacks 1,800 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,800 TO 3.20 SW001 Bennett road water 1,800 TO C 1.79 TOTAL TAX --- 29.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 29.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-9.2 **************** Bennett Rd BILL 710 96.04-1-9.2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 68,080 435.12 Stern Donna J Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,480 County Tax 68,080 361.00 10642 Bennett Rd 10-3-12 68,080 Community Colleges 68,080 75.86 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 68,080 35.19 EAST-0951706 NRTH-0898220 Chargebacks 68,080 1.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,217 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,080 TO 120.97 SW001 Bennett road water 68,080 TO C 67.53 TOTAL TAX --- 1,096.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,096.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-10 ***************** 10636 Bennett Rd BILL 711 96.04-1-10 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,933 Drozdziel Shirley D Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,300 VETS CNTY 41102 825 0 10636 Bennett Rd 10-3-13 69,500 Medicaid 68,675 438.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.90 County Tax 68,675 364.15 EAST-0951723 NRTH-0898119 Community Colleges 68,675 76.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,203 Town Tax 66,567 34.41 Chargebacks 66,567 1.23 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,500 TO 123.50 SW001 Bennett road water 69,500 TO C 68.94 TOTAL TAX --- 1,107.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,107.67 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-11 ***************** 10628 Bennett Rd BILL 712 96.04-1-11 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 68,000 434.60 Halicki Pamela J Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,200 County Tax 68,000 360.57 10628 Bennett Rd Ext E 10-3-14 68,000 Community Colleges 68,000 75.77 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.00 Town Tax 68,000 35.15 EAST-0951740 NRTH-0898023 Chargebacks 68,000 1.26 DEED BOOK 1987 PG-00560 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 68,000 TO 120.83 FULL MARKET VALUE 95,105 SW001 Bennett road water 68,000 TO C 67.46 TOTAL TAX --- 1,095.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,095.64 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 189 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-12 ***************** 10620 Bennett Rd BILL 713 96.04-1-12 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 44,500 284.41 Gill Virginia Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,700 County Tax 44,500 235.96 10620 Bennett Rd 10-3-16 44,500 Community Colleges 44,500 49.59 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 44,500 23.00 EAST-0951565 NRTH-0897895 Chargebacks 44,500 0.82 DEED BOOK 2063 PG-00480 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 44,500 TO 79.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 62,238 SW001 Bennett road water 44,500 TO C 44.14 TOTAL TAX --- 716.99** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 716.99 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-13 ***************** Bennett Road Ext BILL 714 96.04-1-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Gill Richard Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 Gill Virginia 10-3-15 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 10620 Bennett Rd ACRES 0.56 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952010 NRTH-0897942 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 DEED BOOK 2066 PG-00077 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,500 TO 2.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 SW001 Bennett road water 1,500 TO C 1.49 TOTAL TAX --- 24.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 24.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-14 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 715 96.04-1-14 452 Nbh shop ctr Medicaid 1750,000 11,184.65 Regional Shopping Ctr Dunkirk Csd 060300 876,400 County Tax 1750,000 9,279.45 Attn: National Realty & 10-7-1.1 1750,000 Community Colleges 1750,000 1,950.03 Development Corp ACRES 7.20 Town Tax 1750,000 904.54 3 Manhattanville Rd EAST-0952035 NRTH-0896374 Chargebacks 1750,000 32.39 Purchase, NY 10577 FULL MARKET VALUE 2447,552 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1750,000 TO 3,109.60 TOTAL TAX --- 26,460.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26,460.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-15 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 716 96.04-1-15 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 64,320 411.08 Regional Shopping Ctr Dunkirk Csd 060300 64,320 County Tax 64,320 341.06 Attn: National Realty & 10-7-1.2 64,320 Community Colleges 64,320 71.67 Development Corp ACRES 0.50 Town Tax 64,320 33.25 3 Manhattanville Rd EAST-0951938 NRTH-0896088 Chargebacks 64,320 1.19 Purchase, NY 10577 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,958 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,320 TO 114.29 TOTAL TAX --- 972.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 972.54 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 190 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-16 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 717 96.04-1-16 421 Restaurant Medicaid 530,050 3,387.67 ARC Cafeusa001,LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 150,000 County Tax 530,050 2,810.61 C/O Amenican Realty Capital Same As 10-4-1.2.2.1 530,050 Community Colleges 530,050 590.64 200 Dryden Rd Ste 1100 10-4-1.2.201 Town Tax 530,050 273.97 Dresher, PA 19025 ACRES 1.00 Chargebacks 530,050 9.81 EAST-0951555 NRTH-0896164 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 530,050 TO 941.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 741,329 LD011 Vineyard lt1 530,050 TO 57.11 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 530,050 TO C 38.05 TOTAL TAX --- 8,109.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8,109.71 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-17 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 718 96.04-1-17 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 6,300 40.26 ARC Cafeusa001,LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,300 County Tax 6,300 33.41 C/O American Realty Capital Triangular Shape 6,300 Community Colleges 6,300 7.02 200 Dryden Rd Ste 1100 10-6-1.5.1 Town Tax 6,300 3.26 Dresher, PA 19025 FRNT 45.00 DPTH 100.00 Chargebacks 6,300 0.12 EAST-0951488 NRTH-0896075 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,300 TO 11.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,811 LD011 Vineyard lt1 6,300 TO .68 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 6,300 TO C .45 TOTAL TAX --- 96.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 96.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-18 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 719 96.04-1-18 421 Restaurant Medicaid 991,100 6,334.35 Bob Evans Farms LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 314,600 County Tax 991,100 5,255.35 8111 Smith's Mill Rd Same As 10-4-1.2.2.2 991,100 Community Colleges 991,100 1,104.39 New Albany, OH 43054 10-4-1.2.202 Town Tax 991,100 512.28 ACRES 1.30 Chargebacks 991,100 18.35 EAST-0951434 NRTH-0896467 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 991,100 TO 1,761.10 DEED BOOK 2294 PG-341 LD011 Vineyard lt1 991,100 TO 106.78 FULL MARKET VALUE 1386,154 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 991,100 TO C 71.15 TOTAL TAX --- 15,163.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15,163.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 191 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-19 ***************** Route 60 BILL 720 96.04-1-19 453 Large retail Medicaid 5396,800 34,492.20 Home Depot U S A Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 1054,000 County Tax 5396,800 28,616.77 Property Tax Dept #6169 Dunkirk Store 5396,800 Community Colleges 5396,800 6,013.67 PO Box 105842 Same As 10-4-1.2.2.3 Town Tax 5396,800 2,789.50 Atlanta, GA 30348-5842 10-4-1.2.203 Chargebacks 5396,800 99.89 ACRES 5.30 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5396,800 TO 9,589.66 EAST-0951488 NRTH-0896075 LD011 Vineyard lt1 5396,800 TO 581.46 DEED BOOK 2298 PG-310 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 5396,800 TO C 387.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 7547,972 TOTAL TAX --- 82,570.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 82,570.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-20 ***************** Rear Route 60 BILL 721 96.04-1-20 453 Large retail Medicaid 252,000 1,610.59 Home Depot U S A Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 252,000 County Tax 252,000 1,336.24 Property Tax Dept #6169 Dunkirk Store 252,000 Community Colleges 252,000 280.80 PO Box 105842 10-6-1.5.2 Town Tax 252,000 130.25 Atlanta, GA 30348-5842 ACRES 4.20 Chargebacks 252,000 4.66 EAST-0950908 NRTH-0896309 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 252,000 TO 447.78 DEED BOOK 2298 PG-310 LD011 Vineyard lt1 252,000 TO 27.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 352,448 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 252,000 TO C 18.09 TOTAL TAX --- 3,855.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,855.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-21 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 722 96.04-1-21 462 Branch bank Medicaid 700,000 4,473.86 Community Bank NA Dunkirk Csd 060300 280,000 County Tax 700,000 3,711.78 Attn: Accounts Payable 10-6-1.6 700,000 Community Colleges 700,000 780.01 5970 Widewaters Pkwy ACRES 1.40 Town Tax 700,000 361.82 Dewitt, NY 13214 EAST-0950784 NRTH-0896449 Chargebacks 700,000 12.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 979,021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 700,000 TO 1,243.84 LD011 Vineyard lt1 700,000 TO 75.42 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 700,000 TO C 50.25 TOTAL TAX --- 10,709.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 10,709.94 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 192 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-22.1 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 723 96.04-1-22.1 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 150,510 961.94 Hamburg Kasturi Ltd Dunkirk Csd 060300 150,510 County Tax 150,510 798.09 3925 Vineyard Dr 10-6-1.7.1 150,510 Community Colleges 150,510 167.71 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 150,510 77.80 EAST-0950659 NRTH-0896072 Chargebacks 150,510 2.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 210,503 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 150,510 TO 267.44 LD011 Vineyard lt1 150,510 TO 16.22 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 150,510 TO C 10.81 TOTAL TAX --- 2,302.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,302.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-22.2 *************** 3925 Vineyard Dr BILL 724 96.04-1-22.2 415 Motel Medicaid 1720,000 10,992.92 Hamburg Kasturi Ltd Dunkirk Csd 060300 320,000 County Tax 1720,000 9,120.38 3925 Vineyard Dr 10-6-1.7.2 1720,000 Community Colleges 1720,000 1,916.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 1720,000 889.03 EAST-0950616 NRTH-0896305 Chargebacks 1720,000 31.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 2405,594 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1720,000 TO 3,056.30 LD011 Vineyard lt1 1720,000 TO 185.32 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 1720,000 TO C 123.48 TOTAL TAX --- 26,315.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26,315.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-23 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 725 96.04-1-23 421 Restaurant Medicaid 234,000 1,495.55 The Austin Building Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 91,500 County Tax 234,000 1,240.80 3935 Vineyard Dr 10-6-1.10.2 234,000 Community Colleges 234,000 260.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.60 Town Tax 234,000 120.95 EAST-0950456 NRTH-0896490 Chargebacks 234,000 4.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 327,273 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 234,000 TO 415.80 LD011 Vineyard lt1 234,000 TO 25.21 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 234,000 TO C 16.80 TOTAL TAX --- 3,580.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,580.19 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 193 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-24 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 726 96.04-1-24 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 49,300 315.09 Silver Creek Kasturi Ltd Dunkirk Csd 060300 49,300 County Tax 49,300 261.42 3912 Vineyard Dr 10-6-1.10.1 49,300 Community Colleges 49,300 54.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.10 Town Tax 49,300 25.48 EAST-0950480 NRTH-0896300 Chargebacks 49,300 0.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,951 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,300 TO 87.60 LD011 Vineyard lt1 49,300 TO 5.31 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 49,300 TO C 3.54 TOTAL TAX --- 754.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 754.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-25 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 727 96.04-1-25 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 64,000 409.04 MPDKNY LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 64,000 County Tax 64,000 339.36 David H Baldauf 10-6-1.4 64,000 Community Colleges 64,000 71.32 7978 Cooper Creek Blvd Ste 100 ACRES 1.36 Town Tax 64,000 33.08 University Park, FL 34201 EAST-0950359 NRTH-0896167 Chargebacks 64,000 1.18 DEED BOOK 2052 PG-00399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,000 TO 113.72 FULL MARKET VALUE 89,510 LD011 Vineyard lt1 64,000 TO 6.90 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 64,000 TO C 4.59 TOTAL TAX --- 979.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 979.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-26 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 728 96.04-1-26 453 Large retail BUSINV 897 47610 1127,803 1127,803 MPDKNY LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 900,000 Medicaid 4026,903 25,736.87 David H Baldauf 10-6-1.3 5154,706 County Tax 4026,903 21,352.83 7978 Cooper Creek Blvd Ste 100 ACRES 9.00 Community Colleges 4026,903 4,487.19 University Park, FL 34201 EAST-0950020 NRTH-0896297 Town Tax 4026,903 2,081.43 DEED BOOK 2052 PG-00399 Chargebacks 4026,903 74.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 7209,379 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5154,706 TO 9,159.48 LD011 Vineyard lt1 4026,903 TO 433.87 1127,803 EX WD007 Vineyard wtr3 4026,903 TO C 289.10 1127,803 EX TOTAL TAX --- 63,615.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 63,615.31 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 194 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-27 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 729 96.04-1-27 431 Auto dealer Medicaid 591,720 3,781.82 Shults Real Estate LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 300,000 County Tax 591,720 3,137.62 3979 Vineyard Dr 10-6-1.8 591,720 Community Colleges 591,720 659.36 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0949548 NRTH-0896265 Town Tax 591,720 305.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 827,580 Chargebacks 591,720 10.95 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 591,720 TO 1,051.44 LD011 Vineyard lt1 591,720 TO 63.75 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 591,720 TO C 42.48 TOTAL TAX --- 9,053.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9,053.27 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-28.1 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 730 96.04-1-28.1 433 Auto body Medicaid 124,590 796.28 Buffalo Lube Reality Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 100,000 County Tax 124,590 660.64 90 Earhart Dr Ste 4 10-6-1.12.1 124,590 Community Colleges 124,590 138.83 Amherst, NY 14221 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 180.00 Town Tax 124,590 64.40 EAST-0949370 NRTH-0896415 Chargebacks 124,590 2.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 174,252 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 124,590 TO 221.39 LD011 Vineyard lt1 124,590 TO 13.42 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 124,590 TO C 8.94 TOTAL TAX --- 1,906.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,906.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-28.2 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 731 96.04-1-28.2 461 Bank Medicaid 330,940 2,115.11 Woodlawn Auto Workers FCU Dunkirk Csd 060300 134,000 County Tax 330,940 1,754.82 3811 Lakeshore Rd 10-6-1.12.2 330,940 Community Colleges 330,940 368.77 Blazdell, NY 14219 FRNT 134.00 DPTH 180.00 Town Tax 330,940 171.06 EAST-0949338 NRTH-0896173 Chargebacks 330,940 6.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 462,853 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 330,940 TO 588.05 LD011 Vineyard lt1 330,940 TO 35.66 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 330,940 TO C 23.76 TOTAL TAX --- 5,063.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,063.36 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 195 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-30.1 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 732 96.04-1-30.1 450 Retail srvce BUSINV 897 47610 198,420 198,420 ARC AADUNNY001 LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 222,220 Medicaid 420,640 2,688.41 Portfolio Management# 3494 10-6-1.1 619,060 County Tax 420,640 2,230.46 PO Box 460069 ACRES 2.40 Community Colleges 420,640 468.72 Escondido, CA 92046 EAST-0948823 NRTH-0896234 Town Tax 420,640 217.42 DEED BOOK 1953 PG-00226 Chargebacks 420,640 7.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 865,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 619,060 TO 1,100.02 LD011 Vineyard lt1 420,640 TO 45.32 198,420 EX WD007 Vineyard wtr3 420,640 TO C 30.20 198,420 EX TOTAL TAX --- 6,788.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,788.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-30.2 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 733 96.04-1-30.2 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 31,480 201.20 Spacciapolli Larry Dunkirk Csd 060300 31,480 County Tax 31,480 166.92 Spacciapolli D 10-6-1.13 31,480 Community Colleges 31,480 35.08 4568 Lake Rd W FRNT 35.00 DPTH 421.40 Town Tax 31,480 16.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0948696 NRTH-0896229 Chargebacks 31,480 0.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 44,028 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 31,480 TO 55.94 LD011 Vineyard lt1 31,480 TO 3.39 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 31,480 TO C 2.26 TOTAL TAX --- 481.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 481.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-31 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 734 96.04-1-31 431 Auto dealer BUSINV 897 47610 52,364 52,364 Spacciapolli Lawrence Dunkirk Csd 060300 230,000 BUSINV 897 47610 71,911 71,911 Spacciapolli Daryl 10-6-1.11 697,280 Medicaid 573,005 3,662.21 4568 Lake Rd W ACRES 2.30 County Tax 573,005 3,038.38 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0948558 NRTH-0896228 Community Colleges 573,005 638.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 975,217 Town Tax 573,005 296.17 Chargebacks 573,005 10.61 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 697,280 TO 1,239.01 LD011 Vineyard lt1 573,005 TO 61.74 124,275 EX WD007 Vineyard wtr3 573,005 TO C 41.14 124,275 EX TOTAL TAX --- 8,987.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8,987.76 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 196 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-32 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 735 96.04-1-32 436 Self carwash Medicaid 274,820 1,756.44 E Z Clean Car Wash Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 120,700 County Tax 274,820 1,457.25 17 W Harrison St 10-5-1.4.2 274,820 Community Colleges 274,820 306.23 Jamestown, NY 14701 FRNT 171.70 DPTH 205.00 Town Tax 274,820 142.05 EAST-0948544 NRTH-0896667 Chargebacks 274,820 5.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 384,364 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 274,820 TO 488.33 LD011 Vineyard lt1 274,820 TO 29.61 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 274,820 TO C 19.73 TOTAL TAX --- 4,204.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,204.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-33 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 736 96.04-1-33 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 91,000 581.60 Pucci Kids Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 91,000 County Tax 91,000 482.53 4007 Vineyard Dr 10-5-1.4.1 91,000 Community Colleges 91,000 101.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 72.20 DPTH 166.70 Town Tax 91,000 47.04 EAST-0948477 NRTH-0896821 Chargebacks 91,000 1.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 127,273 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 91,000 TO 161.70 LD011 Vineyard lt1 91,000 TO 9.80 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 91,000 TO C 6.53 TOTAL TAX --- 1,392.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,392.28 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-34 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 737 96.04-1-34 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 53,700 343.21 Pucci Kids Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 53,700 County Tax 53,700 284.75 4007 Vineyard Dr 10-5-1.1 53,700 Community Colleges 53,700 59.84 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.58 Town Tax 53,700 27.76 EAST-0948607 NRTH-0896872 Chargebacks 53,700 0.99 DEED BOOK 1953 PG-00226 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,700 TO 95.42 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,105 LD011 Vineyard lt1 53,700 TO 5.79 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 53,700 TO C 3.86 TOTAL TAX --- 821.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 821.62 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 197 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-35 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 738 96.04-1-35 433 Auto body Medicaid 177,210 1,132.59 Pucci Kids Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 75,910 County Tax 177,210 939.66 4007 Vineyard Dr 10-5-1.5 177,210 Community Colleges 177,210 197.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.82 Town Tax 177,210 91.60 EAST-0948700 NRTH-0896693 Chargebacks 177,210 3.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 247,846 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 177,210 TO 314.89 LD011 Vineyard lt1 177,210 TO 19.09 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 177,210 TO C 12.72 TOTAL TAX --- 2,711.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,711.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-37 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 739 96.04-1-37 484 1 use sm bld Medicaid 460,000 2,939.97 Roosa Joseph B Dunkirk Csd 060300 154,000 County Tax 460,000 2,439.17 PO Box 67 North Of Vineyard Drive 460,000 Community Colleges 460,000 512.58 Salamanca, NY 14779 10-5-1.3.2.2 Town Tax 460,000 237.76 ACRES 0.70 Chargebacks 460,000 8.51 EAST-0949137 NRTH-0896705 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 460,000 TO 817.38 FULL MARKET VALUE 643,357 LD011 Vineyard lt1 460,000 TO 49.56 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 460,000 TO C 33.02 TOTAL TAX --- 7,037.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7,037.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-40 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 740 96.04-1-40 485 >1use sm bld Medicaid 4150,000 26,523.61 Dunkirk Limited Dunkirk Csd 060300 1552,000 County Tax 4150,000 22,005.56 Attn: Chase Properties LLC 10-5-1.3.1 4150,000 Community Colleges 4150,000 4,624.36 3333 Richmond Rd Ste 320 10-5-1.3.2.1 Town Tax 4150,000 2,145.05 Beachwood, OH 44122 10-5-2.5.2 Chargebacks 4150,000 76.82 ACRES 11.70 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4150,000 TO 7,374.20 EAST-0949725 NRTH-0896973 LD011 Vineyard lt1 4150,000 TO 447.13 DEED BOOK 2101 PG-00349 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 4150,000 TO C 297.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 5804,196 TOTAL TAX --- 63,494.67** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 63,494.67 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 198 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-41 ***************** 3956 Vineyard Dr BILL 741 96.04-1-41 454 Supermarket Medicaid 882,000 5,637.07 Buffalo Anderson AssociatesLLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 882,000 County Tax 882,000 4,676.84 Benderson Development Includes 10-5-2.3 882,000 Community Colleges 882,000 982.82 570 Delaware Ave 10-5-2.5.1 Town Tax 882,000 455.89 Buffalo, NY 14202 ACRES 5.40 Chargebacks 882,000 16.33 EAST-0949988 NRTH-0897004 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 882,000 TO 1,567.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 1233,566 LD011 Vineyard lt1 882,000 TO 95.03 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 882,000 TO C 63.32 TOTAL TAX --- 13,494.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13,494.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-43.1 *************** 3929 Vineyard Dr BILL 742 96.04-1-43.1 421 Restaurant Medicaid 456,690 2,918.81 Gold Seal Equity Partnership Dunkirk Csd 060300 328,590 County Tax 456,690 2,421.62 2 Wendling Ct 10-5-3.1 456,690 Community Colleges 456,690 508.89 Lancaster, NY 14086 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 456,690 236.05 EAST-0950486 NRTH-0896938 Chargebacks 456,690 8.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 638,727 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 456,690 TO 811.50 LD011 Vineyard lt1 456,690 TO 49.20 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 456,690 TO C 32.79 TOTAL TAX --- 6,987.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,987.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-43.2 *************** 3929 Vineyard Dr BILL 743 96.04-1-43.2 421 Restaurant Medicaid 370,320 2,366.80 Dunkirk Vineyard Realty LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 160,000 County Tax 370,320 1,963.64 Dunkin Donuts 10-5-3.1 370,320 Community Colleges 370,320 412.65 PO Box 4059 ACRES 0.80 Town Tax 370,320 191.41 Winter Park, FL 32793 EAST-0950630 NRTH-0896945 Chargebacks 370,320 6.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 517,930 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 370,320 TO 658.03 LD011 Vineyard lt1 370,320 TO 39.90 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 370,320 TO C 26.59 TOTAL TAX --- 5,665.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,665.87 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 199 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-43.3 *************** 3929 Vineyard Dr BILL 744 96.04-1-43.3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 160,000 1,022.60 GLR Holdings LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 160,000 County Tax 160,000 848.41 20 N Union St 10-5-3.1 160,000 Community Colleges 160,000 178.29 Rochester, NY 14607 ACRES 0.80 Town Tax 160,000 82.70 EAST-0950791 NRTH-0896867 Chargebacks 160,000 2.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 223,776 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 160,000 TO 284.31 LD011 Vineyard lt1 160,000 TO 17.24 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 160,000 TO C 11.49 TOTAL TAX --- 2,448.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,448.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-44.1 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 745 96.04-1-44.1 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 6,980 44.61 Gold Seal Equity Partners Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,980 County Tax 6,980 37.01 2 Wendling Ct 10-5-4.2.1 6,980 Community Colleges 6,980 7.78 Lancaster, NY 14086 ACRES 0.09 Town Tax 6,980 3.61 EAST-0950523 NRTH-0897097 Chargebacks 6,980 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,762 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,980 TO 12.40 LD011 Vineyard lt1 6,980 TO .75 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 6,980 TO C .50 TOTAL TAX --- 106.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 106.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-44.2 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 746 96.04-1-44.2 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 27,130 173.39 Dunkirk Vineyard Realty LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 27,130 County Tax 27,130 143.86 3640 Main St 10-5-4.2.1 27,130 Community Colleges 27,130 30.23 Amherst, NY 14226 ACRES 0.35 Town Tax 27,130 14.02 EAST-0950614 NRTH-0897096 Chargebacks 27,130 0.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,944 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 27,130 TO 48.21 LD011 Vineyard lt1 27,130 TO 2.92 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 27,130 TO C 1.95 TOTAL TAX --- 415.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 415.08 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 200 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-44.3 *************** Vineyard Dr BILL 747 96.04-1-44.3 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 31,000 198.13 GLR Holdings LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 31,000 County Tax 31,000 164.38 20 N Union St 10-5-4.2.1 31,000 Community Colleges 31,000 34.54 Rochester, NY 14607 ACRES 0.40 Town Tax 31,000 16.02 EAST-0950698 NRTH-0897039 Chargebacks 31,000 0.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 43,357 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 31,000 TO 55.08 LD011 Vineyard lt1 31,000 TO 3.34 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 31,000 TO C 2.23 TOTAL TAX --- 474.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 474.29 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-45 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 748 96.04-1-45 421 Restaurant Medicaid 744,000 4,755.08 Ronald Benderson 1995 Dunkirk Csd 060300 300,000 County Tax 744,000 3,945.09 570 Delaware Ave 10-5-3.2 744,000 Community Colleges 744,000 829.04 Buffalo, NY 14202 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 744,000 384.56 EAST-0950913 NRTH-0896989 Chargebacks 744,000 13.77 FULL MARKET VALUE 1040,559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 744,000 TO 1,322.03 LD011 Vineyard lt1 744,000 TO 80.16 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 744,000 TO C 53.41 TOTAL TAX --- 11,383.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 11,383.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-46 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 749 96.04-1-46 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 320,000 2,045.19 Aldi Inc (Ny)#86 Dunkirk Csd 060300 320,000 County Tax 320,000 1,696.81 600 N Noah Dr 10-5-2.4.2 320,000 Community Colleges 320,000 356.58 Saxonburg, PA 16056 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 320,000 165.40 EAST-0951069 NRTH-0897108 Chargebacks 320,000 5.92 DEED BOOK 2384 PG-121 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 320,000 TO 568.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 447,552 LD011 Vineyard lt1 320,000 TO 34.48 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 320,000 TO C 22.97 TOTAL TAX --- 4,895.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,895.96 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 201 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-47 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 750 96.04-1-47 485 >1use sm bld Medicaid 214,160 1,368.75 Dunkirk Triangle Development Dunkirk Csd 060300 22,150 County Tax 214,160 1,135.59 9332 Transit Rd Ste B 10-6-1.9 214,160 Community Colleges 214,160 238.64 East Amherst, NY 14051 FRNT 75.00 DPTH 110.00 Town Tax 214,160 110.70 EAST-0951256 NRTH-0896840 Chargebacks 214,160 3.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 299,524 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 214,160 TO 380.54 LD011 Vineyard lt1 214,160 TO 23.07 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 214,160 TO C 15.37 TOTAL TAX --- 3,276.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,276.62 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-49 ***************** 3874 Vineyard Dr BILL 751 96.04-1-49 454 Supermarket Medicaid 870,000 5,560.37 Aldi Inc (Ny)#86 Dunkirk Csd 060300 320,000 County Tax 870,000 4,613.21 600 N Noah Dr 10-5-2.1 870,000 Community Colleges 870,000 969.44 Saxonburg, PA 16056 ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 870,000 449.69 EAST-0951189 NRTH-0897232 Chargebacks 870,000 16.10 DEED BOOK 2384 PG-124 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 870,000 TO 1,545.92 FULL MARKET VALUE 1216,783 LD011 Vineyard lt1 870,000 TO 93.74 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 870,000 TO C 62.46 TOTAL TAX --- 13,310.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13,310.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-50 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 752 96.04-1-50 460 Bank/Office Medicaid 430,000 2,748.23 Lee Tat-Sum Dunkirk Csd 060300 430,000 County Tax 430,000 2,280.09 618 Center St Encludes 10-5-4.1 430,000 Community Colleges 430,000 479.15 Cherry Creek, NY 14723 10-5-2.4.1 Town Tax 430,000 222.26 ACRES 2.50 Chargebacks 430,000 7.96 EAST-0950935 NRTH-0897339 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 430,000 TO 764.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 601,399 LD011 Vineyard lt1 430,000 TO 46.33 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 430,000 TO C 30.87 TOTAL TAX --- 6,578.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,578.96 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 202 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-51 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 753 96.04-1-51 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Lee Tat-Sum Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 618 Center St Combined With 10-5-2.4.1 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Cherry Creek, NY 14723 10-5-4.1 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 100.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 EAST-0950731 NRTH-0897296 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 0 LD011 Vineyard lt1 0 TO WD007 Vineyard wtr3 0 TO C TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-52 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 754 96.04-1-52 415 Motel Medicaid 1872,860 11,969.88 Silver Creek Kasturi Ltd Dunkirk Csd 060300 340,000 County Tax 1872,860 9,930.92 3912 Vineyard Dr 10-5-4.2.2 1872,860 Community Colleges 1872,860 2,086.93 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 1872,860 968.04 EAST-0950489 NRTH-0897269 Chargebacks 1872,860 34.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 2619,385 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1872,860 TO 3,327.91 LD011 Vineyard lt1 1872,860 TO 201.79 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 1872,860 TO C 134.46 TOTAL TAX --- 28,654.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 28,654.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-54 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 755 96.04-1-54 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 75,000 479.34 Ramos John O Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,500 County Tax 75,000 397.69 Ramos Maria E 10-2-12 75,000 Community Colleges 75,000 83.57 1867 East Middle Rd ACRES 3.90 Town Tax 75,000 38.77 Silver Creek, NY 14136 EAST-0950568 NRTH-0897863 Chargebacks 75,000 1.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,895 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 75,000 TO 133.27 SW001 Bennett road water 75,000 TO C 74.40 TOTAL TAX --- 1,208.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,208.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-55 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 756 96.04-1-55 120 Field crops Medicaid 7,100 45.38 Halliday Darlene P Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,100 County Tax 7,100 37.65 10645 Bennett Rd 10-2-13.1 7,100 Community Colleges 7,100 7.91 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 15.00 Town Tax 7,100 3.67 EAST-0949716 NRTH-0897834 Chargebacks 7,100 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,930 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,100 TO 12.62 SW001 Bennett road water 7,100 TO C 7.04 TOTAL TAX --- 114.40** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 114.40 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 203 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-56 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 757 96.04-1-56 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Ramos John O Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Ramos Maria E 10-2-14.1 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 1867 E Middle Rd ACRES 4.70 Town Tax 500 0.26 Silver Creek, NY 14136 EAST-0948877 NRTH-0897665 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 SW001 Bennett road water 500 TO C .50 TOTAL TAX --- 8.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-61 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 758 96.04-1-61 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Halliday Darlene P Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 10645 Bennett Rd 10-2-11.3 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.83 Town Tax 100 0.05 EAST-0949675 NRTH-0898060 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 SW001 Bennett road water 100 TO C .10 TOTAL TAX --- 1.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-62.1 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 759 96.04-1-62.1 120 Field crops Medicaid 3,880 24.80 Halliday Darlene P Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,880 County Tax 3,880 20.57 10645 Bennett Rd 10-2-11.4 3,880 Community Colleges 3,880 4.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 15.60 Town Tax 3,880 2.01 EAST-0949472 NRTH-0898243 Chargebacks 3,880 0.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,427 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,880 TO 6.89 SW001 Bennett road water 3,880 TO C 3.85 TOTAL TAX --- 62.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 62.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-62.2 *************** Bennett Rd BILL 760 96.04-1-62.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 320 2.05 Cooper Jordan C Dunkirk Csd 060300 320 County Tax 320 1.70 Cooper Pamele 10-2-11.4 320 Community Colleges 320 0.36 10647 Bennett Rd ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 320 0.17 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950407 NRTH-0898280 Chargebacks 320 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 448 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 320 TO .57 SW001 Bennett road water 320 TO C .32 TOTAL TAX --- 5.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5.18 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 204 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-63 ***************** 10645 Bennett Rd BILL 761 96.04-1-63 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 60,500 386.67 Halliday John B Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 60,500 320.80 10645 Bennett Rd 10-2-11.1 60,500 Community Colleges 60,500 67.42 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 60,500 31.27 EAST-0950694 NRTH-0898129 Chargebacks 60,500 1.12 DEED BOOK 2010 PG-00482 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,500 TO 107.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,615 SW001 Bennett road water 60,500 TO C 60.02 TOTAL TAX --- 974.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 974.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-64 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 762 96.04-1-64 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 Cooper Jordan C Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 Cooper Pamela 10-2-11.2 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 10647 Bennett Rd ACRES 0.13 Town Tax 200 0.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950614 NRTH-0898246 Chargebacks 200 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 SW001 Bennett road water 200 TO C .20 TOTAL TAX --- 3.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-65 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 763 96.04-1-65 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 127,090 812.26 Cooper Jordan C Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,100 County Tax 127,090 673.90 Cooper Pamela 10-2-10 127,090 Community Colleges 127,090 141.62 10647 Bennett Rd ACRES 0.81 Town Tax 127,090 65.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950619 NRTH-0898309 Chargebacks 127,090 2.35 FULL MARKET VALUE 177,748 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 127,090 TO 225.83 SW001 Bennett road water 127,090 TO C 126.07 TOTAL TAX --- 2,047.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,047.72 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-66 ***************** 10667 Bennett Rd BILL 764 96.04-1-66 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 129,000 824.47 Ortolano Robert C Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,700 County Tax 129,000 684.03 10669 Bennett Rd 10-2-9 129,000 Community Colleges 129,000 143.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.90 Town Tax 129,000 66.68 EAST-0949559 NRTH-0898499 Chargebacks 129,000 2.39 DEED BOOK 1937 PG-00109 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 129,000 TO 229.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 180,420 SW001 Bennett road water 129,000 TO C 127.97 TOTAL TAX --- 2,078.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,078.51 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 205 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-67 ***************** 10683 Bennett Rd BILL 765 96.04-1-67 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 65,000 415.43 Vetter Ronald G Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 65,000 344.67 10683 Bennett Rd 10-2-7 65,000 Community Colleges 65,000 72.43 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 150.00 DPTH 129.00 Town Tax 65,000 33.60 EAST-0950366 NRTH-0898641 Chargebacks 65,000 1.20 DEED BOOK 2059 PG-00222 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 65,000 TO 115.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 90,909 SW001 Bennett road water 65,000 TO C 64.48 TOTAL TAX --- 1,047.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,047.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-68 ***************** 10683 Bennett Rd BILL 766 96.04-1-68 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Vetter Ronald G Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 10683 Bennett Rd 10-2-8.2 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 130.00 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0950266 NRTH-0898646 Chargebacks 900 0.02 DEED BOOK 2059 PG-00222 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 900 TO 1.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 SW001 Bennett road water 900 TO C .89 TOTAL TAX --- 14.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-69 ***************** 10681 Bennett Rd BILL 767 96.04-1-69 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 55,450 354.39 Vetter Ronald G Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 55,450 294.03 10683 Bennett Rd 10-2-8.1 55,450 Community Colleges 55,450 61.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.80 Town Tax 55,450 28.66 EAST-0949342 NRTH-0898662 Chargebacks 55,450 1.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 77,552 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,450 TO 98.53 SW001 Bennett road water 55,450 TO C 55.01 TOTAL TAX --- 893.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 893.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-1 ****************** 10902 S Roberts Rd BILL 768 97.01-1-1 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 73,000 466.56 Tarnowski Thomas J Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,900 County Tax 73,000 387.09 Tarnowski Diane L 9-16-21.1 73,000 Community Colleges 73,000 81.34 10902 S Roberts Rd ACRES 14.90 Town Tax 73,000 37.73 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954795 NRTH-0901824 Chargebacks 73,000 1.35 DEED BOOK 2633 PG-46 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,000 TO 129.71 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,098 WD058 Comprehensive Water 73,000 TO 37.33 TOTAL TAX --- 1,141.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,141.11 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 206 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-2 ****************** 10880 S Roberts Rd BILL 769 97.01-1-2 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 100,000 639.12 Wentz Jeffrey A Dunkirk Csd 060300 28,200 County Tax 100,000 530.25 Wentz Janet S 9-16-22 100,000 Community Colleges 100,000 111.43 10880 S Roberts Rd ACRES 39.70 Town Tax 100,000 51.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955158 NRTH-0901338 Chargebacks 100,000 1.85 DEED BOOK 2127 PG-00600 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100,000 TO 177.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 139,860 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100,000 TO 51.14 TOTAL TAX --- 1,563.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,563.17 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-3 ****************** 10848 S Roberts Rd BILL 770 97.01-1-3 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 102,800 657.02 Tarnowski Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,100 County Tax 102,800 545.10 10848 South Roberts Rd 9-16-23 102,800 Community Colleges 102,800 114.55 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.00 Town Tax 102,800 53.14 EAST-0955279 NRTH-0900896 Chargebacks 102,800 1.90 DEED BOOK 1762 PG-00184 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 102,800 TO 182.67 FULL MARKET VALUE 143,776 WD058 Comprehensive Water 102,800 TO 52.57 TOTAL TAX --- 1,606.95** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,606.95 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-4 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 771 97.01-1-4 152 Vineyard Medicaid 13,500 86.28 Tarnowski Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,500 County Tax 13,500 71.58 10848 S Roberts Rd 9-16-24 13,500 Community Colleges 13,500 15.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.00 Town Tax 13,500 6.98 EAST-0955397 NRTH-0900722 Chargebacks 13,500 0.25 DEED BOOK 1849 PG-00546 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 13,500 TO 23.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,881 WD058 Comprehensive Water 13,500 TO 6.90 TOTAL TAX --- 211.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 211.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-5 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 772 97.01-1-5 242 Rurl res&rec Medicaid 36,940 236.09 Mancuso Samuel C Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,600 County Tax 36,940 195.88 Mancuso JoAnn Life Use 36,940 Community Colleges 36,940 41.16 36 N Beaver St 9-16-25 Town Tax 36,940 19.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 10.39 Chargebacks 36,940 0.68 EAST-0955531 NRTH-0900474 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 36,940 TO 65.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,664 WD058 Comprehensive Water 36,940 TO 18.89 TOTAL TAX --- 577.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 577.43 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 207 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-6 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 773 97.01-1-6 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Olow Sally Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,000 Medicaid 58,630 374.72 10802 S Roberts Rd 9-16-26 65,980 County Tax 58,630 310.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 7.73 Community Colleges 58,630 65.33 EAST-0955658 NRTH-0900263 Town Tax 65,980 34.10 DEED BOOK 2681 PG-568 Chargebacks 65,980 1.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 65,980 TO 117.24 WD058 Comprehensive Water 65,980 TO 33.74 TOTAL TAX --- 937.24** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 937.24 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-8 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 774 97.01-1-8 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 37,000 236.48 Schrantz Dominick J Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,000 County Tax 37,000 196.19 Schrantz Deborah A 11-1-2 37,000 Community Colleges 37,000 41.23 10789 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.32 Town Tax 37,000 19.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955194 NRTH-0899899 Chargebacks 37,000 0.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,748 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 37,000 TO 65.75 WD058 Comprehensive Water 37,000 TO 18.92 TOTAL TAX --- 578.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 578.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-9 ****************** 10781 S Roberts Rd BILL 775 97.01-1-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 49,000 313.17 Bartelo Betty S Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,500 County Tax 49,000 259.82 10781 South Roberts Rd 11-1-3 49,000 Community Colleges 49,000 54.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 152.00 DPTH 127.00 Town Tax 49,000 25.33 EAST-0955347 NRTH-0899783 Chargebacks 49,000 0.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,531 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,000 TO 87.07 WD058 Comprehensive Water 49,000 TO 25.06 TOTAL TAX --- 765.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 765.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-10 ***************** 10775 S Roberts Rd BILL 776 97.01-1-10 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 78,000 498.52 Ross Julian J Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,400 County Tax 78,000 413.60 10775 South Roberts Rd 11-1-4 78,000 Community Colleges 78,000 86.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.80 Town Tax 78,000 40.32 EAST-0955110 NRTH-0899713 Chargebacks 78,000 1.44 DEED BOOK 1638 PG-00264 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 78,000 TO 138.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,091 WD058 Comprehensive Water 78,000 TO 39.89 TOTAL TAX --- 1,219.29** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,219.29 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 208 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-11 ***************** 10745 S Roberts Rd BILL 777 97.01-1-11 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 76,670 490.02 Janisch Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,200 County Tax 76,670 406.55 10745 South Roberts Rd 11-1-8 76,670 Community Colleges 76,670 85.43 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.00 Town Tax 76,670 39.63 EAST-0955686 NRTH-0898934 Chargebacks 76,670 1.42 DEED BOOK 2132 PG-00150 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 76,670 TO 136.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 107,231 WD058 Comprehensive Water 76,670 TO 39.21 TOTAL TAX --- 1,198.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,198.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-12 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 778 97.01-1-12 120 Field crops Medicaid 56,500 361.10 Brill Daniel Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,800 County Tax 56,500 299.59 3742 E Main Rd Lot 130 11-1-7 56,500 Community Colleges 56,500 62.96 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 35.40 Town Tax 56,500 29.20 EAST-0954589 NRTH-0898928 Chargebacks 56,500 1.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,500 TO 100.40 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,500 TO 28.89 TOTAL TAX --- 883.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 883.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-13 ***************** 10765 S Roberts Rd BILL 779 97.01-1-13 113 Cattle farm P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Wisniewski Mary J Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,400 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 10765 South Roberts Rd 11-1-5.1 51,500 Medicaid 46,500 297.19 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 27.80 County Tax 46,500 246.57 EAST-0954175 NRTH-0899645 Community Colleges 46,500 51.82 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,028 Town Tax 33,724 17.43 Chargebacks 33,724 0.62 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 51,500 TO 91.51 WD058 Comprehensive Water 51,500 TO 26.34 TOTAL TAX --- 731.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 731.48 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-14 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 780 97.01-1-14 323 Vacant rural Medicaid 16,800 107.37 Dimmer James E M Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,800 County Tax 16,800 89.08 156 Willow Rd 11-1-5.2 16,800 Community Colleges 16,800 18.72 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.00 Town Tax 16,800 8.68 EAST-0953167 NRTH-0899417 Chargebacks 16,800 0.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,497 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 16,800 TO 29.85 WD058 Comprehensive Water 16,800 TO 8.59 TOTAL TAX --- 262.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 262.60 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 209 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-15.1 *************** 10803 S Roberts Rd BILL 781 97.01-1-15.1 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 59,940 383.09 Davis John R Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,440 County Tax 59,940 317.83 176 Fizell Ave 11-1-1.1 59,940 Community Colleges 59,940 66.79 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 14.60 Town Tax 59,940 30.98 EAST-0953619 NRTH-0899966 Chargebacks 59,940 1.11 DEED BOOK 2681 PG-433 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 59,940 TO 106.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,832 WD058 Comprehensive Water 59,940 TO 30.65 TOTAL TAX --- 936.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 936.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-15.2 *************** S Roberts Rd BILL 782 97.01-1-15.2 322 Rural vac>10 AG COMMIT 41730 12,670 12,670 Dach John Dunkirk Csd 060300 19,560 Medicaid 6,890 44.04 171 Gardner St 11-1-1.2 19,560 County Tax 6,890 36.53 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 16.30 Community Colleges 6,890 7.68 EAST-0952587 NRTH-0899345 Town Tax 6,890 3.56 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 27,357 Chargebacks 6,890 0.13 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 19,560 TO 34.76 WD058 Comprehensive Water 19,560 TO 10.00 TOTAL TAX --- 136.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 136.70 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-16 ***************** Williams St BILL 783 97.01-1-16 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 20,490 20,490 Dach John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 26,200 Medicaid 5,710 36.49 171 Gardner St 9-15-5 26,200 County Tax 5,710 30.28 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 14.50 Community Colleges 5,710 6.36 EAST-0953064 NRTH-0900390 Town Tax 5,710 2.95 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2129 PG-00070 Chargebacks 5,710 0.11 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FULL MARKET VALUE 36,643 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 26,200 TO 46.56 WD058 Comprehensive Water 26,200 TO 13.40 TOTAL TAX --- 136.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 136.15 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-17 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 784 97.01-1-17 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,300 21.09 Tarnowski Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,300 County Tax 3,300 17.50 10848 S Roberts Rd 9-15-4 3,300 Community Colleges 3,300 3.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.50 Town Tax 3,300 1.71 EAST-0954018 NRTH-0900386 Chargebacks 3,300 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,615 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,300 TO 5.86 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,300 TO 1.69 TOTAL TAX --- 51.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 51.59 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 210 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-18 ***************** 10807 S Roberts Rd BILL 785 97.01-1-18 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 69,320 443.04 Mancuso Samuel Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,800 County Tax 69,320 367.57 Mancuso JoAnn 9-15-3 69,320 Community Colleges 69,320 77.24 36 N Beaver St ACRES 2.70 Town Tax 69,320 35.83 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954468 NRTH-0900434 Chargebacks 69,320 1.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 96,951 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,320 TO 123.18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 69,320 TO 35.45 TOTAL TAX --- 1,083.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,083.59 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-19 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 786 97.01-1-19 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 74,000 472.95 Tarnowski Eugene Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,100 County Tax 74,000 392.39 10848 S Roberts Rd 9-15-2 74,000 Community Colleges 74,000 82.46 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 4.50 Town Tax 74,000 38.25 EAST-0953956 NRTH-0900843 Chargebacks 74,000 1.37 FULL MARKET VALUE 103,497 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 74,000 TO 131.49 WD058 Comprehensive Water 74,000 TO 37.84 TOTAL TAX --- 1,156.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,156.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-20 ***************** Williams St BILL 787 97.01-1-20 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 16,140 16,140 Dach John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 28,700 Medicaid 33,860 216.41 171 Gardner St 9-15-1 50,000 County Tax 33,860 179.54 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 14.50 Community Colleges 33,860 37.73 EAST-0953074 NRTH-0900855 Town Tax 33,860 17.50 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2129 PG-00070 Chargebacks 33,860 0.63 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,930 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,000 TO 88.85 WD058 Comprehensive Water 50,000 TO 25.57 TOTAL TAX --- 566.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 566.23 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-1 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 788 97.03-1-1 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 4,870 31.13 Dach John J Fredonia 065801 2,300 County Tax 4,870 25.82 Dach Nancy J golf range 4,870 Community Colleges 4,870 5.43 171 Gardner St 11-1-6 Town Tax 4,870 2.52 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 10.00 Chargebacks 4,870 0.09 EAST-0952759 NRTH-0898241 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,870 TO 8.65 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,811 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,870 TO 2.49 TOTAL TAX --- 76.13** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 76.13 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 211 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-3 ****************** Swamp Rd BILL 789 97.03-1-3 311 Res vac land AG DIST 41720 920 920 Bull Donald Trustee Fredonia 065801 3,500 Medicaid 2,580 16.49 Bull Mary Trustee 11-4-2 3,500 County Tax 2,580 13.68 Living Trust ACRES 8.80 Community Colleges 2,580 2.87 10567 Swamp Rd EAST-0954551 NRTH-0897786 Town Tax 2,580 1.33 Fredonia, NY 14063 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,895 Chargebacks 2,580 0.05 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,500 TO 6.22 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,500 TO 1.79 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 TOTAL TAX --- 42.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 42.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-4 ****************** Swamp Rd BILL 790 97.03-1-4 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Austin Megan Fredonia 065801 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 10653 Swamp Rd 11-4-3 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 3.20 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 EAST-0955119 NRTH-0898049 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-5 ****************** 10653 Swamp Rd BILL 791 97.03-1-5 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 51,000 325.95 Austin Megan Fredonia 065801 11,600 County Tax 51,000 270.43 10653 Swamp Rd 11-4-4 51,000 Community Colleges 51,000 56.83 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 4.00 Town Tax 51,000 26.36 EAST-0956132 NRTH-0898152 Chargebacks 51,000 0.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 71,329 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 51,000 TO 90.62 WD058 Comprehensive Water 51,000 TO 26.08 TOTAL TAX --- 797.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 797.21 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 212 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-6 ****************** Swamp Rd BILL 792 97.03-1-6 120 Field crops AG DIST 41720 4,260 4,260 Bull Donald R Trustee Fredonia 065801 7,770 Medicaid 3,510 22.43 Bull Mary Trustee 11-4-5.3 7,770 County Tax 3,510 18.61 Living Trust ACRES 11.70 Community Colleges 3,510 3.91 10567 Swamp Rd EAST-0955648 NRTH-0897657 Town Tax 3,510 1.81 Fredonia, NY 14063 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,867 Chargebacks 3,510 0.06 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,770 TO 13.81 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,770 TO 3.97 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 TOTAL TAX --- 64.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 64.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-7 ****************** 10613 Swamp Rd BILL 793 97.03-1-7 311 Res vac land Medicaid 600 3.83 Parks Kenneth R Fredonia 065801 600 County Tax 600 3.18 Parks Diane M 11-4-5.2 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 10613 Swamp Rd FRNT 140.00 DPTH 160.00 Town Tax 600 0.31 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0956240 NRTH-0897798 Chargebacks 600 0.01 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00583 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 WD058 Comprehensive Water 600 TO .31 TOTAL TAX --- 9.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-8 ****************** 10613 Swamp Rd BILL 794 97.03-1-8 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 98,790 631.39 Parks Kenneth R Fredonia 065801 9,800 County Tax 98,790 523.84 Parks Diane M 11-4-7 98,790 Community Colleges 98,790 110.08 10613 Swamp Rd FRNT 160.00 DPTH 160.00 Town Tax 98,790 51.06 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0956239 NRTH-0897651 Chargebacks 98,790 1.83 DEED BOOK 1864 PG-00583 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 98,790 TO 175.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,168 WD058 Comprehensive Water 98,790 TO 50.52 TOTAL TAX --- 1,544.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,544.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-9 ****************** Swamp Rd BILL 795 97.03-1-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 57,230 365.77 Bull Donald R Fredonia 065801 9,000 County Tax 57,230 303.46 10567 Swamp Rd 11-4-5.1 57,230 Community Colleges 57,230 63.77 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.00 Town Tax 57,230 29.58 EAST-0956098 NRTH-0897472 Chargebacks 57,230 1.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,042 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 57,230 TO 101.69 WD058 Comprehensive Water 57,230 TO 29.27 TOTAL TAX --- 894.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 894.60 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 213 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-10 ***************** 10581 Swamp Rd BILL 796 97.03-1-10 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 61,500 393.06 Lis Gregory J Fredonia 065801 9,300 County Tax 61,500 326.11 10581 Swamp Rd 11-4-6.2 61,500 Community Colleges 61,500 68.53 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 61,500 31.79 EAST-0956183 NRTH-0897189 Chargebacks 61,500 1.14 DEED BOOK 2628 PG-816 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 61,500 TO 109.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 86,014 WD058 Comprehensive Water 61,500 TO 31.45 TOTAL TAX --- 961.36** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 961.36 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-11 ***************** Swamp Rd BILL 797 97.03-1-11 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 19,800 19,800 Bull Donald R Trustee Fredonia 065801 24,500 Medicaid 4,700 30.04 Bull Mary Trustee 11-4-6.1 24,500 County Tax 4,700 24.92 10567 Swamp Rd ACRES 13.50 Community Colleges 4,700 5.24 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0955226 NRTH-0897207 Town Tax 4,700 2.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,266 Chargebacks 4,700 0.09 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FP009 E dnk fire prot2 24,500 TO 43.53 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 24,500 TO 12.53 TOTAL TAX --- 118.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 118.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-13 ***************** 10567 Swamp Rd BILL 798 97.03-1-13 152 Vineyard P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,067 Bull Donald R Trustee Fredonia 065801 20,500 VETS CNTY 41102 300 0 Bull Mary Trustee 11-4-8 145,030 AG BLDG 41700 6,410 6,410 10567 Swamp Rd ACRES 10.00 AG COMMIT 41730 10,070 10,070 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0955436 NRTH-0896905 Medicaid 128,250 819.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 202,839 County Tax 128,250 680.05 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT Community Colleges 128,250 142.91 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 Town Tax 127,483 65.89 Chargebacks 127,483 2.36 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 145,030 TO 257.71 WD058 Comprehensive Water 145,030 TO 74.17 TOTAL TAX --- 2,042.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,042.77 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 214 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-14 ***************** 10567 Swamp Rd BILL 799 97.03-1-14 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 14,060 14,060 Bull Donald R Trustee Fredonia 065801 17,400 Medicaid 3,340 21.35 Bull Mary Trustee 11-4-9.2 17,400 County Tax 3,340 17.71 10567 Swamp Rd ACRES 5.80 Community Colleges 3,340 3.72 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0956012 NRTH-0896568 Town Tax 3,340 1.73 DEED BOOK 1930 PG-00406 Chargebacks 3,340 0.06 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 24,336 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 17,400 TO 30.92 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 WD058 Comprehensive Water 17,400 TO 8.90 TOTAL TAX --- 84.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 84.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-15 ***************** 10523 Swamp Rd BILL 800 97.03-1-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 59,980 383.35 Winchell David M Fredonia 065801 8,700 County Tax 59,980 318.05 Winchell Kathleen G 11-4-9.1 59,980 Community Colleges 59,980 66.84 10523 Swamp Rd ACRES 1.60 Town Tax 59,980 31.00 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0956194 NRTH-0896309 Chargebacks 59,980 1.11 DEED BOOK 2115 PG-00209 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 59,980 TO 106.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 83,888 WD058 Comprehensive Water 59,980 TO 30.67 TOTAL TAX --- 937.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 937.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-16 ***************** Swamp Rd BILL 801 97.03-1-16 152 Vineyard Medicaid 15,000 95.87 Nocek Nancy Fredonia 065801 15,000 County Tax 15,000 79.54 3602 E Main Rd 11-4-10 15,000 Community Colleges 15,000 16.71 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 5.00 Town Tax 15,000 7.75 EAST-0956011 NRTH-0896119 Chargebacks 15,000 0.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,979 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 15,000 TO 26.65 WD058 Comprehensive Water 15,000 TO 7.67 TOTAL TAX --- 234.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 234.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-17 ***************** E Main Rd BILL 802 97.03-1-17 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 7,510 7,510 Wood Caroline Fredonia 065801 9,000 Medicaid 1,490 9.52 3624 E Main Rd 11-4-11 9,000 County Tax 1,490 7.90 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 3.00 Community Colleges 1,490 1.66 EAST-0955572 NRTH-0896126 Town Tax 1,490 0.77 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 12,587 Chargebacks 1,490 0.03 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,000 TO 15.99 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,000 TO 4.60 TOTAL TAX --- 40.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 40.47 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 215 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-18.1 *************** 3624 E Main Rd BILL 803 97.03-1-18.1 152 Vineyard Medicaid 42,250 270.03 Country Side Sand & Gravel Inc Fredonia 065801 42,250 County Tax 42,250 224.03 13870 Taylor Hollow Rd 11-4-12.2 42,250 Community Colleges 42,250 47.08 Collins, NY 14034 ACRES 18.00 Town Tax 42,250 21.84 EAST-0955023 NRTH-0896310 Chargebacks 42,250 0.78 DEED BOOK 2031 PG-00049 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,250 TO 75.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,091 WD058 Comprehensive Water 42,250 TO 21.61 TOTAL TAX --- 660.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 660.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-18.2 *************** 3624 E Main Rd BILL 804 97.03-1-18.2 152 Vineyard AG DIST 41720 6,790 6,790 Bull Donald R Fredonia 065801 8,980 Medicaid 2,190 14.00 Bull Mary A 11-4-12.2 8,980 County Tax 2,190 11.61 10567 Swamp Rd ACRES 3.80 Community Colleges 2,190 2.44 Fredonia, NY 14063 EAST-0955023 NRTH-0896310 Town Tax 2,190 1.13 DEED BOOK 2031 PG-00049 Chargebacks 2,190 0.04 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT FULL MARKET VALUE 12,559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,980 TO 15.96 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2018 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,980 TO 4.59 TOTAL TAX --- 49.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 49.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-19 ***************** E Main Rd BILL 805 97.03-1-19 323 Vacant rural Medicaid 500 3.20 Country Side Sand & Gravel Inc Fredonia 065801 500 County Tax 500 2.65 13870 Taylor Hollow Rd 11-4-12.1 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Collins, NY 14034 ACRES 5.00 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0954950 NRTH-0896509 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-20 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 806 97.03-1-20 311 Res vac land Medicaid 400 2.56 B R Dewitt Inc Fredonia 065801 400 County Tax 400 2.12 c/o Marvin F Poer & Company 11-4-13 400 Community Colleges 400 0.45 PO Box 52427 ACRES 4.10 Town Tax 400 0.21 Atlanta, GA 30355 EAST-0954198 NRTH-0896402 Chargebacks 400 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 559 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 400 TO .71 WD058 Comprehensive Water 400 TO .20 TOTAL TAX --- 6.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6.26 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 216 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-21 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 807 97.03-1-21 710 Manufacture Medicaid 91,540 585.05 B R Dewitt Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 43,500 County Tax 91,540 485.39 c/o Marvin F Poer & Company 11-4-14 91,540 Community Colleges 91,540 102.00 PO Box 52427 ACRES 8.85 Town Tax 91,540 47.32 Atlanta, GA 30355 EAST-0953673 NRTH-0896404 Chargebacks 91,540 1.69 FULL MARKET VALUE 128,028 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 91,540 TO 162.66 WD058 Comprehensive Water 91,540 TO 46.81 TOTAL TAX --- 1,430.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,430.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-22 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 808 97.03-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 5,400 34.51 Regional Shopping Ctr Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,400 County Tax 5,400 28.63 Attn: National Realty & 11-4-1 5,400 Community Colleges 5,400 6.02 Development Corp ACRES 4.50 Town Tax 5,400 2.79 3 Manhattanville Rd EAST-0952544 NRTH-0896517 Chargebacks 5,400 0.10 Purchase, NY 10577 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,552 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,400 TO 9.60 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,400 TO 2.76 TOTAL TAX --- 84.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 84.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-1 ****************** 3828 Franklin Ave BILL 809 97.05-1-1 220 2 Family Res VETS CNTY 41102 300 0 Lanski William J Sr Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Lanski Evelyn M 8-3-1 48,240 Medicaid 40,590 259.42 3828 Franklin Ave FRNT 222.80 DPTH 198.20 County Tax 40,590 215.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.75 Community Colleges 40,590 45.23 EAST-0952263 NRTH-0902701 Town Tax 48,240 24.93 DEED BOOK 1872 PG-00085 Chargebacks 48,240 0.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 67,469 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 48,240 TO 85.72 WD058 Comprehensive Water 48,240 TO 24.67 TOTAL TAX --- 656.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 656.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-2 ****************** 3828 Franklin Ave BILL 810 97.05-1-2 484 1 use sm bld Medicaid 16,300 104.18 Jones Barbara Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 16,300 86.43 3828 Franklin Ave 8-3-2 16,300 Community Colleges 16,300 18.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.89 Town Tax 16,300 8.43 EAST-0952372 NRTH-0902640 Chargebacks 16,300 0.30 DEED BOOK 1943 PG-00509 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 16,300 TO 28.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 22,797 WD058 Comprehensive Water 16,300 TO 8.34 TOTAL TAX --- 254.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 254.80 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 217 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-3 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 811 97.05-1-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 6,700 42.82 Halicki Ronald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,700 County Tax 6,700 35.53 3816 Franklin Ave 9-4-1.2 6,700 Community Colleges 6,700 7.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.76 Town Tax 6,700 3.46 EAST-0952515 NRTH-0902654 Chargebacks 6,700 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,371 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,700 TO 11.91 WD058 Comprehensive Water 6,700 TO 3.43 TOTAL TAX --- 104.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 104.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-4 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 812 97.05-1-4 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 52,360 334.64 Damon Kyle J Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,100 County Tax 52,360 277.64 Damon Kristina D 9-4-2 52,360 Community Colleges 52,360 58.34 3805 Greenhurst Ave ACRES 0.22 Town Tax 52,360 27.06 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952616 NRTH-0902675 Chargebacks 52,360 0.97 DEED BOOK 2675 PG-20 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 52,360 TO 93.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 73,231 WD058 Comprehensive Water 52,360 TO 26.78 TOTAL TAX --- 818.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 818.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-5 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 813 97.05-1-5 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,100 7.03 Damon Kyle J Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,100 County Tax 1,100 5.83 Damon Kristina D 9-4-3.2 1,100 Community Colleges 1,100 1.23 3805 Greenhurst Ave ACRES 0.21 Town Tax 1,100 0.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952677 NRTH-0902637 Chargebacks 1,100 0.02 DEED BOOK 2675 PG-20 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,100 TO 1.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,538 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,100 TO .56 TOTAL TAX --- 17.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 17.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-6 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 814 97.05-1-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Barns Edward G Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 575 Danker Rd 9-4-3.1 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 South Dayton, NY 14138 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 218.00 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0952717 NRTH-0902637 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 DEED BOOK 1927 PG-00257 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 218 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-7 ****************** 3795 Greenhurst Ave BILL 815 97.05-1-7 270 Mfg housing Medicaid 14,400 92.03 Barnes Edward G Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,000 County Tax 14,400 76.36 575 Danker Dr 9-4-4 14,400 Community Colleges 14,400 16.05 South Dayton, NY 14138 FRNT 50.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 14,400 7.44 EAST-0952766 NRTH-0902641 Chargebacks 14,400 0.27 DEED BOOK 1927 PG-00257 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 14,400 TO 25.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 14,400 TO 7.36 TOTAL TAX --- 225.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 225.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-8 ****************** 3795 Greenhurst Ave BILL 816 97.05-1-8 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Barnes Edward G Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 575 Danker Rd 9-4-5 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 South Dayton, NY 14138 FRNT 40.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 EAST-0952811 NRTH-0902641 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 DEED BOOK 1927 PG-00257 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 26.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-9 ****************** 3791 Greenhurst Ave BILL 817 97.05-1-9 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 46,500 297.19 Van Schoonhoven Kathryn Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 County Tax 46,500 246.57 3791 Greenhurst Ave 9-4-6 46,500 Community Colleges 46,500 51.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 80.00 DPTH 209.00 Town Tax 46,500 24.03 EAST-0952859 NRTH-0902642 Chargebacks 46,500 0.86 DEED BOOK 2099 PG-00554 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 46,500 TO 82.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,035 WD058 Comprehensive Water 46,500 TO 23.78 TOTAL TAX --- 726.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 726.88 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-15 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 818 97.05-1-15 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 37,000 236.48 Halicki Angeline Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 37,000 196.19 10941 S Roberts Rd 9-4-10.1 37,000 Community Colleges 37,000 41.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.44 Town Tax 37,000 19.12 EAST-0953275 NRTH-0902467 Chargebacks 37,000 0.68 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,748 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 37,000 TO 65.75 WD058 Comprehensive Water 37,000 TO 18.92 TOTAL TAX --- 578.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 578.37 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 219 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-16 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 819 97.05-1-16 433 Auto body Medicaid 53,400 341.29 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,000 County Tax 53,400 283.16 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-4-10.3 53,400 Community Colleges 53,400 59.50 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 128.00 DPTH 306.00 Town Tax 53,400 27.60 EAST-0953189 NRTH-0902416 Chargebacks 53,400 0.99 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,685 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,400 TO 94.89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 53,400 TO 27.31 TOTAL TAX --- 834.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 834.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-17 ***************** 3782 Franklin Ave BILL 820 97.05-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 43,900 280.58 Conway Norman Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,100 County Tax 43,900 232.78 3782 Franklin Ave 9-4-11.2 43,900 Community Colleges 43,900 48.92 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.61 Town Tax 43,900 22.69 EAST-0953048 NRTH-0902422 Chargebacks 43,900 0.81 FULL MARKET VALUE 61,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 43,900 TO 78.01 WD058 Comprehensive Water 43,900 TO 22.45 TOTAL TAX --- 686.24** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 686.24 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-18 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 821 97.05-1-18 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,300 21.09 Conway Norman Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,300 County Tax 3,300 17.50 3782 Franklin Ave 9-4-11.1 3,300 Community Colleges 3,300 3.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 3,300 1.71 EAST-0952946 NRTH-0902422 Chargebacks 3,300 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,615 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,300 TO 5.86 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,300 TO 1.69 TOTAL TAX --- 51.59** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 51.59 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-19 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 822 97.05-1-19 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 10,080 64.42 Clarke Thomas R Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 10,080 53.45 Clarke Margaret 9-4-12 10,080 Community Colleges 10,080 11.23 3790 Franklin Ave ACRES 0.20 Town Tax 10,080 5.21 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952892 NRTH-0902423 Chargebacks 10,080 0.19 DEED BOOK 1619 PG-00250 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 10,080 TO 17.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,098 WD058 Comprehensive Water 10,080 TO 5.15 TOTAL TAX --- 157.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 157.56 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 220 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-20 ***************** 3790 Franklin Ave BILL 823 97.05-1-20 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Clarke Thomas R Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,800 Medicaid 43,090 275.40 Clarke Margaret 9-4-13 47,500 County Tax 43,090 228.49 3790 Franklin Ave ACRES 0.20 Community Colleges 43,090 48.02 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952859 NRTH-0902422 Town Tax 47,500 24.55 DEED BOOK 1619 PG-00250 Chargebacks 47,500 0.88 FULL MARKET VALUE 66,434 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 47,500 TO 84.40 WD058 Comprehensive Water 47,500 TO 24.29 TOTAL TAX --- 686.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 686.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-21 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 824 97.05-1-21 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Privateer Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 63 Cushing St 9-4-14 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 0.20 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0952817 NRTH-0902425 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-22 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 825 97.05-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Privateer Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 63 Cushing St 9-4-15 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 0.25 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0952770 NRTH-0902424 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-23 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 826 97.05-1-23 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,600 10.23 Snyder Daniel M Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,600 County Tax 1,600 8.48 3806 Franklin Ave 9-4-3.3 1,600 Community Colleges 1,600 1.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 91.50 DPTH 218.00 Town Tax 1,600 0.83 EAST-0952701 NRTH-0902420 Chargebacks 1,600 0.03 DEED BOOK 2107 PG-00495 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,600 TO 2.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,238 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,600 TO .82 TOTAL TAX --- 25.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 25.01 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 221 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-24 ***************** 3806 Franklin Ave BILL 827 97.05-1-24 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 85,880 548.88 Snyder Daniel M lll Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,900 County Tax 85,880 455.38 3806 Franklin Ave 9-4-16 85,880 Community Colleges 85,880 95.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.96 Town Tax 85,880 44.39 EAST-0952608 NRTH-0902458 Chargebacks 85,880 1.59 DEED BOOK 2107 PG-00495 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 85,880 TO 152.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,112 WD058 Comprehensive Water 85,880 TO 43.92 TOTAL TAX --- 1,342.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,342.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-25 ***************** 3816 Franklin Ave BILL 828 97.05-1-25 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Halicki Ronald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 Medicaid 47,650 304.54 3816 Franklin Ave 9-4-1.1 55,000 County Tax 47,650 252.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.60 Community Colleges 47,650 53.10 EAST-0952506 NRTH-0902505 Town Tax 55,000 28.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,923 Chargebacks 55,000 1.02 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,000 TO 97.73 WD058 Comprehensive Water 55,000 TO 28.13 TOTAL TAX --- 765.62** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 765.62 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-26 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 829 97.05-1-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 46,000 294.00 Bradley Prudence K Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,200 County Tax 46,000 243.92 Bradley Paul 9-14-1 46,000 Community Colleges 46,000 51.26 3811 Franklin Ave ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 46,000 23.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952469 NRTH-0902250 Chargebacks 46,000 0.85 FULL MARKET VALUE 64,336 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 46,000 TO 81.74 WD058 Comprehensive Water 46,000 TO 23.52 TOTAL TAX --- 719.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 719.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-27 ***************** 3799 Franklin Ave BILL 830 97.05-1-27 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 32,320 206.56 Abramowicz Robert Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 County Tax 32,320 171.38 3799 Franklin Ave 9-14-3 32,320 Community Colleges 32,320 36.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 200.00 Town Tax 32,320 16.71 EAST-0952665 NRTH-0902149 Chargebacks 32,320 0.60 DEED BOOK 1821 PG-00279 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 32,320 TO 57.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 45,203 WD058 Comprehensive Water 32,320 TO 16.53 TOTAL TAX --- 505.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 505.22 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 222 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-28 ***************** 3799 Franklin Ave BILL 831 97.05-1-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Abramowicz Robert Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 3799 Franklin Ave 9-14-5.3 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 112.00 DPTH 110.00 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 EAST-0952664 NRTH-0901995 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 26.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-29 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 832 97.05-1-29 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,700 10.87 Greene Phylip R Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,700 County Tax 1,700 9.01 Lidlow Cheryl 9-14-5.4 1,700 Community Colleges 1,700 1.89 3793 Franklin Ave ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 1,700 0.88 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952780 NRTH-0901994 Chargebacks 1,700 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,378 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,700 TO 3.02 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,700 TO .87 TOTAL TAX --- 26.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 26.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-30 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 833 97.05-1-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 34,200 218.58 Green Phylip R Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 34,200 181.35 Green Lidlow Cheryl 9-14-4 34,200 Community Colleges 34,200 38.11 3793 Franklin Ave ACRES 0.55 Town Tax 34,200 17.68 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952780 NRTH-0902146 Chargebacks 34,200 0.63 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,832 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 34,200 TO 60.77 WD058 Comprehensive Water 34,200 TO 17.49 TOTAL TAX --- 534.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 534.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-31 ***************** 3789 Franklin Ave BILL 834 97.05-1-31 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 49,000 313.17 Pencek Henry W Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 County Tax 49,000 259.82 3789 Franklin Ave 9-14-5.1 49,000 Community Colleges 49,000 54.60 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.74 Town Tax 49,000 25.33 EAST-0952896 NRTH-0902093 Chargebacks 49,000 0.91 FULL MARKET VALUE 68,531 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 49,000 TO 87.07 WD058 Comprehensive Water 49,000 TO 25.06 TOTAL TAX --- 765.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 765.96 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 223 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-32 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 835 97.05-1-32 220 2 Family Res Medicaid 47,000 300.39 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 47,000 249.22 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-14-7 47,000 Community Colleges 47,000 52.37 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 47,000 24.29 EAST-0953106 NRTH-0901948 Chargebacks 47,000 0.87 DEED BOOK 2012 PG-00056 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 47,000 TO 83.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 65,734 WD058 Comprehensive Water 47,000 TO 24.03 TOTAL TAX --- 734.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 734.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-33 ***************** Franklin Ave BILL 836 97.05-1-33 311 Res vac land Medicaid 8,600 54.96 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 8,600 45.60 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-14-8 8,600 Community Colleges 8,600 9.58 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 8,600 4.45 EAST-0953205 NRTH-0901948 Chargebacks 8,600 0.16 DEED BOOK 2012 PG-00056 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,600 TO 15.28 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,028 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,600 TO 4.40 TOTAL TAX --- 134.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 134.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-34 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 837 97.05-1-34 433 Auto body Medicaid 50,500 322.76 Halicki Ronald M Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,800 County Tax 50,500 267.78 3816 Franklin Ave 9-14-9 50,500 Community Colleges 50,500 56.27 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.30 Town Tax 50,500 26.10 EAST-0953408 NRTH-0901946 Chargebacks 50,500 0.93 DEED BOOK 1814 PG-00208 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,500 TO 89.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,629 WD058 Comprehensive Water 50,500 TO 25.82 TOTAL TAX --- 789.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 789.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-35 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 838 97.05-1-35 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 42,000 268.43 Paradiso Kenneth Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 42,000 222.71 10893 S Roberts Rd 9-14-11 42,000 Community Colleges 42,000 46.80 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 42,000 21.71 EAST-0953651 NRTH-0901518 Chargebacks 42,000 0.78 FULL MARKET VALUE 58,741 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,000 TO 74.63 WD058 Comprehensive Water 42,000 TO 21.48 TOTAL TAX --- 656.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 656.54 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 224 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-36 ***************** 10879 S Roberts Rd BILL 839 97.05-1-36 270 Mfg housing Medicaid 33,900 216.66 Tarnowski Irene C Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,000 County Tax 33,900 179.76 10883 S Roberts Rd 9-14-10.2.1 33,900 Community Colleges 33,900 37.77 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 33,900 17.52 EAST-0953741 NRTH-0901290 Chargebacks 33,900 0.63 DEED BOOK 2629 PG-841 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 33,900 TO 60.24 FULL MARKET VALUE 47,413 WD058 Comprehensive Water 33,900 TO 17.34 TOTAL TAX --- 529.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 529.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-37 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 840 97.05-1-37 311 Res vac land Medicaid 900 5.75 Grupa Joan Dunkirk Csd 060300 900 County Tax 900 4.77 10875 S Roberts Rd 9-14-10.2.2 900 Community Colleges 900 1.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 203.00 DPTH 199.00 Town Tax 900 0.47 EAST-0953810 NRTH-0901231 Chargebacks 900 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,259 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 900 TO 1.60 WD058 Comprehensive Water 900 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 14.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-38 ***************** 10875 S Roberts Rd BILL 841 97.05-1-38 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 55,000 351.52 Grupa Joan Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,500 County Tax 55,000 291.64 10875 S Roberts Rd 9-14-12 55,000 Community Colleges 55,000 61.29 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 74.00 DPTH 95.00 Town Tax 55,000 28.43 EAST-0953821 NRTH-0901177 Chargebacks 55,000 1.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 76,923 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 55,000 TO 97.73 WD058 Comprehensive Water 55,000 TO 28.13 TOTAL TAX --- 859.76** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 859.76 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-39 ***************** Williams St BILL 842 97.05-1-39 484 1 use sm bld Medicaid 80,100 511.94 Time Warner Cable Northeast LL Dunkirk Csd 060300 49,100 County Tax 80,100 424.73 Real estate Dept 9-14-10.1 80,100 Community Colleges 80,100 89.26 7820 Crescent Executive Dr ACRES 6.90 Town Tax 80,100 41.40 Charlotte, NC 28217 EAST-0953332 NRTH-0901391 Chargebacks 80,100 1.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 112,028 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 80,100 TO 142.33 WD058 Comprehensive Water 80,100 TO 40.96 TOTAL TAX --- 1,252.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,252.10 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 225 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-40 ***************** 3783 Franklin Ave BILL 843 97.05-1-40 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 65,830 420.73 Miller Marsha J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,700 County Tax 65,830 349.07 3783 Franklin Ave 9-14-6 65,830 Community Colleges 65,830 73.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.44 Town Tax 65,830 34.03 EAST-0953004 NRTH-0901694 Chargebacks 65,830 1.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,070 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 65,830 TO 116.97 WD058 Comprehensive Water 65,830 TO 33.66 TOTAL TAX --- 1,029.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,029.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-41 ***************** Williams St BILL 844 97.05-1-41 152 Vineyard AG COMMIT 41730 9,320 9,320 Dach John J Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,100 Medicaid 2,780 17.77 171 Gardner St 9-14-5.2 12,100 County Tax 2,780 14.74 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 6.70 Community Colleges 2,780 3.10 EAST-0952777 NRTH-0901541 Town Tax 2,780 1.44 MAY BE SUBJECT TO PAYMENT DEED BOOK 2129 PG-00070 Chargebacks 2,780 0.05 UNDER AGDIST LAW TIL 2021 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,923 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12,100 TO 21.50 WD058 Comprehensive Water 12,100 TO 6.19 TOTAL TAX --- 64.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 64.79 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-43 ***************** Williams St BILL 845 97.05-1-43 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,900 24.93 Lack Kevin Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,900 County Tax 3,900 20.68 3711 E Lake Rd 8-4-16.2.2 3,900 Community Colleges 3,900 4.35 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.73 Town Tax 3,900 2.02 EAST-0952324 NRTH-0901317 Chargebacks 3,900 0.07 DEED BOOK 1699 PG-00193 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,900 TO 6.93 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,455 SW001 Bennett road water 3,900 TO C 3.87 TOTAL TAX --- 62.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 62.85 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-44 ***************** 3817 Franklin Ave BILL 846 97.05-1-44 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 59,160 378.11 Kaus Bernard W Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,800 County Tax 59,160 313.70 C/O Paul Kaus 8-2-18 59,160 Community Colleges 59,160 65.92 65 N Martin St ACRES 7.50 Town Tax 59,160 30.58 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952242 NRTH-0901962 Chargebacks 59,160 1.10 DEED BOOK 1912 PG-00125 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 59,160 TO 105.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 82,741 SW001 Bennett road water 800 TO C .79 TOTAL TAX --- 895.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 895.32 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 226 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-45 ***************** 3823 Franklin Ave BILL 847 97.05-1-45 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 73,500 469.76 Savali Liatama Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 73,500 389.74 Savali Valarie 8-2-17 73,500 Community Colleges 73,500 81.90 3823 Franklin Ave ACRES 1.30 Town Tax 73,500 37.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952166 NRTH-0902546 Chargebacks 73,500 1.36 DEED BOOK 2049 PG-00034 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 73,500 TO 130.60 FULL MARKET VALUE 102,797 WD058 Comprehensive Water 73,500 TO 37.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,148.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,148.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-1 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 848 97.05-2-1 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 52,000 332.34 Miller Jacqueline Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,600 County Tax 52,000 275.73 10954 S Roberts Rd 9-11-1 52,000 Community Colleges 52,000 57.94 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.51 Town Tax 52,000 26.88 EAST-0953417 NRTH-0902689 Chargebacks 52,000 0.96 FULL MARKET VALUE 72,727 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 52,000 TO 92.40 WD058 Comprehensive Water 52,000 TO 26.59 TOTAL TAX --- 812.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 812.84 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-2 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 849 97.05-2-2 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 69,500 444.19 Halicki Angeline M Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,100 County Tax 69,500 368.53 10948 S Roberts Rd 9-11-15 69,500 Community Colleges 69,500 77.44 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.26 Town Tax 69,500 35.92 EAST-0953419 NRTH-0902580 Chargebacks 69,500 1.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,203 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 69,500 TO 123.50 WD058 Comprehensive Water 69,500 TO 35.54 TOTAL TAX --- 1,086.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,086.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-3 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 850 97.05-2-3 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 Purol Bonnie 9-11-14.1 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 10940 S Roberts Rd FRNT 11.00 DPTH 160.00 Town Tax 200 0.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953447 NRTH-0902532 Chargebacks 200 0.00 DEED BOOK 1662 PG-00159 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 WD058 Comprehensive Water 200 TO .10 TOTAL TAX --- 3.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.12 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 227 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-4 ****************** S Roberts Rd BILL 851 97.05-2-4 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 700 4.47 Halicki Angeline M Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 700 3.71 10948 S Roberts Rd 9-11-14.2 700 Community Colleges 700 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.35 Town Tax 700 0.36 EAST-0953485 NRTH-0902588 Chargebacks 700 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 979 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 700 TO 1.24 WD058 Comprehensive Water 700 TO .36 TOTAL TAX --- 10.93** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 10.93 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-5.1 **************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 852 97.05-2-5.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 230 1.47 Murphy Clifford J Dunkirk Csd 060300 230 County Tax 230 1.22 Murphy Betsy A 9-11-2 230 Community Colleges 230 0.26 3724 New Rd FRNT 36.80 DPTH 304.80 Town Tax 230 0.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953590 NRTH-0902633 Chargebacks 230 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 322 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 230 TO .41 WD058 Comprehensive Water 230 TO .12 TOTAL TAX --- 3.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-5.2 **************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 853 97.05-2-5.2 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 25,730 164.45 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 25,730 136.43 Purol Bommie S 9-11-2 25,730 Community Colleges 25,730 28.67 3724 New Rd FRNT 126.30 DPTH 304.80 Town Tax 25,730 13.30 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953590 NRTH-0902633 Chargebacks 25,730 0.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 35,986 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 25,730 TO 45.72 WD058 Comprehensive Water 25,730 TO 13.16 TOTAL TAX --- 402.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 402.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-6 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 854 97.05-2-6 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Murphy Clifford 9-11-3 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 3730 New Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953719 NRTH-0902632 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 228 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-7 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 855 97.05-2-7 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 Murphy Clifford 9-11-4 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 3730 New Rd ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953792 NRTH-0902631 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-8 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 856 97.05-2-8 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 3724 New Rd 9-11-5 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0953872 NRTH-0902631 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-9 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 857 97.05-2-9 311 Res vac land Medicaid 500 3.20 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 County Tax 500 2.65 3724 New Rd 9-11-6 500 Community Colleges 500 0.56 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 500 0.26 EAST-0953954 NRTH-0902631 Chargebacks 500 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 500 TO .89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 500 TO .26 TOTAL TAX --- 7.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 7.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-10 ***************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 858 97.05-2-10 152 Vineyard Medicaid 3,200 20.45 Carter Lee R Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 3,200 16.97 3724 New Rd 9-11-7 3,200 Community Colleges 3,200 3.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 3,200 1.65 EAST-0954191 NRTH-0902629 Chargebacks 3,200 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,476 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,200 TO 5.69 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,200 TO 1.64 TOTAL TAX --- 50.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 50.03 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 229 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-11 ***************** New Rd BILL 859 97.05-2-11 152 Vineyard Medicaid 3,200 20.45 Carter Lee R Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,200 County Tax 3,200 16.97 3724 New Rd 9-11-8 3,200 Community Colleges 3,200 3.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.10 Town Tax 3,200 1.65 EAST-0954186 NRTH-0902400 Chargebacks 3,200 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,476 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,200 TO 5.69 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,200 TO 1.64 TOTAL TAX --- 50.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 50.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-12 ***************** 3709 New Rd BILL 860 97.05-2-12 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 56,950 363.98 Tippens Robert Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,100 County Tax 56,950 301.98 Tippens Elaine 9-16-11.2 56,950 Community Colleges 56,950 63.46 3709 New Rd FRNT 90.00 DPTH 250.50 Town Tax 56,950 29.44 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954376 NRTH-0902102 Chargebacks 56,950 1.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,650 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,950 TO 101.20 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,950 TO 29.12 TOTAL TAX --- 890.23** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 890.23 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-13 ***************** 3705 New Rd BILL 861 97.05-2-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,300 8.31 Ellman Todd Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,300 County Tax 1,300 6.89 Foley Jennifer L 9-16-11.1 1,300 Community Colleges 1,300 1.45 3705 New Rd FRNT 30.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 1,300 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954318 NRTH-0902103 Chargebacks 1,300 0.02 DEED BOOK 2125 PG-00427 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,300 TO 2.31 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,818 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,300 TO .66 TOTAL TAX --- 20.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 20.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-14 ***************** 3705 New Rd BILL 862 97.05-2-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 92,280 589.78 Ellman Todd Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 92,280 489.32 Foley Jennifer L 9-16-10 92,280 Community Colleges 92,280 102.83 3705 New Rd FRNT 120.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 92,280 47.70 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954243 NRTH-0902103 Chargebacks 92,280 1.71 DEED BOOK 2125 PG-00427 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 92,280 TO 163.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 129,063 WD058 Comprehensive Water 92,280 TO 47.19 TOTAL TAX --- 1,442.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,442.50 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 230 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-15 ***************** 3721 New Rd BILL 863 97.05-2-15 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 17,776 Lawrence John Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Lawrence Betty 9-16-21.2 54,000 Medicaid 49,000 313.17 3721 New Rd ACRES 0.69 County Tax 49,000 259.82 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954121 NRTH-0902105 Community Colleges 49,000 54.60 DEED BOOK 1982 PG-00127 Town Tax 36,224 18.72 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,524 Chargebacks 36,224 0.67 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 54,000 TO 95.95 WD058 Comprehensive Water 54,000 TO 27.61 TOTAL TAX --- 770.54** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 770.54 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-18 ***************** New Rd BILL 864 97.05-2-18 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 1,778 Knight Phyllis Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,600 VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 3725 New Rd 9-16-7 75,000 Medicaid 70,590 451.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.34 County Tax 70,590 374.31 EAST-0953940 NRTH-0902107 Community Colleges 70,590 78.66 FULL MARKET VALUE 104,895 Town Tax 73,222 37.85 Chargebacks 73,222 1.36 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 75,000 TO 133.27 WD058 Comprehensive Water 75,000 TO 38.35 TOTAL TAX --- 1,114.96** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,114.96 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-19 ***************** New Rd BILL 865 97.05-2-19 312 Vac w/imprv Medicaid 7,400 47.30 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,300 County Tax 7,400 39.24 3724 New Rd 9-11-9 7,400 Community Colleges 7,400 8.25 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 7,400 3.82 EAST-0953951 NRTH-0902403 Chargebacks 7,400 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,350 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,400 TO 13.15 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,400 TO 3.78 TOTAL TAX --- 115.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 115.68 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 231 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-20 ***************** 3724 New Rd BILL 866 97.05-2-20 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,311 Hudson-Carter Jennifer Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 3724 New Rd 9-11-10 66,230 Medicaid 58,880 376.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 County Tax 58,880 312.21 EAST-0953869 NRTH-0902404 Community Colleges 58,880 65.61 FULL MARKET VALUE 92,629 Town Tax 63,919 33.04 Chargebacks 63,919 1.18 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 66,230 TO 117.69 WD058 Comprehensive Water 66,230 TO 33.87 TOTAL TAX --- 939.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 939.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-21 ***************** New Rd BILL 867 97.05-2-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 14,200 90.76 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,100 County Tax 14,200 75.30 Murphy Clifford 9-11-11.1 14,200 Community Colleges 14,200 15.82 3730 New Rd FRNT 160.00 DPTH 93.00 Town Tax 14,200 7.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953821 NRTH-0902405 Chargebacks 14,200 0.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,860 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 14,200 TO 25.23 WD058 Comprehensive Water 14,200 TO 7.26 TOTAL TAX --- 221.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 221.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-22 ***************** 3730 New Rd BILL 868 97.05-2-22 210 1 Family Res VET COM C 41132 7,350 0 Murphy Clifford J Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,000 Medicaid 52,780 337.33 3730 New Rd 9-11-11.2 60,130 County Tax 52,780 279.87 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.51 Community Colleges 52,780 58.81 EAST-0953746 NRTH-0902366 Town Tax 60,130 31.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 84,098 Chargebacks 60,130 1.11 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 60,130 TO 106.85 WD058 Comprehensive Water 60,130 TO 30.75 TOTAL TAX --- 845.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 845.80 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 232 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-24 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 869 97.05-2-24 311 Res vac land Medicaid 200 1.28 Wojcinski Mark S Dunkirk Csd 060300 200 County Tax 200 1.06 Wojcinski Tani K 9-16-5 200 Community Colleges 200 0.22 10912 S Roberts Rd FRNT 60.00 DPTH 100.00 Town Tax 200 0.10 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953788 NRTH-0902034 Chargebacks 200 0.00 DEED BOOK 2632 PG-242 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 200 TO .36 FULL MARKET VALUE 280 WD058 Comprehensive Water 200 TO .10 TOTAL TAX --- 3.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-25 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 870 97.05-2-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,100 7.03 Wojcinski Mark S Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,100 County Tax 1,100 5.83 Wojcinski Tani K 9-16-21.4 1,100 Community Colleges 1,100 1.23 10912 S Roberts Rd FRNT 43.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 1,100 0.57 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953722 NRTH-0901961 Chargebacks 1,100 0.02 DEED BOOK 2632 PG-242 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,100 TO 1.95 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,538 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,100 TO .56 TOTAL TAX --- 17.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 17.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-26 ***************** 10912 S Roberts Rd BILL 871 97.05-2-26 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 56,000 357.91 Wojcinski Mark S Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,800 County Tax 56,000 296.94 Wojcinski Tani K 9-16-4 56,000 Community Colleges 56,000 62.40 10912 S Roberts Rd FRNT 55.00 DPTH 171.00 Town Tax 56,000 28.95 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953683 NRTH-0902013 Chargebacks 56,000 1.04 DEED BOOK 2632 PG-242 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,000 TO 99.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,322 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,000 TO 28.64 TOTAL TAX --- 875.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 875.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-27 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 872 97.05-2-27 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 27,000 172.56 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,000 County Tax 27,000 143.17 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-16-3 27,000 Community Colleges 27,000 30.09 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 54.00 DPTH 191.00 Town Tax 27,000 13.96 EAST-0953671 NRTH-0902071 Chargebacks 27,000 0.50 DEED BOOK 1812 PG-00183 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 27,000 TO 47.98 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,762 WD058 Comprehensive Water 27,000 TO 13.81 TOTAL TAX --- 422.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 422.07 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 233 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-28 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 873 97.05-2-28 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,200 7.67 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-16-2 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 54.00 DPTH 211.00 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 EAST-0953661 NRTH-0902119 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 DEED BOOK 1812 PG-00183 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-29 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 874 97.05-2-29 433 Auto body Medicaid 53,200 340.01 Halicki Rudolph Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,700 County Tax 53,200 282.10 10933 S Roberts Rd 9-16-1 53,200 Community Colleges 53,200 59.28 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 104.80 DPTH 231.00 Town Tax 53,200 27.50 EAST-0953646 NRTH-0902191 Chargebacks 53,200 0.98 FULL MARKET VALUE 74,406 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 53,200 TO 94.53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 53,200 TO 27.21 TOTAL TAX --- 831.61** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 831.61 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-30 ***************** New Rd BILL 875 97.05-2-30 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 43,000 274.82 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 43,000 228.01 Purol Bonnie 9-11-12.1 43,000 Community Colleges 43,000 47.92 10932 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.37 Town Tax 43,000 22.23 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953564 NRTH-0902357 Chargebacks 43,000 0.80 DEED BOOK 1662 PG-00162 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 43,000 TO 76.41 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 43,000 TO 21.99 TOTAL TAX --- 672.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 672.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-31 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 876 97.05-2-31 311 Res vac land Medicaid 300 1.92 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 300 1.59 Purol Bonnie 9-11-12.2 300 Community Colleges 300 0.33 10940 S Roberts Rd ACRES 0.07 Town Tax 300 0.16 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953489 NRTH-0902401 Chargebacks 300 0.01 DEED BOOK 1662 PG-00159 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300 TO .53 FULL MARKET VALUE 420 WD058 Comprehensive Water 300 TO .15 TOTAL TAX --- 4.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.69 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 234 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-32 ***************** New Rd BILL 877 97.05-2-32 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 Purol Bonnie 9-11-13.3 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 10932 S Roberts Rd FRNT 47.00 DPTH 108.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953640 NRTH-0902430 Chargebacks 100 0.00 DEED BOOK 1662 PG-00162 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-33.1 *************** S Roberts Rd BILL 878 97.05-2-33.1 311 Res vac land Medicaid 100 0.64 Roman Dorothy Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 County Tax 100 0.53 Murphy Clifford 9-11-13.1 100 Community Colleges 100 0.11 3730 New Rd FRNT 36.80 DPTH 113.00 Town Tax 100 0.05 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953600 NRTH-0902472 Chargebacks 100 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 100 TO .18 WD058 Comprehensive Water 100 TO .05 TOTAL TAX --- 1.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-33.2 *************** S Roberts Rd BILL 879 97.05-2-33.2 311 Res vac land Medicaid 300 1.92 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 300 County Tax 300 1.59 Purol Bonnie S 9-11-13.1 300 Community Colleges 300 0.33 Roman Dorothy FRNT 71.00 DPTH 138.00 Town Tax 300 0.16 3724 New Rd EAST-0953600 NRTH-0902472 Chargebacks 300 0.01 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FULL MARKET VALUE 420 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300 TO .53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 300 TO .15 TOTAL TAX --- 4.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4.69 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-2-34 ***************** S Roberts Rd BILL 880 97.05-2-34 210 1 Family Res VET WAR C 41122 4,410 0 Purol Richard A Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,300 Medicaid 52,090 332.92 Purol Bonnie 9-11-13.2 56,500 County Tax 52,090 276.21 10940 S Roberts Rd FRNT 122.00 DPTH 160.00 Community Colleges 52,090 58.04 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953472 NRTH-0902470 Town Tax 56,500 29.20 DEED BOOK 1662 PG-00159 Chargebacks 56,500 1.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 79,021 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 56,500 TO 100.40 WD058 Comprehensive Water 56,500 TO 28.89 TOTAL TAX --- 826.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 826.71 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 235 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-1 ****************** Haze Ave BILL 881 97.06-1-1 152 Vineyard Medicaid 1,000 6.39 Degolier Roy T III Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 County Tax 1,000 5.30 Degolier Madilynn H 9-12-1 1,000 Community Colleges 1,000 1.11 430 Park Ave FRNT 160.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 1,000 0.52 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954529 NRTH-0902625 Chargebacks 1,000 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,000 TO 1.78 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,000 TO .51 TOTAL TAX --- 15.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 15.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-2 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 882 97.06-1-2 152 Vineyard Medicaid 600 3.83 Carter Lee Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 3724 New Rd 9-12-2 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 600 0.31 EAST-0954641 NRTH-0902619 Chargebacks 600 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 WD058 Comprehensive Water 600 TO .31 TOTAL TAX --- 9.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-3 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 883 97.06-1-3 152 Vineyard Medicaid 600 3.83 Carter Lee Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 3724 New Rd 9-12-3 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 600 0.31 EAST-0954727 NRTH-0902618 Chargebacks 600 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 WD058 Comprehensive Water 600 TO .31 TOTAL TAX --- 9.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-4 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 884 97.06-1-4 557 Outdr sport Medicaid 42,800 273.54 South Shore Rod & Gun Club Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,400 County Tax 42,800 226.95 PO Box 648 9-12-4 42,800 Community Colleges 42,800 47.69 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 160.00 DPTH 225.00 Town Tax 42,800 22.12 EAST-0954845 NRTH-0902623 Chargebacks 42,800 0.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,860 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 42,800 TO 76.05 WD058 Comprehensive Water 42,800 TO 21.89 TOTAL TAX --- 669.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 669.03 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 236 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-5 ****************** New Rd BILL 885 97.06-1-5 152 Vineyard Medicaid 5,600 35.79 Carter Lee Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,600 County Tax 5,600 29.69 3724 New Rd 9-12-8 5,600 Community Colleges 5,600 6.24 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 5,600 2.89 EAST-0954816 NRTH-0902396 Chargebacks 5,600 0.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,832 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,600 TO 9.95 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,600 TO 2.86 TOTAL TAX --- 87.52** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 87.52 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-6 ****************** New Rd BILL 886 97.06-1-6 152 Vineyard Medicaid 600 3.83 Carter Lee R Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 County Tax 600 3.18 3724 New Rd 9-12-7 600 Community Colleges 600 0.67 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 600 0.31 EAST-0954972 NRTH-0902408 Chargebacks 600 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 600 TO 1.07 WD058 Comprehensive Water 600 TO .31 TOTAL TAX --- 9.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-7 ****************** New Rd BILL 887 97.06-1-7 152 Vineyard Medicaid 7,850 50.17 Carter Lee R Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 County Tax 7,850 41.62 3724 New Rd 9-12-6 7,850 Community Colleges 7,850 8.75 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 7,850 4.06 EAST-0955128 NRTH-0902408 Chargebacks 7,850 0.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,979 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,850 TO 13.95 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,850 TO 4.01 TOTAL TAX --- 122.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 122.71 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-8 ****************** Greenhurst Ave BILL 888 97.06-1-8 152 Vineyard Medicaid 2,600 16.62 Carter Lee R Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,600 County Tax 2,600 13.79 3724 New Rd 9-12-5 2,600 Community Colleges 2,600 2.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.70 Town Tax 2,600 1.34 EAST-0955080 NRTH-0902617 Chargebacks 2,600 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,636 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,600 TO 4.62 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,600 TO 1.33 TOTAL TAX --- 40.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 40.65 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 237 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-11 ***************** New Rd BILL 889 97.06-1-11 270 Mfg housing Medicaid 18,200 116.32 Grant Joseph M Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,700 County Tax 18,200 96.51 Fuller Sandra L 9-16-20 18,200 Community Colleges 18,200 20.28 3603 New Rd FRNT 129.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 18,200 9.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0956319 NRTH-0902089 Chargebacks 18,200 0.34 DEED BOOK 1843 PG-00289 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 18,200 TO 32.34 FULL MARKET VALUE 25,455 WD058 Comprehensive Water 18,200 TO 9.31 TOTAL TAX --- 284.51** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 284.51 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-12 ***************** New Rd BILL 890 97.06-1-12 270 Mfg housing Medicaid 21,530 137.60 Seekings Phillip Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,500 County Tax 21,530 114.16 3605 New Rd 9-16-21.3 21,530 Community Colleges 21,530 23.99 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 129.00 DPTH 302.00 Town Tax 21,530 11.13 EAST-0956316 NRTH-0901813 Chargebacks 21,530 0.40 DEED BOOK 2340 PG-165 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 21,530 TO 38.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,112 WD058 Comprehensive Water 21,530 TO 11.01 TOTAL TAX --- 336.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 336.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-13 ***************** New Rd BILL 891 97.06-1-13 311 Res vac land Medicaid 2,800 17.90 Seekings Phillip Jr Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,800 County Tax 2,800 14.85 3605 New Rd 9-16-21.5 2,800 Community Colleges 2,800 3.12 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.30 Town Tax 2,800 1.45 EAST-0956077 NRTH-0901898 Chargebacks 2,800 0.05 DEED BOOK 2340 PG-165 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,800 TO 4.98 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,916 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,800 TO 1.43 TOTAL TAX --- 43.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 43.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-14 ***************** 3607 New Rd BILL 892 97.06-1-14 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 31,380 200.56 Rosas Gilberto Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,100 County Tax 31,380 166.39 3607 New Rd 9-16-19 31,380 Community Colleges 31,380 34.97 PO Box 605 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 31,380 16.22 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0956165 NRTH-0902090 Chargebacks 31,380 0.58 FULL MARKET VALUE 43,888 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 31,380 TO 55.76 WD058 Comprehensive Water 31,380 TO 16.05 TOTAL TAX --- 490.53** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 490.53 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 238 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-15 ***************** New Rd BILL 893 97.06-1-15 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 27,500 175.76 Sprague Edward F Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,800 County Tax 27,500 145.82 3615 New Rd 9-16-18 27,500 Community Colleges 27,500 30.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 60.00 DPTH 250.50 Town Tax 27,500 14.21 EAST-0956073 NRTH-0902090 Chargebacks 27,500 0.51 DEED BOOK 2675 PG-159 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 27,500 TO 48.87 FULL MARKET VALUE 38,462 WD058 Comprehensive Water 27,500 TO 14.06 TOTAL TAX --- 429.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 429.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-16 ***************** New Rd BILL 894 97.06-1-16 270 Mfg housing P-RATA VET 41003 0 2,400 Snyder Margaret Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 VETS CNTY 41102 675 0 3619 New Rd 9-16-17 28,000 Medicaid 27,325 174.64 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.68 County Tax 27,325 144.89 EAST-0955985 NRTH-0902090 Community Colleges 27,325 30.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 39,161 Town Tax 25,600 13.23 Chargebacks 25,600 0.47 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 28,000 TO 49.75 WD058 Comprehensive Water 28,000 TO 14.32 TOTAL TAX --- 427.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 427.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-17 ***************** New Rd BILL 895 97.06-1-17 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 21,000 134.22 Way Victor D Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 21,000 111.35 3623 New Rd 9-16-16 21,000 Community Colleges 21,000 23.40 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 0.68 Town Tax 21,000 10.85 EAST-0955866 NRTH-0902091 Chargebacks 21,000 0.39 DEED BOOK 2680 PG-919 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 21,000 TO 37.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,371 WD058 Comprehensive Water 21,000 TO 10.74 TOTAL TAX --- 328.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 328.27 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 239 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-18 ***************** 3633 New Rd BILL 896 97.06-1-18 210 1 Family Res P-RATA VET 41003 0 5,000 Szukala Robert D Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,200 VETS CNTY 41102 5,000 0 Szukala Judith A 9-16-15.2 67,500 Medicaid 62,500 399.45 3633 New Rd ACRES 0.41 County Tax 62,500 331.41 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955735 NRTH-0902159 Community Colleges 62,500 69.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 94,406 Town Tax 62,500 32.31 Chargebacks 62,500 1.16 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 67,500 TO 119.94 WD058 Comprehensive Water 67,500 TO 34.52 TOTAL TAX --- 988.43** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 988.43 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-19 ***************** 3541 New Rd BILL 897 97.06-1-19 449 Other Storag Medicaid 50,100 320.20 Szukala Robert D Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,000 County Tax 50,100 265.66 Szukala Judith A 9-16-15.1 50,100 Community Colleges 50,100 55.83 3633 New Rd ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 50,100 25.90 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955622 NRTH-0902092 Chargebacks 50,100 0.93 DEED BOOK 1631 PG-00125 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 50,100 TO 89.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 70,070 WD058 Comprehensive Water 50,100 TO 25.62 TOTAL TAX --- 783.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 783.16 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-20 ***************** 3647 New Rd BILL 898 97.06-1-20 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 54,000 345.13 Federal National Mprtgage Asso Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 54,000 286.34 13455 Noel Rd Ste 6000 9-16-14 54,000 Community Colleges 54,000 60.17 Dallas, TX 72540 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 250.00 Town Tax 54,000 27.91 EAST-0955379 NRTH-0902094 Chargebacks 54,000 1.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 75,524 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 54,000 TO 95.95 WD058 Comprehensive Water 54,000 TO 27.61 TOTAL TAX --- 844.11** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 844.11 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-21 ***************** 3655 New Rd BILL 899 97.06-1-21 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 86,030 549.84 Rivera Ricardo Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 County Tax 86,030 456.18 Rivera Sonia 9-16-13 86,030 Community Colleges 86,030 95.86 3655 New Rd FRNT 120.00 DPTH 250.50 Town Tax 86,030 44.47 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0955258 NRTH-0902095 Chargebacks 86,030 1.59 DEED BOOK 2138 PG-00460 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 86,030 TO 152.87 FULL MARKET VALUE 120,322 WD058 Comprehensive Water 86,030 TO 43.99 TOTAL TAX --- 1,344.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,344.80 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 240 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-22 ***************** New Rd BILL 900 97.06-1-22 311 Res vac land Medicaid 9,900 63.27 Helwig Stephen Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 County Tax 9,900 52.50 1039 Central Ave 9-16-12.1 9,900 Community Colleges 9,900 11.03 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.60 Town Tax 9,900 5.12 EAST-0955006 NRTH-0902097 Chargebacks 9,900 0.18 DEED BOOK 1819 PG-00221 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,900 TO 17.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,846 WD058 Comprehensive Water 9,900 TO 5.06 TOTAL TAX --- 154.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 154.75 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-23 ***************** New Rd BILL 901 97.06-1-23 210 1 Family Res Medicaid 110,870 708.60 Purol Brian R Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,900 County Tax 110,870 587.89 Purol Jill M 9-16-12.2 110,870 Community Colleges 110,870 123.54 3681 New Rd ACRES 2.60 Town Tax 110,870 57.31 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954616 NRTH-0902100 Chargebacks 110,870 2.05 DEED BOOK 1815 PG-00292 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 110,870 TO 197.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 155,063 WD058 Comprehensive Water 110,870 TO 56.70 TOTAL TAX --- 1,733.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,733.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-24 ***************** New Rd BILL 902 97.06-1-24 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Degolier Roy T III Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 Degolier Madilynn H 9-12-9 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 430 Park Ave ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954559 NRTH-0902407 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,500 TO 2.67 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,500 TO .77 TOTAL TAX --- 23.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.46 ******************************************************************************************************* 97.06-1-25 ***************** New Rd BILL 903 97.06-1-25 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,500 9.59 Degolier Roy T Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,500 County Tax 1,500 7.95 Degolier Madilynn H 9-12-10 1,500 Community Colleges 1,500 1.67 430 Park Ave ACRES 0.41 Town Tax 1,500 0.78 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0954486 NRTH-0902413 Chargebacks 1,500 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,098 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,500 TO 2.67 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,500 TO .77 TOTAL TAX --- 23.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23.46 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 241 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-2 ***************** S Of Willow Rd BILL 904 900.00-2-2 733 Gas well Medicaid 4,520 28.89 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 4,520 23.97 KE Andrews Gas Well On 4-7-3 4,520 Community Colleges 4,520 5.04 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 11928 012876 Town Tax 4,520 2.34 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-2 Chargebacks 4,520 0.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,322 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 4,520 TO 9.56 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,520 TO 2.31 TOTAL TAX --- 72.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 72.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-4 ***************** 1000 Ft. S Middle Rd BILL 905 900.00-2-4 733 Gas well Medicaid 9,470 60.52 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 9,470 50.22 KE Andrews Gas Well On 7-7-13 9,470 Community Colleges 9,470 10.55 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 11806 012876 Town Tax 9,470 4.89 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-4 Chargebacks 9,470 0.18 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,245 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,470 TO 16.83 WD005 Urban wtr1 9,470 TO C 9.44 TOTAL TAX --- 152.63** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 152.63 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-5 ***************** 3200 Ft. S Of Middle Rd BILL 906 900.00-2-5 733 Gas well Medicaid 11,830 75.61 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 11,830 62.73 KE Andrews Gas Well On 7-7-13 11,830 Community Colleges 11,830 13.18 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 11807 012876 Town Tax 11,830 6.11 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-5 Chargebacks 11,830 0.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,545 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 11,830 TO 21.02 WD005 Urban wtr1 11,830 TO C 11.79 TOTAL TAX --- 190.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 190.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-6 ***************** 1100 Ft. Sw Of Roberts Ro BILL 907 900.00-2-6 733 Gas well Medicaid 630 4.03 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 630 3.34 KE Andrews Gas Well On 11-1-7 630 Community Colleges 630 0.70 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 11802 012876 Town Tax 630 0.33 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-6 Chargebacks 630 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 881 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 630 TO 1.12 WD058 Comprehensive Water 630 TO .32 TOTAL TAX --- 9.85** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9.85 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 242 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-7 ***************** N Urban Rd BILL 908 900.00-2-7 733 Gas well Medicaid 6,870 43.91 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 6,870 36.43 KE Andrews Gas Well On 7-5-2 6,870 Community Colleges 6,870 7.66 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 18804 012876 Town Tax 6,870 3.55 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-7 Chargebacks 6,870 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,608 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,870 TO 12.21 WD005 Urban wtr1 6,870 TO C 6.85 TOTAL TAX --- 110.74** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 110.74 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-8 ***************** N Urban Rd BILL 909 900.00-2-8 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Empire Energy USA LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 KE Andrews Gas Well On 7-5-2 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 100 Dalrock Rd Dec 11805 012876 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-8 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO WD005 Urban wtr1 0 TO C TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-9 ***************** W Of Bennett Rd BILL 910 900.00-2-9 733 Gas well Medicaid 8,360 53.43 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 8,360 44.33 K E Andrews Gas Well On 10-2-13.1 8,360 Community Colleges 8,360 9.32 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 11800 012876 Town Tax 8,360 4.32 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-9 Chargebacks 8,360 0.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,692 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,360 TO 14.86 SW001 Bennett road water 8,360 TO C 8.29 TOTAL TAX --- 134.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 134.70 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-10 **************** N Of Williams BILL 911 900.00-2-10 733 Gas well Medicaid 5,610 35.85 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 5,610 29.75 K E Andrews Gas Well On 9-14-10.1 5,610 Community Colleges 5,610 6.25 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 11801 020276 Town Tax 5,610 2.90 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-10 Chargebacks 5,610 0.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,846 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,610 TO 9.97 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,610 TO 2.87 TOTAL TAX --- 87.69** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 87.69 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 243 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-12 **************** W Of Temple BILL 912 900.00-2-12 733 Gas well Medicaid 5,190 33.17 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 5,190 27.52 K E Andrews Gas Well On 4-4-2 5,190 Community Colleges 5,190 5.78 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 11929 061176 Town Tax 5,190 2.68 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-12 Chargebacks 5,190 0.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,259 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,190 TO 10.98 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,190 TO 2.65 TOTAL TAX --- 82.88** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 82.88 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-13 **************** N Of Urban BILL 913 900.00-2-13 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 K E Andrews Gas Well On 7-5-4 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12134 070576 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-13 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO WD005 Urban wtr1 0 TO C TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-16 **************** S Of Route 5 BILL 914 900.00-2-16 733 Gas well Medicaid 13,570 86.73 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 13,570 71.96 K E Andrews Gas Well On 1-12-1.2 13,570 Community Colleges 13,570 15.12 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12169 080676 Town Tax 13,570 7.01 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-16 Chargebacks 13,570 0.25 FULL MARKET VALUE 18,979 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 13,570 TO 28.71 SW002 Shorewood water 13,570 TO C 1.06 TOTAL TAX --- 210.84** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 210.84 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-17 **************** W Of Brigham Rd BILL 915 900.00-2-17 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 K E Andrews Gas Well On 5-2-6.1 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12175 080676 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-17 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO WD058 Comprehensive Water 0 TO TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 244 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-18 **************** N Of Route 5 BILL 916 900.00-2-18 733 Gas well Medicaid 11,340 72.48 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 11,340 60.13 K E Andrews Gas Well On 2-1-8 11,340 Community Colleges 11,340 12.64 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12168 080676 Town Tax 11,340 5.86 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-18 Chargebacks 11,340 0.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 15,860 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,340 TO 23.99 SW002 Shorewood water 11,340 TO C .88 TOTAL TAX --- 176.19** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 176.19 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-19 **************** N Of Route 5 BILL 917 900.00-2-19 733 Gas well Medicaid 14,020 89.61 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 14,020 74.34 K E Andrews Gas Well On 2-1-8 14,020 Community Colleges 14,020 15.62 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12167 080676 Town Tax 14,020 7.25 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-19 Chargebacks 14,020 0.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 19,608 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 14,020 TO 29.66 SW002 Shorewood water 14,020 TO C 1.09 TOTAL TAX --- 217.83** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 217.83 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-22 **************** Chestnut Rd BILL 918 900.00-2-22 733 Gas well Medicaid 4,200 26.84 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 4,200 22.27 K E Andrews Gas Well On 4-5-5 4,200 Community Colleges 4,200 4.68 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12171 080676 Town Tax 4,200 2.17 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-22 Chargebacks 4,200 0.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 4,200 TO 8.89 WD058 Comprehensive Water 4,200 TO 2.15 TOTAL TAX --- 67.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 67.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-23 **************** S Of Route 5 BILL 919 900.00-2-23 733 Gas well Medicaid 42,460 271.37 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 42,460 225.15 K E Andrews Gas Well On 3-3-5.1 42,460 Community Colleges 42,460 47.31 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12198 080676 Town Tax 42,460 21.95 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-23 Chargebacks 42,460 0.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 59,385 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 42,460 TO 89.84 SW002 Shorewood water 42,460 TO C 3.30 TOTAL TAX --- 659.71** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 659.71 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 245 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-25 **************** W Of City Line BILL 920 900.00-2-25 733 Gas well Medicaid 27,010 172.63 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 27,010 143.22 K E Andrews Gas Well On 3-7-4 27,010 Community Colleges 27,010 30.10 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12173 080676 Town Tax 27,010 13.96 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-25 Chargebacks 27,010 0.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 37,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 27,010 TO 57.15 WD058 Comprehensive Water 27,010 TO 13.81 TOTAL TAX --- 431.37** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 431.37 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-26 **************** E Of Brigham Rd BILL 921 900.00-2-26 733 Gas well Medicaid 10,330 66.02 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 10,330 54.78 K E Andrews Gas Well On 5-3-8 10,330 Community Colleges 10,330 11.51 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12174 080676 Town Tax 10,330 5.34 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-2-26 Chargebacks 10,330 0.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,448 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 10,330 TO 21.86 WD058 Comprehensive Water 10,330 TO 5.28 TOTAL TAX --- 164.98** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 164.98 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-2-39 **************** E Of Wilbur Rd BILL 922 900.00-2-39 733 Gas well Medicaid 7,170 45.83 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 7,170 38.02 K E Andrews Gas Well On 2-5-8 7,170 Community Colleges 7,170 7.99 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12170 081878 Town Tax 7,170 3.71 Rowlett, TX 75088 900.00-2-39 Sam Chargebacks 7,170 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,028 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,170 TO 15.17 SW002 Shorewood water 7,170 TO C .56 TOTAL TAX --- 111.41** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 111.41 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-3-37 **************** N Of Route 5 BILL 923 900.00-3-37 733 Gas well Medicaid 10,280 65.70 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 10,280 54.51 K E Andrews Gas Well On 3-1-1.1 10,280 Community Colleges 10,280 11.46 1900 Darlock Rd Dec 12717 061377 Town Tax 10,280 5.31 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-3-37 Bolling 1 Chargebacks 10,280 0.19 FULL MARKET VALUE 14,378 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 10,280 TO 21.75 SW002 Shorewood water 10,280 TO C .80 TOTAL TAX --- 159.72** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 159.72 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 246 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-17-41 *************** W Of Swamp Rd BILL 924 900.00-17-41 733 Gas well Medicaid 890 5.69 Chautauqua Energy Fredonia 065801 0 County Tax 890 4.72 PO Box 100 Gas Well On 11-4-2 890 Community Colleges 890 0.99 Westfield, NY 14787 Dec 13711 & 13712 Town Tax 890 0.46 900-17-41 Chargebacks 890 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,245 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 890 TO 1.58 WD058 Comprehensive Water 890 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 13.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-17-45 *************** N Of Kelpien BILL 925 900.00-17-45 733 Gas well Medicaid 890 5.69 Chautauqua Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 890 4.72 PO Box 100 Gas Well On 9-7-6 890 Community Colleges 890 0.99 Westfield, NY 14787 Dec 022379 Town Tax 890 0.46 900-17-45 Chargebacks 890 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,245 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 890 TO 1.58 WD058 Comprehensive Water 890 TO .46 TOTAL TAX --- 13.92** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13.92 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-17-48 *************** N Of Route 5 BILL 926 900.00-17-48 733 Gas well Medicaid 30,840 197.11 U S Energy Development Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 30,840 163.53 2350 N Forest Rd Gas Well On 12-1-29 30,840 Community Colleges 30,840 34.37 Getzville, NY 14068 Dec 14834 Town Tax 30,840 15.94 900-17-48 Chargebacks 30,840 0.57 FULL MARKET VALUE 43,133 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 30,840 TO 54.80 WD058 Comprehensive Water 30,840 TO 15.77 TOTAL TAX --- 482.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 482.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-17-49 *************** N Of Route 5 BILL 927 900.00-17-49 733 Gas well Medicaid 7,670 49.02 Empire Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 7,670 40.67 K E Andrews Gas Well On 12-1-29 7,670 Community Colleges 7,670 8.55 1900 Dalrock Rd Dec 14835 011480 Town Tax 7,670 3.96 Rowlett, TX 75088 900-17-49 Koprowski 2 Chargebacks 7,670 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,727 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,670 TO 13.63 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,670 TO 3.92 TOTAL TAX --- 119.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 119.89 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 247 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-27-46 *************** W Of Temple Rd BILL 928 900.00-27-46 733 Gas well Medicaid 130 0.83 J M Resources Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 130 0.69 Route 60 Gas Well On 3-5-4 130 Community Colleges 130 0.14 Box 390 Dec 13237 031279 Town Tax 130 0.07 Cassadaga, NY 14718 900-27-46 Chargebacks 130 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 182 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 130 TO .28 SW002 Shorewood water 130 TO C .01 TOTAL TAX --- 2.02** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2.02 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-31-34 *************** S Of Williams BILL 929 900.00-31-34 733 Gas well Medicaid 1,180 7.54 Gas Field Specialists Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 1,180 6.26 2107 SR 44S Gas Well On 9-15-1 1,180 Community Colleges 1,180 1.31 PO Box 679 Dec 12702 031577 Town Tax 1,180 0.61 Shinglehouse, PA 16748 Dach 1 Chargebacks 1,180 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,650 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,180 TO 2.10 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,180 TO .60 TOTAL TAX --- 18.44** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.44 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-31-35 *************** E Of Bennett Rd BILL 930 900.00-31-35 733 Gas well Medicaid 130 0.83 Gas Field Specialists Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 130 0.69 2107 SR 44S Gas Well On 10-3-11 130 Community Colleges 130 0.14 PO Box 697 Dec 12701 032977 Town Tax 130 0.07 Shinglehouse, PA 16748 900-31-35 Stranz 1 Chargebacks 130 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 182 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 130 TO .23 SW001 Bennett road water 130 TO C .13 TOTAL TAX --- 2.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2.09 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-32-38 *************** W Of Bennett Rd BILL 931 900.00-32-38 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 20 Bliss St Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 61 East Main St 10-2-1 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Westfield, NY 14787 31-013-12837 062777 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 900-32-38 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO SW001 Bennett road water 0 TO C TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 248 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-32-39 *************** Joy #2 BILL 932 900.00-32-39 733 Gas well Medicaid 5,630 35.98 20 Bliss St Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 5,630 29.85 61 E Main St Gas Well 5,630 Community Colleges 5,630 6.27 Westfield, NY 14787 Joy #2 Town Tax 5,630 2.91 11985 Chargebacks 5,630 0.10 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,874 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,630 TO 11.91 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,630 TO 2.88 TOTAL TAX --- 89.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 89.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-33-47 *************** N Of Route 5 BILL 933 900.00-33-47 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 GH Graf Realty Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 PO Box 241 Gas Well On 2-1-1 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 Dec 13958 042779 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 900-33-47 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO SW002 Shorewood water 0 TO C TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-34-1 **************** N Of Middle Rd BILL 934 900.00-34-1 733 Gas well Medicaid 4,640 29.66 Eclipse Mgt Assoc Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 4,640 24.60 1983 Marcus Ave Gas Well On 6-4-4 4,640 Community Colleges 4,640 5.17 Lake Success, NY 11042 Dec 13753 Town Tax 4,640 2.40 900-34-1 Chargebacks 4,640 0.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,490 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,640 TO 8.24 WD005 Urban wtr1 4,640 TO C 4.62 TOTAL TAX --- 74.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 74.78 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-35-1 **************** S Of Williams BILL 935 900.00-35-1 733 Gas well Medicaid 880 5.62 Gas Field Specialists Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 880 4.67 2107 SR 44S Gas Well On 10-3-2 880 Community Colleges 880 0.98 PO Box 679 Dec 12394 Town Tax 880 0.45 Shinglehouse, PA 16748 Millitello 1 Chargebacks 880 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,231 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 880 TO 1.56 SW001 Bennett road water 880 TO C .87 TOTAL TAX --- 14.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 14.17 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 249 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-35-2 **************** N Of Williams BILL 936 900.00-35-2 733 Gas well Medicaid 1,190 7.61 Gas Field Specialists Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 1,190 6.31 2107 SR 44S Gas Well On 8-2-22.1 1,190 Community Colleges 1,190 1.33 PO Box 679 Dec 12218 Town Tax 1,190 0.62 Shinglehouse, PA 16748 Geiben 2 Chargebacks 1,190 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,664 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,190 TO 2.11 SW001 Bennett road water 1,190 TO C 1.18 TOTAL TAX --- 19.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 19.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-35-3 **************** E Of Roberts Rd BILL 937 900.00-35-3 733 Gas well Medicaid 2,120 13.55 Gas Field Specialists Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 2,120 11.24 2107 SR 44S Gas Well On 9-16-22 2,120 Community Colleges 2,120 2.36 PO Box 679 Dec 12165 Town Tax 2,120 1.10 Shinglehouse, PA 16748 Kraiger 1 Chargebacks 2,120 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,965 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,120 TO 3.77 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,120 TO 1.08 TOTAL TAX --- 33.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 33.14 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-90-44 *************** N Of Vineyard Dr BILL 938 900.00-90-44 733 Gas well Medicaid 29,900 191.10 Kasturi Properties LTD Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 29,900 158.55 3912 Vineyard Dr Gas Well On 10-5-4 29,900 Community Colleges 29,900 33.32 Dunkirk, NY 14048 Dec 12955 011079 Town Tax 29,900 15.45 900-90-44 Chargebacks 29,900 0.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,818 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 29,900 TO 53.13 LD011 Vineyard lt1 29,900 TO 3.22 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 29,900 TO C 2.15 TOTAL TAX --- 457.47** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 457.47 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-91-31 *************** S Of Route 5 BILL 939 900.00-91-31 733 Gas well Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Edgewood Investments Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 5248 West Lake Rd Gas Well On 6-1-4 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 Dec 12655 021477 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 900-91-31 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO WD058 Comprehensive Water 0 TO TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 250 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-92-1 **************** Conference Grounds BILL 940 900.00-92-1 733 Gas well Medicaid 12,430 79.44 Terra Energy Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 12,430 65.91 13692 Cobalt Ct Gas Well On 13-2-1 12,430 Community Colleges 12,430 13.85 Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91739 Dec 20323 Town Tax 12,430 6.42 900-92-1 Chargebacks 12,430 0.23 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,385 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12,430 TO 22.09 WD058 Comprehensive Water 12,430 TO 6.36 TOTAL TAX --- 194.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 194.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-93-1 **************** Kozmer #1 BILL 941 900.00-93-1 733 Gas well Medicaid 8,620 55.09 Cotton Well Drilling Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 8,620 45.71 Center Rd Gas Well On 1-4-6.1 8,620 Community Colleges 8,620 9.61 PO Box 203 Dec 13975 Town Tax 8,620 4.46 Sheridan, NY 14135 Kozmeri Chargebacks 8,620 0.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,056 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,620 TO 18.24 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,620 TO 4.41 TOTAL TAX --- 137.68** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 137.68 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-94-1 **************** Pietrol BILL 942 900.00-94-1 733 Gas well Medicaid 2,660 17.00 US Energy Development Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 2,660 14.10 2350 N Forest Rd Gas Well 2,660 Community Colleges 2,660 2.96 Getzville, NY 14068 Pietro 1 Town Tax 2,660 1.37 3101313615 Chargebacks 2,660 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,720 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,660 TO 4.73 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,660 TO 1.36 TOTAL TAX --- 41.57** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 41.57 ******************************************************************************************************* 900.00-94-2 **************** Manuel BILL 943 900.00-94-2 733 Gas well Medicaid 390 2.49 US Energy Development Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 390 2.07 2350 N Forest Rd Gas Well 390 Community Colleges 390 0.43 Getzville, NY 14068 Manuel Town Tax 390 0.20 3101313627 Chargebacks 390 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 545 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 390 TO .69 WD058 Comprehensive Water 390 TO .20 TOTAL TAX --- 6.09** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6.09 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 251 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX OT001 Omitted Tax-Dn 1 MOVTAX 544.49 544.49 544.49 WD058 Comprehensive 329 TOTAL 9383,960 5,800 9378,160 4,795.89 FP008 W dunk fire pr 391 TOTAL 29392,570 5,800 29386,770 62,175.34 FP009 E dnk fire pro 552 TOTAL 70130,876 70130,876 124,616.78 GE001 Miscellaneous 14 MOVTAX 3,593.72 3,593.72 3,593.72 LD011 Vineyard lt1 39 TOTAL 29265,606 1450,498 27815,108 2,996.86 SD023 East lake rd s 11 FEE 11.00 11.00 275.00 SD024 East lake rd s 70 UNITS 120.50 120.50 9,108.32 SW001 Bennett road w 104 TOTAL C 4963,210 4963,210 4,923.48 SW002 Shorewood wate 295 TOTAL C 25701,570 25701,570 1,999.61 US001 Unpaid sewer 24 MOVTAX 10,663.43 10,663.43 10,663.43 WD005 Urban wtr1 57 TOTAL C 2949,490 2949,490 2,939.10 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 3 TOTAL C 14659,210 1692,533 12966,677 3,000.00 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 39 TOTAL C 29265,606 1450,498 27815,108 1,996.90 WD024 E lake rd ind 4 TOTAL C 3862,000 3862,000 11,801.00 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 923 24560,950 98913,256 6968,151 91,945,105 060300 10900,050 81,045,055 Fredonia 20 202,100 610,190 69,820 540,370 065801 110,250 430,120 S U B - T O T A L 943 24763,050 99523,446 7037,971 92,485,475 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 11010,300 81,475,175 T O T A L 943 24763,050 99523,446 7037,971 92,485,475 T O T A L (CONT) 11010,300 81,475,175

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 252 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 18020 IND DEVEL 1 3300,000 3300,000 41003 P-RATA VET 45 366,651 41102 VETS CNTY 35 89,950 41103 VETS T 1 17,776 41111 VETERAN EX 1 5,000 5,000 41121 VET WAR CT 1 4,410 8,820 41122 VET WAR C 27 123,480 41131 VET COM CT 2 14,700 29,400 41132 VET COM C 30 220,500 41141 VET DIS CT 2 29,400 39,630 41142 VET DIS C 6 67,046 41162 CW_15_VET/ 1 4,410 41700 AG BLDG 1 6,410 6,410 41720 AG DIST 13 104,610 104,610 41730 AG COMMIT 28 356,170 356,170 41802 AGED C 1 19,295 41805 AGED C/S 4 115,775 42120 GREENHOUSE 1 5,800 5,800 47610 BUSINV 897 4 3143,031 3143,031 T O T A L 204 7609,987 7383,298

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 253 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 587,440.37 County Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 487,374.94 Community Colleges 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 102,419.48 Town Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 47,625.49 Chargebacks 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 1,705.50 SPEC DIST TAXES 245,429.92 1 TAXABLE 943 1471,995.70

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 254 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX OT001 Omitted Tax-Dn 1 MOVTAX 544.49 544.49 544.49 WD058 Comprehensive 329 TOTAL 9383,960 5,800 9378,160 4,795.89 FP008 W dunk fire pr 391 TOTAL 29392,570 5,800 29386,770 62,175.34 FP009 E dnk fire pro 552 TOTAL 70130,876 70130,876 124,616.78 GE001 Miscellaneous 14 MOVTAX 3,593.72 3,593.72 3,593.72 LD011 Vineyard lt1 39 TOTAL 29265,606 1450,498 27815,108 2,996.86 SD023 East lake rd s 11 FEE 11.00 11.00 275.00 SD024 East lake rd s 70 UNITS 120.50 120.50 9,108.32 SW001 Bennett road w 104 TOTAL C 4963,210 4963,210 4,923.48 SW002 Shorewood wate 295 TOTAL C 25701,570 25701,570 1,999.61 US001 Unpaid sewer 24 MOVTAX 10,663.43 10,663.43 10,663.43 WD005 Urban wtr1 57 TOTAL C 2949,490 2949,490 2,939.10 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 3 TOTAL C 14659,210 1692,533 12966,677 3,000.00 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 39 TOTAL C 29265,606 1450,498 27815,108 1,996.90 WD024 E lake rd ind 4 TOTAL C 3862,000 3862,000 11,801.00 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 923 24560,950 98913,256 6968,151 91,945,105 060300 10900,050 81,045,055 Fredonia 20 202,100 610,190 69,820 540,370 065801 110,250 430,120 S U B - T O T A L 943 24763,050 99523,446 7037,971 92,485,475 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 11010,300 81,475,175 T O T A L 943 24763,050 99523,446 7037,971 92,485,475 T O T A L (CONT) 11010,300 81,475,175

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 255 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 18020 IND DEVEL 1 3300,000 3300,000 41003 P-RATA VET 45 366,651 41102 VETS CNTY 35 89,950 41103 VETS T 1 17,776 41111 VETERAN EX 1 5,000 5,000 41121 VET WAR CT 1 4,410 8,820 41122 VET WAR C 27 123,480 41131 VET COM CT 2 14,700 29,400 41132 VET COM C 30 220,500 41141 VET DIS CT 2 29,400 39,630 41142 VET DIS C 6 67,046 41162 CW_15_VET/ 1 4,410 41700 AG BLDG 1 6,410 6,410 41720 AG DIST 13 104,610 104,610 41730 AG COMMIT 28 356,170 356,170 41802 AGED C 1 19,295 41805 AGED C/S 4 115,775 42120 GREENHOUSE 1 5,800 5,800 47610 BUSINV 897 4 3143,031 3143,031 T O T A L 204 7609,987 7383,298

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 256 COUNTY - Chautauqua T A X A B L E SECTION OF THE ROLL - 1 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 587,440.37 County Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 487,374.94 Community Colleges 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 102,419.48 Town Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 47,625.49 Chargebacks 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 1,705.50 SPEC DIST TAXES 245,429.92 1 TAXABLE 943 1471,995.70

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 257 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 11-1-11..SF1 *************** BILL 944 11-1-11..SF1 869 Television Medicaid 99,243 634.28 Time Warner Cable-DTS Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 99,243 526.24 PO Box 7467 Special Franchise 99,243 Community Colleges 99,243 110.59 Charlotte, NC 28241 Dunkirk City School Town Tax 99,243 51.30 11-1-11..SF1 Chargebacks 99,243 1.84 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 103,041 TO 218.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 138,801 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 103,040 TO 183.09 TOTAL TAX --- 1,725.35** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,725.35 ******************************************************************************************************* 33-3-33..SF1 *************** BILL 945 33-3-33..SF1 866 Telephone Medicaid 1,394 8.91 Dunkirk & FredoniaTelephone Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 1,394 7.39 Accounts Payable Special Franchise 1,394 Community Colleges 1,394 1.55 PO Box 209 Dunkirk Central School Town Tax 1,394 0.72 Fredonia, NY 14063-0209 33-3-33..SF1 Chargebacks 1,394 0.03 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,394 TO 2.48 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,950 TOTAL TAX --- 21.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 33-3-33..SF2 *************** BILL 946 33-3-33..SF2 866 Telephone Medicaid 182,455 1,166.11 Dunkirk & Fredonia Telephone Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 182,455 967.48 Accounts Payable 33-3-33..SF2 182,455 Community Colleges 182,455 203.31 PO Box 209 BANK 999999 Town Tax 182,455 94.31 Fredonia, NY 14063 FULL MARKET VALUE 255,182 Chargebacks 182,455 3.38 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 182,455 TO 324.21 TOTAL TAX --- 2,758.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,758.80 ******************************************************************************************************* 55-5-55..SF1 *************** BILL 947 55-5-55..SF1 866 Telephone Medicaid 141,277 902.93 Verizon New York Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 141,277 749.13 PO Box 152206 Special Franchise 141,277 Community Colleges 141,277 157.43 Irving, TX 75015-2206 Dunkirk City School Town Tax 141,277 73.02 55-5-55..SF1 Chargebacks 141,277 2.62 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 140,330 TO 296.90 FULL MARKET VALUE 197,590 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 140,330 TO 249.35 TOTAL TAX --- 2,431.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,431.38 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 258 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 66-6-66..SF1 *************** BILL 948 66-6-66..SF1 866 Telephone Medicaid 445,384 2,846.55 Natl Fuel Gas Dist Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 445,384 2,361.67 Real Property Tax Special Franchise 445,384 Community Colleges 445,384 496.29 6363 Main St Dunkirk City School Town Tax 445,384 230.21 Williamsville, NY 14221 66-6-66..SF1 Chargebacks 445,384 8.24 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 222,692 TO 471.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 622,915 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 222,692 TO 395.70 TOTAL TAX --- 6,809.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,809.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..SF1 *************** BILL 949 77-7-77..SF1 866 Telephone Medicaid 600,655 3,838.92 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 600,655 3,185.00 Real Estate Tax Dept Special Franchise 600,655 Community Colleges 600,655 669.31 300 Erie Blvd Dunkirk City School Town Tax 600,655 310.47 Syracuse, NY 13202 77-7-77..SF1 Chargebacks 600,655 11.12 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 300,328 TO 635.42 FULL MARKET VALUE 840,077 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 300,328 TO 533.66 TOTAL TAX --- 9,183.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 9,183.90 ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF1 *************** BILL 950 99-9-99..SF1 866 Telephone Medicaid 0.00 0.00 A T & T Interstate Division Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Property Tax Dept Special Franchise 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 PO Box 7207 Dunkirk City School Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Bedminster, NJ 07921-7207 99-9-99..SF1 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF3 *************** Town Of Dunkirk BILL 951 99-9-99..SF3 866 Telephone Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Broadwing Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Property Tax Dept Special Franchise 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 1025 Eldorado Blvd Rm 102-840 99-9-99..SF3 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Broomfield, CO 80021 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 259 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF6 *************** NYS Thruway BILL 952 99-9-99..SF6 866 Telephone Medicaid 19,795 126.51 Global Crossing N America Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 19,795 104.96 Property Tax Dept 99-9-99..SF6 19,795 Community Colleges 19,795 22.06 1025 Eldorado Blvd BANK 999999 Town Tax 19,795 10.23 Broomfield, CO 80021 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,685 Chargebacks 19,795 0.37 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 9,898 TO 20.94 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 9,898 TO 17.59 TOTAL TAX --- 302.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 302.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF7 *************** NYS Thruway BILL 953 99-9-99..SF7 866 Telephone Medicaid 90,129 576.04 Qwest Communications Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 90,129 477.91 1801 California St Ste 250 99-9-99..SF7 90,129 Community Colleges 90,129 100.43 Denver, CO 80202 BANK 999999 Town Tax 90,129 46.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 126,055 Chargebacks 90,129 1.67 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 45,065 TO 95.35 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 45,065 TO 80.08 TOTAL TAX --- 1,378.07** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,378.07 ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF8 *************** NYS Thruway BILL 954 99-9-99..SF8 866 Telephone Medicaid 22,962 146.76 Broadwing Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 22,962 121.76 Property Tax 99-9-99..SF8 22,962 Community Colleges 22,962 25.59 1025 Eldorado Blvd BANK 999999 Town Tax 22,962 11.87 Broomfield, CO 80021 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,115 Chargebacks 22,962 0.43 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,481 TO 24.29 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 11,481 TO 20.40 TOTAL TAX --- 351.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 351.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF9 *************** BILL 955 99-9-99..SF9 866 Telephone Medicaid 2,130 13.61 Intellifiber Networks Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 2,130 11.29 PO Box 2629 Special Franchise 2,130 Community Colleges 2,130 2.37 Addison, TX 75001 99-9-99..SF9 Town Tax 2,130 1.10 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 2,130 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,979 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 1,065 TO 2.25 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,065 TO 1.89 TOTAL TAX --- 32.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 32.55 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 260 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF10 ************** BILL 956 99-9-99..SF10 866 Telephone Medicaid 38,031 243.06 WilTel Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 38,031 201.66 Property Tax Dept 99-9-99..SF10 38,031 Community Colleges 38,031 42.38 1025 Eldorado Blvd BANK 999999 Town Tax 38,031 19.66 Broomfielf, CO 80021 FULL MARKET VALUE 53,190 Chargebacks 38,031 0.70 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 19,016 TO 40.23 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 19,016 TO 33.79 TOTAL TAX --- 581.48** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 581.48 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 261 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX FP008 W dunk fire pr 11 TOTAL 852,916 852,916 1,804.55 FP009 E dnk fire pro 13 TOTAL 1036,764 1036,764 1,842.24 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 13 1643,455 1,643,455 060300 1,643,455 S U B - T O T A L 13 1643,455 1,643,455 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 1,643,455 T O T A L 13 1643,455 1,643,455 T O T A L (CONT) 1,643,455 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 262 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 1643,455 1,643,455 10,503.68 County Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 8,714.49 Community Colleges 1643,455 1,643,455 1,831.31 Town Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 849.48 Chargebacks 1643,455 1,643,455 30.44 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,646.79 5 SPECIAL FRANCHISE 13 25,576.19

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 263 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX FP008 W dunk fire pr 11 TOTAL 852,916 852,916 1,804.55 FP009 E dnk fire pro 13 TOTAL 1036,764 1036,764 1,842.24 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 13 1643,455 1,643,455 060300 1,643,455 S U B - T O T A L 13 1643,455 1,643,455 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 1,643,455 T O T A L 13 1643,455 1,643,455 T O T A L (CONT) 1,643,455 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 264 COUNTY - Chautauqua SPECIAL FRANCHISE SECTION OF THE ROLL - 5 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 1643,455 1,643,455 10,503.68 County Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 8,714.49 Community Colleges 1643,455 1,643,455 1,831.31 Town Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 849.48 Chargebacks 1643,455 1,643,455 30.44 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,646.79 5 SPECIAL FRANCHISE 13 25,576.19

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 265 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 9-6-16..E ****************** Temple Rd BILL 957 9-6-16..E 883 Gas Trans Impr Medicaid 11,766 75.20 National Fuel Gas Dist Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,680 County Tax 11,766 62.39 Attn: Real Property Tax Station Dkrm 12P 11,766 Community Colleges 11,766 13.11 6363 Mian St 9-6-16..E Town Tax 11,766 6.08 Williamsville, NY 14221 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 11,766 0.22 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,456 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 11,766 TO 24.89 TOTAL TAX --- 181.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 181.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 9-16-6..A ****************** BILL 958 9-16-6..A 883 Gas Trans Impr Medicaid 866,935 5,540.78 National Fuel Gas Dist Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,800 County Tax 866,935 4,596.96 6363 Main St Distribution Mains 866,935 Community Colleges 866,935 966.03 Williamsville, NY 14221 9-16-6..A Town Tax 866,935 448.10 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 866,935 16.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 1212,497 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 277,419 TO 586.95 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 589,516 TO 1,047.52 TOTAL TAX --- 13,202.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 13,202.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 33-3-33..PS2 *************** BILL 959 33-3-33..PS2 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 2,714 17.35 Dunkirk & Fredonia Telephone Fredonia 065801 0 County Tax 2,714 14.39 Accounts Payable Outside Plant 2,714 Community Colleges 2,714 3.02 PO Box 209 33-3-33..PS2 Town Tax 2,714 1.40 Fredonia, NY 14063-0209 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 2,714 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,796 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,714 TO 4.82 TOTAL TAX --- 41.03** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 41.03 ******************************************************************************************************* 55-5-55..PS1 *************** BILL 960 55-5-55..PS1 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 36,831 235.40 Verizon Wireless Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 36,831 195.30 PO Box 2549 55-5-55..PS1 36,831 Community Colleges 36,831 41.04 Addison, TX 75001 BANK 999999 Town Tax 36,831 19.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 51,512 Chargebacks 36,831 0.68 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 18,416 TO 38.96 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 18,415 TO 32.72 TOTAL TAX --- 563.14** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 563.14 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 266 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 55-5-55..PS3 *************** BILL 961 55-5-55..PS3 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 135,380 865.24 Verizon Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 135,380 717.86 PO Box 152206 Outside Plant 135,380 Community Colleges 135,380 150.85 Irving, TX 75015-2206 55-5-55..PS3 Town Tax 135,380 69.98 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 135,380 2.51 FULL MARKET VALUE 189,343 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 67,690 TO 143.22 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 67,690 TO 120.28 TOTAL TAX --- 2,069.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2,069.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 66-6-66..PS1 *************** BILL 962 66-6-66..PS1 835 Cable tv Medicaid 129,718 829.06 Time Warner Cable-DTS Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 129,718 687.84 PO Box 7467 66-6-66..PS1 129,718 Community Colleges 129,718 144.55 Charlotte, NC 28241 BANK 999999 Town Tax 129,718 67.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 181,424 Chargebacks 129,718 2.40 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 64,859 TO 137.23 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 64,859 TO 115.25 TOTAL TAX --- 1,983.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,983.38 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS1 *************** 712003 Nmp BILL 963 77-7-77..PS1 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 86,856 555.12 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 86,856 460.56 300 Erie Blvd West Erie-Dunkirk T-Line 86,856 Community Colleges 86,856 96.78 Syracuse, NY 13202 #68 Town Tax 86,856 44.89 77-7-77..PS1 Chargebacks 86,856 1.61 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 86,856 TO 154.34 FULL MARKET VALUE 121,477 TOTAL TAX --- 1,313.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,313.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS2 *************** BILL 964 77-7-77..PS2 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 336,520 2,150.78 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 336,520 1,784.41 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Gardenville-Dunkirk 336,520 Community Colleges 336,520 374.99 Syracuse, NY 13202 #73 & 74 Town Tax 336,520 173.94 77-7-77..PS2 Chargebacks 336,520 6.23 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 336,520 TO 597.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 470,657 TOTAL TAX --- 5,088.32** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 5,088.32 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 267 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS3 *************** BILL 965 77-7-77..PS3 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 304,232 1,944.42 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 304,232 1,613.20 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Dunkirk-Falconer 304,232 Community Colleges 304,232 339.01 Syracuse, NY 13202 #161 & 162 Town Tax 304,232 157.25 77-7-77..PS3 Chargebacks 304,232 5.63 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 304,232 TO 540.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 425,499 TOTAL TAX --- 4,600.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 4,600.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS4 *************** BILL 966 77-7-77..PS4 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 35,764 228.58 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 35,764 189.64 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Gardenville-Dunkirk 35,764 Community Colleges 35,764 39.85 Syracuse, NY 13202 #141 & 142 Town Tax 35,764 18.49 77-7-77..PS4 Chargebacks 35,764 0.66 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 35,764 TO 63.55 FULL MARKET VALUE 50,020 TOTAL TAX --- 540.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 540.77 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS5 *************** BILL 967 77-7-77..PS5 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 12,001 76.70 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 12,001 63.64 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Roberts Rd Tap 12,001 Community Colleges 12,001 13.37 Syracuse, NY 13202 #161 & #162 Town Tax 12,001 6.20 77-7-77..PS5 Chargebacks 12,001 0.22 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 12,001 TO 21.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 16,785 TOTAL TAX --- 181.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 181.45 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS6 *************** BILL 968 77-7-77..PS6 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 22,658 144.81 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 22,658 120.15 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Willowbrook Brigham 22,658 Community Colleges 22,658 25.25 Syracuse, NY 13202 #164 Town Tax 22,658 11.71 77-7-77..PS6 Chargebacks 22,658 0.42 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 22,658 TO 47.94 FULL MARKET VALUE 31,690 TOTAL TAX --- 350.28** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 350.28 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 268 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS7 *************** BILL 969 77-7-77..PS7 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 40,005 255.68 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 40,005 212.13 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Dunkirk Falconer 40,005 Community Colleges 40,005 44.58 Syracuse, NY 13202 Line 160 Town Tax 40,005 20.68 77-7-77..PS7 Chargebacks 40,005 0.74 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 40,005 TO 84.64 FULL MARKET VALUE 55,951 TOTAL TAX --- 618.45** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 618.45 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS8 *************** BILL 970 77-7-77..PS8 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 15,581 99.58 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 15,581 82.62 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Dunkirk-Hartfield 15,581 Community Colleges 15,581 17.36 Syracuse, NY 13202 #852 Town Tax 15,581 8.05 77-7-77..PS8 Chargebacks 15,581 0.29 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 15,581 TO 32.97 FULL MARKET VALUE 21,792 TOTAL TAX --- 240.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 240.87 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS9 *************** BILL 971 77-7-77..PS9 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 35,255 225.32 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 35,255 186.94 300 Erie Blvd West Tran Dunkirk-West 35,255 Community Colleges 35,255 39.28 Syracuse, NY 13202 Portland #851 Town Tax 35,255 18.22 77-7-77..PS9 Chargebacks 35,255 0.65 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 35,255 TO 74.59 FULL MARKET VALUE 49,308 TOTAL TAX --- 545.00** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 545.00 ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS12 ************** BILL 972 77-7-77..PS12 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 239,304 1,529.45 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 239,304 1,268.92 300 Erie Blvd West Sub Brigham Rd Sub #64 239,304 Community Colleges 239,304 266.66 Syarcuse, NY 13202 77-7-77..PS12 Town Tax 239,304 123.69 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 239,304 4.43 FULL MARKET VALUE 334,691 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 239,304 TO 506.31 TOTAL TAX --- 3,699.46** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,699.46 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 269 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 77-7-77..PS13 ************** BILL 973 77-7-77..PS13 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 541,403 3,460.23 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 541,403 2,870.81 300 Erie Blvd West Sub Bennett Rd Substation 541,403 Community Colleges 541,403 603.29 Syracuse, NY 13202 77-7-77..PS13 Town Tax 541,403 279.84 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 541,403 10.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 757,207 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 541,403 TO 962.03 TOTAL TAX --- 8,186.22** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8,186.22 ******************************************************************************************************* 78.04-1-4 ****************** BILL 974 78.04-1-4 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 5,040 32.21 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,040 County Tax 5,040 26.72 Real Estate Tax Dept 3-3-4 5,040 Community Colleges 5,040 5.62 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 2.10 BANK 999999 Town Tax 5,040 2.61 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0940271 NRTH-0903370 Chargebacks 5,040 0.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,049 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 5,040 TO 10.66 SW002 Shorewood water 5,040 TO C .39 TOTAL TAX --- 78.30** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 78.30 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-13 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 975 80.01-1-13 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 8,400 53.69 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 County Tax 8,400 44.54 Real Estate Tax Dept Non Trans 8,400 Community Colleges 8,400 9.36 300 Erie Blvd 6-3-3 Town Tax 8,400 4.34 Syracuse, NY 14202 ACRES 3.50 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 8,400 0.16 EAST-0955130 NRTH-0908683 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 8,400 TO 14.93 DEED BOOK 2113 PG-00240 WD005 Urban wtr1 8,400 TO C 8.37 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,748 TOTAL TAX --- 135.39** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 135.39 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-39 ***************** Urban Rd BILL 976 80.01-1-39 311 Res vac land Medicaid 3,900 24.93 Timmerman Paul H Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,900 County Tax 3,900 20.68 108 Seymore St Non Trans 3,900 Community Colleges 3,900 4.35 Fredonia, NY 14063 7-2-4.2.1 Town Tax 3,900 2.02 ACRES 6.50 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 3,900 0.07 EAST-0953261 NRTH-0907732 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,900 TO 6.93 DEED BOOK 1974 PG-00329 WD005 Urban wtr1 3,900 TO C 3.89 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,455 TOTAL TAX --- 62.87** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 62.87 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 270 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-40 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 977 80.01-1-40 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 17,300 110.57 CSX-New York Central Lines Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,000 County Tax 17,300 91.73 Property Tax Dept Non Trans 17,300 Community Colleges 17,300 19.28 500 Water St J-910 7-2-4.3 Town Tax 17,300 8.94 Jacksonville, FL 32202 FRNT 100.00 DPTH 400.00 Chargebacks 17,300 0.32 ACRES 0.92 BANK 999999 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 17,300 TO 30.74 EAST-0952698 NRTH-0907475 WD005 Urban wtr1 17,300 TO C 17.24 DEED BOOK 1800 PG-00240 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,196 TOTAL TAX --- 278.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 278.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-41 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 978 80.01-1-41 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 18,800 120.16 CSX- New York Central Lines Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,000 County Tax 18,800 99.69 Property Tax Dept Non Trans 18,800 Community Colleges 18,800 20.95 500 Water St J-910 7-2-4.2.2 Town Tax 18,800 9.72 Jacksonville, FL 32202 ACRES 1.00 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 18,800 0.35 EAST-0952774 NRTH-0907593 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 18,800 TO 33.41 DEED BOOK 1800 PG-00240 WD005 Urban wtr1 18,800 TO C 18.73 FULL MARKET VALUE 26,294 TOTAL TAX --- 303.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 303.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-42 ***************** Middle Rd BILL 979 80.01-1-42 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 3,360 21.47 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,360 County Tax 3,360 17.82 Real Estate Tax Dept Non Trans 3,360 Community Colleges 3,360 3.74 300 Erie Blvd 7-2-3 Town Tax 3,360 1.74 Syracuse, NY 14202 ACRES 1.40 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 3,360 0.06 EAST-0953012 NRTH-0907794 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,360 TO 5.97 DEED BOOK 2113 PG-00240 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,699 TOTAL TAX --- 50.80** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 50.80 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 271 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-1 ****************** BILL 980 80.03-3-1 800 Public Service Medicaid 6,240 39.88 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,240 County Tax 6,240 33.09 Real Estate Tax Dept Formerly 80.03-2-1 6,240 Community Colleges 6,240 6.95 300 Erie Blvd 7-5-1 Town Tax 6,240 3.23 Syracuse, NY 13202 ACRES 2.60 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 6,240 0.12 EAST-0952493 NRTH-0905702 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,240 TO 11.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,727 WD005 Urban wtr1 6,240 TO C 6.22 TOTAL TAX --- 100.58** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 100.58 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.03-3-28 ***************** BILL 981 80.03-3-28 800 Public Service Medicaid 29,568 188.98 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 29,568 County Tax 29,568 156.79 Real Estate Tax Dept Formerly 80.03-2-28 29,568 Community Colleges 29,568 32.95 300 Erie Blvd 9-6-1 Town Tax 29,568 15.28 Syracuse, NY 13202 ACRES 12.32 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 29,568 0.55 EAST-0954612 NRTH-0903949 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 29,568 TO 52.54 FULL MARKET VALUE 41,354 WD058 Comprehensive Water 29,568 TO 15.12 TOTAL TAX --- 462.21** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 462.21 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-6 ****************** BILL 982 80.17-1-6 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 2,088 13.34 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,088 County Tax 2,088 11.07 Real Estate Tax Dept 7-7-1 2,088 Community Colleges 2,088 2.33 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.87 BANK 999999 Town Tax 2,088 1.08 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0952668 NRTH-0904348 Chargebacks 2,088 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,920 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,088 TO 3.71 WD005 Urban wtr1 2,088 TO C 2.08 TOTAL TAX --- 33.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 33.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-13 ***************** BILL 983 80.17-1-13 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 1,200 7.67 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 County Tax 1,200 6.36 Real Estate Tax Dept 9-5-1 1,200 Community Colleges 1,200 1.34 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.50 BANK 999999 Town Tax 1,200 0.62 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0952580 NRTH-0903945 Chargebacks 1,200 0.02 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,200 TO 2.13 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,200 TO .61 TOTAL TAX --- 18.75** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 18.75 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 272 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-16 ***************** BILL 984 80.17-1-16 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 1,920 12.27 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,920 County Tax 1,920 10.18 Real Estate Tax Dept 9-5-5 1,920 Community Colleges 1,920 2.14 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.80 BANK 999999 Town Tax 1,920 0.99 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0952643 NRTH-0903634 Chargebacks 1,920 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,685 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,920 TO 3.41 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,920 TO .98 TOTAL TAX --- 30.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 30.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 95-9-95..PS1 *************** Town Of Dunkirk BILL 985 95-9-95..PS1 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Us Sprint Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Attn: Property Tax Dept Town Of Dunkirk 0 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 PO Box 12913 Us Sprint Cable Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Shawnee Mission, KS 66212 95-9-95..PS1 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 BANK 999999 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95-9-95..PS2 *************** BILL 986 95-9-95..PS2 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 83,823 535.73 AT&T Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 83,823 444.48 PO Box 7207 95-9-95..PS2 83,823 Community Colleges 83,823 93.40 Bedminster, NJ 07921-7207 BANK 999999 Town Tax 83,823 43.33 FULL MARKET VALUE 117,235 Chargebacks 83,823 1.55 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 41,912 TO 88.68 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 41,911 TO 74.47 TOTAL TAX --- 1,281.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,281.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 95-9-95..PS3 *************** BILL 987 95-9-95..PS3 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 242,900 1,552.43 Level 3 Communications Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 242,900 1,287.99 Attn: Property Tax Cable In Rr Right Of Way 242,900 Community Colleges 242,900 270.66 1025 Eldorado Blvd 95-9-95..PS3 Town Tax 242,900 125.55 Broomfield, CO 80021-1901 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 242,900 4.50 FULL MARKET VALUE 339,720 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 121,450 TO 256.96 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 121,450 TO 215.81 TOTAL TAX --- 3,713.90** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3,713.90 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 273 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-17 ***************** BILL 988 95.02-1-17 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 17,352 110.90 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 17,352 County Tax 17,352 92.01 Real Estate Tax Dept 3-6-4 17,352 Community Colleges 17,352 19.34 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 7.23 BANK 999999 Town Tax 17,352 8.97 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0940183 NRTH-0902681 Chargebacks 17,352 0.32 FULL MARKET VALUE 24,269 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 17,352 TO 36.71 WD058 Comprehensive Water 17,352 TO 8.87 TOTAL TAX --- 277.12** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 277.12 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-19 ***************** BILL 989 95.02-1-19 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 20,832 133.14 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,832 County Tax 20,832 110.46 Real Estate Tax Dept 3-7-3 20,832 Community Colleges 20,832 23.21 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 8.68 BANK 999999 Town Tax 20,832 10.77 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0940241 NRTH-0901353 Chargebacks 20,832 0.39 FULL MARKET VALUE 29,136 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 20,832 TO 44.08 WD058 Comprehensive Water 20,832 TO 10.65 TOTAL TAX --- 332.70** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 332.70 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-25 ***************** BILL 990 95.02-1-25 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 3,840 24.54 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,840 County Tax 3,840 20.36 Real Estate Tax Dept 4-3-1 3,840 Community Colleges 3,840 4.28 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.60 BANK 999999 Town Tax 3,840 1.98 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0938064 NRTH-0899895 Chargebacks 3,840 0.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,371 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,840 TO 8.12 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,840 TO 1.96 TOTAL TAX --- 61.31** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 61.31 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-27 ***************** BILL 991 95.02-1-27 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 33,384 213.36 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 33,384 County Tax 33,384 177.02 Real Estate Tax Dept 3-7-1 33,384 Community Colleges 33,384 37.20 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 13.91 BANK 999999 Town Tax 33,384 17.26 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0939107 NRTH-0901137 Chargebacks 33,384 0.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,691 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 33,384 TO 70.63 WD058 Comprehensive Water 33,384 TO 17.07 TOTAL TAX --- 533.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 533.16 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 274 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-28 ***************** BILL 992 95.02-1-28 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 57,800 369.41 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 51,600 County Tax 57,800 306.49 Property Taxation Non Trans 57,800 Community Colleges 57,800 64.41 110 Franklin Road SE 3-6-3 Town Tax 57,800 29.88 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 ACRES 4.30 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 57,800 1.07 EAST-0938924 NRTH-0901194 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 57,800 TO 122.29 FULL MARKET VALUE 80,839 TOTAL TAX --- 893.55** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 893.55 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-12 ***************** BILL 993 95.04-1-12 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 50,000 319.56 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 43,200 County Tax 50,000 265.13 Property Taxation Non Trans 50,000 Community Colleges 50,000 55.72 110 Franklin Road SE 4-2-3 Town Tax 50,000 25.84 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 ACRES 3.60 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 50,000 0.93 EAST-0937209 NRTH-0899149 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 50,000 TO 105.79 FULL MARKET VALUE 69,930 TOTAL TAX --- 772.97** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 772.97 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-13 ***************** BILL 994 95.04-1-13 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 21,744 138.97 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 21,744 County Tax 21,744 115.30 Real Estate Tax Dept 4-4-1 21,744 Community Colleges 21,744 24.23 300 Erie Blvd W ACRES 9.06 BANK 999999 Town Tax 21,744 11.24 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0937396 NRTH-0899138 Chargebacks 21,744 0.40 FULL MARKET VALUE 30,411 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 21,744 TO 46.01 WD058 Comprehensive Water 21,744 TO 11.12 TOTAL TAX --- 347.27** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 347.27 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-23 ***************** BILL 995 95.04-1-23 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 8,000 51.13 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,000 County Tax 8,000 42.42 Real Estate Tax Dept 4-5-1 8,000 Community Colleges 8,000 8.91 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 3.40 BANK 999999 Town Tax 8,000 4.14 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0936705 NRTH-0898152 Chargebacks 8,000 0.15 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,189 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,000 TO 16.93 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,000 TO 4.09 TOTAL TAX --- 127.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 127.77 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 275 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-48 ***************** BILL 996 95.04-1-48 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 33,423 213.61 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 33,423 County Tax 33,423 177.23 Real Estate Tax Dept 2-3-1 33,423 Community Colleges 33,423 37.24 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 13.93 BANK 999999 Town Tax 33,423 17.28 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0935698 NRTH-0897173 Chargebacks 33,423 0.62 FULL MARKET VALUE 46,745 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 33,423 TO 70.72 SW001 Bennett road water 33,423 TO C 33.16 TOTAL TAX --- 549.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 549.86 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-49 ***************** BILL 997 95.04-1-49 843 Non-ceil. rr Medicaid 69,600 444.83 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 44,400 County Tax 69,600 369.06 Property Taxation Non Trans 69,600 Community Colleges 69,600 77.56 110 Franklin Road SE 2-2-3 Town Tax 69,600 35.97 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 ACRES 3.70 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 69,600 1.29 EAST-0935581 NRTH-0897215 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 69,600 TO 147.26 FULL MARKET VALUE 97,343 WD058 Comprehensive Water 69,600 TO 35.59 TOTAL TAX --- 1,111.56** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,111.56 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-1 ****************** BILL 998 96.01-2-1 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 3,168 20.25 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,168 County Tax 3,168 16.80 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-2-3.2 3,168 Community Colleges 3,168 3.53 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.32 BANK 999999 Town Tax 3,168 1.64 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0941813 NRTH-0899961 Chargebacks 3,168 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,431 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 3,168 TO 6.70 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,168 TO 1.62 TOTAL TAX --- 50.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 50.60 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.01-2-10 ***************** BILL 999 96.01-2-10 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 2,112 13.50 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,112 County Tax 2,112 11.20 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-3-6 2,112 Community Colleges 2,112 2.35 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.88 BANK 999999 Town Tax 2,112 1.09 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0944405 NRTH-0899904 Chargebacks 2,112 0.04 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,954 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,112 TO 4.47 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,112 TO 1.08 TOTAL TAX --- 33.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 33.73 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 276 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-1 ****************** BILL 1000 96.02-1-1 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 563,765 3,603.15 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 563,765 2,989.39 Real Estate Tax Dept Bennett Rd Ss 99 563,765 Community Colleges 563,765 628.21 300 Erie Blvd 8-1-2 Town Tax 563,765 291.40 Syracuse, NY 13202 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 563,765 10.44 EAST-0948894 NRTH-0902447 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 140,941 TO 298.20 FULL MARKET VALUE 788,483 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 422,824 TO 751.32 LD011 Vineyard lt1 29,180 TO 3.14 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 29,180 TO C 2.09 TOTAL TAX --- 8,577.34** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8,577.34 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-15 ***************** BILL 1001 96.02-1-15 311 Res vac land Medicaid 1,400 8.95 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,400 County Tax 1,400 7.42 Attn: Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-7 1,400 Community Colleges 1,400 1.56 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.00 BANK 999999 Town Tax 1,400 0.72 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0950796 NRTH-0902536 Chargebacks 1,400 0.03 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,958 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 1,400 TO 2.49 WD058 Comprehensive Water 1,400 TO .72 TOTAL TAX --- 21.89** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 21.89 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-23 ***************** BILL 1002 96.02-1-23 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 2,884 18.43 National Grid Fredonia 065801 2,884 County Tax 2,884 15.29 Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-20.2 2,884 Community Colleges 2,884 3.21 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 2.06 BANK 999999 Town Tax 2,884 1.49 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0951258 NRTH-0902371 Chargebacks 2,884 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,034 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,884 TO 5.12 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,884 TO 1.47 TOTAL TAX --- 45.06** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 45.06 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-26 ***************** BILL 1003 96.02-1-26 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 3,120 19.94 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,120 County Tax 3,120 16.54 Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-14 3,120 Community Colleges 3,120 3.48 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.30 BANK 999999 Town Tax 3,120 1.61 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0951657 NRTH-0902488 Chargebacks 3,120 0.06 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,364 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,120 TO 5.54 WD058 Comprehensive Water 3,120 TO 1.60 TOTAL TAX --- 48.77** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 48.77 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 277 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-34 ***************** BILL 1004 96.02-1-34 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 2,928 18.71 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,928 County Tax 2,928 15.53 Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-22.2 2,928 Community Colleges 2,928 3.26 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.22 BANK 999999 Town Tax 2,928 1.51 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0950743 NRTH-0902278 Chargebacks 2,928 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,095 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 2,928 TO 5.20 SW001 Bennett road water 2,928 TO C 2.90 TOTAL TAX --- 47.16** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 47.16 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-35 ***************** BILL 1005 96.02-1-35 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 140 0.89 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 140 County Tax 140 0.74 Attn: Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-22.4 140 Community Colleges 140 0.16 300 Erie Blvd BANK 999999 Town Tax 140 0.07 Syracuse, NY 14202 EAST-0950577 NRTH-0902369 Chargebacks 140 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 196 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 140 TO .25 WD058 Comprehensive Water 140 TO .07 TOTAL TAX --- 2.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 2.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-36 ***************** Bennett Rd BILL 1006 96.02-1-36 330 Vacant comm Medicaid 28,800 184.07 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 28,800 County Tax 28,800 152.71 Attn: Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-29.2 28,800 Community Colleges 28,800 32.09 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 2.40 BANK 999999 Town Tax 28,800 14.89 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0949837 NRTH-0902375 Chargebacks 28,800 0.53 FULL MARKET VALUE 40,280 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 28,800 TO 51.18 SW001 Bennett road water 28,800 TO C 28.57 TOTAL TAX --- 464.04** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 464.04 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-37 ***************** BILL 1007 96.02-1-37 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 5,040 32.21 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,040 County Tax 5,040 26.72 Real Estate Tax Dept 8-2-28 5,040 Community Colleges 5,040 5.62 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 2.10 BANK 999999 Town Tax 5,040 2.61 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0949854 NRTH-0902286 Chargebacks 5,040 0.09 FULL MARKET VALUE 7,049 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 5,040 TO 8.96 WD058 Comprehensive Water 5,040 TO 2.58 TOTAL TAX --- 78.79** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 78.79 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 278 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-48 ***************** BILL 1008 96.02-1-48 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 7,630 48.77 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,630 County Tax 7,630 40.46 Real Estate Tax Dept 8-1-12 7,630 Community Colleges 7,630 8.50 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 5.45 BANK 999999 Town Tax 7,630 3.94 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0948584 NRTH-0901872 Chargebacks 7,630 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,671 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,630 TO 13.56 SW001 Bennett road water 7,630 TO C 7.57 TOTAL TAX --- 122.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 122.94 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-2 ****************** BILL 1009 96.03-3-2 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 45,600 291.44 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 45,600 County Tax 45,600 241.80 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-2-2 45,600 Community Colleges 45,600 50.81 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 19.00 BANK 999999 Town Tax 45,600 23.57 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0941558 NRTH-0898578 Chargebacks 45,600 0.84 FULL MARKET VALUE 63,776 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 45,600 TO 96.48 WD058 Comprehensive Water 45,600 TO 23.32 TOTAL TAX --- 728.26** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 728.26 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-7 ****************** BILL 1010 96.03-3-7 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 26,400 168.73 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 26,400 County Tax 26,400 139.99 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-3-11.2 26,400 Community Colleges 26,400 29.42 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 11.40 BANK 999999 Town Tax 26,400 13.65 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0943434 NRTH-0898202 Chargebacks 26,400 0.49 FULL MARKET VALUE 36,923 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 26,400 TO 55.86 WD058 Comprehensive Water 26,400 TO 13.50 TOTAL TAX --- 421.64** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 421.64 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-21 ***************** BILL 1011 96.03-3-21 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 2,616 16.72 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,616 County Tax 2,616 13.87 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-6-6.2 2,616 Community Colleges 2,616 2.92 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.09 BANK 999999 Town Tax 2,616 1.35 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0942100 NRTH-0896591 Chargebacks 2,616 0.05 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,659 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 2,616 TO 5.53 WD058 Comprehensive Water 2,616 TO 1.34 TOTAL TAX --- 41.78** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 41.78 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 279 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-22 ***************** BILL 1012 96.03-3-22 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 7,680 49.08 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,680 County Tax 7,680 40.72 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-6-5 7,680 Community Colleges 7,680 8.56 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 3.20 BANK 999999 Town Tax 7,680 3.97 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0941827 NRTH-0896573 Chargebacks 7,680 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,741 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,680 TO 16.25 WD058 Comprehensive Water 7,680 TO 3.93 TOTAL TAX --- 122.65** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 122.65 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-32 ***************** BILL 1013 96.03-3-32 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 700 4.47 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 700 County Tax 700 3.71 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-2-7 700 Community Colleges 700 0.78 300 Erie Blvd BANK 999999 Town Tax 700 0.36 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0942255 NRTH-0898132 Chargebacks 700 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 979 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 700 TO 1.48 WD058 Comprehensive Water 700 TO .36 TOTAL TAX --- 11.17** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 11.17 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-33 ***************** BILL 1014 96.03-3-33 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 8,880 56.75 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,880 County Tax 8,880 47.09 Real Estate Tax Dept 5-2-6.2 8,880 Community Colleges 8,880 9.90 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 3.70 BANK 999999 Town Tax 8,880 4.59 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0942064 NRTH-0898232 Chargebacks 8,880 0.16 FULL MARKET VALUE 12,420 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 8,880 TO 18.79 WD058 Comprehensive Water 8,880 TO 4.54 TOTAL TAX --- 141.82** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 141.82 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-29 ***************** BILL 1015 96.04-1-29 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 7,200 46.02 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,200 County Tax 7,200 38.18 Real Estate Tax Dept 10-6-1.2 7,200 Community Colleges 7,200 8.02 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 3.00 BANK 999999 Town Tax 7,200 3.72 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0949091 NRTH-0896245 Chargebacks 7,200 0.13 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,070 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 7,200 TO 12.79 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 7,200 TO C .52 TOTAL TAX --- 109.38** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 109.38 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 280 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-36 ***************** Vineyard Dr BILL 1016 96.04-1-36 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 6,720 42.95 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,720 County Tax 6,720 35.63 Real Estate Tax Dept 10-5-1.2 6,720 Community Colleges 6,720 7.49 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 2.80 BANK 999999 Town Tax 6,720 3.47 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0948852 NRTH-0896817 Chargebacks 6,720 0.12 FULL MARKET VALUE 9,399 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 6,720 TO 11.94 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 6,720 TO C .48 TOTAL TAX --- 102.08** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 102.08 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-57 ***************** BILL 1017 96.04-1-57 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 528 3.37 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 528 County Tax 528 2.80 Real Estate Tax Dept 10-2-15 528 Community Colleges 528 0.59 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.22 BANK 999999 Town Tax 528 0.27 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0948498 NRTH-0897434 Chargebacks 528 0.01 FULL MARKET VALUE 738 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 528 TO .94 SW001 Bennett road water 528 TO C .52 TOTAL TAX --- 8.50** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 8.50 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-58 ***************** BILL 1018 96.04-1-58 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 3,600 23.01 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,600 County Tax 3,600 19.09 Real Estate Tax Dept 10-2-14.2 3,600 Community Colleges 3,600 4.01 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 1.50 BANK 999999 Town Tax 3,600 1.86 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0948506 NRTH-0897667 Chargebacks 3,600 0.07 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,035 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 3,600 TO 6.40 SW001 Bennett road water 3,600 TO C 3.57 TOTAL TAX --- 58.01** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 58.01 ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-59 ***************** BILL 1019 96.04-1-59 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 240 1.53 National Grid Dunkirk Csd 060300 240 County Tax 240 1.27 Real Estate Tax Dept 10-2-13.2 240 Community Colleges 240 0.27 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 0.11 BANK 999999 Town Tax 240 0.12 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0948444 NRTH-0897932 Chargebacks 240 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 336 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 240 TO .43 SW001 Bennett road water 240 TO C .24 TOTAL TAX --- 3.86** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 3.86 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 281 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-12 ***************** BILL 1020 97.03-1-12 882 Elec Trans Imp Medicaid 82,080 524.59 National Grid Fredonia 065801 82,080 County Tax 82,080 435.23 Real Estate Tax Dept 11-4-15 82,080 Community Colleges 82,080 91.46 300 Erie Blvd ACRES 34.20 BANK 999999 Town Tax 82,080 42.43 Syracuse, NY 13202 EAST-0954149 NRTH-0897356 Chargebacks 82,080 1.52 FULL MARKET VALUE 114,797 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 82,080 TO 145.85 WD058 Comprehensive Water 82,080 TO 41.97 TOTAL TAX --- 1,283.05** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,283.05 ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..PS1 *************** South Of Rt 5 BILL 1021 99-9-99..PS1 831 Tele Comm Medicaid 97,150 620.91 Crown Atlantic LLC Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 County Tax 97,150 515.14 PMB353 Tower And Antenna 97,150 Community Colleges 97,150 108.25 4017 Washington Rd 99-9-99..PS1 Town Tax 97,150 50.21 McMurray, PA 15317 BANK 999999 Chargebacks 97,150 1.80 FULL MARKET VALUE 135,874 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 97,150 TO 172.63 TOTAL TAX --- 1,468.94** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 1,468.94 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 282 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX WD058 Comprehensive 24 TOTAL 399,260 399,260 204.16 FP008 W dunk fire pr 32 TOTAL 1515,427 1515,427 3,206.30 FP009 E dnk fire pro 39 TOTAL 2988,391 2988,391 5,310.13 LD011 Vineyard lt1 1 TOTAL 29,180 29,180 3.14 SW001 Bennett road w 7 TOTAL C 77,149 77,149 76.53 SW002 Shorewood wate 1 TOTAL C 5,040 5,040 .39 WD005 Urban wtr1 6 TOTAL C 56,728 56,728 56.53 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 3 TOTAL C 43,100 43,100 3.09 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 62 541,473 4416,140 4,416,140 060300 4,416,140 Fredonia 3 84,964 87,678 87,678 065801 87,678 S U B - T O T A L 65 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 4,503,818 T O T A L 65 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 T O T A L (CONT) 4,503,818

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 283 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 28,784.92 County Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 23,881.70 Community Colleges 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 5,018.64 Town Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 2,327.93 Chargebacks 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 83.37 SPEC DIST TAXES 8,860.27 6 UTILITIES & N.C. 65 68,956.83

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 284 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX WD058 Comprehensive 24 TOTAL 399,260 399,260 204.16 FP008 W dunk fire pr 32 TOTAL 1515,427 1515,427 3,206.30 FP009 E dnk fire pro 39 TOTAL 2988,391 2988,391 5,310.13 LD011 Vineyard lt1 1 TOTAL 29,180 29,180 3.14 SW001 Bennett road w 7 TOTAL C 77,149 77,149 76.53 SW002 Shorewood wate 1 TOTAL C 5,040 5,040 .39 WD005 Urban wtr1 6 TOTAL C 56,728 56,728 56.53 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 3 TOTAL C 43,100 43,100 3.09 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 62 541,473 4416,140 4,416,140 060300 4,416,140 Fredonia 3 84,964 87,678 87,678 065801 87,678 S U B - T O T A L 65 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 4,503,818 T O T A L 65 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 T O T A L (CONT) 4,503,818

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 285 COUNTY - Chautauqua UTILITY & R.R. SECTION OF THE ROLL - 6 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 28,784.92 County Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 23,881.70 Community Colleges 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 5,018.64 Town Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 2,327.93 Chargebacks 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 83.37 SPEC DIST TAXES 8,860.27 6 UTILITIES & N.C. 65 68,956.83

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 286 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-12 ***************** Railroad BILL 1022 80.01-1-12 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 24,382 155.83 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 11,572 County Tax 24,382 129.29 Property Taxation 6-3-2 24,382 Community Colleges 24,382 27.17 110 Franklin Road Se ACRES 15.40 BANK 999999 Town Tax 24,382 12.60 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 EAST-0955084 NRTH-0908790 Chargebacks 24,382 0.45 FULL MARKET VALUE 34,101 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 24,382 TO 43.32 TOTAL TAX --- 368.66** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 368.66 ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-43 ***************** Railroad BILL 1023 80.01-1-43 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 4,389 28.05 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,851 County Tax 4,389 23.27 Property Taxation 7-2-2 4,389 Community Colleges 4,389 4.89 110 Franklin Road SE ACRES 2.40 BANK 999999 Town Tax 4,389 2.27 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 EAST-0952889 NRTH-0907823 Chargebacks 4,389 0.08 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,138 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 4,389 TO 7.80 WD005 Urban wtr1 4,389 TO C 4.37 TOTAL TAX --- 70.73** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 70.73 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-29 ***************** Railroad BILL 1024 95.02-1-29 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 443,760 2,836.17 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 10,650 County Tax 443,760 2,353.06 Property Taxation 3-6-2 443,760 Community Colleges 443,760 494.48 110 Franklin Road SE ACRES 7.10 BANK 999999 Town Tax 443,760 229.37 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 EAST-0938841 NRTH-0901225 Chargebacks 443,760 8.21 FULL MARKET VALUE 620,643 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 443,760 TO 938.89 TOTAL TAX --- 6,860.18** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 6,860.18 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-11 ***************** Railroad BILL 1025 95.04-1-11 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 7,802 49.86 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,703 County Tax 7,802 41.37 Property Taxation 4-2-2 7,802 Community Colleges 7,802 8.69 110 Franklin Road SE ACRES 4.90 BANK 999999 Town Tax 7,802 4.03 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 EAST-0937132 NRTH-0899179 Chargebacks 7,802 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,912 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,802 TO 16.51 TOTAL TAX --- 120.60** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 120.60 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 287 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-50 ***************** Railroad BILL 1026 95.04-1-50 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 7,316 46.76 Northern Southern Corp Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,009 County Tax 7,316 38.79 Property Taxation 2-2-2 7,316 Community Colleges 7,316 8.15 110 Franklin Road SE ACRES 6.90 BANK 999999 Town Tax 7,316 3.78 Roanoke, VA 24042-0028 EAST-0935530 NRTH-0897292 Chargebacks 7,316 0.14 FULL MARKET VALUE 10,232 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 7,316 TO 15.48 TOTAL TAX --- 113.10** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 113.10 ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-51 ***************** Railroad BILL 1027 95.04-1-51 842 Ceiling rr Medicaid 1524,817 9,745.46 CSX-New York Central Lines Dunkirk Csd 060300 76,650 County Tax 1524,817 8,085.41 500 Water St J-910 Include-2-2-1,3-6-1,4-2-1 1524,817 Community Colleges 1524,817 1,699.11 Jacksonville, FL 32202 6-3-1.1,7-2-1,8-5-1,10-1- Town Tax 1524,817 788.15 2-2-1 Chargebacks 1524,817 28.22 ACRES 6.70 BANK 999999 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 579,430 TO 1,225.93 EAST-0935466 NRTH-0897379 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 945,387 TO 1,679.87 FULL MARKET VALUE 2132,611 TOTAL TAX --- 23,252.15** DATE #1 02/10/15 AMT DUE 23,252.15 ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 288 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX FP008 W dunk fire pr 4 TOTAL 1038,308 1038,308 2,196.81 FP009 E dnk fire pro 3 TOTAL 974,158 974,158 1,730.99 WD005 Urban wtr1 1 TOTAL C 4,389 4,389 4.37 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 060300 2,012,466 S U B - T O T A L 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 2,012,466 T O T A L 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 T O T A L (CONT) 2,012,466 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 289 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 12,862.13 County Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 10,671.19 Community Colleges 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 2,242.49 Town Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 1,040.20 Chargebacks 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 37.24 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,932.17 7 CEILING RAILROADS 6 30,785.42

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 290 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX FP008 W dunk fire pr 4 TOTAL 1038,308 1038,308 2,196.81 FP009 E dnk fire pro 3 TOTAL 974,158 974,158 1,730.99 WD005 Urban wtr1 1 TOTAL C 4,389 4,389 4.37 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 060300 2,012,466 S U B - T O T A L 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 2,012,466 T O T A L 6 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 T O T A L (CONT) 2,012,466 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** NO SYSTEM EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** NO EXEMPTIONS AT THIS LEVEL

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 291 COUNTY - Chautauqua CEILING RAILROAD SECTION OF THE ROLL - 7 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Medicaid 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 12,862.13 County Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 10,671.19 Community Colleges 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 2,242.49 Town Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 1,040.20 Chargebacks 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 37.24 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,932.17 7 CEILING RAILROADS 6 30,785.42

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 292 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 11-1-11..EX **************** 11-1-11..EX 846 Connectors TOWN OWNED 13500 0 0 Town Of Dunkirk Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Willow Rd Bridges; Beaver Crk, Firs 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 W. Lake Rd, Franklin Ave, Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 11-1-11..EX Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-3 ****************** E Lake Rd 63.03-1-3 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 251,400 251,400 St Hyacinths Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 131,100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Lake Rd 13-1-1 251,400 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 15.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0954661 NRTH-0913122 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 351,608 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-5 ****************** 63.03-1-5 582 Camping park - WTRFNT RELIGIOUS 25110 582,200 582,200 New York Conference Dunkirk Csd 060300 328,400 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 United Church Of Christ 13-2-1 582,200 County Tax 0.00 0.00 3049 East Genesee St ACRES 33.90 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Syracuse, NY 13200 EAST-0956237 NRTH-0914383 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 814,266 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 63.03-1-6 ****************** 63.03-1-6 311 Res vac land RELIGIOUS 25110 4,500 4,500 New York Conference Dunkirk Csd 060300 4,500 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 United Church Of Christ 13-3-12 4,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 3049 East Genesee St ACRES 5.70 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Syracuse, NY 13200 EAST-0956427 NRTH-0913167 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,294 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 63.17-1-1 ****************** 3816 Lake Shore Dr E 63.17-1-1 311 Res vac land TOWN OWNED 13500 100 100 Town Of Dunkirk Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Willow Rd 12-1-32.2 100 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 31.30 DPTH 12.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0952556 NRTH-0910806 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2002 PG-00403 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 293 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 80.01-1-38 ***************** Middle Rd 80.01-1-38 652 Govt bldgs CO PROPTY 13100 19,400 19,400 County Of Chautauqua Dunkirk Csd 060300 13,200 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Gerace Office Bldg 7-3-1.3 19,400 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Mayville, NY 14757 ACRES 2.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0953689 NRTH-0907730 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2118 PG-00520 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,133 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO 19,400 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 80.17-1-1 ****************** 71 Tenney St 80.17-1-1 311 Res vac land WHOLLY EX 50000 500 500 Town Of Dunkirk Dunkirk Csd 060300 500 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 4737 Willow Rd 7-6-1 500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 PO Box 850 FRNT 180.00 DPTH 51.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0952470 NRTH-0904498 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2073 PG-00440 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 699 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO 500 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-1 ****************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-1 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 2,900 2,900 Dunkirk Ben Miss Ed Inst Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,900 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 111 South Rdg Ste 302 2-1-1.1 2,900 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Rye Brook, NY 10573 ACRES 1.50 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0935103 NRTH-0901506 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 4,056 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-7 ****************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-7 311 Res vac land NON-PROFIT 25300 2,000 2,000 The Nature Conservancy Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 1800 N Kent St 3-4-1.3 2,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Arlington, VA 22209 ACRES 8.10 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936832 NRTH-0902758 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,797 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 294 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-8 ****************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-8 311 Res vac land NON-PROFIT 25300 600 600 The Nature Conservatory Dunkirk Csd 060300 600 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 1800 North Kent St 3-1-1.2 600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Arlington, VA 22209 ACRES 2.30 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936783 NRTH-0903134 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 839 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-14 ***************** Temple Rd 95.02-1-14 311 Res vac land CO PROPTY 13100 12,600 12,600 NYS J N Adams Ddso Dev Center Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,600 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 10310 Peck Hill Rd 3-3-8.1 12,600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Perrysburg, NY 14129 ACRES 4.80 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0938315 NRTH-0902760 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 17,622 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO 12,600 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-15 ***************** Temple Rd 95.02-1-15 633 Aged - home CO PROPTY 13100 78,200 78,200 County Of Chautauqua Dunkirk Csd 060300 16,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Chaut Co Welfare Dist 3-3-9 78,200 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Mayville, NY 14757 ACRES 30.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0938430 NRTH-0902311 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 109,371 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-34 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-34 311 Res vac land NON-PROFIT 25300 1,200 1,200 The Nature Conservancy Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,200 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 1800 N Kent St 3-5-3 1,200 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Arlington, VA 22200 ACRES 5.60 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0937455 NRTH-0901836 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,678 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-35 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-35 322 Rural vac>10 NON-PROFIT 25300 2,800 2,800 The Nature Conservancy Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 1800 North Kent St 3-5-2 2,800 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Arlington, VA 22200 ACRES 13.80 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0937534 NRTH-0902334 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,916 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 295 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-42 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-42 853 Sewage VILL OWNED 13650 1,800 1,800 The Village Of Fredonia Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Church St 3-5-7.2 1,800 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Fredonia, NY 14063 FRNT 29.50 DPTH 1034.30 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936950 NRTH-0900492 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 1900 PG-00274 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,517 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-43 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-43 853 Sewage VILL OWNED 13650 23,500 23,500 The Village Of Fredonia Dunkirk Csd 060300 23,500 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Church St 3-5-6.2 23,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 4.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936979 NRTH-0900377 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 1900 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 32,867 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-62 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-62 853 Sewage VILL OWNED 13650 2,300 2,300 Village Of Fredonia Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,300 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 9-11 Church St 2-1-8.2 2,300 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 1.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0935278 NRTH-0900661 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,217 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-63 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-63 853 Sewage VILL OWNED 13650 2172,000 2172,000 Village Of Fredonia Dunkirk Csd 060300 105,600 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 9-11 Church St 2-1-1.2 2172,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Fredonia, NY 14063 ACRES 11.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0935328 NRTH-0900851 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 3037,762 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.02-1-64 ***************** W Lake Rd 95.02-1-64 311 Res vac land TOWN OWNED 13500 1,000 1,000 Town Of Dunkirk Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Willow Rd 2-1-1.3 1,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936337 NRTH-0900860 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 1,399 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 296 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-7 ****************** Willow Rd 95.04-1-7 652 Govt bldgs TOWN OWNED 13500 43,000 43,000 Tool House & Storage Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Town Of Dunkirk 2-5-2 43,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Willow Rd ACRES 2.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0936226 NRTH-0898471 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 60,140 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-9 ****************** Willow Rd 95.04-1-9 662 Police/fire VOL FIRE 26400 102,500 102,500 W Dunkirk Vol Fire Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 7,300 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Willow Rd 2-5-1 102,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 200.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0936321 NRTH-0898754 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 143,357 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.04-1-38 ***************** 95.04-1-38 841 Motr veh srv NY STATE 12100 0 0 NYS Thruway Commission Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Albany, NY 12200 4-8-1 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0939596 NRTH-0896653 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.10-1-11 ***************** Beach 95.10-1-11 311 Res vac land - WTRFNT TOWN OWNED 13500 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Beach, 14048 2-4-21 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 ACRES 2.70 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0933233 NRTH-0900064 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 95.13-2-1 ****************** Beach 95.13-2-1 315 Underwtr lnd TOWN OWNED 13500 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 1-1-24 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 ACRES 3.70 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0929938 NRTH-0898223 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 297 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 95.17-1-11 ***************** Beach 95.17-1-11 315 Underwtr lnd - WTRFNT TOWN OWNED 13500 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 1-13-18 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 FRNT 780.00 DPTH 67.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0928592 NRTH-0897021 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-33.1 *************** Williams Rd 96.02-1-33.1 311 Res vac land WHOLLY EX 50000 20,240 20,240 St Marys Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 20,240 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-2-22.1 20,240 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 11.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0950755 NRTH-0901832 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 28,308 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO 20,240 EX SW001 Bennett road water 0 TO C 20,240 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-41 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-1-41 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 76,500 76,500 St Marys Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 76,500 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-2-24 76,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.81 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949937 NRTH-0901845 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 106,993 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-42 ***************** Williams St 96.02-1-42 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 100 100 St Marys Cemetery Society Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 328 Washington Ave 8-2-22.3 100 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 46.00 DPTH 214.70 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0950423 NRTH-0901841 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2067 PG-00084 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 298 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-1-43 ***************** 96.02-1-43 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 228,900 228,900 St Marys Cemetery Dunkirk Csd 060300 92,100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-2-23 228,900 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0950011 NRTH-0901589 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 320,140 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-4 ****************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-4 411 Apartment WHOLLY EX 50000 261,600 261,600 Chautauqua Opportunities Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 12,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 17 W Courtney St also lot 96.02-2-3 261,600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 8-1-11.4.2.1 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 ACRES 1.50 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949357 NRTH-0900543 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 365,874 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO 261,600 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-5 ****************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-5 613 College/univ WHOLLY EX 50000 2041,600 2041,600 Chautauqua Connections Dunkirk Csd 060300 54,400 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-1-11.3.1 2041,600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14148 ACRES 3.20 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949657 NRTH-0900555 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 2855,385 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-6 ****************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-6 613 College/univ WHOLLY EX 50000 1456,300 1456,300 Jamestown Community College Dunkirk Csd 060300 66,300 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Route 60 8-1-11.3.2 1456,300 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 3.90 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949766 NRTH-0900334 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 2036,783 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-7 ****************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-7 438 Parking lot WHOLLY EX 50000 3,900 3,900 Jamestown Cammunity College Dunkirk Csd 060300 1,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Route 60 8-1-11.4.2.2 3,900 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949279 NRTH-0900179 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 5,455 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 299 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-9 ****************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-9 330 Vacant comm NONPROF ED 25120 8,400 8,400 JCC Dunkirk Csd 060300 8,400 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 525 Falconer St Encludes 8-1-11.4.4 8,400 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Jamestown, NY 14701 10-2-1.4 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 ACRES 0.27 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949660 NRTH-0900023 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 11,748 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-10 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-10 453 Large retail WHOLLY EX 50000 529,600 529,600 JCC Foundation Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 18,900 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 525 Falconer St Includes 10-2-1.3 529,600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Jamestown, NY 14701 Also Known As 8-1-11.4.3 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 8-1-11.4.4 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 ACRES 0.41 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949647 NRTH-0900103 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO DEED BOOK 2327 PG-329 529,600 EX FULL MARKET VALUE 740,699 SW001 Bennett road water 0 TO C 529,600 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-12 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-12 453 Large retail WHOLLY EX 50000 0 0 JCC Foundation Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 525 Falconer St Encluded With 8-1-11.4.3 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Jamestown, NY 14701 10-2-1.3 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 ACRES 1.20 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949944 NRTH-0900020 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2327 PG-329 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 0 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-19 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-19 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 93,900 93,900 St Marys Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 750 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-4-2.2 93,900 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 1.50 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0950224 NRTH-0900996 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 131,329 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 300 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-21 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-21 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 110,500 110,500 St Marys Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 97,900 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 8-4-1 110,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 8.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0950064 NRTH-0901237 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 154,545 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.02-2-47 ***************** Bennett Rd 96.02-2-47 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 114,200 114,200 Blessed Mary Angela RC Parish Dunkirk Csd 060300 99,100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Bennett Rd 10-2-4 114,200 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 13.25 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949455 NRTH-0899290 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 159,720 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-4 ****************** 10653 Brigham Rd 96.03-3-4 311 Res vac land WHOLLY EX 50000 9,800 9,800 Chaut County Age & Fair Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 PO Box 191 5-3-11.3 9,800 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 2.50 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0942638 NRTH-0898750 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2232 PG-180 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 13,706 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO 9,800 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-5 ****************** 10653 Brigham Rd 96.03-3-5 322 Rural vac>10 AG SOCIETY 26050 26,300 26,300 Chaut County Age & Fair Dunkirk Csd 060300 26,300 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 PO Box 191 5-3-11.1 26,300 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 33.70 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0943447 NRTH-0898750 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 1661 PG-00236 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 36,783 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO 26,300 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 301 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-13 ***************** Waldorff Rd 96.03-3-13 531 Fairground AG SOCIETY 26050 2,000 2,000 Chaut Co Agri & Fair Assoc Inc Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 1089 Central Ave 5-3-14.2 2,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 PO Box 191 ACRES 3.90 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY EAST-0943742 NRTH-0897664 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 1946 PG-00168 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 2,797 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-14 ***************** Waldorff Rd 96.03-3-14 531 Fairground AG SOCIETY 26050 5,000 5,000 Chau Co Agric Society Dunkirk Csd 060300 5,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Waldorff Rd 5-3-15 5,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 10.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0944113 NRTH-0897662 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 6,993 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-15 ***************** Waldorff Rd 96.03-3-15 531 Fairground AG SOCIETY 26050 16,500 16,500 Chau Co Agric Society Dunkirk Csd 060300 14,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Waldorff Rd 5-3-16 16,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 6.25 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0943998 NRTH-0897168 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 23,077 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-17 ***************** NYS Thruway 96.03-3-17 841 Motr veh srv NY STATE 12100 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 5-4-1 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0942684 NRTH-0896891 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-18 ***************** Agency 96.03-3-18 613 College/univ NYS TCHERS 12200 793,600 793,600 NYS Housing Finance Dunkirk Csd 060300 64,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 5-7-1 793,600 County Tax 0.00 0.00 ACRES 10.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0943423 NRTH-0896450 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 1109,930 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 302 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-19 ***************** Agency 96.03-3-19 613 College/univ NYS TCHERS 12200 55,800 55,800 NYS Housing Finance Dunkirk Csd 060300 55,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 5-7-2 55,800 County Tax 0.00 0.00 ACRES 8.30 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0943404 NRTH-0896175 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 78,042 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.03-3-23 ***************** Back Of NYS Thruway 96.03-3-23 311 Res vac land NONPROF HS 25210 2,500 2,500 United Church Residences Dunkirk Csd 060300 2,500 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 of Fredonia Back Land 2,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 170 East Center St 5-6-5.2 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Marion, OH 43302 ACRES 3.10 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0941769 NRTH-0896373 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 3,497 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO 2,500 EX WD058 Comprehensive Water 0 TO 2,500 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 96.04-1-53 ***************** NYS Thruway 96.04-1-53 841 Motr veh srv NY STATE 12100 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 10-4-1.1 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0949930 NRTH-0897482 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-7 ****************** S Roberts Rd 97.01-1-7 322 Rural vac>10 CO PROPTY 13100 15,000 15,000 People Of The State Of NY Dunkirk Csd 060300 15,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Div Military & Naval Affairs 11-2-1 15,000 County Tax 0.00 0.00 330 Old Niskayuna Rd ACRES 13.10 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 Latham, NY 12110 EAST-0955976 NRTH-0899796 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 1955 PG-00447 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 20,979 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO 15,000 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 303 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.01-1-11.2 *************** 10745 S Roberts Rd 97.01-1-11.2 870 Elect & Gas WHOLLY EX 50000 55,400 55,400 Janisch Michael Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 10745 South Roberts Rd wind mill IDA 15 yrs exem 55,400 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 11-1-8 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 ACRES 8.00 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0955686 NRTH-0898934 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 DEED BOOK 2132 PG-00150 FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO FULL MARKET VALUE 77,483 55,400 EX WD058 Comprehensive Water 0 TO 55,400 EX TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.03-1-2 ****************** NYS Thruway 97.03-1-2 841 Motr veh srv NY STATE 12100 0 0 Special Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , 11-3-1 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 EAST-0953391 NRTH-0897884 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-10 ***************** Greenhurst Ave 97.05-1-10 330 Vacant comm VOL FIRE 26400 6,400 6,400 Volunteer Fire Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 6,400 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Roberts Rd 9-4-7 6,400 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 120.00 DPTH 209.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0952964 NRTH-0902640 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 8,951 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-11 ***************** 97.05-1-11 438 Parking lot VOL FIRE 26400 19,500 19,500 Vol Fire Co No 1 Dunkirk Csd 060300 3,800 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Roberts Rd 9-4-8 19,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953138 NRTH-0902690 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 27,273 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 304 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAX MAP NUMBER SEQUENCE TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 UNIFORM PERCENT OF VALUE IS 071.50 TAX MAP PARCEL NUMBER PROPERTY LOCATION & CLASS ASSESSMENT EXEMPTION CODE------------------COUNTY--------TOWN------------ CURRENT OWNERS NAME SCHOOL DISTRICT LAND TAX DESCRIPTION TAXABLE VALUE CURRENT OWNERS ADDRESS PARCEL SIZE/GRID COORD TOTAL SPECIAL DISTRICTS TAX AMOUNT ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-12 ***************** S Roberts Rd 97.05-1-12 662 Police/fire VOL FIRE 26400 240,300 240,300 Volunteer Fire Co 1 Dunkirk Csd 060300 9,300 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Roberts Rd 9-4-9.1 240,300 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 105.50 DPTH 289.40 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0953159 NRTH-0902591 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 336,084 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-13 ***************** S Roberts Rd 97.05-1-13 662 Police/fire VOL FIRE 26400 100 100 Volunteer Fire Co 1 Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Roberts Rd 9-4-9.2 100 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 FRNT 7.90 DPTH 74.40 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0953297 NRTH-0902543 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-14 ***************** 97.05-1-14 662 Police/fire VOL FIRE 26400 100 100 Volunteer Fire Co Dunkirk Csd 060300 100 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Roberts Rd 9-4-10.2 100 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 EAST-0953230 NRTH-0902537 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 140 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 97.05-1-42 ***************** Railroad Ave 97.05-1-42 695 Cemetery PRIV CEMTY 27350 167,500 167,500 Holy Trinity Cemetary Dunkirk Csd 060300 40,000 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 Railroad Ave 9-14-2 167,500 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Dunkirk, NY 14048 ACRES 5.00 Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 EAST-0952507 NRTH-0901735 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 234,266 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ******************************************************************************************************* 99-9-99..SF5 *************** Special Franchise 99-9-99..SF5 866 Telephone NY STATE 12100 0 0 NYS Thruway Authority Dunkirk Csd 060300 0 Medicaid 0.00 0.00 , Special Franchise 0 County Tax 0.00 0.00 Telephone Community Colleges 0.00 0.00 99-9-99..SF5 Town Tax 0.00 0.00 FULL MARKET VALUE 0 Chargebacks 0.00 0.00 FP008 W dunk fire prot1 0 TO FP009 E dnk fire prot2 0 TO TOTAL TAX --- 0.00** ************************************************************************************************************************************

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 305 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX WD058 Comprehensive 2 TOTAL 57,900 57,900 FP008 W dunk fire pr 5 TOTAL 51,200 51,200 FP009 E dnk fire pro 9 TOTAL 901,740 901,740 SW001 Bennett road w 2 TOTAL C 549,840 549,840 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 060300 S U B - T O T A L 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) T O T A L 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 T O T A L (CONT) *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 50000 WHOLLY EX 10 4378,940 4378,940 T O T A L 10 4378,940 4378,940

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 306 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S U B S E C T I O N - - T O T A L S *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 12100 NY STATE 5 12200 NYS TCHERS 2 849,400 849,400 13100 CO PROPTY 4 125,200 125,200 13500 TOWN OWNED 7 44,100 44,100 13650 VILL OWNED 4 2199,600 2199,600 25110 RELIGIOUS 2 586,700 586,700 25120 NONPROF ED 1 8,400 8,400 25210 NONPROF HS 1 2,500 2,500 25300 NON-PROFIT 4 6,600 6,600 26050 AG SOCIETY 4 49,800 49,800 26400 VOL FIRE 6 368,900 368,900 27350 PRIV CEMTY 9 1045,900 1045,900 T O T A L 49 5287,100 5287,100 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RS 8 TOTAL 1467,990 9666,040 9,666,040 SPEC DIST TAXES 8 WHOLLY EXEMPT 59

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 307 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX WD058 Comprehensive 2 TOTAL 57,900 57,900 FP008 W dunk fire pr 5 TOTAL 51,200 51,200 FP009 E dnk fire pro 9 TOTAL 901,740 901,740 SW001 Bennett road w 2 TOTAL C 549,840 549,840 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 060300 S U B - T O T A L 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) T O T A L 59 1467,990 9666,040 9666,040 T O T A L (CONT) *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 50000 WHOLLY EX 10 4378,940 4378,940 T O T A L 10 4378,940 4378,940

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 308 COUNTY - Chautauqua WHOLLY EXEMPT SECTION OF THE ROLL - 8 VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 R O L L S E C T I O N T O T A L S *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 12100 NY STATE 5 12200 NYS TCHERS 2 849,400 849,400 13100 CO PROPTY 4 125,200 125,200 13500 TOWN OWNED 7 44,100 44,100 13650 VILL OWNED 4 2199,600 2199,600 25110 RELIGIOUS 2 586,700 586,700 25120 NONPROF ED 1 8,400 8,400 25210 NONPROF HS 1 2,500 2,500 25300 NON-PROFIT 4 6,600 6,600 26050 AG SOCIETY 4 49,800 49,800 26400 VOL FIRE 6 368,900 368,900 27350 PRIV CEMTY 9 1045,900 1045,900 T O T A L 49 5287,100 5287,100 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RS 8 TOTAL 1467,990 9666,040 9,666,040 SPEC DIST TAXES 8 WHOLLY EXEMPT 59

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 309 COUNTY - Chautauqua VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk S W I S T O T A L S TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TAX TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE RATE TAX OT001 Omitted Tax-Dn 1 MOVTAX 544.49 544.49 544.49 WD058 Comprehensive 355 TOTAL 9841,120 63,700 9777,420 .511382 5,000.05 FP008 W dunk fire pr 443 TOTAL 32850,421 57,000 32793,421 2.115760 69,383.00 FP009 E dnk fire pro 616 TOTAL 76031,929 901,740 75130,189 1.776916 133,500.14 GE001 Miscellaneous 14 MOVTAX 3,593.72 3,593.72 3,593.72 LD011 Vineyard lt1 40 TOTAL 29294,786 1450,498 27844,288 .107742 3,000.00 SD023 East lake rd s 11 FEE 11.00 11.00 25.000000 275.00 SD024 East lake rd s 70 UNITS 120.50 120.50 75.585062 9,108.32 SW001 Bennett road w 113 TOTAL C 5590,199 549,840 5040,359 .991993 5,000.01 SW002 Shorewood wate 296 TOTAL C 25706,610 25706,610 .077801 2,000.00 US001 Unpaid sewer 24 MOVTAX 10,663.43 10,663.43 10,663.43 WD005 Urban wtr1 64 TOTAL C 3010,607 3010,607 .996477 3,000.00 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 3 TOTAL C 14659,210 1692,533 12966,677 .231362 3,000.00 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 42 TOTAL C 29308,706 1450,498 27858,208 .071792 1,999.99 WD024 E lake rd ind 4 TOTAL C 3862,000 3862,000 3.055671 11,801.00 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 1063 26677,848 116651,357 16634,191 100,017,166 060300 10900,050 89,117,116 Fredonia 23 287,064 697,868 69,820 628,048 065801 110,250 517,798 S U B - T O T A L 1086 26964,912 117349,225 16704,011 100,645,214 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 11010,300 89,634,914 T O T A L 1086 26964,912 117349,225 16704,011 100,645,214 T O T A L (CONT) 11010,300 89,634,914

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 310 COUNTY - Chautauqua VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk S W I S T O T A L S TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 50000 WHOLLY EX 10 4378,940 4378,940 T O T A L 10 4378,940 4378,940 *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 12100 NY STATE 5 12200 NYS TCHERS 2 849,400 849,400 13100 CO PROPTY 4 125,200 125,200 13500 TOWN OWNED 7 44,100 44,100 13650 VILL OWNED 4 2199,600 2199,600 18020 IND DEVEL 1 3300,000 3300,000 25110 RELIGIOUS 2 586,700 586,700 25120 NONPROF ED 1 8,400 8,400 25210 NONPROF HS 1 2,500 2,500 25300 NON-PROFIT 4 6,600 6,600 26050 AG SOCIETY 4 49,800 49,800 26400 VOL FIRE 6 368,900 368,900 27350 PRIV CEMTY 9 1045,900 1045,900 41003 P-RATA VET 45 366,651 41102 VETS CNTY 35 89,950 41103 VETS T 1 17,776 41111 VETERAN EX 1 5,000 5,000 41121 VET WAR CT 1 4,410 8,820 41122 VET WAR C 27 123,480 41131 VET COM CT 2 14,700 29,400 41132 VET COM C 30 220,500 41141 VET DIS CT 2 29,400 39,630 41142 VET DIS C 6 67,046 41162 CW_15_VET/ 1 4,410 41700 AG BLDG 1 6,410 6,410 41720 AG DIST 13 104,610 104,610

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 311 COUNTY - Chautauqua VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk S W I S T O T A L S TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 41730 AG COMMIT 28 356,170 356,170 41802 AGED C 1 19,295 41805 AGED C/S 4 115,775 42120 GREENHOUSE 1 5,800 5,800 47610 BUSINV 897 4 3143,031 3143,031 T O T A L 253 12897,087 12670,398 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ TAX STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RATE Medicaid 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 6.391231 587,440.37 County Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 5.302544 487,374.94 Community Colleges 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 1.114303 102,419.48 Town Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 0.516880 47,625.49 Chargebacks 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 0.018510 1,705.50 SPEC DIST TAXES 245,429.92 1 TAXABLE 943 1471,995.70 Medicaid 1643,455 1,643,455 6.391231 10,503.68 County Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 5.302544 8,714.49 Community Colleges 1643,455 1,643,455 1.114303 1,831.31 Town Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 0.516880 849.48 Chargebacks 1643,455 1,643,455 0.018510 30.44 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,646.79 5 SPECIAL FRANCHISE 13 25,576.19 Medicaid 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 6.391231 28,784.92 County Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 5.302544 23,881.70 Community Colleges 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 1.114303 5,018.64 Town Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 0.516880 2,327.93

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 312 COUNTY - Chautauqua VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk S W I S T O T A L S TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 063400 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ TAX STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RATE Chargebacks 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 0.018510 83.37 SPEC DIST TAXES 8,860.27 6 UTILITIES & N.C. 65 68,956.83 Medicaid 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 6.391231 12,862.13 County Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 5.302544 10,671.19 Community Colleges 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 1.114303 2,242.49 Town Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 0.516880 1,040.20 Chargebacks 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 0.018510 37.24 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,932.17 7 CEILING RAILROADS 6 30,785.42 RS 8 TOTAL 1467,990 9666,040 9,666,040 SPEC DIST TAXES 8 WHOLLY EXEMPT 59 Medicaid 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 6.391231 639,591.10 County Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 5.302544 530,642.32 Community Colleges 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 1.114303 111,511.92 Town Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 0.516880 51,843.10 Chargebacks 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 0.018510 1,856.55 SPEC DIST TAXES 261,869.15 * SUB TOTAL 1,086 1597,314.14 Medicaid 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 6.391231 639,591.10 County Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 5.302544 530,642.32 Community Colleges 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 1.114303 111,511.92 Town Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 0.516880 51,843.10 Chargebacks 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 0.018510 1,856.55 SPEC DIST TAXES 261,869.15 ** GRAND TOTAL 1,086 1597,314.14

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 313 COUNTY - Chautauqua T O W N T O T A L S VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 0634 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** S P E C I A L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL EXTENSION EXTENSION AD VALOREM EXEMPT TAXABLE TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS TYPE VALUE VALUE AMOUNT VALUE TAX OT001 Omitted Tax-Dn 1 MOVTAX 544.49 544.49 544.49 WD058 Comprehensive 355 TOTAL 9841,120 63,700 9777,420 5,000.05 FP008 W dunk fire pr 443 TOTAL 32850,421 57,000 32793,421 69,383.00 FP009 E dnk fire pro 616 TOTAL 76031,929 901,740 75130,189 133,500.14 GE001 Miscellaneous 14 MOVTAX 3,593.72 3,593.72 3,593.72 LD011 Vineyard lt1 40 TOTAL 29294,786 1450,498 27844,288 3,000.00 SD023 East lake rd s 11 FEE 11.00 11.00 275.00 SD024 East lake rd s 70 UNITS 120.50 120.50 9,108.32 SW001 Bennett road w 113 TOTAL C 5590,199 549,840 5040,359 5,000.01 SW002 Shorewood wate 296 TOTAL C 25706,610 25706,610 2,000.00 US001 Unpaid sewer 24 MOVTAX 10,663.43 10,663.43 10,663.43 WD005 Urban wtr1 64 TOTAL C 3010,607 3010,607 3,000.00 WD006 Middle rd wtr2 3 TOTAL C 14659,210 1692,533 12966,677 3,000.00 WD007 Vineyard wtr3 42 TOTAL C 29308,706 1450,498 27858,208 1,999.99 WD024 E lake rd ind 4 TOTAL C 3862,000 3862,000 11,801.00 *** S C H O O L D I S T R I C T S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL CODE DISTRICT NAME PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE ----------- ------------ STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE Dunkirk Csd 1063 26677,848 116651,357 16634,191 100,017,166 060300 10900,050 89,117,116 Fredonia 23 287,064 697,868 69,820 628,048 065801 110,250 517,798 S U B - T O T A L 1086 26964,912 117349,225 16704,011 100,645,214 S U B - T O T A L(CONT) 11010,300 89,634,914 T O T A L 1086 26964,912 117349,225 16704,011 100,645,214 T O T A L (CONT) 11010,300 89,634,914

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 314 COUNTY - Chautauqua T O W N T O T A L S VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 0634 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** S Y S T E M C O D E S S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 50000 WHOLLY EX 10 4378,940 4378,940 T O T A L 10 4378,940 4378,940 *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 12100 NY STATE 5 12200 NYS TCHERS 2 849,400 849,400 13100 CO PROPTY 4 125,200 125,200 13500 TOWN OWNED 7 44,100 44,100 13650 VILL OWNED 4 2199,600 2199,600 18020 IND DEVEL 1 3300,000 3300,000 25110 RELIGIOUS 2 586,700 586,700 25120 NONPROF ED 1 8,400 8,400 25210 NONPROF HS 1 2,500 2,500 25300 NON-PROFIT 4 6,600 6,600 26050 AG SOCIETY 4 49,800 49,800 26400 VOL FIRE 6 368,900 368,900 27350 PRIV CEMTY 9 1045,900 1045,900 41003 P-RATA VET 45 366,651 41102 VETS CNTY 35 89,950 41103 VETS T 1 17,776 41111 VETERAN EX 1 5,000 5,000 41121 VET WAR CT 1 4,410 8,820 41122 VET WAR C 27 123,480 41131 VET COM CT 2 14,700 29,400 41132 VET COM C 30 220,500 41141 VET DIS CT 2 29,400 39,630 41142 VET DIS C 6 67,046 41162 CW_15_VET/ 1 4,410 41700 AG BLDG 1 6,410 6,410 41720 AG DIST 13 104,610 104,610

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 315 COUNTY - Chautauqua T O W N T O T A L S VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 0634 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** E X E M P T I O N S U M M A R Y *** TOTAL CODE DESCRIPTION PARCELS COUNTY TOWN 41730 AG COMMIT 28 356,170 356,170 41802 AGED C 1 19,295 41805 AGED C/S 4 115,775 42120 GREENHOUSE 1 5,800 5,800 47610 BUSINV 897 4 3143,031 3143,031 T O T A L 253 12897,087 12670,398 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ TAX STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RATE Medicaid 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 587,440.37 County Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 487,374.94 Community Colleges 24763,050 99523,446 7,609,987 91,913,459 102,419.48 Town Tax 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 47,625.49 Chargebacks 24763,050 99523,446 7,383,298 92,140,148 1,705.50 SPEC DIST TAXES 245,429.92 1 TAXABLE 943 1471,995.70 Medicaid 1643,455 1,643,455 10,503.68 County Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 8,714.49 Community Colleges 1643,455 1,643,455 1,831.31 Town Tax 1643,455 1,643,455 849.48 Chargebacks 1643,455 1,643,455 30.44 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,646.79 5 SPECIAL FRANCHISE 13 25,576.19 Medicaid 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 28,784.92 County Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 23,881.70 Community Colleges 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 5,018.64 Town Tax 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 2,327.93

STATE OF NEW YORK 2 0 1 5 T O W N T A X R O L L PAGE 316 COUNTY - Chautauqua T O W N T O T A L S VALUATION DATE-JUL 01, 2013 TOWN - Dunkirk TAXABLE STATUS DATE-MAR 01, 2014 SWIS - 0634 RPS155/V04/L015 CURRENT DATE 12/16/2014 *** G R A N D T O T A L S *** ROLL TOTAL ASSESSED ASSESSED EXEMPT TOTAL TOTAL SEC DESCRIPTION PARCELS LAND TOTAL AMOUNT TAXABLE TAX ----------- ------------ TAX STAR AMOUNT STAR TAXABLE RATE Chargebacks 626,437 4503,818 4,503,818 83.37 SPEC DIST TAXES 8,860.27 6 UTILITIES & N.C. 65 68,956.83 Medicaid 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 12,862.13 County Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 10,671.19 Community Colleges 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 2,242.49 Town Tax 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 1,040.20 Chargebacks 107,435 2012,466 2,012,466 37.24 SPEC DIST TAXES 3,932.17 7 CEILING RAILROADS 6 30,785.42 RS 8 TOTAL 1467,990 9666,040 9,666,040 SPEC DIST TAXES 8 WHOLLY EXEMPT 59 Medicaid 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 639,591.10 County Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 530,642.32 Community Colleges 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 111,511.92 Town Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 51,843.10 Chargebacks 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 1,856.55 SPEC DIST TAXES 261,869.15 * SUB TOTAL 1,086 1597,314.14 Medicaid 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 639,591.10 County Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 530,642.32 Community Colleges 26964,912 117349,225 17,276,027 100,073,198 111,511.92 Town Tax 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 51,843.10 Chargebacks 26964,912 117349,225 17,049,338 100,299,887 1,856.55 SPEC DIST TAXES 261,869.15 ** GRAND TOTAL 1,086 1597,314.14 *COPYRIGHT * * * * * * * * * * * *NEW YORK STATE REAL PROPERTY SYSTEM* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * PROPRIETARY PROGRAM MATERIAL * * * * THIS MATERIAL IS PROPRIETARY TO THE NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF REAL PROPERTY SERVICES (OFFICE) * * AND IS NOT TO BE REPRODUCED, USED OR DISCLOSED EXCEPT IN ACCORDANCE WITH PROGRAM LICENSE OR * * UPON WRITTEN AUTHORIZATION OF THE NEW YORK STATE REAL PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM SECTION OF * * THE OFFICE, SHERIDAN HOLLOW PLAZA, 16 SHERIDAN AVENUE, ALBANY, NEW YORK 12210-2714. *

* * * COPYRIGHT (C) 1999 * * * * NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF REAL PROPERTY SERVICES * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * THE OFFICE BELIEVES THAT THE SOFTWARE FURNISHED HEREWITH IS ACCURATE AND RELIABLE, AND MUCH * * CARE HAS BEEN TAKEN IN ITS PREPARATION. HOWEVER, NO RESPONSIBILITY, FINANCIAL OR OTHERWISE, * * CAN BE ACCEPTED FROM ANY CONSEQUENCES ARISING OUT OF THE USE OF THIS MATERIAL, INCLUDING * * LOSS OF PROFIT, INDIRECT, SPECIAL OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES. THERE ARE NO WARRANTIES WHICH * * EXTEND BEYOND THE PROGRAM SPECIFICATION. * * * * THE CUSTOMER SHOULD EXERCISE CARE TO ASSURE THAT USE OF THE SOFTWARE WILL BE IN FULL * * COMPLIANCE WITH LAWS, RULES, AND REGULATIONS OF THE JURISDICTIONS WITH RESPECT TO WHICH IT * * IS USED. * *COPYRIGHT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *