' MINUIES OF THE II'EETING OF DISTRIC LEVEL EXPERT APPRAISAL COMMIITEE DEACSARAIKELA.KHARSAWAN,JHARKHAND HELD OXJIE-SEEIEUEEE.2q6

The 2"d meeiins oI Dstrci Level Expen Appraisal commltlee (DEAC) Saralkela Kharsawai

Jharkha.d s€s held on 6lh september, 2016 underthe Chaimansh p of shn Fani Bhushan in the

conierene Room 107, D srricl Coleclo6le, saraikela-KhaBawai The folLowng membeB were

Executive Engineer, Minor hrigation

ShriSanjay Kumar shama

Assistant Mining Offi cer, Saraikela.

R6gional Oflic6r, JSPCB,

1.

2.

3.

5.

6

Di A. P. Sinha (Reprcsentrtiv6)

Civil Surgoon, Saraikola.

Shri B.N,Tripathi

Ranse Forest Otricer, Chandil.

Ranse Forest Officer, Saraikola.

Dep.rtrnent of Metallurgical and

Materials Engineerins, N. LT. Jamshedpur.

8.

Departnent of Civil Engineedng,

Shr Fan Bhushan, Chanman of ihe Dislricl level Experl Appraisa commiiiee, wecomed all,members to meeiing Various proposals which were received by DEIAA, Saraikela and foMardedto DEAC for hen iechn cal appraisal came up ior discussion A@ordingly, the prcject proponentswere asked to make technicalpresentat on iorthe appraisalofrheh project beiore the commiilee.

The lollowing salient obsetoal ons made during the presentations (Project w se) in briei deserye

Projects recommended to DEIAA for co.sideralion ofsrand of EC.

Proposals related to Stone Mining (Existinq Lease)

Bhadudih Stone Mine of Shri Harelal luahato at Molzs- Bhadudih, thana & Block -chandil, SaEikela-Kha6awan, Jha*hand {2.00acres or 0.81 Ha)Consultant- M/S Safe EnvironmanlJanshedpur, RaP - Dr. c!rupinderSinsh Jaiswat.

This is a Slone Minng Prcject ior havlng an area of 2.00 acres or O.Aj Ha lKhaia No 430, ptotNo.2261 (P)l The committee noted that as per From - ttM it s a prcposatto. exisitng prcject ofmine / leaseforwhich PP is seeking EC Conside ng the facl that it ts 82 category of protect asper EIA Notiflcation dated 149.2006 and the cdelte ot lndia no: 125 dared 15/012016 theenvi.onmenlal impa.l Assessmeni as rell as Poblic Consuttaiion is not reooired The commttieeIell ll-al IOR c nol requtred \o. anv lom. FIA/E|VP E o be prpared as pe tr CazereThese presfiibed exemplions (Based on guldelines an decision taken vtde I,IOEF Notificatondate14.092006)are.ecommendedbylhecommitteetnrheinstant@se.

The protect was ev ewed n tight of OM No_ - J-13012t.12t20131A!t(t), dated 24103/2013 ofIr/OEF SEIAA (Jharkhand) guideiines dated 07/05/2013 and Gazette Notificalion date!l5101/2016 wiih espect to proposed Llining Plan, Environmentat protecring measure p.oposed tobe adopied, proposal ,or carrying out CSR acliviltes for Scio - economtc devetopment,development ol gGen belt, due consideEiion of occupaiionat healh, elc. In view of the s]ze of themlne, prodoclion rate and rhe mineral mlned and ihe assurance gtven by pp that he wil give dueconsiderauon lo environmenr by nainlaining haut .oads and @ler sp nkting on same, carryingout CSR aciiviiies for Socio - economic devetopme.t devetopmenl oi green be[, dueconsideration of oGopational heafth ol peGons engaged n mining. The comminee fel that iheoperal on of the mine wil have not have any major mpaci on the suroundings. The ndicatedprcject cost is Rs 49.90 Lakhs and a povision of 9.05 Lakhs wit be kept for Envnonment

'The delalls oi mine €pacity as per Approved lMining Ptan areMineable proved Reserye I 135873.75 MTlMineable probable Reserue : 25115.62 t\itT

Year - wise Producl on as per Approved l,lining P an Report of folr yeaB (among nve yeaE) is

(2015-16)

\201617)ea17 1A)(2018 19)

40000 94 t\,17

40000.94 tllT39999.75 MT

The dait poduciion as per Frcm tM is 136 62 rones.

PP has submilted @riifi@tes fDm circte Oflicer, DFO & DiMO. The infoma o. were examinedand tourd o be sanshctory a)).o-1Fore1?jpr-ar.or.s te-e@2s00 qdp rg. re.rar6 .1o q ,ao- sJp ro /, o r; po.e.ro. p"1 ;Env{onnenla [,lanagemenl pta. and a]so added n Eivro.menlal L4arage;enr pta. pe.iodrcheallh check up oiworle.and vitagers

Based on ihe presentation made and information provided ihe commitlee decided ihai theprcposal for Bhadudih Stone tvtine (Exisling) of Lasse Shd Haretat Mahalo, ai Mou, _Bhadudi\. rhana & B'oct - Ct-anot. Dist - SaEiketa Kha6awan. J€rkhand ro.8t ha,be€ronrelded .o' consderation ot DETAA subjed io above me. oned obsetoalro; tor grarl oitsLj rrevarioLs cond4ionsforglantoi Fc aegive. alAnnerLre I

.1. The Environmentat Ctearance is subjeot to grait of mininglndusi es, i,4ines & Geotogy, Government of Jharkhand io pp andas imposed by vaious/ DistriciAurhorilies are comptied with.

2. No mlni.g shatt be underiakentoreslry cleara.ce. Minimum disran@slipu aled n allapplicabe cuidelnes

lease by lhe Departmenl ofall oiher Statutory Conditions

tr rhe roresr araa wrllout oolainnq tf requsle pr,o,shall be maintained from Reserved/protected Forest as

lo ina order o he Honbre SJprenp CoLl ot r a.app icable to Minor Mineats.

3. EC s subjectto the grant oi Mtntng Lease tolhe rtghffutowner

4. E.vironmental Cearance is subjectNatonaiGreen Tr bunat/ TMOEF Gurdetnes

5. Ervironmentat Ctearance is subtect ro obtaining ctearance under the Witdtife (prolection)Aci 1972 from lhe competeni author, as may be appicabte to this proiect (in case anv lound i;lMl a'-a,ac relloleo in va.oLc act-edL..(r tr case ioLnd +Fy srojtd oagMr p.oLrlolcollecled alive wth the hetp ot the expert and tEnsfeired them or handing o;er them to lhe

' con@rned authorities Conservaiion ptan tf appticable has to be adhered io

6. The mining operations shal be resiricted to above ground waler iabte and ii shoutd nollnlersect lhe ground waler tabe. tn case of wo*ing beow the ground water tabte prior approvalof ihe Ground Water DirecloEle, covernment of Jharkhard / Centrat Ground Water Board shaltbe obtained. Benches heighr and stope shat be mainiained as per app.oved tMining pan. Themining Plan has to be got app/oved by concerned aulhorities as per DETAA guide;es SaietyreasL'e sial be adopFd r tne wlh DOI,IS Gjde.in(

7. PP shail mal.tain mdmum distance from Reserued / prolected Fo.ests as stiDulated in

8. The proiecl propo.enl shatt ensure thar no natural water@lrse and / or waler resour@sshall be obstructed due ro any mtntng operations Adequale measures shat be iaken lor

conseryal on and protection of the fBt order and the se@nd oder sireams if any emanating /passingih.ough the mlne lease area during lhe oourse olminiag operation.

9. The lop soil, if any sha ltemporarly be stored at earma*ed ste(s) only and il shou d not bekepl unutilized for ong Thetopsolshalbe used for and reclamalion and panlalion.

'10, There shall be no exlemal dumps(s) [lon]toing and manaqement of rehabilitaied areasshallconlinue untillhe vegetation becomes selt-susla n ng, Compliance slalus shallbe submitledlo lhe Jharkhand Slate Pollulion ControL Board, Ranchi and its neaEsl Resiona Offlces on six

11. Catch dEins and sillalion pords ol appropriate size shall be construcled around the mineworking, sub-g.ade a.d mneraLdump(s) to pevenl.un offorwalerand flow orsedimenb dnedLyinlo the agricullural nebs, and olher water bodies The water so collecled should be ulilized forwatering the mne area, haul roads green belt deveopment eic The drains shall be regLrbnydesalted particu ady afler the monsoon and main[ained propeny.

13. Greenbet shall be deve oped all along lhe mine Lease area and haul roads The Projeclproponeni shall do iree plantaUon ln al least 33% of lhe space prefehbly along lhe periphery andin va@nt space. Fasi growing and lo@l species wili beplanled ln case land is not avaiable wlththe lease or lt s not possible to plani tees due io nature oi land, then PP will do ne@ssary aforestalion at other place/and.

14. Effective safeguard measures such as regu arwater sprinkling shallbe carried out in criticalareas prone io air pollulion and having high evels o, parliculale malier such as loadins andunloading poi.t and lransrer points Enensve water sprinkLins shall be carried oul on haul roadwhich shoold be made pucca wilh suitEbLe w.ler drainage arEngemenb. It should be ensuredihat the AmbientAir Qualily Parameters conform lo the norms presffibed by lhe Centralpollltionconirol Board in th s regard.

12. D mension ofthe relain ng wal at the toe of the OB benches wlthin lhe mine lo check ronoffand sllation shallbe based on lhe.a n falldaia

15. The prcject proponenl should implement sutable conservation rneasures io augmentground water resour.es in the a€a in mnsullation with GroLnd Water Dire.torate Govemment oiJharkhand / Cent6l Ground Waler Board

16. The prcject proponqt shal if requned, obran necessary prior permission / Noc of rhecompeienl aulhorlties for drawl of requisiie quantity oi waier required forlhe prcject.

17. Suilable rain waie. hatuesii.g measures shalLbe planned and implemenled !r consultationwilhthe Ground Water Oirectorate. Governmenl of Jharkhand / CenlralGround Water Board.

18, Vehicular emiss ons shallbe kepl under coni.oland egula y moniiored. Measures shallbelaken for malntenance ofvehlces used in mining ope.ations and in iransporiaion of mineral. The

l4ineral T€nspoiation shall be carried oul lhrough lhe covered trucks only and the veh]cescarryinq the mineral shall not be ovenoaded

19, No blasiing shal be carried oul after the sunsel. Blasting operation shall be €nied outdoring the daylime. controlled b asr n9 sha I be pEcti@d The m tigat ve measures lor conl.ol ofground vibraUonsand to airest tly rocks and bouldeB should be implemenied.

20. Drllls shall eilher be opeEted with the dusi exlractoB or equipped wiih water injection

21, PP shalloblain €qulsiie pemission from the cone.ned OGI,IS befo€ any b asting aciivily.

22. Eftective saieguard measures should beiaken lo conkolfugitive emssions so as lo ensu€ihat RSPM (PM 10AND PM 2 5) levels are withi. prescribed limits.

23- Pe- pla@ment medi@l eraminaiion and periodiel medical examinalion of th€ workeEengaged inthe prcjecrshallbe caiiied outand recods maintained.

24. The prcje.1 proponenl shall take all pre@utonary measures during mining operaiion forconse ation and pmleclion of endangered fauna.

i5. Provision shall be made tor ihe housing of conslruclion labor wilhin the site with allnecessary infrastructure and faciities such as fuel for cooking mobile loilet, septc tanks, safedinking waier Medica healih @re, eic The houslng may be in ihe iom oftemporary strLrcturesto be removed afier lhe @mpleiion of ihe p.oieci

26. Proper safety measu@s as per statutory Equireme.t are to be implemented around lhemined out pii p or lo closure of siie. The proponent shall ensure lhat barbed wire fencing is donealong ihe pit as a safetyp€caution

27. A iinal mine closure plan along with corpus fLrnd duly apprcved by Compelent Auihorityshall be submined to Jharkhand Srare Pollulion Contbl Boad, Ranchi and to concemed OIVO inadvan@ oriinalmine c osure for approval.

28. The projecl proponent shall obiain Consenl to Eslablish (CTE) and Consenr ro OpeEre(CTO) ircm the Jha*hand Siate Pollulion Conlrol Board and effeciively impiement all the@ndiiions stpulaled lherein

B, General Conditions

1. No change in min flg technology and scope of workin! should be made witnout prior

approval of the siatutory authorlties / Department of lndushies, llines & GeologyGovernmenl of Jharkhand / Jharkhand Slate Pollution Contol Board Ranchl during the EC

2, No change in lhe ca endar plan incLuding excavation, quantlm of mineral ard wasle

3, The prcject proponent shal make all internal roads puc€ and shall maintain goodhousekeep ng by reg! ar cleaning and wetting of the haul roads and rhe prem ses.

4- The projecl propon;nl shal procure / hire 1 tractor & tanker separately which shal bededicaled for waler sprink ing and green belt developmenl.

5. The p.ojeci proponenl shall maintaln register for production and dispatch and submi

6. The prcjecis proponents shal nol cui irees / carry out tree feelng in eased oui areawithoul the permisslon ol competent althority

7. ireasures shoud be laten for control oi noise levels below prescribed norms in ihe workenvionmenl Wo*ers engaged n operations ol HEMM, etc. Should be provided with earplugs/

8. ndustrlal waste water (workshop and waste water lrom lhe mine) should be popedycolecred, treated so as to conlim ro the standards oi and grease trap should be nstalled beiored scharge of workshop efi oe.ts

9. Personnel working in dusty areas should wear protective respiElory devi@ and theyshould also be povided wilh adequate tEnng and informal oo on safety and heallh aspecisOccupatonalheallh sLtoeilance prcgram of the workeE shou d be undertaken perodica ly lo obserue anycontaclions due to exposuelo dusl end lake co(ecl ve measures, il needed

10. Dispensary facllities for FlEl A d shallbe provided ai site.

11. A separate envnonmenral managemant / monirorng cel with suirable qlaifed personneshould be set-up underlhe conlrolol a Senior Execuiive, who wil report direclly lo ihe Head ol the

12. The funds earmarked tor envronmental prolection measure shoud be kepl in separalea@ount and shou d ror be.diverted for other purpose. Year wise expendilure shou d be reportedto lhe Jharkhand State Pollution Control Board, Ranchi PP shall carry oul CSTR acllvales as perGovemmeni Guidelines (% of pront /turnover) of at leasl Rs I per ton wh chever is higher

t3. The Jharkhand Stale Polllatiog. Co.trolBoard, Ranchidnedly orthrough its RegionaOfficer shall mon tor compl ance of the stipu ated condliions The projeci authoniies shou dextend full coope.ation to the office(s) by fur.shing lhe requsite data/ lnformation/

,4. fhe projecl proponent shall submt six monthly reports on the status oi @mpliance ofthe stipulated environmenta cleaEnce condtions inc uding results of montored data(both inhird copes as we as by e-mail) to the Jharkhand Slate Polluilon Contro Board, Ranch andto iis concemed RegionalOffice

15- The proponent shal upload ihe status of compliance of ihe environmenlal clearancecondilions, inciuding resulls of monitored data o. lheir websile and shall update the sameperiodcally. lt shall simultaneously be sent to Jharkhand Stale Poluiion Cont.olBoard and itsconcerned Regional Offce The criteria poluta.t levels namely; SPM RSPM, SO2, NOx(ambieni leves) oi criilcal seci oral paGmeler, Indicated for the prctect shall be monitoreda.d dispayed at a conve.lent location nearthe project shal be monltored and displayed al a@nvenlent ocat on nearthe main gate for the company ln the company in the public domain

16. The Environrnental statement for each fnancial year ending 3lst march in Form-V asis Mandaied to be submitted by the p@ject proponenl lo the Jharkhand state Pollutoncontrol Board as presfi bed under the Environment (Protect on) rules 1 986, as amendedsubsequently, shall also be put on the websle of the company aLong lhe slatus of complianceof EC condltions and sha I also to lhe concerned Regional Otrice ofJSPCA by E mail

17. AII statutory clearance shall be oblained before stadoim.ing ope€tions.

The Aulhority resetues lhe right to add any rew condition or modify the above1_

conditions or 10 revoke th'e clea.ance ii conditons stipllated above are not implemented toihe satisfaction ofAuthority orforlhat matler for any olherAdministmtive reason.

2. The Env ronmenta CleaEnce accordedof lease or lhe mine (genelally 1 0 years) Thelease area during lhe validiiy ol Environmental

shall be vaid for the period of grant / renewalPP shall not increase prodLrction rate and aller

4. The above slipulalons wolld be enforced among oiher under lhe Water (Prevention &Contro ofPolution)Act'1986, Hazardous wasles ([,lanagemeni Handling ihe Tran BoundaryMovement) Rules, 2008 and lhe Pub c Llab ty lnsurance Act,'1991 aong with ihenamendments and rules made there under and also any other orde.s passed by the Hon blesupreme court ot ndla /High co!rt of Jharkhard and a.y other co!rt of Law relating to ihe

3. ln case of any devialion or alteration in the projectOEIAA. Jharkhand for clearance, a fresh reference shouldadequacy of the condir ons mposed and to in@rporate any

5. Any Appeal against thisTriblnal, if preierred wilhn aCIeaEnce as prescribed under

proposed form those submtted tobe made to DEIAA lo assess thenew @ndil ons frequired.

Envronmenta Cearance shall lie with the Nationa Creenperod of 30 days from the date of ssue of Environmenialsection 16 oflhe Naiions Green TrbunalAci 20'10.

It was decided that the minutes of meeting be foruarded lo th€ DEIAA fo. theirconsid.raton. Vot. of thanks was delivered by Shri Sanjay Kumar Sharna (MemberSecretary, oEAC) and the meetins endod.

(Phani Bhu8han)

(8.N. Tdpati)

(sanjay Kumar shama) {Dr A. P. sinha)

{Dr. Nisam PEkash)