Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road)...

20
Design and Guidance

Transcript of Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road)...

Page 1: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Design and Guidance

Page 2: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

What areYour Choices

Page 3: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road)

Estimated effective-ness (%)

Balance ($/km/yr)

Best practice

(yes)

Animal detection systems (ADS)

82% $3,091 Yes

Increase vis. (vegetation removal)

38% $15,437 Yes

Fence (including dig barrier) 87% $32,728 Yes

Long bridges 100% $739,310

Long tunnels or long bridges 100% $1,458,060

Fence with gap and ADS 82% $24,461 Yes

Fence with underpasses 87% $30,628 Yes

Fence with overpasses 87% $10,003 Yes

Fence with under-and overpasses

87% $28,978 Yes

Page 4: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Wildlife Fencing

•Effectivenss•Materials•Installation•Access Points•Costs•Maintenance

Page 5: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

• Increases the barrier effect• Potential negative effects to Dispersal and Migration

Reducing collisions with large &small mammals by keeping animals off roads

Page 6: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Effectiveness

Fence with gap and ADS

82%

Fence with underpasses

87%

Fence with overpasses

87%

Fence with under-and overpasses

87%

Page 7: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Type of Materials

Woven metal wire Chain LinkElectric

Page 8: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Woven Metal Wire

Page 9: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Chain Link Fence

Page 10: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.
Page 11: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Table 3. Suggested fence height for selected large mammal species.4 Large UngulatesWoven Metal Wire

Fence HeightFurther

Recommendations

White-tailed deer 8-9 ft

Mule deer 8-9 ft

Elk 8-9 ft

Moose 8-9 ft

Mountain goat 8-9 ft

Bighorn sheep 10-12 ft1

Cougar 11 ft Finer mesh size, overhang

Wolf 8 ft

Black bear 8-9 ft Finer mesh size, overhang

Grizzly bear 8-9 ft

Page 12: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Installation

Dig BarrierFence PostsAttaching Wire MessTop Wire

Page 13: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Installation

LocationLengthAdding CrossingsExisting Crossings

Page 15: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Escape Opportunities from the Right-of-Way

Page 16: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Access Points Requiring Fence Breaks

Page 17: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Fencing Construction Costs

Highway Fencing Trans-Canada Highway in Banff National Park Can$25 per foot (2006)U.S. Highway 93 ( Montana) $9 to $12 per foot (2006 prices) [

Jump-outs $6,500 to $11,000

Wildlife Guards for Access Roads $30,000

Page 18: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Maintenance

Page 19: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Electric Fencing

Page 20: Design and Guidance. What are Your Choices Mitigation measure ( keeping Animals off the road) Estimated effective- ness (%) Balance ($/km/yr) Best practice.

Fencing Summary

• Several Materials to select from• Need to keep in mind the types

of Wildlife• Fencing effectiveness• How it is installed is VERY

important• Costs and Maintenance concerns

must be recognized