CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  ·...

25
CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR structures for RH/FP David Wofford Shawn MacDonald Extending Service Delivery Project October 9, 2009

Transcript of CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  ·...

Page 1: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case &

Leveraging CSR structures for RH/FP

David WoffordShawn MacDonaldExtending Service Delivery ProjectOctober 9, 2009

Page 2: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What is the Extending Service Delivery Project (ESD)?

□ Global project in reproductive health and family planning (RH/FP) funded by USAID

□ Addresses unmet need for RH/FP and increases access to services by the poor and underserved at the community level

□ Managed by Pathfinder International in partnership with MSH, IntraHealth, and Meridian Group International, Inc. Meridian provides CSR expertise

Page 3: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What is Corporate Social Responsibility in terms of NGO-Corporate Partnerships?

□ CSR is a movement to integrate social and environmental considerations into business practices

□ In practice, CSR is a growing infrastructure of standards, policies, and practices

□ For ESD, CSR means partnering with the NGOs and private sector based on mutual interests and leveraging the CSR partnerships to improve health

Page 4: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What is ESD’s approach to corporate partnerships and CSR?□ CSR/partnerships embedded in the

project – part of ESD program description□ CSR supports ESD’s mission of extending

access to RH/FP services□ ESD develops models to leverage NGO

and corporate networks at workplace and in supply chains:

1. Corporate Structure Model2. Global Business Association Model3. Global Standards-Setters Model

Page 5: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Why focus on Women in the Workplace?

Page 6: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Why focus on corporations and their suppliers?□ Companies have access to large

target populations:■ Unilever: 102 000 employees (Asia, Africa, Central &

Eastern Europe)

■ Nike suppliers: 800,000 employees, 700 factories in 52 countries □ 80% of these workers are women between the ages of 18-

24

■ GAP suppliers: 130, 000 employees in 2,000 garment factories

■ Levi Strauss suppliers: 11,400 employees worldwide

Page 7: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What evidence is there for workplace health services?

ESD’s Return on Investment Study, Bangladesh:□ Chittagong Garment Factory:

■ 450 workers, 86% female, with no onsite health services

■ Absenteeism/Turnover major business problem□ Program

■ Introduced comprehensive services including RH/FP half day/week – paid for by the factory

■ Clinic use promoted by worker peer educators■ Absenteeism, turnover, attitudes studied over 18

months

Page 8: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What evidence is there for workplace health services?

□ Results ■ Clinic highly valued■ 30% of services for RH/FP■ Absenteeism/turnover

decreased over 18 months – estimated $3 return for every $1 invested

■ Quantitative survey/focus groups – improved attitudes toward management

Page 9: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What’s different in this CSR approach for the non-health sector?□ Workplace health programs are NOT new

BUT Now:□ There are sufficient regulatory

mechanisms (“CSR System”)… and more opportunities for influencing the system

□ ESD leverages the new business context and structures based on:New incentives…New accountability systems…Better program models…Increased sustainability

Page 10: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

The CSR System

- Global Reporting Initiative- U.N. Global Compact- Calvert Women’s Principles

- Global Business Coalition on HIV/AIDS, TB and Malaria - Business for Social Responsibility - UN Global Compact

- United Nations Global Compact- Equator Principles (Private Banks)- Calvert Women’s Principles- NGO standards groups (Ag, Electronics, Toys, Mining)- Industry Associations- IFC/World Bank

- Verité- COVERCO- ITS, SGS, STR- Rainforest Alliance- Fair Trade Labeling- Retailer/Brand compliance staff- Sustainable Agricultural Network

Page 11: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

So why hasn’t business done more in RH/FP & women’s health?

There was no Business Case:

■ No incentives■ No enforcement■ No practical experience■ No data on benefits

Women’s health has not been a toppriority in the supply chain of corporations

Page 12: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

1. The Corporate Structure Model

Unilever Tea Tanzania Ltd

Page 13: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

How has ESD leveraged Unilever Tea’s structures?□ Launched partnership in 2008 to improve UTT

peer education program and health services

□ Linked into UTT’s business needs, CSR codes, and existing UTT structure

□ Piloted “Healthy Images of Manhood” (HIM) approach at workplace■ First male engagement program tailored to the

needs of the workplace■ Furthered ESD priorities in gender and FP-HIV

integration

Page 14: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Background on Unilever Tea Tanzania□ Unilever strong commitment to CSR and

employee health■ 6000 employees, 25,000 dependents, 100,000+

in surrounding rural community■ HIV is a major concern - 21% of its people in

region are HIV(+)

□ Unilever Health system■ Full service hospital and 12 dispensaries■ HIV/AIDS Care and Treatment Center, VCT■ Family planning and maternity care■ 160 worker Peer Health Educators

Page 15: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Impact at Unilever Tea□ FP services, not previously offered in UTT HIV

services, show uptake in FP by HIV clients:■ 17 new FP clients and 70 repeat visits Jan-June

2009

□ Slow increase overall of new FP clients:■ 16/month Jan-June 2009 compared to an average

of 11/month for Jan-June 2007

□ 122,492 male and 5,321 female condoms distributed by HIM-trained PHEs over 17 months

Page 16: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

How had ESD leveraged corporate structures for HIM? □ Through Unilever

■ Scale Up: UTT has expanded HIM training to 50 new PHEs (75 trained in total), managed by UTT project coordinator■ Replication:Unilever Tea Kenya to incorporate HIM into current peer educator program

□ Through other business structuresKenya business groups to incorporate HIM into existing workplace programs

Page 17: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

2. Global Business Association Model

Business for Social Responsibility (BSR)

Page 18: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

2. How is ESD leveraging global business associations for RH/FP?

□ The BSR health initiative: HERproject (“Health Enables Returns”):■ In 5 countries and 30 factories to date■ 9 major brands and long-term influence

on 250 BSR members and their suppliers■ “Return on Investment” data – business

case■ Women’s health programs designed for

the factory

Page 19: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Who is Business for Social Responsibility?

•World’s premier CSR business organization•Companies look to BSR on CSR guidance

Nearly 100 Staff in Asia, Europe, and North America:

San Francisco New York Paris Beijing Guangzhou Hong Kong

250 Corporate Members : Apple AT&T BP Caterpillar Citigroup The Coca-Cola Company Dell Ford Motor Company Gap GE GlaxoSmithKline Goldman Sachs Hitachi Home DepotHP IKEA Levi Strauss & Co.

Page 20: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What is impact of HERproject?

❑ BSR’s primary technical partner:▪ Global TA to BSR on model,

RH/FP programs and ROI and NGOs in Egypt & Pakistan

❑ HERproject impact:▪ Broad dissemination of model

through BSR ▪ Planned expansion in Pakistan▪ New $1 grant from Swedish

development agency▪ Scalability/Replicability–

workplace model tested widely

Page 21: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

3. Global Standard-Setters Model

The Calvert GroupVerité

Brand codes of conduct framed at the Lotus jeans factory in Egypt

Page 22: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

How has ESD leveraged standards-setters in the CSR system?

■ The Calvert Group□ A leading financial firm specializing in

socially responsible investments.□ Launched the Calvert Women’s Principles

for corporations in 2006

■ Verité□ A leading NGO that monitors factories and

trains monitors□ Works in 60 countries, operates a global

system for training monitors, and has conducted 1000s of workplace audits

Page 23: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

What is ESD’s role in the Women’s Principles?

□ The Women’s Principles launched in 2006, required further company guidance and performance indicators

□ ESD role: Providing TA in the re-drafting of standards and development of guidance and indicators

□ Impact: The UN Global Compact to adopt the Women’s Principles – a stakeholder process for adoption launched in June 2009

Page 24: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

How is ESD working with Verité?□ ESD provides TA to Verité in two areas:

■ Training of workplace monitors: ESD is helping to integrate RH/FP and health into compliance program of monitors

■ Standards for Monitor Trainings (US State Department process): ESD is providing input in global accreditation standards for all monitors worldwide to ensure inclusion of RH/FP & women’s health in training curricula

Page 25: CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & Leveraging CSR ...€¦ ·  · 2015-08-04CSR & NGO-Corporate Partnerships: Building the Business Case & ... business

Leveraging all parts of the CSR System for RH/FP & Women’s Health

- ROI Studies/Methodology- “Business Case” data- Male Engagement “HIM” model for workplace

- Practical Models for Factory programs-“How-to” implementation guides for suppliers/NGOs- Lessons learned

- Guidance and compliance metrics for Women’s Principles- RH/FP input on U.S. State Department monitors accreditation standards

- RH/FP into monitor training curricula- Data on country laws relating to women’s health