Crown Heights - Exploring the grid

54
CROWN HEIGHTS Exploring the Grid Antrees Engelen Koen Moesen Pieter Van den Poel Arnout Van Soom Sofie Verjans

description

Crown Heights analysis by 5 students of the thesisgroup Studio Brooklyn

Transcript of Crown Heights - Exploring the grid

  • CROWN HEIGHTSExploring the Grid

    Antrees Engelen

    Koen Moesen

    Pieter Van den Poel

    Arnout Van Soom

    Sofie Verjans

  • Essay

    Copyright by K.U.Leuven

    Without written permission of the promoters and the authors it is forbidden to reproduce or adapt in any form or by any means any part of this publication. Requests for obtaining the right to reproduce or utilize parts of this publication should be addressed to K.U.Leuven, Faculty of Engineering Kasteelpark Arenberg 1, B-3001 Heverlee (Belgi). Telefoon +32-16-32 13 50 & Fax. +32-16-32 19 88.

    A written permission of the promotor is also required to use the methods, products, schematics and programs described in this work for industrial or commercial use, and for submitting this publication in scientific contests.

    All images in this booklet are, unless credits are given, made or drawn by the authors (Studio Brooklyn).

  • CROWN HEIGHTSExploring the Grid

    Antrees Engelen

    Koen Moesen

    Pieter Van den Poel

    Arnout Van Soom

    Sofie Verjans

  • 5East New York

    SOCIAL ENCLAVES PLANNING THE CITY LIVING MODELS CITY ECOLOGY

    12 CASE STUDIES

    BROOKLYN 101

    SITE ANALYSIS

    SITE ANALYSIS

    SITE ANALYSIS

    CASE STUDIES

    COLLECTIVE CULTURE

    13 EXPERIMENTS

    EXPERIMENTS

    Red Hook

    Crown Heights

    The Studio Brooklyn Graduation Project consists of a series of books and thirteen postcards. First of is Five Chapters on a City Life, created by the complete group that works around the observations we did on our trip. The book also holds thirteen postcards, each freezing a memory of an urban experiment we experienced during our stay in New York.The second book contains twelve case studies on a wide array of topics, relevant to the condition in Brooklyn. Then there are three site analyzes carried out by three to five students in the neighborhoods of Red Hook, Crown Heights and East New York. Throughout the different documents we jump in three scales: the borough, our strip from old port to airport and finally the three chosen neighborhoods.

    Red HookCrown Heights

    East New York

    The Studio Brooklyn Graduation Project

    consists of a series of books and thirteen

    postcards. First is Five Chapters on a City

    Life, created by the complete group that

    works around the observations we did on

    our trip.

    Then second are three site analyses

    carried out by three to five students in

    the neighborhoods of Red Hook, Crown

    Heights and East New York.

    This booklet is a specific analysis of the

    neighborhood Crown Heights.

    Throughout the different documents we

    jump in three scales: the borough, our strip

    from old port to airport and finally the three

    chosen neighborhoods. Our neighborhood

    Crown Heights is located in the center of

    Brooklyn, and presents itself mostly as a

    black neighborhood.

    This analysis starts with an overview

    of Crown Heights cultural history, from

    the original inhabitants in the 1700s until

    the ethnic diversity today. Maps of the

    population of Crown Heights show different

    trends that are currently occurring. In the

    following chapter, the infrastructure of the

    neighborhood is set out in various maps,

    coupled with the land use.

    Subsequently the different typologies

    in the neighborhood are explored, and

    to conclude our analysis, some shifting

    tendencies are examined.

    We made this booklet to gain insight in the

    neighborhood Crown Heights, to start our

    individual design proposals with proper

    knowledge.

    13 EXPERIMENTS

    EXPERIMENTS

    The Studio Brooklyn Graduation Project consists of a series of books and thirteen postcards. First of is Five Chapters on a City Life, created by the complete group that works around the observations we did on our trip. The book also holds thirteen postcards, each freezing a memory of an urban experiment we experienced during our stay in New York.The second book contains twelve case studies on a wide array of topics, relevant to the condition in Brooklyn. Then there are three site analyzes carried out by three to five students in the neighborhoods of Red Hook, Crown Heights and East New York. Throughout the different documents we jump in three scales: the borough, our strip from old port to airport and finally the three chosen neighborhoods.

    Red HookCrown Heights

    East New York

    PREFACE

  • P23Ethnic Diversity

    P5Location of Crown Heights

    P11Crown Heights Grid

    P15Historical Map 1845

    P17Historical Map 1890

    P27Transportation

    P29Subway Lines

    P31Long Island Railroad

    P33Bike Routes

    P39Public Housing

    P47Spatial Indicators of Gentrification

    P19Map 2012

    P45Level of Education

    P37Residential Landuse

    P43Unemployment and Public Safety

  • CONTENTS

    Mindmap P09

    Crown Heights Grid P11

    [1] Cultural History Historical Map 1845 P15

    Historical Map 1890 P17

    Map 2012 P19

    Timeline P21

    Ethnic Diversity P23

    [2] Infrastructure Transportation P27

    Subway lines P29

    Long Island Railroad P31

    Bike routes P33

    [3] Typologies Residential Land Use P37

    Public Housing P39

    [4] Shifting TendenciesUnemployment and Public Safety P43

    Level of Education P45

    Spatial indicators of gentrification P47

    References

  • 8 | MindmapINTRODUCTION

  • 10 |

    The analysis presented in this booklet is an

    introduction to 5 design proposals located

    in Crown Heights. The designs are all on

    different scales, and they deal with various

    topics.

    A first approach to analyse Crown

    Heights was to define the borders of the

    neighborhood. This approach taught us

    that neighborhoods with the grid as only

    structure dont have specific borders.

    The aspects that form these borders can

    change in a very short period of time. That

    is why we changed our area of analysis to

    a larger area, including parts of adjacent

    neighborhoods: Bed-Stuy, Brownsville,

    Prospect Heights, East Flatbush and

    Lefferts Garden.

    Crown Heights GridINTRODUCTION

  • Historical Map 1845

    Historical Map 1890

    Map 2012

    Timeline

    Ethnic Diversity

    CULTURAL HISTORY

  • 14

    In 1609, the English explorer Henry Hudson arrived in what is now called the New York Harbor. By the 1630s, Dutch and English settlers were exploring the west of Long Island. Crown Heights was then a hilly forested area inhabited by Lenape Indians. By the 1660-s, the area around the northwestern corner of Crown Heights became known as Bedford. Its roads were based on the Lenapes hunting paths, which on their turn were based on the topography. The settlement was located along one of Long Islands most important road which connected Jamaica with the East River ferries. By the time of the American Revolution (1775-1783) Brooklyn was an agricultural community, housing about four thousand inhabitants. Bedford Corners was a small village with a tavern, a blacksmith, a school, a brewery, and a couple of farmhouses. In the early 1800-s, Bedford was the home of many prominent Dutch families like the Lefferts family. In 1836, the Brooklyn & Jamaica Railroad (later part of the Long Island Rail Road LIRR) opened and connected the East Rivers South Ferry with Jamaica. Although Bedford had a train station, not much development took place. Downtown Brooklyns development would eventually reach Bedford.

    CULTURAL HISTORY | Map 1845

    [1] Bedfort Corners in 1776

  • 16

    City planners designed the street grid in 1855 to stimulate urban development. The grid was based on the main streets of the small existing villages, which on their turn were based on the topography, like the Brooklyns Green Mountains before it was flattened. Although Brooklyns population grew to about 400.000 in 1870, Crown Heights only developed slowly. The Eastern Parkway and Prospect Park, both designed by Olmsted and Vaux, were completed around 1868. By the 1870-s, an extensive network of horse car routes and three city railroads linked North Crown Heights with the many East River ferries. The area was being promoted as a first-class neighborhood and became one of Manhattans suburbs. But its growth appeared to be limited by the unreliability of the ferries, which were dependent on the weather. The completion of the Brooklyn Bridge in 1883 offered a solution to this problem. Residential construction increased although North Crown Heights largest development only came after the opening of the Kings County Elevated Railway in 1888, which went from the Fulton Ferry to Nostrand Avenue. By the mid-1890-s, the former rural area was transformed into a suburban and urban neighborhood. Transportation improvements, like the electrification of the horse car lines and construction of the street grid continued throughout the 1890-s.

    CULTURAL HISTORY | Map 1890

    [1] Bedfort Corners in 1776 and 1916

  • 18

    In 1898, the year in which Brooklyn

    fused with the four other boroughs into

    New York City, the first electrified Kings

    County Railway train crossed the Brooklyn

    Bridge. The direct ride from Crown Heights

    North to Lower Manhattan made the

    neighborhood an even more desirable

    residential area. The area developed from

    towards Eastern Parkway in the south, and

    to west and east along the Kings County

    Railway. Even after the completion of the

    street grid, residential typologies continued

    to evolve: in the 1920-s, developers began

    demolishing the largest mansions in former

    exclusive residential streets in order to build

    apartment houses. Housing development

    in south Crown Heights around Eastern

    Parkway strongly increased with the

    opening of the subway line in 1920. But the

    neighborhood declined through the 1960-

    s as apartment buildings were abandoned

    and the community steadily became

    poorer. This is also represented by the

    construction of public housing throughout

    the 1970-s. Nowadays, north Crown

    Heights experiences a gentrification wave

    from Prospect Heights towards the historic

    districts in the center of Crown Heights.

    CULTURAL HISTORY | Map 2012

  • 20

    Total Population (100%)

    White (%)

    Black (%)

    Hispanic (%)

    As mentioned before, Crown Heights was the former home of the western Long Islands native Lenape Indians. Their tribes and paths ran across the area until it was purchased in 1700 by Leffert Pieterse, to be farmed by African American slaves. The opening of the reliable steam driven Fulton Ferry in 1814 caused a flow of people towards Brooklyn. The state New York prohibited slavery in 1827, 38 years before the official nationwide prohibition in 1865. Some of the African Americans purchased property and founded two black communities known as Weeksville and Carrville in the northeast corner of present-day Crown Heights. The area became known as Crow Hill, probably because the white people called the African Americans crows. City planners designed the street grid in 1855. The northern section quickly became a desirable residential area: mansions and limestone row houses were built to replace the old farms. Eastern Parkway was completed in 1868. The boulevard made the northern part of Crown Heights an even more desirable residential area, and more large houses were built. The opening of the Brooklyn Bridge in 1883 and the unification of the five boroughs into New York City caused a second flow of people from Manhattan to Brooklyn. Many brick and brownstone row houses were built. The attractiveness of south Crown Heights increased with the opening of the subway line under the Eastern

    Parkway in 1920. Many Jews migrated from the heavily Jewish neighbourhoods of Williamsburg, Brownsville and Manhattans Lower East Side. From the 1920s to the 1960s, Crown Heights was a mainly white neighbourhood, largely composed of Protestants, Catholics, and Jews. In the 1940s, Jews even represented 42% of the white population in Crown Heights. Many were Chabad-Lubavitch (Ultra-Orthodox) Jews who had emigrated from the Soviet Union. 770 Eastern Parkway became their headquarters from then on. After World War II, three developments rapidly changed Crown Heights ethnic composition. The first development was the White Flight: the expanding black population of Bed-Stuy pushed southward while many veterans moved to the suburbs with the assistance of the G.I. Bill. The second development was the 1965 Immigration and Nationality Act, which reformed Americas immigration policy. The Act resulted in a sharp increase in the number of immigrants and their ethnic structure. Whereas immigrants before 1965 came primarily from Europe, after 1965, more than 80 % came from Asia, South and Central America, Africa, and the Caribbean. In 1969, the first West Indian-American Day Carnival on Eastern Parkway was organized. And since then the Hispanic population kept growing until what it is today: the largest West Indian neighbourhood in the city. The third factor of the demographic transformation

    of Crown Heights was the growth of the Lubavitch Jewish community. The opening of the subway in 1920 and the immigration of European and Russian Jews after World War II vastly increased the number of Lubavitch Jews. Racial tension between the Jews and African Americans came to a tragic climax in august 1991 when a Guyanese child was killed by a car driven by an important Lubavitch Rabbi. The following riot lasted three days in which a visiting Australian Jew was killed. Neighbourhood organizations responded to the tensions with community-building ventures like the annual Unity Day. Nevertheless racial tensions were seen again in 2008 when a black man was assaulted by Ludavitch Jews because a Jewish teenager was robbed and beaten by black teenagers the week before. Today, racial tensions have decreased due to frequent meetings between the black and Jewish community leaders but are nonetheless still strongly present in a few blocks. Since 1990, there is a gentrification wave noticeable from Park Slope in the west, through Prospect Heights in the past decade, and nowadays entering North Crown Heights towards its historic districts.

    CULTURAL HISTORY | Timeline

  • 1700Leffert

    Pieterse

    LenapeIndians

    512.000 people

    128.000

    32.000

    8.000

    2.000

    500

    1814Fulton Ferry

    1827Weeksville &

    Carrville

    1855Street Grid

    1868Eastern Parkway

    1883Brooklyn Bridge

    1898Consolidation

    of NYC

    1920Opening Subway

    1945White Flight

    1965Immigration and Nationality Act

    1991Crown

    Heights Riots

    2008 Increased

    Racial Tensions

    21

  • 22

    Overall, Crown Heights is a black

    neighborhood with a gradient of 50%

    blacks in the western part to 90% in the

    eastern part.

    Though Crown Heights is mostly a black

    neighborhood, there are some noticeable

    differences:

    The east of Bedford Avenue, there live

    almost 50% whites due to the spreading

    gentrification process. In the center of

    Crown Heights, south of the Eastern

    Parkway, lives a strong concentration of

    whites, the Lubavitch Jew community. In

    the eastern part of Crown Heights, the

    10% non-blacks are generally Hispanic. In

    Bushwick, the north-east of the map, the

    majority of the people are also Hispanic.

    The opening of the subway in 1920 and

    the immigration of European and Russian

    Jews after World War II increased the

    number of Lubavitch Jews. They did not

    move out of Crown Heights like other white

    people because the cultural gap between

    them and their black neighbors was so

    wide that there was a small chance that

    younger Lubavitchers would absorb values

    of the black majority.

    Black100 %

    Hispanic100 %

    White100 %

    CULTURAL HISTORY | Ethnic Diversity

    White 100%

    Black 100%

    Hispanic 100%

    Mosque

    Church

    Synagogue

    [1] Lubavitch Jew Kids

  • Transportation

    Subway lines

    Long Island Railroad

    Bike routes

    INFRASTRUCTURE

  • 26 | TransportationINFRASTRUCTURE

    By car every neighborhood in Brooklyn is

    reachable from Crown Heights within thirty

    minutes. The second fastest way to get to

    other neighborhoods is by bike. By public

    transport almost every neighborhood is

    reachable within one hour. The slowest

    way of transportation is obviously by foot.

    Some neighborhoods are even more than

    a 90 minutes walking distance away [1].

    The streetgrid of Crown Heights is for a

    major part defined by different ways of

    transportation. The differences in car traffic

    intensity, the subway lines, the partially

    elevated Long Island Railroad, and the

    amount of bus traffic shape the grid.

    Time-distance from Crown Heights to other neighborhoods by car/ by bike / by public transport / by foot

    5 m

    in10

    min

    20 m

    in30

    min

    60 m

    in

    90 m

    in

    [1] Time-distance from Crown Heights to other neighborhoods in Brooklyn

    Time-distance from Crown Heights to other neighborhoods by car/ by bike / by public transport / by foot

    5 m

    in10

    min

    20 m

    in30

    min

    60 m

    in

    90 m

    in

    Subway lines

    Elevated Subway lines

    Bus linesTraffic Intensity

  • 28

    [1] Commercial activity at Nostrand Avenue

    [2] Subway station at Kingston Avenue at Eastern Parkway

    The development of the commercial

    streets in Crown Heights is linked with the

    subway stations.

    The A and C lines run along Fulton Street,

    and the 3 and 4 lines run along Eastern

    Parkway. Between the subway stations of

    both lines, commercial activity has been

    developed over time. So the commercial

    streets form connections between the

    subway stations.

    The bus lines running through Crown

    Heights are complementary to the subway

    lines. While the subway lines run east-

    west, the bus lines mostly run north-south,

    along the commercial streets.

    Mixed commercial and residential

    Commerical | Subway linesINFRASTRUCTURE

    Subway lines

    Elevated Subway lines

    Bus lines

  • 30

    [2] The elevated Long Island Railroad along Atlantic Avenue

    [1] Atlantic Avenue

    The partially elevated Long Island Railroad

    runs along Atlantic Avenue from East to

    West all the way through Crown Heights.

    Small industries like auto repair shops and storage facilities create a buffer between

    the noisy train and traffic and the residential

    neighborhood surrounding it.

    The same is to be noted for the elevated

    subway lines, shown on the map.

    Elevated subway lines

    LIRR

    Transporation and UtilityIndustrial and Manufacturing | Long Island RailroadINFRASTRUCTURE

  • 32

    [1] Brooklyn-Queens Greenway

    The Brooklyn-Queens Greenway is a network of bicycle and pedestrian pathways that connects parks and communities.This network runs from Coney Island in the south of Brooklyn, along Prospect Park and the eastern parkway, all the way up to Fort Totten on the Long Island Sound in Queens [1]. The Greenway holds all sorts of amenities, cultural experiences, and passes parks, botanical gardens, the Brooklyn museum, the New York Hall of Science, and different ethnic and historic neighborhoods. The greenways connecting these aminities are multi-use paths for pedestrians, joggers, cyclists, skaters, and wheelchair users. Greenways are natural and constructed linear corridors, where people walk, stroll, or bike for recreation, exercise, and commuting. In Crown Heights, this greenway is interrupted from Ralph Avenue (the end of the Eastern Parkway) until the Highland Park in Queens. To connect this interruption, Mayor Bloomberg proposed a masterplan for the Eastern Parkway Extension, using the existing bike paths that mostly run from east to west.

    Apart from the great Prospect Park, Crown Heights doesnt have a lot of green open spaces. But the few present parks and playgrounds are well spread across the neighborhood.

    [3] Prospect Park

    Open Space and Outdoor Recreation

    Existing Bike Routes

    Eastern Parkway | Bike RoutesINFRASTRUCTURE

    [2] Logo Greenway at Eastern Parkway

    Planned connecting Bike Routes

    Northern and Southern Route to

    connect the greenway

  • Residential Land Use

    Public Housing

    TYPOLOGIES

  • 36 Residential Landuse |

    The fairly equally sized blocks of Crown

    Height are mainly covered with a residential

    use. One is able to note three significant

    different morphological strategies. The

    first one is a (neo-)traditional development

    of row houses, which is surely the

    most prominent. The second one is the

    Modernist tower-in-the-park approach.

    The third one is a rather more suburban

    condition of detached units and is only

    to be found in a small part of the Jewish

    neighborhood.

    On a smaller morphological scale, Crown

    Heights is a historical collage of the

    typical typologies of New York City. The

    original tenements for low income people

    with its small air shafts originate from the

    19th century. Since then they have been

    regulated and the poor living conditions

    have been improved by several Tenement

    Laws. In contrary to the tenement, the

    garden apartment was designed for

    moderate incomes. The single-family

    Brownstone and its similar multi-family

    row house developments, also provided

    better living conditions. From the 1950s

    to the 1970s the slum clearance program

    resulted in many towers, looming over the

    skyline of Crown Heights.

    CROWN HEIGHTS Exploring the grid

    TYPOLOGY

    TYPOLOGIESOne and two family buildings

    Multi-family buildings

    [1] [2] [3]

    [4] [5] [6]

  • [1]

    [2]

    [3][4]

    [5]

    [6]

  • 38

    NYCHA Public Housing

    Median Household income 2005-2009:

    < $25000

    $25000 - $45000

    [1] Prospect Plaza towers

    The New York City Housing Authority (NYCHA) has been providing public housing since 1934. The slum clearance program boosted the amount of public housing, mostly in the shape of Modernist towers-in-the-park. The map shows the success of the NYCHAs ability to create and maintain housing for the poor. Unfortunately this strategy has led to areas of concentrated poverty, not only attracting crime and violence, but also enlarging the racial segregation in public housing. Like many other Housing Authorities all over the U.S., the NYCHA is suffering from its own success. Today, many federal programs are therefore focusing on the demolition of the problematic towers-in-the-park, often resulting in a displacement of 90% of the former residents. The NYCHA is resisting this national trend towards demolition with a preservation and maintenance policy. Unfortunately, despite the crucial role of the NYCHA, a continuously disinvestment by the government in the NCYHA is resulting in the disrepair of many of its buildings, making the living conditions in these concentrated areas of poverty even worse.

    [2] Albany I & II

    Public Housing | TYPOLOGIES

  • Unemployment and Public Safety

    Level of Education

    Spatial indicators of gentrification

    SHIFTING TENDENCIES

  • 42

    The median household income is evidently

    related to the number of unemployed

    inhabitants. Its notable that the

    unemployment rate follows a gradient from

    very low in eastern part of Crown Heights

    near Prospect Heights to very high in the

    western part near Brownsville.

    According to the New York Times the

    number of murders in Crown Heights has

    decreased during the last years. The map

    shows the location of murders from 2007 to

    2011. The murders are clearly following the

    same pattern as the unemployment rate.

    Therefore the surroundings of Prospect

    Heights are a far more safer area than

    the area near Brownsville. An interesting

    anomaly is the significant absence of

    murders in the Jewish neighborhood.

    The unemployment rate in the Jewish

    neighborhood is also remarkably low. Note

    the resemblance of the unemployment

    map and the map of the ethnic diversity.

    0-10%

    ...

    + 40%

    Unemployment: the percentage unemployed (census 2000)

    0 - 10 %

    10 - 20 %20 - 30 %

    30 - 40 %+40 % murdered by knife

    murdered by rearm

    C,M,Y,K = 15,22,0,0

    C,M,Y,K = 30,45,0,0C,M,Y,K = 60,90,0,20

    C,M,Y,K = 60,90,0,40

    C,M,Y,K = 60,90,0,60Murdered by firearm

    Murdered by knife

    Unemployment percentages:

    Unemployment and Public Safety | SHIFTING TENDENCIES

    [1] Surveillance Cameras

  • 44

    The level of education in Crown Heights

    is clearly a determining factor for the

    unemployment rate, as the percentage

    of inhabitants with an educational level

    less than High School appears to show a

    similar gradient from Prospect Heights to

    Brownsville.

    When inspecting the physical presence

    of schools in the different areas, one is

    surprisingly able to conclude that there

    is no correlation between the presence

    of the 18 High Schools and the level of

    education. This seems also to be true

    for the 88 Elementary Schools, the 16

    Middle Schools and the 13 K-12 Schools.

    Although upon looking to the physical

    presence of a possible higher educational

    program, it is noticeable that the colleges

    and universities are only situated in the

    west part of Crown Heights.

    It can be concluded that the level of

    education is not largely influenced by the

    physical presence of schools, but rather

    by other factors like median household

    income or family configuration. One can

    for example note that the inhabitants of the

    Jewish neighborhood are higher educated

    than the surrounding area. Elementary SchoolMiddle School

    High School (HS)

    K-12 Schools and Junior HS / HS

    College / univeristy

    5-10%

    ...

    50-60%

    Percentage less than High School Degree:

    5 - 10 %

    Education: the percentage less than High School (census 2000)

    10 - 15 %15 - 20 %

    20 - 30 %30 - 40 %

    40 - 50 %50 - 60 % College / University

    K-12 Schools and Junior HS / HS

    High School (HS)Middle School

    Elementary School

    C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,10

    C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,15C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,20

    C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,28C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,38

    C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,48

    C,M,Y,K = 0,0,0,60Level of Education | SHIFTING TENDENCIES

    [1] School playground

  • 46

    Increase with 1 to 20%

    Increase with more than 50%

    Decrease with 1 to 20%

    Decrease with more than 50%

    According to an unpublished Kontokosta,

    C.E. and CHPC 2009 gentrification

    model, Prospect Heights and North

    Crown Heights are the most gentrified

    neighborhoods in Brooklyn. Crown Heights

    has several Historic Districts, which have

    a strong attraction to first wave gentrifiers,

    and proximity to public transport and to

    Manhattan. Moreover the proximity to

    gentrified areas like Park Slope accelerates

    the gentrification through a spillover

    effect. For 1990-2000, four possible spatial

    indicators of gentrification in North Crown

    Heights and Prospect Heights are the

    increase in ownership rate (demographic),

    increase in monthly gross rent (economic),

    increase in number of inmovers (moving

    pattern), and the decrease of vacancy rate

    (physical). These indicators result in the

    spatial gentrification index, which shows a

    gentrification wave from Prospect Heights

    going to Crown Heights Historic Districts.

    The 2000-2010 difference in population

    density shows, besides the gentrified

    area near Prospect Heights, also a drastic

    increase in population in the area of

    Brownsville.

    2%

    4 %

    6 %

    8 %

    10 %

    12 %

    $ 250

    $ 350

    $ 450

    $ 550

    $ 650

    $ 750

    6 %

    14 %

    21 %

    28 %

    35 %

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    -6

    -4

    0

    4

    8

    12

    PROSPECT HEIGHTS

    Washington Av

    Bedfort Av

    Vanderbilt Av

    Ralph Av

    Utica Av

    CROWN HEIGHTS

    OWNERSHIP RATE

    MONTLY RENT

    INMOVERS

    VACANCY RATE

    SPACIAL GENTRIFICATION INDEX

    2000

    1990

    Historical Districts

    Population Density evolution 2000-2010:

    25%

    $ 39.270

    average household size: 2,58 22% of total households are withfemale householder and related children

    median household income

    15,6% own his housing unit 31,1% of all families has a vehicle available

    25% of the peoplelives below the poverty level

    foreign born 32,2%

    white 6,8%black 78%

    asian 4,8%

    hispanic 10,4%

    22%

    12%

    $ 80.072

    average household size: 2,33 8,8% of total households are withfemale householder and related children

    median household income

    27,4% own his housing unit 42,6% of all families has a vehicle available

    12% of the peoplelives below the poverty level

    foreign born 16,4%white 54,8%

    black 15,9%asian 3,2%

    hispanic 25,6%

    8,8%

    36%

    $ 25.954

    average household size: 2,96 34% of total households are withfemale householder and related children

    median household income

    15,7% own his housing unit 33,8% of all families has a vehicle available

    36% of the peoplelives below the poverty level

    foreign born 27%

    white 0,9%black 81%

    asian 0,9%

    hispanic 17,2%

    Park Slope

    crown heights

    Brownsville

    34%

    Spatial Indicators of Gentrification | SHIFTING TENDENCIES

  • Bedf

    ord

    Aven

    ue

    Washington Avenue

    Utic

    a Av

    enue

    Ral

    ph A

    venu

    e

    Roc

    kaw

    ay A

    venu

    e

    Nos

    trand

    Ave

    nue

    Vand

    erbi

    lt Av

    enue

  • REFERENCES

  • P11 GOOGLE MAPS Sattelite Image of Crown Heights, Brooklyn, NYC, http://www.google.be/maps, last visited 12/04/12.

    P14 WIKIPEDIA, South Ferry, Brooklyn, 2010, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Ferry,_Brooklyn, last visited: 12/04/12.

    GOLDSCHMIDT, Henry, Race and Religion Among the Chosen People of Crown Heights, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2006. KELLY, Wilhelmena, Images of America: Crown Heights and Weeksville, Arcadia Publishing, Ports- mouth, San Franscisco, 2009.

    SHAPIRO, Edward, Crown Heights, Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot, Brandeis University Press, Waltham, Massachusetts, 2006.

    GROSSMAN, Elizabeth, MECHIK, Leonid, YUCE, Veysel, A History of Tension: Race Relations in Crown Heights, 2012, http://www.humanityinaction.org/knowledgebase/80-a-history-of-tension-race- relations-in-crown-heights, last visited: 12/04/12.

    RULE, Sheila, The Voices and Faces of Crown Heights, 1994, http://www.nytimes.com/1994/04/15/ arts/the-voices-and-faces-of-crown-heights.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm, last visited: 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights North, http://www.crownheightsnorth.com/history2.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    WALLABOUT HISTORIC DISTRICT, Designation Report, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/lpc/down loads/pdf/reports/wallabout.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www. archive.org/stream/bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    NYCLPC, Landmark Designation Report, 1986, http://www.flickr.com/photos/emilio_guer ra/5473377527/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    [Image P14] STILES, Bedford corners in 1776, 1867, van NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www.archive.org/stream/bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/ mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    P15 BACH, A. D.; HASSLER, F. R., New York Bay Harbor, from the David Rumsey Historical Map Collection, 1845, http://www.davidrumsey.com/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    P16 GOLDSCHMIDT, Henry, Race and Religion Among the Chosen People of Crown Heights, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2006.

    KELLY, Wilhelmena, Images of America: Crown Heights and Weeksville, Arcadia Publishing, Ports- mouth, San Franscisco, 2009.

    SHAPIRO, Edward, Crown Heights, Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot, Brandeis University Press, Waltham, Massachusetts, 2006. NYC Bicyce Master Plan, The Greenway System, 2003, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/bike/green sys.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    relations-in-crown-heights, last visited: 12/04/12.

    RULE, Sheila, The Voices and Faces of Crown Heights, 1994, http://www.nytimes.com/1994/04/15/ arts/the-voices-and-faces-of-crown-heights.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm, last visited: 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights North, http://www.crownheightsnorth.com/history2.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    WALLABOUT HISTORIC DISTRICT, Designation Report, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/lpc/down loads/pdf/reports/wallabout.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www. archive.org/stream/bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    NYCLPC, Landmark Designation Report, 1986, http://www.flickr.com/photos/emilio_guer ra/5473377527/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    [Image P16] STILES, Map of Bedford Corners in 1776-77 and 1916, 1916, van NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www.archive.org/stream/ bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    P17 Bien, Joseph Rudolf; The Narrows to Jamaica Bay-Coney Island, north to Brooklyn from the David Rumsey Historical Map Collection, 1890, http://www.davidrumsey.com/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    P18 GOLDSCHMIDT, Henry, Race and Religion Among the Chosen People of Crown Heights, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2006.

    KELLY, Wilhelmena, Images of America: Crown Heights and Weeksville, Arcadia Publishing, Ports- mouth, San Franscisco, 2009.

    SHAPIRO, Edward, Crown Heights, Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot, Brandeis University Press, Waltham, Massachusetts, 2006.

    GROSSMAN, Elizabeth, MECHIK, Leonid, YUCE, Veysel, A History of Tension: Race Relations in Crown Heights, 2012, http://www.humanityinaction.org/knowledgebase/80-a-history-of-tension-race- relations-in-crown-heights, last visited: 12/04/12.

    RULE, Sheila, The Voices and Faces of Crown Heights, 1994, http://www.nytimes.com/1994/04/15/ arts/the-voices-and-faces-of-crown-heights.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm, last visited: 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights North, http://www.crownheightsnorth.com/history2.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    WALLABOUT HISTORIC DISTRICT, Designation Report, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/lpc/down loads/pdf/reports/wallabout.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www. archive.org/stream/bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    NYCLPC, Landmark Designation Report, 1986, http://www.flickr.com/photos/emilio_guer ra/5473377527/, last visited: 12/04/12.

  • P23 THE U.S. CENSUS BUREAU, t_pl_p3a_ct.xlsx, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/download/ censuscensus2010/t_pl_p3a_ct.xlsx, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    UNKNOWN, Map Churches Crown Heights, 2012, http://maps.google.be/maps, last visited 12/04/12.

    References Land Use, see P29 - Public Institutions.

    P26 GOOGLE MAPS - Directions, Brooklyn, NYC, http://www.google.be/maps, last visited 12/04/12.

    P27 METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, Brooklyn Bus Map, 2011, http://www.mta.info/ nyct/maps/busbkln.pdf, last visited: 23/11/2011.

    METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, New York City Subway, with railroad connections,2011, http://www.mta.info/nyct/maps/subwaymap.pdf, last visited: 10/11/2011.

    P29 New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 2, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/ lucds/bk2profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 3, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/ lucds/bk3profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 4, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/ lucds/bk4profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 8, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/ lucds/bk8profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 9, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/ lucds/bk9profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 16, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/ pdf/lucds/bk16profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 17, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/ pdf/lucds/bk17profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    P31 References Land Use, see P29 - Industrial Land Use.

    METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, New York City Subway, with railroad connections,2011, http://www.mta.info/nyct/maps/subwaymap.pdf, last visited: 10/11/2011.

    P32 CITY OF NEW YORK PARKS & RECREATION, Brooklyn-Queens Greenway Guide, 2007, http://www.nycgovparks.org/sub_things_to_do/facilities/images/Brooklyn_Queens_GreenwayGuide. pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    NYC Bicyce Master Plan, The Greenway System, 2003, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/bike/green sys.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    P33 NYC Department of City Planning, The Brooklyn-Queens Greenway, Eastern Parkway Extension , 2006, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/html/transportation/td_eastern_pkwy_extention.

    shtml, last visited: 12/04/12.

    P20 GOLDSCHMIDT, Henry, Race and Religion Among the Chosen People of Crown Heights, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, New Jersey, 2006.

    KELLY, Wilhelmena, Images of America: Crown Heights and Weeksville, Arcadia Publishing, Ports- mouth, San Franscisco, 2009.

    SHAPIRO, Edward, Crown Heights, Blacks, Jews, and the 1991 Brooklyn Riot, Brandeis University Press, Waltham, Massachusetts, 2006.

    GROSSMAN, Elizabeth, MECHIK, Leonid, YUCE, Veysel, A History of Tension: Race Relations in Crown Heights, 2012, http://www.humanityinaction.org/knowledgebase/80-a-history-of-tension-race- relations-in-crown-heights, last visited: 12/04/12.

    RULE, Sheila, The Voices and Faces of Crown Heights, 1994, http://www.nytimes.com/1994/04/15/ arts/the-voices-and-faces-of-crown-heights.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm, last visited: 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights North, http://www.crownheightsnorth.com/history2.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    WALLABOUT HISTORIC DISTRICT, Designation Report, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/lpc/down loads/pdf/reports/wallabout.pdf, last visited: 12/04/12.

    NEW YORK STATE LOCAL HISTORY LEAFLETS, Bedfort Corners, Brooklyn, 1917, http://www. archive.org/stream/bedfordcornersbr00univ#page/n7/mode/2up, last visited: 12/04/11.

    NYCLPC, Landmark Designation Report, 1986, http://www.flickr.com/photos/emilio_guer ra/5473377527/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    P21 WRIGHT, Henry, Fulton Ferry, New York, 1890, http://www.postaprint.co.uk/ilnimages/i901343.jpg, last visited 12/04/12.

    STILES, Edward, Town of Brooklyn and Part of Long Island, 1867, http://www.geographicus-archive.com/P/AntiqueMap/BrooklynTwn-stiles-1867, last visited 12/04/12.

    SCHUSZLER, Alajos, Shoe Shine, Eastern Parkway, 1938, http://www.nycgovparks.org/photo/ archivesthe_african_american_experience/photo-15292-Shoe-Shine#more_text, last visited 12/04/12.

    ILLMAN, Thomas, Twenty Five Miles Round The City Of New York, 1835, http://www.davidrumsey. com/luna/servlet/detail/RUMSEY~8~1~3302~400119:Map-of-the-Country-Twenty-Five-Mile, last visited 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Aerial view of Levittown, 1959, http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/64/ LevittownPA.jpg, last visited 12/04/12.

    OKAMOTO, Yoichi, President Johnson signing the 1965 Immigration Act, 1965, http://www.new america.umd.edu/themes.html, last visited 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights Riots 1991, 1991, http://www.crownheights.info/index.php?itemid=366, last visited 12/04/12.

    UNKNOWN, Crown Heights Protest, 2008, https://picasaweb.google.com/VosIzNeias.Com/Crown HeightsProtes5162008#5201526732365990162, last visited 12/04/12.

  • References Land Use, see P29 - Open space and recreation. GROSSMAN, Elizabeth, MECHIK, Leonid, YUCE, Veysel, A History of Tension: Race Relations in Crown Heights, 2012, http://www.humanityinaction.org/knowledgebase/80-a-history-of-tension-race- NYC DEPARTMENT OF CITY PLANNING AND TRANSPORTATION, NYC Cycling Map, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/downloads/pdf/2012_nyc-cycling-map.pdf, last visited: 23/11/2011.

    P37 References Land Use, see P27 - Residential Land Use.

    PLUNZ, Richard, A History of Housing in New York City, Columbia University Press, New York, 1992.

    BING MAPS, Birds eye, 2012, http://be.bing.com/maps/, last visited: 12/04/2012.

    P39 SORKIN, Michael, All Over The Map, Verso, New York, 2011.

    DODGE, David, An Overview of New York Public Housing - Submitted by the Right to the City Alliance to Marguerite Casey Foundation, September 2009, http://www.cdp-ny.org/report/NYpublic housing_sept09.pdf, last visited: 12/04/2012.

    PRATT CENTER FOR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, Building communities of opportunity, 2009, http://prattcenter.net/sites/default/files/publications/PrattCenterPublicHousing.pdf, p13, last visited: 04/04/2012.

    NEW YORK CITY HOUSING AUTHORITY, NYCHA Housing Developments, 2012, http://www.nyc. gov/htmlnycha/html/developments/dev_guide.shtml, last visited: 12/04/2012.

    NYC OASIS, Median Household Income (2005-09), http://www.oasisnyc.net/map.aspx, last visited: 12/04/2012.

    P43 NEW YORK TIMES, Murder: New York City, http://projects.nytimes.com/crime/homicides/map, last visited: 13/04/2012.

    SOCIAL EXPLORER, 2000 Census Tract - % Unemployed, http://www.socialexplorer.com, last visited: 13/04/2012.

    P45 SOCIAL EXPLORER, 2000 Census Tract - % Less than High School, http://www.socialexplorer. com, last visited: 13/04/2012.

    References Land Use, see P29 - Public Institutions.

    P46 HESSE, Hannah, Gentrification - Chance & Rick for a New York City neighborhood - A case study of North Crown Heights | Prospect Heights, 2009, http://hannah-hesse.com/Urban%20Planning/ thesis_excerpt.pdf, last visited: 12/04/2012, used with written permission.

    THE U.S. CENSUS BUREAU, t_pl_p1_ct.xlsx, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/download/census/ census2010/t_pl_p1_ct.xlsx, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    Juravich, Nick, Crown Heights, Riots, Gentrification: Some Fresh Takes on the Usual Topics, 2001, http://ilovefranklinave.blogspot.com/2011/10/crown-heights-riots-gentrification-some.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    Juravich, Nick, Two Years of Commercial Development on Franklin, 2010, http://ilovefranklinave. blogspot.com/2010/11/two-years-of-commercial-development-on.html, last visited: 12/04/12.

    The Citizen Housing and Planning Council (CHPC), Kontokosta, C.E. and CHPC 2009 gentrificationmodel, http://www.chpcny.org/, last visited: 12/04/12.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 6, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/ pdf/lucds/bk6profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 8, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/ pdf/lucds/bk8profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    New York City Department of City Planning, Brooklyn CD 16, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/ pdf/lucds/bk16profile.pdf, last visited: 05/04/2012.

    P47 UNKNOWN, Historic Districts Council Brooklyn, 2012, http://hdc.org/hdc-across-nyc/brooklyn, last visited: 12/04/12.

    THE U.S. CENSUS BUREAU, t_pl_p1_ct.xlsx, 2011, http://www.nyc.gov/html/ dcp/download/ census/ census2010/t_pl_p1_ct.xlsx, last visited: 05/04/2012.