CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
-
Upload
ey-venezuela -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
1/20
Megadeals returningAnalysis of transactions in Q2 2012
in the global consumer products sector
Issue 11
AprilJune 2012
Consumer ProductsDeals Quarterly
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
2/20
WelcomeWelcome to Consumer Products Deals Quarterly a report from Ernst & Young that
analyzes acquisitions and disposals in the global consumer products sector.
In our last issue, we asked: is deal activity bottoming out? After three consecutive
quarterly declines, second-quarter deal volume was only fractionally lower than inthe opening three months of the year. More signicantly, the second quarter was
book-ended by large deal announcements in April and late June, which helped push
total deal value to the highest level recorded in any quarter in our review period.
While the timing of deals cannot be accurately predicted, given the extent of ongoing
economic uncertainty and market volatility, it is impressive that consumer products
companies have the appetite to deploy this amount of capital in such a tough
environment.
Our analysis is based on data collected by Thomson Reuters. As usual we have drawn
on the insights of our global professionals to analyze the key investment trends
underlying deal activity.
We hope that this data and the perspectives we offer will be of use to the leaders of
consumer products companies and to the nancial investors who continue to focus on
this sector. We are happy to provide further insight on request.
Contents
Overview 1
Megadeals returning
Volume and value 6
Jump in values underpinned
by megadeals
Top 10 deals 7
Focus on rapid-growth markets drives
resurgence in big-ticket deals
Sector focus 12
Tobacco groups diversifying away
from traditional cigarettes
Geographic focus 14
US leading the M&A country rankings
Methodology 15
Contacts 16
David Murray
Global Consumer Products Transactions Leader
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
3/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 1
Following three consecutive quarterly declines, deal activity stabilized in Q2 12.
Two megadeals (with a value in excess of US$5b) were announced in the quarter,illustrating that despite continuing economic uncertainty, appetite remains amongconsumer products groups to deploy signicant sums of capital, particularly inpursuit of opportunities in rapid-growth markets.
Megadeals returning
Overview
Deal activity bottoming out
Overall deal activity in the second quarter was virtually
unchanged from Q1 12. Total deal volumes declined by just
2 deals (1%) to 303 transactions from 305. Accompanying this
stabilization in deal ow was a dramatic rise in value. Total valuein Q2 12 reached US$51.2b, exceeding the previous high point
in our review period (US$38.7b recorded in Q1 10) by a third.
Average deal value also rose sharply from the rst-quarter low
point, increasing to US$466m from US$96m.
The second quarter also witnessed the return of the megadeal
(value of more than US$5b), with two transactions falling into
this category: AB InBevs US$20.1b purchase of the remaining
half of Modelo that it did not already own, and Nestls
acquisition of Pzers infant nutrition division for US$11.9b. The
precise timing of any transaction is difcult to predict, and too
much signicance should not be attached to a deals eventual
announcement date, but the increase in large deals is consistent
with the amount of due diligence work that we see our clients
conducting.
The appetite for megadeals is still there.
Consumer products companies are acquiring
businesses for cash, increasing their exposure
to rapid-growth markets where possible and
also playing to their strengths in existing
categories within their heartlands.
Andrew Cosgrove
Global Consumer Products, Lead Analyst
Data highlights Q2 2012
Deal volumes stabilize after three consecutive
quarterly declines
Second-quarter deal volumes were broadly at, decliningvery slightly to 303 deals from 305 in Q1 12. The
four-period long-term moving average of total deal volume
continued to decline, from 391 deals to 351.
Total value rises sharply
Disclosed deal value increased almost sevenfold from
US$7.5b in Q1 12 to US$51.2b in Q2 12. There were two
megadeals, with a value greater than US$5b in the quarter,
and six deals had a value of more than US$1b.
Private equity activity increases while corporate
activity slips
Corporate deals (representing 83% of total deals in Q2 12)
fell to 252 from 262 in Q1 12, but private equity deals
increased to 51 from 43 in Q1 12 (19% increase).
Cross-border activity increases
In comparison with the slight overall decline in total deal
volume, cross-border activity increased by 12% from
98 deals in Q1 12 to 110 deals in Q2 12. The US was the
most active deal-making country in the second quarter.
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
4/20
2 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
What is also striking is that boards are making decisions on
signicant investments despite the ongoing uncertainty
surrounding the global economic outlook. Large consumer
products companies have cash on their balance sheets as
well as the ability to borrow, as shown by AB InBev raising
US$14b in loans to part nance the Modelo acquisition and
are prepared to look through near-term volatility and makestrategic decisions.1
The nature of those decisions reects a number of ongoing
investment themes, which we have previously identied and
which the second quarter further illustrated.
Expansion into rapid-growth marketsdriving deal activity
The dominant theme in Q2 12 was the pursuit of growth
opportunities in rapid-growth markets. This theme has
both cyclical and structural elements. The economies of the
developed world continue to struggle in the aftermath of the
global nancial crisis and with the ongoing uncertainty createdby the Eurozone debt crisis. Prior to the announcement of its
acquisition in Morocco this quarter, for example, Groupe Danone
warned that shrinking demand in Spain and other areas of the
southern Eurozone may affect its prots.
Consumer products companies can no longer rely on historical
growth rates in mature markets, but they cannot ignore them.
At the same time as they look to expand into rapid-growth
markets, they must seek to maintain and grow their business in
mature markets through brand extensions, new formulations and
product innovations.
Underlying this cyclical component is the long-term shift ineconomic power toward the rapid-growth markets and the
accompanying creation of a new middle class of consumers.
Of the quarters top 10 deals, ve have a rapid-growth market
rationale, including both of the megadeals:
AB InBevs purchase of Modelo increasingly exposes the
worlds largest brewer to the fast-growing Mexican market.
The competition for Pzers baby-food business between
Nestl and Groupe Danone reects the opportunity on offer,
with the bulk of future growth in the category expected to
come from rapid-growth markets, particularly China, which
already accounts for a signicant proportion of Pzers sales.
1 AB InBev to pay US$20b for Grupo Modelo, The Financial Times,
www.ft.com, 29 June 2012.
Molson Coors purchase of StarBev and General Mills
acquisition of Brazils Yoki Alimentos are two examples of
companies executing their strategy to expand in rapid-growth
markets.
Groupe Danone has been pursuing opportunities in rapid-
growth markets, with transactions in the CIS and India in 2010
and 2011, respectively. This quarters deal for Moroccos
Centrale Laitiere is the latest example.
Better the devil you know
Groupe Danones deal to increase its holding in Centrale Laitiere
from 29% to 67% also illustrates another investment theme being
pursued by consumer products groups, which is to increase
the size of their stakes or buy out the minorities in businesses
in which they already have an ownership interest. Increasing
control over a business that the acquirer already knows well is a
strategy that makes sense in an uncertain economy because it
helps limit the risk in the acquisition process.
The AB InBev/Modelo megadeal is the most signicant example
of this trend among the quarters deals, with AB InBev buying
the remaining 50% of Modelo that it didnt already own. On the
back of the deal, Constellation Brands acquired the other half of
its Crown Imports US joint venture with Modelo from AB InBev.
Evidence of this strategy can be found all the way down from the
megadeal to small bolt-on deals. For example, in June, Diageo
paid US$21.8m through a public offering to raise its stake in
Vietnams biggest spirits company, Halico, by 10.6% to 45.5%.2
2 Diageo tops up stake in Vietnams Halico, Reuters, www.reuters.com, 15 June 2012.
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
5/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 3
Consolidating in developed markets
The second quarter also provided examples of another
signicant investment theme: consolidation within developed
markets to strengthen brand portfolios and increase scale.
Asahi Groups acquisition of Calpis, for example, marks a further
diversication by the beer maker into soft drinks through thepurchase of a leading brand in the Japanese market.
Japanese consumer products groups also continue to be active
in overseas acquisitions in developed markets, leveraging the
strength of the yen and taking advantage of Europes status
as a relatively higher-growth region. In Q2 12, UCC Holdings
announced that it had agreed to buy Switzerlands United Coffee
from private equity rm CapVest Equity Partners, Japan Tobacco
purchased family-owned Belgian rolling tobacco company
Gryson, and vinegar-maker Mizkan bought the Sarsons,
Haywards pickled onion and Dufrais vinegar brands from the
UKs Premier Foods.
In the top 10 deals this quarter, Beams acquisition of the
Pinnacle vodka and Calico Jack rum brands from White Rock
Distilleries represents a shift by Beam into the fast-growing
avored-vodka market in the US. Constellation Brands buyout of
its JV partner Modelo, however, is a more defensively motivated
transaction, aimed at securing its route to market well before the
joint venture agreement expires in 2017.
Outside the top 10, French cosmetics maker LOreal paid
US$264m for baby products company Cadum from Anglo-French
buyout group Milestone Capital to reach more customers in its
domestic market. Cadum is an important acquisition for LOreal
in France, said the companys consumer products head Herve
Navellou. It blends seamlessly into our strategy to conquer new
consumers in France.3
3 LOreal buys Cadum to extend domestic reach, Reuters, www.reuters.com, 26 April 2012.
Global consumer products corporate and PE transactions scorecard by subsectorDeals announced 2Q 2012 1Q 2012 Seq % change 2Q 2012 2Q 2011 YoY % change
Corporate deals by subsector
Beverages 50 55 -9% 50 54 -7%
Food 173 175 -1% 173 243 -29%
HPC 27 31 -13% 27 42 -36%
Tobacco 2 1 100% 2 5 -60%
Total 252 262 -4% 252 344 -27%
PE deals by subsector (based on seller sector)
Beverages 7 9 -22% 7 15 -53%Food 39 31 26% 39 90 -57%
HPC 5 2 150% 5 11 -55%
Tobacco 0 1 -100% 0 2 -100%
Total 51 43 19% 51 118 -57%
Total consumer products (CP) deals by sector, corporate and PE
Beverages 57 64 -11% 57 69 -17%
Food 212 206 3% 212 333 -36%
HPC 32 33 -3% 32 53 -40%
Tobacco 2 2 0% 2 7 -71%
Total 303 305 -1% 303 462 -34%
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
6/20
4 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Internationalization of brands goes botheast and west
Taking brands global is a well-established theme, which is gaining
an additional rapid-growth markets dimension in the beverage
sector. Beverage groups are looking for the next tier of local
drinks that can provide exposure to rapid-growth markets,access to distribution capabilities and future potential for brand
internationalization.
In 2011, Diageo bought Turkish Raki maker Mey Icki and took
a stake in Chinese baijiu producer Shui Jing Fang. The drinks
groups acquisition activity in Q2 12 shows further evidence of
this trend. In May, Diageo paid US$453.9m to acquire the Ypica
brand from Ypica Agroindustrial. Ypica is the market leader
in Brazils premium market for cachaa, Brazils best-selling
spirit. Diageo will gain access to a strong distribution platform in
Brazils northeast region, complementing the companys existing
strength in the southeast. Diageos CEO Paul Walsh said the deal
will also provide Diageo with an enhanced platform from which
to accelerate the long-term growth of our premium international
spirits brands in Brazil.4
The acquisition of 60% of Weetabix by Chinas Bright Food
represents a similar trend of widening the reach of a brand, but
with the direction of travel running from global markets into
the Chinese market. Bright Food plans to sell Weetabix in China
through its large distribution network, hoping to cash in on the
trend toward more consumption of western foods.
In a similar vein, in April, Indian leisure company India Hospitality
bought UK convenience food producer Adelie Food Holdings for
US$350m from private equity rm Duke Street Capital. Adelie
supplies products including salads, quiches and sandwiches to
UK supermarkets. Ravi Deol, the entrepreneur who controls the
Indian food group, said the rising demand for quality fast-foodproducts among Indias growing middle class is one of the main
reasons India Hospitality acquired Adelie.5
4 Diageo snaps up Ypioca, as domestic spirits gain further appeal,Just Drinks,
www.just-drinks com, 30 May 2012.
5 Indias IHC buys food producer Adelie, The Financial Times, www.ft.com, 12 April 2012.
Companies are looking for brands
they can internationalize.
Jeremy Barnes
Transactions Advisory Services, Latin America
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
7/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 5
Cautious optimism
From the deals announced this quarter and from our knowledge
of ongoing due diligence work by our corporate clients, we are
cautiously optimistic that deal activity will continue to bottom
out into the latter half of the year.
Further announcements of signicantly sized deals immediatelyafter the end of the quarter add to our optimism. In the
US, Campbell Soup announced the acquisition of Bolthouse
Farms, a producer of juices, salad dressings and baby carrots
for US$1.6b. In Asia, ThaiBev agreed to buy a 22% stake in
Singapore conglomerate Fraser & Neave (F&N) for US$2.2b,
and at the same time, Kindest Place Groups, which is run by
ThaiBevs owners son-in-law, bought an 8.4% stake in Asia
Pacic Breweries (APB).
Heineken and F&N have a joint venture, which owns a majority
stake in APB. The day after ThaiBevs announcement, Heineken
responded by offering to buy F&Ns stake for US$4.1b, setting up
a potential takeover battle for APB.6
Of course, the wider economic backdrop remains very uncertain,
and there is potential for event risk, such as a Greek exit from
the Eurozone, to delay corporate decision making on strategicinvestments. However, this quarter provides ample evidence of
the willingness of global consumer products groups, who are
becoming accustomed to living in a new normal of increased
volatility, to look beyond the short-term uncertainty. The market
environment they face is one of continuous, accelerating change
and spiraling complexity that we call the brand new order
(www.ey.com/brandneworder), but they have the appetite to
make the strategic decisions to access growth opportunities.
6 Heineken bids US$4.07b to take full control of Asia Pacic Breweries,Just Drinks,
www.just-drinks.com, 20 July 2012.
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
8/20
6 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Deal volumes were at in the second quarter, but total deal values jumped sharply.
Q1 12 marked the low point in deal values since Q2 09, and in stark contrastQ2 12 marked the high point by some considerable margin. Six of the top 10 dealshad values in excess of US$1b, and two megadeals were announced in the quarter.
Jump in values underpinned by megadeals
Volume and value
Deal volumes declined just 1% in Q2 12 to 303 deals from 305
in Q1 12. Given the three preceding consecutive quarters of
declining volumes, the four-period long-term moving average
of deal volume continued to move lower in the second quarter,
dropping to 351 deals from 391 in Q1 12. After dropping by
almost two-thirds in three quarters, private equity activity partlyrecovered in Q2 12, rising from 43 deals to 51 deals.
Total disclosed deal value increased sharply in the second
quarter, rising almost sevenfold from US$7.5b in Q1 12 to
US$51.2b in Q2 12, driven by the announcement of two
megadeals and a number of other large-ticket transactions.
Average deal value also increased markedly from US$96m
in Q1 12 to US$466m in Q2 12, reversing six quarters ofconsecutive decline. The proportion of deals with disclosed
values increased to 36% in Q2 12 from 26% in Q1 12.
Deal values Q3 09 to Q2 12Deal volumes Q3 09 to Q2 12
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
226
229
238
223 2
68
279 3
34
333
283
247
206
212
69 7
9 73
62
73 7
5
89
69
78
69
64
57
26 4
3 51
36
38 5
3
32
53
55
52
33
32
2
3 3
3
1
3
2 7
6
5
2 2
Q32009
Q42009
Q12010
Q22010
Q32010
Q42010
Q12011
Q22011
Q32011
Q42011
Q12012
Q22012
Number
Food Average LTM number of dealsBeveragesHPCTobacco Q3
2009
Q4
2009
Q1
2010
Q2
2010
Q3
2010
Q4
2010
Q1
2011
Q2
2011
Q3
2011
Q4
2011
Q1
2012
Q2
2012
Food Beverages HPC
Tobacco Average LTM value Average deal size
Average
dealvalue
(US$
b)Totaldealvalue
(US$b)
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0
20
40
60
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
9/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 7
The top 10 deals in Q2 12 had a combined value of US$43.6b, 85% of total deal
value. There were two megadeals, with values of more than US$5b in the quarter. Ofthe top 10 deals, ve were in the beverage sector and ve were in the food sector. Allthe buyers were corporates, and private equity was the seller in three deals.
Focus on rapid-growth markets drivesresurgence in big-ticket deals
Top 10 deals
The biggest gets even bigger ...
At the end of June, AB InBev announced the US$20.1b
all-cash purchase of the remaining 49.7% it did not already
own in Mexican beer giant Modelo. AB InBev, already the worlds
largest brewer, will gain increased exposure to the Mexican
market, which is growing at 3% per year and where Modelo
is the biggest brewer.7
AB InBev also gains access to the growth potential offered by
Modelos brands, particularly Corona, which is the top imported
beer in 38 countries. We have a big opportunity to expand
Corona on a global basis as we have with global Budweiser these
last three years, said Carlos Brito, AB InBevs chief executive.
However, because of its already large US market share, AB InBev
will have to give up the import rights to Modelos brands in the
US (see Constellation brands deal at below right).8
7 Mexican wave for brewing giant as it snaps up Corona, The Scotsman, 30 June 2012.
8 Modelo deal a win-win: AB InBev would sacrice US import rights for a shot at bigger prots
overseas, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 8 July 2012.
The deal was struck at a high price a 30% premium to Modelos
closing price on June 22, which is 13 times 2012 consensus
EBITDA, according to Bernstein Research. AB InBev took on
US$14b in additional bank borrowing to nance the cash
purchase.9
Analysts, however, received the deal favorably. It wasalways going to be high, given that Modelo shareholders are
under no compulsion to sell, said Socit Gnrale analyst
Andrew Holland. But InBev has a strong track record in
integration and cost savings. AB InBev stated that it expects
to generate at least US$600m a year in cost savings.10
Speculation has already begun over what AB InBevs next deal
will be once it has digested Modelo. Many analysts believe the
next major acquisition could be SABMiller or PepsiCo.11
... but needs to divest to satisfycompetition concerns
In a related transaction to AB InBevs purchase of Modelo,
Constellation Brands bought Modelos 50% stake in Crown
Imports, the US distribution joint venture between Constellation
and Modelo, for US$1.9b. Constellation and Crown will have
complete, independent control of distribution, marketing and
pricing for all Modelo brands in the US, while AB InBev will
ensure continuity of supply, quality of products and the ability to
introduce innovations.
However, from AB InBevs perspective, uncertainty remains over
whether the divestiture will be enough to satisfy US competition
authorities, because the companys share of total beer
9 AB InBev to pay US$20b for Grupo Modelo, The Financial Times,
www.ft.com, 29 June 2012.
10 AB InBev to buy Corona brewer for US$20.1b, Financial Post, 30 June 2012.
11 The largest brewery gets bigger, Beer Universe www.beer-universe.com, 29 June 2012.
The deal is a logical continuation of ABInBevs strategy. AB InBev gains greater
exposure in rapid-growth markets while
at the same time, by buying out the other
stakeholders in a business it already knows,
the deal is a better utilization of capital
because its less risky than a completely new
acquisition.
David Murray
Global Consumer Products Transactions Leader
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
10/20
8 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Top 10 deals in Q2 2012
distribution in the country would be more than 50%. Analysts
at Bernstein Research said, When InBev bought Anheuser-
Busch, the Department of Justice (DoJ) required the disposal of
the Labatt brand in the USA and the associated manufacturing
contract, which resulted in Molson Coors brewing Labatt on
behalf of the new brand owners.12
The purchase price values Crown at about 8.5 times EBIT.13The agreement is a perpetual one, although AB InBev has
12 Grupo Modelos Crown Imports sell-off may not satisfy regulators,Just Drinks,
www.just-drinks.com, 29 June 2012.
13 Constellation Brands Inc. to Acquire Remaining 50 Percent Interest in Crown Imports JointVenture, Yahoo! Finance, www.nance.yahoo.com, 29 June 2012.
an option every 10 years to buy out Constellation at a pricey
13 times EBIT. The deal was seen as solving a problem for
Constellation as some had worried Constellation might actually
lose its rights to distribute Modelo brands when its previous
contract expired in 2017.14
14 Constellation Stars Amid AB InBev-Modelo Deal, The Wall Street Journal,www.blogs.wsj.com, 29 June 2012.
Buyer Name Buyer Country Seller Name Seller Country
Disclosed Value
(US$m) Announced Deal Type Sector
Cross-border or
in-border
Anheuser-
Busch InBev
Belgium Grupo Modelo
SAB de CV
Mexico $20,093 6/29/2012 Corporate Beverages Cross-border
Nestl SA Switzerland Pzer Inc.
Nutrition
business
United States $11,850 4/23/2012 Corporate Food Cross-border
Molson Coors
Brewing Co.
United States Starbev
managementServices sro
United Kingdom $3,531 4/3/2012 Corporate Beverages Cross-border
Bright Food
(Group) Co. Ltd.
China Weetabix Ltd. United Kingdom $1,938 5/3/2012 Corporate Food Cross-border
Constellation
Brands Inc.
United States Crown Imports
LLC
United States $1,850 6/29/2012 Corporate Beverages In-border
Asahi Group
Holdings Ltd.
Japan Ajinomoto Co.
Inc. Calpis
Japan $1,502 5/8/2012 Corporate Beverages In-border
General Mills
Inc.
United States Yoki Alimentos
SA
Brazil $962 5/24/2012 Corporate Food Cross-border
Danone SA France Centrale
Laitiere SA
Morocco $686 6/27/2012 Corporate Food Cross-border
UCC Holdings
Co Ltd.*
Japan United Coffee United Kingdom $616 4/23/2012 Corporate Food Cross-border
Beam Inc. United States White Rock
Distilleries
Pinnacle Vodka
and Calico Jack
rum brands
United States $605 4/23/2012 Corporate Beverages In-border
*UCC Holdings transaction is recorded as a food deal as per Ernst & Young sector classication
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
11/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 9
Nestl wins the battle for Pzer infant
nutrition
The second quarters other megadeal, announced in April,
was Nestls acquisition of Pzers infant-nutrition business for
US$11.9b in cash. Nestl outbid Groupe Danone to secure the
deal, which is the largest in the companys history.
The transaction was perceived as a good strategic move for
Nestl, while Pzer is disposing of a non-core asset acquired
when it merged with Wyeth in 2009. According to Santander
analyst Pedro Gil, This transaction takes Nestls leading
global market share in the fast-growing US$30b infant formula
category to an estimated 23% from 17%, signicantly expanding
its presence in key emerging markets, and conrms our view
that Nestl was the natural buyer for the asset in a competitive
auction process.15
Pzers baby food division derives 85% of its US$2.1b revenues
from rapid-growth markets, with particularly strong positions in
Asia and the Middle East. China accounts for about one-third ofthe Pzer units sales, and 45% of the growth in the market for
infant-nutrition products will come from China in the next ve
years, according to Euromonitor gures.16
Given the competition for the asset, the price Nestl paid was
high, reecting a transaction multiple of 19.8 times 2012
estimated EBITDA, according to analysts at Jefferies. This
compares with the estimated 15.7 times Gerbers pre-tax prot
Nestl paid when it acquired the baby food brand for US$5.5b
in 2007.17
15 Nestl Buys Pzer Infant Nutrition, Santander equity research report, 23 April 2012.
16 Nestles acquisition to alter baby-food market, China Daily Information
Company, 25 April 2012.
17 Pzer Nutrition Eps Accretive,Jefferies equity research report, 24 April 2012.
Molson Coors looks east
At the start of April, US-Canadian brewer Molson Coors
announced it had agreed to buy StarBev, the Eastern European
brewer of Staropramen, from private equity group CVC for
US$3.5b in cash, debt and convertible bonds.
The focus of Molson Coors business has been largely focusedon the developed markets of the US, Canada and the UK. The
acquisition of StarBev ts squarely into Molson Coors strategy to
increase our portfolio of premium brands and deepen our reach
into growth markets around the world, said Peter Swinburn,
President and Chief Executive Ofcer of Molson Coors.18
According to Morgan Stanley, the purchase price of 11 times
2011 EBITDA (9.5 times including synergies) is in line with
brewer deal multiples over the past decade. While Morgan
Stanleys analysts agree that the deal ts Molson Coors
ambition to expand its rapid-growth markets footprint, they
also note that these CEE markets are already well-developed
in terms of per capita consumption, limiting growth potentialversus other emerging markets.19J.P. Morgan also noted
that CEE (Central and Eastern European) markets are highly
competitive: JP Morgan analysts noted StarBev has a solid
position in most of the countries it operates in, but competes
with Heineken, Carlsberg and SABMiller.20
18 Molson Coors to Acquire Central and Eastern European Brewer StarBev, Investment WeeklyNews, 21 April 2012.
19 StarBev Deal Will Expand Emerging Markets Footprint, Morgan Stanley equity research
report, 4 April 2012.
20 Big Deal For Molson Coors In Eastern Europe,J.P. Morgan equity research note,
3 April 2012.
Consumer products companies are willing
to pay high multiples for assets that
complement their portfolios and that have
good growth prospects.
Gregory J. Stemler
Consumer Products Transactions Leader, Americas
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
12/20
10 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Bright Food opts for an Englishbreakfast
In May, Bright Food, one of Chinas largest food groups, agreed
to buy a 60% stake in British breakfast cereal maker Weetabix
from private equity group Lion Capital for US$1.9b. Bright Food
and Lion Capital said the acquisition signals that the Chinesefood company will enter both the British and global food markets
through the iconic Weetabix brand.21
In addition to gaining access to international markets Weetabix
is sold in 80 countries Bright Foods acquisition will also provide
the opportunity to sell Weetabix in China, through its network of
more than 3,000 stores.
Weetabix offers the Chinese company established retail-
distribution channels in major Western markets such as the U.S.,
Canada, Italy and Israel and will provide bargaining power to
Bright Food as it seeks retail shelf space in the West, said Marcia
Mogelonsky, an analyst for London-based market-research
rm Mintel.22
Asahi strengthens its domestic portfolio
Japans Asahi Group agreed to acquire Japanese beverage
maker Calpis for US$1.5b (Yen 120b) in cash from food
and seasoning maker Ajinomoto. Asahi has diverse food
and beverage businesses, including Japans top-selling beer,
Asahi Super Dry.
Calpis is well known in Japan for its fermented milk drink, which
is branded under the same name. The deal will push Asahi into
third place in the Japanese soft drinks market with share of 12%.
The market, however, is dominated by Coca-Cola and Suntory
Beverage & Food, which have a combined market share of 48%.
According to analysts at Deutsche Bank, the deal reects a
valuation of 9.1 times EV/EBITDA based on the year to March
2012, and Asahis aim is to strengthen its product portfolio as
well as to create synergies in distribution and procurement.23
From Ajinomotos perspective, it is selling the protable Calpis
to pursue its aim of becoming the worlds top producer of
seasonings.24
21 Chinese company to buy 60% stake in British food maker Weetabix,
Xinhua Business Weekly, 7 May 2012.22 Chinese food company eats English breakfast, The Wall Street Journal,
www.wsj.com, 3 May 2012.
23 Company alert: Asahi Group, Deutsche Bank equity research note, 8 May 2012.
24 Ajinomoto Sells Calpis To Focus Global Ops On Amino Acids , Nihon Keizai
Shimbun, 9 May 2012.
General Mills expands in Brazil
During the quarter General Mills signed a denitive agreement to
acquire Yoki Alimentos, a privately held food company based in
Brazil for an estimated US$962m. The deal will provide General
Mills with a strong portfolio of local snack and convenience
meal brands.
Yoki, which is a family-owned Brazilian company established
in 1960, has a strong share of Brazils snack market and also
makes soup, seasonings and other packaged foods under its Yoki
and Kitano brands.
General Mills, whose brands include Cheerios, Betty Crocker and
Green Giant, expects the Yoki buyout to more than double its
annual sales in Latin America to almost US$1b.25
25 General Mills buying Brazils Yoki Alimentos, Yahoo! News, 24 May 2012.
Lions sale of 60% of its stake secures a
partial exit but also offers the private equity
group the opportunity to share in any futureupside from Bright Foods introduction of
Weetabix into China.
Mike Sills
Global Food Co-Leader
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
13/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 11
Danone tightens its grip on Moroccandairy leader
At the end of the quarter, French food group Danone announced
it had taken a majority stake in Moroccan dairy rm Centrale
Laitire, which is the countrys leading dairy product company
with nearly 60% of the market.26Danone increased its stake,which it has held since 2001, from 29% to 67% by buying part of
the stake owned by Societe Nationale dInvestissement, a local
holding company, for US$686m.
UCC leverages the yens strength
In April, Japans biggest coffee maker, UCC Holdings, announced
it had agreed to buy Switzerlands United Coffee from private
equity rm CapVest Equity Partners for an undisclosed sum.
Estimates placed the deals value at US$616m.27
The deal will increase UCCs overseas sales to 20% from 3%.28
Geneva-based United Coffee supplies retail customers in Spain,
the Netherlands, Switzerland, Scandinavia, France, Germany, the
UK and in several export markets. United Coffee owns about 20
brands, including Giger in Switzerland and Smit & Dorlas in the
Netherlands.
26 Danone takes majority stake in Centrale Laitire,Just Food,
www.just-food.com, 30 June 2102.
27 Japans UCC Holdings buys United Coffee, The Financial Times, www.ft.com, 23 April 2012.
28 Japans UCC to buy Switzerlands United Coffee, Marketwatch,
www.marketwatch.com, 23 April 2012.
Beam whips up a storm
Rounding out the top 10 deals, Beam, which makes Jim Beam
bourbon, purchased the Pinnacle Vodka and Calico Jack
rum brands from privately owned White Rock Distilleries for
US$605m. Pinnacle pioneered the dessert-avored vodka
category with Pinnacle Whipped Vodka in 2010, which has since
grown into the most popular avored-vodka brand in the U.S.
Analysts at SunTrust Robinson Humphrey said the deal
strengthens Beams portfolio and noted that the vodka
opportunity is 25% of the U.S. spirits market but was less than
10% of Beams sales prior to this deal.
Beam indicated that it can achieve cost synergies equating to
20% of sales, which implies it should be able to double Pinnacles
EBITDA over the next few years. SunTrust said that Beams cost
synergy estimate also gave greater comfort with the purchase
price of 20 times EBITDA excluding tax benets, which post-
synergies would drop down to 10 to 12 times EBITDA.29
29 Beam Inc. whips up a sweet deal, SunTrust Robinson Humphrey equity
research note, 23 April 2012.
Japanese companies continue to take
advantage of the strong yen to pursue
acquisitions providing faster growth
opportunities than the domestic Japanese
market can offer.
John Hope
Transaction Advisory Services Leader, Asia-Pacic
Danones continuing push into rapid-growth
markets, which already account for more
than 50% of sales, helps offset faltering
growth in the mature markets in which it
operates.
Emmanuelle Roman
Global Consumer Products Markets Leader
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
14/20
12 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Total deal value in food and beverage was underpinned by the announcementof one megadeal and four other top 10 deals in both sectors. Japan Tobaccospurchase of Gryson fell just outside the top 10 deals, while activity in thehousehold and personal care sector was subdued in both volume and value terms.
Tobacco groups diversifying away fromtraditional cigarettes
Sector focus
Tobacco
There were just two tobacco deals in the second quarter, a
similar number to the rst quarter, but both illustrate the efforts
tobacco companies are making to diversify away from traditional
cigarettes.
Japan Tobacco agreed to pay US$596m for Belgian roll-your-
own and make-your-own tobacco group Gryson. According to
analysts at J.P. Morgan, the RYO/MYO cigarette market offers
attractive growth prospects its Compound Annual Growth
Rate (CAGR) for the 10 years up to 2010 was 3.9%. The analysts
wrote in a report, we think well of this unexpected addition to
JTs portfolio within a growth eld.30
Taking a different approach to diversication, Lorillard, the
third-largest US tobacco company, purchased Blu Ecigs, a maker
of battery-powered electronic cigarettes, which turn heated
nicotine-laced liquid into a vapor mist, for US$135m. The
strategic shift comes as the US Food and Drug Administration is
considering a possible crackdown on menthol-avored cigarettes,
which account for about 90% of Lorillards revenues.31
30 Acquisition of Gryson Comes as a Positive Surprise; Overseas Growth Set to Accelerate,
J.P. Morgan equity research note, 24 May 2012.
31 Got a Lighter Charger? Big Tobaccos Latest Buzz, the Wall Street Journal,
www.wsj.com, 25 April 2012.
Food
There were 212 food subsector deals in the second quarter, an
increase of six deals from Q1 12. Total disclosed value in the
food sector, however, increased sharply from US$4.5b in
Q1 2012 to US$20.8b in Q2 12, driven largely by the ve food
deals in the top 10 deals, including Nestls megadeal purchase
of Pzers infant-nutrition business.
Number and value of tobacco deals Q3 09 to Q2 12
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
Number and value of food deals Q3 09 to Q2 12
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
5.0
10.0
0
5
10
Q32009
Q42009
Q12010
Q12011
Q22010
Q32010
Q42010
Q22011
Q12012
Q22012
Q32011
Q42011
Disclosed
value
(US$b)N
umberofdeals
0.0
Volume Value (US$b)
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
0 0.0
100
200
300
400
Q32009
Q42009
Q12010
Q22010
Q32010
Q42010
Q12011
Q22011
Q32011
Q42011
Q12012
Q22012
Disclosed
value
(US$b)
Numberofdeals
Volume Value (US$b)
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
15/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 13
Household and personal care
Deal volume in the household and personal care sector was
broadly stable with 32 deals in Q2 12 compared with 33 deals
in Q1 12, although total disclosed deal value increased from
US$490m to US$670m. There were no HPC transactions in the
top 10 deals.
Beverage
The beverage sector showed a similar pattern of a modest
decline in volume accompanied by a surge in total disclosed
value. Deal volume in the subsector slipped from 64 deals
in the rst quarter to 57 in the second, but total deal value
increased from US$2.5b to US$29.1b. Once again it was the
announcement of one megadeal (AB InBevs purchase of Modelo)
and four other top 10 deals that drove the increase in value.
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
Number and value of household and personal caredeals Q3 09 to Q2 12
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Q32009
Q42009
Q22010
Q32010
Q42010
Q12010
Q22011
Q32011
Q42011
Q12011
Q22012
Q12012
Disclosed
value
(US$b)
Volume Value (US$b)
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
Q32009
Q42009
Q12010
Q22010
Q32010
Q42010
Q12011
Q22011
Q12012
Q22012
Q32011
Q42011
Disclosed
value(US$b)
Numberofdeals
Volume Value (US$b)
Number and value of beverage deals Q3 09to Q2 12
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
16/20
14 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
The US was the most prolic deal-making nation in the second quarter, recording
twice the number of transactions as the second-most-active nation, Japan. USrms are active in both in-border and cross-border acquisitions and are bothacquiring and disposing of assets.
US leading the M&A country rankings
Geographic focus
The US was the most active individual country for M&A activity
in Q2 12, recording 55 deals, which is equivalent to 18.2% of
total deal volume (cross-border and in-border combined). Japan,
which has also been active, based partly on the strength of
the yen, was a distant second with 27 deals (8.9% of total deal
volume). The US was also active at the top end of the deal size
spectrum, appearing as the buyer country in four of the top 10
deals and as a seller in three.
Regional volume comparisons (buy/sell combined),Q3 09 to Q2 12
When aggregated into regions, Europe once again dominated
cross-border activity, accounting for 45% of seller region volume
and 46% of buyer region volume. North America accounted for
25% buyer and 23% of seller region cross-border activity.
We continue to believe that US companies have both the
repower and the appetite for deals, and the degree of due
diligence work we observe suggests this will translate intoincreased transaction activity as the year progresses.
Regional value comparisons (buy/sell combined)Q3 09 to Q2 12
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
Source: Ernst & Youngs analysis of Thomson Reuters data.
31
22
17
15
21
22
27
34
32 3
5
23
26
34
48
60
59
48 7
187
72
72 5
357
53
16
24
20
29
54 3
637
37
39
29 1
6
28
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Q32
009
Q42
009
Q12
010
Q22
010
Q32
010
Q42
010
Q12
011
Q22
011
Q32
011
Q42
011
Q12
012
Q22
012
North America Europe Asia-Pacific
20.2
3.5
1.2 1
.6
3.4
7.6
9.4
2.0 3
.8
2.1
0.1
5.1
2.8
3
.7
13.8 4
.4
6.0
3.3
9.8
16.0
3.6
6.0
2.7 3
4.9
0.4
1.7
2.4
1.0
6.1
1.4
1.5
0.4
6.6
0.8
0.5
3.8
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
North America Europe Asia-Pacific
Q3
2009
Q4
2009
Q1
2010
Q2
2010
Q3
2010
Q4
2010
Q1
2011
Q2
2011
Q3
2011
Q4
2011
Q1
2012
Q2
2012
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
17/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 15
Methodology
Deals include transactions between companies in the four
consumer products subsectors, consumer products companiesacquiring businesses in other subsectors and non-consumer
products companies acquiring consumer products companies.
PE deal activity includes both full- and partial-stake
transactions and was analyzed based on acquisitions by rms
classied as PE, alternative investment management groups,
certain commercial banks, investment banks, venture capital
and other similar entities.
For non-consumer products acquirers, deals were classied
based on the consumer products sector of the seller.
Equity investments were included (corporate and PE).
Joint ventures were not included.
The value and status of all deals highlighted in this report are
as of 31 June 2012.
All dollar amounts are in US dollars unless otherwise indicated.
There is no minimum US dollar deal threshold.
Only disclosed deal values (as per Thomson Reuters) are used
in all value analyses.
As used in this report, total value refers to the aggregate
value of deals with disclosed values for the period underdiscussion.
The disclosed value as stated in the top 10 deals table is the
total value of consideration paid by the acquiror, excluding
fees and expenses. The dollar value includes the amount paid
for all common stock, common stock equivalents, preferred
stock, debt, options, assets, warrants and stake purchases
made within six months of the announcement date of the
transaction. Liabilities assumed are included in the value if
they are publicly disclosed. Preferred stock is only included if
it is being acquired as part of a 100% acquisition. If a portion
of the consideration paid by the acquiror is common stock, the
stock is valued using the closing price on the last full tradingday before the stock swap terms were announced. If the
exchange ratio of shares offered changes, the stock is valued
based on its closing price on the last full trading date prior to
the date of the exchange ratio change. For public target 100%
acquisitions, the number of shares at date of announcement
is used.
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly is based on Ernst & Youngs
analysis of Thomson Reuters data from Q3 09 to Q2 12. Data
was pulled from the Thomson Reuters database using standardindustrial classication codes together with Ernst & Youngs
identied deals. Please note that we have changed data sets last
quarter from FactSet Mergerstat to Thomson Reuters. All data
in the charts for previous quarters has been revised using the
Thomson Reuters data so that it is consistent.
For the purposes of this publication, our denition of consumer
products is only those companies in the food, beverages, tobacco
and HPC subsectors.Deal activity and valuations may uctuate slightly based on the
date that the Thomson Reuters database is accessed.
In January 2011, we reorganized the data set so that it can be
segmented globally into three regions (Europe, Asia-Pacic and
North America). All data in the charts from previous quarters
reects this reclassication.
Data source and industry scope
Qualifying deals
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
18/20
16 Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11
Contacts
Region Contact Email/telephone
Global/EMEIA David Murray
Global Consumer Products Transactions
Leader
+44 158 264 3248
Asia-Pacic John Hope
Transaction Advisory Services Leader
+852 2846 9997
Americas Gregory J. Stemler
Consumer Products Transactions Leader
+1 312 879 3351
Latin America Jeremy Barnes
Transaction Advisory Services
+55 11 3055 0115
Country Contact Email/telephone
Brazil Alfredo Della Savia
Consumer Products Leader
+55 11 2573 3788
Russia Dmitry Khalilov
Retail and Consumer Products Leader
+7 495 755 9757
India Ajay AroraTransaction Advisory Services [email protected]+91 124 464 4000
China Robert Partridge
Transaction Advisory Services Leader
+852 2846 9973
Sector Contact Email/telephone
Global Howard Martin
Global Consumer Products Leader
+44 20 7951 4072
Global Emmanuelle Roman
Global Consumer Products Market
Leader
+44 20 7951 1651
Global Andrew Cosgrove
Global Consumer Products Lead Analyst
+44 20 7951 5541
Beverages Steve WillsGlobal Leader [email protected]+44 20 7951 1336
Food Patricia Novosel
Global Co-Leader
+1 312 879 6715
Food Mike Sills
Global Co-Leader
+41 58 286 5538
HPC Anastasia Economos
Global Co-Leader
+1 201 750 0919
HPC Mark Twine
Global Co-Leader
+44 20 7951 0735
Tobacco Ed Hudson
Global Leader
+44 20 7951 4816
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
19/20
Consumer Products Deals Quarterly Issue 11 17
Notes
-
7/31/2019 CPD QIssue11 10Aug12
20/20
2012 EYGM Limited.
All Rights Reserved.
EYG no. EN0386
In line with Ernst & Youngs commitment to minimize
its impact on the environment, this document has
been printed on paper with a high recycled content.
This publication contains information in summary form and is
therefore intended for general guidance only. It is not intended
to be a substitute for detailed research or the exercise of
professional judgment. Neither EYGM Limited nor any other
member of the global Ernst & Young organization can accept
any responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting
or refraining from action as a result of any material in this
publication. On any specific matter, reference should be made
to the appropriate advisor. The opinions of third parties set out
in this publication are not necessarily the opinions of the globalErnst & Young organization or its member firms. Moreover,
they should be viewed in the context of the time they were
expressed.
ED None
Ernst & Young
Assurance | Tax | Transactions | Advisory
About Ernst & Young
Ernst & Young is a global leader in assurance,
tax, transaction and advisory services.
Worldwide, our 152,000 people are united
by our shared values and an unwavering
commitment to quality. We make a difference
by helping our people, our clients and our
wider communities achieve their potential.
Ernst & Young refers to the global organization
of member firms of Ernst & Young Global
Limited, each of which is a separate legal
entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK
company limited by guarantee, does
not provide services to clients. For more
information about our organization, please
visit www.ey.com.
How Ernst & Youngs Global Consumer
Products Center can help your business
The global recession has reset the consumer
products landscape. Value-seeking consumers,
intensified competition, increased commodity
costs, and growth opportunities in emerging
markets are driving change. Consumer
products companies now need to be leaner
and more agile, with a relentless focus on
execution. If you lead a consumer products
business, you need to anticipate trends,
identify implications and make informed
decisions that support your business goals.
Our Global Consumer Products Center enables
our worldwide network of over 13,000
sector-focused assurance, tax, transaction
and advisory professionals to share powerfulinsights and deep sector knowledge with
businesses like yours. This intelligence,
combined with our technical experience,
can help you accelerate and improve your
execution. We can help you to realize the full
value of your transactions, improve customer
and brand profitability, drive down costs and
build an agile and resilient supply chain. If you
want to compete powerfully in your market,
well help you achieve your potential
today and tomorrow.