CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration...

55
CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella - U Bari Antonio Piscitelli - U Napoli

Transcript of CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration...

Page 1: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH

Marco Zannetti - U Salerno

in collaboration with

Federico Corberi - U SalernoGiuseppe Gonnella - U BariAntonio Piscitelli - U Napoli

Page 2: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

temperature quench

study of fluctuationsduring relaxation• energy• heat

t

T

IT

FT

0

Page 3: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

temperature quench

• Brownian Oscillator• Gaussian Model : collection of independent oscillators condensation of fluctuations

t

T

IT

FT

0

Page 4: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

temperature quench

• Brownian Oscillator• Gaussian Model• Large – N Model: mean field of interacting system

no equilibration!

t

T

IT

FT

CT

0

Page 5: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Oscillator2

2

1)( H

Page 6: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

2

2

11

)(

IT

II e

ZP

t

T

IT

FT

0

Page 7: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

2

2

11

)(

IT

II e

ZP

2

)(2

11

),(

tT

t

eZ

tP

2

)()(

2

1 2 tTtH

t

1Bk

effective temperature

J.R.Gomez-Solano, A.Petrosyan, S.Ciliberto – PRL 106, 200602 (2011)

Page 8: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

2

2

11

)(

IT

II e

ZP

2

)(2

11

),(

tT

t

eZ

tP

2

)()(

2

1 2 tTtH

t

FI

Ft

TTT

TTetT

2)(

FT

effective temperature

Page 9: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Energy fluctuations

ete

eteP

tee

)(2),(

)(2

2

)()(

tTte

0 t

Page 10: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Heat fluctuations

),(),()(),( www PHHq

• q < 0 heat released • q > 0 heat absorbed

wt t0

w

Page 11: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

)~()~(~)( qqPqPqdqP AR

)(2

)(

)(2

)(

2

2

qqq

eqP

qqq

eqP

A

qq

A

R

qq

R

A

R

2)]()([ wAR tTtTqqq

Page 12: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

fluctuation relation

qqqqP

qP

AR

11

2

1

)(

)(ln

Page 13: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

fluctuation relation

qqqqP

qP

AR

11

2

1

)(

)(ln

1

2 111111

2

1

wt

I

F

FIAR

eT

T

TTqq

FI TT

11

wt

Page 14: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

collection of brownian oscillatorsGAUSSIAN MODEL

0,

2

1][

])[(2

1)]([

2

22

rrk

VH

rxdxH

k

kkk kk

V

Page 15: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Temperature Quench FI TT

kkkk

Page 16: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Temperature Quench FI TT

kkkk

k

tT

k

kkkke

tZtP

)(2

1

)(

1),(

Ft

k TTetT k 2)(

spectrum ofeffective temperatures

Page 17: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Energy

])[(),(),( HVetPdteP

Page 18: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Energy

])[(),(),( HVetPdteP

zxi

i

ei

dzx

2)(

Page 19: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Energy

),(

][),(2

])[(),(),(

tzQ

zHVezi

i

etPdei

dz

HVetPdteP

][),(),(

1),,( zH

C etPtzQ

tzP

partition function in the biased ensemble

Page 20: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Energy

),(ln

2

])[(),(),(

tzQVezi

i

ei

dz

HVetPdteP

biased free energy

Page 21: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Energy

),(ln

2

])[(),(),(

tzQVezi

i

ei

dz

HVetPdteP

large V),ˆ,( tzeVIe

zH

Ve

ˆ

1

zetzQV

tzeI ˆ),ˆ(ln1

),ˆ,(

),ˆ,( tzPC

saddle point ẑ

Page 22: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

zetzQV

tzeI ˆ),ˆ(ln1

),ˆ,(

fluctuations in the gaussian model

average properties in the biased ensemble

condensation• spherical model• BEC

Page 23: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k

zkHVe

1

Page 24: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k kkzk ztTV

HV

e)(

1

2

111

Page 25: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k kkzk ztTV

HV

e)(

1

2

111

1Mk

T z

e~

11 min kk TTM

hottestmode

Page 26: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k kkzk ztTV

HV

e)(

1

2

111

1Mk

T z

e~0Mk

Page 27: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k kkzk ztTV

HV

e)(

1

2

111

10T z

e~0Mk

Ce

Page 28: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

condensation

k kkzk ztTV

HV

e)(

1

2

111

10Tz

Ce

z

0e

e~0Mk e

zC HV

eeeˆ00

1

finite contribution fromthe zero mode

Page 29: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

phase diagram

Ce

t

condensed

normal

Page 30: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

phase diagram

Ce

t

condensed

normal

e

Page 31: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Heat

])[][(),(),,( wwww HHVqPddttqP

Page 32: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Fluctuations of extensive quantities: Heat

])[][(),(),,( wwww HHVqPddttqP ),,ˆ,(),,( wttzqVI

w ettqP

)]ˆ1)(ˆ1(ln[2

1ˆ),,ˆ,( ,, zqzq

VzqttzqI kAkR

kw

Page 33: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

0FT 0, kAq

k kRkzkR zqV

qV

q1,

ˆ,

1

2

1

2

1

mostreleasing

mode

1,

MkRq0

z

saddle point ẑ

Page 34: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

0Mk

1,

MkRq

z

0Mk

10,

Rq

z

Cq

q 0q

Page 35: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

phase diagram 0FT

q

tt

condensed

normal

Page 36: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

N-VECTOR MODEL

0,0),,..,(

2)(

2

1)]([

1

2222

gr

N

grxdxH

N

V

02 CTd

Page 37: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

22

N

gr

Page 38: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

22

N

gr

Large N limitself-average

)(),(2 tStx

Page 39: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

kkkk t ,,, )(

22

N

gr

)(),(2 tStx

Large N limitself-average

Page 40: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

)()(

)()(

)(

0

02

,,,

tgSrt

tkt

t

k

kkkk

22

N

gr

)(),(2 tStx

Large N limitself-average

Page 41: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Temperature Quench 0 FI TT

kk tgSrk ,2

, )]([

Page 42: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Temperature Quench 0 FI TT

kk tgSrk ,2

, )]([

1t

0

Page 43: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

Temperature Quench 0 FI TT

kk tgSrk ,2

, )]([

0,02 kk

0

1t

unstable modes

Page 44: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

t1t

1t

kMk

kT

effective temperatures

)()()()( ttttT kkkk

0

Page 45: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

)()()()( ttttT kkkk

effective temperatures

t2t

0

1t

k

2t

Mk

kT

Page 46: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

t3t

1t

kMk

2t3t

kT

)()()()( ttttT kkkk

effective temperatures

0

Page 47: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k

kT

t

0)(2

10

k

k tTV

H

)(

)(

0)(

0

0

0

tT

tT

tT

k

k

ksystem permanently

out of equilibrium

0

«apparent» equilibrium

Page 48: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k

kT

k k ztTVe

)(

111

energy fluctuations

Page 49: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k k ztTVe

)(

111

1Mk

T z

k

kT

1Mk

T

normal fluctuations

e~

0Mk

Page 50: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k

kT

k k ztTVe

)(

111

Page 51: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k

1kT

1Mk

T

10T

k k ztTVe

)(

111

hottestmode

1Mk

T10T 0

z

coldestmode

Page 52: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

k

1kT

1Mk

T

10T

condensation of negative energy

fluctuationsdue to unstable modes

k k ztTVe

)(

111

1Mk

Tz

10T

e~

Ce~

e0e

Page 53: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

phase diagram 0FT

Ce

t

normal

condensednormal

LARGE-N

Ce

t

condensednormal

GAUSSIAN

Page 54: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 46, 042001 (2013)

),,( wttqI

wttx

condensation

Page 55: CONDENSATION OF FLUCTUATIONS IN A TEMPERATURE QUENCH Marco Zannetti - U Salerno in collaboration with Federico Corberi - U Salerno Giuseppe Gonnella -

conclusions and outlook

• Fluctuations of energy and heat after a temperature quench non trivial even in trivial non interacting systems• Condensation of fluctuations is related to the duality fluctuations in unbiased ensemble ↔ average properties in biased ensemble• Effective temperature key quantity – relation with effective temperature from FDR• Mean field qualitatively different from real system (energy unbounded below) - go beyond mean field