Comparison of Polarimetric C Band Doppler Radar Observations with Reflectivity Fields obtained at S...
-
Upload
carol-boyd -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of Comparison of Polarimetric C Band Doppler Radar Observations with Reflectivity Fields obtained at S...
Comparison of Polarimetric C Band Doppler Radar Observations with Reflectivity Fields obtained at S Band: A Case Study of Water induced AttenuationR. Keränen (1) , Ylläsjärvi J. (2) , Passarelli R. (1) and Selzler J. (1)
Heikki Pohjola, Vaisala
(1) Vaisala, (2) Finnish Meteorolological Institute
Page 2 / ©Vaisala
Introduction
Attenuation due to the liquid water major challenge at weather radar frequencies (X and C bands)
Traditionally, this has justified investments in S band technology in climates of heavy precipitation
This situation has changed: Modern Dual Polarization C band weather radars are an attractive choice in all climates
The cost issue: A turnkey-installed C band system is 1/2 to 1/3 the price of an S band system
Page 3 / ©Vaisala
What is attenuation?
Attenuation is the reduction of intensity of electromagnetic wave along the path of propagation
It is caused by scattering and absorption by the propagation medium
Strongly dependent on wave lenght: C band (λ=5 cm) three times higher than S band (λ=10 cm) and X band (λ=3 cm) 30 times stronger than C band (λ=5 cm) (Doviak and Zrnic 1993)
In addition to drop size characteristics water induced attenuation depends on temperature: It is about 50% stronger at 0 C degrees compared to 20 C, in comparable rain
Page 4 / ©Vaisala
Typical values of attenuation at C band
Cause of attenuation
Hail
Rain
Mixed rain
Snow
Clouds
Atmospheric gases
Increasing attenuation
Typical value (C-band)
~ 10 - 30 dBZ
~ 2 - 25 dBZ
~ 1 - 5 dBZ ?
~ 0 - 3 dBZ
~ 0 - 3 dBZ
~ 0 - 2 dBZ
Battan, L. J., 1973
Page 5 / ©Vaisala
Example of attenuation at C band in Finland
Page 6 / ©Vaisala
Example of attenuation at C band in Finland
Page 7 / ©Vaisala
Attenuation correction in single polarization radars
Traditional correction method uses a power law relation between specific attenuation and reflectivity (single polarization radars) (Hitschfeld and Bordan, 1954)
This method is unstable High sensitivity to radar calibration errors Uncertainty in correction bigger or equal to errors due to the
attenuation Not very widely used operationally
Page 8 / ©Vaisala
Correction method is based on the measurement of differential phase (ΦΦdpdp): ): Phase difference between the received signals in horizontal and vertical channels (Bringi et al, 1990)
Nearly linear relationship between the specific attenuation (adp) and the evolution of Φdp in range (K dp ),
Rule of thumb: Change of 10 degrees in differential phase <-> path integrated attenuation of 1 dB
Sources of uncertainty: Sampling noise in Φdp , Non-Rayleigh scatters such as large drops, hail/graupel mixtures of rain, non-meteorological targets (clutter)
Can be diminished with advanced filtering techniques
Attenuation correction in dual polarization radars
Page 9 / ©Vaisala
How Differential Phase Works
Page 10 / ©Vaisala
Case study of significant precipitation in Huntsville, Alabama, USA
The observations by the ARMOR polarimetric C Band radar (Petersen et al 2007)
The independent observations made at the NEXRAD S Band radar are used for comparison to an unattenuated reference
Squall line approaching Huntsville from north-west, maximum reflectivities exceed 58 dBZ
Page 11 / ©Vaisala
C Band radar
S Band radar
Reflectivity, dBZ
Page 12 / ©Vaisala
C Band radar, dBZ
S Band radar
C Band radar, Φdp
Page 13 / ©Vaisala
C Band radar, uncorrectedC Band radar, corrected
S Band radar
Reflectivity, dBZ
Page 14 / ©Vaisala
A single ray comparison of C Band reflectivities, azimuth 40 degrees
-20-10
0102030405060708090
0 20 40 60 80 100 120Earth Range (km)
Re
flect
ivity
(d
B)
Zh(S-band)Zh(C-band) observedZh(C-band) corrected
Page 15 / ©Vaisala
Conclusions
Dual polarization techniques applied in C Band weather radar specifies C Band radar to be useful in "all climate weather conditions"
Dual polarization C Band weather radars with advanced signal processing techniques offers new methods to mitigate attenuation
Attenuation is not anymore major limitation for the broader use of short wave lengths technology in climates of intense rain
Applying attenuation correction techniques demands modern weather radar with latest dual polarization technology
Page 16 / ©Vaisala
Correction factor for rain intensity with different bias
Bias /dB
Co
rre
ctio
n fa
ctor