COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS · 2014-02-28 · Community Development Financial...
Transcript of COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS · 2014-02-28 · Community Development Financial...
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Community Economic Development Manual
Disclaimer
This fact sheet was produced by the California Community Economic Development Association, in
partnership with the Community Action Partnership National Office, as part of the U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services, Office of Community Services. The “Community Economic Development” publication
series is designed to increase the knowledge of processes for community economic development projects
nationwide. The contents of this manual are presented as a matter of information only. Nothing herein should
be construed as providing legal, tax, or financial advice. The materials referenced and the opinions expressed
in this product do not necessarily reflect the position of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
Office of Community Services, and no official endorsements by that agency should be inferred.
Support for the Community Economic Development project and this toolkit is provided by the
Department of Health and Human Services Administration for Children and Families,
Office of Community Services (OCS), grant award number: 90ET0426/01.
Entire contents copyright © 2011 Community Action Partnership. All rights reserved.
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 1
COMMUNITYACTIONPARTNERSHIP
COMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTFINANCIALINSTITUTIONS
TOOLKIT
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 2
COMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTFININCIALINSTITUTIONS
TABLEOFCONTENTS
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………………………….……….……………….3CommunityEconomicDevelopmentandintegration………………………………………………………………..5Background……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….6WhatisaCDFI?………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………...7CDFIProgramBenefits………………………………………………………………………………………………………………7CDFIFinancialAssistanceandTechnicalAssistance………………………………………………………………..…9CDFIDesignationRequirements………………………………………………………………………………………………11BecomingaCDFI……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..11CDFIEligibility……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…11CDFIAwardCategories……………………………………………………………………………………………………………11CDFIApplicationforTechnicalAssistanceAwards………………………………………………………………..…11CDFIApplicationforFinancialAssistanceAwards…………………………………………………………………...12ComprehensiveRatingsforCDFIInvestments(CARS)……………………………………………………………..13BusinessPlanandGrowthStrategy………………………………………………………………………………………...13ProgramFeasibilityConcepts………………………………………………………………………………………………….14StartUporExpansion/BecomingaCDFI………………………………………………………………………………….15StartUpCDFI…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..15SlightlyExperiencedLoanFund……………………………………………………………………………………………….17ExistingorExperiencedLoanFund……………………………………………………………………………………….…17SummaryStepstoBecomingaCDFI………………………………………………………………………………………..17DevelopmentTips……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………18OtherNotes…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….19FinalNote………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..19AppendixA–ForMoreinformation………………………………………………………………………………………..21OpportunityFinanceNetwork………………………………………………………………………………………………...21CoalitionofCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions(CDFICoalition)………………………….21CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutionsFund……………………………………………………………..21CaliforniaAssociationforMicroEnterpriseOpportunity(CAMEO)……………………………………….…21NationalCommunityReinvestmentFund(CRF,USA)………………………………………………………………22ForMoreinformation:Websites,OrganizationalExamples…………………………………………………….22NCBCapitalImpact………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….22RegionalCDFIs…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………23ClearinghouseCDFI…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………23CoastalEnterprise,Inc.(CEI)…………………………………………………………………………………………………..23CommunityBasedFunds…………………………………………………………………………………………………………23FresnoCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitution(FCDFI)………………………………………………..23PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServices…………………………………………………………………………………..23
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 3
COMMUNITYDEVELOPMENTFINANCIALINSTITUTIONS
INTRODUCTIONThisCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions(CDFIs)Guideisintendedforusebycommunitydevelopmentorganizationsforthefollowingpurposes:
1. OrganizationswantingtolearnaboutCDFIs2. OrganizationsconsideringbecomingacertifiedCommunityDevelopmentFinancial
Institutionwhichhaveanexistingloanprogram3. OrganizationsconsideringbecomingacertifiedCommunityDevelopmentFinancial
Institutionandhavenotoperatedaloanprogram4. OrganizationslookingforCDFIservicesfortheirownuseorfortheircommunity
TheCDFIdesignationisacertificationprocessconferredbytheCDFIfundoftheDepartmentofTreasury.Thedesignationisforfinancialinstitutions(andlendingprogramsincludingcommunityloanfunds)andallowsaccesstoTreasuryprogramsandinvestments.Thedesignationhasbecomeakeyidentificationfactorforfoundations,local,stateandotherfederalprogramstoinvestadditionalcapital.ThemissionoftheCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutionsFundisto“expandthecapacityoffinancialinstitutionstoprovidecredit,capitalandfinancialservicestounderservedpopulationsandcommunitiesintheUnitedStates”1TheCDFIFundhasseveralprogramsthatenhancesaccesstocapital.Uponreceivingcertification,CDFI’sareeligibletocompetefortechnicalassistancegrants,capitalgrants,NewMarketsTaxCreditsaswellasothertargetedincentiveprograms.TheCDFIdesignationallowslendingprogramsaccesstocompeteforCDFIresources,buttheseresourcesareinveryhighdemand.Sincethestartoftheprogramin1994,thecompetitivebarhasrisendramaticallyandorganizationsreceivinggrantshavesignificantexperienceinsuccessfullyoperatingaloanfundorconductionlendingactivities.Thereforewehighlyrecommendthatorganizationcloselystudytheapplicationguidelinesfoundatwww.cdfifund.gov.
“CDFIsprovideauniquerangeoffinancialproductsandservicesineconomicallydistressedtargetmarkets,suchasmortgagefinancingforlow‐incomeandfirst‐timehomebuyersandnot‐for‐profitdevelopers,flexibleunderwritingandriskcapitalforneededcommunityfacilities,andtechnicalassistance,commercialloansandinvestmentstosmallstart‐uporexpandingbusinessesinlow‐incomeareas.CDFIsincluderegulatedinstitutionssuchascommunitydevelopmentbanksandcreditunions,andnon‐regulatedinstitutionssuchasloanandventurecapitalfunds”.2
1 Community Development Financial Institutions Fund “CDFI Certification Application”, Department of Treasury, June 2007, pg 4 2 CDFI Fund Summary, www.cdfifund.gov
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 4
Forsuccessfulloanfunds,theCDFIdesignationisveryimportantandallowsyourlendingprogramtogrowdramatically.MostfoundationandcorporategrantsandinvestmentsfromfinancialinstitutionslookfortheCDFIdesignationbeforegrantorinvestmentdiscussionsbegin.Overthelastthreeyears,financialinstitutionshavebeenveryactivelyseekingsoundCDFIstoinvestin.CDFIshavebeenaverysuccessfulmechanismforfinancialinstitutionstomeetlendingandinvestmentmeasuresrequiredbytheCommunityReinvestmentAct(CRA)andenforcedbybankingregulators.AhighCRAratingisneededifthefinancialinstitutionhasplanstoexpandinthefuture.Duetorecenteconomicandfinancialturmoil,commerciallendersandinvestorshavesubstantiallytightenedlendingrequirements,resultingina“creditcrunch”wherecreditneedsaregreaterthanresources.ThiseconomiclandscaperesultedincommercialfinancialinstitutionsgreaterrelianceoncommunityloanfundsandCDFIsasthemechanismtobetterservemarketneeds.FinancialinstitutionsbegantoinvestandlendmoreaggressivelytosoundCDFIs.ThisinvestmentandlendingstrategyenablesinstitutionstomeetCRArequirementswhilemakesafeandsoundinvestments.CDFIshavebuiltastrongreputationinunderstandinglocalcreditnuancesandneedsresultinginstrongloanportfolios.Recently,theFederalHomeLoanBank(FHLB)systemhasallowedCDFI’saccesstomembershippreviouslylimitedtocommercialbanks,thriftsandsavingsandloans(determinedonaregionalbankbybankapprovalprocess).ThereareverystringentrequirementshoweveraccessallowsCDFIstoleverageCDFIequityandbelow‐marketfinancingtoservemorecustomersandprovidemorelendingproducts.ThecostoffundsfromtheFHLBistypicallygreaterthantheratesfromgrantsourcesforCDFIs,sotheuseofthisresourceissomewhatlimitedtolargerCDFIinvolvedwithlargerloans.Approvalisheavilyweightedonsuccessfulmanagementexperienceandlendinghistory.AnadditionalveryimportantresourcewascreatedbytheSmallBusinessJobsActof2010whichincludetheCDFIBondGuaranteeProgramwhichwillbeadministeredbytheCDFIFund.Withcurrentlowinterestrates,CDFIswillbeabletolockincurrentextremelylowinterestratesofupto30yeardebt.ThiswouldresultinacapitalinfusionforCDFIsof$3billiondollars(by2014),atratesinthecurrentmarketatabout3%.
“Keyfeaturesoftheprograminclude:1. $3Billioninbondguaranteeauthoritythrough2014withminimumbondsizeof
$100million2. CDFIswillbeabletoissuetaxablebondswithtermsupto30years3. TheFederalGovernmentGuaranteeensuresrepaymentofverifiablelossesof
principal,interest,andcallpremium,ifany,onbondsandnotes4. TheFederalFinancingBankwillbuy100percentofbondsandnotesissuedto
simplifyexecutionandminimizecostandpricing5. ParticipatingCDFIswillberequiredtoestablisharisksharepoolofthreepercentof
thebondornoteamount
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 5
6. ProceedscanbeusedbyCDFIstofinanceorrefinanceactivitythatmeetsthecommunityandeconomicdevelopmenttdefinitionoftheRiegleAct(enablinglegislationfortheCDFIFund.”3
COMMUNITYECONOMICDEVELOPMENTAPPLICABILITYANDINTEGRATIONCDFIsplayanintegralroleinacommunityeconomicdevelopmentstrategy.CDFIsbringcapitaltounderservedmarketsthatincludebusinessfinance(startup,micro,non‐profit,smallandbusinessexpansion),realestatedevelopmentfinance(affordablehousing,commercialandoffice,communityfacilitiesandindustrial)andpersonalfinance(auto,homeorpersonal).Thiscapitalcreateseconomicstabilitywhilecreatingjobsandopportunitiesforcommunityresidents.CDFIsalsobringcommunitiesahigherleveloftechnicalexpertiseinbusinessandfinanceincreasingthepotentialforsustainedcommunitystabilityandgrowth.CDFI’shavealsoenabledfinancialinstitutionstobecomemoreeffectiveinmeetingcustomerdemandsinlowincomeanddisadvantagedcommunities.ThegrowthofsuccessfulCDFI’sallowsfundstomoreeasilycoveroperatingandoverheadexpensesandgenerateadditionalincometosupportotherorganizationalcommunitydevelopmentactivitiessuchasbusinesstechnicalassistanceprogramsandexpansionoflendingservicestomeetotheraspectsofcommunitycreditneeds(suchasautoloans,microloans,homeorbusinessloans).Astrongerandfinanciallyviablelendingbusinesswillenhancetheoverallsuccessandlongevityofyourcommunitydevelopmentorganization.TheCDFIdesignationincreasesresources(expertiseandcapital)resultingingreaterlendingactivities.Thisexpansionenhancestheorganizationandcommunity.Theeffectsaresubstantialandinclude:FortheOrganization:
1. Allowsforexpansionandstabilityfortheorganizationslendingefforts2. Generatesadditionalincomefortheprogram3. Supportsandallowsforthecreationofadditionalcomplementaryprograms,services
andprojects4. Expandsstaffcapacityacapabilitiesbyattractingandretainingexperienced
professionalsinbusinessfinanceanddevelopmentForthecommunity:
1. Increasesaccesstocapital2. Increasedaccessrelatedresourcessuchastrainingandtechnicalassistanceintheareas
offinanceandbusinessdevelopment3. Enhancesthelocaleconomybysupportingimportantsegmentsoftheeconomic
infrastructureincludingbusiness,residentialandindustrialsectors
3 Dolan, Cathy “CDFI Bond: Opportunity of a Decade, Community Investments” Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Fall 2011, page 28
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 6
Successfullendingefforts(andancillaryfinancialprograms)resultsineconomicallystrongercommunities,strongerworkforces,moreinformedandcapablebusinessesandtenants,andultimatelyastrongerandmoreinclusiveeconomy.BecauseCDFIfundresourcesarelimited,highlycompetitiveandrequireastrongtrackrecordandhighlevelofexpertise,alternativesolutionsincludethecreationofpartnershipswithexistingCDFIs.PartnershipscouldbeassimpleashavingandexistingCDFIexpandtheirmarketareatoincludeyourgeographyorbyprovidingalocalsitefortrainingandtechnicalassistanceservices.AnothersolutioncanincludecreationofanewfundtargetedtotheneedsofyourcommunitybutismanagedandoperatedbyasuccessfulCDFI.
CDFI’sareimportantresourcesforlowincomecommunities.“CDFIsareprofitablebutnotprofitmaximizing.Theyputcommunityfirst,nottheshareholder.Theyhavehadgreatsuccessoverthepast30years,andhaveaproventrackrecordofmakinganimpactinthoseareasofAmericathatneeditmost”.4
InaJune2009speech,FederalReserveChairmanBenBernankerecognizedthatCDFIsfacilitateeconomicgrowthanddevelopment:
“Today,nationwide,therearemorethan1,000certifiedCDFIswithacollective$25billioninassets.Theseorganizationshaveloanedandinvestedbillionsofdollarsinournation’smostdistressedcommunitiesandhaveattractedmanyconventionalinvestorsintounderservedareas….Asacomplementtolending,CDFIsoffertrainingandtechnicalassistancetotheircustomers,directlyorthroughpartnerships,thusincreasingborrowercapacityandmitigatingloanrisk.SuccessfulCDFIborrowers’oftengraduatetoconventionalfinancingastheirneedsgrow,therebyattractingtheparticipationofmainstreamlenderswhilefreeingupCDFIresourcestoplantnewseedsinthecommunity”5
ThisguidewillprovideyoubackgroundontheCDFIprogram,discussprogramaspectsandsummarizetheeligibility/applicationprocess.TheguidewillalsodiscussandpresentsuccessfulCDFIstrategiesandidentifyresourcesfororganizationsinterestedinpursuingaCDFIdesignation.WewillalsodiscussvariousstrategiesforpartnershipsthatwillbringthebenefitsCDFI’soffertoyourcommunityororganization.BACKGROUND
TheCDFIprogramwasestablishedin1994aspartoftheCommunityDevelopmentBankingandFinancialInstitutionsAct.TheprogramhaditsearliergenesisfromPresidentBillClintonwhileasacandidatein1992visitedtheSouthShoreBank,aspecializedcommunitydevelopmentbankfocusedonincreasinginvestmentinneglectedneighborhoods.ThePresidentsinterestincreatingsimilareffortsledtothecreationoftheCDFIfundinTreasury.
4 Opportunity Finance Network (OFN), “About CDFIs”, website www.ofn.net 5 Opportunity Finance Network “CARS, Comprehensive Ratings for CDFI Investments”, An Independent Project of Opportunity Finance Network, www.CARSratingsystem.net
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 7
The1994lawwasdesignedto“promoteeconomicrevitalizationandcommunitydevelopmentindistressedurban,ruralandNativeAmericancommunitiesacrossthenation.TheCDFIFunddoesthisprimarilybyawardingfinancialassistancetoCDFI’sandinsureddepositoryinstitutions.”6WHATISACDFI?TheCDFICertificationApplication7definesCDFIsasfollows:“ACommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitution(CDFI)isaspecializedfinancialinstitutionthatworksinmarketnicheswhichareunderservedbytraditionalfinancialinstitutions.CDFIsprovideauniquerangeoffinancialproductsandservices,suchasmortgagefinancingforlow‐incomeandfirst‐timehomebuyersandnot‐for–profitdevelopers,flexibleunderwritingandriskcapitalforneededcommunityfacilities,andtechnicalassistance,commercialloansandinvestmentstosmallstart‐uporexpandingbusinessesinlowincomeareas.ACDFImustprovidedevelopmentservicesthatsupportfinancialtransactionsandshowthatitisdirectlyaccountabletoitscommunityoritscustomers.CDFIsincluderegulatedinstitutionssuchascommunitydevelopmentbouncesandcreditunions,anonregulatedinstitutionsuchasloanfunds,venturecapitalfundsandmicro‐enterpriseloanfunds.”TobecomeaCDFItheentitymustmeetthefollowingsixcertificationcriteria:
1. Haveaprimarymissionofpromotingcommunitydevelopment2. Beafinancingentity3. Primarilyserveoneormoretargetmarkets4. Providedevelopmentservicesinconjunctionwithitsfinancingactivities5. Maintainaccountabilitytoitsdefinedtargetmarket6. Beanon‐governmentalentityandnotbeundercontrolofanygovernmententity
(excludingtribalgovernments).
CDFIPROGRAMBENEFITSTheCDFIcertificationisarequirementthatwillallowyoutoaccessCDFIprogramfunds.Theseprogramsinclude:Note:SourcematerialforthissectionisfromtheCDFIwebsiteat:www.cdfifund.gov.Thewebsiteincludesannualchangesintheprogramorspecialprograms,forexamplethe2011applicationprocessincludedtheHealthyFoodFinancingInitiativethatmade12awardsfor$25million.ThegoalofthisprogramistouseCDFIcapacitytomakeinvestmentsinarangeofhealthfoodprojectsservingfooddesertsincludinggrocerystores,mobilefoodretailers.Farmersmarkets,cooperatives,cornerstores,bodegasorotherfoodrelateditems(includinghealthfoods).
1. BankEnterpriseAward(BEA):CDFIscanpartnerwithaFDICinsuredfinancialinstitutiontoseekaBEAaward.Thisprogramprovidesincentivestoinstitutionsbyproviding
6 Abt Associates Inc., “From Insight to Impact, Assessment of the Community Development Financial Intuitions Fund (CDFI) Program, Training Program & CDFI Certification – Final Report” Executive Summary, August 17, 2007, page iii 7 CDFI Fund Summary, Op Cit
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 8
financialincentivestoexpandinvestmentsinCDFIsandtoincreaselending,investment,andserviceactivitieswithineconomicallydistressedcommunitiesoveraspecifictimeperiod.Activitiesinclude:
a. CDFIRelatedActivities:Equityinvestments,equity‐likeloans,grants,loans,deposits/shares,andtechnicalassistancetoqualifiedCDFIpartners
b. DistressedCommunityFinancingActivities:Affordablehomemortgageloans,affordablehousingdevelopmentloans,smallbusinessloans,homeimprovementloans,educationloans,andcommercialrealestateloans
c. ServiceActivities:Deposits,communityservices,andfinancialservices2. CapitalMagnetFund(CMF):providecompetitivelyawardedgrantstoCDFIsand
qualifiednonprofithousingorganizations.CMFawardscanbeusedtofinanceaffordablehousingactivitiesaswellasrelatedeconomicdevelopmentactivitiesandcommunityservicefacilities.Awardeeswillbeabletoutilizefinancingtoolssuchasloanlossreserves,loanfunds,risk‐sharingloans,andloanguaranteestoproduceeligibleactivitieswhoseaggregatecostsareatleasttentimesthesizeoftheawardamount.
3. CDFIPrograms:(SeenextsectionfordetailsontheFinancialAssistanceandTechnicalAssistancePrograms)
4. FinancialEducationandCounseling(FEC):ThroughtheFECPilotProgram,theCDFIFundshallprovidegrantstoeligibleorganizationstoenablethemtoprovidearangeoffinancialeducationandcounselingservicestoprospectivehomebuyers,withthegoalsof:
a. Increasingthefinancialknowledgeanddecision‐makingcapabilitiesofprospectivehomebuyers;
b. Assistingprospectivehomebuyerstodevelopmonthlybudgets,buildpersonalsavings,financeorplanformajorpurchases,reducetheirdebt,improvetheirfinancialstability,andsetandreachtheirfinancialgoals;
c. Helpingprospectivehomebuyerstoimprovetheircreditscoresbyunderstandingtherelationshipbetweentheircredithistoriesandtheircreditscores;and
d. Educatingprospectivehomebuyersabouttheoptionsavailabletobuildsavingsforshort‐andlong‐termgoals
TheultimateprogramgoalsoftheFECPilotProgramaretoidentifysuccessfulmethodsresultinginpositivebehavioralchangeforfinancialempowerment,andtoestablishprogrammodelsfororganizationstocarryouteffectivefinancialeducationandcounselingservicestoprospectivehomebuyers.
5. NewMarketsTaxCredits:CDFIsareeligibletocompeteforNewMarketsTaxCredits(NMTC).ThroughthecreationofaCommunityDevelopmentEntity(CDE),creditsareallocatedtoeligiblenonhousingrealestatedevelopmentprojectsineligiblelocations.Communitybenefitandjobcreationaretheprimarygoalsoftheprogram.TheNewMarketsTaxCreditProgram(NMTCProgram)wasestablishedbyCongressin2000tospurneworincreasedinvestmentsintooperatingbusinessesandrealestateprojectslocatedinlow‐incomecommunities.TheNMTCProgramattractsinvestmentcapitaltolow‐incomecommunitiesbypermittingindividualandcorporateinvestorstoreceiveataxcreditagainsttheirFederalincometaxreturninexchangeformakingequityinvestmentsinspecializedfinancialinstitutionscalledCommunityDevelopmentEntities(CDEs).Thecredittotals39percentoftheoriginalinvestmentamountandisclaimedoveraperiodofsevenyears(fivepercentforeachofthefirstthreeyears,andsix
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 9
percentforeachoftheremainingfouryears).TheinvestmentintheCDEcannotberedeemedbeforetheendoftheseven‐yearperiod.NOTE:TheNMTCprogramhasbecomeaveryimportanttoolforCommunityEconomicDevelopment.PleasereviewtheseparateGuideonNewMarketsTaxCreditsformoredetails.
6. NativeAmericanCDFIAssistanceProgram(NACA):FocusedprogramsupportingactivitiesforNativeAmericancommunities:TheCDFIFund'sNativeInitiativesaredesignedtoovercomeidentifiedbarrierstofinancialservicesinNativeCommunities.Theseinitiativesseektoincreasetheaccesstocredit,capitalandfinancialservicesinNativeCommunitiesthroughthecreationandexpansionofCDFIsprimarilyservingNativeCommunities
7. CertificationforCommunityDevelopmentEntities(CDE):ACDEisadomesticcorporationorpartnershipthatisanintermediaryvehiclefortheprovisionofloans,investments,orfinancialcounselinginlow‐incomecommunities.BenefitsofbeingcertifiedasaCDEincludebeingabletoapplytotheCDFIFundtoreceiveaNewMarketsTaxCredit(NMTC)allocationtoofferitsinvestorsinexchangeforequityinvestmentsintheCDEand/oritssubsidiaries;ortoreceiveloansorinvestmentsfromotherCDEsthathavereceivedNMTCallocations
8. CertificationforCDFIs:CDFIcertificationisadesignationconferredbytheCDFIFundandisarequirementforaccessingfinancialandtechnicalawardassistancefromtheCDFIFundthroughtheCDFIProgram,NativeAmericanCDFIAssistance(NACA)Programs,andcertainbenefitsundertheBEAProgramtosupportanorganization'sestablishedcommunitydevelopmentfinancingprograms
CDFIFinancialAssistanceandTechnicalAssistance:TobeeligibleforanFAaward,aCDFImustbecertifiedbytheCDFIFundbeforeitappliesfortheaward.ProspectiveapplicantsthatarenotyetcertifiedmustsubmitaseparatecertificationapplicationtobeconsideredforFAduringafundinground.
Bothcertifiedandnon‐certifiedCDFIsareeligibletoapplyforTAawards.However,non‐certifiedorganizationsmustbeabletobecomecertifiedwithintwoyearsafterreceivingaTAaward.TheTAawardswillcoverexpensesneededtobuildthecapacityoforganizationstobecomeeligibleforCDFIdesignation.
TechnicalAssistance(TA):TAgrantsallowcertifiedCDFIsandestablishedentitiesseekingtobecomecertifiedtobuildtheircapacitytoprovideaffordablefinancialproductsandservicestolow‐incomecommunitiesandfamilies.Grantsmaybeusedforawiderangeofpurposes.Forexample,awardeescanuseTAfundstopurchaseequipment,materials,orsupplies;forconsultingorcontractingservices;topaythesalariesandbenefitsofcertainpersonnel;and/ortotrainstafforboardmembers.TheCDFIFundmakesawardsofupto$100,000undertheTAcomponentoftheCDFIProgram
FinancialAssistance(FA):TheCDFIFundmakesawardsofupto$2milliontocertifiedCDFIsundertheFAcomponentoftheCDFIProgram.ACDFImayusetheawardforfinancingcapital,loanlossreserves,capitalreserves,oroperations.FAawardsaremadeintheformofequityinvestments,loans,deposits,orgrants,andtheCDFIisrequiredtomatchitsFAawarddollar‐for‐dollarwithnon‐federalfundsofthesametypeastheawarditself.Thisrequirementenables
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 10
CDFIstoleverageprivatecapitaltomeetthedemandforaffordablefinancialproductsandservicesineconomicallydistressedcommunities.
CDFIProgramActivities:TheCDFIFundpublishesannualreportsonwhoreceivedawards.TheinformationissummarizedandispresentedbyCDFInameandbyStatetheyarelocatedin.Thesummaryshowsthegeographictargetofthefunds(canvaryfromneighborhoods,tocountiestomulti‐stategeographies),andwhattypeoflendingandinvestmenttheCDFItargets(microloans,businessloans,homeloans,realestateloansand/orloanstonon‐profitorganizations).Thefollowingsummarizesactivitiesforthe2011awards.
1. 155organizationsreceived$142million(allgrants)2. 118FAand37TAawardsweremade3. 125loanfunds,25creditunions,threeventurecapitalfunds,andtwodepository
institutions/holdingcompaniesreceivedawards4. 69servedmajormarkets,39servedminorurbanmarketsand47servedruralareas
FinancialAssistanceAwards:1. 267CDFIsappliedrequestingover$448million2. 118received$139million3. 94loanfunds,20creditunionsand4awardswenttoothers4. CoreCDFIs(receivedpreviousFAgrants)received86awardswith32goingtoEmerging
CDFIs(neworpreviouslyreceivedTAgrants)5. Awardeeswereheadquarteredin35differentstates6. Typeofservicesincluded:
a. 32%providedaffordablehousingproductsb. 29%providedsmallbusinessloansc. 21%providedconsumerfinanceloansd. 14%providedmicroenterprisefinancinge. 3%providedcommercialloanproducts
TechnicalAssistanceAwards1. 114applicantsrequestedover10.8million2. 37awardsweremadeforatotalof$3.15million3. 31loanfunds,fivecreditunionsand1otherreceivedgrants4. Awardsrangedfrom$13,456to$100,0005. Useofthefundsincluded:
a. 48%forPersonnelb. 26%ProfessionalServicesc. 9.3%FringeBenefitsd. 4.1%Equipmente. 3.8%Trainingf. 2.7%Materials/Suppliesg. 2.6%Travelh. 2.6%Other
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 11
CDFIDESIGNATIONREQUIREMENTS:ThefollowingoutlinesummarizesthekeyelementsintheapplicationtobecomeaCDFI.YoucanlocatethefullCDFIapplicationontheCDFIFundwebsite.BecomingaCDFI:
1. ACDFIisaspecializedfinancialinstitutionthatworksinmarketnichesthatareunderservedbytraditionalfinancialinstitutions.
2. Provideauniquerangeoffinancialproductsandservicesineconomicallydistressedtargetmarketssuchas:
a. Mortgagefinancingforlowincomeandfirsttimehomebuyersandnon‐profitdevelopers
b. Flexibleunderwritingandriskcapitalforneededcommunityfacilitiesandtechnicalassistance
c. Commercialloansandinvestmentstosmallstartuporexpandingbusinessesinlowincomeareas
3. Couldincluderegulatedinstitutionssuchascommunitydevelopmentbanksandcreditunionsandnonregulatedentitiessuchasloanandventurecapitalfunds
CDFIEligibility:ThisisthefirststepyouneedtoestablisheligibilitytoapplyforTechnicalAssistanceorFinancialAssistanceAwards.YoumustsubmitaCDFICertificationApplicationtothefundforreview.Youmust:
1. Bealegalentityatthetimeofcertificationapplication2. Haveaprimarymissionofpromotingcommunitydevelopment3. Beafinancingentity4. Primarilyserveoneormoretargetmarkets5. Providedevelopmentservicesinconjunctionwithfinancingactivities6. Maintainaccountabilitytoitsdefinedtargetmarket7. Beanongovernmententityandnotbeunderthecontrolofanygovernment
2011CDFIAwardCategories:
1. FinancialAssistance:CertifiedCDFIsmayreceiveawardsintheformofgrants,loans,equityinvestments,depositsandinsuredcreditunionshares
2. TechnicalAssistance:NoncertifiedCDFI’smayapplyforTA(notboth)tobuildorganizationalcapacity.Ifyouhavenotbeencertified,TAcouldhelpyougetcertified.Thesefundsdonotrequirematchingfunds.
3. HealthyFoodsFinancingInitiative:AwardstoCDFIstoaddresstheneedforhealthyfoodsintheirmarkets(USDAandHHSsupport)
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 12
CDFIApplicationforTechnicalAssistanceAwards:ThisisAwardallowsyoutobuildyourorganizationssystemsandcapacitytoapplyfortheFinancialAssistanceAwards.Requiredinformationincludes:
1. TAProposala. Howwillithelpmeetbusinessplanproposalb. Howwillithelpbuildyourcapacity
2. Usea. Training,travelandsupplies/materialsb. Professionalservices(consultantsforlendingpoliciesandprocedures,market
analysis,evaluateexistingservicesandprogramsanddevelopanddelivertrainingtopotentialborrowers.
3. EconomicDistressPriorityPointsa. Levelofdistress(qualitativeandquantitative)intargetmarketb. Prioritypoints:ID5prioritycounties
4. FinancialProductsandFinancialServicesa. Listproductsandneedsaddressedb. Examplesofpastcustomersandimpactsc. Returnsandleveraging
5. ServicestotheTargetedMarket6. MarketDemand7. OrganizationalCapacity
a. Trackrecord(productsandservices)b. Growth(demand)c. Impactd. Leveraginge. Projectedactivityandresultsf. Managementteam(keystaff)g. Systems,policiesandproceduresforunderwriting,portfolioreview,financial
accountingandMISsystems.h. Financialcapacity(portfoliohealth,viability,capitalizationandperformance)i. Capitalmeasuresandratios
CDFIApplicationforFinancialAssistanceAwards:Thisawardisagrantthatcanbeusedfororganizationalsystemsimprovementasseedcapital(orexpansioncapital)foryourloanfund.Itisagrantandthereforecomestoyoua0%interest.Informationrequiredincludes:
1. TargetMarket:a. Customersb. NationalMarkets:WherehaveyouprovidedFinancialProductsoverthelast5
years2. FinancialAssistancePlan(ForFA)
a. Organizationsimpactstodateinthetargetmarketb. Businessplanonceawardisreceived
3. HighImpactNarrativea. How,timeline,objectivesandimpact
4. EconomicDistressandPriorityPointsa. Levelofeconomicdistress(areaswithinlargergeography)
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 13
b. Economicdata;credit,capitalandfinancialneed5. FinancialProductsandFinancialServices
a. Listproductsandneedsaddressedb. Examplesofpastcustomersandimpactsc. Returnsgeneratedbyproductsandservicesd. Howfundingisbeingleveraged
6. ServicetoTargetMarketa. Developmentservicessummaryb. Linkagetoproductsc. Otherservices
7. MarketDemanda. Quantifydemandforproductsandservicesb. Marketstudiesc. Otherresources
8. OrganizationalCapacitya. Trackrecord(productsandservices)b. Growth(demand)c. Impactd. Leveraginge. Projectedactivityandresultsf. Managementteam(keystaff)g. Systems,policiesandproceduresforunderwriting,portfolioreview,financial
accountingandMISsystems.h. Financialcapacity(portfoliohealth,viability,capitalizationandperformance)i. Capitalmeasuresandratios
ComprehensiveRatingsforCDFIInvestments(CARS):CARS,theCDFIAssessmentandRatingsSystem,waslaunchedin2004asanindependentprojectofOpportunityFinanceNetwork.Itis“theonlyratingssystemtoprovideacomprehensive,third‐partyassessmentofbothimpactperformanceandfinancialstrengthandperformance[ofCDFIs]CARShelpsinvestorsconfidentlyassessCDFIsthatmatchtheirsocialobjectivesandriskparameters”8.TheanalysisincludesanassessmentbyanexperiencedprofessionalexpertinunderwritingCDFIs.Theanalysisincludesassessmentoffinancialandprogrammaticperformanceandreviewofloanportfolios,riskmanagementsystems,staffandboard.Theanalysiscreatesasinglestandardizedratingsystemtoassistinvestorsfromsourcessuchasfoundations,corporationsorindividualstouniformlydecidewheretheywillinvesttheirfundsbasedonimpactandrisktolerance.ManyinstitutionssolelyrelyoftheCARSratingandrequireapplicantstoparticipateinCARS.BusinessPlanandGrowthStrategy:TheCDFIapplicationprocessessentiallylaysoutthemajorityofitemsneededforasoundbusinessplan.Keyelementsthatarenotpartoftheapplicationinclude:
8 OFN, CARS, Comprehensive Rating for CDFI Investments, Op Cit
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 14
1. MarketAnalysis:Identificationandanalysisofcompetitionanddeterminationofmarketsizeandneeds
Inmostcases,thecompetitionisnonexistent.Thisistheprimaryreasonwhyanorganizationwouldseektocreatealoanfund/CDFI.Thisanalysisisimportantinidentifyingthecreditgapsthatyouaretryingtofill,whileunderstandingwhyotherinstitutionshavenotattemptedtomeetthisneed.Italsoallowsyoutoidentifypotentialpartners,suchasthosethatmayreferbusinesstoyouorwhereyoumightneedtoreferclientswithneedsthatyourfunddoesnotaddress.Thisprocessalsohelpsyouidentifysourcesthatmaybeinterestedinmatchinggrantfunds.
2. FinancingPlan:Financialanalysisoftheexistingandproposedloanportfolioandcashflowforyourbusinessoperations
Youshouldalsoidentifyadditionalsourcesoffinancingthatcouldbeleveragedforyourfund.Ifyouareawardedatechnicalassistancegrantorafinancialassistancegrant,youshouldbereadytoleveragethesefundswithotherpublicandprivatesectorresources.Initiallyaconceptpaperandthelaterbusinessplanarekeyelementsneededtoattractinvestors.
ProgramFeasibilityConcepts:Operatingaloanfundisabusiness.Loanfundscangenerateincomefororganizationsiftheyareoperatedproperlyandhavetherightlevelofactivity.Keytermsandconceptsthatneedtobemanagedinclude:
1. CostofFunds:Yourloanpoolmayincludevarioussourcesofgrantsandinvestmentfunds.Somewillcomeinatdifferentinterestrates.Theblendedrateistheaveragerateforyourloanpool.Ifyoureceivedallgrantstheratewouldbe“0”butifyoureceivedaninvestmentorloan,theratemightbe2‐5%.
2. InterestRateSpread:Thespreadisthedifferentialbetweenyourcostoffundsandwhatrateofreturnis(averageinterestrateyouarecharging)foryourfunds.
3. Breakeven:Thisistheminimumrate(abovethecostoffunds)youneedtochargetocoveryourexpenses.
4. FundExpensesandOverhead:Businessoperations(loanandportfoliomanagement),businessmanagement,marketing,officeandstaffcostsareexpensesthatshouldbepaidfromthe“interestratespread”.Ifyourincomedoesnotcoverexpenses,youwillneedtosecureongoingfundingforoperations.
5. LoanLoss:Thisistheexpectedrateoflossesinbadloans.Allfundshaveprovisionsforloanlossesandthemoreaggressivethefundis(willingtotakemorelendingrisks)thegreaterthelossescouldbe.Successfulfundsestimateloanlosseswellbelow5%(whichatonetimewasastandardcommerciallendinglossexpectation).
6. LoanLossReserve:Loanlossreservesarefundssetasidethatmaybeneededtorepayanyloansorinvestmentsmadetoyourfund.Ifyourfundconsistedofamixofloansinvestmentsandgrants,andaportionofthefundneededtoberepaidtoalenderorinvestoryouwouldsetasidefundsinaloanlossreserve.Ifoneoftheloansyoumadewentbadandyourfundlost$25,000youwouldneedtotapintothereservetorepaythelenderorinvestor.Theriskieryourlendingisorifyouhavehadhistoricallyhighloanlosses,youwouldreflectahigherloanlossreserve.Highloanlossreservesdonotbenefityourfundsinceitissetasideandisnot“working”inthemarketandgeneratinginterestincome.
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 15
Infinancialinstitutionsandinlargerfunds,loansinportfolioareratedandloanswithgreaterriskorareindistress(latepayments)willhaveahigherpercentagesetasideforpotentialloanlosses.
7. Feasibility:Incomeneedstoexceedexpenses.Thelargerthelendingpool(andleveloffundingyouhaveouttoborrowers)thegreateryourpotentialreturnsare.Similarly,smallersizedfundshaveamoredifficulttimegeneratingincometocoverexpenses.Smallerloansalsoincreaseoperatingcosts(handlingandprocessingcostsforeachtransactionisrelativelythesamewhethertheloanisfor$500or$5,000,000.
STARTUPOREXPANSION/BECOMINGACDFIThefollowingsectionwilldiscussvariousstrategiesandstepsthatshouldbeconsideredifyouareastartupCDFIorifyouareexpandingtobecomeaCDFI.Wewilllookatthefollowing:
1. StartUpCDFI:TwoStructuresa. Asanewfundb. Throughapartnership
2. Existing,SlightlyExperiencedLoanFund3. Existing,ExperiencedLoanFund
StartUpCDFI:Forthosewhodonothavealoanfundorlendingprogramyoufirstneedtocreatealoanfundtobuildthelendingtrackrecordandorganizationalexperience.ThisinitialloanfundwillsubsequentlyseekCDFIcertification.Oncecertified,youareeligibletoapplyfortheCDFIFund’sprograms.NOTE:Formoreinformationoncreatingloanfunds,pleaseseethe“LoanFundGuide”ThisisthemostdifficultstartingpointbecausemanyCDFIandlendingresourcesrequireexperience.Thefollowingisasuggestedguideforthoseorganizationsthathaveclearlyidentifiedneedwithstrongsupporttocreateafund.Supportfromyourorganizationandboardiscritical.Thefundshouldbetargetedtoaspecificmarketsegment:microbusinesses,smallbusinesses,affordablehousingorconsumerfinancing.TherearetwomethodsofbecomingaCDFI,onestartingfromscratchandonethroughpartnerships.Strategy1:NewFund(Ifyourplanscallforthecreationofanewfundorstartup).Asignificantamountoffundingandpredevelopmentworkisneededfordevelopingthebusinessplan,marketingandmanagementplans.ConsiderapplyingforaCDFITechnicalAssistanceGrant.Youwillalsoneedfundingforoperationsandfortheloanfund.Ifthisisthecase,youwillneedtoconsiderthefollowing3steps:
1. FundInitiation:Secureseedfundstoallowstafforconsultanttoassistinthefollowing:A. ConceptPaper:Creationofaone‐twopagesummarythatincludesasummary
ofyourorganization,need,size,managementandpotentialresourcesavailableforthebusinessandfund.
B. CommunitySupport:Obtainsupportfromentitiesthatrepresentsyourtargetmarket
C. PublicandPrivateSectorSupport:Identifysupportfromentitiesthatrepresentsyourtargetmarket
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 16
D. IdentifypotentialsourcesforpredevelopmentfundsE. Seekgrants(orplantoselffinance)
2. GO/NOGO:Theinformationresearchedabovewillallowyoutoupdatetheconceptpaper.Thiswillallowyourorganizationtodecideifthecreationofaloanfundmakessenseandisfeasible.Securingpredevelopmentfundswillbeessential.Theconceptpaperwillbethebasisofthebusinessandmarketingplan.
Determinationofthescope,size,anddirectionofyourloanfundshouldprovideagoodindicationoffeasibility.Sourcesofinitialcapitalaresecuredthroughfoundationandcorporategrantsand,insomeinstances,fromlocalgovernmentprograms,especiallyifthereisatargetedmarketwithtremendousneeds.
Financialinstitutionsoftenprovidecorporategrantsthatallowthemtopenetratemarketsbyeffectivelypartneringwithcommunityorganizationsthatrepresentandservethesecommunities.Asinallprogramproposals,makingthecase,presentingneed,andindicatinghowyourorganization’srolewillenhancetheeffortmustbemade.(SeeDevelopmentTipsattheendoftheGuide)
YourorganizationmustassesshowtheproposedprogramcostswillbenefittheoverallcommunityeconomicdevelopmentstrategyofthecommunityandorganizationwhileassessingimpactstoindividualCEDprojectsandprograms.Thecreationofaloanfundofferssubstantialbenefitstothecommunityanditseconomicwellbeing.
3. Pre‐developmentActivities:A. BusinessPlan/MarketAnalysis:Conductamarketanalysisanddevelopa
businessplanforthefund.B. ManagementPlan:
1.) FundManagement:Includedarethedocumentsthatdefinelendingparameters,lendingguidelines,requirementsandapplicationprocess.
2.) LoanManagement:Includedaretheloanmanagementfunctions(loanapprovalprocess,closing,documentationandloanmanagement(billing/collections)process).
3.) PortfolioManagement:Guidelinesandstandardsonriskmanagement(loanlosstolerance,reservesandriskratingofloans).
4. StartUpLendingActvities5. ApplicationforaCDFIcertification.Onceyoureceivecertificationyouareeligibleto
applyforaTechnicalAssistanceGrant(toconductorupgradeyourbusinessplan)orforaFinancialAssistanceAward(grantforyourloanpool).NOTE:YoucanapplyforaTechnicalAssistanceGranttostartaCDFIandloanpoolfromscratch,buttheseareinveryhighdemandandareverydifficulttoobtain.Themoreexperienceyouhavethegreaterthepossibilityofreceivingagrant.
Strategy2:Partnership:IfthereareotherCDFIsoperatinginyourarea(ornearby),youmaywanttoconsiderpartnershipsthatwillleveragetheirexpertisewithyourunderstandingoflocalneeds.ThisstrategyallowsyoutobuildcapacityandexpertiseandmaintainagoalofcreatingyourownloanfundandobtainCDFIcertificationatalaterdate.Someofthevariousstrategiesinclude:
1. ExpansionofServiceArea:Ifitispossible,anexistingCDFIcouldexpandtheircoverageareatoincludeyourgeography.Youcouldbecomeamarketingarmfortheirproducts
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 17
andservicesandpossiblyprovidespace,coordinatemeetingsorprovidelanguageservices.
2. CreationofaDedicatedFund:Ifthereissignificantinterestandresourcesincreatingafund,youmaywanttoconsidercreatingafundandhavingtheCDFIorneighboringloanfundmanagethefund.Therearesignificantongoingexpensesforoperationsandall“back‐room”operations(loanservicingandmanagement).Yourorganizationcouldparticipateindevelopingthelendingguidelinesandstandards,orpossiblybeontheloancommitteeforthefund.Thisintermediarystepallowsyoutogainexperiencethatwillallowyoutocreateyourownfund.
Thepartnershipstructureisimportantifyouareconsideringoperatingasmallloanfundorprovidesmallloans.Remember,themanagementandhandlingcostsforasmallloanisthesameasforlargerloans.Inaddition,thelargertheloanpool(andthegreatertheamountoffundsyouhaveout)generatesthemoreinterestincomeusedforoperationsandmanagement.Forthesesmallerpools,itmayfinanciallywisetohaveanotherinstitutionserviceandmanageyourloanfund.Forsmallerfundsanotherstrategytoloweroperatingcostsistopartnerwithotherorganizationsthatmighthandlemarketing,trainingandtechnicalassistance.SlightlyExperiencedLoanFund:Ifyourorganizationhassomeexperienceinlendingorwantstobuildalendingtrackrecord,youcanimmediatelyapplytobecomeaCertifiedDevelopmentEntity(CDE).AlthoughthedefinitionfocusesonNewMarketsTaxCredits,aCDE’sactivitiesmeetCDFIstandardsandprovideanestablishedcertifiedlendingtrackrecordfororganizations.AsaCDEyouwillbeabletoapplyforCDFIcertificationandaTechnicalAssistanceAward.TheprocesstobecomeaCDEisstraightforwardandrelativelysimple.
AsdefinedontheCDFIwebsite,“aCDEisadomesticcorporationorpartnershipthatisanintermediaryvehiclefortheprovisionofloans,investments,orfinancialcounselinginLow‐IncomeCommunities(LICs).BenefitsofbeingcertifiedasaCDEincludebeingabletoapplytotheCDFIFundtoreceiveaNewMarketsTaxCredit(NMTC)allocationtoofferitsinvestorsinexchangeforequityinvestmentsintheCDEand/oritssubsidiaries;ortoreceiveloansorinvestmentsfromotherCDEsthathavereceivedNMTCallocations.”9
TobecomecertifiedasaCDE,anorganizationmustsubmitaCDECertificationApplicationtotheFundforreview.Theapplicationmustdemonstratethattheapplicantmeetseachofthefollowingrequirementstobecomecertified:
• Bealegalentityatthetimeofapplication;• HaveaprimarymissionofservingLICs;and• MaintainaccountabilitytotheresidentsofistargetedLICs.
ExistingorExperiencedLoanFund:IfyouarecurrentlyoperatingaloanfundyouwillneedtosimplyapplytotheCDFIFundforcertification.Thecertificationprocessisstraightforward(checkatwww.CDFIfund.gov).Onceyoureceivecertification,youareeligibletoapplyforaTechnicalAssistanceAward(toallowyoutocreatethebusiness,marketingandmanagement
9 CDFI Fund Website, Op Cit
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 18
plans)foryourCDFI.YoucanalsoapplyforaFinancialAssistanceAwardthatprovidescapitalforyouneworexpandedloanfund.SummaryStepstoBecomingaCDFI:TogainCDFIdesignationthestepsarerelativelysimple.Theworkisintheplanningandapplicationprocess.Process:
1. TechnicalAssistancetodevelopingtheorganizationandprogramstructure2. ObtainCommunityDevelopmentEntity(CDE)designation3. Financingparticipation/partnership(strategytogainexperience)4. ApplicationforTechnicalAssistanceAwards5. DevelopingtheCDFIorganizationalandprogramstructure6. ApplyforCDFIstatus7. RequestforCDFIfunding8. Otherinvestmentsandmatches9. Makeloans10. Manageloans
DEVELOPMENTTIPS:Somekeydevelopmenttipstorememberinclude:1. Ifyouarestartinganewfund,dotheinitialinvestigativeresearchandconceptpaperto
determineiftheprojectisfeasible.Theconceptpaperwillalsobecomeyourbasetoolfortodiscusstheconcepttopotentialfundingandresourcepartnersandbecomesthebasisforyourbusinessplan.Asyougatherdatayourconceptpapershouldbecontinuallyupdatedandwillbecomethebasisofyourbusinessplan.
2. Insteadofstartingyourownfund,considerpartnershipstobringtheresourcetoyourcommunityortocreateaspecializedfundthatcanbemanagedbyanexistingCDFIorloanfund.Thismaybeanintermediarystepforyoutogainexperienceifyoulaterwanttocreateandmanageyourownfund.
3. BecomeaCommunityDevelopmentEntity(CDE)andgetCDFICertification.Thisisespeciallytrueifyourorganizationhasalendingprogram.
4. TheCDFIdesignationonlyallowsyoutoapplyforCDFIFundresourcesandtheyareverycompetitive.Itisimportanttobuildyourcapacityandtrackrecord.
5. Onceyougetadesignationmakesureconventionallendinginstitutionsarepartofyouplanning/developmentprocess.Enlistthemassupporters(onyourboard,advisoryboardorprojectcommittee).Remember,theconventionalfinancialmarketshaverealizedtheimportanceandsuccessesofCDFIsandseekCDFIstoplaceinvestments.
6. ManageExpenses:Managingyourincomeandexpensesisessentialforyourlongtermsurvival.
a. Partnershipswithotherrelatedlendingentitiesallowyoutoexpandyourmarketandcutdownonyourownexpensesintheareasofmarketing,loanprocessingandloanmanagement.
b. Loanlossesdecreasesthesizeofyourloanpoolandlowersyourpotentialincomec. Reservesimpactyourbusinesssuccess.Thesearefundssetasidethatdonot
generateincome.
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 19
d. Yourlendingguidelinesandapprovalsalsoimpactyoursuccess…thegreaterrisksyourfundincurs;thegreaterthepotentialisforlosses.
e. Theexpensesformarketing,processingandmanagingasmallloanarethesameasexpensesforalargerloan.
f. Partneringandsharingofloanmanagementandportfoliomanagementfunctionsareanexcellentmeansofmanagingandreducingexpenses.
g. Ifyoualreadyhaveloanprocessingandmanagementexperience,youmaywanttomarketthiscapacityandgenerateadditionalincomebymanagingfundsforpartnerorganizations.
7. AdditionalCapital:TheCDFIFinancialAssistanceAwardisagrantthatcanstartyourlendingprogram,butyoushouldlookatitasanopportunitytolocateadditionalmatchingfundstoexpandyourloanpool.
Itisimportanttodeterminewhointhemarketplacehasinterestinsupportingyourlendingactivities.
Yourboard,advisoryboardorprojectcommitteeshouldhavemembersthatrepresentfinancialinstitutions,localbusinessesandcorporations,andlocalgovernmentandcommunityleaders.Theycanbecomeyourspokesperson(s)andcanconvenemeetingswiththeirpeerstomarketinterestinyourfund.
Engagementanddiscussionswiththebankingregulators;FederalDepositInsuranceCorporation(FDIC),OfficeoftheComptrollerofCurrency(OCC)andFederalReserveBank(FRB)regardingyourfundisaveryimportantstep.Theseinstitutionscanbeanimportantresourceforknowingwhomightbeinterestedinsupportinglendingactivitiesorareinterestedinyourcommunity.Theyarealsoagreatresourceforconveningmeetingswithfinancialleaderstogenerateinterestinyourfund.
OTHERNOTES:ServiceGaps:OnecriticismofCDFIlendingprogramshasbeenthe“unevenlandscape”thatresultsingapsinservice.MosteffectiveCDFIsoperateinsmallgeographies(communities,citiesandcounties)whilelargerentitiesmightservestatesormulti‐stateareas.Afewmightbe“national”suchassomeofthelargerlendinginstitutions;howevertheymaynotserveallcommunitieswiththesamelendingproducts.DespitethenumberofCDFIoperatingacrossthecountry,therearemanyareasnotbeingservedbyanyCDFIormightbeservedbyoneswithouttheneededlendingproduct.ManyCDFIsserveonlyonesegmentoflendingactivitysuchasbusinesses,realestateorpersonal,resultinginnothavinganeededserviceinanygivenarea.ThisdoeshoweverpresentsanopportunityforaCDFItoexpandorforanewCDFItogrow,especiallyifthereissubstantialneedandinterestamongsttheresidentsandconstituencyaffectedbythelackofcapital.
FinalNote:
AlthoughbecomingaCDFIisanaturalstepforloanfunds,becomingaloanfundisnoteasyandrequiresastrongcommitmentfromtheorganizationandthemembersofthedevelopment
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 20
team.Thegoalcanbeaccomplishedwiththesupportofthecommunity,localgovernmentandinterestedfinancialinstitutions.Itismostimportanttohavestaffdedicatedtotheprojectandiftheydonothavetheexpertise,locateresourcestosupportandguidetheeffort.Thisdocumentisintendedtobeaguidethatoutlinessomeofthekeyissuesandidentifiespossiblesolutionsandsteps.Itisnotintendedtobeyoursourcesinceeveryprojecthasitsownissues,concernsandpeculiaritiesanditsownuniquesolutions.Thedocumentisnotintendedtoencourageanyorganizationintoprojectdevelopmentbutonlytolayoutsomeofthekeystepsandissuesoncethedecisionismadetoproceed.
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 21
APPENDIXA‐FORMOREINFORMATION:ResourcesWebsites:
OpportunityFinanceNetwork:(www.ofn.org)“OpportunityFinanceNetwork(OFN)isanationalnetworkofcommunitydevelopmentfinancialinstitutions(CDFIs)investinginopportunitiesthatbenefitlow‐income,low‐wealth,andotherdisadvantagedcommunitiesacrossAmerica.
OFNMembersareperformance‐oriented,responsibleinvestorsthatfinancecommunitybusinesses,sparkingjobgrowthintheareasthatneeditmost,anddeliveringbothsoundfinancialreturnsandrealchangesforpeopleandcommunities.
OurNetworkhasoriginatedmorethan$23.2billioninfinancinginurban,rural,andNativecommunitiesthrough2009.Withcumulativenetcharge‐offratesoflessthan1.4%,wehavedemonstratedourabilitytolendprudentlyandproductivelyinunconventionalmarketsoftenoverlookedbyconventionalfinancialinstitutions.”
CoalitionofCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions(CDFICoalition):(www.CDFI.org)“Formedin1992asanad‐hocpolicydevelopmentandadvocacyinitiative,theCoalitionofCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions(CDFICoalition)istheleadnationalorganizationintheUnitedStatespromotingtheworkofcommunitydevelopmentfinancialinstitutions(CDFIs).Throughitsmemberorganizations,theCoalitionrepresentsCDFIsworkinginall50statesandtheDistrictofColumbia.ThisnationalnetworkofCDFIsincludescommunitydevelopmentloanfunds,communitydevelopmentbanks,communitydevelopmentcreditunions,microenterpriselenders,communitydevelopmentcorporationsandcommunitydevelopmentventurecapitalfunds.TheCDFICoalitioncoordinatesindustrywideinitiativestoincreasetheavailabilityofcapital,creditandfinancialservicestolow‐incomecommunitiesacrossthenation.”
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutionsFund:(www.cdfifund.gov)“Throughmonetaryawardsandtheallocationoftaxcredits,theCDFIFundhelpspromoteaccesstocapitalandlocaleconomicgrowthinurbanandrurallow‐incomecommunitiesacrossthenation.
Throughitsvariousprograms,theCDFIFundenableslocallybasedorganizationstofurthergoalssuchas:economicdevelopment(jobcreation,businessdevelopment,andcommercialrealestatedevelopment);affordablehousing(housingdevelopmentandhomeownership);andcommunitydevelopmentfinancialservices(provisionofbasicbankingservicestounderservedcommunitiesandfinancialliteracytraining).
CaliforniaAssociationforMicroEnterpriseOpportunity(CAMEO):(www.microbiz.org)“CAMEO’smissionistopromoteeconomicopportunityandcommunitywell‐beingthroughMicroEnterprisedevelopment.
Ourmemberorganizationsprovideentrepreneurswithsmallbusinessfinancingsuchasloansandcredit,technicalassistanceandbusinessmanagementtraining.
AsCalifornia’sstatewideMicroEnterpriseassociation,CAMEOisthevoiceforMicroEnterpriseinCalifornia.Weexpandresourcesandbuildingcapacityforitsmemberorganizations–over
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 22
160lenders,trainingprograms,jobcreators,agenciesandindividualsdedicatedtofurtheringMicroEnterprisedevelopmentinCalifornia
NationalCommunityReinvestmentFund(CRF,USA):(www.crfusa.com):“CommunityReinvestmentFund,USA(CRF)helpschangethelivesofpeoplelivingineconomicallydistressedcommunitiesacrossthecountry.Wesupplycapitaltolocalcommunitydevelopmentlenderssotheycanmeetgoalslikethese:
• Growsmallbusinesses• Increaseaffordablehousing• Createandpreservejobs• Buildchildcarecenters• Developcommunityfacilities
Atthesametime,weenablefinancialinstitutions,socially‐motivatedinvestors,andaccreditedindividualstoreachtheirsocialinvestmentgoals.CRFoperatestheleadingnationalsecondarymarketforcommunityandeconomicdevelopmentloans—amarketCRFpioneered.Wepurchaseeconomicdevelopmentandaffordablehousingloansfromcommunitydevelopmentlenders.Wethenpoolthemintoasset‐backeddebtsecuritiesandNewMarketsTaxCredit(NMTC)investmentfunds,whichweprivatelyplacewithinstitutionalinvestors”FORMOREINFORMATION:Websites,OrganizationalExamplesNationalSpecializedFund:
LowIncomeInvestmentFund(LIIF):(www.liif.org):“LIIFisacommunitydevelopmentfinancialinstitution(CDFI)thatprovidesinnovativecapitalsolutionsthatsupporthealthyfamiliesandcommunities.AsaCDFI,LIIFinvestsinprojectsthathavehighsocialvaluebutmaynotbeabletoaccesstheservicesofferedbytraditionalfinancialinstitutions.Inthisway,LIIFconnectslowincomecommunitieswiththecapitalmarkets.LIIFoffersawiderangeofproducts,includingcommunitycapitalloans,NewMarketsTaxCredits,grantsandtechnicalassistance.LIIF’smission‐drivenapproachcombinedwithitsmarketandindustryknowledgehavedistinguisheditasaCDFIthatcreatesflexible,affordablefinancingsolutionsthatworkforcommunityorganizationsandinvestors.In2011,LIIFinvestedover$1.1Billion.”
NCBCapitalImpact(NCB,formerlytheNationalCoopBank):(www.ncbcapitalimpact.org)“AsanationalnonprofitorganizationandacertifiedCommunityDevelopmentFinanceInstitution,NCBCapitalImpactimprovesaccesstohigh‐qualityhealthandeldercare,healthyfoods,housing,andeducationinlow‐incomecommunities.Ourimpactisbuiltonadiverseandextensivenetworkofalliances,ourdepthofexperience,andacooperativeapproach.Wepartnerwithpublicandprivateorganizationsthatarelike‐mindedinmission,anddedicatedtolong‐termsuccess.NCBCapitalImpacthasdeployed$1.6Billioninloans,investmentsandassistance.”
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 23
RegionalCDFIs:
ClearinghouseCDFI:(www.clearinghousecdfi.com):“AtClearinghouseCDFIwebelieveinprovidingequalaccesstocreditinneighborhoodsofallincomelevelsandethnicities.Wespendthetimeandenergyrequiredtofindcreditworthyborrowerswhoseprojectscreateassetsinthecommunity.Theseborrowers,becauseoftheiruniquecircumstances,arerejectedornotevenconsideredbytraditionallenders.Communitydevelopmentlendingmustbeprofitableinordertobesustained.Aswithconventionallenders,wecarefullyevaluateeachapplicant’sabilitytorepaytheloan.Unliketraditionallenders,wedonothavepredefinedloanprograms.Weanalyzeeachloanapplicationindividually.Everyloanwemakebenefitsthecommunityinameasurableway.ClearinghouseCDFIisaCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutionservinglow‐incomecommunitiesandfamiliesthroughouttheStateofCalifornia.Throughourtwolinesofbusiness,CoreandNMTClending,wehavefunded$760millioninloansandequityinvestmentsinlow‐incomecommunities.Our1,232loanshaveassistedborrowerssuchasnonprofitsandothercommunitydevelopmentgroupstocreate3,005affordablehousingunits,enable846first‐timehomebuyers,create4,270constructionandpermanentjobs,andserve215,000clientsoflow‐incomecommunitiesannually.”
CoastalEnterprisesInc(CEI):(www.ceimaine.org)“CEIin2012isaMaine‐basedorganizationwithstrategicexpansionsoutsideofMaine,servingmoreruralcommunitiesdirectlyorthroughalliancesandhavinganevergreaterimpactonpoverty,whichisdocumentedwithdata.Theorganizationhasahighfinancialsustainabilityratio,thankstonewandexpandedsourcesoffundsthroughprivategiving,publicfunds,andincomefromfundsandventurecapital.CEIhasametricforlookingatthebalanceofthe3Es—economy,equityandenvironment—throughallinitiatives,andhasagroupinplacemeasuringimpact,scanningforopportunities,anddevelopingpolicy.”
CommunityBasedFunds:
FresnoCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitution(FCDFI):(www.fresnocdfi.org)“FresnoCDFIisacomprehensivefinancialservices,training,andassetdevelopmentinstitutionforlow‐andmoderate‐incomeresidentsandbusinesspersons.SinceourinceptioninMay2008,ourprofessional,seasoned,andmulti‐lingualstaff–experiencedinmicro‐finance,creditcounseling,businessplandevelopment,andadvocacyforlow‐incomefamilies–hashelpedhundredsofentrepreneursrealizetheirdreams.Weservea9‐countyregioninCentralCalifornia.”
PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServices:(www.peopleinc.net)“PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServiceswascreatedin2001toaddressbusinessdevelopmentfinancingneedsthroughoutVirginia.ThisPeopleIncorporatedaffiliateadministersthemicroenterprisedevelopmentandsmallbusinessfinancingactivitiesforPeopleIncorporatedAsaCommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutioncertifiedbytheU.S.DepartmentofTreasury,PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServicesoffersloans,developmentservicesandfinancialproducts
CommunityDevelopmentFinancialInstitutions 24
tosmallandemergingbusinesses.PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServicesworkstostrengthenlocaleconomiesin17‐jurisdictionserviceareas.
PeopleIncorporatedFinancialServiceshasextensiveexperienceprovidingsmallbusinessandmicroenterprisedevelopmentandlendingservicesinlow‐incomecommunities,andistheonlyCDFIheadquarteredinruralVirginia.Sinceitsinceptionin1992,thePeopleIncorporatedFinancialServicesloanportfoliohasgrowntoinclude308microenterpriseandbusinessloans,whichtodatehavecreated475jobsandretained180more.”