Community Currency Magazine April 2011

download Community Currency Magazine April 2011

of 33

Transcript of Community Currency Magazine April 2011

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    1/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    2/33

    Contents Credits

    Volunteer staff this issue:

    Editor:

    Production:

    Contributors:

    A word from the editor

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    3/33

    The Role of Time Banks

    in Crisis Response

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    4/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    5/33

    Madison, Wisconsin: Leading

    the fight for economic sanity

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    6/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    7/33

    BitCoin: a rube-goldberg

    machine for using

    electricity

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    8/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    9/33

    European co-op law for

    Hungary local vouchers

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    10/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    11/33

    Maia Maia for carbon

    emissions reductions!

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    12/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    13/33

    Financial Terrorism:

    15 years for Liberty

    Dollar founder

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    14/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    15/33

    Is it time

    for Time

    Banking?Sometimes introducing

    accounting to a functioning

    voluntary sphere can

    actually be counter

    productive. If the UK

    government is to support

    time banking, it must be

    sensitive when paying

    professionals to work

    alongside volunteers, says

    Alex Fox on

    alexfoxbog.wordpress.com

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    16/33

    Transition economics

    In a separate article, Nalini Sivathasan from the East London Times talked to some Time

    Bankers about the UK government's plans to build a 'Big Society'...

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    17/33

    The elevator-pitch for

    community currenciesby Eric Harris-Braun

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    18/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    19/33

    Transition economics

    Analyses of the financial crisis present us with a

    false dichotomy, argues Thomas Greco. We need

    to look deeper into the systemic issues inherent to

    the design of money.

    The world's ominous reckoning

    The reckoning will be

    global because the

    money and banking

    regime is global -- and

    deeply flawed.

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    20/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    21/33

    Stephen de MeulenaereFollowing on from the interview last issue with Bernard

    Lieter, we take a big picture look at challenges and

    opportunities in the complementary currency movement

    1. What are the questions

    you would most want to

    explore with fellow movers

    and shakers in the

    complementary currency

    movement?

    2. What recent developments

    in the field do you find most

    exciting?

    3. And what do you see askey challenges, obstacles or

    blind spots which hinder the

    movement's success?

    "All the different strands of

    the movement, like the grass

    roots efforts, academics, and

    entrepreneurs aren't

    communicating effectively

    enough. This is reducing the

    opportunities for productive

    synergies to appear"

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    22/33

    4. Where do you see

    untapped resources and

    unmet needs within the field

    of complementary

    currencies? And do you haveany suggestions about how

    to bridge them?

    5. Besides financial support,

    what would help the

    acceleration of the monetary

    shifts that are needed?

    6. What could bring about a

    tipping point in the shift from

    a monopoly of bank debt

    money toward a monetary

    ecology? And is the idea of a

    tipping point the best way

    of thinking about that

    change?

    7. There are those who feel

    we need to organize

    ourselves more efficiently

    (the way the Right has done

    in the United States), and

    those who suggest that there

    is strength in our natural

    diveristy or that networkedsystems organise

    themselves. Where do you

    stand on this question?

    8. A lot of valuable

    community-building

    initiatives in this movement

    are done by dedicated

    people, as a labor of love,

    but would often highly

    benefit from actual financial

    support. if you were given

    $10,000 to $50,000 to invest

    in strengthening the

    currency movement, how

    would you invest these

    funds?

    Actionables:

    1 explore closer relations with regional and local governments

    2. improve interaction between different actors in the movement

    3. Trust in diversity, as long as it is healthy

    "all the different roles

    have to be filled,

    academics, innovators,

    practitioners and

    promoters, financiers,

    and broadcasters"

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    23/33

    Exploring theSuperFluid

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    24/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    25/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    26/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    27/33

    International Journal of Community Currency Research 15 (2011) D 61-67 61

    Introduction

    Oneofthemostinterestingdevelopmentsin

    theUKcomplementarycurrencymovement

    overthepast4yearshasbeentheemergence

    oflocalpapercurrencyschemesinTransition

    towns.FollowingTotnesin2007,thetownsof

    Lewes,StroudandBrixtoninSouthLondon

    haveallsuccessfullylaunchedlocalpounds,

    theusageofwhichisrestrictedtoindependent

    businessesintheirrespectiveareas.Broadly

    speaking,thegoalofthecurrenciesistohelpre-localiseproductionandconsumptionand

    buildeconomicresilience,akeytenetofthe

    Transitionmovement.Thispapersetsthe

    Transitioncurrenciesincontextandreviews

    theirprogresssofar.1

    The Transition Network

    TheTransitionNetworkisaglobalgrassroots

    movementofcommunitiesseekingtocreate

    greaterlocalresilienceandwell-beinginthefaceofthetwinthreatsofclimatechangeand

    peakoil.Transitionthinkingdrawsinspiration

    frompermacultureandecologyasthebasisfor

    reimagininghowsettlementsandlocaleconomiesmightbeabletoadapttheshocks

    thesetwophenomenonwillinevitablycreate

    withoutcreatingmajorsocialandeconomic

    dislocation.Thenotionofresilienceiskeyto

    Transitionthinking,deMinedas:

    ...thecapacityofasystemtoabsorbdisturbance

    andreorganisewhileundergoingchange,soas

    tostillretainessentiallythesamefunction,

    structure,identityandfeedbacks(Walkeretal,

    2004)

    Tocreategreaterresilience,Transitionargues

    forthere-localisationofmanyaspectsof

    productionandconsumption,arguingthat

    lossesinnarrowlydeMinedefMicienciesofscale

    aremadeupforintermsofreduced

    vulnerabilitytoshocksbecauseofgreater

    diversity,justasinnature.Transitionalso

    involvescollectivelyimaginingadifferentlow-

    carbonfuturefortheareaandthecreationof

    anenergydescentplan(EDAP).

    TheTransitionmovementishighlydecentralisedandnon-hierarchicalinstructure

    andculture.Schemesarealmostallnot-for-

    proMitandmainlydependentonvolunteer

    Building Local Resilience:The Emergence of the UK TransitionCurrenciesJosh Ryan-Collins

    new economics foundation

    [email protected]

    InternationalJournal ofCommunityCurrency

    Research

    IJCCR

    Abstract

    ThispaperexaminestheemergenceofanewtypeoflocalcurrencyTransitionCurrencies-in

    theUnitedKingdomoverthepast4years.TheTransitionCurrencymodel,sharedbytheinitial

    fourschemes,isexplainedandthetheoreticalrootsoftheschemesreviewed.Thepapergoeson

    to examine the success and limitations of the currencies and reMlects on potential future

    developments andhowthe Transitioncurrenciesmightupscale anddeliveradditional social,

    economicandenvironmentalobjectives.

    www.ijccr.net

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    28/33

    International Journal of Community Currency Research 15 (2011) D 61-67 62

    labour.Theemphasisisverymuchopenactive

    localparticipationandidentity,positivity,

    innovation,creativityandcollectiveaction.

    Therearecurrentlyaround270active

    transitioncommunitiesacrosstheworld,

    mainlyinEnglish-speakingcountries.2

    Transition Local Currencies

    LocalComplementarycurrencieshaveemerged

    asinitiativesfromTransitioncommunities

    acrossEngland,normallyfromwithin

    transitiongroupsbusinessoreconomysub-

    groups.Threeofthetransitioncurrenciesare

    intownsinmoreruralareas- Totnesand

    StroudintheSouthWestofEnglandandLewes

    intheSouthEast.Thefourth,theBrixton

    Pound,isininner-cityLondon.Allfourofthe

    schemespreviouslyhadactiveLocalExchangeTradingSchemes(LETS)inthe1980sor1990s

    andinsomecasesthesameindividualswho

    runtheLETSschemesareinvolved.Thereare

    alsoanumberofnascentTransition

    currenciesintheplanningstages,includingin

    Bristol,CanterburyandCamden.Theschemes

    sharethefollowingbroadgoals:

    Toenhancelocaleconomicresiliencethrough

    encouragingmorelocalproductionand

    consumptionandlimitingtheleakageof

    moneyfromthelocaleconomy

    supportandprotectlocalindependent

    businesses3which:

    protectsjobsandlivelihoodsand

    maintainsthediversityandidentityof

    thelocalarea

    Createstrongerconnectionsbetweenlocal

    peopleandbusinesses,boostingsocial

    capitalandcohesion.

    Stimulatethinkinganddiscussionabouthow

    moneyworksandhowlocaleconomies

    functionandcouldbemademoresustainable

    Promotethearea,creatingprideforits

    citizens,asenseofindependenceand

    attractingtourists

    Encouragingaself-helpmodelofexchange

    andmutualsupport

    Reducecarbonemissionsthroughreducing

    thetransportationofproductsformlong

    distances.

    Thehardcurrencymodeladoptedbyallfour

    existingtransitioninitiativesisbroadlysimilar:

    Notesbacked1to1againstUKsterling,with

    aone-ortwo-yearvalidity

    Notesindenominationsof1,5,10(andin

    thecaseofBrixton20andLewes21)with

    multiplesecurityfeaturesandfeaturing

    attractiveandoriginaldesignsreMlectinglocal

    celebritiesorplaces

    Currencycanbeacceptedonlyby

    independent(broadlydeMined)local

    businessesin(part-)paymentforanygoods

    orservices

    Currencyissoldintocirculationvia

    selectedparticipatingbusinesses(Stroud

    chargesa3%purchasefeewhichisdonated

    tolocalcharities)orgivenaschange

    CurrencycanbeexchangedbackintoUK

    sterlingata1to1rateatselectedexchange

    points(Stroudonlyallowsregisteredtraders

    toredeemnotesandhasa5%redemption

    fee)

    Businessesareencouragedtoofferdiscounts

    whencustomersusethecurrencytopayfor

    goods,butattemptsbyTotnesandLewesto

    introduceacompulsorydiscountwere

    abandonedduetobusinessdissatisfaction.

    EachschemehasawebsiteandleaMletlisting

    allparticipatingbusinessesandinformation

    astohowtheschemeworks

    TheStroudPoundhasmodelleditselfmore

    closelyontheChiemgauercomplementary

    currencybasedinGermany(Gelleri,2009).It

    hasademurragefeatureonthenoterequiring

    userstopaya3%feeandhavethenote

    stampedeverysixmonthstomaintainitsvalue,

    theaimofwhichistofurtherincreasethe

    circulationofthenote.TheChiemgauerwas

    itselfinspiredbythewritingsofSilvioGesell

    andthehighlysuccessfulWorglcurrencythat

    helpedrebuildthetownofthesamenamein

    Austriainthe1930sduringtheGreat

    Depression(Gesell1958).

    Stroudalsochargesa5%redemptionfeeand

    anannualmembershipfeeforusersand

    IJCCRTheUKTran

    sitionCurrencies

    The emphasis is very muchopen active local participationand identity, positivity,innovation, creativity andcollective action.

    http://www.transitionnetwork.org/totnespound/homehttp://www.stroudpound.org.uk/http://www.thelewespound.org/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.chiemgauer.info/http://www.chiemgauer.info/http://www.chiemgauer.info/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.brixtonpound.org/http://www.thelewespound.org/http://www.thelewespound.org/http://www.stroudpound.org.uk/http://www.stroudpound.org.uk/http://www.transitionnetwork.org/totnespound/homehttp://www.transitionnetwork.org/totnespound/home
  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    29/33

    International Journal of Community Currency Research 15 (2011) D 61-67 63

    businesseswhojointheStroudPound

    cooperative,apercentageofwhichisdonated

    toalocalcharityoftheconsumerschoice.

    Noneoftheotherthreecurrenciesoperatefee

    basedmembershipschemes.BothBrixtonand

    Leweshaveamoreinformalmembership

    schemewithmembersreceivingamonthly

    newsletterupdatingthemonthelatestnews.Intermsoforganisationalstructure,Lewesand

    Brixtoncurrencygroupshavebothoptedfor

    theCommunityInterestCompany(CIC)limited

    byguaranteestatus.TheCICmodelisseento

    providesomeoftheadvantagesofboth

    charitableandlimitedcompanystatusasit

    allowsorganisationstoqualifyforcharitable

    donationsbutalsoallowsthemtomakea

    surplusaslongasthatsurplusisinvested

    solelyinthecommunity.TheCICmodelalso

    providesDirectorswithlimitedliability.Totnesstartedtheprocessofregisteringasan

    IndustrialandProvidentSocietybutraninto

    issueswiththeFinancialServicesAuthority.

    Stroud,againfollowingtheChiemgauer,isa

    cooperativeandmembersarechargedan

    annualfee.Noneoftheotherthreecurrencies

    operatefeebasedmembershipschemes.

    Theoretical Roots

    TheintellectualinspirationfortheTransitioncurrenciescanbefoundintheworkofauthors

    suchasBernardLietaerandRichard

    Douthwaite,whowroteontheneedforlocal

    currenciestosupportlocaleconomiesinthe

    faceofglobalisation(Douthwaite,1996;

    Douthwaite,2000;Lietaer,2001).Rob

    Hopkins,oneofthefoundersoftheTotnes

    Pound,wasinspiredbyatalkheheardby

    BernardLietaeraspartofashortcourseon

    TheFutureofoneyheldatSchumacher

    Collegein2006inTotnes,DevonwhereLietaerspeciMicallyreferencedtheU.S.Berkshareslocal

    currency.TheBerksharescurrency,basedin

    BerkshireinassachusettsintheU.S.was

    foundedin2006bytheEFSchumacherSociety,

    athink-tankpromotingecologicaleconomics.

    TheeconomicargumentsfortheTransition

    currenciesareoftenjustiMiedbyreferenceto

    theideaofthelocalmultiplier.Thisideais

    baseduponRichardKahns(andlaterKeynes)

    notionofthespendingmultipliereffectatthe

    nationalleveloftheeconomy,wherebyanincreaseingovernmentspending,iftranslated

    intohigherlevelsofconsumptionby

    individuals,canhaveaproportionatelygreater

    effectontotaloutputoraggregatedemand

    (Keynes1936;Hahn1931).Asthetransition

    currenciescannotbebanked,thereisgreater

    incentivetocirculatethemlocally,enhancing

    localdemandandcreatingamultipliereffect

    withinadeMinedlocalarea.

    WithintheUKtheconceptofthelocal

    multiplierhasbeendevelopedbynef(theneweconomicsfoundation),theLondon-based

    think-and-do-tankwhichhas,throughits

    researchandpublications,developedthe

    argumentthatlocaleconomiesasproneto

    leakagethroughtaxes,externalcontractors

    andthenon-localsupplychainsand

    shareholdersofnationalandinternational

    chainstores.(WardandLewis2002).In

    contrast,smallindependentshopsaremore

    likelytoemploylocalMirmsforthesekindof

    servicesandspendanyproMitslocally(Sacks2002).nefconductedastudyin2002which

    suggestedonlyaround10-12penceofevery

    poundspentinsupermarketchainsremained

    withinthelocaleconomy,whilstamorerecent

    studyoftheWestichiganEconomyintheU.S.

    concludedthatifresidentsoftheareawereto

    redirect10percentoftheirtotalspendingfrom

    chainstolocallyownedbusinesses,theresult

    wouldbe$140millioninneweconomic

    activityfortheregion,including1,600newjobs

    and$53millioninadditionalpayroll(Sacks,2002;CivicEconomics,2007).

    Followingthislineofargument,theTransition

    currenciescanbeseenaspromotingthe

    mediumofexchangefunctionofmoneyatthe

    expenseofthestoreofvaluefunction.The

    tensionbetweenthesuccessfulfulMilmentof

    thesetwofunctionsofmoneywithinasingle

    unitofaccount(thethirdfunction)iswidely

    seenamongstmonetarytheoristsasoneofthe

    maincausesofinstabilityinthemodernMiat-

    basedmonetarysystem(Dodd1994;Douthwaite1999).

    Key Challenges 5

    TheTransitioncurrenciesmajorsuccesssofar

    hasbeenasawareness-raisingtools.Theyhave

    generatedastonishingmediacoverageand

    capturedthepublicimaginationlocally,

    nationallyandinternationally.Nodoubtthe

    colourfulandhighlyoriginalnote-designhas

    playedamajorpartinthis.TheDirectorof

    BrixtonTownCentre,forexample,saidofthe

    BrixtonPoundthatithaddonemorefor

    Brixtonsreputationthananythingsincethe

    IJCCRTheUKTran

    sitionCurrencies

    http://www.berkshares.org/http://www.berkshares.org/http://www.berkshares.org/
  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    30/33

    Launch In Circulation 4 No. Businesses Population

    Totnes March 2007 c.5000 c.70 (2008) 8,000

    Lewes September 2008 (firstissue), July 2009, (2ndissue)

    c.15,000 (2nd

    issuance) c.130 16,000

    Stroud September 2009 4,329 37 20,000

    Brixton September 2009 30,000 140 65,000

    International Journal of Community Currency Research 15 (2011) D 61-67 64

    IJCCRTheUKTransition

    Currencies Table 1: Back round information on the Transition currencies an 2010

    lightingofElectricAvenuein1900.TheLondon

    BoroughofLambeth,whereBrixtonisbased,have

    estimatedthevalueoftheschemeintermsof

    positivemediacoveragetobearound100,000.Thereislittledoubtoftheimpacttheschemeshave

    hadintermsofcreatingasenseofcommunitypride

    anddiscussioninthefourareas.However,anumber

    ofchallengeshaveemergedfortheschemesandthe

    existing,UKsterling-backed,model.

    a) Incentives for consumers and businesses

    PerhapsthegreatestchallengefortheTransition

    currenciesisthattheexistingmodelisdependent,

    broadlyspeaking,uponnon-economicincentives.Asthecurrencyexchangesat1to1withUKsterlingand

    noneoftheschemeshavebeensuccessfulin

    implementingcompulsorydiscounts,consumers

    mainmotivationforusingthecurrencyisabeliefin

    theethicalprinciplesoftheinitiative.Thismay

    restricttheuseofthecurrencytothesmall

    proportionofthepopulationwhosharetheschemes

    values.Evenwiththispopulationgroup,thereisthe

    dangerofthenoveltyvaluewearingoffandthe

    inconvenienceofcarryingtwopapercurrencies(and

    ofusingapapercurrencyratherthanelectronicpaymentforlargerpurchases)outweighingthis

    ethicalmotivation.Accessingthecurrencyalso

    involvestwotransactionsinmostcases

    withdrawingUKsterlingfromamachineandthen

    purchasingthelocalcurrencyfromanissuingpoint.

    Lackofknowledgeaboutthelocationofissuing

    pointsisoftenquotedasareasonwhyusersdonot

    usetheTransitioncurrenciesmoreoften.

    Forbusinesses,themaineconomicincentivefor

    acceptingthecurrencyisthefreemarketingwhichit

    ishopedwillleadtoanincreaseinfootfall.However,

    ifthemainusersofthecurrencyarecustomerswho

    alreadyholdthevaluesadvocatedbythescheme,

    businessesmayfeeltheincreasedfootfalleffectis

    negligible.6

    Thecosttobusinessesofdealingwithtwocurrencies

    isalsoarguablygreaterthanforconsumers.

    Businessescannot,atpresent,bankthelocal

    currencies,hencetheymustspendthecurrencyon

    supplies,offeritaspaymenttostaff,giveitaschange

    oruseitpersonallyiftheyaretokeepitin

    circulation.Whilstthiscouldbeseenasadvantagein

    termsofthegoalsoftheschemetoencouragelocal

    circulationofmoney,someofthetransitionschemes

    havehadexperienceofbusinessesleavingthe

    schemebecausetheyareunabletospendthecurrencyand/orseechangingitbacktoUKsterling

    asa)acostandb)evidencethattheschemeisnot

    workingadequately.

    b) Social justice challenges

    Relatedtotheabove,therearequestionsastohow

    theTransitioncurrenciessupportpeopleor

    businessesfacingMinancialexclusionoreconomic

    hardship,anissuethathascometothesurface

    signiMicantlyinthepasttwoyearswiththerecession.

    Thehardcurrencymodeldoesnotcreateanykindof

    additionalliquiditysinceeverynotemustbe

    exchangedforUKsterlingandsofartheschemes

    havebeenunabletodevelopaloanmechanism.Nor

    doesitenableanyadditionaloralternativeformsof

    exchangeorexploitunderutilizedcapacitieswithin

    communities.Thiscontrasts,forexample,with

    currencieswhichhavenon-monetarybacking,such

    astime-backedcurrencysystems,whichareableto

    involvepeopleinexchangeswhoarecurrently

    excludedbythemarket.

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    31/33

    International Journal of Community Currency Research 15 (2011) D 61-67 65

    ThetransitionmodeldoescreateaUKsterling

    backingorassetequivalentinsizetothe

    amountsoldandexploitingthisinsomeway

    appearsasonepotentialwayofcreating

    additionalliquidity,e.g.throughaloworzero

    interestloanscheme.However,anykindof

    loanschemewouldrequiresigniMicant

    administrativeandMinancialinfrastructureandsofartheTransitionschemeshavebeenunable

    toMindwillingpartners,althoughbothhigh

    streetbanksandcreditunionshavebeen

    involvedindiscussionsaboutpotential

    collaboration.ThiscontrastswiththeUnited

    States,wheretheBerksharesmodelhasthe

    supportof5regionalbanksand12branches

    andtheChiemgauerinGermanywhichalsohas

    regionalbankingsupport.

    c) Financial sustainability

    TheTransitioncurrencies,aswiththeother

    transitioninitiatives,weresetupasnot-for-

    proMitschemesandhavebeendependent

    mainlyonunpaidlabourandoneoffdonations.

    Theyhavebeensuccessfulinattractingsmall

    Minancialorin-kindinvestmentsfromlocal

    councilsandbusinessestopayforevents,set-

    upcosts,marketingandprintingofthenotes.

    BothLewesandBrixtonweresuccessfulin

    raisingsponsorshipfundsfromlocal

    businessesinreturnforfeaturingtheir

    businesslogosprominentlyontheirmarketingmaterials.BrixtonandLeweshavealso

    recentlybeensuccessfulinattractingpart-time

    fundingforaprojectmanagerfrom,

    respectively,theLabourgovernmentsFuture

    JobsFund(nowdroppedbytheCoalition

    government)andfromaCharitableTrust.One

    wayinwhichmoneyhasbeenandwill

    continuetobegeneratedfortheschemesis

    throughleakage-unredeemednotesuponthe

    completionofthevalidityperiod.

    Nevertheless,volunteerfatigueremainsa

    majorchallengefortheTransitioncurrencies

    giventhedependenceonunpaidlabourfor

    muchofthepromotionalandbusiness

    engagementwork.Stroudistheonlyinitiative

    tohavebuiltintoitsmodelafacilityfor

    generatingfundingthroughmembershipand

    redemptionfeesbutatpresentthisdoesnot

    generateenoughfundingtopayforlabour

    time.

    d) Measurement and Evaluation

    Onemajordrawbackinusingpapernotesisit

    thatnotpossibletotrackhowthecurrencyis

    beingusedandhowmanynotesareactuallyin

    circulation.Theschemeshavethusbeen

    reliantonsimplebalanceofaccountsMigureson

    issuanceandredemptionandadhocand

    anecdotalfeedbackfrombusinessesand

    consumersaboutactualusage.Thereisasuspicionthataconsiderableproportionofthe

    notessoldarefornovelty/souvenirpurposes

    ratherthanpurposesofnormalexchange.

    Evidenceforthiscomesfrombothaslowdown

    inissuanceafteraninitialhoneymoonperiod

    andthenon-redemptionpercentageforLewes

    followingthe1-yearpilot(admittedlyfeaturing

    just1issuance)whichwasover50%.In

    termsofattractingfurtherpublicorcharitable

    sectorfunding,evidenceofimpactwillbe

    importantfortheschemes.

    e) Under-developed bankinginfrastructure and support

    TheTransitioncurrenciesintheUKhave

    struggledtoMindsupportfromeitherthe

    mainstreamcommercialbankingorcommunity

    Minancesectors.ThisplacessigniMicant

    additionalburdenonthevolunteersinvolvedto

    carryoutadministration,reconciliationand

    accountingfunctions.Italsolimitsthe

    potentialofdevelopinglocalcurrencybank

    accountfacilitiesorloaninitiatives,bothof

    whichmightbewelcomedbythesmall

    businessessigneduptheschemes,manyof

    whomstruggletoaccesscreditfrom

    commercialbanks.

    ItmaybethattheUKsbankingsystem,which

    hasseenthegradualdisappearanceoflocaland

    regionalbanksandareductioninbranches

    followingtheMinancialderegulationofthe1980sand1990s(LeyshonandSignoretta

    IJCCRTheUKTran

    sitionCurrencies

    volunteer fatigue remains a majorchallenge for the Transition currenciesgiven the dependence on unpaid labourfor much of the promotional andbusiness engagement work

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    32/33

  • 8/7/2019 Community Currency Magazine April 2011

    33/33

    IJCCRTheUKTran

    sitionCurrencies Endnotes

    1FurtherinformationabouttheemergenceoftheTransition

    CurrenciescanbefoundinPeteNorthsrecentbook,Local

    oney,publishedbytheTransitionnetworkinJune2010.

    2FormoreinformationonthehistoryandaimsofTransition,

    see:http://transitiontowns.organdRobHopkinsbook,The

    TransitionHandbook:fromoildependencytolocalresilience,

    (GreenBooks2008).

    3AccordingtotheFederationofSmallBusinesses,2000local

    shopsareclosingeachyearseeTradeLocalanifesto,http://

    www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocal.Despite

    this,smallbusinessesaccountforthemajorityofprivatesector

    jobsintheUK:59.2%in2007,around13.5millionjobsoverall

    4N.b.thisMigureistheamountofcurrencyactuallyincirculation

    ratherthanthetotalamountofnotesissued.

    5Itshouldbenotedthataccuratedataontheimpactof

    TransitionCurrenciesislimitedastherehasbeenveryfew

    robustempiricalstudiesoftheschemes.6ArecentstudyoftheLewesPoundfoundthat70%oftraders

    felttheschemehadmadelittledifferencetofootfall.See

    Graugard,J,(2009)Amixed-methodcasestudyoftheLewes

    Poundanditscapacitytobuildresilienceinthecommunityof

    Lewes,unpublishedAthesis,UniversityofEastAnglia.

    7The-pesaschemeinKenyaallowsMinancialpaymentsusing

    mobilephonesandhashelpedrevolutionizethefarmingtrade.

    Seehttp://www.safaricom.co.ke/index.php?id=745

    References

    CivicEconomics(2007)TheSanFranciscoRetailDiversity

    Study,http://www.civiceconomics.com/SF[accessed16th

    April2009]

    Dodd,N.B.,1994,TheSociologyofoney,Cambridge:Polity;

    Douthwaite(1999)TheEcologyofoney,Totnes:GreenBooks

    Douthwaite,R.,(1996)ShortCircuit:StrengtheningLocaleconomiesforsecurityinanunstableworld,Totnes:Green

    Books;

    Douthwaite,R.,(1999)TheEcologyofoney,Totnes:Green

    Books

    Gelleri,C.,ChiemgauerRegiomoney:TheoryandPracticeofa

    LocalCurrency,InternationalJournalofCommunityCurrency

    Research,Vol13(2009)pp.61-75

    Gesell,Silvio.TheNaturalEconomicOrder,Revisededition.

    London:PeterOwen,1958.

    Kahn,R.F.,Therelationofhomeinvestmenttounemployment,TheEconomicJournal,June1931,Vol.41,No.162(Jun.,1931),

    pp.173-198

    Keynes,J.,[1936](2008)TheGeneralTheoryofEmployment,

    Interestandoney,BNPublishing

    Leyshon,A.andSignoretta,P.(2008)Allgonenow:thematerial,

    discursiveandpoliticalerasureofbankandbuildingsociety

    branchesinBritain.Antipode,40:79101.

    Lietaer,B.,(2001)TheFutureofoney:CreatingNewWealth,

    WorkandaWiserWorld,London:Century

    Sacks,J,(2002)TheoneyTrail,Appendix5,London:nef(the

    neweconomicsfoundation),pp114-117,accessibleathttp://

    www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20oney

    %20Trail.pdf

    Stodder,J,(2005)ReciprocalExchangeNetworks:Implications

    formacroeconomicstability

    TransitionBristol,(2010)ABristolPoundfortheCityandthe

    Southwest,availableatwww.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/

    document1002_5_1051.pdf[accessed22ndJune2010]

    Walker,B,Hollinger,C.S,Carpenter,S.R.&Kinzig,A.(2004)

    Resilience,AdaptabilityandTransformabilityinSocial

    ecologicalsystems.EcologyandSociety9(2)p5.

    Ward,B,andLewis,J.,(2002)PluggingtheLeaks:makingthe

    mostofeverypoundthatentersyourlocaleconomy,nef(new

    economicsfoundation

    http://transitiontowns.org/http://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://www.safaricom.co.ke/index.php?id=745http://www.civiceconomics.com/SFhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.agoraspace.org/document/pdf/document1002_5_1051.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.neweconomics.org/gen/uploads/The%20Money%20Trail.pdfhttp://www.civiceconomics.com/SFhttp://www.civiceconomics.com/SFhttp://www.safaricom.co.ke/index.php?id=745http://www.safaricom.co.ke/index.php?id=745http://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://www.fsb.org.uk/default.aspx?id=0&loc=keeptradelocalhttp://transitiontowns.org/http://transitiontowns.org/