Comment

1
157 Practice Development in Health Care, 3(3) 157, 2004 © Whurr Publishers Ltd Comment Absolutely critical to the development of health care practice is an understanding of the context in which a development is to take place. Indeed, it is this dependence on context that very often differentiates practice development and its associated research from purer forms of research. Some forms of research, such as trials, seek very purpose- fully to eliminate any context so that the claim that an outcome is as a result of a clear-cut intervention is stronger. But for some forms of interventions, for some client groups, for some health care problems, the context is all-important and to strip it away is to fail to recognize the complexity of the issue. The focus of the paper that is featured in this section is a classic example – young men and suicide: a complex social problem with hard-to-define causal links. And this paper adopts a very creative approach to tackling the research. Instead of rejecting the context, it is embraced, and through action research it is the context that is under examination. There is of course a need for all sorts of research – it all depends on what question you are asking – but to ask questions that depend on embracing the context of the issue will allow us to identify solutions with which we are able to engage and feed into developing practice with confidence. Charlotte Clarke Associate Editor ? Research and review

Transcript of Comment

Page 1: Comment

157Practice Development in Health Care, 3(3) 157, 2004 © Whurr Publishers Ltd

CommentAbsolutely critical to the development of health care practice is an understanding ofthe context in which a development is to take place. Indeed, it is this dependence oncontext that very often differentiates practice development and its associated researchfrom purer forms of research. Some forms of research, such as trials, seek very purpose-fully to eliminate any context so that the claim that an outcome is as a result of aclear-cut intervention is stronger. But for some forms of interventions, for some clientgroups, for some health care problems, the context is all-important and to strip it awayis to fail to recognize the complexity of the issue. The focus of the paper that is featuredin this section is a classic example – young men and suicide: a complex social problemwith hard-to-define causal links. And this paper adopts a very creative approach totackling the research. Instead of rejecting the context, it is embraced, and throughaction research it is the context that is under examination. There is of course a needfor all sorts of research – it all depends on what question you are asking – but to askquestions that depend on embracing the context of the issue will allow us to identifysolutions with which we are able to engage and feed into developing practice withconfidence.

Charlotte ClarkeAssociate Editor

?Research and review

3(3) 8/25/04 1:39 AM Page 157