CL Paper

download CL Paper

of 8

Transcript of CL Paper

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    1/8

    Julia Weeks

    Professor Martinez

    Communication and Leadership

    24 April. 2012

    Mother Teresa

    Let us touch the dying, the poor, the lonely and the unwanted according to the graces we

    have received and let us not be ashamed or slow to do the humble work (Mother Teresa of

    Calcutta). These are words spoken from a woman who came from nothing, but from her work,

    dedication, and vigor for life came everything. Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu, commonly known as

    Mother Teresa, is a true example of a leader that exemplifies every characteristic of a

    transformational/charismatic and servant type leader. Transformational leadership, according to

    Peter G. Northouse, author of the bookLeadership Theory and Practice is defined as a process

    that changes and transforms people. It is concerned with emotions, values, ethics, standards, and

    long-term goals. It includes assessing followers motives, satisfying their needs, and treating

    them as full human beings (171). Servant leadership is directly related to transformational

    leadership and both styles are intertwined; however, there are a few differences. Sunita Mehta,

    author of the articleRevisiting Servant Leadership: An Empirical Study in Indian Contextsheds

    light on servant leadership:

    Servant leadership is all about putting ones ego, needs, desires, and status aside to

    initiate a change process that will transform the followers into individuals who are

    willing to serve others and the organization in turn. Very few people are able to walk the

    talk to serve others before leading, which is the very crux of servant leadership (25).

    Mother Teresas ability to bring about change from within each person, touch the lives of

    Weeks 1

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    2/8

    millions of people, and acquire a following of individuals that strive to emulate her love, care,

    and compassion in order to better others, provides direct evidence of her ability to lead

    effectively. Through various examples of the way in which Mother Teresa applies leadership,

    numerous good-works, and the use of scholarly resources, the reader is able to view Mother

    Teresa as a servant and transformational type leader.

    Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu was born on August 26th 1910, in Skopje Macedonia and is of

    Albanian decent. At the young age of 12, Agnes felt Gods presence in her life and a strong

    calling do His will. Due to this calling, Agnes left home at the age of 18 and joined the Sisters

    of Loreto. Sisters of Loreto is an Irish community of nuns with missions in India, which

    therefore, set the stage for her mission work in India and around the world. On May 24th, 1931,

    Mother Teresa took her final vows as a nun and began to teach school at St. Marys High School

    and live in Calcutta, India. Though Mother Teresa received great satisfaction from teaching, she

    felt as though she was called to do more. The suffering and poverty she glimpsed outside the

    convent walls made such a deep impression on her that in 1948 she received permission from her

    superiors to leave the convent school and devote herself to working among the poorest of the

    poor in the slums of Calcutta (http://www.nobelprize.org).

    Mother Teresas desire to do more for those in need is intrinsic and comes deep from

    within. Many individuals have the want to help others, however, not all individuals are willing to

    drop everything and put their all into creating change. Though she did not have monetary means,

    she relied on Divine Providence and created an opened air school for poor children. Soon after,

    Mother Teresa gained a great amount of volunteers and funds began to make their way. With this

    help, she was able to expand the scope of her work/charity. Finally on October 7th, 1950, Mother

    Teresa gained permission to start her own order, The Missionaries of Charity. The

    Weeks 2

    http://www.nobelprize.org/http://www.nobelprize.org/
  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    3/8

    Missionaries of Charity focused on providing care and love to those who had no one to look

    after them. In 1965, The Missionaries of Charity became an International Religious Family,

    which was granted by Pope Paul VI. This is what separates Mother Teresa from others; she puts

    her thoughts, cares, and concerns into action. Although she did not have the monetary means to

    create speedy change, she utilized what she could in order to give all that she had. Mother

    Teresas story sheds light on the ways in which she exemplifies transformational and servant

    type leadership style. John Valk, author of the articleLeadership For Transformation: The

    Impact Of a Christian Worldview provides the reader with the basis of transformational

    leadership from a Christian persepective:

    Leadership for transformation links humans becoming to the divine purpose by giving

    artful expression to the divine and the human; by creatively unfolding human potential;

    by striving for peace, justice, security, and right relationships; by acting locally, thinking

    globally, and by being steward of the earth and resources contained in it (84).

    This quote is a direct representation of Mother Teresa. Early in her life she felt a divine calling

    to give more, a calling to give more to God and humanity, which Valk says is one of the key

    components of a transformational leader. Moreover, Mother Teresas main goal as a leader was

    to ensure that peace, stewardship, and mainly relationships were built between all people. The

    change she wanted to create began on a local level; however, through her ministry she touched

    the lives of many. The people that Mother Teresa came into contact with spread her message of

    love and charity, and therefore strove to emulate her. However, in order to be a leader in which

    others truly strive to follow, it takes a certain kind person to achieve this. Not all individuals are

    capable of the type of transformational leadership that Valk discusses in his article. Moreover,

    Weeks 3

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    4/8

    not all transformational leaders care for the well being of others.

    There are many leaders, known and unknown throughout history, however not all of

    these individuals have been able to obtain their goals throughout the course of their leadership.

    Moreover, there are leaders that were considered to be transformational but these leaders had no

    regard for humanity, i.e. Adolf Hitler, Mussolini, and Stalin. These leaders, though evil and cruel

    as they are, are transformational leaders. Northouse, provides evidence of this: Because of the

    conceptualization of transformational leadership set forth by Burns (1987) includes raising the

    level of morality in others, it is difficult to use this term when describing leaders such as Adolf

    Hitler and Sadam Hussein, who were transforming in a negative way (173). Though these men

    were transformational in their leadership, they had no morals or regard for human life or dignity.

    In order to solve this issue, the term pseudotransformational leadership was created, and

    therefore Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, and Hussein hold merit in this category.

    Pseudotransformational leadership is referred to as a leader that is self obsessed, power-

    hungry, unethical, and having a warped sense of morals. Leaders that fall under the

    pseudotransformational category focus on their own self-interest and gain, as opposed to the

    interest and well being of others. Because of this, many individuals do not strive to emulate

    these leaders, due to their immoral/unethical nature. Mother Teresas ability to lead with

    compassion and a genuine heart is the sole reason why she had so much power, which led to

    many followers. Not all leaders are able to achieve the worldwide recognition as Mother Teresa

    did. Since Mother Teresa cared about humanity and the bond that ties individuals together, she

    became a true example, an example in which many wanted to emulate and follow. She is a direct

    representation of a transformational leader. Valk sheds further light on the idea of a

    transformational leader, by discussing a leaders duty to humanity:

    Weeks 4

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    5/8

    Humans are not individuals socially isolated from one another. They form communities

    large and small that bind people together. Membership in a community comes with

    benefits and securities, but also with recognition and obligations. It entails not only

    taking, but also giving back, and as such leadership that is transformative recognizes

    citizen responsibilities and obligations at a variety of levels (84).

    Mother Teresa viewed each individual as interconnected with one another and therefore, those

    that sought to help with her with her mission and charities had to realize that they were all one in

    the same. Moreover, in regard to what Valk has said, transformational leaders require a lot out of

    those that strive help. For example, many are asked to take a vow of poverty in order to relate to

    those they are helping, many leave their families, their homes, and livelihoods to fully be

    immersed in helping others. Mother Teresa truly rid herself of all materialistic goods and

    received many benefits from helping others. All that she gave up, she received back by helping

    others. Mother Teresa put much responsibility on others; she expected a lot from those that had

    much to give. Through this example, the reader is able to view Mother Teresa as a truly

    transformational leader. Valk continues to shed light on the way in which Mother Teresa

    exemplifies transformational style leadership, by relating leadership for transformation to the

    Serenity Prayer, the serenity to accept the things that cannot be changed, the courage to change

    the things that can be changed, and the wisdom to know the difference (Reinhold Niebuhr).

    Mother Teresa knew that there were some goals she would be unable to change or accomplish,

    but with the courage and vigor for life that she possessed she was able to achieve all that was

    achievable through God and his endless love and mercy.

    In relation to Valks article and his perspective on transformational leadership, is

    Weeks 5

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    6/8

    transformational leadership and charisma. Those that are charismatic leaders behave in

    distinctive ways that have exact charismatic effects on their devotees. Northouse sheds light on

    characteristics of transformational charismatic leader behavior, charismatic leaders also

    demonstrate specific types of behaviors. First they are strong role models for the beliefs and

    values they want their followers to adopt (174). Mother Teresa is a direct example of a leader

    that encourages and shares beliefs and values with others. Sharing their beliefs and values to the

    point that their followers adopt their beliefs, provides further evidence of her transformational

    charismatic leadership style. Northouse goes on to say that those that are charismatic leaders

    have great confidence in the abilities of their followers to meet their goals and expectations.

    Robert House, a scholar in the communication field sheds further light on Northouses

    explanation, by introducing charismatic theory; the basis behind transformational leadership and

    charisma. House suggests that several effects are the result of charismatic leadership:

    They include follower trust in the leaders ideology, similarity between the followers

    beliefs and the leaders beliefs, unquestioning acceptance of the leader, expression of

    affection toward the leader, follower obedience, identification with the leader, emotional

    involvement with the leaders goals (175).

    It is no question that Mother Teresas ideologies matched up with those of her followers. Mother

    Teresa gained followers from all walks of life, backgrounds, and beliefs. Many of her followers

    were of the Christian faith and particularly the Catholic denomination. Catholics adore Mother

    Teresa, her devotion to God, her works, and her kindness. Even those that are not of the

    Christian faith or of no faith at all respect and admire her humanitarian works and goal for peace

    and unity. Not only is there a deep affection for her, but there is also a sense of willingness to

    Weeks 6

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    7/8

    please her. The main reasoning behind Mother Teresas success as a leader is her ability to relate

    to those she helps. Mother Teresa came from nothing and the little she had she gave away. She

    may have been poor material wise, but she was rich spiritually. Another way in which Mother

    Teresa was able to relate to her followers was through her struggle with her faith. Though a

    devout Catholic, she often felt very far away from God. It said that she often doubted Gods

    existence and many times she felt unworthy of Gods love and mercy. Though she struggled with

    her faith, she continued to pray and never stopped believing. Many people endure the same trials

    with their faith, as she did. Mother Teresas faith provided hope for those encountering the same

    kind of doubt. There is much to say when a leader is able to gain a diverse number of followers.

    In most cases, there are individuals that do not agree with the leader, and therefore harsh

    judgment and critique is placed on the leader, i.e. Martin Luther King, who was an amazing

    transformational and charismatic leader, but there were those that did not agree. When

    conducting research on Mother Teresa, however, there were close to zero negative opinions of

    her. Through her ability to relate to those she serves, the extreme devotion she gained, Mother

    Teresa truly transformed others.

    Sangeeta Parameshwar, author of the articleInventing Higher Purpose through suffering:

    The transformation of the transformational leaderprovides further insight into Mother Teresa as

    a transformational leader by linking transformational style leadership to a higher phenomenon.

    Parameshwar goes on to explain:

    the development of their higher purpose is elucidated by four propositions that

    demonstrate how the leaders awakened from entranced consciousness by (a) reframing

    personal suffering in the light of perceived eternal truths (b) referencing inspiring

    standards of others in reflecting upon suffering (c) reinforcing their identification with

    Weeks 7

  • 7/30/2019 CL Paper

    8/8

    others in suffering (d) reorienting themselves toward serving others (455).

    Weeks 8