Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385...

55
Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 1 of 55 12/29/2015

Transcript of Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385...

Page 1: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 1 of 55

12/29/2015

Page 2: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 2 of 55

Page 3: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 3 of 55

Page 4: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 4 of 55

Page 5: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 5 of 55

Page 6: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 6 of 55

Page 7: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 7 of 55

Page 8: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 8 of 55

Page 9: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 9 of 55

Page 10: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 10 of 55

Page 11: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 11 of 55

Page 12: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 12 of 55

Page 13: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 13 of 55

Page 14: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 14 of 55

Page 15: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 15 of 55

Page 16: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 16 of 55

Page 17: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 17 of 55

Page 18: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 18 of 55

Page 19: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 19 of 55

Page 20: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 20 of 55

Page 21: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 21 of 55

Page 22: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 22 of 55

Page 23: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 23 of 55

Page 24: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 24 of 55

Page 25: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 25 of 55

Page 26: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 26 of 55

Page 27: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 27 of 55

Page 28: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 28 of 55

Page 29: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 29 of 55

Page 30: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 30 of 55

Page 31: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 31 of 55

Page 32: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 32 of 55

Page 33: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 33 of 55

Page 34: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 34 of 55

Page 35: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 35 of 55

Page 36: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 36 of 55

Page 37: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 37 of 55

Page 38: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 38 of 55

Page 39: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 39 of 55

Page 40: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 40 of 55

Page 41: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 41 of 55

Page 42: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 42 of 55

Page 43: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 43 of 55

Page 44: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 44 of 55

Page 45: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 45 of 55

Page 46: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 46 of 55

Page 47: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 47 of 55

Page 48: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 48 of 55

Page 49: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 49 of 55

Page 50: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 50 of 55

Page 51: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 51 of 55

Page 52: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 52 of 55

Page 53: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 53 of 55

Page 54: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55

Page 55: Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page …...Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 54 of 55. V. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons and as set forth

V. Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons and as set forth above, the

motions for class certification, appointment as Class

Representatives, and appointment of Class Counsel are granted.

In light of the confidentiality stipulation and order

entered in this case, the parties are directed to jointly submit

a redacted version of this opinion to be filed publicly.

It is so ordered.

New York, NY December J / , 2015

U.S.D.J.

55

Case 1:12-md-02389-RWS Document 385 Filed 12/29/15 Page 55 of 55