Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute...

72
1 1 Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment Canada Canada - - wide Strategy for the wide Strategy for the Management of Management of Municipal Wastewater Effluent Municipal Wastewater Effluent Fall/Winter 2006/07 Consultation

Transcript of Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute...

Page 1: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

11

Canadian Council of Ministers of the EnvironmentCanadian Council of Ministers of the Environment

CanadaCanada--wide Strategy for thewide Strategy for theManagement of Management of

Municipal Wastewater EffluentMunicipal Wastewater Effluent

Fall/Winter 2006/07Consultation

Page 2: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

22

Consultation documentsConsultation documentsDocument for consultation Document for consultation

Options for a CanadaOptions for a Canada--wide Strategy for wide Strategy for Managing Municipal Wastewater Effluent (with Managing Municipal Wastewater Effluent (with appendices)appendices)

Background informationBackground informationMWWE background paperMWWE background paperSupporting documents Supporting documents

All documents will be posted to CCME website All documents will be posted to CCME website at at www.ccme.cawww.ccme.ca..

Page 3: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

33

Goals and Overview of the CCME Goals and Overview of the CCME CanadaCanada--wide strategy for the management wide strategy for the management of municipal wastewater effluentsof municipal wastewater effluentsEnvironmental Risk Management ModelEnvironmental Risk Management ModelScience and ResearchScience and ResearchGovernanceGovernanceImplementation & TimelinesImplementation & TimelinesEconomic ImplicationsEconomic ImplicationsNext StepsNext Steps

Presentation overviewPresentation overview

Page 4: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

44

Goals of the strategyGoals of the strategy

Municipalities will have certainty and Municipalities will have certainty and clarity in how municipal wastewater clarity in how municipal wastewater effluents are managed and regulatedeffluents are managed and regulatedHuman and environmental health Human and environmental health protection will be improvedprotection will be improvedFinancing to improve treatment of Financing to improve treatment of municipal wastewater effluent will be municipal wastewater effluent will be distributed in an equitable and sustainable distributed in an equitable and sustainable manner manner

Page 5: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

55

Wastewater discharged to surface water, Wastewater discharged to surface water, including marine, from a municipal or including marine, from a municipal or community wastewater collection or community wastewater collection or treatment facilitytreatment facilityConsists of endConsists of end--ofof--pipe discharges and pipe discharges and overflows, including combined sewer and overflows, including combined sewer and sanitary sewer overflowssanitary sewer overflowsBiosolids, separate stormwater discharges Biosolids, separate stormwater discharges or septic tank discharges to infiltration or septic tank discharges to infiltration facilities are not includedfacilities are not included

Defining wastewater Defining wastewater

Page 6: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

66

Generic wastewater frameworkGeneric wastewater framework

Air

Effluent

Solid

Atmosphere

Surface Water

Land

Re-use

Release Receiving Environment

TreatmentCollectionInfluentProducts & Pre-disposal

Sources

Page 7: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

77

CanadaCanada--wide strategywide strategy

Performance•National Performance Standards•Site-specific standards

Harmonised Regulatory Framework•Certainty & clarity to rules for owners/operators•One-window reporting

Implementation •New/upgraded systems are designed to meet standards at time of commissioning• Existing systems to meet standards over time based on risk-based priorities

Economic Implications•Economic implementation plan supports implementation of strategy

Science and Research•Research priorities established and coordinated through national committee

Page 8: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

88

Environmental Risk Environmental Risk ManagementManagement

Page 9: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

99

National performance standards (NPS)National performance standards (NPS)Environmental riskEnvironmental risk--based approach based approach Preliminary Risk Assessment (PRA)Preliminary Risk Assessment (PRA)Environmental risk assessment (ERA)Environmental risk assessment (ERA)Monitoring requirementsMonitoring requirementsOverflowsOverflows

OverviewOverview

Page 10: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1010

Environmental RiskEnvironmental Risk--Based Approach Based Approach –– EffluentEffluent

Wastewater Treatment:Opportunities for

reduction?

EnvironmentalRisk

Assessment

NoYes

RiskManagement

Decisions

Effluent Discharge Objectives

Effluent Discharge

Effluent Discharge meets National Performance Standards

No

Yes

NationalPerformance

Standards

Effluent Discharge meets Effluent Discharge

Objectives

Reduction at source:Opportunities for

reduction?

Page 11: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1111

National Performance StandardsNational Performance StandardsApply to all facilities, with some proposed Apply to all facilities, with some proposed regulated exceptionsregulated exceptionsEndEnd--ofof--pipe, as periodic averagespipe, as periodic averagesCBODCBOD55 –– 25 mg/L25 mg/LTSS TSS –– 25 mg/L25 mg/LTRC TRC –– 0.02 mg/L0.02 mg/L

Note that National Performance Standards are Note that National Performance Standards are minimum requirements and provincial minimum requirements and provincial requirements may be more stringentrequirements may be more stringent

Page 12: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1212

Wastewater facility size categoriesWastewater facility size categories

> 100,000> 100,000>50,000>50,000Very largeVery large

>35,000 >35,000 –– 100,000100,000>17,500 >17,500 –– 50,00050,000LargeLarge

>5,000 >5,000 –– 35,00035,000> 2,500 > 2,500 –– 17,50017,500MediumMedium

>1,000 >1,000 –– 5,0005,000> 500 > 500 –– 2,5002,500SmallSmall

≤≤ 1,0001,000≤≤ 500500Very smallVery small

Estimated Estimated PopulationPopulation

Flow (m3/day)Flow (m3/day)Wastewater Wastewater facility sizefacility size

Very small and small wastewater facilities which have industrial input associated with municipal wastewater effluent flows are considered as medium wastewater facilities

Page 13: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1313

CanadaCanada’’s far norths far northAddresses extreme climatic conditionsAddresses extreme climatic conditionsInterim measures are proposedInterim measures are proposed

A riskA risk--based approach will continue to be used based approach will continue to be used The standards in use in current permits in the far north The standards in use in current permits in the far north will be retained will be retained Further research will be conducted within the next five Further research will be conducted within the next five years years

•• identify the factors that affect performance of lagoons and identify the factors that affect performance of lagoons and wetlands in northern conditionswetlands in northern conditions

•• how lagoons and wetlands can be improved.how lagoons and wetlands can be improved.Once adequate information is available, National Once adequate information is available, National Performance Standards for northern conditions will be Performance Standards for northern conditions will be developed within 5 yearsdeveloped within 5 years

Page 14: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1414

Options for proposed exceptionsOptions for proposed exceptions

Existing discharges from very small Existing discharges from very small wastewater facilities, discharges with a wastewater facilities, discharges with a maximum of 50 mg/L of CBOD and/or TSS maximum of 50 mg/L of CBOD and/or TSS may be acceptable if an ERA indicates no may be acceptable if an ERA indicates no significant impact to the receiving significant impact to the receiving environment, there is no industrial input, and environment, there is no industrial input, and remoteness and/or climatic factors are a remoteness and/or climatic factors are a consideration. consideration. For existing discharges from very small For existing discharges from very small wastewater facilities that are remote, wastewater facilities that are remote, discharge requirements are based on an discharge requirements are based on an ERA.ERA.

Page 15: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1515

Options for proposed exceptions Options for proposed exceptions [cont[cont’’d]d]

For existing discharges from very small and For existing discharges from very small and small wastewater facilities that are remote small wastewater facilities that are remote and/or discharge to a marine receiving and/or discharge to a marine receiving environment, discharges with a maximum of environment, discharges with a maximum of 50 mg/L of CBOD and TSS, and 0.02 mg/L 50 mg/L of CBOD and TSS, and 0.02 mg/L TRC may be acceptable if an ERA indicates TRC may be acceptable if an ERA indicates no significant impact to the receiving no significant impact to the receiving environment. A waiver for marine discharges environment. A waiver for marine discharges similar to that in the US is also being similar to that in the US is also being considered.considered.

Page 16: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1616

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 1 Box 1 -- Page 5 of Consultation DocumentPage 5 of Consultation Document

Page 17: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1717

Environmental risk assessmentEnvironmental risk assessment

SiteSite--specific assessments evaluate risksspecific assessments evaluate risksCharacterizing the effluentsCharacterizing the effluentsCharacterizing the receiving environment Characterizing the receiving environment

Completed for each facility or at a watershed level Completed for each facility or at a watershed level Guides development of EDOs, where requiredGuides development of EDOs, where requiredUse national/provincial water quality guidelines as Use national/provincial water quality guidelines as benchmarksbenchmarksEDOs developed for pollutants that are found at 80% of a EDOs developed for pollutants that are found at 80% of a water quality guideline, when backwater quality guideline, when back--calculated from the edge calculated from the edge of the mixing zoneof the mixing zone

Page 18: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1818

Effluent discharge objectivesEffluent discharge objectivesEstablishes discharge requirements for Establishes discharge requirements for substances not covered by National substances not covered by National Performance Standards Performance Standards and/orand/orMore stringent discharge requirements for those More stringent discharge requirements for those substances that are already covered by National substances that are already covered by National Performance Standards if needed (CBOD5, Performance Standards if needed (CBOD5, TSS, TRC)TSS, TRC)These become part of permitsThese become part of permitsFinal strategy will include procedures and Final strategy will include procedures and decision points for the conduct of ERAs and the decision points for the conduct of ERAs and the derivation of EDOsderivation of EDOs

Page 19: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

1919

Option 1All wastewater facilities do Preliminary Risk Assessment(based on flow, industries, receiving environment)

Preliminary risk ranking -High – Medium – Low Order to undertake ERAs

Option 2First, only large and very large facilities complete ERAs

Results used toundertake focusedERAs for medium, small and very small facilities

All facilities complete ERAs, in order of risk

Ranking of Facilities based on ERA resultsHigh – Medium - Low

Options for Environmental Risk AssessmentOptions for Environmental Risk Assessment

Page 20: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2020

Options for ImplementationOptions for Implementation

Option 1High risk facilities - comply in [5]-[10] yrsMedium risk facilities - comply in[10]-[20] yrsLow risk facilities - comply in [20]-[30] yrs

Option 2All comply at existing facility end of life(maximum [30] years)

Option 3No timelines until funding options are defined

Page 21: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2121

Monitoring requirementsMonitoring requirementsContinuous DischargeContinuous Discharge

Initial characterizationInitial characterizationCompliance monitoringCompliance monitoringToxicity testingToxicity testing

Intermittent DischargeIntermittent DischargeInitial characterizationInitial characterizationCompliance monitoringCompliance monitoringToxicity testingToxicity testing

Page 22: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2222

Effluent initial characterizationEffluent initial characterizationMonitoring frequencies Monitoring frequencies –– continuous discharge facilitiescontinuous discharge facilities

Quarterly

Every 6 months

Every 6 months

Every 6 months

n/a

Sub-lethal Toxicity Testing

Frequency

Monthly

Quarterly

Quarterly

Quarterly

n/a

Acute Lethality Testing

Frequency

Quarterly

Quarterly

Quarterly

n/a

n/a

Test Series/Substance

Monitoring Frequency

Daily (5-7 days/week)

Weekly

Weekly

Monthly

Monthly

CBOD5, TSS, TRC1, Pathogens

and Nutrients2

Monitoring Frequency

Very Large

Large

Medium

Small

Very Small

Facility Size

Page 23: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2323

Effluent initial characterization Effluent initial characterization

Fluoride, Nitrate, Nitrate + NitriteAmmonia Dissolved Metals and Metal Hydrides, full rangeTotal PhosphorusTotal Suspended SolidsCarbonaceous BOD (5-day)COD

OrganochlorinePesticidesPCBs PAHsCyanide (total)pH Volatile Organic CompoundsMercury Phenolic compounds

Monitoring is for the following test groupsMonitoring is for the following test groups

Page 24: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2424

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 2 & 3 Box 2 & 3 -- Page 8 of Consultation Page 8 of Consultation DocumentDocumentBox 4Box 4-- Page 9 of Consultation DocumentPage 9 of Consultation Document

Page 25: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2525

Compliance monitoringCompliance monitoring

Monitoring Monitoring frequencies for frequencies for continuous continuous dischargesdischarges

DailyVery Large

WeeklyLarge

WeeklyMedium

MonthlySmall

MonthlyVery Small

TSS, CBOD5 and TRC1

Monitoring Frequency

Facility Size

Page 26: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2626

Toxicity testingToxicity testingTesting frequencies for continuous discharge facilitiesTesting frequencies for continuous discharge facilitiesTest failure requires development and implementation of ToxicityTest failure requires development and implementation of ToxicityReduction Evaluation plan to find and correct causeReduction Evaluation plan to find and correct cause

Quarterly-Fathead minnow-Ceriodaphniadubia

Monthly-Rainbow trout-Daphnia magna

Very Large

Every 6 months-Fathead minnow-Ceriodaphniadubia

Quarterly-Rainbow trout-Daphnia magna

Large

Every 6 months-Fathead minnow-Ceriodaphniadubia

Quarterly-Rainbow trout-Daphnia magna

Medium

n/an/an/an/aSmall

n/an/an/an/aVery Small

Sub-lethal Toxicity Testing

Frequency

Sub-lethal Toxicity Tests

Acute Lethality Testing

Frequency

Acute Lethality Tests

Facility Size

Page 27: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2727

Intermittent dischargesIntermittent discharges

Initial characterizationInitial characterizationTwice during each discharge Twice during each discharge –– once in the first once in the first half and once in the second halfhalf and once in the second half

Compliance monitoringCompliance monitoringOnce during the last half of each discharge Once during the last half of each discharge periodperiod

Toxicity testingToxicity testingTest once during the last half of each discharge Test once during the last half of each discharge periodperiod

Page 28: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2828

Environmental monitoringEnvironmental monitoring

Implement once in compliance with National Implement once in compliance with National Performance Standards and Effluent Performance Standards and Effluent Discharge ObjectivesDischarge ObjectivesConfirms modeled outcomes on which EDOs Confirms modeled outcomes on which EDOs were basedwere basedProposed optionsProposed options

Mandatory modeling by all facilities OR a subsetMandatory modeling by all facilities OR a subsetRequirements determined by each jurisdictionRequirements determined by each jurisdiction

Page 29: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

2929

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 5 Box 5 -- Page 11 of Consultation DocumentPage 11 of Consultation DocumentBox 6 Box 6 -- Page 12 of Consultation DocumentPage 12 of Consultation Document

Page 30: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3030

Environmental RiskEnvironmental Risk--Based Approach Based Approach –– OverflowsOverflows

Collection SystemManagement:

Opportunities for Reduction?

Environmental Risk

Assessment

Overflows meetObjectives?

NoYes

RiskManagement

Decision

Overflow Objectives

Overflows –CSOs, SSOs

Overflows meetNational Standards

No

Yes

National Standards

Page 31: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3131

Combined and sanitary sewer overflowsCombined and sanitary sewer overflows

Primary objective is to reduce the impact Primary objective is to reduce the impact of CSO and SSO events on the of CSO and SSO events on the environmentenvironmentOther objectives include:Other objectives include:

Elimination of CSOs through combined sewer Elimination of CSOs through combined sewer separation, where possibleseparation, where possibleSSOs should not occur SSOs should not occur -- eliminate through eliminate through corrective measures corrective measures No discharge upstream of designated areasNo discharge upstream of designated areasOther siteOther site--specific objectives may be specific objectives may be determined by the jurisdictiondetermined by the jurisdiction

Page 32: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3232

Overflow management Overflow management –– 4 steps4 steps1.1. CSO and SSO events will be recorded.CSO and SSO events will be recorded.2.2. National overflow standards must be achieved:National overflow standards must be achieved:

No new combined sewers will be constructedNo new combined sewers will be constructedNo increase of CSO frequency due to No increase of CSO frequency due to developmentdevelopmentNo CSO discharge during dry weather, except No CSO discharge during dry weather, except during spring thaw or emergenciesduring spring thaw or emergenciesFloatable materials will be removedFloatable materials will be removed

3.3. Owners must demonstrate that everything that can be Owners must demonstrate that everything that can be done with existing equipment is being done to limit done with existing equipment is being done to limit overflowsoverflows

4.4. Owners must develop a long term plan to reduce Owners must develop a long term plan to reduce CSOs and SSOs, and capture substances CSOs and SSOs, and capture substances -- based on based on achieving overflow objectivesachieving overflow objectives

Page 33: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3333

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 7 Box 7 -- Page 14 of Consultation DocumentPage 14 of Consultation Document

Page 34: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3434

Discussion questionsDiscussion questions

Are the performance requirements Are the performance requirements reasonable? (e.g., national performance reasonable? (e.g., national performance standards, effluent discharge objectives, standards, effluent discharge objectives, monitoring requirements, etc.)monitoring requirements, etc.)What other requirements or elements What other requirements or elements should be considered?should be considered?

Page 35: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3535

Coordinated ScienceCoordinated Scienceand Researchand Research

Page 36: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3636

Review of science and researchReview of science and researchCanadian wastewater research body is Canadian wastewater research body is recommendedrecommended

Include a diversity of organizationsInclude a diversity of organizationsOptions for implementation include:Options for implementation include:

FederalFederal--provincialprovincial--territorial committeeterritorial committeeIndependent committeeIndependent committee

Science and Research OverviewScience and Research Overview

Page 37: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3737

Focus of National Research GroupFocus of National Research Group

Strengthen links between municipal Strengthen links between municipal wastewater effluent, health and wastewater effluent, health and environmentenvironmentExamine reducing harmful pollutants in Examine reducing harmful pollutants in surface waters Identifying and filling surface waters Identifying and filling information gapsinformation gapsCoordinating technology research Coordinating technology research Addressing research needs in CanadaAddressing research needs in Canada’’s s Far NorthFar North

Page 38: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3838

FunctionsFunctions

Rank substances for researchRank substances for researchEnsure national and international linkagesEnsure national and international linkagesMaintain research inventoriesMaintain research inventoriesAssess emerging issues and identify actionsAssess emerging issues and identify actionsDisseminate informationDisseminate informationEducationEducationCoordinate research and fundingCoordinate research and fundingSponsor workshopsSponsor workshops

Page 39: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

3939

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 8 Box 8 -- Page 16 of Consultation DocumentPage 16 of Consultation Document

Page 40: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4040

Discussion questionsDiscussion questions

How should Canadian wastewater research How should Canadian wastewater research be coordinated, priorities established and be coordinated, priorities established and information shared? information shared? Do you have research priorities which are Do you have research priorities which are important to you?important to you?What mechanisms should be used to What mechanisms should be used to ensure increased linkage between health ensure increased linkage between health and environmental concerns from effluent?and environmental concerns from effluent?How should coHow should co--ordinated research be ordinated research be funded?funded?

Page 41: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4141

GovernanceGovernance

Page 42: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4242

Goals of HarmonizationGoals of Harmonization

Greater regulatory predictability and clarityGreater regulatory predictability and clarityDefinition of roles and responsibilitiesDefinition of roles and responsibilitiesAvoid duplication of efforts and gaps in Avoid duplication of efforts and gaps in accountabilitiesaccountabilities

Page 43: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4343

Managing sourcesManaging sources

Instruments include:Instruments include:Sewer Use Bylaw Sewer Use Bylaw Federal authority such as under CEPAFederal authority such as under CEPAWater management instrumentsWater management instruments

Page 44: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4444

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 9 Box 9 -- Page 17 of Consultation DocumentPage 17 of Consultation Document

Page 45: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4545

Model sewer use bylawModel sewer use bylaw

Developed in response to stakeholders Developed in response to stakeholders suggestion in 2005suggestion in 2005Provides guidance to municipalities and Provides guidance to municipalities and communities in implementing source control communities in implementing source control activitiesactivitiesTwo options for implementationTwo options for implementation

Voluntary implementation ORVoluntary implementation ORImplementation linked to fundingImplementation linked to funding

Page 46: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4646

Managing releasesManaging releases

National performance standards (CBOD, National performance standards (CBOD, TSS, TRC) reflected in national regulation TSS, TRC) reflected in national regulation ((Fisheries ActFisheries Act) and provincial licenses) and provincial licensesSite specific standards (e.g., EDOs)Site specific standards (e.g., EDOs)

Page 47: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4747

Formal agreementsFormal agreementsAdministrative agreements between the federal Administrative agreements between the federal government and the provinces similar to the pulp government and the provinces similar to the pulp and paper regulation under the and paper regulation under the Fisheries ActFisheries Act

•• Reflecting agreedReflecting agreed--to national standardsto national standards•• OneOne--window reportingwindow reporting•• Coordinated approach to compliance and enforcementCoordinated approach to compliance and enforcement

Options being developed for federal and territorial Options being developed for federal and territorial governments and water boardsgovernments and water boards

Page 48: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4848

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 10 Box 10 -- Page 19 of Consultation Page 19 of Consultation DocumentDocument

Page 49: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

4949

ReportingReportingImprove available information and Improve available information and communication communication Reporting to jurisdictions and the publicReporting to jurisdictions and the publicOptionsOptions

Facilities report annually to public on national Facilities report annually to public on national performance standards and applicable EDOsperformance standards and applicable EDOsFacilities report annually to public on all Part A Facilities report annually to public on all Part A requirementsrequirementsFacilities report annually to public on all operating Facilities report annually to public on all operating license/permit requirementslicense/permit requirements

Page 50: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5050

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 11 Box 11 -- Page 20 of Consultation Page 20 of Consultation DocumentDocument

Page 51: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5151

Discussion questionsDiscussion questions

Are the governance mechanisms Are the governance mechanisms reasonable and appropriate?reasonable and appropriate?What other approaches and options should What other approaches and options should be considered? be considered?

Page 52: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5252

Economic ImplicationsEconomic Implications

Page 53: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5353

Economic strategy is needed to ensure Economic strategy is needed to ensure successsuccessTo dateTo date

Cost template generated as a planning toolCost template generated as a planning toolFunding mechanisms examinedFunding mechanisms examinedCostCost--benefit analysis completedbenefit analysis completedAffordability issue examinedAffordability issue examined

Preliminary analysis estimates strategy to Preliminary analysis estimates strategy to cost between $8 and $13 billion nationally cost between $8 and $13 billion nationally in wastewater facility developmentin wastewater facility development

Overview

Page 54: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5454

Economics and funding task groupEconomics and funding task group

Funding and economics task group Funding and economics task group establishedestablishedExamine funding programsExamine funding programsDevelop options for funding strategy to Develop options for funding strategy to ensure implementation of the Canadaensure implementation of the Canada--wide strategywide strategyResults will be included in revisions to Results will be included in revisions to Strategy next springStrategy next spring

Page 55: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5555

Comparative templateObjectiveObjective

to identify the economic impact of upgrading to identify the economic impact of upgrading from one level of MWWE treatment to a from one level of MWWE treatment to a higher levelhigher level

DeliverablesDeliverablesTemplate is a tool that can be used to Template is a tool that can be used to estimate infrastructure upgrade costs at a estimate infrastructure upgrade costs at a facility level in a consistent mannerfacility level in a consistent mannerCosting scenarios obtained using template Costing scenarios obtained using template have been used to determine the overall costhave been used to determine the overall cost

Page 56: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5656

Cost/benefit analysisObjectiveObjective

Identify potential tangible and nonIdentify potential tangible and non--tangible tangible costs and benefits that would result from the costs and benefits that would result from the implementation of a MWWE strategy implementation of a MWWE strategy

DeliverablesDeliverablesModel/method that can be used at the facility Model/method that can be used at the facility or jurisdictional level to gauge the success of or jurisdictional level to gauge the success of implementing a MWWE strategyimplementing a MWWE strategyReport includes relevant examples of Report includes relevant examples of common discharge scenarios along with costs common discharge scenarios along with costs and benefitsand benefits

Page 57: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5757

Affordability

ObjectiveObjectiveAppropriately measure and consistently Appropriately measure and consistently compare the compare the ““affordabilityaffordability”” of a household or of a household or community to meet the requirements of the community to meet the requirements of the MWWE strategyMWWE strategy

DeliverableDeliverableReport investigates the affordability of Report investigates the affordability of

wastewater services in relation to other utilitieswastewater services in relation to other utilities

Page 58: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5858

Funding mechanismsObjectiveObjective

Identify funding mechanisms and evaluate Identify funding mechanisms and evaluate their applicability to the MWW sector their applicability to the MWW sector

DeliverablesDeliverablesReport outlines recommendations that can be Report outlines recommendations that can be used to improve funding activities (strategic, used to improve funding activities (strategic, capital, operation and maintenance)capital, operation and maintenance)Recommends options for funding programs Recommends options for funding programs according to community sizeaccording to community size

Page 59: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

5959

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 15 Box 15 -- Page 25 of Consultation Page 25 of Consultation DocumentDocument

Page 60: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6060

Discussion QuestionsDiscussion Questions

What approaches and options to funding What approaches and options to funding should be considered?should be considered?How much will the implementation of this How much will the implementation of this strategy cost municipalities?strategy cost municipalities?

Capital CostsCapital CostsAnnual O&M CostsAnnual O&M CostsOther costsOther costs

Who will provide the funding?Who will provide the funding?What criteria should be considered for What criteria should be considered for strategy implementation (i.e. risk, strategy implementation (i.e. risk, population, combination of both)population, combination of both)

Page 61: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6161

Implementation & TimelinesImplementation & Timelines

Page 62: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6262

Economic strategy will influenceEconomic strategy will influenceimplementationimplementationGoal should be risk reduction Goal should be risk reduction Activities proposed over a time frame up to Activities proposed over a time frame up to [20][30] years [20][30] years Review of strategy after 5 yearsReview of strategy after 5 yearsJurisdictions to develop own detailed Jurisdictions to develop own detailed implementation timelines and methodsimplementation timelines and methods

Implementation & Timelines

Page 63: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6363

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 12 Box 12 -- Page 22 & 23 of Consultation Page 22 & 23 of Consultation DocumentDocument

Page 64: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6464

Timelines Timelines –– Option 1Option 1New and upgraded facilities will be designed to New and upgraded facilities will be designed to meet the national standards and the necessary meet the national standards and the necessary EDOsEDOsFor existing facilities, phased implementation of For existing facilities, phased implementation of strategystrategy

00--[5] years [5] years –– focus on ERAsfocus on ERAs[3[3--5] 5] –– [5[5--10] years 10] years –– high risk facilities meet national high risk facilities meet national performance standardsperformance standards[5[5--10] 10] –– [10[10--20] years 20] years –– longlong--term plan to manage term plan to manage CSO/SSOs; medium risk facilities meet national CSO/SSOs; medium risk facilities meet national performance standardsperformance standards[20[20--30] years 30] years –– low risk facilities meet national low risk facilities meet national performance standardsperformance standards

Page 65: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6565

Timelines Timelines –– Option 2Option 2

New and upgraded facilities will be designed to New and upgraded facilities will be designed to meet the national standards and the necessary meet the national standards and the necessary EDOs.EDOs.Existing discharge requirements continue to apply Existing discharge requirements continue to apply to a wastewater facility until the to a wastewater facility until the end of lifeend of life of of existing equipment, up to a [30]existing equipment, up to a [30]--year maximumyear maximumEnvironmental risk assessment must show that Environmental risk assessment must show that immediate action is NOT necessary immediate action is NOT necessary At At end of lifeend of life, the National Performance Standards , the National Performance Standards will applywill apply

Page 66: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6666

Feedback QuestionsFeedback Questions

Box 13 Box 13 -- Page 23 of Consultation Page 23 of Consultation DocumentDocumentBox 14 Box 14 -- Page 24 of Consultation Page 24 of Consultation DocumentDocument

Page 67: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6767

Discussion questionsDiscussion questions

Are the proposed timelines reasonable?Are the proposed timelines reasonable?What other approaches and options should What other approaches and options should be considered?be considered?

Page 68: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6868

Fall/winter 2006/07 consultationJurisdictional consultationsMarch 1st 2007 – last day for submission of comments

Revisions to strategy considering input from consultation, Spring 2007Review and comment on entire package May/June 2007Fall 2007 submit to CCME for approval

Next stepsNext steps

Page 69: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

6969

Questions & Discussion

Page 70: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

7070

Please help us shape the strategyPlease help us shape the strategy

Please provide comment and input on the Please provide comment and input on the document and its optionsdocument and its optionsPlease respond to the questions for Please respond to the questions for stakeholdersstakeholdersPlease provide any general commentPlease provide any general commentBy March 1, 2007By March 1, 2007

Page 71: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

7171

All information is posted to the CCME website when available - www.ccme.caSign up for the CCME listserv for automatic notification of new information Send comments to your DC member or to the CCME Secretariat

Contact InformationContact Information

Page 72: Canada-wide Strategy for the Management of … › sd › eal › publs › ccme_effluent.pdfAcute Lethality Testing Frequency Acute Lethality Tests Facility Size 27 Intermittent discharges

7272

DC MemberMike Van Den BoschManitoba Conservation160-123 Main StreetWinnipeg, MBR3C [email protected]

CCME SecretariatJennifer Vigano360-123 Main StreetWinnipeg MBR3C 1A3fax [email protected]

Website Linkhttp://www.ccme.ca/ourwork/water.html?category_id=81#211

Contact InformationContact Information