Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung THE COST EFFECTIVE DEVELOPMENT OF HLA FEDERATIONS FOR...
-
Upload
wilhelm-schieber -
Category
Documents
-
view
105 -
download
0
Transcript of Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung THE COST EFFECTIVE DEVELOPMENT OF HLA FEDERATIONS FOR...
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
THE COST EFFECTIVE DEVELOPMENT OF HLA FEDERATIONS FOR
COMPUTER-ASSISTED EXERCISES (CAX)
K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-1
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-2
The PATHFINDER Promise
airair
LiveParticipants
seasea
landland
NationalSimulations
HLA Runtime Infrastructure (RTI)
Courseof
Action
LogisticModels
Federated Tools
PlanningSupport
DATABASESDATABASESDATABASES
CJTF
C3 I SYSTEM
Monolithic
Simulation
DATABASE
landairsea
AB
PATHFINDER Current NATO CAX Capability
Decision Support Tools
potential
Future NATO CAX Capability
ManagementTools
?
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-3
CJTF
C3 I SYSTEM
Monolithic
Simulation
DATABASE
landairsea
AB
Current NATO CAX Capability
Decision Support Tools
potential
The Approach I
ManagementToolsairair
LiveParticipants
seasea
landland
NationalSimulations
HLA Runtime Infrastructure (RTI)
Courseof
Action
LogisticModels
Federated Tools
PlanningSupport
DATABASESDATABASESDATABASES
1.Lessons Noted
2.Operational Requiremen
ts
3.Coupling CIS to M&S
?
4.Cost
Effectiveness
5. The Standardisation Concert
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-4
Modelling
Scenario Generation
Coupling withCIS
Identifying federates/
SRL
ADS
Monolithic vs.distributed
Data Marshalling
Problem Spaces
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-5
Deficiency:
Mismatch of simulation systems
Lack of operational requirements
No realistic CAX environment
Non “Operational” scenario
Management issues
DiM
uN
DS
20
00
Facilitate by:
Repository/Surveyof NATO models
CJTF requirement definition
CAX Guide light
Interfacing CIS
Scenario Generation PA
TH
FIN
DER
MO
DELLIN
G
Observations from DiMuNDS 2000
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-6
CIS to M&S Coupling
CIS
HLA
Federation
M & S
Swivel Chair
“Replication” Mechanism
Proprietary Protocol
Response Cell
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-7
“Loose”Coupling
ReferenceData Model
CIS SIM O =
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-8
REFERENCEDATAMODEL
SIMCIS
C2SimProxy
DMF OO
C2Sim-Proxy
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-9
The “Pi”-regime in CAX development
Cost (money, personnel, time)
Com
ple
xit
y (
resolu
tion
, LoD
, fi
delity
)
Seminars
DiMuNDS
PATHFINDER
NMSG Vision
CAX
RTP11.13
JSIMS
Pre-requisites:•Common Data models;•Mediation functionality;•CIS to Sim-coupling
State-of-the art
Monolithic simulation
Federated simulation
Support Tools
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-10
Dow Jones 1960 - 1993
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Another “Pi-Regime”
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-11
Operational relevance
Te
ch
nic
al
r ele
va
nc
e
Cost
DiMuNDS
PATHFINDER
CAX
Coupling w/ CIS
Om
it Re
sp
on
se
Ce
lls
Cost-Effectiveness
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-12
Technical Requirements
Synergy Effects
Academic Treatment
StandardisationIssues
ManagementMSG-002/TG-002
MSG-012/TG-009
MSG-020/SY-002
MSG-013/TG-010
MSG-018/TG-015
MSG-005/TG-005
MSG-017/TG-014
Establish technical infrastructure as outlined in this report;
Analyse technical pre-requisites of scenario generation for simulation system under consideration for PATHFINDER.
Analyse data models and interfaces of NATO CIS.
Rapid Generation of Scenarios and Databases for CAX and Operational support
FEDEP support tools for PATHFINDER
Simulation Resource Library
Interop. of Models and simulation in NATO
Modelling and Simulation Course
Standards Development
M&S Support from PATHFINDER Programmes
Extended analyse of NATO CIS and simulation system in terms of data models and interfaces.
Conduct capability demonstration of SIMULTAAN, PSI-SA etc. and explore conditions for use (e.g. licensing, voluntary contribution, etc.
Exploit synergies w/ other NATO or WEAG programs: e.g. JWID, RTP 11.13
Establish common and thorough understanding of Modelling.
Foster standardisation of data models ( e.g. ATCCIS);
Establish/foster NATO representative to OMG
Establish a PATHFINDER programme office
Re-Focusing NMSG TAPs
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-13
The Model Driven Archtecture
Bundesamt für Wehrtechnik und Beschaffung
FE I 5; K. Pixius
23-Sep-02 Folie 5-14
The overall recommendation is to establish a dedicated group devoted to the issue ofinterconnecting CIS and simulation systems, this is to be complemented by the followingactivities:
Short-term:
1. Re-focus existing MSG TAPs to identified problem spaces, whereappropriate;
2. Establish virtual PATHFINDER project office;
3. Launch academic approach to M & S;Mid-term:
4. Analyse capabilities of existing national simulation frameworks;
5. Participate in international, non-military standardisation activities, i.e. NATOto join OMG;
6. Analyse data models, standards and architectures as appropriate;Long-term:
7. Establish technical infrastructure to interconnect CIS and simulationsystems.
Recommendations