Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

74
April 12, 2012 1 Quarry Operations Appendix A2 ct5308 Breakwaters and Closure dams H.J. Verhagen Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences Section Hydraulic Engineering

Transcript of Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

Page 1: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012

Vermelding onderdeel organisatie

1

Quarry OperationsAppendix A2

ct5308 Breakwaters and Closure dams

H.J. Verhagen

Faculty of Civil Engineering and GeosciencesSection Hydraulic Engineering

Page 2: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 2

Types of quarries

• Production of aggregates• Production of blocks (dimension stone)

Page 3: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 3

Geological features

• Joints• Faults• Discontinuities

Page 4: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 4

joints and fractures

joints

fractures

Page 5: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 5

types of fractures

attitude of thediscontinuity

Page 6: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 6

distanced between discontinuities

Page 7: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 7

Page 8: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 8

block size

Page 9: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 9

Page 10: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 10

Giant Causeway, Northern Ireland

Page 11: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 11

Page 12: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 12

mining plan

Page 13: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 13

mining plan

Page 14: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 14

Terraces in a quarry

Sini Vir quarry, Bulgaria

Page 15: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 15

effect of rock density and water absorptionon required rock weight

Page 16: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 16

Page 17: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 17

Methods to get rock out of the mountain• Drilling and blasting

• using dynamite• using gunpowder

• Sawing

Vegard Olsen, ICS 2005, Iceland

Page 18: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 18

Blasting large blocks in a quarry

Vegard Olsen, ICS 2005, Iceland

Page 19: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 19

Drilling equipment

Sini Vir quarry, Bulgaria

Page 20: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 20

Page 21: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 21

Blasting at Jebel Berri Jubail, nov 1982

Page 22: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 22

Sawing of dimension stone

Page 23: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 23

Scrap stone from a dimension stone quarry

Page 24: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 24

Loading of rejected dimension stone

Larvik, Tveidalen, Stema loading facility

Page 25: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 25

ELL: Extreme upper limitNLL: Nominal lower limitNUL: Nominal upper limitEUL: Extreme upper limit

Page 26: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 26

in 60-300 and 300-1000 kg

Page 27: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 27

Page 28: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 28

production screen for 10-60 kg (falling through) and greater than 300 kg (sliding over)

Page 29: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 29

al Rakeeb sorting facility

Page 30: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 30

sorting – bar sizer

Page 31: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 31

Page 32: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 32

sorting – side kick

Page 33: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 33

Page 34: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 34

Page 35: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 35

Page 36: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 36

Page 37: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 37

Splitting oversize blocks with a hydraulic 'pecker'

Page 38: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 38

Page 39: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 39

Page 40: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 40

Weight reduction of armour between blasting and operation in breakwater

Page 41: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 41

Page 42: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 42

Page 43: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 43

Page 44: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 44

How big is this rock ??

Page 45: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 45

This is small rock !

Vietnam, Hue area

Page 46: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 46

Stockpile 300-1000 kg and 1-3 tons

Page 47: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 47

300 - 100 kg

Page 48: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 48

Stockpile 1-3 ton basalt

Page 49: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 49

How big is this rock ??

1 - 3 cm 1-3 tonnes

Page 50: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 50

What is dn ?

A4

dn = 22 cm

Devnya quarry, Bulgaria, fieldwork 2002

Page 51: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 51

weighing blocks individually

Page 52: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 52

analysis Devnya quarry

Mass distribution

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 100.0 120.0

Mass [kg]

Perc

enta

ge b

y m

ass

light

er

M50 = 24 kgρ = 2284 kg/m3

dn50 = 22 cm

Page 53: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 53

dn log-linear scale

Distribution Dn

0%

10%20%

30%40%

50%

60%70%

80%90%

100%

0.10 1.00

Dn logarithmic scale [m]

Perc

enta

ge b

y D

n sm

alle

r

Page 54: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 54

dn on log-Gaussian scaleGaussian distribution

-2.1

-1.6

-1.1

-0.6

-0.1

0.4

0.9

1.4

1.9

0.10 1.00

Dn Gaussian scale [m]

pr(%

) - G

auss

sca

le

Page 55: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 55

New standard

• Old standard: NEN 5180 – 5188

• New standard: EN 13383• part 1: Armourstone – Specifications• part 2: Armourstone – Test Methods

Page 56: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 56

Standard conformity declaration

For armourstone use category 4

Name producerYear of markStandard numberProduct descriptionInformation on product details

Page 57: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 57

Properties description method

• When selecting an armourstone grading or property the approach is to select the appropriate category

• For example:

20DEMThe property description. In this case Micro-Devalindex

Value selected; or maximum or minimum value allowed. In this case max. value

Page 58: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 58

Categories

• An option to use No Requirement (NR) category is also possible• For example, for crushed stone, the Rounding

Index is usually not used (required for a minimum proportion of crushed or broke surfaces). So this would be RONR

• If properties are outside specific limits, the producer may declare a value• E.g. if % of armourstone pieces with L/T>3 for a

course grading is 25% (normal max. is 20%) the producer would state LT25.

• A client could buy this as an LTNR core material

Page 59: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 59

Gradings in New standard

• Course Grading45/125 – 63/180 – 90/250 – 45/180 – 90/180 mm(30/60 – – 40/100 – 50/150 – 80/200 mm)

• Light Grading5/40 – 10/60 – 40/200 – 60/300 – 5/300 kg

• Heavy Grading0.3/1 – 1/3 – 3/6 – 6/10 – 10/15 tons

Category A and B: A has some tighter control on mass distribution, but usually B is sufficient (For cover layers use category A)

Page 60: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 60

Course gradings• For general use: 45/125 63/180 90/250 mm• For wide grading: 45/180 mm• For gabion stone: 90/180 mm

Light gradings• For general use: 5 to 40 kg, 40 to 200 kg, 60 to 300 kg• For wide grading: 15 to 300 kg

Producer declared• Producer may declare other gradings, for example

HM2000/4000

Page 61: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 61

Overview of classes inEN 13383

45/125 mm63/180 mm90/250 mm45/200 mm90/180 mm5-40 kg10-60 kg40-200 kg60-300 kg15-300 kg300-1000 kg1-3 ton3-6 ton6-10 ton

CP45/125CP63/180CP90/250CP45/180CP90/180LMA 5-40LMA 10-60LMA 40-200LMA 60-300LMA 15-300HMA 300-1000HMA 1000-3000HMA 3000-6000HMA 6000-10000

rangeClass name

Page 62: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 62

Grading system

ELLextreme lower limitNLLnormal lower limitNULnormal upper limitEULextreme upper limit

Page 63: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 63

Grading description

• For course gradings:CPNLL/NUL e.g. CP90/250

• For light and heavy gradings:LMANLL/NUL

HMBNLL/NUL e.g. HMB60/300

category A or Blight of heavy grading

Page 64: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 64

Weight distribution acc. to EN13383

0

20

40

60

80

100

100 1000 10000 100000

kg

cum

ulat

ive

frac

tion 0.3-1 ton

1-3 ton3-6 ton6-10 ton10-15 ton-

Standard distributions

Mean weightcategory A Dn-distribution (adapted from EN13383)

0

20

40

60

80

100

0.3 0.8 1.3 1.8

Dn (m)

cum

ulat

ive

fract

ion

0.1-3 ton-1-3 ton-3-6 ton-6-10 ton-10-15 ton-

Page 65: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 65

Other parameters in new standard

• Shape (LT)• Crushed surface (RO)• Particle density• Resistance to breakage (CS)• Petrographic description• Dangerous substances

• proportion crushed• resistance to wear (MDE)• water absorption (WA)• freezing/thawing (FT)• salt crystallization (MS)• impurities

• dicalcium silicate disintegration• iron disintegration• steel slag disintegration (DS)• sonnenbrand (SB)

Page 66: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 66

Density requirements

• Average density of 10 pieces: > x Mg/m3

• Density of at least 36 pieces of 40 pieces tested:> x-0.10Mg/m3

• The value for x shall be declared by the producer and stated to 2 decimals places and shall not be less than 2.30.

• Note: for design use wet density:• ρwet = (1+0.0050 WA) ρdry (submerged) • ρwet = (1+0.0025 WA) ρdry (not submerged)

Page 67: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 67

Shape requirements

LTNRNo requirementNo requirement

No requirement

LTA

LTdeclared

≤5

Other value declared by the

producer

≤20

Other value declared by

the producer

≤20

Other value declared by

the producer

heavy gradingslight gradingscourse gradings

Percentage by number

Percentage by mass

categoryLT

Length to thickness ratio greater than 3

Page 68: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 68

Resistance to wear

• Micro Deval test• use MDENR for everything except cover layers• use MDE20 for most cover layers

• The test is done by placing samples in a drum, add steel balls and water, and rotate the drum for 2 hrs

• Then dry the residue and determine the percentage of abraded material

• For details see EN1097-1

Page 69: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 69

Mineral breakage

• Determine compressive strength using EN 1926• preferred category: CS80

Page 70: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 70

Durability

• Water absorption test• If WA0.5 is achieved (i.e. WA is not more than

0.5%) no further testing is needed• If not, then:

• test salt crystallisation• select category MS25

• If likely to freeze above waterline, check freeze thaw resistance

• required category FTA

Page 71: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 71

Crushed surfaces

• Only relevant when rock is NOT from a quarry, but in case river boulders, etc. are used

• So this parameter is usually not relevant

Page 72: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 72

Smaller aggregates

• Stones smaller than CP45/125 are not defined in EN13383

• Other standards:• EN12620 for the concrete industry • EN13242 (for civil engineering works and road

construction).

Page 73: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 73

From EN13242

GC Course gradingsGF Fine gradingsGNG Natural gradedGA Wide gradation

Page 74: Breakwaters and closure dams appendix a2

April 12, 2012 74

Grading categories (EN13242)Example for grading 20/40 mm (e.g. for polymer bonded materials)