Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged...

27
Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams Operations Manager CIMS - Overlay Technologies Division (780) 477-2467 [email protected] Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E. President Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC (832) 512-0109 [email protected]

Transcript of Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged...

Page 1: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large

Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Operations ManagerCIMS - Overlay Technologies Division

(780) [email protected]

Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E.President

Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC(832) 512-0109

[email protected]

Page 2: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Overview• The application process– Automated weld overlay– Equipment– Challenges– Case studies

• QA Research program• Summary

2

Page 3: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

• Fully Fused Surface Protection for Pressure Vessels

• Cost Effective Long Term Solution, Short Timeframe

• Alloy Selection for Erosion/Corrosion Needs

Automated Weld Overlay

3

Page 4: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

• Weld Process Control – Locked In Parameters

• Fail Safe with Error Diagnosis

• Inter-machine System Compatibility

• Fewer Components

Advanced Equipment

4

Page 5: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Challenges

5

Page 6: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

• Inspection• Temper-bead WPS• Surface Preparation• Heat Input• Machine Location -

Distortion

Coke Drum Seam Repair

6

Page 7: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

First Layer

7

Page 8: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Second Layer

8

Page 9: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

QA Research Program

Page 10: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

WHY?

• Verify adequacy of weld overlay for structural applications.

• Quantify as-welded properties.• Improve the ability to model the overlay

and predict consequences.

10

Page 11: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

OBJECTIVES• Test Program

– Characterize and obtain key mechanical properties of as-welded overlay.

– Examine the bond between the weld overlay and base metal.

– Determine the impact of the weld overlay process on base metal.

– Compare fatigue strength of unrepaired and repaired plates.

• Finite element analysis– Compare simulation of weld overlay results and

plate distortion measurements.– Calibrate weld simulation process to improve the

accuracy of predicting distortion and residual stresses.

11

Page 12: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

TEST PLATEClad carbon steel plate:• 3’ x 4’ x 5/8”• A36 base metal• 304L SS clad• Tensile 67.2 ksi• Yield 41.5 ksi, 36% in

2”Weld overlay:• Inconel 625 • Two or three 3/16”

layers• Weld on base metal or

clad 12

Plate Roll direction

Weld direction

Page 13: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

AUTOMATED WELDING

13

Page 14: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

TEST SCOPE• Tensile Testing• Metallographic Examination• Hardness Survey• Fracture Toughness • Crack Growth• Chemical Analysis• Fatigue Testing

14

Page 15: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Tensile TestingStress-strain curves• Room Temperature• High Temperature

15

Page 16: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Metallographic ExaminationBond quality between the layers.

16

Page 17: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Metallographic ExaminationBond quality between base metal and weld.

17

Page 18: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Hardness SurveyHardness and microhardness

measurements.

18

Page 19: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Charpy V-Notch Impact

19

Page 20: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Fracture ToughnessThese tests are conducted to quantify the ability of the as-welded overlay to resist cracks.

20

Page 21: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Fatigue Crack GrowthCrack propagation rates in through-wall & circumferential directions.

21

Page 22: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Chemical AnalysisThis analysis is conducted to determine the chemistry of the three layers and compare them to nominal composition.

22

Page 23: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Fatigue TestingIsothermal tests at room temperature.

23

Page 24: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Finite Element Simulation

24

Page 25: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Equivalent Plastic Strain

25

Page 26: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

Summary • Automated weld overlay can be used to

provide consistent high-quality repairs to large equipment.

• On-going test program provides unique material properties of as-welded overlays that can be used in structural applications.

• Distortion from weld overlay repairs can be predicted with higher accuracy

26

Page 27: Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged …cimsltd.com/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/WilliamsSamman...Automated Weld Overlay Repairs of Large Damaged Equipment Eric G. Williams

QUESTIONS?Eric G. Williams

Operations ManagerCIMS - Overlay Technologies Division

(780) [email protected]

Mahmod Samman, Ph.D., P.E.President

Houston Engineering Solutions, LLC(832) 512-0109

[email protected]