7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

1/519

DATE:

Type of Project >>>>

Total Weights Total Score Total Weights Total Score

Risk parameter

I. Pre-Construction Risks 30 30

1. Statutory Clearances 5 5

2. Non-Statutory Approvals 2 2

3. Finalization of Key Contracts 13 13

4. Design Parameters 10 10

II. Construction Risks 40 40

III. Operations & Maintenance Risks 10 10

1. Operational Risks 10 10

2. Sales & Offtake Risk

3. Political/Economy and Social Risks

4. Force Majeure Events

5. Techno Economic Parameters

IV.Financials 20 20

Total Score Obtained 100 100

100

Stage of the Proje

COMPANY NAME :

Project Name:

Pre-Construction Construction

Pre-Construction Construction

COAL GAS

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

2/519

Total Weights Total Score Stage of the Project>> Pre-Construction Construction

Total Score 100

Grade Assigned to Project PC1

80 and above PP1 PC1

Above 65 and below 80 PP2 PC2

Above 50 and below 65 PP3 PC3

Below 50 PP4 PC4

Grading Matrix >>>

t

Operations & Maintenance Project Grading Matrix

Operations & Maintainence

HYDEL

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

3/519

Ops.&Maint.

PO1

PO2

PO3

PO4

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

4/519

No. Type of Risk Applicable Y/N Weightage Adjusted

Wt.

Marks

Awarded

Out Of 10

Approvals/Permits/Clearan

ces

I.1 Statutory Clearances 10 10

TEC Obtained

Y 1 1 10 10

Allocation Obtained

Y 2 2 10 10

State Government

Acceptance Ontained

Y 1 1 10 10

SG's Consent Obtained

Y 1 1 10 10

EC Issued

Y 2 2 10 10

Approval from

MoEF/SGMoEF

Y 2 2 10 10

Obtained Aviation

Clearance

Y 0.5 0.5 10 10

Obtained

Y 0.5 0.5 10 10

I.2 Non-Statutory5 5

Techno-economic clearance

from CEAA

Water AvailabilityB

SPU/State Govt. clearanceC

Pollution Clearance (water

and air)D

Environment Clearance (EC)E

Other Statutory ClearancesH

F Forest Land Clearance (FC)

G

Civil Aviation Clearance for

chimney height

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

5/519

Available as per

Normative Total

Requirement

A Y 3 3 10 10

Very Good

Y 1 1 10 10

Obtained

Y 1 1 10 10

1.3 Finalisation of Key

Contracts 40 40

Signed PPA for at least

60% of Capacity

Y 2 2 10 10

Highly Favorable

2 PPA-Tariff Y 2 2 10 10

Very Good

3 PPA- Term Y 1 1 10 10

Very Good

Y 8 8 10 10Fuel Required at

Normative Availability

(NA) for 12 Years is

tied up

Y 10 10 10 10

2

D A ) Project Implementation

StructureEPC Contractor

Finalized and EPC

Awarded

Y 8 0 10 10

Experience of Power

Sector

Y 4 0 10 10

Land/Site

Others

AccessB

Fuel SupplyC

C

A PPA - Quantitative

B PPA - Qualitative

PPA - (% of capacity)1

Status of EPC contract

Contractor

EPC NON-EPC

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

6/519

Advantageous

Y 3 0 10 10

D B) Project Implementation

Structure

Supplier Finalized and

Contract Awarded

Y 7 7 10 10

Supplier Finalized and

Contract Awarded

Y 3 3 10 10

Very Good

Y 5 5 10 10

Contacts Awarded

Y 1 1 10 10

Contacts Awarded

Y 1 1 10 10

I.4 Design Parameters15 15

Thermal

Hydro

Gas

Thermal

Hydro

Gas

Thermal

Gas -Open Cycle

Combined Cycle

Thermal

4 10Y 4

3 103Y

O & M Contracts

Y 102 2

Status of BTG Package

Owner's, Owner Engineer's

Experience/Track RecordE

F

Contractor's Relation with

Owner's Group

Status of BOP Package

OthersG

A Project Cost

B Availability Factor

C Heat Rate

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

7/519

Gas

Combined Cycle

Thermal

Very Reputed

F DPR Consultants Y 2 2 10 10

II. Construction Risk15 15

Acquired at least 75%

of Requirement

Y 5 5 10 10

Stage 2 Clearance

Issued

Y 2 2 10 10

No History/Very Low

Risk

Y 2 2 10 10

Very Good

Y 4 4 10 10

Stage 2 Clearance

IssuedY 2 2 10 10

IV. Project Financials15 15

70:30

Y 4 4 10 10

> 1.5

Y 4 4 10 10

REC PLR +4%

Y 3 3 10 10

>18%

Y 2 2 10 10

60-70%

Y 2 2 10 10

2 10

Y 2 102

Y 2

A Land/Site

D Auxiliary Consumption

Average DSCR

IRR

Return on Equity

Break Even PLF (@ DSCR =1)

D Evacuation Infrastructure

EEvacuation Infrastructure -Forestry Clearance

Debt-Equity

B

Plant Site - Forestry

Clearance

C Natural Disaster Risks

E

Secondary Fuel

Consumption

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

8/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

9/519

Total Scored

10

DPR Submitted Feasibility Study Done

Pre-Feasibility

(Survey of Site) Rejection

8 4 2 0 1.0In-principle Approval

from SG Obtained for

Full requirement

In-principle Approval

from SG Obtained for

partial requirement Source Identified Rejection

8 6 2 0 2.0

- - Applied For Rejection

- - 2 0 1.0

- -

Applied For Consent

of the SPCB Rejection

8 6 2 0 1.0Public Hearing

Completed

Scoping (TOR

Issued)

Screening

Completed Rejection

8 4 2 0 2.0

In-Principle Approval

from MoEF

SG Forestry

Recommends

Application for

Diversion of Land Rejection

8 6 2 0 2.0

- - Applied For Rejection

8 6 2 0 0.5

Applied For Rejection

8 6 2 0 0.5

5

Grading Guidelines

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

10/519

About 80% or above

of the Norms

About 60% or above

(50% of Fuel Required

(@NA) for 12 Years is

tied up

>50% of Fuel

Required (@NA) for

5 Years is tied up No Action Yet

8 6 4 0 10

Bids Received and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

8 4 2 0 0

Experience of Allied

Power

Good experience of

other than Power

Sector

Very Less

experience of other

than Power Sector No experience

8 6 2 0 0

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

11/519

Low Risk Medium Risk High Risk Very High Risk

8 6 4 0 0

Bids Received and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

8 6 4 0 7Bids Received and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

8 6 4 0 3

Above Average Average Below Average Poor

8 6 2 0

5Bids Received andContactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

8 4 2 0 1Bids Received and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

8 4 2 0 1

15

4-5 Crores 5-6 Crores 6.0-6.5 Crores 6.5-7.0 Crores

10 8 6 46-7 Crores 7-8 Crores 8-8.5 Crores > 8.5 Crores

10 8 6 4

4-4.5 Crores 4.5-5.0 Crores 5-5.50 Crores > 5.50 Crores

10 8 6 4

>85% 70-85% 60-70% 60% 50-60% 40-50% 85% 75-85% 65-75%

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

12/519

10 8 6 4

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

13/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

14/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

15/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

16/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

17/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

18/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

19/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

20/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

21/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

22/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

23/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

24/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

25/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

26/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

27/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

28/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

29/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

30/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

31/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

32/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

33/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

34/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

35/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

36/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

37/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

38/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

39/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

40/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

41/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

42/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

43/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

44/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

45/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

46/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

47/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

48/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

49/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

50/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

51/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

52/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

53/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

54/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

55/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

56/519

Y 1 1 10

Y 0.5 0.5 10

Y 0.5 0.5 10

I.3 Key Contracts

13 13

A PPA-Quantitative

Y 2 2 10

PPA-Tariff Y 1 1 10

PPA- Term Y 1 1 10

Y 1 1 10

Y 2 2 10

2

Y 2 0 10

Status of EPC contract

AccessB

OthersC

Land/SiteA

PPA -% of Capacity1

2

3

PPA - QualitativeB

C Fuel Supply

D A ) Project Implementation Structure

EPC NON-EPC

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

57/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

58/519

F DPR Consultants

II. Construction Risk

40 40

Y 7 7 10

Y 5 5 10

Y 5 5 10

Y 5 5 10

Y 4 4 10

Y 6 6 10

Y 6 6 10

Y

Y 1 101

11 10

FProject Implementation - Plant &Machinery - Costs

G

Project Implementation - Plant &

Machinery -Time Schedule

Evacuation Infrastructure

C Natural Disaster Risks

D

Evacuation Infrastructure - Forestry

ClearanceE

Plant Site - Forestry Clearance

Auxilary ConsumptionD

Y 1 1 10

Secondary Fuel ConsumptionE

A Land/Site

B

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

59/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

60/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

61/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

62/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

63/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

64/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

65/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

66/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

67/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

68/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

69/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

70/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

71/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

72/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

73/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

74/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

75/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

76/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

77/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

78/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

79/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

80/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

81/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

82/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

83/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

84/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

85/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

86/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

87/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

88/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

89/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

90/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

91/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

92/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

93/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

94/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

95/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

96/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

97/519

Total Scored

5

TEC Obtained DPR Submitted Feasibility Study Done

Pre-Feasibility

(Survey of Site) Rejection

10 8 4 2 0 0.5

Allocation Obtained

from SG Obtained for

Full requirement

from SG Obtained for

partial requirement Source Identified Rejection

10 8 6 2 0 1

State GovernmentAcceptance Obtained - - Applied For Rejection

10 - - 2 0 0.5

SPCB's Consent (NOC)

Obtained - -

Applied For Consent

of the SPCB Rejection

10 8 6 2 0 0.5

EC Issued

Public Hearing

Completed

Scoping (TOR

Issued)

Screening

Completed Rejection

10 8 4 2 0 0.5

Approval from

MoEF/SGMoEF

In-Principle Approval

from MoEF

SG Forestry

Recommends

Application for

Divesrion of Land Rejection

10 8 6 2 0 1

Obtained Aviation

Clearance - - Applied For Rejection

10 8 6 2 0 0.5

Obtained Applied For Rejection

10 8 6 2 0 0.5

2

Grading Guidelines

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

98/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

99/519

10 8 6 2 0 0

Advantageous Low Risk Medium Risk High Risk Very High Risk

10 8 6 4 0 0

Supplier Finalized and

Contract Awarded

Bids Reeceived and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

10 8 6 4 0 2.00

Supplier Finalized and

Contract Awarded

Bids Reeceived and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

10 8 6 4 0 1

Very Good Above Average Average Below Average Poor

10 8 6 2 0 1.00

Contacts Awarded

Bids Reeceived andContactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

10 8 4 2 0 1

Contacts Awarded

Bids Reeceived and

Contactor(s) being

finalized

Bidders shortlisted and

RFP Floated RFQ for Bids Floated No Action Yet

10 8 4 2 0 1

10

Thermal 4-5 Crores 5-6 Crores 6.0-6.5 Crores 6.5-7.0 Crores

10 8 6 4

Hydro 6-7 Crores 7-8 Crores 8-8.5 Crores > 8.5 Crores

10 8 6 4

Gas 4-4.5 Crores 4.5-5.0 Crores 5-5.50 Crores > 5.50 Crores

10 8 6 4

Thermal >85% 70-85% 60-70% 60% 50-60% 40-50% 85% 75-85% 65-75%

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

100/519

10 8 6 4

Combined Cycle 2.0

10 8 6 4

Very Reputed Reputed Experienced Limited Exp. Unknown

10 8 6 4 2

40

Acquired at least 75%

of Requirement

Acquired at least 50%

of Requirement

Acquired at least 33%

of Requirement

Land Identified and

Acquisition in

progress -Advances

Paid/Notification

Issued Not Yet Started

10 8 6 2 0 7

Stage 2 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 2

Clearance

Stage 1 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 1

Clearance Not Yet Started

10 8 6 2 0 5

No Hostory/Very Low

Risk Low Risk Medium Risk High Risk Very High Risk

10 8 6 2 0 5

Very Good Above Average Average Below Average Poor

10 8 6 2 0 5

Stage 2 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 2

Clearance

Stage 1 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 1

Clearnce Not Yet Started

10 8 6 2 0 4

No Impact and Risk

completely Addressed

Low Impact and Risk

Adequately

Addressed Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

10 8 6 2 0 6

No Impact and Risk

completely Addressed

(10)

Low Impact and Risk

Adequately

Addressed (8) Average Impact (6) High Impact (4) Very High Impact (6)

10 8 6 2 0 6

No Impact and Risk

completely Addressed

Low Impact and Risk

Adequately

Addressed Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

1

1

1

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

101/519

10 8 6 2 0 2

10

Available for

Expansion

More than Required

for Capacity

Adequate for Proposed

Capacity

Less than Normative

Requirement Not Adequate

10 8 6 2 0 5

More than AdequateAdequate for Life of

the PlantAdequate for Medium

TermAdequate only for

Short Term Not Adequate

10 8 6 2 0 5

20

70:30 75:25 80:20 85:15 90:10

10 8 6 2 0

> 1.5 1.3 - 1.5 1.2 - 1.3 1.1 - 1.2 1.0 - 1.1

10 8 6 4 2

REC PLR +4% REC PLR +3% REC PLR +2% REC PLR +1% REC PLR +0.5%

10 8 6 4 2

>18% 15-18% 13-15% 10-13% 90%

10 8 6 4 2 3

5

5

4

3

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

102/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

103/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

104/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

105/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

106/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

107/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

108/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

109/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

110/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

111/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

112/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

113/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

114/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

115/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

116/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

117/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

118/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

119/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

120/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

121/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

122/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

123/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

124/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

125/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

126/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

127/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

128/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

129/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

130/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

131/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

132/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

133/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

134/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

135/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

136/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

137/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

138/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

139/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

140/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

141/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

142/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

143/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

144/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

145/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

146/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

147/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

148/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

149/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

150/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

151/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

152/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

153/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

154/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

155/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

156/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

157/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

158/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

159/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

160/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

161/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

162/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

163/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

164/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

165/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

166/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

167/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

168/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

169/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

170/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

171/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

172/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

173/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

174/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

175/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

176/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

177/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

178/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

179/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

180/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

181/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

182/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

183/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

184/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

185/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

186/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

187/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

188/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

189/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

190/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

191/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

192/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

193/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

194/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

195/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

196/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

197/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

198/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

199/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

200/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

201/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

202/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

203/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

204/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

205/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

206/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

207/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

208/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

209/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

210/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

211/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

212/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

213/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

214/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

215/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

216/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

217/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

218/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

219/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

220/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

221/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

222/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

223/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

224/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

225/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

226/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

227/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

228/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

229/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

230/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

231/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

232/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

233/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

234/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

235/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

236/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

237/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

238/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

239/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

240/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

241/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

242/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

243/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

244/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

245/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

246/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

247/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

248/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

249/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

250/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

251/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

252/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

253/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

254/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

255/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

256/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

257/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

258/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

259/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

260/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

261/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

262/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

263/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

264/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

265/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

266/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

267/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

268/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

269/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

270/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

271/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

272/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

273/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

274/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

275/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

276/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

277/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

278/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

279/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

280/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

281/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

282/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

283/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

284/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

285/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

286/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

287/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

288/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

289/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

290/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

291/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

292/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

293/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

294/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

295/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

296/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

297/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

298/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

299/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

300/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

301/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

302/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

303/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

304/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

305/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

306/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

307/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

308/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

309/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

310/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

311/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

312/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

313/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

314/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

315/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

316/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

317/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

318/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

319/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

320/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

321/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

322/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

323/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

324/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

325/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

326/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

327/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

328/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

329/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

330/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

331/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

332/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

333/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

334/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

335/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

336/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

337/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

338/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

339/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

340/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

341/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

342/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

343/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

344/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

345/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

346/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

347/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

348/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

349/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

350/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

351/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

352/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

353/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

354/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

355/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

356/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

357/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

358/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

359/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

360/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

361/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

362/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

363/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

364/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

365/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

366/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

367/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

368/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

369/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

370/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

371/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

372/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

373/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

374/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

375/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

376/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

377/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

378/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

379/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

380/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

381/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

382/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

383/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

384/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

385/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

386/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

387/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

388/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

389/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

390/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

391/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

392/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

393/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

394/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

395/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

396/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

397/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

398/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

399/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

400/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

401/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

402/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

403/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

404/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

405/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

406/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

407/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

408/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

409/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

410/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

411/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

412/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

413/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

414/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

415/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

416/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

417/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

418/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

419/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

420/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

421/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

422/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

423/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

424/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

425/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

426/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

427/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

428/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

429/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

430/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

431/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

432/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

433/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

434/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

435/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

436/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

437/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

438/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

439/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

440/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

441/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

442/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

443/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

444/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

445/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

446/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

447/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

448/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

449/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

450/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

451/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

452/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

453/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

454/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

455/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

456/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

457/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

458/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

459/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

460/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

461/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

462/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

463/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

464/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

465/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

466/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

467/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

468/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

469/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

470/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

471/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

472/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

473/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

474/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

475/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

476/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

477/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

478/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

479/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

480/519

No. Type of Risk Applicable

Y/N

Weightage Adjusted

Wt.

Marks

Awarded

Out Of 10

I Statutory Clearances 5 5

Obtained

Y 5 5 10 10

II. Construction Risk 15 15

Acquired at least 75% of

Requirement

Y 2 2 10 10

Stage 2 Clearance Issued

Y 2 2 10 10

No Hostory/Very Low Risk

Y 2 2 10 10

Very Good

Y 2 2 10 10

Stage 2 Clearance Issued

Y 1 1 10 10

No Impact and Risk completely

Addressed

Y 3 3 10 10

No Impact and Risk completely

Addressed

Y 2 2 10 10

No Impact and Risk completely

Addressed

Y 1 1 10 10

III. Operations &

Maintenance

III.1 Operational Risks

18 18

Very Good

Land/SiteA

A Statutory Clearances

B

Plant Site - Forestry

Clearance

C Natural Disaster Risks

D

G

Project Implementation -

Plant & Machinery -Time

Schedule

H

Accident/ Damage/

Destruction

Evacuation Infrastructure

E

Evacuation Infrastructure

- Forestry Clearance

F

Project Implementation -

Plant & Machinery -

Costs

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

481/519

Y 4 4 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 2 2 10 10

Available for ExpansionY 1 1 10 10

Low

Y 1 1 10 10

Fuel Related Risks

Very Strong

Y 2 2 10 10

Vey High

Y 2 2 10 10

More than Adequate

Y 2 2 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

III.2 Sales/ Offtake Risk 10 10

Highly Favorable

Y 1 1 10 10

Signed PPAs for: >70% of

Capacity

Y 2 2 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

A Equipment Performance

E Source

F Supplier

G Fuel - Quantity & Quality

B

Performance Guarantee

& LDs

CWater Availability &Adequacy

Cooling TechnologyD

L

Environmental/ Pollution

Risks

A Demand Risk

B

Capacity Tied up through

PPAs

I Fuel Price risk

J Fuel transportation Risk

K O & M risks

Evacuation RiskC

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

482/519

Highly Favorable

Y 2 2 10 10

Very Good

Y 2 2 10 10

Very Good

Y 1 1 10 10

Very Good

Y 1 1 10 10

III.3 Political/Economic Risks

5 5

Low

Y 2 2 10 10

Low

Y 1 1 10 10Low

Y 2 2 10 10

III.4 Force Majeure Risk2 2

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

Adequately Covered

Y 1 1 10 10

III.5 Techno Economic10 10

Thermal

Hydro

Gas

Thermal

Hydro

Gas

Thermal

Gas -Open Cycle

Y 4 4 10

Y 3 10B PLF/ Availability 3

A

Foreign Exchange -

Project Cost

B

Foreign Exchange - On

Cost of Generation

C

Change of Policies - Fuel

Supply

Tariff Risk

Levelised Tariff

Quality of Receivables

Payment Security

D

E

F

G

A

Natural

Calamity/Disaster

BNon-Natural: DirectPolitical

A Project Cost

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

483/519

Combined Cycle

Thermal

Gas

Combined Cycle

Thermal

IV. Financials

35 35

70:30

Y 7 7 10 10

> 1.5

Y 8 8 10 10

REC PLR +4%

Y 8 8 10 10

>18%

Y 6 6 10 10

60-70%

Y 6 6 10 10

Y 1 101

D Auxilary Consumption 1

1Y 1 10

Y 1 10

E

Secondary Fuel

Consumption

Average DSCR

IRR

Return on Equity

Break Even PLF (@ DSCR

=1)

Debt-Equity

C Heat Rate

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

484/519

Total Scored

5

5

15

Acquired at least 50%

of Requirement

Acquired at least 33%

of Requirement

Acquistion in progress

-Advances

Paid/Notification Not Yet Started

8 6 2 0 2

Applied for Stage 2

Clearance

Stage 1 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 1

Clearnce Not Yet Started

8 6 2 0 2

Low Risk Medium Risk High Risk Very High Risk

8 6 2 0 2

Above Average Average Below Average Poor

8 6 2 0 2

Applied for Stage 2

Clearance

Stage 1 Clearance

Issued

Applied for Stage 1

Clearnce Not Yet Started

8 6 2 0 1

Low Impact and Risk

Adequately

Addressed Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0 3

Low Impact and Risk

Adequately

Addressed Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0 2ow mpact an s

Adequately

Addressed Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0 1

18

Above Average Average Below Average Poor

Some Clearances are Still Pending

0

Grading

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

485/519

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

More than Required

for Capacity

Adequate for

Proposed Capacity

Less than Normative

Requirement Not Adequate8 6 2 0

Medium Impact Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0

Strong Medium Strength Weak Very Weak

8 6 2 0

High Average Low Very Low

8 6 2 0

Adequate for Life of

the Plant

Adequate for Medium

Term

Adequate only for

Short Term Not Adequate

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

10

Favorable Somewhat Favorable Unfavorable Highly Unfavorable

8 6 2 0

Signed PPAs for: 60-

70% of Capacity

Signed PPAs for: 50-

60% of Capacity

Signed PPAs for: 40-

50% of Capacity

Signed PPAs for:

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

486/519

Favorable Moderately Favorable Lowly Favorable Unfavorable

8 6 2 0

Good Average Below Average Poor

8 6 4 2

Good Average Below Average Poor

8 6 4 2

Above Average Average Below Average Poor

8 6 2 0

5

Medium Impact Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0

Medium Impact Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0

Medium Impact Average Impact High Impact Very High Impact

8 6 2 0

2

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

Reasonably Covered Medium Coverage Low Coverage Not Covered

8 6 2 0

10

4-5 Crores 5-6 Crores 6.0-6.5 Crores 6.5-7.0 Crores

10 8 6 4

6-7 Crores 7-8 Crores 8-8.5 Crores > 8.5 Crores

10 8 6 4

4-4.5 Crores 4.5-5.0 Crores 5-5.50 Crores > 5.50 Crores

10 8 6 4

>85% 70-85% 60-70% 60% 50-60% 40-50% 85% 75-85% 65-75%

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

487/519

10 8 6 4

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

488/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

489/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

490/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

491/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

492/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

493/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

494/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

495/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

496/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

497/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

498/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

499/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

500/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

501/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

502/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

503/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

504/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

505/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

506/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

507/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

508/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

509/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

510/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

511/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

512/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

513/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

514/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

515/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

516/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

517/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

518/519

7/31/2019 Appraisal Risk Matrix REC Crisil

519/519