Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002...

16
a .I .,_ ,’ .+ (. .. -I i I c ..I ,. : Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts For inspection purposes only. Consent of copyright owner required for any other use. EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Transcript of Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002...

Page 1: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

a

” .I .,_ ,’

.+ (.

.. -I

i I c ..I ,.

: Appendix’ L4.2

Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 2: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

Comparisun of phosphorus levels in nutrient management plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry

Iq-redients for spreading of sludge.

FOR

KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO. KERRY.

Contact: Sean Pender

Prepared by Cyril Browne October 2003

.

l .’ ̂ ‘:.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 3: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

received sIr?dge from Kerry Ingedieats under th.e Iandbazk management programmes 1999/‘2000 and 2001,‘2002.

A comparison of the 16 1 samples shotlin, shows that 52 samples had no change in index, 55 samples showed a.decrease in index ( tots1 drop in index = 601, while just 34 samples showed an increase in index ( total increase in index = 36). The net result of this comparative analysis therefore shows that there is an overall fall of 24 index points for phosphorous between the 1999/2000 Iandbank management programme and the 200 L’2002 landbank management programme.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 4: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 5: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

+lde ! Name j Address I Permanent

a

1 , ou.up’c I

; 09 j Tony 1 area no.

/ Greenville, j Carey

; 1

/ 09 I Tony / Listowel j Greenville,

I ; 7

1 ’ ! ̂ - j 5.6 12 j 3.2 i 2 ; 0

4 I

i 10 I L.&rev

,

1 Jack I Listowel

Carhoona, I / cal.-r011 Tarbert j3 / 1: i Syhie 1 Lisduff. I I

j Carroll j 11 j Syhie

! BalIyhe Lisdui?

I -7

/ brmll ( Ballyhe j Sylvie 1 Lisduff,

Carroll Jack Corridan

/ Ballyhorgan,

1 Jack j ~Listowel 1 Ballyhorgan.

- ! * 1 3.9 ;3 ’ :&hue 1 I f

j i

5.4 ;2 40 2

i 5.0

ighue I 2

i 4.7 ! 7 13 1 !-

jo /

)

Ballyhei_ghu / i 6.0 I ‘7 1 )- j 6.2

I 1 I I I3 / tl

I / 3.1 i 2 i I 2.6 j I j -1

/ 12 ! ConicIan / Listowel ! / Jack

I / Ballyhorgan. 1 3

I

7.7 j 3 /

5.6 / 2 /

I fhridan , - -- . . . ..&‘A

/ Jack 1 Baliyhorgan, j Cortidan

j Jack : Listowel j j Ballyhorgan. / 6 Listowel j - . . I 7

I Corridan ( / Jack i BaAyhorgan, ) Corridan 1 Lixnaw / ( Jack / Ballyhorgan, I Corridan I Lixnaw

i 8 I

I -I I

/ 5.8 i 7 -

j Jack j Ballyhorgan, I 9

; 12 i Corridan , i Jack / Ballyhorgan, i 10 I 5.2

1 15 I Lomdan 1 Batt

j Listowel i Ahaben.

i 15

: l<

! Dineen / Lixna; / Batt

1

/ Dineen ! Ahabeg, j Lixnaw

._ : - , t no.. I . / I I j aart j -Mabeg,

I 1 Dineen ! Lixnaw 15 1 Batt ,

/ Ahabeg, (

mF- -

; 16

. ! Dineen j Batt

j Lixnaw I4

1 Ahabeg, /5 I I

j 5.8 / I / 2 I ] -1 I I Dineen / Lixnaw I -

i Thomas i I I ! I

, Carrigafoyle, 1 j

! I

1 5.7 12 I / I 8.6 I

1 J I / ; G-1

i , I

Carrigafoyle. 1 4 / 5.0 i 2 I I 7.2 : : /

i - i t-1 _

: I,. I EnrIght 1 BaWongford 1 ! IO j Thomas j / 17

( Kevin Enright 1 Baliylongford /

j

1 Carhoona, / 3 Finucane /

I

Tarbert I ! 1.1 2 I I 3 j I

17 1 Kevin

i Carhoonay !

I

i FT...... i 4

.e Tarbert 1 -’ I rmucan

! 18 I -Martin

I i Foiey 1 18 I -Martin

! Foley

1 Glin Castle, i Tm4-m-t

/ Tarbert ’

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 6: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

! Code Name j no.

1 Address /

/ Permanent / Soil P test / SOil P

I ! I

I sample i Mg/kg j index ’ Soil P test j Soil P

area wb I index

’ Change in

0

7” no. A/

/ A$khael

j Kissane

i hamore, 2 4. 11 99%000 i 1999/2000 1 2001/2002 1 2001j2002 ’ index

i 27 ! Listowel

1 1 I 1

1

i ?I(:-L--I I r

j _ / 2. 4.7 j2 ‘0 I

! 27

I”LIc;Irdel I lKamGre7

' 3 K&sane / Listowel

/ 2.8 I . . . I i I

I Michael ) J.rra,more, -?. 14 ! I 7.5 /3

!r / 4.3 I ? / .Kman.e

I C.~ J Listowel

-- . ! feamus 1 Knockenagh, 1 1 I Lane / Listowel I c,,-...- IT, 3 . I-

! Lane I Llstowel 7.3 I 1

1 John I 3

I 0

j 29 Tarbert house, ! I

I Leslie Tar-bet-t 1 5.3 2 1 1 5.5 j2 /

! 0 29

i John

1

I j T-1. j

I

Tarbert.house, 2 1 3.3 Leslie Tarbert 2 / j 13.5 j 39 I-. i: 0

j JUIlll

/ ,

,_ i 4.:

I / Leslie

/ 1 arbert house, j 3 i Tarbert

3.7 12 29 ! T I

1 J0Il3-1 -

j 10 1 ,

I- I

j Tarbert house, / 5

i Leslie j Tarbert ( 3.4 1 12

i 0 I 7i-s Jr, . I !

i7

I ; JOllil :v /

Tarbert house, / 6

. . ( 8.1 j 3 i 4.5 / 1 i i -1

1 JUIIII

i Leslie 1 lamer-t house, / 8

, I Tarber .! / 7.5

I I - ! 19 ; John

I ! I ] Tarben house, ) 9 j 4.:

> J” 1 ray ) Ennismore, /2

j i Leslie I Tarbert

/ 1/-l in. I- , - j? / 5.9 ; 2 ; 0 j

j 5.6 12 I

/ 3 / -

: T(-) j6

i .? i McCarthy j ListoweI I I

/o ;

I ” I D-r 7- . I _ !

I ; IdL I IxJmsmore. / 3 I 9.3 ’ 3 I

i 2.j i 1

I 3” i McCarthv j Listowe / .~

, v I 3-l-L I

I I rat I_

-- ( Jz.rnsmore, ! MCUrthy ( Listowel

14 ; 6.5

j-i 1

i -

I ( /J : j 1.8 i 1 -2 1 ?A I n-A I- . / I I

I -) ! McCarthy / Listowe] I I ’ I 2.5

I j 1

I 1 -2

j I

i ?, i -I-. I 1 / ._ I I

; - / i xrcLVanon ( Lrxnaw

I 9.4 I I i 3 j Sl I : 31 77. I . I / I ,

! 4.2 12 J n I lim ! McMahon

1 ,Ahabeg East, ~-

! Listowel 1 4 j-5.2 12

, I I ”

/ Donal ,

/ / Mulvihill , Gortnaminch, / 3

I ! I Listowel

1 6.0 j2 : 2.7 I

I 1 I

; -1 I I 33 j Pat BaIlyline, 14

I I

) Yeville 1 Ballylongford ) j 4.3 12 i 7 I I I / ) j I +1

/ Liam 1 CIaanbrane, /Drum1 I

; ‘6 I

! MGyvane / 3. ; -I

: Nolan I I 2. j 1.8 : J j -J

I 3s I

j Liam / Claanbrane, / Drum2 I I j/

1 Nolan / 35 j Liam

j Moyvane , j 6.0 j 2 i 4 : 2 I I I 4

/o j

j Nolan / 6.0 I * IL

/ 35 yv j Liam

i(JyEene. ~Jhnn3 )

I

I Nolan j Claanbrane,

;q 12 i. /

I

j Liam j -hhy-+ae

! Drum4 (

; 5.0 I 2 I I 1 1 2.1 j 1 ! - ! /

I Yolan / Claanbrane, I

1 I

I ! Claan 1 i 6.2 i 7 I ; 3 I

: 35 ! Liarn j Moyvane !

/ 9.5 , i 3 !

j 0 / , I

( Nolan i CIaanbrane. I Mowane

j Chum2 1 5.6 !

I

12 159 ;j ;

i Ai I

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 7: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

1 Code 1 Address I Permanent Soil P test / S&l P 1 no. / sample *a / index

I area no. / E$LZOOO i 1999/2000 ’ 18 Martin

l I Glin Castle, ( 3 2

Foley Tarbert I ! I 18 Martin Glin Castle, i 4

Foley 1 Tarbert I 18

i Martin Glin Castle, 5 Foley Tarbert

IS Martin Glin Castle, 6 Foley Tarbert Martin Glin Castle, ’ 7 Foley , Tarbert

/ 1x i Martin GIin Castle, 1 Foley

13 Tarbert I

/ 18 Martin / Glin Castle, 1 9 Foley ’ Tarbert !

1 18 / j

-Martin ! Glin Castie, j 10 Foley Tarbert

1 19 I 1 I I

I Gerry I

Glenoe, !

i 1 I / Fuller I Listowel I

0 19 ’ Gen-y j Glenoe,

Fuller / Listowel i 3

I 20 I

1 I I

’ Thomas I Rathea, I ’ , Gaivin !- Listowel

121 ’ Liam / Greenville, I

j l(peat) I Healv ! Listowel 1

! 2 ’ 1 i Liam I 1 Greenville, [ 2(peat)

I 1 Healv 1 Listowei ; i 21 ! Liam 1 Greenville, / it

1 Heaiy I Listowel / / 71 ! - ) Liam 1 Greenville, j 6

( Healy ) Listowel ! 1 21 1 Liam I Greenville, / i Healy I Listowel ; 22 1 Noel I Coolanoonagh,

I Kane 1 Tarbert ; 22 j Noel I Coolanoonaghh, j 2 I

1 Kane 1 Tarbert I j y / -- I Noel

1 Kane I CooIanoonag4 1 3 1 Tarbert I

/ Michael I Keane

; - ' 34 / Michael I Dromerin j4 ; 2 ) i

I Keane I” I Listowel , 2 I Cl I I

I I I j I - ?4 j Michael ! Dromerin, / 5

i /

/ Keane j 3. ‘8 j 2

i Listowel ; 1.4 1 , j -1

I I ! ! I I I I 35 I 1 i- 1 Teddy I Slievecahili, j 1 / 7? ,

/ Keane I .w 3

/ Listowel / 8.5 3 I I 0

I I : 7< I I I 1

dd I Teddy i SFevecahill, i4 1 4.7 / ,

/ Keane 2 / I 1 / 1 Lk3towel

i 7.1 ! j / -kI /

! 7L; I f I i --’ / Teddy j Slievecahiil, 1 6 : 3.0 / 1 i 1

I Keane / Listowel i 2.5 I ! 2 1 -1 I , 1

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:13

Page 8: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

i Code Name 1 Address ’ Permanent no. /

I I sample Soil P test j &iii P Soil P test , SOit P j Change

, I area no. I wk / index w% Index / in

35

e:

I Liam j Nolan

j Claanbrane, j Claan4 1 1999/2000 ’ 1999/2000 ’ 2001/2002 2001/2002 / index i 6.0

/ Moyvane I 2. 3.9 p O I

! 7L I\rf-L~.l r-7.- . I -’ \ 1 11.6 2 , 3.2 ’ 1

1 77

1 w wnnen 1 aai3w ! - 1

I B,*,h,..., I l-x----:- 1 I

1 :?" I

! I u LOMof I kMlybumon I I I 1 2, In-. . I

jl.4 11. I

1-2 1 A ,41...-.. A I n

I7 i3 !O I

j COMOr \ ! I ;8

/ Listowel 4 t 3 -I j Deny0 1 Tulhnore, 4 i 6.0 2 i ( I 3.9 /o 1

I i Connor ) Listowel I I

/ jg 1 Derry 0 1 Tullamore, I

j 5 1

)

I I Listowel I 5.6 j2 I ? I

Connor j I A / 6.3 ! 3 j -t-l 1 I

* ;8 j Deny0

j 1 Listowel Tullamore, 1 i 6

/ I

8.3 i 7

/

I

j CoMor ! J 4.5 ! 2 -1 I

I !

39 1 ; j

/ I Desmond Glencullane, 1 i I

3 I ! 1 Tarbert ; 3.1 0 Connor I l- 1 2.8 ( 1 ) -1 i

; 30 1 I Desmond / Glencuilane. , / i ? / . ! 0 Connor j Tarbert

j I

2.5 I I

1 4.8 ] 2

i 3 9 i Desmond !

Glencuihne, ! I

i 1 3

jy j

1 8.5 ’ - , 0 Connor

/ Tarbert 13 9.3 I

3 i0 ,

I jg I %mond 1:

) Glencullane, ! L) Connor 1 Tarbert

1 5 I 5 I 2 l

I 7.7

,

~ksmond

1 I

Glencullane. i 6 !

/

,-. I 7 .,-.

! 39- Jonnor 1 Tarbert 1 / ! ” Desmond Glencullane, ) /

I 12 3.8 /2

I / /?

I I 4.1 ! rl

i 0 Connor 1 Tarbert I I I I i - i .^ I I .. 1 I : 4CJ I James0

:--

! Connor J ’ Farranpierce, j l(peat) / 7.1 j 1 / 8.3 j 1 : ) James0 BaIlybunion / ! i 1 - , Farranpierce,

1 / I 3 9.5

/ COMOr j I J

j 40 Ballybunion j I 110 I3

I !b I

I

j James 0

Farranpierce, I

3.4 1 Connor

\ I j1i ;JohO / Sallybunion

1 4 I2 / 9.4 I I

i j / 8

1 Glanasmol, / i / 1.7 1 1 I 4; connor i Baliyoneen, / I j ! L 7L / /

I / / / Lisselton ] I I

I ’ ! I ,

I / ! 9 , i j 1

I j 1 I?1 1 T / -1.2 ‘,. I I / !

i I

I / i : j ;

/ 41 i

; John 0 i Glanasmoi, I i 2

1 j COMOr 1 Ballyoneen. /

; Lisselton j I ! /

L Tl I

, /

.’

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 9: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

i Code 1 Name 1 Address I

Soil P test ( no.

j

j Permanent Sbil P sample mgflrg

j Soil P test I Soil P index

i area no. mg/kg 1 index

Change , in

John 0 ! Glanasmol, 3 1999/2000 1999J2000 2001/2002 / 2001/‘2002 index ,

1 COMOf

i 2 Ballyoneen, J I

1 I 2.5 ‘I

1 0

I ’ Lissklton I j 41 ! .3ohn 0 Glanasmol, I 4 ,

I.7

, [

Ballyoneen, j 1

Lisselton j 41 John 0 1 ’ - I

Glanasmoi, 2.7 Connor

1 1 Balivoneen, I

1 j

I 1 I Lissklton I I

! 4i ’ John0 I

! Glanasmol, 16 I / 5,s

I Connor BaSlyoneen, / I

i John0 / Lisselton

I

! 41 ’ Glanasmol, I I

/ 2.9 1 1 1 Connor Ballyoneen, 1 i7 j4 2 +1

Lisselton I

1 j John 0 I I 41 j

Ballyoneen, Glanasmol,

I

/ ’

!C 1 2

1

1 onnor j 1.6 ‘0

I j 1 I 1 I

I Lisseiton I j Donagh 0 Ballysheen, ’ r I 3 i Dowd I Abbeydomev I

I ’ Donagh 0 Ballysheen, , Dowd

/S Abbeydoumey j

i Donagh 0 ’ Ballysheen 19 1 Dowd Abbeydoukev 1 / Donagh 0 1 Ballysheen, I 11 , ; +4

i Dowd / Abbeydoumev I 3

I / 5.8 I 3 ! - : A.‘ - .-I 1 . ,

I Dowd i 45 / Michael

I Aiibeydoumey 1 1 Doonard

io

/ 1 I

I -1 I

j 44 ; Uonagh 0 j Ballysneen, j 12 j 4.7

! ’ Michael 0 Flynn / ! Doonard upper, Tarbert 1 / 3 / I I j - : 45 1 i ‘ 9.7 I I

I ! 0 Flynn i Tarbert 1 j upper,

! I 4.3 /2 j -1

i 45 j Michael I3

Doonard I ‘1 jOFlynn / upper, Tarbert

! 1 / j 3.8

I 6.7 1 3 1 2

1 I -1 I

1 46 j

gy$. 1 p;;;:: 1 1

i

1 9.4 / 13 1 6.9 T ,

q

i46 I ’ ! 0

1 Michael 1 Moybella,

I

! 0 Keefe Lisselton 12 /lo 13 ,j6

47 ’ Liam I i2 1-1

!

I j

Dromin, / 1 , 8.3

/ 8.2 j / I I

3 9 7 , Liam Regan Dromin Listowel 7.7 ,I I i 2 7 ] 3

/

1 Regan i Listowel

jo I

j I i j I ‘!

/ 5.4

1 /

1 3 / - I

!

I 48 i P.J.

I I

! Relihan / Bedford, / I ! 4.3 1 2

] 4s \ Listowel

i P.J. ] I

;5

1 Relihan ] Bedford, I

’ 2 1 8.4 I

j L&towel i \ 3

i / 3 I

i; :I’ j

j 3.4 ; ? I 1

j 48 / P.J. / Bedford,

) Relihan / Listowel

I 4.1

! / - 1 I I I

/ I2 ] 1.6 j 1

1 I

I -1 i

I /

j 38 j P.J. 1 Bedford,

i 4 I / ! ! ’

1 Relihan 2.5 I

b i Llstowel ) 7

: 32 1

/ 3.7 i I +1 !

/ Pat i Sheehan

/ Ballyiine,

/*

‘2 /

1

1 9.1

!

1 Ballylongford 3

/ 4.3 I j 2 I -1 ,

I

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 10: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

/ Code I I Name j Address Permanent ’ no. I , sample

1 Soii P test Sail P I SL.. _ cc~ I ma% index m* - I 1 v a 1 index 1 in j ’ / ) 1 area *, 52 no, Pat Sheehan I 1wmooo ! i Ballvlontiord Ballyline, I 1999/2000 3 I 2001/2002 j I 8.6 3 / j / 3.9 2001/2002 I 1 -1 index

, I - ‘I I2 I 1 54 ’ Pat 1 Laccamore,

7 8.6

1 I I I

Slattery 1 3 I 3.1

! 2 j -1 I 55

I /Mary Abbeydoumey 1 )

1 j Tram

1 Toomageehy, I

! 1

10.0

Listowel

i J 1

1 8.7 3.

I 1

0

55 I I / I

I I 34ai-y

Trant / j5

! 1 ~~~~hy’ 1 ’ / 4.1 12 5.8

Mary i

! Trant Toomageehy, ’ 3

j2 i” j Listowel /3.4 I2 ; 2.6 i 1 -1

; 32 ‘< / lvfary / I foomageehy, ! 4 / ? I 1 I Trant i I =. 9

1 i - A ’ 5.9

1 I / I Listowel 12 0

j 55 !

iMq 1 Toomageehy,

5 1

i 1 Trant j Listowel i 55

I /

lMary ’

/ Toomageehy,

j 6 / 3.7 (

I I- ? / 5.9 2 , I j 6.0

I 1” , 1

I i2 (3.1 j2 I0

4 Trant Listowel / , j 56 / Michael j Guhard /

I j Lisselton South, I j 1 8.0

/3

4.3 / 2 I ; 56

1 Walsh / Michael ’

/ / Walsh

; Fhard South: 1 / 2

0

! Llsselton /

.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 11: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

AhunTed

i\llman Bernard

BehanAidan

Behan Rlchard

Breen Edward

Broderick Patrick

Brosnan James

BuckleyBrendan

Buckley Willam

Byrne James

Daly John

Dowling Barnev

Egan Mairead

HO39001 HO39002 HO39003 HO39004 HO39005 HO39006 HO01001 H001002 HC02001 HOD2002 HO02003 HO02004 HO02005 HO02006 HO02007 HO02006 HO41001 HO41002 HO41003 HO41004 HO41005 HO41006 H04100T HO03001 HO03002 HC03003 HO03004 HO44001 HO44002 HO44003 HO44004 HO04001 HO04002 HO04003 HO04004 HO04005 HO04006 HD04007 HO04006 HO04009 H004010 HO07001 HO07002 HO07003 HO07004 HO07005 HO07006 HO07007 HO07006 HO07009 HO45001 HO45002 HO06001 HO08002 HO08003 HC08004 HOOPGOS HO06006 HO06007 HO46001 HO46002 HO46003 HO46004 HO46005 HO46006 HO46007 HGI 1001 HO11002 HO11003 HO11004 HO11005 H071006 HO11007 HO11008 HO1 1009 HO12001 HO12002 HO12003 HO12004 HO12005 HO12006 HC12007 H01201X

1 SAS 1 ggg 2000 5/G 5A i/3

5 Bil 2/2 517 9/l

11 418 716 8!2 l/5 916 3/6 if7

l/3 9/6 s/3 B/E;

2 13

217 416 ?5 25 20

4/a 3

14 12 15 12 11 IA 11

716 1119 419

1 8f7 814 i/3 15

519 419

i/6 2/6

3 5

15 11 12 11

116 13 416 3i-7 214 B/R 414 if7 S/6 6/T 92 816

6 11 ! 218 13

5 I!9 18 13

78 a/5 115 6/T 6/5 912 612 36 w/2 418 4w i/5 I/; i/7 ill 3t3 911 9/l 313 713

d Y/S 66 313 6/4 5/3 17

313 614 815 4/i 11 12 15.

2/a 7/9 4/a ii5

l/Z 5/4 3/6 915 l/3 616 91

6121 719 7w 3/G 3/6 4/3 315 l/6 i/6 714

2002

712 Lower Index 3tolndex i 713 NoChanae s/i Lower index2tolndex I 12 Htghcr Index 2tolndexd

813 Hlyher lndexltolndex2 15 Higher indexltoindex4

5/l Lower lndex3to Index 1 2/2 NoChange

Lower lndex4tolndex3 Lower Index3tolndex 1 Htgher lndex3tolndex4 Higher lndexltoIndex4 Higher lndex2tolndex4 Higher lndex3tolndex4 Higher lndex3tolndex4 Higher lndex3tolndex4 Higher lndex2tolndex4 NoChange Higher lndex2tolndex4 NoChange NoChange Lower lndex4tolndex3 Low?r lndex3tolndex2 Lower NoChange

,lndex3tolndex2

Lower lndex4tolndex3 Lower lndex4tolndex3

12 Higher lndex3tolndex4 415 tower lndex3tolndex2 8/4 Higher lndexltolndex2 713 NoChange

NoChange NoChange Higher lndex3tolndex4 NoChange Higher lndex2tolndex3 Higher Index2tolndex3 NoChange Higher Index 1 tolndex3 Higher lndex3tolndex4 Higher Index3tolndex4

8 INoChange 5/l Lower lndex3to Index1

1 Lower lndex4tolndex2 414 Lower lndex4to Index2 9/3 NoChange 6/l Lower lndex2tolndexl 514 Lower lndex3tolndex2 814 Lower lndex3tolndex2 812 Lower lndex2tolndexi 115 Higher lndexltolndex2 32 NoChange 614 Lower lndex3tolndex2

3 NoChange fi/l Lower lndex3tolndexi

2 Lower lndex3tolndexi 614 NoChanoe 6/3 Lower I- Index3tolndex; 914 Lower lndex3to Index2 9/5 Higher Index 1 to Index2 215 NoChange

4 Higher lndexltolndex2 Q/5 Higher lndexltolndex2 10 Higher Index 2to Index4

719 Higher lndex2to Index3 13 Higher lndexZtolndex4

Lower index 2tolndexi NoChange Higher lndex2tolndex3 NoChange NoChange Lower lndex4tolndex3 Lower lndex2tolndex1 Higher lndex2tolndex4 Higher lndex?tolndex3 NoChange Lower lndex4to Index3 Lower lndex4tolndex3 Lower lndex4to Index2 Lower lndex3tolndex2 NoChange No Change NoChange

.

. I

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 12: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

Galwn Aldan

Healy Sheila

tioliy Denis

HO12009 HO12010 HO12011 HO12012 H01300; HO1 3002 HO'I3003 HO13004 HO13005 HO!0001 f/15 HO1 0002 71:i HO10003 4110 HO10004 363 HO10005 7/a HO49001 HO49002 HO41001

Holly Mike HO41 007 HO11001 HO11002 HO11003 HOI1004 HO11005

Seamus Huni HOllb06 HO05001 HO05002 HO05003 HO05004 HO05005 HO05006 HO05007 HO05008

HO41002 HO41003 HO41004 HO41005 HO41006

Kissane Dick

HO05009 HO52001 HO52002 HO52003 HO52004 HO52005 HO52006 HO52007 HO52008 HO52009 HO17001

Klssane Edward

KlssaneJohn

Lynch Pat

H01iOo; HO17003 HO17004 HO17005 HO17006 HO17007 HO17008 HO53001 HO53002 HO53003 HO53004 HO54001 HO54002 HO54003 HO54004 HO21001 HO21002 HO21003 HO21004 HO21005 HO21006 HO21007 HO23001 HO23002 HO23003 HO23004 HO23005 HO23006 HO23007 HO23008 HO23009

McMahon David

HO23010 HO22001 HO22002 HO22003

j,2

s/7 35

5

2/l 412

1 111

811

28 :‘A

8iJ 11

517 3/i

3 5

15 20

417 518 618 3/i 4/d

l/IO

11 12

5i3 911

3 512 413 4/3 413 614 912 6/2 811 5/l

918 4i5 313 214 a2

3 412 w/F, 715 8A n3 3/5 516

7

9f2 93 2/4 312 112 aIt 5/i 911 612 515 713 x5 5/4 113 2/4 i/3 l/4 713

9/6 25 415 717 yJ/T

716 7

913 3/3 7R 32

815 2/G 914 21

l/9

i/2 811

3 2 1

513

412 413 3/8

5 816 l/2 !/3

St7 6/i 2/i

3 315 12 2G

ER II6

Higher Lower Lower Lower

I5 Higher 21 Higher 813 NoChange 116 Higher 213 Higher

LU"Ver Lower Lower NoChange

1 NoChange 211 NoChange 913 Lower 914 NoChange 912 Lower 5/3 NoChange 811 Lower 912 Lower 513 LO\Wi '

NoChange NoChange NoChange NoChange hlcchange

Inder. It0 Index? Index 3to Index 2 Index 2to Index 1 Index 2tolndex ' Index 3to Index 4 Index2tolnder4

lndex2to Index 3 lndexltolndex2 lndex4tolndex2 lndex4tolndex3 lndex4tolndex2

index4to Index 3

lndex3tolndex2

lndex2tolndexl

lndex2tolndexi index3tolndexl lndex3tolndex2

Higher lndexltolndex2 l/2 NoChange

2/i Lower Index2tolndex 1 R/l Lower 612 NoChange

lndex2tolndexl

414 Higher 5/2 NoChange

Index1 toIndex

815 Higher l/l NoChanae

Indexltolndex2

l/l NoChange 6/3 NoChange 814 NoChange 17 Higher Index2tolndex4 15 Higher lndex2tolndex4

5/G Higher lndex2tolndex3 115 NoChange 7/E Higher 7/6 Higher

lndex2tolndex3 lndex2tolndex3

15 Higher lndex2tolndex4 Lo\Wer lndex4tolndexi Lfitier lndex4tolndex2 Higher lndex2tolndex3 Lower lndexItolndex2 NoChange Lower lndex3tolndex 1 NoChange Htgher lndex2tolndex3 Lower lndex4tolndex2 Lower lndex4tolndex2 Lower lndex3tolndexl Lower lndex3tolndex2 Higher lndex3tolndex 4 Higher lndex3tolndex4 Lower lndex2tolndexi Lower lndex4tolndex3

812 Lower lndex3tolndexl 113 NoChange

814 NoChange 613 Lower 214 Lower

Index3toIndex:

713 Lower lndex3to Index2 lndex3tolndexZ

613 Lower lndex3tolndex2 14 NoChange IS NoChange

719 NoChange 11 Higher Index1 to Index 2 17 Higher Indexltolndex2

513 NoChange 317 NoChange 15 Higher lndex2iolndex4

4/4 NoChange 11 Higher lndex2tolndex4 15 Higher Index1 toIndex 10 Higher lndexltolndex2

513 NoChange 2i7 NoChange

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 13: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

McNamara Martin

McNamaraStaohen

Moran Gerard

Nolan Con

Nolan Liam

Nolan PJ

O'Emen Michael

O'Carrcll Maurice

oconnor Denls

O'Connor Larry

O’Connor Padralg

O'ConnorTom

Quilter Eugene

11022005 HO22006 HO22007 HGZOOR HO22003 HO22010 HO22011 HO24001 HO24002 HO24OD3 HO24004 HO24005 HO24006 HO24007 HO24008 HO24009 HO24010 HO25001 HO25002 HO25003 HO25004 HO25005 HO25006 HO25007 HO25008 HO25009 HO26001 HO26002 HO26003 HO26004 HO26005 HO26006 H0260Oi HO26008 H02800i HO28002 HO28003 HO28004 HO28005 HO28006 HO28007 HO16001 HO16002 HO16003 HO16004 HO16005 HO16006 HO1600i HO16008 HO15001 HO15002 HO15003 HO60001 HO60002 HO60003 HO50004 HO60005 HO61001 H06:002 HO61003 HO61004 HO61005 H031Wl HO31002 HO31003 HO31004 HO31005 HO31006 HO62001 HO62002 HO62003 HO62004 HO63001 H063G02 HO63003 HO63004 HO63005 HO63006 HO63007 HO17001 HO17002 HO33001 HO33002 HO33003

4/! 712

6 213 116 319 n/3 2/5 E/4 :/3 al2 6/2 315 616 8/2

3 5!a

7 i/6 2/4 11

l/6

712 3/7 519 ii3 2l2 3/Q 912

2 8/5 313 312 8/l 711 2/3 713 612 I5

5!4 01

317 a/5

s‘/lfi 413 6113

5:22

8 515

10 13

9/4 6 7

6/2 813 115 314

505 a

11 618 15 16

6 73 18

816 l/i 7/3

7/2 313 i/6 3/3 :/5 6/l l/8

3/i 6/l 512 313 5/l a/r 8/? 3ii l/2

2 22 113 413 l/4 i/6 114 513 412 i/2 l/3 SP +

11 a/5 114 22

3/4

917 6/9 4/8 w3 812 :5

617 9/2

18 Highei 2/5 NcChailge 9!6 No Change 35 NC Change

5 NoChange 6% NoChange 616 NoChange at2 ~0wer S/6 Higher 414 NoChange 415 NoChange 9/B Higher 912 NoChange 31 Lower 8/S NoChange 22 Higher

316 Higher l/6 No Change ii7 NoChange 6/i No Change 713 NoChange 412 Lower 711 Lower 5/z Lower 5/i NoChange 114 Lower 3/7 NoChange 10 NoChange

219 Higher 10 Higher 10 Higher 13 Higher

515 NoChange 614 NoChange

NoChsnge Higher Higher NoChange NoChange NoChange Lower LCWer NoChange Lcwer NoChange Lower Lower LCVEr Lower Lower Lower LOWS

18 Higher 22 Higher 15 Higher

319 NoChange l/9 NoChange 415 NoChange 14 Higher

6 Higher 13 Higher

i/6 Higher NoChange Lower NoChange Higher NoChange LCWer

214 Higher 6/2 Lower 514 NC Change S/8 Higher

Lower NoChange Lower NoChange LCWer NoChange NoChange Lower Lower

6 Lower 811 Lower 2i2 Lower

!r~dex 'i to Index 2

lndex2tclndexl lndex2tclndex3

Index itclndex3

IndexZtolndex 1

Index 1 to Index 2 lndexitclndex3

lndex4toIndexZ lndex3tc Index1 lndex2tolndexl

Index3tc Index2

lndexltolndex3 IndexZtclndexA Index ltolndex3 lndexitolndex3

lndexltolndex2 lndexltclndex3

lndex4tclndex3 lndex2tclndex:

lndex3tclndex i

Index 4tc Index 2 lndex2tclndexl lndex3tclndex 1 Index4tolndex3 lndex3tolndex 1 lndex3to Index 1 lndex2tolndex 1 Index2tolndex4 lndex2tolndex4 lndex2to index4

lndexltclndex4 Index ltolndex2 lndex2tc Index4 Index2tclndex3

lndex4tclndex2

lndex2tclndex4

Index 4tolndex2 Index1 to Index2 lndex2tclndexl

Index1 to Index3 lndex4tolndex3

lndex4tclndex3

lndex4tolndex2

lndex4tclndex2 lndex4tclndex 2 lndex3tcIndex: lndex3tclndexl lndex2tclndex 1

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 14: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

Qudter James

Quilter Maurice

Reldy Donal

Ryan John

Sheehan WIllam

Slattery Maurice

Stack John

Walshe John

Walshe Maurice

Wren John

HO33004 HO33005 HO33006 HO33007 HO33006 9033009 HO65001 c1065002 ‘1065003 HO85004 HO65005 HO65006 HO65007 HO65008 HO65009 HO66001 HO66002 HO66003 HO67001 HO67002 HO67003 HO67004 HO68001 HO68002 HO68003 HO6aoO4 HO21001 HO21002 HO21003 HO21004 HO21005 HO21006 HO21 007 HO21008 HO21009 HO34001 HO24002 HO34003 HO34004 HO34005 HO34006 HO22001 HO22002 HO22003 HO22004 HO22005 HO22006 HO22007 HO22008 HO36001 HO38002 HO38003 HO38004 HO38005 HO38006 HO38007 HO36001 HO36002 HO36003 HO36004 HO36005 HO36006 HOTlOOl HO71002 HO71 003

4t7 21-I

5 J/3 712 714 5/6 l/4 215 35

2l5 5;3 6/3 9/l

2

117 615

l/l2 2/19

916 48 38

9125 55

ii 18

2l9 14

2/9 13

29 9114 l/17 414 34

l/l8 5115 ?I12

3!T 6

8/E 10

5/9 818 315 10 15 10 19 29

2/a 615 10

25

412 315 414 514 3/3 4/6

4 2/3 413

713 613 3fi i/4 9/j 915 815 214 614 512 113

2i5 813 5/5 T/l 9/l 9/l l/i 711

4/7 513 813 10

6/4 418 12

415 17 17

3/7 716 18 13

.5/E; 213 i/5 8/5 813 313 612 34 10 15 11

3w 2/5 215 613 813

1 Lower Index 3 to Index 413 No Cnangb 812 Lower Index 2 to Index

3 Lower Index 2 to Index l/l No Cnange 615 No Change

Lower Index 3to Index 1 No Change No Change

Higher Index 1 to Index 2 No Charige

Htgher Index 2 to Index 3 No Change

Higher Index 1 to Index 2 Higher Index 1 to Index 2

913 No Change 614 No Chanoe 8/J Lower - Index 3 to Index 2 814 No Chance

- 2 Lower Index 2 to Index 1 2 Lower Index 2 to Index 1

912 Lower Index 2 to Index 1 2 Lower Index 2 to Index 1

l/2 Lower Index 2 to Index 1 1 NoChange

l/4 No Chanoe Lower I Index 3 to Index 2 No Chanae

- Lower Index 4 to Index 2 Lower Index 4 to Index 1 Lower Index 3 to Index 1 Lower Index 4 to Index 1 Lower Index 4 to Index 1 Lower Index 4 to Index 1 Lower Index 4 to Index 1 Lower Index 4 to Index 3 Lower Index 4 to Index 2 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower Index 4 to Index 3 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower index 4 to Index 3 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower Index 4 to Index 2 No Change Higher Index 2 to Index 4 Lower index 4 to Index 3 Lower Index 4 to Index 3 No Change No Change Lower Index 3 ia Index 2 No Change Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower Index 4 to Index 2 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 Lower Index 2 to Index 1 No Change No Change No Change No Change Lower Index 4 to Index 3 Lower Index 3 to Index 2 No Change ILower Index d to Index 2 No Change

A total of 315 permanent mi mnplm9 areas have been solled at least twice of these 316 5011 samples the ohosphate !ndices have been reduced over t,me ov

Of the soil samples that have shown an reducilon 23 % showed a reduction of Index 3 to Index 2 22 % showed a reduction of Index 2 to Index 1 17 % showed a reduction of Index 4 to Index 2 61% showed a reduction of one inaex

17% showed a reduction of Index 3 to Index 1 34% showed a reduction of 2 Indices

16% showed a reduction of Index 4 to Index 3 5% showed a reduction of 3 indices

5 % showed a reduction of Index 4 to Index 1

of the soil samples that showed an increase 29% showed an Increase of Index 1 to Index 2 26% showed an increase of Index 2 to Index 4 61% showed an increase of one Index

18% showed an increase of Index 2 to Index3 35% showed an increase of 2 indices

9% showed an increase sf Index 1 to Index 3 4X showed an increase of 3 indices

14% showed an Increase of Index3 to Index4 .4% showed an increase of Index 1 to Index 4

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 15: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

’ ‘i

“ ,

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14

Page 16: Appendix’ L4.2 Comparison of Phosphorus Levels ReDorts · plans t&en in 1999/2000 and 2001/2002 by Kerry Iq-redients for spreading of sludge. FOR KERRY INGREDIENTS, LISTOWEL, CO.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 25-07-2013:14:50:14