Apex Court Order Clarifies That Appeal and Complaint Made Under RTI Act Are Different Mechanisms...

8/11/2019 Apex Court Order Clarifies That Appeal and Complaint Made Under RTI Act Are Different Mechanisms With Differen

1/30

REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NOs.10787-10788 OF 2011

(Arising out of S.L.P(C) No.!"#$%!"#&'!)

C*i+f Infor,-tion Co,,r. -n Anot*+r ...A//+00-nt(s)

- Versus -

St-t+ of M-ni/ur -n Anot*+r ...R+s/on+nt(s)

J U D G M E N T

GANGULY, J.

. L+-1+ gr-nt+.

2. T*+s+ -//+-0s *-1+ 2++n fi0+ 23 t*+ C*i+f

Infor,-tion Co,,ission+r4 M-ni/ur -n on+ Mr.

5-*-ng2-, Jo36u,-r i,/ugning t*+ 7ug,+nt -t+

!&t* Ju03 ! /-ss+ 23 t*+ Hig* Court in 5rit

A//+-0 Nos. -n ! of !$ in 8onn+8tion 9it*

t9o 5rit P+tition No." of !" -n 5rit P+tition

1


2/30

No. :"$ of !". T*+ ,-t+ri-0 f-8ts gi1ing ris+ to

t*+ 8ontro1+rs3 in t*is 8-s+ 8-n 2+ su,,-ri;+ -s

fo00o9s -s

8ont-in+ in Arti80+ &()(-) of t*+ Constitution

of Ini- -n -0so *+0 t*-t rig*t to infor,-tion

is +finit+03 - fun-,+nt-0 rig*t. In 8o,ing to

t*is 8on80usion4 t*is Court tr-8+ t*+ origin of

t*+ s-i rig*t fro, t*+ Uni1+rs-0 D+80-r-tion of

Hu,-n Rig*ts4 &:$ -n -0so Arti80+ & of t*+

Int+rn-tion-0 Co1+n-nt on Ci1i0 -n Po0iti8-0

Rig*ts4 9*i8* 9-s r-tifi+ 23 Ini- in &"$. T*is

Court -0so foun - si,i0-r +nun8i-tion of

/rin8i/0+ in t*+ D+80-r-tion of Euro/+-n

Con1+ntion for t*+ Prot+8tion of Hu,-n Rig*ts

8


9/30

(&) -n foun t*-t t*+ s/irit of t*+ Uni1+rs-0

D+80-r-tion of &:$ is +8*o+ in Arti80+ &()(-)

of t*+ Constitution. (S++ /-r-s :4 :# :" -t

/-g+ :& of t*+ r+/ort)

#. T*+ ++r8is+ of 7ui8i-0 is8r+tion in f-1our of

fr++ s/++8* is not on03 /+8u0i-r to our

7uris/ru+n8+4 t*+ s-,+ is - /-rt of t*+

7uris/ru+n8+ in -00 t*+ 8ountri+s 9*i8* -r+

go1+rn+ 23 ru0+ of 0-9 9it* -n in+/+n+nt

7ui8i-r3. In t*is 8onn+8tion4 if 9+ ,-3 ?uot+

9*-t Lor A8ton s-i in on+ of *is s/++8*+s

". It is4 t*+r+for+4 80+-r t*-t - so8i+t3 9*i8*

-o/ts o/+nn+ss -s - 1-0u+ of o1+r-r8*ing

signifi8-n8+ not on03 /+r,its its 8iti;+ns - 9i+

r-ng+ of fr++o, of +/r+ssion4 it -0so go+s

9


10/30

furt*+r in -8tu-003 o/+ning u/ t*+ +0i2+r-ti1+

/ro8+ss of t*+ @o1+rn,+nt its+0f to t*+ sun0ig*t

of /u20i8 s8rutin3.

$. Justi8+ Fr-n6furt+r -0so o/in+ T*+ f0-g is t*+ s3,2o0 of ourn-tion-0 unit34 tr-ns8+ning -00 int+rn-0iff+r+n8+s4 *o9+1+r 0-rg+4 9it*in t*+fr-,+9or6 of t*+ Constitution.>

&. A8tu-003 t*+ 8on8+/t of -8ti1+ 0i2+rt34 9*i8* is

stru8tur+ on fr++ s/++8*4 ,+-ns s*-ring of -

n-tions so1+r+ign -ut*orit3 -,ong its /+o/0+.

So1+r+ignt3 in1o01+s t*+ 0+giti,-83 of -

go1+rn,+nt-0 -8tion. An - s*-ring of so1+r+ign

-ut*orit3 sugg+sts inti,-t+ 8orr+0-tion 2+t9++n

t*+ fun8tioning of t*+ @o1+rn,+nt -n 8o,,on ,-ns

6no90+g+ of su8* fun8tioning.

(Active Liberty by Stephen Breyer page 15)

10


11/30

!. Ho9+1+r4 9*i0+ 8onsi+ring t*+ 9it* -n s9++/ of

t*is rig*t -s 9+00 -s its fun-,+nt-0 i,/ort-n8+

in - +,o8r-ti8 r+/u20i84 t*is Court is -0so

8ons8ious t*-t su8* - rig*t is su27+8t to

r+-son-20+ r+stri8tions un+r Arti80+ &(!) of t*+

Constitution.

21. T*us not+ of 8-ution *-s 2++n soun+ 23 t*is

Court in D()esh T%(e&(, M.P. * O!he%s1. U)(#) #$

I)&(" * #!he%s (&&") : SCC # 9*+r+ it *-s

2++n *+0 -s fo00o9s

11


12/30

(/-r- &4 /-g+ :)

!!. T*+ A8t *-s si C*-/t+rs -n t9o S8*+u0+s. Rig*t

to Infor,-tion *-s 2++n +fin+ un+r S+8tion !(7)

of t*+ A8t to ,+-n -s fo00o9s ,+-ns t*+ rig*t to

infor,-tion -88+ssi20+ un+r t*is A8t 9*i8* is

*+0 23 or un+r t*+ 8ontro0 of -n3 /u20i8-ut*orit3 -n in80u+s t*+ rig*t to%

(i) ins/+8tion of 9or64 o8u,+nts4 r+8ors

(ii) t-6ing not+s4 +tr-8ts4 or 8+rtifi+

8o/i+s of o8u,+nts or r+8ors

(iii) t-6ing 8+rtifi+ s-,/0+s of ,-t+ri-0

(i1) o2t-ining infor,-tion in t*+ for, of

is6+tt+s4 f0o//i+s4 t-/+s4 1i+o 8-ss+tt+s or

in -n3 ot*+r +0+8troni8 ,o+ or t*roug*

/rintouts 9*+r+ su8* infor,-tion is stor+ in -

8o,/ut+r or in -n3 ot*+r +1i8+>

!. Rig*t to Infor,-tion *-s -0so 2++n st-tutori03

r+8ognis+ un+r S+8tion of t*+ A8t -s fo00o9s

35. T*+ /ro8+ur+ for *+-ring t*+ -//+-0s *-1+ 2++n

fr-,+ in ++r8is+ of /o9+r un+r 80-us+s (+) -n

(f) of su2%s+8tion (!) of S+8tion !" of t*+ A8t.

T*+3 -r+ 8-00+ t*+ C+ntr-0 Infor,-tion Co,,ission

(A//+-0 Pro8+ur+) Ru0+s4 !. T*+ /ro8+ur+ of

21


22/30

+8iing t*+ -//+-0s is 0-i o9n in Ru0+ of t*+

s-i Ru0+s.

T*+r+for+4 t*+ /ro8+ur+ 8ont+,/0-t+ un+r

S+8tion $ -n S+8tion & of t*+ s-i A8t is

su2st-nti-003 iff+r+nt. T*+ n-tur+ of t*+ /o9+r

un+r S+8tion $ is su/+r1isor3 in 8*-r-8t+r

9*+r+-s t*+ /ro8+ur+ un+r S+8tion & is -n

-//+00-t+ /ro8+ur+ -n - /+rson 9*o is -ggri+1+

23 r+fus-0 in r+8+i1ing t*+ infor,-tion 9*i8* *+

*-s soug*t for 8-n on03 s++6 r+r+ss in t*+ ,-nn+r

/ro1i+ in t*+ st-tut+4 n-,+034 23 fo00o9ing t*+

/ro8+ur+ un+r S+8tion &. T*is Court is4

t*+r+for+4 of t*+ o/inion t*-t S+8tion " r+- 9it*

S+8tion & /ro1i+s - 8o,/0+t+ st-tutor3 ,+8*-nis,

to - /+rson 9*o is -ggri+1+ 23 r+fus-0 to r+8+i1+

infor,-tion. Su8* /+rson *-s to g+t t*+

infor,-tion 23 fo00o9ing t*+ -for+s-i st-tutor3

/ro1isions. T*+ 8ont+ntion of t*+ -//+00-nt t*-t

infor,-tion 8-n 2+ -88+ss+ t*roug* S+8tion $ is

8ontr-r3 to t*+ +/r+ss /ro1ision of S+8tion & of

t*+ A8t. It is 9+00 6no9n 9*+n - /ro8+ur+ is 0-i

o9n st-tutori03 -n t*+r+ is no 8*-00+ng+ to t*+

22


23/30

s-i st-tutor3 /ro8+ur+ t*+ Court s*ou0 not4 in

t*+ n-,+ of int+r/r+t-tion4 0-3 o9n - /ro8+ur+

9*i8* is 8ontr-r3 to t*+ +/r+ss st-tutor3

/ro1ision. It is - ti,+ *onour+ /rin8i/0+ -s

+-r03 -s fro, t*+ +8ision in T"3#% 1. T"3#%

($"#) C*. D. :!#K t*-t 9*+r+ st-tut+ /ro1i+s

for so,+t*ing to 2+ on+ in - /-rti8u0-r ,-nn+r it

8-n 2+ on+ in t*-t ,-nn+r -0on+ -n -00 ot*+r

,o+s of /+rfor,-n8+ -r+ n+8+ss-ri03 for2i+n.

T*is /rin8i/0+ *-s 2++n fo00o9+ 23 t*+ Jui8i-0

Co,,itt++ of t*+ Pri13 Coun8i0 in N"9(% Ah/"& 1.

E/e%#% AIR PC !()K -n -0so 23 t*is

Court in Dee Ch")&1. !"!e #$ R"'"s!h") AIR

SC !"4 (/-r- &)K -n -0so in !"!e #$ U.P.

1. ()h"%" ()h r+/ort+ in AIR : SC $

(/-r- $).

#. T*is Court -88+/ts t*+ -rgu,+nt of t*+ -//+00-nt

t*-t -n3 ot*+r 8onstru8tion 9ou0 r+n+r t*+

/ro1ision of S+8tion &($) of t*+ A8t tot-003

r+un-nt. It is on+ of t*+ 9+00 6no9n 8-nons of

int+r/r+t-tion t*-t no st-tut+ s*ou0 2+

23


24/30

int+r/r+t+ in su8* - ,-nn+r -s to r+n+r - /-rt

of it r+un-nt or sur/0us-g+.

". 5+ -r+ of t*+ 1i+9 t*-t S+8tions $ -n & of t*+

A8t s+r1+ t9o iff+r+nt /ur/os+s -n 0-3 o9n t9o

iff+r+nt /ro8+ur+s -n t*+3 /ro1i+ t9o

iff+r+nt r+,+i+s. On+ 8-nnot 2+ - su2stitut+

for t*+ ot*+r.

38. It ,-3 2+ t*-t so,+ti,+ in st-tut+ 9ors -r+ us+

23 9-3 of -2un-nt 8-ution. T*+ s-,+ is not t*+

/osition *+r+. H+r+ - 8o,/0+t+03 iff+r+nt

/ro8+ur+ *-s 2++n +n-8t+ un+r S+8tion &. If

t*+ int+r/r+t-tion -1-n8+ 23 t*+ 0+-rn+ 8ouns+0

for t*+ r+s/on+nt is -88+/t+ in t*-t 8-s+

S+8tion & 9i00 2+8o,+ un9or6-20+ -n +s/+8i-003

S+8tion &($) 9i00 2+ r+n+r+ - sur/0us-g+. Su8*

-n int+r/r+t-tion is tot-003 o//os+ to t*+

fun-,+nt-0 8-nons of 8onstru8tion. R+f+r+n8+ in

t*is 8onn+8tion ,-3 2+ ,-+ to t*+ +8ision of

t*is Court in As5()( :+/"% Gh#se ")& ")#!he% 1.

A%"6()&" B#se ")& ")#!he% AIR &! SC #&. At

24


25/30

/-g+ "" of t*+ r+/ort C*i+f Justi8+ P-t-n7-0i

S-stri *- 0-i o9n.

39. S-,+ 9-s t*+ o/inion of Justi8+ J-g-nn-*--s in

R"# h( B"h"&+% ()h ")& ")#!he% 1. !"!e #$

U.P. AIR & SC &: -t /-g+ &".

40. Justi8+ D-s @u/t- in J.:. C#!!#) ())() *

;e"() M(33s C#. L!&. 1. !"!e #$ U!!"% P%"&esh

")& #!he%s AIR SC " -t /-g+ ":

1irtu-003 r+it+r-t+ t*+ s-,+ /rin8i/0+s in t*+

fo00o9ing 9ors.

25


26/30

41. It is 9+00%6no9n t*-t t*+ 0+gis0-tur+ o+s not

9-st+ 9ors or s-3 -n3t*ing in 1-in or for no

/ur/os+. T*us - 8onstru8tion 9*i8* 0+-s to

r+un-n83 of - /ortion of t*+ st-tut+ 8-nnot 2+

-88+/t+ in t*+ -2s+n8+ of 8o,/+00ing r+-sons. In

t*+ inst-nt 8-s+ t*+r+ is no 8o,/+00ing r+-son to

-88+/t t*+ 8onstru8tion /ut for9-r 23 t*+

r+s/on+nts.

:!. A/-rt fro, t*-t t*+ /ro8+ur+ un+r S+8tion & of

t*+ A8t4 9*+n 8o,/-r+ to S+8tion $4 *-s s+1+r-0

s-f+gu-rs for /rot+8ting t*+ int+r+st of t*+

/+rson 9*o *-s 2++n r+fus+ t*+ infor,-tion *+ *-s

soug*t. S+8tion &()4 in t*is 8onn+8tion4 ,-3 2+

r+f+rr+ to. S+8tion &() /uts t*+ onus to

7ustif3 t*+ +ni-0 of r+?u+st on t*+ infor,-tion

offi8+r. T*+r+for+4 it is for t*+ offi8+r to

7ustif3 t*+ +ni-0. T*+r+ is no su8* s-f+gu-r in

S+8tion $. A/-rt fro, t*-t t*+ /ro8+ur+ un+r

S+8tion & is - ti,+ 2oun on+ 2ut no 0i,it is

26


27/30

/r+s8ri2+ un+r S+8tion $. So out of t*+ t9o

/ro8+ur+s4 2+t9++n S+8tion $ -n S+8tion &4 t*+

on+ un+r S+8tion & is ,or+ 2+n+fi8i-0 to -

/+rson 9*o *-s 2++n +ni+ -88+ss to infor,-tion.

:. T*+r+ is -not*+r -s/+8t -0so. T*+ /ro8+ur+ un+r

S+8tion & is -n -//+00-t+ /ro8+ur+. A rig*t of

-//+-0 is -09-3s - 8r+-tur+ of st-tut+. A rig*t of

-//+-0 is - rig*t of +nt+ring - su/+rior foru, for

in1o6ing its -i -n int+r/osition to 8orr+8t

+rrors of t*+ inf+rior foru,. It is - 1+r3

1-0u-20+ rig*t. T*+r+for+4 9*+n t*+ st-tut+

8onf+rs su8* - rig*t of -//+-0 t*-t ,ust 2+

++r8is+ 23 - /+rson 9*o is -ggri+1+ 23 r+-son

of r+fus-0 to 2+ furnis*+ 9it* t*+ infor,-tion.

In t*-t 1i+9 of t*+ ,-tt+r t*is Court o+s not

fin -n3 +rror in t*+ i,/ugn+ 7ug,+nt of t*+

Di1ision B+n8*. In t*+ /+nu0ti,-t+ /-r-gr-/* t*+

Di1ision B+n8* *-s ir+8t+ t*+ Infor,-tion

Co,,ission+r4 M-ni/ur to is/os+ of t*+ 8o,/0-ints

of t*+ r+s/on+nt no.! in -88or-n8+ 9it* 0-9 -s

+/+itious03 -s /ossi20+.

27


28/30

::. T*is Court4 t*+r+for+4 ir+8ts t*+ -//+00-nts to

fi0+ -//+-0s un+r S+8tion & of t*+ A8t in

r+s/+8t of t9o r+?u+sts 23 t*+, for o2t-ining

infor,-tion 1i+ -//0i8-tions -t+ &.!.!" -n

&..!" 9it*in - /+rio of four 9++6s fro,

to-3. If su8* -n -//+-0 is fi0+ fo00o9ing t*+

st-tutor3 /ro8+ur+ 23 t*+ -//+00-nts4 t*+ s-,+

s*ou0 2+ 8onsi+r+ on ,+rits 23 t*+ -//+00-t+

-ut*orit3 9it*out insisting on t*+ /+rio of

0i,it-tion.

:. Ho9+1+r4 on+ -s/+8t is sti00 r+?uir+ to 2+

80-rifi+. T*is Court ,-6+s it 80+-r t*-t t*+

notifi8-tion -t+ ..! 9*i8* *-s 2++n

2roug*t on r+8or 23 t*+ 0+-rn+ 8ouns+0 for t*+

r+s/on+nt 1i+ I.A. No. of ! *-s 2++n /+rus+

23 t*+ Court. B3 1irtu+ of t*+ s-i notifi8-tion

issu+ un+r S+8tion !: of t*+ A8t4 t*+ @o1+rn,+nt

of M-ni/ur *-s notifi+ t*+ ++,/tion of 8+rt-in

org-ni;-tions of t*+ St-t+ @o1+rn,+nt fro, t*+

/ur1i+9 of t*+ s-i A8t. T*is Court ,-6+s it 80+-r

28


29/30

t*-t t*os+ notifi8-tions 8-nnot -//03

r+tros/+8ti1+03. A/-rt fro, t*-t t*+ s-,+

++,/tion o+s not 8o1+r -00+g-tions of 8orru/tion

-n *u,-n rig*t 1io0-tions. T*+ rig*t of t*+

r+s/on+nts to g+t t*+ infor,-tion in ?u+stion

,ust 2+ +8i+ on t*+ 2-sis of t*+ 0-9 -s it

stoo on t*+ -t+ 9*+n t*+ r+?u+st 9-s ,-+. Su8*

rig*t 8-nnot 2+ +f+-t+ on t*+ 2-sis of -

notifi8-tion if issu+ su2s+?u+nt03 to ti,+ 9*+n

t*+ 8ontro1+rs3 -2out t*+ rig*t to g+t infor,-tion

is /+ning 2+for+ t*+ Court. S+8tion !: of t*+ A8t

o+s not *-1+ -n3 r+tros/+8ti1+ o/+r-tion.

T*+r+for+4 no notifi8-tion issu+ in ++r8is+ of

t*+ /o9+r un+r S+8tion !: 8-n 2+ gi1+n

r+tros/+8ti1+ +ff+8t -n +s/+8i-003 so in 1i+9 of

t*+ o27+8t -n /ur/os+ of t*+ A8t 9*i8* *-s -n

in*+r+nt *u,-n rig*t 8ont+nt.

:#. T*+ -//+-0s 9*i8* t*+ r+s/on+nts *-1+ 2++n gi1+n

0i2+rt3 to fi0+4 if fi0+ 9it*in t*+ ti,+

s/+8ifi+4 9i00 2+ +8i+ in -88or-n8+ 9it*

S+8tion & of t*+ A8t -n -s +-r03 -s /ossi20+4

29


30/30

/r+f+r-203 9it*in t*r++ ,ont*s of t*+ir fi0ing.

5it* t*+s+ ir+8tions 2ot* t*+ -//+-0s -r+

is/os+ of.

:". T*+r+ 9i00 2+ no or+r -s to 8osts.

.......................J.

(ASO UMAR @AN@UL)

.......................J.

N+9 D+0*i (@AN SUDHA MISRA)

D+8+,2+r !4 !

Apex Court Order Clarifies That Appeal and Complaint Made Under RTI Act Are Different Mechanisms...

Documents

Transcript of Apex Court Order Clarifies That Appeal and Complaint Made Under RTI Act Are Different Mechanisms...