8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

1/9Missio Immaculat International | September/October 2014 | 11

Mary in the Writings of the Saints

THE IMPORTANCE OF SAINT ANSELM OF

CANTERBURY FOR SCOTUS DEFENSE OFTHE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION

by J. Isaac Goff

!!"#$ '()* +, -!#$(./0.1 234556

33478 "' ! 9(1 ,":0.( "# $;( ;"'$+.1

+, $;( **!=0)!$( -+#=(?$"+#@ R;"' (''!1

O")) $!9( ! )++9 !$ $;( "*?+.$!#$ .+)(

$;( F(#(>>E (990.("0/0 8(*:

.#A2(*#2-"$$!

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

2/912| September/October 2014 | Missio Immaculat International

"#'$!#$ +, ;(. (P"'$(#=(@5

H(A+$"+# $+ $;( ,(!'$ +, Q!.1D'-+#=(?$"+# "#=.(!'(< "# X#:)!#990.,"0/# 8(*.#H/2(*7 12$/(46 0*% -25:

*2;2.0*.#E (

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

3/9Missio Immaculat International | September/October 2014 | 13

,(#**!=0)!$( -+#6

=(?$"+#h :.(!$ *1'$(.1 +, ,!"$;@\34V(;)6

#(. ,0.$;(. '$!$(' $;!$ I$@ '()* "'

=+#'"**!=0)!$(

N F!)"=E [R;( Q(**!=0)!$( -+#=(?6$"+#E\ "# 3042("(567 D K,2%# ;(4 M42#$/N +#0:

.(*$N -#92*0420*$ 0*% 8(*$#.40/#% M#4$(*$E

(**!=0)!$( -+#=(?6

$"+#k "#$+k ?+O(.,0) !.:0*(#$ "# "$'

!#< /"/)"+:.!?;"(' +# /+$; I=+$0' !#E =@ 3K 2I=;*"$$E JE

33K8^ []!* )"=($ "?'! ;+*"#"' ("0'

)(=$!$"+#"' ?(==!$+E A".:+ $!*(# "?'! 0## ;"' (!.)"(. $.(!$6

*(#$' +, $;( '0/Y(=$ +, Q!.1D' =+#=(?6

$"+# I=+$0' !$$(*?$' $+ (P?)!"# !O!1 $;"'

+/Y(=$"+# +# $;( /!'"' $;!$ "# $;( S0+$(

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

4/914| September/October 2014 | Missio Immaculat International

># !

)+O"#: $;( )+'' +, +.":"#!) Y0'$"=( "' [)(:!))1

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

5/9Missio Immaculat International | September/October 2014 | 15

Stained glass window from the Church of

Our Lady and the English Martyrs (OLEM)in Cambridge, England.

#(O *(*/(. +, $;( +,,(#

,!*")1 $+ +,,(. '+*($;"#: *+.( ?)(!'6

"#: !#< :.!="+0' $+ $;( 9"#: $;!# $;(

+.":"#!) +,,(#'(@ >, '0=; !# "##+=(#$

?(.'+# !==+*?)"';(< $;"' !=$E I=+$0'

!A(.' $;!$ $;"' O+0)< /( '0,,"="(#$ ,+.

$;( 9"#: $+ +A(.$0.# ;"' ?."+. !#1 *!##(.^ "@(@E $;.+0:; +.":"#!) +.!=$0!) '"#@

I=+$0' ?.+A"

)(#$ *!##(. "# O;"=; Q!.1 "' .(=6

+#=")(< $+ c+#=!.#!$"+# !#< (#;!#=('

.(:!.< ,+. j"*@57

># $;( ,".'$ ?.++,E I=+$0' !''(.$'

$;!$ ! $.0)1 *+'$ ?(.,(=$ !#< (P=())(#$

*(

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

6/916| September/October 2014 | Missio Immaculat International

O"$;+0$ +.":"#!) '"# !=$0!))1 *!#",('$'

-;."'$ *($"A()1 +. "#$(#'"A()1@UK

HOWMARYCOULDHAVEBEEN

CONCEIVEDWITHOUTORIGINAL

SINGIVENNATURALGENERATION:

SCOTUS REBUTTAL!"$%&'%$

!&(%)$*

T( #+O $0.# $+ I=+$0'D .('?+#'(

$+ $;( !.:0*(#$ !,,".*"#: Q!.1D' =+#6

=(?$"+# "# +.":"#!) '"#E O;"=; '$!$('$;!$ Q!.1 *0'$ ;!A( /((# =+#=("A(**!=0)!$( -+#=(?$"+#E +# $;( /!'"'

+, '()*D' )+=!$"#: +, +.":"#!) Y0'$"=(

!#< '"# (P=)0'"A()1 O"$;"# $;( O"))E !#**!=0)!$( -+#=(?$"+#E

O;(# ;( '!1' $;!$ ["$ O!' ,"$$"#: $;!$

$;"' `".:"# ';+0)< ';"#( O"$; ! ?06

."$1 '+ :.(!$E $;!$E (P=(?$ ,+. c+**!=0)!$( -+#=(?$"+# "# $;(

Q4%2*0/2(@ R;(.("# I=+$0' '$!$(' $;!$

"$ '((*' ?.+/!/)( $;!$ O;!$ "' *+.(

#E.#""#*/';+0)< /( !$$."/0$(< $+ Q!.1@

V+))+O"#: $;( '$!$(*(#$ +, ;"'

+?"#"+#E I=+$0' :+(' +# $+ .(?)1 $+

$;( !0$;+."$"(' )"'$(< !$ $;( /(:"##"#:

+, $;( S0('$"+#@ I=+$0' :.!#$' $+ $;(!0$;+."$"(' $;!$ "$ "' $;( =!'( $;!$ #

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

8/918| September/October 2014 | Missio Immaculat International

=;")< +, &

!*D' O")),0)

$;(;24$/ 2*$/0*/+, $;( =.(!$"+# +, ! #(O

'+0)E :.!=( =+0)< /( "#,0'(# =;!?$(. '(A(# +, $;( '!*(

$.(!$"'(E O;(#

># ;"' .(?)1 $+ $;( ,".'$ +/Y(=$"+#EI=+$0' !:!"# :.!#$' ;"' +??+#(#$'D

?.(*"'( !,,".*"#: $;( 0#"A(.'!)"$1 +,

-;."'$D' *(

+, #!$0.(E Q!.1E $#.,*%,9 V,2%E +0:;$E

/1 A".$0( +, ;(.

*!# .!=( #((< #+$ !#J2%@

K5 T+)$(.E =(,4 L,#$/2(*$ (* 3046E UUE UK6_@

#+$ (P$(#< $+ ! *+.!) ;(!

$;(

#+ *+.!) ;(!

"(' !.( +.":"#!) '"# !#< +.":"#!) Y0'$"=(!## $;( +.# "

8/10/2019 Anselm Scotus Immaculate Conception

9/9| |

$;( ,.((# $;( ,"#!) '(=$"+# +, ;"' $.(!$6

*(#$ +, $;( S0('$"+#E I=+$0' :"A('

'?(="!) !$$(#$"+# $+ I$@ F(.#!.J2%@E UNE L3@

#!.

$;.+0:; $;('(E "' !/)( $+ !,,".* $;(

>**!=0)!$( -+#=(?$"+#@ R;.+0:;

I=+$0'E '()* '$")) "#,)0(#=(' !#