Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to...

112
Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers 445 Hoes Lane Piscataway, NJ 08854 USA Report prepared by: Anthony Breitzman, Ph.D. 1790 Analytics LLC 130 Haddon Avenue Haddonfield, NJ 08033 www.1790analytics.com 3 May 2014

Transcript of Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to...

Page 1: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences,

and Standards 1997-2013

Report prepared for:

Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers

445 Hoes Lane

Piscataway, NJ 08854 USA

Report prepared by:

Anthony Breitzman, Ph.D.

1790 Analytics LLC

130 Haddon Avenue

Haddonfield, NJ 08033

www.1790analytics.com

3 May 2014

Page 2: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Executive Summary

IEEE engaged 1790 Analytics in this project to assess the impact of IEEE publications on

developments in various technologies. This impact is measured by examining the extent

to which patented inventions build upon papers from IEEE journals, IEEE-sponsored

conferences, and IEEE standards. This is an update of previous reports, and examines

patents issued from January 1, 1997 through December 31, 2013.

The main findings of this report are:

New technology continues to build upon science, and the dependence is increasing.

When we did a similar study last year, we found that the top 40 companies were

granted 92,152 patents in 2012. These patents made a total of 371,910 non-patent

references, an average of 4.04 non-patent references per patent. In this study, the

top 40 firms were granted 70,839 patents, which patents made a total of 386,215

non-patent references (an average of 5.45 non-patent references per patent). Thus,

we continue to see the number of non-patent references trending upward. Since a

large number of these non-patent references are to scientific articles and conference

papers, this suggests that today’s technology developments are increasingly linked

to developments in published science.

A large portion of this science base comes from papers presented at IEEE sponsored

conferences and published in IEEE journals. The top 40 patenting firms in 2013

have referenced over 961,385 articles in the last 17 years. About 31% (300,280) of

those articles appeared in IEEE journals or IEEE sponsored conferences.

In this study, we also went beyond the top 40 patenting companies and analyzed all

patents from the last 17 years in several technology categories of interest to IEEE

members and customers. For example, approximately 35% of all scientific

references from Computer Hardware patents go to IEEE publications. The second

most referenced publisher is ACM (Association for Computer Machinery) with 17

% of the referenced publications. In other Information Technology areas, such as

Information Storage, Semiconductor Manufacturing, and Computer Software, the

results are similar.

In Telecommunications technology, IEEE is particularly important. The 302,000+

references to IEEE articles and conferences represent almost half of all science

references from Telecommunications patents since 1997. To help put this in

perspective consider: Telecommunications is a very technology driven industry and

that technology is often built upon scientific discoveries published in journal and

conference papers. If we consider this set of papers as the science base of

telecommunications, than roughly half of that science base is published in IEEE

journals or presented at IEEE sponsored conferences. In addition, the 302,000+

references to IEEE dwarf the combined total of the next 25 publishing organizations

in this technology.

Page 3: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

ii

IEEE is referenced a surprising amount in areas which are not central to its mission.

For example, almost 7% of the science references from patents in medical

devices go to IEEE publications. This ranks IEEE third behind Elsevier and

Lippincott (with 24% and 11% respectively). The latter publishers have 400+

and 100+ journals in the medical area, whereas IEEE has only a few, so the 7%

figure is quite solid for a non-core area.

Optics is also somewhat surprising. IEEE publications receive the most

references from Optics patents, and IEEE is referenced significantly more than

the two large Optics Societies that would be expected to lead the area: OSA –

The Optical Society of America, and SPIE – The International Society of

Optical Engineering.

Another non-Information Technology Area in which IEEE does very well is

Clocks & Timepieces. About 42% of all references from clock related patents

reference articles from IEEE. No other organization receives more than 6% of

the references from patents in this category.

In Measuring, Testing, and Control, IEEE gets 19% of all references, which is

just ahead of Elsevier’s 14.6% while, again, Elsevier has many more journal

titles in the space.

In the Nuclear, X-Ray, and Radiant Energy category IEEE is referenced fourth

most often behind Elsevier, The American Chemical Society, and The American

Institute of Physics. This is not terribly surprising since a large number of

patents in this space are related to Nuclear Medicine where Elsevier has journal

titles but IEEE has none.

In the Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing category, 43% of the patent

references are to articles published in IEEE journals or in proceedings of IEEE

sponsored conferences. Second place Elsevier receives only about one-fifth as

many references in the category.

Patents related to Power Systems and Transmission also reference IEEE

publications most frequently. The nearly 17,000 references to IEEE journal and

proceedings papers are more than the next two top referenced publishers

(Elsevier and Electrochemical Society) combined. We also examined a

specialized subset of the Power Transmission category related to smart meters

and smart grids. In this category, a full 64% of the scientific references from

patents go to IEEE journal or conference papers. The second most referenced

publisher is ACM with only 3.5% of all references.

Two new categories were added this year: Solar and Photovoltaic energy and

Wind energy. In the latter category IEEE science has a big advantage over the

Page 4: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

iii

other publishers with more than 45% of the references. In solar energy, Elsevier

leads with IEEE in second place. The Elsevier lead is not surprising since it has

more than 50 journal titles related to the area including several high impact

journals such as Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, Thin Solid Films, Solar

Energy, Synthetic Metals, Journal of Crystal Growth, and Solar Cells.

It has been shown that high-quality, high-impact, and valuable patents tend to be

cited more frequently by later patents. Citation impact is thus often used as a

quantitative measure for evaluating patents (see [3]). In this study, we found that

the patents that reference IEEE papers are cited more often than patents that do not.

This was shown to be true for each of the fifteen technology categories we

examined. This suggests that, not only do IEEE publications frequently provide the

science base for new inventions, but that inventions that build upon IEEE

publications are more likely to be valuable in the future than inventions that do not

build upon IEEE.

Although this study concentrates on patents in specific technology areas, it should

be noted that the importance of scientific and technical literature to patented

technology is increasing in all areas. Our research shows that the average US patent

had only 2.76 non-patent references (NPRs) back in 1997. That number jumped to

10.08 by 2013 – a 265% increase. During those same periods, the number of

references per patent to IEEE has increased by 240%. In terms of total references,

NPRs to IEEE published papers have increased 768% compared with 1997. Again,

these numbers are for all issued US patents and not just those in the fifteen

categories covered in this report.1 This means that in the overall patent system,

patented technologies are increasingly referencing scientific articles and that IEEE

provides an increasing portion of that science base.

1 Including science intensive areas like Biotechnology, Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals, and other areas where

IEEE typically has little influence.

Page 5: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute
Page 6: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 2

Table of Contents

Section Page

I. Introduction 2

II. Methodology 2

III. Results 5

IV. Conclusions 11

V. References 12

Appendix A A-1

Appendix B B-1

Appendix C C-1

Page 7: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 3

I. Introduction

In previous studies, it was found that patents reference papers from IEEE journals much more

often than papers from other journal publishers. In this report, we update the previous results,

and study US patents issued from January 1997 through December 2013. Although this report is

an update of previous results, we have made our best efforts to make this report self-contained.

The aim of this report, as in previous reports, is to analyze references from patents to journal

articles, conferences and standards documents, in order to assess IEEE’s impact upon

technological developments.

This report covers 15 subcategories of Technology where IEEE members and readers are active.

Many, but not all are related to Information Technology. The categories (including two new

categories related to solar and wind), with patent counts are shown below in Table 1.

Table 1: Number of Patents for Each Category Covered in this Study Category # Patents 1997-2013

Clocks/Watches/Time Pieces 3087

Computer Hardware 258233

Computer Software 145874

Diagnosis/Surgery/Medical Instruments 138880

Information Storage 102807

Measuring, Testing and Control Devices 152271

Nuclear/X-Ray/Radiant Energy 29895

Optics/Photography/Electrophotography 121116

Power Systems 62735

Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing 22388

Semiconductors/Solid-State Devices/Electronics 192618

Smart Grid/Smart Meters/Energy Infrastructure 2541

Solar/Photovoltaic 5990

Telecom and Other Communications 370640

Wind Energy 3146

II. Methodology

This study is based on referencing patterns from patents to prior art documents. When an

inventor files a patent for a new invention, he/she will typically reference earlier documents to

show that the new invention either builds upon, or improves upon, what came earlier. The

inventor’s patent attorney and/or the examiner may also add prior art references to either clarify

or limit the claims of the new invention.

As an example, Figure 1 shows the front page of a General Electric patent. The prior art

references on this patent come in two forms - references to earlier patents, and “other

references”. These other references are often to scientific publications, such as those produced by

IEEE. In this report we are primarily concerned with these other references, which are also

sometimes called “Non-Patent References”.

Page 8: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 4

It has been suggested that patents with many non-patent references are likely to contain new

leading-edge ideas, whereas patents that only reference earlier patents are likely to be

incremental improvements on earlier patented technologies. For a comprehensive study on

various hypotheses surrounding the motivations of inventors in citing other references, see [1].

Patent Sets used in the Analysis

This study is based on two patent sets. Our analysis is based on determining the number of

references from these patent sets to publications from publishers such as IEEE, Elsevier, the

American Institute of Physics, and others.

The first set contains patents from the top 40 patenting companies in 2013. Analysis of this

patent set provides an insight into how the top tier companies rely upon science from IEEE and

other publishers. The second set contains all patents in fifteen technology categories from all

companies, universities, government agencies, and individuals. The fifteen technology categories

examined are shown in Table 1 above. Analysis of this patent set reveals the wider influence of

IEEE science in these technologies.

Identifying Relevant Non-Patent References

Non-patent references can be to any published document, from comic strips and brochures, to

scientific articles and standards documents. The main difficulty in identifying relevant non-

patent references for a study such as this is that inventors do not use a standard form for listing

references. As an example, Table 2 contains eight different variants for the IEEE Global

Telecom Conference. Note that some inventors just use the GLOBECOM shorthand, while

others list the entire name. Sometimes IEEE is mentioned and sometimes it is not. When

abbreviation variations are included such as Telecom, Tele, Tcom, Proc., Proceed., the number

of variants increases further. The same issue exists for variants in journal names and standards

documents. For example there are more than 30 variant spellings of the journal title Journal Of

Thoracic And Cardiovascular Surgery including numerous mis-spellings of thoracic and every

conceivable way of abbreviating cardiovascular.

Table 2 – Variants for IEEE Global Telecom Conference

Proceedings of Globecom '96

IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference

GLOBECOM '90:IEEE

Proceedings of IEEE Globecom '94

Globecom '97

IEEE Globecom, Global Telecommunications Conference and Exhibiton

Proc of the Global Tele Conf, U.S. New York, IEEE

Conference Identification – to identify conference proceedings among the non-patent

references, we first identified references containing keywords such as meeting, symposia,

conference, etc. We then used parsing software to identify 2-word and 3-word phrases that

appear frequently in this set of papers. The full string was identified for these string sub-

Page 9: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 5

sequences in order to identify frequently cited conferences. In this way, we identified the top

conferences referenced in the patent sets, and standardized the names of these conferences (i.e.

all of the different variants of a conference were collected under a single name). As an example,

all of the variants shown in Table 2 are assigned to the name ‘<conf> IEEE Global

Telecommunications Conference (GLOBECOM)’.

We then looked up each of these conferences on the web to determine who is listed as their

primary sponsor. For example, many of the conferences are sponsored by organizations such as

IEEE, ACM (Association for Computer Machinery) and ASME (American Society of

Mechanical Engineers). Some conferences are jointly sponsored by multiple organizations and

this is noted as well.

When we first started identifying conferences in the 2005 report, we looked up the top 100 most

referenced conferences in order to identify the primary sponsors or hosts. In this current report

we have identified the sponsors for the top 1,000+ most referenced conferences. These 1,000+

conferences are listed under more than 12,000 variant names.

Standards Identification – Standards documents are increasingly referenced, and in general they

are easy to identify by looking for strings such as ‘standard’ or ‘std’. Once the records containing

the standards were located, it was relatively easy to identify the organization that produced each

standard (ITU, IEEE, ISO, JEDEC, ANSI, etc.). Further, once the standards bodies are

identified, we then identify references to other documents that do not specifically list the words

‘standard’ or ‘std.’ The latter step is necessary since some references look like this

“ISO/TC97/SC21/N2066” or “IEEE802.3” without a specific mention of the word “standard.”

As a consequence we also identify other non-standard documents released from these

organizations including draft standards and “requests for comments” documents.

Journal Identification – identifying and standardizing journal names is a very difficult process

because there are so many different journals, and their names can be abbreviated in many

different ways. To make the problem more manageable, we base our analysis primarily to the

16,000+ journals covered by the ISI/Thomson Scientific Database. This is not a severe

limitation, since these 16,000+ journals include more than 100 IEEE journals, 1400+ Elsevier

journals, and 350+ Wiley journals. In addition, we also identify publishers of about 1,000 non-

ISI journals if they appear very frequently in the patent references, but do not appear in the ISI

database.

Once restricted to these 17,000+ journals, we used software that transforms journal names into

common abbreviations and then implements string matching. Care must be taken with string

matching because, for example, searching for “Urology Journal” will also accidentally identify

“Neurology Journal”. Similarly, a search for the journal “Science” would accidentally pick up

any reference with ‘science’ in the paper title as well as any of the 800+ journals with science in

their titles such as “Game and Wildlife Science”. Our proprietary software for journal

identification deals with all of these problems along with some human intervention, so that we

generate an accurate match between the patent references and 17,000+ journals. After

identifying all of the relevant journals, we then used the ISI database and web research to

identify the publisher of each journal

Page 10: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 6

III. Results

References from Top 40 Patenting Organizations

Table 3 shows the 40 firms that were granted the largest number of US patents in 2013. It should

be noted that many of these firms consist of multiple subsidiaries, and these firms patent under

many names. (For example General Electric has patents filed under 316 names, of which only a

fraction contain General Electric in the name.) We identified all of the subsidiary names for each

company to ensure that our patent counts are accurate.

We identified the top 40 patenting firms because we want to understand the extent to which the

current technology leaders use IEEE science. Figure 2 shows the 20 publishers of science whose

publications are referenced most frequently by the 40 firms shown in Table 3. This figure shows

that patents issued to the top 40 firms between 1997 and 2013 reference IEEE papers,

conferences, and standards more than 300,000 times. This is more than three times as many

references as the second placed publisher (Elsevier). In addition, if conference publications that

are jointly sponsored are counted, such as the conferences jointly sponsored between IEEE and

the Japanese Society of Applied Physics, or IEEE and ACM, then the number of references from

the top 40 companies to IEEE increases by another 20,000 references.

IEEE receives about 31% of the science references from the patents of the top 40 companies.

The next closest publisher (Elsevier) has 8.5% of the total and IEEE’s share of references is

about the same as the next 8 publishers combined. About 1/3 of the 300,000+ patent references

to IEEE are to IEEE sponsored conferences.

Table 4 illustrates the reference distribution of IBM, which is the top patent holder in 2013 (and

for the past 15 years). This reference distribution is typical of the top 40 firms. The references

from IBM to IEEE are actually to a number of different IEEE journals and conferences. In this

table, IEEE journals are highlighted in yellow and IEEE conferences are highlighted in orange.

The top overall reference is to IEEE is to the International Electron Device Meeting. The top

IEEE journals are IEEE Computer Magazine and IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices.

Notice that a full 26 of the top 50 journals and conferences referenced by IBM patents are

published or sponsored by IEEE. Ten of the top 50 journals and conferences are published or

sponsored by ACM. As a software firm, IBM tends to reference ACM much more than most of

the top 40 firms, but still IBM references IEEE almost twice as often as ACM as seen in

Appendix A (32,396 total references to IEEE from IBM versus 16,729 references to ACM). The

reader may notice the large number of references to ‘IEEE Unseparated’ or ‘Misc ACM.’ These

are articles that reference IEEE or ACM, but the inventor has not given a reference specific

enough to identify the proper journal or conference. A few examples can be found in Table 5

below. These are relatively complete references; it is not clear why the inventors were not more

careful about listing the full journal names.

Page 11: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 7

Table 3 – Top Patenting Firms in 2013

Assignee

2013 US

Patent Count

1997-2013 US

Patent Count

International Business Machines Corp 6208 67641

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 4275 45490

Canon Inc 3614 39380

Sony Corp 3058 32088

Panasonic Corporation 3016 39740

Toshiba Corp 2432 29126

Microsoft Corporation 2428 22900

Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd. 2342 14502

Fujitsu Limited 2238 26803

Hitachi Ltd 2117 32834

LG Electronics Inc. 2097 13669

Google Inc. 1979 5622

Qualcomm Inc 1950 8453

General Electric Company 1888 23766

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1661 22502

Apple Inc 1601 6089

Fuji Film Holdings Corp 1581 21218

Intel Corporation 1560 23124

General Motors Corp 1527 9885

Samsung SDI Co Ltd 1458 5081

Toyota Motor Corp 1427 11974

AT&T Inc 1425 11448

Ricoh Co. Ltd. 1391 12812

Seiko Epson Corporation 1365 16055

Hewlett-Packard Co 1318 27049

Micron Technology Inc. 1164 22322

Sharp Corp 1163 13150

Ericsson 1128 10186

Honda Motor Co. Ltd. 1070 12783

NEC Corp 1064 19874

Xerox Corp 1047 12405

Broadcom Corp. 1035 8560

Semiconductor Energy Laboratory Co. Ltd. 959 7162

Du Pont (E.I.) de Nemours & Co. 921 10367

Bosch (Robert) GmbH 903 12108

Brother Industries Ltd 902 6764

Research in Motion Ltd. 897 4329

Renesas Electronic Corporation 886 9673

Honeywell International Inc. 877 12042

Koninklijke Philips N.V. 867 16380

Page 12: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 8

Table 4 – Reference Distribution from IBM Patents 1997-2013 # References journal/conference/standard

2689 Misc ACM

2100 <conf> IEEE Int Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM)

1704 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGMOD Symp

1696 IEEE Unseparated

1366 APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS

1266 IBM JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

1249 ACM SIGPLAN Notices

1186 <conf> Int Conf on Very Large Data Bases (VLDB)

972 COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM

956 Computer (IEEE)

925 IEEE tr ELECTRON DEVICES

892 <conf> ACM/IEEE Design Automation conf

892 <conf> IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys - symp on VLSI tech

887 JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS

872 <conf> USENIX Conference Proceedings

867 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS

858 IBM SYSTEMS JOURNAL

811 IEEE tr COMPUTERS

797 <conf> IEEE int conf on Data eng (ICDE)

774 Proc SPIE

727 <conf> IEEE int conf on Distributed comp sys

670 <std> IETF Std

606 IEEE tr MAGNETICS

592 <conf> IEEE ann int symp on comp Architecture

575 IEEE ELECTRON DEVICE LETTERS

547 J Vac Sci tech

535 <conf> IEEE Int Conf Acous, Speech, and Sig Proc (ICASSP)

509 IPCOM

507 IEEE tr comp Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and sys

490 ACM SIGOPS

482 ACM (MISC)

474 <conf> IEEE Hawaii Int Conf on Sys Sci (HICSS)

463 IEEE tr Software eng

463 ACM comp Surveys CSUR

442 Misc SPIE

434 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGPLAN Symp

429 ACM tr comp sys TOCS

429 SCIENCE

424 IEEE tr KNOWLEDGE AND DATA ENGINEERING

412 <conf> proc IEEE int Solid State Circuits Conf (ISSCC)

407 comp Architecture News

391 <conf> IEEE/ACM int conf on comp Aided Design (ICCAD)

382 <conf> ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI)

379 <conf> IEEE/ACM Proceedings on Supercomputing (SUPERCOMP)

371 IEEE tr INFORMATION THEORY

361 <conf> ACSA/IEEE ann comp Security app conf (ACSAC)

343 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGCOMM Symp

338 <conf> IEEE comp soc int conf (COMPCON)

328 <conf> IEEE int symp on Circuits and sys (ISCAS)

321 <conf> IEEE International Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium

Page 13: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 9

Table 5 – Examples of References Mapped to “IEEE Unseparated”

Patent NPR

# NPR Text

05692177 3 Lewis et al. "Hashing for dynamic and static internal tables." IEEE, pp. 45-56 Oct. 1988.

05699518 4 "The Design and Implementation of a Reliable Distributed Operating System--ROSE", Ng, IEEE, pp. 2-11, Apr. 1990.

05699518 5 "A service Platform for Distributed Applications", Popescu-Zeletin et al, IEEE, pp. 11-17, Jul. 1992.

05709219 5 Kotoku, Tetsuo et al., "Environment Modeling for the Interactive Display (EMID) Used in Telerobotic Systems," IEEE Nov. 3-5 1991, pp. 999-1004.

05709219 6

Kotoku, Tetsuo, "A Predictive Display with Force Feedback and Its Application to Remote Manipulation System with Transmission Time Delay," IEEE Jul. 7-10 1992, pp. 239-246.

05709219 8 Burdea, Grigore et al., "Distributed Virtual Force Feedback," IEEE May 2, 1993, Atlanta, GA, pp. 25-44.

References from Companies in Fifteen Technology Categories

In the previous section, we analyzed the use of IEEE science by the top patenting organizations.

Out of all science publishers, IEEE was cited most often by these organizations by a wide

margin. However, looking only at the top companies tells an incomplete story. IEEE publishes

journals and runs conferences mainly in information technology, electronic and other areas. It is

therefore useful to examine the extent to which IEEE science is referenced by all organizations

that patent in specific technologies and not just the leading companies.

As mentioned in the methodology section, we identified all patents in the fifteen technology

categories shown above in Table 1. 1790 Analytics has developed a classification scheme that

categorizes all patents into 50 broad technology areas, and this scheme was used to identify all

relevant patents for this part of the analysis.

We examined each of the fifteen technology areas separately, and the results are summarized in

Figures 3-15. The first category shown (in Figure 3) is Clocks, Watches, and Timepieces. We

identified all non-patent references on patents related to this technology issued between 1997 and

2013. We then determined the science publishers responsible for the largest number of these

non-patent references. Figure 3 shows the result of this analysis, namely that IEEE science is

referenced far more by clock and watch related patents than science from any other publisher.

Forty two percent of all science references from these patents go to IEEE journal papers or IEEE

sponsored conference papers (the graphs also include standards documents, but the vast majority

of the references are to journal or conference papers).

Page 14: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 10

Figures 4 and 5 are analogous to Figure 3 except they show referencing patterns from Computer

Hardware and Software patents. Here IEEE once again receives far more references than the

other publishers. In both cases, ACM is the second most referenced publisher, but it receives

about half of the references that papers published by IEEE receive.

Figure 6 examines the top referenced publishers in the Medical Device field, which covers

devices as well as diagnostic tools and surgical instruments. Here, IEEE is a respectable third in

an area that is somewhat outside its core competency. When we first started covering this

category in our 2005 report, the top publisher in this area was Lippincott Williams and Wilkins,

which publishes more than 100 health and diagnostic related journals, including Circulation,

Neurosurgery, Investigative Radiology, Anesthesiology, and Annals of Surgery. In recent years

Lippincott had been surpassed by Elsevier, which has more than 400 journals in the field, such as

Annals of Thoracic Surgery, and the Journal of the American College of Cardiology. In this

report, we see that Elsevier’s lead in references has further increased so that Lippincott now has

less than half as many references as Elsevier in the category.

The huge increase in references to Elsevier in this (and other) categories is due to several factors.

First, the number of science references in the medical field is much higher for recent patents than

for older patents, so a leading publisher in 2006 is likely to have a larger lead in 2011. Secondly,

Elsevier has been rather acquisitive in recent years and continues to acquire other publishers.

Finally, Elsevier has many journal titles, so that as ISI/Thomson has increased the number of

journals it covers in its database, Elsevier has benefited the most. Moreover, 1790 has increased

the number of journals identified outside of the ISI set, which also benefits Elsevier.

Figure 7 shows the results for the information storage category. In this area, IEEE is particularly

dominant. Almost half (44.6%) of all of the science references from patents in information

storage are to papers in IEEE journals or conferences. IEEE’s 53,791 references in this category

are about 6 times as many as second place AIP.

Figure 8 contains the results of patents covering Measuring, Testing, and Control technology.

Patents in this category are related to measuring or testing, force, pressure, weight, etc. as well as

chemically measuring substances (e.g. measuring CO2 levels). The category also contains

control devices since these technologies are often combined. For example a patent might be

related to a valve that adjusts at a certain pressure or at a certain pollution level. Since this type

of measuring can be done both mechanically, magnetically, electrically, or chemically, it is not

too surprising to see both IEEE and Elsevier and the Optical and Chemical Societies all near the

top of Figure 8. IEEE receives the most references, but the lead is not as dominant as in the

Information Technology related technology areas.

Figure 9 contains reference counts for Nuclear and X-Ray technology patents. Much of the

patenting in this category is related to Nuclear Medicine so it is not surprising that the top

referenced publisher is Elsevier. IEEE is fourth in referencing in this category behind the

American Chemical Society and the American Institute of Physics.

The results for the Optics category can be found in Figure 10. This is another area that is slightly

outside the IEEE core. IEEE still has a substantial lead over the second and third place publishers

Page 15: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 11

– the Optical Society of America (OSA) and the International Society of Optical Engineering

(SPIE). Since these latter two societies are Optical societies, it would be reasonable to assume

that one of these societies would lead in the category but IEEE strong journals and conferences

in the area receive more references from optics patents.

Figure 11 contains results for the patents related to power generation and transmission.

Although this is a non-information technology category, IEEE leads in references in this

category as well. 34% of science references from patents in this category go to IEEE

publications.

Intelligent Manufacturing and Robotics contains patents related to robotics, and robotics and

control systems related to manufacturing. According to Markets and Markets, the Robotics

market is expected to reach $21 billion in 2014 as a result of a population explosion in “service

robots” that mow lawns, vacuum floors, and manufacture things.

As this industry grows, new innovations will be patented, and from Figure 12 it looks like those

innovations will build upon ideas published in IEEE journal articles or presented at IEEE

conferences. We see in Figure 12 that 43% of all science references from patents in this space

refer to IEEE published articles. Elsevier is the second ranked publisher, but its papers receive

only 8.6% of the science references. In this category, IEEE has more references then the next 15

publishers combined.

Figure 13 shows that IEEE is also very strong in the Semiconductor category. Here, the inclusion

of conferences gives IEEE a substantial boost. Approximately one-third of the references to

IEEE are to conference papers. With conferences excluded, IEEE would be just slightly ahead

of the American Institute of Physics in terms of science references from semiconductor patents.

The Smart Meter/Smart Grid category covers patents related to improving the power grid as well

as for advanced residential electric meters. This is a relatively small category but as we see in

Figure 14, the IEEE provides the bulk of the science base with 64% of all patent references.

Solar and Photovoltaic energy results are contained in Figure 15. This is a new category this

year and is led by Elsevier. Elsevier has several strong journals in this category including Solar

Energy Materials and Solar Cells, Thin Solid Films, Solar Energy, Synthetic Metals, Journal of

Crystal Growth, Solar Cells, plus more than 50 smaller journal titles related to this technology.

The references to IEEE science in this category mainly go to the IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists

conference, the IEEE World conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, and IEEE

Transactions on Electronic Devices.

The Telecommunications category is the strongest large category for IEEE. There are over 7

times as many references to IEEE conference and journal papers as to second place publisher

3GPP (which is a standards body). Standards are referenced more frequently in

telecommunications, but still not nearly as often as journal and conference papers. About 56% of

the 600,000 total references to all publishers are to journal articles; 25% of the references are to

conference papers, and about 19% are to standards documents. In terms of standards documents,

the 3GPP General Partnership Project, Internet Engineering Task Force and International

Page 16: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 12

Telecommunication Union received the most references in the category. New

telecommunications patents are referencing scientific articles to a larger extent than in the past.

In this category in 2008 there were just over 118,000 references to IEEE and last year there were

257,000 references to IEEE papers. Now as we see in Figure 15, there are more than 302,000

references to IEEE for telecommunications patents from 1997-2013. Thus just one more year of

patents added more than 45,000 references to IEEE papers.

Standards documents are referenced increasingly often in Telecommunications patents. Four of

the top 12 referenced publishers are standards bodies. Moreover of the 302,000 references to

IEEE, over 17,000 are to various IEEE standards (mostly to the IEEE 802 family of standards).

Another new category is shown in Figure 17. This chart shows that 45% of all science

references from Wind Energy patents go to IEEE journal and conference papers.

Figures 3-7 show aggregate counts of references from all patents in each technology category.

Readers who wish to see the firms that reference IEEE publications in each category can consult

Appendix B. This appendix contains the 100 organizations that reference IEEE most frequently

in each category. Appendix C is similar, except that it contains the organizations that reference

IEEE most frequently in the fifteen technology categories combined.

Citation Index for Patents Referencing IEEE

In an earlier study (see [2]) it was shown that patents that reference specific IEEE journals

perform better on a number of quality metrics. Moreover, it was shown that the results were

statistically significant. In this report, we update a key figure from the previous study showing

the citation index of patents that reference IEEE papers versus peer patents that do not reference

IEEE.

The citation index is a normalized citation metric that takes the number of citations received by a

particular set of patents, and divides it by the expected number of citations for patents of the

same age and technology class. A random set of patents therefore should have a citation index of

1.0. Research has shown that patents cited by many later patents tend to contain important ideas

upon which the later patents are building (see [3] and [6]). Citation indicators are also the basis

for the patented financial models (see [4] and [7]) invented by the two 1790 founders Breitzman

and Thomas.

Figure 18 contains the Citation Index for the patents in the fifteen technology categories that

reference IEEE papers and conferences. Also shown is the Citation Index for the set of the

remaining patents in each category that do not reference IEEE. Note that the set of all patents in

each category should have a citation index near 1.0. Thus we see that the patents that reference

IEEE are cited 21% to 116% more than expected, while the patents that do not reference IEEE

are cited up to 14% less often than expected. This of course does not imply that all patents that

reference IEEE are likely to be more valuable than patents that do not reference IEEE, but it does

suggest that in general, patented technologies that build upon IEEE published or sponsored

Page 17: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 13

science are more likely to be valuable than patented technologies that do not reference IEEE

science.

IV. Conclusions

When a patent is filed, it must reference the prior art upon which it builds, as well as any prior art

that limits the claims of the new invention. This study and prior studies show that science

published by IEEE forms a significant portion of this prior art for new patents.

In this study, we examined two separate patent sets. The first patent set consisted of patents

granted between 1997 and 2013 to the 40 organizations with the largest number of US patents

granted in 2013. The second patent set consisted of all US patents granted between 1997 and

2013 patents in fifteen key technologies: clocks, computer hardware, software, nuclear/x-ray,

robotics, semiconductors, solar energy, wind energy, measuring and testing, medical devices,

telecommunications, optics, power systems, and information storage. In both of these patent

sets, IEEE is the dominant source of non-patent prior art. In other words, IEEE journals and

conferences are key outlets for scientific discoveries relevant to cutting edge technology.

Finally, we conducted an analysis of citation indices for IEEE related patents and non-IEEE

related patents. These types of metrics have been shown in validation studies to be good markers

for the quality, impact, and potential value of patents [3]. In this study, it was shown that patents

that build upon IEEE published science tend to have higher citation indices than patents that do

not reference IEEE. This suggests but does not guarantee that patents that build upon IEEE

science are more likely to become high-quality, high-impact, valuable inventions than patents

that do not build upon IEEE.

Specific key results are identified in the Executive Summary.

Page 18: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Page 14

V. References

[1] Branstetter, Lee. “Is Academic Science Driving a Surge in Industrial Innovation? Evidence

from Patent Citations,” Columbia Business School, Discussion Paper #28.

[2] Breitzman, Anthony. "IEEE and Patents: An Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers,

Conferences and Standards", 1790 Analytics, LLC, May 23, 2005

[3] Breitzman, Anthony and Mogee, Mary Ellen. “The Many Applications of Patent Analysis,”

of Information Science, 28, 3, 187-205, 2002.

[4] Breitzman, Anthony., “Method and Apparatus for Choosing a Stock Portfolio, Based on

Patent Indicators,” US Patent #6,175,824, Jan. 16, 2001.

[5] Fortune Magazine, “Ten Tech Trends,” January 10, 2005.

[6] Hall, Bronwyn H., Jaffe, Adam B. and Trajtenberg, Manuel., "The NBER Patent Citations

Data File: Lessons, Insights and Methodological Tools" (December 2001). CEPR Discussion

Paper No. 3094.

[7] Thomas, Patrick., “System and Method for Producing Technology-Based Price Targets for a

Company Stock,” US Patent #6,832,211, Dec. 14, 2004.

Page 19: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Apple Inc39.47336IEEE

22.14123ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.9548Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

1.9345Ziff-Davis

1.4264Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.4256Joint IEEE and ACM

1.32333GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.2222Network Working Group RFC

1.2221OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.2227ISO/IEC

1.1211CBS Interactive

1.1211MAC PUBLICATIONS, 501 SECOND ST, SAN FRANCISCO, USA, CA, 94107

1.0180SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

185 others with less than 1% each 4245 22.2

AT&T Inc43.76465IEEE

9.91465ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.9577The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

3.2476Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.5367IET/IEE

2.5368Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.5377International Telecommunication Union

1.8261ISO/IEC

1.7245ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)

1.6231European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

1.4209John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.4206Joint IEEE and ACM

1.2172ATM Forum Standards Body

1.21713GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.1157OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.0145Network Working Group RFC

196 others with less than 1% each 2893 18.5

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-1Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 20: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Bosch (Robert) GmbH25.01671IEEE

8.2549Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

6.9461Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

4.6308Am Diabetese Assoc

4.5304AMER THORACIC SOC, 1740 BROADWAY, NEW YORK, USA, NY, 10019-4374

2.9196SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

2.5170SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC

2.4158GEORG THIEME VERLAG KG, RUDIGERSTR 14, STUTTGART, GERMANY, D-70469

2.2147WICHTIG EDITORE, 72/74 VIA FRIULI, MILAN, ITALY, 20135

2.1138Ziff-Davis

1.7113SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.7115John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.6106Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

1.386ASSOC ADVANCEMENT MEDICAL INSTRUMENTATION-AAMI, 3330 WASHINGTON BLV

1.384SCHATTAUER GMBH-VERLAG MEDIZIN NATURWISSENSCHAFTEN, HOLDERLINSTRAS

1.278Peter Peregrinus Ltd

1.173Miller Freeman

1.176Soc Science and the Public

1.176AMA-Am Medical Assoc

1.176MOLECULAR DIVERSITY PRESERVATION INTERNATIONAL, MATTHAEUSSTRASSE 11,

1.174Lancet Ltd

1.173AMER SOC CLINICAL PATHOLOGY, 2100 W HARRISON ST, CHICAGO, USA, IL, 60612

1.172COLLEGE AMER PATHOLOGISTS, C/O KIMBERLY GACKI, 325 WAUKEGAN RD, NORTH

1.171United Business Media/UBM Tech

1.173AUSTRALASIAN MED PUBL CO LTD, LEVEL 1, 76 BERRY ST, SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA, NS

1.065BRITISH PSYCHOLOGICAL SOC, ST ANDREWS HOUSE, 48 PRINCESS RD EAST, LEIC

1.065IET/IEE

1.066AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.065Penton Media

1.065FORBES INC

1.068Incisive Media

133 others with less than 1% each 948 12.6

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-2Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 21: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Broadcom Corp.57.614717IEEE

4.21069International Telecommunication Union

4.11043SMTA-Surface Mount Technology Association

3.0769ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.8703IHS Publishing Group

2.0515Cahners-Denver Pub

1.8452IPC - Institute of Interconnecting and Packaging Electronic Circuits

1.7440GSM Association (standards org)

1.4364IET/IEE

1.3332Joint IEEE and ACM

1.3326Network Working Group RFC

1.0243Miller Freeman

152 others with less than 1% each 4578 17.1

Brother Industries Ltd23.267IEEE

8.324ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

8.023Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.321AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

6.218IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

5.215ACS-Am Chem Soc

5.215The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

4.212AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

3.510SID-Society for Information Display

3.19Information Processing Society of Japan

2.47Nikkei Business Publications, Inc.

2.16IET/IEE

2.16INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.75IOP Publishing

1.75John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.03Japan Standards Assoc

1.03SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.03McGraw Hill

29 others with less than 1% each 37 11.9

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-3Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 22: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Canon Inc22.64434IEEE

13.42637Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

12.42431AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

5.51079ACS-Am Chem Soc

3.8741ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.3646John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.3646SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.3459Nature Publishing Group

2.1421INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.9365OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.9373Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.6320SID-Society for Information Display

1.4266AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.4279Electrochemical Society

1.2233Vac Soc JPN

1.2230Am Physical Soc

1.2228Amer Soc Microbiology

1.2229IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.1226IET/IEE

1.0194CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

301 others with less than 1% each 3217 13.7

Du Pont (E.I.) de Nemours & Co.20.713388Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

11.07121Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

7.85061ACS-Am Chem Soc

4.83103Amer Soc Microbiology

4.62971Nature Publishing Group

4.32781John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.92508Natl Acad Sciences

3.92496National Institutes of Health - NIH

3.72423Amer Soc Plant Biologists

3.32119Am Soc Biochemistry Molec Biology

3.32157Oxford Univ Press

3.01916CROP SCIENCE SOC AMER, 677 S SEGOE ROAD, MADISON, USA, WI, 53711

2.61677Blackwell Futura

2.51592AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.1688AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.0639Royal Society of Chemistry

1.0632Cell Press

1.0616Portland Press

323 others with less than 1% each 10902 15.0

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-4Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 23: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Ericsson51.58310IEEE

13.521713GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

5.1825The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

2.9462ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.8458IET/IEE

2.7428Network Working Group RFC

2.0317European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

2.0320International Telecommunication Union

1.6266Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

1.3206Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.1185Ericsson

192 others with less than 1% each 2186 11.4

Fuji Film Holdings Corp17.01510IEEE

11.71042ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

10.3916Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.2641ACS-Am Chem Soc

5.9527AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

5.2465SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

3.8334John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.6232OSA-Opt Soc Amer

2.4211Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.0180Nature Publishing Group

1.9171IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.6143INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.5136Royal Society of Chemistry

1.4126AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.2104IET/IEE

280 others with less than 1% each 2164 22.4

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-5Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 24: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Fujitsu Limited42.97683IEEE

5.1905IET/IEE

5.1910IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

4.9871OSA-Opt Soc Amer

4.7838Joint IEEE and ACM

4.1727ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.6648AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.4604Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

3.15563GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

2.0357ATM Forum Standards Body

1.8323The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.2215International Telecommunication Union

1.1201SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

249 others with less than 1% each 3080 14.7

General Electric Company27.310466US Dept of Energy

11.44352IEEE

10.74092Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

9.03433General Electric Co.

5.42063John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

4.21603ACS-Am Chem Soc

2.3896AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.9734Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.8706Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

1.3496Am Physical Soc

1.2456SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.1434Nature Publishing Group

1.0366ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

1.0372Society of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine (SMRM)

1.0399Radiological Soc North Am

458 others with less than 1% each 7462 16.1

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-6Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 25: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

General Motors Corp28.41042IEEE

16.3599SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

13.2485Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

5.8213ACS-Am Chem Soc

3.3121John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.8103ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

2.798Electrochemical Society

2.385AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

2.281Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.764Automotive Industries

1.140Nature Publishing Group

1.141ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.140Royal Society of Chemistry

1.141IET/IEE

116 others with less than 1% each 613 16.4

Google Inc.32.65090IEEE

24.43807ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

7.511703GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

4.4693Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.7429Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.3366World Wide Web Consortium

2.2341ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

1.2183The USENIX Association

1.2186International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)

1.0149International Telecommunication Union

203 others with less than 1% each 3187 19.5

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-7Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 26: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Hewlett-Packard Co30.98069IEEE

13.63561ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.71230Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

4.11076Joint IEEE and ACM

4.01047The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

3.3849AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

2.3610SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.0510Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.9488The USENIX Association

1.8470ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.4354Hewlett Packard Inc.

1.3338OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.2325AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.1280Am Physical Soc

1.0259Ziff-Davis

1.0272John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

348 others with less than 1% each 6377 22.2

Hitachi Ltd

27.75229IEEE

6.81285Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

6.41208AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

6.21167ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.1766IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

2.5470The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

2.4459ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.8341John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.8339Nikkei Business Publications, Inc.

1.8330INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.7314International Telecommunication Union

1.6296SID-Society for Information Display

1.5290Network Working Group RFC

1.5274IET/IEE

1.3243IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.3245Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.3254SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.2232Am Physical Soc

1.0196Joint IEEE and ACM

1.0195IBM Corp

1.0183Nature Publishing Group

338 others with less than 1% each 4529 21.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-8Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 27: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd.16.8284AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

13.2224ACS-Am Chem Soc

11.2190AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

10.5178Am Physical Soc

9.6163IEEE

9.0153Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.6129Nature Publishing Group

4.779John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.560ROYAL SOC LONDON

2.441Sci American Inc

1.322ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.322Science X Network

1.017Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

48 others with less than 1% each 132 8.9

Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda Giken Kogyo KK)38.91673IEEE

18.1779Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

4.8207Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

3.7157ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.3140ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

3.1132ACS-Am Chem Soc

2.8120IEEE/RSJ

1.459AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.461Electrochemical Society

1.041Nature Publishing Group

1.041MIT/MIT Press

1.043SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

156 others with less than 1% each 844 17.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-9Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 28: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Honeywell International Inc.29.64757IEEE

13.42149Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.71241ACS-Am Chem Soc

6.2994SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

3.5566AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.4540Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.6412John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.6417OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.9301MRS-Materials Research Soc

1.8291Royal Society of Chemistry

1.5234IET/IEE

1.5246ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.4225SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

1.4217SID-Society for Information Display

1.0162AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

276 others with less than 1% each 3306 17.3

Intel Corporation48.017920IEEE

8.93338ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

5.72137Joint IEEE and ACM

3.21198Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.91088AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.6588SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.5545The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.5545IET/IEE

1.55433GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.4519IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.3479The USENIX Association

1.2454ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.0387Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

285 others with less than 1% each 7556 18.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-10Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 29: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

International Business Machines Corp35.632396IEEE

18.416729ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.84328Joint IEEE and ACM

4.64166Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

3.32965AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

2.42228IBM Corp

1.91747Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.51392SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.41292ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.31226Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)

1.31208The USENIX Association

1.11005IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.1990John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.0937The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

460 others with less than 1% each 18378 17.8

Koninklijke Philips N.V.27.55189IEEE

10.01892Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.91488Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

4.7889Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

3.9733John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.3618AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.1594SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.3425Blackwell Futura

2.0373ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.8331Society of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine (SMRM)

1.5280American Medical Informatics Association

1.4262IOP Publishing

1.2227IET/IEE

1.2219Am Assoc Physicists Med/Am Inst Physics

1.2224Am Physiological Soc

1.2232OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.1209SID-Society for Information Display

1.0186Radiological Soc North Am

334 others with less than 1% each 4501 21.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-11Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 30: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

LG Electronics Inc.31.352103GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

28.84786IEEE

8.71454ISO-International Standards Organization

4.3713International Telecommunication Union

3.7615Audio Eng Soc

3.3555European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

3.1523ISO/IEC

1.8307ATSC Std

1.3217The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

108 others with less than 1% each 2246 12.6

Micron Technology Inc.31.135347IEEE

17.920304Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

11.613195AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

4.14655IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

3.13514Electrochemical Society

3.03408John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.73067MRS-Materials Research Soc

2.42697INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.32652Am Physical Soc

2.02313ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.71983SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.61791Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.31514CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

1.31499IOP Publishing

216 others with less than 1% each 15627 12.8

Microsoft Corporation32.236609IEEE

28.031856ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.04501Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.62897Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.22491The USENIX Association

2.02307The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.71956Joint IEEE and ACM

1.51727International Telecommunication Union

1.31436SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.11212Miller Freeman

1.01116Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)

414 others with less than 1% each 25474 19.8

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-12Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 31: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

NEC Corp42.36653IEEE

5.6874IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

5.3827AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

4.4687ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.36743GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

4.0631Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

3.2502Joint IEEE and ACM

3.1482IET/IEE

1.9291Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.8284OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.5230INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.5230SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.3204Am Physical Soc

1.1171IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.1175SID-Society for Information Display

1.0160The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.0150John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

231 others with less than 1% each 2503 13.9

Panasonic Corporation

33.87574IEEE

7.21613Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.015603GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

5.31184IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

5.31198AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.9864INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.4533International Telecommunication Union

1.9427ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.9430Electrochemical Society

1.9436The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.7375IET/IEE

1.6364ISO-International Standards Organization

1.5331ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.5341SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.4307JPN Soc App Phys

1.3284ISO/IEC

1.3295Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.1249John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.1257IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.0224SID-Society for Information Display

1.0226Joint IEEE and ACM

278 others with less than 1% each 3326 11.8

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-13Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 32: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Qualcomm Inc50.014064IEEE

12.535283GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

5.01411SID-Society for Information Display

2.6744Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.5690Telecomm Industry assoc-TIA

2.5708The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

2.4684SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.0552AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.7482Network Working Group RFC

1.6440ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.4397IET/IEE

1.3353OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.1314European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

164 others with less than 1% each 3750 11.9

Renesas Electronic Corporation61.92923IEEE

7.7366IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

3.9184AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.51653GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

2.096IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.885Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

1.675Nikkei Business Publications, Inc.

1.674JPN Soc App Phys

1.569Joint IEEE and ACM

1.467SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.045ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.045Am Physical Soc

65 others with less than 1% each 529 10.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-14Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 33: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Research in Motion Ltd.36.82946IEEE

23.919133GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

4.5357ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.3342The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

2.8222Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

1.9155Network Working Group RFC

1.8148International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)

1.6131Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.4111John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.3107IET/IEE

1.297Ziff-Davis

1.296The USENIX Association

1.077Miller Freeman

1.082United Business Media/UBM Tech

119 others with less than 1% each 1231 13.8

Ricoh Co. Ltd.42.54432IEEE

16.71740ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

6.4669SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

5.2538International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)

4.9508Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

3.3340Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.4148ISO-International Standards Organization

1.4143AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.3135IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.0103I S & T - SOC IMAGING SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY

147 others with less than 1% each 1661 14.2

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-15Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 34: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd41.78258IEEE

6.01195Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

5.61112SID-Society for Information Display

5.11010AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.6717ACS-Am Chem Soc

3.67043GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

2.6507ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.0395John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.6318SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.5290Am Physical Soc

1.4283IET/IEE

1.2237IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.1218Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.0197ISO-International Standards Organization

1.0203AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

290 others with less than 1% each 4172 18.7

Samsung SDI Co Ltd28.3415Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

10.6156SID-Society for Information Display

10.4152IEC-International Electrotechnical Commission

8.1118AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

7.2105ACS-Am Chem Soc

5.073IEEE

4.870John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

4.870Electrochemical Society

3.247Royal Society of Chemistry

2.638Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.522Nature Publishing Group

1.522AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.420INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

53 others with less than 1% each 157 11.2

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-16Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 35: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Seiko Epson Corporation35.02769IEEE

8.2650Joint IEEE and ACM

7.8616ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

7.0556SID-Society for Information Display

6.2493Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

6.2493AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

2.3181IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

2.1165ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.9149IBM Corp

1.6126INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.4111SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.3104IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.190John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.189IET/IEE

1.077Am Physical Soc

145 others with less than 1% each 1243 14.6

Semiconductor Energy Laboratory Co. Ltd.28.010941SID-Society for Information Display

17.56855AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

10.64143IEEE

9.53706Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

6.02330Am Physical Soc

4.71842INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.91126Nature Publishing Group

2.5976Electrochemical Society

2.5960Japan Soc Applied Physics/IEEE

2.5970JPN Soc App Phys

1.9730CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

1.7646John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.3490Korean Information Display Society (KIDS)

1.2469Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.1416AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

73 others with less than 1% each 2478 5.8

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-17Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 36: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Sharp Corp28.53569IEEE

9.61201SID-Society for Information Display

9.01128AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

7.18873GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

4.9614ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.2528Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

4.2523ISO/IEC

3.3412SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.7341INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.0255The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

2.0250IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.9238ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.6203International Telecommunication Union

1.2148ISO-International Standards Organization

1.1140John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.1133IET/IEE

1.1136CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

1.0123MRS-Materials Research Soc

157 others with less than 1% each 1688 11.8

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft

29.07440IEEE

14.23642Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

3.9989John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.6921AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.0762Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

2.5641SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.2575ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.0524ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.4364Nature Publishing Group

1.3321Acoust Soc Amer/Amer Inst Physics

1.3326Natl Acad Sciences

1.3333IET/IEE

1.3336IOP Publishing

1.2312Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

1.1292Amer Soc Microbiology

1.1281Radiological Soc North Am

1.0257OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.0248AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.0259Amer Assoc Clin Chem

1.0244Am Assoc Physicists Med/Am Inst Physics

431 others with less than 1% each 6612 22.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-18Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 37: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Sony Corp46.39091IEEE

9.01774ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

5.61100Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

2.9563SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.4471AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

1.7330The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.5300IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.4281IET/IEE

1.4266Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.3254ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.22403GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.2228Joint IEEE and ACM

1.0189John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

291 others with less than 1% each 4539 20.0

Toshiba Corp41.37052IEEE

6.81159AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

6.01017Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

4.3737IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

3.1521Am Physical Soc

3.0506IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

2.8483ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.5434John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.4407SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.2379INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.5259International Telecommunication Union

1.4243The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

1.2200JPN Soc App Phys

1.2201IET/IEE

1.2212Joint IEEE and ACM

1.0164Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

279 others with less than 1% each 3105 15.7

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-19Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 38: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 40 Companies

(Top 40 Companies in terms of 2013 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2013 Patents)

Toyota Motor Corp21.0627IEEE

18.5552Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

6.4191ACS-Am Chem Soc

5.7171SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

3.4102Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

3.296AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

3.295Am Soc Biochemistry Molec Biology

2.988John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.472Cahners-Denver Pub

2.060Amer Soc Microbiology

1.958OSA-Opt Soc Amer

1.648Electrochemical Society

1.544Natl Acad Sciences

1.339Royal Society of Chemistry

1.237IET/IEE

1.236AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.134SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.031IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.031Nature Publishing Group

136 others with less than 1% each 572 18.0

Xerox Corp21.13573IEEE

14.72493ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

8.41423Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

7.51271ACS-Am Chem Soc

4.9823AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

4.0673John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.7633SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.7452Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

1.9320SID-Society for Information Display

1.8307Xerox Corp.

1.8303ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

1.5248AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.5247Royal Society of Chemistry

1.3228International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)

1.1190I S & T - SOC IMAGING SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY

1.0163MRS-Materials Research Soc

249 others with less than 1% each 3613 19.0

Thursday, May 01, 2014 A-20Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 39: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Clocks/Watches/Time Pieces1 Weatherford International Ltd 63IEEE63 64 1The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force98.4 98.4 1.6

2 Teradyne Inc. 20IEEE20 24 2AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics83.3 83.3 8.3

3 DYNAMIC INVENTION LL 15IEEE15 17 1ACM-Assoc Comput Mach88.2 88.2 5.9

4 GUIDE TECHNOLOGY INC 15IEEE15 20 5Hewlett Packard Inc.75.0 75.0 25.0

5 Infineon Technologies AG 14IEEE14 14 100.0 100.0

6 STMicroelectronics 12IEEE12 12 100.0 100.0

7 Texas Instruments Inc 10IEEE10 11 1Acoust Soc Amer/Amer Inst Physics90.9 90.9 9.1

8 Xilinx Inc. 10IEEE10 10 100.0 100.0

9 International Business Machi 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9 47 9IEEE19.1 31.9 19.1

10 Alacritech Inc 6IEEE6 9 2United Business Media/UBM Tech66.7 66.7 22.2

11 Hewlett-Packard Co 7ACM-Assoc Comput Mach6 23 6IEEE26.1 30.4 26.1

12 Research in Motion Ltd. 6IEEE6 8 2European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)75.0 75.0 25.0

13 General Dynamics Corp 4IEEE4 12 4Network Working Group RFC33.3 33.3 33.3

14 Sony Corp 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

15 Yamaha Corp 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

16 European Space Agency (The 3IEEE3 7 2Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)42.9 42.9 28.6

17 FEIG ELECTRONIC GMBH 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

18 FRIEDRICH-ALEXANDER- 3IEEE3 5 1Joint IEEE and ACM60.0 60.0 20.0

19 Huawei Technologies Compa 11Network Working Group RFC3 16 3IEEE18.8 68.8 18.8

20 Industrial Techology Researc 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

21 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 3IEEE3 6 2ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.0 50.0 33.3

22 OUTBURST TECHNOLOGI 3IEEE3 8 1The USENIX Association37.5 37.5 12.5

23 PHATRAT TECHNOLOGY 3IEEE3 7 1NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin42.9 42.9 14.3

24 Seiko Epson Corporation 3IEEE3 8 2SID-Society for Information Display37.5 37.5 25.0

25 Toshiba Corp 3IEEE3 4 1Audio Eng Soc75.0 75.0 25.0

26 CareFusion Corp 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

27 Denso Corp 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

28 Ericsson 2IEEE2 5 1ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.0 40.0 20.0

29 Garmin Ltd 2ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng2 5 2IEEE40.0 40.0 40.0

30 Google Inc. 2IEEE/RSJ2 4 2IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

31 INVICTA NETWORKS INC 2IEEE2 3 1IET/IEE66.7 66.7 33.3

32 Johnson Controls Inc 3Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau2 12 2IEEE16.7 25.0 16.7

33 Motorola Solutions Inc. 2ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2 5 2IEEE40.0 40.0 40.0

34 NEC Corp 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

35 Nuance Communications Inc 2ISCA (International Speech Communication A2 9 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders22.2 22.2 22.2

36 RF Micro Devices Inc. 2IEEE2 5 1GSM Association (standards org)40.0 40.0 20.0

37 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

38 Swatch Group AG (The) 2IEEE2 13 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders15.4 15.4 15.4

39 Symmetricom Inc. 2IEEE2 3 1BUREAU INT POIDS MESURES, B1 PM PAVILLION DE B66.7 66.7 33.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-1Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 40: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 TVIPR LLC 2IEEE2 6 1McGraw Hill33.3 33.3 16.7

41 ABB Ltd 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

42 Adobe Systems Inc. 2Network Working Group RFC1 6 2The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force16.7 33.3 33.3

43 Apple Inc 1IEEE1 5 1NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin20.0 20.0 20.0

44 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

45 Broadcom Corp. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

46 Casio Computer 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

47 Commissariat A L'Energie At 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

48 Cornell University 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

49 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 1Acoust Soc Amer/Amer Inst Physics1 3 1Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.3 33.3 33.3

50 Fujitsu Limited 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

51 General Electric Company 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

52 GENERAL SIGNAL POWE 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

53 Intel Corporation 1Joint IEEE and ACM1 4 1The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force25.0 25.0 25.0

54 LSI Corporation 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

55 Microsoft Corporation 9ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1 10 1IEEE10.0 90.0 10.0

56 Nokia Corp 13GPP General Partnership Project Standards 1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

57 Oki Electric Industry Co. Ltd. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

58 Panasonic Corporation 1IEEE1 2 1IET/IEE50.0 50.0 50.0

59 Rohde & Schwarz GmbH & 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

60 Synopsys Inc. 4Joint IEEE and ACM1 5 1IEEE20.0 80.0 20.0

61 Teledyne Technologies Incor 1AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics1 3 1IEEE33.3 33.3 33.3

62 VTech Holdings :td 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

63 WIMM LABS 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

64 WIMM LABS INC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-2Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 41: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Computer Hardware1 International Business Machi 9322IEEE9322 28010 7218ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.3 33.3 25.8

2 Microsoft Corporation 11547ACM-Assoc Comput Mach7589 30954 7589IEEE24.5 37.3 24.5

3 Intel Corporation 4631IEEE4631 10126 1529ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.7 45.7 15.1

4 Oracle Corporation 5199ACM-Assoc Comput Mach4247 14474 4247IEEE29.3 35.9 29.3

5 Cadence Design Systems Inc 3275IEEE3275 8296 2981Joint IEEE and ACM39.5 39.5 35.9

6 Immersion Corp. 3149IEEE3149 8690 967ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.2 36.2 11.1

7 Sony Corp 2595IEEE2595 5381 759ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.2 48.2 14.1

8 Hewlett-Packard Co 2412IEEE2412 8015 1573ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.1 30.1 19.6

9 Apple Inc 2903ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2222 8117 2222IEEE27.4 35.8 27.4

10 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 2061IEEE2061 4289 715ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.1 48.1 16.7

11 Broadcom Corp. 1792IEEE1792 3179 271ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.4 56.4 8.5

12 MicroUnity Systems Enginee 1583IEEE1583 2489 241Joint IEEE and ACM63.6 63.6 9.7

13 Canon Inc 1540IEEE1540 4253 433Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders36.2 36.2 10.2

14 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 1523IEEE1523 4167 906SID-Society for Information Display36.5 36.5 21.7

15 Fujitsu Limited 1471IEEE1471 3712 443ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.6 39.6 11.9

16 Panasonic Corporation 1457IEEE1457 3274 204ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.5 44.5 6.2

17 Seiko Epson Corporation 1307IEEE1307 3435 492Joint IEEE and ACM38.0 38.0 14.3

18 Xilinx Inc. 1244IEEE1244 1900 257Joint IEEE and ACM65.5 65.5 13.5

19 Rambus Inc. 1213IEEE1213 1700 81IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys71.4 71.4 4.8

20 Qualcomm Inc 1162IEEE1162 2437 262SID-Society for Information Display47.7 47.7 10.8

21 NEC Corp 1124IEEE1124 2388 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.1 47.1 9.5

22 Alcatel-Lucent 1117IEEE1117 2377 325ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.0 47.0 13.7

23 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 1108IEEE1108 3107 344Joint IEEE and ACM35.7 35.7 11.1

24 Google Inc. 1430ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1108 4158 1108IEEE26.6 34.4 26.6

25 Micron Technology Inc. 1077IEEE1077 1993 149ACM-Assoc Comput Mach54.0 54.0 7.5

26 Texas Instruments Inc 1073IEEE1073 1952 131Penton Media55.0 55.0 6.7

27 Synopsys Inc. 1052IEEE1052 2737 655Joint IEEE and ACM38.4 38.4 23.9

28 Toshiba Corp 1048IEEE1048 2362 196ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.4 44.4 8.3

29 LSI Corporation 1024IEEE1024 1583 182Joint IEEE and ACM64.7 64.7 11.5

30 Motorola Solutions Inc. 1000IEEE1000 1687 140ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.3 59.3 8.3

31 Cisco Systems Inc. 960IEEE960 3230 604The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force29.7 29.7 18.7

32 Personalized Media Commun 1690Soc Motion Picture TV Eng Inc896 5340 896IEEE16.8 31.6 16.8

33 Honeywell International Inc. 895IEEE895 2494 200Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders35.9 35.9 8.0

34 Altera Corp. 892IEEE892 1805 194ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.4 49.4 10.7

35 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 891IEEE891 1395 178Joint IEEE and ACM63.9 63.9 12.8

36 Hitachi Ltd 888IEEE888 2904 476ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.6 30.6 16.4

37 STMicroelectronics 874IEEE874 1510 85ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.9 57.9 5.6

38 AT&T Inc 864IEEE864 2313 459ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.4 37.4 19.8

39 SRC Computers Inc. 815IEEE815 910 30ACM-Assoc Comput Mach89.6 89.6 3.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-3Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 42: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Tessera Technologies Inc. 783IEEE783 1195 93Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders65.5 65.5 7.8

41 Xerox Corp 959ACM-Assoc Comput Mach770 3423 770IEEE22.5 28.0 22.5

42 Tabula Inc 802ACM-Assoc Comput Mach740 2006 740IEEE36.9 40.0 36.9

43 Sap AG 896ACM-Assoc Comput Mach739 2669 739IEEE27.7 33.6 27.7

44 Mentor Graphics Corp. 703IEEE703 1215 324Joint IEEE and ACM57.9 57.9 26.7

45 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 672IEEE672 1567 199ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.9 42.9 12.7

46 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 670IEEE670 1368 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.0 49.0 16.7

47 Imagination Technologies Gr 647IEEE647 1950 395ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.2 33.2 20.3

48 LG Electronics Inc. 600IEEE600 1685 263Audio Eng Soc35.6 35.6 15.6

49 Sharp Corp 583IEEE583 2101 393SID-Society for Information Display27.7 27.7 18.7

50 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 573IEEE573 1259 95ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.5 45.5 7.5

51 Silverbrook Pty Ltd 572IEEE572 1460 288Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders39.2 39.2 19.7

52 Netapp Inc 883ACM-Assoc Comput Mach569 2275 569IEEE25.0 38.8 25.0

53 Massachusetts Institute of Te 568IEEE568 1367 188ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.6 41.6 13.8

54 EMC Corp. 548IEEE548 1653 450ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.2 33.2 27.2

55 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 540IEEE540 894 91Joint IEEE and ACM60.4 60.4 10.2

56 Marvell Technology Group Lt 528IEEE528 689 26ACM-Assoc Comput Mach76.6 76.6 3.8

57 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 527IEEE527 1585 384ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.2 33.2 24.2

58 Research in Motion Ltd. 514IEEE514 1241 137ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.4 41.4 11.0

59 National Instruments Corp. 508IEEE508 918 120ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.3 55.3 13.1

60 University of California 492IEEE492 2526 337Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.5 19.5 13.3

61 Commvault Systems Inc. 475IEEE475 671 98ACM-Assoc Comput Mach70.8 70.8 14.6

62 Nokia Corp 447IEEE447 1198 141The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force37.3 37.3 11.8

63 Ericsson 442IEEE442 1098 1273GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body40.3 40.3 11.6

64 CREATIVE KINGDOMS LL 428IEEE428 1201 349ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.6 35.6 29.1

65 SRI International 420IEEE420 790 58Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders53.2 53.2 7.3

66 General Electric Company 416IEEE416 1097 103Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.9 37.9 9.4

67 Washington University in St. 413IEEE413 844 108ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.9 48.9 12.8

68 EXEGY INC 406IEEE406 794 141ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.1 51.1 17.8

69 Adobe Systems Inc. 628ACM-Assoc Comput Mach403 1458 403IEEE27.6 43.1 27.6

70 MOSAID Technologies Inc. 383IEEE383 484 31Joint IEEE and ACM79.1 79.1 6.4

71 QST Holdings Llc 377IEEE377 599 71Joint IEEE and ACM62.9 62.9 11.9

72 Digimarc Corp. 366IEEE366 1086 147ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.7 33.7 13.5

73 Arm Holdings Plc 359IEEE359 710 112Joint IEEE and ACM50.6 50.6 15.8

74 Citrix Systems Inc 354IEEE354 1164 170ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.4 30.4 14.6

75 NVIDIA Corp. 352IEEE352 794 227ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.3 44.3 28.6

76 Raytheon Co. 344IEEE344 801 56Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders42.9 42.9 7.0

77 Columbia University 338IEEE338 1150 233ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.4 29.4 20.3

78 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 320IEEE320 953 113IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng33.6 33.6 11.9

79 Intertrust Technologies Corp 317ACM-Assoc Comput Mach317 1823 317IEEE17.4 17.4 17.4

80 Irobot Corp 313IEEE313 576 129SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering54.3 54.3 22.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-4Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 43: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Rockstar Consortium (Nortel 308IEEE308 661 70The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force46.6 46.6 10.6

82 Lockheed Martin Corp. 307IEEE307 676 51Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders45.4 45.4 7.5

83 Intellectual Ventures Manage 296IEEE296 768 183ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.5 38.5 23.8

84 Ignis Innovation Inc 295IEEE295 357 27Emerald Group Publishing82.6 82.6 7.6

85 Power-One Inc 293IEEE293 450 93IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium65.1 65.1 20.7

86 Tangis Corp 293IEEE293 434 81ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.5 67.5 18.7

87 CA Inc 292IEEE292 715 121ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.8 40.8 16.9

88 NCR Corp. 286IEEE286 834 125ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.3 34.3 15.0

89 Emerson Electric Co. 280IEEE280 1022 84Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.4 27.4 8.2

90 Infineon Technologies AG 280IEEE280 502 43Joint IEEE and ACM55.8 55.8 8.6

91 Pioneer Corp. 279IEEE279 396 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders70.5 70.5 4.0

92 SanDisk Corp. 273IEEE273 610 50ISO-International Standards Organization44.8 44.8 8.2

93 Silicon Graphics Internationa 270IEEE270 709 229ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.1 38.1 32.3

94 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 267IEEE267 762 120ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.0 35.0 15.7

95 Symantec Corp. 267IEEE267 1141 243ACM-Assoc Comput Mach23.4 23.4 21.3

96 Applied Materials Inc. 263IEEE263 442 34Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders59.5 59.5 7.7

97 Renesas Electronic Corporati 244IEEE244 488 41Joint IEEE and ACM50.0 50.0 8.4

98 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 242IEEE242 536 66Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders45.1 45.1 12.3

99 Electronics and Telecommuni 241IEEE241 503 57ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.9 47.9 11.3

100 ParkerVision Inc 241IEEE241 524 151IET/IEE46.0 46.0 28.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-5Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 44: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Computer Software1 Microsoft Corporation 17508IEEE17508 53781 15046ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.6 32.6 28.0

2 International Business Machi 9288IEEE9288 28092 6860ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.1 33.1 24.4

3 Oracle Corporation 4217ACM-Assoc Comput Mach3299 11710 3299IEEE28.2 36.0 28.2

4 Google Inc. 2474IEEE2474 7678 2226ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.2 32.2 29.0

5 Hewlett-Packard Co 2168IEEE2168 5717 1178ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.9 37.9 20.6

6 Intel Corporation 1817IEEE1817 4637 1021ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.2 39.2 22.0

7 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1790IEEE1790 3812 395Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.0 47.0 10.4

8 Tessera Technologies Inc. 1756IEEE1756 2830 212Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.0 62.0 7.5

9 Cadence Design Systems Inc 1608IEEE1608 3321 874Joint IEEE and ACM48.4 48.4 26.3

10 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 1591IEEE1591 3552 599ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.8 44.8 16.9

11 Apple Inc 1588IEEE1588 4208 933ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.7 37.7 22.2

12 Alcatel-Lucent 1573IEEE1573 3161 408ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.8 49.8 12.9

13 AT&T Inc 1483IEEE1483 3794 543ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.1 39.1 14.3

14 Digimarc Corp. 1466IEEE1466 3676 454SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering39.9 39.9 12.4

15 Cognex Corp. 1405IEEE1405 3022 609Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders46.5 46.5 20.2

16 Xerox Corp 1334IEEE1334 4889 1180ACM-Assoc Comput Mach27.3 27.3 24.1

17 Sap AG 1881ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1288 5433 1288IEEE23.7 34.6 23.7

18 Sony Corp 1257IEEE1257 2532 403ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.6 49.6 15.9

19 Applied Materials Inc. 1229IEEE1229 1964 170AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62.6 62.6 8.7

20 NEC Corp 1205IEEE1205 2564 317ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.0 47.0 12.4

21 Synopsys Inc. 1190IEEE1190 4215 1178SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering28.2 28.2 27.9

22 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1185IEEE1185 3672 414Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders32.3 32.3 11.3

23 PHOENIX SOLUTIONS INC 1057IEEE1057 2957 407ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)35.7 35.7 13.8

24 Adobe Systems Inc. 1025IEEE1025 2647 959ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.7 38.7 36.2

25 MicroUnity Systems Enginee 940IEEE940 1477 140Joint IEEE and ACM63.6 63.6 9.5

26 Qualcomm Inc 861IEEE861 1564 93Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders55.1 55.1 5.9

27 LG Electronics Inc. 837IEEE837 1581 138Audio Eng Soc52.9 52.9 8.7

28 Panasonic Corporation 811IEEE811 1582 97ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.3 51.3 6.1

29 LSI Corporation 809IEEE809 1548 381Joint IEEE and ACM52.3 52.3 24.6

30 ParkerVision Inc 791IEEE791 1693 487IET/IEE46.7 46.7 28.8

31 Cisco Systems Inc. 787IEEE787 3033 623The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force25.9 25.9 20.5

32 Motorola Solutions Inc. 754IEEE754 1134 38Joint IEEE and ACM66.5 66.5 3.4

33 Nokia Corp 711IEEE711 2014 191The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force35.3 35.3 9.5

34 Research in Motion Ltd. 711IEEE711 1461 98Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders48.7 48.7 6.7

35 Accenture Ltd. 700IEEE700 2275 398ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.8 30.8 17.5

36 Honeywell International Inc. 687IEEE687 1302 120Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders52.8 52.8 9.2

37 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 673IEEE673 1420 175Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.4 47.4 12.3

38 General Electric Company 672IEEE672 1711 161Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders39.3 39.3 9.4

39 Dolby Laboratories Inc 646IEEE646 1291 310Audio Eng Soc50.0 50.0 24.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-6Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 45: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 STMicroelectronics 630IEEE630 1024 61Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders61.5 61.5 6.0

41 BT Group PLC 625IEEE625 1252 103Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders49.9 49.9 8.2

42 Eastman Kodak Company 608IEEE608 1343 141Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders45.3 45.3 10.5

43 Broadcom Corp. 600IEEE600 1040 73ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.7 57.7 7.0

44 Nuance Communications Inc 599IEEE599 1504 198ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)39.8 39.8 13.2

45 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 593IEEE593 1339 334ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.3 44.3 24.9

46 Texas Instruments Inc 584IEEE584 822 44Joint IEEE and ACM71.0 71.0 5.4

47 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 573IEEE573 1176 165ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.7 48.7 14.0

48 Fujitsu Limited 553IEEE553 1390 267Joint IEEE and ACM39.8 39.8 19.2

49 Sharp Corp 545IEEE545 1169 122ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.6 46.6 10.4

50 Canon Inc 543IEEE543 1340 174ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.5 40.5 13.0

51 NVIDIA Corp. 677ACM-Assoc Comput Mach540 1760 540IEEE30.7 38.5 30.7

52 Raytheon Co. 540IEEE540 1049 55Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders51.5 51.5 5.2

53 Ericsson 523IEEE523 1298 159ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.3 40.3 12.2

54 Silicon Graphics Internationa 480IEEE480 1529 453ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.4 31.4 29.6

55 eBay Inc 472IEEE472 3027 292ACM-Assoc Comput Mach15.6 15.6 9.6

56 HRL Laboratories LLC 460IEEE460 795 75Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders57.9 57.9 9.4

57 Commvault Systems Inc. 456IEEE456 628 87ACM-Assoc Comput Mach72.6 72.6 13.9

58 Xilinx Inc. 454IEEE454 711 115Joint IEEE and ACM63.9 63.9 16.2

59 Hitachi Ltd 450IEEE450 1675 282ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.9 26.9 16.8

60 Citrix Systems Inc 444IEEE444 1426 235ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.1 31.1 16.5

61 Seiko Epson Corporation 438IEEE438 889 101Joint IEEE and ACM49.3 49.3 11.4

62 Irobot Corp 427IEEE427 771 143SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.4 55.4 18.5

63 Massachusetts Institute of Te 422IEEE422 1979 229Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders21.3 21.3 11.6

64 Level 3 Communications 517ACM-Assoc Comput Mach419 1715 419IEEE24.4 30.1 24.4

65 Georgia Institute of Technolo 416IEEE416 556 40ACM-Assoc Comput Mach74.8 74.8 7.2

66 Lockheed Martin Corp. 412IEEE412 894 90Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders46.1 46.1 10.1

67 Amazon.com Inc. 862ACM-Assoc Comput Mach411 2774 411IEEE14.8 31.1 14.8

68 University of California 408IEEE408 2142 282Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.0 19.0 13.2

69 Toshiba Corp 402IEEE402 1016 139ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.6 39.6 13.7

70 Columbia University 385IEEE385 1272 213ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.3 30.3 16.7

71 AVISTAR COMMUNICATI 384IEEE384 752 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.1 51.1 30.3

72 Boeing Co. (The) 377IEEE377 1056 118Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders35.7 35.7 11.2

73 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 369IEEE369 830 89ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.5 44.5 10.7

74 EMC Corp. 356IEEE356 1012 205ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.2 35.2 20.3

75 Netapp Inc 1154ACM-Assoc Comput Mach342 2390 433The USENIX Association14.3 48.3 18.1

76 JPMorgan 735Source Media334 3326 352ACS-Am Chem Soc10.0 22.1 10.6

77 AOL Inc 334ACM-Assoc Comput Mach322 1471 322IEEE21.9 22.7 21.9

78 Harris Corp. 322IEEE322 545 73The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force59.1 59.1 13.4

79 Yahoo Inc 652ACM-Assoc Comput Mach320 2385 320IEEE13.4 27.3 13.4

80 NOMADIX INC 316IEEE316 1221 195Network Working Group RFC25.9 25.9 16.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-7Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 46: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Verizon Communications Inc 314IEEE314 1029 189The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force30.5 30.5 18.4

82 Altera Corp. 313IEEE313 532 106Joint IEEE and ACM58.8 58.8 19.9

83 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 304IEEE304 2643 262Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer11.5 11.5 9.9

84 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 300IEEE300 1120 161ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.8 26.8 14.4

85 Mentor Graphics Corp. 475SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering298 1106 298IEEE26.9 42.9 26.9

86 National Instruments Corp. 294IEEE294 520 55ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.5 56.5 10.6

87 ICOSYSTEM CORP 292IEEE292 372 18Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders78.5 78.5 4.8

88 United States Navy 277IEEE277 541 50SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering51.2 51.2 9.2

89 SRI International 266IEEE266 560 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.5 47.5 6.8

90 CA Inc 259IEEE259 657 115ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.4 39.4 17.5

91 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 360ACM-Assoc Comput Mach259 1068 259IEEE24.3 33.7 24.3

92 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 257IEEE257 383 53Joint IEEE and ACM67.1 67.1 13.8

93 Intellectual Ventures Manage 252IEEE252 545 92ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.2 46.2 16.9

94 Technicolor SA 248IEEE248 560 66SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering44.3 44.3 11.8

95 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 242IEEE242 399 51SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 60.7 60.7 12.8

96 COLLABORATION PROPE 238IEEE238 330 48ACM-Assoc Comput Mach72.1 72.1 14.5

97 Tabula Inc 267ACM-Assoc Comput Mach237 669 237IEEE35.4 39.9 35.4

98 Tela Innovations inc 309SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering236 862 236IEEE27.4 35.8 27.4

99 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 229IEEE229 515 53IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng44.5 44.5 10.3

100 YANICKLO TECHNOLOG 431ACM-Assoc Comput Mach220 1011 220IEEE21.8 42.6 21.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-8Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 47: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Diagnosis/Surgery/Medical Instruments1 Medtronic Inc 9214Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau3040 39631 7927Lippincott Williams & Wilkins7.7 23.2 20.0

2 Covidien Plc 2163IEEE2163 16263 1841Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders13.3 13.3 11.3

3 Dexcom Inc 9950Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau2043 33568 3538Am Diabetese Assoc6.1 29.6 10.5

4 Boston Scientific Corp. 16454Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau2002 47002 4367Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.3 35.0 9.3

5 Abbott Laboratories 10097Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau1184 30099 4005ACS-Am Chem Soc3.9 33.5 13.3

6 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1148IEEE1148 3686 454Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders31.1 31.1 12.3

7 The Invention Science Fund 1084IEEE1084 6171 714Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.6 17.6 11.6

8 General Electric Company 827IEEE827 4443 681Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders18.6 18.6 15.3

9 COVIDIEN LP 741IEEE741 5282 584Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer14.0 14.0 11.1

10 General Hospital Corporation 2431OSA-Opt Soc Amer641 8922 1412Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders7.2 27.2 15.8

11 Masimo Corp 594IEEE594 1414 157Lippincott Williams & Wilkins42.0 42.0 11.1

12 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1141Lippincott Williams & Wilkins549 5896 746Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.3 19.4 12.7

13 Massachusetts Institute of Te 746Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau541 3100 541IEEE17.5 24.1 17.5

14 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 539IEEE539 1124 220SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 48.0 48.0 19.6

15 St. Jude Medical Inc. 2706Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau527 10881 1720Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.8 24.9 15.8

16 ArthroCare Corp. 1125Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau523 3582 523IEEE14.6 31.4 14.6

17 Johnson & Johnson 4928Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau453 17821 2529Lippincott Williams & Wilkins2.5 27.7 14.2

18 Cleveland Clinic (and Found 386Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau301 1633 301IEEE18.4 23.6 18.4

19 Medispectra Inc 281IEEE281 755 158Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.2 37.2 20.9

20 BIO CONTROL MEDICAL ( 250IEEE250 964 165Lippincott Williams & Wilkins25.9 25.9 17.1

21 University of California 900Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau228 4452 418Lippincott Williams & Wilkins5.1 20.2 9.4

22 BRAINGATE CO LLC 223IEEE223 583 92Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.3 38.3 15.8

23 RHYTHMIA MEDICAL INC 238Lippincott Williams & Wilkins207 970 207IEEE21.3 24.5 21.3

24 Stanford University 794Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau186 4481 470Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.2 17.7 10.5

25 SRI International 185IEEE185 295 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.7 62.7 8.5

26 St. Louis University 241Lippincott Williams & Wilkins173 1164 202Am Assoc Neurological Surgeons14.9 20.7 17.4

27 MIRAMAR LABS INC 170IEEE170 463 61IOP Publishing36.7 36.7 13.2

28 Smith & Nephew Plc. 831Lippincott Williams & Wilkins164 3934 783Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders4.2 21.1 19.9

29 Columbia University 248Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau152 1050 156Lippincott Williams & Wilkins14.5 23.6 14.9

30 NEUROVISTA CORP 326Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau150 1059 150IEEE14.2 30.8 14.2

31 NYXOAH SA 148IEEE148 373 46Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders39.7 39.7 12.3

32 Spectrum Dynamics Llc 146IEEE146 426 40John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss34.3 34.3 9.4

33 University of Texas 700Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau146 3452 405Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.2 20.3 11.7

34 University of Florida 200Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau145 882 145IEEE16.4 22.7 16.4

35 GUIDED THERAPY SYSTE 139IEEE139 367 61Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.9 37.9 16.6

36 ALGODYNE LTD 136IEEE136 244 40Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer55.7 55.7 16.4

37 University of Washington 241Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau131 1477 131IEEE8.9 16.3 8.9

38 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 448Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau129 2344 376Lippincott Williams & Wilkins5.5 19.1 16.0

39 University of Wisconsin 193John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss129 1468 168Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders8.8 13.1 11.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-9Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 48: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Impulse Dynamics N.V. 336Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau126 1593 255Lippincott Williams & Wilkins7.9 21.1 16.0

41 Sotera Wireless 123IEEE123 232 38Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer53.0 53.0 16.4

42 Palomar Medical Technologi 301AMA-Am Medical Assoc119 1851 296SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering6.4 16.3 16.0

43 Duke University 176Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau118 781 118IEEE15.1 22.5 15.1

44 IWALK INC 118IEEE118 346 83Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.1 34.1 24.0

45 California Institute of Techno 173Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau117 979 117IEEE12.0 17.7 12.0

46 Hitachi Ltd 116IEEE116 501 50Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.2 23.2 10.0

47 Sonova Holding AG 125Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau115 727 115IEEE15.8 17.2 15.8

48 University of Minnesota (The 274Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau115 1071 139Lippincott Williams & Wilkins10.7 25.6 13.0

49 University of Illinois 313ACS-Am Chem Soc114 2070 282Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders5.5 15.1 13.6

50 VIVAQUANT LLC 114IEEE114 177 15Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders64.4 64.4 8.5

51 KONA MEDICAL INC 174Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau108 565 108IEEE19.1 30.8 19.1

52 Georgia Institute of Technolo 125Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau107 685 107IEEE15.6 18.2 15.6

53 University of Michigan 478Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau103 2012 216Lippincott Williams & Wilkins5.1 23.8 10.7

54 Vanderbilt University 114Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau100 639 100IEEE15.6 17.8 15.6

55 CLINICAL DECISION SUPP 102Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau99 424 99IEEE23.3 24.1 23.3

56 Novartis AG 371Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau99 1480 137OSA-Opt Soc Amer6.7 25.1 9.3

57 AngioDynamics Inc. 477Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau98 2060 207Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.8 23.2 10.0

58 Volcano Corporation 97IEEE97 330 49Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.4 29.4 14.8

59 Mako Surgical Corp 110Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Klu95 250 95IEEE38.0 44.0 38.0

60 Stryker Corp. 396Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau94 1904 248Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.9 20.8 13.0

61 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 92Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Klu92 950 92IEEE9.7 9.7 9.7

62 SICEL TECHNOLOGIES IN 132Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau92 525 92IEEE17.5 25.1 17.5

63 Concormis Inc 465Lippincott Williams & Wilkins91 2714 326Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders3.4 17.1 12.0

64 International Business Machi 91IEEE91 138 10SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering65.9 65.9 7.2

65 Asahi Kasei Corp. 409Lippincott Williams & Wilkins89 1110 255Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders8.0 36.8 23.0

66 TEAM MEDICAL LLC 88IEEE88 150 16SIAM PUBLICATIONS, 3600 UNIV CITY SCIENCE CENT58.7 58.7 10.7

67 Bayer AG 123Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau86 774 86IEEE11.1 15.9 11.1

68 North Carolina State Universi 163Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau86 607 86IEEE14.2 26.9 14.2

69 Hewlett-Packard Co 83IEEE83 207 40Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders40.1 40.1 19.3

70 Case Western Reserve Univer 80IEEE80 345 63Lippincott Williams & Wilkins23.2 23.2 18.3

71 DUNE MEDICAL DEVICES 80IEEE80 135 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders59.3 59.3 11.9

72 Cyberonics Inc 355Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau79 1430 291Blackwell Futura5.5 24.8 20.3

73 Mayo Foundation for Medica 303Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau79 1081 142Lippincott Williams & Wilkins7.3 28.0 13.1

74 Olympus Corp. 281Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau78 914 87Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer8.5 30.7 9.5

75 Brown University Research F 90Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau76 422 76IEEE18.0 21.3 18.0

76 Varian Medical Systems Inc. 233Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau76 961 198Am Assoc Physicists Med/Am Inst Physics7.9 24.2 20.6

77 Bard (C.R.) Inc 1936Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau74 6945 1776Lippincott Williams & Wilkins1.1 27.9 25.6

78 Nuvasive Inc 1638Lippincott Williams & Wilkins71 2479 373Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders2.9 66.1 15.0

79 RMX LLC 101Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau69 559 98Lippincott Williams & Wilkins12.3 18.1 17.5

80 University of Iowa 65IEEE65 367 37Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.7 17.7 10.1

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-10Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 49: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 MEDACOUSTICS INC 64IEEE64 165 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.8 38.8 23.0

82 Purdue University 193Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau64 867 91John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.4 22.3 10.5

83 Toshiba Corp 96John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss64 447 64IEEE14.3 21.5 14.3

84 Given Imaging Ltd. 97Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau63 305 63IEEE20.7 31.8 20.7

85 PROTEUS DIGITAL HEALT 63IEEE63 274 55Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.0 23.0 20.1

86 Analogic Corporation 62IEEE62 160 18Am Assoc Physicists Med/Am Inst Physics38.8 38.8 11.3

87 Lockheed Martin Corp. 80Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau62 544 62IEEE11.4 14.7 11.4

88 BIOCONTROL MEDICAL L 61IEEE61 155 22Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders39.4 39.4 14.2

89 University of Pennsylvania 309Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau59 1602 190John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss3.7 19.3 11.9

90 Hansen Medical Inc 55IEEE55 93 29Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer59.1 59.1 31.2

91 INSIGHTEC LTD 55IEEE55 173 47John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss31.8 31.8 27.2

92 PerkinElmer Inc. 171OSA-Opt Soc Amer55 651 55IEEE8.4 26.3 8.4

93 TRANSSCAN MEDICAL LT 55IEEE55 84 5Peter Peregrinus Ltd65.5 65.5 6.0

94 Washington University in St. 131Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau55 806 92Lippincott Williams & Wilkins6.8 16.3 11.4

95 COMPUTERIZED MEDICA 54IEEE54 145 34Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.2 37.2 23.4

96 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 54IEEE54 170 18Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders31.8 31.8 10.6

97 MIRABILIS MEDICA INC 53IEEE53 140 27Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.9 37.9 19.3

98 WIDEMED LTD 53IEEE53 179 51Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.6 29.6 28.5

99 BIOSENSORS INTERNATI 52IEEE52 220 26Lippincott Williams & Wilkins23.6 23.6 11.8

100 Accuray Inc 51IEEE51 208 32Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders24.5 24.5 15.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-11Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 50: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Information Storage1 Micron Technology Inc. 10503IEEE10503 24430 4501Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.0 43.0 18.4

2 SanDisk Corp. 2707IEEE2707 3959 403IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys68.4 68.4 10.2

3 International Business Machi 2567IEEE2567 6215 995ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.3 41.3 16.0

4 Macronix International Co. L 1927IEEE1927 3308 488IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys58.3 58.3 14.8

5 MOSAID Technologies Inc. 1677IEEE1677 1941 107IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys86.4 86.4 5.5

6 Seagate Technology Plc 1658IEEE1658 3874 793AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics42.8 42.8 20.5

7 Western Digital Corp. 1593IEEE1593 2924 594AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics54.5 54.5 20.3

8 Toshiba Corp 1504IEEE1504 3045 358AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics49.4 49.4 11.8

9 Innovative Silicon SA 1468IEEE1468 1875 84Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders78.3 78.3 4.5

10 Rambus Inc. 1378IEEE1378 2342 235AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics58.8 58.8 10.0

11 Texas Instruments Inc 1154IEEE1154 1633 137United Business Media/UBM Tech70.7 70.7 8.4

12 Hitachi Ltd 980IEEE980 2333 189ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.0 42.0 8.1

13 Apple Inc 958IEEE958 1459 86JEDEC Semiconductor Standards Organization65.7 65.7 5.9

14 Renesas Electronic Corporati 850IEEE850 1136 79IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys74.8 74.8 7.0

15 Intel Corporation 736IEEE736 1666 227ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.2 44.2 13.6

16 Oracle Corporation 1011ACM-Assoc Comput Mach732 2536 732IEEE28.9 39.9 28.9

17 Netapp Inc 928ACM-Assoc Comput Mach671 2315 671IEEE29.0 40.1 29.0

18 Spansion Inc. 623IEEE623 726 49AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics85.8 85.8 6.7

19 LSI Corporation 521IEEE521 645 21Joint IEEE and ACM80.8 80.8 3.3

20 Broadcom Corp. 507IEEE507 827 83Miller Freeman61.3 61.3 10.0

21 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 502IEEE502 1301 181AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics38.6 38.6 13.9

22 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 488IEEE488 818 105ECMA International59.7 59.7 12.8

23 Fujitsu Limited 454IEEE454 826 78AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics55.0 55.0 9.4

24 Semiconductor Energy Labor 1514SID-Society for Information Display443 4296 530AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.3 35.2 12.3

25 STMicroelectronics 438IEEE438 593 27Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders73.9 73.9 4.6

26 TDK Corporation 436IEEE436 1267 337AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics34.4 34.4 26.6

27 Hewlett-Packard Co 433IEEE433 1316 244ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.9 32.9 18.5

28 Synopsys Inc. 392IEEE392 769 129AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics51.0 51.0 16.8

29 BTG Plc. 388IEEE388 513 52IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys75.6 75.6 10.1

30 Sony Corp 370IEEE370 809 55INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS45.7 45.7 6.8

31 ZENO SEMICONDUCTOR I 362IEEE362 462 91IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys78.4 78.4 19.7

32 Microsoft Corporation 626ACM-Assoc Comput Mach353 1677 353IEEE21.0 37.3 21.0

33 Avid Technology Inc. 321IEEE321 626 201ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.3 51.3 32.1

34 Infineon Technologies AG 311IEEE311 450 36IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys69.1 69.1 8.0

35 Cirrus Logic Inc. 299IEEE299 364 12Institute of Business Adminsitration (IBA) and IEEE82.1 82.1 3.3

36 Intertrust Technologies Corp 387ACM-Assoc Comput Mach287 1774 287IEEE16.2 21.8 16.2

37 NEC Corp 279IEEE279 617 90AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics45.2 45.2 14.6

38 Microchip Technology Inc. 276IEEE276 321 18Penton Media86.0 86.0 5.6

39 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 268IEEE268 354 10AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics75.7 75.7 2.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-12Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 51: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 QST Holdings Llc 255IEEE255 406 48Joint IEEE and ACM62.8 62.8 11.8

41 Marvell Technology Group Lt 251IEEE251 342 32ECMA International73.4 73.4 9.4

42 EMC Corp. 247IEEE247 761 173ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.5 32.5 22.7

43 Commvault Systems Inc. 246IEEE246 364 61ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.6 67.6 16.8

44 Panasonic Corporation 241IEEE241 872 102INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS27.6 27.6 11.7

45 Altera Corp. 231IEEE231 414 111Penton Media55.8 55.8 26.8

46 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 227IEEE227 635 63ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.7 35.7 9.9

47 Pioneer Corp. 231SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering205 686 205IEEE29.9 33.7 29.9

48 Xilinx Inc. 202IEEE202 270 19Joint IEEE and ACM74.8 74.8 7.0

49 Sharp Corp 199IEEE199 487 60AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40.9 40.9 12.3

50 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. 188IEEE188 252 19IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys74.6 74.6 7.5

51 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 168IEEE168 225 26IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys74.7 74.7 11.6

52 Arm Holdings Plc 156IEEE156 247 35Joint IEEE and ACM63.2 63.2 14.2

53 Nantero Inc 514ACS-Am Chem Soc144 1881 372AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics7.7 27.3 19.8

54 Hynix Semiconductor Inc 141IEEE141 165 9IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys85.5 85.5 5.5

55 NETLIST INC 232IP.Com139 683 173JEDEC Semiconductor Standards Organization20.4 34.0 25.3

56 AVALANCHE TECHNOLO 191AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics138 611 138IEEE22.6 31.3 22.6

57 HGST NETHERLANDS BV 134IEEE134 263 64AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics51.0 51.0 24.3

58 Qualcomm Inc 134IEEE134 183 9Joint IEEE and ACM73.2 73.2 4.9

59 California Institute of Techno 116IEEE116 221 18AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci52.5 52.5 8.1

60 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 116IEEE116 208 23IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys55.8 55.8 11.1

61 Alcatel-Lucent 112IEEE112 254 53ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.1 44.1 20.9

62 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 110IEEE110 261 17AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics42.1 42.1 6.5

63 Intellectual Ventures Manage 107IEEE107 109 1Joint IEEE and ACM98.2 98.2 0.9

64 Round Rock Research LLC 105IEEE105 301 68Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.9 34.9 22.6

65 Cisco Systems Inc. 102IEEE102 223 57ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.7 45.7 25.6

66 Columbia University 98IEEE98 248 46ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.5 39.5 18.5

67 Qimonda AG 98IEEE98 205 34IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys47.8 47.8 16.6

68 Tilera Corp 94IEEE94 217 75Joint IEEE and ACM43.3 43.3 34.6

69 Google Inc. 93IEEE93 213 73ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.7 43.7 34.3

70 DENSBITS TECHNOLOGIE 91IEEE91 142 13Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer64.1 64.1 9.2

71 Carnegie Mellon University 86IEEE86 176 66AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics48.9 48.9 37.5

72 PMC-Sierra Inc. 86IEEE86 113 6Pennwell Pub76.1 76.1 5.3

73 Waratek 84IEEE84 195 54ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.1 43.1 27.7

74 Motorola Solutions Inc. 81IEEE81 134 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.4 60.4 4.5

75 Imation Corp. 76IEEE76 178 20Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders42.7 42.7 11.2

76 Soitec SA 72IEEE72 90 5IET/IEE80.0 80.0 5.6

77 Sap AG 71IEEE71 220 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.3 32.3 11.4

78 Interuniversity MicroElectron 70IEEE70 106 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach66.0 66.0 5.7

79 Kilopass Technologies Inc 70IEEE70 70 100.0 100.0

80 Monolithic System Technolo 70IEEE70 92 8SLDRAM Consortium76.1 76.1 8.7

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-13Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 52: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 NVIDIA Corp. 69IEEE69 114 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.5 60.5 21.1

82 Commissariat A L'Energie At 68IEEE68 194 38AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics35.1 35.1 19.6

83 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 67IEEE67 135 24AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics49.6 49.6 17.8

84 The Invention Science Fund 64IEEE64 186 36MIT/MIT Press34.4 34.4 19.4

85 Cadence Design Systems Inc 58IEEE58 96 20Penton Media60.4 60.4 20.8

86 Seiko Epson Corporation 68IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys57 144 57IEEE39.6 47.2 39.6

87 Silicon Graphics Internationa 57IEEE57 105 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach54.3 54.3 23.8

88 Honeywell International Inc. 55IEEE55 80 9Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer68.8 68.8 11.3

89 BAE Systems Plc. 49IEEE49 51 1Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders96.1 96.1 2.0

90 CROSSBAR INC 49IEEE49 231 35Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders21.2 21.2 15.2

91 Intersil Corp. 49IEEE49 58 6Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer84.5 84.5 10.3

92 INVOICE TECHNOLOGY I 48IEEE48 52 4AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics92.3 92.3 7.7

93 Fuji Electric Holdings Co. Lt 46IEEE46 104 21AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics44.2 44.2 20.2

94 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 45IEEE45 186 26IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng24.2 24.2 14.0

95 University of California 122ACS-Am Chem Soc45 398 46AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.3 30.7 11.6

96 BOISE STATE UNIVERSIT 102Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau43 371 68ACS-Am Chem Soc11.6 27.5 18.3

97 Industrial Techology Researc 43IEEE43 83 9IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys51.8 51.8 10.8

98 Microsemi Corp 43IEEE43 70 12Cahners-Denver Pub61.4 61.4 17.1

99 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 42IEEE42 54 4IET/IEE77.8 77.8 7.4

100 Halo LSI Inc. 41IEEE41 56 8IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys73.2 73.2 14.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-14Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 53: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Measuring, Testing and Control Devices1 General Hospital Corporation 11510OSA-Opt Soc Amer2825 29709 4141Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.5 38.7 13.9

2 Cascade Microtech Inc. 1662IEEE1662 3131 642Nature Publishing Group53.1 53.1 20.5

3 Mentor Graphics Corp. 1254IEEE1254 1493 118Joint IEEE and ACM84.0 84.0 7.9

4 International Business Machi 1207IEEE1207 2759 200ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.7 43.7 7.2

5 Microsoft Corporation 973IEEE973 2393 539ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.7 40.7 22.5

6 Texas Instruments Inc 938IEEE938 1233 36IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys76.1 76.1 2.9

7 Honeywell International Inc. 880IEEE880 2546 348Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.6 34.6 13.7

8 Irobot Corp 870IEEE870 1637 314SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering53.1 53.1 19.2

9 Life Technologies Corporatio 1678Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau747 4748 747IEEE15.7 35.3 15.7

10 Emerson Electric Co. 723IEEE723 3084 390Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.4 23.4 12.6

11 Applied Materials Inc. 687IEEE687 1407 168AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics48.8 48.8 11.9

12 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 647IEEE647 2033 288John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss31.8 31.8 14.2

13 California Institute of Techno 671Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau525 4248 525IEEE12.4 15.8 12.4

14 General Electric Company 761US Dept of Energy525 4309 682John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss12.2 17.7 15.8

15 Alcatel-Lucent 440IEEE440 1054 58Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.7 41.7 5.5

16 Midtronics Inc. 440IEEE440 990 198Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders44.4 44.4 20.0

17 Intel Corporation 429IEEE429 1084 83AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics39.6 39.6 7.7

18 ABB Ltd 414IEEE414 580 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders71.4 71.4 6.6

19 Synopsys Inc. 388IEEE388 484 28SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering80.2 80.2 5.8

20 Apple Inc 378IEEE378 733 91ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.6 51.6 12.4

21 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 373IEEE373 833 98Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders44.8 44.8 11.8

22 Hewlett-Packard Co 365IEEE365 1308 121SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering27.9 27.9 9.3

23 University of Illinois 461Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau360 3548 457ACS-Am Chem Soc10.1 13.0 12.9

24 Agilent Technologies Inc 346IEEE346 1131 142Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders30.6 30.6 12.6

25 Boeing Co. (The) 335IEEE335 987 99Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.9 33.9 10.0

26 ParkerVision Inc 331IEEE331 510 50IET/IEE64.9 64.9 9.8

27 Qualcomm Inc 328IEEE328 724 1243GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body45.3 45.3 17.1

28 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 319IEEE319 683 136SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 46.7 46.7 19.9

29 Advantest Corp. 305IEEE305 418 23AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics73.0 73.0 5.5

30 NEC Corp 304IEEE304 652 36IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng46.6 46.6 5.5

31 Abbott Laboratories 3250ACS-Am Chem Soc298 10962 3157Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders2.7 29.6 28.8

32 Stanford University 298IEEE298 2004 276OSA-Opt Soc Amer14.9 14.9 13.8

33 Ericsson 295IEEE295 541 483GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body54.5 54.5 8.9

34 University of Texas 291IEEE291 1879 284Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders15.5 15.5 15.1

35 Schlumberger Ltd. 798soc of Exploration Geophysists289 4226 782Society of Petroleum Engineers6.8 18.9 18.5

36 Micron Technology Inc. 287IEEE287 531 37AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics54.0 54.0 7.0

37 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 280IEEE280 622 69SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering45.0 45.0 11.1

38 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 337John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss276 1391 276IEEE19.8 24.2 19.8

39 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 270IEEE270 380 26Joint IEEE and ACM71.1 71.1 6.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-15Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 54: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Georgia Institute of Technolo 269IEEE269 825 125OSA-Opt Soc Amer32.6 32.6 15.2

41 Massachusetts Institute of Te 319Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau269 2372 269IEEE11.3 13.4 11.3

42 University of California 600Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau255 3957 508ACS-Am Chem Soc6.4 15.2 12.8

43 Lockheed Martin Corp. 250IEEE250 1261 148Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.8 19.8 11.7

44 Panasonic Corporation 250IEEE250 804 172Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders31.1 31.1 21.4

45 LSI Corporation 249IEEE249 382 19Joint IEEE and ACM65.2 65.2 5.0

46 Marvell Technology Group Lt 245IEEE245 267 6Bluetooth Special Interest Group91.8 91.8 2.2

47 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 238IEEE238 452 41Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders52.7 52.7 9.1

48 Fujitsu Limited 230IEEE230 452 31The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force50.9 50.9 6.9

49 Nintendo Co. Ltd. 221IEEE221 630 158ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.1 35.1 25.1

50 HRL Laboratories LLC 219IEEE219 477 62Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders45.9 45.9 13.0

51 Rockwell Automation Inc 217IEEE217 400 58Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders54.3 54.3 14.5

52 Hitachi Ltd 214IEEE214 1027 150Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.8 20.8 14.6

53 United States Navy 211IEEE211 1288 191Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.4 16.4 14.8

54 Toshiba Corp 208IEEE208 883 191John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss23.6 23.6 21.6

55 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 206IEEE206 904 88Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders22.8 22.8 9.7

56 Infineon Technologies AG 205IEEE205 327 39Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.7 62.7 11.9

57 Cisco Systems Inc. 326The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineerin204 975 204IEEE20.9 33.4 20.9

58 General Motors Corp 199IEEE199 384 40SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers51.8 51.8 10.4

59 Duke University 198IEEE198 907 121OSA-Opt Soc Amer21.8 21.8 13.3

60 Immersion Corp. 194IEEE194 458 42ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng42.4 42.4 9.2

61 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 193IEEE193 363 19ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.2 53.2 5.2

62 LTX-Credence Corp 187IEEE187 328 43AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics57.0 57.0 13.1

63 Xerox Corp 185IEEE185 591 58Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders31.3 31.3 9.8

64 Motorola Solutions Inc. 184IEEE184 545 73ACS-Am Chem Soc33.8 33.8 13.4

65 Fluidigm Corp 204ACS-Am Chem Soc183 1218 183IEEE15.0 16.7 15.0

66 Invensys Plc. 295I S A-INSTRUM SYS AUTOMATION SOC180 1930 244Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.3 15.3 12.6

67 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 179IEEE179 206 7Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders86.9 86.9 3.4

68 Teradyne Inc. 177IEEE177 382 58ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng46.3 46.3 15.2

69 University of Southern Califo 177IEEE177 351 37Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer50.4 50.4 10.5

70 Current Communications Gro 176IEEE176 233 19Echelon Corp75.5 75.5 8.2

71 Michigan State University 284OSA-Opt Soc Amer176 1497 195AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.8 19.0 13.0

72 Sony Corp 176IEEE176 400 30ACS-Am Chem Soc44.0 44.0 7.5

73 Analog Devices Inc. 174IEEE174 257 13Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders67.7 67.7 5.1

74 TROXLER ELECTRONIC L 173IEEE173 400 97AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS, 100 BARR HARBOR 43.3 43.3 24.3

75 Commissariat A L'Energie At 170IEEE170 715 157Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.8 23.8 22.0

76 Raytheon Co. 170IEEE170 556 51SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering30.6 30.6 9.2

77 STMicroelectronics 170IEEE170 247 27Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders68.8 68.8 10.9

78 Cadence Design Systems Inc 167IEEE167 286 56Joint IEEE and ACM58.4 58.4 19.6

79 AT&T Inc 165IEEE165 316 33The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force52.2 52.2 10.4

80 NANONEXUS INC 163IEEE163 231 21AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics70.6 70.6 9.1

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-16Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 55: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Nokia Corp 160IEEE160 311 303GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body51.4 51.4 9.6

82 University of Michigan 157IEEE157 676 101ACS-Am Chem Soc23.2 23.2 14.9

83 KLA-Tencor Corp. 657SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering156 2777 525OSA-Opt Soc Amer5.6 23.7 18.9

84 Xilinx Inc. 156IEEE156 186 10Joint IEEE and ACM83.9 83.9 5.4

85 ICOSYSTEM CORP 150IEEE150 187 10IET/IEE80.2 80.2 5.3

86 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 149IEEE149 499 69Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.9 29.9 13.8

87 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 1217Society of Petroleum Engineers148 3093 558SPWLA-Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log Analysts4.8 39.3 18.0

88 Broadcom Corp. 141IEEE141 198 10The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force71.2 71.2 5.1

89 Teledyne Technologies Incor 140IEEE140 260 14Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders53.8 53.8 5.4

90 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 135IEEE135 304 353GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body44.4 44.4 11.5

91 Oracle Corporation 135IEEE135 280 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.2 48.2 8.6

92 Schneider Electric S.A. 130IEEE130 388 39ANSI-American National Standards Institute33.5 33.5 10.1

93 SRI International 130IEEE130 481 62Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.0 27.0 12.9

94 Sanken Electric Co. Ltd. 128IEEE128 169 24Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders75.7 75.7 14.2

95 Battelle Memorial Institute 147Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau121 644 121IEEE18.8 22.8 18.8

96 PENRITH CORP 121IEEE121 168 15DYNAMEDIA INC72.0 72.0 8.9

97 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 121IEEE121 195 16AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62.1 62.1 8.2

98 Baker Hughes Inc. 349Society of Petroleum Engineers118 1412 174soc of Exploration Geophysists8.4 24.7 12.3

99 BIOSCALE INC 181Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau118 735 157ACS-Am Chem Soc16.1 24.6 21.4

100 ROY-G-BIV CORP 117IEEE117 272 31Microsoft43.0 43.0 11.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-17Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 56: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Nuclear/X-Ray/Radiant Energy1 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 293IEEE293 729 83Soc Nucl Med40.2 40.2 11.4

2 General Electric Company 261IEEE261 1072 164Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders24.3 24.3 15.3

3 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 225IEEE225 845 86OSA-Opt Soc Amer26.6 26.6 10.2

4 Dynasil Corporation of Ameri 149IEEE149 293 31Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders50.9 50.9 10.6

5 Stanford University 125IEEE125 579 114AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics21.6 21.6 19.7

6 Spectrum Dynamics Llc 121IEEE121 370 32John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss32.7 32.7 8.6

7 Virgin Islands Microsystems 120IEEE120 479 87AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics25.1 25.1 18.2

8 Medispectra Inc 82IEEE82 223 46Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders36.8 36.8 20.6

9 University of California 195Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau82 1125 182AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics7.3 17.3 16.2

10 BIOSENSORS INTERNATI 79IEEE79 276 44Soc Nucl Med28.6 28.6 15.9

11 ASML Holding NV 489AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics76 1306 253SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering5.8 37.4 19.4

12 Brookhaven Science Associat 76IEEE76 179 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders42.5 42.5 21.2

13 General Hospital Corporation 309OSA-Opt Soc Amer74 843 129Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders8.8 36.7 15.3

14 INTEGRATED SENSORS L 72IEEE72 87 5SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering82.8 82.8 5.7

15 University of Texas 78ACS-Am Chem Soc72 562 72IEEE12.8 13.9 12.8

16 Hitachi Ltd 211AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics66 986 140Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders6.7 21.4 14.2

17 TROXLER ELECTRONIC L 66IEEE66 148 34AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS, 100 BARR HARBOR 44.6 44.6 23.0

18 Apple Inc 64IEEE64 124 16CBS Interactive51.6 51.6 12.9

19 Purdue University 167Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau63 781 155ACS-Am Chem Soc8.1 21.4 19.8

20 California Institute of Techno 71OSA-Opt Soc Amer58 528 69AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.0 13.4 13.1

21 Honeywell International Inc. 58IEEE58 337 55Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.2 17.2 16.3

22 Alcatel-Lucent 55IEEE55 164 29AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.5 33.5 17.7

23 University of Michigan 54IEEE54 224 22AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics24.1 24.1 9.8

24 Micron Technology Inc. 50IEEE50 214 40AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics23.4 23.4 18.7

25 SICEL TECHNOLOGIES IN 76Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau50 369 50IEEE13.6 20.6 13.6

26 Hamamatsu Photonics KK 71Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau49 226 49IEEE21.7 31.4 21.7

27 Boston University 48IEEE48 84 18Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders57.1 57.1 21.4

28 Carl-Zeiss Stiftung 432AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics47 1353 311Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders3.5 31.9 23.0

29 University of Pennsylvania 45IEEE45 115 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics39.1 39.1 13.0

30 Advio Biosciences Inc. 350ACS-Am Chem Soc44 674 131Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders6.5 51.9 19.4

31 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 56Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau44 312 44IEEE14.1 17.9 14.1

32 University of Washington 127Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau44 413 44IEEE10.7 30.8 10.7

33 Innovative American Technol 43IEEE43 76 23Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders56.6 56.6 30.3

34 Applied Materials Inc. 208AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics42 624 98SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering6.7 33.3 15.7

35 Massachusetts Institute of Te 355ACS-Am Chem Soc41 918 116Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders4.5 38.7 12.6

36 Stichting voor de Technische 41IEEE41 122 39Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.6 33.6 32.0

37 Boeing Co. (The) 40IEEE40 175 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders22.9 22.9 21.7

38 International Business Machi 72AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40 243 40IEEE16.5 29.6 16.5

39 Duke University 39IEEE39 175 29OSA-Opt Soc Amer22.3 22.3 16.6

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-18Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 57: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Rohm Co. Ltd. 310ACS-Am Chem Soc38 597 108Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders6.4 51.9 18.1

41 Michigan State University 88OSA-Opt Soc Amer37 471 75Am Physical Soc7.9 18.7 15.9

42 Toshiba Corp 49AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics37 253 40Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders14.6 19.4 15.8

43 United States Navy 72Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau36 279 44ACS-Am Chem Soc12.9 25.8 15.8

44 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OP 78OSA-Opt Soc Amer35 372 66Am Physical Soc9.4 21.0 17.7

45 KLA-Tencor Corp. 214SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering35 762 189AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics4.6 28.1 24.8

46 SAIC Inc 42SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering34 251 34IEEE13.5 16.7 13.5

47 DIGIRAD CORP 33IEEE33 100 18Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.0 33.0 18.0

48 XY LLC 77Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau32 360 73AMER SOC ANIMAL SCIENCE, 1111 NORTH DUNLAP A8.9 21.4 20.3

49 NANOLAMBDA INC 31IEEE31 71 12OSA-Opt Soc Amer43.7 43.7 16.9

50 FEI Co. 129AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics30 411 87Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders7.3 31.4 21.2

51 Los Alamos National Securit 85Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau30 335 32John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss9.0 25.4 9.6

52 William Marsh Rice Universi 41AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics28 279 39ACS-Am Chem Soc10.0 14.7 14.0

53 Agilent Technologies Inc 90ACS-Am Chem Soc27 461 89Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders5.9 19.5 19.3

54 Canon Inc 157AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics27 468 73ACS-Am Chem Soc5.8 33.5 15.6

55 Commissariat A L'Energie At 46Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau27 202 28OSA-Opt Soc Amer13.4 22.8 13.9

56 University of Wisconsin 88AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics27 442 82ACS-Am Chem Soc6.1 19.9 18.6

57 Covidien Plc 26IEEE26 130 18Lippincott Williams & Wilkins20.0 20.0 13.8

58 Lockheed Martin Corp. 34Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau26 233 26IEEE11.2 14.6 11.2

59 MEVION MEDICAL SYSTE 26IEEE26 93 21Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.0 28.0 22.6

60 National Institute of Radiolog 26IEEE26 53 13Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders49.1 49.1 24.5

61 University of Illinois 263ACS-Am Chem Soc26 913 117Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders2.8 28.8 12.8

62 3M Co 61Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau25 360 47ACS-Am Chem Soc6.9 16.9 13.1

63 Anritsu Corp. 25IEEE25 35 5IET/IEE71.4 71.4 14.3

64 PROPORTIONAL TECHNO 25IEEE25 29 3Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders86.2 86.2 10.3

65 Corning Inc. 32OSA-Opt Soc Amer24 124 24IEEE19.4 25.8 19.4

66 FBI CO 60Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau24 113 24IEEE21.2 53.1 21.2

67 Xerox Corp 24IEEE24 171 20John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss14.0 14.0 11.7

68 Safran S.A. 23IEEE23 111 21AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics20.7 20.7 18.9

69 Qinetiq Group Ltd 26OSA-Opt Soc Amer22 94 25SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering23.4 27.7 26.6

70 TECHNISCAN INC 22IEEE22 56 12soc of Exploration Geophysists39.3 39.3 21.4

71 The Invention Science Fund 47AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics22 274 33Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders8.0 17.2 12.0

72 BOARD OF REGENTS OF T 50AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics21 131 33Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.0 38.2 25.2

73 University of Alabama 98Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau21 246 27Blackwell Futura8.5 39.8 11.0

74 Washington University in St. 21Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau21 76 21IEEE27.6 27.6 27.6

75 Affymetrix Inc. 292Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau20 1142 175ACS-Am Chem Soc1.8 25.6 15.3

76 AT&T Inc 20IEEE20 28 4IET/IEE71.4 71.4 14.3

77 Jefferson Science Associates 20IEEE20 29 5Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders69.0 69.0 17.2

78 L-3 Communications Holdin 20IEEE20 74 18SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering27.0 27.0 24.3

79 STILL RIVER SYSTEMS IN 20AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics20 100 20IEEE20.0 20.0 20.0

80 Shimadzu Corp. 49Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau19 161 26John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss11.8 30.4 16.1

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-19Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 58: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 SRU Biosystems Inc 29OSA-Opt Soc Amer19 149 22Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.8 19.5 14.8

82 Waters Corp 147ACS-Am Chem Soc19 508 122John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss3.7 28.9 24.0

83 Zyvex Corp 26AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics19 75 19IEEE25.3 34.7 25.3

84 Danaher Corp. 149Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau18 681 108ACS-Am Chem Soc2.6 21.9 15.9

85 Illumina Inc. 55Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau18 301 54ACS-Am Chem Soc6.0 18.3 17.9

86 Medtronic Inc 35Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau18 195 22Lippincott Williams & Wilkins9.2 17.9 11.3

87 Nippon Kayaku Co. Ltd. 20AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics18 98 18IEEE18.4 20.4 18.4

88 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 18IEEE18 41 5OSA-Opt Soc Amer43.9 43.9 12.2

89 Schlumberger Ltd. 33ACS-Am Chem Soc18 161 31Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders11.2 20.5 19.3

90 Sionex Corp 74Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau18 202 20Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer8.9 36.6 9.9

91 Sony Corp 18IEEE18 29 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.1 62.1 13.8

92 Charles Stark Draper Laborat 66Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau17 217 24Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer7.8 30.4 11.1

93 HAMMERSMITH IMANET 17IEEE17 19 2IOP Publishing89.5 89.5 10.5

94 Varian Medical Systems Inc. 35Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau17 161 17IEEE10.6 21.7 10.6

95 BIOSCALE INC 16IEEE16 59 14Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.1 27.1 23.7

96 Cornell University 50ACS-Am Chem Soc16 257 35John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.2 19.5 13.6

97 Intematix Corp 52AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics16 137 20INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS11.7 38.0 14.6

98 SAN DIEGO STATE UNIVE 16IEEE16 20 2Soc Nucl Med80.0 80.0 10.0

99 Lawrence Livermore National 47Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau15 140 20ACS-Am Chem Soc10.7 33.6 14.3

100 REDZONEROBOTICS INC 15IEEE15 15 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-20Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 59: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Optics/Photography/Electrophotography1 Infinera Corporation 1346IEEE1346 2121 395IET/IEE63.5 63.5 18.6

2 Qualcomm Inc 1230IEEE1230 3494 753SID-Society for Information Display35.2 35.2 21.6

3 General Hospital Corporation 3163OSA-Opt Soc Amer753 7951 1128Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.5 39.8 14.2

4 Alcatel-Lucent 668IEEE668 2157 349OSA-Opt Soc Amer31.0 31.0 16.2

5 IDC Llc 637IEEE637 1595 272SID-Society for Information Display39.9 39.9 17.1

6 Corning Inc. 610OSA-Opt Soc Amer595 2565 595IEEE23.2 23.8 23.2

7 Hoya Corp 588IEEE588 1280 260AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics45.9 45.9 20.3

8 Massachusetts Institute of Te 566IEEE566 2403 406OSA-Opt Soc Amer23.6 23.6 16.9

9 Lightsmyth Technologies Inc 462IEEE462 949 217OSA-Opt Soc Amer48.7 48.7 22.9

10 Kotura Inc 439IEEE439 1010 279IET/IEE43.5 43.5 27.6

11 Synopsys Inc. 1443SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering411 3033 462INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS13.6 47.6 15.2

12 Dainippon Screen Manufactu 374IEEE374 1381 215Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.1 27.1 15.6

13 Intel Corporation 370IEEE370 965 166SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering38.3 38.3 17.2

14 Nikon Corp. 1086SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering368 2154 368IEEE17.1 50.4 17.1

15 LG Ericsson 544OSA-Opt Soc Amer351 1136 351IEEE30.9 47.9 30.9

16 Cheetah Omni LLC 337IEEE337 1120 275OSA-Opt Soc Amer30.1 30.1 24.6

17 JDS Uniphase Corp 302IEEE302 903 185OSA-Opt Soc Amer33.4 33.4 20.5

18 SiPix Imaging Inc. 456SID-Society for Information Display301 1129 301IEEE26.7 40.4 26.7

19 3M Co 556OSA-Opt Soc Amer270 3349 317Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders8.1 16.6 9.5

20 Stanford University 332OSA-Opt Soc Amer264 1371 264IEEE19.3 24.2 19.3

21 Finisar Corp 244IEEE244 642 100SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering38.0 38.0 15.6

22 Prysmian SPA 239IEEE239 702 177OSA-Opt Soc Amer34.0 34.0 25.2

23 Texas Instruments Inc 233IEEE233 871 150AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics26.8 26.8 17.2

24 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 231IEEE231 557 48Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer41.5 41.5 8.6

25 STEYPHI SERVICES DE LL 231IEEE231 458 104OSA-Opt Soc Amer50.4 50.4 22.7

26 University of California 222IEEE222 1188 166OSA-Opt Soc Amer18.7 18.7 14.0

27 Fujitsu Limited 212IEEE212 887 151IET/IEE23.9 23.9 17.0

28 United States of America De 210IEEE210 583 152IET/IEE36.0 36.0 26.1

29 Adobe Systems Inc. 179IEEE179 411 105ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.6 43.6 25.5

30 Electronics and Telecommuni 178IEEE178 341 46IET/IEE52.2 52.2 13.5

31 Princeton University 177IEEE177 384 44AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics46.1 46.1 11.5

32 International Business Machi 370SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering172 1411 172IEEE12.2 26.2 12.2

33 Sumitomo Electric Industries 226OSA-Opt Soc Amer171 865 222IET/IEE19.8 26.1 25.7

34 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 168IEEE168 548 127IET/IEE30.7 30.7 23.2

35 OMNIGUIDE COMMUNIC 168IEEE168 489 95OSA-Opt Soc Amer34.4 34.4 19.4

36 California Institute of Techno 406OSA-Opt Soc Amer160 1173 160IEEE13.6 34.6 13.6

37 LIGHTCHIP INC 159IEEE159 463 113IET/IEE34.3 34.3 24.4

38 Rockstar Consortium (Nortel 159IEEE159 338 60OSA-Opt Soc Amer47.0 47.0 17.8

39 Micron Technology Inc. 316SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering153 1443 266AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.6 21.9 18.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-21Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 60: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Hewlett-Packard Co 144IEEE144 718 89OSA-Opt Soc Amer20.1 20.1 12.4

41 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. 214OSA-Opt Soc Amer143 617 143IEEE23.2 34.7 23.2

42 Emcore Corp. 140IEEE140 157 8OSA-Opt Soc Amer89.2 89.2 5.1

43 Georgia Institute of Technolo 137IEEE137 380 80OSA-Opt Soc Amer36.1 36.1 21.1

44 The Invention Science Fund 136IEEE136 532 68Am Physical Soc25.6 25.6 12.8

45 Ericsson 134IEEE134 303 72IET/IEE44.2 44.2 23.8

46 Xerox Corp 195ACS-Am Chem Soc132 1080 145Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.2 18.1 13.4

47 NEC Corp 128IEEE128 673 75TECHNICAL ASSOC PHOTOPOLYMERS19.0 19.0 11.1

48 PTS Corporation 125IEEE125 232 34OSA-Opt Soc Amer53.9 53.9 14.7

49 Cubic Wafer Inc 124IEEE124 222 42SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.9 55.9 18.9

50 Honeywell International Inc. 124IEEE124 424 60SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering29.2 29.2 14.2

51 Motorola Solutions Inc. 121IEEE121 417 94AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics29.0 29.0 22.5

52 KOTUSA INC 118IEEE118 236 57IET/IEE50.0 50.0 24.2

53 Lockheed Martin Corp. 246OSA-Opt Soc Amer116 690 116IEEE16.8 35.7 16.8

54 Calient Technologies Inc. 111IEEE111 179 27OSA-Opt Soc Amer62.0 62.0 15.1

55 Neophotonics Corporation 105IEEE105 278 48OSA-Opt Soc Amer37.8 37.8 17.3

56 Applied Materials Inc. 111SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering97 494 97IEEE19.6 22.5 19.6

57 Eastman Kodak Company 146ACS-Am Chem Soc96 1121 130SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering8.6 13.0 11.6

58 CIRREX SYSTEMS LLC 94IEEE94 272 40OSA-Opt Soc Amer34.6 34.6 14.7

59 University of Colorado ( The 237OSA-Opt Soc Amer94 620 94IEEE15.2 38.2 15.2

60 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 93IEEE93 292 51SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering31.8 31.8 17.5

61 University of Texas 117AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics89 703 89IEEE12.7 16.6 12.7

62 OMM INC 86IEEE86 194 43SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering44.3 44.3 22.2

63 TE Connectivity Ltd 86IEEE86 159 21IWCS Inc.54.1 54.1 13.2

64 Northrop Grumman Corp 85IEEE85 268 62OSA-Opt Soc Amer31.7 31.7 23.1

65 Panasonic Corporation 113SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering85 567 85IEEE15.0 19.9 15.0

66 NANOOPTO CORP 115AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics84 327 84IEEE25.7 35.2 25.7

67 ASML Holding NV 1591SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering81 4399 873AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics1.8 36.2 19.8

68 Yuen Foong Yu Paper Manuf 1563SID-Society for Information Display81 2708 206Nature Publishing Group3.0 57.7 7.6

69 Columbia University 93ACS-Am Chem Soc80 363 80IEEE22.0 25.6 22.0

70 Fujikara Ltd. 140OSA-Opt Soc Amer80 421 85IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng19.0 33.3 20.2

71 Tessera Technologies Inc. 86OSA-Opt Soc Amer80 229 80IEEE34.9 37.6 34.9

72 Analog Devices Inc. 77IEEE77 139 21Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders55.4 55.4 15.1

73 Canon Inc 187SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering75 1011 135OSA-Opt Soc Amer7.4 18.5 13.4

74 Microsoft Corporation 139ACM-Assoc Comput Mach75 283 75IEEE26.5 49.1 26.5

75 Extreme Networks Inc 72IEEE72 156 22ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.2 46.2 14.1

76 Oclaro Inc 71IEEE71 252 59OSA-Opt Soc Amer28.2 28.2 23.4

77 Olympus Corp. 109OSA-Opt Soc Amer69 381 69IEEE18.1 28.6 18.1

78 Seiko Epson Corporation 68IEEE68 262 55SID-Society for Information Display26.0 26.0 21.0

79 HRL Laboratories LLC 66IEEE66 201 33OSA-Opt Soc Amer32.8 32.8 16.4

80 United States Navy 74OSA-Opt Soc Amer65 357 65IEEE18.2 20.7 18.2

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-22Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 61: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 VASCULAR IMAGING CO 65IEEE65 129 40IET/IEE50.4 50.4 31.0

82 Hitachi Ltd 64IEEE64 357 38OSA-Opt Soc Amer17.9 17.9 10.6

83 Iowa State University 64IEEE64 145 13AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics44.1 44.1 9.0

84 Current Communications Gro 61IEEE61 76 7Echelon Corp80.3 80.3 9.2

85 OSTERHOUT GROUP INC 61IEEE61 199 54SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering30.7 30.7 27.1

86 Volcano Corporation 61IEEE61 132 20IET/IEE46.2 46.2 15.2

87 Agilent Technologies Inc 59IEEE59 277 51OSA-Opt Soc Amer21.3 21.3 18.4

88 Ohio State University 71OSA-Opt Soc Amer59 223 59IEEE26.5 31.8 26.5

89 OMNIGUIDE INC 122OSA-Opt Soc Amer58 413 58IEEE14.0 29.5 14.0

90 LSI Corporation 63SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57 205 57IEEE27.8 30.7 27.8

91 MICRON OPTICS INC 57IEEE57 159 46OSA-Opt Soc Amer35.8 35.8 28.9

92 CONFLUENT PHOTONICS 56IEEE56 185 45IET/IEE30.3 30.3 24.3

93 General Electric Company 55IEEE55 330 48ACS-Am Chem Soc16.7 16.7 14.5

94 Oewaves Inc 74OSA-Opt Soc Amer55 183 55IEEE30.1 40.4 30.1

95 Cisco Systems Inc. 54IEEE54 110 25OSA-Opt Soc Amer49.1 49.1 22.7

96 Cornell University 54ACS-Am Chem Soc54 379 54IEEE14.2 14.2 14.2

97 Brigham Young University 57OSA-Opt Soc Amer53 304 53IEEE17.4 18.8 17.4

98 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 52IEEE52 457 43SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering11.4 11.4 9.4

99 MOLECULAR OPTOELEC 79IET/IEE51 258 64OSA-Opt Soc Amer19.8 30.6 24.8

100 NETWORK PHOTONICS IN 51IEEE51 110 24OSA-Opt Soc Amer46.4 46.4 21.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-23Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 62: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Power Systems1 Cirrus Logic Inc. 1172IEEE1172 1297 42ISO-International Standards Organization90.4 90.4 3.2

2 ABB Ltd 703IEEE703 1119 65CIGRE-International Council on Large Electric Systems62.8 62.8 5.8

3 SYNQOR INC 591IEEE591 675 27Penton Media87.6 87.6 4.0

4 Flextronics International LTD 586IEEE586 630 29United Business Media/UBM Tech93.0 93.0 4.6

5 Texas Instruments Inc 470IEEE470 538 18IET/IEE87.4 87.4 3.3

6 SOLARBRIDGE TECHNOL 298IEEE298 329 11IET/IEE90.6 90.6 3.3

7 Emerson Electric Co. 287IEEE287 363 20IET/IEE79.1 79.1 5.5

8 General Electric Company 773US Dept of Energy272 1566 272IEEE17.4 49.4 17.4

9 AMPT LLC 220IEEE220 303 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders72.6 72.6 8.3

10 Alcatel-Lucent 218IEEE218 255 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders85.5 85.5 3.1

11 University of Wisconsin 213IEEE213 242 8EPE Association88.0 88.0 3.3

12 Power-One Inc 208IEEE208 378 94IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium55.0 55.0 24.9

13 Vicor Corp 192IEEE192 270 37Center for Power Electronics Systems (Virginia Tech)71.1 71.1 13.7

14 Intel Corporation 184IEEE184 241 14IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys76.3 76.3 5.8

15 Toshiba Corp 174IEEE174 375 91Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders46.4 46.4 24.3

16 Exar Corp. 161IEEE161 169 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss95.3 95.3 1.8

17 Rockwell Automation Inc 160IEEE160 170 8IET/IEE94.1 94.1 4.7

18 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 157IEEE157 282 19EPE Association55.7 55.7 6.7

19 Linear Technology Corp. 396Cahners-Denver Pub147 739 147IEEE19.9 53.6 19.9

20 Midtronics Inc. 143IEEE143 354 69Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer40.4 40.4 19.5

21 Power Integrations Inc. 135IEEE135 228 46Penton Media59.2 59.2 20.2

22 Micron Technology Inc. 132IEEE132 188 22IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys70.2 70.2 11.7

23 O2Micro International Ltd. 126IEEE126 193 33Texas Instruments65.3 65.3 17.1

24 STMicroelectronics 125IEEE125 181 13Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders69.1 69.1 7.2

25 University of Illinois 304Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau117 670 117IEEE17.5 45.4 17.5

26 SRI International 134SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering114 654 114IEEE17.4 20.5 17.4

27 Silicon Laboratories Inc 113IEEE113 126 12SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers89.7 89.7 9.5

28 Enpirion Inc 111IEEE111 111 100.0 100.0

29 Intersil Corp. 111IEEE111 137 5Cahners-Denver Pub81.0 81.0 3.6

30 Analog Devices Inc. 108IEEE108 124 3IET/IEE87.1 87.1 2.4

31 Marvell Technology Group Lt 107IEEE107 138 16Texas Instruments77.5 77.5 11.6

32 Eaton Corp. 106IEEE106 141 13Electrochemical Society75.2 75.2 9.2

33 General Motors Corp 107Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau104 371 104IEEE28.0 28.8 28.0

34 Avago Technologies Ltd 103IEEE103 125 10AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics82.4 82.4 8.0

35 WITRICITY CORP 101IEEE101 185 20AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics54.6 54.6 10.8

36 Massachusetts Institute of Te 216Electrochemical Society98 766 162Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.8 28.2 21.1

37 International Business Machi 95IEEE95 127 6Joint IEEE and ACM74.8 74.8 4.7

38 MOSAID Technologies Inc. 95IEEE95 103 3Joint IEEE and ACM92.2 92.2 2.9

39 Lockheed Martin Corp. 91IEEE91 192 30Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.4 47.4 15.6

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-24Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 63: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 89IEEE89 140 20IET/IEE63.6 63.6 14.3

41 SOLAREDGE LTD 86IEEE86 119 27WIP-Renewable Energies72.3 72.3 22.7

42 Maxim Integrated Products In 85IEEE85 105 14Texas Instruments81.0 81.0 13.3

43 MOJO MOBILITY INC 84IEEE84 108 9Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders77.8 77.8 8.3

44 Schneider Electric S.A. 83IEEE83 116 9IEEE/DOE/JPL71.6 71.6 7.8

45 United Technologies Corp 83IEEE83 168 40SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers49.4 49.4 23.8

46 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. 82IEEE82 104 8IET/IEE78.8 78.8 7.7

47 Infineon Technologies AG 81IEEE81 90 2IET/IEE90.0 90.0 2.2

48 Raytheon Co. 81IEEE81 100 8AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro81.0 81.0 8.0

49 Delta Electronics Inc 80IEEE80 87 2PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)92.0 92.0 2.3

50 SanDisk Corp. 80IEEE80 93 9McGraw Hill86.0 86.0 9.7

51 MOTOR EXCELLENCE LL 79IEEE79 93 14IEEE/ASME84.9 84.9 15.1

52 Panasonic Corporation 312Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau79 941 270Electrochemical Society8.4 33.2 28.7

53 Renesas Electronic Corporati 74IEEE74 100 10IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys74.0 74.0 10.0

54 Apple Inc 73IEEE73 153 28ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.7 47.7 18.3

55 University of California 68IEEE68 392 63Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.3 17.3 16.1

56 University of Colorado ( The 66IEEE66 68 2<conf> Int Conf Phys Semi (ICPS)97.1 97.1 2.9

57 Sony Corp 65IEEE65 229 46Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.4 28.4 20.1

58 FMC Technologies Inc. 64IEEE64 91 9IET/IEE70.3 70.3 9.9

59 INFINITE POWER SOLUTI 102AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62 435 91Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders14.3 23.4 20.9

60 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 62IEEE62 122 5ILLUMINAT ENG SOC NORTH AMER50.8 50.8 4.1

61 Current Communications Gro 61IEEE61 73 4Echelon Corp83.6 83.6 5.5

62 Microsemi Corp 61IEEE61 81 4Universal Serial Bus Specification75.3 75.3 4.9

63 Honeywell International Inc. 59IEEE59 152 37Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.8 38.8 24.3

64 Dialog Semiconductor Plc. 58IEEE58 87 18ONLINE INC66.7 66.7 20.7

65 Toyota Motor Corp 87Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau57 381 72Cahners-Denver Pub15.0 22.8 18.9

66 Advanced Energy Industries I 56IEEE56 57 1IET/IEE98.2 98.2 1.8

67 Hitachi Ltd 56IEEE56 203 41IET/IEE27.6 27.6 20.2

68 CPG TECHNOLOGIES LLC 55IEEE55 120 12Am Physical Soc45.8 45.8 10.0

69 Industrial Techology Researc 54IEEE54 65 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders83.1 83.1 6.2

70 Atmel Corp. 53IEEE53 63 9IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng84.1 84.1 14.3

71 BOARD OF REGENTS OF T 52IEEE52 64 12IET/IEE81.3 81.3 18.8

72 Procter & Gamble Co. 305Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau52 775 169Electrochemical Society6.7 39.4 21.8

73 American Superconductor Co 50IEEE50 62 7IET/IEE80.6 80.6 11.3

74 Ericsson 50IEEE50 75 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders66.7 66.7 10.7

75 INI POWER SYSTEMS INC 196Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau50 525 89Electrochemical Society9.5 37.3 17.0

76 PTS Corporation 48IEEE48 78 12AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics61.5 61.5 15.4

77 TDK Corporation 48IEEE48 70 5IET/IEE68.6 68.6 7.1

78 Electric Power Research Insti 47IEEE47 53 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders88.7 88.7 3.8

79 Johnson Controls Inc 46IEEE46 103 26Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders44.7 44.7 25.2

80 Cameron International Corp. 45IEEE45 45 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-25Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 64: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Cornell University 45IEEE45 136 21Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.1 33.1 15.4

82 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 43IEEE43 142 34Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders30.3 30.3 23.9

83 Motorola Solutions Inc. 42IEEE42 92 14Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders45.7 45.7 15.2

84 SUSTAINABLE ENERGY T 42IEEE42 43 1EPE Association97.7 97.7 2.3

85 TIGO ENERGY INC 42IEEE42 65 17WIP-Renewable Energies64.6 64.6 26.2

86 Georgia Institute of Technolo 41IEEE41 65 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders63.1 63.1 12.3

87 ADVANCED MAGNET LA 40IEEE40 45 5IEEE/APS88.9 88.9 11.1

88 Broadcom Corp. 40IEEE40 46 2Bluetooth Special Interest Group87.0 87.0 4.3

89 Continental AG (Germany Fe 40IEEE40 49 6IET/IEE81.6 81.6 12.2

90 LSI Corporation 39IEEE39 53 2Joint IEEE and ACM73.6 73.6 3.8

91 Virginia Tech University 39IEEE39 44 2MRS-Materials Research Soc88.6 88.6 4.5

92 Commissariat A L'Energie At 38IEEE38 110 32Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.5 34.5 29.1

93 Fairchild Semiconductor Inte 38IEEE38 53 8Penton Media71.7 71.7 15.1

94 Fujitsu Limited 38IEEE38 79 10Joint IEEE and ACM48.1 48.1 12.7

95 Hong Kong University of Sci 38IEEE38 40 1Joint IEEE and ACM95.0 95.0 2.5

96 RF Micro Devices Inc. 38IEEE38 78 27Cahners-Denver Pub48.7 48.7 34.6

97 City University of Hong Kon 37IEEE37 40 2IET/IEE92.5 92.5 5.0

98 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 37IEEE37 41 4IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys90.2 90.2 9.8

99 Harman International Industri 37IEEE37 42 2Audio Eng Soc88.1 88.1 4.8

100 University of Michigan 37IEEE37 71 13Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders52.1 52.1 18.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-26Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 65: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing1 Irobot Corp 1911IEEE1911 3412 602SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering56.0 56.0 17.6

2 Applied Materials Inc. 1489IEEE1489 2379 185AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62.6 62.6 7.8

3 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 838IEEE838 1563 280SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 53.6 53.6 17.9

4 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 594IEEE594 1263 156Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.0 47.0 12.4

5 Microsoft Corporation 458IEEE458 1276 286ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.9 35.9 22.4

6 International Business Machi 409IEEE409 1031 135ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.7 39.7 13.1

7 Sony Corp 381IEEE381 491 23IEEE/RSJ77.6 77.6 4.7

8 Immersion Corp. 286IEEE286 716 76ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.9 39.9 10.6

9 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 242IEEE242 475 62Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders50.9 50.9 13.1

10 SIPCO LLC 237IEEE237 402 35The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force59.0 59.0 8.7

11 INTOUCH TECHNOLOGIE 233IEEE233 433 29Lippincott Williams & Wilkins53.8 53.8 6.7

12 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 218IEEE218 463 51Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.1 47.1 11.0

13 VistaPrint NV 179IEEE179 425 166Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders42.1 42.1 39.1

14 SRI International 158IEEE158 365 55SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering43.3 43.3 15.1

15 ICOSYSTEM CORP 150IEEE150 187 10IET/IEE80.2 80.2 5.3

16 Caterpillar Inc. 143IEEE143 304 38SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers47.0 47.0 12.5

17 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 142IEEE142 232 25IEEE/RSJ61.2 61.2 10.8

18 HRL Laboratories LLC 141IEEE141 227 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.1 62.1 7.0

19 Cadence Design Systems Inc 135IEEE135 290 82Joint IEEE and ACM46.6 46.6 28.3

20 University of Nebraska 131IEEE131 503 77Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer26.0 26.0 15.3

21 ROY-G-BIV CORP 123IEEE123 372 67ISO-International Standards Organization33.1 33.1 18.0

22 Emerson Electric Co. 122IEEE122 517 62Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.6 23.6 12.0

23 Fanuc Ltd. 112IEEE112 150 6Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders74.7 74.7 4.0

24 Toshiba Corp 105IEEE105 166 7Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders63.3 63.3 4.2

25 Amada Co. Ltd. 103IEEE103 287 55Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders35.9 35.9 19.2

26 Massachusetts Institute of Te 102IEEE102 308 29ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.1 33.1 9.4

27 Fujitsu Limited 101IEEE101 163 13Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.0 62.0 8.0

28 University of Southern Califo 100IEEE100 150 16Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer66.7 66.7 10.7

29 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 99IEEE99 206 10Lippincott Williams & Wilkins48.1 48.1 4.9

30 Xerox Corp 97IEEE97 216 27ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.9 44.9 12.5

31 American Express Co. 96IEEE96 320 39The USENIX Association30.0 30.0 12.2

32 Evolution Robotics Inc 96IEEE96 138 8IEEE/RSJ69.6 69.6 5.8

33 CA Inc 92IEEE92 158 37Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.2 58.2 23.4

34 Battelle Memorial Institute 91IEEE91 125 15IEEE/RSJ72.8 72.8 12.0

35 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 90IEEE90 155 15Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.1 58.1 9.7

36 NEC Corp 89IEEE89 151 12ACM-Assoc Comput Mach58.9 58.9 7.9

37 ABB Ltd 88IEEE88 123 12Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders71.5 71.5 9.8

38 General Electric Company 88IEEE88 177 14Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders49.7 49.7 7.9

39 Rockwell Automation Inc 88IEEE88 175 24Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders50.3 50.3 13.7

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-27Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 66: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Lockheed Martin Corp. 87IEEE87 168 12Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders51.8 51.8 7.1

41 Panasonic Corporation 83IEEE83 164 11IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng50.6 50.6 6.7

42 Hewlett-Packard Co 80IEEE80 204 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.2 39.2 11.8

43 Sensable Technologies Inc 80IEEE80 157 40ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.0 51.0 25.5

44 ALOFT MEDIA LLC 79IEEE79 96 6ASCE-AMER SOC CIVIL ENGINEERS, 1801 ALEXANDER82.3 82.3 6.3

45 Tokyo Electron Limited 76IEEE76 211 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders36.0 36.0 11.8

46 ARCHI CON DES INVENTI 115ACM-Assoc Comput Mach71 342 71IEEE20.8 33.6 20.8

47 Boeing Co. (The) 71IEEE71 232 64Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders30.6 30.6 27.6

48 Honeywell International Inc. 71IEEE71 170 28Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.8 41.8 16.5

49 Cirrus Logic Inc. 69IEEE69 87 10Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders79.3 79.3 11.5

50 Health Discovery Corp 69IEEE69 242 22Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.5 28.5 9.1

51 Mako Surgical Corp 78Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Klu69 179 69IEEE38.5 43.6 38.5

52 Sap AG 69IEEE69 242 42Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.5 28.5 17.4

53 AUREON LABORATORIES 64IEEE64 254 43Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders25.2 25.2 16.9

54 Motorola Solutions Inc. 64IEEE64 96 4ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)66.7 66.7 4.2

55 Texas Instruments Inc 63IEEE63 115 13Penton Media54.8 54.8 11.3

56 Oracle Corporation 61IEEE61 105 17ACM-Assoc Comput Mach58.1 58.1 16.2

57 United Technologies Corp 61IEEE61 90 7EPE Association67.8 67.8 7.8

58 HURCO COMPANIES INC 60IEEE60 126 16Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer47.6 47.6 12.7

59 TEST ADVANTAGE INC 58IEEE58 69 3SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering84.1 84.1 4.3

60 Delphi Automotive Plc 56IEEE56 120 38Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders46.7 46.7 31.7

61 Ford Motor Co. 53IEEE53 149 24Winter Simulation Conference Board of Directors35.6 35.6 16.1

62 Georgia Institute of Technolo 52IEEE52 97 15American Automatic Control Council (AACC)53.6 53.6 15.5

63 INTUITION INTELLIGENC 50IEEE50 60 3Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer83.3 83.3 5.0

64 University of Minnesota (The 48IEEE48 87 9Emerald Group Publishing55.2 55.2 10.3

65 Eaton Corp. 47IEEE47 49 1Cahners-Denver Pub95.9 95.9 2.0

66 General Motors Corp 45IEEE45 107 15NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin42.1 42.1 14.0

67 ROBOTICVISIONTECH LL 44IEEE44 60 5Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders73.3 73.3 8.3

68 California Institute of Techno 43IEEE43 61 4Am Physical Soc70.5 70.5 6.6

69 Micron Technology Inc. 43IEEE43 69 8AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62.3 62.3 11.6

70 Accenture Ltd. 42IEEE42 141 33ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.8 29.8 23.4

71 AT&T Inc 42IEEE42 84 13Bellcore50.0 50.0 15.5

72 FTL SYSTEMS INC 42IEEE42 50 7ACM-Assoc Comput Mach84.0 84.0 14.0

73 Agilent Technologies Inc 41IEEE41 59 2ACM-Assoc Comput Mach69.5 69.5 3.4

74 Procter & Gamble Co. 41IEEE41 60 7Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders68.3 68.3 11.7

75 University of Michigan 40IEEE40 84 10INST MEASUREMENT CONTROL47.6 47.6 11.9

76 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 39IEEE39 79 5CRC Press/Taylor & Francis49.4 49.4 6.3

77 Kuka AG 39IEEE39 49 2IEEE/RSJ79.6 79.6 4.1

78 France Telecom S.A. 38IEEE38 55 6Joint IEEE and ACM69.1 69.1 10.9

79 The National Aeronautical an 38IEEE38 83 17NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin45.8 45.8 20.5

80 ASML Holding NV 100SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering37 149 37IEEE24.8 67.1 24.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-28Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 67: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Hitachi Ltd 37IEEE37 97 8ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng38.1 38.1 8.2

82 KNOWMTECH LLC 59ACS-Am Chem Soc37 334 58AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.1 17.7 17.4

83 New York University 37IEEE37 62 10ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.7 59.7 16.1

84 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 35IEEE35 49 3MIT/MIT Press71.4 71.4 6.1

85 NUMENTA INC 35IEEE35 118 15Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer29.7 29.7 12.7

86 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 34IEEE34 78 13ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.6 43.6 16.7

87 Raytheon Co. 34IEEE34 100 14SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC34.0 34.0 14.0

88 Cascade Microtech Inc. 33IEEE33 54 7Nature Publishing Group61.1 61.1 13.0

89 National Instruments Corp. 33IEEE33 75 12SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering44.0 44.0 16.0

90 Align Technology Inc 65JCO - Journal of Clinical Orthodontics32 319 64Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders10.0 20.4 20.1

91 Brooks Automation Inc. 32IEEE32 60 5ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng53.3 53.3 8.3

92 Dassault Systemes SA 32IEEE32 129 31Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders24.8 24.8 24.0

93 IMMERSION HUMAN INT 32IEEE32 64 7SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering50.0 50.0 10.9

94 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 32IEEE32 51 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.7 62.7 7.8

95 REDZONE ROBOTICS INC 32IEEE32 32 100.0 100.0

96 Alcatel-Lucent 31IEEE31 62 7IET/IEE50.0 50.0 11.3

97 EXEGY INC 31IEEE31 62 10ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.0 50.0 16.1

98 Tangis Corp 31IEEE31 55 13ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.4 56.4 23.6

99 Canon Inc 30IEEE30 72 11Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.7 41.7 15.3

100 MICROSCRIBE LLC 30IEEE30 48 5SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering62.5 62.5 10.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-29Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 68: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Semiconductors/Solid-State Devices/Electronics1 Micron Technology Inc. 19935IEEE19935 73775 14280Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.0 27.0 19.4

2 International Business Machi 5279IEEE5279 11551 1770AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics45.7 45.7 15.3

3 Macronix International Co. L 3475IEEE3475 6689 1045IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys52.0 52.0 15.6

4 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 3445IEEE3445 9068 2285AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics38.0 38.0 25.2

5 Intel Corporation 3210IEEE3210 5959 640AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.9 53.9 10.7

6 Semiconductor Energy Labor 7233SID-Society for Information Display3206 28744 5447AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.2 25.2 19.0

7 Megic Corporation 2832IEEE2832 3388 265Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders83.6 83.6 7.8

8 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 2548IEEE2548 4607 512IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys55.3 55.3 11.1

9 Tela Innovations inc 2982SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering2494 8532 2494IEEE29.2 35.0 29.2

10 Texas Instruments Inc 2394IEEE2394 4425 505AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics54.1 54.1 11.4

11 SanDisk Corp. 2386IEEE2386 4150 506AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics57.5 57.5 12.2

12 Cree Inc. 2384IEEE2384 6878 1643AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics34.7 34.7 23.9

13 Amberwave Inc 2354IEEE2354 6723 1777AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics35.0 35.0 26.4

14 Toshiba Corp 1687IEEE1687 3791 495AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics44.5 44.5 13.1

15 Infineon Technologies AG 1624IEEE1624 3073 352AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.8 52.8 11.5

16 Applied Materials Inc. 2057AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics1592 9839 1690Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.2 20.9 17.2

17 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 1585IEEE1585 2978 323AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.2 53.2 10.8

18 Fairchild Semiconductor Inte 1493IEEE1493 1970 185Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders75.8 75.8 9.4

19 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. 1430IEEE1430 3255 589AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics43.9 43.9 18.1

20 Finisar Corp 1205IEEE1205 3153 566AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics38.2 38.2 18.0

21 Motorola Solutions Inc. 1163IEEE1163 3489 849AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.3 33.3 24.3

22 STMicroelectronics 1096IEEE1096 2275 293Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders48.2 48.2 12.9

23 Panasonic Corporation 1082IEEE1082 4261 781AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics25.4 25.4 18.3

24 University of California 2481AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics999 9365 1288Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders10.7 26.5 13.8

25 Fujitsu Limited 994IEEE994 2477 323AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40.1 40.1 13.0

26 California Institute of Techno 964IEEE964 4956 771Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.5 19.5 15.6

27 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 941IEEE941 3210 590AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics29.3 29.3 18.4

28 Renesas Electronic Corporati 925IEEE925 1648 221IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.1 56.1 13.4

29 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 917IEEE917 1890 222AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics48.5 48.5 11.7

30 NEC Corp 900IEEE900 2318 372AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics38.8 38.8 16.0

31 Broadcom Corp. 993SMTA-Surface Mount Technology Associatio896 4014 896IEEE22.3 24.7 22.3

32 University of Illinois 1724AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics832 7609 1125ACS-Am Chem Soc10.9 22.7 14.8

33 Massachusetts Institute of Te 1009AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics747 4693 747IEEE15.9 21.5 15.9

34 Hitachi Ltd 641IEEE641 2075 385AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics30.9 30.9 18.6

35 HRL Laboratories LLC 636IEEE636 1261 210AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics50.4 50.4 16.7

36 Sharp Corp 776AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics622 2694 622IEEE23.1 28.8 23.1

37 LSI Corporation 587IEEE587 1234 180AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics47.6 47.6 14.6

38 Alcatel-Lucent 556IEEE556 2344 468AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics23.7 23.7 20.0

39 Commissariat A L'Energie At 727AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics554 3182 576Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.4 22.8 18.1

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-30Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 69: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Synopsys Inc. 542IEEE542 1346 247AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40.3 40.3 18.4

41 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 647AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics520 2451 520IEEE21.2 26.4 21.2

42 Hynix Semiconductor Inc 501IEEE501 953 87AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.6 52.6 9.1

43 JDS Uniphase Corp 499IEEE499 1545 474AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics32.3 32.3 30.7

44 Lam Research Corp. 616AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics467 2478 467IEEE18.8 24.9 18.8

45 ASM International N.V. 1012Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau463 4296 906AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.8 23.6 21.1

46 Xtera Communications Inc. 450IEEE450 1095 325IET/IEE41.1 41.1 29.7

47 Qualcomm Inc 445IEEE445 1147 143SID-Society for Information Display38.8 38.8 12.5

48 Innovative Silicon SA 421IEEE421 532 24Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders79.1 79.1 4.5

49 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 419IEEE419 790 74AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.0 53.0 9.4

50 Avago Technologies Ltd 413IEEE413 637 78AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics64.8 64.8 12.2

51 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 408AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics401 1571 401IEEE25.5 26.0 25.5

52 Canon Inc 745AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics387 3028 424Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.8 24.6 14.0

53 Electronics and Telecommuni 382IEEE382 972 240AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics39.3 39.3 24.7

54 Michigan State University 955OSA-Opt Soc Amer367 4375 709AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics8.4 21.8 16.2

55 Interuniversity MicroElectron 364IEEE364 991 129Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders36.7 36.7 13.0

56 Seiko Epson Corporation 361IEEE361 1384 238AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics26.1 26.1 17.2

57 Xerox Corp 524AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics348 1926 348IEEE18.1 27.2 18.1

58 Hong Kong University of Sci 345IEEE345 600 133AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics57.5 57.5 22.2

59 Power Integrations Inc. 344IEEE344 450 47INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS76.4 76.4 10.4

60 General Hospital Corporation 1343OSA-Opt Soc Amer338 3460 483Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.8 38.8 14.0

61 Georgia Institute of Technolo 335IEEE335 918 123AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics36.5 36.5 13.4

62 University of Wisconsin 353AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics334 1292 334IEEE25.9 27.3 25.9

63 Spansion Inc. 317IEEE317 398 32AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics79.6 79.6 8.0

64 Global Foundries Inc 301IEEE301 578 62AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.1 52.1 10.7

65 Nantero Inc 1943ACS-Am Chem Soc299 6282 1186AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics4.8 30.9 18.9

66 Analog Devices Inc. 297IEEE297 492 48Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders60.4 60.4 9.8

67 Hewlett-Packard Co 397AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics294 1759 294IEEE16.7 22.6 16.7

68 Sony Corp 296AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics292 1364 292IEEE21.4 21.7 21.4

69 Ziptronix Inc 368AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics290 1354 290IEEE21.4 27.2 21.4

70 Coherent Inc. 451OSA-Opt Soc Amer273 2004 429AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics13.6 22.5 21.4

71 PEREGRINE SEMICONDU 273IEEE273 457 59AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics59.7 59.7 12.9

72 University of Michigan 271IEEE271 896 143OSA-Opt Soc Amer30.2 30.2 16.0

73 Silicon Genesis Corporation 307Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau269 1334 285AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics20.2 23.0 21.4

74 Industrial Techology Researc 261IEEE261 588 82AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics44.4 44.4 13.9

75 Lockheed Martin Corp. 359AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics259 1409 284OSA-Opt Soc Amer18.4 25.5 20.2

76 Honeywell International Inc. 377ACS-Am Chem Soc257 1694 257IEEE15.2 22.3 15.2

77 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 254IEEE254 408 69Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.3 62.3 16.9

78 Corning Inc. 254IEEE254 965 145Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders26.3 26.3 15.0

79 General Electric Company 251IEEE251 1088 180AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics23.1 23.1 16.5

80 Promos Technologies Inc. 243IEEE243 319 68IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys76.2 76.2 21.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-31Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 70: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 United Microelectronics Corp 240IEEE240 525 72IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys45.7 45.7 13.7

82 Aisin Seiki Co. Ltd. 705OSA-Opt Soc Amer236 1433 236IEEE16.5 49.2 16.5

83 Fuji Electric Holdings Co. Lt 225IEEE225 358 39AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics62.8 62.8 10.9

84 Raytheon Co. 224IEEE224 787 130AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics28.5 28.5 16.5

85 Northrop Grumman Corp 223IEEE223 809 165AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics27.6 27.6 20.4

86 Vishay Intertechnology Inc. 222IEEE222 353 22PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)62.9 62.9 6.2

87 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. 221IEEE221 636 122IET/IEE34.7 34.7 19.2

88 Eastman Kodak Company 295AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics214 1022 214IEEE20.9 28.9 20.9

89 SRI International 214IEEE214 1156 199SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering18.5 18.5 17.2

90 Emcore Corp. 211IEEE211 415 74US Dept of Energy50.8 50.8 17.8

91 Denso Corp 210IEEE210 534 66AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics39.3 39.3 12.4

92 Microsemi Corp 209IEEE209 309 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics67.6 67.6 4.9

93 United States Navy 360AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics209 1183 209IEEE17.7 30.4 17.7

94 Tabula Inc 231ACM-Assoc Comput Mach205 566 205IEEE36.2 40.8 36.2

95 Sulvolta Inc 203IEEE203 379 51AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.6 53.6 13.5

96 UNISANTIS ELECTRONIC 203IEEE203 234 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders86.8 86.8 6.8

97 Sumitomo Electric Industries 363AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics201 1597 282Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.6 22.7 17.7

98 Amkor Technology Inc. 196IEEE196 481 79Penton Media40.7 40.7 16.4

99 Soitec SA 323AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics194 1166 222Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.6 27.7 19.0

100 Columbia University 1024AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics192 2850 353MRS-Materials Research Soc6.7 35.9 12.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-32Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 71: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Smart Grid/Smart Meters/Energy Infrastructure1 Current Communications Gro 811IEEE811 1036 78Echelon Corp78.3 78.3 7.5

2 Elster Group GmbH 211IEEE211 245 9Joint IEEE and ACM86.1 86.1 3.7

3 TRILLIANT NETWORKS I 128IEEE128 190 13The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force67.4 67.4 6.8

4 SIPCO LLC 84IEEE84 139 13The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force60.4 60.4 9.4

5 ABB Ltd 65IEEE65 79 5IET/IEE82.3 82.3 6.3

6 3M Co 33IEEE33 38 1ASM INTERNATIONAL, SUBSCRIPTIONS SPECIALIST C86.8 86.8 2.6

7 Microsoft Corporation 30IEEE30 59 11ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.8 50.8 18.6

8 CURRENT GRID LLC 28IEEE28 35 3<std> CLC SC 105A80.0 80.0 8.6

9 Texas A&M University 28IEEE28 35 3IET/IEE80.0 80.0 8.6

10 Qualcomm Inc 27IEEE27 40 3Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders67.5 67.5 7.5

11 ENERGY TECHNOLOGY G 26IEEE26 30 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders86.7 86.7 6.7

12 Georgia Institute of Technolo 43ACM-Assoc Comput Mach20 70 20IEEE28.6 61.4 28.6

13 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 17IEEE17 34 15Elecrostatic Discharge Association50.0 50.0 44.1

14 ELSTER SOLUTIONS LLC 15IEEE15 17 1Joint IEEE and ACM88.2 88.2 5.9

15 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 14IEEE14 32 11United Business Media/UBM Tech43.8 43.8 34.4

16 Sony Corp 20SID-Society for Information Display13 40 13IEEE32.5 50.0 32.5

17 REDWOOD SYSTEMS INC 12IEEE12 12 100.0 100.0

18 Rockwell Automation Inc 12IEEE12 16 2Electric Power Research Institute75.0 75.0 12.5

19 Schneider Electric S.A. 27ANSI-American National Standards Institute11 89 14ISO-International Standards Organization12.4 30.3 15.7

20 THE DETROIT EDISON CO 11IEEE11 11 100.0 100.0

21 Itron Inc. 10IEEE10 17 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.8 58.8 11.8

22 Johnson Controls Inc 10IEEE10 10 100.0 100.0

23 NORWEB PLC 10IEEE10 24 5Pennwell Pub41.7 41.7 20.8

24 General Electric Company 9IEEE9 19 6IET/IEE47.4 47.4 31.6

25 RADAR ENGINEERS 9IEEE9 10 1Penton Media90.0 90.0 10.0

26 TIGO ENERGY INC 9IEEE9 13 3WIP-Renewable Energies69.2 69.2 23.1

27 University of Wisconsin 9IEEE9 10 1MONTANA HISTORICAL SOC, 225 N ROBERTS ST, HEL90.0 90.0 10.0

28 Belkin International Inc 13ACM-Assoc Comput Mach8 27 8IEEE29.6 48.1 29.6

29 Massachusetts Institute of Te 8IEEE8 11 2AMER SOC NAVAL ENG INC, 1452 DUKE STREET, ALE72.7 72.7 18.2

30 Panasonic Corporation 8IEEE8 11 2IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng72.7 72.7 18.2

31 AT&T Inc 7IEEE7 7 100.0 100.0

32 CURRENT TECHNOLOGIE 7IEEE7 11 2Hewlett Packard Inc.63.6 63.6 18.2

33 CURRETN GRID LLC 7IEEE7 11 2Echelon Corp63.6 63.6 18.2

34 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 8Elecrostatic Discharge Association7 15 7IEEE46.7 53.3 46.7

35 INTERNATIONAL BROAD 7IEEE7 13 4ISO-International Standards Organization53.8 53.8 30.8

36 POWER TAGGING TECHN 7IEEE7 8 1IET/IEE87.5 87.5 12.5

37 Terahop Networks Inc 7IEEE7 11 1The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force63.6 63.6 9.1

38 The Invention Science Fund 7IEEE7 13 4ANSI-American National Standards Institute53.8 53.8 30.8

39 Honeywell International Inc. 6IEEE6 7 1IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys85.7 85.7 14.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-33Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 72: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Vacon Oyj 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.0

41 Alstom 5IEEE5 8 2IET/IEE62.5 62.5 25.0

42 Canon Inc 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

43 COM/ENERGY TECHNOL 6McGraw Hill5 16 5IEEE31.3 37.5 31.3

44 D-Wave Systems Inc. 9Am Physical Soc5 28 5AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics17.9 32.1 17.9

45 International Business Machi 5IEEE5 7 1IBM Corp71.4 71.4 14.3

46 On Semiconductor Corporati 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

47 Roche Holding Ltd. 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

48 University of Alberta 5IEEE5 8 1John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss62.5 62.5 12.5

49 University of Connecticut 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

50 Cisco Systems Inc. 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

51 DGI CREATIONS LLC 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

52 Fujitsu Limited 4IEEE4 8 2AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro50.0 50.0 25.0

53 HUDSON BAY WIRELESS 4IEEE4 5 1Condé Nast80.0 80.0 20.0

54 TX RX SYSTEMS INC 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

55 ACEX TECHNOLOGIES IN 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

56 American Superconductor Co 5Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau3 8 3IEEE37.5 62.5 37.5

57 Danaher Corp. 3IEEE3 4 1Penton Media75.0 75.0 25.0

58 Digi International Inc 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

59 Electric Power Research Insti 6Electric Power Research Institute3 9 3IEEE33.3 66.7 33.3

60 Hewlett-Packard Co 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

61 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

62 NEW YORK STATE ELECT 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.0

63 ADVANCED TESTING TEC 2IEEE2 3 1Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders66.7 66.7 33.3

64 Amazing Microelectronic Cor 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

65 BASIC MEASURING INST 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

66 BITRONICS INC 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

67 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

68 Conexant Systems Inc. 2IEEE2 4 1The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force50.0 50.0 25.0

69 COOPER TECHNOLOGIES 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

70 CORRIDOR SYSTEMS INC 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

71 DISTRIBUTION CONTROL 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

72 Eaton Corp. 2IEEE2 4 2McGraw Hill50.0 50.0 50.0

73 Electro Industries Gauge Tec 4ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2 6 2IEEE33.3 66.7 33.3

74 Electronics and Telecommuni 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

75 ExxonMobil Corp 6soc of Exploration Geophysists2 14 2IEEE14.3 42.9 14.3

76 GENSCAPE INC 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

77 INTERNATIONAL BROAD 2IEEE2 4 2ISO-International Standards Organization50.0 50.0 50.0

78 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 2IEEE2 4 1Sci American Inc50.0 50.0 25.0

79 Motorola Solutions Inc. 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

80 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-34Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 73: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 STMicroelectronics 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss2 7 2IEEE28.6 42.9 28.6

82 TENNESSEE VALLEY AUT 2IEEE2 3 1Pennwell Pub66.7 66.7 33.3

83 TII INDUSTRIES INC 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

84 Toshiba Corp 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

85 Universite de Liege 2IEEE2 4 1IOP Publishing50.0 50.0 25.0

86 University of California 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

87 Alcatel-Lucent 1United Business Media/UBM Tech1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

88 Arraycomm Inc. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

89 Boeing Co. (The) 1TRANS TECH PUBLICATIONS LTD, BRA1 5 1AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS, 100 BARR HARBOR 20.0 20.0 20.0

90 BOH TECHNOLOGY LLC 1INST OPERATIONS RESEARCH MANAGE1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

91 Clemson University 1IEEE1 3 1AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.3 33.3 33.3

92 COMTECH XICOM TECHN 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

93 DOMINION WIRELESS 1NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admi1 3 1IEEE33.3 33.3 33.3

94 DOMOSYS CORP 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

95 Emerson Electric Co. 1IEEE1 2 1SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC50.0 50.0 50.0

96 ENMETRIC SYSTEMS INC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

97 France Telecom S.A. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

98 GENSCAPE INTANGIBLE 1IEEE1 2 1INST MEASUREMENT CONTROL50.0 50.0 50.0

99 GIGLE SEMICONDUCTOR 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

100 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-35Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 74: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Solar/Photovoltaic1 Sunpower Corp 197IEEE197 279 34WIP-Renewable Energies70.6 70.6 12.2

2 Emcore Corp. 196IEEE196 364 76US Dept of Energy53.8 53.8 20.9

3 Xerox Corp 97IEEE97 258 42Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.6 37.6 16.3

4 Canon Inc 85IEEE85 224 47AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics37.9 37.9 21.0

5 Applied Materials Inc. 76IEEE76 218 50WIP-Renewable Energies34.9 34.9 22.9

6 SOLEXEL INC 108Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau67 303 69John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss22.1 35.6 22.8

7 University of Illinois 132ACS-Am Chem Soc62 678 124AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9.1 19.5 18.3

8 Nanosolar Inc 237Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau61 828 107Electrochemical Society7.4 28.6 12.9

9 Advanced Energy Industries I 54IEEE54 56 2IET/IEE96.4 96.4 3.6

10 SOLARBRIDGE TECHNOL 53IEEE53 57 2WIP-Renewable Energies93.0 93.0 3.5

11 TIGO ENERGY INC 51IEEE51 78 21WIP-Renewable Energies65.4 65.4 26.9

12 Lockheed Martin Corp. 50IEEE50 153 41AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics32.7 32.7 26.8

13 Miasole 49IEEE49 192 41Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders25.5 25.5 21.4

14 EVERGREEN SOLAR INC 48IEEE48 96 44ACS-Am Chem Soc50.0 50.0 45.8

15 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 80AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics47 225 47IEEE20.9 35.6 20.9

16 General Electric Company 83ACS-Am Chem Soc44 284 44IEEE15.5 29.2 15.5

17 Sharp Corp 39IEEE39 91 17Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders42.9 42.9 18.7

18 JX CRYSTALS INC 38IEEE38 107 30Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders35.5 35.5 28.0

19 SOLYNDRA LLC 44Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau36 158 36IEEE22.8 27.8 22.8

20 University of Toledo 72Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau33 122 33IEEE27.0 59.0 27.0

21 Stion Corp 156Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau30 405 76AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics7.4 38.5 18.8

22 Texas Instruments Inc 30IEEE30 39 4Electrochemical Society76.9 76.9 10.3

23 AMPT LLC 28IEEE28 38 3Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders73.7 73.7 7.9

24 Panasonic Corporation 40AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics27 144 30Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders18.8 27.8 20.8

25 Guardian Industries Corp. 105Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau25 258 70AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9.7 40.7 27.1

26 Imperial College 25IEEE25 75 22AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.3 33.3 29.3

27 Midwest Research Institute 25IEEE25 91 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.5 27.5 27.5

28 SOLAREDGE LTD 25IEEE25 33 6WIP-Renewable Energies75.8 75.8 18.2

29 Solyndra Inc 46Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau25 139 25IEEE18.0 33.1 18.0

30 Raytheon Co. 24IEEE24 40 6AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics60.0 60.0 15.0

31 SUNIVA INC 22IEEE22 42 5AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.4 52.4 11.9

32 Ignis Innovation Inc 20IEEE20 22 1Emerald Group Publishing90.9 90.9 4.5

33 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 20IEEE20 34 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.8 58.8 11.8

34 Q-CELLS SE 20IEEE20 33 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders60.6 60.6 12.1

35 SOLARWORLD INNOVATI 20IEEE20 50 9Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders40.0 40.0 18.0

36 Alliance for Sustainable Ener 19IEEE19 64 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.7 29.7 25.0

37 Boeing Co. (The) 19IEEE19 58 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders32.8 32.8 27.6

38 EBARA SOLAR INC 19IEEE19 33 6Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders57.6 57.6 18.2

39 Solopower Inc 97Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau19 200 37AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9.5 48.5 18.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-36Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 75: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 United States of America De 18IEEE18 51 13AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics35.3 35.3 25.5

41 University of California 54AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics18 264 47ACS-Am Chem Soc6.8 20.5 17.8

42 Interuniversity MicroElectron 17IEEE17 53 10Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders32.1 32.1 18.9

43 NEXTREME THERMAL SO 17IEEE17 60 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics28.3 28.3 25.0

44 Twin Creeks Technologies In 17IEEE17 57 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.8 29.8 14.0

45 4POWER LLC 16IEEE16 32 9AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics50.0 50.0 28.1

46 Georgia Institute of Technolo 16IEEE16 25 3WIP-Renewable Energies64.0 64.0 12.0

47 International Business Machi 15IEEE15 82 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics18.3 18.3 18.3

48 Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. Ltd. 15IEEE15 44 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.1 34.1 18.2

49 Solfocus Inc 15Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau15 58 15IEEE25.9 25.9 25.9

50 ARCHITECTURAL GLASS 14IEEE14 41 7Sci American Inc34.1 34.1 17.1

51 ATHENAEUM LLC 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau14 80 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics17.5 31.3 18.8

52 ENCORE SOLAR POWER I 14IEEE14 21 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss66.7 66.7 14.3

53 OSTENDO TECHNOLOGIE 14IEEE14 35 11Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders40.0 40.0 31.4

54 SHOWA SHELL SEKIYU K 14IEEE14 22 4Japan Standards Assoc63.6 63.6 18.2

55 Commissariat A L'Energie At 12IEEE12 41 10Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders29.3 29.3 24.4

56 Compagnie de Saint-Gobain 21SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering12 61 12IEEE19.7 34.4 19.7

57 The National Aeronautical an 23Nature Publishing Group12 136 16OSA-Opt Soc Amer8.8 16.9 11.8

58 University of Houston 12IEEE12 39 6McGraw Hill30.8 30.8 15.4

59 Leonhard Kurz Stiftung & Co 14AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11 55 12Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.0 25.5 21.8

60 University of Arkansas 45AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11 95 12Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders11.6 47.4 12.6

61 University of Michigan 19John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss11 93 18AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.8 20.4 19.4

62 Honeywell International Inc. 355ACS-Am Chem Soc10 863 154Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders1.2 41.1 17.8

63 Kyocera Corp. 10IEEE10 45 5AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics22.2 22.2 11.1

64 NTHDEGREE TECHNOLO 29Nature Publishing Group10 148 20OSA-Opt Soc Amer6.8 19.6 13.5

65 Rensselaer Polytechnic Instit 10IEEE10 23 4AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics43.5 43.5 17.4

66 Silicon Genesis Corporation 28AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10 65 10Electrochemical Society15.4 43.1 15.4

67 SILICOR MATERIALS INC 10IEEE10 16 4WIP-Renewable Energies62.5 62.5 25.0

68 SUNPREME LTD 10IEEE10 26 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.5 38.5 30.8

69 United States Navy 14Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau10 65 10IEEE15.4 21.5 15.4

70 University of Central Florida 17Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Klu10 84 16AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics11.9 20.2 19.0

71 AMI RESEARCH & DEVEL 9IEEE9 12 2IET/IEE75.0 75.0 16.7

72 AMOCO/ENRON SOLAR 9IEEE9 17 3AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.9 52.9 17.6

73 Boston College 27AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9 73 9IEEE12.3 37.0 12.3

74 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 9IEEE9 43 6Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.9 20.9 14.0

75 ROSESTREET LABS ENER 13AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics9 34 9IEEE26.5 38.2 26.5

76 Toyota Motor Corp 9John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss9 29 9IEEE31.0 31.0 31.0

77 California Institute of Techno 29AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics8 111 29MRS-Materials Research Soc7.2 26.1 26.1

78 Du Pont (E.I.) de Nemours & 24Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau8 91 13AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics8.8 26.4 14.3

79 First Solar Inc 8IEEE8 14 2AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics57.1 57.1 14.3

80 GTAT CORP 11AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics8 40 9Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.0 27.5 22.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-37Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 76: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Helmholtz Zentrum Berlin for 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau8 32 8IEEE25.0 25.0 25.0

82 SOLAR JUNCTION CORP 9AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics8 31 8IEEE25.8 29.0 25.8

83 Sony Corp 20Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau8 71 9Electrochemical Society of Japan11.3 28.2 12.7

84 UNIVERSITE DE NEUCHA 8IEEE8 11 1AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics72.7 72.7 9.1

85 BP P.l.c. 7IEEE7 11 3WIP-Renewable Energies63.6 63.6 27.3

86 City University of Hong Kon 7IEEE7 11 4IET/IEE63.6 63.6 36.4

87 Continental AG (Germany Fe 7IEEE7 9 2IET/IEE77.8 77.8 22.2

88 Princeton University 79AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics7 182 28Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders3.8 43.4 15.4

89 Qualcomm Inc 7IEEE7 26 4SID-Society for Information Display26.9 26.9 15.4

90 SOLAREXCEL BV 8Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau7 15 7IEEE46.7 53.3 46.7

91 SUNCORE PHOTOVOLTAI 7IEEE7 21 7US Dept of Energy33.3 33.3 33.3

92 CRYSTAL SOLAR INC 8WIP-Renewable Energies6 20 6IEEE30.0 40.0 30.0

93 Industrial Techology Researc 18Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau6 48 6IEEE12.5 37.5 12.5

94 Massachusetts Institute of Te 34ACS-Am Chem Soc6 105 11AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics5.7 32.4 10.5

95 MOBIL SOLAR ENERGY C 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.0

96 Semiconductor Energy Labor 15AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics6 45 9IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys13.3 33.3 20.0

97 SILICON CHINA (HK) LTD 6IEEE6 10 4Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer60.0 60.0 40.0

98 SKYLINE SOLAR INC 7Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau6 28 6SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering21.4 25.0 21.4

99 Umicore S.A. 6IEEE6 16 4Electrochemical Society37.5 37.5 25.0

100 1366 TECHNOLOGIES INC 15Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau5 29 5IEEE17.2 51.7 17.2

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-38Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 77: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Telecom and Other Communications1 Qualcomm Inc 9824IEEE9824 18716 35273GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body52.5 52.5 18.8

2 Broadcom Corp. 9586IEEE9586 14613 989International Telecommunication Union65.6 65.6 6.8

3 ParkerVision Inc 8808IEEE8808 17678 4455IET/IEE49.8 49.8 25.2

4 InterDigital Inc 89253GPP General Partnership Project Standards 7656 20121 7656IEEE38.0 44.4 38.0

5 Microsoft Corporation 7489IEEE7489 17224 2312ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.5 43.5 13.4

6 Marvell Technology Group Lt 6865IEEE6865 8423 8743GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body81.5 81.5 10.4

7 Ericsson 6578IEEE6578 12373 19553GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body53.2 53.2 15.8

8 Alcatel-Lucent 5613IEEE5613 11311 6263GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body49.6 49.6 5.5

9 Personalized Media Commun 9300Soc Motion Picture TV Eng Inc5267 29291 5267IEEE18.0 31.8 18.0

10 Intel Corporation 5217IEEE5217 8784 5183GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body59.4 59.4 5.9

11 Rockstar Consortium (Nortel 4408IEEE4408 8002 662OSA-Opt Soc Amer55.1 55.1 8.3

12 Cisco Systems Inc. 4149IEEE4149 12372 2508The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force33.5 33.5 20.3

13 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 4113IEEE4113 6482 7203GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body63.5 63.5 11.1

14 Sony Corp 3783IEEE3783 7088 446ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.4 53.4 6.3

15 AT&T Inc 3757IEEE3757 7988 441ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.0 47.0 5.5

16 Nokia Corp 3643IEEE3643 8225 16893GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body44.3 44.3 20.5

17 Fujitsu Limited 3450IEEE3450 7234 5653GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body47.7 47.7 7.8

18 International Business Machi 3434IEEE3434 7305 937ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.0 47.0 12.8

19 Panasonic Corporation 3386IEEE3386 8496 15603GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body39.9 39.9 18.4

20 Texas Instruments Inc 3288IEEE3288 4300 1773GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body76.5 76.5 4.1

21 LG Electronics Inc. 50093GPP General Partnership Project Standards 3152 12265 3152IEEE25.7 40.8 25.7

22 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 3013IEEE3013 7195 14683GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.9 41.9 20.4

23 Motorola Solutions Inc. 2819IEEE2819 4510 1983GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body62.5 62.5 4.4

24 Fractus SA 2715IEEE2715 4406 754IET/IEE61.6 61.6 17.1

25 LSI Corporation 2659IEEE2659 3198 68IET/IEE83.1 83.1 2.1

26 NEC Corp 2324IEEE2324 4962 6513GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body46.8 46.8 13.1

27 Apple Inc 2302IEEE2302 4158 2283GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body55.4 55.4 5.5

28 University of Minnesota (The 2300IEEE2300 2508 43John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss91.7 91.7 1.7

29 Raytheon Co. 2171IEEE2171 3533 160IET/IEE61.4 61.4 4.5

30 Verizon Communications Inc 2072IEEE2072 4603 748The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force45.0 45.0 16.3

31 Electronics and Telecommuni 2017IEEE2017 2940 2633GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.6 68.6 8.9

32 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 1928IEEE1928 2709 140IET/IEE71.2 71.2 5.2

33 Digimarc Corp. 1884IEEE1884 4655 533SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering40.5 40.5 11.5

34 Rambus Inc. 1869IEEE1869 2672 147International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)69.9 69.9 5.5

35 Silicon Laboratories Inc 1827IEEE1827 2287 114Cahners-Denver Pub79.9 79.9 5.0

36 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 1702IEEE1702 3255 2503GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body52.3 52.3 7.7

37 Massachusetts Institute of Te 1699IEEE1699 3182 296OSA-Opt Soc Amer53.4 53.4 9.3

38 Hewlett-Packard Co 1657IEEE1657 4952 687The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force33.5 33.5 13.9

39 Research in Motion Ltd. 17453GPP General Partnership Project Standards 1619 5023 1619IEEE32.2 34.7 32.2

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-39Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 78: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 Micron Technology Inc. 1611IEEE1611 2673 164IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys60.3 60.3 6.1

41 TE Connectivity Ltd 1607IEEE1607 2505 136IET/IEE64.2 64.2 5.4

42 Toshiba Corp 1574IEEE1574 3062 271IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng51.4 51.4 8.9

43 STMicroelectronics 1553IEEE1553 2169 66Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders71.6 71.6 3.0

44 MOSAID Technologies Inc. 1482IEEE1482 2659 92EIA/TIA Std55.7 55.7 3.5

45 Harris Corp. 1370IEEE1370 2363 232The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force58.0 58.0 9.8

46 Hitachi Ltd 1362IEEE1362 3649 318IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng37.3 37.3 8.7

47 Google Inc. 1360IEEE1360 3735 11803GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body36.4 36.4 31.6

48 Huawei Technologies Compa 19413GPP General Partnership Project Standards 1343 5351 1343IEEE25.1 36.3 25.1

49 University of California 1339IEEE1339 2171 112IET/IEE61.7 61.7 5.2

50 Oracle Corporation 1315IEEE1315 3838 538ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.3 34.3 14.0

51 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1308IEEE1308 2541 128Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders51.5 51.5 5.0

52 Softbank Corp 1861International Telecommunication Union1298 5326 1298IEEE24.4 34.9 24.4

53 Sharp Corp 1235IEEE1235 4485 8813GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body27.5 27.5 19.6

54 Altera Corp. 1196IEEE1196 1997 203Penton Media59.9 59.9 10.2

55 Tabula Inc 1274ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1147 3139 1147IEEE36.5 40.6 36.5

56 Honeywell International Inc. 1140IEEE1140 2003 76ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.9 56.9 3.8

57 L-3 Communications Holdin 1095IEEE1095 1353 78IET/IEE80.9 80.9 5.8

58 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1081IEEE1081 2400 1993GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body45.0 45.0 8.3

59 Industrial Techology Researc 1079IEEE1079 1498 39SID-Society for Information Display72.0 72.0 2.6

60 Commscope Inc. 1076IEEE1076 1314 126IET/IEE81.9 81.9 9.6

61 Intersil Corp. 1057IEEE1057 1472 223IET/IEE71.8 71.8 15.1

62 Infineon Technologies AG 1042IEEE1042 1522 853GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.5 68.5 5.6

63 Analog Devices Inc. 1038IEEE1038 1275 46IET/IEE81.4 81.4 3.6

64 HRL Laboratories LLC 1021IEEE1021 1521 186IET/IEE67.1 67.1 12.2

65 Technicolor SA 1005IEEE1005 2087 168ISO-International Standards Organization48.2 48.2 8.0

66 Deutsche Telekom AG 998IEEE998 1531 59ACM-Assoc Comput Mach65.2 65.2 3.9

67 California Institute of Techno 968IEEE968 1512 105SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering64.0 64.0 6.9

68 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 959IEEE959 1880 249MPEG.org51.0 51.0 13.2

69 Xilinx Inc. 930IEEE930 1238 68ACM-Assoc Comput Mach75.1 75.1 5.5

70 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. 927IEEE927 1213 733GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body76.4 76.4 6.0

71 SIPCO LLC 922IEEE922 1560 119The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force59.1 59.1 7.6

72 Juniper Networks Inc. 890IEEE890 1857 386The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force47.9 47.9 20.8

73 Canon Inc 858IEEE858 1929 94ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.5 44.5 4.9

74 Kyocera Corp. 839IEEE839 1154 74IET/IEE72.7 72.7 6.4

75 Current Communications Gro 829IEEE829 1049 79Echelon Corp79.0 79.0 7.5

76 PEREGRINE SEMICONDU 809IEEE809 1001 24Joint IEEE and ACM80.8 80.8 2.4

77 Wisteria Trading Inc 785IEEE785 1412 189SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.6 55.6 13.4

78 Lockheed Martin Corp. 779IEEE779 1580 183OSA-Opt Soc Amer49.3 49.3 11.6

79 REARDEN LLC 774IEEE774 851 33IET/IEE91.0 91.0 3.9

80 Texas A&M University 759IEEE759 832 15IET/IEE91.2 91.2 1.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-40Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 79: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

81 Columbia University 725IEEE725 1149 86ACM-Assoc Comput Mach63.1 63.1 7.5

82 BT Group PLC 720IEEE720 1424 127IET/IEE50.6 50.6 8.9

83 Tessera Technologies Inc. 688IEEE688 1099 86ACM-Assoc Comput Mach62.6 62.6 7.8

84 Northrop Grumman Corp 687IEEE687 1084 51IET/IEE63.4 63.4 4.7

85 Finisar Corp 671IEEE671 1020 185IET/IEE65.8 65.8 18.1

86 BAE Systems Plc. 666IEEE666 867 29SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering76.8 76.8 3.3

87 MULTI-TECH SYSTEMS IN 663IEEE663 1052 80International Telecommunication Union63.0 63.0 7.6

88 CSR Plc 631IEEE631 919 73IET/IEE68.7 68.7 7.9

89 Cirrus Logic Inc. 624IEEE624 866 71Audio Eng Soc72.1 72.1 8.2

90 Mediatek Inc. 624IEEE624 753 27Bluetooth Special Interest Group82.9 82.9 3.6

91 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 623IEEE623 892 35Joint IEEE and ACM69.8 69.8 3.9

92 HTC Corporation 622IEEE622 1321 3643GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body47.1 47.1 27.6

93 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 621IEEE621 899 42Penton Media69.1 69.1 4.7

94 WI-Lan Inc 615IEEE615 795 30Alcatel-Lucent77.4 77.4 3.8

95 Nokia Siemens Networks 581IEEE581 1436 5413GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body40.5 40.5 37.7

96 United States Navy 567IEEE567 1116 79Am Physical Soc50.8 50.8 7.1

97 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 564IEEE564 1008 114IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.0 56.0 11.3

98 Boeing Co. (The) 557IEEE557 1167 58ION-The Inst of Navigation47.7 47.7 5.0

99 Extreme Networks Inc 555IEEE555 1130 122ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.1 49.1 10.8

100 France Telecom S.A. 550IEEE550 1035 64The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force53.1 53.1 6.2

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-41Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 80: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

Wind Energy1 Vestas Wind Systems A/S 339IEEE339 500 38AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro67.8 67.8 7.6

2 ABB Ltd 101IEEE101 170 12CIGRE-International Council on Large Electric Systems59.4 59.4 7.1

3 General Electric Company 116US Dept of Energy68 259 68IEEE26.3 44.8 26.3

4 THE UNIVERSITY OF NE 23IEEE23 24 1IET/IEE95.8 95.8 4.2

5 INGETEAM ENERGY SA 19IEEE19 29 3Blackwell Futura65.5 65.5 10.3

6 University of Alabama 17IEEE17 20 3IET/IEE85.0 85.0 15.0

7 FMC Technologies Inc. 13IEEE13 17 1ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng76.5 76.5 5.9

8 INGETEAM POWER TECH 13IEEE13 19 2John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss68.4 68.4 10.5

9 NRG SYSTEMS INC 12IEEE12 18 4Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders66.7 66.7 22.2

10 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 10IEEE10 17 6John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss58.8 58.8 35.3

11 KITE GEN RESEARCH S L 9IEEE9 15 6Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders60.0 60.0 40.0

12 ZOND ENERGY SYSTEMS 9IEEE9 11 1Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders81.8 81.8 9.1

13 GENEDICS CLEAN ENERG 49Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau7 63 7IEEE11.1 77.8 11.1

14 Oregon State University 7IEEE7 7 100.0 100.0

15 Suzlon Energy Ltd 7IEEE7 16 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss43.8 43.8 18.8

16 Covidien Plc 6IEEE6 8 1Nature Publishing Group75.0 75.0 12.5

17 GENEDICS LLC 35Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Sau6 47 6IEEE12.8 74.5 12.8

18 GREEN ENERGY CORP 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

19 Alstom 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

20 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 4IEEE4 5 1PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)80.0 80.0 20.0

21 INGETEAM SA 4IEEE4 6 1Blackwell Futura66.7 66.7 16.7

22 Nordex SE 4IEEE4 8 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss50.0 50.0 37.5

23 REPOWER SYSTEMS SE 4IEEE4 5 1EPE Association80.0 80.0 20.0

24 UNIVERSIDAD PUBLICA 4IEEE4 5 1I S A-INSTRUM SYS AUTOMATION SOC80.0 80.0 20.0

25 Woodward Inc 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.0

26 GLOBAL ENERGYCONCE 3IEEE3 4 1PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)75.0 75.0 25.0

27 Mitsubishi Heavy Industries 24John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss3 40 7ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng7.5 60.0 17.5

28 ADVANCED MAGNET LA 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

29 Alliance for Sustainable Ener 2ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng2 5 2IEEE40.0 40.0 40.0

30 Dana Holding Corp. 2IEEE2 3 1EVS.org66.7 66.7 33.3

31 Gamesa Corporacion Tecnolo 2IEEE2 4 2EPE Association50.0 50.0 50.0

32 Harris Corp. 2IEEE2 4 2Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders50.0 50.0 50.0

33 HAWAIIAN ELECTRIC CO 2John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss2 4 2IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

34 Hitachi Ltd 2Hitachi Ltd2 4 2IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

35 Honeywell International Inc. 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

36 ONSEMBLE LLC 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

37 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

38 TREVI ENERGY S P A 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.0

39 American Superconductor Co 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-42Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 81: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2013 Patents by Category)

40 BASELOAD ENERGY INC 1SPACE MAGAZINE, 219 WONSEO-DONG,1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

41 California Institute of Techno 1IEEE1 2 1Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders50.0 50.0 50.0

42 CLEAN CURRENT LP 1IEEE1 2 1PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING PUBLISHING LTD, NOR50.0 50.0 50.0

43 Fiat Spa 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

44 Flo 9AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro1 17 7John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.9 52.9 41.2

45 MAKANI POWER INC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

46 Mitsuba Corp. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

47 OPENHYDRO GROUP LTD 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

48 SATCON TECHNOLOGY C 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

49 Schneider Electric S.A. 1IET/IEE1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

50 TECHNOLOGY SERVICE C 1IOP Publishing1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.0

51 ZF Friedrichshafen AG (Ger 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 B-43Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 82: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

1 Micron Technology Inc. 33920IEEE33920 105641 19172Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders32.1 32.1 18.1

2 Microsoft Corporation 33814IEEE33814 105850 30007ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.9 31.9 28.3

3 International Business Machin 31296IEEE31296 85363 16157ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.7 36.7 18.9

4 Intel Corporation 16615IEEE16615 33770 3198ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.2 49.2 9.5

5 Qualcomm Inc 14002IEEE14002 28296 37953GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body49.5 49.5 13.4

6 Broadcom Corp. 13554IEEE13554 23903 1068International Telecommunication Union56.7 56.7 4.5

7 Alcatel-Lucent 10336IEEE10336 23067 1223ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.8 44.8 5.3

8 ParkerVision Inc 10257IEEE10257 20577 5186IET/IEE49.8 49.8 25.2

9 Texas Instruments Inc 10173IEEE10173 15870 714AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics64.1 64.1 4.5

10 Oracle Corporation 10993ACM-Assoc Comput Mach9884 33083 9884IEEE29.9 33.2 29.9

11 Sony Corp 8568IEEE8568 17983 1651ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.6 47.6 9.2

12 Marvell Technology Group Lt 8276IEEE8276 10230 8783GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body80.9 80.9 8.6

13 Ericsson 8018IEEE8018 15824 22403GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body50.7 50.7 14.2

14 InterDigital Inc 93143GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo7890 20843 7890IEEE37.9 44.7 37.9

15 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 7808IEEE7808 17174 1085SID-Society for Information Display45.5 45.5 6.3

16 Apple Inc 7607IEEE7607 18988 4182ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.1 40.1 22.0

17 Hewlett-Packard Co 7558IEEE7558 24176 3396ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.3 31.3 14.0

18 Panasonic Corporation 7435IEEE7435 21091 15923GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body35.3 35.3 7.5

19 Fujitsu Limited 7407IEEE7407 17101 883IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng43.3 43.3 5.2

20 Toshiba Corp 6706IEEE6706 15604 1023AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics43.0 43.0 6.6

21 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 6503IEEE6503 17708 1766Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders36.7 36.7 10.0

22 AT&T Inc 6401IEEE6401 14653 1463ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.7 43.7 10.0

23 NEC Corp 6299IEEE6299 14522 838IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng43.4 43.4 5.8

24 Cisco Systems Inc. 6297IEEE6297 19977 4007The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force31.5 31.5 20.1

25 Personalized Media Communi 10990Soc Motion Picture TV Eng Inc6163 34631 6163IEEE17.8 31.7 17.8

26 Motorola Solutions Inc. 6157IEEE6157 12056 1060AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics51.1 51.1 8.8

27 LSI Corporation 5947IEEE5947 8860 688Joint IEEE and ACM67.1 67.1 7.8

28 SanDisk Corp. 5570IEEE5570 9203 706IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys60.5 60.5 7.7

29 Macronix International Co. Lt 5519IEEE5519 10216 1552IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys54.0 54.0 15.2

30 Rockstar Consortium (Nortel 5343IEEE5343 10106 766OSA-Opt Soc Amer52.9 52.9 7.6

31 Cadence Design Systems Inc 5252IEEE5252 12304 3947Joint IEEE and ACM42.7 42.7 32.1

32 Google Inc. 5195IEEE5195 16135 4017ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.2 32.2 24.9

33 Nokia Corp 5035IEEE5035 12070 19693GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.7 41.7 16.3

34 Massachusetts Institute of Tec 4986IEEE4986 21066 2544Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.7 23.7 12.1

35 STMicroelectronics 4926IEEE4926 8209 587Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders60.0 60.0 7.2

36 Hitachi Ltd 4828IEEE4828 15745 1063ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.7 30.7 6.8

37 LG Electronics Inc. 54193GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo4821 16687 4821IEEE28.9 32.5 28.9

38 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 4795IEEE4795 17752 1781Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders27.0 27.0 10.0

39 General Hospital Corporation 19061OSA-Opt Soc Amer4755 52099 7438Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.1 36.6 14.3

40 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 4747IEEE4747 9602 746ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.4 49.4 7.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-1Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 83: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

41 Rambus Inc. 4646IEEE4646 7068 335JEDEC Semiconductor Standards Organization65.7 65.7 4.7

42 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 4411IEEE4411 9702 593ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.5 45.5 6.1

43 Semiconductor Energy Labora 11450SID-Society for Information Display4219 39420 6672AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.7 29.0 16.9

44 Honeywell International Inc. 4166IEEE4166 11080 1112Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.6 37.6 10.0

45 University of California 4144IEEE4144 27789 3854Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders14.9 14.9 13.9

46 Taiwan Semiconductor Manuf 4101IEEE4101 10211 2347AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40.2 40.2 23.0

47 Nippon Telegraph & Telephon 4072IEEE4072 10313 15463GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body39.5 39.5 15.0

48 Synopsys Inc. 4033IEEE4033 12665 3062SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering31.8 31.8 24.2

49 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 4005IEEE4005 9115 1385ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.9 43.9 15.2

50 Immersion Corp. 3797IEEE3797 10326 1118ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.8 36.8 10.8

51 MOSAID Technologies Inc. 3746IEEE3746 5385 128IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys69.6 69.6 2.4

52 Digimarc Corp. 3731IEEE3731 9456 1098SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering39.5 39.5 11.6

53 Infineon Technologies AG 3673IEEE3673 6369 443AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics57.7 57.7 7.0

54 General Electric Company 3668IEEE3668 18640 3108US Dept of Energy19.7 19.7 16.7

55 Raytheon Co. 3625IEEE3625 7367 328Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders49.2 49.2 4.5

56 Canon Inc 3606IEEE3606 12945 1408AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics27.9 27.9 10.9

57 Applied Materials Inc. 3575IEEE3575 14364 2698AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics24.9 24.9 18.8

58 Tessera Technologies Inc. 3372IEEE3372 5474 397Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders61.6 61.6 7.3

59 Medtronic Inc 10078Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund3305 42317 8069Lippincott Williams & Wilkins7.8 23.8 19.1

60 California Institute of Technol 3270IEEE3270 15654 2368Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.9 20.9 15.1

61 Sharp Corp 3268IEEE3268 11368 1167SID-Society for Information Display28.7 28.7 10.3

62 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 3231IEEE3231 5829 649IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys55.4 55.4 11.1

63 Xerox Corp 3211IEEE3211 13238 2308ACM-Assoc Comput Mach24.3 24.3 17.4

64 Xilinx Inc. 3191IEEE3191 4614 457Joint IEEE and ACM69.2 69.2 9.9

65 Electronics and Telecommunic 3113IEEE3113 5421 313IET/IEE57.4 57.4 5.8

66 Freescale Semiconductor Inc. 3073IEEE3073 5710 666AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.8 53.8 11.7

67 Tela Innovations inc 3491SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering2965 10119 2965IEEE29.3 34.5 29.3

68 Research in Motion Ltd. 2891IEEE2891 7873 19183GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body36.7 36.7 24.4

69 Altera Corp. 2881IEEE2881 5157 477ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.9 55.9 9.2

70 Megic Corporation 2875IEEE2875 3439 269Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders83.6 83.6 7.8

71 University of Minnesota (The 2815IEEE2815 5416 552Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders52.0 52.0 10.2

72 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 2799IEEE2799 4301 350Joint IEEE and ACM65.1 65.1 8.1

73 Fractus SA 2762IEEE2762 4465 755IET/IEE61.9 61.9 16.9

74 Renesas Electronic Corporatio 2741IEEE2741 4493 366IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys61.0 61.0 8.1

75 Verizon Communications Inc 2698IEEE2698 6418 1051The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force42.0 42.0 16.4

76 HRL Laboratories LLC 2571IEEE2571 4618 337AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics55.7 55.7 7.3

77 MicroUnity Systems Engineeri 2527IEEE2527 3992 382Joint IEEE and ACM63.3 63.3 9.6

78 Cree Inc. 2478IEEE2478 7114 1673AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics34.8 34.8 23.5

79 Seiko Epson Corporation 2459IEEE2459 6745 596Joint IEEE and ACM36.5 36.5 8.8

80 Tabula Inc 2682ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2451 6676 2451IEEE36.7 40.2 36.7

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-2Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 84: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

81 Seagate Technology Plc 2410IEEE2410 5561 1064AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics43.3 43.3 19.1

82 Amberwave Inc 2354IEEE2354 6723 1777AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics35.0 35.0 26.4

83 Lockheed Martin Corp. 2324IEEE2324 7636 873OSA-Opt Soc Amer30.4 30.4 11.4

84 Cirrus Logic Inc. 2295IEEE2295 2829 94Audio Eng Soc81.1 81.1 3.3

85 Mentor Graphics Corp. 2292IEEE2292 3956 604Joint IEEE and ACM57.9 57.9 15.3

86 Covidien Plc 2248IEEE2248 16916 1898Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders13.3 13.3 11.2

87 Sap AG 2916ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2204 8724 2204IEEE25.3 33.4 25.3

88 Silicon Laboratories Inc 2177IEEE2177 2703 122Cahners-Denver Pub80.5 80.5 4.5

89 Finisar Corp 2171IEEE2171 4891 755IET/IEE44.4 44.4 15.4

90 Irobot Corp 2123IEEE2123 3904 727SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering54.4 54.4 18.6

91 Dexcom Inc 10399Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund2120 35000 3681Am Diabetese Assoc6.1 29.7 10.5

92 Boston Scientific Corp. 16527Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund2110 47379 4394Lippincott Williams & Wilkins4.5 34.9 9.3

93 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 2030IEEE2030 2879 149IET/IEE70.5 70.5 5.2

94 Columbia University 2014IEEE2014 8523 1081AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics23.6 23.6 12.7

95 Western Digital Corp. 1974IEEE1974 3555 652AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics55.5 55.5 18.3

96 Analog Devices Inc. 1932IEEE1932 2636 101Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders73.3 73.3 3.8

97 Industrial Techology Research 1930IEEE1930 3276 179Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.9 58.9 5.5

98 University of Illinois 2381AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics1908 16319 2292ACS-Am Chem Soc11.7 14.6 14.0

99 Harris Corp. 1904IEEE1904 3305 309The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force57.6 57.6 9.3

100 Innovative Silicon SA 1889IEEE1889 2407 108Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders78.5 78.5 4.5

101 The Invention Science Fund 1 1886IEEE1886 11175 1078Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.9 16.9 9.6

102 TE Connectivity Ltd 1860IEEE1860 3002 166IET/IEE62.0 62.0 5.5

103 Adobe Systems Inc. 1839IEEE1839 5097 1811ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.1 36.1 35.5

104 Boeing Co. (The) 1742IEEE1742 5538 648AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro31.5 31.5 11.7

105 Georgia Institute of Technolog 1742IEEE1742 4219 385Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.3 41.3 9.1

106 Huawei Technologies Compan 21443GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo1738 6651 1738IEEE26.1 32.2 26.1

107 Netapp Inc 3030ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1684 7388 1684IEEE22.8 41.0 22.8

108 Cognex Corp. 1672IEEE1672 3512 643Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders47.6 47.6 18.3

109 Cascade Microtech Inc. 1670IEEE1670 3150 648Nature Publishing Group53.0 53.0 20.6

110 Emerson Electric Co. 1645IEEE1645 5803 620Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.3 28.3 10.7

111 BT Group PLC 1640IEEE1640 3566 289IET/IEE46.0 46.0 8.1

112 Abbott Laboratories 14461Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund1618 46084 7913ACS-Am Chem Soc3.5 31.4 17.2

113 Softbank Corp 1885International Telecommunication Union1595 6181 1595IEEE25.8 30.5 25.8

114 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 1573IEEE1573 3361 270MPEG.org46.8 46.8 8.0

115 Fairchild Semiconductor Inter 1563IEEE1563 2062 185Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders75.8 75.8 9.0

116 Stanford University 1563IEEE1563 11109 1325Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders14.1 14.1 11.9

117 United States Navy 1556IEEE1556 5366 613AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics29.0 29.0 11.4

118 SRI International 1548IEEE1548 4407 423SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering35.1 35.1 9.6

119 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 1537IEEE1537 7459 947Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders20.6 20.6 12.7

120 ABB Ltd 1527IEEE1527 2434 119Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders62.7 62.7 4.9

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-3Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 85: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

121 Technicolor SA 1519IEEE1519 3256 206ISO-International Standards Organization46.7 46.7 6.3

122 Intersil Corp. 1443IEEE1443 2005 233IET/IEE72.0 72.0 11.6

123 Infinera Corporation 1435IEEE1435 2326 412IET/IEE61.7 61.7 17.7

124 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 1389IEEE1389 6026 487Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.1 23.1 8.1

125 EMC Corp. 1389IEEE1389 4243 944ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.7 32.7 22.2

126 NVIDIA Corp. 1387IEEE1387 3352 970ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.4 41.4 28.9

127 Interuniversity MicroElectroni 1348IEEE1348 2803 202Joint IEEE and ACM48.1 48.1 7.2

128 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 1332IEEE1332 6246 921ACM-Assoc Comput Mach21.3 21.3 14.7

129 Eastman Kodak Company 1328IEEE1328 5115 410SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering26.0 26.0 8.0

130 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 1317IEEE1317 3000 427Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.9 43.9 14.2

131 Intertrust Technologies Corp 1618ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1315 8441 1315IEEE15.6 19.2 15.6

132 Northrop Grumman Corp 1298IEEE1298 2932 252AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics44.3 44.3 8.6

133 Commissariat A L'Energie Ato 1278IEEE1278 5198 909Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders24.6 24.6 17.5

134 QST Holdings Llc 1245IEEE1245 1998 231Joint IEEE and ACM62.3 62.3 11.6

135 University of Michigan 1199IEEE1199 5150 754Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.3 23.3 14.6

136 L-3 Communications Holdings 1195IEEE1195 1620 80IET/IEE73.8 73.8 4.9

137 PHOENIX SOLUTIONS INC 1191IEEE1191 3361 460ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)35.4 35.4 13.7

138 Agilent Technologies Inc 1189IEEE1189 3557 354Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.4 33.4 10.0

139 Commvault Systems Inc. 1182IEEE1182 1671 248ACM-Assoc Comput Mach70.7 70.7 14.8

140 Juniper Networks Inc. 1175IEEE1175 2669 497The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force44.0 44.0 18.6

141 Corning Inc. 1169IEEE1169 4684 934OSA-Opt Soc Amer25.0 25.0 19.9

142 Deutsche Telekom AG 1169IEEE1169 2013 96Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.1 58.1 4.8

143 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 1157IEEE1157 2298 400SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Su50.3 50.3 17.4

144 Wisteria Trading Inc 1145IEEE1145 2055 271SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.7 55.7 13.2

145 Current Communications Gro 1144IEEE1144 1451 110Echelon Corp78.8 78.8 7.6

146 University of Texas 1450Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund1139 8692 1139IEEE13.1 16.7 13.1

147 Texas A&M University 1130IEEE1130 2138 187OSA-Opt Soc Amer52.9 52.9 8.7

148 PEREGRINE SEMICONDU 1112IEEE1112 1494 67AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics74.4 74.4 4.5

149 Commscope Inc. 1096IEEE1096 1353 128IET/IEE81.0 81.0 9.5

150 Intellectual Ventures Manage 1092IEEE1092 2179 343ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.1 50.1 15.7

151 University of Wisconsin 1083IEEE1083 5460 526AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics19.8 19.8 9.6

152 Spansion Inc. 1053IEEE1053 1261 85AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics83.5 83.5 6.7

153 JDS Uniphase Corp 1038IEEE1038 3070 568AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.8 33.8 18.5

154 SIPCO LLC 1038IEEE1038 1748 132The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force59.4 59.4 7.6

155 IDC Llc 1025IEEE1025 2594 444SID-Society for Information Display39.5 39.5 17.1

156 SRC Computers Inc. 1016IEEE1016 1148 41ACM-Assoc Comput Mach88.5 88.5 3.6

157 Dolby Laboratories Inc 1008IEEE1008 2526 335Audio Eng Soc39.9 39.9 13.3

158 BAE Systems Plc. 987IEEE987 1607 107SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering61.4 61.4 6.7

159 France Telecom S.A. 979IEEE979 1942 144IET/IEE50.4 50.4 7.4

160 Citrix Systems Inc 975IEEE975 3229 561ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.2 30.2 17.4

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-4Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 86: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

161 Level 3 Communications 969IEEE969 3102 651ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.2 31.2 21.0

162 Accenture Ltd. 958IEEE958 3168 630ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.2 30.2 19.9

163 Kyocera Corp. 947IEEE947 1687 92Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders56.1 56.1 5.5

164 University of Southern Califor 944IEEE944 4992 683ACS-Am Chem Soc18.9 18.9 13.7

165 Hynix Semiconductor Inc 940IEEE940 1783 102TECHNICAL ASSOC PHOTOPOLYMERS52.7 52.7 5.7

166 Life Technologies Corporation 2332Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund940 6989 940IEEE13.4 33.4 13.4

167 Extreme Networks Inc 938IEEE938 1949 224ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.1 48.1 11.5

168 Nuance Communications Inc 925IEEE925 2604 465ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.5 35.5 17.9

169 Silicon Graphics International 917IEEE917 2492 714ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.8 36.8 28.7

170 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 914IEEE914 1521 158Joint IEEE and ACM60.1 60.1 10.4

171 PMC-Sierra Inc. 912IEEE912 1354 58ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.4 67.4 4.3

172 Pioneer Corp. 907IEEE907 1787 287SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering50.8 50.8 16.1

173 National Instruments Corp. 888IEEE888 1571 176ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.5 56.5 11.2

174 Imagination Technologies Gro 885IEEE885 2670 594ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.1 33.1 22.2

175 Rockwell Automation Inc 871IEEE871 1481 120Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders58.8 58.8 8.1

176 NXP Semiconductors NV 853IEEE853 1341 60Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders63.6 63.6 4.5

177 Mediatek Inc. 831IEEE831 1368 80ACS-Am Chem Soc60.7 60.7 5.8

178 TDK Corporation 821IEEE821 2447 536AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics33.6 33.6 21.9

179 Microsemi Corp 812IEEE812 1312 105Cahners-Denver Pub61.9 61.9 8.0

180 University of Washington 794IEEE794 4364 608Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders18.2 18.2 13.9

181 CSR Plc 790IEEE790 1254 97IET/IEE63.0 63.0 7.7

182 Avaya Inc 781IEEE781 2883 483The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force27.1 27.1 16.8

183 REARDEN LLC 779IEEE779 916 53OSA-Opt Soc Amer85.0 85.0 5.8

184 Avago Technologies Ltd 776IEEE776 1172 92AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics66.2 66.2 7.8

185 Washington University in St. L 759IEEE759 2629 340Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.9 28.9 12.9

186 COVIDIEN LP 757IEEE757 5422 597Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer14.0 14.0 11.0

187 Flextronics International LTD 753IEEE753 860 31United Business Media/UBM Tech87.6 87.6 3.6

188 3M Co 1188Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund727 8262 796ACS-Am Chem Soc8.8 14.4 9.6

189 Rovi Corporation 718IEEE718 2401 176ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.9 29.9 7.3

190 Hoya Corp 708IEEE708 1736 341AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics40.8 40.8 19.6

191 Arm Holdings Plc 703IEEE703 1242 179Joint IEEE and ACM56.6 56.6 14.4

192 Michigan State University 1327OSA-Opt Soc Amer700 6706 979AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.4 19.8 14.6

193 Midtronics Inc. 692IEEE692 1598 306Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.3 43.3 19.1

194 General Motors Corp 687IEEE687 1639 202Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.9 41.9 12.3

195 Thales 672IEEE672 1253 84Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders53.6 53.6 6.7

196 MULTI-TECH SYSTEMS IN 669IEEE669 1062 81International Telecommunication Union63.0 63.0 7.6

197 United States Army 668IEEE668 2754 300AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics24.3 24.3 10.9

198 Nokia Siemens Networks 667IEEE667 1646 5903GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body40.5 40.5 35.8

199 Carnegie Mellon University 662IEEE662 2112 210Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders31.3 31.3 9.9

200 Synergy Microwave Corp 659IEEE659 772 66HORIZON HOUSE PUBLICATIONS INC85.4 85.4 8.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-5Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 87: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

201 Teledyne Technologies Incorp 654IEEE654 1271 96SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering51.5 51.5 7.6

202 RF Micro Devices Inc. 652IEEE652 804 29AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics81.1 81.1 3.6

203 Silverbrook Pty Ltd 648IEEE648 1906 460Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer34.0 34.0 24.1

204 WI-Lan Inc 634IEEE634 826 383GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body76.8 76.8 4.6

205 Conexant Systems Inc. 631IEEE631 970 49International Telecommunication Union65.1 65.1 5.1

206 General Dynamics Corp 631IEEE631 1683 248Am Physical Soc37.5 37.5 14.7

207 HTC Corporation 626IEEE626 1372 4043GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body45.6 45.6 29.4

208 AOL Inc 625IEEE625 2725 565ACM-Assoc Comput Mach22.9 22.9 20.7

209 Round Rock Research LLC 625IEEE625 1811 247Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.5 34.5 13.6

210 Amazon.com Inc. 1184ACM-Assoc Comput Mach619 3774 619IEEE16.4 31.4 16.4

211 Xtera Communications Inc. 618IEEE618 1488 450IET/IEE41.5 41.5 30.2

212 Oki Electric Industry Co. Ltd. 606IEEE606 1348 156IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng45.0 45.0 11.6

213 Masimo Corp 602IEEE602 1446 158Lippincott Williams & Wilkins41.6 41.6 10.9

214 Johnson & Johnson 5415Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund597 20082 2563Lippincott Williams & Wilkins3.0 27.0 12.8

215 eBay Inc 595IEEE595 3749 407ACM-Assoc Comput Mach15.9 15.9 10.9

216 CA Inc 594IEEE594 1498 251ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.7 39.7 16.8

217 BTG Plc. 591IEEE591 1704 210IET/IEE34.7 34.7 12.3

218 SYNQOR INC 591IEEE591 675 27Penton Media87.6 87.6 4.0

219 Cheetah Omni LLC 581IEEE581 1821 448OSA-Opt Soc Amer31.9 31.9 24.6

220 Hong Kong University of Scie 573IEEE573 1036 175AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics55.3 55.3 16.9

221 Avid Technology Inc. 572IEEE572 1400 512ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.9 40.9 36.6

222 Cornell University 565IEEE565 3066 373Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders18.4 18.4 12.2

223 Dainippon Screen Manufacturi 561IEEE561 2103 311Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders26.7 26.7 14.8

224 Advantest Corp. 559IEEE559 758 28AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics73.7 73.7 3.7

225 St. Jude Medical Inc. 2729Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund551 11023 1725Lippincott Williams & Wilkins5.0 24.8 15.6

226 Schlumberger Ltd. 1543Society of Petroleum Engineers550 6609 933SOC EXPLORATION GEOPHYSICISTS8.3 23.3 14.1

227 Purdue University 647Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund548 3664 548IEEE15.0 17.7 15.0

228 Virgin Islands Microsystems 548IEEE548 2251 418AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics24.3 24.3 18.6

229 LibertyMedia 546IEEE546 736 843GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body74.2 74.2 11.4

230 Toyota Motor Corp 543IEEE543 1603 249Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders33.9 33.9 15.5

231 Princeton University 930AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics542 4265 554ACS-Am Chem Soc12.7 21.8 13.0

232 Power-One Inc 539IEEE539 892 202IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium60.4 60.4 22.6

233 Rockwell Collins Inc. 538IEEE538 927 62OSA-Opt Soc Amer58.0 58.0 6.7

234 NCR Corp. 535IEEE535 1695 355ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.6 31.6 20.9

235 Lam Research Corp. 659AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics531 2660 531IEEE20.0 24.8 20.0

236 Brocade Communciation Syste 528IEEE528 1471 272ANSI-American National Standards Institute35.9 35.9 18.5

237 Yahoo Inc 1013ACM-Assoc Comput Mach524 3560 524IEEE14.7 28.5 14.7

238 ArthroCare Corp. 1125Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund523 3582 523IEEE14.6 31.4 14.6

239 New Jersey Institute of Techno 523IEEE523 958 79Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders54.6 54.6 8.2

240 Comcast Corp 522IEEE522 1232 135ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.4 42.4 11.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-6Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 88: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

241 University of Florida 521IEEE521 2127 369Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders24.5 24.5 17.3

242 Sumitomo Electric Industries 515IEEE515 2908 408AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics17.7 17.7 14.0

243 Ciena Corp 513IEEE513 981 183OSA-Opt Soc Amer52.3 52.3 18.7

244 Pulse Link Inc 513IEEE513 626 24Sci American Inc81.9 81.9 3.8

245 LG Ericsson 732OSA-Opt Soc Amer510 1588 510IEEE32.1 46.1 32.1

246 Kotura Inc 509IEEE509 1156 303IET/IEE44.0 44.0 26.2

247 JPMorgan 878Source Media507 4363 507IEEE11.6 20.1 11.6

248 Power Integrations Inc. 503IEEE503 724 52Penton Media69.5 69.5 7.2

249 Nantero Inc 2666ACS-Am Chem Soc502 8827 1663AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics5.7 30.2 18.8

250 Nikon Corp. 1257SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering496 2818 496IEEE17.6 44.6 17.6

251 Symantec Corp. 584ACM-Assoc Comput Mach496 2314 496IEEE21.4 25.2 21.4

252 EXEGY INC 494IEEE494 973 173ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.8 50.8 17.8

253 Lightsmyth Technologies Inc 491IEEE491 1010 232OSA-Opt Soc Amer48.6 48.6 23.0

254 Maxim Integrated Products Inc 488IEEE488 606 16Texas Instruments80.5 80.5 2.6

255 Emcore Corp. 482IEEE482 913 104AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.8 52.8 11.4

256 Medispectra Inc 482IEEE482 1273 269Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders37.9 37.9 21.1

257 Dell Inc 479IEEE479 1506 391ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.8 31.8 26.0

258 ASM International N.V. 1018Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund476 4356 917AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics10.9 23.4 21.1

259 Aptina Imaging Corp 467IEEE467 767 73SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering60.9 60.9 9.5

260 Sensable Technologies Inc 467IEEE467 974 250ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.9 47.9 25.7

261 Agency for Science Technolog 466IEEE466 1332 174Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders35.0 35.0 13.1

262 Math Works Inc (The) 455IEEE455 936 195ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.6 48.6 20.8

263 Schneider Electric S.A. 454IEEE454 1263 65ANSI-American National Standards Institute35.9 35.9 5.1

264 Tellabs Inc. 453IEEE453 885 138The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force51.2 51.2 15.6

265 EADS NV 448IEEE448 1038 97Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.2 43.2 9.3

266 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. 448IEEE448 1525 381OSA-Opt Soc Amer29.4 29.4 25.0

267 ViXS Systems Inc 448IEEE448 711 85SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering63.0 63.0 12.0

268 ASML Holding NV 2862SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering447 8633 2020AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics5.2 33.2 23.4

269 Nintendo Co. Ltd. 668ACM-Assoc Comput Mach447 2285 447IEEE19.6 29.2 19.6

270 Cleveland Clinic (and Foundat 519Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund444 2323 444IEEE19.1 22.3 19.1

271 University of South Florida 438IEEE438 2047 300Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders21.4 21.4 14.7

272 SiPix Imaging Inc. 679SID-Society for Information Display437 1663 437IEEE26.3 40.8 26.3

273 Solarflare Communications In 1294ACM-Assoc Comput Mach436 2365 452Joint IEEE and ACM18.4 54.7 19.1

274 Viasat 436IEEE436 643 23ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.8 67.8 3.6

275 ALOFT MEDIA LLC 431IEEE431 629 1053GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.5 68.5 16.7

276 Denso Corp 430IEEE430 997 90Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.1 43.1 9.0

277 North Carolina State Universit 741AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics430 3381 566Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders12.7 21.9 16.7

278 CREATIVE KINGDOMS LL 428IEEE428 1202 349ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.6 35.6 29.0

279 ICOSYSTEM CORP 427IEEE427 544 27Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders78.5 78.5 5.0

280 Caterpillar Inc. 425IEEE425 1036 148SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers41.0 41.0 14.3

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-7Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 89: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

281 United Technologies Corp 425IEEE425 1462 134AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro29.1 29.1 9.2

282 Via Technologies Inc. 420IEEE420 815 103Joint IEEE and ACM51.5 51.5 12.6

283 NOMADIX INC 419IEEE419 1632 271Network Working Group RFC25.7 25.7 16.6

284 The National Aeronautical and 418IEEE418 1797 154Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders23.3 23.3 8.6

285 Invensys Plc. 661I S A-INSTRUM SYS AUTOMATION SOC416 3962 449Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders10.5 16.7 11.3

286 Microchip Technology Inc. 413IEEE413 545 41IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys75.8 75.8 7.5

287 Novell Inc. 412IEEE412 1147 318ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.9 35.9 27.7

288 ACACIA MEDIA TECHNOL 410IEEE410 720 66ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.9 56.9 9.2

289 North American Communicati 410IEEE410 1167 248Joint IEEE and ACM35.1 35.1 21.3

290 Duke University 409IEEE409 2322 354Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.6 17.6 15.2

291 Arraycomm Inc. 407IEEE407 441 15SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering92.3 92.3 3.4

292 ITT Corp 405IEEE405 854 63The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force47.4 47.4 7.4

293 Voxer Llc 401IEEE401 590 37CBS Interactive68.0 68.0 6.3

294 Adaptix 400IEEE400 477 29Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer83.9 83.9 6.1

295 Battelle Memorial Institute 488Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund400 2544 400IEEE15.7 19.2 15.7

296 Charles Stark Draper Laborato 400IEEE400 1389 195Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.8 28.8 14.0

297 Tokyo Electron Limited 431Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund400 2931 400IEEE13.6 14.7 13.6

298 Lightsquared Company 399IEEE399 736 130Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer54.2 54.2 17.7

299 Safran S.A. 398IEEE398 1160 101Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders34.3 34.3 8.7

300 SAIC Inc 552SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering398 2534 398IEEE15.7 21.8 15.7

301 MicroStrategy Inc. 396IEEE396 1450 258ACM-Assoc Comput Mach27.3 27.3 17.8

302 Aisin Seiki Co. Ltd. 1210OSA-Opt Soc Amer394 2511 394IEEE15.7 48.2 15.7

303 Elster Group GmbH 393IEEE393 461 18ACM-Assoc Comput Mach85.2 85.2 3.9

304 Coherent Inc. 578OSA-Opt Soc Amer392 2465 481AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics15.9 23.4 19.5

305 State University of New York 391IEEE391 2356 332Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders16.6 16.6 14.1

306 Oclaro Inc 390IEEE390 1049 262OSA-Opt Soc Amer37.2 37.2 25.0

307 Spectrum Dynamics Llc 389IEEE389 1177 109John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss33.1 33.1 9.3

308 AVISTAR COMMUNICATI 388IEEE388 756 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.3 51.3 30.2

309 Global Foundries Inc 387IEEE387 787 75AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics49.2 49.2 9.5

310 Tangis Corp 384IEEE384 573 105ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.0 67.0 18.3

311 ZENO SEMICONDUCTOR I 384IEEE384 491 98IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys78.2 78.2 20.0

312 Ruckus Wireless Inc 381IEEE381 512 38Hitachi Ltd74.4 74.4 7.4

313 United States of America Depa 381IEEE381 1255 204IET/IEE30.4 30.4 16.3

314 Linear Technology Corp. 407Cahners-Denver Pub364 1011 364IEEE36.0 40.3 36.0

315 TRILLIANT NETWORKS I 362IEEE362 544 38The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force66.5 66.5 7.0

316 University of Central Florida 362IEEE362 1573 256OSA-Opt Soc Amer23.0 23.0 16.3

317 Olympus Corp. 360IEEE360 1892 357Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.0 19.0 18.9

318 Technion - Israel Institute of T 356IEEE356 881 82Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders40.4 40.4 9.3

319 Delphi Automotive Plc 355IEEE355 731 100Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders48.6 48.6 13.7

320 SOLARBRIDGE TECHNOL 355IEEE355 390 12IET/IEE91.0 91.0 3.1

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-8Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 90: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

321 Oewaves Inc 442OSA-Opt Soc Amer353 1117 353IEEE31.6 39.6 31.6

322 Vestas Wind Systems A/S 349IEEE349 513 38AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro68.0 68.0 7.4

323 Ford Motor Co. 348IEEE348 1292 325SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers26.9 26.9 25.2

324 Danaher Corp. 384Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund345 2234 345IEEE15.4 17.2 15.4

325 CenturyLink Inc 344IEEE344 724 96International Telecommunication Union47.5 47.5 13.3

326 COLLABORATION PROPE 343IEEE343 480 70ACM-Assoc Comput Mach71.5 71.5 14.6

327 Realtek Semiconductor Corp. 339IEEE339 407 14Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer83.3 83.3 3.4

328 Sigma Corp 339IEEE339 445 66SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering76.2 76.2 14.8

329 Prysmian SPA 335IEEE335 984 223OSA-Opt Soc Amer34.0 34.0 22.7

330 Korea Advanced Institute for S 334IEEE334 802 67Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.6 41.6 8.4

331 Ignis Innovation Inc 333IEEE333 403 30Emerald Group Publishing82.6 82.6 7.4

332 RONALD A KATZ TECHN 332IEEE332 2143 222International Data Group15.5 15.5 10.4

333 Cray Inc 505ACM-Assoc Comput Mach330 1298 330IEEE25.4 38.9 25.4

334 KLA-Tencor Corp. 1211SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering329 4404 742AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics7.5 27.5 16.8

335 University of Colorado ( The 500OSA-Opt Soc Amer326 1857 326IEEE17.6 26.9 17.6

336 Yuen Foong Yu Paper Manufa 3701SID-Society for Information Display326 6604 505Nature Publishing Group4.9 56.0 7.6

337 Hexagon AB 325IEEE325 938 108ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.6 34.6 11.5

338 United Microelectronics Corp 325IEEE325 631 73IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys51.5 51.5 11.6

339 On Semiconductor Corporatio 324IEEE324 409 8SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering79.2 79.2 2.0

340 Assa Abloy AB 344International Association for Cryptologic Resear323 1719 323IEEE18.8 20.0 18.8

341 Unisys Corp. 323IEEE323 712 167ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.4 45.4 23.5

342 F5 NETWORKS INC 321IEEE321 1474 258ACM-Assoc Comput Mach21.8 21.8 17.5

343 Johnson Controls Inc 319IEEE319 837 161Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.1 38.1 19.2

344 University of Pennsylvania 622Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund317 3437 329John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss9.2 18.1 9.6

345 SercoNet Ltd 316IEEE316 604 41INTERTEC PUBL CORP PRIMEDIA CO52.3 52.3 6.8

346 Teradyne Inc. 316IEEE316 589 67ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng53.7 53.7 11.4

347 Leonhard Kurz Stiftung & Co 325AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics315 1348 315IEEE23.4 24.1 23.4

348 National Chiao Tung Universi 314IEEE314 608 63AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics51.6 51.6 10.4

349 Atmel Corp. 302IEEE302 489 22AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics61.8 61.8 4.5

350 Soitec SA 325AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics302 1308 302IEEE23.1 24.8 23.1

351 NUMENTA INC 301IEEE301 931 91Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer32.3 32.3 9.8

352 Fluidigm Corp 311ACS-Am Chem Soc297 2082 311Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders14.3 14.9 14.9

353 The Nielsen Co BV 454Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund297 2327 297IEEE12.8 19.5 12.8

354 YANICKLO TECHNOLOG 604ACM-Assoc Comput Mach297 1409 297IEEE21.1 42.9 21.1

355 Fuji Electric Holdings Co. Ltd. 296IEEE296 545 62AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics54.3 54.3 11.4

356 Northwestern University 346AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics294 2539 318Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders11.6 13.6 12.5

357 Ziptronix Inc 368AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics290 1354 290IEEE21.4 27.2 21.4

358 DIGITAL VOICE SYSTEMS 288IEEE288 305 12Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders94.4 94.4 3.9

359 Duchossois Industries Inc. 288IEEE288 722 110International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)39.9 39.9 15.2

360 United States Air Force 288IEEE288 978 122AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics29.4 29.4 12.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-9Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 91: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

361 University of North Carolina 288IEEE288 1642 217Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders17.5 17.5 13.2

362 BANDSPEED INC 287IEEE287 476 140Bluetooth Special Interest Group60.3 60.3 29.4

363 Qinetiq Group Ltd 287IEEE287 953 122OSA-Opt Soc Amer30.1 30.1 12.8

364 Harvard University 878ACS-Am Chem Soc286 4979 685AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics5.7 17.6 13.8

365 AVALANCHE TECHNOLO 395AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics281 1248 281IEEE22.5 31.7 22.5

366 Japan Science and Technology 749AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics281 2847 438Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders9.9 26.3 15.4

367 Ohio State University 353Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund281 1706 281IEEE16.5 20.7 16.5

368 Arizona State University 280IEEE280 1116 206AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics25.1 25.1 18.5

369 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 280IEEE280 611 50IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng45.8 45.8 8.2

370 VERANCE CORP 280IEEE280 482 46SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering58.1 58.1 9.5

371 CIRREX SYSTEMS LLC 278IEEE278 775 125OSA-Opt Soc Amer35.9 35.9 16.1

372 University of Connecticut 278IEEE278 1051 153OSA-Opt Soc Amer26.5 26.5 14.6

373 National University of Singap 276IEEE276 806 76AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics34.2 34.2 9.4

374 BLACKBERRY LTD 3753GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo275 961 275IEEE28.6 39.0 28.6

375 Promos Technologies Inc. 275IEEE275 365 69IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys75.3 75.3 18.9

376 ROY-G-BIV CORP 275IEEE275 937 198ISO-International Standards Organization29.3 29.3 21.1

377 Synaptics Inc. 275IEEE275 580 57ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.4 47.4 9.8

378 Tensorcomm Inc 275IEEE275 312 13IET/IEE88.1 88.1 4.2

379 Eaton Corp. 274IEEE274 399 16SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers68.7 68.7 4.0

380 Polycom Inc. 274IEEE274 430 43International Telecommunication Union63.7 63.7 10.0

381 Exar Corp. 273IEEE273 351 25Joint IEEE and ACM77.8 77.8 7.1

382 REALTIME DATA LLC 273IEEE273 851 130IBM Corp32.1 32.1 15.3

383 Pennsylvania State University 381Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund272 2201 272IEEE12.4 17.3 12.4

384 INTOUCH TECHNOLOGIE 270IEEE270 521 35IEEE/RSJ51.8 51.8 6.7

385 Silicon Genesis Corporation 307Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund269 1335 286AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics20.1 23.0 21.4

386 Enablence Technologies Inc 267IEEE267 587 60IET/IEE45.5 45.5 10.2

387 INLINE CONNECTION CO 266IEEE266 402 35INTERTEC PUBL CORP PRIMEDIA CO66.2 66.2 8.7

388 National Taiwan University 266IEEE266 412 35AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics64.6 64.6 8.5

389 TELECOMMUNICATIONS 265IEEE265 378 38IET/IEE70.1 70.1 10.1

390 Qimonda AG 264IEEE264 728 125AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics36.3 36.3 17.2

391 ACORN TECHNOLOGIES I 263IEEE263 816 180AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics32.2 32.2 22.1

392 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 2635Society of Petroleum Engineers262 5980 575SPWLA-Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log Analysts4.4 44.1 9.6

393 Telecom Italia SPA 261IEEE261 656 963GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body39.8 39.8 14.6

394 LTX-Credence Corp 260IEEE260 499 74AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics52.1 52.1 14.8

395 Rohm Co. Ltd. 630AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics259 2424 391ACS-Am Chem Soc10.7 26.0 16.1

396 ST-Ericsson SA (Patents split 258IEEE258 344 273GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body75.0 75.0 7.8

397 Tel Aviv Univiversity 258IEEE258 1133 194Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders22.8 22.8 17.1

398 Walt Disney Co. 928ACM-Assoc Comput Mach258 1668 258IEEE15.5 55.6 15.5

399 Autodesk Inc. 739ACM-Assoc Comput Mach256 1374 256IEEE18.6 53.8 18.6

400 Catholic University Leuven 256IEEE256 499 40AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics51.3 51.3 8.0

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-10Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 92: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

401 Tilera Corp 255IEEE255 553 170Joint IEEE and ACM46.1 46.1 30.7

402 Johns Hopkins University 339Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund253 1972 253IEEE12.8 17.2 12.8

403 PTS Corporation 253IEEE253 450 43OSA-Opt Soc Amer56.2 56.2 9.6

404 BIO CONTROL MEDICAL ( 250IEEE250 964 165Lippincott Williams & Wilkins25.9 25.9 17.1

405 TROXLER ELECTRONIC L 250IEEE250 573 131AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS, 100 BARR HARBOR D43.6 43.6 22.9

406 University of Maryland 283Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund248 1755 248IEEE14.1 16.1 14.1

407 Logitech International SA 247IEEE247 488 116ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.6 50.6 23.8

408 Omnivision Technologies Inc 269OSA-Opt Soc Amer245 779 245IEEE31.5 34.5 31.5

409 Iowa State University 244IEEE244 1113 150ACS-Am Chem Soc21.9 21.9 13.5

410 Cubic Wafer Inc 243IEEE243 370 70SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering65.7 65.7 18.9

411 Searete LLC 243IEEE243 1585 155ACM-Assoc Comput Mach15.3 15.3 9.8

412 Airbiquity Inc 242IEEE242 344 453GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body70.3 70.3 13.1

413 Volcano Corporation 242IEEE242 738 80Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders32.8 32.8 10.8

414 Communications Research Ce 241IEEE241 394 37IET/IEE61.2 61.2 9.4

415 National University of Ireland 241IEEE241 500 42Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders48.2 48.2 8.4

416 Waratek 238IEEE238 548 147ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.4 43.4 26.8

417 Vicor Corp 236IEEE236 332 40Center for Power Electronics Systems (Virginia Tech)71.1 71.1 12.0

418 Centre National De La Recher 616Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund235 2356 235IEEE10.0 26.1 10.0

419 KT Corp. 234IEEE234 323 19IET/IEE72.4 72.4 5.9

420 Comverse Technology Inc. 984International Data Group233 3077 598ACM-Assoc Comput Mach7.6 32.0 19.4

421 University of New Mexico 233IEEE233 1196 139OSA-Opt Soc Amer19.5 19.5 11.6

422 Vishay Intertechnology Inc. 233IEEE233 372 23PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)62.6 62.6 6.2

423 National Institute of Informati 232IEEE232 660 132IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng35.2 35.2 20.0

424 ON-RAMP WIRELESS INC 232IEEE232 317 25IET/IEE73.2 73.2 7.9

425 Aerospace Corp. 231IEEE231 532 67Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders43.4 43.4 12.6

426 STEYPHI SERVICES DE LL 231IEEE231 458 104OSA-Opt Soc Amer50.4 50.4 22.7

427 University of Pittsburgh 288Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund231 1582 231IEEE14.6 18.2 14.6

428 United States Health & Huma 516Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund229 2587 271John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss8.9 19.9 10.5

429 Fujikara Ltd. 228IEEE228 722 165OSA-Opt Soc Amer31.6 31.6 22.9

430 Adaptive Spectrum & Signal 227IEEE227 425 147ANSI-American National Standards Institute53.4 53.4 34.6

431 Alacritech Inc 227IEEE227 470 106United Business Media/UBM Tech48.3 48.3 22.6

432 Vanderbilt University 347Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund227 1883 227IEEE12.1 18.4 12.1

433 Monolithic System Technolog 226IEEE226 259 10Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders87.3 87.3 3.9

434 LINEX TECHNOLOGIES IN 225IEEE225 253 8IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng88.9 88.9 3.2

435 Takata Corporation 225IEEE225 314 20European Microwave Association71.7 71.7 6.4

436 TRANSPHORM INC 225IEEE225 453 79AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics49.7 49.7 17.4

437 UT-Battelle LLC 339AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics225 1909 295Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders11.8 17.8 15.5

438 Skyhook Wireless Inc 224IEEE224 366 34European Alliance for Innovation61.2 61.2 9.3

439 Sulvolta Inc 224IEEE224 416 56AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics53.8 53.8 13.5

440 BRAINGATE CO LLC 223IEEE223 583 92Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders38.3 38.3 15.8

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-11Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 93: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

441 New York University 265OSA-Opt Soc Amer221 1761 221IEEE12.5 15.0 12.5

442 TRACBEAM LLC 221IEEE221 434 85ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.9 50.9 19.6

443 AMPT LLC 220IEEE220 303 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders72.6 72.6 8.3

444 West Corp 219IEEE219 828 150ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.4 26.4 18.1

445 DISCOVERY COMMUNICA 217IEEE217 413 36ACM-Assoc Comput Mach52.5 52.5 8.7

446 M/A-COM Technology Soluti 216IEEE216 346 36International Telecommunication Union62.4 62.4 10.4

447 Creative Technology Ltd. 215IEEE215 408 110ACM-Assoc Comput Mach52.7 52.7 27.0

448 BE HERE CORP 212IEEE212 581 72ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.5 36.5 12.4

449 Baker Hughes Inc. 543Society of Petroleum Engineers211 1901 211IEEE11.1 28.6 11.1

450 Asahi Kasei Corp. 585Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund210 2247 409Lippincott Williams & Wilkins9.3 26.0 18.2

451 Schweitzer Engineering Labor 210IEEE210 248 7Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders84.7 84.7 2.8

452 Skyworks Solutions Inc 209IEEE209 302 13AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics69.2 69.2 4.3

453 RHYTHMIA MEDICAL INC 238Lippincott Williams & Wilkins207 970 207IEEE21.3 24.5 21.3

454 American Express Co. 421RFID Journal/YGS Group206 1759 206IEEE11.7 23.9 11.7

455 BIOSENSORS INTERNATI 206IEEE206 755 107Soc Nucl Med27.3 27.3 14.2

456 University of Nebraska 206IEEE206 1033 174Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders19.9 19.9 16.8

457 ECOLE DE TECHNOLOGIE 205IEEE205 292 263GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body70.2 70.2 8.9

458 TELEBUYER LLC 205IEEE205 537 60IFIP - International Federation for Information Processing38.2 38.2 11.2

459 Voicebox Technologies Inc 205IEEE205 243 32ACM-Assoc Comput Mach84.4 84.4 13.2

460 ARITHMATICA LTD 204IEEE204 275 22Alta Frequenza74.2 74.2 8.0

461 Samplify Systems Inc 204IEEE204 265 16IET/IEE77.0 77.0 6.0

462 UNISANTIS ELECTRONIC 203IEEE203 234 16Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders86.8 86.8 6.8

463 University of Utah 202IEEE202 1251 159ACS-Am Chem Soc16.1 16.1 12.7

464 Amkor Technology Inc. 200IEEE200 485 79Penton Media41.2 41.2 16.3

465 University of Iowa 200IEEE200 1065 123Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders18.8 18.8 11.5

466 Brown University Research Fo 343AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics199 1466 199IEEE13.6 23.4 13.6

467 PerkinElmer Inc. 935ACS-Am Chem Soc199 3223 510Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders6.2 29.0 15.8

468 Semiconductor Technology Ac 199IEEE199 326 37IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng61.0 61.0 11.3

469 William Marsh Rice Universit 205ACS-Am Chem Soc199 1443 199IEEE13.8 14.2 13.8

470 National Science Council Tai 198IEEE198 417 69AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics47.5 47.5 16.5

471 Sunpower Corp 198IEEE198 282 34WIP-Renewable Energies70.2 70.2 12.1

472 Lawrence Livermore National 197IEEE197 683 122Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders28.8 28.8 17.9

473 Weatherford International Ltd. 786Society of Petroleum Engineers197 1598 218Gulf Publications12.3 49.2 13.6

474 Visa Inc 195IEEE195 623 97ISO-International Standards Organization31.3 31.3 15.6

475 AUDIENCE INC 194IEEE194 273 25Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders71.1 71.1 9.2

476 ESS Technology Inc. 194IEEE194 254 20SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering76.4 76.4 7.9

477 Du Pont (E.I.) de Nemours & 763Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saund193 3131 485ACS-Am Chem Soc6.2 24.4 15.5

478 Rutgers University 192IEEE192 740 124Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders25.9 25.9 16.8

479 VistaPrint NV 192IEEE192 461 166Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders41.6 41.6 36.0

480 BLUERISC INC 191IEEE191 534 152Joint IEEE and ACM35.8 35.8 28.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-12Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 94: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

#

IEEE Refs

Total

Science Refs

# Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

%

IEEE Refs

% Refs

#

Refs

%

Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from 15 Categories Combined

481 NGK Insulators Ltd. 190IEEE190 599 100AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics31.7 31.7 16.7

482 SYNCHRODYNE NETWOR 190IEEE190 329 32The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force57.8 57.8 9.7

483 University of Rochester 240OSA-Opt Soc Amer189 1441 211Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders13.1 16.7 14.6

484 COMTECH TELECOMMUN 188IEEE188 203 6Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders92.6 92.6 3.0

485 IPCO LLC 188IEEE188 315 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.7 59.7 7.9

486 JVC Kenwood Holdings Inc 188IEEE188 507 57ISO-International Standards Organization37.1 37.1 11.2

487 NANONEXUS INC 187IEEE187 261 22AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics71.6 71.6 8.4

488 Triquint Semiconductors Inc. 187IEEE187 308 34AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics60.7 60.7 11.0

489 Mitre Corp 185IEEE185 385 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.1 48.1 6.5

490 PDF Solutions 185IEEE185 312 37SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering59.3 59.3 11.9

491 Carl-Zeiss Stiftung 895SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering184 4178 745OSA-Opt Soc Amer4.4 21.4 17.8

492 MUREX SECURITIES LTD 184IEEE184 297 24ANSI-American National Standards Institute62.0 62.0 8.1

493 Siemens Enterprise Communic 184IEEE184 434 64The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force42.4 42.4 14.7

494 IMPINJ Inc 183IEEE183 244 18United Business Media/UBM Tech75.0 75.0 7.4

495 Trimble Navigation Ltd. 183IEEE183 448 121ION-The Inst of Navigation40.8 40.8 27.0

496 CRESTCOM INC 182IEEE182 209 8IET/IEE87.1 87.1 3.8

497 Kopin Corp. 197AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics181 759 181IEEE23.8 26.0 23.8

498 ADARA NETWORKS INC 179IEEE179 393 76ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.5 45.5 19.3

499 Calient Technologies Inc. 179IEEE179 311 56Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders57.6 57.6 18.0

500 ENCYCLOPAEDIA BRITA 536ACM-Assoc Comput Mach179 1086 179IEEE16.5 49.4 16.5

Sunday, May 04, 2014 C-13Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 95: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 1 – Front Page of Patent # 5,591,372

United States Patent 5,591,372

Venkataramani , et al. January 7, 1997

Piezoelectric composite with anisotropic 3-3 connectivity

Abstract

A piezoelectric or electrostrictive composite exhibiting anisotropic 3-3 connectivity with a dense ceramic phase

and an infiltrate polymer phase. The ceramic phase is an interconnected ceramic lamelli structure that is

arranged substantially parallel in one direction. The ceramic lamelli have greater connectivity in the z direction

than in the x and y directions, while the connectivity in the x and y directions are essentially equal.

Inventors: Venkataramani; Venkat S. (Clifton Park, NY); Smith; Lowell S. (Niskayuna, NY)

Assignee: Generla Electric Company (Schenectady, NY)

Appl. No.: 531840

Filed: September 22, 1995

Current U.S. Class: 252/62.9R; 252/62.9PZ; 501/32; 501/95.2; 501/136; 501/137;

501/139

Intern'l Class: C04B 035/00

Field of Search: 252/62.9 R,62.9 PZ 428/260,272,289,290 501/32,134,136,137,95

264/28

References Cited

U.S. Patent Documents

4122041 Oct., 1978 Mahler 251/449.

4330593 May., 1982 Shrout et al. 252/62.

Other References

"Injection Molded Fine-Scale Piezoelectric Composite Transducers", LJ Bowen, et al. 1993

Ultrasonics Symposium, 1993 IEEE, pp. 499-503. no month.

"Modeling 1-3 Composite Piezoelectrics: Thickness-Mode Oscillations", W A Smith, B A Auld,

IEEE Trans. on Ultrasonics Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control, vol. 38, No. 1, Jan. 1991.

"Properties of Composite Piezoelectric Materials for Ultrasonic Transducers", W A Smith, et al.,

1984 Ultrasonics Symposium, IEEE 1984, pp. 539-544. no month.

"The Role of Piezocomposites in Ultrasonic Transducers", W A Smith, 1989 Ultrasonics

Symposium, 1989 IEEE, pp. 755-766. no month.

"Development of 1-3 Ceramic-Air Composite Transducers", C. Oakley, et al., SPIE vol. 1733 (1992)

pp. 274-283. no month.

"Freeze-formed Silica Fibers", W. Hahler, et al., May 1980, Central Research & Development Dept.,

E.I. duPont de Nemours & Company, Wilmington, Delaware.

Primary Examiner: Bonner; Melissa

Attorney, Agent or Firm: Johnson; Noreen C., Pittman; William H.

Page 96: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 2 - # and % of Patent References from Top 40 Companies to Top 20 Journal Publishers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

300280 (31.23%)

82119 (8.54%)

80530 (8.38%)

42416 (4.41%)

23850 (2.48%)

20450 (2.13%)

19915 (2.07%)

19237 (2.00%)

18729 (1.95%)

15790 (1.64%)

14986 (1.56%)

11151 (1.16%)

10531 (1.10%)

9904 (1.03%)

9297 (0.97%)

9249 (0.96%)

9130 (0.95%)

8952 (0.93%)

8471 (0.88%)

7638 (0.79%)

0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000 350000

Electrochemical Society

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

Nature Publishing Group

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

Am Physical Soc

IET/IEE

US Dept of Energy

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

Joint IEEE and ACM

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

SID-Society for Information Display

ACS-Am Chem Soc

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % References to Papers/Standards/Conferences from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 97: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 3 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Clock, Watch, and

Timepiece Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

299 (42.05%)

38 (5.34%)

35 (4.92%)

32 (4.50%)

22 (3.09%)

20 (2.81%)

15 (2.11%)

14 (1.97%)

13 (1.83%)

13 (1.83%)

10 (1.41%)

9 (1.27%)

8 (1.13%)

8 (1.13%)

8 (1.13%)

7 (0.98%)

7 (0.98%)

5 (0.70%)

5 (0.70%)

5 (0.70%)

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350

Blackwell Futura

Nature Publishing Group

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

SID-Society for Information Display

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

Joint IEEE and ACM

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

Hewlett Packard Inc.

McGraw Hill

IET/IEE

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

British Horological Inst

Am Physical Soc

Network Working Group RFC

ACS-Am Chem Soc

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 98: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 4 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Computer Hardware

Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

145963 (34.51%)

69840 (16.51%)

20869 (4.93%)

20324 (4.80%)

8416 (1.99%)

8264 (1.95%)

7565 (1.79%)

5811 (1.37%)

5755 (1.36%)

4275 (1.01%)

3877 (0.92%)

3273 (0.77%)

3241 (0.77%)

2911 (0.69%)

2864 (0.68%)

2696 (0.64%)

2452 (0.58%)

2427 (0.57%)

2156 (0.51%)

2111 (0.50%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000 150000 175000

International Data Group

McGraw Hill

Network Working Group RFC

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

United Business Media/UBM Tech

Ziff-Davis

Miller Freeman

IBM Corp

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

IET/IEE

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

The USENIX Association

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

SID-Society for Information Display

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

Joint IEEE and ACM

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 99: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 5 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Computer Software

Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

147736 (31.90%)

74152 (16.01%)

31032 (6.70%)

12472 (2.69%)

11197 (2.42%)

10880 (2.35%)

7906 (1.71%)

6063 (1.31%)

5068 (1.09%)

4356 (0.94%)

4006 (0.86%)

3976 (0.86%)

3465 (0.75%)

3426 (0.74%)

3289 (0.71%)

3273 (0.71%)

3020 (0.65%)

2996 (0.65%)

2966 (0.64%)

2724 (0.59%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000 150000 175000

Miller Freeman

Source Media

ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)

United Business Media/UBM Tech

Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)

Blackwell Futura

International Data Group

Network Working Group RFC

Ziff-Davis

IET/IEE

The USENIX Association

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

Joint IEEE and ACM

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 100: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 6 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Medical Device

Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

135600 (24.12%)

63092 (11.22%)

37974 (6.76%)

27266 (4.85%)

26713 (4.75%)

25266 (4.49%)

15468 (2.75%)

8441 (1.50%)

8013 (1.43%)

7959 (1.42%)

7662 (1.36%)

7205 (1.28%)

6808 (1.21%)

6768 (1.20%)

6438 (1.15%)

5800 (1.03%)

4857 (0.86%)

4792 (0.85%)

4605 (0.82%)

4576 (0.81%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000 150000 175000

IOP Publishing

Mass Med Soc

BMJ Publishing Group

Am Assoc Neurological Surgeons

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

Am Diabetese Assoc

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

Mary Ann Liebert Inc.

Nature Publishing Group

AMA-Am Medical Assoc

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Am Physiological Soc

Radiological Soc North Am

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Blackwell Futura

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

IEEE

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 101: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 7 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Information Storage

Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

53791 (44.55%)

8965 (7.42%)

8445 (6.99%)

7484 (6.20%)

3859 (3.20%)

3373 (2.79%)

2439 (2.02%)

1658 (1.37%)

1588 (1.32%)

1497 (1.24%)

1375 (1.14%)

1343 (1.11%)

1282 (1.06%)

1179 (0.98%)

992 (0.82%)

973 (0.81%)

946 (0.78%)

937 (0.78%)

828 (0.69%)

783 (0.65%)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

IOP Publishing

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

United Business Media/UBM Tech

IBM Corp

Nature Publishing Group

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

The USENIX Association

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

SID-Society for Information Display

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

Joint IEEE and ACM

Am Physical Soc

IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

IEEE

# and % Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 102: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 8 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013

Measuring/Testing/Control Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference

Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

59259 (19.10%)

45354 (14.62%)

23800 (7.67%)

20917 (6.74%)

13924 (4.49%)

12458 (4.02%)

11814 (3.81%)

6529 (2.10%)

5498 (1.77%)

4815 (1.55%)

4397 (1.42%)

3798 (1.22%)

3717 (1.20%)

3462 (1.12%)

3427 (1.10%)

3100 (1.00%)

2971 (0.96%)

2909 (0.94%)

2267 (0.73%)

2128 (0.69%)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

Royal Society of Chemistry

IET/IEE

Soc Exploration Geophysicists

Society of Petroleum Engineers

Natl Acad Sciences

Blackwell Futura

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

Am Physical Soc

IOP Publishing

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

Nature Publishing Group

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

ACS-Am Chem Soc

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 103: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 9 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Nuclear/X-Ray/

Radiant Energy Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

12614 (17.61%)

8140 (11.37%)

7639 (10.67%)

6953 (9.71%)

3772 (5.27%)

3654 (5.10%)

3429 (4.79%)

1850 (2.58%)

1622 (2.26%)

1463 (2.04%)

1400 (1.95%)

1389 (1.94%)

985 (1.38%)

727 (1.02%)

682 (0.95%)

647 (0.90%)

637 (0.89%)

517 (0.72%)

493 (0.69%)

484 (0.68%)

0 2500 5000 7500 10000 12500 15000

Amer Soc Microbiology

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

Soc Applied Spectroscopy

Oxford Univ Press

Am Assoc Physicists Med/Am Inst Physics

Royal Society of Chemistry

Blackwell Futura

Natl Acad Sciences

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

IOP Publishing

Nature Publishing Group

Am Physical Soc

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

IEEE

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 104: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 10 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Optics Patents to

Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

27003 (19.74%)

21435 (15.67%)

17650 (12.90%)

11195 (8.19%)

9637 (7.05%)

6793 (4.97%)

4883 (3.57%)

4523 (3.31%)

2580 (1.89%)

2112 (1.54%)

1734 (1.27%)

1727 (1.26%)

1532 (1.12%)

1459 (1.07%)

1378 (1.01%)

1217 (0.89%)

1054 (0.77%)

919 (0.67%)

919 (0.67%)

910 (0.67%)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

SEMATECH Consortium

Technical Assoc Photopolymers

Pennwell Pub

IOP Publishing

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

Nature Publishing Group

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

Am Physical Soc

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

SID-Society for Information Display

IET/IEE

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 105: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 11 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Power Systems

Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

16762 (34.16%)

9551 (19.47%)

5173 (10.54%)

2336 (4.76%)

1089 (2.22%)

1050 (2.14%)

874 (1.78%)

874 (1.78%)

682 (1.39%)

644 (1.31%)

524 (1.07%)

486 (0.99%)

474 (0.97%)

412 (0.84%)

362 (0.74%)

359 (0.73%)

317 (0.65%)

289 (0.59%)

261 (0.53%)

237 (0.48%)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000

MRS-Materials Research Soc

General Electric Co.

SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro

Royal Society of Chemistry

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Nature Publishing Group

Penton Media

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

Cahners-Denver Pub

IET/IEE

US Dept of Energy

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Electrochemical Society

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 106: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 12 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Robotics and

Intelligent Mfg Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

202 (0.48%)

203 (0.49%)

243 (0.58%)

243 (0.58%)

267 (0.64%)

269 (0.65%)

283 (0.68%)

300 (0.72%)

357 (0.86%)

393 (0.94%)

461 (1.11%)

469 (1.12%)

577 (1.38%)

708 (1.70%)

849 (2.04%)

1326 (3.18%)

1614 (3.87%)

2282 (5.47%)

3587 (8.60%)

17853 (42.81%)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000

Blackwell Futura

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC

MIT/MIT Press

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

Winter Simulation Conference Board of Directors

ACS-Am Chem Soc

SAGES-Soc of Am Gastro and Endoscopic Surgeons

ISA-Instrument Sys Automation Society

Joint IEEE and ACM

IET/IEE

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

IEEE/RSJ

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 107: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 13 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Semiconductor

Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

127408 (25.94%)

84671 (17.24%)

59470 (12.11%)

20306 (4.13%)

14174 (2.89%)

13468 (2.74%)

13291 (2.71%)

12427 (2.53%)

12036 (2.45%)

11815 (2.41%)

11774 (2.40%)

10275 (2.09%)

8913 (1.81%)

8489 (1.73%)

8457 (1.72%)

8435 (1.72%)

7743 (1.58%)

6381 (1.30%)

3192 (0.65%)

2763 (0.56%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000 150000

Joint IEEE and ACM

JPN Soc App Phys

IOP Publishing

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

Nature Publishing Group

IET/IEE

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

SID-Society for Information Display

IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

MRS-Materials Research Soc

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

Electrochemical Society

Am Physical Soc

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 108: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 14 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Smart Meter/Smart

Grid Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

1957 (64.14%)

108 (3.54%)

101 (3.31%)

99 (3.24%)

82 (2.69%)

49 (1.61%)

42 (1.38%)

38 (1.25%)

32 (1.05%)

30 (0.98%)

26 (0.85%)

24 (0.79%)

23 (0.75%)

22 (0.72%)

21 (0.69%)

21 (0.69%)

19 (0.62%)

18 (0.59%)

17 (0.56%)

15 (0.49%)

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500

Mitsubishi Electric Corp

Penton Media

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

United Business Media/UBM Tech

ISO-International Standards Organization

Joint IEEE and ACM

SID-Society for Information Display

Elecrostatic Discharge Association

Hewlett Packard Inc.

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ANSI-American National Standards Institute

<std> CLC SC 105A

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

Echelon Corp

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

IET/IEE

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 109: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 15 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Solar/Photovoltaic

Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

3360 (19.53%)

2884 (16.77%)

2312 (13.44%)

2277 (13.24%)

1136 (6.60%)

518 (3.01%)

459 (2.67%)

423 (2.46%)

413 (2.40%)

368 (2.14%)

327 (1.90%)

278 (1.62%)

277 (1.61%)

236 (1.37%)

194 (1.13%)

191 (1.11%)

162 (0.94%)

116 (0.67%)

80 (0.47%)

79 (0.46%)

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

US Dept of Energy

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

IOP Publishing

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

Am Physical Soc

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

Electrochemical Society

WIP-Renewable Energies

Royal Society of Chemistry

MRS-Materials Research Soc

Nature Publishing Group

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

IEEE

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

# and % of Science References from 1997-2014 Patents

Page 110: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 16 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013

Telecommunications Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

302133 (46.95%)

42685 (6.63%)

23246 (3.61%)

23115 (3.59%)

19305 (3.00%)

14244 (2.21%)

13135 (2.04%)

10690 (1.66%)

9901 (1.54%)

9009 (1.40%)

8066 (1.25%)

7307 (1.14%)

7187 (1.12%)

6626 (1.03%)

6353 (0.99%)

5756 (0.89%)

5463 (0.85%)

4933 (0.77%)

4898 (0.76%)

4122 (0.64%)

0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000 350000

National Cable & Telecommunications Association

ISO-International Standards Organization

European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

Joint IEEE and ACM

SID-Society for Information Display

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

Network Working Group RFC

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

OSA-Opt Soc Amer

Soc Motion Picture TV Eng Inc

International Telecommunication Union

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

The Internet Society/IETF-Internet Engineering Task Force

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IET/IEE

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Patents

Page 111: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 17 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2013 Wind Energy

Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

766 (45.87%)

176 (10.54%)

140 (8.38%)

87 (5.21%)

75 (4.49%)

67 (4.01%)

45 (2.69%)

43 (2.57%)

42 (2.51%)

27 (1.62%)

13 (0.78%)

13 (0.78%)

12 (0.72%)

11 (0.66%)

11 (0.66%)

10 (0.60%)

9 (0.54%)

8 (0.48%)

7 (0.42%)

6 (0.36%)

0 250 500 750 1000

Blackwell Futura

Professional Engineering Publishing Ltd

Asea Brown Boveri - ABB

Pennwell Pub

AVS-AIP Am Inst Physics

McGraw Hill

Electric Power Research Institute

CIGRE-International Council on Large Electric Systems

Springer/Springer Wien/Springer-Verlag/Kluwer

Nature Publishing Group

AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

EPE Association

NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

IET/IEE

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro

US Dept of Energy

Reed/Elsevier/Pergamon/Academic Press/Saunders

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2014 Patents

Page 112: Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences ... · Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2013 Report prepared for: Institute

Figure 18 - 1997-2013 Citation Index of Patents Referencing IEEE Papers and

Conferences Versus Patents not Referencing IEEE for 15 Categories

Copyright (c) 2014, 1790 Analytics, LLC

1.4

8

1.2

1

1.2

5

1.4

9

1.3

7 1.4

9

1.5

4 1.6

7

1.6

2

1.3

2

1.3

5

1.9

5

1.5

6

1.3

2

2.1

6

0.9

8

0.8

9

0.9

7

0.9

7

0.9

0

0.9

5

0.9

1

0.9

1

0.9

6

0.8

6

0.9

3

1.2

2

1.1

2

0.9

1

1.3

4

0.00

1.00

2.00

Clo

cks/W

atc

hes/T

ime P

ieces

Com

pute

r H

ard

ware

Com

pute

r S

oftw

are

Dia

gnosis

/Surg

ery

/Medic

al In

str

um

ents

Info

rmation S

tora

ge

Measuring, T

esting a

nd C

ontr

ol

Devic

es

Nucle

ar/

X-R

ay/R

adia

nt E

nerg

y

Optics/P

hoto

gra

phy/E

lectr

ophoto

gra

phy

Pow

er

Syste

ms

Robotics a

nd Inte

lligent M

anufa

ctu

ring

Sem

iconducto

rs/S

olid

-Sta

te

Devic

es/E

lectr

onic

s

Sm

art

Grid/S

mart

Mete

rs/E

nerg

y

Infr

astr

uctu

re

Sola

r/P

hoto

voltaic

Tele

com

and O

ther

Com

munic

ations

Win

d E

nerg

y

Cit

ati

on

In

de

x

Patents Referencing IEEE

Patents Not Referencing IEEE