Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE...

114
Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane P.O. Box 1331 Piscataway, NJ 08855-1331, USA Report prepared by: 1790 Analytics LLC 130 Haddon Avenue Haddonfield, NJ 08033 www.1790analytics.com July 8, 2018

Transcript of Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE...

Page 1: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017

Report prepared for:

IEEE 445 Hoes Lane P.O. Box 1331

Piscataway, NJ 08855-1331, USA

Report prepared by:

1790 Analytics LLC 130 Haddon Avenue

Haddonfield, NJ 08033 www.1790analytics.com

July 8, 2018

Page 2: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Executive Summary IEEE engaged 1790 Analytics in this project to assess the impact of IEEE publications on developments in various technologies. This impact is measured by examining the extent to which patented inventions build upon papers from IEEE journals, IEEE-sponsored conferences, and IEEE standards. This is an update of previous reports, and examines US patents issued from January 1, 1997 through December 31, 2017. The main findings of this report are: • New technology continues to build upon science, and the dependence is increasing.

In this study, the top 30 firms (in 2017) were granted 75,102 patents, which made a total of 535,999 non-patent references (an average of 7.13 non-patent references per patent). Back in 2010 the top 30 firms had 58,179 patents which made a total of 239,789 non-patent references (an average of 4.13 non-patent references per patent) Thus, the number of patents is trending upward but the number of references from those patents is rising at a greater rate. Since a large number of these non-patent references are to scientific articles and conference papers, this suggests that today’s technology developments are increasingly linked to developments in published science.

• A large portion of this science base comes from papers presented at IEEE sponsored

conferences and published in IEEE journals. The top 30 patenting firms in 2017 have referenced over 1,276,109 articles in the last 21 years. About 31% (390,314) of those articles appeared in IEEE journals, IEEE sponsored conferences or IEEE Standards Documents.

• In this study, we also went beyond the top 30 patenting companies and analyzed all

patents from the last 21 years in several technology categories of interest to IEEE members and customers. For example, 33.5% of all scientific references from Computer Hardware patents go to IEEE publications. The second most referenced publisher is ACM (Association for Computer Machinery) with 16.57% of the referenced publications. In other Information Technology areas, such as Information Storage, Semiconductor Manufacturing, and Computer Software, the results are similar.

• In Telecommunications technology, IEEE is particularly important. The 449,917

references to IEEE articles and conferences represents 44% of all science references from Telecommunications patents since 1997. To help put this in perspective consider: Telecommunications is a very technology driven industry and that technology is often built upon scientific discoveries published in journal and conference papers. If we consider this set of papers as the science base of telecommunications, than almost half of that science base is published in IEEE journals or presented at IEEE sponsored conferences. In addition, the 496,628 references to IEEE dwarf the combined total of the next 25 publishing organizations in this technology.

Page 3: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

ii

• This year for the first time we examined three new technology categories: Artificial

Intelligence (AI), Autonomous Vehicles, and Internet-of-Things related patents. In AI, IEEE enjoys a 3-fold lead over second place ACM. In Autonomous Vehicles, IEEE has a dominant lead (8-fold lead) over second place SPIE. And in the Internet-of-Things category IEEE has a 6-fold lead over second place ACM.

• IEEE is referenced a surprising amount in areas which are not central to its mission.

− For example, just over 7% of the science references from patents in medical devices go to IEEE publications. This ranks IEEE fourth behind RELX and Lippincott-Williams, and Wiley (with 23%, 11%, and 9% respectively). The latter publishers have hundreds of journals in the medical area, whereas IEEE has only a few, so the 7% figure is quite solid for a non-core area.

− Optics is also somewhat surprising. IEEE publications receive the most

references from Optics patents, and IEEE is referenced even more than the two large Optics Societies that would be expected to lead the area: OSA – The Optical Society of America, and SPIE – The International Society of Optical Engineering.

− In Measuring, Testing, and Control, IEEE gets 18.99% of all references, which

is just ahead of the 14.37% of RELX while, again, RELX has many more journal titles in the space.

− In the Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing category, 42.74% of the patent

references are to articles published in IEEE journals or in proceedings of IEEE sponsored conferences. Second place RELX receives about one-fifth as many references in the category.

− Patents related to Power Systems and Transmission also reference IEEE

publications most frequently. The 39,778 references to IEEE journal and proceedings papers are more than the next two top referenced publishers (RELX and Electrochemical Society) combined. We also examined a specialized subset of the Power Transmission category related to smart meters and smart grids. In this category, 64% of the scientific references from patents go to IEEE journal or conference papers. The second most referenced publisher is RELX with only 4.24% of all references.

− A few years back we started tracking some green energy categories: Solar and

Photovoltaic energy and Wind energy. In the latter category IEEE science has a big advantage over the other publishers with more than 42% of the references. In solar energy, IEEE has a small lead over RELX. RELX has more than 50 journal titles related to the area including several high impact journals such as Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, Thin Solid Films, Solar Energy,

Page 4: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

iii

Synthetic Metals, Journal of Crystal Growth, and Solar Cells, IEEE has only a few.

− In broadcasting technologies IEEE leads with 36% of the references, which is 5

times as many as second place International Telecommunication Union. The latter produces standards documents while the IEEE references are to standards documents as well as peer reviewed scientific papers from journals and conferences.

• It has been shown that high-quality, high-impact, and valuable patents tend to be

cited more frequently by later patents. Citation impact is thus often used as a quantitative measure for evaluating patents (see [3]). In this study, we found that the patents that reference IEEE papers are cited more often than patents that do not. This was shown to be true for each of the seventeen technology categories we examined. This suggests that, not only do IEEE publications frequently provide the science base for new inventions, but that inventions that build upon IEEE publications are more likely to be valuable in the future than inventions that do not build upon IEEE.

• Although this study concentrates on patents in specific technology areas, it should

be noted that the importance of scientific and technical literature to patented technology is increasing in all areas. Our research shows that the average US patent had only 2.76 non-patent references (NPRs) back in 1997. That number jumped to 11.21 by 2017 – a 306% increase. These numbers are for all issued US patents and not just those in the seventeen categories covered in this report.1 This means that in the overall patent system, patented technologies are increasingly referencing scientific articles.

• Since we only look at specific categories of technology plus the top 30 firms, there

is no way to know exactly how much referencing to IEEE has increased since 1997. However, we can make an estimate for the whole patent system by identifying any Non-Patent References that mention “IEEE” or “I.E.E.E.” (This will of course miss things like the Journal of Lightwave Technology or Spectrum which may not have IEEE in the reference, but it will be a reasonable estimate.) If we do a comparison as above we find that there were just 14,635 patent references with IEEE or I.E.E.E in 1997, but 143,349 in 2017 (an 879% increase). Thus science referencing and IEEE referencing have both increased greatly since 1997.

1 Including science intensive areas like Biotechnology, Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals, and other areas where IEEE typically has little influence.

Page 5: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Table of Contents Section Page I. Introduction 2 II. Methodology 2 III. Results 5 IV. Conclusions 12 V. References 13 VI. Figures 14 Appendix A A-1 Appendix B B-1 Appendix C C-1

Page 6: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 2

I. Introduction In previous studies, it was found that patents reference papers from IEEE journals much more often than papers from other journal publishers. In this report, we update the previous results, and study US patents issued from January 1997 through December 2017. Although this report is an update of previous results, we have made our best efforts to make this report self-contained. The aim of this report, as in previous reports, is to analyze references from patents to journal articles, conferences and standards documents, in order to assess IEEE’s impact upon technological developments. This report covers seventeen subcategories of Technology where IEEE members and readers are active. Many, but not all are related to Information Technology. The categories patent counts are shown below in Table 1. Table 1: Number of Patents for Each Category Covered in this Study

Category # Patents 1997-2017AI/Artificial Intelligence 8553Autonomous Vehicles 1242Broadcasting 145686Computer Hardware 399435Computer Software 227936Diagnosis/Surgery/Medical Instruments 206775Information Storage 132680IOT/Internet of Things 5924Measuring, Testing and Control Devices 207316Optics/Photography/Electrophotography 157693Power Systems 108289Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing 30356Semiconductors/Solid-State Devices/Electronics 275250Smart Grid/Smart Meters/Energy Infrastructure 3886Solar/Photovoltaic 12159Telecom and Other Communications 570557Wind Energy 5989 II. Methodology This study is based on referencing patterns from patents to prior art documents. When an inventor files a patent for a new invention, he/she will typically reference earlier documents to show that the new invention either builds upon, or improves upon, what came earlier. The inventor’s patent attorney and/or the examiner may also add prior art references to either clarify or limit the claims of the new invention. As an example, Figure 1 shows the front page of a patent owned by IBM. The prior art references on this patent come in two forms - references to earlier patents, and “other references”. These other references are often to scientific publications, such as those produced by

Page 7: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 3

IEEE. In this report we are primarily concerned with these other references, which are also sometimes called “Non-Patent References”. It has been suggested that patents with many non-patent references are likely to contain new leading-edge ideas, whereas patents that only reference earlier patents are likely to be incremental improvements on earlier patented technologies. For a comprehensive study on various hypotheses surrounding the motivations of inventors in citing other references, see [1]. Patent Sets used in the Analysis This study is based on two patent sets. Our analysis is based on determining the number of references from these patent sets to publications from publishers such as IEEE, RELX (formerly Elsevier), the American Institute of Physics, and others. The first set contains patents from the top 30 patenting companies in 2017. Analysis of this patent set provides an insight into how the top tier companies rely upon science from IEEE and other publishers. The second set contains all patents in seventeen technology categories from all companies, universities, government agencies, and individuals. The seventeen technology categories examined are shown in Table 1 above. Analysis of this patent set reveals the wider influence of IEEE science in these technologies. Identifying Relevant Non-Patent References Non-patent references can be to any published document, from comic strips and brochures, to scientific articles and standards documents. The main difficulty in identifying relevant non-patent references for a study such as this is that inventors do not use a standard form for listing references. As an example, Table 2 contains eight different variants for the IEEE Global Telecom Conference. Note that some inventors just use the GLOBECOM shorthand, while others list the entire name. Sometimes IEEE is mentioned and sometimes it is not. When abbreviation variations are included such as Telecom, Tele, Tcom, Proc., Proceed., the number of variants increases further. The same issue exists for variants in journal names and standards documents. For example there are more than 30 variant spellings of the journal title Journal Of Thoracic And Cardiovascular Surgery including numerous mis-spellings of thoracic and every conceivable way of abbreviating cardiovascular.

Table 2 – Variants for IEEE Global Telecom Conference Proceedings of Globecom '96 IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference GLOBECOM '90:IEEE Proceedings of IEEE Globecom '94 Globecom '97 IEEE Globecom, Global Telecommunications Conference and Exhibiton Proc of the Global Tele Conf, U.S. New York, IEEE

Page 8: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 4

Conference Identification – to identify conference proceedings among the non-patent references, we first identified references containing keywords such as meeting, symposia, conference, etc. We then used parsing software to identify 2-word and 3-word phrases that appear frequently in this set of papers. The full string was identified for these string sub-sequences in order to identify frequently cited conferences. In this way, we identified the top conferences referenced in the patent sets, and standardized the names of these conferences (i.e. all of the different variants of a conference were collected under a single name). As an example, all of the variants shown in Table 2 are assigned to the name ‘<conf> IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference (GLOBECOM)’. We then looked up each of these conferences on the web to determine who is listed as their primary sponsor. For example, many of the conferences are sponsored by organizations such as IEEE, ACM (Association for Computer Machinery) and ASME (American Society of Mechanical Engineers). Some conferences are jointly sponsored by multiple organizations and this is noted as well. When we first started identifying conferences in the 2005 report, we looked up the top 100 most referenced conferences in order to identify the primary sponsors or hosts. In this current report we have identified the sponsors for the top 1,200+ most referenced conferences. These 1,200+ conferences are listed under more than 10,000 variant names. Standards Identification – Standards documents are increasingly referenced, and in general they are easy to identify by looking for strings such as ‘standard’ or ‘std’. Once the records containing the standards were located, it is straightforward to identify the organization that produced each standard (ITU, IEEE, ISO, JEDEC, ANSI, etc.). Further, once the standards bodies are identified, we then identify references to other documents that do not specifically list the words ‘standard’ or ‘std.’ The latter step is necessary since some references look like this “ISO/TC97/SC21/N2066” or “IEEE802.3” without a specific mention of the word “standard.” As a consequence we also identify other non-standard documents released from these organizations including draft standards and “requests for comments” documents if they are cited by patents. Journal Identification – identifying and standardizing journal names is a very difficult process because there are so many different journals, and their names can be abbreviated in many different ways. To make the problem more manageable, we base our analysis primarily to the 45,000+ journals covered by the combined databases of ISI/Thomson Reuters, Elesevier/SCOPUS, and 1790 Analytics, LLC. This is not a severe limitation, since these databases include more than 100 IEEE journals, 3,000+ RELX/Elsevier journals, and 1,200 Wiley journals. In addition, we also identify publishers of about 1,000 non-ISI, non-SCOPUS journals if they appear very frequently in the patent references, but do not appear in these databases. Once restricted to these 45,000+ journals, we used software that transforms journal names into common abbreviations and then implements string matching. Care must be taken with string matching because, for example, searching for “Urology Journal” will also accidentally identify “Neurology Journal”. Similarly, a search for the journal “Science” would accidentally pick up

Page 9: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 5

any reference with ‘science’ in the paper title as well as any of the 800+ journals with science in their titles such as “Game and Wildlife Science”. Our proprietary software for journal identification (along with some human intervention) deals with all of these problems, so that we generate an accurate match between the patent references and 45,000+ journals. After identifying all of the relevant journals, we then used the ISI and SCOPUS databases and web research to identify the publisher of each journal III. Results References from Top 30 Patenting Organizations Table 3 shows the 30 firms that were granted the largest number of US patents in 2017. It should be noted that many of these firms consist of multiple subsidiaries, and these firms patent under many names. (For example General Electric has patents filed under 316 names, of which only a fraction contain General Electric in the name.) We identified all of the subsidiary names for each company to ensure that our patent counts are accurate. We identified the top 30 patenting firms because we want to understand the extent to which the current technology leaders use IEEE science. Figure 2 shows the 20 publishers of science whose publications are referenced most frequently by the 30 firms shown in Table 3. This figure shows that patents issued to the top 30 firms between 1997 and 2017 reference IEEE papers, conferences, and standards more than 390,000 times. This is more than three times as many references as the second placed publisher ACM (Association for Computer Machinery). In addition, if conference publications that are jointly sponsored are counted, such as the conferences jointly sponsored between IEEE and the Japanese Society of Applied Physics, or IEEE and ACM, then the number of references from the top 30 companies to IEEE increases by another 30,000+ references. IEEE receives almost 31% of the science references from the patents of the top 30 companies. The next closest publisher (ACM) has 10% of the total and IEEE’s share of references is about the same as the next seven publishers combined. About 1/3 of the 390,000+ patent references to IEEE are to IEEE sponsored conferences. Table 4 illustrates the reference distribution of IBM, which is the top patent holder in 2017 (and for the past 15 years). This reference distribution is typical of the top 30 firms. The references from IBM to IEEE are actually to a number of different IEEE journals and conferences. In this table, IEEE journals are highlighted in yellow and IEEE conferences are highlighted in orange. The top overall reference is to IEEE is to the International Electron Device Meeting. The top IEEE journals are IEEE Computer Magazine and IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices. Notice that 33 of the top 65 journals and conferences referenced by IBM patents are published or sponsored by IEEE. Fifteen of the top 65 journals and conferences are published or sponsored by ACM. As a software firm, IBM tends to reference ACM much more than most of the top 30 firms, but still IBM references IEEE about twice as often as ACM as seen in Appendix A-9 (53,139 references to IEEE and 27,883 references to ACM.) The reader may notice the large

Page 10: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 6

number of references to ‘IEEE Unseparated’ or ‘Misc ACM’ in Table 4. These are articles that reference IEEE or ACM, but the inventor has not given a reference specific enough to identify the proper journal or conference. A few examples can be found in Table 5 below. These are relatively complete references; it is not clear why the inventors were not more careful about listing the full journal names. Table 3 – Top-Patenting Firms in 2017

Rank Full Parent Name2017

Patent Count1997-2017

Patent Count1 International Business Machines Corp 9052 1007792 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 6161 691663 Canon Inc 3787 575394 Intel Corporation 3744 377265 Samsung SDI Co Ltd 2795 157726 Qualcomm Inc 2741 218887 LG Electronics Inc. 2718 226668 Google Inc. 2681 160489 General Electric Company 2615 38661

10 Microsoft Corporation 2606 3552911 Sony Corp 2505 4340112 Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. 2421 1561013 Toyota Motor Corp 2288 1858414 Apple Inc 2252 1479515 Amazon.com Inc. 2052 740316 Huawei Technologies Company Ltd. 1977 861517 Panasonic Corporation 1904 4917018 Ford Motor Co. 1876 1260319 Toshiba Corp 1853 3930120 Fujitsu Limited 1830 3496121 Dell Technologies Inc 1778 1222222 Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd.(also known as 1705 3714223 Ericsson 1587 1676824 Hitachi Ltd 1584 3983725 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1506 2626326 Medtronic Inc 1463 1860227 BOE Technology Group Ltd 1446 307728 Seiko Epson Corporation 1416 2258429 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 1385 1875130 Nokia Corp 1374 30730

Page 11: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 7

Table 4 – Reference Distribution from IBM Patents 1997-2017 References Journal/Conference/Standard

4349 Misc ACM4194 IP.com2932 IEEE Unseparated2773 <conf> IEEE Int Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM)2379 ACM SIGPLAN Notices2296 IBM JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT2263 APPLIED PHYSICS LETTERS2072 IETF Network Working Group1771 COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ACM1710 <conf> Int Conf on Very Large Data Bases (VLDB)1692 <std> IETF Document1431 IEEE tr ELECTRON DEVICES1421 Computer (IEEE)1344 JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS1336 <conf> USENIX Conference Proceedings1280 <conf> IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys - symp on VLSI tech1252 IEEE JOURNAL OF SOLID-STATE CIRCUITS1249 <conf> IEEE int conf on Data eng (ICDE)1248 <conf> ACM/IEEE Design Automation conf1231 Proc SPIE1225 <std> IETF Std1205 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGMOD Symp1182 IBM SYSTEMS JOURNAL1149 <conf> ACM/IEEE int symp on comp Architecture (ISCA)1138 IEEE tr COMPUTERS1004 IEEE ELECTRON DEVICE LETTERS994 Proceedings of ACM SIGMOD972 ACM SIGOPS836 IEEE tr MAGNETICS790 <std> NIST Document787 <conf> IEEE int conf on Distributed comp sys782 J Vac Sci tech772 comp Architecture News712 <conf> IEEE Int Conf Acous, Speech, and Sig Proc (ICASSP)708 IEEE tr Software eng682 SCIENCE676 IEEE tr comp Aided Design of Integrated Circuits and sys675 <conf> ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI)614 <conf> IEEE int symp On High Performance comp Architecture (HPCA)601 IEEE tr KNOWLEDGE AND DATA ENGINEERING597 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGCOMM Symp597 <conf> proc IEEE int Solid State Circuits Conf (ISSCC)595 IEEE tr PARALLEL AND DISTRIBUTED SYSTEMS572 <conf> IEEE Hawaii Int Conf on Sys Sci (HICSS)562 IEEE Proceedings559 JOURNAL OF THE ACM555 <conf> IEEE/ACM Proceedings on Supercomputing (SUPERCOMP)545 <conf> IEEE/ACM Int Conf on Software eng (ICSE)535 Misc SPIE532 <conf> IEEE Misc Conf519 <conf> IEEE Electronic Components and tech conf514 IEEE tr INFORMATION THEORY510 <conf> IEEE/ACM int conf on comp Aided Design (ICCAD)497 <conf> IEEE International Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium493 <conf> Proceedings ACM SIGPLAN Symp492 ACM (MISC)486 PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS484 NATURE475 IEEE MICRO470 NANO LETTERS463 ACM comp Surveys CSUR462 <conf> ACSA/IEEE ann comp Security app conf (ACSAC)452 <std> Network Working Group RFC451 <conf> IEEE int Symp on High Performance Distributed comp444 IEEE JOURNAL ON SELECTED AREAS IN COMMUNICATIONS

Page 12: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 8

Table 5 – Examples of References Mapped to “IEEE Unseparated”

Patent NPR

# NPR Text

05692177 3 Lewis et al. "Hashing for dynamic and static internal tables." IEEE, pp. 45-56 Oct. 1988.

05699518 4 "The Design and Implementation of a Reliable Distributed Operating System--ROSE", Ng, IEEE, pp. 2-11, Apr. 1990.

05699518 5 "A service Platform for Distributed Applications", Popescu-Zeletin et al, IEEE, pp. 11-17, Jul. 1992.

05709219 5 Kotoku, Tetsuo et al., "Environment Modeling for the Interactive Display (EMID) Used in Telerobotic Systems," IEEE Nov. 3-5 1991, pp. 999-1004.

05709219 6

Kotoku, Tetsuo, "A Predictive Display with Force Feedback and Its Application to Remote Manipulation System with Transmission Time Delay," IEEE Jul. 7-10 1992, pp. 239-246.

05709219 8 Burdea, Grigore et al., "Distributed Virtual Force Feedback," IEEE May 2, 1993, Atlanta, GA, pp. 25-44.

References from Companies in Seventeen Technology Categories In the previous section, we analyzed the use of IEEE science by the top patenting organizations. Out of all science publishers, IEEE was cited most often by these organizations by a wide margin. However, looking only at the top companies tells an incomplete story. IEEE publishes journals and runs conferences mainly in information technology, electronics and other areas. It is therefore useful to examine the extent to which IEEE science is referenced by all organizations that patent in specific technologies and not just the leading companies. As mentioned in the methodology section, we identified all patents in the seventeen technology categories shown above in Table 1. 1790 Analytics has developed a classification scheme that categorizes all patents into 50 broad technology areas based on International Patent Classes (IPCs) which are assigned to each patent as part of the examination process. This scheme was used to identify all relevant patents for the current analysis. We examined each of the seventeen technology areas separately, and the results are summarized in Figures 3-19. The first category shown (in Figure 3) is Artificial Intelligence (AI). We identified all non-patent references on patents related to this technology issued between 1997 and 2017. We then determined the science publishers responsible for the largest number of these non-patent references. Figure 3 shows the result of this analysis, namely that IEEE science is referenced far more in AI related patents than science from any other publisher. Thirty four percent of all science references from these patents go to IEEE journal papers or IEEE sponsored conference papers (the graphs also include standards documents, but the vast majority of the references are to journal or conference papers). In second place is the ACM with 11.39% of the references.

Page 13: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 9

AI is a new category for this year as is Autonomous Vehicles in Figure 4. Here again IEEE dominates in references. In this case more than half (57.92%) of all references are to IEEE in this category. Figure 5 covers Broadcasting patents, which is a category we first added in 2015. This category consists of US patents in the IPCs for Broadcast Communication and Pictorial Communication (Television). It would seem that this would be an area that is somewhat tangential to IEEE’s core mission. However, Thirty seven percent of all science references from these patents go to IEEE journal papers or IEEE sponsored conference papers. The International Tele-communications Union is a distant second with 7.15% of all references. Figures 6 and 7 show referencing patterns from Computer Hardware and Software patents. Here IEEE once again receives far more references than the other publishers. In both cases, ACM is the second most referenced publisher, but it receives about half of the references that papers published by IEEE receive. Figure 8 examines the top referenced publishers in the Medical Device field, which covers devices as well as diagnostic tools and surgical instruments. Here, IEEE is a respectable fourth in an area that is somewhat outside its core competency. RELX who has more than 400 journals in the field, such as Annals of Thoracic Surgery, and the Journal of the American College of Cardiology has a substantial lead with 20.5% of all references. Wiley and Lippincott have 7.9% and 7.8% respectively, so although IEEE is in fourth place, it is not far off of second or third with 7.3% of all references. Figure 9 contains the results for the information storage category. In this area, IEEE is particularly dominant. 43.9% of all of the science references from patents in information storage are to papers in IEEE journals or conferences. IEEE’s 81,148 references in this category are more than six times as many as second place AIP (American Institute of Physics). Another new category for this year covers Internet-of-Things patents. As Figure 10 shows, IEEE science is very important to the development of this new and active area of patenting. More than 51% of all science references are to IEEE content. ACM is a distant second with 7.99% of all references. Figure 11 contains the results of patents covering Measuring, Testing, and Control technology. Patents in this category are related to measuring or testing, force, pressure, weight, etc. as well as chemically measuring substances (e.g. measuring CO2 levels). The category also contains control devices since these technologies are often combined. For example a patent might be related to a valve that adjusts at a certain pressure or at a certain pollution level. Since this type of measuring can be done both mechanically, magnetically, electrically, or chemically, it is not too surprising to see both IEEE and RELX and the Optical and Chemical Societies all near the top of Figure 11. IEEE receives the most references, but the lead is not as dominant as in the Information Technology related technology areas. The results for the Optics category can be found in Figure 12. This is another area that is slightly outside the IEEE core. IEEE still has a lead over the second and third place publishers – the

Page 14: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 10

Optical Society of America (OSA) and the International Society of Optical Engineering (SPIE). Since these latter two societies are Optical societies, it would be reasonable to assume that one of these societies would lead in the category but IEEE strong journals and conferences in the area receive more references from optics patents. Figure 13 contains results for the patents related to power generation and transmission. Although this is a non-information technology category, IEEE leads in references in this category as well. 33.9% of science references from patents in this category go to IEEE publications. RELX is second with 20.34% of all US patent references in the category. Intelligent Manufacturing and Robotics contains patents related to robotics, and robotics and control systems related to manufacturing. According to Markets and Markets, the Robotics market is about a $20 billion dollar industry because of a population explosion in “service robots” that mow lawns, vacuum floors, and manufacture things. As this industry grows, new innovations will be patented, and from Figure 14 it looks like those innovations will build upon ideas published in IEEE journal articles or presented at IEEE conferences. We see in that 42.74% of all science references from patents in this space refer to IEEE published articles. RELX is the second ranked publisher, but its papers receive only 8.19% of the science references. In this category, IEEE has more references then the next 15 publishers combined. Figure 15 shows that IEEE is also very strong in the Semiconductor category. Here, the inclusion of conferences gives IEEE a substantial boost. Approximately one-third of the references to IEEE are to conference papers. With conferences excluded, IEEE would be about the same level as the American Institute of Physics in terms of science references from semiconductor patents. The Smart Meter/Smart Grid category covers patents related to improving the power grid as well as for advanced residential electric meters. This is a relatively small category but as we see in Figure 16, the IEEE provides the bulk of the science base with 64% of all patent references. Solar and Photovoltaic energy results are contained in Figure 17. IEEE holds a small lead over RELX in this category in spite of having fewer journal titles. RELX has several strong journals in this category including Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells, Thin Solid Films, Solar Energy, Synthetic Metals, Journal of Crystal Growth, Solar Cells, plus more than 50 smaller journal titles related to this technology. The references to IEEE science in this category mainly go to the IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists conference, the IEEE World conference on Photovoltaic Energy Conversion, and IEEE Transactions on Electronic Devices. The Telecommunications category is the strongest large category for IEEE. There are over three times as many references to IEEE conference and journal papers as to second place publisher 3GPP (which is a standards body). Standards are referenced more frequently in telecommunications, but still not nearly as often as journal and conference papers. About 55% of the nearly one million total references to all publishers are to journal articles; 25% of the references are to conference papers, and about 20% are to standards documents. In terms of standards documents, the 3GPP General Partnership Project, Internet Engineering Task Force

Page 15: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 11

and International Telecommunication Union received the most references in the category. New telecommunications patents are referencing scientific articles to a larger extent than in the past. In this category in 2008, there were just over 118,000 references to IEEE and last year there were 450,000 references to IEEE papers. Now as we see in Figure 18, there are more than 496,000 references to IEEE for telecommunications patents from 1997-2017. Thus, just one more year of patents added more than 46,000 references to IEEE documents. Standards documents are referenced increasingly often in Telecommunications patents. Five of the top 11 (7 of the top 20) referenced publishers are standards bodies. Moreover, of the 496,000 references to IEEE, over 20,000 are to various IEEE standards (mostly to the IEEE 802 family of standards). Wind Energy patents were tracked for the first time in last year’s report. We see in Figure 19 that in this area 39.96% of all science references from Wind Energy patents go to IEEE journal and conference papers. Here again, this is four times as many references as second place RELX receives, in spite of having fewer journal titles in the area than RELX does. Figures 3-19 show aggregate counts of references from all patents in each technology category. Readers who wish to see the firms that reference IEEE publications in each category can consult Appendix B. This appendix contains the 100 organizations that reference IEEE most frequently in each category. Appendix C is similar, except that it contains the organizations that reference IEEE most frequently in the seventeen technology categories combined. Citation Index for Patents Referencing IEEE In an earlier study (see [2]) it was shown that patents that reference specific IEEE journals perform better on a number of quality metrics. Moreover, it was shown that the results were statistically significant. In this report, we update a key figure from the previous study showing the citation index of patents that reference IEEE papers versus peer patents that do not reference IEEE. The citation index is a normalized citation metric that takes the number of citations received by a particular set of patents, and divides it by the expected number of citations for patents of the same age and technology class. A random set of patents therefore should have a citation index of 1.0. Research has shown that patents cited by many later patents tend to contain important ideas upon which the later patents are building (see [3] and [6]). Citation indicators are also the basis for the patented financial models (see [4] and [7]) invented by the two 1790 founders Breitzman and Thomas. Figure 20 contains the Citation Index for the patents in the seventeen technology categories that reference IEEE papers and conferences. Also shown is the Citation Index for the set of the remaining patents in each category that do not reference IEEE. Note that the set of all patents in each category have an expected citation index of 1.0. Thus we see that the patents that reference IEEE are cited at least 30% more than expected, while the patents that do not reference IEEE are cited up to 30% less often than expected in some categories. This of course does not imply that all patents that reference IEEE are likely to be more valuable than patents that do not reference

Page 16: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 12

IEEE, but it does suggest that in general, patented technologies that build upon IEEE published or sponsored science are more likely to be valuable than patented technologies that do not reference IEEE science. IV. Conclusions When a patent is filed, it must reference the prior art upon which it builds, as well as any prior art that limits the claims of the new invention. This study and prior studies show that science published by IEEE forms a significant portion of this prior art for new patents. In this study, we examined two separate patent sets. The first patent set consisted of patents granted between 1997 and 2017 to the 30 organizations with the largest number of US patents granted in 2017. The second patent set consisted of all US patents granted between 1997 and 2017 patents in seventeen key technologies: Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous Vehicles, Broadcasting, and several other categories. In both of these patent sets IEEE is the dominant source of non-patent prior art. In other words, IEEE journals and conferences are key outlets for scientific discoveries relevant to cutting edge technology. Finally, we conducted an analysis of citation indices for IEEE related patents and non-IEEE related patents. These types of metrics have been shown in validation studies to be good markers for the quality, impact, and potential value of patents [3]. In this study, it was shown that patents that build upon IEEE published science tend to have higher citation indices than patents that do not reference IEEE. This suggests but does not guarantee that patents that build upon IEEE science are more likely to become high-quality, high-impact, valuable inventions than patents that do not build upon IEEE. Specific key results are identified in the Executive Summary.

Page 17: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 13

V. References [1] Branstetter, Lee. “Is Academic Science Driving a Surge in Industrial Innovation? Evidence from Patent Citations,” Columbia Business School, Discussion Paper #28. [2] Breitzman, Anthony. "IEEE and Patents: An Analysis of Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences and Standards", 1790 Analytics, LLC, May 23, 2005 [3] Breitzman, Anthony and Mogee, Mary Ellen. “The Many Applications of Patent Analysis,” of Information Science, 28, 3, 187-205, 2002. [4] Breitzman, Anthony., “Method and Apparatus for Choosing a Stock Portfolio, Based on Patent Indicators,” US Patent #6,175,824, Jan. 16, 2001. [5] Fortune Magazine, “Ten Tech Trends,” January 10, 2005. [6] Hall, Bronwyn H., Jaffe, Adam B. and Trajtenberg, Manuel., "The NBER Patent Citations Data File: Lessons, Insights and Methodological Tools" (December 2001). CEPR Discussion Paper No. 3094. [7] Thomas, Patrick., “System and Method for Producing Technology-Based Price Targets for a Company Stock,” US Patent #6,832,211, Dec. 14, 2004.

Page 18: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Page 14

Page 19: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 2 - # and % of US Patent References from Top 30 Companies to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers, and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

390314 (30.59%)

127692 (10.01%)

85359 (6.69%)

81983 (6.42%)

35714 (2.80%)

29940 (2.35%)

29034 (2.28%)

23789 (1.86%)

23457 (1.84%)

20993 (1.65%)

19381 (1.52%)

17951 (1.41%)

17151 (1.34%)

11052 (0.87%)

10613 (0.83%)

9918 (0.78%)

9752 (0.76%)

8417 (0.66%)

8255 (0.65%)

6818 (0.53%)

0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000

Nature Publishing Group

SID-Society for Information Display

Optical Society of America

The USENIX Association

Network Working Group RFC

US Dept of Energy

IET/IEE

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.

ACS-Am Chem Soc

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

International Telecommunication Union

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

Joint IEEE and ACM

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

American Institute of Physics

RELX Group (Elsevier)

3GPP Gen Partnership Project Standards Body

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % References to Papers/Standards/Conferences from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 15

Page 20: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 3 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Artificial Intelligence US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

15918 (34.19%)

5302 (11.39%)

3927 (8.43%)

1967 (4.22%)

1067 (2.29%)

914 (1.96%)

810 (1.74%)

749 (1.61%)

619 (1.33%)

611 (1.31%)

586 (1.26%)

582 (1.25%)

530 (1.14%)

401 (0.86%)

365 (0.78%)

332 (0.71%)

298 (0.64%)

297 (0.64%)

288 (0.62%)

276 (0.59%)

0 5000 10000 15000 20000

World Wide Web Consortium

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

National Institutes of Health - NIH

Natl Acad Sciences

Assoc for the Advance of Artificial Intelligence

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

Neural Information Proc Systems Foundation

Oxford University Press

International Machine Learning Society (IMLS)

Nature Publishing Group

Joint IEEE and ACM

Numenta Inc.

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

MIT Press

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

RELX Group (Elsevier)

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 16

Page 21: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 4 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Autonomous Vehicle US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

2121 (57.92%)

244 (6.66%)

201 (5.49%)

134 (3.66%)

87 (2.38%)

74 (2.02%)

46 (1.26%)

38 (1.04%)

37 (1.01%)

32 (0.87%)

31 (0.85%)

31 (0.85%)

24 (0.66%)

21 (0.57%)

18 (0.49%)

18 (0.49%)

18 (0.49%)

17 (0.46%)

17 (0.46%)

17 (0.46%)

0 1500 3000

New York Times

Defense Adv Res Projects Agency (DARPA)

Florida International University (FIU)

Frontiers Media S.A.

American Automatic Control Council (AACC)

NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin

IP.Com

MIT Press

SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

Assoc for the Advanc of Artificial Intelligence

SAGE Publications

KES International

Condé Nast

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE/RSJ

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 17

Page 22: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 5: # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Broadcasting US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

104214 (36.49%)

20433 (7.15%)

18729 (6.56%)

15947 (5.58%)

12113 (4.24%)

9150 (3.20%)

5879 (2.06%)

5850 (2.05%)

5441 (1.90%)

4776 (1.67%)

3814 (1.34%)

3642 (1.28%)

3076 (1.08%)

2992 (1.05%)

2943 (1.03%)

2446 (0.86%)

2395 (0.84%)

2305 (0.81%)

2168 (0.76%)

1722 (0.60%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000

Joint IEEE and ACM

SID-Society for Information Display

ISO-International Standards Organization

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

Mcgraw Hill

Optical Society of America

New York Times

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

Digital Equipment Corp

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

IET/IEE

National Cable & Telecommunications Assoc

ISO/IEC

RELX Group (Elsevier)

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Soc Motion Picture and Television Engineers

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

International Telecommunication Union

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 18

Page 23: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 6 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Computer Hardware US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers, and

Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

223960 (33.50%)

110797 (16.57%)

31337 (4.69%)

30557 (4.57%)

14237 (2.13%)

11469 (1.72%)

11221 (1.68%)

10255 (1.53%)

9667 (1.45%)

9663 (1.45%)

5722 (0.86%)

5237 (0.78%)

4597 (0.69%)

4552 (0.68%)

3920 (0.59%)

3835 (0.57%)

3617 (0.54%)

3468 (0.52%)

3211 (0.48%)

2952 (0.44%)

0 100000 200000 300000

Very Large Data Base (VLDB) Endowment

Mcgraw Hill

Soc Motion Picture and Television Engineers

Miller Freeman

United Business Media/UBM Tech

Ziff-Davis

IBM Corp.

Network Working Group RFC

American Institute of Physics

IET/IEE

The USENIX Association

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

SID-Society for Information Display

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

Joint IEEE and ACM

RELX Group (Elsevier)

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 19

Page 24: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 7 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Computer Software US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

235033 (31.72%)

118042 (15.93%)

47033 (6.35%)

21841 (2.95%)

17681 (2.39%)

17424 (2.35%)

15238 (2.06%)

13066 (1.76%)

8574 (1.16%)

7385 (1.00%)

5837 (0.79%)

5348 (0.72%)

5195 (0.70%)

5064 (0.68%)

4564 (0.62%)

4510 (0.61%)

4057 (0.55%)

3920 (0.53%)

3787 (0.51%)

3669 (0.50%)

0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000

International Assoc for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)

Source Media

ISCA (International Speech Communication Assoc)

Oxford University Press

International Data Group

United Business Media/UBM Tech

Very Large Data Base (VLDB) Endowment

IET/IEE

Ziff-Davis

ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

The USENIX Association

Network Working Group RFC

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Joint IEEE and ACM

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

RELX Group (Elsevier)

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 20

Page 25: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 8 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Medical Device US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

210863 (20.50%)

81226 (7.90%)

80536 (7.83%)

75197 (7.31%)

57441 (5.58%)

28507 (2.77%)

23108 (2.25%)

21094 (2.05%)

17626 (1.71%)

14022 (1.36%)

13952 (1.36%)

13862 (1.35%)

13522 (1.31%)

13443 (1.31%)

12800 (1.24%)

12716 (1.24%)

12011 (1.17%)

11823 (1.15%)

11567 (1.12%)

8960 (0.87%)

0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000

BMJ Publishing Group

Radiological Society of North America

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

Optical Society of America

American Institute of Physics

American Diabetes Association

American Physiological Society

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Nature Publishing Group

Oxford University Press

Mary Ann Liebert Inc.

Wolters Kluwer

Blackwell Publishing Inc.

Mosby Inc.

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

IEEE

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

RELX Group (Elsevier)

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 21

Page 26: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 9 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Information Storage US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

81148 (43.90%)

13463 (7.28%)

11326 (6.13%)

10769 (5.83%)

7783 (4.21%)

6267 (3.39%)

4712 (2.55%)

2549 (1.38%)

2507 (1.36%)

2331 (1.26%)

2327 (1.26%)

2156 (1.17%)

1879 (1.02%)

1843 (1.00%)

1758 (0.95%)

1613 (0.87%)

1533 (0.83%)

1490 (0.81%)

1284 (0.69%)

1134 (0.61%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000

Electrochemical Society, Inc.

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

IBM Corp.

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

Nature Publishing Group

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

The USENIX Association

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

Am Physical Soc

American Physical Society

Joint IEEE and ACM

SID-Society for Information Display

IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

RELX Group (Elsevier)

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

American Institute of Physics

IEEE

# and % Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 22

Page 27: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 10 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Internet-Of-Things (IOT) US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

5233 (51.40%)

813 (7.99%)

588 (5.78%)

398 (3.91%)

195 (1.92%)

156 (1.53%)

103 (1.01%)

95 (0.93%)

92 (0.90%)

90 (0.88%)

83 (0.82%)

77 (0.76%)

76 (0.75%)

61 (0.60%)

51 (0.50%)

47 (0.46%)

46 (0.45%)

44 (0.43%)

43 (0.42%)

42 (0.41%)

0 3000 6000

Association for the Adv of Artificial Intelligence

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Miller Freeman

Electric Power Research Institute

ANSI-American National Standards Institute

Ziff-Davis

American Institute of Physics

United Business Media/UBM Tech

ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)

Echelon Corp

European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

Joint IEEE and ACM

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

IET/IEE

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

RELX Group (Elsevier)

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 23

Page 28: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 11 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Measuring/Testing/Control US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference

Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

87666 (18.99%)

66355 (14.37%)

30156 (6.53%)

29529 (6.40%)

25401 (5.50%)

23610 (5.11%)

16829 (3.65%)

11104 (2.41%)

8472 (1.84%)

6355 (1.38%)

5890 (1.28%)

4996 (1.08%)

4261 (0.92%)

3935 (0.85%)

3891 (0.84%)

3877 (0.84%)

3556 (0.77%)

3464 (0.75%)

3369 (0.73%)

2826 (0.61%)

0 25000 50000 75000 100000 125000

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

American Physical Society

Oxford University Press

IOP Publishing

IET/IEE

Royal Society of Chemistry

Society of Petroleum Engineers

Society of Exploration Geophysicists

Natl Acad Sciences

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

Nature Publishing Group

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

American Institute of Physics

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Optical Society of America

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 24

Page 29: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 12 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Optics US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

28075 (15.34%)

26908 (14.70%)

24012 (13.12%)

15431 (8.43%)

13900 (7.60%)

6242 (3.41%)

6175 (3.37%)

6075 (3.32%)

5470 (2.99%)

4981 (2.72%)

2441 (1.33%)

2366 (1.29%)

2096 (1.15%)

2006 (1.10%)

1884 (1.03%)

1545 (0.84%)

1371 (0.75%)

1309 (0.72%)

1293 (0.71%)

1253 (0.68%)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000

Am Physical Soc

PennWell Publishing Co.

European Conf on Optical Comm (ECOC) Society

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

American Physical Society

SEMATECH Consortium

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

Nature Publishing Group

SID-Society for Information Display

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

IEEE/OSA

IET/IEE

ACS-Am Chem Soc

RELX Group (Elsevier)

American Institute of Physics

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Optical Society of America

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 25

Page 30: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 13 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Power Systems US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

39778 (33.79%)

23946 (20.34%)

10825 (9.19%)

6996 (5.94%)

4102 (3.48%)

3550 (3.02%)

1847 (1.57%)

1556 (1.32%)

1526 (1.30%)

1437 (1.22%)

1270 (1.08%)

1265 (1.07%)

748 (0.64%)

726 (0.62%)

692 (0.59%)

675 (0.57%)

567 (0.48%)

518 (0.44%)

485 (0.41%)

477 (0.41%)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000

EPE Association

Am Physical Soc

Penton Media, Inc.

AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro

SID-Society for Information Display

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

Reed Business

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

US Dept of Energy

IET/IEE

Royal Society of Chemistry

Nature Publishing Group

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

American Institute of Physics

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Electrochemical Society, Inc.

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 26

Page 31: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 14 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Robotics and Intelligent Mfg US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

290 (0.39%)

357 (0.49%)

377 (0.51%)

386 (0.52%)

390 (0.53%)

396 (0.54%)

443 (0.60%)

468 (0.64%)

599 (0.81%)

602 (0.82%)

666 (0.91%)

796 (1.08%)

1041 (1.41%)

1524 (2.07%)

1705 (2.32%)

2935 (3.99%)

2980 (4.05%)

3080 (4.19%)

6025 (8.19%)

31453 (42.74%)

0 10000 20000 30000 40000

Nature Publishing Group

ISA-Instrum Sys Automation Soc

American Automatic Control Council (AACC)

Society of Petroleum Engineers

SAGES-Soc of American Gastro and Endoscopic Surgeons

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.

SAGE Publications

IET/IEE

CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

Joint IEEE and ACM

American Institute of Physics

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

IEEE/RSJ

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 27

Page 32: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 15 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Semiconductor US Patents to Top 20 Publishers and Conference Organizers

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

186263 (23.81%)

140500 (17.96%)

86871 (11.11%)

35977 (4.60%)

34167 (4.37%)

26481 (3.39%)

19939 (2.55%)

19176 (2.45%)

18949 (2.42%)

18127 (2.32%)

15444 (1.97%)

15330 (1.96%)

13371 (1.71%)

12327 (1.58%)

12083 (1.54%)

11560 (1.48%)

10677 (1.36%)

9925 (1.27%)

5650 (0.72%)

5352 (0.68%)

0 50000 100000 150000 200000

Joint IEEE and ACM

Japan Society of Applied Physics

IET/IEE

MRS-Materials Research Soc

American Assoc for the Advancement of Science

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

American Physical Society

Am Physical Soc

Nature Publishing Group

Optical Society of America

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

Electrochemical Society, Inc.

IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

SID-Society for Information Display

RELX Group (Elsevier)

American Institute of Physics

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 28

Page 33: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 16 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Smart Meter/Smart Grid US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

3195 (64.26%)

211 (4.24%)

161 (3.24%)

136 (2.74%)

83 (1.67%)

82 (1.65%)

69 (1.39%)

58 (1.17%)

45 (0.91%)

45 (0.91%)

41 (0.82%)

37 (0.74%)

33 (0.66%)

28 (0.56%)

26 (0.52%)

25 (0.50%)

24 (0.48%)

24 (0.48%)

23 (0.46%)

23 (0.46%)

0 1000 2000 3000 4000

Elecrostatic Discharge Association

Defense Adv Res Projects Agency (DARPA)

Hewlett-Packard Company

WIP-Renewable Energies

Electrochemical Society, Inc.

SID-Society for Information Display

ACS-Am Chem Soc

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

ANSI-American National Standards Institute

Joint IEEE and ACM

American Institute of Physics

Electric Power Research Institute

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

Echelon Corp

IET/IEE

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 29

Page 34: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 17 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Solar/Photovoltaic US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

7439 (19.11%)

6877 (17.67%)

5579 (14.33%)

4967 (12.76%)

3111 (7.99%)

1047 (2.69%)

862 (2.21%)

851 (2.19%)

651 (1.67%)

642 (1.65%)

597 (1.53%)

505 (1.30%)

456 (1.17%)

410 (1.05%)

368 (0.95%)

364 (0.94%)

307 (0.79%)

276 (0.71%)

216 (0.55%)

198 (0.51%)

0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000

Cambridge University Press

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

American Physical Society

Am Physical Soc

Optical Society of America

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

US Dept of Energy

MRS-Materials Research Soc

Electrochemical Society, Inc.

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

Amer Assoc for the Advancement of Science

Royal Society of Chemistry

WIP-Renewable Energies

Nature Publishing Group

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

ACS-Am Chem Soc

American Institute of Physics

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2018 Patents

Page 30

Page 35: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 18 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Telecommunications US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

496628 (42.44%)

150549 (12.87%)

47874 (4.09%)

34574 (2.95%)

31818 (2.72%)

28587 (2.44%)

24069 (2.06%)

18587 (1.59%)

16165 (1.38%)

14334 (1.22%)

13900 (1.19%)

13111 (1.12%)

11329 (0.97%)

11199 (0.96%)

11065 (0.95%)

10917 (0.93%)

10735 (0.92%)

7690 (0.66%)

7476 (0.64%)

6606 (0.56%)

0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000 600000

ISO/IEC

IEEE/OSA

IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

Joint IEEE and ACM

European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

SID-Society for Information Display

American Institute of Physics

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

Soc of Motion Picture and Television Engineers

Optical Society of America

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Network Working Group RFC

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IET/IEE

International Telecommunication Union

Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3GPP Gen Partnership Proj Standards Body

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 31

Page 36: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 19 - # and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Wind Energy US Patents to Top 20 Publishers, Conference Organizers,

and Standards Organizations

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

1269 (39.96%)

316 (9.95%)

171 (5.38%)

160 (5.04%)

153 (4.82%)

151 (4.75%)

137 (4.31%)

105 (3.31%)

85 (2.68%)

52 (1.64%)

50 (1.57%)

32 (1.01%)

32 (1.01%)

22 (0.69%)

20 (0.63%)

14 (0.44%)

13 (0.41%)

13 (0.41%)

13 (0.41%)

12 (0.38%)

0 500 1000 1500

SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

Electric Power Research Institute

Reed Business

Nature Publishing Group

TIMES MIRROR MAG

American Automatic Control Council (AACC)

American Institute of Physics

Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

Amer Assoc for the Advancement of Science

EPE Association

NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin

IET/IEE

AWEA-American Wind Energy Association

ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

EWEA-European Wind Energy Association

US Dept of Energy

John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro

RELX Group (Elsevier)

IEEE

# and % of Science References from 1997-2017 Patents

Page 32

Page 37: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

Figure 20 - 1997-2017 Citation Index of US Patents Referencing IEEE Papers and Conferences Versus US Patents not Referencing IEEE for 17 Categories

Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

1.3

3.0

2.0

1.8

2.1

4.3

1.5

2.5

1.6

1.5 1.6

2.0

1.5

2.6

1.8

1.6

2.5

0.8

2.7

1.2

1.2

1.7

2.5

0.9

1.8

0.9

0.7 0.

8 1.0

0.9

1.6

1.1 1.2 1.2

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0A

I/Arti

ficia

l Int

ellig

ence

Aut

onom

ous

Veh

icle

s

Bro

adca

stin

g

Com

pute

r Har

dwar

e

Com

pute

r Sof

twar

e

Dia

gnos

is/S

urge

ry/M

edic

alIn

stru

men

ts

Info

rmat

ion

Sto

rage

IOT/

Inte

rnet

of T

hing

s

Mea

surin

g, T

estin

g an

dC

ontro

l Dev

ices

Opt

ics/

Phot

ogra

phy/

Ele

ctro

phot

ogra

phy

Pow

er S

yste

ms

Rob

otic

s an

d In

telli

gent

Man

ufac

turin

g

Sem

icon

duct

ors/

Sol

id-

Sta

te D

evic

es/E

lect

roni

cs

Sm

art G

rid/S

mar

t Met

ers/

Ene

rgy

Infra

stru

ctur

e

Sol

ar/P

hoto

volta

ic

Tele

com

and

Oth

erC

omm

unic

atio

ns

Win

d En

ergy

Cita

tion

Inde

x

Patents Referencing IEEE

Patents Not Referencing IEEE

Page 33

Page 38: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Amazon.com Inc.28.42909ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

23.32391IEEE

5.5565RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.9498Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

2.2226International Data Group

2.0203Joint IEEE and ACM

2.0203The USENIX Association

2.0201Information Processing Society of Japan

1.9192Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.7178Ziff-Davis

1.6167CBS Interactive

1.4144New York Times

1.1110International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)

1.1114SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.0103United Business Media/UBM Tech

1.0103John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

182 others with less than 1% each 1936 17.7

Apple Inc

38.924712IEEE

20.813223ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.32718RELX Group (Elsevier)

1.81125Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.61041ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)

1.59373GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.3845Joint IEEE and ACM

1.1686Ziff-Davis

1.1723Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence

1.0628Optical Society of America

1.0641ISO/IEC

323 others with less than 1% each 16265 23.6

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-1Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 39: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

BOE Technology Group Ltd19.746ACS-Am Chem Soc

12.830RELX Group (Elsevier)

12.830John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

11.126American Institute of Physics

6.816SID-Society for Information Display

4.310IEEE

3.48China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House

3.07INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.66Nature Publishing Group

2.66CRC Press/Taylor & Francis

1.74Chinese Academy of Sciences

1.74SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.74Electrochemical Society, Inc.

1.74APS/OSA/IEEE

1.74Optical Society of America

1.33Royal Society of Chemistry

1.33I S A-INSTRUM SYS AUTOMATION SOC

1.33MRS-Materials Research Soc

15 others with less than 1% each 20 8.5

Bosch (Robert) GmbH24.72371IEEE

8.4805RELX Group (Elsevier)

7.2691Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

3.8361American Diabetes Association

3.6347Amer Thoracic Soc

2.4234SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

2.1199John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.0193American Medical Informatics Association

1.9186Georg Thieme Verlag

1.8175Wichtig Publishing

1.7164Ziff-Davis

1.6158Electrochemical Society, Inc.

1.5144SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.3123SAGE Publications

1.2116ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.1101Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI)

1.1102Assoc Advancement Medical Instrumentation-AAMI

1.098Schattauer GmbH

1.097Am Diabetese Assoc

1.098IET/IEE

224 others with less than 1% each 2832 27.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-2Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 40: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Canon Inc21.36414IEEE

13.03914American Institute of Physics

12.73817RELX Group (Elsevier)

5.21560ACS-Am Chem Soc

5.11550SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

4.91470John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

3.1945ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.0606Nature Publishing Group

2.0610Optical Society of America

1.9575INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.8552Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.4420AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

1.1345Electrochemical Society, Inc.

1.0305SID-Society for Information Display

437 others with less than 1% each 7018 19.2

Dell Technologies Inc

36.04541ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

25.43209IEEE

8.01014The USENIX Association

5.3666Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

3.4425Joint IEEE and ACM

2.0249RELX Group (Elsevier)

1.6201Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.3161International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)

1.0126Network Working Group RFC

189 others with less than 1% each 2030 14.3

Ericsson

33.513186IEEE

31.2122803GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

8.03133Network Working Group RFC

5.62220Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

2.3899Optical Society of America

2.1843ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.8704International Telecommunication Union

1.8690European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

1.6648IET/IEE

1.0399IEEE/OSA

1.0397RELX Group (Elsevier)

262 others with less than 1% each 3905 7.9

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-3Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 41: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Ford Motor Co.36.12179SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

19.11150IEEE

11.1672RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.8287IP.Com

2.5149American Automatic Control Council (AACC)

2.2134ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.7103ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.593Society of Automotive Engineers of Japan, Inc. (JSAE)

1.588ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

1.272Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.167IEEE/RSJ

1.059IET/IEE

1.059John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

163 others with less than 1% each 918 13.2

Fujitsu Limited

38.510202IEEE

9.324603GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

4.11073Joint IEEE and ACM

4.01061Optical Society of America

3.91041American Institute of Physics

3.81018ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.7976IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

3.3884RELX Group (Elsevier)

2.4627IET/IEE

2.1553IEEE/OSA

1.9491European Conference on Optical Communication (ECOC) Society

1.4359ATM Forum Standards Body

1.4378Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.4380IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.3345International Telecommunication Union

1.1280Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.0275SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

352 others with less than 1% each 4084 12.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-4Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 42: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

General Electric Company17.810535US Dept of Energy

13.47892RELX Group (Elsevier)

13.07656IEEE

6.84012John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

6.33746Society of Petroleum Engineers

5.83433General Electric Co.

4.52630ACS-Am Chem Soc

2.61532American Institute of Physics

2.41413Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.2705Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.

1.2712SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.1645Nature Publishing Group

1.0578ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng

736 others with less than 1% each 13610 18.3

Google Inc.

33.114694IEEE

22.910168ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.82150RELX Group (Elsevier)

3.01351SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.91292Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

2.61177International Telecommunication Union

1.88013GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.7777World Wide Web Consortium

1.6700John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.5660ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics

1.2554Joint IEEE and ACM

1.1496Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

342 others with less than 1% each 9599 19.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-5Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 43: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Hitachi Ltd25.96241IEEE

7.01687RELX Group (Elsevier)

6.51559ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

6.01442American Institute of Physics

3.2772IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

2.7655John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.6629Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

2.4588ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.7417The USENIX Association

1.6393INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.5369Network Working Group RFC

1.5371International Telecommunication Union

1.5357Nikkei Business Publications, Inc.

1.3314SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.2294SID-Society for Information Display

1.2286IET/IEE

1.2285Nature Publishing Group

1.2286Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.1259IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.12553GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

1.1259IBM Corp.

1.0234Optical Society of America

1.0250Joint IEEE and ACM

463 others with less than 1% each 5875 20.1

Hon Hai Precision Industry Co. Ltd.(also known as Foxconn]21.24587IEEE

17.036653GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

7.51631American Institute of Physics

6.81480SID-Society for Information Display

5.11102RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.2912ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.6788ACS-Am Chem Soc

2.6562ISO/IEC

2.5543International Telecommunication Union

2.5538SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.2467AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

2.2470John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.8380INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.6342Nature Publishing Group

1.3276Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.3284IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.0220Electrochemical Society, Inc.

271 others with less than 1% each 3370 13.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-6Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 44: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Huawei Technologies Company Ltd.37.886903GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

25.85926IEEE

8.92054International Telecommunication Union

8.41933Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

5.51267Network Working Group RFC

1.6369Open Mobile Alliance (Standards Org)

1.4321European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

1.4330ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

173 others with less than 1% each 2101 7.7

Intel Corporation48.130247IEEE

7.44680ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

7.245343GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

5.73601Joint IEEE and ACM

2.61613RELX Group (Elsevier)

2.41502American Institute of Physics

1.71087IET/IEE

1.2769IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.1713Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.1679SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

412 others with less than 1% each 13407 18.3

International Business Machines Corp33.253139IEEE

17.427883ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

5.18109Joint IEEE and ACM

4.57250RELX Group (Elsevier)

3.35365Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

3.14977American Institute of Physics

2.64230IP.Com

2.23478IBM Corp.

1.92998Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.62596ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.62544The USENIX Association

1.32120SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.32101John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.11796Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)

755 others with less than 1% each 31690 16.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-7Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 45: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

LG Electronics Inc.50.0177523GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

23.08159IEEE

4.31530ISO/IEC/JTC/ANSI

3.11096International Telecommunication Union

2.6919European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

2.3817Audio Eng Soc

2.3819ISO/IEC

1.5528ATSC Std

1.3449ISO-International Standards Organization

159 others with less than 1% each 3450 9.2

Medtronic Inc17.323772RELX Group (Elsevier)

11.716058Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.

7.710566IEEE

7.39960Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

6.79211John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.43266American Association of Neurological Surgeons

2.22989Blackwell Publishing Inc.

2.12911Oxford University Press

1.92560American Physiological Society

1.82471ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.82495Radiological Society of North America

1.52104Mosby Inc.

1.31838SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.31803Wolters Kluwer

1.21659International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics (FIGO)

1.11511S. Karger AG

574 others with less than 1% each 41908 28.1

Microsoft Corporation

34.159300IEEE

27.547853ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

3.35809RELX Group (Elsevier)

2.34054Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

2.23902The USENIX Association

2.03536Joint IEEE and ACM

1.72984Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.42451International Telecommunication Union

1.42369SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.01691Very Large Data Base Endowment Inc. (VLDB Endowment)

612 others with less than 1% each 40052 19.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-8Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 46: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Nokia Corp38.520172IEEE

15.379913GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

5.02630Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

4.52378ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.81489RELX Group (Elsevier)

2.51331IET/IEE

2.31208International Telecommunication Union

2.31179Optical Society of America

2.11113American Institute of Physics

1.8926Network Working Group RFC

1.5805European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

1.4752IEEE/OSA

1.3697Joint IEEE and ACM

1.0518ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.0536Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

446 others with less than 1% each 8647 13.3

Panasonic Corporation

31.810273IEEE

13.042103GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

6.42070RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.61486International Telecommunication Union

4.51462IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

4.41436American Institute of Physics

2.9945INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.8573Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.6517ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.5486Electrochemical Society, Inc.

1.4449SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.3409IET/IEE

1.3431ISO/IEC

1.3435ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.1344ISO/IEC/JTC/ANSI

1.1366John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.1340Japan Society of Applied Physics

1.0316Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

390 others with less than 1% each 5806 15.9

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-9Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 47: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Qualcomm Inc43.035946IEEE

17.8149093GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

7.36136International Telecommunication Union

2.31908ISO/IEC/JTC/ANSI

2.21806SID-Society for Information Display

2.11747Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

2.01678ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.01698RELX Group (Elsevier)

1.61324SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.21028European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)

1.2995IET/IEE

1.21015American Institute of Physics

1.1879ISO/IEC

1.1899Network Working Group RFC

1.0808John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.0864Telecomm Industry assoc-TIA

1.0825Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

343 others with less than 1% each 9110 8.8

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd32.413636IEEE

12.452073GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

6.02526RELX Group (Elsevier)

5.32227ACS-Am Chem Soc

4.92073American Institute of Physics

3.51463John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.61090ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.61113International Telecommunication Union

2.3982SID-Society for Information Display

1.6678SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.4596Nature Publishing Group

1.3536Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.3541Audio Eng Soc

478 others with less than 1% each 9374 19.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-10Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 48: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Samsung SDI Co Ltd21.61624American Institute of Physics

21.01583RELX Group (Elsevier)

13.1987ACS-Am Chem Soc

8.6647John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

5.7428SID-Society for Information Display

3.6271IEEE

2.4183Electrochemical Society, Inc.

2.4184Royal Society of Chemistry

2.0152INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.0152IEC-International Electrotechnical Commission

1.8132Nature Publishing Group

1.5112Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.4103J. Van Voorst

1.182Am Physical Soc

1.075Chemical Society of Japan/Nippon Kagakukai

122 others with less than 1% each 817 9.3

Seiko Epson Corporation

34.03101IEEE

7.6690ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

7.2657Joint IEEE and ACM

7.0635American Institute of Physics

6.6607RELX Group (Elsevier)

6.0548SID-Society for Information Display

2.8259ACS-Am Chem Soc

2.0181IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

1.8165INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.7156John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.6149IBM Corp.

1.5135SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.3122Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.3118IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.1100Optical Society of America

1.095IET/IEE

201 others with less than 1% each 1413 13.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-11Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 49: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft34.912868IEEE

10.83966RELX Group (Elsevier)

6.62437John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

4.31570SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

3.01121Joint IEEE and ACM

2.6941Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

2.3855American Institute of Physics

2.3863ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

1.3488ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.0385Radiological Society of North America

1.0359Society of Magnetic Resonance in Medicine (SMRM)

1.0358Natl Acad Sciences

617 others with less than 1% each 10628 24.2

Sony Corp43.712352IEEE

8.42372ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

4.91380RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.111633GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body

2.7765SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.3643International Telecommunication Union

2.2616American Institute of Physics

1.5431Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.4405John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.4398Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.3373IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

1.2327IET/IEE

1.2345Joint IEEE and ACM

1.2347ACS-Am Chem Soc

404 others with less than 1% each 6339 18.9

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co.

36.28351IEEE

28.36531American Institute of Physics

9.32146RELX Group (Elsevier)

3.6827Electrochemical Society, Inc.

3.3757IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

2.6589INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

2.4542SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

1.8418John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

1.4329Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.1253IET/IEE

1.1250MRS-Materials Research Soc

139 others with less than 1% each 2050 7.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-12Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 50: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

# Pat Refs to:Publisher Percent of Total

Appendix A - Publishers Receiving Most References from Top 30 Companies

(Top 30 Companies in terms of 2017 Patent Activity; References from 1997-2017 Patents)

Toshiba Corp39.28967IEEE

7.71760American Institute of Physics

6.31432RELX Group (Elsevier)

4.0915IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys

3.1720John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

2.4560IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng

2.4556ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

2.3524SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering

2.0450INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS

1.6355Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force

1.5335International Telecommunication Union

1.5343Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

1.4314Am Physical Soc

1.3308American Physical Society

1.3299AACS-Advanced Access Content System

1.3288ACS-Am Chem Soc

1.1259Joint IEEE and ACM

1.0235IET/IEE

1.0238Japan Society of Applied Physics

395 others with less than 1% each 4010 13.5

Toyota Motor Corp19.91490RELX Group (Elsevier)

17.01270IEEE

6.3473ACS-Am Chem Soc

6.1456John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss

4.2316American Society of Plant Biologists

4.2317Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad

3.4254SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers

3.4253American Institute of Physics

2.5184AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci

2.4182Natl Acad Sciences

2.0147Optical Society of America

1.8132Electrochemical Society, Inc.

1.6121Nature Publishing Group

1.6117American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Inc.

1.4108American SocIETy for Microbiology

1.397Oxford Univ Press

1.289Royal Society of Chemistry

1.186National Institutes of Health - NIH

1.184ACM-Assoc Comput Mach

239 others with less than 1% each 1305 15.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 A-13Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 51: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

AI/Artificial Intelligence1 Microsoft Corporation 1635IEEE1635 4486 1281ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.4 36.4 28.62 International Business Machi 1239IEEE1239 3699 531ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.5 33.5 14.43 Google Inc. 972IEEE972 2373 337ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.0 41.0 14.24 Brain Corporation 861IEEE861 2156 383MIT Press39.9 39.9 17.85 HRL Laboratories LLC 574IEEE574 1229 116RELX Group (Elsevier)46.7 46.7 9.46 NUMENTA INC 806Numenta Inc.570 2244 570IEEE25.4 35.9 25.47 Qualcomm Inc 391IEEE391 1039 86MIT Press37.6 37.6 8.38 Apple Inc 264IEEE264 618 136ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.7 42.7 22.09 Xerox Corp 214IEEE214 698 101ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.7 30.7 14.5

10 Columbia University 211IEEE211 553 50ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.2 38.2 9.011 Cortica Ltd 186IEEE186 258 23ACM-Assoc Comput Mach72.1 72.1 8.912 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 167IEEE167 443 45RELX Group (Elsevier)37.7 37.7 10.213 Fujitsu Limited 153IEEE153 351 79Joint IEEE and ACM43.6 43.6 22.514 Giant Grey Inc (formerly BR 133IEEE133 155 17International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)85.8 85.8 11.015 ICOSYSTEM CORP 125IEEE125 171 10RELX Group (Elsevier)73.1 73.1 5.816 Sony Corp 119IEEE119 271 30ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.9 43.9 11.117 NEC Corp 98IEEE98 278 28ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.3 35.3 10.118 General Electric Company 95IEEE95 240 38RELX Group (Elsevier)39.6 39.6 15.819 United States Navy 94IEEE94 179 30RELX Group (Elsevier)52.5 52.5 16.820 AT&T Inc 92IEEE92 280 83ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.9 32.9 29.621 FireEye Inc 87IEEE87 226 41The USENIX Association38.5 38.5 18.122 Raytheon Co. 87IEEE87 191 19SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering45.5 45.5 9.923 SAS Institute 87IEEE87 284 47RELX Group (Elsevier)30.6 30.6 16.524 eBay Inc 83IEEE83 95 5Joint IEEE and ACM87.4 87.4 5.325 Boeing Co. (The) 82IEEE82 234 42RELX Group (Elsevier)35.0 35.0 17.926 Lockheed Martin Corp. 81IEEE81 116 11RELX Group (Elsevier)69.8 69.8 9.527 Massachusetts Institute of Te 81IEEE81 300 29RELX Group (Elsevier)27.0 27.0 9.728 ALOFT MEDIA LLC 79IEEE79 147 24Institute for Operations Research and the Management Science53.7 53.7 16.329 Amazon.com Inc. 79IEEE79 206 47ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.3 38.3 22.830 Nuance Communications Inc 79IEEE79 173 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.7 45.7 13.931 Oracle Corporation 79IEEE79 313 74ACM-Assoc Comput Mach25.2 25.2 23.632 HP Inc 76IEEE76 271 62ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28.0 28.0 22.933 Accenture Ltd. 75IEEE75 337 65ACM-Assoc Comput Mach22.3 22.3 19.334 BLANDING HOVENWEEP 75IEEE75 214 41SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering35.0 35.0 19.235 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 74IEEE74 159 20ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.5 46.5 12.636 Verizon Communications Inc 154ACM-Assoc Comput Mach73 393 73IEEE18.6 39.2 18.637 WORLD ASSETS CONSUL 71IEEE71 142 18ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.0 50.0 12.738 University of Alabama 70IEEE70 89 9RELX Group (Elsevier)78.7 78.7 10.139 Adobe Systems Inc. 69IEEE69 140 35ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.3 49.3 25.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-1Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 52: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 EXEGY INC 65IEEE65 137 26ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.4 47.4 19.041 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 65IEEE65 143 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.5 45.5 17.542 PRIMAL FUSION INC 64IEEE64 131 23ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.9 48.9 17.643 Cavium Inc 63IEEE63 106 32ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.4 59.4 30.244 University of Illinois 61IEEE61 194 23Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad31.4 31.4 11.945 University of Tennessee 61IEEE61 128 18RELX Group (Elsevier)47.7 47.7 14.146 Causam Energy Inc 59IEEE59 66 3RELX Group (Elsevier)89.4 89.4 4.547 Sap SE 59IEEE59 193 40ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.6 30.6 20.748 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 58IEEE58 148 18RELX Group (Elsevier)39.2 39.2 12.249 KNOWMTECH LLC 58American Institute of Physics57 227 57IEEE25.1 25.6 25.150 Zebra Technologies Corp. 57IEEE57 76 12RFID Journal/YGS Group75.0 75.0 15.851 Cisco Systems Inc. 56IEEE56 85 8ACM-Assoc Comput Mach65.9 65.9 9.452 Intel Corporation 55IEEE55 124 16ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.4 44.4 12.953 ConvergeOne Inc 54IEEE54 123 19ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.9 43.9 15.454 University of California 134RELX Group (Elsevier)54 880 115Oxford University Press6.1 15.2 13.155 Rethink Robotics Inc 51IEEE51 80 12RELX Group (Elsevier)63.8 63.8 15.056 SOCIETE DE COMMERCIA 51IEEE51 137 22RELX Group (Elsevier)37.2 37.2 16.157 Commissariat A L'Energie At 49IEEE49 63 5RELX Group (Elsevier)77.8 77.8 7.958 United States of America De 48IEEE48 120 15ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics40.0 40.0 12.559 Rockwell Automation Inc 47IEEE47 101 17RELX Group (Elsevier)46.5 46.5 16.860 Cornell University 63RELX Group (Elsevier)46 404 46IEEE11.4 15.6 11.461 Aerospace Corp. 75RELX Group (Elsevier)45 182 45IEEE24.7 41.2 24.762 Nokia Corp 45IEEE45 116 28ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.8 38.8 24.163 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 43IEEE43 90 5International Speech Communication Association (ISCA)47.8 47.8 5.664 Nevada System of Higher Ed 43IEEE43 73 12RELX Group (Elsevier)58.9 58.9 16.465 California Institute of Techno 42IEEE42 163 16RELX Group (Elsevier)25.8 25.8 9.866 Micron Technology Inc. 42IEEE42 66 4ACL - Association for Computational Linguistics63.6 63.6 6.167 Symantec Corp. 42IEEE42 166 39ACM-Assoc Comput Mach25.3 25.3 23.568 Toyota Motor Corp 42IEEE42 66 6RELX Group (Elsevier)63.6 63.6 9.169 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 41IEEE41 65 4ACM-Assoc Comput Mach63.1 63.1 6.270 PEGASYSTEMS INC 40IEEE40 82 15ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.8 48.8 18.371 Walt Disney Co. 40IEEE40 61 4RELX Group (Elsevier)65.6 65.6 6.672 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 49Society of Petroleum Engineers37 132 37IEEE28.0 37.1 28.073 IP RESERVOIR LLC 35IEEE35 71 12ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.3 49.3 16.974 University of Notre Dame Du 35IEEE35 40 2John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss87.5 87.5 5.075 Analog Devices Inc. 34IEEE34 49 4Neural Information Processing Systems Foundation69.4 69.4 8.276 Dell Technologies Inc 34IEEE34 92 21ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.0 37.0 22.877 Health Discovery Corp 34IEEE34 158 13RELX Group (Elsevier)21.5 21.5 8.278 Avigilon Corp 33IEEE33 36 3International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)91.7 91.7 8.379 Canon Inc 33IEEE33 89 11RELX Group (Elsevier)37.1 37.1 12.480 FTI Consulting Inc 50ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33 153 33IEEE21.6 32.7 21.6

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-2Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 53: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Knowles Corp 33IEEE33 49 4RELX Group (Elsevier)67.3 67.3 8.282 BAE Systems Plc. 31IEEE31 58 5ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.4 53.4 8.683 Seiko Epson Corporation 31IEEE31 55 4Neural Information Processing Systems Foundation56.4 56.4 7.384 EUCLID DISCOVERIES LL 30IEEE30 64 19RELX Group (Elsevier)46.9 46.9 29.785 Khalifa University of Science 30IEEE30 49 6Computers in Cardiology, Inc.61.2 61.2 12.286 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 30IEEE30 81 14RELX Group (Elsevier)37.0 37.0 17.387 Honeywell International Inc. 33RELX Group (Elsevier)29 92 29IEEE31.5 35.9 31.588 PELMOREX CANADA INC 47IEE/IEEE29 96 29IEEE30.2 49.0 30.289 23ANDME INC 28IEEE28 66 8John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss42.4 42.4 12.190 Arizona State University 28IEEE28 50 4SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering56.0 56.0 8.091 BRAINGATE CO LLC 28IEEE28 72 9RELX Group (Elsevier)38.9 38.9 12.592 Georgia Institute of Technolo 28IEEE28 63 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.4 44.4 38.193 Hitachi Ltd 28IEEE28 48 8Information Processing Society of Japan58.3 58.3 16.794 Battelle Memorial Institute 27IEEE27 59 5Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad45.8 45.8 8.595 BRIAN CORP 27IEEE27 53 9MIT Press50.9 50.9 17.096 Brooks Automation Inc. 27IEEE27 48 8Chapman & Hall56.3 56.3 16.797 Electronics and Telecommuni 27IEEE27 44 4Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad61.4 61.4 9.198 Math Works Inc (The) 27IEEE27 56 6RELX Group (Elsevier)48.2 48.2 10.799 University of Southern Califo 68ACL - Association for Computational Linguist27 160 27IEEE16.9 42.5 16.9

100 MANYWORLDS INC 26IEEE26 27 1Joint IEEE and ACM96.3 96.3 3.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-3Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 54: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Autonomous Vehicles1 Irobot Corp 1301IEEE1301 2061 221SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering63.1 63.1 10.72 ZOOX INC 142IEEE142 198 20SAGE Publications71.7 71.7 10.13 Brain Corporation 94IEEE94 202 19MIT Press46.5 46.5 9.44 Google Inc. 51IEEE51 106 11ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.1 48.1 10.45 California Institute of Techno 33IEEE33 78 6IOP Publishing42.3 42.3 7.76 SZ DJI Technology Co Ltd 33IEEE33 56 5Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence58.9 58.9 8.97 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 32IEEE32 80 6Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad40.0 40.0 7.58 WAYMO LLC 29IEEE29 42 3Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA)69.0 69.0 7.19 Deere & Co. 24IEEE24 44 3AMER SOC AGRICULTURAL & BIOLOGICAL ENGINEER54.5 54.5 6.8

10 NUTONOMY INC 23IEEE23 37 4RELX Group (Elsevier)62.2 62.2 10.811 Oshkosh Corporation 23IEEE23 30 2SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers76.7 76.7 6.712 Digimarc Corp. 21IEEE21 41 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.2 51.2 14.613 NONEND INVENTIONS N 20IEEE20 21 1The International Association for Computers and Communicat95.2 95.2 4.814 SPHERO INC 20IEEE20 21 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC)95.2 95.2 4.815 Battelle Memorial Institute 18IEEE18 24 4IEEE/RSJ75.0 75.0 16.716 Toyota Motor Corp 18IEEE18 27 4Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad66.7 66.7 14.817 Intel Corporation 17IEEE17 25 2JOURNAL OF CENTRAL SOUTH UNIV TECHNOLOGY, E68.0 68.0 8.018 International Business Machi 21IP.Com17 106 17IEEE16.0 19.8 16.019 BRIAN CORP 14IEEE14 17 3MIT Press82.4 82.4 17.620 Ford Motor Co. 13IEEE13 27 3IET/IEE48.1 48.1 11.121 ZYTEK COMMUNICATIO 12IEEE12 44 6COMPANY OF BIOLOGISTS LTD27.3 27.3 13.622 Amazon.com Inc. 9IEEE9 9 100.0 100.023 PERRONE ROBOTICS INC 8IEEE8 12 2IEEE/RSJ66.7 66.7 16.724 King Fahd University of Petr 7IEEE7 9 1Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad77.8 77.8 11.125 Raytheon Co. 7IEEE7 18 3RELX Group (Elsevier)38.9 38.9 16.726 AUTONOMOUS SOLUTIO 6IEEE6 12 3American Automatic Control Council (AACC)50.0 50.0 25.027 Lockheed Martin Corp. 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.028 Porsche Automobil Holding 6IEEE6 7 1ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng85.7 85.7 14.329 Commonwealth Scientific an 5IEEE5 9 1IET/IEE55.6 55.6 11.130 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 5IEEE5 7 1Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad71.4 71.4 14.331 Walmart Stores Inc 5IEEE5 14 1Cambridge University Press35.7 35.7 7.132 Walt Disney Co. 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.033 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 4IEEE4 7 1SAGE PUBLICATIONS INC57.1 57.1 14.334 Crown Equipment Corporatio 4IEEE4 8 2IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng50.0 50.0 25.035 FedEx Corp 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.036 General Motors Corp 4IEEE4 11 2RELX Group (Elsevier)36.4 36.4 18.237 OPTIMAL RANGING INC 4IEEE4 6 2RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 33.338 SZ DJ TECHNOLOGY CO L 4IEEE4 7 1SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.1 57.1 14.339 Uber Technologies Inc 4IEEE4 6 2RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 33.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-4Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 55: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Boeing Co. (The) 4AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro3 15 3IEEE20.0 26.7 20.041 BYTELIGHT INC 3IEEE3 4 1Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad75.0 75.0 25.042 Carnegie Mellon University 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.043 EPISYS SCIENCE INC 3IEEE3 6 2MIT Press50.0 50.0 33.344 FTS ComputerTechnik 3IEEE3 4 1ACM-Assoc Comput Mach75.0 75.0 25.045 International Electronic Mach 3IEEE3 5 1SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering60.0 60.0 20.046 Lenovo Group Ltd 3IEEE3 5 1ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.0 60.0 20.047 Omron Corp. 4RELX Group (Elsevier)3 11 3IEEE27.3 36.4 27.348 United States Navy 3IEEE3 9 1RELX Group (Elsevier)33.3 33.3 11.149 XOLLAI INC 3IEEE3 7 2Society of Instrument and Control Engineers42.9 42.9 28.650 Agency for Defense Develop 2IEEE2 4 1SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering50.0 50.0 25.051 Allstate Corp 4ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2 6 2IEEE33.3 66.7 33.352 BAE Systems Plc. 2IEEE2 5 2IEEE/RSJ40.0 40.0 40.053 DRONOMY LTD 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.054 GoPro Inc 2IEEE2 5 1Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad40.0 40.0 20.055 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 2IEEE2 4 2RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 50.056 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 3RELX Group (Elsevier)2 8 2IEEE25.0 37.5 25.057 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.058 Massachusetts Institute of Te 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.059 MASSIVE ANALYTIC LTD 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.060 Microsoft Corporation 2IEEE2 4 1IET/IEE50.0 50.0 25.061 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 2IEEE2 3 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC)66.7 66.7 33.362 National Chiao Tung Univers 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.063 Renault SA 2IEEE2 3 1Cambridge University Press66.7 66.7 33.364 ROBART GMBH 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.065 State Farm Mutual Automobi 2IEEE/RSJ2 10 2InnoVision Communications20.0 20.0 20.066 University of Sydney 2IEEE2 3 1SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering66.7 66.7 33.367 X Development Llc 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.068 ZEROTECH (SHENZHEN) I 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.069 ANKI INC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.070 ASTER LABS INC 1IEEE1 2 1ION-The Inst of Navigation50.0 50.0 50.071 AZURE SKY GROUP LLC 1AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.072 Caterpillar Inc. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.073 CENTER OF HUMAN-CEN 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.074 CNH Industrial NV 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.075 Continental AG (Germany Fe 2RELX Group (Elsevier)1 3 1IEEE33.3 66.7 33.376 ConvergeOne Inc 1ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1 3 1Joint IEEE and ACM33.3 33.3 33.377 Electronics and Telecommuni 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.078 FLORIDA A & M UNIVERS 1IEEE1 2 1IET/IEE50.0 50.0 50.079 GENGHISCOMM HOLDIN 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.080 GMV AEROSPACE & DEF 2ION-The Inst of Navigation1 4 1Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force25.0 50.0 25.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-5Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 56: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Honeywell International Inc. 4ION-The Inst of Navigation1 5 1IEEE20.0 80.0 20.082 Hong Kong University of Sci 1Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (1 5 1Lucent Technologies20.0 20.0 20.083 L-3 Communications Holdin 1NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admi1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.084 Lely Group 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.085 Murata Machinery Ltd. 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC1 5 1RELX Group (Elsevier)20.0 20.0 20.086 Northrop Grumman Corp 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.087 Panasonic Corporation 1Am Physical Soc1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.088 PROXY TECHNOLOGIES I 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.089 Saab AB 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.090 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.091 Sony Corp 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.092 UNMANNED INNOVATIO 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.093 XCRAFT ENTERPRISES LL 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-6Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 57: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Broadcasting1 Microsoft Corporation 8625IEEE8625 18104 2151ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.6 47.6 11.92 Personalized Media Commun 14093Society of Motion Picture and Television Engi7673 47847 7673IEEE16.0 29.5 16.03 Qualcomm Inc 5691International Telecommunication Union3929 15322 3929IEEE25.6 37.1 25.64 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 3299IEEE3299 5924 599SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.7 55.7 10.15 Sony Corp 3200IEEE3200 6797 562ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.1 47.1 8.36 Google Inc. 3012IEEE3012 8325 1108ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.2 36.2 13.37 Pelican Imaging Corporation 2428IEEE2428 5027 804SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering48.3 48.3 16.08 Apple Inc 2154IEEE2154 5303 495ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.6 40.6 9.39 TiVo Corp 2048IEEE2048 7714 583ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.5 26.5 7.6

10 Technicolor SA 1866IEEE1866 4055 357ISO/IEC46.0 46.0 8.811 Broadcom Ltd 1808IEEE1808 2827 167ACM-Assoc Comput Mach64.0 64.0 5.912 Magna International Inc. 1784IEEE1784 3065 225SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers58.2 58.2 7.313 Cisco Systems Inc. 1677IEEE1677 4136 305Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force40.5 40.5 7.414 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 1668IEEE1668 4522 1003International Telecommunication Union36.9 36.9 22.215 LG Electronics Inc. 1582IEEE1582 6061 1182ISO/IEC/JTC/ANSI26.1 26.1 19.516 Panasonic Corporation 1512IEEE1512 4826 1227International Telecommunication Union31.3 31.3 25.417 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 1248IEEE1248 3454 523International Telecommunication Union36.1 36.1 15.118 Dolby Laboratories Inc 1145IEEE1145 3554 743International Telecommunication Union32.2 32.2 20.919 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 1123IEEE1123 2326 233MPEG.org48.3 48.3 10.020 Adobe Systems Inc. 1087IEEE1087 2283 485ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.6 47.6 21.221 Nokia Corp 988IEEE988 2356 204International Telecommunication Union41.9 41.9 8.722 AT&T Inc 891IEEE891 2317 207ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.5 38.5 8.923 Intel Corporation 875IEEE875 2015 3903GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body43.4 43.4 19.424 Massachusetts Institute of Te 857IEEE857 1393 140ACM-Assoc Comput Mach61.5 61.5 10.125 Canon Inc 838IEEE838 2111 161International Telecommunication Union39.7 39.7 7.626 International Business Machi 823IEEE823 2154 314ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.2 38.2 14.627 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 753IEEE753 1437 161Elettronica e Telecomunicazioni52.4 52.4 11.228 HP Inc 701IEEE701 1490 174ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.0 47.0 11.729 STMicroelectronics 691IEEE691 1036 52RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 5.030 InterDigital Inc 678IEEE678 1356 4123GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body50.0 50.0 30.431 California Institute of Techno 669IEEE669 1155 110SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.9 57.9 9.532 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 579IEEE579 1224 157ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.3 47.3 12.833 NETWORK-1 TECHNOLO 506IEEE506 1289 337ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.3 39.3 26.134 Xerox Corp 504IEEE504 1237 187SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering40.7 40.7 15.135 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 477IEEE477 1069 99ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.6 44.6 9.336 Huawei Technologies Compa 556International Telecommunication Union469 1627 469IEEE28.8 34.2 28.837 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 468IEEE468 970 52Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad48.2 48.2 5.438 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 466IEEE466 971 90SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering48.0 48.0 9.339 ARRIS Group Inc 461IEEE461 1045 52International Telecommunication Union44.1 44.1 5.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-7Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 58: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Sonos Inc 460IEEE460 1082 137SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering42.5 42.5 12.741 Columbia University 454IEEE454 793 100ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.3 57.3 12.642 Digimarc Corp. 451IEEE451 1062 165SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering42.5 42.5 15.543 Blackberry Ltd. 444IEEE444 930 1373GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body47.7 47.7 14.744 PixelWorks Inc 432IEEE432 651 61SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering66.4 66.4 9.445 Toshiba Corp 431IEEE431 1143 226International Telecommunication Union37.7 37.7 19.846 Wisteria Trading Inc 427IEEE427 858 98SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.8 49.8 11.447 Verance Corp 410IEEE410 783 102SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering52.4 52.4 13.048 ACACIA MEDIA TECHNO 406IEEE406 736 66ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.2 55.2 9.049 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 379IEEE379 983 152International Telecommunication Union38.6 38.6 15.550 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 361IEEE361 1081 237ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.4 33.4 21.951 Honeywell International Inc. 348IEEE348 706 82SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.3 49.3 11.652 Marvell Technology Group Lt 340IEEE340 413 8SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering82.3 82.3 1.953 Hitachi Ltd 319IEEE319 1032 88ISO-International Standards Organization30.9 30.9 8.554 NEC Corp 316IEEE316 674 42IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng46.9 46.9 6.255 Nant Holdings IP Llc 329ACM-Assoc Comput Mach315 1116 315IEEE28.2 29.5 28.256 Industrial Techology Researc 309IEEE309 473 35SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering65.3 65.3 7.457 Ericsson 300IEEE300 1049 138International Telecommunication Union28.6 28.6 13.258 On Semiconductor Corporati 290IEEE290 415 42SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering69.9 69.9 10.159 EchoStar Corp 285IEEE285 575 52RELX Group (Elsevier)49.6 49.6 9.060 Raytheon Co. 270IEEE270 473 53SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.1 57.1 11.261 Texas Instruments Inc 346International Telecommunication Union268 791 268IEEE33.9 43.7 33.962 Electronics and Telecommuni 265IEEE265 772 235International Telecommunication Union34.3 34.3 30.463 Eastman Kodak Company 263IEEE263 774 91SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering34.0 34.0 11.864 Nielsen Holdings Plc 253IEEE253 1353 183RELX Group (Elsevier)18.7 18.7 13.565 Cortica Ltd 249IEEE249 330 31ACM-Assoc Comput Mach75.5 75.5 9.466 BT Group PLC 246IEEE246 448 37RELX Group (Elsevier)54.9 54.9 8.367 Micron Technology Inc. 241IEEE241 416 55SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.9 57.9 13.268 CONVERGENT MEDIA SO 257ACM-Assoc Comput Mach240 930 240IEEE25.8 27.6 25.869 Avid Technology Inc. 236IEEE236 546 174ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.2 43.2 31.970 Semiconductor Energy Labor 796SID-Society for Information Display235 2393 358American Institute of Physics9.8 33.3 15.071 ECOLE DE TECHBOLOGIE 234IEEE234 363 403GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body64.5 64.5 11.072 NVIDIA Corp. 234IEEE234 534 96ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.8 43.8 18.073 Sigma Corp 232IEEE232 292 40SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering79.5 79.5 13.774 Walt Disney Co. 247ACM-Assoc Comput Mach230 668 230IEEE34.4 37.0 34.475 BLACK HILLS MEDIA LLC 513Open Connectivity Foundation224 998 224IEEE22.4 51.4 22.476 INTERVAL RESEARCH CO 219IEEE219 435 29ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.3 50.3 6.777 EUCLID DISCOVERIES LL 216IEEE216 424 100RELX Group (Elsevier)50.9 50.9 23.678 Seiko Epson Corporation 216IEEE216 432 35ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.0 50.0 8.179 University of California 216IEEE216 423 31ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.1 51.1 7.380 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 212IEEE212 489 36RELX Group (Elsevier)43.4 43.4 7.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-8Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 59: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Omnivision Technologies Inc 207IEEE207 360 62SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.5 57.5 17.282 Fujitsu Limited 204IEEE204 609 89International Telecommunication Union33.5 33.5 14.683 Stanford University 203IEEE203 529 106ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.4 38.4 20.084 United States Navy 195IEEE195 406 58John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss48.0 48.0 14.385 Verizon Communications Inc 194IEEE194 568 63ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.2 34.2 11.186 IMAX Corp 193IEEE193 370 80SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering52.2 52.2 21.687 Intellectual Ventures Manage 190IEEE190 459 95ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.4 41.4 20.788 SRI International 189IEEE189 295 21RELX Group (Elsevier)64.1 64.1 7.189 Kofax Inc 188IEEE188 480 77ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.2 39.2 16.090 General Electric Company 175IEEE175 532 98International Telecommunication Union32.9 32.9 18.491 Amazon.com Inc. 174IEEE174 416 97ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.8 41.8 23.392 ARC DEVICES LTD 301ACM-Assoc Comput Mach174 643 174IEEE27.1 46.8 27.193 BE HERE CORP 173IEEE173 526 59ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.9 32.9 11.294 LIFESIZE COMMUNICATI 165IEEE165 362 105ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.6 45.6 29.095 Commscope Inc. 164IEEE164 264 16National Cable & Telecommunications Association62.1 62.1 6.196 Orange 159IEEE159 257 19SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering61.9 61.9 7.497 Comcast Corp 156IEEE156 592 154ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.4 26.4 26.098 Mediatek Inc. 154IEEE154 286 73International Telecommunication Union53.8 53.8 25.599 Alarm.com Holdings Inc 148IEEE148 227 12SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering65.2 65.2 5.3

100 NXP Semiconductors NV 146IEEE146 245 26International Telecommunication Union59.6 59.6 10.6

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-9Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 60: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Computer Hardware1 International Business Machi 15430IEEE15430 49652 12153ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.1 31.1 24.52 Microsoft Corporation 17800ACM-Assoc Comput Mach12922 48772 12922IEEE26.5 36.5 26.53 Intel Corporation 8611IEEE8611 17758 2231ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.5 48.5 12.64 Apple Inc 7596ACM-Assoc Comput Mach7230 23334 7230IEEE31.0 32.6 31.05 Oracle Corporation 6072ACM-Assoc Comput Mach4861 17345 4861IEEE28.0 35.0 28.06 Immersion Corp. 3870IEEE3870 10247 1143ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.8 37.8 11.27 Broadcom Ltd 3823IEEE3823 6361 427ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.1 60.1 6.78 Cadence Design Systems Inc 3673IEEE3673 9139 3230Joint IEEE and ACM40.2 40.2 35.39 Sony Corp 3182IEEE3182 7107 1005ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.8 44.8 14.1

10 Qualcomm Inc 3044IEEE3044 7239 490ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.1 42.1 6.811 Google Inc. 3274ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2850 10537 2850IEEE27.0 31.1 27.012 HP Inc 2715IEEE2715 8887 1801ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.6 30.6 20.313 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 2648IEEE2648 6898 739SID-Society for Information Display38.4 38.4 10.714 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 2484IEEE2484 5123 885ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.5 48.5 17.315 Nokia Corp 2398IEEE2398 5654 797ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.4 42.4 14.116 Canon Inc 2275IEEE2275 5922 568RELX Group (Elsevier)38.4 38.4 9.617 Fujitsu Limited 2099IEEE2099 5203 578ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.3 40.3 11.118 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1922IEEE1922 3980 525Joint IEEE and ACM48.3 48.3 13.219 MicroUnity Systems Enginee 1859IEEE1859 3018 267Joint IEEE and ACM61.6 61.6 8.820 Panasonic Corporation 1810IEEE1810 4326 286International Telecommunication Union41.8 41.8 6.621 Rambus Inc. 1580IEEE1580 2220 92IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys71.2 71.2 4.122 Personalized Media Commun 2931Society of Motion Picture and Television Engi1518 10044 1518IEEE15.1 29.2 15.123 NEC Corp 1492IEEE1492 3425 378ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.6 43.6 11.024 Xilinx Inc. 1417IEEE1417 2231 307Joint IEEE and ACM63.5 63.5 13.825 Synopsys Inc. 1416IEEE1416 3551 835Joint IEEE and ACM39.9 39.9 23.526 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 1385IEEE1385 3796 497Joint IEEE and ACM36.5 36.5 13.127 Seiko Epson Corporation 1377IEEE1377 3744 496Joint IEEE and ACM36.8 36.8 13.228 Cisco Systems Inc. 1344IEEE1344 4296 769Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force31.3 31.3 17.929 Toshiba Corp 1340IEEE1340 3098 231ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.3 43.3 7.530 Micron Technology Inc. 1308IEEE1308 2462 204ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.1 53.1 8.331 AT&T Inc 1281IEEE1281 3603 745ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.6 35.6 20.732 Honeywell International Inc. 1280IEEE1280 3506 265RELX Group (Elsevier)36.5 36.5 7.633 Hitachi Ltd 1240IEEE1240 4238 720ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.3 29.3 17.034 Texas Instruments Inc 1198IEEE1198 2199 145Joint IEEE and ACM54.5 54.5 6.635 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 1184IEEE1184 2004 192ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.1 59.1 9.636 Dell Technologies Inc 1199ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1170 3925 1170IEEE29.8 30.5 29.837 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 1148IEEE1148 1834 236Joint IEEE and ACM62.6 62.6 12.938 STMicroelectronics 1109IEEE1109 1917 97ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.9 57.9 5.139 Columbia University 1107IEEE1107 3953 859ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28.0 28.0 21.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-10Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 61: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Xerox Corp 1186ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1090 4467 1090IEEE24.4 26.6 24.441 Sap SE 1377ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1082 4155 1082IEEE26.0 33.1 26.042 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 1029IEEE1029 1570 109RELX Group (Elsevier)65.5 65.5 6.943 Commvault Systems Inc. 1005IEEE1005 1443 231ACM-Assoc Comput Mach69.6 69.6 16.044 Motorola Solutions Inc. 983IEEE983 1538 128ACM-Assoc Comput Mach63.9 63.9 8.345 Marvell Technology Group Lt 922IEEE922 1255 45ACM-Assoc Comput Mach73.5 73.5 3.646 Blackberry Ltd. 912IEEE912 2359 313ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.7 38.7 13.347 Ignis Innovation Inc 875IEEE875 1164 133SID-Society for Information Display75.2 75.2 11.448 Tabula Inc 873IEEE873 2330 864ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.5 37.5 37.149 Adobe Systems Inc. 1256ACM-Assoc Comput Mach829 2936 829IEEE28.2 42.8 28.250 SRC Computers Inc. 814IEEE814 911 30ACM-Assoc Comput Mach89.4 89.4 3.351 Semiconductor Energy Labor 3870SID-Society for Information Display813 10290 1555American Institute of Physics7.9 37.6 15.152 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 809IEEE809 3375 500SID-Society for Information Display24.0 24.0 14.853 Softbank Corp 793IEEE793 1602 217Joint IEEE and ACM49.5 49.5 13.554 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 787IEEE787 1648 252ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.8 47.8 15.355 Massachusetts Institute of Te 762IEEE762 1862 262ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.9 40.9 14.156 LG Electronics Inc. 728IEEE728 2319 340Audio Eng Soc31.4 31.4 14.757 Imagination Technologies Gr 710IEEE710 2311 436ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.7 30.7 18.958 Technicolor SA 706IEEE706 1331 104ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.0 53.0 7.859 IP RESERVOIR LLC 697IEEE697 1468 263ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.5 47.5 17.960 General Electric Company 690IEEE690 1887 178RELX Group (Elsevier)36.6 36.6 9.461 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 690IEEE690 1707 141RELX Group (Elsevier)40.4 40.4 8.362 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 689IEEE689 2032 482ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.9 33.9 23.763 Ericsson 640IEEE640 1872 2923GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body34.2 34.2 15.664 Verizon Communications Inc 802ACM-Assoc Comput Mach635 3118 635IEEE20.4 25.7 20.465 Netapp Inc 1202ACM-Assoc Comput Mach633 2962 633IEEE21.4 40.6 21.466 NXP Semiconductors NV 629IEEE629 1120 180Joint IEEE and ACM56.2 56.2 16.167 University of California 625IEEE625 3081 381RELX Group (Elsevier)20.3 20.3 12.468 NVIDIA Corp. 617IEEE617 1544 468ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.0 40.0 30.369 Brain Corporation 615IEEE615 1675 316MIT Press36.7 36.7 18.970 Tela Innovations inc 615IEEE615 1672 492SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering36.8 36.8 29.471 Conversant Intellectual Prope 598IEEE598 832 53Joint IEEE and ACM71.9 71.9 6.472 ConvergeOne Inc 594IEEE594 1773 578Joint IEEE and ACM33.5 33.5 32.673 National Instruments Corp. 588IEEE588 1101 131ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.4 53.4 11.974 Silverbrook Pty Ltd 587IEEE587 1483 292RELX Group (Elsevier)39.6 39.6 19.775 Irobot Corp 586IEEE586 1109 231SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering52.8 52.8 20.876 Western Digital Corp. 586IEEE586 1628 193ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.0 36.0 11.977 Citrix Systems Inc 560IEEE560 1743 267ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.1 32.1 15.378 CREATIVE KINGDOMS LL 537IEEE537 1630 447ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.9 32.9 27.479 Raytheon Co. 522IEEE522 1286 132ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.6 40.6 10.380 Amazon.com Inc. 711ACM-Assoc Comput Mach521 2101 521IEEE24.8 33.8 24.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-11Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 62: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Texas A&M University 521IEEE521 606 12IET/IEE86.0 86.0 2.082 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 519IEEE519 673 23RELX Group (Elsevier)77.1 77.1 3.483 Huawei Technologies Compa 498IEEE498 1825 2913GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body27.3 27.3 15.984 RPX Corp 498IEEE498 1284 148Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force38.8 38.8 11.585 ABB Ltd 491IEEE491 749 93IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium65.6 65.6 12.486 SRI International 481IEEE481 961 68ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.1 50.1 7.187 Math Works Inc (The) 478IEEE478 1105 262ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.3 43.3 23.788 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 475IEEE475 951 82Audio Eng Soc49.9 49.9 8.689 Digimarc Corp. 464IEEE464 1303 185ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.6 35.6 14.290 Industrial Techology Researc 463IEEE463 858 89ACM-Assoc Comput Mach54.0 54.0 10.491 Washington University in St. 460IEEE460 1114 122ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.3 41.3 11.092 InterDigital Inc 450IEEE450 1103 3153GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body40.8 40.8 28.693 HRL Laboratories LLC 444IEEE444 936 80ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.4 47.4 8.594 Symantec Corp. 437IEEE437 1715 375ACM-Assoc Comput Mach25.5 25.5 21.995 Electronics and Telecommuni 435IEEE435 945 104ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.0 46.0 11.096 EXEGY INC 416IEEE416 850 141ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.9 48.9 16.697 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 410IEEE410 2041 273RELX Group (Elsevier)20.1 20.1 13.498 TiVo Corp 401IEEE401 1686 213ACM-Assoc Comput Mach23.8 23.8 12.699 Hewlett Packard Enterprises 399IEEE399 1129 289ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.3 35.3 25.6

100 Lenovo Group Ltd 396IEEE396 833 111ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.5 47.5 13.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-12Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 63: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Computer Software1 Microsoft Corporation 25925IEEE25925 75731 20844ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.2 34.2 27.52 International Business Machi 14343IEEE14343 46035 10495ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.2 31.2 22.83 Apple Inc 9226IEEE9226 23587 4764ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.1 39.1 20.24 Google Inc. 6399IEEE6399 19321 5222ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.1 33.1 27.05 Oracle Corporation 4995ACM-Assoc Comput Mach3965 15145 3965IEEE26.2 33.0 26.26 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 3066IEEE3066 7404 902SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering41.4 41.4 12.27 Qualcomm Inc 2883IEEE2883 5744 306RELX Group (Elsevier)50.2 50.2 5.38 Intel Corporation 2666IEEE2666 5954 1212ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.8 44.8 20.49 Xerox Corp 2654IEEE2654 7786 1638ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.1 34.1 21.0

10 HP Inc 2617IEEE2617 6899 1470ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.9 37.9 21.311 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 2602IEEE2602 4407 280SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering59.0 59.0 6.412 Nokia Corp 2579IEEE2579 6125 609ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.1 42.1 9.913 Adobe Systems Inc. 2252IEEE2252 5576 1838ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.4 40.4 33.014 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 2186IEEE2186 4618 764ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.3 47.3 16.515 AT&T Inc 2165IEEE2165 5512 732ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.3 39.3 13.316 Sap SE 3178ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1836 8781 1836IEEE20.9 36.2 20.917 Cadence Design Systems Inc 1835IEEE1835 3821 1081Joint IEEE and ACM48.0 48.0 28.318 Broadcom Ltd 1830IEEE1830 3528 458Joint IEEE and ACM51.9 51.9 13.019 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1808IEEE1808 5703 588RELX Group (Elsevier)31.7 31.7 10.320 Dolby Laboratories Inc 1767IEEE1767 3262 619Audio Eng Soc54.2 54.2 19.021 Digimarc Corp. 1740IEEE1740 4384 594SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering39.7 39.7 13.522 Sony Corp 1688IEEE1688 3444 543ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.0 49.0 15.823 Cognex Corp. 1670IEEE1670 3791 705RELX Group (Elsevier)44.1 44.1 18.624 Synopsys Inc. 1555IEEE1555 5146 1268SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering30.2 30.2 24.625 Cisco Systems Inc. 1440IEEE1440 5323 988Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force27.1 27.1 18.626 NEC Corp 1433IEEE1433 3181 397ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.0 45.0 12.527 Irobot Corp 1430IEEE1430 2449 375SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering58.4 58.4 15.328 Verizon Communications Inc 1613ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1342 6946 1342IEEE19.3 23.2 19.329 General Electric Company 1313IEEE1313 3201 307RELX Group (Elsevier)41.0 41.0 9.630 Applied Materials Inc. 1266IEEE1266 2179 128American Institute of Physics58.1 58.1 5.931 Amazon.com Inc. 1737ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1245 6018 1245IEEE20.7 28.9 20.732 Accenture Ltd. 1192IEEE1192 3592 574ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.2 33.2 16.033 Nuance Communications Inc 1153IEEE1153 3028 333ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)38.1 38.1 11.034 Blackberry Ltd. 1143IEEE1143 3072 288ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.2 37.2 9.435 Honeywell International Inc. 1141IEEE1141 2172 179RELX Group (Elsevier)52.5 52.5 8.236 Commvault Systems Inc. 1139IEEE1139 1608 251ACM-Assoc Comput Mach70.8 70.8 15.637 PHOENIX SOLUTIONS INC 1070IEEE1070 3168 422ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)33.8 33.8 13.338 HRL Laboratories LLC 1038IEEE1038 2183 226RELX Group (Elsevier)47.5 47.5 10.439 Raytheon Co. 1002IEEE1002 1970 154SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering50.9 50.9 7.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-13Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 64: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 MicroUnity Systems Enginee 941IEEE941 1507 140Joint IEEE and ACM62.4 62.4 9.341 LG Electronics Inc. 898IEEE898 1896 139Audio Eng Soc47.4 47.4 7.342 Canon Inc 885IEEE885 2151 223ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.1 41.1 10.443 Panasonic Corporation 861IEEE861 1706 109ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.5 50.5 6.444 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 854IEEE854 1840 221RELX Group (Elsevier)46.4 46.4 12.045 Ericsson 848IEEE848 2498 3183GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body33.9 33.9 12.746 STMicroelectronics 836IEEE836 1336 75RELX Group (Elsevier)62.6 62.6 5.647 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 822IEEE822 1774 153ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.3 46.3 8.648 NVIDIA Corp. 1095ACM-Assoc Comput Mach820 2891 820IEEE28.4 37.9 28.449 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 795IEEE795 1701 351ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.7 46.7 20.650 ParkerVision Inc 792IEEE792 1710 488IET/IEE46.3 46.3 28.551 Motorola Solutions Inc. 770IEEE770 1076 38Joint IEEE and ACM71.6 71.6 3.552 Magna International Inc. 748IEEE748 1243 77SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers60.2 60.2 6.253 eBay Inc 747IEEE747 4239 502ACM-Assoc Comput Mach17.6 17.6 11.854 Dell Technologies Inc 1009ACM-Assoc Comput Mach737 2851 737IEEE25.9 35.4 25.955 Walt Disney Co. 1677ACM-Assoc Comput Mach729 3146 729IEEE23.2 53.3 23.256 Fujitsu Limited 726IEEE726 1836 326Joint IEEE and ACM39.5 39.5 17.857 Pelican Imaging Corporation 703IEEE703 1524 266SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering46.1 46.1 17.558 Texas Instruments Inc 679IEEE679 990 47Joint IEEE and ACM68.6 68.6 4.759 Hewlett Packard Enterprises 677IEEE677 2120 589ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.9 31.9 27.860 BT Group PLC 675IEEE675 1399 114ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.2 48.2 8.161 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 669IEEE669 1398 138ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.9 47.9 9.962 Columbia University 666IEEE666 1959 314ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.0 34.0 16.063 Boeing Co. (The) 657IEEE657 1855 231RELX Group (Elsevier)35.4 35.4 12.564 Eastman Kodak Company 651IEEE651 1475 150RELX Group (Elsevier)44.1 44.1 10.265 Facebook Inc 747ACM-Assoc Comput Mach648 2620 648IEEE24.7 28.5 24.766 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 630IEEE630 1086 71SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 58.0 58.0 6.567 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 618IEEE618 1360 240ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.4 45.4 17.668 Tela Innovations inc 697SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering615 1973 615IEEE31.2 35.3 31.269 Hitachi Ltd 597IEEE597 2451 413ACM-Assoc Comput Mach24.4 24.4 16.970 Technicolor SA 587IEEE587 1192 113SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.2 49.2 9.571 Massachusetts Institute of Te 582IEEE582 2443 282ACM-Assoc Comput Mach23.8 23.8 11.572 Seiko Epson Corporation 558IEEE558 1081 120ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.6 51.6 11.173 Citrix Systems Inc 547IEEE547 1755 310ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.2 31.2 17.774 Intellectual Ventures Manage 535IEEE535 1269 197ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.2 42.2 15.575 Level 3 Communications 644ACM-Assoc Comput Mach528 2304 528IEEE22.9 28.0 22.976 Xilinx Inc. 526IEEE526 810 134Joint IEEE and ACM64.9 64.9 16.577 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 525IEEE525 1153 157Audio Eng Soc45.5 45.5 13.678 Lockheed Martin Corp. 522IEEE522 1151 118RELX Group (Elsevier)45.4 45.4 10.379 University of California 518IEEE518 3951 500RELX Group (Elsevier)13.1 13.1 12.780 NOMADIX INC 487IEEE487 1904 305Network Working Group RFC25.6 25.6 16.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-14Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 65: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Nant Holdings IP Llc 472IEEE472 1591 459ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.7 29.7 28.882 Toshiba Corp 471IEEE471 1155 123ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.8 40.8 10.683 United States Navy 466IEEE466 946 72SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.3 49.3 7.684 Georgia Institute of Technolo 456IEEE456 619 44ACM-Assoc Comput Mach73.7 73.7 7.185 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 452IEEE452 1942 270ACM-Assoc Comput Mach23.3 23.3 13.986 Battelle Memorial Institute 423IEEE423 637 61RELX Group (Elsevier)66.4 66.4 9.687 Math Works Inc (The) 423IEEE423 938 186ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.1 45.1 19.888 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 422IEEE422 3389 353Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad12.5 12.5 10.489 Harris Corp. 413IEEE413 714 74Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force57.8 57.8 10.490 Netapp Inc 1455ACM-Assoc Comput Mach410 3060 532The USENIX Association13.4 47.5 17.491 JPMorgan 916Source Media407 4426 419ACS-Am Chem Soc9.2 20.7 9.592 TiVo Corp 399IEEE399 1447 226ACM-Assoc Comput Mach27.6 27.6 15.693 AVISTAR COMMUNICATI 386IEEE386 763 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.6 50.6 29.994 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 384IEEE384 800 40RELX Group (Elsevier)48.0 48.0 5.095 VirnetX Holding Corp 2794Network Working Group RFC382 5910 1176Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force6.5 47.3 19.996 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 376IEEE376 653 65Joint IEEE and ACM57.6 57.6 10.097 Marvell Technology Group Lt 364IEEE364 449 16Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force81.1 81.1 3.698 RPX Corp 364IEEE364 1231 174Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force29.6 29.6 14.199 Verance Corp 364IEEE364 643 78SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering56.6 56.6 12.1

100 NUMENTA INC 523Numenta Inc.359 1483 359IEEE24.2 35.3 24.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-15Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 66: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Diagnosis/Surgery/Medical Instruments1 Medtronic Inc 20136RELX Group (Elsevier)9393 1E+05 15099Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.7.9 16.8 12.62 Boston Scientific Corp. 19530RELX Group (Elsevier)4076 69146 7106John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.9 28.2 10.33 Dexcom Inc 16490RELX Group (Elsevier)3922 64508 6764American Diabetes Association6.1 25.6 10.54 Abbott Laboratories 17979RELX Group (Elsevier)3283 73721 7445ACS-Am Chem Soc4.5 24.4 10.15 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 2467IEEE2467 5318 301SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 46.4 46.4 5.76 The Invention Science Fund 1597IEEE1597 10747 1245RELX Group (Elsevier)14.9 14.9 11.67 Partners HealthCare Systems 5420Optical Society of America1563 20587 3177RELX Group (Elsevier)7.6 26.3 15.48 Johnson & Johnson 7711RELX Group (Elsevier)1550 37318 3446John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss4.2 20.7 9.29 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1406IEEE1406 4760 563RELX Group (Elsevier)29.5 29.5 11.8

10 Massachusetts Institute of Te 1231RELX Group (Elsevier)1211 5475 1211IEEE22.1 22.5 22.111 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1233RELX Group (Elsevier)1199 9250 1206Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.13.0 13.3 13.012 General Electric Company 994IEEE994 5085 732RELX Group (Elsevier)19.5 19.5 14.413 Smith & Nephew Plc. 2686RELX Group (Elsevier)969 12450 1147John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.8 21.6 9.214 GUIDED THERAPY SYSTE 864IEEE864 2567 387RELX Group (Elsevier)33.7 33.7 15.115 Stryker Corp. 987RELX Group (Elsevier)855 5576 855IEEE15.3 17.7 15.316 LivaNova Plc 2403RELX Group (Elsevier)842 12043 1715John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.0 20.0 14.217 Masimo Corp 806IEEE806 2023 187Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.39.8 39.8 9.218 VIVAQUANT LLC 644IEEE644 1076 101RELX Group (Elsevier)59.9 59.9 9.419 Stanford University 1588RELX Group (Elsevier)554 9765 829John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.7 16.3 8.520 Sotera Wireless 500IEEE500 972 175Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad51.4 51.4 18.021 University of California 1361RELX Group (Elsevier)496 7093 671John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.0 19.2 9.522 Cleveland Clinic (and Found 553RELX Group (Elsevier)475 2682 475IEEE17.7 20.6 17.723 MIRAMAR LABS INC 471IEEE471 1115 105IOP Publishing42.2 42.2 9.424 BUTTERFLY NETWORKS I 445IEEE445 506 28Acoustical Society of America87.9 87.9 5.525 Vanderbilt University 396IEEE396 1629 246RELX Group (Elsevier)24.3 24.3 15.126 Columbia University 392IEEE392 1730 341RELX Group (Elsevier)22.7 22.7 19.727 University of Nebraska 386IEEE386 1756 284Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad22.0 22.0 16.228 IWALK INC 384IEEE384 1017 207RELX Group (Elsevier)37.8 37.8 20.429 BIO CONTROL MEDICAL ( 383IEEE383 1409 221Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.27.2 27.2 15.730 BIONX MEDICAL TECHN 379IEEE379 995 207RELX Group (Elsevier)38.1 38.1 20.831 Google Inc. 350IEEE350 762 96RELX Group (Elsevier)45.9 45.9 12.632 University of Texas 951RELX Group (Elsevier)328 5271 574John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.2 18.0 10.933 BIOSENSORS INTERNATI 301IEEE301 968 141John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss31.1 31.1 14.634 Ossur hf 300IEEE300 986 240RELX Group (Elsevier)30.4 30.4 24.335 Novartis AG 1970RELX Group (Elsevier)297 6523 520ASSOC RESEARCH VISION OPHTHALMOLOGY INC4.6 30.2 8.036 Cirrus Logic Inc. 289IEEE289 406 40Acoustical Society of America71.2 71.2 9.937 University of Washington 579RELX Group (Elsevier)288 2960 293John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss9.7 19.6 9.938 Bonutti Technologies LLC 397Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAca286 1724 296RELX Group (Elsevier)16.6 23.0 17.239 University Health Network 283IEEE283 639 84RELX Group (Elsevier)44.3 44.3 13.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-16Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 67: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Maui Diagnostic Imaging 282IEEE282 382 33RELX Group (Elsevier)73.8 73.8 8.641 KONA MEDICAL INC 475RELX Group (Elsevier)281 1805 281IEEE15.6 26.3 15.642 Medispectra Inc 281IEEE281 778 85RELX Group (Elsevier)36.1 36.1 10.943 Nyxoah SA 274IEEE274 608 70RELX Group (Elsevier)45.1 45.1 11.544 Becton Dickinson and Co. 3118RELX Group (Elsevier)267 18005 2763Wolters Kluwer1.5 17.3 15.345 Concormis Inc 1279Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAca261 7585 952RELX Group (Elsevier)3.4 16.9 12.646 Johns Hopkins University 305RELX Group (Elsevier)258 1910 258IEEE13.5 16.0 13.547 BRAINGATE CO LLC 251IEEE251 672 101RELX Group (Elsevier)37.4 37.4 15.048 University of Illinois 592ACS-Am Chem Soc243 3988 548RELX Group (Elsevier)6.1 14.8 13.749 University of Michigan 1157RELX Group (Elsevier)243 4357 357John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.6 26.6 8.250 California Institute of Techno 318RELX Group (Elsevier)230 1790 230IEEE12.8 17.8 12.851 Proteus Biomedical Inc 225IEEE225 933 188RELX Group (Elsevier)24.1 24.1 20.252 AngioDynamics Inc. 575RELX Group (Elsevier)221 2628 229Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad8.4 21.9 8.753 HIGHLAND INSTRUMENT 220IEEE220 367 29RELX Group (Elsevier)59.9 59.9 7.954 University of Minnesota (The 361RELX Group (Elsevier)201 1628 201IEEE12.3 22.2 12.355 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 1366RELX Group (Elsevier)200 6013 687Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.3.3 22.7 11.456 SRI International 198IEEE198 341 25NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin58.1 58.1 7.357 Asahi Kasei Corp. 643Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.197 2291 385RELX Group (Elsevier)8.6 28.1 16.858 University of Florida 229RELX Group (Elsevier)186 1193 186IEEE15.6 19.2 15.659 University of Pennsylvania 583RELX Group (Elsevier)186 3627 492John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.1 16.1 13.660 St. Louis University 238Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.185 1241 202American Association of Neurological Surgeons14.9 19.2 16.361 CLINICAL DECISION SUPP 189RELX Group (Elsevier)183 865 183IEEE21.2 21.8 21.262 Varian Medical Systems Inc. 568John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss180 2108 505RELX Group (Elsevier)8.5 26.9 24.063 Nevro Corp 342Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.174 1488 174IEEE11.7 23.0 11.764 HEMOSONICS LLC 171IEEE171 377 45RELX Group (Elsevier)45.4 45.4 11.965 Lockheed Martin Corp. 185John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss167 1712 180RELX Group (Elsevier)9.8 10.8 10.566 University of Pittsburgh 532RELX Group (Elsevier)167 2093 194John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss8.0 25.4 9.367 Victhom Human Bionics Inc 166IEEE166 351 86RELX Group (Elsevier)47.3 47.3 24.568 Impulse Dynamics N.V. 339John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss164 2134 308Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.7.7 15.9 14.469 Mevion Medical Systems Inc 162IEEE162 580 122RELX Group (Elsevier)27.9 27.9 21.070 Hitachi Ltd 159IEEE159 643 71RELX Group (Elsevier)24.7 24.7 11.071 GEARBOX LLC 158IEEE158 639 60RELX Group (Elsevier)24.7 24.7 9.472 Elwha LLC 154IEEE154 897 96RELX Group (Elsevier)17.2 17.2 10.773 Case Western Reserve Univer 152IEEE152 496 60Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.30.6 30.6 12.174 NEUROVISTA CORP 335RELX Group (Elsevier)150 1138 150IEEE13.2 29.4 13.275 Sonova Holding AG 148IEEE148 858 131RELX Group (Elsevier)17.2 17.2 15.376 Washington University in St. 252RELX Group (Elsevier)147 1670 175Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.8.8 15.1 10.577 Georgia Institute of Technolo 182RELX Group (Elsevier)146 989 146IEEE14.8 18.4 14.878 Duke University 242RELX Group (Elsevier)145 1433 193John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss10.1 16.9 13.579 Electrocor Llc 144IEEE144 574 70Natl Acad Sciences25.1 25.1 12.280 MC10 Inc 318American Institute of Physics143 1302 156John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss11.0 24.4 12.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-17Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 68: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Cynosure Inc 426RELX Group (Elsevier)142 2248 392John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.3 19.0 17.482 ALGODYNE LTD 140IEEE140 248 40Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad56.5 56.5 16.183 Mayo Foundation for Medica 452RELX Group (Elsevier)140 2144 275John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.5 21.1 12.884 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 139IEEE139 283 28John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss49.1 49.1 9.985 University of Wisconsin 377John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss138 1887 204RELX Group (Elsevier)7.3 20.0 10.886 Bayer AG 283RELX Group (Elsevier)133 1650 221Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.8.1 17.2 13.487 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 129IEEE129 409 60RELX Group (Elsevier)31.5 31.5 14.788 Bardy Diagnostics Inc 128IEEE128 268 47RELX Group (Elsevier)47.8 47.8 17.589 Valencell Inc 127IEEE127 369 31RELX Group (Elsevier)34.4 34.4 8.490 Nuvasive Inc 2907Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.126 5468 656RELX Group (Elsevier)2.3 53.2 12.091 Purdue University 382RELX Group (Elsevier)126 1608 231John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.8 23.8 14.492 Virginia Tech University 131RELX Group (Elsevier)122 695 122IEEE17.6 18.8 17.693 International Business Machi 120IEEE120 246 14RELX Group (Elsevier)48.8 48.8 5.794 University of Virginia (and P 143RELX Group (Elsevier)120 806 120IEEE14.9 17.7 14.995 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 134Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAca119 1278 119IEEE9.3 10.5 9.396 OSTEOPLASTICS LLC 119IEEE119 315 48RELX Group (Elsevier)37.8 37.8 15.297 VASCULAR IMAGING CO 119IEEE119 239 70IET/IEE49.8 49.8 29.398 United States of America De 116IEEE116 308 48RELX Group (Elsevier)37.7 37.7 15.699 Zimmer Biomet Holdings 1845RELX Group (Elsevier)113 8599 1024John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss1.3 21.5 11.9

100 Mindray Medical Internation 112IEEE112 157 12RELX Group (Elsevier)71.3 71.3 7.6

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-18Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 69: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Information Storage1 Micron Technology Inc. 14410IEEE14410 29973 4625RELX Group (Elsevier)48.1 48.1 15.42 Western Digital Corp. 5946IEEE5946 10842 1193American Institute of Physics54.8 54.8 11.03 International Business Machi 4354IEEE4354 12117 1986ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.9 35.9 16.44 Broadcom Ltd 2505IEEE2505 3085 129ACM-Assoc Comput Mach81.2 81.2 4.25 ZENO SEMICONDUCTOR I 2471IEEE2471 3218 606IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys76.8 76.8 18.86 Macronix International Co. L 2456IEEE2456 4292 828IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys57.2 57.2 19.37 Conversant Intellectual Prope 2210IEEE2210 2686 200IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys82.3 82.3 7.48 Seagate Technology Plc 1986IEEE1986 4941 1022American Institute of Physics40.2 40.2 20.79 Semiconductor Energy Labor 6164SID-Society for Information Display1961 18602 2761American Institute of Physics10.5 33.1 14.8

10 Rambus Inc. 1928IEEE1928 3228 245American Institute of Physics59.7 59.7 7.611 Toshiba Corp 1696IEEE1696 3652 431American Institute of Physics46.4 46.4 11.812 Innovative Silicon SA 1580IEEE1580 1959 84RELX Group (Elsevier)80.7 80.7 4.313 Apple Inc 1332IEEE1332 2031 121Joint IEEE and ACM65.6 65.6 6.014 Intel Corporation 1246IEEE1246 2787 373ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.7 44.7 13.415 Texas Instruments Inc 1228IEEE1228 1760 136United Business Media/UBM Tech69.8 69.8 7.716 Hitachi Ltd 1072IEEE1072 2545 195ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.1 42.1 7.717 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 1001IEEE1001 1235 64American Institute of Physics81.1 81.1 5.218 Innovative Network Corporat 956IEEE956 1293 91IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys73.9 73.9 7.019 Oracle Corporation 1089ACM-Assoc Comput Mach806 2786 806IEEE28.9 39.1 28.920 ATTOPSEMI TECHNOLOG 787IEEE787 1008 146IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys78.1 78.1 14.521 Netapp Inc 1178ACM-Assoc Comput Mach653 2793 653IEEE23.4 42.2 23.422 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 637IEEE637 1667 201American Institute of Physics38.2 38.2 12.123 TDK Corporation 612IEEE612 1800 417American Institute of Physics34.0 34.0 23.224 Microsoft Corporation 966ACM-Assoc Comput Mach594 2652 594IEEE22.4 36.4 22.425 Fujitsu Limited 537IEEE537 1001 103American Institute of Physics53.6 53.6 10.326 NXP Semiconductors NV 529IEEE529 764 53Joint IEEE and ACM69.2 69.2 6.927 STMicroelectronics 513IEEE513 740 40RELX Group (Elsevier)69.3 69.3 5.428 HP Inc 509IEEE509 1565 279ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.5 32.5 17.829 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 492IEEE492 840 105ECMA International58.6 58.6 12.530 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 489IEEE489 894 93IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys54.7 54.7 10.431 Synopsys Inc. 467IEEE467 928 134American Institute of Physics50.3 50.3 14.432 Infineon Technologies AG 448IEEE448 706 72IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys63.5 63.5 10.233 Marvell Technology Group Lt 443IEEE443 582 34ECMA International76.1 76.1 5.834 Qualcomm Inc 437IEEE437 714 65Joint IEEE and ACM61.2 61.2 9.135 Avid Technology Inc. 435IEEE435 843 269ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.6 51.6 31.936 Commvault Systems Inc. 424IEEE424 612 106ACM-Assoc Comput Mach69.3 69.3 17.337 Sony Corp 422IEEE422 977 57American Institute of Physics43.2 43.2 5.838 BTG Plc. 391IEEE391 516 52IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys75.8 75.8 10.139 Dell Technologies Inc 361IEEE361 1191 357ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.3 30.3 30.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-19Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 70: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Microchip Technology Inc. 342IEEE342 411 18IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys83.2 83.2 4.441 Intertrust Technologies Corp 386ACM-Assoc Comput Mach315 1917 315IEEE16.4 20.1 16.442 NEC Corp 305IEEE305 695 104American Institute of Physics43.9 43.9 15.043 Cirrus Logic Inc. 301IEEE301 366 12Institute of Business Adminsitration (IBA) and IEEE82.2 82.2 3.344 Massachusetts Institute of Te 294IEEE294 527 56ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.8 55.8 10.645 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 291IEEE291 807 117Joint IEEE and ACM36.1 36.1 14.546 QST Holdings Llc 289IEEE289 485 56Joint IEEE and ACM59.6 59.6 11.547 Crossbar Inc 279IEEE279 1102 152American Institute of Physics25.3 25.3 13.848 Panasonic Corporation 278IEEE278 944 104INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS29.4 29.4 11.049 Densbits Technologies Ltd 271IEEE271 502 78Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad54.0 54.0 15.550 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 257IEEE257 350 47IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys73.4 73.4 13.451 Softbank Corp 256IEEE256 437 80Joint IEEE and ACM58.6 58.6 18.352 Xilinx Inc. 223IEEE223 311 30Joint IEEE and ACM71.7 71.7 9.653 Nantero Inc 580ACS-Am Chem Soc216 2204 490American Institute of Physics9.8 26.3 22.254 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 211IEEE211 518 65American Institute of Physics40.7 40.7 12.555 Intellectual Ventures Manage 210IEEE210 240 23ACM-Assoc Comput Mach87.5 87.5 9.656 Pioneer Corp. 231SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering205 688 205IEEE29.8 33.6 29.857 California Institute of Techno 199IEEE199 324 18AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci61.4 61.4 5.658 Google Inc. 199IEEE199 493 167ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.4 40.4 33.959 Netlist Inc 251IP.Com191 829 206JEDEC Semiconductor Standards Organization23.0 30.3 24.860 SK Hynix Inc 190IEEE190 275 22IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys69.1 69.1 8.061 ConvergeOne Inc 161IEEE161 319 67Joint IEEE and ACM50.5 50.5 21.062 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 158IEEE158 274 24ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.7 57.7 8.863 Nokia Corp 157IEEE157 361 60ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.5 43.5 16.664 Avalanche Technology Inc 202American Institute of Physics143 650 143IEEE22.0 31.1 22.065 OVONYX MEMORY TECH 135IEEE135 167 9IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys80.8 80.8 5.466 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 131IEEE131 262 25RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 9.567 Global Foundries Inc 130IEEE130 225 17Joint IEEE and ACM57.8 57.8 7.668 Arizona State University 127IEEE127 242 25Joint IEEE and ACM52.5 52.5 10.369 Commissariat A L'Energie At 124IEEE124 308 58American Institute of Physics40.3 40.3 18.870 Mellanox Technologies Ltd 122IEEE122 287 99Joint IEEE and ACM42.5 42.5 34.571 NVIDIA Corp. 122IEEE122 228 37ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.5 53.5 16.272 Hewlett Packard Enterprises 120IEEE120 238 41ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.4 50.4 17.273 OPTICAL DEVICES LLC 120IEEE120 218 30American Automatic Control Council (AACC)55.0 55.0 13.874 Cisco Systems Inc. 118IEEE118 261 62ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.2 45.2 23.875 Round Rock Research LLC 136RELX Group (Elsevier)109 480 109IEEE22.7 28.3 22.776 Soitec SA 109IEEE109 136 7IET/IEE80.1 80.1 5.177 Columbia University 108IEEE108 283 48ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.2 38.2 17.078 University of California 126ACS-Am Chem Soc103 513 103IEEE20.1 24.6 20.179 Industrial Techology Researc 102IEEE102 180 16IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.7 56.7 8.980 Kandou 99IEEE99 108 8IET/IEE91.7 91.7 7.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-20Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 71: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 97IEEE97 177 25American Institute of Physics54.8 54.8 14.182 Sap SE 94IEEE94 298 39ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.5 31.5 13.183 Integrated Device Technolog 92IEEE92 109 6Pennwell Pub84.4 84.4 5.584 Carnegie Mellon University 90IEEE90 185 70American Institute of Physics48.6 48.6 37.885 Imation Corp. 90IEEE90 210 21RELX Group (Elsevier)42.9 42.9 10.086 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 90IEEE90 239 17American Institute of Physics37.7 37.7 7.187 Waratek 86IEEE86 220 55ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.1 39.1 25.088 Texas A&M University 83IEEE83 104 5Science Press79.8 79.8 4.889 Microsemi Corp 82IEEE82 124 12Reed Business66.1 66.1 9.790 Motorola Solutions Inc. 82IEEE82 137 7ACM-Assoc Comput Mach59.9 59.9 5.191 Interuniversity MicroElectron 75IEEE75 118 7Joint IEEE and ACM63.6 63.6 5.992 FireEye Inc 73IEEE73 173 29ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.2 42.2 16.893 Tela Innovations inc 87SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering72 240 72IEEE30.0 36.3 30.094 McAfee Inc 70IEEE70 199 54ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.2 35.2 27.195 Monolithic System Technolo 70IEEE70 96 8SLDRAM Consortium72.9 72.9 8.396 The Invention Science Fund 69IEEE69 215 38Massachusetts Institute of Technology32.1 32.1 17.797 BLUERISC INC 64IEEE64 188 50Joint IEEE and ACM34.0 34.0 26.698 Yonsei University 63IEEE63 86 10IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys73.3 73.3 11.699 Honeywell International Inc. 62IEEE62 103 9Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad60.2 60.2 8.7

100 Cadence Design Systems Inc 60IEEE60 98 20Penton Media, Inc.61.2 61.2 20.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-21Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 72: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

IOT/Internet of Things1 Velatia Group 839IEEE839 1125 81Echelon Corp74.6 74.6 7.22 Apple Inc 816IEEE816 2019 451ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.4 40.4 22.33 Honeywell International Inc. 234IEEE234 280 10ACM-Assoc Comput Mach83.6 83.6 3.64 TRILLIANT NETWORKS I 218IEEE218 320 18Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force68.1 68.1 5.65 LG Electronics Inc. 193IEEE193 233 383GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body82.8 82.8 16.36 ORIGIN WIRELESS INC 174IEEE174 225 10Acoustical Society of America77.3 77.3 4.47 Rockwell Automation Inc 158IEEE158 276 55ACM-Assoc Comput Mach57.2 57.2 19.98 SIPCO LLC 155IEEE155 269 27Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force57.6 57.6 10.09 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 152IEEE152 175 13WIP-Renewable Energies86.9 86.9 7.4

10 ABB Ltd 110IEEE110 135 6IET/IEE81.5 81.5 4.411 General Electric Company 80IEEE80 123 11IET/IEE65.0 65.0 8.912 Alstom 69IEEE69 83 9IET/IEE83.1 83.1 10.813 Qualcomm Inc 69IEEE69 148 403GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body46.6 46.6 27.014 Microsoft Corporation 67IEEE67 136 19ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.3 49.3 14.015 Intel Corporation 60IEEE60 109 343GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body55.0 55.0 31.216 Google Inc. 59IEEE59 107 21ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.1 55.1 19.617 International Business Machi 57IEEE57 106 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.8 53.8 5.718 Battelle Memorial Institute 56IEEE56 82 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach68.3 68.3 7.319 SOLAREEDGE TECHNOLO 55IEEE55 68 7WIP-Renewable Energies80.9 80.9 10.320 Toyota Motor Corp 46IEEE46 120 28ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.3 38.3 23.321 Itron Inc. 39IEEE39 70 11Joint IEEE and ACM55.7 55.7 15.722 3M Co 36IEEE36 44 3AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro81.8 81.8 6.823 ASTROLINK INTERNATIO 36IEEE36 42 4IET/IEE85.7 85.7 9.524 DOMINION ENERGY TEC 36IEEE36 42 4IET/IEE85.7 85.7 9.525 AT&T Inc 35IEEE35 51 4John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss68.6 68.6 7.826 Georgia Institute of Technolo 49ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34 91 34IEEE37.4 53.8 37.427 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 34IEEE34 84 11United Business Media/UBM Tech40.5 40.5 13.128 Knowles Corp 32IEEE32 48 4RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 8.329 Witricity Corp 32IEEE32 36 3American Institute of Physics88.9 88.9 8.330 Texas A&M University 28IEEE28 35 3IET/IEE80.0 80.0 8.631 Total SA 28IEEE28 32 4EPE Association87.5 87.5 12.532 AMPT LLC 26IEEE26 28 2IET/IEE92.9 92.9 7.133 ENERGY TECHNOLOGY G 26IEEE26 30 2ACM-Assoc Comput Mach86.7 86.7 6.734 Legrand S.A. 24IEEE24 76 11TIMES MIRROR MAG INC, 380 MADISON AVE, NEW YO31.6 31.6 14.535 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 21IEEE21 39 15Elecrostatic Discharge Association53.8 53.8 38.536 Accenture Ltd. 20IEEE20 26 3A B B Corporate Management Services AG76.9 76.9 11.537 M2M & IOT TECHNOLOGI 24Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force20 56 20IEEE35.7 42.9 35.738 SPARQ SYSTEMS INC 20IEEE20 25 3RELX Group (Elsevier)80.0 80.0 12.039 TEMPORAL POWER LTD 20IEEE20 20 100.0 100.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-22Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 73: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 AFERO INC 19IEEE19 24 5United Business Media/UBM Tech79.2 79.2 20.841 ConvergeOne Inc 19IEEE19 21 1Condé Nast90.5 90.5 4.842 Schneider Electric S.A. 27ANSI-American National Standards Institute19 103 19IEEE18.4 26.2 18.443 Commscope Inc. 18IEEE18 18 100.0 100.044 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 17IEEE17 18 1Hindawi Publishing Corporation94.4 94.4 5.645 New Jersey Institute of Techn 17IEEE17 17 100.0 100.046 Nokia Corp 233GPP General Partnership Project Standards 17 51 17IEEE33.3 45.1 33.347 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 283GPP General Partnership Project Standards 17 71 17IEEE23.9 39.4 23.948 Massachusetts Institute of Te 16IEEE16 22 4AMER SOC NAVAL ENG INC72.7 72.7 18.249 Industrial Techology Researc 15IEEE15 21 53GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body71.4 71.4 23.850 InterDigital Inc 1163GPP General Partnership Project Standards 15 148 15IEEE10.1 78.4 10.151 Sony Corp 24SID-Society for Information Display14 48 14IEEE29.2 50.0 29.252 Cisco Systems Inc. 12IEEE12 26 73GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body46.2 46.2 26.953 ECHOSTAR TECHNOLOGI 12IEEE12 16 4CBS Interactive75.0 75.0 25.054 Johnson Controls Internation 12IEEE12 13 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC)92.3 92.3 7.755 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 12IEEE12 12 100.0 100.056 Belkin International Inc 16ACM-Assoc Comput Mach11 39 11IEEE28.2 41.0 28.257 Panasonic Corporation 11IEEE11 14 2IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng78.6 78.6 14.358 THE DETROIT EDISON CO 11IEEE11 11 100.0 100.059 Elwha LLC 10IEEE10 18 3RELX Group (Elsevier)55.6 55.6 16.760 Huawei Technologies Compa 463GPP General Partnership Project Standards 10 69 10IEEE14.5 66.7 14.561 NORWEB PLC 10IEEE10 27 5IET/IEE37.0 37.0 18.562 Roche Holding Ltd. 10IEEE10 10 100.0 100.063 University of Missouri 10IEEE10 11 1Summit Technical Media90.9 90.9 9.164 Verizon Communications Inc 10IEEE10 15 2European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)66.7 66.7 13.365 EchoStar Corp 9IEEE9 11 2CBS Interactive81.8 81.8 18.266 INTERNATIONAL BROAD 9IEEE9 17 6ISO-International Standards Organization52.9 52.9 35.367 RADAR ENGINEERS 9IEEE9 10 1Penton Media, Inc.90.0 90.0 10.068 STMicroelectronics 9IEEE9 17 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss52.9 52.9 17.669 Tigo Energy Inc 9IEEE9 13 3WIP-Renewable Energies69.2 69.2 23.170 University of Wisconsin 9IEEE9 10 1MONTANA HISTORICAL SOC90.0 90.0 10.071 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 8IEEE8 60 6Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad13.3 13.3 10.072 LSIS Co Ltd (Formerly LS In 8IEEE8 9 1EPE Association88.9 88.9 11.173 TELESHUTTLE TECH2 LL 8IEEE8 20 4New York Times40.0 40.0 20.074 The Invention Science Fund 8IEEE8 15 4ANSI-American National Standards Institute53.3 53.3 26.775 WEAVED INC 11Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force8 22 8IEEE36.4 50.0 36.476 Clemson University 7IEEE7 9 1American Institute of Physics77.8 77.8 11.177 CURRENT GRID LLC 7IEEE7 11 2Echelon Corp63.6 63.6 18.278 CURRENT TECHNOLOGIE 7IEEE7 12 2Hewlett-Packard Company58.3 58.3 16.779 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 8Elecrostatic Discharge Association7 15 7IEEE46.7 53.3 46.780 Ericsson 923GPP General Partnership Project Standards 7 149 32European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)4.7 61.7 21.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-23Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 74: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Hubbell Inc. 7IEEE7 9 1Research Institute of Intelligent Computer Systems77.8 77.8 11.182 POWER TAGGING TECHN 7IEEE7 8 1IET/IEE87.5 87.5 12.583 Toshiba Corp 7IEEE7 12 2Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force58.3 58.3 16.784 Universal Electronics Inc. 7IEEE7 7 100.0 100.085 Boeing Co. (The) 6IEEE6 19 2Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad31.6 31.6 10.586 Danfoss A/S 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.087 Eaton Corp. 6IEEE6 10 2Mcgraw Hill60.0 60.0 20.088 Gemalto 163GPP General Partnership Project Standards 6 24 6IEEE25.0 66.7 25.089 King Fahd University of Petr 6IEEE6 9 3United Business Media/UBM Tech66.7 66.7 33.390 Sap SE 6IEEE6 12 1IP.Com50.0 50.0 8.391 Somfy SA 6IEEE6 7 1RELX Group (Elsevier)85.7 85.7 14.392 STEM INC 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.093 TACTILIS SDN BHD 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.094 University of Oxford 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.095 UT-Battelle LLC 12RELX Group (Elsevier)6 38 12Electrochemical Society, Inc.15.8 31.6 31.696 ASOKA USA CORP 5IEEE5 6 1National Association of Industrial Technology83.3 83.3 16.797 Canon Inc 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.098 COM/ENERGY TECHNOL 6Reed Business5 16 5IEEE31.3 37.5 31.399 DGI CREATIONS LLC 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.0

100 D-Wave Systems Inc. 8American Physical Society5 29 5American Institute of Physics17.2 27.6 17.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-24Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 75: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Measuring, Testing and Control Devices1 Partners HealthCare Systems 15011Optical Society of America2872 41115 5645RELX Group (Elsevier)7.0 36.5 13.72 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 2832IEEE2832 5775 852John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss49.0 49.0 14.83 Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc 4431RELX Group (Elsevier)2321 13236 2321IEEE17.5 33.5 17.54 Irobot Corp 2076IEEE2076 3855 578SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering53.9 53.9 15.05 FormFactor Inc 1887IEEE1887 3402 642Nature Publishing Group55.5 55.5 18.96 International Business Machi 1882IEEE1882 4835 278American Institute of Physics38.9 38.9 5.77 Microsoft Corporation 1555IEEE1555 3837 932ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.5 40.5 24.38 Honeywell International Inc. 1495IEEE1495 4013 493RELX Group (Elsevier)37.3 37.3 12.39 Texas Instruments Inc 1347IEEE1347 1705 62Joint IEEE and ACM79.0 79.0 3.6

10 General Electric Company 1281IEEE1281 8317 1039RELX Group (Elsevier)15.4 15.4 12.511 Sanken Electric Co. Ltd. 1238IEEE1238 1590 230RELX Group (Elsevier)77.9 77.9 14.512 Illumina Inc. 856IEEE856 3270 477Royal Society of Chemistry26.2 26.2 14.613 Emerson Electric Co. 808IEEE808 3545 433RELX Group (Elsevier)22.8 22.8 12.214 California Institute of Techno 913RELX Group (Elsevier)714 5960 714IEEE12.0 15.3 12.015 Applied Materials Inc. 711IEEE711 1506 154American Institute of Physics47.2 47.2 10.216 Apple Inc 673IEEE673 1360 173ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.5 49.5 12.717 Nokia Corp 670IEEE670 1656 1033GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body40.5 40.5 6.218 ABB Ltd 645IEEE645 1011 63RELX Group (Elsevier)63.8 63.8 6.219 Intel Corporation 637IEEE637 1461 1163GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body43.6 43.6 7.920 Massachusetts Institute of Te 34American Society for Biochemistry and Molec623 3624 31IOP Publishing17.2 0.9 0.921 Broadcom Ltd 13International Telecommunication Union601 966 11John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss62.2 1.3 1.122 Qualcomm Inc 597IEEE597 1301 2163GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body45.9 45.9 16.623 Midtronics Inc. 559IEEE559 1304 234RELX Group (Elsevier)42.9 42.9 17.924 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 536IEEE536 1149 166SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 46.6 46.6 14.425 University of Illinois 892American Institute of Physics493 5240 786RELX Group (Elsevier)9.4 17.0 15.026 Boeing Co. (The) 1<std> Department of Defense Standard477 1569 1World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology30.4 0.1 0.127 Schlumberger Ltd. 1209Society of Petroleum Engineers475 7562 1152Society of Exploration Geophysicists6.3 16.0 15.228 NXP Semiconductors NV 467IEEE467 726 53RELX Group (Elsevier)64.3 64.3 7.329 Synopsys Inc. 461IEEE461 569 33Joint IEEE and ACM81.0 81.0 5.830 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 446IEEE446 998 121RELX Group (Elsevier)44.7 44.7 12.131 Abbott Laboratories 3526ACS-Am Chem Soc444 13475 3166RELX Group (Elsevier)3.3 26.2 23.532 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 441IEEE441 962 57Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad45.8 45.8 5.933 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 554John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss423 2419 423IEEE17.5 22.9 17.534 Schneider Electric S.A. 409IEEE409 2683 314RELX Group (Elsevier)15.2 15.2 11.735 Google Inc. 405IEEE405 1128 232ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.9 35.9 20.636 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 395IEEE395 551 40Joint IEEE and ACM71.7 71.7 7.337 Marvell Technology Group Lt 392IEEE392 444 11Bluetooth Special Interest Group88.3 88.3 2.538 Infineon Technologies AG 384IEEE384 597 63RELX Group (Elsevier)64.3 64.3 10.639 HP Inc 381IEEE381 1460 142ACS-Am Chem Soc26.1 26.1 9.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-25Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 76: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Lockheed Martin Corp. 530American Institute of Physics375 3587 411RELX Group (Elsevier)10.5 14.8 11.541 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 374IEEE374 850 90RELX Group (Elsevier)44.0 44.0 10.642 Agilent Technologies Inc 368IEEE368 1465 211RELX Group (Elsevier)25.1 25.1 14.443 STMicroelectronics 366IEEE366 563 65RELX Group (Elsevier)65.0 65.0 11.544 Ericsson 365IEEE365 873 1493GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.8 41.8 17.145 Duke University 364IEEE364 1649 214Optical Society of America22.1 22.1 13.046 University of California 974RELX Group (Elsevier)345 6378 898ACS-Am Chem Soc5.4 15.3 14.147 NEC Corp 344IEEE344 786 40Joint IEEE and ACM43.8 43.8 5.148 Rockwell Automation Inc 343IEEE343 600 71RELX Group (Elsevier)57.2 57.2 11.849 Commissariat A L'Energie At 332RELX Group (Elsevier)332 1381 332IEEE24.0 24.0 24.050 ParkerVision Inc 332IEEE332 531 50IET/IEE62.5 62.5 9.451 Advantest Corp. 323IEEE323 453 26American Institute of Physics71.3 71.3 5.752 University of Texas 366RELX Group (Elsevier)320 2328 320IEEE13.7 15.7 13.753 Micron Technology Inc. 314IEEE314 580 38American Institute of Physics54.1 54.1 6.654 Analog Devices Inc. 313IEEE313 463 24American Institute of Physics67.6 67.6 5.255 Stanford University 392John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss308 3103 387Optical Society of America9.9 12.6 12.556 Toshiba Corp 308IEEE308 1188 245John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss25.9 25.9 20.657 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 301IEEE301 662 71SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering45.5 45.5 10.758 Georgia Institute of Technolo 297IEEE297 967 123Optical Society of America30.7 30.7 12.759 Panasonic Corporation 294IEEE294 1012 201RELX Group (Elsevier)29.1 29.1 19.960 FARO Technologies Inc. 292IEEE292 823 152SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering35.5 35.5 18.561 Industrial Techology Researc 290IEEE290 645 94RELX Group (Elsevier)45.0 45.0 14.662 Cisco Systems Inc. 404Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force285 1313 285IEEE21.7 30.8 21.763 University of Minnesota (The 282IEEE282 1365 255RELX Group (Elsevier)20.7 20.7 18.764 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 279IEEE279 1314 136RELX Group (Elsevier)21.2 21.2 10.465 United States Navy 276IEEE276 1766 258RELX Group (Elsevier)15.6 15.6 14.666 Fujitsu Limited 272IEEE272 578 31Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force47.1 47.1 5.467 Hitachi Ltd 267IEEE267 1511 208RELX Group (Elsevier)17.7 17.7 13.868 HRL Laboratories LLC 264IEEE264 634 81RELX Group (Elsevier)41.6 41.6 12.869 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 262IEEE262 788 111RELX Group (Elsevier)33.2 33.2 14.170 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 262IEEE262 509 35RELX Group (Elsevier)51.5 51.5 6.971 Adaptix 252IEEE252 373 47European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)67.6 67.6 12.672 Raytheon Co. 252IEEE252 844 111SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering29.9 29.9 13.273 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 247IEEE247 294 26WIP-Renewable Energies84.0 84.0 8.874 Xerox Corp 245IEEE245 951 96American Institute of Physics25.8 25.8 10.175 General Motors Corp 242IEEE242 485 48RELX Group (Elsevier)49.9 49.9 9.976 AT&T Inc 241IEEE241 547 56Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force44.1 44.1 10.277 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 241IEEE241 275 11RELX Group (Elsevier)87.6 87.6 4.078 Nintendo Co. Ltd. 238IEEE238 814 165ACM-Assoc Comput Mach29.2 29.2 20.379 Battelle Memorial Institute 265RELX Group (Elsevier)235 1197 235IEEE19.6 22.1 19.680 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 228IEEE228 346 21American Institute of Physics65.9 65.9 6.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-26Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 77: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 University of Michigan 227IEEE227 1103 165RELX Group (Elsevier)20.6 20.6 15.082 Teradyne Inc. 224IEEE224 510 78ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng43.9 43.9 15.383 Sony Corp 223IEEE223 548 42RELX Group (Elsevier)40.7 40.7 7.784 University of Southern Califo 219IEEE219 524 37Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad41.8 41.8 7.185 Verizon Communications Inc 216IEEE216 516 61Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force41.9 41.9 11.886 Immersion Corp. 215IEEE215 492 41ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng43.7 43.7 8.387 TROXLER ELECTRONIC L 211IEEE211 505 123AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS41.8 41.8 24.488 Fluidigm Corp 235ACS-Am Chem Soc209 1444 209IEEE14.5 16.3 14.589 NANONEXUS INC 209IEEE209 306 28American Institute of Physics68.3 68.3 9.290 Xcerra Corp 209IEEE209 352 43American Institute of Physics59.4 59.4 12.291 Cadence Design Systems Inc 203IEEE203 348 67Joint IEEE and ACM58.3 58.3 19.392 Purdue University 274RELX Group (Elsevier)203 1397 229ACS-Am Chem Soc14.5 19.6 16.493 Canon Inc 241John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss201 1477 201IEEE13.6 16.3 13.694 Brain Corporation 196IEEE196 389 47MIT Press50.4 50.4 12.195 KLA-Tencor Corp. 738SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering195 3052 547Optical Society of America6.4 24.2 17.996 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 1361Society of Petroleum Engineers194 4117 613SPWLA-Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log Analysts4.7 33.1 14.997 Xilinx Inc. 189IEEE189 226 12Joint IEEE and ACM83.6 83.6 5.398 Motorola Solutions Inc. 184IEEE184 543 74ACS-Am Chem Soc33.9 33.9 13.699 Teledyne Technologies Incor 183IEEE183 362 24RELX Group (Elsevier)50.6 50.6 6.6

100 Velatia Group 178IEEE178 246 19Echelon Corp72.4 72.4 7.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-27Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 78: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Optics/Photography/Electrophotography1 Qualcomm Inc 1833IEEE1833 5114 924SID-Society for Information Display35.8 35.8 18.12 Infinera Corporation 1157IEEE1157 2153 350IET/IEE53.7 53.7 16.33 Partners HealthCare Systems 5082Optical Society of America932 13603 1905RELX Group (Elsevier)6.9 37.4 14.04 IDC Llc 641IEEE641 1778 236SID-Society for Information Display36.1 36.1 13.35 Finisar Corp 570IEEE570 1618 270Optical Society of America35.2 35.2 16.76 Nikon Corp. 1698SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering561 3831 761SEMATECH Consortium14.6 44.3 19.97 Nokia Corp 518IEEE518 2470 419Optical Society of America21.0 21.0 17.08 Corning Inc. 756Optical Society of America484 3383 484IEEE14.3 22.3 14.39 Massachusetts Institute of Te 455IEEE455 2773 425Optical Society of America16.4 16.4 15.3

10 Synopsys Inc. 1450SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering439 3099 462INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS14.2 46.8 14.911 Hoya Corp 424IEEE424 1333 262American Institute of Physics31.8 31.8 19.712 YFY Inc 1836SID-Society for Information Display420 4685 489National Symposium on Information Display9.0 39.2 10.413 The Invention Science Fund 389IEEE389 1647 214American Institute of Physics23.6 23.6 13.014 Google Inc. 388IEEE388 852 73RELX Group (Elsevier)45.5 45.5 8.615 Screen Holdings Co Ltd (For 375IEEE375 1383 215RELX Group (Elsevier)27.1 27.1 15.516 Microsoft Corporation 346IEEE346 966 220ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.8 35.8 22.817 Ericsson 532Optical Society of America327 1468 327IEEE22.3 36.2 22.318 Intel Corporation 327IEEE327 1136 181SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering28.8 28.8 15.919 Mellanox Technologies Ltd 313IEEE313 1038 262IET/IEE30.2 30.2 25.220 Cheetah Omni LLC 294IEEE294 1138 274Optical Society of America25.8 25.8 24.121 International Business Machi 501SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering279 1946 279IEEE14.3 25.7 14.322 Stanford University 331Optical Society of America242 1677 242IEEE14.4 19.7 14.423 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 236IEEE236 567 97Optical Society of America41.6 41.6 17.124 Texas Instruments Inc 233IEEE233 891 152American Institute of Physics26.2 26.2 17.125 Adobe Systems Inc. 219IEEE219 512 127ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.8 42.8 24.826 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 216IEEE216 680 123SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering31.8 31.8 18.127 University of California 213IEEE213 1458 197Optical Society of America14.6 14.6 13.528 Viavi Solutions Inc 199IEEE199 904 170Optical Society of America22.0 22.0 18.829 3M Co 584Optical Society of America198 3936 386RELX Group (Elsevier)5.0 14.8 9.830 California Institute of Techno 488Optical Society of America198 1604 198IEEE12.3 30.4 12.331 Micron Technology Inc. 371American Institute of Physics179 1894 344SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering9.5 19.6 18.232 Fujitsu Limited 174IEEE174 963 144Optical Society of America18.1 18.1 15.033 HP Inc 173IEEE173 887 104Optical Society of America19.5 19.5 11.734 University of Colorado ( The 485Optical Society of America171 1414 171IEEE12.1 34.3 12.135 ASML Holding NV 2545SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering170 7227 1440American Institute of Physics2.4 35.2 19.936 Princeton University 170IEEE170 386 44American Institute of Physics44.0 44.0 11.437 Prysmian SPA 211Optical Society of America169 929 169IEEE18.2 22.7 18.238 Lockheed Martin Corp. 268Optical Society of America168 998 168IEEE16.8 26.9 16.839 Osterhout Design Group 168IEEE168 467 127ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.0 36.0 27.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-28Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 79: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 STEYPHI SERVICES DE LL 166IEEE166 459 105Optical Society of America36.2 36.2 22.941 United States of America De 163IEEE163 662 131IET/IEE24.6 24.6 19.842 Electronics and Telecommuni 157IEEE157 428 53IEEE/OSA36.7 36.7 12.443 Honeywell International Inc. 138IEEE138 581 105SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering23.8 23.8 18.144 Canon Inc 266SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering137 1838 239American Institute of Physics7.5 14.5 13.045 Pelican Imaging Corporation 137IEEE137 299 53SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering45.8 45.8 17.746 Xerox Corp 237ACS-Am Chem Soc137 1307 164RELX Group (Elsevier)10.5 18.1 12.547 CIRREX SYSTEMS LLC 136IEEE136 615 89Optical Society of America22.1 22.1 14.548 Georgia Institute of Technolo 135IEEE135 439 80Optical Society of America30.8 30.8 18.249 OmniGuide Inc 242Optical Society of America134 1019 134IEEE13.2 23.7 13.250 University of Texas 187American Institute of Physics134 1049 142Optical Society of America12.8 17.8 13.551 Emcore Corp. 133IEEE133 163 11IEEE/OSA81.6 81.6 6.752 VASCULAR IMAGING CO 133IEEE133 280 80IET/IEE47.5 47.5 28.653 Cubic Wafer Inc 125IEEE125 223 42SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering56.1 56.1 18.854 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 114IEEE114 639 112IET/IEE17.8 17.8 17.555 Sumitomo Electric Industries 247Optical Society of America111 1007 153European Conference on Optical Communication (ECOC) Soc11.0 24.5 15.256 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 193SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering109 684 109IEEE15.9 28.2 15.957 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. 254Optical Society of America107 787 107IEEE13.6 32.3 13.658 NEC Corp 107IEEE107 763 77American Institute of Physics14.0 14.0 10.159 PTS Corporation 102IEEE102 232 34Optical Society of America44.0 44.0 14.760 Calient Technologies Inc. 101IEEE101 200 29Optical Society of America50.5 50.5 14.561 Eastman Kodak Company 185ACS-Am Chem Soc95 1406 185RELX Group (Elsevier)6.8 13.2 13.262 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 93IEEE93 306 52SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering30.4 30.4 17.063 Neophotonics Corporation 93IEEE93 296 51Optical Society of America31.4 31.4 17.264 Broadcom Ltd 90IEEE90 319 70SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering28.2 28.2 21.965 Panasonic Corporation 120SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering89 640 89IEEE13.9 18.8 13.966 University of Arizona 125Optical Society of America89 487 89IEEE18.3 25.7 18.367 Applied Materials Inc. 122SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering86 523 92American Institute of Physics16.4 23.3 17.668 KOTUSA INC 85IEEE85 236 51IET/IEE36.0 36.0 21.669 OMM INC 85IEEE85 194 43SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering43.8 43.8 22.270 NXP Semiconductors NV 84IEEE84 272 45American Institute of Physics30.9 30.9 16.571 RPX Corp 84IEEE84 216 30IEEE/OSA38.9 38.9 13.972 Motorola Solutions Inc. 93American Institute of Physics83 348 83IEEE23.9 26.7 23.973 Huawei Technologies Compa 81IEEE81 152 18Optical Society of America53.3 53.3 11.874 Oewaves Inc 106Optical Society of America76 253 76IEEE30.0 41.9 30.075 Extreme Networks Inc 72IEEE72 156 22ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.2 46.2 14.176 Seiko Epson Corporation 72IEEE72 288 61SID-Society for Information Display25.0 25.0 21.277 HRL Laboratories LLC 70IEEE70 288 47American Institute of Physics24.3 24.3 16.378 Oracle Corporation 70IEEE70 125 16Optical Society of America56.0 56.0 12.879 Hong Kong University of Sci 66IEEE66 108 5American Institute of Physics61.1 61.1 4.680 Industrial Techology Researc 66IEEE66 316 44SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering20.9 20.9 13.9

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-29Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 80: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Cornell University 65IEEE65 511 60ACS-Am Chem Soc12.7 12.7 11.782 Apple Inc 64IEEE64 203 44Optical Society of America31.5 31.5 21.783 Iowa State University 61IEEE61 157 15American Institute of Physics38.9 38.9 9.684 Olympus Corp. 114Optical Society of America61 420 61IEEE14.5 27.1 14.585 Velatia Group 61IEEE61 80 7Echelon Corp76.3 76.3 8.886 Fujikara Ltd. 155Optical Society of America60 564 112IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng10.6 27.5 19.987 Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. Ltd. 694SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering60 1434 367Technical Association of Photopolymers4.2 48.4 25.688 University of Illinois 111American Institute of Physics60 373 60IEEE16.1 29.8 16.189 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 102ACS-Am Chem Soc59 793 85American Institute of Physics7.4 12.9 10.790 LIGHTCHIP INC 107Optical Society of America58 481 101IEEE/OSA12.1 22.2 21.091 NANOOPTO CORP 111American Institute of Physics56 327 56IEEE17.1 33.9 17.192 United States Navy 72Optical Society of America56 416 56IEEE13.5 17.3 13.593 Boeing Co. (The) 55IEEE55 248 44SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering22.2 22.2 17.794 Oclaro Inc 55IEEE55 243 54Optical Society of America22.6 22.6 22.295 Ohio State University 71Optical Society of America55 230 55IEEE23.9 30.9 23.996 Evans & Sutherland Compute 139ACM-Assoc Comput Mach54 245 54IEEE22.0 56.7 22.097 General Electric Company 65Optical Society of America54 471 62ACS-Am Chem Soc11.5 13.8 13.298 Hitachi Ltd 54IEEE54 382 39Optical Society of America14.1 14.1 10.299 Luxtera Inc 54IEEE54 89 16Optical Society of America60.7 60.7 18.0

100 University of Michigan 54IEEE54 328 43Optical Society of America16.5 16.5 13.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-30Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 81: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Power Systems1 Witricity Corp 2887IEEE2887 5203 460American Institute of Physics55.5 55.5 8.82 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 1841IEEE1841 2200 208WIP-Renewable Energies83.7 83.7 9.53 Flex Ltd (Formerly Flextronic 1605IEEE1605 1726 67United Business Media/UBM Tech93.0 93.0 3.94 Cirrus Logic Inc. 1569IEEE1569 1722 50ISO-International Standards Organization91.1 91.1 2.95 Total SA 1402IEEE1402 1570 52IET/IEE89.3 89.3 3.36 ABB Ltd 1326IEEE1326 2059 94IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium64.4 64.4 4.67 Massachusetts Institute of Te 1003IEEE1003 2590 377Electrochemical Society, Inc.38.7 38.7 14.68 Rockwell Automation Inc 962IEEE962 1028 27EPE Association93.6 93.6 2.69 SYNQOR INC 892IEEE892 1023 45Penton Media, Inc.87.2 87.2 4.4

10 General Electric Company 812IEEE812 2420 773US Dept of Energy33.6 33.6 31.911 Texas Instruments Inc 691IEEE691 809 25IET/IEE85.4 85.4 3.112 MOJO MOBILITY INC 591IEEE591 758 54RELX Group (Elsevier)78.0 78.0 7.113 Intel Corporation 559IEEE559 665 19IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys84.1 84.1 2.914 AMPT LLC 434IEEE434 560 34RELX Group (Elsevier)77.5 77.5 6.115 Maxim Integrated Products In 422IEEE422 456 14Texas Instruments92.5 92.5 3.116 Infineon Technologies AG 413IEEE413 465 10EPE Association88.8 88.8 2.217 Analog Devices Inc. 399Reed Business351 993 351IEEE35.3 40.2 35.318 Innovative Network Corporat 344IEEE344 430 11IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys80.0 80.0 2.619 STMicroelectronics 336IEEE336 427 20RELX Group (Elsevier)78.7 78.7 4.720 Qorvo 326IEEE326 407 27Reed Business80.1 80.1 6.621 Irobot Corp 325IEEE325 584 92SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering55.7 55.7 15.822 Qualcomm Inc 309IEEE309 412 32RELX Group (Elsevier)75.0 75.0 7.823 NXP Semiconductors NV 306IEEE306 367 12IET/IEE83.4 83.4 3.324 Alstom 291IEEE291 379 23IET/IEE76.8 76.8 6.125 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 270IEEE270 556 68AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro48.6 48.6 12.226 Industrial Techology Researc 257IEEE257 451 113RELX Group (Elsevier)57.0 57.0 25.127 Power Integrations Inc. 254IEEE254 392 61Penton Media, Inc.64.8 64.8 15.628 Nokia Corp 248IEEE248 399 28RELX Group (Elsevier)62.2 62.2 7.029 University of Wisconsin 230IEEE230 290 12RELX Group (Elsevier)79.3 79.3 4.130 Broadcom Ltd 225IEEE225 284 10American Institute of Physics79.2 79.2 3.531 University of Illinois 340RELX Group (Elsevier)225 912 225IEEE24.7 37.3 24.732 Toshiba Corp 216IEEE216 611 169RELX Group (Elsevier)35.4 35.4 27.733 Vicor Corp 211IEEE211 299 42Center for Power Electronics Systems (Virginia Tech)70.6 70.6 14.034 Tigo Energy Inc 203IEEE203 294 68WIP-Renewable Energies69.0 69.0 23.135 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 199IEEE199 234 6RELX Group (Elsevier)85.0 85.0 2.636 Eaton Corp. 198IEEE198 270 16RELX Group (Elsevier)73.3 73.3 5.937 International Business Machi 195IEEE195 321 13ACS-Am Chem Soc60.7 60.7 4.038 Maxlinear Inc 189IEEE189 200 3Scripta Pub Co.94.5 94.5 1.539 Midtronics Inc. 189IEEE189 482 81RELX Group (Elsevier)39.2 39.2 16.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-31Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 82: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 Vertiv Corp 185IEEE185 201 3Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad92.0 92.0 1.541 Schneider Electric S.A. 177IEEE177 235 9IEEE/DOE/JPL75.3 75.3 3.842 Energous Corporation 175IEEE175 186 11RELX Group (Elsevier)94.1 94.1 5.943 Delta Electronics Inc 172IEEE172 186 2EPE Association92.5 92.5 1.144 Dialog Semiconductor Plc. 170IEEE170 205 18ONLINE INC82.9 82.9 8.845 Semiconductor Energy Labor 634SID-Society for Information Display166 2467 337American Institute of Physics6.7 25.7 13.746 General Motors Corp 685RELX Group (Elsevier)159 1658 271Electrochemical Society, Inc.9.6 41.3 16.347 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 157IEEE157 238 7McGraw Hill66.0 66.0 2.948 Micron Technology Inc. 153IEEE153 221 22IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys69.2 69.2 10.049 O2Micro International Ltd. 152IEEE152 232 33Texas Instruments65.5 65.5 14.250 R2 SEMICONDUCTOR INC 146IEEE146 149 2European Microwave Association98.0 98.0 1.351 Emerson Electric Co. 141IEEE141 218 21IET/IEE64.7 64.7 9.652 Silicon Laboratories Inc 137IEEE137 152 12SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers90.1 90.1 7.953 Marvell Technology Group Lt 135IEEE135 170 16Texas Instruments79.4 79.4 9.454 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 134IEEE134 199 23IET/IEE67.3 67.3 11.655 Powwermat Technologies Ltd 133IEEE133 137 4American Institute of Physics97.1 97.1 2.956 Western Digital Corp. 133IEEE133 162 16McGraw Hill82.1 82.1 9.957 United Technologies Corp 132IEEE132 289 40SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers45.7 45.7 13.858 INFINITE POWER SOLUTI 317RELX Group (Elsevier)130 1398 309American Institute of Physics9.3 22.7 22.159 Raytheon Co. 127IEEE127 165 9AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro77.0 77.0 5.560 Boeing Co. (The) 126IEEE126 329 47RELX Group (Elsevier)38.3 38.3 14.361 Hong Kong University of Sci 125IEEE125 212 34RELX Group (Elsevier)59.0 59.0 16.062 SRI International 152SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering124 720 124IEEE17.2 21.1 17.263 Conversant Intellectual Prope 120IEEE120 144 12Joint IEEE and ACM83.3 83.3 8.364 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 222RELX Group (Elsevier)117 752 117IEEE15.6 29.5 15.665 Panasonic Corporation 367RELX Group (Elsevier)112 1191 312Electrochemical Society, Inc.9.4 30.8 26.266 Apple Inc 111IEEE111 240 33ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.3 46.3 13.867 MOTOR EXCELLENCE LL 111IEEE111 125 14IEEE/ASME88.8 88.8 11.268 Microchip Technology Inc. 110IEEE110 125 9IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng88.0 88.0 7.269 Arizona State University 109IEEE109 408 80RELX Group (Elsevier)26.7 26.7 19.670 Lockheed Martin Corp. 127RELX Group (Elsevier)107 527 107IEEE20.3 24.1 20.371 Advanced Energy Industries I 106IEEE106 113 3IET/IEE93.8 93.8 2.772 CPG TECHNOLOGIES LLC 106IEEE106 227 23American Institute of Physics46.7 46.7 10.173 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 104IEEE104 120 6IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys86.7 86.7 5.074 Utah State University 104IEEE104 115 6IET/IEE90.4 90.4 5.275 TDK Corporation 103IEEE103 224 49RELX Group (Elsevier)46.0 46.0 21.976 University of California 179RELX Group (Elsevier)101 901 152ACS-Am Chem Soc11.2 19.9 16.977 On Semiconductor Corporati 100IEEE100 121 8Penton Media, Inc.82.6 82.6 6.678 Tesla Motors Inc 99IEEE99 106 4WIP-Renewable Energies93.4 93.4 3.879 University of Colorado ( The 98IEEE98 105 2<conf> Int Conf Phys Semi (ICPS)93.3 93.3 1.980 Alticor Inc 94IEEE94 121 9RELX Group (Elsevier)77.7 77.7 7.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-32Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 83: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Hitachi Ltd 93IEEE93 296 46IET/IEE31.4 31.4 15.582 Lenovo Group Ltd 92IEEE92 115 9RELX Group (Elsevier)80.0 80.0 7.883 ENECSYS LTD 91IEEE91 101 5WIP-Renewable Energies90.1 90.1 5.084 Huawei Technologies Compa 89IEEE89 94 3Audio Eng Soc94.7 94.7 3.285 Microsemi Corp 87IEEE87 108 4Penton Media, Inc.80.6 80.6 3.786 University of Texas 166RELX Group (Elsevier)86 585 100Electrochemical Society, Inc.14.7 28.4 17.187 GENESIS ROBOTICS LLP 85IEEE85 111 5IET/IEE76.6 76.6 4.588 Honeywell International Inc. 110RELX Group (Elsevier)85 320 85IEEE26.6 34.4 26.689 TechnipFMC 85IEEE85 118 12ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng72.0 72.0 10.290 Ericsson 84IEEE84 111 8RELX Group (Elsevier)75.7 75.7 7.291 IDEAL POWER INC 84IEEE84 103 15EPE Association81.6 81.6 14.692 INI POWER SYSTEMS INC 306RELX Group (Elsevier)81 816 148Electrochemical Society, Inc.9.9 37.5 18.193 Cree Inc. 80IEEE80 100 6SID-Society for Information Display80.0 80.0 6.094 Enphase Energy Inc 80IEEE80 93 4IET/IEE86.0 86.0 4.395 TEMPORAL POWER LTD 78IEEE78 90 4NASA-National Aeronautics and Space Admin86.7 86.7 4.496 Fujitsu Limited 76IEEE76 176 20RELX Group (Elsevier)43.2 43.2 11.497 Sony Corp 79RELX Group (Elsevier)76 330 76IEEE23.0 23.9 23.098 Microsoft Corporation 75IEEE75 185 18Joint IEEE and ACM40.5 40.5 9.799 SPARQ SYSTEMS INC 70IEEE70 84 6RELX Group (Elsevier)83.3 83.3 7.1

100 Commissariat A L'Energie At 138RELX Group (Elsevier)69 400 69IEEE17.3 34.5 17.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-33Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 84: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Robotics and Intelligent Manufacturing1 Irobot Corp 5330IEEE5330 9194 1270SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering58.0 58.0 13.82 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 3321IEEE3321 6172 380SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic 53.8 53.8 6.23 Applied Materials Inc. 1585IEEE1585 2696 157American Institute of Physics58.8 58.8 5.84 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 996IEEE996 2106 109Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad47.3 47.3 5.25 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 691IEEE691 1542 182RELX Group (Elsevier)44.8 44.8 11.86 Microsoft Corporation 594IEEE594 1542 333ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.5 38.5 21.67 International Business Machi 515IEEE515 1424 182ACM-Assoc Comput Mach36.2 36.2 12.88 Brain Corporation 460IEEE460 1004 135MIT Press45.8 45.8 13.49 University of Nebraska 424IEEE424 1714 277Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad24.7 24.7 16.2

10 Sony Corp 403IEEE403 529 23IEEE/RSJ76.2 76.2 4.311 Massachusetts Institute of Te 392IEEE392 1107 171RELX Group (Elsevier)35.4 35.4 15.412 Stryker Corp. 340IEEE340 989 184Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad34.4 34.4 18.613 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 337IEEE337 784 83RELX Group (Elsevier)43.0 43.0 10.614 Vanderbilt University 337IEEE337 461 29IEEE/RSJ73.1 73.1 6.315 Immersion Corp. 313IEEE313 773 76ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.5 40.5 9.816 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 243IEEE243 490 53RELX Group (Elsevier)49.6 49.6 10.817 SIPCO LLC 237IEEE237 414 35Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force57.2 57.2 8.518 HRL Laboratories LLC 226IEEE226 383 26SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering59.0 59.0 6.819 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 213IEEE213 337 33IEEE/RSJ63.2 63.2 9.820 Google Inc. 197IEEE197 384 72ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.3 51.3 18.821 Cadence Design Systems Inc 183IEEE183 430 149Joint IEEE and ACM42.6 42.6 34.722 SRI International 181IEEE181 405 56SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering44.7 44.7 13.823 Cimpress NV 179IEEE179 435 121RELX Group (Elsevier)41.1 41.1 27.824 PDF Solutions 175IEEE175 259 61SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering67.6 67.6 23.625 Medrobiotics Corp 152IEEE152 391 95Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad38.9 38.9 24.326 Caterpillar Inc. 150IEEE150 321 38SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers46.7 46.7 11.827 ICOSYSTEM CORP 150IEEE150 200 10IET/IEE75.0 75.0 5.028 Emerson Electric Co. 146IEEE146 619 89RELX Group (Elsevier)23.6 23.6 14.429 Harris Corp. 146IEEE146 169 11American Institute of Physics86.4 86.4 6.530 Battelle Memorial Institute 143IEEE143 193 19IEEE/RSJ74.1 74.1 9.831 Boeing Co. (The) 133IEEE133 366 76RELX Group (Elsevier)36.3 36.3 20.832 Johns Hopkins University 132IEEE132 258 21RELX Group (Elsevier)51.2 51.2 8.133 University of Southern Califo 128IEEE128 189 15Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad67.7 67.7 7.934 IWALK INC 127IEEE127 259 38RELX Group (Elsevier)49.0 49.0 14.735 ABB Ltd 126IEEE126 189 20RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 10.636 Fanuc Ltd. 125IEEE125 181 15RELX Group (Elsevier)69.1 69.1 8.337 General Electric Company 124IEEE124 252 17RELX Group (Elsevier)49.2 49.2 6.738 BIONX MEDICAL TECHN 123IEEE123 259 43RELX Group (Elsevier)47.5 47.5 16.639 ROY-G-BIV CORP 123IEEE123 385 67ISO-International Standards Organization31.9 31.9 17.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-34Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 85: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 122IEEE122 219 23IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys55.7 55.7 10.541 Xerox Corp 119IEEE119 273 36ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.6 43.6 13.242 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 116IEEE116 204 16RELX Group (Elsevier)56.9 56.9 7.843 Walt Disney Co. 111IEEE111 239 51ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.4 46.4 21.344 Toshiba Corp 109IEEE109 179 8SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering60.9 60.9 4.545 Fujitsu Limited 108IEEE108 185 14RELX Group (Elsevier)58.4 58.4 7.646 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 108IEEE108 233 8ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.4 46.4 3.447 Amada Holdings Co. Ltd. 104IEEE104 291 64RELX Group (Elsevier)35.7 35.7 22.048 Rockwell Automation Inc 104IEEE104 208 27RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 13.049 Honeywell International Inc. 101IEEE101 241 33RELX Group (Elsevier)41.9 41.9 13.750 Lockheed Martin Corp. 98IEEE98 237 19RELX Group (Elsevier)41.4 41.4 8.051 American Express Co. 96IEEE96 323 39The USENIX Association29.7 29.7 12.152 Tokyo Electron Limited 95IEEE95 240 26RELX Group (Elsevier)39.6 39.6 10.853 NEC Corp 94IEEE94 171 11ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.0 55.0 6.454 CA Inc 92IEEE92 161 37RELX Group (Elsevier)57.1 57.1 23.055 Panasonic Corporation 92IEEE92 179 10IET/IEE51.4 51.4 5.656 Bonutti Technologies LLC 110Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAca91 394 91IEEE23.1 27.9 23.157 3D Systems Corp. 88IEEE88 224 40ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.3 39.3 17.958 HP Inc 87IEEE87 214 25ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.7 40.7 11.759 GENESIS ROBOTICS LLP 85IEEE85 109 5World Academy of Science Engineering and Technology78.0 78.0 4.660 University of Washington 84IEEE84 192 17RELX Group (Elsevier)43.8 43.8 8.961 ALOFT MEDIA LLC 82IEEE82 102 6ASCE-AMER SOC CIVIL ENGINEERS80.4 80.4 5.962 Johnson & Johnson 128RELX Group (Elsevier)82 593 91John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss13.8 21.6 15.363 Sap SE 77IEEE77 279 48RELX Group (Elsevier)27.6 27.6 17.264 ARCHI CON DES INVENTI 115ACM-Assoc Comput Mach76 377 76IEEE20.2 30.5 20.265 Rethink Robotics Inc 76IEEE76 122 16RELX Group (Elsevier)62.3 62.3 13.166 ZOOX INC 73IEEE73 99 9SAGE Publications73.7 73.7 9.167 MKS Instruments Inc. 72IEEE72 170 27John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss42.4 42.4 15.968 General Motors Corp 71IEEE71 175 19RELX Group (Elsevier)40.6 40.6 10.969 HURCO COMPANIES INC 71IEEE71 166 19Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad42.8 42.8 11.470 Health Discovery Corp 70IEEE70 281 24IWDM Org24.9 24.9 8.571 Texas Instruments Inc 70IEEE70 129 13Penton Media, Inc.54.3 54.3 10.172 Cirrus Logic Inc. 69IEEE69 91 14RELX Group (Elsevier)75.8 75.8 15.473 Kuka AG 69IEEE69 92 7IEEE/RSJ75.0 75.0 7.674 Toyota Motor Corp 68IEEE68 141 14RELX Group (Elsevier)48.2 48.2 9.975 AUREON LABORATORIES 67IEEE67 273 35RELX Group (Elsevier)24.5 24.5 12.876 United Technologies Corp 66IEEE66 98 7EPE Association67.3 67.3 7.177 Canon Inc 65IEEE65 168 20SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering38.7 38.7 11.978 Tela Innovations inc 65IEEE65 158 49SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering41.1 41.1 31.079 Arizona State University 64IEEE64 105 7RELX Group (Elsevier)61.0 61.0 6.780 Ford Motor Co. 63IEEE63 169 24Winter Simulation Conference Board of Directors37.3 37.3 14.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-35Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 86: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Georgia Institute of Technolo 63IEEE63 119 22American Automatic Control Council (AACC)52.9 52.9 18.582 Oracle Corporation 61IEEE61 115 17ACM-Assoc Comput Mach53.0 53.0 14.883 Nokia Corp 60IEEE60 106 7ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.6 56.6 6.684 TEST ADVANTAGE INC 60IEEE60 70 4SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering85.7 85.7 5.785 Motorola Solutions Inc. 59IEEE59 83 4ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)71.1 71.1 4.886 University of California 59IEEE59 118 12RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 10.287 Procter & Gamble Co. 58IEEE58 91 8RELX Group (Elsevier)63.7 63.7 8.888 The Invention Science Fund 57IEEE57 308 43RELX Group (Elsevier)18.5 18.5 14.089 Delphi Automotive PLC 56IEEE56 136 40RELX Group (Elsevier)41.2 41.2 29.490 Brooks Automation Inc. 54IEEE54 120 10RELX Group (Elsevier)45.0 45.0 8.391 KNOWMTECH LLC 98American Institute of Physics54 495 92ACS-Am Chem Soc10.9 19.8 18.692 Raytheon Co. 53IEEE53 157 17SAGE Publications33.8 33.8 10.893 Agilent Technologies Inc 52IEEE52 100 8American Association for Clinical Chemistry, Inc.52.0 52.0 8.094 California Institute of Techno 52IEEE52 83 4John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss62.7 62.7 4.895 Deere & Co. 51IEEE51 100 11RELX Group (Elsevier)51.0 51.0 11.096 United States Navy 51IEEE51 94 7IEEE/RSJ54.3 54.3 7.497 INTUITION INTELLIGENC 50IEEE50 60 3Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad83.3 83.3 5.098 Eaton Corp. 49IEEE49 52 2IET/IEE94.2 94.2 3.899 Micron Technology Inc. 49IEEE49 85 13American Institute of Physics57.6 57.6 15.3

100 University of Minnesota (The 49IEEE49 88 9Emerald Group Publishing Ltd.55.7 55.7 10.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-36Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 87: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Semiconductors/Solid-State Devices/Electronics1 Micron Technology Inc. 23713IEEE23713 85180 15283RELX Group (Elsevier)27.8 27.8 17.92 Semiconductor Energy Labor 33857SID-Society for Information Display9711 1E+05 19620American Institute of Physics8.7 30.4 17.63 International Business Machi 8359IEEE8359 19181 3023American Institute of Physics43.6 43.6 15.84 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 7328IEEE7328 13017 1382IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.3 56.3 10.65 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 6776IEEE6776 20310 6392American Institute of Physics33.4 33.4 31.56 Macronix International Co. L 4600IEEE4600 8730 1634IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys52.7 52.7 18.77 Tela Innovations inc 5066SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering4395 14422 4395IEEE30.5 35.1 30.58 Intel Corporation 4369IEEE4369 8202 927American Institute of Physics53.3 53.3 11.39 Cree Inc. 3893IEEE3893 10965 2514American Institute of Physics35.5 35.5 22.9

10 Western Digital Corp. 3631IEEE3631 7217 902American Institute of Physics50.3 50.3 12.511 Chipbond Technology Corp 2897IEEE2897 3630 268RELX Group (Elsevier)79.8 79.8 7.412 Texas Instruments Inc 2610IEEE2610 4880 570American Institute of Physics53.5 53.5 11.713 On Semiconductor Corporati 2568IEEE2568 3463 249RELX Group (Elsevier)74.2 74.2 7.214 Infineon Technologies AG 2552IEEE2552 5112 713American Institute of Physics49.9 49.9 13.915 NXP Semiconductors NV 2366IEEE2366 4854 778American Institute of Physics48.7 48.7 16.016 Amberwave Inc 2335IEEE2335 6826 2045American Institute of Physics34.2 34.2 30.017 Toshiba Corp 2171IEEE2171 5376 853American Institute of Physics40.4 40.4 15.918 Broadcom Ltd 2154IEEE2154 6388 1017SMTA-Surface Mount Technology Association33.7 33.7 15.919 Applied Materials Inc. 2716American Institute of Physics2101 12280 2101IEEE17.1 22.1 17.120 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 1920IEEE1920 2680 120American Institute of Physics71.6 71.6 4.521 University of Illinois 4074American Institute of Physics1875 17700 2686ACS-Am Chem Soc10.6 23.0 15.222 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 1620IEEE1620 3052 335American Institute of Physics53.1 53.1 11.023 Fujitsu Limited 1482IEEE1482 3747 577American Institute of Physics39.6 39.6 15.424 STMicroelectronics 1459IEEE1459 3279 453RELX Group (Elsevier)44.5 44.5 13.825 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 1278IEEE1278 5963 1220American Institute of Physics21.4 21.4 20.526 Innovative Network Corporat 1277IEEE1277 2431 282IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys52.5 52.5 11.627 University of California 3538American Institute of Physics1273 13276 1769RELX Group (Elsevier)9.6 26.6 13.328 Global Foundries Inc 1259IEEE1259 2494 373American Institute of Physics50.5 50.5 15.029 California Institute of Techno 1184IEEE1184 7082 1134American Institute of Physics16.7 16.7 16.030 Finisar Corp 1140IEEE1140 3269 611American Institute of Physics34.9 34.9 18.731 Motorola Solutions Inc. 1134IEEE1134 3513 848American Institute of Physics32.3 32.3 24.132 Panasonic Corporation 1131IEEE1131 5146 955American Institute of Physics22.0 22.0 18.633 Qualcomm Inc 1126IEEE1126 2307 201American Institute of Physics48.8 48.8 8.734 Qorvo 1045IEEE1045 1480 198American Institute of Physics70.6 70.6 13.435 Transphorm Inc 1028IEEE1028 2039 389American Institute of Physics50.4 50.4 19.136 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 991IEEE991 2073 232American Institute of Physics47.8 47.8 11.237 Massachusetts Institute of Te 1459American Institute of Physics941 6550 941IEEE14.4 22.3 14.438 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 918IEEE918 1511 123American Institute of Physics60.8 60.8 8.139 NEC Corp 899IEEE899 2454 409American Institute of Physics36.6 36.6 16.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-37Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 88: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 PDF Solutions 885IEEE885 1303 343SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering67.9 67.9 26.341 Commissariat A L'Energie At 1091American Institute of Physics884 4708 884IEEE18.8 23.2 18.842 HRL Laboratories LLC 861IEEE861 1779 317American Institute of Physics48.4 48.4 17.843 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 784IEEE784 2620 632American Institute of Physics29.9 29.9 24.144 Synopsys Inc. 752IEEE752 1643 280American Institute of Physics45.8 45.8 17.045 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 970American Institute of Physics713 3640 713IEEE19.6 26.6 19.646 ASM International N.V. 1453RELX Group (Elsevier)712 6588 1433American Institute of Physics10.8 22.1 21.847 Hitachi Ltd 684IEEE684 2304 449American Institute of Physics29.7 29.7 19.548 Lam Research Corp. 966American Institute of Physics659 3745 659IEEE17.6 25.8 17.649 Crossbar Inc 635IEEE635 2260 330American Institute of Physics28.1 28.1 14.650 Analog Devices Inc. 582IEEE582 899 70RELX Group (Elsevier)64.7 64.7 7.851 SK Hynix Inc 566IEEE566 1091 124American Institute of Physics51.9 51.9 11.452 Unisantis Electronics Ltd 553IEEE553 633 36RELX Group (Elsevier)87.4 87.4 5.753 Nokia Corp 564American Institute of Physics552 2792 552IEEE19.8 20.2 19.854 Michigan State University 1522Optical Society of America541 6878 1071American Institute of Physics7.9 22.1 15.655 Mevion Medical Systems Inc 527IEEE527 1833 388RELX Group (Elsevier)28.8 28.8 21.256 Industrial Techology Researc 490IEEE490 1391 213American Institute of Physics35.2 35.2 15.357 Aisin Seiki Co. Ltd. 1235Optical Society of America481 3328 481IEEE14.5 37.1 14.558 Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc 788RELX Group (Elsevier)480 2357 480IEEE20.4 33.4 20.459 Interuniversity MicroElectron 473IEEE473 1422 242American Institute of Physics33.3 33.3 17.060 Innovative Silicon SA 453IEEE453 556 24RELX Group (Elsevier)81.5 81.5 4.361 Maxim Integrated Products In 448IEEE448 551 19Joint IEEE and ACM81.3 81.3 3.462 Sulvolta Inc 448IEEE448 930 139American Institute of Physics48.2 48.2 14.963 Electronics and Telecommuni 444IEEE444 1252 291American Institute of Physics35.5 35.5 23.264 Hong Kong University of Sci 442IEEE442 823 164American Institute of Physics53.7 53.7 19.965 Canon Inc 929American Institute of Physics431 3768 532RELX Group (Elsevier)11.4 24.7 14.166 Nantero Inc 2087ACS-Am Chem Soc426 6975 1517American Institute of Physics6.1 29.9 21.767 Power Integrations Inc. 423IEEE423 625 58INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS67.7 67.7 9.368 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 418IEEE418 1175 187American Institute of Physics35.6 35.6 15.969 Lockheed Martin Corp. 525American Institute of Physics413 2274 413IEEE18.2 23.1 18.270 ZENO SEMICONDUCTOR I 402IEEE402 517 94IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys77.8 77.8 18.271 Xerox Corp 667American Institute of Physics400 2325 400IEEE17.2 28.7 17.272 Partners HealthCare Systems 2200Optical Society of America384 5937 829RELX Group (Elsevier)6.5 37.1 14.073 Sony Corp 383American Institute of Physics381 1768 381IEEE21.5 21.7 21.574 Seiko Epson Corporation 375IEEE375 1530 269American Institute of Physics24.5 24.5 17.675 Xtera Communications Inc. 375IEEE375 1111 263Optical Society of America33.8 33.8 23.776 Georgia Institute of Technolo 374IEEE374 1110 158American Institute of Physics33.7 33.7 14.277 Apple Inc 367IEEE367 711 75American Institute of Physics51.6 51.6 10.578 University of Wisconsin 436American Institute of Physics362 1511 362IEEE24.0 28.9 24.079 Soraa Inc 1484American Institute of Physics355 4733 865INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS7.5 31.4 18.380 Jiangsu ChangJiang Electroni 348IEEE348 447 49International Microelectronics And Packaging Society77.9 77.9 11.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-38Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 89: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 Viavi Solutions Inc 374American Institute of Physics347 1077 347IEEE32.2 34.7 32.282 United States Navy 524American Institute of Physics337 1855 337IEEE18.2 28.2 18.283 General Electric Company 330IEEE330 1329 230American Institute of Physics24.8 24.8 17.384 Silicon Genesis Corporation 330IEEE330 1611 328RELX Group (Elsevier)20.5 20.5 20.485 Soitec SA 486American Institute of Physics330 1768 330IEEE18.7 27.5 18.786 Columbia University 1522American Institute of Physics325 4085 436MRS-Materials Research Soc8.0 37.3 10.787 United Microelectronics Corp 325IEEE325 676 82IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys48.1 48.1 12.188 Vishay Intertechnology Inc. 323IEEE323 486 24RELX Group (Elsevier)66.5 66.5 4.989 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 316IEEE316 536 93RELX Group (Elsevier)59.0 59.0 17.490 HP Inc 470American Institute of Physics312 1961 312IEEE15.9 24.0 15.991 Honeywell International Inc. 424ACS-Am Chem Soc307 2004 307IEEE15.3 21.2 15.392 University of Michigan 321American Institute of Physics301 1468 301IEEE20.5 21.9 20.593 Total SA 299IEEE299 493 53WIP-Renewable Energies60.6 60.6 10.894 Fuji Electric Holdings Co. Lt 297IEEE297 540 62American Institute of Physics55.0 55.0 11.595 TDK Corporation 295IEEE295 1141 291American Institute of Physics25.9 25.9 25.596 Xilinx Inc. 287IEEE287 414 25IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys69.3 69.3 6.097 ZENA TECHNOLOGIES IN 287IEEE287 1105 233American Institute of Physics26.0 26.0 21.198 Raytheon Co. 283IEEE283 1091 189American Institute of Physics25.9 25.9 17.399 Emcore Corp. 281IEEE281 562 83American Institute of Physics50.0 50.0 14.8

100 Coherent Inc. 439American Institute of Physics278 2169 424Optical Society of America12.8 20.2 19.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-39Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 90: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Smart Grid/Smart Meters/Energy Infrastructure1 Velatia Group 839IEEE839 1125 81Echelon Corp74.6 74.6 7.22 Honeywell International Inc. 234IEEE234 279 10Joint IEEE and ACM83.9 83.9 3.63 TRILLIANT NETWORKS I 218IEEE218 320 18Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force68.1 68.1 5.64 SIPCO LLC 155IEEE155 269 27Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force57.6 57.6 10.05 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 152IEEE152 175 13WIP-Renewable Energies86.9 86.9 7.46 ABB Ltd 109IEEE109 133 6IET/IEE82.0 82.0 4.57 General Electric Company 80IEEE80 123 11IET/IEE65.0 65.0 8.98 Alstom 69IEEE69 83 9IET/IEE83.1 83.1 10.89 Battelle Memorial Institute 56IEEE56 82 6ACM-Assoc Comput Mach68.3 68.3 7.3

10 SOLAREEDGE TECHNOLO 55IEEE55 68 7WIP-Renewable Energies80.9 80.9 10.311 Qualcomm Inc 46IEEE46 69 53GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body66.7 66.7 7.212 International Business Machi 37IEEE37 61 5IP.Com60.7 60.7 8.213 3M Co 36IEEE36 44 3AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro81.8 81.8 6.814 ASTROLINK INTERNATIO 36IEEE36 42 4IET/IEE85.7 85.7 9.515 DOMINION ENERGY TEC 36IEEE36 42 4IET/IEE85.7 85.7 9.516 Itron Inc. 35IEEE35 62 8Joint IEEE and ACM56.5 56.5 12.917 Witricity Corp 32IEEE32 36 3American Institute of Physics88.9 88.9 8.318 Microsoft Corporation 31IEEE31 63 11ACM-Assoc Comput Mach49.2 49.2 17.519 Georgia Institute of Technolo 47ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28 83 28IEEE33.7 56.6 33.720 Texas A&M University 28IEEE28 35 3IET/IEE80.0 80.0 8.621 Total SA 28IEEE28 32 4EPE Association87.5 87.5 12.522 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 27IEEE27 51 11United Business Media/UBM Tech52.9 52.9 21.623 AMPT LLC 26IEEE26 28 2IET/IEE92.9 92.9 7.124 ENERGY TECHNOLOGY G 26IEEE26 30 2RELX Group (Elsevier)86.7 86.7 6.725 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 21IEEE21 39 15Elecrostatic Discharge Association53.8 53.8 38.526 SPARQ SYSTEMS INC 20IEEE20 25 3RELX Group (Elsevier)80.0 80.0 12.027 TEMPORAL POWER LTD 20IEEE20 20 100.0 100.028 ConvergeOne Inc 19IEEE19 21 1Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force90.5 90.5 4.829 Schneider Electric S.A. 27ANSI-American National Standards Institute19 102 19IEEE18.6 26.5 18.630 Commscope Inc. 18IEEE18 18 100.0 100.031 Rockwell Automation Inc 18IEEE18 25 3IET/IEE72.0 72.0 12.032 New Jersey Institute of Techn 17IEEE17 17 100.0 100.033 Massachusetts Institute of Te 16IEEE16 22 4AMER SOC NAVAL ENG INC72.7 72.7 18.234 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 15IEEE15 16 1Hindawi Publishing Corporation93.8 93.8 6.335 Sony Corp 24SID-Society for Information Display13 44 13IEEE29.5 54.5 29.536 AT&T Inc 12IEEE12 14 1John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss85.7 85.7 7.137 Johnson Controls Internation 12IEEE12 13 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC)92.3 92.3 7.738 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 12IEEE12 12 100.0 100.039 Panasonic Corporation 11IEEE11 14 2IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng78.6 78.6 14.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-40Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 91: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 THE DETROIT EDISON CO 11IEEE11 11 100.0 100.041 Elwha LLC 10IEEE10 18 3RELX Group (Elsevier)55.6 55.6 16.742 Google Inc. 10IEEE10 17 1Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force58.8 58.8 5.943 NORWEB PLC 10IEEE10 27 5Pennwell Pub37.0 37.0 18.544 Roche Holding Ltd. 10IEEE10 10 100.0 100.045 University of Missouri 10IEEE10 11 1Summit Technical Media90.9 90.9 9.146 Accenture Ltd. 9IEEE9 13 3A B B Corporate Management Services AG69.2 69.2 23.147 Belkin International Inc 16ACM-Assoc Comput Mach9 33 9IEEE27.3 48.5 27.348 Cisco Systems Inc. 9IEEE9 13 4Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force69.2 69.2 30.849 INTERNATIONAL BROAD 9IEEE9 17 6ISO-International Standards Organization52.9 52.9 35.350 Nokia Corp 9IEEE9 15 2Joint IEEE and ACM60.0 60.0 13.351 RADAR ENGINEERS 9IEEE9 10 1Penton Media, Inc.90.0 90.0 10.052 Tigo Energy Inc 9IEEE9 13 3WIP-Renewable Energies69.2 69.2 23.153 University of Wisconsin 9IEEE9 10 1MONTANA HISTORICAL SOC90.0 90.0 10.054 LSIS Co Ltd (Formerly LS In 8IEEE8 9 1EPE Association88.9 88.9 11.155 The Invention Science Fund 8IEEE8 15 4ANSI-American National Standards Institute53.3 53.3 26.756 Clemson University 7IEEE7 9 1ACS-Am Chem Soc77.8 77.8 11.157 CURRENT GRID LLC 7IEEE7 11 2Echelon Corp63.6 63.6 18.258 CURRENT TECHNOLOGIE 7IEEE7 12 2Hewlett-Packard Company58.3 58.3 16.759 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 8Elecrostatic Discharge Association7 15 7IEEE46.7 53.3 46.760 Hubbell Inc. 7IEEE7 9 1Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI)77.8 77.8 11.161 POWER TAGGING TECHN 7IEEE7 8 1IET/IEE87.5 87.5 12.562 STMicroelectronics 7IEEE7 12 3John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss58.3 58.3 25.063 Toshiba Corp 7IEEE7 12 2Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force58.3 58.3 16.764 Boeing Co. (The) 6IEEE6 12 1Trans Tech Publications Ltd.50.0 50.0 8.365 Danfoss A/S 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.066 Eaton Corp. 6IEEE6 10 2IET/IEE60.0 60.0 20.067 King Fahd University of Petr 6IEEE6 9 3United Business Media/UBM Tech66.7 66.7 33.368 STEM INC 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.069 TACTILIS SDN BHD 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.070 University of Oxford 6IEEE6 6 100.0 100.071 UT-Battelle LLC 12Electrochemical Society, Inc.6 38 12RELX Group (Elsevier)15.8 31.6 31.672 Canon Inc 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.073 COM/ENERGY TECHNOL 6Reed Business5 16 5IEEE31.3 37.5 31.374 DGI CREATIONS LLC 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.075 D-Wave Systems Inc. 8American Physical Society5 29 5American Institute of Physics17.2 27.6 17.276 Fujitsu Limited 5IEEE5 15 4ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.3 33.3 26.777 Korea Electrotechnology Res 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.078 Nth Degree Technologies Wo 5IEEE5 9 4American Institute of Physics55.6 55.6 44.479 On Semiconductor Corporati 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.080 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 5IEEE5 19 3ACS-Am Chem Soc26.3 26.3 15.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-41Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 92: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 State University of New York 5IEEE5 6 1RELX Group (Elsevier)83.3 83.3 16.782 University of Alberta 5IEEE5 8 1RELX Group (Elsevier)62.5 62.5 12.583 University of Connecticut 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.084 Digimarc Corp. 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.085 Hello Inc 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.086 HUDSON BAY WIRELESS 4IEEE4 5 1Condé Nast80.0 80.0 20.087 LUMIRADX UK LTD 4IEEE4 5 1Bluetooth Special Interest Group80.0 80.0 20.088 National Instruments Corp. 4IEEE4 6 2RELX Group (Elsevier)66.7 66.7 33.389 Northeastern University (Bost 4IEEE4 8 2International Network for Scientific Information Publication (I50.0 50.0 25.090 TX RX SYSTEMS INC 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.091 ACEX TECHNOLOGIES IN 3IEEE3 4 1Penton Media, Inc.75.0 75.0 25.092 American Superconductor Co 5RELX Group (Elsevier)3 8 3IEEE37.5 62.5 37.593 ASOKA USA CORP 3IEEE3 4 1National Association of Industrial Technology75.0 75.0 25.094 BAE Systems Plc. 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.095 Bayer AG 3IEEE3 4 1International Telecommunication Union75.0 75.0 25.096 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.097 Digi International Inc 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.098 DSP Group Inc 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.099 Electric Power Research Insti 6Electric Power Research Institute3 9 3IEEE33.3 66.7 33.3

100 Electro Industries Gauge Tec 5ACM-Assoc Comput Mach3 12 3IEEE25.0 41.7 25.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-42Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 93: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Solar/Photovoltaic1 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 992IEEE992 1174 105WIP-Renewable Energies84.5 84.5 8.92 Total SA 544IEEE544 770 60WIP-Renewable Energies70.6 70.6 7.83 Emcore Corp. 246IEEE246 478 76US Dept of Energy51.5 51.5 15.94 Tigo Energy Inc 243IEEE243 343 75WIP-Renewable Energies70.8 70.8 21.95 University of Illinois 516American Institute of Physics237 2559 457ACS-Am Chem Soc9.3 20.2 17.96 Sanan Optoelectronics Techn 245US Dept of Energy209 555 209IEEE37.7 44.1 37.77 Taiwan Semiconductor Manu 333American Institute of Physics189 821 189IEEE23.0 40.6 23.08 SolAero Technologies Corp 188IEEE188 337 61American Institute of Physics55.8 55.8 18.19 International Business Machi 180IEEE180 721 155American Institute of Physics25.0 25.0 21.5

10 AMPT LLC 177IEEE177 206 12IET/IEE85.9 85.9 5.811 SEMPRIUS INC 319American Institute of Physics150 1692 307ACS-Am Chem Soc8.9 18.9 18.112 Xerox Corp 150IEEE150 481 88RELX Group (Elsevier)31.2 31.2 18.313 Solexel Inc 180RELX Group (Elsevier)132 558 132IEEE23.7 32.3 23.714 Hanergy Holding Group Ltd 120IEEE120 362 58RELX Group (Elsevier)33.1 33.1 16.015 Solar Junction Corp 152American Institute of Physics102 485 121RELX Group (Elsevier)21.0 31.3 24.916 Tesla Motors Inc 90IEEE90 126 8American Institute of Physics71.4 71.4 6.317 Canon Inc 88IEEE88 241 48American Institute of Physics36.5 36.5 19.918 Advanced Energy Industries I 84IEEE84 91 4IET/IEE92.3 92.3 4.419 Lockheed Martin Corp. 82IEEE82 286 63American Institute of Physics28.7 28.7 22.020 Applied Materials Inc. 79IEEE79 240 51WIP-Renewable Energies32.9 32.9 21.321 Massachusetts Institute of Te 78IEEE78 316 58American Institute of Physics24.7 24.7 18.422 Stion Corp 225RELX Group (Elsevier)77 671 146American Institute of Physics11.5 33.5 21.823 Alliance for Sustainable Ener 161American Institute of Physics75 512 105RELX Group (Elsevier)14.6 31.4 20.524 Solyndra Inc 117RELX Group (Elsevier)68 361 68IEEE18.8 32.4 18.825 Nanosolar Inc 248RELX Group (Elsevier)61 873 107Electrochemical Society, Inc.7.0 28.4 12.326 General Electric Company 83ACS-Am Chem Soc52 314 52IEEE16.6 26.4 16.627 ZENA TECHNOLOGIES IN 49IEEE49 120 35American Institute of Physics40.8 40.8 29.228 Dartmouth College 48IEEE48 58 4RELX Group (Elsevier)82.8 82.8 6.929 EVERGREEN SOLAR INC 48IEEE48 97 44ACS-Am Chem Soc49.5 49.5 45.430 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 47IEEE47 190 37RELX Group (Elsevier)24.7 24.7 19.531 Texas Instruments Inc 47IEEE47 59 4Electrochemical Society, Inc.79.7 79.7 6.832 SUNIVA INC 45IEEE45 88 12WIP-Renewable Energies51.1 51.1 13.633 First Solar Inc 90RELX Group (Elsevier)44 200 44IEEE22.0 45.0 22.034 California Institute of Techno 119American Institute of Physics43 364 43IEEE11.8 32.7 11.835 JXTG Holdings Inc 39IEEE39 130 30RELX Group (Elsevier)30.0 30.0 23.136 LG Electronics Inc. 39IEEE39 118 23American Institute of Physics33.1 33.1 19.537 University of Toledo 79RELX Group (Elsevier)37 137 37IEEE27.0 57.7 27.038 Boeing Co. (The) 36IEEE36 118 22RELX Group (Elsevier)30.5 30.5 18.639 Witricity Corp 36IEEE36 67 6American Institute of Physics53.7 53.7 9.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-43Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 94: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 APOLLO PRECISION FUJI 35IEEE35 47 5RELX Group (Elsevier)74.5 74.5 10.641 4POWER LLC 34IEEE34 66 18American Institute of Physics51.5 51.5 27.342 Ignis Innovation Inc 34IEEE34 41 4SID-Society for Information Display82.9 82.9 9.843 Panasonic Corporation 52American Institute of Physics34 185 34RELX Group (Elsevier)18.4 28.1 18.444 Azur Space Solar Power Gmb 31IEEE31 83 21RELX Group (Elsevier)37.3 37.3 25.345 University of California 114American Institute of Physics31 652 107ACS-Am Chem Soc4.8 17.5 16.446 Commissariat A L'Energie At 74RELX Group (Elsevier)29 182 29IEEE15.9 40.7 15.947 Solarworld AG 29IEEE29 73 16John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss39.7 39.7 21.948 Ostendo Technologies Inc 28IEEE28 78 23RELX Group (Elsevier)35.9 35.9 29.549 AMI RESAERCH & DEVEL 27IEEE27 65 8John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss41.5 41.5 12.350 Koch Industries Inc 120RELX Group (Elsevier)27 309 83American Institute of Physics8.7 38.8 26.951 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 27IEEE27 51 8WIP-Renewable Energies52.9 52.9 15.752 Arizona State University 36American Institute of Physics26 119 26IEEE21.8 30.3 21.853 DowDuPont 94RELX Group (Elsevier)26 285 59American Institute of Physics9.1 33.0 20.754 GTAT Corp (AT Advanced T 26IEEE26 126 25American Institute of Physics20.6 20.6 19.855 Teijin Ltd. 26IEEE26 68 11WIP-Renewable Energies38.2 38.2 16.256 The National Aeronautical an 26IEEE26 194 20Optical Society of America13.4 13.4 10.357 Imperial College 25IEEE25 76 23American Institute of Physics32.9 32.9 30.358 Midwest Research Institute 26RELX Group (Elsevier)25 95 25IEEE26.3 27.4 26.359 Raytheon Co. 25IEEE25 52 6American Institute of Physics48.1 48.1 11.560 United States Navy 25IEEE25 118 19RELX Group (Elsevier)21.2 21.2 16.161 Interuniversity MicroElectron 24IEEE24 95 20RELX Group (Elsevier)25.3 25.3 21.162 Semiconductor Energy Labor 141SID-Society for Information Display24 393 61American Institute of Physics6.1 35.9 15.563 Compagnie de Saint-Gobain 30SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering23 121 26RELX Group (Elsevier)19.0 24.8 21.564 Precursor Energetics Inc 481ACS-Am Chem Soc23 1095 237RELX Group (Elsevier)2.1 43.9 21.665 Solopower Inc 101RELX Group (Elsevier)23 211 43American Institute of Physics10.9 47.9 20.466 Hanwha Q-Cells GmbH 22IEEE22 56 11American Institute of Physics39.3 39.3 19.667 Qualcomm Inc 22IEEE22 65 11SID-Society for Information Display33.8 33.8 16.968 City University of Hong Kon 21IEEE21 38 12IET/IEE55.3 55.3 31.669 Nth Degree Technologies Wo 20Optical Society of America20 163 20IEEE12.3 12.3 12.370 Ebara Corp. 19IEEE19 37 7RELX Group (Elsevier)51.4 51.4 18.971 Toshiba Corp 19IEEE19 84 16ACS-Am Chem Soc22.6 22.6 19.072 United States of America De 19IEEE19 69 16American Institute of Physics27.5 27.5 23.273 ATHENAEUM LLC 30RELX Group (Elsevier)18 104 18IEEE17.3 28.8 17.374 CLEAN POWER RESEARC 18IEEE18 29 8RELX Group (Elsevier)62.1 62.1 27.675 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 18IEEE18 72 17WIP-Renewable Energies25.0 25.0 23.676 Industrial Techology Researc 44RELX Group (Elsevier)18 143 18ACS-Am Chem Soc12.6 30.8 12.677 Laird Group Plc 18IEEE18 63 16American Institute of Physics28.6 28.6 25.478 New Jersey Institute of Techn 18IEEE18 23 3American Institute of Physics78.3 78.3 13.079 Shin-Etsu Chemical Co. Ltd. 18IEEE18 49 8RELX Group (Elsevier)36.7 36.7 16.380 University of Michigan 53American Institute of Physics18 219 38ACS-Am Chem Soc8.2 24.2 17.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-44Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 95: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 ASCENT SOLAR TECHNO 17IEEE17 43 11RELX Group (Elsevier)39.5 39.5 25.682 TESLA INC 17IEEE17 67 16WIP-Renewable Energies25.4 25.4 23.983 Georgia Institute of Technolo 16IEEE16 33 5John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss48.5 48.5 15.284 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 16IEEE16 41 11RELX Group (Elsevier)39.0 39.0 26.885 SMA Solar Technology AG 16IEEE16 17 1IET/IEE94.1 94.1 5.986 Toyota Motor Corp 16IEEE16 62 12RELX Group (Elsevier)25.8 25.8 19.487 1366 TECHNOLOGIES INC 45RELX Group (Elsevier)15 87 15IEEE17.2 51.7 17.288 Intevac Inc 24American Institute of Physics15 72 15IEEE20.8 33.3 20.889 Solfocus Inc 15RELX Group (Elsevier)15 59 15IEEE25.4 25.4 25.490 University of Houston 15IEEE15 62 12American Institute of Physics24.2 24.2 19.491 ARCHITECTURAL GLASS 14RELX Group (Elsevier)14 42 14IEEE33.3 33.3 33.392 Kyocera Corp. 14IEEE14 57 11American Institute of Physics24.6 24.6 19.393 ROSESTREET LABS ENER 17American Institute of Physics14 44 14IEEE31.8 38.6 31.894 Showa Shell Sekiyu KK 14IEEE14 28 4RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 14.395 Sony Corp 20RELX Group (Elsevier)14 86 14IEEE16.3 23.3 16.396 Centre National De La Reche 39RELX Group (Elsevier)13 133 21ACS-Am Chem Soc9.8 29.3 15.897 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 19American Institute of Physics13 113 16RELX Group (Elsevier)11.5 16.8 14.298 China National Chemical Cor 12IEEE12 21 3American Institute of Physics57.1 57.1 14.399 Hitachi Ltd 12IEEE12 41 8Hitachi Ltd29.3 29.3 19.5

100 Stanford University 22American Institute of Physics12 97 17ACS-Am Chem Soc12.4 22.7 17.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-45Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 96: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Telecom and Other Communications1 Qualcomm Inc 24433IEEE24433 58614 140903GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.7 41.7 24.02 Broadcom Ltd 17028IEEE17028 26001 1161International Telecommunication Union65.5 65.5 4.53 Marvell Technology Group Lt 16907IEEE16907 21544 30013GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body78.5 78.5 13.94 Microsoft Corporation 14034IEEE14034 31248 4589ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.9 44.9 14.75 Nokia Corp 12200IEEE12200 30700 72273GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body39.7 39.7 23.56 AT&T Inc 10877IEEE10877 22399 1350ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.6 48.6 6.07 InterDigital Inc 248933GPP General Partnership Project Standards 10497 40131 10497IEEE26.2 62.0 26.28 Ericsson 114533GPP General Partnership Project Standards 10300 31376 10300IEEE32.8 36.5 32.89 Intel Corporation 10101IEEE10101 19981 42983GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body50.6 50.6 21.5

10 ParkerVision Inc 9929IEEE9929 19551 4586IET/IEE50.8 50.8 23.511 Personalized Media Commun 12048Society of Motion Picture and Television Engi6764 40751 6764IEEE16.6 29.6 16.612 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 6742IEEE6742 16124 50863GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.8 41.8 31.513 Cisco Systems Inc. 6736IEEE6736 22714 4038Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force29.7 29.7 17.814 LG Electronics Inc. 172563GPP General Partnership Project Standards 6249 29754 6249IEEE21.0 58.0 21.015 International Business Machi 6242IEEE6242 15141 2142ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.2 41.2 14.116 Sony Corp 5535IEEE5535 11380 11413GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body48.6 48.6 10.017 Apple Inc 5484IEEE5484 11570 921ACM-Assoc Comput Mach47.4 47.4 8.018 Panasonic Corporation 5370IEEE5370 15051 40943GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body35.7 35.7 27.219 Fractus SA 4721IEEE4721 8100 1182IET/IEE58.3 58.3 14.620 Massachusetts Institute of Te 4679IEEE4679 8040 387Optical Society of America58.2 58.2 4.821 Huawei Technologies Compa 81733GPP General Partnership Project Standards 4640 19067 4640IEEE24.3 42.9 24.322 Fujitsu Limited 4375IEEE4375 11640 23633GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body37.6 37.6 20.323 Adaptix 4353IEEE4353 6322 683European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)68.9 68.9 10.824 Blackberry Ltd. 75973GPP General Partnership Project Standards 3902 15846 3902IEEE24.6 47.9 24.625 Texas Instruments Inc 3843IEEE3843 5725 4683GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body67.1 67.1 8.226 Nippon Telegraph & Telepho 3800IEEE3800 11285 36773GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body33.7 33.7 32.627 RPX Corp 3647IEEE3647 8520 840IEEE/OSA42.8 42.8 9.928 Google Inc. 3614IEEE3614 10097 1085ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.8 35.8 10.729 NEC Corp 3282IEEE3282 9522 30803GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body34.5 34.5 32.330 Commscope Inc. 3144IEEE3144 4842 4253GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body64.9 64.9 8.831 Rambus Inc. 3136IEEE3136 4416 196International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)71.0 71.0 4.432 University of Minnesota (The 3113IEEE3113 3440 47John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss90.5 90.5 1.433 Conversant Intellectual Prope 2943IEEE2943 5480 216Primedia Business Magazines & Media Inc.53.7 53.7 3.934 Electronics and Telecommuni 2896IEEE2896 4850 5763GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body59.7 59.7 11.935 Raytheon Co. 2882IEEE2882 4816 206IET/IEE59.8 59.8 4.336 Motorola Solutions Inc. 2858IEEE2858 4852 3423GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body58.9 58.9 7.037 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 2737IEEE2737 3612 103John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss75.8 75.8 2.938 Verizon Communications Inc 2618IEEE2618 6970 1224Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force37.6 37.6 17.639 REARDEN LLC 2592IEEE2592 2928 99IET/IEE88.5 88.5 3.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-46Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 97: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 STMicroelectronics 2589IEEE2589 3504 78RELX Group (Elsevier)73.9 73.9 2.241 NXP Semiconductors NV 2510IEEE2510 3350 1043GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body74.9 74.9 3.142 Comcast Corp 2482IEEE2482 4482 6043GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body55.4 55.4 13.543 Technicolor SA 2342IEEE2342 4628 330ISO/IEC50.6 50.6 7.144 Toshiba Corp 2137IEEE2137 4446 305IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng48.1 48.1 6.945 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 2091IEEE2091 4688 7503GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body44.6 44.6 16.046 Digimarc Corp. 2076IEEE2076 5088 578SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering40.8 40.8 11.447 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 2044IEEE2044 3162 161Elettronica e Telecomunicazioni64.6 64.6 5.148 Silicon Laboratories Inc 2009IEEE2009 2563 113Reed Business78.4 78.4 4.449 Honeywell International Inc. 1982IEEE1982 3397 140RELX Group (Elsevier)58.3 58.3 4.150 Columbia University 1948IEEE1948 3235 289ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.2 60.2 8.951 Analog Devices Inc. 1940IEEE1940 2389 72IET/IEE81.2 81.2 3.052 Industrial Techology Researc 1940IEEE1940 2956 2843GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body65.6 65.6 9.653 HP Inc 1888IEEE1888 5572 705Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force33.9 33.9 12.754 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 1869IEEE1869 3586 443SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering52.1 52.1 12.455 Micron Technology Inc. 1780IEEE1780 2905 174IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys61.3 61.3 6.056 Pelican Imaging Corporation 1757IEEE1757 3585 555SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.0 49.0 15.557 Harris Corp. 1742IEEE1742 3068 240Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force56.8 56.8 7.858 SIPCO LLC 1732IEEE1732 2978 234Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force58.2 58.2 7.959 Softbank Corp 1869International Telecommunication Union1714 6440 1714IEEE26.6 29.0 26.660 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 1696IEEE1696 3462 2383GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body49.0 49.0 6.961 TiVo Corp 1675IEEE1675 6158 441ACM-Assoc Comput Mach27.2 27.2 7.262 Hon Hai Precision Industry C 35643GPP General Partnership Project Standards 1668 8372 1668IEEE19.9 42.6 19.963 University of California 1628IEEE1628 2777 119American Institute of Physics58.6 58.6 4.364 Oracle Corporation 1621IEEE1621 5820 6783GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body27.9 27.9 11.665 Innovative Network Corporat 1619IEEE1619 2692 215IEEE/OSA60.1 60.1 8.066 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 1586IEEE1586 3117 263MPEG.org50.9 50.9 8.467 Hitachi Ltd 1536IEEE1536 4285 341IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng35.8 35.8 8.068 Semiconductor Energy Labor 5314SID-Society for Information Display1527 14962 2282American Institute of Physics10.2 35.5 15.369 ARRIS Group Inc 1470IEEE1470 2572 109International Telecommunication Union57.2 57.2 4.270 HRL Laboratories LLC 1470IEEE1470 2464 235IET/IEE59.7 59.7 9.571 Qorvo 1409IEEE1409 1756 78European Microwave Association80.2 80.2 4.472 Juniper Networks Inc. 1378IEEE1378 3961 1011Network Working Group RFC34.8 34.8 25.573 Corning Inc. 1376IEEE1376 2392 223IET/IEE57.5 57.5 9.374 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 1371IEEE1371 2964 2323GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body46.3 46.3 7.875 WI-Lan Inc 1368IEEE1368 2001 108European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)68.4 68.4 5.476 California Institute of Techno 1355IEEE1355 2546 168Optical Society of America53.2 53.2 6.677 L-3 Communications Holdin 1333IEEE1333 1748 89IET/IEE76.3 76.3 5.178 Infineon Technologies AG 1316IEEE1316 1905 883GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body69.1 69.1 4.679 Tabula Inc 1337ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1316 3545 1316IEEE37.1 37.7 37.180 Mediatek Inc. 1289IEEE1289 2134 5653GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body60.4 60.4 26.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-47Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 98: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 LibertyMedia 1252IEEE1252 2093 1443GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body59.8 59.8 6.982 Canon Inc 1205IEEE1205 2882 164International Telecommunication Union41.8 41.8 5.783 Xilinx Inc. 1180IEEE1180 1550 77Joint IEEE and ACM76.1 76.1 5.084 Deutsche Telekom AG 1175IEEE1175 2158 1433GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body54.4 54.4 6.685 Kyocera Corp. 1088IEEE1088 2176 7363GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body50.0 50.0 33.886 MagnaCom Ltd 1072IEEE1072 1133 61AMER TELEPHONE TELEGRAPH CO, 550 MADISON AV94.6 94.6 5.487 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 1072IEEE1072 1906 204IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.2 56.2 10.788 Xerox Corp 1068IEEE1068 2598 675ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.1 41.1 26.089 Dolby Laboratories Inc 1062IEEE1062 3295 752International Telecommunication Union32.2 32.2 22.890 Wisteria Trading Inc 1061IEEE1061 2135 249SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.7 49.7 11.791 Lockheed Martin Corp. 1042IEEE1042 2721 232Optical Society of America38.3 38.3 8.592 Lenovo Group Ltd 17943GPP General Partnership Project Standards 980 3300 980IEEE29.7 54.4 29.793 BT Group PLC 976IEEE976 1998 173Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force48.8 48.8 8.794 Boeing Co. (The) 971IEEE971 1950 79SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.8 49.8 4.195 Microsemi Corp 877IEEE877 1410 95International Telecommunication Union62.2 62.2 6.796 United States Navy 875IEEE875 1670 95American Institute of Physics52.4 52.4 5.797 BAE Systems Plc. 869IEEE869 1138 36SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering76.4 76.4 3.298 Orange 867IEEE867 1612 102Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force53.8 53.8 6.399 Velatia Group 854IEEE854 1131 80Echelon Corp75.5 75.5 7.1

100 Texas A&M University 784IEEE784 893 16IET/IEE87.8 87.8 1.8

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-48Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 99: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

Wind Energy1 Vestas Wind Systems A/S 392IEEE392 814 98AWEA-American Wind Energy Association48.2 48.2 12.02 General Electric Company 128IEEE128 422 116US Dept of Energy30.3 30.3 27.53 ABB Ltd 127IEEE127 228 18EWEA-European Wind Energy Association55.7 55.7 7.94 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 61IEEE61 76 7WIP-Renewable Energies80.3 80.3 9.25 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 59IEEE59 98 8RELX Group (Elsevier)60.2 60.2 8.26 Ingeteam Corporation SA 41IEEE41 66 6EWEA-European Wind Energy Association62.1 62.1 9.17 University of Alabama 29IEEE29 36 6IET/IEE80.6 80.6 16.78 Arizona State University 28IEEE28 31 2AMER TELEPHONE TELEGRAPH CO, 550 MADISON AV90.3 90.3 6.59 University of New Brunswick 25IEEE25 27 1IET/IEE92.6 92.6 3.7

10 National Cheng Kung Univer 18IEEE18 19 1IET/IEE94.7 94.7 5.311 UWM Research Foundation 17IEEE17 19 1IET/IEE89.5 89.5 5.312 Senvion SE 15IEEE15 42 6AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro35.7 35.7 14.313 TechnipFMC 13IEEE13 17 1ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng76.5 76.5 5.914 Fujitsu Limited 12IEEE12 13 1RELX Group (Elsevier)92.3 92.3 7.715 Nordex SE 12IEEE12 19 4John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss63.2 63.2 21.116 NRG SYSTEMS INC 12IEEE12 22 4RELX Group (Elsevier)54.5 54.5 18.217 UNIVERSITY OF ZAGREB 12IEEE12 13 1EWEA-European Wind Energy Association92.3 92.3 7.718 Enercon GmbH 11IEEE11 13 2RELX Group (Elsevier)84.6 84.6 15.419 SPARQ SYSTEMS INC 11IEEE11 13 2IET/IEE84.6 84.6 15.420 Woodward Inc 10IEEE10 10 100.0 100.021 Kite Gen Research Srl 9IEEE9 19 7RELX Group (Elsevier)47.4 47.4 36.822 ZOND ENERGY SYSTEMS 9IEEE9 11 1RELX Group (Elsevier)81.8 81.8 9.123 GENEDICS CLEAN ENERG 49RELX Group (Elsevier)7 63 7IEEE11.1 77.8 11.124 Oregon State University 7IEEE7 7 100.0 100.025 Tigo Energy Inc 7IEEE7 7 100.0 100.026 GENEDICS LLC 35RELX Group (Elsevier)6 47 6AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci12.8 74.5 12.827 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 6IEEE6 23 6ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng26.1 26.1 26.128 Medtronic Inc 6IEEE6 8 1AMA-Am Medical Assoc75.0 75.0 12.529 GREEN ENERGY CORP 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.030 Mitsubishi Heavy Industries 25John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5 53 13ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng9.4 47.2 24.531 NEC Corp 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.032 RHEINISCH-WESTFALISC 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.033 University of Western Ontari 5IEEE5 5 100.0 100.034 Alstom 4IEEE4 6 2A B B Corporate Management Services AG66.7 66.7 33.335 Hitachi Ltd 4IEEE4 7 3Hitachi Ltd.57.1 57.1 42.936 HYPER TECH RESEARCH 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.037 KK WIND SOLUTIONS A/S 4IEEE4 4 100.0 100.038 NORTHERN POWER SYST 4IEEE4 5 1PennWell Publishing Co.80.0 80.0 20.039 UNIVERSIDAD PUBLICA 4IEEE4 5 1Instrument Society of America80.0 80.0 20.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-49Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 100: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

40 AB SKF 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.041 Daewoo Shipbuilding & Mari 3IEEE3 6 1MACMillan Publishing Company50.0 50.0 16.742 DowDuPont 7RELX Group (Elsevier)3 24 3Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad12.5 29.2 12.543 GLOBAL ENERGYCONCE 3IEEE3 5 1PCIM (Power Conversion, Intelligent Motion)60.0 60.0 20.044 Honeywell International Inc. 3IEEE3 5 1TIMES MIRROR MAG INC, 380 MADISON AVE, NEW YO60.0 60.0 20.045 SAMAYS INNOVACIONES 3IEEE3 5 1RELX Group (Elsevier)60.0 60.0 20.046 Schweitzer Engineering Labo 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.047 University of Wisconsin 3IEEE3 3 100.0 100.048 ADVANCED MAGNET LA 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.049 Alliance for Sustainable Ener 7ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng2 12 2IEEE16.7 58.3 16.750 Apple Inc 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.051 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.052 COMBINED ENERGIES LL 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.053 Dana Holding Corp. 2IEEE2 3 1EVS.org66.7 66.7 33.354 Harris Corp. 2Reed Business2 4 2IEEE50.0 50.0 50.055 HAWAIIAN ELECTRIC CO 2IEEE2 4 2John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss50.0 50.0 50.056 ONSEMBLE LLC 2IEEE2 4 2John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss50.0 50.0 50.057 Rockwell Automation Inc 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.058 ROCKY RESEARCH 2IEEE2 4 1Palgrave Macmillan Ltd.50.0 50.0 25.059 Rolls Royce Holdings Plc 4ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng2 7 2IEEE28.6 57.1 28.660 Trevii - Finanziaria Industrial 2IEEE2 2 100.0 100.061 University of Florida 8American Institute of Physics2 34 6ACS-Am Chem Soc5.9 23.5 17.662 X Development Llc 2AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro2 7 2IEEE28.6 28.6 28.663 Airbus SE 1American Institute of Physics1 3 1IEEE33.3 33.3 33.364 ALSTOM RENEWABLE TE 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.065 American Superconductor Co 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.066 BASELOAD ENERGY INC 1Konggansa1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.067 BLUE WATER SHIPPING A 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.068 California Institute of Techno 4RELX Group (Elsevier)1 6 1American Institute of Physics16.7 66.7 16.769 Cisco Systems Inc. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.070 CLEAN CURRENT LP 1IEEE1 3 1PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING PUBLISHING LTD33.3 33.3 33.371 DCNS Group 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.072 Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.073 Florida State University 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.074 General Motors Corp 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.075 GLOUSTER APPLICATION 6RELX Group (Elsevier)1 8 1AAAS-Am Assoc Advancement Sci12.5 75.0 12.576 Google Inc. 2Royal Society of Chemistry1 5 2ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng20.0 40.0 40.077 Indiana University 2RELX Group (Elsevier)1 5 1SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers20.0 40.0 20.078 Institut Francais du Petrole 2American Automatic Control Council (AACC1 3 1IEEE33.3 66.7 33.379 International Business Machi 2RELX Group (Elsevier)1 4 1IEEE25.0 50.0 25.080 INVENTUS HOLDINGS LL 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-50Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 101: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix B: Top 100 Organizations That Cite IEEE; (1997-2017 Patents by Category)

81 JST LLC 1IEEE1 2 1Konggansa50.0 50.0 50.082 Khalifa University of Science 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.083 KITENERGY S R L 1IEEE1 2 1American Automatic Control Council (AACC)50.0 50.0 50.084 LSIS Co Ltd (Formerly LS In 1IEEE1 2 1EPE Association50.0 50.0 50.085 MAGNOMATICS LTD 1IET/IEE1 2 1IEEE50.0 50.0 50.086 Mitsuba Corp. 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.087 Ogin Inc (Formerly FloDesig 11AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro1 20 8John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss5.0 55.0 40.088 OXFORD BROOKES UNIV 1IEEE1 2 1RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 50.089 POWEROASIS LTD 1IEEE1 2 1RELX Group (Elsevier)50.0 50.0 50.090 PV SOLUTIONS LLC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.091 QFE 002 LLC 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.092 SATCON TECHNOLOGY C 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.093 Schneider Electric S.A. 1IEEE1 2 1IET/IEE50.0 50.0 50.094 TECHNOLOGY SERVICE C 1IEEE1 2 1IOP Publishing50.0 50.0 50.095 TECNOTURBINES S L 1RELX Group (Elsevier)1 3 1PROFESSIONAL ENGINEERING PUBLISHING LTD33.3 33.3 33.396 Toshiba Corp 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.097 WEG ELECTRIC CORP 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.098 WESTERN MICHIGAN UNI 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.099 Wilic Sarl 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

100 ZF Friedrichshafen AG (Ger 1IEEE1 1 100.0 100.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 B-51Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 102: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

1 Microsoft Corporation 55685IEEE55685 164010 45323ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.0 34.0 27.62 International Business Machin 51224IEEE51224 150766 26998ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.0 34.0 17.93 Micron Technology Inc. 42368IEEE42368 128059 20891RELX Group (Elsevier)33.1 33.1 16.34 Qualcomm Inc 34729IEEE34729 81589 148533GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body42.6 42.6 18.25 Intel Corporation 28587IEEE28587 58496 45233GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body48.9 48.9 7.76 Broadcom Ltd 28273IEEE28273 46941 1263ACM-Assoc Comput Mach60.2 60.2 2.77 Apple Inc 24585IEEE24585 63239 13625ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.9 38.9 21.58 Nokia Corp 19373IEEE19373 50381 79153GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body38.5 38.5 15.79 Marvell Technology Group Lt 19334IEEE19334 24674 30533GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body78.4 78.4 12.4

10 AT&T Inc 14715IEEE14715 32391 2903ACM-Assoc Comput Mach45.4 45.4 9.011 Google Inc. 14419IEEE14419 43659 10006ACM-Assoc Comput Mach33.0 33.0 22.912 Semiconductor Energy Labora 50528SID-Society for Information Display14371 159717 26859American Institute of Physics9.0 31.6 16.813 Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 12885IEEE12885 37065 52083GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body34.8 34.8 14.114 Ericsson 12583IEEE12583 38414 122253GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body32.8 32.8 31.815 Siemens Aktiengesellschaft 11885IEEE11885 28612 2258RELX Group (Elsevier)41.5 41.5 7.916 Texas Instruments Inc 11870IEEE11870 19085 793American Institute of Physics62.2 62.2 4.217 Sony Corp 11699IEEE11699 26188 2235ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.7 44.7 8.518 Oracle Corporation 12776ACM-Assoc Comput Mach11658 41879 11658IEEE27.8 30.5 27.819 ParkerVision Inc 11381IEEE11381 22489 5318IET/IEE50.6 50.6 23.620 InterDigital Inc 257513GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo11224 42231 11224IEEE26.6 61.0 26.621 Western Digital Corp. 11027IEEE11027 21339 2171American Institute of Physics51.7 51.7 10.222 Massachusetts Institute of Tec 10778IEEE10778 43802 5502RELX Group (Elsevier)24.6 24.6 12.623 Medtronic Inc 21639RELX Group (Elsevier)10094 125906 15474Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.8.0 17.2 12.324 Panasonic Corporation 10057IEEE10057 30594 41903GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body32.9 32.9 13.725 Cisco Systems Inc. 10017IEEE10017 34153 6144Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force29.3 29.3 18.026 Fujitsu Limited 9775IEEE9775 25338 24403GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body38.6 38.6 9.627 MONOLITHIC 3D INC 9012IEEE9012 16043 1702IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys56.2 56.2 10.628 Personalized Media Communi 16312Society of Motion Picture and Television Engin8952 55578 8952IEEE16.1 29.3 16.129 HP Inc 8712IEEE8712 27885 4096ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.2 31.2 14.730 Toshiba Corp 8501IEEE8501 21009 1580American Institute of Physics40.5 40.5 7.531 LG Electronics Inc. 180273GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo8180 35366 8180IEEE23.1 51.0 23.132 Taiwan Semiconductor Manuf 8105IEEE8105 22654 6499American Institute of Physics35.8 35.8 28.733 NEC Corp 7919IEEE7919 21331 31443GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body37.1 37.1 14.734 STMicroelectronics 7346IEEE7346 12185 867RELX Group (Elsevier)60.3 60.3 7.135 Macronix International Co. Lt 7208IEEE7208 13289 2481IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys54.2 54.2 18.736 NXP Semiconductors NV 7112IEEE7112 11878 893American Institute of Physics59.9 59.9 7.537 Rambus Inc. 6999IEEE6999 10614 482IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys65.9 65.9 4.538 Xperi Corporation (Formerly 6986IEEE6986 13449 872SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering51.9 51.9 6.539 Koninklijke Philips N.V. 6856IEEE6856 25799 2668RELX Group (Elsevier)26.6 26.6 10.340 Honeywell International Inc. 6564IEEE6564 16713 1651RELX Group (Elsevier)39.3 39.3 9.9

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-1Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 103: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

41 General Electric Company 6524IEEE6524 29862 3568RELX Group (Elsevier)21.8 21.8 11.942 Partners HealthCare Systems I 29057Optical Society of America6271 89516 12908RELX Group (Elsevier)7.0 32.5 14.443 Motorola Solutions Inc. 6136IEEE6136 12179 1057American Institute of Physics50.4 50.4 8.744 Blackberry Ltd. 79483GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo6065 21677 6065IEEE28.0 36.7 28.045 Conversant Intellectual Proper 6054IEEE6054 9540 250IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys63.5 63.5 2.646 Cadence Design Systems Inc 6025IEEE6025 13906 4411Joint IEEE and ACM43.3 43.3 31.747 Huawei Technologies Compan 86793GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo5850 22843 5850IEEE25.6 38.0 25.648 Irobot Corp 5839IEEE5839 10277 1518SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering56.8 56.8 14.849 Xerox Corp 5815IEEE5815 20587 3555ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28.2 28.2 17.350 Hitachi Ltd 5778IEEE5778 19966 1453ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28.9 28.9 7.351 Tela Innovations inc 6435SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering5772 18540 5772IEEE31.1 34.7 31.152 Mitsubishi Electric Corp 5668IEEE5668 12146 834ACM-Assoc Comput Mach46.7 46.7 6.953 Infineon Technologies AG 5574IEEE5574 9875 835American Institute of Physics56.4 56.4 8.554 University of California 6503RELX Group (Elsevier)5510 47032 5510IEEE11.7 13.8 11.755 Canon Inc 5438IEEE5438 20141 2037American Institute of Physics27.0 27.0 10.156 Murata Manufacturing Co. Lt 5422IEEE5422 7343 209John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss73.8 73.8 2.857 Ricoh Co. Ltd. 5229IEEE5229 11714 1779ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.6 44.6 15.258 Raytheon Co. 5227IEEE5227 11168 602SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering46.8 46.8 5.459 Synopsys Inc. 5184IEEE5184 15075 3162SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering34.4 34.4 21.060 Advanced Micro Devices Inc 4980IEEE4980 11066 839Joint IEEE and ACM45.0 45.0 7.661 Nippon Telegraph & Telephon 4960IEEE4960 15229 38093GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body32.6 32.6 25.062 Verizon Communications Inc 4837IEEE4837 17604 2833ACM-Assoc Comput Mach27.5 27.5 16.163 RPX Corp 4777IEEE4777 11644 914Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force41.0 41.0 7.864 Fractus SA 4770IEEE4770 8163 1183IET/IEE58.4 58.4 14.565 Innovative Network Corporati 4704IEEE4704 7825 476IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys60.1 60.1 6.166 Columbia University 4688IEEE4688 16831 1727American Institute of Physics27.9 27.9 10.367 Cypress Semiconductor Corp. 4666IEEE4666 6893 462Joint IEEE and ACM67.7 67.7 6.768 Immersion Corp. 4640IEEE4640 12136 1326ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.2 38.2 10.969 Adaptix 4605IEEE4605 6695 730European Telecom Standards Institute (ETSI)68.8 68.8 10.970 California Institute of Technol 4527IEEE4527 26978 4035RELX Group (Elsevier)16.8 16.8 15.071 Hon Hai Precision Industry Co 4381IEEE4381 20426 36293GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body21.4 21.4 17.872 Digimarc Corp. 4376IEEE4376 11009 1335SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering39.7 39.7 12.173 Electronics and Telecommunic 4317IEEE4317 8455 6013GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body51.1 51.1 7.174 Boston Scientific Corp. 19661RELX Group (Elsevier)4289 69840 7178John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.1 28.2 10.375 Applied Materials Inc. 4256IEEE4256 17531 3383American Institute of Physics24.3 24.3 19.376 HRL Laboratories LLC 4225IEEE4225 8603 536RELX Group (Elsevier)49.1 49.1 6.277 Abbott Laboratories 23314RELX Group (Elsevier)4139 98004 12319ACS-Am Chem Soc4.2 23.8 12.678 Adobe Systems Inc. 4108IEEE4108 10796 3567ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.1 38.1 33.079 Cree Inc. 4091IEEE4091 11351 2554American Institute of Physics36.0 36.0 22.580 University of Minnesota (The 4088IEEE4088 8436 851RELX Group (Elsevier)48.5 48.5 10.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-2Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 104: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

81 Intuitive Surgical Inc. 4076IEEE4076 8286 531SAGES-Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Su49.2 49.2 6.482 Dexcom Inc 16898RELX Group (Elsevier)4043 66148 6922American Diabetes Association6.1 25.5 10.583 Industrial Techology Research 3985IEEE3985 7788 653RELX Group (Elsevier)51.2 51.2 8.484 Xilinx Inc. 3880IEEE3880 5609 571Joint IEEE and ACM69.2 69.2 10.285 University of Illinois 6123American Institute of Physics3783 33796 4750ACS-Am Chem Soc11.2 18.1 14.186 Technicolor SA 3744IEEE3744 7454 385ISO/IEC50.2 50.2 5.287 Analog Devices Inc. 3648IEEE3648 5516 444Reed Business66.1 66.1 8.088 On Semiconductor Corporatio 3406IEEE3406 4657 269RELX Group (Elsevier)73.1 73.1 5.889 Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc 7296RELX Group (Elsevier)3386 24803 3386IEEE13.7 29.4 13.790 Lockheed Martin Corp. 3323IEEE3323 16774 2217RELX Group (Elsevier)19.8 19.8 13.291 Commscope Inc. 3322IEEE3322 5543 4743GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body59.9 59.9 8.692 Dolby Laboratories Inc 3254IEEE3254 7501 773International Telecommunication Union43.4 43.4 10.393 Sap SE 4956ACM-Assoc Comput Mach3247 14298 3247IEEE22.7 34.7 22.794 Cirrus Logic Inc. 3246IEEE3246 4009 101Audio Eng Soc81.0 81.0 2.595 The Invention Science Fund 1 3244IEEE3244 20846 2103RELX Group (Elsevier)15.6 15.6 10.196 Softbank Corp 3180IEEE3180 9642 1893International Telecommunication Union33.0 33.0 19.697 Dell Technologies Inc 4475ACM-Assoc Comput Mach3094 12353 3094IEEE25.0 36.2 25.098 Witricity Corp 3078IEEE3078 5441 481American Institute of Physics56.6 56.6 8.899 Boeing Co. (The) 3002IEEE3002 9786 1011RELX Group (Elsevier)30.7 30.7 10.3

100 Fraunhofer Gesellschaft 3001IEEE3001 6550 452RELX Group (Elsevier)45.8 45.8 6.9101 Seagate Technology Plc 2976IEEE2976 7247 1366American Institute of Physics41.1 41.1 18.8102 Chipbond Technology Corp 2940IEEE2940 3683 272RELX Group (Elsevier)79.8 79.8 7.4103 ZENO SEMICONDUCTOR I 2933IEEE2933 3812 717IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys76.9 76.9 18.8104 ABB Ltd 2922IEEE2922 4715 202IVI Foundation/SCPI Consortium62.0 62.0 4.3105 Tabula Inc 2903IEEE2903 7804 2878ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.2 37.2 36.9106 Qorvo 2883IEEE2883 3793 237American Institute of Physics76.0 76.0 6.2107 MicroUnity Systems Engineeri 2811IEEE2811 4559 408Joint IEEE and ACM61.7 61.7 8.9108 Seiko Epson Corporation 2748IEEE2748 7722 644ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.6 35.6 8.3109 Comcast Corp 2721IEEE2721 5486 6053GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body49.6 49.6 11.0110 Commvault Systems Inc. 2622IEEE2622 3737 603ACM-Assoc Comput Mach70.2 70.2 16.1111 Harris Corp. 2616IEEE2616 4739 318Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force55.2 55.2 6.7112 Pelican Imaging Corporation 2597IEEE2597 5408 874SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering48.0 48.0 16.2113 REARDEN LLC 2597IEEE2597 2993 99IET/IEE86.8 86.8 3.3114 TiVo Corp 2543IEEE2543 9545 896ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.6 26.6 9.4115 United States Navy 2486IEEE2486 8619 969American Institute of Physics28.8 28.8 11.2116 SolarEdge Technologies Inc 2450IEEE2450 2933 289WIP-Renewable Energies83.5 83.5 9.9117 Silicon Laboratories Inc 2433IEEE2433 3106 121Reed Business78.3 78.3 3.9118 Commissariat A L'Energie Ato 2428IEEE2428 9482 1764RELX Group (Elsevier)25.6 25.6 18.6119 INDIVIDUAL PATENTER 2373RELX Group (Elsevier)2342 14995 2342IEEE15.6 15.8 15.6120 Amazon.com Inc. 2847ACM-Assoc Comput Mach2341 10058 2341IEEE23.3 28.3 23.3

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-3Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 105: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

121 Finisar Corp 2341IEEE2341 6225 847IET/IEE37.6 37.6 13.6122 Amberwave Inc 2335IEEE2335 6826 2045American Institute of Physics34.2 34.2 30.0123 NVIDIA Corp. 2303IEEE2303 5976 1685ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.5 38.5 28.2124 Stanford University 2505RELX Group (Elsevier)2268 20289 2268IEEE11.2 12.3 11.2125 Corning Inc. 2191IEEE2191 8240 1204Optical Society of America26.6 26.6 14.6126 DIRECTV Group Inc. (The) 2191IEEE2191 3436 161Elettronica e Telecomunicazioni63.8 63.8 4.7127 PACT XPP TECHNOLOGIE 2165IEEE2165 3725 358ACM-Assoc Comput Mach58.1 58.1 9.6128 Cognex Corp. 2065IEEE2065 4599 778RELX Group (Elsevier)44.9 44.9 16.9129 Georgia Institute of Technolog 2043IEEE2043 6068 703RELX Group (Elsevier)33.7 33.7 11.6130 Innovative Silicon SA 2033IEEE2033 2515 108RELX Group (Elsevier)80.8 80.8 4.3131 BT Group PLC 2000IEEE2000 4455 318ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.9 44.9 7.1132 Rockwell Automation Inc 1993IEEE1993 2975 168RELX Group (Elsevier)67.0 67.0 5.6133 Bosch (Robert) GmbH 1972IEEE1972 8388 692RELX Group (Elsevier)23.5 23.5 8.2134 Total SA 1963IEEE1963 2607 120RELX Group (Elsevier)75.3 75.3 4.6135 Juniper Networks Inc. 1944IEEE1944 5584 1207Network Working Group RFC34.8 34.8 21.6136 Global Foundries Inc 1928IEEE1928 4062 438American Institute of Physics47.5 47.5 10.8137 SIPCO LLC 1922IEEE1922 3315 258Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force58.0 58.0 7.8138 FormFactor Inc 1920IEEE1920 3484 648Nature Publishing Group55.1 55.1 18.6139 Intellectual Ventures Manage 1915IEEE1915 3990 597ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.0 48.0 15.0140 Magna International Inc. 1898IEEE1898 3920 348SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers48.4 48.4 8.9141 University of Michigan 1874IEEE1874 10693 1852RELX Group (Elsevier)17.5 17.5 17.3142 ConvergeOne Inc 1858IEEE1858 5827 849Joint IEEE and ACM31.9 31.9 14.6143 University of Texas 2359RELX Group (Elsevier)1853 14516 1853IEEE12.8 16.3 12.8144 ARRIS Group Inc 1827IEEE1827 3306 137International Telecommunication Union55.3 55.3 4.1145 Flex Ltd (Formerly Flextronics 1827IEEE1827 2451 242CBS Interactive74.5 74.5 9.9146 Lenovo Group Ltd 18643GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo1827 4887 1827IEEE37.4 38.1 37.4147 Netapp Inc 3925ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1826 9386 1826IEEE19.5 41.8 19.5148 Johnson & Johnson 8616RELX Group (Elsevier)1814 41424 3789John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss4.4 20.8 9.1149 Fuji Film Holdings Corp 1808IEEE1808 8109 1144ACM-Assoc Comput Mach22.3 22.3 14.1150 Honda Motor Co. Ltd.(Honda 1777IEEE1777 4335 624RELX Group (Elsevier)41.0 41.0 14.4151 Interuniversity MicroElectroni 1776IEEE1776 3970 359American Institute of Physics44.7 44.7 9.0152 SRI International 1765IEEE1765 5079 471SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering34.8 34.8 9.3153 Emerson Electric Co. 1673IEEE1673 6518 737RELX Group (Elsevier)25.7 25.7 11.3154 Accenture Ltd. 1660IEEE1660 5104 954ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.5 32.5 18.7155 Nuance Communications Inc 1650IEEE1650 4804 726ACM-Assoc Comput Mach34.3 34.3 15.1156 Microsemi Corp 1596IEEE1596 2531 123Reed Business63.1 63.1 4.9157 University of Washington 1712RELX Group (Elsevier)1566 10861 1566IEEE14.4 15.8 14.4158 Texas A&M University 1552IEEE1552 3351 278RELX Group (Elsevier)46.3 46.3 8.3159 Sanken Electric Co. Ltd. 1524IEEE1524 2000 276RELX Group (Elsevier)76.2 76.2 13.8160 Mediatek Inc. 1520IEEE1520 2472 5813GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body61.5 61.5 23.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-4Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 106: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

161 Wisteria Trading Inc 1500IEEE1500 3012 351SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.8 49.8 11.7162 Arizona State University 1490IEEE1490 4784 613RELX Group (Elsevier)31.1 31.1 12.8163 Hewlett Packard Enterprises 1480IEEE1480 4200 991ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.2 35.2 23.6164 L-3 Communications Holdings 1473IEEE1473 2126 113SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering69.3 69.3 5.3165 Intertrust Technologies Corp 1736ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1458 9576 1458IEEE15.2 18.1 15.2166 WI-Lan Inc 1447IEEE1447 2107 1123GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.7 68.7 5.3167 TDK Corporation 1443IEEE1443 4211 767American Institute of Physics34.3 34.3 18.2168 Citrix Systems Inc 1433IEEE1433 4508 813ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.8 31.8 18.0169 Eastman Kodak Company 1401IEEE1401 5879 543RELX Group (Elsevier)23.8 23.8 9.2170 University of Southern Califor 1393IEEE1393 7608 1022ACS-Am Chem Soc18.3 18.3 13.4171 Deutsche Telekom AG 1379IEEE1379 2780 1553GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body49.6 49.6 5.6172 Orange 1369IEEE1369 2690 139IET/IEE50.9 50.9 5.2173 University of Wisconsin 1346IEEE1346 8850 1128ACS-Am Chem Soc15.2 15.2 12.7174 BAE Systems Plc. 1329IEEE1329 2328 144SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering57.1 57.1 6.2175 QST Holdings Llc 1315IEEE1315 2255 249Joint IEEE and ACM58.3 58.3 11.0176 Infinera Corporation 1298IEEE1298 2522 364IET/IEE51.5 51.5 14.4177 INTOUCH HEALTH INC 1271IEEE1271 2704 144Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad47.0 47.0 5.3178 LibertyMedia 1260IEEE1260 2113 1493GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body59.6 59.6 7.1179 Kyocera Corp. 1252IEEE1252 3008 7493GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body41.6 41.6 24.9180 Northrop Grumman Corp 1245IEEE1245 2774 221American Institute of Physics44.9 44.9 8.0181 Transphorm Inc 1238IEEE1238 2438 447American Institute of Physics50.8 50.8 18.3182 Maxim Integrated Products Inc 1237IEEE1237 1459 20Texas Instruments84.8 84.8 1.4183 Agilent Technologies Inc 1226IEEE1226 4183 437RELX Group (Elsevier)29.3 29.3 10.4184 Walt Disney Co. 2318ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1222 4840 1222IEEE25.2 47.9 25.2185 Microchip Technology Inc. 1219IEEE1219 1799 84ACM-Assoc Comput Mach67.8 67.8 4.7186 Level 3 Communications 1209IEEE1209 4299 891ACM-Assoc Comput Mach28.1 28.1 20.7187 PHOENIX SOLUTIONS INC 1206IEEE1206 3604 478ISCA (International Speech Communication Association)33.5 33.5 13.3188 SK Hynix Inc 1203IEEE1203 2223 140American Institute of Physics54.1 54.1 6.3189 Velatia Group 1182IEEE1182 1571 113Echelon Corp75.2 75.2 7.2190 Synaptics Inc. 1176IEEE1176 2170 117ACM-Assoc Comput Mach54.2 54.2 5.4191 Facebook Inc 1197ACM-Assoc Comput Mach1168 4351 1168IEEE26.8 27.5 26.8192 Schneider Electric S.A. 1160IEEE1160 6206 681I S A-INSTRUM SYS AUTOMATION SOC18.7 18.7 11.0193 Imagination Technologies Gro 1118IEEE1118 3425 743ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.6 32.6 21.7194 United States of America Depa 1227RELX Group (Elsevier)1116 6315 1116IEEE17.7 19.4 17.7195 National Instruments Corp. 1101IEEE1101 1949 189ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.5 56.5 9.7196 Extreme Networks Inc 1095IEEE1095 2280 255ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.0 48.0 11.2197 PDF Solutions 1095IEEE1095 1624 394SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering67.4 67.4 24.3198 Hong Kong University of Scie 1088IEEE1088 2264 243American Institute of Physics48.1 48.1 10.7199 Brain Corporation 1074IEEE1074 2666 453MIT Press40.3 40.3 17.0200 MagnaCom Ltd 1072IEEE1072 1133 61AMER TELEPHONE TELEGRAPH CO, 550 MADISON AVE94.6 94.6 5.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-5Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 107: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

201 Toyota Motor Corp 1067IEEE1067 3832 826RELX Group (Elsevier)27.8 27.8 21.6202 Purdue University 1301RELX Group (Elsevier)1060 7451 1060IEEE14.2 17.5 14.2203 United States Army 1057IEEE1057 4428 450American Institute of Physics23.9 23.9 10.2204 Avaya Inc 1054IEEE1054 3844 632Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force27.4 27.4 16.4205 IDC Llc 1038IEEE1038 2898 391SID-Society for Information Display35.8 35.8 13.5206 McAfee Inc 1022IEEE1022 3936 816ACM-Assoc Comput Mach26.0 26.0 20.7207 SRC Computers Inc. 1015IEEE1015 1149 41ACM-Assoc Comput Mach88.3 88.3 3.6208 Stryker Corp. 1086RELX Group (Elsevier)1015 6314 1015IEEE16.1 17.2 16.1209 University of South Florida 1013IEEE1013 4210 685RELX Group (Elsevier)24.1 24.1 16.3210 Thales 1006IEEE1006 1939 120RELX Group (Elsevier)51.9 51.9 6.2211 Verance Corp 1002IEEE1002 1880 244SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering53.3 53.3 13.0212 Smith & Nephew Plc. 2750RELX Group (Elsevier)1001 12689 1171John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.9 21.7 9.2213 General Motors Corp 999IEEE999 3699 887RELX Group (Elsevier)27.0 27.0 24.0214 Michigan State University 2115Optical Society of America993 10957 1528American Institute of Physics9.1 19.3 13.9215 Illumina Inc. 987IEEE987 5220 636RELX Group (Elsevier)18.9 18.9 12.2216 Ignis Innovation Inc 983IEEE983 1321 163SID-Society for Information Display74.4 74.4 12.3217 Agency for Science Technolog 973IEEE973 2968 434RELX Group (Elsevier)32.8 32.8 14.6218 Washington University in St. L 965IEEE965 5409 756RELX Group (Elsevier)17.8 17.8 14.0219 Battelle Memorial Institute 990RELX Group (Elsevier)964 5240 964IEEE18.4 18.9 18.4220 Solarflare Communications In 4095ACM-Assoc Comput Mach961 6907 1371Joint IEEE and ACM13.9 59.3 19.8221 Crossbar Inc 960IEEE960 3524 503American Institute of Physics27.2 27.2 14.3222 eBay Inc 952IEEE952 5314 687ACM-Assoc Comput Mach17.9 17.9 12.9223 Math Works Inc (The) 935IEEE935 2100 452ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.5 44.5 21.5224 Symantec Corp. 924IEEE924 3695 895ACM-Assoc Comput Mach25.0 25.0 24.2225 Carnegie Mellon University 917IEEE917 3484 381RELX Group (Elsevier)26.3 26.3 10.9226 Pioneer Corp. 908IEEE908 1827 288SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.7 49.7 15.8227 TRILLIANT NETWORKS I 907IEEE907 1391 93Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force65.2 65.2 6.7228 IP RESERVOIR LLC 892IEEE892 1838 329ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.5 48.5 17.9229 SYNQOR INC 892IEEE892 1023 45Penton Media, Inc.87.2 87.2 4.4230 New Jersey Institute of Techno 872IEEE872 2125 416RELX Group (Elsevier)41.0 41.0 19.6231 YFY Inc 3756SID-Society for Information Display871 9892 1125National Symposium on Information Display8.8 38.0 11.4232 Schlumberger Ltd. 2569Society of Petroleum Engineers865 12040 1386Society of Exploration Geophysicists7.2 21.3 11.5233 GUIDED THERAPY SYSTE 864IEEE864 2567 387RELX Group (Elsevier)33.7 33.7 15.1234 LivaNova Plc 2448RELX Group (Elsevier)863 12218 1724John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss7.1 20.0 14.1235 Midtronics Inc. 856IEEE856 2042 357RELX Group (Elsevier)41.9 41.9 17.5236 BIOSENSORS INTERNATI 851IEEE851 2627 372John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss32.4 32.4 14.2237 HTC Corporation 16423GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo850 3261 850IEEE26.1 50.4 26.1238 Cornell University 846IEEE846 5718 775RELX Group (Elsevier)14.8 14.8 13.6239 Mellanox Technologies Ltd 846IEEE846 2270 291IET/IEE37.3 37.3 12.8240 Teledyne Technologies Incorp 841IEEE841 1708 156SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering49.2 49.2 9.1

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-6Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 108: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

241 NUVOTRONICS INC 831IEEE831 992 35American Institute of Physics83.8 83.8 3.5242 Masimo Corp 830IEEE830 2106 192Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.39.4 39.4 9.1243 Nielsen Holdings Plc 999RELX Group (Elsevier)826 5995 826IEEE13.8 16.7 13.8244 Integrated Device Technology 818IEEE818 1128 32ACM-Assoc Comput Mach72.5 72.5 2.8245 Nantero Inc 3296ACS-Am Chem Soc816 11031 2289American Institute of Physics7.4 29.9 20.8246 3M Co 1808RELX Group (Elsevier)798 11691 1254ACS-Am Chem Soc6.8 15.5 10.7247 Viasat 793IEEE793 1269 60RELX Group (Elsevier)62.5 62.5 4.7248 ATTOPSEMI TECHNOLOG 787IEEE787 1008 146IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys78.1 78.1 14.5249 Technion - Israel Institute of T 781IEEE781 2200 242RELX Group (Elsevier)35.5 35.5 11.0250 Elwha LLC 780IEEE780 2838 216RELX Group (Elsevier)27.5 27.5 7.6251 REALTIME DATA LLC 780IEEE780 3109 419Network Working Group RFC25.1 25.1 13.5252 CA Inc 775IEEE775 2096 404ACM-Assoc Comput Mach37.0 37.0 19.3253 Johns Hopkins University 959RELX Group (Elsevier)771 5606 771IEEE13.8 17.1 13.8254 University of Florida 771IEEE771 3833 645RELX Group (Elsevier)20.1 20.1 16.8255 Mevion Medical Systems Inc 764IEEE764 2740 581RELX Group (Elsevier)27.9 27.9 21.2256 Viavi Solutions Inc 764IEEE764 2666 470American Institute of Physics28.7 28.7 17.6257 Nikon Corp. 1917SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering761 4752 767SEMATECH Consortium16.0 40.3 16.1258 Round Rock Research LLC 758IEEE758 2376 345RELX Group (Elsevier)31.9 31.9 14.5259 Knowles Corp 756IEEE756 1467 172RELX Group (Elsevier)51.5 51.5 11.7260 University of North Carolina 744IEEE744 4900 659RELX Group (Elsevier)15.2 15.2 13.4261 Rockwell Collins Inc. 741IEEE741 1616 79Optical Society of America45.9 45.9 4.9262 Vanderbilt University 741IEEE741 4291 662RELX Group (Elsevier)17.3 17.3 15.4263 Lam Research Corp. 1039American Institute of Physics740 4047 740IEEE18.3 25.7 18.3264 ASM International N.V. 1476RELX Group (Elsevier)736 6771 1472American Institute of Physics10.9 21.8 21.7265 Cleveland Clinic (and Foundat 784RELX Group (Elsevier)736 3968 736IEEE18.5 19.8 18.5266 Airbus SE 732IEEE732 1781 200RELX Group (Elsevier)41.1 41.1 11.2267 Synergy Microwave Corp 732IEEE732 894 66Horizon House Publications81.9 81.9 7.4268 Skyworks Solutions Inc 731IEEE731 997 52Summit Technical Media73.3 73.3 5.2269 PixelWorks Inc 729IEEE729 1115 109SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering65.4 65.4 9.8270 Avid Technology Inc. 728IEEE728 1774 641ACM-Assoc Comput Mach41.0 41.0 36.1271 FireEye Inc 728IEEE728 1792 310ACM-Assoc Comput Mach40.6 40.6 17.3272 Aisin Seiki Co. Ltd. 1855Optical Society of America723 5120 723IEEE14.1 36.2 14.1273 Ford Motor Co. 723IEEE723 2354 435SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers30.7 30.7 18.5274 Fortinet Inc 723IEEE723 1239 178ACM-Assoc Comput Mach58.4 58.4 14.4275 Voxer Llc 714IEEE714 1197 90Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force59.6 59.6 7.5276 Power Integrations Inc. 713IEEE713 1084 67Penton Media, Inc.65.8 65.8 6.2277 Kandou 711IEEE711 783 51IET/IEE90.8 90.8 6.5278 KLA-Tencor Corp. 1864SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering710 6184 944American Institute of Physics11.5 30.1 15.3279 M/A-COM Technology Soluti 701IEEE701 1479 189American Institute of Physics47.4 47.4 12.8280 Headwater Partners 1 LLC 696IEEE696 1575 307ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.2 44.2 19.5

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-7Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 109: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

281 MULTI-TECH SYSTEMS IN 691IEEE691 1096 81International Telecommunication Union63.0 63.0 7.4282 General Dynamics Corp 686IEEE686 1923 239American Society For Artificial Internal Organs35.7 35.7 12.4283 Silverbrook Pty Ltd 685IEEE685 1952 440Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad35.1 35.1 22.5284 Princeton University 1290American Institute of Physics682 5796 709ACS-Am Chem Soc11.8 22.3 12.2285 Duke University 666IEEE666 4595 623RELX Group (Elsevier)14.5 14.5 13.6286 JPMorgan 1098Source Media666 5906 666IEEE11.3 18.6 11.3287 III HOLDINGS 1 LLC 665IEEE665 1078 123ACM-Assoc Comput Mach61.7 61.7 11.4288 University of Nebraska 664IEEE664 3444 418Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad19.3 19.3 12.1289 Cortica Ltd 654IEEE654 886 86ACM-Assoc Comput Mach73.8 73.8 9.7290 Charles Stark Draper Laborato 648IEEE648 2265 288RELX Group (Elsevier)28.6 28.6 12.7291 VIVAQUANT LLC 644IEEE644 1076 101RELX Group (Elsevier)59.9 59.9 9.4292 Maxlinear Inc 638IEEE638 836 41ACM-Assoc Comput Mach76.3 76.3 4.9293 Northwestern University 2374ACS-Am Chem Soc636 10609 1365RELX Group (Elsevier)6.0 22.4 12.9294 State University of New York 635IEEE635 3808 575RELX Group (Elsevier)16.7 16.7 15.1295 NUMENTA INC 873Numenta Inc.632 2489 632IEEE25.4 35.1 25.4296 Advantest Corp. 628IEEE628 890 40American Institute of Physics70.6 70.6 4.5297 NOMADIX INC 621IEEE621 2444 408Network Working Group RFC25.4 25.4 16.7298 Sulvolta Inc 620IEEE620 1301 200American Institute of Physics47.7 47.7 15.4299 BUTTERFLY NETWORKS I 616IEEE616 685 32Acoustical Society of America89.9 89.9 4.7300 Oki Electric Industry Co. Ltd. 616IEEE616 1487 160IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng41.4 41.4 10.8301 Micro Focus International PL 615IEEE615 1755 448ACM-Assoc Comput Mach35.0 35.0 25.5302 North Carolina State Universit 837American Institute of Physics607 4049 645RELX Group (Elsevier)15.0 20.7 15.9303 Sonos Inc 606IEEE606 1530 238SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering39.6 39.6 15.6304 Johnson Controls International 602IEEE602 1674 238RELX Group (Elsevier)36.0 36.0 14.2305 SUN PATENT TRUST 9443GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo599 2798 823International Telecommunication Union21.4 33.7 29.4306 Zebra Technologies Corp. 597IEEE597 1303 66Optical Society of America45.8 45.8 5.1307 Fastback Networks Inc 596IEEE596 836 57IET/IEE71.3 71.3 6.8308 BANDSPEED INC 595IEEE595 863 188Bluetooth Special Interest Group68.9 68.9 21.8309 University of Pennsylvania 1038RELX Group (Elsevier)595 6642 758John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss9.0 15.6 11.4310 MOJO MOBILITY INC 591IEEE591 758 54RELX Group (Elsevier)78.0 78.0 7.1311 BTG Plc. 588IEEE588 2219 293RELX Group (Elsevier)26.5 26.5 13.2312 Coriant 586IEEE586 1324 181Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force44.3 44.3 13.7313 Harvard University 1416ACS-Am Chem Soc585 10300 1254RELX Group (Elsevier)5.7 13.7 12.2314 ASML Holding NV 4170SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering577 12206 2676American Institute of Physics4.7 34.2 21.9315 Screen Holdings Co Ltd (Form 577IEEE577 2151 317RELX Group (Elsevier)26.8 26.8 14.7316 Ciena Corp 560IEEE560 1687 293Optical Society of America33.2 33.2 17.4317 NCR Corp. 557IEEE557 1770 359ACM-Assoc Comput Mach31.5 31.5 20.3318 Nintendo Co. Ltd. 739ACM-Assoc Comput Mach557 2982 557IEEE18.7 24.8 18.7319 Unisantis Electronics Ltd 557IEEE557 642 38RELX Group (Elsevier)86.8 86.8 5.9320 3D Systems Corp. 556IEEE556 1251 305ACM-Assoc Comput Mach44.4 44.4 24.4

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-8Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 110: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

321 United Technologies Corp 551IEEE551 2706 244RELX Group (Elsevier)20.4 20.4 9.0322 X ONE INC 549IEEE549 1384 268ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.7 39.7 19.4323 Virgin Islands Microsystems 548IEEE548 2251 461American Institute of Physics24.3 24.3 20.5324 Sumitomo Electric Industries 544IEEE544 3745 544American Institute of Physics14.5 14.5 14.5325 University of Maryland 575RELX Group (Elsevier)542 3599 542IEEE15.1 16.0 15.1326 Tel Aviv Univiversity 554RELX Group (Elsevier)538 3483 538IEEE15.4 15.9 15.4327 CREATIVE KINGDOMS LL 537IEEE537 1631 447ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.9 32.9 27.4328 The National Aeronautical and 535IEEE535 2703 271AIAA-Am Inst Aero Astro19.8 19.8 10.0329 National Chiao Tung Universi 531IEEE531 1050 99American Institute of Physics50.6 50.6 9.4330 Centre National De La Recher 1451RELX Group (Elsevier)530 5468 530IEEE9.7 26.5 9.7331 Pulse Electronics 530IEEE530 706 141IET/IEE75.1 75.1 20.0332 Denso Corp 524IEEE524 1235 122RELX Group (Elsevier)42.4 42.4 9.9333 ORIGIN WIRELESS INC 524IEEE524 702 39American Physical Society74.6 74.6 5.6334 Hoya Corp 523IEEE523 1826 347American Institute of Physics28.6 28.6 19.0335 Soitec SA 523IEEE523 2023 493American Institute of Physics25.9 25.9 24.4336 Xtera Communications Inc. 521IEEE521 1535 359IET/IEE33.9 33.9 23.4337 Emcore Corp. 519IEEE519 1175 165American Institute of Physics44.2 44.2 14.0338 Pulse Link Inc 516IEEE516 630 24Scientific American Inc.81.9 81.9 3.8339 Sotera Wireless 514IEEE514 1037 182Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad49.6 49.6 17.6340 Via Technologies Inc. 511IEEE511 1090 145Joint IEEE and ACM46.9 46.9 13.3341 Halliburton Co. (Holding) 3332Society of Petroleum Engineers507 8981 646SPWLA-Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log Analysts5.6 37.1 7.2342 NETWORK-1 TECHNOLOG 506IEEE506 1289 337ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.3 39.3 26.1343 Ecole Polytechnique Federale 505IEEE505 1798 169RELX Group (Elsevier)28.1 28.1 9.4344 EXEGY INC 505IEEE505 1040 173ACM-Assoc Comput Mach48.6 48.6 16.6345 ACORN TECHNOLOGIES I 503IEEE503 1442 352American Institute of Physics34.9 34.9 24.4346 Nant Holdings IP Llc 502IEEE502 1673 475ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.0 30.0 28.4347 VerintSys 1318International Data Group500 4497 886ACM-Assoc Comput Mach11.1 29.3 19.7348 ZTE Corp. 13303GPP General Partnership Project Standards Bo500 2449 500IEEE20.4 54.3 20.4349 Caterpillar Inc. 499IEEE499 1274 157SAE-Society of Automobile Engineers39.2 39.2 12.3350 ST-Ericsson SA (Patents split 495IEEE495 698 833GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body70.9 70.9 11.9351 EchoStar Corp 491IEEE491 949 74RELX Group (Elsevier)51.7 51.7 7.8352 Comtech Telecommunications 489IEEE489 1029 2183GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body47.5 47.5 21.2353 Olympus Corp. 487IEEE487 2781 423RELX Group (Elsevier)17.5 17.5 15.2354 VirnetX Holding Corp 4279Network Working Group RFC485 8456 1487Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force5.7 50.6 17.6355 Medispectra Inc 482IEEE482 1316 148RELX Group (Elsevier)36.6 36.6 11.2356 ZENA TECHNOLOGIES IN 480IEEE480 1821 392American Institute of Physics26.4 26.4 21.5357 Cheetah Omni LLC 478IEEE478 1857 445Optical Society of America25.7 25.7 24.0358 MC10 Inc 1051American Institute of Physics478 5376 796ACS-Am Chem Soc8.9 19.5 14.8359 Eaton Corp. 474IEEE474 693 36RELX Group (Elsevier)68.4 68.4 5.2360 CenturyLink Inc 473IEEE473 1085 141International Telecommunication Union43.6 43.6 13.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-9Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 111: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

361 Fitbit Inc 473IEEE473 1209 190Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad39.1 39.1 15.7362 MIRAMAR LABS INC 471IEEE471 1115 105IOP Publishing42.2 42.2 9.4363 Qinetiq Group Ltd 470IEEE470 1513 168American Institute of Physics31.1 31.1 11.1364 Ligado Networks (formerly Li 468IEEE468 863 132Baltzer Science Publishers B.V.54.2 54.2 15.3365 University of Colorado ( The 788Optical Society of America466 3275 466IEEE14.2 24.1 14.2366 ECOLE DE TECHBOLOGIE 464IEEE464 681 543GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.1 68.1 7.9367 Lattice Semiconductor Corp. 464IEEE464 668 38Joint IEEE and ACM69.5 69.5 5.7368 Korea Advanced Institute for S 463IEEE463 1546 177RELX Group (Elsevier)29.9 29.9 11.4369 SAS Institute 460IEEE460 1403 213RELX Group (Elsevier)32.8 32.8 15.2370 Tokyo Electron Limited 515RELX Group (Elsevier)460 3589 475American Institute of Physics12.8 14.3 13.2371 Pennsylvania State University 598RELX Group (Elsevier)459 3233 459IEEE14.2 18.5 14.2372 University of Central Florida 517RELX Group (Elsevier)455 3717 455IEEE12.2 13.9 12.2373 Oewaves Inc 568Optical Society of America447 1412 447IEEE31.7 40.2 31.7374 ALOFT MEDIA LLC 446IEEE446 650 1053GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body68.6 68.6 16.2375 Assa Abloy AB 444IEEE444 2775 402International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)16.0 16.0 14.5376 MicroStrategy Inc. 444IEEE444 1793 359United Business Media/UBM Tech24.8 24.8 20.0377 Realtek Semiconductor Corp. 441IEEE441 533 15IET/IEE82.7 82.7 2.8378 SAIC Inc 577SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering437 2652 437IEEE16.5 21.8 16.5379 PLUSN LLC 436IEEE436 600 57IET/IEE72.7 72.7 9.5380 Fortive Corporation 435IEEE435 1077 95RELX Group (Elsevier)40.4 40.4 8.8381 AMPT LLC 434IEEE434 560 34RELX Group (Elsevier)77.5 77.5 6.1382 IDEMIA 431IEEE431 1137 79SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering37.9 37.9 6.9383 United Microelectronics Corp 428IEEE428 805 84IEEE/JPN Soc App Phys53.2 53.2 10.4384 Proteus Biomedical Inc 427IEEE427 1856 367RELX Group (Elsevier)23.0 23.0 19.8385 ICOSYSTEM CORP 425IEEE425 579 33RELX Group (Elsevier)73.4 73.4 5.7386 Schweitzer Engineering Labor 424IEEE424 519 15IET/IEE81.7 81.7 2.9387 Alstom 422IEEE422 687 55ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng61.4 61.4 8.0388 MegaChips Corp 421IEEE421 659 34American Institute of Physics63.9 63.9 5.2389 F5 Networks Inc 416IEEE416 2291 358ACM-Assoc Comput Mach18.2 18.2 15.6390 Densbits Technologies Ltd 414IEEE414 767 119Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad54.0 54.0 15.5391 TRACBEAM LLC 413IEEE413 796 108ACM-Assoc Comput Mach51.9 51.9 13.6392 Vestas Wind Systems A/S 413IEEE413 842 98AWEA-American Wind Energy Association49.0 49.0 11.6393 IPCO LLC 411IEEE411 732 54ACM-Assoc Comput Mach56.1 56.1 7.4394 Coherent Inc. 577Optical Society of America410 2799 507American Institute of Physics14.6 20.6 18.1395 FARO Technologies Inc. 410IEEE410 1109 200SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering37.0 37.0 18.0396 Fuji Electric Holdings Co. Ltd. 410IEEE410 826 101American Institute of Physics49.6 49.6 12.2397 Omnivision Technologies Inc 409IEEE409 1064 284Optical Society of America38.4 38.4 26.7398 Soraa Inc 1642American Institute of Physics408 5233 972INST PURE APPLIED PHYSICS7.8 31.4 18.6399 University of Pittsburgh 746RELX Group (Elsevier)408 3780 408IEEE10.8 19.7 10.8400 ACACIA MEDIA TECHNOL 406IEEE406 736 66ACM-Assoc Comput Mach55.2 55.2 9.0

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-10Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 112: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

401 ZF Friedrichshafen AG (Germ 406IEEE406 1082 105American Institute of Physics37.5 37.5 9.7402 Ygomi LLC 405IEEE405 443 15SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering91.4 91.4 3.4403 ITT Corp 404IEEE404 875 63Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force46.2 46.2 7.2404 Aerospace Corp. 403IEEE403 1089 164American Institute of Physics37.0 37.0 15.1405 INTERVAL RESEARCH CO 402IEEE402 958 239ACM-Assoc Comput Mach42.0 42.0 24.9406 University of Utah 402IEEE402 2632 337RELX Group (Elsevier)15.3 15.3 12.8407 Commonwealth Scientific and 401IEEE401 856 89RELX Group (Elsevier)46.8 46.8 10.4408 DowDuPont 1781RELX Group (Elsevier)399 7914 1133ACS-Am Chem Soc5.0 22.5 14.3409 National Taiwan University 398IEEE398 737 52American Institute of Physics54.0 54.0 7.1410 New York University 396IEEE396 2812 311Optical Society of America14.1 14.1 11.1411 TE Connectivity Ltd 395IEEE395 1087 117Optical Society of America36.3 36.3 10.8412 Red Hat Inc 394IEEE394 1293 333ACM-Assoc Comput Mach30.5 30.5 25.8413 Asahi Kasei Corp. 1083RELX Group (Elsevier)393 4762 656Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.8.3 22.7 13.8414 United States Air Force 391IEEE391 1522 185American Institute of Physics25.7 25.7 12.2415 AVISTAR COMMUNICATI 390IEEE390 767 228ACM-Assoc Comput Mach50.8 50.8 29.7416 United States of America Depa 390IEEE390 1828 297American Institute of Physics21.3 21.3 16.2417 ON-RAMP WIRELESS INC 389IEEE389 569 48IET/IEE68.4 68.4 8.4418 YANICKLO TECHNOLOG 854ACM-Assoc Comput Mach389 2412 389IEEE16.1 35.4 16.1419 Atos SE 388IEEE388 929 118Internet Soc/IETF-Internet Eng Task Force41.8 41.8 12.7420 Communications Research Ce 388IEEE388 610 43IET/IEE63.6 63.6 7.0421 ETA DEVICES INC 387IEEE387 447 18Summit Technical Media86.6 86.6 4.0422 Telecom Italia SPA 387IEEE387 987 1423GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body39.2 39.2 14.4423 University of New Mexico 387IEEE387 1958 239American Institute of Physics19.8 19.8 12.2424 IWALK INC 384IEEE384 1017 207RELX Group (Elsevier)37.8 37.8 20.4425 BIO CONTROL MEDICAL ( 383IEEE383 1409 221Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Ltd.27.2 27.2 15.7426 Delphi Automotive PLC 381IEEE381 866 113RELX Group (Elsevier)44.0 44.0 13.0427 Teradyne Inc. 380IEEE380 772 95ASME-Am Soc Mech Eng49.2 49.2 12.3428 BIONX MEDICAL TECHN 379IEEE379 995 207RELX Group (Elsevier)38.1 38.1 20.8429 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. 424Optical Society of America379 1868 379IEEE20.3 22.7 20.3430 TANGIS CORP 375IEEE375 540 92ACM-Assoc Comput Mach69.4 69.4 17.0431 Ohio State University 422RELX Group (Elsevier)374 2464 374IEEE15.2 17.1 15.2432 Autodesk Inc. 1476ACM-Assoc Comput Mach369 2456 369IEEE15.0 60.1 15.0433 NORTHERN TELECOM LT 369IEEE369 662 46IET/IEE55.7 55.7 6.9434 Oclaro Inc 369IEEE369 1169 268Optical Society of America31.6 31.6 22.9435 Cray Inc 532ACM-Assoc Comput Mach368 1390 368IEEE26.5 38.3 26.5436 Novartis AG 2431RELX Group (Elsevier)366 8510 546ASSOC RESEARCH VISION OPHTHALMOLOGY INC4.3 28.6 6.4437 Tigo Energy Inc 364IEEE364 531 125WIP-Renewable Energies68.5 68.5 23.5438 City University of Hong Kong 363IEEE363 912 84RELX Group (Elsevier)39.8 39.8 9.2439 Genesys Telecommunications 363IEEE363 843 136ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.1 43.1 16.1440 Hexagon AB 362IEEE362 1112 124ACM-Assoc Comput Mach32.6 32.6 11.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-11Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 113: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

441 Sigma Corp 362IEEE362 480 70SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering75.4 75.4 14.6442 Virginia Tech University 362IEEE362 1351 174RELX Group (Elsevier)26.8 26.8 12.9443 Becton Dickinson and Co. 3395RELX Group (Elsevier)361 20110 2776Wolters Kluwer1.8 16.9 13.8444 University of Connecticut 360IEEE360 1944 345RELX Group (Elsevier)18.5 18.5 17.7445 Catholic University Leuven 359IEEE359 904 109American Institute of Physics39.7 39.7 12.1446 Avalanche Technology Inc 496American Institute of Physics357 1586 357IEEE22.5 31.3 22.5447 Voicebox Technologies Inc 355IEEE355 463 63ACM-Assoc Comput Mach76.7 76.7 13.6448 UT-Battelle LLC 570RELX Group (Elsevier)352 3286 480American Institute of Physics10.7 17.3 14.6449 Council of Scientific and Indus 351IEEE351 1195 243RELX Group (Elsevier)29.4 29.4 20.3450 William Marsh Rice Universit 736ACS-Am Chem Soc351 3706 495RELX Group (Elsevier)9.5 19.9 13.4451 Rohm Co. Ltd. 896American Institute of Physics350 3138 434RELX Group (Elsevier)11.2 28.6 13.8452 Jiangsu ChangJiang Electronic 348IEEE348 447 49International Microelectronics And Packaging Society77.9 77.9 11.0453 Polycom Inc. 347IEEE347 542 57International Telecommunication Union64.0 64.0 10.5454 Japan Science and Technology 1047American Institute of Physics346 3982 553RELX Group (Elsevier)8.7 26.3 13.9455 Fluidigm Corp 411RELX Group (Elsevier)345 2773 401ACS-Am Chem Soc12.4 14.8 14.5456 COLLABORATION PROPE 343IEEE343 494 70ACM-Assoc Comput Mach69.4 69.4 14.2457 CIRREX SYSTEMS LLC 341IEEE341 1421 223Optical Society of America24.0 24.0 15.7458 Quest Software Inc 341IEEE341 883 269ACM-Assoc Comput Mach38.6 38.6 30.5459 SYNTROPY SYSTEMS LLC 340IEEE340 381 18Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad89.2 89.2 4.7460 Unisys Corp. 339IEEE339 779 176ACM-Assoc Comput Mach43.5 43.5 22.6461 Vishay Intertechnology Inc. 339IEEE339 516 28RELX Group (Elsevier)65.7 65.7 5.4462 VASCULAR IMAGING CO 337IEEE337 695 200IET/IEE48.5 48.5 28.8463 EDGE 3 TECHNOLOGIES I 334IEEE334 529 37International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)63.1 63.1 7.0464 Maui Diagnostic Imaging 334IEEE334 456 40RELX Group (Elsevier)73.2 73.2 8.8465 National University of Singap 334IEEE334 1232 134American Institute of Physics27.1 27.1 10.9466 RONALD A KATZ TECHN 332IEEE332 2326 222International Data Group14.3 14.3 9.5467 Carl-Zeiss Stiftung 1544SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering330 7938 1232Optical Society of America4.2 19.5 15.5468 Kofax Inc 330IEEE330 844 140ACM-Assoc Comput Mach39.1 39.1 16.6469 Silicon Genesis Corporation 330IEEE330 1612 328RELX Group (Elsevier)20.5 20.5 20.3470 HEMOSONICS LLC 329IEEE329 628 70RELX Group (Elsevier)52.4 52.4 11.1471 Tensorcomm Inc 329IEEE329 369 13IET/IEE89.2 89.2 3.5472 Concormis Inc 1531Springer/Sp. Wien/Springer-Verlag/KluwAcad326 9607 1232RELX Group (Elsevier)3.4 15.9 12.8473 University of Virginia (and Pat 323IEEE323 1893 290RELX Group (Elsevier)17.1 17.1 15.3474 TROXLER ELECTRONIC L 321IEEE321 739 174AMER SOC TESTING MATERIALS43.4 43.4 23.5475 University Health Network 320IEEE320 933 136RELX Group (Elsevier)34.3 34.3 14.6476 TELECOMMUNICATIONS 319IEEE319 485 41IET/IEE65.8 65.8 8.5477 Cavium Inc 318IEEE318 764 105SPIE-Int Soc Opt Engineering41.6 41.6 13.7478 Searete LLC 317IEEE317 1986 174American Institute of Physics16.0 16.0 8.8479 SercoNet Ltd 317IEEE317 613 41Primedia Business Magazines & Media Inc.51.7 51.7 6.7480 Leonhard Kurz Stiftung & Co 325American Institute of Physics316 1364 316IEEE23.2 23.8 23.2

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-12Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC

Page 114: Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers ......Analysis of US Patent Referencing to IEEE Papers, Conferences, and Standards 1997-2017 Report prepared for: IEEE 445 Hoes Lane

rank assignee Top Referenced Organization

# IEEE Refs

Total Science

Refs#

Refs2nd Most Referenced Organization

% IEEE Refs

% Refs

# Refs

% Refs

Appendix C: Top Organizations from All Categories Combined

481 University of Rochester 315IEEE315 2269 278RELX Group (Elsevier)13.9 13.9 12.3482 ODYSSEY WIRELESS INC 314IEEE314 413 253GPP General Partnership Project Standards Body76.0 76.0 6.1483 KT Corp. 313IEEE313 691 125International Telecommunication Union45.3 45.3 18.1484 PerkinElmer Inc. 1137ACS-Am Chem Soc311 4537 686RELX Group (Elsevier)6.9 25.1 15.1485 Duchossois Industries Inc. 308IEEE308 858 120International Association for Cryptologic Research (IACR)35.9 35.9 14.0486 Seoul National University 307IEEE307 1187 144ACS-Am Chem Soc25.9 25.9 12.1487 Seoul Semiconductor Co Ltd 837American Institute of Physics307 2189 307IEEE14.0 38.2 14.0488 Varian Medical Systems Inc. 681John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss306 2886 645RELX Group (Elsevier)10.6 23.6 22.3489 University of Massachusetts 390ACS-Am Chem Soc303 2753 339RELX Group (Elsevier)11.0 14.2 12.3490 Continental AG (Germany Fed 302IEEE302 622 48RELX Group (Elsevier)48.6 48.6 7.7491 Ossur hf 300IEEE300 989 240RELX Group (Elsevier)30.3 30.3 24.3492 Giant Grey Inc (formerly BRS 298IEEE298 343 38International Association for Pattern Recognition (IAPR)86.9 86.9 11.1493 Trimble Inc 298IEEE298 1047 284ION-The Inst of Navigation28.5 28.5 27.1494 CHRIMAR SYSTEMS INC 296IEEE296 673 55Ziff-Davis44.0 44.0 8.2495 Iowa State University 296IEEE296 1582 225ACS-Am Chem Soc18.7 18.7 14.2496 Rohde & Schwarz GmbH & C 296IEEE296 505 66ATSC Std58.6 58.6 13.1497 Danaher Corp. 829RELX Group (Elsevier)295 4619 391John Wiley & Sons/Wiley-Verlag/Wiley-Liss6.4 17.9 8.5498 Drexel University 803RELX Group (Elsevier)295 3278 660American Institute of Physics9.0 24.5 20.1499 Dialog Semiconductor Plc. 290IEEE290 343 18ONLINE INC84.5 84.5 5.2500 National Institute of Informati 290IEEE290 825 138IEICE-Inst Elec Info Comm Eng35.2 35.2 16.7

Wednesday, July 04, 2018 C-13Copyright (c) 2018, 1790 Analytics, LLC