An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing',...

12
ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016 1 An Émigré Bauhauser in Australia An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959 Figure 1 | Screen shot image from the Ian Potter Museum of Art website of Preparing, 1959 with the image caption that contradicts the collections catalogue above (Ian Potter Museum of Art 2016a).

description

Examination of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959, though online records at the Ian Potter Museum of Art and comparative analysis of similar works online has revealed that it may be an example of his durchdrückzeichnung drawing technique, commonly used throughout his career. Historical research and investigation of the materials and techniques involved uncovered the enduring influence of Hirschfeld-Mack’s training in lithography and the artistic sensibility developed during the Weimar period of the Bauhaus school. Even without insitu examination of 'Preparing' to confirm conclusions, this analysis has provided a deeper appreciation of the contributions of an eminent émigré artist practicing in Australia, with direct links to the influential Bauhaus school and prominent European modern artists, but who has been largely unrecognised in Australian cultural history. Written by Robyn Ho.

Transcript of An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing',...

Page 1: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

1

An Émigré Bauhauser in Australia

An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959

Figure 1 | Screen shot image from the Ian Potter Museum of Art website of Preparing, 1959 with the image caption that contradicts the collections catalogue above (Ian Potter Museum of Art 2016a).

Page 2: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

2

Introduction

Upon investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959, housed at the Ian Potter Museum of Art,

contradictions concerning the work’s construction arose. Various descriptions of the artwork list the medium as

either durchdrückzeichnung (press-through drawing) (Figure 2), or as a painting comprising of ‘watercolour on

kalsomine on tempera on cardboard’ (Figure 1). Insitu examination was not feasible during the course of

research to confirm which medium description was correct and only a cursory examination of Preparing could

be conducted. Analysis was based on images provided on the Ian Potter website, historical research and

comparative analysis of similar works in various Australian institutions. Based on this research, it is in the

author’s opinion that Preparing is an example of Hirschfeld-Mack’s durchdrückzeichnung drawings, a technique

that generated a prolific amount of work in the later part of his career. However, determining which medium

description is correct is not the impetus of this paper. This investigation of Preparing provides a springboard to

discuss the techniques and influences of Hirschfeld-Mack, who was a student and teacher at the famed

Bauhaus school during the Weimar period (1919-1925), providing a direct link to a period of seminal European

modernist artistic practices in Australia.

Figure 2 | Screen shot image of the online catalogue entry on the Ian Potter Museum of Art website of Preparing, 1959 (Ian Potter Museum of Art 2016b).

Ludwig Hircshfeld Mack and the Bauhaus in Australia

Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack (1893-1965) was a German-born artist and teacher, whose formative education at the

Weimar Bauhaus was to have a lasting impact on his practice in Australia. Formed by Walter Gropius In 1919,

Weimar, Germany, the Bauhaus was an art and architectural school with a new utopian and progressive spirit

that was to have lasting influence on modern art and design. The curriculum involved training in a craft where

‘…every student at the Bauhaus was trained by two teachers in each subject, that is, by an artist [termed Master

Page 3: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

3

of Form] and a master craftsman [designated Master of Craft]’ (Hirschfeld-Mack 1963, p. 7). A truly holistic

approach that spanned international boundaries, the Bauhaus’ attracted leading European artists as Bauhaus

Masters, including Paul Klee, Wassily Kandinsky, Johannes Itten, Lyonel Feininger and Oskar Schlemmer, László

Maholy-Nagy, Josef Albers and Marcel Breuer (Hirschfeld-Mack 1963, p. 7; Mead 2003; Siebenbrodt & Schöbe

2009). The early Expressionist ideology was the production of a ‘total’ artwork through a union between the

various arts and crafts disciplines (Geelhaar 1973, p. 13; Siebenbrodt & Schöbe 2009, pp. 40-1). The later

Constructivist influences saw the Bauhaus’ second phase, following Gropius’ new motto: ‘art and technology – a

new unity’ (Gropius cited in Siebenbrodt & Schöbe 2009, p. 41), advocating for an economy of materials and

abstraction (Geelhaar 1973, pp. 14-5). Artistic disciplines were progressively isolated over the years, with an

emphasis on design culminating with the Bauhaus’ relocation to Dessau in 1925. Hirschfeld-Mack’s creative

output was intrinsically shaped by the early history of the Bauhaus with both Expressionist and Constructivist

influences that sees ‘…an appeal to the universal as well as a constant struggle between figuration and

abstraction, particularly in his graphic work’ (McNamara 2008, p. 15).

Hirschfeld-Mack received training in the Bauhaus Printing Workshop, developing techniques that were to persist

throughout his career. Hirschfeld-Mack became a lithography apprentice in the Printing Workshop in 1920 and

promoted to journeymen in 1922, providing opportunities for active collaboration with the Bauhaus Masters

(Draffin 1974, pp. 40-1). Hirschfeld-Mack’s particular interest was colour theory and he conducted informal

seminars at the Bauhaus, developed from his training with Kandinsky, Klee and earlier with Adolf Hözel

(Bauhaus-Archiv 2016; Siebenbrodt & Schöbe 2009, p. 49). His most celebrated Bauhaus contributions were his

Colour Light Plays (Farbenlichtspiele), multi-sensory music and light performances, and the Colour Top

(Farbenkriese) (McNamara 2008, 2009). Hirschfeld-Mack did not follow the Bauhaus to Dessau, but instead,

remained in Weimar and taught in schools, eventually moved to Berlin and then fleeing to Britain in 1936 upon

the rise of the Nazis due to his part-Jewish heritage (Fisher 1996; Mead 2003). Subsequently deported to

Australia on the Dunera in 1940, Hirschfeld-Mack was interned at camps near Hay, Orange, and Tatura ,

producing woodcut prints illustrating life under detention (Mead 2003, p. 2; Thomas 1993, p. 520). Under the

sponsorship of the headmaster of Geelong Church of England Grammar School, Hirschfeld-Mack was

appointed art master in 1942 where he implemented holistic material-based learning techniques and promoted

Bauhaus pedagogy in Australian art education (Stasny 1999; Thomas 1993).

Art education was Hirschfeld-Mack’s primary focus and his artistic output was more or less ignored, with little

contact with the local art community. This is surprising considering the recognition of his fellow Bauhaus

colleagues, who he had maintained close contact with (Bosse 2012; Hirschfeld-Mack 1963). Hirschfeld-Mack

Page 4: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

4

held only a handful of exhibitions in Melbourne of original works, with international exhibitions mainly interested

in his Bauhaus era works (Draffin 1974, p. 45; Mead 2003). It was not until his retirement in 1957 that saw a

renewed focus on art as his widow, Olive Hirschfeld-Mack elaborated in 1977:

I expect it does seem surprising that my husband was not more in touch with some of the other artists here,

but he was a shy man who never sought the lime light and he gave himself so completely to his teaching

while at Geelong Grammar School (GCS). One of the Bauhaus staff once said of him, ‘He will either become

a great artist or a great teacher.’ I think the latter became true. He was so concerned to liberate the creative-

ness in young people and that came first so that he often had little time for his own painting until he retired’

(Hirschfeld-Mack O, cited in McNamara 2008, p. 7).

After his death in 1965, his widow bequeathed his artworks and records to Ian Potter Museum of Art, National

Gallery of Australia, National Gallery of Victoria, Art Gallery of New South Wales and the Museum of Modern Art

in the United States. It is during the later period of Hirschfeld-Mack’s retirement that Preparing was completed

and it compels examination of the work in the context of an artistic development that had been continually

disrupted by history and his dedication to education, only to be resumed in relative isolation upon his retirement.

Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack was an important and active figure at the Weimar Bauhaus and his significance in

Australia’s cultural history has largely been unrecognised.

Making of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959

History of Hirschfeld-Mack’s durchdrückzeichnung technique

The durchdrückzeichnung technique begins to appear in Hirschfeld-Mack’s work from 1920 onwards and it is

likely he first encountered it through Paul Klee, a colleague of Hirschfeld-Mack who occupied the adjoining

studio (Bobele 2010, p. 17). The technique is essentially a hand traced print using oil-based paints or

lithographic inks (Jordan 1983, p. 94). The technique was used most prolifically by Klee between 1919 and 1925

during the Weimar Bauhaus period. Klee described the process as ‘a sheet of paper is painted with black oil

colouring and is used as a carbon. The reverse of the drawing is then worked with a needle’ (Klee, cited in

Draffin 1974, p. 42). For Klee, the technique was intended for duplicating works or drawings that could be

transferred onto the lithographic stone. The technique imparted the ‘carbon’ paper’s texture from accidental

smudges of the palm and the soft fuzzy broad character of the traced line created by the pressure of the stylus,

diffused through multiple layers of paper (Gryberger 1979, p. 11; Jordan 1983, p. 94). Some prints were

subsequently coloured with watercolour with the colour receding from the line due to the chemical antipathy of

Page 5: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

5

the oil linework and the water-based medium, making the sequence of the work’s construction evident in

alignment with Klee’s theories on art (Bobele 2010, p. 17; Jordan 1983, pp. 92-3).

Purportedly, Klee regarded the technique of durchdrückzeichnung as a closely guarded secret (Geelhaar 1973,

pp. 87-8; Jordan 1983, p. 96). However, such a simple technique could readily occur to an accomplished printer

such as Hirschfeld-Mack who would be accustomed to working with paper and slow drying inks, and skilled in

achieving delicate textures through lithography (Draffin 1974, p. 42). Many of Hirschfeld-Mack’s 1920s

durchdrückzeichnung works share the figurative qualities and ‘fuzzy’ aesthetic of Klee’s work, suggesting his

influence on Hirschfeld-Mack’s practice (Draffin 1974) (Figure 3). Many of the Hirschfeld-Mack’s later works in

the Ian Potter collection from his time in Australia are classified as durchdrückzeichnung, with a similar visual

quality, strongly suggesting Preparing was made using this method. Comparing online records of visually similar

works from the same period housed in the National Gallery of Australia, National Gallery of Victoria and at the Ian

Potter, all these institutions classify these artworks as prints, transfer prints or monotypes, suggesting Preparing

indeed involved a similar application of ink on a paper support, however, employed in a more direct manner.

Figure 3 | Image of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Untitled (Room interior with figures and star), 1922 on the left, and Paul Klee’s Steamer for Lugano, 1922. The figurative and lyrical drawing of Hirschfeld-Mack’s work displays some visual similarities to Klee’s work, both dated 1922 where they were both at the Weimar Bauhaus.

Left: Ludwig Hirschfeld, Untitled (Room interior with figures and star), 1922, ink; paper transfer print, printed in black ink, from one plate, 18.4 x 17.9 cm, National Gallery of Victoria (National Gallery of Australia 2016b).

Right: Paul Klee, Steamer for Lugano, 1922, lithograph, c. 27.8 x 38.8 cm, Museum of Modern Art (Museum of Modern Art 2016).

Adaptation of the durchdrückzeichnung technique in Preparing

Bobele (2010) examines Hirschfeld-Mack’s adaptation of Klee’s technique, employed on works at the Ian Potter

which reflects a more direct method which had not been seen in his work prior to his arrival in Australia. With

Page 6: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

6

either pencil or ballpoint pen, the drawing was made directly on the back of the receiving paper placed on an

inked plate, creating an instantaneous imprint on the reverse. On the National Gallery of Australia’s website,

Hirschfeld-Mack’s work, Untitled (Landscape with moon and trees), 1959, reveals both the recto and verso,

clearly demonstrating the method (Figure 4).

[T]he reasons for choosing it were thus obviously aesthetic – the line produced is of a fine yet darkly

definitive nature that varies in its quality according to viscosity of ink, texture of paper and the relative

hardness of the pencil or pen used in the ‘original’ drawing’ (Bobele 2010, p. 18).

Comparing the defined linework of Preparing with the fainter ‘scratches’ of his 1920s works, it appears Preparing

was indeed drawn in such a direct method. The more deliberately composed background ‘smudges’ seem have

a textured appearance with striations achieved by scratching the ink surface on the plate.

Figure 4 | Image of the recto (left) and verso (right) of Hirschfeld-Mack’s Untitled (Landscape with moon and trees), 1959, showing the adjustment of the durchdrückzeichnung technique which involved directly drawing on the back of the receiving paper to imprint the ink onto the underside (recto side).

Ludwig Hirschfeld, Landscape with moon and trees, 1959, transfer print, printed in black ink; watercolour additions (recto); black pencil (verso), 22.2 x 27.4 cm, National Gallery of Victoria (National Gallery of Australia 2016a).

Such a direct technique would undoubtedly inform the imagery, requiring a simpler pictorial language as one

would not have the benefits of tracing a pre-prepared sketch. Bobele (2010) concurs with this observation and

remarks on the abstract quality of Hirschfeld-Mack’s later drawings:

The ability to produce such a line in an action akin to drawing undoubtedly informed the imagery used by

Mack in many of the monotypes in the Potter collection, most of which are explorations of the natural

rhythms of line, form and (where watercolours have been incorporated) colour. … Almost through the use of

a single stroke, Mack explores the potential for change of a particular form through several metamorphoses’

(Bobele 2010, pp. 18-9).

Page 7: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

7

The abstract imagery of Preparing reflects the form and colour theories espoused by the Bauhaus Master,

Wassily Kandinsky. Preparing depicts three figures constructing a totem composed of triangles with a circle at

the apex, the watercolour passages in primary colours. Kandinsky famously associated the circle, triangle and

square with blue, yellow and red respectively(Hirschfeld-Mack 1963, p. 6; Poling 1986, pp. 72-3). The use of

these fundamental shapes and the application of primary colours show the recurrence of Hirschfeld-Mack’s

Bauhaus influences in not only in his adaptation of Klee’s durchdrückzeichnung printmaking technique, but also

in the abstract pictorial language in his later works.

Materials of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959

Preparing is potentially composed of a paper support with a lithographic ink ‘print’ or ‘press-through’ drawing

with watercolour applied over. Aligned with Bauhaus ideology that championed the ‘truth’ of materials and an

economy of production, the durchdrückzeichnung technique is relatively simple, exploiting the innate

characteristics of the materials. The execution of Preparing appears more refined compared to Hirschfeld-

Mack’s earlier work, demonstrating his mastery and familiarity with the materials in his later career.

Support layer

In Preparing, Hirschfeld-Mack shows a nuanced command of the primary material, paper. Choice of support is

often informed by the intended media, and with the predominately watercolour surface and technical

requirements of the durchdrückzeichnung process, Hirschfeld-Mack would have considered paper absorbency

and thickness. The material qualities that the paper in Preparing would need to exhibit are: adequate absorbency

for watercolour and lithographic ink application without bleeding and yet with enough absorbency to adhere to

the surface; and, significant stiffness to ensure the paper can support itself above the inked plate without

unwanted contact whilst also allowing reasonable pliability to be imprinted from the reverse. Premium

watercolour paper appears to be most suitable material. Premium papers would have been used, especially

since his drawings are effectively one-of-a-kind hand-watercoloured monoprints. In European papermaking,

mold or handmade rag papers made purely from cotton are considered the finest support for artists’ papers

(Gettens & Stout 1966, p. 244; Gottsegen 1987, p. 18). Cotton fibres compared to linen have longer lengths,

uniform diameter and high cellulose composition, qualities that are highly prized for producing and paper with

bulk, opacity and strength for art prints and drawings (Bolam 1965, p. 86; Gettens & Stout 1966, p. 242).

Page 8: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

8

The predominately watercolour surface would have primarily dictated the selection of a suitably sized paper.

Watercolour paper requires impregnation with sizing that produces the correct balance of absorbency – too

much will produce irregular effects, whist too little will give dull results (Mayer 1991, p. 301). Internal sizes of

ideally gelatine or hide glue are used in artists’ papers, though starch, gums, oils, waxes, potash alum (later

replaced by aluminium sulphate), and synthetic resins can also be used to produce other standards of paper

(Henry 1988; National Archives of Australia 2013). The durchdrückzeichnung technique relies on mechanical

pressure of the pencil to impress the ink. Compare this process to standard lithography that depend on the mere

contact with skilfully placed ink on the stone and therefore requiring a highly absorbent or unsized paper

(Grabowski & Fick 2009, pp. 26,159). Therefore, the adhesion of the lithographic ink on Preparing is facilitated

by pressure of the pencil rather than the paper’s absorbancy, suggesting that the work may have been

completed on sized artist quality papers.

Thickness is an important quality in watercolour papers. Thin papers less than 280 pounds (600 grams /m2) tend

to cockle on contact with water, requiring stretching onto a board, whilst heavyweight board-like papers do not

require such preparation (Krug 2007, p. 118; Mayer 1991, pp. 302-3). Considering reasonable flexibility is

required for the pressure of the pencil to impress through the paper, heavyweight paper would not have been

used for Preparing. Commonly, 140 pounds (300 grams/m2) and similar paper gauges are used in watercolours

and could conceivably provide the required stiffness to sit above the inked plate but pliable enough for the

pressure of the pencil (Krug 2007, p. 118; Mayer 1991, p. 302). However, mid-weight papers require stretching

before painting. Preparing measures 635mm x 505mm, smaller than the most common standard-sized ‘imperial’

sheet (762mm x 558mm) (Mayer 1991, p. 303). This may indicate Hirschfeld-Mack did indeed fix the paper on a

board with tape, glue or tacks to the edges, which were subsequently trimmed off upon completion of the work.

Media layer

The media of Preparing possibly consists of lithographic ink with watercolour paint over, illustrating Hirschfeld-

Mack’s printmaking skills developed at the Bauhaus. The lithographic process relies on the chemical

incompatibility of oil and water, requiring careful modification of oil-based inks to resist water successfully

(Leach & Pearce 1993, p. 4). Traditional inks were based on heat-bodied linseed oils (oil partially polymerised by

heat) and rosin, with the addition of waxes and other additives to produce the desired viscosity (Gottsegen 1987,

pp. 59-62; Leach & Pearce 1993, p. 4; Mayer 1991, p. 598). The 1920s saw the introduction of synthetic resins

and the eventual prevalence of synthetic resin inks in the postwar era (Leach & Pearce 1993, p. 4). Lithographic

processes produce a smooth uniform ink layer, requiring a stiff ‘buttery’ paste with higher viscosities to be

readily rolled and levelled with the necessary tackiness and oiliness (Mayer 1991, p. 598). These rheological

Page 9: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

9

qualities are closely controlled and graded in commercial inks, with master printers formulating the desired inks

by combining two or more viscosities (Mayer 1991, p. 598). Lithographic inks are formulated on slower

evaporating solvents, due to the large surface area of the roller system and the relatively long time the ink is

exposed during the traditional lithography process (Leach & Pearce 1993, p. 7). Lithographic inks dry mainly

through absorption into the substrate and chemical and oxidation reactions of the resins, creating cross-linked

and durable films (Leach & Pearce 1993, pp. 9-10).

Preparing was completed in 1959, well within the arrival of synthetic resins. However, considering Hirschfeld-

Mack’s history at the Bauhaus, traditional linseed oil-based inks may also be present. Hirschfeld-Mack’s training

in the Bauhaus Printing Workshop was conducted under the Master of Form, Lyonel Feininger (1871 – 1957)

(Draffin 1974, pp. 15-7). Gropius’ first appointment and already an established practitioner before arriving at the

Bauhaus, Feininger would have been familiar with the printing process using traditional oil-based ink. It could be

inferred that Hirschfeld-Mack would have been initially trained in the manipulation of traditional oil-based inks,

and due to his disrupted artistic output, potentially resuming established practices during this later career when

Preparing was completed. In any case, either oil- or synthetic-based lithographic inks may have been used. The

material qualities of lithographic ink would assist the durchdrückzeichnung method: slow evaporation rate would

ensure time could be taken to compose the image and improvise during the drawing process; whilst the

customisation of ink viscosity would allow the adhesion qualities to be controlled to prevent unwanted ink to be

deposited on the receiving paper.

Hirschfeld-Mack’s lithography experience may have informed his ability to create the stippled shading and

water-coloured areas in Preparing. In lithography, a variety of painterly textured effects can be achieved with the

drawing or brushing of oil-based tusche onto to the stone or transfer paper, allowing oil-based ink to be

deposited onto the tusche, whilst leaving the untouched hydrophilic gum Arabic etched areas un-inked

(Gascoigne 1986, pp. 1c-2a,b; Grabowski & Fick 2009, pp. 163-5; Mayer 1991, pp. 588-98). For a skilled

lithographer, achieving the stippled texture would be simple, potentially mimicking Klee’s methods where he

used papers, fabrics and other materials inked up with tusche to impress textures (Jordan 1983, p. 94).

Hirschfeld-Mack may have used a similar technique to disturb the smooth ink on the plate. An understanding of

the antipathy of water and oil crucial to lithography would have also informed the application of watercolour

which allows the ink linework and shading to maintain intensity and clarity, and a common technique to colour

prints and used by Klee (Bobele 2010, p. 20). Watercolour paints are pigments suspended in a gum Arabic and

water solution, solutions already in use in the lithography process (Mayer 1991, p. 304). The colours used on

Preparing appear to be single pigments: ultramarine blue, alizarin and lemon yellow (pale cadmium or strontium

Page 10: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

10

yellows potentially), all suitable for watercolour (Mayer 1991, p. 79). Such a ‘pure’ use of colour would be

considered aligned with the artistic ideology of the Bauhaus which advocated non-representational abstraction,

showing the ongoing influence of the Bauhaus on Hirschfeld-Mack’s later works.

Conclusion

Examination of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s Preparing, 1959, though online records at the Ian Potter and

comparative analysis of similar works online has revealed that it may be an example of his durchdrückzeichnung

drawing technique, commonly used throughout his career. Historical research and investigation of the materials

and techniques involved uncovered the enduring influence of Hirschfeld-Mack’s training in lithography and the

artistic sensibility developed during the Weimar period of the Bauhaus school. Indeed, Hirschfeld-Mack

embodied in his practice the union of craft and art, espoused by the Weimar Bauhaus, displaying an intimate

understanding of materials and the tradition of lithography but employing them in new ways using a modern

abstracted pictorial language. Even without insitu examination of Preparing to confirm conclusions, this analysis

has provided a deeper appreciation of the contributions of an eminent émigré artist practicing in Australia, with

direct links to the influential Bauhaus school and prominent European modern artists, but who has been largely

unrecognised in Australian cultural history.

Page 11: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

11

References

Bauhaus-Archiv 2016, Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack, Bauhaus-Archiv, viewed 24 April 2016, <http://www.bauhaus-online.de/en/atlas/personen/ludwig-hirschfeld-mack>. Bobele, S 2010, 'A journey into abstraction: The pictorial language of Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack', University of Melbourne Collections, no. 7, pp. 17-23. Bolam, FM (ed.) 1965, Stuff Preparation for Paper and Paperboard Making : Monographs on Paper and Board Making, Pergamon Press, Oxford. Bosse, J 2012, 'Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack', in Visions Past and Present: Celebrating 40 years, The Ian Potter Museum of Art, University of Melbourne, pp. 92-3. Draffin, N 1974, Two Masters of the Weimar Bauhaus: Lyonel Feininger, Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack, Trustees of the Art Gallery of New South Wales, Sydney. Fisher, T 1996, 'Hirschfeld-Mack, Ludwig (1893–1965)', in J Ritchie & D Langmore (eds), Australian Dictionary of Biography, Melbourne University Press, Carlton, Victoria, viewed 24 April 2016, <http://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/hirschfeld-mack-ludwig-10510>. Gascoigne, B 1986, How to Identify Prints: A complete guide to manual and mechanical processes from woodcut to ink jet, Thames and Hudson, London. Geelhaar, C 1973, Paul Klee and the Bauhaus, New York Graphic Society, Greenwich, Connecticut. Gettens, RJ & Stout, GL 1966, Painting Materials, Dover, New York. Gottsegen, MD 1987, A Manual of Painting Materials and Techniques, Harper and Row, New York. Grabowski, B & Fick, B 2009, Printmaking: A complete guide to materials and processes, Laurence King Publishing, London. Gryberger, BG 1979, In celebration of Paul Klee: Fifty Prints, vol. 18, Stanford Art Book, Stanford University, Stanford, California. Henry, W (ed.) 1988, Chapter 17 - Sizing / Resizing, Paper Conservation Catalog, American Institute for Conservation Book and Paper Group, Washington D.C. Hirschfeld-Mack, L 1963, The Bauhaus: An introductory survey, Longmans, Croydon, Victoria. Ian Potter Museum of Art 2016a, The Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack Collection, Ian Potter Museum of Art, viewed 24 April 2016, <http://www.art-museum.unimelb.edu.au/collection/named-collections/namecol/4>. Ian Potter Museum of Art 2016b, Search the Collection, Ian Potter Museum of Art, viewed 24 April 2016, <http://www.art-museum.unimelb.edu.au/collection/search-the-collection/>. Jordan, J 1983, 'Klee's Prints and Oil Transfer Works: Some Futher Reflections', in The Graphic Legacy of Paul Klee, Bard College, Annandale-on-Hudson, New York. Krug, M 2007, An Artist's Handbook: Materials and Techniques, Laurence King Publishing, London. Leach, RH & Pearce, RJ (eds) 1993, The Printing Ink Manual, 5th edn, Springer, Dordrecht. Mayer, R 1991, The Artist's Handbook of Materials and Techniques, Viking, New York. McNamara, A 2008, 'The Bauhaus in Australia', in A Stephen, P Goad & A McNamara (eds), Modern Times: The untold story of modernism in Australia, The Miegunyah Press / Powerhouse Museum, Carlton, Victoria. McNamara, A 2009, 'The Colour of Modernism: Colour-Form Experiements in Europe and Australia', in S Bru, J Baetens & B Hjartarson (eds), Europa! Europa?, De Gruyter, Berlin / Boston, pp. 494-513. Mead, S 2003, In Detail: Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack, Ian Potter Museum of Art, viewed 20 April 2016, <http://www.art-museum.unimelb.edu.au/assets/files/general/15Mack.pdf>.

Page 12: An émigré Bauhauser in Australia: An investigation of Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack’s 'Preparing', 1959

ASSIGNMENT 2 OBJECT INVESTIGATION CUMC90028 CONSERVATION AND OBJECT BASED LEARNING

Student Details | Robyn Ho (672025) Date | 20.05.2016

12

Museum of Modern Art 2016, German Expressionism: Works from the collection, MoMA, viewed 9 May 2016, <http://www.moma.org/collection_ge/object.php?object_id=67394>. National Archives of Australia 2013, Research Project Report: 20th Century Paper Quality, National Archives of Australia, Canberra, viewed 7 May 2016, <http://paper.naa.gov.au/assets/data/Final-Report.pdf>. National Gallery of Australia 2016a, Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack, (Landscape with moon and trees) [recto] (Study for 'Landscape with moon and trees') [verso], National Gallery of Australia, viewed 24 April 2016, <http://artsearch.nga.gov.au/Detail-LRG.cfm?IMG=32617_a&IRN=32617&vID=2>. National Gallery of Australia 2016b, Ludwig Hirschfeld Mack, not titled [Room interior with figures and star], National Gallery of Australia, viewed 09 May 2016, <http://artsearch.nga.gov.au/Detail-LRG.cfm?IRN=56989>. Poling, CV 1986, Kandinsky's Teaching at the Bauhaus, Rizzoli International, New York. Siebenbrodt, M & Schöbe, L 2009, Bauhaus: 1919-1933 Weimar-Dessau-Berlin, Parkstone International, New York. Stasny, P 1999, 'Bauhaus Pedagogy in Exile: Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack and Art Education', paper presented to International Society for Education through Art (InSEA) 30th World Congress: Cultures and Transitions, Brisbane, 21-26 September. Thomas, D 1993, 'Hirschfeld-Mack: Daniel Thomas on the influence of his teacher Ludwig Hirschfeld-Mack', Art and Australia, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 518-20.