American Loyalty (1893)
Transcript of American Loyalty (1893)
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
1/24
AMERICANLOYALTY.
WASHINGTONFOUNDER,WEBSTEREXPOUNDER
OFTHE
FEDERALCONSTITUTION.
ANADDRESS,
(DeliveredJune20th,1893;duringCommencementExercisesoftheUniversityofGeorgia,byinvita-tionoftheAlumniSociety,andpublishedatitsrequest.
BYHENRYR.JACKSON,LL.D.
SAVANNAH,GA.1893.
LadiesandGentlemen:
TheorationofMr.ChaunceyM.Depewonthehun-dredthanniversaryoftheinaugurationofPresidentWashingtonsuggestedtheremarksIamnowabout
tomake.Ihadhopedtoutterthemortheirlike,veryshortlyafterthathistoricoccasion,beforeanotheracademicinstitution.Disappointedinthis,andsub-sequentlyhonoredbytheinvitationwhichhasbroughtmehither,afterserioushesitancybecauseofthelapseoftime,Ihaveconcludedthatitwillnotbepossibleformetodobetterthantoofferthemhere.
Itoughtcertainlytogowithoutsaying,Ithink,that,DanielWebsterdead,thefirstcentennialcel-ebrationofWashington'sinaugurationcouldbutbeincomplete.IthadtheMaster'sownspecialworkforthegreatestword-painterthatevertilledtherostrum.
Belonging,notlesstotheSouthernthantotheEast-ern,NorthernorWesternStates,theoccasionitselfhaditsownspecialneedofascatholicapatriotaseverfacedanAmericanaudience.Howsadly,then,diditrecalltheoratorwhoaboveallothersbyhisutterances,andthestatesmanwho,evenmoresignallyinhiscareer,hadillustratedthedistinctiveAmericanmeaningofthewordLoyalty!Nodictionarygivesit.NoahWebster,ofA.D.1859,definesthewordthus:Loyal,a.Truetoplightedfaith,dutyor
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
2/24
love,asaloyalsubject,aloyalwife.Loyalty,n.Fidelitytoaprinceorsovereign,ortoahusbandorlover.
But,sinceJuly4th,1776,forthepeopleoftheNorthAmericanStateSovereignties,therehadbeennoprince!Didthedeclarersofindependence,andtheframersoftheconstitution,whentheyabolishedprinces,abolishalsoloyalty?DidtheykillthenerveofthatgovernmentalforcewhichdrewEuropeoutoftheNightoftheMiddleAges;givingrootandsaptotheoutgrowthoftheFeudalSystem,and,throughit,totheentiresuper-growthofmodernEuropeancivilization?alreadysomewhatoldwhentransplantedtothisnewcontinentbyourloyalfore-fathers.Itstap-rootdeadenedbytheirrebelsons,havetheleavesbegunsosoon,andappallingthought!forus,towither?
NoahWebster,ofA.D.1869,thusdefinestheword:Loyal,a.Devotedtothemaintenanceoflaw.Loyalty,n.Thestateorqualityofbeingloyal.
Thewordstillthere!butwherethepassionthatitnamed?Wholovesthelaw?WholovestheCon-stitution,StateorFederal?Whocanlovetheabstractlaw?GodpermitsustolovenothingHim-selfinnaturedidnotmake.Aman?adog?-Yes!Atree?alake?amountain?
LivesthereamanwithsoulsodeadWhonevertohimselfhathsaid.Thisismyown,mynativeland?
Butabook?acodeoflaws?astatue?WhenhasfranticyouthdrownedhimselfintheArnobecause
oflovefortheVenusdeMedici?InthetwinklingofaneyethelexicographerwouldtransportusoverdeadcenturiesofChristianEuropeanhistorybacktothelivingPaganlanguagewhichhasgivenroottoaworditdidnothaveitself;andhaditnotbecausetheFeudalpassionhadnoplaceinthePagansoul.Itdidnotspeak,atThermopylae,inthemessage:Traveller,tellitinLacedaemonthatwefellhereinobediencetoherlaws.ItwasnotatRomeneargreatCaesar,when,withettuBruteonhislips,hedied.Andwhen,toavertidealdangerfromhi&imperialmaster,AntinoussprangintotheNile,thedazedclassicintellect,vainlyseekingtheimpulsein
emotionknownbeneaththesun,locateditabovethestars;apotheosizedthesuicide,andthehumblepagebecameaPagangod.Apotheosisstartlinglyexcep-tionaltotheotherwiseexceptionlessruleofthePaganMythology!whichhadalreadycrowdeditsOlympuswithdivinities,eachofthembutareflectionofsomeself-assertingattributeofmerehumannature;show-ingthatthecivilizationoftheGreekandtheRomanwhichhadprobablycarriedphilosophicthought,andartconceptionandexecution,totheirculminating
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
3/24
pointseveninthisitslatterday,wasstillalivetotheold,pre-historic,yearningofearthdiscontentforsomethingassumedmayitnothavebeenfelt?tobeintheultimateheaven.Formodern,probably;nay!comparativelyspeaking,very,very,verymod-ern,possibly,thereporteddialoguebetweenthetwoAthenians,who,standinguponthetop-mostpeakeverscaledbythepureintellectofearthwitharmsout-stretchedintothethin,coldair,andeyesupturnedtothecold,unsympatheticstarsexclaimed,
SOCRATESAmanmustcometotellusmore.AlcibiadesHecannotcometoosoon.Wasnotthis,probably,butrepetitionofwhathadalreadyoccurred,nay!hadbeenoccurring,andcast-ingitsshadowintraditionbackward?thepiling,forexample,ofPelionandOssauponOlympustoscalecelestialwalls,followedbythedescentofthemountainsuponthegiantsofEarth;thebuildingofthetowerofBabel,followedbytheconfusionoftongues;thestealingbytheafterwardrock-held,vul-turedevouredPrometheusforEarthofthefireofHeaven.Notthuswasittocome!Andwhenitdidinfactcometoteachbythebirthinastable,and
thedeathuponacross,thatThefoolishnessofGodiswiserthanmen;theweaknessofGodisstrongerthanmen;andthustofortifythefinitemindofManagainstthatGod-annihilatingcrazewhich,butforthisinterpositionofHeaven,musthaveindubita-blyfollowedthethenapproachingtelescopicrevela-tionofthematerialinfinite,thelessonwastooanni-hilatingoftheself-sufficiencyofapurelyintellectualcivilizationforacceptancebyit.OnceagainthegiantofEarthroseHeaven-defying;andonceagaindowncametheimprecatedmountaininform,assuredly,notunprecedented!LettheexhumationsbyourowngenerationinAsiaMinorbeartestimony!sidebyside
withtheexhumationsbymanygenerationsinRome;notaloneonPalatine-hill,butthroughouttheentiresiteofthemodernandallovertheCampagna,sitealsooftheancientcityoritssuburbsexhumationsofthebeautifulbonesofadeadcivilization,scarcecolderindeaththanitwasinlife,wheretheylayburied,bynoabrasionofanAlp,itistrue,bynoVesuvianeruption,but,literally,bytheslowdrift-ingsofthedustofages!nohandsoactiveastobrushitaside;notastesolivingastoremovethethingofbeautytobeajoyforeverinsomehumanhome!WhenitsshadowscouldthusrestsoheavilyupontheEternalCity,howdarkover
Europegenerallyandespeciallythosevastprovinceswhichlayoutofsightofthefewotherminorcenterswherethemonkcouldkeephistaperburninghowdarkmusthavebeenthatmediaevalnight!
IntheHeathen,andinthePagan,and,heretofore,intheChristianworld;and,hereafter,ifthesombrepicturevaticinatedbyMacauleyoftheNewZea-landerstandinguponLondonBridgeandsketchingtheruinsofSt.Paulshallberealized,howclosely
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
4/24
doesthelifeofsociety,ortheaggregate-man,assimilatetothatoftheunit-man?inbirth,child-hood,youth,maturity,decrepitude,anddeath?thecivilizationsandthebarbarismsoftheone,tothegoodhabitsandthebadhabitsoftheother?nohabitandnocivilizationtobedisplacedbyacoupdemain,oracoupd'etat;noryetbyamiraclefromHeaven!tobeconqueredonlybythegradualsubstitutionofanother.Andtheprocess,howlikethemovementofanarmedinvasion?capturingterritory,holdingit,extendingit,losingit;recapturingit,timesandtimesagainwithoutnumber,untilthefinalresultshallhavebeenreachedintheabsorptionortheexterminationoftheonebytheother.
Andthedissolutionofacivilization,howlikethedecompositionofacorpse!startingmorequicklyatthispoint,progressingmorerapidlyatthat,andyetbygradationonlypossessingitselfofall.Disintegra-tionofsociety,ortheaggregate-mats',bytheindi-vidualizationoftheunit-manunderthebrutalizingdespotismofself!processwhich,oncewellunderway,canbearrested,intheverynatureofthings,onlybyextrinsicforce.Andwhenhasthisever
occurredIBut,unlessarrested,progressingwiththecertaintyoffateitselftobarbarismashideousinthemysteriesofitsgloomasisthedarknessofthegraveitself;raylessnight!fromwhichthephilo-sophichistorianfallsbaffledback,andleavestoad-venturousspeculationtheuncertainattempttogiveanythingofformorfixationtowhatexistedortran-spiredwithinitsCimmerianbosom.Andwhereshallspeculationseekafoot-holduponwhichtocatchun-lessitcanbefoundinpossibleassimilationtosome-thingwhichhascomewithinsightofourownday?thecondition,forexample,oftheearth-manofAfrica,asreported;oroftheroot-eatingIndian,aswefound
himamongtheRockyMountains;worshippingno-thing,lovingnothingthemanbuthimself,thewomanlovingheroffspringasthecow:loveshercalf.Uponhumanitythusbrutalizeditisaltogetherclearthatnothingbutbruteforcethesuperiormuscleofthephysicalarm,thesuperiornerve-pluckofthematerialbraincouldtell.Andthis,doubtless,be-cameactiveintherobber-knight,wholashedhisserforslaveintosubjection.Doesitnotseemthat,inthelifeofMan,thetwoextremesmustalwaystoucheachother'?Forrighthere,astheeffectofalawwhichwouldappearatleastsincetheadventofourSaviourtobeasinexorableasitisuniversal;that,
wherevertwohumancreaturesshallbethrowntogetherinthepersonalrelationshipofMasterandSlave,BaronandVassal,SovereignandSubject,mutualin-terest,sympathy,affection,lovewillshootoutfromtheonetotheotherasnaturallyasgrasssproutsfromtheearth:co-operatingwithyetanotherlawofuni-versalpotencyevenyetmoreassured;thatlovebeitbuttheloveofamanforhisdog!inasmuchasitdrawshimoutofhimself,elevateshimuponthescaleofhumanity;righthereweareprobablycontemplat-
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
5/24
ingtheflashingoutofthefirstsparkoftheChristiancivilization,atlasttriumphant,fromthedetestablegraveoftheeldercivilizations.Righthere,sayI,wearestandingatthebirth-timeandthebirthplaceofmodernEuropeanloyalty.Wasthefirstscreamofthenew-bornbabeannouncementtotheworldthat,Heaven'sgovernmentofManhavingbeenmadebyin-carnationofthedivineattributeoflovepersonal,Earth'sgovernmentofManmustbequickenedbythesamecelestialpotency,andmustbealsopersonal?Terrificquestion!uponwhichwe,Americans,havebeenandstillarethemostconspicuousexperimen-ters.
Needlessforme,withsuchanaudience,tofollowcloselythephilosophichistorianofModernEuropeanCivilizationforthepurposeofshowingthat,forcentu-riesofitsdevelopment,tohavewithdrawnfromitthatgovernmentalforceofwhichloyalty*wasindeedthespinalnervewouldhavebeenlikecuttingofffromnostrilsthevitalizingair.Andhownaturalwasthatdevelopment?Beginningwiththefirstshootingsfromtheearth,whichdrewtheindividualintothefamily,tothemultitudinousinter-twiningsofroots
andinter-lacingsofbranches,whichdrewthefamilyintothebarony,andthebaronyintotheearldom,andtheearldomintothedukedom,andthedukedomintotheprincipality;givingtothechieforprinceofeach,consecutively,permanentfixationasapersonalityofpowerintheorganismoftheStatepast,present,futurethusmakingofeachlivingoneofthem,asitwere,butasinglelinkinachainwhichshoulddrawhimfromthepresentandoutofhimselftowardthepast,asitshouldrunglitteringbackthroughthegen-erationsofhisancestry;whichshoulddrawhimfromthepresentandoutofhimselftowardthefuture,towhichhewastotransmititstillglitteringthrough
thegenerationsofhisposterity.Wastherenothinginthisinothingtoexpandthereflecting,nothingtoennobletheemotionalbeing)nothingtofithimtobethenucleusorcynosureofsocialaggregation,itselftobecomeapermanentvitalofthenation(thevitalsofeachsuchvitaltobeheldtogetherinitsowndevelopment,andallsuchvitalstobethemselvesheldtogetherinthenational,byLoyaltycreepingfromonetotheotherandoverall,liketheivy,but,unliketheivy,burstingoutattimesintoloveliestbloom,andsheddingthecelestialfragranceofself-sacrificeoversomeofthebrightest,andyetmoreofthesaddest,pagesofEuropeanHistory.Wastherenothingin
this?
*Loyalty,generallyactivewith,butclearlydistinguishablefrom,Fealtytheonebornofthespiritual,theotheroftheintellectualnature.
Irepeat,Hownaturalwasthatdevelopment?Slowapparentlyatfirst,butprogressingwitheverac-celeratedvelocity,untilithadprobablytouchedtheperfectionofitsfruitageinthereproductionintheModernoftheIslesofGreeceintheAncient
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
6/24
World.
TheIslesofGreece,theIslesofGreece,WhereburningSappholovedandsung;Wheregrewtheartsofwarandpeace;
wherethehumanintellectwasprobablyhypertro-phiedandthehumansoulwaspossiblyatrophied;theveryworld'sradiatingcentreoflearningandofpleasure;ofphilosophy,alwaysclearCequin'estpasclairn'estpasFrancais!andoffashion,alwaysfit;ofthetragicandthecomicmusetheeagleandthehumming-bird;beautiful,sparkling,kaleid-oscopic;charming,enchanting,ravishingParis!resplendentthrone!uponwhich,inthehistoricejacu-lation:L'etat!C'estmoi!TheState!ItisI!LouisQuatorzetheFeudalPrinceprobablywokethechordwhichwastosoundhisowndeath-knell.Centuriesbefore,acrossthechannel,MagnaCartahadbeenpluckedfromtheprince'sbeard.ButtheAnglo-Saxonistenacious,isconservative;andseemedbuttofondleyetmorecloselytheFeudalPassiontohisheart.Nay!truetotheinstinct,sogenerallyascribedtoJohnBull,heseemstohave
actuallyappropriatedtohimselfwhatbelongedtomodernmankind.Atleast,sotellsusthelexico-grapher.NoahWebster,of1887,givingLoyaltyas:Fidelitytoasuperior,quotesfromTrench,Englishlexicographer:Loyalty,derivedfromtheFrenchwordLoi,expressesproperlythatfidelitywhichoneowesaccordingtolaw;anddoesnotneces-sarilyincludethatattachmenttotheroyalpersonwhich,happily,weinEnglandhavebeenablefurthertothrowintotheword.
ItremainedforGeorgeWashington,puttingasidetheFeudalCrownfromhisownbrow,todeper-
sonateEarth'sgovernmentofMan,andtofixitintheabstractlaw.Hereitis!Cold,butpure!unsym-pathetic,butincorruptible!acrownedabstraction!holdingthesceptreofempireinapulselesshandtheConstitutionoftheUnitedStates!Sublimecontemplation!thattheAmericanCitizenisthesub-jectonlyofthought!that,mattersnotwhoorwherehemaybe,whetherinWashingtonthenation'sChief,orfollowinghisplowinthebroadblazeofthenoon-daysunupontheWesternprairie,herecognizesnomaterialmediumbetweenhimselfandthedivinesourceofallthought,ofalllaw,ofalltruth;andthat,,whenhebendstheknee,hekneelsonlytohisGod!
Here,indeed,wasrebelliontriumphant!Here,indeed,hadbeentheveryground-swellofrevolutionwhich,tearingthroughthecomplicated,giantgrowthofnearlyathousandyears,hadtosseditsquickeningprinciple,loyalty,uponthetop-mostbillow,towardthestars!Butwastherenovacuumleftwhichhumannaturemightabhor?Wastherenodangertosociety,ortheaggregate-man,inthusagainindividualizingtheunit-man?
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
7/24
sosuddenly,soviolently,sothoroughly?thuscut-tinghimofffromallorganicrelationshipwiththePastthroughhisancestry,withtheFuturethroughhisposterity;fromanythingonearthtolookupto,and,obeying,learntolove;fromanythingtolookdownupon,and,protecting,cometolove?Thusiso-latedintimeuponthatfugaciouspoint,thePresent,andinLifewithinthatpitifulinfinitesimality,Mm-self,whereindidhisownpersonalstatusdifferfromthatofhisbarbaricsire,atthemediaevalmidnight?Wastherenodangerthattheprocessofreintegration,whichhadcommencedatthatpoint,thusarrestedbyrevolution,andwhocouldsay,withassurance,notprematurely?mightnotbereversed?anddisinte-grationonceagainbegininthemidstofthemodernasithadbeguninthemidstoftheancientcivilization?Wastherenovoidhere,which,soonerorlater,mightcometoache?DidtheFoundersofourGov-ernmentnothingtofillit?Icanconceiveofnoanswertothisquestionunlessitshallbefoundinasinglesen-tencewhichIreadfromtheConstitutionof1786:TheSenatorsandRepresentativesbeforementionedandtheMembersoftheseveralStateLegisla-tures,andallExecutiveandJudicialOfficers,
bothoftheUnitedStatesandoftheseveralStates,shallbeboundbyoathtosupportthisConstitution.
IsitnotaltogetherclearthatWashingtonandhisassociatesmusthavebelievedthatthepointhadbeenreachedinthedevelopmentoftheChristianCiviliza-tion,whenitmightbesafelyassumedthatloyaltytotheprincesofthisworldhadbeenmergedandlostthroughtheprogressiveworkoftheIncarnation-inabroaderandaloftierpassion?totheextent,atleast,ofsustainingthemintheirpracticalassumptionthatitmightbedispensedwith,asavitalpotency,in
thegovernmenttheywerefounding?andthat,foritssuccessfuladministration,andforthepreserva-tionoftheAmerico-Anglo-SaxonCivilization,theymightsafelyrelyupontheoaththeoath!theoath!!theOATH!!!tobindtheofficialandthecitizentoGodinheaven,and,uponearth,tothefaithfuldis-chargeofduty?
Thecentury,overwhichMr.Depewdirectedthethoughtofhisaudience,beganwiththeinstantofthefirsttakingoftheOathtosupporttheConsti-tution.Whereindidthateventfallshortofbeingthemostsignificant,practically,intheprogressive
civilizationofMansince,attheseatofthePagan,St.PauldeclaredtheGodoftheChristian?amidtheculminationsoftheintellectualplantingthecul-minationofthespiritualthewoodencrossofCal-varyfastbythemarbletempleofMinerva;towhichdoubtlesshepointedwhenhesaid:WhomyeignorantlyworshiphimdeclareIuntoyou;Godthatmadetheworldandallthethingsthereinseeingthatheislordofheavenandearthdwellethnotintemplesmadewithhands;althoughhebenotfarfrom
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
8/24
everyoneofus:Forinhimweliveandmoveandhaveourbeing.DidnottheOathitself,ofneces-sity,vitalwiththetranscendentalmeaningoftheseawfulwords--didnottheOath,alsoofnecessity,vitalizetheCivilContractofwhichitselfwastobethebindingSpiritualSealwiththecognatemorallaw,astaughtbyourSaviour?andtaught,onceagainofnecessityexhaustively,seeingthatDivinitywouldteachnothingitselfdidnotexhaust.WasnotthefirsttakingoftheOath,then,theconcentra-tingpointofinterestinthehistoricpicture?life-essenceofthesubjectwhichtheOccasionclaimedfromChaunceyM.Depew,itsOrator?Inthein-visiblepresenceinvokedbythetakingoftheOathdidnotthemajesticfigureofWashingtonhimselfshrinkintocomparativenothingness?Andyet,althoughalreadyFirstinwar,Firstinpeace,Firstintheheartsofhiscountrymen,wasnotyetanotherpremiershipofinfinitelybroaderhistoricsignifi-cancedescendinguponhisbowedhead,inthein-visiblehaloofnew-bornAmericanloyalty?Wasnotheretheexhaustivedistinctionbetweenthein-augurationofanAmericanPresidenttorulebyvirtueofaHeaven-recordedvow,bornofthereligion
ofself-crucifixion,andthecoronationofaFeudalPrincetoreignbyforceofthedivinerightofkings,bornwith,andin,himself?
Why,then,wasMr.DepewsoreticentabouttheOath?Whydidhesquanderhiseloquenceuponnamesandeventsalreadysofamiliartothenurseryandthekinder-garten,andpasssosilentlybythehis-toricsignificanceofthefirsttakingoftheOathtosupporttheConstitution?ThisquestionIanswerbypropoundinganother.ThinkyouthatMr.DepewwasatallconcernedastothesignificanceoftakinganOathtodo,ornottodo,anything,whenheuttered
thewordsofhisorationtowhichInowbegattention?
WiththefirstattempttoexercisenationalpowerbeganthedueltothedeathbetweenStateSovereignty,claimingtherighttonullifyfederallawsorsecedefromtheUnion,andthepoweroftheRepublictocommandtheresourcesofthecountrytoenforceitsauthorityandprotectitslife.Itwasthebeginningofthesixtyyears'warfortheConstitutionandthenation.Itsearedconsciences,degradedpolitics,destroyedparties,ruinedstatesmen,andretardedtheadvanceanddevelopmentofthecountry;itsacrificedhundredsofthousandsofpreciouslives,andsquan-
deredthousandsofmillionsofmoney;itdesolatedthefairestportionoftheland,andcarriedmourningintoeveryhome,NorthandSouth,butitendedatAppomattoxintheabsolutetriumphoftheRepublic.
PosterityowestoWashington'sadministrationthepolicyandmeasures,theforceanddirectionwhichmadepossiblethisgloriousresult.***Hamil-ton'smarvelousversatilityandgeniusdesignedthearmoryandtheweaponsforthepromotionofnational
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
9/24
powerandgreatness,butWashington'ssteadysup-portcarriedhimthrough.***UpontheplanmarkedoutbytheConstitutionthisgreatarchitectwithunfailingfaithandunfalteringcouragebuildedtheRepublic.Hegavetothegovernmenttheprinci-plesofactionandsourcesofpowerwhichcarrieditsuccessfullythroughthewarwithGreatBritainin1812andMexicoin1848,whichenabledJacksontodefeatnullification,andrecruitedandequippedmil-lionsofmenforLincoln,andjustifiedandsustainedhisProclamationofEmancipation.OrationsandAfterDinnerSpeechesofChaunceyM.Depeic,pp.25,26,27.
Throughthethin,phosphorescentglamourofMr.Depew'srhetoricwho,bypossibility,canfailtodetecthisattempttosubstituteforthetruthofhistoryafabricationofhisownbrain,asnotablyimbecileasitwastransparentlyfalse?Imbecile?Weneedbutconfrontitwithonemajesticmemory.UponwhoseshouldersdescendedthemantleofHamilton,ifnotuponWebster's?Along-protractedwardidin-deedbeginbeforeWashington'sadministrationended.OriginatingwiththeExpounders,whonaturally
pressedcloseupontheFounders,oftheConstitution;bequeathedbyJefferson,leaderofthestrict,andbyHamilton,leaderoftheliberalconstructionists,totheirrespectivesuccessors,foragenerationnay,longer!itfilledtheAmericanCapitolwithaper-petualblazeofintellectuallight,absolutelyunrivaledinRomanSenate,BritishParliament,orFrenchNationalAssembly.Andwhowasitthatsprangyounggiant!totheheadoftheFederalForce!pre-eminent,palinginthecomparisoneventhehis-toricfameofHamiltonhimselfwhowasit?ifnotDanielWebster,sometimecalledtheGodlike?ThisquestionIsubmitforanswertoMr.Depew.
Hearhim!
But,atthecriticalperiodwhenthepopularity,courageandaudacityofGeneralJacksonwerealmostthesolehopeofnationality,WebsterdeliveredintheSenateaspeechunequaledintheannalsofelo-quenceforitsimmediateeffectsandlastingresults.TheappealofDemosthenestotheAtheniandemoc-racy,thedenunciationsofCiceroagainsttheconspir-aciesofCataline,thepassionateoutcryofMirabeaupendingtheFrenchrevolution,thewarningsofChat-hamintheBritishParliament,thefervorofPatrickHenryforindependence,wereoftemporaryinterest,
andyieldedfeebleresults,comparedwiththetremen-dousconsequencesofthismightyutterance.
ItbrokethespellofsupremeloyaltytotheState,andcreatedanunquenchableandresistlesspatriotismfortheUnitedStates.Itappearedintheschoolbooks,and,bydeclaimingglowingextractstherefrom,thejuvenileoratorsofthatandsucceedinggenera-tionswonprizesatacademicexhibitionsandinmimiccongresses.Childreneducatedparents,andthepride
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
10/24
ofthefathersandthekindledimaginationsofthesonsunitedtheminanobleidealofthegreatRepub-lic.Nosubsequentpatrioticorationmettherequire-mentsofanypublicoccasion,greatorsmall,whichdidnotbreathethesentimentof'libertyandunion,nowandforever,oneandinseparable!Idem.pp.
Whoofuswouldsuppressorenfeebleonewordofthispanegyric?WherebreathesthetrueSouthronwhowouldnotbequicktorecognizewithpatrioticpridetheassimilationoftheAmericanWebster,amongtheorators,totheAmericanNiagara,amongthecataractsofEarth?Andyetbutpartialjusticewouldbedonehismemorydidwenotfurtherinsistthatheroseto,andstilloccupies,aneminence,asfarabovetheplaneofmereearthlyoratoryasthespiritualswellsbeyondandabovetheintellectualworld.ButhereweareforcedintoantagonismwithaportionofhisownimmediatepeopleoftheNorthconspicuousamongthemtheOratoroftheHundredthAnniversaryoftheInaugurationofPresidentWashington;whoavailedhimselfoftheopportunity,officiallygivenhim,toprostituteanationaloccasiontotruth-sacri-ficingsectionaluse;therebydrawinganimpassable
lineofdemarcationbetweenhimselfandDanielWebster.
ToenableustocomprehendhowbroadanddeepitiswemustneedscontemplateforafewmomentsthecareerofthelatterincompanionshipwiththeonlytwoAmericansofhisday,whoafterWilliamH.Crawfordhadbeenprematurelystrickendownbyparalysiswereatallcomparablewithhim.Andintowhatheroicproportionshadthethreerisen,almostsimultaneously,abovethesurgesofthatfrontbattle-fieldofAmericanAmbitions,theFederalCon-gress?attractingtothemselvesfarmorelegitimately
thancouldthegreatNapoleonplaceuponhisownheadthecrownwhichhepickedupfromthestreet;attractingtothemselvestheworkofindividualiza-tionhadnotyetprogressedtoofarforthat!eachfromhisownsection,afervorofpersonaldevotioninallessentialsidenticalwiththeloyaltypaidtotheFeudalPrinceoftheoldentime:nay!exercisingthroughitanabsolutismoftheone-manpowerquiteunattainablebythemodernCaesar!For,whileinRussiatheCzarmayindeedfullyembodytheone-manwillinhisedict,itbyfartoooftenoccursthathemustbringhisbayonettobearuponthephysical,toconstrainthereflecting,subjecttoobedience;whereas
inSouthCarolina,Calhoun,actingdirectlyuponthereflecting,neverfailedtoconstrainthephysical,manofhisdominantpartytovotehiswill.SoClayinKentucky;so,forawhile,WebsterinMassa-chusetts.Andtimewaswhowithassurancecangainsayit?when,hadthethreeconspiredforanendofambitioncommontothemall,theymighthavesupplantedtheConstitutionalGovernmentofWash-ingtonwithaTriumvirateoftheirown.Butsuchpossibilitycouldneverhaveoccurredtoeitherof
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
11/24
them,or,indeed,to.anyintelligentAmericanoftheirday;forthesimplereasonthatnotoneofthethree,inhislife-longcareer,hadgivenslightestgroundforsuspicionthathecouldbemorerecreanttotheOathtosupporttheConstitutionwhichheldhimtotheinvisiblecenterofthemoraluniversethancouldtheEarthitselfberecreanttothelawofgravitywhichholdsittotheSun.Notthus,however,withafourthcharacterunhappilyalsohistoric!RaisedbytheaccidentofconflictbetweenCLAYr,theStates-man,andJackson,theSoldier,oftheWest,notsofarabovehisgreatcotemporariesinplaceashewasbeneaththeminthegranderelementsofmoralandintellectualforce;allaflamewiththathell-bornthirst,whichneverfailstofollowthealcoholicdraughtofgratifiedambition,andalwaysinverselyproportionatetothemoraldimensionsofthedrinker,hedescendedfromthePresidentialChairtodesecratetheHouseofRepresentativesbydirectingfromitsflooragainsttheConstitution,whichhe,incommonwithallitsmem-bers,hadtakentheOathtosupport,thatlong-con-tinuedanddesperatelyresistedonslaught,forwhichMr.Depewundertooktosubstitutetheflimsyfigmentofhisownbrain;andtotheinitiationofwhichWm.
H.Seward,announcingfromthealreadydesecratedstepsofFaneuilHallthegrandpurposeoftheRepublicanPartyinthepoliticalcampaignthenpro-gressingtocloseinthedefactoelectionofPresi-dentLincolnusedthewordswhichwillnowbekindlyread:
Inresponsetotheenthusiasticcheersofthepeo-ple,Mr.Sewardmadeaspeechfromwhichwemakethefollowingimpressiveandsignificantextracts.AfterrelatinghowhehadearlyderivedhispoliticalprinciplesandsentimentsfromtheMassachusettsschool,undertheteachingsoftheimmortalSageof
Quincy,heproceedsasfollows:
IknowthatcitizensofMassachusetts,aswellascitizensofotherStates,haveattemptedtodrivethedisciplesofthatillustriousteacherfromtheirpolicy.Butitisto-nightthatIamfreetoconfessthatwhen-everanyman,whereverhemightbefound,whetherhewasofNorthernorSouthernbirth,whetherhewasofthesolidmenofBoston,orofthelightmenofMississippi,haveassailedmeforthemaintenanceofthosedoctrines,Ihavesoughttocommunewithhisspirit,andtolearnfromhimwhetherthethinginwhichIwasengagedwaswellandworthilydone.
Whatacommentaryuponthewisdomofmanisgiveninthissinglefact,thatfifteenyearsonlyafterthedeathofJohnQuincyAdams,thepeopleoftheUnitedStates,whohurledhimfrompowerandfromplace,arecallingtotheheadofthenation,totheveryseat,fromwhichhewasexpelled,AbrahamLincoln,whoseclaimtothatseatisthatheconfessestheobligationofthathigherlawwhichtheSageofQuincypro-claimed,andthatheavowshimselfforwealorwoe,forlifeordeath,asoldieronthesideoffreedomin
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
12/24
theirrepressibleconflictbetweenfreedomandslavery.Tims,gentlemen,ismysimpleconfession.Idesirenow,onlytosaytoyouthatyouhavearrivedatthelaststageofthisconflictbeforeyoureachthetriumphwhichistoinauguratethisgreatpolicyintothegov-ernmentoftheUnitedStates.TheCrisis.WhatisResistance?pp.25,26.
IntroducedwiththeintroductionofAbolitionPeti-tionsintoCongressbyAdams;thusproclaimedbySewardtobeirrepressibleconflictbetweenFree-domandSlaveryinBostonBoston!!whosepeo-plehadbeensoconspicuouslyactiveinfasteninguponthevitalorganismsoftheSouthernStatesthatInsti-tution,*towhichthegenericnameofSlavery,ascontra-distinguishedfromFreedom,wascunninglygivenbytheunscrupulousdemagoguebothAdamsandSewardopenlyavowingallegiancetoLawHigherthantheConstitution,whicheachofthemhadreapeatedlytakentheOathtosupportthismovement,thusinitiated,mustliveinAmericanHis-tory,wheneverandwhereveritshallbetruthfullywrittenandintelligentlyread,asthewarwhichsearedconsciences,degradedpolitics,destroyed
parties,ruinedstatesmen,andretardedtheadvanceanddevelopmentofthecountry:manufactured,fromtheelementsofsectionalprejudice,jealousyandself-sufficientfanaticism,throughouttheentireEast-ern,NorthernandNorthwesternStates,thatgiganticPublicOpinionviolentlyaggressivefromthefirst,frenziedintodemoniacfurytowardthelastwhichmightwellwearthenameinhistoryofGrandArmyoftheHigherLaw;generallycommanded,nevereffectivelyresisted,byStateofficialsGovernors,Legislators,JudgeseachofwhomheldplaceuponhisOathtakentosupporttheConstitution,andwhichabsolutelynullifiedthosesupremelyvitalpro-
visionsofit,perfectedbyitsframersintoclear,ex-plicitlaw,purposelythatitmightgotothePeopledirectfromtheConstitutiontoexacteverywhereobediencethemostimplicit,enforcementthemostloyal,asbeingsolemnTreatyStipulationsbetweenstillexistingSovereignties,withoutwhichtheUnioncouldnothavebeenformed,anduponthefaithfulmaintenanceofwhichonlycoulditrightfullycontinuetoexist:dictatedandsecuredthoselegislativeenact-ments,knownasPersonalLibertyLaws,whichmadeitcrimeagainstthesovereigntyoftheStatetoattempttoenforceuponitssoiltheFederalConsti-tution,orFederalLawsenactedtosupportit
whereitcouldnolonger,becauseofrevolutionaryre-sistance,supportitself:tookdefactopossessionoftheElectoralCollegeof1860byforceofamajoritycom-posedalmostwhollyofdelegatesfromthesesameStates,whiletheflagofRebellionwasthusfloatingfromthecapitolofeachasthoughitmightbepos-sibleforaStatetobedefactooutoftheUnion,forthepurposeofresistingitslaws,andsimultaneouslydejureintheUnion,forthepurposeofmakingaPresident;majority,too,whichrepresentedonly
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
13/24
aminorityoftheAmericanPeopleadecisivema-jorityofwhomhadexpressed,throughtheballot-boxinthepresidentialelection,antagonismtoSewardandhisrevolutionaryfaction:inauguratedthepresi-dentelectofabodythuscomposedandcontrolled,inutterdisregardofthewillofthePeoplethusmademanifest:andsousurpedthegovernmentoftheUnitedStates;itsname,prestigeandcapital;itsarmy,navyandillimitableresources,toconcentrateandwieldthemallagainstStateswhosepeoplehadalwaysbeenloyaltotheUnionundertheConstitutiontherebymostunrighteouslyforcingthemintoades-peratelyunequalconflicttopreservefortheirchildrenthecivilizationandinstitutionsbequeathedtothembytheirfathers,undersecurityofanoath-sealedcompactwithStateswhichwerenowtramplingitunderfoot,todegradeanddestroythem.ThiswTasindeedthewarwhichsacrificedhundredsofthousandsofpreciouslives,andsquanderedthousandsofmillionsofmoney:desolatedthefairestportionoftheland,andcarriedmourningintoeveryhomeNorthandSouth:followedthetrackofbarbaricSherman'sdevastatingarmieswiththewrongs,op-pressionsandnever-to-be-numberedinfamiesofRe-
construction,underthedefactoconsulateoftheCarpet-BaggerandScalawag:wrenchedEnglishwordsfromtheirlegitimateapplicationcallingthehistoricallygrandandgloriousself-defenseoftheConfederateStates,theGreatRebellion;naminghimtraitorwhohadbeentruetohisman-hood,andresistedtheHigherLaw;himrebelwhohadbeentruetohisoath,andsupportedtheConstitution:cut,withtheswordofforce,intotheConstitutionitselfthatprovisionstillremainingtheretoscarit!whichgaveallofficesofhonorandemolumenttothesupportersoftheHigherLaw,anddestituteditsowndevotedsupportersuponthe
groundofhavingbeenfalsetotheoathtosupporttheConstitutionofanyrightwhatsoever,asthoughitmightbepossibletoConstitutionizeintotheTruthofHistoryaneverywhereintrinsicallyself-revealinglie:soughttoputtoshamethetrue,bravepeoplewhosehomesithaddesolatedbyfetter-ingwithironstheiralreadyincarceratedChief,asthoughhewereacommonandmeanlydangerousmalefactor,andthenwithheldfromhimthattrium-phantvindicationinhistorywhichallintelligentmenknewmustcertainlyresultfromanytrialatall;and,finally,attemptedtosubstitute,throughoutthatsectionwhichhadgivenGeorgeWashingtontomankind,
forthedistinctiveAmericanLoyaltyfirstbreathedbyhispurelipssynonymous,thewide-worldover,withTruthitselfthathistoricmusicoftwowords,trulyloyal,sopotentintheworkoffraud,op-pressionandplunderonthelipofCarpet-BaggerandScalawag;butfromtheinsidiouslyamicableapproachofwhichtohimselfthetrueAmericaneverywhereshrank,asshrinksthemostdelicateofwomenfromthefoulestinsectthatdronesthroughthefetidairofnight.
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
14/24
*SeeLectureontheWandererCase,byH.R.Jackson.
FromtheplaneofWashington,Jefferson,Ham-iltonFounders;fromthelevelofWebster,Clay,CalhounExpounders,oftheConstitution,whatafallwashere,mycountrymen!Andcoulditbewithintherangeofpossibilityconceivablettettoneman,soinferiortoeitherofthem,shouldhavethepowertoraise,andlivinganddeadtogivedirec-tionto,thestormwhichwasthustodashtheelabo-ratedworkofthemallintomonumentalwreck?precipitatingupontheAmericanPeopletheultimatetestoftheGreatAmericanExperimentofMan'scapacityforself-government,intheonlycrucialques-tionpracticallypossible:ShalltheConstitutionstand,asabstractlawcanonlystand,uponimplicitobedience?or,byoneactofrebelliousdisobedienceuncontroled,stabbed-likeCesartotheheart,shallitfallbeneaththefeetofmerebruteforcetobetram-pleduponatpleasure?
Ascircumstance,morepotentthanmeritintheman,hadmadeAdamsPresident,socircumstancewas
againathandtosupplyhimwithextrinsicforceforthisworkoftranscendentmischief.Itsochancedthat,inprosecutinghisownambitiousends,hemetadireneedgrowingfromyeartoyearmoreandmoredireoftheyoungerambitions,whichwererevealingthemselvesinallsectionsofthecountrywithphenome-nalrapidity.Isayphenomenalbecauseitresultedfromaphenomenoncharacteristicoftheearlydevelop-mentoftheAmerico-Englishcivilization.Pre-ex-istinghistorytaughtthatthehabitsofthoughtandactionwithresultinganddependentsocialorganismsoftheAnglo-Saxon,wouldsurvivetherevolutionof1776,forlengthsoftimeasvariantasthemselves.It
didnotteachthatoneofthetwomasterpassionsofthehumansoul,letfullylooseuponthebreathingworldbyrevolutionarydemolitionofallrestrainingFeudalbars,wouldinstantlybegin,andprosecutewitharapidityofachievementabsolutelyunprecedented,itsformidablework:andthat,whileitwouldbealto-gethernatural,ontheonehand,forPresidentWashington,inhisdailywalkaroundPhiladelphia,tostridelikeaFeudalPrince,followedattenpaceswithmilitaryprecisionbyanAideindashingmilitarygarb,itwouldbequiteasnatural,ontheotherhand,buttwogenerationslaterduringthatintervalofpal-pitationbetweentheelectionandtheinaugurationof
PresidentLincolnforaGeorgiaCaptain,standingwithhiscompanyinamicablelinedeployedbeforetheurchinsofaragged-schooluponLongIsland,toexclaim,Myboys!whatagloriouscountryisours!WhocantellbutthatoneofyoumaybePres-identoftheUnitedStates!
Universaldevelopmentofambition!thatexhaust-iveconcentrationofself-assertion,thusculminatinginthethoughtofpresident-makingwasthis,then,
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
15/24
thefirstpracticaleffectoftherevolutionofSeventy-Sixdistinctlytorevealitself?Such,indeed,hadrapidlybecometheuniversallesson;taughtbytheproudmothertotheeagerlylisteningboyatherknee;bythepreceptor,temptingBrown,ashetookhisplaceaboveBlackinthespellingclass,tofindpleasureinwhatwasgivingtoanotherpainhypertrophyoftheintellect!atrophyofthesoul!thusbeguneveninthekinder-garten!SuchhadbeenthelessontaughtbytheFourthofJulyoratoreverywhere;selectingforhistextthatquestionablegeneralizationoftheDeclar-ationofIndependence,Allmenarebornequal,anddoingitdowninthecrucibleofhisowndeductivephilosophywiththatothergeneralization,theun-alienablerighttothepursuitofhappiness;andprecipitatingtherefromineachAmericanCitizenasovereign,bornwiththedivinerightofkings'todetermineforhimselfwhathappiness'is,andtopursueitbygettingabovehisequals.
Wasitindeedpossiblethat,soimmediatelyaftertheprofoundly-teachinginaugurationoftheirFirstPresident,theentireAmericanPeople,withanunan-imityofthoughtandactionnevertobeexceeded,had
setthemselvestothesuicidalworkofthusscatteringbroad-castovertheircountrytheseedofself-asser-tion,theseedofbarbarizingindividualization,thetheveryseedofHellitself?Whatwonderthat,inthelapseofasinglegeneration,thereshouldappearaswarmmultitudinoustobenumberedonlybytheconscientiouscensus-takerresemblingbyfartoocloselythatotherswarmwhichperiodicallyemergesfromtheearthtorestoretotheforestinmid-summeritswintryaspect,crawlingalongthesurface,eachbornequaltohisneighborandtothatextentindeedasovereign;assertinghisunalienablerighttothepursuitofhappinessingettingabove
hisequals,bymountingthefirstuprightthinghemeets;beitanelm,thefoliagereachedtofeedandfattenthere;beitabald-headedpost,thetopattained,stretchingalean,lankformintovacancy,alwaysup-ward!toperishthereaveritablewormExcel-sior!
TheorganismoftheBritishParliamentsurvivingintheAmericanCongress,itwasbutnaturalthatthelong-establishedhabitofAnglo-Saxonthoughtshouldfastentheeyeofpoliticalambitionuponthelatter;inutterdisregardofthefact,sovitaltoaconstitu-tionalgovernmentoftheAmericanUnion,thateach
StatelegislaturemustbeartotheFederaltherelation-shipbornebyacourtoforiginalandgeneraltoacourtofdelegatedandlimitedjurisdiction;or,speakingmoredirectly,therelationshipbornebythelegislatureofoneofaNationofSovereigntiestothelegislatureofanagencycreatedbyandcommontothemall;butwhollydestituteofsovereigntyoriginalinitself.Andthat,therefore,whiletheassimilationoftheformertotheBritishParliamentmightbecomplete,thatofthelattermust,inthenatureofthings,bepartial;that,
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
16/24
immaterialhowextensivetheterritoryoftheUnion,howvastorcomplicatedthemachineryneedfulforitsgovernment,thatgovernment,asconstituted!couldnotdirectlyandfullytouchoneAmericancitizenastouchestheBritishgovernmentallBritishsubjects,astoucheseachStategovernmentitseverycitizen;andthathencethemainlifeofthePeoplelaybeyondthesphereofitsaction.AmongtheFoundersoftheConstitutionPatrickHenryseemstohavestoodaloneinhisactiveappreciationofthenecessityofkeepingthisvitaltruthpracticallymanifest.CouldhehavegivendirectiontoAmericanambition,divert-ingitfromtheterritoriallybroader,butcomparativelyshallow,fieldofFederalPolitics,tothedevelopmentoftheState,underwiseandeffectiveHome-Rule,theimmediatecauseofthenowhistoricWarbetweentheStatescouldnothavebeenengendered.But,asthroughParliamenthadlainforgenerationstheavenuetotheBritishPremiership,itwasnaturallyassumedthatsothroughCongressmustliethehigh-waytotheAmericanPresidency;andCongresspre-cipitatelybecamethefrontbattle-fieldofAmericanAmbitions.
Oratoryistheartofrevolutionaryepochs.ThespiritoftheAmericanRevolutionmadeitselffirstheardintheBritishParliament.WhocanhavefailedtorecognizeintheeloquenceofPatrickHenrytheim-pressofLordChatham's?InrousingtheAmericanPeopletoRevolutiontheindispensabletriospeaker,audienceandsubjecteverywheregroupedthemselvestogetherforthegenerationofelo-quence.Independenceachieved,therestillremainedworkforStatesmen,andforOrators,inthefoundingoftheConstitutionandtheUnion.AndthiswasquicklyfollowedbytheepochofConstruction,theepochofWebster,ClayandCalhoun,andthoseefful-
gentgalaxieswhichtheopportunitiesoftheTimeclusteredroundthethreegreatcentralorbs;whenex-PresidentAdamstookhisseatintheHouseofRepre-sentatives.Oratory,monopolizingtheart-passionandart-tasteoftheAmericanPeople,hadnowfullypos-sesseditselfoftheschools;andwaseverywheresedu-ouslytaught.ItisbutfairtoassumethatfortheyoungpoliticalaspirantswhowerenowbeginningtocometotheFederalCapitol,allaglowwiththethetouchofthelivecoalfromtheiraltars,themerematterofPresident-makingdidnotwearasuperlativelyattrac-tiveface.Whatpartintheworld'slifewasamerePresidenttoplay?ThenormalcareerofaRoman
Emperorwaslife-long.Everypenthatshouldwritethehistoryofhisdaymustneedswritehisbiography;forthatwasactuallythehistoryoftheworld.And,yet,whatschool-boy'smemorystrongenoughtocarrythelistednamesoftheRomanEmperors?HowwidelydifferentwiththeDemostheneses,theCiceros,theChathamsofthePast.Here,indeed,werenamesthatcouldnotdie.TheycomenexttotheAlexan-ders,theCaesars,andtheBonapartes.Theystand,withtheHomers,VirgilsandShakspeares,amongthe
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
17/24
quickenersofimmortalthoughtGod'svicegerentsuponearthtoberecognizedforever.
WitheachsucceedingCongressthenumberofsuchaspirantswasincreasing,and,erethefifthdecadehadbeenreached,inCongressandincountryitwaslegion.TherapiddevelopmentofnewspaperlifehadexpandedtheiraudienceintoThePublic.Butthethirdessentialforeloquence,thesubject,wasrapidlyperishing.Theheroicdaysoftheworld-startlingRevolutionwerenowgrowingdistant.TheworkoftheFourthofJulyoratorhadbeenover-done.ThefieldofConstitutionalConstruction,oncesoabounding,hadbeensweptbythegreatscythesofthemasters;thesehadleftbutlittleforthegleaner.Intruth,thepointwasbeingrapidlynearedwhentheprofessionalFederalstatesmanmustberemittedtohisnormaloccupationpresident-makingandmetingoutthespoilstothevictors.Thedaysofelo-quencewereabouttobeover.
Hereitwasthetempterfoundhisopportunity.BeyondtheConstitutionlayotherfieldsunlimited,illimitablewheretheharvestwasrichandthescythe
hadneverswept.Tomakeentranceintothem:Hiclaborhocopuserat.ButtodothismeanttodeposetheConstitution;andhelinealsuccessorofWash-ingtonhadtakentheoathtosupporttheConstitu-tion.Simplethingenough,perhaps,topartcompanywithhisconscience!butwherewashetofindaful-crumuponwhichtoplanttheleverfitforhiswork?Hefounditinanassumptionasfalsetohistoryashewasfalsetotruthandtoduty;namely,thattherightofsubjecttopetitionsovereignwasoneofthoserightsproclaimedbytheDeclarationofInde-pendencetobeunalienable,andthereforelawhigherthantheConstitutionitself;right,indeed,
whichhadbeenwrungbytheBaronsfromKingJohninMagnaCharta,andhadbeenmadesupremelyvitalbyitandbyalltheEnglishBillsofRightwhichcon-stitutewithittheBibleofAnglo-SaxonLiberty.Isitnotpassingstrangethat,inallthediscus-sionsofthesubject-matterofthepresentationofAbo-litionPetitions,theabsolutefalsityofthisassump-tiondoesnotseemtohaveprovokedacomment,Andyetitwasmanifest,notonlyinthenatureofthings,butinthewordsoftheConstitutionitself.InthenatureofthingsfortherightofsubjecttopetitionsovereignwassupremelyvitalinthetheoryofthepatriarchalfirstformofgovernmentknowntoAg-
gregate-man.What,then,wassecuredbyMagnaChartaandtheBillsofRight?doesanyonein-quireiLettheConstitutionitselfanswer!
Congressshallmakenolawabridgingtherightofthepeoplepeaceablytoassembleandtopetitionthegovernmentforaredressofgrievances.U.S.Con-stitution.Amendments,Article1.
Thewordassembleisprincipal,thewordpeti-
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
18/24
tionisaccessory;theoneiseverything,theotherabsolutelynothing,intheAmericanConstitutionandinalltheEnglishBillsofRight.Theoreticallytheinbornrightofsubjecttopetitionsovereignmustberecognized,aboveallothergovernments,bythemostdespoticthepatriarchal!butthechildmustapproachtheparentquitealone.Theassemblageofthemanyisthechronicterroroftheone-manpower.Now,ofallpeoplesonearththeAbolitionistswereinthefullestenjoymentoftherighttoassemble,whenAdamsandhisLieutenant-Generals,aswellwithoutaswithintheFederalCapitol,werethun-deringtotheworldthegreatwrongdonethemfirst,innotreceivingtheirPetitions,and,sec-ondly,insimplylayingthemonthetable.BytreasonableabuseoftherighttoassembletheywererousingthepassionsofthepeopleagainsttheConstitution,andorganizingundertheHigheeLawthatPublicOpinionwhichfinallyusurpedtheFed-eralGovernmentanddelugedtheSouthernStatesinblood.
Adamshavingselectedforthefirstalignmentofhisforcesagroundsoabsolutelyuntenable,thequestion
mustalwayspresentitself:Whywasitnotatoncestrickenfrombeneathhim?Whywasnotthefinalissuethenmade%Didnotthecrisiscallforapplicationoftheprinciple:Secondsmaybeworthmorethanregi-ments?Whatotheranswercanbegiventhanthatthetempterhadtemptedtoowisely?Thepabulumforeloquencewastoorichandsavorytoberejected!Thewishbeingfathertothethoughteasy,doubt-less,becamethetaskofpersuadingoneselfthatthemerereceiptofpetitions,tobelaiduponthetable,couldscarcelyworkseriousharmtotheRepublic.Andyet,lookingtotheimperialdignityoftheFed-eralConstitution,thecrimeofallmostimmediately
dangeroustogovernment,wasbeingcovertlycommit-ted;crime,madesubjectinallEuropeancommuni-tiestopunishmentthemostinstantaneousandcon-dignthecrimeofLese-Majeste.SoAdams,bringingtheConstitutionintocontemptattheNorth,andsubjectingtheSouthtorudestassaultinthetenderestofhervitals,madeanintenselyemo-tionalsubjectfortheoratorwiththecacoethesloquendiuponhim,bothSouthandNorth.Onlywiththisexplanation,asitseemstome,willthephi-losophichistorianofthefuturebeenabledtocompre-hendhow,withpowerssoinferiortothoseofhisgreatcontemporaries,andventuringuponhisworkwithso
fragileaninstrument,hecouldhaveoverwhelmedthecombinedeffortsofthemallandaccomplishedanendofmischiefsocolossal.
Theyandhehadpassedfromthestageofactionbeforethewarofwordsattaineditsmostformidableproportionsandbegantomergeitselfinthewarbe-tweentheStates.ButtheCongressof1850willbealwaysmemorablefromthefactthatitgroupedClay,WebsterandCalhouneachofwhom,howeverwidely
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
19/24
theymayhavedifferedfromtimetotimeuponpoliti-calquestions,hadbeentruethroughouttothenobleutteranceofthefirstIhadratherberightthanPresidentagainsttherapidlydevelopingrevolu-tionaryspiritoftheNorthandinevokingfromeachofthethreeaforensicmaster-pieceofhislife.Mr.Benton,inhisThirtyYearsintheSenate,saysthattheperorationofMr.Webster'sspeech,uponFoote'sResolutions,inanswertoHayne,surpassedanythinginancientormoderneloquence.ItwastheeffectofAdams'workthatgavetohisspeechof1850,ascomparedevenwithit,atranscendentsub-limity.Beforehisdeath,in1848,Adamshadsuc-ceededinsectionalizingtheWhigpartyatleastinNewEngland.HencethepositionofWebster,when,in1850,hestoodinlinewithClayandCalhoun,dif-feredinonerespecttotocaelofromtheirs.Eachofthelatterwassupportedneversofervently,nevermoreunanimouslybyhisownsection,byhisowncon-stituents.ButhowwasitwithWebster?Imyselfre-membertohaveheardatthetimethat,ontheeveningbeforethedeliveryofthatspeech,hecalledinpersonuponeveryWhigSenatorandRepresentativefromNewEnglandbuttofindthat,whenheshouldtake
hisstandonthemorrow,hewouldstandalone.IheresolicityourattentiontoanextractfromthatmostmasterlyproductionoftheSouthernPenMr.Stephens'WarbetweentheStates(SeeVol.1,p.p.405,406,407.)asgivingajustestimateofhisheroicpatriotismatthatcrisis.
Hewastoogreatamanandhadtoogreatanin-tellectnottoseethetruthwhenitwaspresented;andhewastoohonestandtoopatrioticamannottoproclaimatruth,whenhesawit,toanunwillingpeople.InthisqualityofmoralgreatnessIoftenthoughtMr.Websterhadtheadvantageofhisgreat
contemporaries,Messrs.ClayandCalhoun.NotthatIwouldbeunderstoodassayingthattheywerenotmenofgreatmoralcourage,forbothofthemshowedthishighqualityinmanyinstances,butthattheynevergavetheworldsuchstrikingexhibitionsofitashedid.Itwasthegloryofhislifethathiswasputtoatestinthisparticular;thattheirsneverwas.OnnooccasionthatIamawareofdidMr.ClayevertakeapositionwhichhedidnotknowthathewouldbesustainedinbythepeopleofKentucky.SowithMr.Calhoun,astoSouthCarolina.Idonotsaythattheymightnothavedoneit,ifasenseofdutyhadre-quiredit,buttheywereeithersofortunateorsoun-
fortunateasnevertohavehadthatissuepresentedtothem.Webster,onthecontrary,oftenpassedthisordeal;andthathepasseditwithunflinchingfirm-nessisoneofthegrandestfeaturesinthegeneralgrandeurofhischaracter.
Oneofthehighestexhibitionsofthemoralsub-limetheworldeverwitnessedwasthatofDanielWebster,when,onanopenbaroucheinthestreetsofBoston,heproclaimed,insubstance,toavastassem-
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
20/24
blyofhisconstituentsunwillinghearersthattheyhadconqueredanuncongenialclime;theyhadcon-queredasterilesoil;theyhadconqueredthewindsandcurrentsoftheocean;theyhadconqueredmostoftheelementsofnature;buttheymustyetlearntoconquertheirprejudices.ItwasanexhibitionofmoralgrandeursurpassingthatofAristideswhenhesaid,O,AthenianswhatThemistoclesrecommendswouldbegreatlytoyourinterests,butitwouldbeunjust.A.H.Stephens.TheWarbetweentheStates.Vol.1.Pages405,406,407.
TwobriefpassageswillnowbereadfromMr.Web-ster'sspeechof1850.
Now,sir,thisprejudice,createdbytheincessantactiononthepublicmindofabolitionsocieties,abo-litionpresses,andabolitionlecturers,hasgrownverystrong.Nodrum-headinthelongestday'smarchwasevermoreincessantlybeatenandsmittenthanpublicsentimentintheNorthhasbeen,everymonth,andday,andhour,bythedin,androll,andrub-a-dubofabolitionwritersandabolitionlecturers.Thatitiswhichhascreatedtheprejudice.
Sir,theprincipleoftherestitutionofrunawayslavesisnotobjectionableunlesstheConstitutionisobjectionable.IftheConstitutionisrightinthatre-specttheprincipleisright,andthelawforcarryingitintoeffectisright.Ifthatbeso,andifthereisnoabuseoftherightunderlawofCongress,oranyotherlaw,thenwhatistheretocomplainof?
BeforeIpassfromthissubject,sir,Iwillsaythatwhatseemsextraordinaryisthatthisprincipleofres-titutionwhichhasexistedinthecountryformorethantwohundredyearswithoutcomplaint,sometimes
asamatterofagreementbetweentheNorthandSouth,andsometimesasamatterofcomity,shouldallatonce,andafterthelengthoftimeIhavementioned,becomeasubjectofexcitement.
ImeantostandupontheConstitution.Ineednootherplatform.Ishallknowbutonecountry.TheendsIaimatshallbemycountry's,myGod's,andTruth's.IwasbornanAmerican,IwillliveanAmer-ican;IshalldieanAmerican;andIintendtoper-formthedutiesincumbentuponmeinthatcharactertotheendofmycareer.Imeantodothis,withab-solutedisregardofpersonalconsequences.Whatare
personalconsequences?Whatistheindividualman,withallthegoodorevilwhichmaybetidehim,incomparisonwiththegoodorevilwhichmaybefallagreatcountryinacrisislikethis,andinthemidstofgreattransactionswhichconcernthatcountry'sfate?Lettheconsequencesbewhattheywill,Iamcareless.Nomancansuffertoomuchandnomancanfalltoosoon,ifhesufferorifhefallindefenceoftheliber-tiesandConstitutionofhiscountry.TheWorksofDanielWebster.Vol.5,p.p.433,437.
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
21/24
AlfredtheGreatwasConditor,EdwardtheConfessorRestitutoroftheBritishConstitu-tion.AllmenwillagreethattoWashingtonbe-longsthetitleofFounderoftheAmerican.But,thanksbetotheGodofNations!theAmericanCon-stitutionhasneedednoRestorer.Ithadintrin-sicpowerofitsowntorestoreitself.But,ifWash-ingtonistoliveinhistoryasFounder,mustnotallreflectingmenbeholdinWebster,standingclosebyhisside,thehistoricExpounderoftheFederalConstitution?Andisitmakingtooheavyadraftupontheimaginationtosupposethat,asheutteredthewordslastreadsograndlypotentintheirsim-plicitythetranscendentNewEnglandermaytousehisowninimitableimageryhavefeltthegreatarmoftheSouthronleanuponhimforsupport?
Thelastquotations,however,werenothislastutter-ancesatthecrisis,anduponthesubject-matter,whichinvolvedthelifeoftheUnion.AtCaponSprings,Virginia,in1851,lieusedtheexplicitandemphaticwordswhichwillnowberead.
Howabsurditistosupposethatwhendifferentpartiesenterintoacompactforcertainpurposes,eithercandisregardanyoneprovision,andexpect,nevertheless,theothertoobservetherest.Iintend,forone,toregard,andmaintain,andcarryout,tothefullestextent,theConstitutionoftheUnitedStates,whichIhavesworntosupport,inallitspartsandallitsprovisions.ItiswrittenintheConstitution:
'NopersonheldtoserviceorlaborinoneStateunderthelawsthereofandescapingintoanother,shall,inconsequenceofanylaworregulationtherein,
bedischargedfromsuchserviceorlabor,butshallbedelivereduponclaimofthepartytowhomsuchlabororservicemaybedue.'
ThatisasmuchapartoftheConstitutionasanyother,andasequallybindingandobligatoryasanyotheronallmen,publicorprivate.
Ihavenothesitatedtosay,andIrepeat,thatiftheNorthernStatesrefuse,wilfullyanddeliberately,tocarryintoeffectthatpartoftheConstitutionwhichrespectstherestorationoffugitiveslaves,andCon-gressprovidenoremedy,theSouthwouldnotlonger
beboundtoobservethecompact.Abargaincannot.bebrokenononesideandstillbindtheotherside.
IamasreadytofightandfallfortheConstitutionalrightsofVirginiaasIamforthoseofMassachu-setts.Mr.Webster'sSpeechatCaponSprings,Vir-ginia,June28th,1851.
WhowillquestionthatDanielWebster,fromtheloftiestpointofview,wasbyfarthemosteffectivead-
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
22/24
vocateofthatconstructionoftheFederalConstitu-tionwhichcalledtheConfederateStatesintobeing,andplacedtheirarmiesinthefield;orthathewasthefirstself-devotingchampiontosufferandtofallindefenceofthenowsometimescalledLostCause.Theremovesnotuponthefaceofearth,theresleepsnotinherbosom,onemutilatedorslaugh-teredConfederateSoldierwhomaynottruthfullyex-claiminhisthought,orinhisdream:I,too,likeWebster,suffered;I,too,likeWebster,fell,indefenceofthelibertiesandConstitutionofmycountry!ThegloryofThermopylaeisnottoXerxesandhismillion;itistoLeonidasandhisthreehun-dred.
MightitnotbewiseforMr.Depew,whosetonguesofrequentlydoesdropmanna,toreconcilehiseloquentexpressionofadmirationforDanielWeb-sterwithhisattempttomaketheworseappearthebettercauseinhisOrationonthehundredthan-niversaryoftheInaugurationofPresidentWashing-ton.Untilthisshallbedone,thequestionwillre-mainunanswered,whether,atthecloseofthathistoricaddress,theghostofWebsterwouldhavebeenmore
acceptabletohimthanwasBanquo'sghosttoMac-bethatthesupper-table;orthanwouldhavebeentheghostofthemurderedLincolntoJudge-AdvocateHolt,immediatelyaftertheexecutionofMrs.Surratt.
And,further,mightitnotbewellforhimtorecon-cileitssignificancewiththeviewsofMr.AlexanderJohnstonsurelyasdevotedaNorthernerandmem-beroftheRepublicanPartyasMr.DepewhimselfviewsobviouslywrungbysheerforceoftruthfromaconscientiousmantowhichInowprayspecialatten-tion?
Theobjectiontotheconstitutionalityofthefugi-tiveslavelawis,inbrief,thattherenditionoffugi-tiveslaves,aswellasoffugitivesfromjustice,wasanobligationimposedbytheConstitutionupontheStates;andthatthefederalgovernment,whichhasneverattemptedtogivethelawinthelattercase,hadnomorerighttodosointheformer.Thisopinion,however,hasagainstittheunanimousopinionoftheSupremeCourtinthecaseofAblemanvs.Booth,citedbelow.Butthereisabsolutelynolegalexcuseforthepersonallibertylaws.Iftherenditionoffugitiveslaveswasafederalobligation,thepersonallibertylawswereinflatdisobediencetolaw;iftheobliga-
tionwasupon-theStates,theywereagrossbreachofgoodfaith,fortheywereintended,andoperated,topreventrendition;andineithercasetheywereinviolationoftheConstitution,whichtheStatelegisla-torsthemselvesweresworntosupport.Thedilemmaissoinevitablethatonlythepressureofanintenseandnaturalhorrorofsurrenderingtoslaveryamanwhohadescapedfromit,orwhohadneverbeensub-jecttoit,canpalliatethepassageofthelawsinques-tion.Plainly,thepeople,inadoptingthefugitive
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
23/24
slaveclauseoftheConstitution,hadassumedanobli-gationwhichitwasnotpossibletofulfill.Thewriter'sownbeliefthattheobligationofrenditionwasupontheStatesalone,haspreventedhimfromclass-ingthepersonallibertylawsundernullification.CyclopoediaofPoliticalScience,PoliticalEconomyandUnitedStatesHistory.Vol.3d,p.163.
Finally,wouldnottheAmericanPeopleofthepresentdayalsoturnwithinterestandprofittoanex-pressionoftheviewsnowentertainedbybothMr.DepewandMr.JohnstonofWhittier's
PoemonWebster?
Sofallen!solost!thelightwithdrawnWhichoncehewore!
ThegloryfromhisgreyhairsgoneForevermore!
Revilehimnot,theTempterhathAsnareforall;
Andpityingtears,notscornandwrath,Befithisfall.
Odumbbepassion'sstormyrage,Whenhe,whomight
Havelightedupandledhisage,Fallsbackinnight.
Scorn!wouldtheangelslaugh,tomarkAbrightsouldriven
Fiend-goadeddowntheendlessdarkFromhopeandheaven?
LetnotthelandonceproudofhimInsulthimnow,
NorbrandwithdeepershamehisdimDishonoredbrow.
Ofallwelovedandhonored,naughtButpowerremains;
AfallenAngel'sprideofthoughtStillstronginchains.
Allelseisgone;fromthosegreateyesThesoulisfled;
Whenfaithislost,whenhonordies,Themanisdead.
ThenpaythereverenceofolddaysTohisdeadfame;
Walkbackward,withavertedgaze,Andhidetheshame!
Bythispowerfulbutabortiveefforttoimpaleforshametheforemost,andbyfarthegrandest,figureinNewEnglandhistory,thepeople'spoet,inthesecruelstanzans,hassuppliedthehonestseekeraftertruth,throughallcomingtime,withalife-likephoto-
-
8/2/2019 American Loyalty (1893)
24/24
graphofthatfrenziedPublicOpinionwhichhaden-thralledanddebasedtheNorthernmind,andtowhichtheauthorhimselfwaspandering.AsalsopanderedthepainterwhofrescoedwithinthedomeofthecapitolatWashington,infullviewfromthero-tunda,thefiguresofRobertE.Lee,AlexanderHamiltonStephensandStonewallJackson,asdiscomfitedandterror-strickentraitors,crouchingbe-neaththeout-spreadtalonsofthetriumphantAmericanEagle;wheretheystillremain!toputtoblushthenationwhoselawsareenacted,beneaththelyingdaub;andastheyshallremaingroupedinhistorywithDanielWebster,andthepurest,bravestandmostself-devotingpatriotsofalltheagestoclaimforeverthesupremeadmirationofmankind!Such,assuredly,mustbetheverdictofposteritywhen,inthefull,purelightoftruth,unaffectedbyinterest,prejudice,orpassion,itshallcometoreviewthatdominationofForcehydra-headed,million-handedwhichforsomanydeplorableyearstorturedtheSouthanddarkenedtheLand;temperedattimes,undoubtedly,bythebroadpatriotismandever-activehumanityofLincoln,andbytheunostentatious,thoughheroic,magnanimityofGrant:butchecked
onlybytheloyaltyoftheSupremeCourt,which,clingingsteadfastlytothevitalprinciplesoftheGov-ernment,hasfinallyrestoredtotheAmericanNationofindestructibleStateSovereigntiesthecalmruleoftheConstitution.Beitperpetual!