Akhil Derivatives
-
Upload
akhil-varshney -
Category
Documents
-
view
226 -
download
0
Transcript of Akhil Derivatives
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
1/148
A RESEARCH REPORT ONDERIVATIVES- AN INNOVATIVE TOOL FOR RISK
MINIMISATION
FOR THE FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD
OF THE DEGREE OF MASTERS OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
U.P.TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY, LUCKNOW
Under the Guidance of Submitted by
MR. DURGESH AGARWAL AKHIL VARSHNEY
MBA-3rd SEM
Submitted to
MR. SAIF AZAM
ASSITANT PROFESSOR
(ABIMS)
AL-BARKAAT INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENTSTUDIES, ALIGARH
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
2/148
2
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
3/148
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to take this opportunity to express my sincere gratitude to all the
people who have directly and indirectly aided my research and extended his
full support to my visit to his company.
I would also like to thank Mr. Durgesh Agarwal, for his support and help
anytime I approached him. His advice and support made all the difference to
my work and gave it the form it has.
AKHIL VARSHNEY
3
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
4/148
Table of content
Chapters pageno.
1. Executive summery 52. Company profile 6-
7
3. History of Religare 84. Introduction of derivatives 9-
35
What are derivatives?
Features of derivatives
Kinds of derivative contracts Advantages and disadvantages of derivatives contracts
OTC v/s exchange derivative market
Application of derivatives derivative market in India
Factors driving the growth of derivatives
Pre-requisites for derivative
Global derivatives market
5. Review of literature36-47
The advent of derivatives
L.C Gupta committee report6. Present study
48-109
Derivatives instruments
Pay-off of futures and options
Options and future strategies for hedger
Options strategies
7. Methodology110-111
8. Results112-116
Current constraints Need for derivative
Market in India
Future prospects
Precautionary measures to be taken
4
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
5/148
9. Discussion117-118
Are derivative a failure?
10. Recommendations119-123
11. Conclusions124
12. References125
13. Appendix126-133
5
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
6/148
LIST OF TABLES
1. Forwards v/s futures2. Requirements for professional clearing membership3. Eligibility criteria for membership on the F&O segment
4. Option Strategies5. Option Strategies for a bullish and a bearish market6. Long call strategy7. Covered call strategy v/s Long stock strategy8. Long put strategy
9. Covered put strategy
LIST OF FIGURES
1. Types of derivative contracts2. Payoff for buyer of futures: long futures
3. Payoff for seller of futures: short futures4. Payoff of a long call5. Payoff of a short call6. Payoff of a long put7. Payoff of a short put8. Payoff of a strangle9. Up and in options10. Payoff for buyer of call options at various strikes11. Payoff for writer of put options at various strikes12. Payoff for seller of call options at various strikes13. Payoff for buyer of put options at various strikes14. Payoff of a bull spread15. Payoff of a bear spread16. Interest rate swap
LIST OF APPENDIX
1. Article- Fall of Barings Bank2. Article- Orange Club
6
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
7/148
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Financial derivatives have crept into the nation's popular economic vocabulary on a
wave of recent publicity about serious financial losses suffered by municipal
governments,. Well -known corporations, banks and mutual funds that had invested
in these products. Government has held hearings on derivatives and financial
commentators have spoken at length on the topic.
In a way, derivatives are like electricity. Properly used, they can provide great
benefit. If they are mishandled or misunderstood, the results can be catastrophic.
Derivatives are not inherently "bad". When there is full understanding of these
instruments and responsible management of the risks, financial derivatives can be
useful tools in pursuing an investment strategy.
This is a modest attempt to provide an insight into the world of Derivatives,
covering the gamut of products, operators, institutional set up and regulatory
framework. A Derivatives is a contractual relationship established by two (or more)
parties where payment is based on (or derived from) some agreed upon benchmark.
Like any other financial instrument derivatives too require a conducive environment
for its success.
Although world derivative markets have existed in some form since at least 17 th
century, modern derivative markets developed in mid 19 th century with the opening
up of Chicago Board of trust Derivative trading. Since then derivatives have come a
long way. Derivative trading is now the worlds largest business with an estimated
daily turnover of USD 2.5 trillion and an annual growth rate of around 14%.
THIS PROJECT ATTEMPTS TO FAMILIARIZE THE READER WITHFINANCIAL DERIVATIVES, THEIR USE AND THE NEED TO
APPRECIATE AND MANAGE RISK. IT IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE;
HOWEVER, COMPETENT PROFESSIONAL ADVICE SHOULD BE
7
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
8/148
SOUGHT BEFORE BECOMING INVOLVED IN A FINANCIAL
DERIVATIVE PRODUCT.
COMPANY PROFILE
Religare Enterprises Limited (REL) is a global financial services
group with a presence across Asia, Africa, Middle East, Europe and
the Americas. In India, RELs largest market, the group offers a
wide array of products and services ranging from insurance, asset
management, broking and lending solutions to investment banking
and wealth management. The group has also pioneered the
concept of investments in alternative asset classes such as arts
and films .With 10,000 plus employees across multiple
geographies, REL serves over a million clients, including corporate
8
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
9/148
and institutions, high net worth families and individuals, and retail
investors
Religare is driven by ethical and dynamic process for wealth
creation. Based on
This, the company started its endeavor in the financial market.
Religare Enterprises Limited through Religare Securities Limited,
Religare
Finevest Limited, Religare Commodities Limited and Religare
Insurance
Advisory Services Limited provides integrated financial solutions to
its
corporate, retail and wealth management clients. Today, we
provide various financial services which include Investment
Banking, Corporate Finance, Portfolio Management Services, Equity
& Commodity Broking, Insurance and Mutual Funds. Plus, theres a
lot more to come your way.
Religare is proud of being a truly professional financial service
provider managed by a highly skilled team, who have proven track
record in their respective domains. Religare operations are
managed by more than 1500 highly skilled professionals who
subscribe to Religare philosophy and are spread across its country
wide branches.
Our business philosophy is to treat each client situation as unique,
requiring customized solutions. Our list of corporate clients reads
like a Whos Who of the Indian Industry and we have been
successful in providing them with practical customized solutions
for their requirements. We are propelled by our group vision and
desire to strive tirelessly and aim to be the best within this
category.
9
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
10/148
The primary focus of RCL is to cater to services in Commodity
Market. The Company is a member of the Multi commodity
exchange (MCX) and National commodity derivative exchange
(NCDEX). The growing list of financial institutions with whom FCL is
empanelled, as approved Broker is a reflection of the high levels of
services maintained by the Company.
Religare has a very credible team in its Research & Analysis
division, which not only caters to the need of our Institutional
clientele but also gives their valuable input to Investment Dealers.
History of Religare Ltd.
Religare Securities Limited, a Ranbaxy Promoter Group Company,
was founded by late Dr. Parvinder Singh (CMD Ranbaxy
Laboratories Limited), with the vision of providing integrated
financial care driven by the relationship of trust & confidence. To
realize its vision the Religare group provides various financial
services which include broking (stocks & commodities), depository
participant services, portfolio management services, advisory on
mutual fund investments and many more. Working on the
philosophy of being Financial Care Partner, Religare unlike other
traditional broking firms not only executes the trades for the
10
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
11/148
clients but also provides them critical and timely investment
advice. The growing list of financial institutions with which Religare
is empanelled as an approved broker is a reflection of the high
levels of service standard maintained by the company. Religare is
a truly professional financial service provider managed by a team
of highly skilled professionals who have proven track record in
their respective domains. Religare has the widest reach through its
Regional, Zonal and Branch Offices spread across the length &
breadth of the country.
Religare Enterprises Limited (REL) is one of the leading integrated
financial services groups of India. Backed by a blue chip promoter
pedigree and a proven track record, RELs businesses are broadly
clubbed across three key verticals, the Retail, Institutional and
Wealth spectrums, catering to a diverse and wide base of clients.
REL offers a multitude of investment options and a diverse
bouquet of financial services and can boast of a reach that spreads
across the length and breadth of the country with its presence in
more than 1460 locations across more than 450 cities and towns.
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
The word Derivative has gained popularity by acting as an insulator to risk
management. Derivative products such as Options, Futures or Swaps have become a
standard risk management tool that involves risk sharing and thus facilitates the
efficient allocation of capital to productive investment opportunities. Derivativeshave enabled commercial corporations, governments, financial firms, and other
institutions worldwide to reduce their exposure to fluctuations in interest rates,
currency exchange rates, and the prices of equities and commodities. Derivatives
also have enabled users to reduce funding costs and speculate on changes in market
11
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
12/148
rates and prices. A derivative is simply a new name for a tried and trusted set of
risk management instruments. It covers any transaction where there is no movement
of principle and where the price performance of derivatives is driven by an
underlying commodity. "Derivatives is cited as a simile to Aspirin, which when
taken as an antidote for headache, will make the pain go away. Paradoxically if the
whole bottle is consumed it might lead to disastrous consequences.
What are derivatives?
The primary objectives of any investor are to maximize returns and minimize risks.
Derivatives are contracts that originated from the need to minimize risk.
The word 'derivative' originates from mathematics and refers to a variable, which
has been derived from another variable. Derivatives are so called because they have
no value of their own. They derive their value from the value of some other asset,
which is known as the underlying.
Therefore, derivative is a product which derives its value from the value of one or
more basic variables, called bases (underlying asset, index or reference rate) in a
contractual manner. The underlying asset can be equity, forex, commodity or anyother asset. For example, a derivative of the shares of Infosys (underlying), will
derive its value from the share price (value) of Infosys. Similarly, a derivative
contract on soybean depends on the price of soybean.
With Securities Laws (Second Amendment) Act, 1999, Derivatives has been
included in the definition of Securities. The term Derivative has been defined in
Securities Contracts (Regulations) Act, as:-
A Derivative includes: -
1. a security derived from a debt instrument, share, loan, whether secured or
unsecured, risk instrument or contract for differences or any other form of security;
12
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
13/148
2. a contract which derives its value from the prices, or index of prices, of
underlying securities
Features of derivatives:
Derivatives are specialized contracts which signify an agreement or an
option to buy or sell the underlying asset of the derivate up to a certain time
in the future at a prearranged price, the exercise price.
The contract also has a fixed expiry period mostly in the range of 3 to 12
months from the date of commencement of the contract. The value of the
contract depends on the expiry period and also on the price of the underlying
asset. For example, a farmer fears that the price of soybean (underlying),
when his crop is ready for delivery will be lower than his cost of production.
Lets say the cost of production is Rs 8,000 per ton. In order to overcome
this uncertainty in the selling price of his crop, he enters into a contract
(derivative) with a merchant, who agrees to buy the crop at a certain price
(exercise price), when the crop is ready in three months time (expiry
period).In this case, say the merchant agrees to buy the crop at Rs 9,000 per
ton. Now, the value of this derivative contract will increase as the price of
soybean decreases and vice-a-versa. If the selling price of soybean goes
down to Rs 7,000 per ton, the derivative contract will be more valuable for
the farmer, and if the price of soybean goes down to Rs 6,000, the contract
becomes even more valuable. This is because the farmer can sell the soybean
he has produced at Rs .9000 per tonne even though the market price is much
less. Thus, the value of the derivative is dependent on the value of the
underlying.
If the underlying asset of the derivative contract is coffee, wheat, pepper, cotton,
gold, silver, precious stone or for that matter even weather, then the derivative is
known as a commodity derivative.
13
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
14/148
If the underlying is a financial asset like debt instruments, currency, share price
index, equity shares, etc, the derivative is known as a financial derivative.
Derivative contracts can be standardized and traded on the stock exchange.
Such derivatives are called exchange-traded derivatives. Or they can be
customized as per the needs of the user by negotiating with the other party
involved.
Such derivatives are called over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives. Continuing
with the example of the farmer above, if he thinks that the total production
from his land will be around 150 quintals, he can either go to a food
merchant and enter into a derivatives contract to sell 150 quintals of soybean
in three months time at Rs 9,000 per ton. Or the farmer can go to acommodities exchange, like the National Commodity and Derivatives
Exchange Limited, and buy a standard contract on soybean. The standard
contract on soybean has a size of 100 quintals. So the farmer will be left with
50 quintals of soybean uncovered for price fluctuations.
However, exchange traded derivatives have some advantages like low
transaction costs and no risk of default by the other party, which may exceed
the cost associated with leaving a part of the production uncovered.
TYPES OF DERIVATIVE CONTRACTS
FUTURES
LEAPS BASKETS
14
DERIVATIVE
CONTRACTS
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
15/148
FORWARDS OPTIONS
WARRANTS
SWAPOPTIONS
SWAPS
FORWARD CONTRACTS
A cash market transaction in which delivery of the commodity is deferred until after
the contract has been made. Although the delivery is made in the future, the price is
determined on the initial trade date. Most forward contracts don't have standards
and aren't traded on exchanges. A farmer would use a forward contract to "lock-in"
a price for his grain for the upcoming fall harvest.
FUTURES CONTRACT
Futures Contract means a legally binding agreement to buy or sell the underlying
security on a future date. Future contracts are the organized/standardized contracts
in terms of quantity, quality (in case of commodities), delivery time and place for
settlement on any date in future. The contract expires on a pre-specified date whichis called the expiry date of the contract. On expiry, futures can be settled by delivery
of the underlying asset or cash. Cash settlement enables the settlement of obligations
arising out of the future/option contract in cash.
FORWARDS FUTURES
OTC in nature Traded on an organized exchange
Customized contract terms Standardized contract terms
Less liquid More liquid
No margin payment Requires margin paymentSettlement happens at the end of the
period
Follows daily settlement
Counterparty risk No counterparty risk
15
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/forwardcontract.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/forwardcontract.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/forwardcontract.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/f/forwardcontract.asp#%23 -
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
16/148
OPTIONS CONTRACT
Options Contract is a type of Derivatives Contract which gives the buyer/holder of
the contract the right (but not the obligation) to buy/sell the underlying asset at a
predetermined price within or at end of a specified period. The buyer / holder of the
option purchases the right from the seller/writer for a consideration which is called
the premium. The seller/writer of an option is obligated to settle the option as per the
terms of the contract when the buyer/holder exercises his right. The underlying asset
could include securities, an index of prices of securities etc.
Under Securities Contracts (Regulations) Act, 1956 options on securities has been
defined as "option in securities" means a contract for the purchase or sale of a right
to buy or sell, or a right to buy and sell, securities in future, and includes a teji, a
mandi, a teji mandi, a galli, a put, a call or a put and call in securities;
An Option to buy is called Call option and option to sell is called Put option.
Further, if an option that is exercisable on or before the expiry date is called
American option and one that is exercisable only on expiry date, is called European
option. The price at which the option is to be exercised is called Strike price orExercise price.
Therefore, in the case of American options the buyer has the right to exercise the
option at anytime on or before the expiry date. This request for exercise is submitted
to the Exchange, which randomly assigns the exercise request to the sellers of the
options, who are obligated to settle the terms of the contract within a specified time
frame.
As in the case of futures contracts, option contracts can be also be settled by
delivery of the underlying asset or cash. However, unlike futures cash settlement in
option contract entails paying/receiving the difference between the strikes
16
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
17/148
price/exercise price and the price of the underlying asset either at the time of expiry
of the contract or at the time of exercise / assignment of the option contract.
SWAPS
Traditionally, the exchange of one security for another to change the maturity
(bonds), quality of issues (stocks or bonds), or because investment objectives have
changed. Recently, swaps have grown to include currency swaps and interest rate
swaps.
If firms in separate countries have comparative advantages on interest rates, then a
swap could benefit both firms. For example, one firm may have a lower fixed
interest rate, while another has access to a lower floating interest rate. These firms
could swap to take advantage of the lower rates.
WARRANTS
Options generally have lives upto one year, the majority of options traded on options
exchanges having a maximum maturity of nine months. Longer dated options are
called warrants and are generally traded over- the- counter.
LEAPS
The acronym LEAPS means Long Term Equity Anticipation Securities. These are
options having a maturity of upto three years.
BASKETS
17
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/swap.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/swap.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/swap.asp#%23http://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/swap.asp#%23 -
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
18/148
Basket options are options on portfolio of underlying assets. The underlying asset is
usually a moving average of a basket of assets. Equity index options are a form of
basket options.
SWAPTIONS
They are options to buy or sell a swap that will become operative at the expiry of the
options. Thus a swaption is an option on a forward swap. Rather than have calls and
puts, the swaptions market has receiver swaptions and payer swaptions. A receiver
swaption is an option to receive fixed and pay floating. A payer swaption is an
option to pay fixed and receive floating.
ADVANTAGES OF DERIVATIVES
The advantages are:
1. A tool for hedging: Derivatives provides an excellent mechanism to hedge the
future price risk. Think of a farmer, who doesnt know what price he is going to get
for his crop at the time of harvest. He can sell his crop in the futures market & lock
in the price. If the future spot price is more than the futures price, he can take the off
setting position & can get out of the market (with a marginal loss). Otherwise he
will get the locked in price.
2. Risk management: Derivatives provide an excellent mechanism to Portfolio
Managers for managing the portfolio risk and to Treasury Managers for managing
interest rate risk. The importance of index futures & Forward Rate Agreement
(FRA) in this process cant be overstated.
3. Better avenues for raising money: With the introduction of currency & interest
rate swaps, Indian corporate will be able to raise finance from global markets at
better terms.
18
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
19/148
4. Price discovery: These derivative instruments make the spot price discovery
more reliable using different models like Normal Backwardation hypothesis. These
instruments will cause any arbitrage opportunities to disappear & will lead to better
price discovery.
5. Increasing the depth of financial markets: When a financial market gets such
sort of risk-management tools, its depth increases since the Institutional Investors
get better ways of hedging their risks against unfavorable market movements.
6. Derivatives market on Indian underlying elsewhere: These days, with the
advent of technology, Indian prices are available globally on Reuters & Knight
rider. Nothing prevents any foreign market from launching derivatives on these
Indian underlying. This will put Indians in a disadvantageous position as they cant
take the advantages of derivatives of securities or commodities traded in India but
someone lese can take. So we will have to move fast in this direction.
Empirical evidence: There is strong empirical evidence from other countries that
after derivative markets have come about, the liquidity and market efficiency of the
underlying market has improved.
DISADVANTAGES OF DERIVATIVES
1. Speculation: Many people fear that these instruments will unnecessarily increase
the speculation in the financial markets, which can have far reaching consequences.
The recent Barrings Bank incident is the classic case in point.
2. Market efficiency: Many people fear that the Indian markets are not mature &
efficient enough to introduce these instruments. These instruments require a well
functioning & mature spot market. Like recently The Economic Times reported the
19
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
20/148
strong correlation of Indian equity markets to the NASDAQ. Such type of market
imperfections makes the functioning of derivatives market all the more difficult.
3. Volatility: The increased speculation & inefficient market will make the spot
market more volatile with the introduction of derivatives.
4. Counter party risk: Most of the derivative instruments are not exchange traded.
So there is a counter party default risk in these instruments. Again the same Barrings
case, Barrings declared itself bankrupt when it faced huge losses in these
instruments.
5. Liquidity risk: Liquidity of a market means the ease with which one can enter or
get out of the market. There is a continued debate about the Indian markets
capability to provide enough liquidity to derivative trader.
Hence, the pros of derivatives outweigh the cons. And moreover, by imposing
margin requirements, by limiting the exposure one can take and other measures like
that, these vices of derivatives can be controlled. The importance of derivatives for
any financial market cant be overstated.
RISKS IN DERIVATIVES
20
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
21/148
As derivatives are risk shifting devices, it is important to identify and fully
comprehend the risks being assumed, evaluate those risks and continuously
monitor and manage those risks. Each party to a derivative contract should
be able to identify all the risks that are being assumed (interest rate,
currency exchange, stock index etc) before entering into a derivative
contract.
Risk management is a logical development and execution of a plan to deal with
potential losses. The risk management process involves 3 basic steps:
Identification of risk
Measurement of risk
Monitoring and managing of risks
The fundamental risks involved in derivative business include:
Credit RiskThis is the risk of failure of a counter party to perform its obligation as
per the contract. Also known as default or counter party risk, it differs with different
instruments. Credit risk associated with OTC derivative contracts is generally lower
than the exchange-traded derivative instruments.
Liquidity Risk: There are two types of liquidity risk.
i) Market liquidity risk: Market liquidity risk is the risk that an institution
may not be able to, or cannot easily, liquidate or offset a particular position
at or near previous market price because of inadequate market depth or
disruption in the market place.
ii) Funding liquidity risk: Funding liquidity risk is the risk that an institution
will be unable to meet its payment obligation on settlement dates or in the
event of margin calls
Legal Risk: Derivatives cut across judicial boundaries; therefore the legal aspects
associated with the deal should be looked into carefully. Legal risk is the risk that
contracts are not legally enforceable or documented correctly. There should be
21
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
22/148
guidelines and processes in place to ensure the enforceability of counter party
agreements.
Operational Risk: the risk of direct loss resulting from inadequate or failed
internal processes, people and systems or from external events. The Board ofdirectors and senior management should ensure proper dedication of resources
(financial and personnel) to support operations and systems development and
maintenance
Market Risk:Market risk is the risk to an institution's financial condition resulting
from adverse movement in the level or volatility of market prices of the underlying
asset/instrument.
OTC V/S EXCHANGE TRADED DERIVATIVES
The OTC derivative markets have witnessed rather sharp growth over the last few
years, which have accompanied the modernization of commercial and investment
banking and globalization of financial activities. The recent developments in
information technology have contributed to a great extent to these developments.
While both exchange- traded and OTC derivative contracts offer many benefits, the
former have rigid structures compared to the latter. It has been widely stated that the
highly leveraged institutions and their OTC derivative positions were the main cause
of turbulence in financial markets in 1998. These episodes of turbulence revealed
the risks posed to market stability originating in features of OTC derivative
instruments and markets.
The OTC derivatives market has the following features compared to exchange trade
derivatives:
22
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
23/148
1. The management of counter-party (credit) risk is decentralized and located
within individual institutions.
2. There are no formal centralized limits on individual positions, leverage or
margining.
3. There are no formal rules for risk and burden sharing.
4. there are no formal rules or mechanisms for ensuring market stability and
integrity and for safeguarding the collective interests of market participants
and
5. The OTC contracts are generally not regulated by a regulatory authority and
the exchanges self regulatory organization although they are affected
indirectly by national legal systems, banking supervision and market
surveillance.
Some of the features of OTC derivatives markets embody risks to financial market
stability. The following features of OTC derivatives markets can give rise to
instability in institutions, markets, and the international financial system:
1. The dynamic nature of gross credit exposure
2. information asymmetries
3. the effects of OTC derivative activities on available aggregate credit
4. the high concentration of OTC derivative activities in major institutions
5. the central role of OTC derivative activities in the global financial system
Instability arises when shocks, such as counter-party credit events and sharp
movements in asset prices that underlie derivative contracts occur, which
significantly alter the perceptions of current and potential future credit exposures.
When asset prices change rapidly, the size and configuration of counter-party
exposures can become unsustainable large and provoke a rapid unwinding of
positions.
23
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
24/148
There has been come progress in addressing these risks and perceptions. However,
the progress has been limited in implementing reforms in risk management;
including counterparty, liquidity and operational risks, and OTC derivatives market
continue to pose a threat to international financial stability. The problem is more
acute as heavy reliance on OTC derivatives creates the possibility of systematic
financial events, which fall outside the more formal clearing house structures.
Moreover, those who provide OTC derivative products, hedge their risks associated
with OTC derivatives, and their dependence on exchange traded derivatives, Indian
law considers them illegal.
APPLICATIONS OF DERIVATIVES
Any organization which has to divert its time to foreign exchange problems needs
and seeks information.
Most often, it is confronted with some dilemmas depending on whether the concern
is mainly with imports or with exports, with overseas investments, or with the
purchase of raw materials or factory installations from abroad.
With this view in mind, this section highlights the typical choices and decisions
which confront Indian industry today.
The analysis is based on the views of a cross section of the industry. The sample
interviewed and questioned includes banks, FIs on the one hand and hand and
companies into software exports, production and training on the other.
The areas discussed below were found to be of the most relevance for the largest
number of managing or financial directors in industrial and commercial firms.
Spot or Forward?
24
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
25/148
Should those who have entered into a firm commercial commitment to buy from
abroad and pay in foreign currency, cover the currency straight away on a forward
basis or should they wait until the time of payment or receipt and then cover it on
spot basis?
Normal prudence suggested that customer should cover forward all their
commitments as they provide a professional service to be used without the end-
beneficiary being involved in difficult considerations.
However, this view was not tenable to more sophisticated companies with frequent
and substantial involvement in international transactions. To such a company the
argument is like not interviewing a prospective secretary because one's business is
the manufacture of shoes and not the assessment of personnel.
The Siemens Case presented in the next section highlights the above corporate view.
Unfortunately, no two companies have the risks or the cost of cover the same in any
weeks of the year. Yet, some common relevant guiding questions emerged from the
study:
1. Is it likely that the currency to be bought will be up valued or will
float upwards before the time of payment (or that currency to be sold
will be devalued or will float downwards)?
2. Is the home currency likely to change its official parity or actual
exchange rate against some, many or all foreign currencies or to float
out side present limits?
3. Is the foreign currency or home currency likely to be involved in any
general realignment of rates during this period, such as occurs in the
European Monetary System (EMS) from time to time?
4. How might the foreign currency or home currency fare if there are
further changes in the international monetary system, such as the
25
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
26/148
introduction of new intervention points or the extension of floating
rates or the re-fixing of now freely floating currencies?
5. What is the most that changes feared (whether likely or unlikely to
occur) will cost the organization (i) as a percentage, (ii) in actual
cash.
6. What is the actual cost of forward cover (the difference between spot
now and forward now) : (i) in as a percentage per annum and
adjusted for the period of concern, (ii) in actual cash?
7. What is (i) the likely and (ii) the possible improvement or worsening
in the spot rate between now and the end of the period?
8. Is the forward rate, as sometimes happens, actually more favorable
than the spot rate, so that the forward cover is desirable even though
risks (questions a g) are deemed insufficient to justify insurance?
Nobody denied the difficulty in answering the above questions.
The costs and losses consequent upon an exposed position are such as to merit the
most careful consideration in taking the appropriate decisions.
These decisions do not always remain valid for long periods and therefore need
frequent and careful review.
The Duty to Cover Forward
For a commercial transaction which relies heavily on overseas raw materials or
overseas sales the fluctuations in exchange rates due to their being floating, profits
can be wiped out or doubled.
Hence, banks apply the following advice:
1. If already bought in one currency and already sold in another currency, cover
forward.
26
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
27/148
Deviate from above if there is a danger ahead or only the likelihood of a change in
favour and if the amount is small in relation to total trade. Deviate only if
knowledge is sufficient and advice good. This is rare and specific to situations.
2. If already bought in one currency and yet to sell in another, the decision is more
difficult as in both cases there is an unavoidable risk which contains a large
speculative element inevitable to business.
Time options or Swap?
When the exact data of need of foreign currency may not be known, organizations
tend to use time options but these are costly.
Thus, some have shown a definite inclination towards a fixed date forward contract
followed by an adjusting swap, which may give only partial protection but are
cheaper.
These are those with a fair volume of business, adequate foreign exchange staff andthe will to take small risks.
Invoicing in Foreign/Home Currency?
Conventionally, firms have been invoicing in their home currency.
The study shows that invoices in foreign currency for exports can increase
profitability.
Even imports transactions should be analyzed in real terms before taking the course
of convenience without thought.
27
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
28/148
Do banks advise or merely serve?
There was considerable divergence of opinion among banks and their customers on
this issue.
However, it is true that professional service needs to be an integral part of a good
foreign exchange department while awareness among the customers also has to rise.
Currency options : an essential tool in certain situations
Useful to firms which have to tender for projects or some other transactions in a
foreign currency.
Costing calculations are impossible until it is established in which currency the
contract will materialize, but such calculations must be completed before
negotiations begin.
For most firms however, they are inappropriate where a firm commercial contract
already exists.
Very few professionals with suitable skills and experience have used them in India
as better alternative instruments.
The Siemens Case
Siemens, the $60 billion German industrial conglomerate, installed a financial risk
management system developed by Wall Street Systems to track all its worldwide
assets, liabilities, and risks. Not only does it coordinate the company's exposure to
foreign currencies in the more than 100 countries where Siemens operates, but it
also monitors interest rates on the company's sizable debt portfolio and produces
accounting entries for its treasury department. It gives management a better comfort
28
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
29/148
level to know exactly where they stand and know exactly what their position in
derivatives and currencies is at any point in time.
The system allows Siemens to offset its positions in different parts of he world. A
few years ago, if an American subsidiary needed Deutschmarks, Siemens might
have hired a bank to match the subsidiary with another Siemens operation willing to
swap excess Deutschmarks. Instead of going out and paying a spread to a bank, all
financial engineering is done internally.
DERIVATIVES MARKET IN INDIA
Approval for derivatives trading
The first step towards introduction of derivatives trading in India was the
promulgation of the Securities Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 1995, which
withdrew the prohibition on options in securities. The market for derivatives,
however, did not take off, as there was no regulatory framework to govern trading of
derivatives. SEBI set up a 24-member committee under the chairmanship of
Dr.L.C.Gupta on November 18, 1996 to develop appropriate framework for
derivatives trading in India. The committee submitted its report on March 17, 1998prescribing pre-conditions for introduction of derivatives trading in India. The
committee recommended that derivatives should be declared as securities so that
regulatory framework applicable to trading of securities could also govern trading
of derivatives. SEBI also set up a group in June 1998 under the chairmanship of Prof
.J.R.Varma, to recommend measures for risk containment in derivatives market in
India. The report, which was submitted in October 1998, worked out the operational
details of margining system, methodology for charging initial margins, broker net
worth, deposit requirement and real-time monitoring requirements.
The SCRA was amended in December 1999 to include derivatives within the ambit
of securities and the regulatory framework was developed for governing
29
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
30/148
derivatives trading. The act also made it clear that derivatives shall be legal and
valid only if such contracts are traded on a recognized stock exchange, thus
precluding OTC derivatives. The government also rescinded in March 2000, the
three-decade old notification, which prohibited forward trading in securities.
Derivatives trading commenced in India in June 2000 after SEBI granted the final
approval to this effect in may 2000. SEBI permitted the derivative segments of two
stock exchanges, NSE and BSE, and their clearing house/corporation to commence
trading and settlement in approved derivatives contracts. To begin with, SEBI
approved trading in index futures contracts based on S&P CNX Nifty and BSE-30
(Sensex) index. This was followed by approval for trading in options based on these
two indexes and options on individual securities. The trading in index optionscommenced in June 2001, and the trading in options on individual securities
commenced in July 2001. Futures contracts on individual stocks were launched in
November 2001. Trading and settlement in derivative contracts is done in
accordance with the rules, byelaws, and regulations of the respective exchanges and
their clearing house/ corporation duly approved by SEBI and notified in the official
gazette.
Derivatives market at NSE
The derivatives trading on the exchange commenced with S&P CNX Nifty Index
futures on June 12,2000. The trading in index options commenced on June 4, 2001
and trading in options on individual securities commenced on July, 2 2001. Single
stock futures were launched on November 9,2001. The index futures and options
contract on NSE are based on S&P CNX Nifty index. Currently, the futures
contracts have a maximum of 3-month expiration cycles. Three contracts are
available for trading with 1 month, 2 months and 3 months expiry. A new contract is
introduced on the next trading day following the expiry of the near month contract.
Trading mechanism
30
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
31/148
The futures and options trading system of NSE, called NEAT- F&O trading system,
provides a fully automated screen based trading for nifty futures & options and
stock futures and options on a nationwide basis and an online monitoring and
surveillance mechanism. It supports an anonymous order driven market which
provides complete transparency of trading operations and operated on strict price-
time priority. It is similar to that of trading of equities in the cash market segment.
The NEAT- F&O trading system is accessed by two types of users. The trading
members have access to functions such as order entry, order matching, and order
and trade management. It provides tremendous flexibility to users in terms of kinds
of orders that can be placed to the system. Various conditions like good-till-day,
good-till-canceled, good-till-date, immediate or cancel, limit/ market price, stop
loss, etc can be built into an order. The clearing members use the trader workstation
for the purpose of monitoring the trading members for whom they clear the trades.
Additionally, they can enter and set limits to positions, which a trading member can
take.
Membership criteria
NSE admits members on its derivative segment in accordance with the rules and
regulations of the exchange and the norms specified by SEBI. NSE follows 2- tier
membership structure stipulated by SEBI to enable wider participation. Those
interested in taking membership on F&O segment are required to take membership
of CM and F&O segment or CM, WDM and F&O segment. Trading and clearing
members are admitted separately. Essentially, a clearing member does clearing for
all his trading members, undertakes risk management and performs actual
settlement. There are three types of CMS:
1. Self clearing member: a SCM clears and settles trades executed by him only
either on his own account or on account of his clients.
31
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
32/148
2. Trading member clearing member: TM-CM is a CM who is also a TM. TM-
CM may clear and settle his own proprietary trades and clients trades as well
as clear and settle for other TMs.
3. Professional clearing member: PCM is a CM who is not a TM. Typically,
banks or custodians could become a PCM and clear and settle for TMs.
Requirements for professional clearing membership
Particulars (all
values in Rs. Lakh)
F&O segment CM & F&O segment
Eligibility Trading members of
NSE/SEBI registered
custodians/ recognized banks
Trading members of
NSE/SEBI registered
custodians/ recognized banks
Networth 300 300
Interest Free
Security Deposit
(IFSD)
25 34
Collateral security
deposit
25 50
Annual
subscription
nil 2.5
Note: the PCM is required to bring in IFSD of Rs. 2 lakh and CSD of Rs.8 Lakh per
trading member whose trades he undertakes to clear and settle in F&O segment.
Eligibility criteria for membership on F&O segment
Particulars (all values in
Rs Lakh)
CM and F&O segment CM,WDM and F&O
segment
Net worth(1) 100 200
Interest free security
deposit(IFSD)(2)
125 275
Collateral security deposit
(CSD)(3)
25 25
Annual subscription 1 2
1: No additional net worth is required for self clearing members. However, a net
worth of Rs. 300 lakhs is required for TM-CM and PCM.
2&3: Additional Rs. 25 lakh is required for clearing membership (SCM, TM-CM).
in addition, the claring member is required to bring in IFSD of Rs. 2 lakh and CSD
of Rs. 8 lakh per trading member he undertakes to clear and settle.
32
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
33/148
The TM-CM and the PCM are required to bring in additional security deposit in
every TM whose trades they undertake to clear and settle. Besides this, trading
members are required to have qualified users and sales persons, who have passed a
certification programme approved by SEBI.
Turnover
The trading volumes on NSEs derivatives market have seen a steady increase since
the launch of the first derivatives contract, i.e. Index futures in June 2000. The
average daily turnover now exceeds a 1000 crore. A total of 41, 96,873 contracts
with a total turnover of Rs. 1, 01,926 crore was traded during 2001.02.
Clearing and settlement
NSCCL undertakes clearing and settlement of all deals executed on the NSEs F&O
segment. It acts as legal counterparty to all deals on the F&O segment and
guarantees settlement.
1. Clearing
The first step in clearing process is working out open positions or obligations ofmembers. A CMs open position is arrived at by aggregating the open position of all
the TMs and all custodial participants clearing through him, in the contracts in
which they have traded. A TMs open position is arrived at as the summation of his
proprietary open position and clients open positions, in the contracts in which they
have traded. While entering orders on the trading system, TMs are required to
identify the orders, whether proprietary ( if they are their own trades) or clients( if
entered on behalf of clients). Proprietary positions are calculated on net basis (buy-
sell) position of each individual client for each contract. A TMs open position is the
sum of proprietary open position, client open long position and client open short
position.
33
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
34/148
2. Settlement
All futures and options contracts are cash settled .i.e. through exchange of cash. The
underlying for index futures/ options of the nifty index cannot be delivered. These
contracts, therefore, have to be settled in cash. Futures and options on individual
securities can be delivered as in the spot market. However, it has been currently
mandated that stock options and futures would also be cash settled. The settlement
amount for a CM is netted across all their TMs/ clients in respect of MTM,
premium and final exercise settlement. For the purpose of settlement, all CMs are
required to open a separate bank account with NSCCL designated clearing banks for
F&O segment.
Risk management system
The salient features of risk containment measures on the F&O segment are:
1. Anybody interested in taking membership of F&O segment is required to take
membership of CM and F&O or CM, WDM and F&O segment. An existing
member of CM segment can also take membership of F&O segment.
2. NSCCL charges an upfront margin for all the open positions of a CM upto client
level. It follows the VaR based margining system through SPAN system. NSCCL
computes the initial margin percentage for each nifty index futures contract on a
daily basis and informs the CMs. The CM in turn collects the initial margin from
the TMs and their respective clients.
3. NSCCLS on line position monitoring system monitors A CMs open positions on
a real time basis. Limits are set for each CM based on his base capital and
additional capital deposited with NSCCL. The on-line position monitoring system
generates alerts whenever a CM reaches a position limit set up NSCCL. NSCCL
monitors the CMs and TMs for mark to market value violation and for contract-
wise position limit violation.
34
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
35/148
4. CMs are provided with a trading terminal for the purpose of monitoring the open
positions of all the TMs clearing and settling through them. A CM may set
exposure limits for a TM clearing and settling through him. NSCCL assists the
CM to monitor the intra-day exposure limits set up by a CM and whenever a TM
exceeds the limits, it withdraws the trading facility provided to such TM.
5. A separate settlement guarantee fund for this segment has been created out of the
capital deposited by the members with NSCCL.
Factors driving the growth of derivatives
Over the last three decades, the derivatives market has seen a phenomenal growth. A
large variety of derivatives contracts have been launched at exchanges across the
world. Some of the factors driving the growth of financial derivatives are:
a. increased volatility in asset prices in financial markets,
b. increased integration of national financial markets with the
international markets
c. marked improvement in communication facilities and sharp decline
in their costs,
d. development of more sophisticated risk management tools, providing
economic agents a wider choice of risk management strategies, and
e. innovations in the derivatives markets, which optimally combine the
risks, returns over a large number of financial assets leading to higher
returns, reduced risk as well as transaction costs as compared to
individual financial assets.
Economic function of the derivatives market
Inspite of the fear and criticism with which the derivative markets are commonly
looked at, these markets perform a number of economic functions.
35
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
36/148
1. Prices in an organized derivatives market reflect the perception of market
participants about the future and lead the prices of underlying to the
perceived future level. The prices of derivatives converge with the prices of
the underlying at the expiration of the derivative contract. Thus derivatives
help in discovery of future as well as current prices.
2. The derivatives market helps to transfer risks from those who have them but
may not like them to those who have an appetite for them.
3. Derivatives, due to their inherent nature, are linked to the underlying cash
markets. With the introduction of derivatives, the underlying market
witnesses higher trading volumes because of participation by more players
who would not otherwise participate for lack of an arrangement to transfer
risk.
4. Speculative trades shift to a more controlled environment of derivatives
market. In the absence of an organized derivatives market, speculators trade
in the underlying cash market. Margining, monitoring and surveillance of the
activities of various participants become extremely difficult in these kinds of
mixed markets.
5. An important incidental benefit that flows from derivatives trading is that it
acts as a catalyst for new entrepreneurial activity. The derivatives have a
history of attracting many bright, creative, well-educated people with an
entrepreneurial attitude. They often energise others to create new businesses,
new products and new employment opportunities, the benefit of which are
immense.
In a nut shell, derivatives markets help increase savings and investment in the long
run. Transfer of risk enables market participants to expand their volume and activity.
Pre-requisites for Derivatives
Strong and healthy cash market
36
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
37/148
The first and the foremost requirement is the existence of a strong and healthy
cash market. An efficient, transparent and fair cash market with short settlement
cycles help in building an efficient derivatives market.
Empirical evidence from international markets suggests that the derivativesmarket and cash market are synergistic. A healthy cash market is a prerequisite
for developing a good derivatives market, while good derivative volumes make
the cash market even healthier. As the derivatives volume grow, it contributes
significantly to the cash market volumes resulting from growing opportunities
for arbitrage.
Clearing corporation and settlement guarantee
Existence of a common clearing corporation providing settlement guarantee as
well as cross margining is essential for speedy settlement as well as for risk
minimization. This is particularly important in case of derivatives where there
are often no securities to be delivered; the settlement is arranged in the form of
cash 'difference'.
Reliable wide area telecommunication network
Since derivatives trading must be introduced on nation wide basis so as to
providing equal opportunities for hedging to the investors population
throughout the country, existing of proven automated trading systems is
extremely important.
Risk containment mechanism
There should exist a strong and disciplined margining system in the form of
daily and mark-to-market margins, which provide a cover for exposure along
with price risk and notional loss in case of default in settling outstanding
positions; thereby minimizing market risk.
37
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
38/148
The Indian Derivatives market continues to remain in the Stone Age. This is evident
from the fact that only fifteen to twenty corporate including the blue-chips and the
government owned companies have been able to make effective use of the limited
foreign exchange. While most of the smaller forex earners are undeterred by the
developments in the forex and derivatives market.
Hedging is an exercise, which involves using derivatives to manage risks. Risk
management involves both understanding risks and choosing appropriate techniques
to be protected against the risk. The forex market provides a forum in which the
operators can exchange risks. To hedge or not to hedge is the million dollar
question. Very few corporation have in use policies on the extent to which
speculation is permitted in terms of budgets associated and overnight open position
to be carried.
Examples
Essar Gujarat Ltd., one of the leading corporate players in the forex market, has a
well defined policy on hedging. Their policy includes a core cover to total exposure
ratio in keeping with the market condition which implies that the policy covers a
certain minimum proposition of every exposure.
Reliance Industries it is which figures among the bigger corporate dealers, has
raised funds through Euro in the past one year. The companies foreign exchange
exposures are reviewed daily on a market to market basis and the hedging sharing is
formulated accordingly Reliance also has an internal loss limits, depending on
market conditions.
GLOBAL DERIVATIVES MARKETS
38
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
39/148
The significant growth of the formal, organized and officially recognized derivatives
market globally has taken place only during the past two decades. There are about
forty futures and options exchanges in Europe and Japan and about twelve in the
U.S. The U.S. alone accounted for 60 per cent of the total futures business in the
world in 1990. In the US, the financial futures market accounted for about 73
percent of the total future trading volume in 1990. Among interest rates futures,
treasury bonds futures dominate the market. The share of futures in equity indices,
foreign currencies, treasury bonds, and interest rates was 5 per cent, 10 per cent, 27
per cent and 45 per cent respectively in 1990 in America. At the global level, the
total value of derivatives trading has increased phenomenally from just $ 1,118
billion to $ 27,175 billion i.e. 2,331 percent or at the annual average rate of 259
percent during 1986 to 1995. As a part of this total, the share of OTC traded
derivatives has increased over the years. It was 66 percent in 1995, the rest being
accounted for by the exchange traded derivatives. Among the later, interest rates
futures and interest rates options accounted for 60 to 65 per cent and 24 to 30 per
cent respectively during 1986-95.
THE INTERNATIONAL DIMENSION
One of the more remarkable stories in the history of financial markets came about in
the aftermath of the worldwide stock market crash of October 1987. In Japan,
regulators asked themselves what needed to be done to prevent such occurrences in
future. Regulators and economists who worked with them pondered and came with a
completely incorrect diagnosis: they decided that "Programme trading" was to
blame. Programme trading enters the picture when the cash index and futures are out
of sync. When this happens, arbitrageurs use programme trading to rapidly buy (or
sell) all the index stocks using the computer. Japan's regulators made the arbitrage
very difficult by putting restrictions upon programme trading.
Today, the working of index futures markets is better understood - arbitrage is
essential to the functioning of any futures markets. Without the index arbitrage, the
39
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
40/148
index futures market would be useless for hedgers since the price of futures would
often stray away form their fair values. But this was perhaps not clearly understood
at that time.
The sequence of events which followed the clamp down by Japan's regulators was
interesting. Thanks to the pervasive mispricing of the Japanese index futures without
index arbitrage, the Japanese futures market was unable to meet the needs of the
users.
Singapore saw a strong derivative exchange as an essential part of its desire to be
center for international finance. Simex was created in the early 80s as an example
of strategic policy making. It perceived the unmet demand among Japanese users of
index futures. A great deal of usage of the futures on the Nikkei 225 moved off to
Simex. This was bad for Japanese financial industry as it lost fees but it was good
for users who were not locked into using their inferior domestic market: they were
able to use the offshore market. The idea commonly recurs with foreign
competition: when foreign airlines start operating in India, 8000 workers of Indian
Airlines will be hurt and eight million users of air travel in India will benefit.
Japan's regulators since removed many restrictions but a very important Nikkei 225
future market remains in Singapore. This is because liquidity is hard to dislodge
once it comes about, also because of he elevated transaction and brokerage fees in
Japan's highly rigid financial industry. This story is one of the important battles in a
burgeoning industry of exchanges competing for order flow on an international
scale.
40
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
41/148
CHAPTER 5
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
The introduction of derivatives trading will separate leveraged positions from the spot markets
and make it easier for exchanges to implement rolling settlement. This should reduce volatility
in the existing markets, and make risk containment and regulation easier by making markets
safer."
Ashish Kumar Chauhan, Vice-President, National Stock Exchange (NSE).
"It had to start at one point of time or the other. Just like a plant needs soil, water and
minerals to nurture well, for derivatives you need a healthy cash market in place."
- Alok Churiwala, Member of Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE).
INTRODUCTION
Derivatives may have become popular now but their origin can be traced back to
Aristotles writings. Aristotle tells the story of Thales; a poor philosopher who
developed a financial devise, which he said, could be universally applicable. Thales
had great skill in forecasting and predicting how good the harvest would be in the
autumn. Confident about his prediction, he made agreements with area olive press
owners to deposit what little money he had with them to guarantee him exclusive
use of their olive presses when the harvest was ready. Thale successfully negotiated
41
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
42/148
low prices because the harvest was in future and one knew whether the harvest
would be plentiful or pathetic and because the olive press owners were willing to
hedge against the possibility of poor yield and these contracts were exercised
some 2500 years ago.
Derivatives have probably been around for as long as people have been trading with
one another. Forward contracting dates back at least to the 12th century, and may
well have been around before then. Merchants entered into contracts with one
another for future delivery of specified amount of commodities at specified price. A
primary motivation for pre-arranging a buyer or seller for a stock of commodities in
early forward contracts was to lessen the possibility that large swings would inhibit
marketing the commodity after a harvest.
The concept of forward delivery, with contracts stating what is to be delivered for a
fixed price at a specified place at a specified date, existed in ancient Greece and
Rome. Perhaps the first organized commodity exchange on which forward contracts
existed in early 1700s in Japan. Futures and options trading in commodities appear
to have originated in the 17th century. The first formal commodity exchange in the
United States for spot and forward trading was formed in 1848: the Chicago Board
Of Trade (CBOT).
Options also have a long history. The concept of options existed in ancient Greece
and Rome. Options were used by speculators in the tulip craze of 17 th century
Holland. Unfortunately there was no mechanism to guarantee the performance of
options, terms, and when the tulip craze collapsed in 1636 many of the speculators
were wiped out. In particular the put writers refuse to take delivery of the tulip bulbs
and pay high prices they had originally agreed to pay.
The explosion of growth in the derivative markets coincided with the collapse of the
Bretton Woods fixed exchange rate regime and the suspension of the dollars
convertibility into gold. Trading in financial futures began in the early 1970s after
almost a decade of accelerating inflation, which exposed market participants to the
unprecedented levels of exchange and interest rates volatility. A means of managing
42
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
43/148
risk was required. To mitigate this risk, foreign currency derivatives were
introduced on an Over the Counter (OTC). Growth in this area has come from the
two directions namely innovations in technology and financial economics.
This eventually resulted in the creation of the financial derivatives industry.(seetable 1 & 2 in the appendix)
The process of development in the derivatives market still continues. Over 50
exchanges throughout the world now trade in some form of derivatives or other.
Recent trends
The global market for derivatives has grown substantially in the recent past. The
Foreign Exchange and Derivatives Market Activity survey conducted by Bank for
International Settlements (BIS) points to this increased activity. The total estimated
notional amount of outstanding OTC contracts increasing to $111 trillion at end-
December 2001 from $94 trillion at end-June 2000. This growth in the derivatives
segment is even more substantial when viewed in the light of declining activity in
the spot foreign exchange markets. The turnover in traditional foreign exchange
markets declined substantially between 1998 and 2001. In April 2001, average daily
turnover was $1,200 billion, compared to $1,490 billion in April 1998, a 14%
decline when volumes are measured at constant exchange rates. Whereas the globaldaily turnover during the same period in foreign exchange and interest rate
derivative contracts, including what are considered to be "traditional" foreign
exchange derivative instruments, increased by an estimated 10% to US $1.4 trillion.
(see table 3 in the appendix)
The first 'futures' contracts can be traced to the Yodoya rice market in Osaka,
Japan around 1650. These were evidently standardized contracts, which
made them much like today's futures. The Chicago Board of Trade (CBOT), the largest derivative exchange in the
world, was established in 1848 where forward contracts on various
commodities were standardized around 1865. From then on, futures
43
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
44/148
contracts have remained more or less in the same form, as we know them
today.
Derivatives have had a long presence in India. The commodity derivative
market has been functioning in India since the nineteenth century with
organized trading in cotton through the establishment of Cotton Trade
Association in 1875. Since then contracts on various other commodities have
been introduced as well.
Exchange traded financial derivatives were introduced in India in June 2000
at the two major stock exchanges, NSE and BSE. There are various contracts
currently traded on these exchanges. On June 9, 2000, the Bombay Stock
Exchange (BSE) introduced India's first derivative instrument - the BSE-
30(Sensex) index futures. It was introduced with three month trading cycle -
the near month (one), the next month (two) and the far month (three). The
National Stock Exchange (NSE) followed a few days later, by launching the
S&P CNX Nifty index futures on June 12, 2000 .
National Commodity & Derivatives Exchange Limited (NCDEX) started its
operations in December 2003, to provide a platform for commodities trading.
The initial steps to launch derivatives were taken in 1995 with the introduction ofthe Securities Laws (Amendment) Ordinance, 1995 that withdrew the prohibition on
trading in options on securities in the Indian stock market. In November 1996, a 24-
member committee was set up by the Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
under the chairmanship of LC Gupta to develop an appropriate regulatory
framework for derivatives trading. The committee recommended that the regulatory
framework applicable to the trading of securities would also govern the trading of
derivatives.
The L C Gupta Committee report
SEBI appointed L.C.Gupta Committee on 18th November 1996 to develop
44
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
45/148
appropriate regulatory framework for the derivatives trading and to recommend
suggestive bye-laws for Regulation and Control of Trading and Settlement of
Derivatives Contracts. The Committee was also to focus on the financial derivatives
and equity derivatives. The Committee submitted its report in March 1998.
The Board of SEBI in its meeting held on May 11, 1998 accepted the
recommendations and approved the introduction of derivatives trading in India
beginning with Stock Index Futures. The Board also approved the "Suggestive Bye-
laws" recommended by the LC Gupta Committee for Regulation and Control of
Trading and Settlement of Derivatives Contracts. SEBI circulated the contents of the
Report in June 98.
The LC Gupta Committee had conducted a wide market survey with contact of
several entities relevant to derivatives trading like brokers, mutual funds, banks/FIs,
FIIs and merchant banks. The Committee observation was that there is a widespread
recognition of the need for derivatives products including Equity, Interest Rate and
Currency derivatives products. However Stock Index Futures is the most preferred
product followed by stock index options. Options on individual stocks are the third
in the order of preference. The participants took interviews, mostly stated that their
objective in derivative trading would be hedging. But there were also a few
interested in derivatives dealing for speculation or dealing.
Goals of Regulation - Regulatory Objectives
LCGC believes that regulation should be designed to achieve specific and well-
defined goals. It is inclined towards positive regulation designed to encourage
healthy activity and behavior. The Committee outlined the goals of regulation
admirably well in Paragraph 3.1 of its report.
The important recommendations of L.C.Gupta Committee are reproduced
hereunder.
45
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
46/148
Need for coordinated development
To quote from the report of the Committee -"The Committee's main concern is with
equity based derivatives but it has tried to examine the need for financial derivatives
in a broader perspective. Financial transactions and asset-liability positions are
exposed to three broad types of price risks, viz:
"Equities "market risk", also called "systematic risk" (which cannot be
diversified away because the stock market as a whole may go up or down
from time to time).
"Interest rate risk (as in the case of fixed-income securities, like treasury
bond holdings, whose market price could fall heavily if interest rates shot
up), and
"Exchange rate risk (where the position involves a foreign currency, as in the
case of imports, exports, foreign loans or investments).
"The above classification of price risks explains the emergence of (a) equity futures,
(b) interest rate futures and (c) currency futures, respectively. Equity futures have
been the last to emerge.
"The recent report of the RBI-appointed Committee on Capital Account
Convertibility (Tara pore Committee) has expressed the view that "time is ripe for
introduction of futures in currencies and interest rates to facilitate various users to
have access to a wide spectrum of cost-efficient hedge mechanism" (p.24). In the
same context, the Tara pore Committee has also opined that "a system of trading in
futures ... is more transparent and cost-efficient than the existing system (of forward
contracts)". There are inter-connections among the various kinds of financial
futures, mentioned above, because the various financial markets are closely inter-
linked, as the recent financial market turmoil in East and South-East Asian countries
has shown. The basic principles underlying the running of futures markets and their
regulation are the same. Having a common trading infrastructure will have
46
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
47/148
important advantages. The Committee, therefore, feels that the attempt should be to
develop an integrated market structure. SEBI-RBI coordination mechanism
"As all the three types of financial derivatives are set to emerge in India in the near
future, it is desirable that such development be coordinated. The Committee
recommends that a formal mechanism be established for such coordination between
SEBI and RBI in respect of all financial derivatives markets. This will help to avoid
the problem of overlapping jurisdictions."
Cash and Futures Market Relationship
The Committee felt that the operations of the cash market, on which the derivatives
market will be based, needed improvement in many respects. It therefore suggested
improvements to the Cash Market.
Derivatives Exchanges
The Committee strongly favoured the introduction of financial derivatives to
facilitate hedging in a most cost-efficient way against market risk. There is a need
for equity derivatives, interest rate derivatives and currency derivatives. There
should be phased introduction of derivatives produces. To start with, index futures
to be introduced, which should be followed by options on index and later options on
stocks. The derivative trading should take place on a separate segment of the
existing stock exchanges with an independent governing council where the number
of trading members should be limited to 40 percent of the total number. Common
Governing Council and Governing Board members not allowed. The Chairman of
the governing council should not be permitted to trade (broking/dealing business) on
any of the stock exchanges during his term. Trading to be based on On-line screen
47
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
48/148
trading with disaster recovery site. Per half hour capacity should be 4-5 times the
anticipated peak load. Percentage of broker-members in the council to be prescribed
by SEBI. Other recommendations of the Committee about the structure of
Derivative Exchanges are as under:
The settlement of derivatives to be through an independent clearing
corporation/clearing house, which should become counter party for all trades or
alternatively guarantee the settlement of all trades. The clearing corporation to have
adequate risk containment measures and to collect margins through EFT. The
derivative exchange to have both on-line trading and surveillance systems. It should
disseminate trade and price information on real time basis through two information
vending net works. It should inspect 100 percent of members every year. The
segment can start with a minimum of 50 members. The Committee recommended
separate membership for derivatives segment. Members of equity segment cannot
automatically become members of derivative segment. Provision for arbitration and
investor grievances cells to be set up in four regions. Provision of adequate
inspection capability and all members to be inspected.
Regulatory framework
Regulatory control should envisage modern systems for fool-proof and fail-proof
regulation. Regulatory framework for derivatives trading envisaged two-level
regulation i.e. exchange-level and SEBI-level, with considerable emphasis on self-
regulatory competence of derivative exchanges under the overall supervision and
guidance of SEBI. There will be complete segregation of client money at the level
of trading /clearing member and even at the level of clearing corporation. Other
recommendations are as under:
Regulatory Role of SEBI
48
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
49/148
SEBI will approve rules, bye-laws and regulations. New derivative contracts to be
approved by SEBI. Derivative exchanges to provide full details of proposed
contract, like - economic purposes of the contract; likely contribution to the market's
development; safeguards incorporated for investor protection and fair trading.
Specifications Regarding Trading
Stock Exchanges to stipulate in advance trading days and hours. Each contract to
have pre-determined expiration date and time. Contract expiration period may not
exceed 12 months. The last trading day of the trading cycle to be stipulated in
advance.
Membership Eligibility Criteria
The trading and clearing member will have stringent eligibility conditions. The
Committee recommended for separate clearing and non-clearing members. There
should be separate registration with SEBI in addition to registration with the stock
exchange. At least two persons should have passed the certification program
approved by SEBI. A higher capital adequacy for Derivatives segment
recommended than prescribed for cash market. The clearing members should
deposit minimum Rs. 50 lakh with the clearing corporation and should have a net
worth of Rs. 3 crore. A higher deposit proposed for Option writers.
Clearing Corporation
The Clearing System to be totally restructured. There should be no trading interests
on board of the CC. The maximum exposure limit to be liked the deposit limit. To
make the clearing system effective the Committee stressed stipulation of Initial and
mark-to-market margins. Extent of Margin prescribed to co-relate to the level of
volatility of particular Scripps traded. The Committee therefore recommended
49
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
50/148
margins based on value at risk - 99% confidence (The initial margins should be
large enough to cover the one day loss that can be encountered on the position on
99% of the days. The concept is identified as "Worst Scenario Loss"). It did not
favour the system of Cross-margining (This is a method of calculating margin after
taking into account combined positions in futures, options, cash market etc. Hence,
the total margin requirement reduces due to cross-hedges). Since margins to be
adjusted frequently based on market volatility margin payments to be remitted
through EFT (Electronic Funds Transfer). To prevent brokers who fail/default to
provide/restore adequate margin from trading further the stock exchange must have
the power/facility to disable the defaulting member from further trading.
Brokers/sub-brokers also to collect margin collection from clients. Exposure limits
to be on gross basis. Own/clients margin to be segregated. No set off permitted.
Trading to be clearly indicated as own/clients and opening/closing out. In case of
default, only own margin can be set off against members' dues and the CC should
promptly transfer client's margin in separate account. CC to close out all open
positions at its option. CC can also ask members to close out excess positions or it
may itself close out such positions. CC may however permit special margins on
members. It can withhold margin or demand additional margin. CC may prescribe
maximum long/short positions by members or exposure limit in quantity / value / %
of base capital.
Mark to Market and Settlement
There should the system of daily settlement of futures contracts. Similarly the
closing price of futures to be settled on daily basis. The final settlement price to be
as per the closing price of underlying security.
Sales Practices
Risk disclosure document with each client mandatory
50
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
51/148
Sales personnel to pass certification exam
Specific authorization from client's board of directors/trustees
Trading Parameters
Each order - buy/sell and open/close
Unique order identification number
Regular market lot size, tick size
Gross exposure limits to be specified
Price bands for each derivative contract
Maximum permissible open position Off line order entry permitted
Brokerage
Prices on the system shall be exclusive of brokerage
Maximum brokerage rates shall be prescribed by the exchange
Brokerage to be separately indicated in the contract note
Margins from Clients
Margins to be collected from all clients/trading members
Daily margins to be further collected
Right of clearing member to close out positions of clients/TMs not paying
daily margins
Losses if any to be charged to clients/TMs and adjusted against margins
Other Recommendations
51
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
52/148
Removal of the regulatory prohibition on the use of derivatives by mutual
funds while making the trustees responsible to restrict the use of derivatives
by mutual funds only to hedging and portfolio balancing and not for
speculation.
Creation of derivatives Cell, a derivative Advisory Committee, and
Economic Research Wing by SEBI.
Declaration of derivatives as securities under section 2(h)(iia) of the SCRA
and suitable amendment in the notification issued by the Central
Government in June 1969 under section 16 of the SCRA
Consequent to the committee's recommendations the following legal
amendments were carried out:
Legal Amendments
Securities Contract Regulation Act
Derivatives contract declared as a 'security' in Dec 1999 Notification in June
1969 under section 16 of SCRA banning forward trading revoked in March
2000.
In order to recommend a guideline for effective implementation of the
recommendations of LC Gupta Committee Report, SEBI entrusted the task
to another Committee, i.e. JR Verma Committee appointed by it.
The derivatives market in India has grown exponentially, especially at NSE. Stock
Futures are the most highly traded contracts on NSE accounting for around 55% of
the total turnover of derivatives at NSE, as on April 13, 2005.
The plan to introduce derivatives in India was initially mooted by the National Stock
Exchange (NSE) in 1995. The main purpose of this plan was to encourage greater
participation of foreign institutional investors (FIIs) in the Indian stock exchanges.
52
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
53/148
Their involvement had been very low due to the absence of derivatives for hedging
risk. However, there was no consensus of opinion on the issue among industry
analysts and the media. The pros and cons of introducing derivatives trading were
debated intensely. The lack of transparency and inadequate infrastructure of the
Indian stock markets were cited as reasons to avoid derivatives trading. Derivatives
were also considered risky for retail investors because of their poor knowledge
about their operation. In spite of the opposition, the path for derivatives trading was
cleared with the introduction of Securities Laws (Amendment) Bill in Parliament in
1998.
The introduction of derivatives was delayed for some more time as the infrastructure
for it had to be set up. Derivatives trading required a computer-based trading
system, a depository and a clearing house facility. In addition, problems such as low
market capitalization of the Indian stock markets, the small number of institutional
players and the absence of a regulatory framework caused further delays.
Derivatives trading eventually started in June 2000.
53
-
8/3/2019 Akhil Derivatives
54/148
CHAPTER 6
PRESENT STUDY
Derivative instruments
FORWARDS
A cash market transaction in which delivery of the commodity is deferred until after
the contract has been made. Although the delivery is made in the future, the price is
determined on the initial trade date. Most forward contracts don't have standards
and aren't traded on exchanges. A farmer would use a forward contract to "lock-in"a price for his grain for the upcoming fall harvest.
FUTURES
Futures Contract means a legally binding agreement to buy or sell the underlying
security on a future date. Future contracts are the organized/standardized contracts
in terms of quantity, quality (in case of commodities), delivery time and place for
settlement on any date in future. The contract expires on a pre-specified date which
is called the expiry date of the contract. On expiry, futures can be settled by delivery
of the underlying asset or cash. Cash settlement enables the settlement of obligation