Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

download Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

of 6

Transcript of Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    1/6

    1*1/1, {{\{n{ i`V>>VViV>

    `V>] *>VVi >` iL>i

    `V

    i > i}V> ``i V} v

    iVi ii i} v iVii]

    Vi` iiVV> >V i L> ii

    i i > ``i L>>Vi VV Liii

    i iV> >` L vVi i

    i v VV> i v> v > ``i

    i v iV> /i>i v ii

    VViv i > v V>i] L i ` v

    iiV >i >i iv>V i>i

    /i> Li ii / i vii

    v v >>Vi> ii >

    /i >}`>>] > i> Li Vi >

    > v i LV i] > } Lii iV}i`

    v Vi> i i >` i>

    Li> *>}V> >i> i>

    iV>L i >}`>> > > > i

    i >}ii >` >} v i>

    Li ii -ii> i v i`iVi i

    ViV V>] >i > i >}`>>

    i i> Li i}] > i i }

    v VV ii / >i

    /i `}ii > Lii ii

    iii > > VV `i v i> Li

    ii `} > ii iiL

    V> v vV> ii V }

    vV> iiVV> L> > `Vi > Vi>

    }ii V>}i ii i `> ii

    / }i i>` >>i v > LV

    >` viL> > i] L

    `>>V v i> Li Vi] V > i

    >}`>> >` v Vi 7 `> ii

    >` i iVi v i vV > iV>i

    i i>` v ii] `} Vi `i

    Vi >> ii iV`>

    }ii>> >` >vi > `> v }}i}

    `i` ii L i iiii] ii Li}

    >i> >i >V> v i

    `} {

    6>} ii > 6- i>i >

    i> >i>i i> v >i

    >V>Li iix >} iiV`i

    >i` >` i >} ii i iV >` >

    }>>Li i }ii> >` L>i >V >i

    }V> >i` i >i Vi >

    } i iVi iV> v >V v 6-

    ] } >` i ii` > x

    i`V ii viiV 6-x

    9v "} >>

    ii>V >>

    i>i v >

    Vi

    * i

    ,ii>V ii

    -V v i`Vi

    1i v >>>

    >L] /i

    V>>J

    >>>i`

    i] iiV>VVi >` i Vi vi > >V9v "} >>

    L>V

    6>}> ii > >` iiV>VVi >i i i > iiVi i>i v >i

    Vi` ii > Lii `i>i` > > v >VVi i

    iii i > v i >} ii Li > i >iiV ivviV v ii

    >V> } Li >}i} i >i Vii i L> /i Vi v i > >V] V >

    > i > V >}> >vvii i>i] > i i v >vvii >> v v>V>] V> >`

    >V> >VVi > }i>] ViV> > >` }>}i> ii />i }ii

    >L> v`}] i iiVi >> v iiV>VVi iiV `i > i v

    i V>L> v >v>> >` iV >V } i Vi v i > >V

    > >} ii >

    i`

    Vi > >V] ii] >VVi

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    2/6

    1*1/1, {{\{ni`V>>VViV> x

    `V>] *>VVi >` iL>i

    /i `> >}> Vi 6 V>i` i

    `V>`> L>i] i v v i v

    iVi>V iVi] >` Vi i Vi

    >V > /-] i >i> i> >` i

    `> Vi v i >} ii 8

    /i /- i > iVi v >vvii > vi >} ii] v V>`>V>] i>

    >` }>i> i iVi] i i

    8 V> i Vi L` v ivvii >}>

    i}>}V i v Vi> vV

    }} L` v i`iVi }}i > i

    Vi> V v >V vV > i

    iiiVi`ii`i >V v 6 i>

    i V> i} >} i 6 Vi

    vi i>i` L > `vv> ii

    v `> L>i i\ ii ] i>>V>

    >V >V} `i >Vi ii v` `vvi

    >> v > >/- iV i }

    i i 6 L > > i `}

    L>i i Vi> ii] iii >

    v >vvii vLi i> }i `ii

    v iV> >i i /-] i L

    >i i>i`

    6Vi> i> i i /- i}>i

    Li> >` >V ivi vV /i /-

    i i v >}> >vvii iV]

    > iVii i`} v }>}i>] v>V>

    >` }i> iin /i /- > i iVi

    v ii> Vi> >vvii }

    > v i Vi > iVii > `iV

    iV v i /- iV L>V i Vi

    iV iV v i ViiL> Vi i

    /- >i > Lii `ivi ii i>V

    > i >}`>> Vi } i i > viL>

    L`i i vLi > }>i v i /-n

    `iVi v i} >` >V >V} `i

    }}i > V> >` vV> Liii

    i V> >` /- iV iivVi i i> >Vi v iVV>

    VV> Liii ii L> i}

    > Lii ii` i i>i > >

    iiV>VVi i V`} L`] v>V> >`

    >V> >] >i >iiV >`

    iiVi ivviV v ii

    }V i > `i>i` > > v

    >VVi i iii ii` i

    > v i >} ii >` i iiV

    >VVi iVvV ii > Lii`

    > >vi V>V ii `ii> i] - i

    > `i>i` > i >ii ivviV v

    >V> iiV>VVi `>i>i` v i

    }i>i >V> ii v > > iii` Livi

    iiVV> > v i i>

    i-Vi iVi ii>V > > iVi

    iiV ii `Vi i`i}ii> i

    >}`>> >` V> >i

    Vi` ii] vV} i >ii

    iV> v >}> ii > >`

    iiV>VVi >i LiVi i }vV>

    > Li >iiV i>i] >` > > Li

    iiVi i>i > V> > Li i`

    >vi ii v i`V} v>> Vi

    V> Li >i` > ii >V> }

    >i i >i >> >i i >i Vii

    ii i VV> >iiV >> }>i`

    ` Li >>Li V`i i /- > >

    i>>V> iiV Vii v > i

    >> v >V>] V>] v>Vi] L` >VVi

    >` >} ii >vvii > i ii v i

    L>i

    `iVi >` V

    /i /- > > i > V >}> >vvii

    i>i iV>i >vvii >}> ii >

    > Lii `i>i` >i >V> ivviV]

    i > V>}i >V > i

    /- V> i}>i ii ViL /-

    > ivii i `iii v

    Vi i >` iV`> }ii>>{x

    > Lii > LV ii >`

    >` >i i>Vi ii ]

    ii ] >` iV v>V >>

    /D , i V> ] > `

    >V>> iV v E Vi>i` ii

    >V

    > Vi ,ii >i >Vi`L iV Vi Vi>i` i /D >`

    E i > Vi>i > i /D >` E

    , i /- >` V>n i >

    > i i ` > > > >

    iiVi ivviV i `>i}V i

    L L} i i}> v i ii v /D

    >` E , i L>> }>

    } > L 6- >} ii

    v] V Vi}V] i `iVi`

    >V>}i >` `i`V Vi >` i>V

    VV >ViVi iVi] ,>] iiL

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    3/6

    1*1/1, {{\{n i`V>>VViV>

    `V>] *>VVi >` iL>i

    i} i i v /D >` E >`

    iiV>VVi V> `iVi>i i /D >`

    ii > >Vi}V >>

    ii] L> `ii` iV v>V

    > Lii }}ii` Li i`

    ii}ii >ii i > `i>i` >

    >}iV Vi `iVi>i` }>}

    >i i`Vi` ii}ii " i i >`]

    ii> i `i>i > >V>>

    v v V> >i>i i>` i`iii v ii ii] i> i

    i>i V> i>V >> i` >

    > }vV> ii` ,

    ii i V> Li` L

    L> i{ } > Lii

    > >> i>i` >}> i}>}V i

    `Vi ]x ii i>i >L i

    i> Liii 6- >` V>>

    ii

    1>Li} i > `i>i` > }>

    >` ViV ii>i >i >i` L

    >V> v i >vvii }>} ]

    LV>i i > i > Vi V ivviV

    >i i`>i` > i >}> ii

    }i> /- ViV V> ii i v>V>

    >V > `iV i /-n

    L>> i > > `i>i` > iiVV>

    > v i > ii ii` >

    v i /- i] i i v >i ` L

    Li i > i` > i v>> v i

    >ii Vi] > VVii v v>V>`ii i] i > `ii>` V>}i

    i> >V i > }i> Vi

    >` /- > `ii` > i i} v i

    >}{ /] >`` >V>

    }>i VVii ii] v>V> `ii i

    > V > v>V> iiV>VVi >

    Vi` >Vi> >` >>V

    Vi} > VLi Vi> i>

    >V> V> iiV>VVi V> >

    >i i /- > i >V> L>V v >}]

    }i>] }>}i> >` ViV> >

    }i -Vi>V > v >iiV ivviV v i iiV>VVi >` i>i`

    i>>V> >> Li iii i i>i` iviiVi

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    4/6

    ii > Lii > ii> }>

    >i` L iii viVi i V>

    > i /-{ ">i i > >i `i>i` >

    >vvii i `i >>> >>V Vi

    i V>i> i }ii> Vii `

    v i /- >` ii V>i> > V`>iV>}i Vi> ivi iV>L >`

    >>VV> V >i }vV> v>V

    v ii{ /- iV iV> >>V

    Vi > iV }>V> i iv>

    Vi] V> >` i> LV >]

    i} >V>i` L Vi> >{

    6> >ii i > `V>i > i >>]

    >>V>> }] V> >` >} >>

    ii > `i>V>i` L 6-{ i] iiVV>

    i i L>i> V>`> /- V> `Vi

    }vV> LV>`i v iiV>VVi `Vi`

    ii i>Vii] V `V>i > i>i`

    iV> > v >>VV> >`

    VV> iV>L{{ /ii iii ViV

    `V>i > i /- > i Vi v >V

    vV > i > v i}> v >V >`

    >V ii >` i iV>L v iVvV

    L> i} ii] >> >i

    > v /- >` >}`>` `} V

    > >> `i v ii `Vi` L vV>

    iiVV> > v i >}`>> `` i>V

    i > >}i 6] i>} i> >}i ]{x

    >` v`} `i > i> iV> v

    i ii iV L>i` iiV

    >VVi >` >}> > > i /-

    V

    / VVi >i }}i > i /- > Li

    i Vii v i >iiV ivviV v v>V>] V>]

    >V> >` L iiV>VVi > }i>]

    ViV> >] >}> >` > ii iiVi

    />i }ii] i iiVi >> v >i v iiV>VVi iiV `i >

    i v i V>L> v >v>>

    >` iV >V } i /- > >}

    ii >

    ,iviiVi

    *> ] 1V>i} 9] >}i> ] "i}> ] ->

    ,] ii`i `i > *`> /i >}V>

    v`> v i>Li ii\ `i >

    >` >> ,i i {\

    >``i>> 6] +> ] >}> iV>

    i}>} i}V L > i

    L>>i> >}`>>\ V> v ii >` >i

    ``i V` \nL >i>` v

    }i ] *i i / i\ > Viii iL

    1-\ Vq,>i

    { Vi ] i ] vii -/ >` -"7

    >}`>> `} > > V> v >}`>>]

    V>>] v >` i> Vi `} i

    > i ,i x\

    x } ] i " 6>} ii > v iv>V

    `>V }ii>i` ii -ii {\n

    i ] >i -] >i ] > 6] >V -] i>

    i}ii >` i> i Vi i `> >}>

    Vi v >` > L>\ i > >L >V

    i}> p > ii iV \xqn

    ,}}i ] 1`i` ] > ] > ] >}

    6 /i > Vi v i > >V\ Vi> >>

    ii>i` > i >V} i`

    i -\n

    n 7i /] >>> ] > /i L> >> >

    > }`i i > Vi> i i `

    i` 1-\ 7i E - i> Q/i Vi >V >\ i>>V]

    iViV> >` vV> >iVR V *

    V x\x

    > -] ii ] > -] ii -9 i> v

    >i iVvV Vi> >V Vi v}

    > Vi > i> n\x

    , ] i>vi V>> > Vi>

    VVLL> >>\ > >>V> >`

    iiV}V> ` i > > ,i

    n\

    - ] ,9] >} 8 vvV>V v i> >

    iii> `Vi` ii VV iVi

    ,i x\{x

    +] ] ] i} -] 9>} , ii v

    >i iV`Vi` ii >` >V v

    >VVi\ > i> i VV iVi

    ,i x\{

    { -] ] />L>] ` i ] >V ] `i "i>

    ] i iV>VVi ii V}i `ivV

    V>iiiV > iV ixn{\{

    n

    x - ] ,9] >} 8 /i ivviV v i> >

    i Vi v >> >` >V`

    i>i L> v > iii> ii

    VV iVi ,i {\{x

    >} } ,] i ] i} -QvviV v

    iiV>VVi >` iV`Vi` ii>` i i> >V>> " V>}iR -i}

    8i > xx\xn{

    *>i ,] > >V> >VVi

    i>i v `>V V>i ii\ > i> i

    i` {\

    n `i ] >L>V ] >>}i - VVi

    i> v i i>i v >V>Li] `>V ii

    vi `} VV iVi ,i n\{

    } }`>> iiv

    V>}iR \n

    }V ] >> Vi>i }>V >V`

    ii iiV>VVi > v i `L

    v >iii` > * {\xn

    1*1/1, {{\{ni`V>>VViV>

    `V>] *>VVi >` iL>i

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    5/6

    1*1/1, {{\{nn i`V>>VViV>

    `V>] *>VVi >` iL>i

    ->ii> /] i ] ,Li ] 6>i ,] *>i

    ] >>i , V>> `>>}i i `>}i`

    vV> ii\ > iVi , ` i}

    x{\n

    >>} ] "] ii ] i ]

    >i ,] *>i *}i v L> `>>}i

    >vi > iiV >` >V>

    ii}ii\ > >>i , ` > > `i v

    i> Li ii i> {{x\{{

    *>i ] i ] >>} ] > ]

    "] ii ,] i > *}i v i> `>>}i

    >vi > iiV >` `} >i ii >

    > `i v i> Li ii *} > ,i

    x\n

    { 7>i ,] > ] >i ,i}> v LV

    ii L >` }>>i > Vi

    >V > i> {n\x

    x >}`>i> }> 6] 6>`i] >i6>}>

    ] >i ] >> -] i>`i> ,] i>`i

    >`> vviV v iiVV> > v i Vi v

    i > >V i `iii v iiVV> >}`>`} i V> i> {\{

    6i> ] i> ] ,VV ] >` ]

    -] ,>> /] i > V> i v v>>

    Vi >` >v>> iVi ii >`

    ii}ii i> {- x\x

    V ] /> *] 7>} ] >` ] i>i ] ,i>

    ] i > > `L v Vi , `Vi` L

    iV >`> v iiLi>

    iV v>V >> > ,i \{

    n i /,] i`> -] "V> ] ,> ,] ->> -]

    > ] i > i}V >v>> >>

    L v iV v>V `} Vi>

    iiv 6>V -} \

    89] 9] >} 8] ] 8i ] i >

    iV>VVi > iV >i}V

    i v v>>i`>i` `>>}i i`>

    viL> L`i>iVi` > i {

    n\n

    i} ] } -] >9] 9>} -] 9-] >i -]

    i > /i ivviV v >VVi v>> Vi

    `V >i VV i>`>Vi\ > i>

    i i`\{xx{

    8 8 vviV v iiV>VVi

    i ii v iLi> , >vi >i

    vV> ViiL> Vi> VV iVi ,i

    \x

    >ii -] *>i ] ->>i>i /] i ] i

    ] >i iVi>i` }>} >}iV

    Vi i`Vi ii}ii iV

    x{\{

    >> ,] i}>> 9 / \ > i

    iiV V> iVi x{\n

    { 9 -] *> ] 9i ] > ] ii ] ii

    vviV v iiV>VVi i i`Vi` V>}i

    L>`ii` iV v>V ii >

    V> iV i n\nxqn

    x ` -] >v ] }}i /] > >i>i`

    >}> i}>}V i ii L>`ii`

    iV v>V >` / iVi\ V> v

    i> >V > ,i x{{\{

    1>Li} ] `iLi} /] i ] i *

    6>}> i`>i` ii>i v }> >` ViV

    v} i > V> * -V>`

    {\{x

    Li ] Li ,] ,i >iiV v>>`Vi`

    i ii i }i> i>V>`>

    > i\ VL v >i>}>>`i>i}> > ,i n{x\xx

    n > ] ii *] iii> ] i>

    /}i>v>V> >> > i

    x{n\n

    L>> ] >> 9 />}i i v L v

    L>ivi >}> L>`V>`> L >> > >

    ,i {\{

    { >> /] 7> *ii> >>i>i`

    i `>i iii ii>i i

    V> > viVi L>i Vi i>

    > ,i {x\nx

    { ">i ] ,i ] ,}}i vvii i `i

    >> i V>i> i Vi >V >\ >

    >>V> L> v >>V >` Vi> ivi i}>

    iV {{\x{

    { ,}}i ] > -] ] Vi - 6Vi>

    >vvii >> i >> >` v>V LiVi\

    Li>> V> > ,i n\x

    { 6> >ii ] 6V ] *] 6i ] iV ,

    *iv -*/ V>}i >vi >Vi >` VV >}

    ii > i> i V` >`

    }i VV> ivvV>V V i`{\{{

    {{ 9 *] /> ] ] ] >} vviV v

    iiV>VVi > > > >V ii

    >Vi >\ i V> v i V>`> Vi >V

    > i` -V {x\x

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/
  • 7/30/2019 Acupunct Med 2006 Cakmak 164 8

    6/6

    doi: 10.1136/aim.24.4.1642006 24: 164-168Acupunct Med

    Yusuf Ozgur Cakmaknucleus of the solitary tractEpilepsy, electroacupuncture and the

    http://aim.bmj.com/content/24/4/164Updated information and services can be found at:

    These include:

    serviceEmail alerting

    the box at the top right corner of the online article.Receive free email alerts when new articles cite this article. Sign up in

    Notes

    http://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissionsTo request permissions go to:

    http://journals.bmj.com/cgi/reprintformTo order reprints go to:

    http://group.bmj.com/subscribe/To subscribe to BMJ go to:

    group.bmj.comon May 14, 2013 - Published byaim.bmj.comDownloaded from

    http://aim.bmj.com/content/24/4/164http://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissionshttp://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissionshttp://journals.bmj.com/cgi/reprintformhttp://journals.bmj.com/cgi/reprintformhttp://group.bmj.com/subscribe/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/http://aim.bmj.com/http://group.bmj.com/subscribe/http://journals.bmj.com/cgi/reprintformhttp://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissionshttp://aim.bmj.com/content/24/4/164